30 ms·
Can turning office towers into apartments save downtowns?
- Simulacra 3y agoTurn them into low income housing and service centers for the poor.
- rak 3y agoI like this idea. I would even settle for the mixed income housing that a lot of development companies here (DC) were supposed to build when they received subsidies from the government.
- ltbarcly3 3y agoYes, lets concentrate poor people in tall apartment towers in downtown areas. What could go wrong?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> What could go wrong? Or what could go right. Service and civic workers would finally have housing that wasn't 2 hours away from their city jobs.
- ltbarcly3 3y agoNobody will live in the projects except people who have no way to escape.
- pineaux 3y agoThis is not true. Here in Holland developers of high rises are forced to make 40% of it social housing. This works quite well. The social housing system is broken, but thats mostly because they havent built enough housing in the last 50 years.
- anon291 3y ago> The social housing system is broken, but thats mostly because they havent built enough housing in the last 50 years. So it's not working well.
- TimedToasts 3y agoThe hypothetical housing is doing great!
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Nobody will live in the projects except people who have no way to escape. There are more people for whom ex-commercial housing would work - than there are (or ever will be) units to house them. Even in a tough neighborhood I'd of done it, if I had work nearby. I once parked the I was living in my employer's parking lot.
- Raztuf 3y agoNot to be cynical but this is an invitation to rampant criminality in city centers.
- scanr 3y agoLondon seems to manage this petty well. I think it’s quite healthy for a city to commingle folk from different income groups rather than house them in specific areas.
- GardenLetter27 3y agoWhy should the government steal my income to destroy the value of my property by paying to house criminals next door? The Free Market solves this perfectly - let people own their property and have a stake in where they live and maintaining the community and safety. We just need to let people build and bring a real free market to property.
- phone8675309 3y agoThe fact that you assume all of the poor are criminals disqualifies you from having your opinion on this taken seriously.
- oo0shiny 3y agoHow is the government stealing your income or destroying the value of your property? Seems a bit hyperbolic. And if the free market solves this, why are we in this situation in the first place? Shouldn't the free market have solved this already? Instead we have piles of empty houses/buildings and more homeless than ever before.
- GardenLetter27 3y agoBecause there is no free market in housing whatsoever. Owning land doesn't give you the right to build anything. You need planning permission - which means permission from the local council, local homeowners and consultation, etc. which gives the NIMBY attitude so much power. There aren't piles of empty houses. There aren't enough houses at all.
- SmoothBrain123 3y agoI love Judge Dredd.
- schneems 3y agoMixed income and mixed use is my preference. The Austin Plaza Saltillo project is a great example. Shops at the bottom make it useful for the whole community. Parking is in garages underneath which promotes walk ability. When you see someone going to their place you don’t know if they are on food stamps or are a tech millionaire. There’s less stigma and more respect for all neighbors.
- redtexture 3y agoIt is expensive to convert a building. Not exactly low cost, nor low income capable.
- the_optimist 3y agoRather than this relatively low-effort idea, just think about the other marginalized groups for which appeal could be curried: - orphans and widowers - statutorily limited peoples - losers of the womb lottery - the soft in spirit - students of life - unhoused migrants - homeless encampment simulator And failing this: - displaced urban wildlife - tear it down and make space for plants
- cynicalsecurity 3y ago> losers of the womb lottery What?
- i_play_stax 3y agoHe means people not born into significant privilege
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoThis is a recipe for disaster.
- lenerdenator 3y agoYou'll hear the owners and developers crow about how it's not worth it.
- pwthornton 3y agoConventional wisdom is thaty only certain office buildings can be converted to housing. The depth and shape of the building matters quite a bit. A lot of office buildings are very deep and would result in a lot of rooms/space without windows or access to natural light. The DC area is doing a pretty good job with conversions. A lot of these midrise buildings are a good fit for this. Although the very broad midrise buildings are a poor fit. But I wonder if we could challenge the conventional wisdom on conversions of deeper buildings. Could we come up with novel things to do with this deep interior space?
- umutisik 3y agoCan the right LED panels make up for the lack of daylight in the interior areas?
- redtexture 3y agoFire codes and building codes are an impediment to modifying distance from openable windows, for bedrooms. Novel means changing the national fire code, which was written the way it was for a reason.
- elicash 3y agoI can absolutely see the safety argument for distance from a window. Fair! But I will say, as someone who made his windowless basement his bedroom even though I had other options in my home, I love a super dark space to sleep.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoYes. And in a city, it can be made more quiet. And there are techniques to transporting natural light indoors. This thread's obsession with bedroom windows, egress out them from 20 stories up, and "code" is nuts. We are in a housing crisis that is destroying the economic viability of several generations. You could also have ceiling to floor OLED displays, or just a large display that shows the current view of the outside. I also don't understand why they can't basically put large corridors across the building in addition to light transfer, more common space than hallway to provide more light if the interior residents want it. Fundamentally, people want a safe, affordable place to sleep, go to the bathroom, and eat. Windows and views just need to be a quick walk away. I possibly spend less than .1% of my time at home looking out a window. My bedrooms generally have the windows completely covered to maximize my sleep. At generic hotel-motel rooms I almost never open the curtains. It's ridiculous this isn't simply put up to market economics. Finally I have a great idea for internal areas: simply provide them as storage units. Cheap, no water, minimal electricity, still makes money, and its one of the things people complain about city living.
- sharpshadow 3y agoThere was a big value drop during the pandemic which is still ongoing because of home office. Turning them into housing could indeed be a good option for people in big cities, but the real estate market cares about money and housing is not the best option for them.
- FredPret 3y agoThe other option is empty offices
- sharpshadow 3y agoIm not sure about the laws in the US but here in Germany for example if you rent an apartment and pay your rent you can’t be kicked out. The set of laws is different for office buildings and apartments.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FredPret 3y agoAre you saying they can't evict the office tenants in order to convert the building? I'm sure any transition from office -> condos will be long, messy, and expensive. Still better than dead, empty cities though.
- swozey 3y agoIIRC (it's been awhile) most office leases are for 5 years, or maybe 3.. I forget. Not sure if they'd have any stipulations to allow evictions in an instance like this.
- FredPret 3y agoI would imagine if office buildings offered tenants a get-out-of-your-lease-free card, they'd jump on it. Office leases are not cheap, and go on for years (last one I dealt with was 7!). And if the office is empty...
- jmyeet 3y agoArchived: https://archive.is/Rg8g2 https://archive.is/Rg8g2
- jmathai 3y agoI don't see how downtowns without offices would thrive. The main attraction of downtowns where people live are that they don't need cars because work and social lives are within walking distance. The idea quickly falls apart once you need a car to get to either social events or to work.
- 1980phipsi 3y agoYou're overthinking it. The equilibrium is that there would be fewer offices, not no offices.
- radlad 3y agoRemember the reason that offices are empty is because people are working from home. So there is no "commute to work." Social and shopping needs would still be met inside the city.
- Chris2048 3y agoWork that isn't in an office?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoThe main attraction of living downtown is there's lots of life with the people around: plentiful meetups for whatever you like, more neighbors for friends, more people to socialize. There's a large, living, breathing, constantly-changing ecosystem that's self-rearranging of bars for all tastes (including non-alcoholic); chain stores and indie ones; parks for to frolic; restaurants and food trucks of all shapes and flavors; entertainment venues; parades to savor; sports games, stand-up, concerts and shows; city festivals, conventions, expos; all that and more within walkable distance. If your work is nearby, that's just chef's kiss, then.
- kumarsw 3y agoBack when I worked out of an office in an industrial park in the suburbs of Boston, a number of the younger/single folks would reverse-commute in from the city. Since it was against the prevailing flow of traffic it was a pretty easy drive for them.
- BobbyTables2 3y agoNo
- ltbarcly3 3y agoLet's not "save" them, which is just an attempt to bail out the landlords who have been gouging the rents and manipulating building codes and laws, sabotaging rail, and doing everything in their power to keep rents artificially high. Step 1: Let all the landlords go bankrupt. The buildings will be repossessed and owned by creditors, but still there. Step 2: New people buy them for a fraction of even the current price, and redevelop them. Or nobody buys them, and we get an empty lot. Any other plan is an attempt to transfer wealth from the people to the landlord class to save their skin. Hard pass, let them use their 75 years of ill gotten rents.
- germinalphrase 3y ago“ New people buy them for a fraction of even the current price, and redevelop them. Or nobody buys them, and we get an empty lot” If no one truly buys them, you don’t get an empty lot. You get abandoned, dilapidated buildings and all the associated social/environmental problems that comes with that.
- pseudocomposer 3y agoOr the city could just invoke eminent domain, buy it at a very low price if the owner can’t demonstrate it having a high market price, restore the building and democratically choose an equitable process to rent it or sell it, hopefully favoring existing citizens. But of course, we’d have to be a lot more aggressive about invoking eminent domain for this to be effective. To that end, it would make sense to also establish policies ensuring it’s easy to invoke it fairly and transparently - ie, easily allowing other parties to bid against the city for higher prices in cases where eminent domain is to be used this way (stipulating that those parties also take measures to restore the building, etc).
- cm2187 3y agoYour city will rather go bankrupt. Just take Detroit as a guide.
- eep_social 3y ago
- jmyeet 3y agoA big issue is what we're building rather than how much we're building or what we're converting. There is way too much ultra-luxury buildings getting built in NYC. It's simply too profitable and there's little to no incentive to build (or convert) apartments normal people can afford. Another problem for NYC in particular, a lot of the buildings that exist already would be illegal to build now. I get the desire to avoid streets being in constant shadow from surrounding buildings but large footprint buildings are simply a more efficient use of space once you factor in things like elevators, fire escapes and electrical/mechanical ducting. The NYC government works at the behest of property developers so this is unlikely to change.
- Scubabear68 3y agoI lived in Manhattan for 10 years from late 90s into the late 2000s, live in NJ now. A major trend I have seen is NYC skewing more and more towards the rich/ultra rich and ignoring the rich and middle class. We recently visited NYC for the first time in a couple of years, and it seemed like everything was transformed into Gucci and YSL and Bulgari etc etc. I don’t know how this is sustainable given that Manhattan is an island.
- jareklupinski 3y agothey just opened a Chanel in the Upper West Side
- 1980phipsi 3y agoThe reason why it's more profitable to do ultra-luxury is that regulations increase fixed costs, which make it less profitable to do projects that would have had lower expected returns, like affordable apartments.
- esafak 3y agoThis is an interesting argument. Can we quantify the harm done by regulation? Which regulations should be repealed first?
- 3y ago
- adolph 3y agoThe thesis isn't about "downtowns" across the country but a particular developer in NYC. Older buildings have more usable space because they aren't subject to the same standards as new buildings. And, because of zoning reforms, no new building would be allowed to overwhelm a Manhattan street the way the hulking towers of the postwar period did. A developer who constructed a tower the same height as 55 Broad would likely have to sacrifice twenty per cent of the rentable space. The target demographic doesn't care about windowlessness: New York remains a place where many ambitious young people go to start their careers, if not to stay, and this demographic is ideal for the hotel-style conversions for which office towers are most suitable. Moreover, Berman said, “young people are social—they don’t want to sit in the middle of a forest on a Zoom call.” Renters are now used to the layouts of chain hotels, where there’s one window by the bed, so Berman’s bathrooms and kitchens didn’t need to be sunny, and the kitchens could have a minimal footprint. “Our demographic doesn’t cook,” he said. He referred to the other rooms without windows as “home offices.” Avinash Malhotra, an architect who has done several conversions with Berman, noted that a single office tower can be carved up into hundreds of little units, as in a hotel. “He is not making housing for the homeless,” Malhotra said. “But I often joke among my employees that what we do is slums for the rich.”
- alberth 3y agoPlumbing (Kitchens & Bathrooms) The huge issue in conversions is the amount of plumbing needed (and associated cost). It's not uncommon that an entire office floor might only have 1 restroom area & 1 mini-kitchen. But that same floor, configured as apartments, might have 10+ apartments ... which means 10x the plumbing for bathrooms and kitchens that didn't exist before. And having feeder plumbing that can support that 10x (or more) increase in water/waste volume.
- user90131313 3y agoI think they can use/invent something like dirty water towers in NYC. use that for whatever the NYC use it for. Water there really proven dirty so it doesn't matter.
- infecto 3y agoGeneral building/fire code but even be a larger issue. I suspect you could probably solve the plumbing side of things but meeting building code might be the larger challenge.
- teeray 3y agoIt’s not even just the obvious plumbing providing hot and cold water, and the drain pipes carrying away waste water. You also need vent stacks for all the drains. You also need to put in a whole lot of hot water heaters and the associated electrical work to handle their demands.
- bdcravens 3y agoI've seen plenty of "apartments" (really just a room) in NYC on Tiktok that don't have proper restrooms (though they do often have a small sink)
- Dowwie 3y agoFrame additional walls within the room that include additional plumbing lines, branching from existing lines as needed. Granted, you lose space but at least you'll have a fully compliant residence, no?
- 3y ago
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoAbsolutely 100%. There is no reason why office buildings cannot be rezoned and regulations loosened to allow for all office buildings to be changed into affordable housing. The only problems are a lack of political will with regard to zoning and codes. A common retort is, "well some apartments won't get access to natural light" or "utilities are in one place". In many countries where housing security is tight, there are people who live inside apartments without windows. Secondly, share housing where kitchens and bathrooms were used communely (aka a dorm) used to exist for many working class poor. Again, if the choice is the street versus a share house the choice is obvious. No one said affordable housing needs to provide natural light, private bathrooms, and kitchens. Until the political will exists to return to what used to be normal for America and in many respects the entire world homelessness will continue. Sometimes a roof over ones head and a place to sleep is all the homeless want. Price it accordingly.
- kkfx 3y agoA simple note: why people should want to live there? If there is no more work in cities except for city services, witch happen to be more and more bound to some bigger/external entities, so no real margins to evolve for any local company, why be there? Yes, there are many desperate enough to flock anywhere if they see a possible accommodation, but how can they survive locally? After the '80s logistic revolution and then TLC/IT progress finally making offices useless in cities there is no viable economy anymore. The new right density for the economy of scale are single-family homes and small buildings spread enough to have room to change but not too far, intermixed with homes enough to avoid the US suburbs error. We can't have a new deal in dense cities. P.v. works best for self-consumption only and we heading toward cheap enough batteries to make almost-autonomous homes the norm in a large slice of the inhabited world (30kWh capacity per home at minimum), we can collect and store and clorate enough water to make semi-autonomous homes and various shops. It start to be cheaper than creating large aqueducts. We start to being able to treat sewers enough to been able to have local treatment instead of a sewerage network, we are not there, but near enough. The world change and we have to change accordingly meaning we can't keep up the immense infra we have made for cities while people move around to escape too frequently flooded areas, too hot areas and so on. We need infra for industries, and many industries need a certain size to be viable, but the trend it's clear we need to produce modern way to live less and less dependent on complex services existing on ground networks. We still need roads, personal air mobility and last-mile air mobility is still far despite certain claims https://www.easa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/dfu/uam-full-report.pdf https://www.easa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/dfu/uam-full-... but we know where we should go. Smart cities can't work like the old Fordlandia can't. Classic cities already not work anymore, so we do not have other options so far and we need to evolve anyway.
- dgacmu 3y agoBecause cities are awesome: density gives you choice. In a city, if I have a gifted child, I almost certainly have several options for what school to send them to, many probably within walking distance. In a sparse suburb, I have one, unless they want an hour-long bus ride. Same goes for restaurants, and social activities -- and people! (i.e., potential friends) Cities are drastically more efficient. PV does -not- work best for personal consumption, that's actually the hardest way to go because you're not sharing available resources. Same goes for almost everything else you listed. What's not awesome are cities defined by gridlock and huge highways, something that is itself addressed by increasing the amount of residential space relative to office space.
- freddealmeida 3y agoNo
- BenFranklin100 3y agoYes and no. Lots of new residential can save downtowns. Just build new residential however. It's not that much more expensive. The existing office can continue to be used as commercial real estate, especially by the new residents. Together, this will help create walkable, vibrant downtown with no need for a car to commute to work. The only thing preventing this is zoning, which currently bans most new residential.
- rtkwe 3y agoThere are a lot of cities that don't have much undeveloped land in their downtowns left. Add in things like work from home for your traditional office workers and you've got a lot more office space than you need so there's a push to find some use for these buildings before the bottom completely falls out of the office real estate market.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoOne of the great NIMBY myths is that there is a lack of developable land in urban areas. Without exception, every North American city has vast swaths of underdeveloped land where shorter, outdated buildings can be torn down and replaced with denser, more modern, energy efficient housing. WFH is great for some jobs, but many jobs are better in person, and relatively few people have the luxury of an at-home office, especially those within urban areas. Perhaps you're happy with your employer pushing office costs onto you, but I prefer an employer that provides me with an office that I can walk/bike to instead.
- rtkwe 3y agoThere are vanishingly few cities in the US where a walkable/bikeable commute is even a real option even if you're willing to move deep into the downtown and move each time you get a new job. The costs of having my own office are far offset by not having to drive at all most days and I'm only ~15-20 minutes by car from my office. I work in a large multi-site company so I'm either at home on zoom for meetings or in the office on zoom for meetings hearing 60 other people also have zoom meetings. There's vanishingly small benefits for coming to the office for me because the people I could conceivably benefit from in person collaboration with are hours away so no matter what my day lives on video calls and Teams chats. > WFH is great for some jobs, but many jobs are better in person, I'm increasingly convinced this is simply not true for most jobs and it's being pushed by a) middle management who like in office because they can wander by and check in on everyone easier or b) the real estate arms of companies trying to justify extremely expensive leases they can't get out of. Personally I think b is the ultimate reason because it looks bad to have this cost sitting around with no 'justification'. Anecdotally our leadership was effusive with praise about how productive we were during the 2 years+ of complete work from home and yet no matter how much feedback they get that people aren't happy with RTO we've been slowly ratcheting up the number of days required in and increasing the level of tracking of adherence to this new policy no one but the C-Suite seem to want.
- quinnquan 3y agoWill we be able to afford them is the real question.
- hackernewds 3y agoWhy should we "save downtowns" is another
- throw0101c 3y agoA few months ago Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast had an episode on this: > Big cities like New York have two real estate problems. Housing is scarce and office buildings are empty (or at least under-utilized.) So there would seem to be an obvious solution: turn the offices into homes. And indeed there has been a lot of talk lately about "office-to-resi" conversions. But it's very hard, for a wide variety of reasons. Zoning, financing, and then, of course, the operational aspects of the construction all need to be in place. So what does it take? On this episode, we speak with Joey Chilelli, managing director at the Vanbarton Group, a firm that's been involved with these projects for a decade and long before the pandemic upended both real estate markets. We discuss the challenges involved in actually pulling off these complex projects. * https://omny.fm/shows/odd-lots/what-it-really-takes-to-convert-office-building https://omny.fm/shows/odd-lots/what-it-really-takes-to-conve... * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HNkLcD3PKyk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HNkLcD3PKyk
- burningChrome 3y agoI've only seen one successful project that was able to convert a business office to residential apartments/condos. If I remember correctly, the building had been vacant for a while (it was built in 1986) and the company who bought it got a really good deal and so the conversion was able to happen without having a massive amount to overcome in order to be profitable. The building just had the perfect layout and structure that made it suitable for a conversion. Ironically, the developer filed bankruptcy during the 2008 housing collapse and several other conversions he was aiming to do also went under. Here's some information about the project: Cloud 9 Sky Flats: https://www.homes.com/building/cloud-9-at-sky-flats-minnetonka-mn/psxcc29q9w658/ https://www.homes.com/building/cloud-9-at-sky-flats-minneton... A recent article about one of the condos going up for sale: https://www.startribune.com/corporate-office-turned-condo-in-minnetonka-could-be-yours-for-379000/600360285/#9 https://www.startribune.com/corporate-office-turned-condo-in...
- pydry 3y agoI used to live in one too (not yours). It's weird how often people would tell me that this was infeasible and impossible to do it at all. I also almost bought one that was in a converted school. I'm sure some people could come up with reasons for why that is impossible too. Zoning is the only absolute impediment I can think of and that is a self imposed one.
- EGreg 3y agoYes certainly, now that people have realized they can work from home, the corporate jig is up. Time to convert those offices into more residential buildings!
- giantg2 3y agoThere's lots of stuff in the article about the feasibility of turning the buildings into apartments. But I don't see anything convincing about it saving the downtown. It seems to me that a lot of people who do leave downtown areas are leaving for non-housing issues - lack of services (police), high taxes, bad schools, etc.
- darkwizard42 3y agoI think you might be conflating two issues. Housing in downtown isn't desirable for a populace of people (probably true for those who need more space and/or want to think about issues like schooling etc.) and downtown isn't being used (even for office use). The idea to turn office towers into apartments tries to address the second issue without explicitly trying to solve the first (which is make downtown more desirable to live in).
- giantg2 3y agoI'm not conflating them at all. They are two interdependent variables in the system. Even TFA says that 20% usage of the empty buildings would be extremely optimistic. So you're not going to be even close to solving it by focusing on just the second.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoNope, absurd property-speculation driven tax burdens and chaotic zoning inevitably drive out both residential dwellings and business competition. Cities were traditionally a side-effect of communication hubs, trade collocated with rail/shipping locales, and centralized labor-driven stable factory lines. Communication is now decentralized due to technology changes since the early 90's, trade is now settled with online brokerages/logistics, and factories were either outsourced or moved into more favorable tax districts to maintain competitive posture. Most modern cities are now running unsustainable theme-park service economies. Note municipal districts are never stripped of jurisdictional tax boundaries, and this still holds true even for areas in economic decline due to mismanagement/arrogance. Have a wonderfully awesome day, and I thank god it is not my task to try and fix these issues =) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- gffrd 3y agoTL;DR: No.
- pfdietz 3y agoLarge buildings with controlled ventilation offer the prospect of better control over air composition, in particular reduction of CO2 levels. As CO2 rises this could become very important.
- qwerty456127 3y agoI may be overlooking a downside but it always seemed obvious to me office and apartment buildings should be intermixed. Separating living, shopping and office into different zones always felt strikingly absurd. I am happy to live in a place where it's not the case so my office building is less than 15 minutes walking from my home, as well as a supermarket, a swimming pool, a forest, a university and everything else one can imagine wanting in their life.
- gffrd 3y agoI think the separation happens organically, and is driven by efficiency. The environment needed for maximizing work is often at odds with the environment for maximizing leisure.
- wuyishan 3y ago"maximizing" seems to be the problem here.
- babypuncher 3y agoWell it hurts the efficiency of both when people have to spend 2+ hours of every work day commuting.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoUnless you're in the business of selling gas or cars... Or single family homes with a large yard and a white picket fence 1+ hour outside of the city...
- beretguy 3y agoSeparation does not happen organically. Rich people and governments are in charge of city planning and they make wrong decisions based on making profits. In city where I live some rich dude contributed to our city governor’s campaign or something. Now governor has to “return the favor” by relocating thousands of government employees from downtown area which is close to a lot of people’s homes to outskirts of the city where nobody lives and where that rich dude owns office space for rent. https://www.thestate.com/news/politics-government/article281838213.html https://www.thestate.com/news/politics-government/article281... Wasting hours in traffic every day/week won’t give you any time for leisure.
- tomrod 3y agoSave? Absolutely not. Evolve? Yes.
- vondur 3y agoSadly, it's probably cheaper or a similar cost to tear down the office buildings and just build new residential housing.
- hn_version_0023 3y agoAre we rapidly brushing past the question “do we want and need to save downtowns in the first place?”? I have not really thought that through; at first blush it seems obvious that one would want to save these downtowns. But also some of the best innovations arise out of the creation that follows destruction. I’m open to clarifying opinions on the matter
- tylerFowler 3y agoI do think the simple fact of offering hyper-dense communities (especially in cities that lack them otherwise, like many midwestern cities, say) makes any downtown attractive as a living option to a certain group of people who want the "15 minute city" experience. Doing so tends to transform downtowns into actual communities as well, as opposed to places with many low quality vendors that cater to duller, less personable 9-to-5 routines. And then of course there are knock-on effects to placing people like that (typically young professionals and artists) together like that to rub shoulders, talk about ideas, start businesses etc...
- austin-cheney 3y agoNew growth cities have a supreme advantage here, because they can redistribute prior growth strategies into their current growth models. The faster these newer cities are currently growing the less they will be disrupted by loyalty to prior growth patterns. Older cities are doomed to empty at their cores unless they have something unique and specific that is cause for perseverance. There is no illusion to any of this. Wishful thinking and nostalgia won't fix it. Its just economics. The answers to over coming economic disruption are always the same: be where you are not expected or do that which others cannot.
- tomohawk 3y agoHow would that fix the broken governments, schools, and rampant crime? The cities I live near seem to have no problem attracting young singles and couples. Young urbanites I've worked with have all moved out when (a) they have kids and realize how bad the schools are, (b) when one of them gets mugged, (c) they get married to a non-urbanite, (d) they want local governance that is at least slightly sane.
- flanked-evergl 3y agoIt's insane that so many cities will spare no expense to avoid doing things that actually matter, no amount of resources is spared to ensure serious drug addiction, homelessness and crime runs amok.
- geodel 3y agoHasn't RTO (return-to-office) mandate solved the issue of empty office towers. Other day I read 90% of employers have forced RTO. And for companies with significant downtown real estate they are really aggressive with 100% compliance.
- colechristensen 3y agoNo. There is a bit of a crisis with commercial real estate. Locally there are several stories of large businesses slashing their footprint, say, in half or selling buildings outright.
- geodel 3y agoAh good to now. I was thinking about this and come to conclusion that city govt, builders, employers which are all powerful entities and they all looking to fill office buildings. But I do not see a powerful counterbalancing force on this issue. Because employees are typically on receiving end of this my way or highway policy.
- junto 3y agoIn countries where the news media is largely consolidated, there seems to be a campaign of news articles pro-return-to-work. My assumption is that the overlap in interests between rich connected news and media magnates and commercial property ownership is somewhat aligned. In my opinion we have already crossed the rubicon on this topic and the pandemic caused a paradigm shift that means it’s very hard to put that genie back on the bottle, regardless of how many news articles they write. Organizations are finding it extremely hard to hire if they have an in-office policy. Few people want to lose two hours a day commuting in cities like London and rammed into busy public transport which used to be the case.
- gffrd 3y agoI know many people whose companies have an RTO mandate, and would put themselves in that "90% of employers with forced RTO" group … but where the rubber meets the road, many are not in office and enforcement is more of an unspoken agreement with a manager about being in from time to time. So, public face / private face stuff. Commercial real estate is in a much worse place than they care to say.
- Animats 3y agoThat article says "we're building slums for rich people".
- gwbas1c 3y ago> Although fewer people may want to work in Manhattan, more than enough still want to live there. And if you can live closer to work, there's a better chance you'll want to show up in person instead of telecommute.
- cpursley 3y agoNo, only safe multi-modal infrastructure and improved safety will. Fix that and the highest and best use of properties will sort themselves out.
- bitcharmer 3y agoSave from what exactly? This is phrased as if the current state of affairs where nearly all real estate is owned by investors whose only goal is to milk it for maximum value at the expense of the working class and common people. What exactly do we need to save these down towns again?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tylerFowler 3y agoIt's kind of odd to me (as someone who used to live there at its latest boom time) that nobody talks about Kansas City when it comes to this topic. From the ~70's until the early 2010's Kansas City's downtown was in a similar "doom loop" of crime, undevelopment, decaying historic buildings, etc... In that city 75% of the metro lives in suburbs, drives in to downtown for work and promptly leaves. Until about 2012 or so. Urban redevelopment kicked in, adding (free!) transit, boosting retail, arts district events, a new stadium, and crucially - *massive office to housing conversion projects*. There are tons of success stories like the historic Fidelity Tower at 909 Walnut (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/909_Walnut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/909_Walnut), a huge 35-story tower that sat vacant (creepy) for the better part of a decade and is now home to 159 units. Ditto with the Power & Light Building (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kansas_City_Power_and_Light_Building https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kansas_City_Power_and_Light_Bu...) (36 stories) - largely vacant for the better part of 20 years and now home to nearly 300 units. I could go on, every block has similar projects of 100+ year old buildings of nontrivial sizes that are now super unique apartments. I myself lived in the 30-story Commerce Tower (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Tower) for a while and it was incredibly cheap to do so (~$1100/month for 750sqft 1 bed on the 14th floor), I had a 10 minute commute by foot to my office, it was awesome. Even the more squat, broad midsize banking buildings have had major success with residential conversions. These kinds of conversions have been proven out when there is willpower to do so at the city level - people will move in and prices typically get competitive fast if done at scale. I've lived in SF for 4 years now and I'm convinced its a policy problem not an economic problem.
- tetris11 3y ago> 750sqft 70m2 for anyone wondering
- melenaboija 3y agoI have seen something similar happen in Birmingham, AL while living there since 2015 to 2022.
- RankingMember 3y agoI was under the impression that Kansas City was still in a bit of a dire situation as far as crime is concerned[1], so I appreciate you highlighting some positive developments. In particular, I'm surprised and impressed they made transit free- that's something I experienced in Estonia and thought was an amazing idea considering the cost of policing turnstiles and fare collection itself plus the benefits of people moving around a city via mass transit over individual vehicular traffic. [1]https://realestate.usnews.com/places/rankings/most-dangerous-places https://realestate.usnews.com/places/rankings/most-dangerous...
- indymike 3y agoI've looked at the cost of converting office space to residential, and every time, it was slightly less costly than a tear down and rebuild - and in one case it was a lot more. And that's before you deal with parking. The other issue was taxes: the city would not get the same tax revenue out of the building and wasn't very interested in the project as a result.
- Vvector 3y agocan you explain why parking would be an issue? Typically offices are more people-dense than residential. So converting office to residential should reduce the number of parking spaces needed.
- indymike 3y agoThe ocean of concrete around a typical suburban office building is very expensive to remediate. Downtown buildings often have integrated parking garages which create substantial expense when converting to residential. Also, family residences may actually increase parking demands in downtown properties (i.e. walk/train/etc to work means less demand for spaces then when 2 car families move in). If converting to residential was doable outside of extremely low value/tax incentive properties, every REIT would be converting their poor performing commercial holdings... It's just not simple, easy or rewarding right now.
- Vvector 3y agoCan you explain the "substantial expense" required to convert an office parking garage to a residential parking garage? Typically, office building parking ratio is currently around 4 spots per 1,000 square feet (1). With two people sharing a 750 sqft 1BR apartment, there should be 50% extra parking spaces. (1) https://www.commercialrealestate.loans/commercial-real-estate-glossary/parking-ratio/ https://www.commercialrealestate.loans/commercial-real-estat...
- indymike 3y agoTypical != Local
- throwitaway222 3y agowhy would people want to live there if there are no jobs there
- CodeWriter23 3y agoHow come nobody ever talks about industrializing the suburbs? I live 6 minutes by car from the small scale manufacturing concern where I work. It’s kind of amazing.
- fHr 3y agoreturn to office boomer cto policies are in full swing though
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agowho bought the office towers during covid and wants to sell/repurpose them? ya
- wnc3141 3y ago1) smaller office complexes around the perimeter of downtowns make cheap tear downs while businesses concentrate into most desirable office space. 2) older buildings are more viable for residential conversions, if subsidized into positive economics 3) permit + incentivize residential construction - you'd be surprised how much of typical US downtowns are made up of parking lots/structures which can easily be scraped for housing. Lastly as people do fill into downtowns, that will naturally convert into the ecosystem that serves those people - for all but capital intensive projects which will need to be spearheaded by municipalities and developers alike.
- byronic 3y agohttps://archive.is/Rg8g2 https://archive.is/Rg8g2
- kderbyma 3y agoIt's more than just a density problem. People need to be locally consistent. They need a place that caters to their culture(including the town or city itself - micro culture) - they need a place to hang out with people of like mind, they need hobbies and places to go, they need restaurants, events, parks, quiet places, loud and busy places, areas to connect with nature, areas to focus on business or meet fellow enthusiasts. It's not a numbers game .... it's human emotions and reality. we need hospitals and daycares and public pools, arcades, shops, zoos, heritage sites, pop ups, concerts, etc ... it's more than just walls + plumbing and electrical codes.....
- epolanski 3y agoI don't understand that argument too much. If you turn office towers into apartments, where are people gonna work? May work in some cities that benefit of high tourism or are high status enough (Manhattan, city of London) that you'll always fill them, but it just doesn't scale beyond them. Ain't nobody dreaming about living in downtown Columbus or Cleveland or Detroit. You live there if you work there.
- jimt1234 3y agoI'm not so sure New York City is a valid comparison with other cities (in the US) wrt "downtown" living. NYC has a long, solid history of this kind of living that most other cities just don't have. For example, transportation: NYC is perhaps the only city in the US where you can live a completely full life without a car. Most other cities have developed around cars as the primary transportation method, so if you want to live any sort of normal life, you're probably gonna need a car. If you live on the Upper West side in Manhattan and want to see a friend in Hicksville, Long Island, it's a simple subway/train ride. However, if you live in downtown St. Louis, and you wanna see a friend in Oakville, South County, you're not getting there without a car. And I think most cities in the US are like this - maybe exceptions are San Francisco and Chicago? Maybe?
- bluGill 3y agoThat isn't quite true, but close. Most cities before about 1950 developed just like NYC. However NYC had subways that were not torn out unlike most cities with streetcars that got ripped out. That difference meant that NYC stayed dense in the core, while other cities were forced to become less dense in the core because the residential options didn't work.
- sam0x17 3y agoIt's funny, I've been writing for years that the CRE market is terminally doomed and we might as well turn the skyscrapers into affordable public housing. Refreshing to see this reality leaking into the public consciousness.
- spxneo 3y ago[dead]
- gnabgib 3y agoProjects are underway in Calgary and Halifax; others are being planned or debated in Toronto, London, and Yellowknife. https://ici.radio-canada.ca/rci/en/news/1953973/turning-empty-offices-into-housing-is-a-popular-idea-experts-say-its-easier-said-than-done https://ici.radio-canada.ca/rci/en/news/1953973/turning-empt... Five more downtown Calgary office towers to be converted to residential homes https://globalnews.ca/news/9637005/calgary-office-towers-to-be-converted-homes/ https://globalnews.ca/news/9637005/calgary-office-towers-to-...
- h0l0cube 3y agoI too have been waiting for the inner city CRE market to crash for a long time now, but conversions of skyscrapers are generally impractical for all the reasons listed in this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40292219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40292219 So we might have to wait until it makes economic sense to demolish and rebuild before life returns to the cities
- Ericson2314 3y ago> And, because of zoning reforms, no new building would be allowed to overwhelm a Manhattan street the way the hulking towers of the postwar period did. A developer who constructed a tower the same height as 55 Broad would likely have to sacrifice twenty per cent of the rentable space.
- Ericson2314 3y ago> Residents would be provided with compact HVAC units under certain windows, as in a motel. Sounds like https://vxtwitter.com/GoodGuyGuaranty/status/1757533056276046268 https://vxtwitter.com/GoodGuyGuaranty/status/175753305627604...
- mvkel 3y agoNon-starter due to fundamental differences in slab between commercial and residential. Not financially feasible to convert
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- Refusing23 3y agoTurning office buildings into apartments or small businesses (or both) could be a good solution. there's a severe lack of housing in a lot of cities in many countries
- Bluescreenbuddy 3y agoNo because it's very hard and costly to do so and even then the units have to meet habitability requirements.