48 ms·
The pro-Israel information war
- ars 3y agoPlease keep in mind this was posted on the Eve of the Jewish Shabbath (in the US, and in the middle of the Shabbath in Israel), so the conversation here is missing a lot of voices.
- waffleiron 3y agoAlso keep in mind Gaza has been cut of from electricity and internet, many there have been killed. The conversation is missing a lot of voices
- ars 3y agoNice snarky reply, but what you are saying is around 0.11% of Muslims can't talk here, but around 30% of Jews can't. Not exactly comparable.
- throwaway55479 3y agoWhile it might be a bit dated, the leaked 2009 Global Language Dictionary [1] remains pertinent to this subject. Essentially, it serves as a manual for communication. I discovered it through another intriguing resource, the documentary "The Lobby - USA." [2] Admittedly, the perspective it offers is somewhat biased, but it provides a straighforward presentation of the situation, especially through the lens of an undercover agent who recorded behind-the-scenes discussions among advocates of the Pro-Israel Information War. [1] https://www.transcend.org/tms/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/sf-israel-projects-2009-global-language-dictionary.pdf https://www.transcend.org/tms/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/sf-... [2] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHEvpbppx_4rgC8q0TVMf2QlNE5hXvcZS https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHEvpbppx_4rgC8q0TVMf...
- hypeit 3y agoIf I'm ever fired for taking a pro-Palestinian stance, I will spend the rest of my life suing everyone involved. The capital community has crossed so many lines in their witch hunt for pro-Palestinan voices that it's not even funny. Our industry has reached a breaking point and I'm not sure what's going to happen since most of the VCs are extremely pro-Zionism and a huge portion of people under the age of 45 are pro-Palestinian, including most engineers and tech people I know.
- ristlane 3y agoI’m very pro-Palestinian. That’s yet another reason why I want Hamas gone. There’s no chance for social justice while terrorists are running the show.
- hypeit 3y ago[flagged]
- sys32768 3y agoBy your logic, any peoples defeated in warfare and kicked off lands are justified to commit murder, rape, to pillage, and to kidnap occupiers. In America that would include hundreds of Native American tribes today whose descendants could resist that way against Americans, yes?
- hypeit 3y agoThe Native Americans definitely had the right to fight back against occupation and did famously on many occasions. Sadly they were successfully ethnically cleansed from the land. The Palestinians are 75 years into the process of colonization and ethnic cleansing. They are actively resisting, as would anyone.
- localplume 3y ago
- zeronullempty 3y agoPaul Graham: Well, well, well. That felt coordinated. Turns out it was. https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Etweet https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465?ref_src...
- 1970-01-01 3y ago[flagged]
- smoldesu 3y agoLike how Elon "trashed his rep" and then got on a plane to meet Netanyahu a week later? Don't be hyperbolic for the sake of politicking. PG has recovered from vastly dumber takes, and still finds people to give him money.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoNo, like this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38572877 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38572877 Tweet: https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ristlane 3y ago
- propercoil 3y ago[flagged]
- metadat 3y ago[flagged]
- ForkMeOnTinder 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Off-Topic: Most stories about politics
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjgreen 3y agoBut some is allowed it seems https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38562946 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38562946
- ForkMeOnTinder 3y agoThat story is about economics, not politics.
- pesfandiar 3y agoWithout having to take any sides, just the surprising importance of culture wars on social media could be interesting. The societal effects of social media are regularly discussed here. This particular issue has become so emotional that careers and relationships were ruined just by taking the wrong side. Because of that, I imagine most HN folks rationally steer clear of any public discussion.
- csydas 3y agoThis is a story about social media technology and a fairly deep and documented look at how a specific group is using this technology to spread their version of propaganda and harassment. The use of the technology may be political, but I would not call this a political article. I was surprised this made it to the front page too at first but as I read on, it ended up being a really interesting article detailing fairly specifically how social media tech is used to engage in harassment, attack people for voicing an opposing political opinion, alter public narratives on important divisive events, etc. It's probably the most plain explanation of how this process works and how social media tech accelerates it I've read to date.
- jdross 3y agoPro-Palestinian views outrank Pro-Israeli online by around 36 to 1 on TikTok and 8 to 1 on other online platforms. https://twitter.com/antgoldbloom/status/1721561226151612602 https://twitter.com/antgoldbloom/status/1721561226151612602 If anything the skew within the platforms is to prioritize pro-palestinian views https://twitter.com/committeeonccp/status/1732792434961031436 https://twitter.com/committeeonccp/status/173279243496103143... It also seems like these platforms create (rather than support) anti-Israeli views: https://twitter.com/antgoldbloom/status/1730255552738201854 https://twitter.com/antgoldbloom/status/1730255552738201854 US views skew pro-israel, and GenZ is closer to 50/50, so if there's something going on online, it's not in favor of Israel. It's probably relevant that there are 1 billion Muslims to 16 million Jews, and that the largest relevant population of pro-Israeli internationals is India and Indian Hindus, and they are not on TikTok (blocked in India).
- mqp 3y agoIt's not about muslims vs Jews. It's about being pro genocide and being anti genocide. Don't make this about religion. Human beings do not want to see genocide carried out on concentration camp of 2.3 million people.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- master_crab 3y agoAnti-semitism in and of itself is unequivocally wrong. But conflating anti-Israeli views with anti-Semitic views does a disservice to Jews and Palestinians alike.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago[flagged]
- everybodyknows 3y agoWhat did he say? Nothing new on his home page.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38572076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38572076
- pazimzadeh 3y agohe tweeted a while back the number of palestinian vs israeli children who have died since october 7 there were way more palestinian children who had died, and some didn't like that being broadcast
- Unfrozen0688 3y ago[flagged]
- pazimzadeh 3y agothis would work both ways. more israelis died on october 7th than any time since the holocaust. does this mean hamas is getting better?
- izacus 3y agoHey... talking about children here. The heck are you doing?
- sebzim4500 3y agoOk. More German children died in WWII than US children. Are the Nazis the good guys now?
- dang 3y agoAll: if you're going to comment, please take a moment to be sure that you're up on the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) and that the comment you're about to post will be strictly within them. Note, for example: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." As this is probably the most divisive topic that exists right now, the comments should be as thoughtful and substantive as commenters can make them. At a minimum, that means no flamebait, no name-calling, and no snark. Thank you.
- seydor 3y agoI think the behavior of the EU is more problematic TBH. Ursula VdL went heavily pro-israel the first day kind of giving carte blanche to israel for the following days This situation is not a good look for western response in general. The world is watching. Reminder that Srebrenica was 8000 deaths, but 17100 palestinians are justified losses.
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- throwaway43256 3y ago[flagged]
- seydor 3y agogood for you, but this is not about how we feel, but about making peace. The palestine issue won't be solved this time like it was not solved in decades of war. you will just have thousands more new terrorists now, who watched family members die while trying to follow orders that israel had given them to protect them. This is a complex issue and not one for taking sides.
- ristlane 3y agoIf Hamas wanted peace, they could have it. They don’t. They want to kill the Jews.
- sudosysgen 3y agoWhy is Israel settling the West Bank and refusing to make peace with Fatah and the PA? There's no Hamas in power there but Israel has refused to stop violently removing people from their land on the basis of their ethnicity.
- ristlane 3y ago
- qaq 3y agoInformation warfare has being part of war for a long time. It is happening from both sides of this war with multiple players taking part. Israel obviously has a large amount of resources dedicated to it, but Arab states and Russia a chipping in heavily too on the other side.
- imp0cat 3y agoThis. Take everything you read with a grain of salt.
- throwaway43256 3y ago[flagged]
- sampa 3y agooh that evil omnipresent Russia!
- qaq 3y agoWell it is omnipresent because they allocate resources to be omnipresent. If you did not notice helping to shift focus to what is going on in Gaza is helping them reduce the focus on what they are up to in Ukraine.
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- Boogie_Man 3y agoThis article, more than making me feel one way or another about the particular issue at hand (Isreal Hamas) makes me speculate what other unknown, better coordinated, better funded, interest groups might be doing this sort of thing on a massive scale. I'm reminded of the "Come out - we have you surrounded" meme where the mentally insane man is hiding behind a desk with a shotgun screaming "Get out of my head" or "I hate the Antichrist", because that's how thinking about these groups make me feel
- ristlane 3y ago[flagged]
- hypeit 3y agoNo, when capital coordinates people get worried and rightfully so. There are a lot of non Jewish Zionists, just as there are a lot of Jewish non-Zionists. In our industry, the VCs are overwhelmingly Zionist while the rest of the industry is non-Zionist and it's the Zionists that are getting people fired and blacklisted.
- quonn 3y ago[flagged]
- mandmandam 3y agohttps://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1733146138226614465 Plenty of examples wrapped up in a short well sourced tweet. Enjoy.
- __loam 3y agoThere are ample articles in reputable publications like the financial times discussing how pro-israel many of the country's business leaders are. Many of these people are going out of their way to blacklist students who have publicly expressed pro-palestinian views from positions at prestigious law firms (and to be fair, some of those comments were very incindiery). But many of them have gone further, threatening universities who don't kick pro-palestinian groups off campus with pulled donations. Israel also notably has close ties with the American business community, with some calling them "start up nation". https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/11/business/harvard-israel-hamas-ceos-students/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/11/business/harvard-israel-h...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _3u10 3y ago[flagged]
- imp0cat 3y ago[flagged]
- olliecornelia 3y ago[flagged]
- throwaway43256 3y ago[flagged]
- Animats 3y ago"That’s where the efforts of J-Ventures’ hasbara WhatsApp group come in. The group, which also includes attorneys and individuals affiliated with the influential American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), has tirelessly worked to fire employees and punish activists for expressing pro-Palestinian views." Is that even legal under US law? Apparently it is in some states. Federal law does not, apparently, prohibit political discrimination. But some states do - California, New York, DC, Colorado, and North Dakota.[1] This should be reported to the FBI's Foreign Influence Task Force.[2] Anyone involved in such suppression activities may be considered an "unregistered foreign agent".[3] Anyone or any organization attempting to influence US policy on behalf of a foreign government is supposed to register. Here's the database.[4] [1] https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/political-affiliation-discrimination.html https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/political-aff... [2] https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/counterintelligence/foreign-influence https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/counterintelligence/foreign-... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Agents_Registration_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Agents_Registration_Ac... [4] https://search.justice.gov/search?affiliate=justice_fara https://search.justice.gov/search?affiliate=justice_fara
- flyinglizard 3y ago[flagged]
- Animats 3y agoAIPAC is the American-Israel Political Action Committee. "The largest pro-Israel PAC in America", their web site says. They are, quite openly, a lobby for Israel's interests in the US.
- flyinglizard 3y ago[flagged]
- Animats 3y agoFARA defines "foreign agents" as individuals or entities engaged in domestic lobbying or advocacy for foreign governments, organizations, or persons. Doesn't matter if they are US persons. It's a registration and disclosure requirement.[1] [1] https://www.justice.gov/nsd-fara/fara-index-and-act#611c https://www.justice.gov/nsd-fara/fara-index-and-act#611c
- deadbabe 3y ago[flagged]
- m_a_g 3y agoBit of a tangent, but I'm proud of the HN community. This post was flagged almost immediately, even though there were around 70 upvotes. Then, the admins decided to give us a chance. And so far, the discussions have been civil and very interesting.
- nostromo 3y agoDon't forget that you can "vouch" for an article or comment that you think was unfairly flagged. From the FAQ: > If you see a [dead] post that shouldn't be dead, you can vouch for it. Click on its timestamp to go to its page, then click 'vouch' at the top. When enough users do this, the post is restored. There's a small karma threshold before vouch links appear.
- m_a_g 3y agoThat's a great reminder, thank you! I should revisit the guidelines and the FAQ sometime. Also, here is a link that explains undocumented features and behaviors of HN for anyone interested: https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Scubabear68 3y agoI have no skin in this game. What I have seen is a confusion (perhaps intentional) between anti-semitism, and protesting Israel’s behavior since the Hamas attack in October. Criticizing Israel’s response is not anti-Semitism- it is literally just criticizing the response.
- ristlane 3y ago[flagged]
- craigmccaskill 3y agoSo I have to have been involved in protesting a non-Israel conflict to have an opinion on this one?
- Scubabear68 3y agoI’m not holding them to a higher standard. Imagine if you will someone going to start large scale bombing NYC. Or London. Or Rome. The Hamas attack was unprecedented and horrific. I don’t know that it justifies declaring all out war on and entire city. I can say that without being anti-Semitic.
- ristlane 3y agoHamas is hiding among civilians. I don’t want innocent people to be hurt, but their use of human shields is simply the standard playbook in this type of warfare. Hamas rationally wants Gazan civilians to be nearby and indistinguishable from combatants.
- ajb 3y agoThis is true but not the whole story. If Hamas were dug in under an Israeli school or hospital, would it similarly by okay to treat civilian deaths as 'just Hamas fault'? Obviously not. The problem here has that the situation is between a war and a policing situation. Gaza is not a state, but it is not a suburb of Israel either. So who is responsible for the safety of Palestinian civilians?
- odiroot 3y agoThat's a really... weird article to read. It's like reading a fantasy book about another universe. Or a desperate attempt at "inception". Reddit, at least, seems to be (rightfully or not) dominated by a strongly anti-Israel narrative. Even the "great" BBC is not willing to call a spade a spade.
- Interesco 3y agoInterestingly I've seen a strong pro-Israel bias, particularly on the larger subreddits (like the default ones). Some of the smaller ones do seem to have a pro-Palestine (or pro-civilian) outlook but nothing that I would describe as "strongly anti-Israel"
- localplume 3y agoyou should look at the r/palestine if you want see manifestation of hatred. or any heavily left leaning subs.
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- m_a_g 3y agoThe default subreddits are truly awful. r/worldnews is the first one that comes to mind. They were accusing the murdered Reuters journalist of being a member of hamas. I decided to never look at those subreddits ever again.
- elihu 3y agoWhenever the topic of water in Gaza comes up in /r/worldnews, there's an oft-repeated bit of misinformation that Gaza doesn't have water because they dug up the EU-financed pipes to make rockets. It's not quite based on nothing: there is footage of Hamas (or maybe Islamic Jihad?) digging up pipes to use for rockets and a Guardian article saying that Hamas could use the EU-financed pipes to make rockets, but as far as I can tell there isn't any evidence that the pipes Hamas are using are from critical in-use infrastructure. One reddit commenter posted that the video of the pipe being dug up was to supply an abandoned Israeli settlement. Israel shut that water off a long time ago. I can't verify that's correct, but it sounds plausible.
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoMost of what I see online and in the news is pro-palestine. Reading up on the conflict, I support Israel more and more.
- skybrian 3y agoWhat have you read?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- fxd123 3y agoIs there a reason why you created an account specifically for this comment thread?
- Unfrozen0688 3y ago[flagged]
- aprilthird2021 3y agoI live in the bay. I'm an engineer. I've read HN for years. This topic hit home for me enough to get me to comment whereas normally I was a lurker
- fxd123 3y agoI didn't ask where you live, but ok?
- aprilthird2021 3y agoYou asked why I created an account. This forum is popular among people who live in the bay...
- rs999gti 3y ago[flagged]
- boeingUH60 3y ago[flagged]
- Dowwie 3y ago[flagged]
- hotdogscout 3y agoSorry you're being downvoted, HN has always been DJ'd by administrators (which is fine) but people here are under the illusion they're seeing everything there is to this argument and not a curated view by people who are pro Palestinians.
- MPlus88 3y agoI don't pro anything. I am against the ethnic cleansing and extermination of a people. In this case, the people are the Palestinian people.
- nomdep 3y ago[flagged]
- qwertthrowway 3y agoGlad to see actual discussion on this topic related to technology. Many investigations into social media being used to suppress pro-Palestinian activism, and the involvement of VCs is no less surprising. Anyone in tech who doesn’t care about what’s going on should really take a look into the huge efforts to silence people who are just trying to protect human lives.
- grumple 3y agoMeanwhile Jews who work at TikTok actually report the opposite: https://www.timesofisrael.com/report-jewish-tiktok-staff-reveal-rampant-antisemitism-israel-hate-in-workplace/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/report-jewish-tiktok-staff-rev...
- fxd123 3y ago> which also included a denunciation of the “Zionist ideology which promotes an exclusivist state,” That's an interesting claim, since Israel is definitely not a exclusivist state. Yet again, 'anti-zionism' seems to be used as a dog whistle for anti-semitism This article is pretty bad, it screams the typical "jews run the media" trope The authors also collaborated on an article called 'Moderna is spying on you'. So they are anti-vax conspiracy theorists as well? Yikes
- ComputerGuru 3y agoNot an exclusivist state, really? https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/israel-adopts-divisive-law-declares-only-jews-have-right-self-n892636 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/israel-adopts-divisive-la... Basically every human rights org has come out and declared it an apartheid state based off how non-Jews are treated within Israel proper and in Israeli-occupied territory.
- fxd123 3y ago> Although the law is largely symbolic
- ComputerGuru 3y agoThen why pass it? Also “largely” is not “altogether.” And a symbolic law speaks to intent, which is embodied in the other not-so-symbolic laws.
- adastra22 3y agoWhat are you referring to? 2 million Arab Israelis enjoy all the rights and freedoms of being an Israeli citizen without any restrictions. They vote, they travel, they are allowed to practice their religion.
- dubcanada 3y agoI find this whole thing very weird, it's all about what side are you on as if it's a game to win. Are you pro-Palestine or pro-Israel, wrong answer and you're out of the club! Are you not just allowed to have an opinion without you being classified as some sort of adjective? The same thing is happening with politics, you're either a republican or a democrat. Well, what if you're just a regular guy who pours concrete for a living. Why can't you just be Bob Smith?
- mrangle 3y agoThere was always going to be an opinion war after 1200 massacred civilians, when a large portion of the other side doesn't take the primary tack of "stop bombing Palestine" but instead "Free Palestine". This particular pro-Palestinian argument being so imprecise and tactically wrong, at this crucial time to saving the lives of Palestinians, only guarantees an unsovable hurricane of noise with no outcome but more civilian deaths and more war. As the other side can not and will not reward the spark of the initial massacre to force a benefits negotiation, obviously. Let alone one that discusses ceding territory. It's morally logical to be aghast at the Palestinian Civilian death toll, regardless of the argument as to who is ultimately responsible. But it is morally unforgiveable for people, living in safety and ostensibly in support of voiceless Palestinians in a war zone, to decide to put a territory argument above Paelstinian lives. This argument further endangers Palestinian lives when it radicalizes them in a manner, within the context of an unwinnable situation, that all but assures their deaths. Hamas has been clear about their choice of the promise of territory over the lives of the entire Palestinian population. Less doomed and morally clearer people need to make the choice to discharge the Palestinian population from their duty as pawns. Even if it means living a long life in another desert that isn't under terrorist militia control. In the context of an absolutely unwinnable situation. Israel is clear, whatever one thinks of the nature of that clarity. That the Palestinians are unclear is why there will be a continued "information war" until the exact point when there isn't the possibility of Palestinians tolerating a single further death. At which point the rallying cry will focus solely on Palestinian lives. We should all hope that this mutual clarity comes in this very minute. If not in this minute, then in the next. So that the maximum number of lives can be saved. People can rail against that reality forever, but it will remain reality.
- knd775 3y ago> There was always going to be an opinion war after 1200 massacred civilians, when a large portion of the other side doesn't take the primary tack of "stop bombing Palestine" but instead "Free Palestine". The West Bank shows what happens if they only stop being bombed without actually being free. Palestine needs to be free in order for there to be peace.
- 3y ago
- carabiner 3y agoIf you want to stop making hummus, stop smashing chickpeas.
- pphysch 3y agoThere's so much (intentional) confusion around basic terms in this info war. Anti-Semitism, "antisemitism", anti-Judaism, anti-Zionism, and anti-Israel are all different concepts. Semitic peoples include both Jews and Arabs. To erase the latter (as Zionism does) and replace them with Europeans is by definition anti-Semitic, therefore Zionism is anti-Semitic. To address that, Zionism coined the term "antisemitism" as a synonym for "anti-Zionism". Being pro-2-state-solution is pro-Israel (and pro-Palestine, pro-Semitic) but anti-Zionist. Anti-Zionism is also not anti-Judaism, because there are many non-Jews that identify as Zionists, e.g. from Winston Churchill to Joe Biden and Donald Trump. (There are also distinctions between ethnic and religious Judaism) All this said, there are unfortunately real anti-Semitic, anti-Jew, anti-Israel individuals and groups out there that also leverage this confusion. This does not take away from the fact that anti-Zionism is an extremely sound moral and political position, akin to anti-Nazism and other anti-totalitarianisms.
- Aloisius 3y agoThe difference between "Antisemitism" and "anti-Semitism" is merely stylistic. Both have been in use in English since 1880 when the word was borrowed from German. It refers exclusively to hatred of Jewry not because Zionists, but because the term was was popularized in Germany in the 19th century by people who hated Jews prior to being brought into English.
- thsksbd 3y agoMy Israeli brother-in-law is afraid to join a pro-Palestine rally because he looks too Jewish. Life's ironies I guess.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoEvery pro-Palestine rally I’ve been to has had many Jews and they’re welcomed with open arms. It’s not a religious war, despite what some would have you believe. Tell him about IfNotNow and Jewish Voice for Peace.
- simplypeter 3y agoPeople tend to support David against Goliath. I've never been there, and I had no idea what was happening. All the information I have (and most of what you have) is propaganda, from both sides.
- hotdogscout 3y ago[flagged]
- ComputerGuru 3y ago“Vocally against Israel” when he was just responding to character assassinations?
- kamikazeturtles 3y agoWelcome to the internet the last couple months. Where any statement that isn't overwhelmingly pro-Israel is "antisemitic" but somehow justifying genocide against Palestinians is ok
- hotdogscout 3y agoI've seen a lot of people chant From River to Sea, which is a call for Jewish genocide, I did not see a lot of people chant for Palestinian genocide.
- kamikazeturtles 3y ago"From the river to the sea" is a phrase that was used in the 1977 election manifesto by the Israeli ruling Likud party. The manifesto stated that "there will only be Israeli sovereignty between the Sea and the Jordan" It's an Israeli slogan by the Netanyahu's party People don't need to chant for Palestinian genocide when it's already being carried out and based on recent polling, the Israeli public is fully in support of it and think there should be even more intense bombing
- hotdogscout 3y agoYou are omitting information. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_the_river_to_the_sea https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_the_river_to_the_sea It is mainly used by Palestine supporters now but also far right Israelis, like you said. How Palestinian supporters can say it unopposed goes against the view you put forward.
- narag 3y agoTwo ideas: 1. It was surprising to me that Hamas believed that filming and publishing their atrocities was a good idea. And more surprising that the response hasn't been a bigger backlash. 2. That makes me think that despite the fact that both parts think that infowar is necessary, the real war is fought on the ground, with weapons, bullets and bombs. Not with protests, declarations and tweets. Neither Israel nor the Palestinians' supporters in the West give a fuck.
- Unfrozen0688 3y ago1. News outlets here actually did not show the full Hamas footage from Oct 7. But they have no problem showing Hamas propaganda.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoYou know it is in overdrive when the ICC thinks about investigating the IOF for war crimes and Netanyahu says the ICC is anti-Semitic. https://www.euronews.com/2021/02/06/israel-netanyahu-denounces-icc-war-crimes-move-as-pure-anti-semitism https://www.euronews.com/2021/02/06/israel-netanyahu-denounc... If Israel has its way, even thinking about Gaza as a concentration camp would be anti-Semitic. "anti-Semitic" has been thrown around so much that it has lost its value. A red balloon, a walrus, or a nice cup of tea can be anti-Semitic nowadays.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- senderista 3y ago"One participant even suggested that they appeal to the university’s 'woke' aversion to exposing students to uncomfortable ideas. The participant drafted a sample letter claiming that Tlaib’s appearance threatened ASU’s 'commitment to a safe and inclusive environment.' The following day, ASU officially canceled the Tlaib event, citing 'procedural issues.'"
- YeBanKo 3y agoThis article made it to front with 297 pts and generally it negative towards Israel. I don't think any of the articles about Hamas atrocities and their use of social media made to cause panic and fear made it that far on HN. Back in Oct about a week after the attack Bloomberg 's reporting on the attack and the beginning of the ended up being flagged on NH and only has 23pts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37910148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37910148 It seems that anti-Israel propaganda is way more successful than this pro-Israel information war.
- aprilthird2021 3y agoNot much is known about Hamas propaganda because sharing it is illegal in the USA where YC and HN are based. On the contrary the IDF is pretty open about its online media budget, spend, and goals. So isn't it natural that people would study it more? https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/news/social-media-is-a-warzone-the-idf-s-strategy-for-war-as-online-spectacle https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/news/social-media-is-a-warz...
- Dowwie 3y agoIt's easier for anti-Israel propaganda to be more successful here when the people leading Y-Combinator, who own and manage Hacker News, are also anti-Israel, some possibly antisemitic. If it didn't take sides and mandated neutrality, it would flag content from both sides. If a moderator on HN acts out of line with the policy or sentiments of YC leadership, they would be corrected. The battle of ideas begins with who controls the platform and what their policies are.
- bitcharmer 3y ago> some possibly antisemitic Ah yes, there it is. You didn't even wait untill the second sentence to use this empty term. Because of comments like yours this word completely lost its meaning. Intelligent people just ignore it now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 3y agoDespite all this, as a casual observer, my general impression is Israel has done terribly at making the case for war, and specifically the kind of war their military seems to be carrying out. The most relevant comparison seems to be with the Russians. Russia has no credibility in the West and Israel is rapidly losing any they had, at least with younger people. My general impression is of a Russian-level intensity of destruction, too. But perhaps these impressions are wrong. I would normally assume the Israelis aren’t complete idiots. I’d like to read a “steelman” case for this military campaign, if anyone knows of one. Why are these impressions misleading? What’s really going on? (Yes, a major difference is that this is a counter-attack, but beyond that?)
- aprilthird2021 3y agoYou will be made quite miserable if you find what you seek. The Israeli politicians basically see Gaza as a "problem" population which they cannot deal with and which is hampering their national goals. And it's shockingly and ironically similar to how Jewish people were looked at in another time and another place by another leader
- burnerburnson 3y agoI like how you put "problem" in quotes as if Palestine does not regularly shoot unguided missiles at Israel with the goal of killing civilians. Maybe you need a quick history refresher but the Jews were not doing that in 1930s Germany.
- adastra22 3y agoAre you serious? They were attacked first and invaded, experiencing the equivalent of Pearl Harbor + 9/11 together in relative terms, or in absolute terms the 2nd worst terrorist attack EVER. Entire communities viciously wiped out, and hundreds of hostages taken, followed by a barrage of thousands of rockets on the cities of Israel. I'm at a loss of words. What kind of explanation are you missing?
- skybrian 3y ago
- Animats 3y agoSome of this information war seems to be intended from keeping the US from considering a third option - sitting this one out. One U.S. State Department official resigned over this when he saw Israel's weapons shopping list.[1] The US could provide humanitarian aid, but not military aid. Cut military aid to Israel. Maybe still provide Iron Dome reloads, but that's about it. Bring in a hospital ship off Gaza, to care for the injured. Send a few frigates to protect it from all parties. Discourage outside interference. Then wait to see how this plays out. It's not the US's fight, after all. Creating a lot of noise over the issue tends to force people to choose a side and eliminates middle options. That may be part of the intent of this campaign. "Are you with us, or against us". No, we're fed up with both of you. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/news/the-political-scene/why-a-state-department-official-lost-hope-in-israel https://www.newyorker.com/news/the-political-scene/why-a-sta...
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- fny 3y agoThis opinion is surfacing in the likes of Ramaswamy.
- fxd123 3y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Recall that Palestine's goal is to eliminate all Jews. No, that's not Palestine’s goal. Its not even clearly the goal of the Palestinian Islamist extremist group Israel fostered specifically to have a less sympathetic enemy to deflect pressure for peace with Palestine to use as a pretext for perpetual war, though it may be, and whose fault is that?
- fxd123 3y ago
- senderista 3y agoI'm not trying to deflect, but I do find it interesting that just 2 months ago, >100K Armenians were permanently displaced from their homes in Nagorno-Karabakh where they've lived for literally millenia, and I saw essentially no coverage of this in Western media (in contrast, it was all over Russian media, possibly because Armenia is a historical ally of Russia and a lot of Russians are frustrated that Russia and the CSTO did basically nothing to prevent this ethnic cleansing). The Armenian-American community is rather large (>500K) but apparently nowhere near as influential as the Jewish-American community. There are many other recent instances of ethnic cleansing that nobody seems to care about. The number of ethnic Germans who were permanently expelled from their homes in Europe and the USSR (at about the same time as Palestinians) exceeds the number of Palestinian refugees by more than an order of magnitude (10-12M, with at least 500K dead), making it the largest ethnic cleansing in modern history, but this episode is basically forgotten (presumably because sympathy for Germans was rather scarce after WW2). The hundreds of thousands of Turks and Greeks who were mutually expelled from their homes after WW2 will never get to return either. Nor will all the ethnic minorities in the former Yugoslavia who were "cleansed" from their historic homelands. So my question is, given that ethnic cleansings are not uncommon in the recent past, and that the Palestinian Nakba is not even close to the worst case, why is it basically the only one that anyone seems to care about?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ComputerGuru 3y agoTotally unrelated, did you know it was Israel that armed the Azeri army for their ethnic cleansing campaign? https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/rjhofzoet https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/rjhofzoet
- senderista 3y agoI certainly did. They won't even sell Harop or Spike to Ukraine. Did you know about the Israeli killer drone sales demo for the Azeris that practiced on live Armenian soldiers? https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2017-08-15/ty-article/israeli-suicide-drone-used-on-armenian-army-targets-in-live-demo/0000017f-e3bd-df7c-a5ff-e3ffa9910000 https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2017-08-15/ty-article/is...
- mastrsplyntr 3y agoWhy is America so fixated on Israel? Groups like AIPAC and the Israeli lobby seem to be steering U.S. policies in ways that don't necessarily benefit the U.S., while potentially harming its interests. Here's what's at stake: This alliance seems to be turning about two billion people and dozens of muslim-majority nations against America, driving them towards alliances with countries like China. American taxpayer money is being heavily invested in Israel. We're talking about a staggering $260 billion given to Israel, seemingly without direct benefits to the U.S. Ethically, the U.S. is on shaky ground. By consistently supporting Israel, even in cases involving civilian casualties, the U.S. appears to be undermining international law and the United Nations, often standing alone against global consensus. Looking at the U.S. presidency, it seems like candidates from both major parties have to win the favor of the Israeli lobby to secure their nomination. Take Obama, for example. Despite his apparent disdain for Netanyahu – remember the leaked conversation with Sarkozy where they called Netanyahu a liar? – he still seemed unable to counter the lobby's influence. This focus on Israel is a massive distraction from more pressing issues, like the rise of China. And let's be clear – Israel's loyalty as a Western ally is questionable. It's kept friendly ties with the Kremlin, hasn't joined in sanctioning Russia, and has turned down requests to send defensive weapons to Ukraine. It seems Israel would not hesitate to shift its allegiance to China if it suited its national interests.
- miketery 3y agoIt's realpolitik. It's not about Israel. It's about Russia and Iran. To a lesser extent it's also about the Suez. It also doesn't hurt that any aid, is defense spending in the US which is a stimulus for jobs or manufacturing for defense. Overall it's cheap expenditure for the US.
- bhouston 3y ago> It's realpolitik. It's not about Israel It is not at all. This funding is only occurring because of AIPAC and similar organizations including Christian groups who want to see the end times happen and supporting Israel is apparently important for that. Israel is not a counter balance to Russia at all. And Israel (specifically Netanyahu and AIPAC) undermined the Iran agreement that was going to see them stop their nuclear program.
- tlogan 3y agoI have no skin in this game but I have a lot of Jewish friends. I have two conclusions: - Whoever is in charged for this "pro-Israel" information war failed miserably. Even in Jewish communities. - Putin is clearly the winner here. The mistakes are the following: - They focused way too much on the mainstream media. And nearly nothing on TikTok, forums, etc. - They did nothing about China's and Russia's influence and their own info-war. - They assumed Biden is popular - or maybe they hoped his support will help in public. It did not. - They pushed "canceling" but public option about canceling changed considerable in last 6 months.
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- hackandthink 3y agoJournalists live dangerously in an information war: https://www.afp.com/en/inside-afp/journalists-killed-and-injured-lebanon-afps-investigation-points-israeli-army https://www.afp.com/en/inside-afp/journalists-killed-and-inj...
- Waterluvian 3y agoI think the frustrating thing about the “information space” is that through a sum of “intentionally manipulative,” “willfully ignorant,” and “poised to attack you” voices, the whole space is pretty useless if your goal is to try to reconcile your strong emotions and thoughts on deeply nuanced, complex issues. I’m inclined, more than ever, to just stay quiet, but as a social animal that’s exceedingly uncomfortable.
- fortran77 3y ago[flagged]
- aprilthird2021 3y ago[flagged]
- fortran77 3y ago[flagged]
- istultus 3y agoWhat an absolute mind-fuck. I think the greatest thing the Moscow-Teheran-Beijing "bot army diplomacy doctrine" is showing us is that you can radicalize both the US right AND the US Left at the same time by speaking to each side's idiocies at full throat. We are nearing Elders of Zion territory here where the ratio of 2 Billion Muslims to 15 Million Jews, and thus the constant stream of anti-Israeli propaganda, now contains propaganda suggesting that we are deceived and in fact there is more pro-Israeli discoursem when in reality it is being drowned out.
- submeta 3y agoThere is no need for Russian/Iranian propaganda bots. Israel does that already for them: Seeing how Israel tries to defeat Hamas by withholding water, food, electricity, medicines for 2.2mil civilians in Gaza or by using genocidal language by Netanyahu and his war cabinet (Netanyahu: „they are Amalek!“, Gallant: „they are human animals“, Herzog: „there are no innocent in Gaza“, and then compring Hamas to Hitler/Nazis/ISIS/Satan) or by bombing hospitals, schools, ambulances, killing civilians by the thousands, then at the same time handing out guns to Settlers who loot, kill, start pogroms in the West Bank.
- ssnistfajen 3y agoWhat discourse you see online is entirely dependent on who you follow. TikTok is not force feeding you pro-Palestine content (and pro-Palestine ≠ pro-Hamas, people who are unironically pro-Hamas are not to be taken seriously since they usually come with other nonsensical takes on everything). Neither is Twitter, Youtube, Instagram, or any other platform where content is recommended based on user preferences. Don't like what you see? Close it or use whatever feedback function built-in to strongly signal your distaste, and the algorithms will recommend less of that. My tech twitter timeline was unusable for weeks after October 7 because many people I follow started posting pro-Israel messages nonstop, to the point where I had to mute them because it's not what I followed them for despite having sympathy for Israelis after the attack from Hamas. I started getting ads obviously funded by the State of Israel and pro-Israel organizations on Youtube, on Twitter, on Instagram, and on TikTok (for a day or two). There were "Missing Person" posters of October 7th victims in my neighbourhood street which is located more than 10000+km from Israel (I feel bad for them and hope they will return home safe and sound, but what are these posters trying to achieve here in my neighbourhood? My local representative legislator is already supporting Israel and condemning Hamas). I'm not going to stop recognizing propaganda for being propaganda even if I mostly agree with its underlying message. That's a basic critical thinking skill and evidently that skill is lacking even mong highly successful and "intelligent" people on HN, tech Twitter, and so on.
- zlg_codes 3y agoIt is a disgusting waste of my tax dollars to send it to an imperialist group trying to settle an area that was never theirs. Journalists are killed more by Israel than the rest. Why, if they were satisfied and confident they are correct? Those are the actions of guilty souls. Same for the ADL; they hide behind accusations of anti-semitism if you criticize them at all. They have weak positioning and simply want to genocide other groups. No better than ISIS and the Taliban as far as I'm concerned. Money sent to Israel could have gone to Ukraine. Instead, Americans sponsored the massacre of innocent Gazans. I didn't vote for that, most of us didn't vote for that. Why should we accept it, or approve of Israel's genocidal war? The least they could do is be honest about how much they hate people showing the world the truth. I truly have no respect or love in my heart for human beings who are comfortable killing to cover up their war crimes. As an American I'm sick of my tax dollars going to a bunch of desert conflicts that won't improve life for anyone.
- jhallenworld 3y agoI've been watching Project Ask recently: https://www.youtube.com/@CoreyGilShusterAskProject/videos https://www.youtube.com/@CoreyGilShusterAskProject/videos It's fascinating to hear opinions on the ground from both sides. Some things I've learned or concluded: Young Palestinians are much more radical than older ones, who seem more flexible. I personally think the two-state solution is a non-starter, and watched these videos to see if a one state solution is at all viable (meaning make Palestinians into Israeli citizens with full rights- basically the Zionists conquered the land, but they must also take the people). The problem is that neither side wants this. Many Jewish Israelis think the Arabs would outnumber them due to birth rate, but recently Ultra-Orthodox Jews have an even higher birth rate, and Palestinian birth rate has fallen (I speculate due to increased education). Extremist settlers absolutely won't have it, and there is rampant racism. Palestinians want the Jews gone from their lands, but when pressed would probably accept those of Palestinian descent. Sadly, I think we are going to continue with the one state with Apartheid. And, an interesting thing has happened in post-Apartheid South Africa: the realization that they are collectively poor, and not a rich first world country. One example from SA is that the electrical infrastructure was sized for only the whites, now that the full population is counted, there is just not enough, it's a big current problem. Any per-capita measurement of Israel should include the Palestinians to see the depth of this problem.
- sudosysgen 3y agoHave you thought about why young Palestinians have a different opinion from older ones? The opinion of powerless people is not set in stone, but is often a reaction to things outside of their control.
- jhallenworld 3y agoDirect experience? Learning from their parents? Typical young person reaction to perceived injustice? Dangerous to have a differing opinion? They have internet, but unfortunately it's not a force for moderation.
- alephnerd 3y agoOlder ones used to be able to work in Israel as migrant workers. After the 2nd Intifada and Hamas's takeover of Gaza, Israel cracked down on Palestinian migrant workers and began importing labor from Thailand, Nepal, and other countries.
- neilv 3y agoI don't know what's going on, and I wonder who actually has accurate information. Speaking as an early online person, who has long believed in the democratizing power and goodness potential of the Internet... Contemporary "social media" are usually wastelands, both of rampant manipulation, and of people who haven't yet learned critical thinking nor even seen much examples of same. I would like to call for there to once again be eminently credible and respected journalists, academics, and officials, who research and understand various global situations, and report accurate assessments that people can trust. Trustworthy experts could answer immediate questions, and also show everyone else by example, how to think and speak better, to answer future questions.
- goalonetwo 3y agoComing from Europe and living in the US for the last couple of years, I'm shocked at how society here is clearly pro-israel. It is very clear that in the US the life of an israel citizen is valued way above the one of a palestinian. It is sad to lose that level of humanity. all of the discourse also conveniently ignores that Israel created a large-scale open-air prison in Gaza and removed any hope left for people living there.
- marcell 3y agoIt seems like Hamas values one Palestinian less than one Israeli. This is based on prisoner exchanges. Hamas gives up one Israeli prisoner for more than one Palestinian. Most recently it was 2:1, but historically it was 100:1 or more.
- timeagain 3y agoThis is silly right? It isn’t like Hamas demanded this ratio, or that they forced Israel to accept. Should Hamas refuse out of principle if Israel gave them prisoners for free? On the contrary it seems more like a power play on Israel’s part. “Take our prisoners we will just defeat them again!”
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> It isn’t like Hamas demanded this ratio thats exactly what its like. If israel wanted their hostages back they needed to give up twice as many palestinian prisoners.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI think a lot of Americans either consciously or subconciosuly see the similarity between Israel's situation and the US's with regards to the natives. If there was a native independence movement that resorted to terrorism the us would flatten every reservation in the country.
- aprilthird2021 3y ago
- paganel 3y agoThis [1] is why the Palestinians are winning the information war among the people that still have a well-functioning soul. And, of course, the fact that the Tsahal has already annihilated thousands of Palestinians kids ("people under 18 years of age", to use the BBC euphemism) and is planning to annihilate thousands more. [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/18dp0jp/mentally_diseased_country/ https://old.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/18dp0jp/mental...
- mupuff1234 3y agohttps://twitter.com/sama/status/1732925866836210151 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1732925866836210151
- loughnane 3y agoI think it’s been clear to most of us from the early days that the media is the second front in this war in way it’s never been. “Success”, whatever that looks like, lies in getting the rest of the world to care more about your side and/or be too apathetic or paralyzed to side when your enemies. That’s always been the case to some degree, but this conflict is dropping on a hyper-connected video world that is new. It’d be foolish for the heads of either camp to not try to manipulate popular opinion. Sadly that makes it harder—though not impossible—to grok the truth, but practically I don’t see it ever changing for the simpler.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoCan you imagine that all it took for her to lose her job was "“Freedom for Palestine”. That's the insanity about this whole thing. The Zionists don't believe Palestine nor the Palestinians deserve a homeland while many Jews believe they do. Zionism is an incredibly powerful entity that even brought Musk to his knees. That's the real story here..... Just saying....
- nomdep 3y ago[flagged]
- fxd123 3y ago> Can you imagine that all it took for her to lose her job was "“Freedom for Palestine”. Which she said after Israel was a victim of a terrorist attack. Quite tone deaf, no?
- ChumpGPT 3y agoTell me do you think the Palestinians deserve their own country?
- fxd123 3y agoYes, as long as they can avoid shooting rockets at their neighbors. Which is sadly not the case right now
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChumpGPT 3y agoYeah, I don't agree with shooting rockets indiscriminately into Israel is the right thing or killing regular people. But there is the chance they are shooting rockets because Zionists believe they shouldn't have a homeland and have been killing regular Palestinians for a long time.
- zer00eyz 3y agoThis is not surprising at all. I feel like we had this war's WMD moment and its just not being covered! The Al-Shifa hospital is a pretty interesting place: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Shifa_Hospital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Shifa_Hospital In 2014 it was called "...a de facto headquarters for Hamas leaders, who can be seen in the hallways and offices." From: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/while-israel-held-its-fire-the-militant-group-hamas-did-not/2014/07/15/116fd3d7-3c0f-4413-94a9-2ab16af1445d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/while-israe... The US and Israel claim that the hospital is again being used by Hammas: https://web.archive.org/web/20231205215049/http://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/white-house-says-it-has-evidence-hamas-using-al-shifa-hospital-run-military-2023-11-14/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231205215049/http://www.reuter... "Hamas is using bunkers built by Israel under Al-Shifa Hospital, former Israeli prime minister says" From: https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-war-gaza-news-11-20-23/h_91e66ecbf3286b946f264a3b8016c37e https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-wa... Israel takes the hospital: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-67436154 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-67436154 and this is one of the few reports from the time. I find it odd that there is more coverage on getting there then on everything they found (or did not find). It takes almost a week to get footage of the "tunnel" that they found: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/nov/19/idf-israel-army-footage-claims-hamas-tunnel-al-shifa-hospital-gaza https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/nov/19/idf-israel-arm... I have yet to see a diagram, or some solid on the ground reporting. I hear mixed messages that the tunnel is on the "hospital compound" or was found "Under a wall" that the tunnel is under the hospital or to a pharmacy next door. I get that there is a fog of war, but the BBC and CNN and all our other normal news sources just quit covering or explaining at that point. Israel has a history of bombing hospitals (2014): https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/21/gaza-crisis-unsc-and-obama-call-for-immediate-ceasefire-live-updates https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/21/gaza-crisis-un... so not exactly the first time this sort of thing has gone on. I would love for someone to COVER this, to explain what happened, what went right and what went wrong. To put all the peices in one place and paint a more accurate picture, because right now there isn't one, and I think that's indicative of this entire war.
- wslh 3y ago[dead]
- wslh 3y ago[flagged]
- burnerburnson 3y ago[flagged]
- wslh 3y agoIt is always good to remember that Jewish people include people with dark skins and black people.
- SCAQTony 3y agoWe must remember this: The credibility of both sides in a war is more than suspect. i.e., incomplete information, pure B.S., or propaganda. "The first casualty of war is the truth." This has been stated throughout history back to Aeschylus og Greece circa 550 BC. https://www.societyofeditors.org/soe_blog/the-first-casualty-of-war-is-the-truth/ https://www.societyofeditors.org/soe_blog/the-first-casualty...
- dorongrinstein 3y agoThere are about 1.8 Billion Muslims on planet earth. There are about 15 Million Jews on the planet. There are about 120 Muslims for every Jewish person. In Israel there are about 7 million Jews. The anti Israel propaganda and blatant lies on social media is sickening. To someone who knows what's on the ground, reading countless 100% false posts from many (not all!) Muslims and Palestinian supporters is downright scary. Israelis (including myself) try to educate people about who is who and what's right and what is false. This article that singles out Israel for trying to provide its (true) version of reality and facts as nefarious-is misguided to be polite.
- hereme888 3y ago[flagged]
- giraffe_lady 3y agoIf someone's supporters lie enough can you genocide them? If not then I don't see how this is relevant.
- dmix 3y agoThis is a discussion about propaganda, not justifying the scale of a military response. As an aside throwing the word "genocide" around lightly is also one of the cheapest forms of discourse. Constantly escalating language doesn't make for useful debate. It's just an overused tactic to make your opinions sound more important.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoClaiming that a force currently committing a genocide has "moral clarity" is simultaneously propaganda and a justification of the genocide, yes. I'm not using it for effect, it's an accurate description according to this israeli scholar of genocides. https://jewishcurrents.org/a-textbook-case-of-genocide https://jewishcurrents.org/a-textbook-case-of-genocide
- snird 3y agoWhat is the story here? That Israelis try to defend themselves online? The fact that it is a story at all is concerning.
- FailMore 3y agoI have not read this article. I am sad to see it here. I am Jewish and Hacker News has been my one sanctuary from all that has been going on. I feel a dreadful sadness about this whole situation, and unfortunately I have found that any issue I have looked into in any detail descends into a battle of claim and counterclaim. I have had to just give up and let it play out, not only what has happened and what will happen in Israel and Gaza, but also the battle of words on social media and newspapers. It is too painful for me to interact with.
- kamikazeturtles 3y agoI know a lot of Palestinians and they don't have the luxury of avoiding the news because they still have family in Gaza.
- alephnerd 3y agoA couple of my colleagues are VCs who are in active combat in Gaza as we speak. Another VC I knew lost his daughter in the Nova massacre (or is a hostage - they don't know yet). This VC was very active in the peace process and lobbied a very large tech company we all know to open a large development office in West Bank and Gaza and pay pretty high salaries. I also know a lot of line level engineers and PMs from my previous jobs who are drafted, knew people drafted, or knew people at Nova. You can and should oppose war crimes, but at the end of the day, Hamas, PIJ, and other Gazan jihadi groups did unspeakable actions on 10/7. And honestly, I've seen and heard of Afghans fighting back against the Taliban, but I haven't seen Gazans fighting back against Hamas.
- kamikazeturtles 3y agoWhat happened on 10/7 was very tragic and I'm sorry to hear about your friends suffering. Right now 2 million Palestinians are displaced and, so far, 1% of Gaza's population has been killed by the Israeli army offensive. With many more injured, crippled, psychologically scared. The saddest part? It doesn't look like this horror will end. Many more will die No suffering is justified No killing is justified
- wslh 3y agoThe discussion is open, looking at Israel is not looking at the whole information war. - Is TikTok Really Boosting Pro-Palestinian Content? [1] - TikTok: ‘The biggest antisemitic movement since the Nazis’ says actor Sacha Baron Cohen [2] - Apple, Disney and IBM to pause ads on X after antisemitic Elon Musk tweet [3] - How Bad Is Antisemitism Online? It’s Increasingly Hard to Know. [4] [1] https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/right-tiktok-boost-palestinian-content-1234876108/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/right-... [2] https://www.euronews.com/culture/2023/11/20/tiktok-the-biggest-antisemitic-movement-since-the-nazis-says-actor-sacha-baron-cohen https://www.euronews.com/culture/2023/11/20/tiktok-the-bigge... [3] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/17/elon-musk-antisemitic-tweet-apple-pausing-ads https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/17/elon-musk... [4] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/17/technology/israel-hamas-war-meta-tiktok-social-media.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/17/technology/israel-hamas-w... [4]
- noamelf 3y agoI thought I'd get some better take on the situation here then in the rest of social media but apparently that's difficult to come by. Especially when discussing a 100 years old conflict. I can't see how any leftist could support Oct 7 events, and call it resistance or freedom fighting in some form. Just for context, if Hamas would have targeted military positions in the attack, then it would have been possible to say they are fighting for some liberation goal. But as this is not the case and they clearly targeted civilians locations like a rave party and villages, it's clear that this was not their goal, but their goal was to inflict terror on Israeli population. My take is that in this long fought battle both sides made wrongdoings, but we need to be very clear and nuanced about each event. In this case it's clear that Hamas, and I may say that since Hamas is a popular movement, the Palestine public in Gaza in genera, made a grave mistake and now suffer the consequences of that decision as there is very little possibility for Israel to defeat Hamas without causing civilian casualties when they are some embedded within the population. In this sense President Biden approach makes perfect sense; defeat Hamas with minimal civilian casualties. The Palestines deserve better, but I think that as long as they stay fixated on the results of the 1948 war, and do not agree to let that stay in the past, there will be no end in sight.
- globalnode 3y agoOk heres my thoughtful comment: It doesnt matter what Israel says or does from this point forward, nothing can undo the genocide they have committed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- brindlejim 3y agoI find this supposed expose profoundly underwhelming. So a bunch of people collaborated on private channels to promote a point of view? That happens about 10 thousand times per week. We're all living in nested, overlapping and opposing conspiracies that express themselves on social media and in policy. And of course, the people supporting Palestine or Hamas or whatever are doing the same. So what?
- ilitirit 3y agoMany of these comments talking about how many pro-this or anti-that news exist are quite baffling. I don't really think that's the point. I think the point is more about the existence of groups with links to private companies and even government(s?) who actively seek to punish people who post views and opinions they don't like. And this is supposedly is in a democracy, not dictatorship, or religious state.
- nojvek 3y agoI really wished Israel didn’t blatantly start airbombing Gaza civilian infrastructure and blockade food, water, gas. When Russia does this on Ukraine, we call them war criminals but when Israel does it on Palestinians we call it business as usual. The idea of military revenge doesn’t get us anywhere. Defense is the best offense. Little gains the world made in Middle East stability have now been reversed for decades. As technology progresses, the drones and missiles will become cheaper and more destructive. An eye for an eye makes the world blind. I really wished US provided weapons based on condition of only making precise targeted attacks for specific terrorists. That means our a big chunk of $800B defense money, funded by our tax money is used to obliterate civilians in Gaza. That makes me sad. It’s likely this turns into another Afghanistan multi decade war with trillions spent and nothing to show for it. The only winners are defense contractors. US could have played peace maker role. Be the party to stop missiles flying everywhere. Provided humanitarian and medical aid. Demilitarize and deescalate. The current strategy of destroying hamas by destroying Gaza and its inhabitants is pretty stupid. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
- adastra22 3y agoWhat, specifically, should they have done instead?
- timeu 3y agoAfter an initial military response, take their time and specifically plan and target the terrorists who were responsible and organized the attacks on the 7.10. Yeah this will obviously take way longer and is harder than levelling Gaza but would avoid eventually bringing the entire world against you and producing much more terrorists than before. At the same time also try to make sure that the civilians in Gaza get humanitarian aid, so you remove the breeding ground for terrorism. This approach was also suggested by Jocko Willink retured Navy Seal (https://youtu.be/3O4dW24az98 https://youtu.be/3O4dW24az98) But the mistakes happened way before by moving troops away from the Gaza border to West Bank to protect illegal settlements and also supporting Hamas as an opposition to PLO. Don't get me wrong. Don't get me wrong the world would be a better place without Hamas however your policy has to be strategic and not emotional (i.e. revenge)
- silexia 3y agoWhy can't I downvote this article here? There is only an upvote button.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aerbil313 3y ago[flagged]
- Aerbil313 3y agoHN is absolutely disgusting on this one. Yes, I’m telling you, the guy who’s gonna see this comment before it gets shadowbanned.
- Aerbil313 3y agoEveryone, just a reminder: History exists. But ofc, you have a smartphone, don’t you? Oh, someone tweeted something, lemme check!
- MichaelMoser123 3y agoMost of the top comments here are against Israel, the country that is defending itself against Hamas-ISIS. I think the bias in this discussion is a direct illustration of Sam Altmans tweet from yesterday: https://twitter.com/sama/status/1732925866836210151 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1732925866836210151 "for a long time i said that antisemitism, particularly on the american left, was not as bad as people claimed. i'd like to just state that i was totally wrong. i still don't understand it, really. or know what to do about it. but it is so fucked."
- aprilthird2021 3y agoWhy does only Israel have the right to defend itself and not Palestine? When Israeli settlers steal Palestine day by day why does Palestine not have a right to exist and only Israel does? When Israel imprisons Palestinians for years without charging them with crimes and there is documented proof of them raping and torturing them [1] why doesn't Palestine have the right to defeat Israel to make sure that never happens again? Why isn't everything Israel wants also allowed for Palestinians? [1] https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20231205-resigned-us-state-department-official-reveals-details-of-child-rape-case-in-israeli-prison-calls-for-accountability/ https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20231205-resigned-us-state...
- MichaelMoser123 3y agothis 'resistance' is just killing every civilian right and left, that's just pure evil. Go inform yourself.
- hsuduebc2 3y agoI'm not sure why author is surprised by this. There is enormous amount of propaganda from another side too. This is how war is done today. Sadly today our narratives are shaped by algorithms and I'm afraid that most of the people are not very well aware of that. Not gonna lie. That gives me mild anxiety.
- botanical 3y agoIsrael is an Apartheid State long before killing 20 000 people in the past 2 months. Israel will never get the peace they seek with the oppression they inflict. * Illegal Settlers living in Palestine can vote in Israel but not Palestinians; Israeli settlers all the rights of being a citizen of Apartheid Israel while the Palestinian neighbour doesn't have any. Apartheid South Africa did the same, they put the people in their own "country" and so couldn't vote. Israel doesn't want 2 states as that would mean millions more voting. * There were 5,248,185 Palestinian refugees neighbouring countries in 2020; that's equal to half the population of Israel. Israel is committing genocide in trying to ethnically cleanse the land. * Israel has ethnically cleansed and fragmented areas into [isolated cantons divided by Israeli settlements](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_enclaves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_enclaves), and implemented [lebensraum](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebensraum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebensraum) tactics. This was called [Bantustans](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bantustan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bantustan) in South Africa. * The Apartheid Separation wall - https://i.pinimg.com/originals/d0/73/81/d07381fffef632350bcbb535bbaeced8.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/d0/73/81/d07381fffef632350bcb... * The settlers killing in the West Bank, and burning homes to get rid of people and destroying olive tree groves. * They control the water completely - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_the_State_of_Palestine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_supply_and_sanitation_in... * They get 12 hours of electricity a day - https://www.ochaopt.org/page/gaza-strip-electricity-supply https://www.ochaopt.org/page/gaza-strip-electricity-supply * Palestinians didn't have 3G until 2018, their access is also spied on and restricted. * Segregated road system - https://s3.amazonaws.com/VP2/visuals/en/4db97391fe7cb246224980917f5bd997.png https://s3.amazonaws.com/VP2/visuals/en/4db97391fe7cb2462249... * 50% of Palestinians are children. As someone from South Africa, I've seen ethnic cleansing and Israel is doing worse. Israel is absolutely an Apartheid state. Various human rights organisations have already stated this. Not to mention the Israeli government's rhetoric of calling Palestinians rats and that their lives are less important than an Israeli's. Hamas wouldn't exist if not for Apartheid Israel's actions, in the same way uMkhonto we Sizwe doesn't exist now that Apartheid has been disbanded in South Africa. And it seems in the comments here and elsewhere on the interent, Zionism is conflated with antisemitism. Zionism is extreme nationalism (at the expense of innocent Palestinians), not anti-Jew.
- ckemere 3y agoI appreciate this post not yet being removed. The HN discussion often can contain nuggets of insight which are lacking from the “media”. The challenge of balancing equity, justice, and personal security, and how conversations around this challenge are positioned is certainly not unique to the conflict in Israel/Palestine. I’d love to hear thoughts about how to have these conversations in ways that will lead to long term growth/positive change…
- gerash 3y agoThere's so much semantic discussion on anti semitic, pro Israel, etc. What I see is two groups of people fighting for a long time, one with orders of magnitude more fire power who does not hesitate to drop it on civilians willy as a show of force. I just don't want my tax money to fund these weapons
- kundi 3y agoI find it incredibly fascinating that some of the 1000 smartest people on internet are discussing if apple looks like orange, and if orange looks more like apple. Instead of building things and relationships (which according to our very humble observation can be more fulfilling than building billion dollar companies), the culture as it is (and you can figure out which) is still today so attached to the ideas and conceptions that no longer serve humans and their fulfillment, living in times where no-one should be lacking anything. If we start discussing if blocking water and food is can be excused by any God or highest of the dearest reason, then we should ask ourselves who brought these leaders to their positions and what is the fundamental flaw in the unfortunate human psyche.
- maratbn 3y ago[flagged]
- jimboBimbo69 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhy does dang resurrect these flamebait threads to carry water for PG?
- tracer4201 3y ago[dead]
- pxc 3y agoIt became clear very quickly this October that the whole issue of the conflict got a very different (more censorious) treatment here on HN than around the world. That was such a depressing and infuriating experience for me that it turned watching the censorship play out into my main interest in HN for a few weeks, and eventually turned me off of the site altogether. I understand some of the tensions at play for moderators here and the kind of online space they want to facilitate, and the work that controversial topics put on small moderation teams. But it still ultimately damaged my relationship with this site and broke my habit of frequently using it. I can't be the only one. It's no wonder that when the moderation team finally decided that a post closely relating to this conflict deserves to remain on the front page, it shot up into the thousands of comments. I appreciate this post's presence here, and I hope the discussion stays manageable. I wonder how many people will be doxxed for their comments here on this very post, just like Carey in the OP.
- thread_id 3y agoVery illuminating information - now reading this ABC article about what is happening on university campuses and the pressure that university presidents are under is seen in an entirely new light. https://abcnews.go.com/US/uproar-university-presidents-remarks-antisemitism-underscores-tensions-campuses/story?id=105502845 https://abcnews.go.com/US/uproar-university-presidents-remar...
- thread_id 3y agoSo now one day hence the new light is even brighter!!! Interesting that this 5th column can have so much power over so many U.S. institutions and be able to bring down university presidents. https://www.cnn.com/2023/12/09/business/upenn-board-of-trustees-meeting-liz-magill/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/12/09/business/upenn-board-of-trust... Doesn't seem coordinated to me... https://www.foxnews.com/politics/stefanik-applauds-resignation-upenn-president-liz-magill-one-down-two-go https://www.foxnews.com/politics/stefanik-applauds-resignati...
- wslh 3y agoI recommend to add to this thread the pro-Israel Twitter user: Shaun Maguire: https://twitter.com/shaunmmaguire https://twitter.com/shaunmmaguire and one of his latest thread is: https://twitter.com/shaunmmaguire/status/1733251364787302553 https://twitter.com/shaunmmaguire/status/1733251364787302553
- wslh 3y agoBTW, I added the "In a Worldwide War of Words, Russia, China and Iran Back Hamas" thread to see how it goes [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38581205 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38581205
- roshin 3y ago[flagged]
- diebeforei485 3y agoBased on opinion polling and UN votes, most of the world is opposed to Israel's treatment of Palestinians, so the null hypothesis is that you would find far more pro-Palestinian voices represented on social media (not just the users, but also the unpaid and paid moderators). We clearly see moderation policies being biased against pro-Palestinian points of view. All the "mistakes" moderators make are in the same direction.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- rmrf100 3y agothe world sucks
- literallyWTF 3y ago[dead]
- incomingpain 3y agoFrom my anecdotal point of view, there's nothing but pro-Palestinian stuff that I see here in Canada. There are signs about 'stop the occupation' literally all over my city. Sorry, but it looks like the Palestinians are the ones winning this information war. They broke the peace, they attacked israel, they are the ones responsible for this ongoing war. If you condemn Russia for them breaking the peace and starting a war. Then you condemn the Palestinians just as much.
- guanny 3y ago[dead]