22 ms·
Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F
- steelframe 2y agoCool. Can I take one without my identity and travel patterns being tracked? Like, suppose I want to get picked up from work and dropped off at my girlfriend's house in San Mateo. Something I might not want my soon-to-be-ex's lawyer to be able to subpoena. There's one of those machines onboard that are all over the place in supermarkets where I can feed bills right? Or maybe not. Okay then, Luxor Cab it is. Cheaper, better conversation, more aggressive about squeezing through traffic, and doesn't violate my privacy. I'm not against automated taxi services in principle. I'm just not interested if it's a package deal where I have to surrender my physical comings and goings to a scummy data broker like Google.
- yazzku 2y agoObviously you do surrender all of your travel privacy to the data broker. That's why they are making self-driving cars in the first place. But you're already doing all of that by carrying an Android phone.
- bamboozled 2y agoStrange this is downvoted no ?
- qlaotht 2y ago[flagged]
- astrange 2y agoPretending they're being tracked and that people are making money from it makes them feel important, more like. You aren't actually that valuable.
- quqalx 2y agoIt isn't actually a secret: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jul/04/smile-youre-on-camera-self-driving-cars-are-here-and-theyre-watching-you https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jul/04/smile-you...
- astrange 2y agoYou can tell this is an academic fight because it contains the phrase "disproportionately harm marginalised groups", which is the San Francisco version of pounding the table when they don't have an actual argument. More importantly it doesn't mention making money off it.
- yazzku 2y agoI also found it strange. The parent comment has some amount of hyperbole, but it does not detract from the point they are conveying.
- pier25 2y ago> That's why they are making self-driving cars in the first place It is? I thought they wanted to disrupt transportation.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoI mean the most obvious reason is making money. But other things like making the roads safer is a nice side effect.
- steelframe 2y ago> But you're already doing all of that by carrying an Android phone. I'm not.
- yazzku 2y agoMy boy. Now, when a self-driving car drives past you, make sure you show them that sweet middle finger of yours.
- steelframe 2y agoActually whenever I give one my sweet middle finger it's stuck in SF traffic and I'm zipping around it on my bike.
- yazzku 2y agoGoogle fanboys entered the chat room. Care to explain what is it that you dislike about my comment? Was any of it non-factual?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- currymj 2y agointerestingly the NYC yellow cabs were recording all this data for a while and released it in an "anonymized" dataset, which turned out to be pretty easy to deanonymize because people tend to be picked up or dropped off near their homes or workplaces. https://agkn.wordpress.com/2014/09/15/riding-with-the-stars-passenger-privacy-in-the-nyc-taxicab-dataset/ https://agkn.wordpress.com/2014/09/15/riding-with-the-stars-... i think the answer is just that you don't have much meaningful privacy when using a taxi service in a normal way.
- steelframe 2y agoMy trick is to walk a block or two on either end of the trip.
- joecasson 2y agoHow would you design that system? I can't imagine a self-driving car request via an app could be accomplished without _someone_ knowing / tracking your travel patterns. You can't do cash transactions because that would be rife for smash-n-grabs from others.
- steelframe 2y agoWith a regular taxi I just call from a phone in a hotel lobby and ask to be picked up a block or so from my location. No reason there can't be a dispatch service you can call for self-driving taxis too. Crime happens, but that's why there's insurance. It's not like cab drivers don't get robbed too. It doesn't (and shouldn't) stop cash commerce.
- spankalee 2y agoIn what was is Google a data broker? Where can you buy this data?
- mhfga 2y agoI do not know where/if the plebs can buy this data, but advertisers can: https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/13381216?hl=en https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/13381216?hl=en "Waymo may disclose user personal information to third parties to tailor advertising and offers to your interests. Such disclosures may be considered “sales” or “sharing” of personal information under the California Consumer Privacy Act." It is rather surprising that so many here downvote the obvious, which even non-technical Guardian journalists have found out.
- spankalee 2y agoThe phrasing here is due to the CPRA which specifically requires that the link be titled "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information" even for ad targeting. As far as I understand the advertising model is the same as with Google Ads - Google builds profiles and lets advertisers target users based on profiles. They do not sell user data, and I'm not personally aware of a case where Google has even been alleged to be selling user data.
- steelframe 2y agoYou can buy it from Google by becoming an app developer. https://www.dli.tech.cornell.edu/post/facebook-and-google-are-the-new-data-brokers#:~:text=They%20sell%20it%20to%20developers,are%20the%20modern%20data%20brokers https://www.dli.tech.cornell.edu/post/facebook-and-google-ar...
- seeknotfind 2y agoWooooooo! Goodbye Lyft and Uber. Honestly, I get a bag driver, use the AI for a while. Feels too sterile, switch back, get some interesting drivers. Waymo has everything going for it but good company. Love it.
- Me1000 2y agoUnfortunately Waymo still wont operate on freeways or at SFO. But I long for the day when I can take a Waymo between SF and Berkley or to SFO, those are my most frequent reasons to call a Lyft.
- vineyardmike 2y agoWell they just got the permit to expand, so you shouldn’t have to wait too long. That said, I think the plan was first to expand down the peninsula.
- dntrkv 2y agoAnytime I go to east bay I go for BART. I’m not trying to sit in bay bridge traffic. BART gets a bad rap, like every other public transit in the US, but I’ve been using it pretty frequently recently (stopped around beginning of lockdowns) and it’s a great experience.
- Me1000 2y agoI also use BART most of the time, but I often end up heading back to SF pretty late in the night so that’s not always an option.
- extragood 2y agoKeep using Waymo and stream with a stranger on one of the Omegle clones when you ride. Problem solved.
- ortusdux 2y agoI'm still surprised that they, and most of their competitors, chose to start off in such difficult to navigate regions. I would have started off in a retirement community or the like.
- SheinhardtWigCo 2y agoThey kinda did that - they were operating in the suburbs around Phoenix AZ for years before launching in SF. Not operating in difficult areas would slow them down because progress in this domain is bound by the breadth of edge cases encountered in the wild.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoThere was actually an autonomous vehicle company focused specifically on retirement communities called voyage. They were acqui-hired by Cruise several years ago and the project shut down because there was no real viability.
- AzzyHN 2y agoThey did some driving in some Arizona suburbs too, iirc. The reasoning for having so much driving in SF is twofold 1. Silicon Valley, both for the workers and the general public's willingness to embrace fancy new tech 2. SF is DIFFICULT to drive in. If you follow all driving laws & drive super defensively, you'll never get anywhere on time. If an AI can learn to effectively navigate around traffic, construction, stopped rideshare and foodshare cars, large crowds, etc etc, it can drive anywhere. SF also gets a lot of rain and dense fog, good for testing low-visibility conditions
- joshchaney 2y agoThey did some driving in some Arizona suburbs too I think you are really understating it. I believe Chandler, AZ has been Waymo's proving grounds for years, and according to this article (https://www.wsj.com/us-news/waymo-phoenix-arizona-self-driving-vehicles-72a0bbb5# https://www.wsj.com/us-news/waymo-phoenix-arizona-self-drivi...) the Phoenix area is the leader of autonomous vehicle service.
- tanvach 2y agoWe recently started using Waymo more often: - Quality of Lyft and Uber rides have gone down significantly. - Consistently spacious, clean and quiet cars. You know what you'll get. - AC always works and not up to the whim of the driver. - No chatty driver to disturb our sleeping baby. Negatives: - Rides have usually 10% mark up over Lyft and Uber. - Pick up and drop off tend to be a small walk from requested locations. Forgot one more positive - you can choose a soothing music play list in the car and it automatically resumes in the next ride. Small but really nice detail when traveling with a baby.
- perfectstorm 2y agodo you have to tip the 'driver'? jokes aside, i would be happy to take them once the expand to SFO region so i can have a consistent experience.
- tanvach 2y agoWorth trying to sign up now. The waitlist takes a while.
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoIt's not on a waitlist in SF anymore, Waymo is just open.
- tanvach 2y agoInteresting, my wife was still on waitlist in SF last week.
- vineyardmike 2y agoI’d love to take it to the airport, but I imagine it’ll be a mess trying to pull up and park at departures. It’s already incredibly chaotic with the way humans are, and I don’t expect they’ll even pretend to extend any curtesy to a robot. Maybe I’m wrong though? I think they go to the airport in phoenix, I just haven’t heard any reports on the experience.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoWaymos are fantastic, I actually look forward to riding them every time. It's a quiet, peaceful space where you can relax for a bit on the way to your destination. Haven't had any issues with them except for one time where the car was super hot on the inside for whatever reason and the AC was not working.
- athoun 2y agoIn my experience Waymo has been much worse compared to Lyft/Uber for longer rides. A big problem with Waymo in its current state is how its routes are terribly inefficient. It purposely avoids freeways and higher speed roads, opting to take more inefficient routes without regards to the number of stop signs, hills, and other factors which will inevitably lead to a longer travel time. It's almost like it's using a worse version of the "Avoid highways" feature on Google Maps, and getting to a further destination can take almost twice the amount of time as compared to a Lyft/Uber. Another problem is its lack of human intuition and strategies when driving in the city during some kind of event where many of the roads are blocked off. A human driver would have been navigating the blocked roads throughout the day and already know where to go to avoid the crowds, where as Waymo naively follows its navigation system and gets stuck in a bunch of traffic for no reason. It also drives annoyingly slowly which leads to frustration from human drivers who constantly try to overtake you.
- tanvach 2y agoWe actually prefer safer and slower ride, some Lyft/Uber drivers drive way too dangerously for no reason.
- athoun 2y agoI could definitely see that. If you're not pressed on time it can be a smoother ride for sure. But if you're trying to get somewhere fast or efficiently like going to the airport, you'd want to get a regular Lyft/Uber otherwise you might miss your flight. It would be cool if you can configure the ride preferences for how aggressive you'd like it to drive.
- vineyardmike 2y agoWell it doesn’t go to the airport today, because it doesn’t go on highways or out of the city. So i don’t think anyone has missed their flight. I suspect with their new permits approved, you’ll see them drive on the highway soon, which will result in much faster trips where applicable. I am really glad it’s not aggressive at driving - they drive how humans are supposed to - cautiously. Humans kill people regularly from aggressive driving.
- renewiltord 2y agoThey're fantastic. I can't wait to take one to the airport.
- _jab 2y agoGlad to see this development. The amount of FUD around AVs is too high, and allowing each individual municipality to set their own regulations for AVs would have been a ridiculous amount of red tape for these companies to deal with. Just to pull one particularly bad quote from this article: > “I hope that, in the meantime, our communities do not suffer too much in terms of injuries and community damages due to the current regulatory gaps,” Cortese said in a statement. What gaps? What injuries? What community damages? If someone can actually present statistics that these cars are more socially dangerous than an equivalent amount of Ubers and Lyfts, I would be very, very surprised.
- benced 2y agoIt's been nonstop lies from opponents, especially South Bay opponents of this technology with the tiniest kernel of truth that Cruise has not been very responsible. I still can't get over San Mateo County flatly lying about Waymo not talking to them (https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/-/media/cpuc-website/divisions/consumer-protection-and-enforcement-division/documents/tlab/av-programs/waymo-al-2-disposition-letter-20240301_signed.pdf https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/-/media/cpuc-website/divisions/consu..., "in its protests, San Mateo stated...").
- labrador 2y agoBased on anecdotal evidence, I strongly suspect these are remotely driven cars, not completely self-driving, which means there is a remote saftey operator ready to take over if the ride starts to go bad. "Self-driving" sounds sexier and is the ultimate goal, but if it were my company I'd probably lead with "remotely monitored by safety driver" to calm any fears people might have. I'm guessing the percentage of people who are willing to put their lives in the hands of this tech is rather small and the percentage of people who don't trust tech is rather large.
- akira2501 2y agoWouldn't the fear just become that not enough safety drivers will always be available or that the internet connection they use to "drive" the car remotely would fail? It's a taxi that you don't have to risk having a conversation with a stranger in. Outside of that it seems that all other benefits are marginal or well crafted illusions. Anyways, I'm sure I'm just being a pessimist, it's not as if large monopolistic companies with no human customer service have failed us significantly before. I mean, I trust them with my data completely, so why not my life, too?
- labrador 2y agoIf it loses remote monitoring I'd rather it would pull over and park rather than barelling down the steep hills of San Francisco without a safety monitor.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoWaymo has been pretty clear about this: they do have remote navigators/coaches who tell the cars what to do if it gets stuck/confused, but they're not directly driving the car, they're telling it where to go, like a navigator in the front passenger seat. Remote operation is considered dangerous due to possible issues with network connection latency or stability. If it was actually happening, Waymo is big enough now (IIRC they said 50,000 paid rides each week) to where someone would've leaked such a secret.
- 2y ago
- worstspotgain 2y agoSome curiosities from seeing them on the road a lot. You can tell it's them even when you can't see the extra protuberances: - They take extended stops at stop signs, around 3-4 seconds. - They have extra-bright headlights and brake lights. - When waiting for a ride, they pull up next to parks and parking lots to avoid bothering residents. Their brake lights are on the whole time. If demand is low, they'll hang out in batches of 2-4. If a block has a hazy red hue at night, you know you've found a Waymo nest.
- toomanyrichies 2y agohttps://archive.ph/gxy1S https://archive.ph/gxy1S
- benced 2y agoAs a cyclist, I trust the Waymos significantly more than human drivers to not hit me (I've been biking in SF since Jan and already had 3 unsafe incidents). The more, the better, I say.
- konschubert 2y agoYep. Once human drivers are banned from streets, cycling will be much safer!
- rsingla 2y agoI love Waymos compared to my ride sharing experience. The base car is appealing (currently Jaguars). They're spacious for a >6 ft individual like myself. The user interface is intuitive and fun. There's a cool factor that exists. Against ride sharing, given the lack of a driver, there's no variability in driver with regards to ambiance, scents, cleanliness, chattiness, and smoothness of the ride. I am very much looking forward to this expansion.
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- coolspot 2y agoOnce it goes really mainstream, I can see angry Uber/Lyft drivers and/or their supporters destroy Waymos in large quantities (isolated incidents already have happened multiple times in SF [0][1]), driving economical feasibility to zero and causing Waymo to cease operations in some cities. [0] - https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/11/24069251/waymo-driverless-taxi-fire-vandalized-video-san-francisco-china-town https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/11/24069251/waymo-driverless... [1] - https://abc7news.com/waymo-sf-attacked-self-driving-car-incidents/14397184/ https://abc7news.com/waymo-sf-attacked-self-driving-car-inci...
- kristopolous 2y agoI don't think uber/lyft drivers will be the culprit here. Generally, it's a pretty lousy job these days. There's also other options like survey or click work which pays more or less about the same net income. If I were to place my bets on the biggest risk it'll be YouTubers finding out how to fuck around with the cars in unexpected ways and potentially tricking them. Here's a dumb example. If you use one of those phone apps that flashes your screen like a police siren, could you trick the car to pull over? Would it unlock the doors and allow you to just hop in? What if you put a dog shaped balloon in the road on front of it? Could you set up some confusing cones and get it to drive into a wall? Could you confuse it at a stoplight with a green flashlight and have it start driving?
- diebeforei485 2y agoI know it's still the "honeymoon phase", but I actually do like Waymo when I'm walking, biking, driving another car, or riding in the Waymo.
- brap 2y agoCan’t wait to have it in my country. With the current apps/services, 70% of the time the driver won’t stop talking on the phone, or won’t turn on the AC, or will drive in a way that’ll make you want to throw up, etc etc.
- blendo 2y agoAnd Elon Musk would improve on these 5,000 lb Waymo SUVs carrying 1-2 passengers in favor of 7,000 lb Cybertrucks carrying 1-2 passengers. The improved 0-60 times alone will prove Elon the more effective accellerationist.
- Rakshith 2y agothey should move away from the shitty jaguars and chryslers they have in their fleet though. Maybe Honda would make a good partner as they have the only US autonomous level 3.
- refulgentis 2y agoShitty Jaguar? Pacifica we can quibble, but really? Jaguar?
- sherbondy 2y agoCan’t wait to be able to hail a Waymo from SFO. They are truly a marvel of modern technology.
- revlolz 2y agoWaymo rides in PHX area were a pleasent surprise. While on our trip, the waymo slammed it's brakes as a precarious event transpired that I'm almost positive if a human was at the wheel, would have resulted in an accident. Very optimistic to see how many lives they can save over the next decade.