24 ms·
The Apple Vision Pro’s missing apps
- tiahura 3y agoThat’s some of the most fact-free pontificating I’ve ever read.
- apples_oranges 3y agoI bought a Meta Quest 3 and it also seems to miss apps that were there before on the Oculus Rift a few years back.. at least I recall having a Google Earth app, now I can't find it.
- cableshaft 3y agoBecause Google never updated the app to support the Quest or released it on the Quest store, which is a different store than the Rift, and probably has different requirements. You could try the Wooorld or Wander apps, though, as alternatives, which are on the Quest store. Good example, though.
- PaulHoule 3y agoYou can use the MQ3 as a PCVR headset by plugging in a very fast USB 3 cable and in that case you can use the Rift version on the Quest to run Google Earth. I was also looking at this model https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/m2020-zcam-bettys-rock-sol-498-6b91dfe3d99447a4af3f4d3ef5798d93 https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/m2020-zcam-bettys-rock-sol-4... which I am about to publish in an A-Frame world.
- cableshaft 3y agoI know you can use a Quest Link cable to play some things on the PC store and almost included it, but I didn't see Quest on the supported platforms for the store page and assumed it needed to be on there explicitly if it was going to work. I'm now cross-referencing it with Lone Echo, which I know works on Quest 2 and 3 since I played it recently, and it also only says Rift and Rift S for supported platforms, so yeah Google Earth probably still works on Quest 3 via a Link cable, especially since it still has new reviews as of January 2024 on there. Haven't tried it myself though.
- TiredOfLife 3y agoYou can use Quest Link or Steam link to play all pc VR stuff on Quest.
- alberth 3y agoThis might be Apple's first product launch in 20-years that doesn't solve a customer problem/need (at time of launch).
- wateralien 3y agoWhat problem did Apple Watch solve?
- steveBK123 3y agoThe ability to tell time while giving Apple more money?
- zitterbewegung 3y agoHigh fidelity fitness tracking for workouts and data collection of your own personal health.
- asylteltine 3y ago[dead]
- robterrell 3y agoThe first watch wasn't that -- I think Apple Watch 3 first really delivered on this.
- mafuyu 3y agoThe first couple AW gens didn’t really have much of a fitness angle, though. The hardware and software for health tracking was very lacking. It was only later on that they pivoted hard on fitness and did a big marketing push with the “three rings”.
- rahoulb 3y agoWhile it did some fitness tracking (especially the heart rate stuff which couldn't be done with a phone), it certainly wasn't promoted as a fitness device. There was all that stuff about "connecting" (where you could send doodles and heartbeats to your Apple Watch wearing friends) and they made a big deal about watch apps and notification management. And of course the "luxury watch" aspect (gold watches that go out of date in a couple of years - sheesh). It's only after a couple of iterations that Apple doubled down on the fitness side of things.
- post_break 3y agoI have a VR headset, I think it's amazing. The game play is incredible, it's like the Wii all over again but so much more immersive. I will never watch a full movie from start to finish due to discomfort. It's just not worth it. Unless they made the Vision Pro like the Bigscreen headset I won't be in the minority.
- mtmail 3y agoI've read the tweet people will start using VR headsets on airplanes. Is that realistic? I mean due to size of the battery, size of the whole device (on your backpack or such), comfort etc?
- sroussey 3y agoI think the xreal is more likely. It’s way smaller and can connect to laptop or phone.
- escapecharacter 3y agoI was using the Gear VR on planes in 2015/2016 and it rocked!
- Philpax 3y agoI've watched movies for ten hours with a VR headset on a flight, only stopping for food and bathroom breaks. The AVP should comfortably tackle all the issues I had with that (rear-mounted battery, resolution, facial interface comfort, controllers, tracking), and I'm looking forward to taking it on my next flight :-)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shmatt 3y ago>There are, to be sure, valid business reasons for all three services to have not built a native app; the latest prediction from Apple supply chain analyst Ming-Chi Kuo put first-year sales at around 500,000 units, which as a tiny percentage of these services’ user bases may not be worth the investment Except for the fact the iPhone users spend 7x more on apps than Android users[1]. And it would be safe to assume Vision Pro users are on the higher end of having extra money to spend. Apple has made a clear definition for "Rich AF" iOS users and app makers are trying to look the other way? Their loss. Hell, even having a list of iPhone users that pre-ordered the Vision Pro is worth targeting $$$$ [1] https://9to5mac.com/2023/09/06/iphone-users-spend-apps/ https://9to5mac.com/2023/09/06/iphone-users-spend-apps/
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Except for the fact the iPhone users spend 7x more on apps than Android users[1]. Sure, but rich people with frivolous spending habits are a finite resource. After a while you run out of rich people you can monetize so your growth slows to a crawl. Who is richer? Toyota or Porsche?
- shmatt 3y agoFrom that same article it was 650 million active iphone users vs. 2.5 billion android I think Apple is *very* happy to be Porsche in this story
- anileated 3y ago> After a while you run out of rich people you can monetize so your growth slows to a crawl. Neat trick: create an ecosystem that genuinely helps your users live well & prosper, increasing their wealth so they can spend more money. It’s a circle of something!
- jitl 3y agoToyota has about 4x the profit per second compared to Porsche, but at 36,996 employees compared to Toyota’s 375,235, I think I would rather try to build a Porsche shaped business which seems more sustainable and obtainable.
- Erratic6576 3y agoAll that I want is Google Earth on VR. I’ve been waiting for years but I don’t know which headset to buy. Sadly, Meta is a no-no for me
- dandrew5 3y agoSame. I bought a Vive a few weeks ago but it is currently in the mail being returned. The technology as it is today is just not quite there yet, in my opinion. The biggest letdown was the lack of peripheral vision. To see something clearly, I'd have to move my whole head to face it head-on directly. Doing some research, I discovered that is just the way it works right now. It will be interesting to see if the VP has an answer to this problem.
- chaostheory 3y agoVive is the worst option because they insist on using bad fresnel lenses instead of fish eye lenses. As you’ve pointed out, fresnel lenses tend to be terrible and HTC’s are the worst in that class. The Big Screen Beyond is really the only affordable choice for PCVR that isn’t out of date and isn’t Meta.
- copirate 3y agoThere is one[0] that works on all PCVR headsets and it's great, but unfortunately it's been abandoned by Google. [0] https://store.steampowered.com/app/348250/Google_Earth_VR/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/348250/Google_Earth_VR/
- Erratic6576 3y agoLast update in February 2018. Can’t blame them; they must be short of cash
- chaostheory 3y agoMeta is still the best all round value. If you refuse to go with it, then the next best option is the big screen beyond. Total cost would likely run $1500 with controllers, assuming you have a VR capable PC
- nxobject 3y agoThe article ends on an interesting note - another Apple/Disney partnership. The two companies have always had an interestingly close relationship…
- piconanomicro 3y agoDisney hasn't been doing so well content wise so I don't think such a partnership would matter much. After the last Avengers movie and the unsuccessful star wars trilogy, no-one really cares about disney IP anymore.
- steveBK123 3y agoI don't think Steve Jobs would have launched this product. Apparently the main use case Om sees this is replacing the family TV in the living room? To me it seems to be pushing people to retreat further into isolation.
- shmatt 3y agoThe sales numbers so far are pretty much on par with the iPhone 1, which wasn't that great a product either with no app store or 3g connectivity
- steveBK123 3y agoIt's going to be a typical new category release for Apple where v1 has some very obvious flaws that prevent it from mass market penetration, which quickly get cleaned up in v2. But I'm talking more like culturally / philosophically, I don't think Steve Jobs would have marketed it this way or wanted it framed this way. To that point I'm not sure he'd have green lighted the product at all. It can be very dystopian. The silly eyes thing seems like someone along the way realized that and is trying to mitigate it poorly.
- al_borland 3y agoI had an iPhone on launch day. Compared to phones of today it wasn’t great, but compared to some of the phones it was replacing, it was fantastic. I was coming from a Moto Razr, so it was pretty much better in every way. For the smart phones of the day, there were a lot of things they could technically do on paper, but no one did, because they were too clunky to use. The iPhone solved this. The features it did have were a joy to use and easy to figure out and discover. There were also some pretty easy jailbreaks after not too long, which allowed for 3rd party apps before Apple had an official store. I think the only things holding back the original iPhone were the price and production volume. As I remember, it sold out quickly. And everywhere I went people were every interested in it. The guys selling cell phones at the mall were trying to stop me to see it, a girl at the bar said having that was better than a puppy. Pulling it out to use it was like being a celebrity, everyone started paying attention and trying to get close to it; it was a very strange time. I don’t recall anyone saying they didn’t want it due to a lack of features, other than people online looking for clicks or who had a history of Apple criticism.
- strict9 3y agoMuch of this discussion is centered on how the headset will replace theaters and TV. I may be an outlier but in our house the only time we watch shows or movies is a social context--usually Friday or Saturday nights as a family. I'm struggling to see how the headset could replace what is in my experience a mostly social activity. Will it ever be comfortable enough for the binge watcher to watch it all day? I have my doubts. I think it will be a coexistence and replacement of flat screens will be a very long time away.
- curiouscavalier 3y agoI'm in the same boat. The idea of everyone watching TV in isolation defeats the purpose for me. Even (maybe especially) for sports, where for large swaths of a game it is essentially background content to a cultural gathering. Not to mention issues around comfort and battery life.
- SquareWheel 3y agoFor you, VR likely wouldn't be able to replace that social context. However for those kilometers apart, it might allow them to simulate it. See for example Big Screen[1] which lets you enjoy a group watching experience. It might not be as good as sharing real popcorn, but it can be a surprisingly convincing imitation. [1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/457550/Bigscreen_Beta/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/457550/Bigscreen_Beta/
- 3y ago
- zitterbewegung 3y agoThere is a tweet reference by the Author that "Apple can’t convince streaming video companies to check the “allow iPad app” box." If you saw what happened to the music companies and you are big enough you can get around all of the nonsense that Apple can leverage against you why do what apple wants?
- PaulHoule 3y agoIf people are still talking about the AVP in six months then Netflix can tick that box or they can port the Netflix VR app which already exists on Meta Quest to the AVP.
- Philpax 3y agoThey haven't touched that app in years, and it's not very good. I'd prefer they enabled using the iPad version over using that app - at least I'd be able to use Apple's window placement for the video!
- PaulHoule 3y ago(1) All of these video apps, including Netflix, are on Meta Quest, which makes it all the more of a snub. (It's a dirty little secret that apps are highly portable between VR and AR headsets because they are almost all written in Unity anyway) (2) If you're thinking about buying an AVP and not thinking about buying an MQ3 at 1/7 the price you're not thinking or at least you're not an technology enthusiast you're an Apple enthusiast. (3) So far all the video apps (not to mention remote desktop apps like Immersed) I've seen have a poor user interface for situating and controlling the virtual screens. It doesn't seem like an insurmountable problem but it's somewhat startling that it hasn't been addressed. Maybe AVP will point the way to something better. (4) I tried the "VR camera" view of NBA games on Xtadium. I've lately taken a shine to sitting in the front row at college games (Newman Auditorium is rarely full so usually I can sit courtside with a $8 ticket) so the "courtside view" was appealing to me but: (a) my 20Mbps DSL connection is not slow enough to support it (though every normal streaming service works fine) and (b) the perception of space around the camera is really strange. I just can't say it is really any better than watching an NBA game on an ordinary TV. Once you get your AVP (or if you "think different" and get an MQ3) you will realize there are some troubles when you try to synthesize views out of multiple cameras in different spots and even a camera like https://us.kandaovr.com/products/obsidian-pro https://us.kandaovr.com/products/obsidian-pro that shoots great pano video will get strange results when people get close. The problems I am having w/ it have to do with the network and camera so I don't see it being better on AVP.
- Kerrick 3y ago“If you’re thinking about buying an iPod and not thinking about buying a Sansa Clip at 1/6 the price you're not thinking or at least you're not an music enthusiast you're an Apple enthusiast.“
- neogodless 3y agoAs someone who loved his $10 Sansa Clip and never owned an iPod Shuffle, you make a good point. There was no point in the iPod Shuffle, except for Apple enthusiasts.
- 3y ago
- lapcat 3y ago> The iTunes Music Store does still exist, although its revenue contribution to the labels has long been eclipsed by streaming. It’s more important contribution to modern computing is that it provided the foundation for the App Store. I'm glad that Ben mentioned this. I discussed it at length in my own blog post "App Store is neither console nor retail but jukebox": https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/jukebox.html https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/jukebox.html The App Store was a carbon copy of the iTunes Music Store, thrown together very quickly, as shown in evidence and testimony from the Epic trial, but a store for selling 99 cent songs is an extremely bad fit for selling computer software. A lot of the problems with the App Store today stem from its origins in the iTunes Music Store, and unfortunately Apple has done very little to reshape the App Store to be more suitable for software. As a software developer myself, I have very little interest in Vision Pro right now. One major problem, especially for indie developers of paid apps, is that customers have come to expect free support for new platforms. Last month I finally gave in and made my Mac and iOS apps a universal purchase instead of separate purchases, but to me it's ridiculous to give away a new version for free on Vision Pro when consumers are giving $3500+ to Apple for a new device. Consumers are resentful if they have to give third-party developers any extra money. The level of consumer entitlement for free software is over the top. Apple gets to make all the money from expensive hardware, and we're supposed to be indentured servants supporting any and all new Apple hardware for no profit.
- pm 3y agoConsumers find it easy to justify a hardware purchase: it's tangible, and save for requiring an electrical outlet (which is ubiquitous in our society), runs anywhere. Software is, in some regards, intangible, and is constrained to certain platforms. It makes it easier to dismiss, even though it's no less work to make great software.
- skydhash 3y agoAnd that has not been helped by freemium and ads supported platforms. When I first got into computing (around windows XP SP2) if something was free and not open source, it was viewed with suspicions. Piracy was rampant, but they’re already not your market. It’s easy to buy software when it’s fulfilling a real need.
- sub7 3y agoIf businesses don't buy these in bulk, this will be an Apple Newton v2. Likely to be uncomfortable/look stupid and be stupidly overpriced as well for what you get. I'm sure Apple is in a much better position than in the mid 90s so they can probably absorb bad sales and these headsets will shrink down soon enough and get killer apps and get cheaper so the real question is who's going to build the Android of VR and take the non-walled garden market?
- PaulHoule 3y agoMeta Quest. It even runs on Android. For that matter, so does Magic Leap 2. If they deign to do so all the "usual suspects" who make Android phones could make Android-based VR headsets. As much as the media has been obsessed with the train wreck that is Horizon Worlds, it's a well kept secret that Meta Quest has an app store that works like the app store on a game console. You can even sideload phone, tablet and TV apps and they "just work" most of the time. There is no working "metaverse" and even meaningful multiplayer games are thin on the ground, but no shortage of good single-player games and what I'd call game-adjacent apps. It's little recognized that XR apps are highly portable because they are almost always based on portable frameworks like Unity. In fact, just about every XR headset supports WebXR which makes it outright easy to make web-based virtual worlds https://aframe.io/ https://aframe.io/ these work with desktop, phones and tablets as well as most of the AR and VR headsets. All it takes is that you "think different" and choose to live life outside the app store.
- jitl 3y ago> If businesses don't buy these in bulk When was the last time Apple’s success depended on business bulk purchase? Apple didn’t become the highest market cap company in the world selling expensive phones to businesses in bulk orders.
- junipertea 3y agoDoesn’t meta quest literally run on android?
- righthand 3y agoLuckily the fanatics don’t care about looking stupid as proven with the wireless ear buds. There’s also probably a large enough fanatic culture where this will be a niche product for a generation or two. While they claim it’s the best selling headset or something.
- ewzimm 3y agoAs great as the hardware seems, the Quest 3's support of basically every Android app ever made plus native apps plus PCVR apps which are free with the purchase of their native Quest counterpart makes it much more appealing to me. Now that they seem to be adding native support for converting Apple's spacial video, I'm having a hard time seeing any advantage other than increased clarity that I would get from moving from a Quest 3 to a Vision Pro right now, but like everyone else, I'm eager to see what they do for the next iteration. Seems like a great dev tool for now.
- dpkonofa 3y agoThere is a non-insignificant number of people that would never buy or use a Meta product because of their data and privacy issues. The Quest 3 is nowhere close to the AVP simply because of that.
- ewzimm 3y agoI respect that point of view, but Meta has over 3 billion monthly active users. This is a large enough potential customer base for any product. I also find the privacy options on the Quest perfectly adequate, and I'm curious if there's any specific option you feel is missing or if it's just their tarnished brand reputation that causes the lack of trust.
- MikusR 3y agoOut of Apple and Meta only one company keeps user data on servers freely accesed by a dictatorship. And it's not Meta.
- Philpax 3y agoHow do you get those Android apps without sideloading? How do you find them? How do you participate in the wider Android ecosystem? The AVP has a much stronger OS and software ecosystem play; you can just download and use your regular iOS apps, and multitask with ease in a variety of scenarios. I want the Quest 3 to be able to compete with that, but it's not there yet. Perhaps Google and Samsung will be able to pull it together for their take?
- no1youknowz 3y agoOne use case this would immediately solve for me. Is travel. When I travel I'm usually in an airbnb, hotel room or temporary rented apartment for months at a time. Usually I may not even have a desk or a tiny one in the corner. Having the ability to increase my area of productivity via this device from a 14"/16" laptop. Intrigues me quite a bit. However, the current weight factor and fov (rumoured 100deg) puts me off right now. Should apple do something similar (or another competitor) like the big screen beyond and 210 deg (starvr) with a much later iteration. The value proposition for me would make it an instant purchase. I'm more than happy to sit this round out. But the new product segment is something that I and probably many people are interested in. I know Apple will innovate and more importantly push the whole industry forward. I'm watching and waiting with interest!
- simiones 3y agoEven for travel, most people travel in groups, even those who live alone or with non-friends. So, media consumption while traveling is even less likely to be happening alone (except on the plane) than at home. I'm not saying your own use-case is invalid. But it doesn't sound like a good strategy for Apple.
- threeseed 3y ago> Even for travel, most people travel in groups For ordinary travellers, sure. But there is a lot of business travel where people are flying just for a day or two for sales meetings etc. And given they power frequent flyer programs clearly there are a lot of them. Having done many such flights I would much rather a Vision Pro than a cheap LCD hotel room TV.
- sf_rob 3y agoI agree. Granted it's out of my price range for the time being, but a device to make a plane more bearable while giving me a screen that doesn't require craning my neck on the other side would be a huge deal.
- joshstrange 3y agoMy #1 use case for the AVP I ordered is productivity followed by consumption. If I can get my MBP as a large 4K screen in the AVP and I'm productive in it then I can do away with my 3-4 monitor setup I have at 2 locations and open up the places I can work productively to nearly anywhere.
- sschueller 3y agoIt's too heavy for prolonged use so although the work features are very interesting this seems to kill it as a replacement for a multi monitor setup.
- joshstrange 3y agoEhh, you can get used to almost anything. People complained about the weight of the AirPods Max but there are plenty of people who use them all the time/all day. I think any discomfort with be temporarily and worth "powering through", or at least that's my hope. I'm probably going to be wearing my 8hrs a day as soon as I get it and if it doesn't work or if the productivity isn't worth it (and/or the consumption isn't breathtaking) I'll consider returning it for sure.
- chaostheory 3y agoIMO you need to try it first. Headsets are too personal for a “one to rule them all” model. The Quest Pro is one of the most comfortable headsets that I’ve ever used and it weighs 100g more than the Apple Vision Pro
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt's not the weight, it's the balance. The MQ3 plus the elite strap weighs more than the AVP by quite a bit and I did some 5+ hours days playing Asgard's Wrath 2 over the Christmas break easily though I did take breaks to recharge myself and the headset.
- chaostheory 3y ago
- codeulike 3y agoWe could replace those with a singular, more personal screen — that will sit on our face Its not going to happen. Strapping something to your face is fun for a little while but its not going to become the primary means of doing _anything_. It's just damn uncomfortable, no matter how light and expensive you make it.
- xixixao 3y agoCannot upvote enough. I had the first Rift, Quest 1, I have a Quest Pro: the experience is always a short-term novelty.
- Fluorescence 3y agoYup. I just want to fast-forward through the "omg this changes everything" hype articles from first time VR users in the grip of peak novelty euphoria and get to the "I've not touched my AVP for 6 months" dehype phase. I enjoy VR but I feel really done with headsets. I find them more irritating to wear than covid masks and look how folk feel about those. Itchy sweaty forehead, dig into your cheeks, head straps messing your hair, can't lie down on your side, scuba face when you take it off. Once the genuinely awesome experiences get old and passe, it becomes pretty tiresome.
- dpkonofa 3y agoYou do realize that billions of people wear glasses all day, right?
- tempaway14751 3y agoIts not the same. Glasses perch on your nose. VR headsets have to have the edges pushed up against your skin to avoid light bleeding in from outside. Its great for thirty minutes or so but mainstream consumers are not ever going to use these headsets as the primary means of watching movies or bingeing on boxsets.
- dpkonofa 3y ago
- tptacek 3y agoI read most of this, and it's interesting, but carrots-and-sticks aside, is it not possible that nobody is doing native apps for this thing simply because it's a $3500 product in an entirely new category that (to a first approximation) nobody owns or will own in 2024, and that could vanish from the market in a year or two if there's no uptake?
- tomjakubowski 3y agoApple still has a lotto' cash. Maybe enough to keep the product line going without much initial uptake.
- tptacek 3y agoAbsolutely. But why would Netflix rush to get a native app for a platform that 0.007% (I looked this up!) of their customers use?
- realusername 3y agoIt's even worse than that, this product is additional to smartphones or computers and by not supporting it you aren't even losing a single customer since they have other main devices.
- tptacek 3y agoThey can also still watch Netflix on the headset with the browser!
- arielweisberg 3y agoI think the main pain point is going to be that you can't download content to watch on a plane. I checked and I can't do that in MacOS Safari.
- sleepybrett 3y agoWell I think there is also the 'what does a netflix app look like in vr and specifically vision pro' to contend with. Sure they could cross compile the current app and I assume you'd have a rectangle with the current ipad interface floating in the middle of your vision... not very exciting. The disney app with native 3d movie support is exciting, i haven't read the description enough to say if they place the screen in an environment or if you have the ability to just 'stick it in a window' off to the side of a web browsing session or what. I've played around a bit with a Valve Index and various virtual desktop software. There is something there. Most of them allow you to put app windows all around your 3d bubble etc. I have yet to see anyone talk about actual productivity software on the vision pro. A couple of videos of people browsing photos etc. But what does xcode look like, how does it change, is the pixel density high enough to code on. As someone who has done a lot of multiweek on-site trips where I spend a lot of time pounding out code on a laptop with no extra monitors in a hotel room, being able to have virtual multi monitors has some appeal.
- bparsons 3y agoThe iPhone is a pro-social technology, enabling, at least in a virtual sense, for you to connect with people through the interface. You can argue whether it has reduced a lot of in-person socialization, but the function remains the same. This VR stuff is completely anti-social. It is a dystopian vision of the future where your sensory system is sealed off from the world, controlled entirely by corporate entities. There is a reason that it has not taken off yet-- nobody other than the tech executives want it to succeed.
- chaostheory 3y ago1. You can do the same thing in VR. Many VR apps are online and multiuser with voice 2. VR’s higher immersion makes #1 more appealing. I regularly play ping pong with relatives who live thousands of miles away. Mini golf and bowling are also popular options. The immersion also makes it easier to interact with multiple people at the same time compared to a phone. 3. We’re already transitioning to mixed reality You really need to at least try a modern VR headset for yourself before coming to a strong conclusion.
- rpmisms 3y agoThe real question isn't being asked: will it be good for porn? I think it probably will, so it'll likely see tons of usage.
- becquerel 3y agoThe Quest 3 is pretty admirable for that purpose. The resolution of the Vision Pro will probably make the experience a little better, but not significantly so. You're still going to be bottlenecked by the quality of the content itself.
- rpmisms 3y agoDepends on if the Vision Pro can record well enough to seem lifelike. If it can do both, it will absolutely take off.
- becquerel 3y agoAh, for amateur content creation people will probably be using the newer iPhones, no? A focus of Apple's marketing has been 'record 3d video on your phone, play it back on the headset'.
- crazygringo 3y ago> It’s certainly possible that I’m reading too much into these absences: maybe these three companies simply didn’t get enough Visions Pro to build a native app, and felt uncomfortable releasing their iPad versions without knowing how useful they would be. I think it's just that simple. It's a low-volume device for now that doesn't justify native apps. Even enabling the iPad app requires testing and, likely, modifications. It's quite possible the Netflix web experience is better than the Netflix iPad app. Apps are probably not going to come out until Apple releases a lower-cost Vision for the masses.
- lukeschlather 3y agoAlso given how draconian Apple is around NDAs and app store terms, I wouldn't be surprised if the companies read the terms and decided "we will wait until the legal/business side of this is as simple as developing for iOS." Only getting one headset and being required to pay $3500 is annoying, but Apple also imposes a lot of soft costs for this kind of prelaunch hardware.
- dragon-hn 3y agoApple was giving out pre release devices to partners that they really wanted to be ready for launch. All 3 of these companies could have had hardware well ahead of launch.
- spcebar 3y agoSome thoughts. YouTube and Spotify not having an app at launch is really surprising to me, more surprising than Netflix. Could well be a case of "we'll wait and see before we sink money into a native app," and I don't think YouTube, Spotify, and Netflix are the killer apps that will sell the Vision, but a surprise nonetheless. I think the vision of the Vision is what's going to sell the Vision. First to really wealthy people, and then, if and only if the price comes down _dramatically_, to those wealthy people's friends who see it and think it's cool/useful. The part in the beginning of the article... > If you live in Asia, like you live in Taiwan, people don’t have big homes, they don’t have 85-inch screen televisions. Plus, you have six, seven, eight people living in the same house, they don’t get screen time to watch things so they watch everything on their phone. I think you see that behavior and you see this is going to be the iPod. ...isn't very compelling to me, because, at this price point, someone who has to live in a house with 8 people isn't going to be able to afford the Vision. Maybe the Vision will prove the use case and create an industry of knockoff competitors, but I don't know. Personally, I'd rather watch a movie on my phone than have a headset on for 2 hours at a time, completely blocking out the outside world. Later in the article... > with a VR camera at every game it televises would, in my estimation, make the Vision Pro an essential purchase for every sports fan. ... That's a bold prediction. Are sports fans bullish enough on VR, or primed to be primed to become bullish on VR, to want to watch games on a headset? The 8 people in the house, with users already watching on their phones, situation doesn't seem to apply here, and "watching the game" is itself often a social experience, which would preclude shutting yourself away in a headset. All of the discussion of streaming service buy-in is muddled somewhat by the state of flux the streaming industry is in right there. There's been a lot of consolidation in the last few years and the business models of streaming are changing. Building a device on the current landscape of streaming seems like a risky idea to me at the moment. They should really put a DVD player in the Vision just to be safe /s. All of this kind of assumes what the primary use case for the Vision will be. We don't know yet exactly what consumer adoption and acceptance is going to look like, whether it be a media consumption platform, a productivity platform, a gaming platform, or a combination of the three and more. I still have low expectations for the Vision, but if anyone can sell and normalize a new technology it's Apple. We'll see.
- dclowd9901 3y agoDid anyone see any of the tv ads for this thing yet? I don’t think they make this thing look appealing. It comes off as dystopian and creepy.
- idopmstuff 3y agoI think this whole thing is fairly overwrought - after all, the iPhone launched with zero third party apps (maybe there were a few, but I don't recall that being the case). Given the volume of VP sales, it feels more like a production-ready dev kit and tool for enthusiasts. It's really the version that people will use to build apps on, so that v2, v3, etc., which will be lighter/cheaper/whatever else is needed to make them more mass-market, won't have the same problem when they launch. If you're Netflix et al, why support the VP now? Even if it's just checking a box, it still means you'll get some support load. You'll also have to make some design and implementation decisions that will be less-informed than if you wait a while and see what other apps are doing on there. At the end of the day, is having Netflix on the VP going to generate any incremental revenue? Tough to imagine that everybody buying it doesn't already have a Netflix subscription. Building for it right now is zero upside and some downside. We'll see a Netflix app eventually, though.
- jandrese 3y agoThe iPhone was even worse, it launched without support for third party apps. Steve Jobs said that web apps would take their place. The original iPhone was also overpriced and underspecced in some areas and forced you on a crappy phone provider, but it had a significant price drop shortly after release and the iPhone 3G fixed most of the performance issues (mostly around the slow cell modem). Plus Apple released the app store and it was an enormous success, far more than the existing app stores on the Symbian phones.
- idopmstuff 3y agoIs that right? Man, did not recall that... funny how the state of apps today has colored my recollection.
- mandeepj 3y ago> Is that right? Absolutely! I also remember those chain of events exactly that way. They are also documented in Steve Jobs biography as well.
- 3y ago
- wahnfrieden 3y agoDon’t forget that visionOS 2.0 is about 18 weeks away
- cowboyscott 3y agoSo much spilled ink reading tea leaves, i.e., tortured historical analogies. We have market data on existing headset efforts, and we will have data on the adoption of the Vision Pro very soon. I'm not sure who this analysis benefits other than firms catering to day traders.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- helpfulContrib 3y agoI have multiple Macs in my house, a couple iPads and tons of iPhones .. what I really want more than anything is to be able to access any/all of them with virtual screens. If Vision Pro provides this experience - seamless displays of all devices on a single headset - then that is the point where I immediately invest. I'm too old for 3D games, they make me puke. But if I can sit comfortably in a lounge chair with this thing strapped to my noggin and access all the machines in my house, for work (code), then I'm sold.
- jumploops 3y agoIsn’t traditional streaming kinda missing the point of this device? Consuming traditional 2D content is like using a PS2 to watch DVDs, sure it’s possible, but is that really the target market?
- MikusR 3y agoYou have a 150" screen at home? With VR devices you do.
- jumploops 3y agoAccording to ChatGPT, my 34" widescreen monitor is equivalent to a 340" TV at 10ft away. So, yes(?), however I certainly don't like watching movies at my desk. I may or may not feel the same way about the Vision Pro. Time will tell! Now it would be great if I could sit in a "theatre" with others, let's say my family, thousands of miles away. We could shadow cast, Rocky Horror style, in real-time.
- michael1999 3y agoApple is at its best when serving me, and building software like Safari that protects me from predatory conglomerates like Google. Apple is at its worst when acting like a predatory conglomerate itself, shoving crappy payola recommendations in Music, and squeezing the app store as a revenue-maximizing monster. Netflix would be crazy to spend a penny supporting Apple in any kind of new-media venture. I'd love to see an anti-trust breakup of the media side of Apple from the systems + hardware side.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- swozey 3y agoNot having controllers is absolutely ridiculous with this. I know it's focused more on AR, but what, can you not plug it into steam and use it in an FPS? What would you do, make finger pointy gun gestures? Is it only Apple Store apps and they're going to not allow anything like that? My friend wants to buy one and use his Xbox controller. Just stupid. I have 3 VR systems. Vive, Q2, Q3.. I have Skyrim installs with 300-500 mods, Assetto Corso with my racing sim wheel/seat. How am I doing any of that with this? How do I swing a sword? My Q3 supports hand gestures. They're nice when using virtual desktop sort of things, but in a game? no way. No tactical feedback sucks.
- Philpax 3y agoIt's not really for "traditional" VR gaming. The Quest is a console; the VP is a computer you can work on, with an OS designed for it. (I own six VR headsets and have an AVP on the way.) I love gaming and would like Apple to support it more, but it's not the reason I'm interested in the AVP. They're looking into it [0], but it's just not that relevant to them right now, and that's OK. [0]: https://www.roadtovr.com/apple-vision-pro-xr-controller-patent/ https://www.roadtovr.com/apple-vision-pro-xr-controller-pate...
- swozey 3y agoDo you have a specific use case in mind or are you going to get it and figure out how you'd like to use it? I'm sure it'll be great for AR stuff like training people in surgery and things of that nature. AR in education will be amazing, being able to walk through Rome, etc in History classes.
- Philpax 3y agoMovie watching (I've been holding off on watching Dune for this!), general-purpose computer-y stuff (browsing, writing, media consumption, etc), game streaming, using it as a larger display for a MBP, seeing what people build, and (maybe) building some things myself. In general, I want to treat it like an iPad / MBP hybrid with enormous virtual screens that I can take around with me. There's a lot of potential for what could be built (especially with the AR stuff you mention), but having access to the majority of the iPad ecosystem, MBP mirroring, and other miscellaneous features already makes it an enticing device to me.
- nottorp 3y agoAre they shipping the thingamajigs yet? The hype seems to have died completely.
- nefarious_ends 3y ago[flagged]
- jedberg 3y agoI think the premise of this article is flawed. It will not hurt Netflix or YouTube or Spotify's business one bit to not have a native app. It's not like they will be locked out of the platform. The web experience exists and is good enough. However, it also costs those company nothing for development because it's already there. Even converting the iPad app would take development, testing, and adding extra QA cycles to every release thereafter. This way those companies can get great data on which customers actually have a headset and how many and how much they pay now (because everyone will probably try it at least once). Then they can make a data driven decision on if there are enough customers to justify the expense of dev and maintenance. The consensus estimate is that they sold 200,000 units. That is nothing in terms of customers, even if every one of them has a Netflix subscription. Apple had such low sales expectations that they opened up Vision Pro for employee discount before the launch. Usually employees don't get a discount until 4-5 months after launch after interest has died down. This decision does not signal that those companies don't believe in Vision Pro -- it signals that they want to wait until there are enough users to justify it since everyone already has access to their product on Vision Pro.
- pwthornton 3y agoI think this is 100% it for many companies. Predictions are Apple sells in the hundreds of thousands of units this year. There is no market any of these companies/products care about that has that small of a user base. Once Apple starts selling millions of these, and the demand is there from users, we will see companies change their tune. Spotify, in particular, doesn't make that much sense. Even amongst Apple Vision Pro users, I would be surprised if music listening is a big use case for this device. All of these users will already have their phones and other devices to listen on. There is nothing about the Vision Pro that is particularly good for music. Video, however, may be something the Vision Pro does exceedingly well.
- Philpax 3y ago> Even amongst Apple Vision Pro users, I would be surprised if music listening is a big use case for this device. All of these users will already have their phones and other devices to listen on. The main application would be to listen to music alongside whatever else you're already doing, similar to using Spotify on any other kind of computer. I'll begrudgingly use the website, but I'd prefer to have a native app. > There is nothing about the Vision Pro that is particularly good for music. I am curious about the spatial audio solution, especially as it's integrated with all of the other environmental sensing (i.e. the audio can "bounce" around your room). I have a quadraphonic mix of Dark Side of the Moon that I'm looking forward to listening to :-)
- gigel82 3y agoIt's surprising Apple went ahead and released this product that will 100% be a flop in the market. Many hoped Apple would have the "killer feature/app" that would make AR/VR relevant, but instead they launched yet another uncomfortable doodad: 8 years after HoloLens, at the same price, and only marginally smaller, with the same exact number of killer apps - zero!.
- hendersoon 3y agoThe real problem isn't that giant companies aren't supporting the Vision Pro with AR-capable innovative apps. The real problem is they aren't even releasing their existing iPad apps with the "works on Vision Pro" flag checked.
- aksss 3y agoI just want glasses that will give me a solidly good experience of one >= 27” monitor (or more), ideally dual 32”, for remote and airplane work on text based content. Wake me up when that happens.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SigmundA 3y agoFeel like a mistake that Apple makes dev opt in/out to iPad app support, same issue on M-series Macs there are iPad app that just don't show up in the app store on Mac because the dev didn't check the box to allow it. They could perhaps warn that the app isn't tested for the device but otherwise allow all iPad apps on Vision Pro and Mac's.
- karaterobot 3y agoI don't see the use case for Vision Pro being watching TV or movies. A lot (most?) people watch while doing other things, and many do it with someone else in the room. Are a husband and wife each going to have separate Apple Vision Pro headsets, put them on, and watch TV side by side in a virtual space? It's hard to imagine this. The use case I like is working by myself in VR—being able to take a fast computer and large display with me on the road. As a remote worker, I can theoretically work from anywhere, but in practice I miss my 35" monitor, and can't effectively change my workflow to swap in a 13" laptop screen instead. But with the Vision, I could have everything, for one high price, and it's appealing enough that I've at least thought about trying it.
- iteratethis 3y agoI think "really great TV" isn't good enough for mass appeal. I think even for a group of wealthy early adapters, the novelty may soon wear off. It's heavy and you're constrained, can't do much else whilst watching TV. And let's face it, the way people consume "TV" is quite different from what the ad suggests. Most video is consumed in short format, rapidly, whilst messaging someone. I'm sure watching some epic movie using this device is incredible, but that doesn't mean this device has a use case for lengthy daily usage. Consuming media on a larger screen is also not really a game changer. I upgraded my TV by 20" in size, and you get used to it in a single day. At home I have giant monitors but I don't mind working with the smaller screens at work. I have the time/money to watch lots of movies in a cinema but can't be bothered as my home screen is good enough. Note also how most people that have an iPhone, also have an iPad, but the iPad is only marginally used as the tiny iPhone screen is just so much more practical and flexible. Bigger screen doesn't cut it. You need top notch VR content that is spatial. Problem with that is 99.99% of app developers cannot deliver it. It is extremely difficult and costly to produce. In general, I don't believe anything that is heavy and worn and still largely isolates you from your surroundings will work. And I'll admit that I hope it fails. We need less screen time and less isolation, not more.
- onyxringer 3y agoLOL at people who think VR will be a mass thing anytime soon. All these tons of app developers on the market that can do JS/Java UI code will not start writing 3d or even 3d enhanced graphics apps anytime soon. So the VR is just inconvenient screen that you can only see yourself and gives you headaches, with nothing that a normal screen couldn't do. On top of it no one has any motive to start supporting Vission Pro - either as a big tech competitor of Apple, or just independent developer to get rekt by 30% fees for a handful of users. I have two Quest devices and even kids don't ever use them because they suck in their very nature. Terrible hassle for everyone involved, can't use it for all that long and so on. And if the kids don't use some tech it has no future, because an old geezers like me are even less likely to do it.
- diebeforei485 3y agoVision Pro ships with Safari, so people can just go to Netflix.com to watch content in fullscreen. Really no reason for Netflix to implement a native app. But yes if Apple treated their developers better we would likely see a Netflix app.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]