17 ms·
Emmett Shear becomes interim OpenAI CEO as Altman talks break down
- wnc3141 3y agoWhat will be the dilution in value of Microsoft's stake if Altman has funding for a competitor?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- extheat 3y agoThis is not a serious BOD. This is going to the courts, and it couldn't happen any sooner.
- dragonwriter 3y agoWho do you imagine is going to sue, and on what basis?
- mupuff1234 3y agoWho's gonna sue if there's no shareholders being that it's a non profit?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- seanhunter 3y agoThere are investors including sequoia, Tiger Global and Microsoft[1]. They may well have standing to sue. [1] Sorry - the full list is behind a paywall https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/openai/company_financials https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/openai/company_finan...
- mupuff1234 3y agoI believe those are investor the in for-profit organization while the board is responsible for the non-profit org, and I believe the for-profit is bound to the mission of the non profit but not the other way around. But I'm sure someone here knows the legal structure better than I do, I just quickly skimmed over https://openai.com/our-structure https://openai.com/our-structure
- seanhunter 3y agoThat's why I said they may well have standing to sue. It's going to get messy if it goes there for sure.
- dorkwood 3y agoI thought they switched to a "capped profit" model, where investors are capped at a 100x return on investment.
- jatins 3y agoHow do these decisions even happen? Does the board just say "Hey I know a guy, let me check if they are interested" Surely Emmett must be really capable but still seems a bit of wild card entry
- captainkrtek 3y agoIf the board was trying to further erode trust in their decision making, doesn’t inspire confidence that all of this happened in the span of a weekend: - fired, CTO announced as interim CEO - wait, come back - never mind, oh and a new interim CEO
- 15457345234 3y agoOne might assume that the board has known 'whatever they know' for quite some time, possibly discussed quietly behind the scenes, which includes them scouting out potential interim CEOs. Then when it becomes clear that negotiations won't solve the problem the board drops the hammer and lets the other side make their move. If they act professionally and like adults, well, maybe there's room for negotiation after all. If, on the other hand, they do weird childish shit, well... guess not. In with the new guy!
- panarky 3y agoCourts take years. This industry is changing far too fast for the legal calendar. By the time the lawsuits are resolved, it will all be irrelevant.
- jmtame 3y ago[dead]
- shippintoboston 3y agoCrazy how a 4 person board staved off pressure from a behemoth like Microsoft
- __turbobrew__ 3y agoAs we speak Satya is on his way to turn off OpenAI servers.
- acl777 3y agothey prolly played the: "we've got GPT-5" card :-)
- dougmwne 3y agoThey may be king of the ash pile. Trust seems to have been broken with investors, Microsoft, the staff and the developer community at large. I expect them to continue to be relevant, but just one of the chorus, no longer the leader.
- karmasimida 3y agoIt will be funny if MSFT relicense GPT4 to Sam's new venture, I am very much looking forward to this development.
- sudosysgen 3y agoI'm pretty sure only OpenAI (the non-profit) holds the IP. I don't see why they'd give Microsoft a transferable license.
- pyrophane 3y agoMS doesn't own GPT4
- mupuff1234 3y agoThe options were probably either resign and be on the crosshairs of SV royalty for the rest of their careers or stay and play it out.
- LudwigNagasena 3y ago
- charlie0 3y agoReal question: I've never heard/seen of this website before, is it reputable?
- d3nt 3y agoYes, they get the scoop on many Silicon Valley news stories
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jdminhbg 3y agoYes, it’s real. This story is also confirmed by Bloomberg.
- xeriuno 3y agoThe Information is very reputable
- mattzito 3y agoThe information? Yes, they are highly focused on the tech industry and very diligent. They make most (all?) of their revenue on subscriptions, so that limits their incentives to make clickbait content.
- astrange 3y agoWell, they make different kinds of bad content, like in-depth investigations of how cool the parties their subscribers hold are.
- pigscantfly 3y agoYes, this is one of the top outlets focused on the valley tech scene. It's subscription based, and they are more expensive than most others, which is probably why you haven't seen it posted much.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tentacleuno 3y agoThis appears to be paywalled; is there an alternative link / source? Edit: This was in reply to the prior, non-paywalled URL. Comment moved by dang.
- tempsy 3y agoThe Twitch guy who now spends his day tweeting about mundane YIMBY stuff? Bizarre…
- operatingthetan 3y agoThe whole affair has been bizarre. Professionals discuss all this stuff out of the public eye and execute when they have a plan. Every single move from all parties here has been run and gun and looks like amateur hour. These people do business like the characters on Succession.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoI think trump and elon sort of made it ok to showcase the shit online. Like how YC got involved with fighting other VCs on twitter. I have huge respect for YC and never thought they would do that, but here we are. Again a stark reminder that all of these guys from Ray Dalio to the run of the mill SF VC are all just normal, twisted people who don't know much better about anything and merely had a run of good luck. Stop paying attention to them.
- AutoDunkGPT 3y agoOr in other words, there’s no downside to narcissism when you can broadcast it and accumulate loyal followers who will ply you with money and fame
- Racing0461 3y agoFeels like the board were "true believers" in the nonprofit/human first/guardrails and sam just wanted to zuckerberg openai by growing as fast as possible and in the end the true believers won.
- dougmwne 3y agoWhat did they win exactly? This is far from the only effort to develop AI models. They were a leader for a time, but seem unlikely to continue in that position.
- JCM9 3y agoYou can hear Microsoft’s billions going up in flames. You literally couldn’t make this stuff up.
- acl777 3y agoBillions... of AzureBucks!!! :-)
- threeseed 3y agoActually this is going to be great for Microsoft. By cutting its other revenue streams OpenAI has lost all of its leverage. So now will shrink to being effectively an external dev team for Bing / Windows.
- nextworddev 3y agoHuh? Last time I checked I'm paying OpenAI for my Chatgpt plus subscription, not msft
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMicrosoft owns the GPUs and has rights to continue operating current models. The only value OpenAI had was cohesion of engineering talent as it relates to model development velocity. https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/ai/openai-azure-supercomputer/ https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/ai/openai-azure-s... https://www.semafor.com/article/11/18/2023/openai-has-received-just-a-fraction-of-microsofts-10-billion-investment https://www.semafor.com/article/11/18/2023/openai-has-receiv... > Only a fraction of Microsoft’s $10 billion investment in OpenAI has been wired to the startup, while a significant portion of the funding, divided into tranches, is in the form of cloud compute purchases instead of cash, according to people familiar with their agreement. > That gives the software giant significant leverage as it sorts through the fallout from the ouster of OpenAI CEO Sam Altman. The firm’s board said on Friday that it had lost confidence in his ability to lead, without giving additional details. > One person familiar with the matter said Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella believes OpenAI’s directors mishandled Altman’s firing and the action has destabilized a key partner for the company. It’s unclear if OpenAI, which has been racking up expenses as it goes on a hiring spree and pours resources into technological developments, violated its contract with Microsoft by suddenly ousting Altman. > Microsoft has certain rights to OpenAI’s intellectual property so if their relationship were to break down, Microsoft would still be able to run OpenAI’s current models on its servers.
- famouswaffles 3y agoMurati being Interim CEO for a day to be replaced by another Interim CEO is exceedingly funny. Also if some of the wilder motives behind this shitshow are true then Microsoft will never see GPT-5.
- wannacboatmovie 3y agoEven funnier is someone (in a now flagged and dead'd post) accused me of being a misogynist for daring to even think of questioning her experience or capability as CEO. If you are CEO for a day do you get to wear a paper crown like at Burger King?
- famouswaffles 3y agoI don't know if you're misogynist but her qualifications are fine. She's not CEO anymore because she wanted Sam and Greg back not because she somehow failed her 1 day duties.
- sudosysgen 3y agoI'm not disputing her qualifications but going to war against the board is failing your duties. In a for profit it can work if you have your shareholders on your side but it's clear here that this maneuver can't work.
- famouswaffles 3y agoNeedless pedantry. Incompetence isn't the reason she's out is the point anymore than incompetence is the reason Sam is out.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kromem 3y agoFoundational AI companies fracturing is going to be good for the overall market. Just like Anthropic spinning off from OpenAI brought some very cool research (particularly liked the functional introspection vs node based stuff), Altman going into his own venture to compete will help diversify the overall space. And while many seem to be thinking this is going to bode poorly for OpenAI, I think perhaps long term it might be a good thing. Ilya is quite impressive and his having greater influence with Altman gone may result in them exploring more interesting avenues that have long term value which might not have been as prioritized with a focus on maximizing short term rollouts. While the way the board handled it wasn't great optics, this is probably going to be an overall positive shakeup for AI and LLMs in 2024-2025.
- dougmwne 3y agoIt probably is a good thing, not because Ilya is going to safeguard humanity’s future, but because it’s better to have a very competitive field rather than one break away winner. No lone genius will invent AGI. It will be a collective effort of dozens of labs, trading talent and methods. If OpenAI is a few years ahead now, they will quickly lose that edge due to this infighting and others will catch up.
- peanuty1 3y agoI wonder how successful Sam's next AI venture will be without Ilya.
- threatripper 3y agoThe problems that had been solved remain solved, no need for a genius for those problems. They will also have solutions that the public doesn't know about yet.
- Palmik 3y agoThe default winners in this race, in the medium-term horizon (~18 months), are the existing incumbents: Alphabet, Microsoft, Meta. OpenAI was positioned to be able to compete. I am not sure a diluted OpenAI will be.
- siva7 3y agoThis is more bizarre than an episode of silicon valley. Must be the happiest day for Google in the last year.
- throwaway128128 3y agoI was thinking Game of Thrones.
- francisduvivier 3y agoIndeed, on the Lex Fridman podcast, Musk said it was a very tough recruiting battle for Ilya. Now it looks like they have a shot at getting him back.
- tempsy 3y agoHow so? Ilya won. OpenAI is now more his than it was before Sam was fired.
- erichocean 3y agoA pyrrhic victory.
- skygazer 3y agoI think Ilya is getting what he wanted. Although, that may yet have disastrous consequences for the company if employees follow through on mass quitting, thus freeing him up. But if they can quickly prevent people leaving in the short term, maybe urgent discontent will pass.
- kfrzcode 3y agoIf you mean they is Google and Larry, sure. But in that clip Elon was recruiting for OpenAI
- minimaxir 3y agoMaybe OpenAI can now realize the true potential of AI Seinfeld.
- Trasmatta 3y agoI feel like the board probably refused the demand that they issue a statement retracting the claims of wrongdoing by Altman.
- brandall10 3y agoDoubtful that was an issue. Altman asked for the board's resignation. So basically Ilya would have to leave the company.
- jxi 3y agoThat would have opened them up to a lawsuit (while employment is "at will", you can still get sued for negligence or baseless slandering). A statement retracting claims for such a high profile move would be a pretty solid piece of evidence in such a case.
- karmasimida 3y agoGuess i was right then. On to the next, Sam. Nobody deserved to be treated like this.
- thatsadude 3y agoThis is ridiculous. AI doomer as the new CEO.
- reducesuffering 3y agoBad news for you, their last CEO was too. Sam Altman signed a statement saying "Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war." Looks like you're not on any of their team, but you do have crypto king Marc Andreessen. https://twitter.com/robbensinger/status/1726039794197872939 https://twitter.com/robbensinger/status/1726039794197872939
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> Bad news for you, their last CEO was too. Did anyone believe that he seriously believed in that? I thought the consensus was he was angling for a government backed monopoly with OpenAI as the “steward” of large AI models.
- comp_throw7 3y agoThis view was totally divorced from reality. Sam literally laid out his own case for AI posing an extinction risk on his blog in 2015, before OpenAI was even founded: https://blog.samaltman.com/machine-intelligence-part-1 https://blog.samaltman.com/machine-intelligence-part-1 "Development of superhuman machine intelligence (SMI) [1] is probably the greatest threat to the continued existence of humanity."
- blobbers 3y agoSam must have sizable equity in the company. He sells to Microsoft and they dissolve the board, problem solved.
- famouswaffles 3y agoSam doesn't have any equity in Open AI
- localhost 3y agoHe has nearly zero equity in OpenAI by design.
- stephenitis 3y agohave you read any of the articles at all before firing off that sentence?
- blobbers 3y agoNone of them seem to have mentioned it, but indeed it is confirmed he had very little equity in the company. This seems like a fairly unconventional idea in a capitalist world where Altman has made all his money on exactly that - equity. Seems like it has ultimately bit him, the investors, and the board in the ass. Poor incentive structure in the corporate governance is going to really mess with people's heads.
- pyrophane 3y agoActually, from what I read he did not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kuter 3y agoI wonder if the recent departure of Kyle Vogt from Cruise is related. Emmett Shear and Kyle Vogt founded Twitch together.
- threeseed 3y agoIt would make a lot of sense. Kyle knows the space, is already wealthy and has always been pretty altruistic. And the fact that Emmett is only interim should give you a hint something is up.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y agoOn the other hand, if Kyle was ousted for pushing too hard too fast at Cruise, that seems like out of the frying pan into the fire. See https://archive.is/Vqjpr https://archive.is/Vqjpr
- dragonwriter 3y ago> And the fact that Emmett is only interim should give you a hint something is up. That they didn't complete the process of a permanent CEO over the weekend after firing and then negotiating with Altman?
- alsodumb 3y agoWait why would you think this is would be related to Kyle? Kyle's story was brewing from the moment GM appointed their attorney to manage Cruise - everyone knew there was gonna be restructuring of the executive team after the incident. If anything, it was a convenient time for Kyle to step down as it wouldn't get a lot of prime time thanks to OpenAI drama.
- himaraya 3y agoIf Emmett has any say at all in the matter, Kyle's almost definitely under consideration.
- keyle 3y agoAnd water is blue and so is the sky. Coincidence I think not! /s
- d3nt 3y agoMore details in this tweet thread: https://twitter.com/ashleevance/status/1726469283734274338 https://twitter.com/ashleevance/status/1726469283734274338
- _lvbh 3y agoI’m glad people in this thread are supporting the OpenAI board in this decision. There seems to be too much celebrity worship around Altman from all the tech/crypto bros. Also, any new competition started by Altman would be good for the ecosystem in general.
- swax 3y agoSo much judgement this weekend with so little information.
- alsodumb 3y agoI'd have agreed with you if it was an extensive board with many experts, both technical and policy, without any strong conflict of interests. But at this point, we have Ilya who clearly has strong difference of opinions with Sam, Adam D'Angelo, whose company Poe has a conflict of interest with the existance of for profit OpenAI and their GPT store/customizable agents, and two other board members.
- eddiewithzato 3y agoWas Ilya not the brains of OpenAI? Seems like rest were investors
- vagabund 3y agoAs long as we're speculating from the outside, in a strong difference of opinions between Altman and Sutskever, I'm inclined to support Sutskever.
- beeyaw 3y agoAre you for real? "Difference of opinions" isn't a problem for a board, it's exactly why multiple people are on one. And Adam will not have any conflict of interest with Poe very shortly.
- alsodumb 3y agoIt is a problem when you pretty much fired two board members who would've been against Ilyas opinion. Maybe Adam will not have any conflict in a few months, but he does now. He did when he and others got rid of Greg and Sam from the board. That's my point.
- jart 3y agoSo long Mira Murati. That's the second CEO OpenAI has ousted in one week. https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transition https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transiti...
- peanuty1 3y agoThank god they went with Emmett over Murati.
- matt_daemon 3y agoWhy?
- jxi 3y agoHer move makes even less sense than what the board did. The board told her the day before that they're firing Sam, so she obviously accepted it. But, one day later she caves and sides with Sam (that's what the heart tweet means)? That's weak leadership and resolve.
- flylib 3y agoSeems like he liked anti sama stuff as well https://x.com/moridinamael/status/1725893666663768321?s=46 https://x.com/moridinamael/status/1725893666663768321?s=46
- polygamous_bat 3y agoWould be pretty weird to step in Sam’s replacement if he was philosophically aligned with him?
- tempsy 3y agoYes, but you rarely see two people who run in the same circles/part of the same OG YC class publicly criticize one or the other.
- babyshake 3y agoThat's not Emmett?
- flylib 3y agohe liked the tweet
- ec109685 3y agoPart of the interview process.
- schleck8 3y agoUnless the tweet I saw was fake, he's also decided to slow down pace to 1 or 2 on a scale of 1 to 10. Going to run that company into the floor
- webwielder2 3y agoThe real winner in all this is once again Tim Cook, the only tech CEO to not constantly flail around dripping in flop sweat chasing the buzzword du jour.
- hirsin 3y agoI know it's small potatoes but those other CEOs have added hundreds of millions of dollars in ARR to their bottom lines on AI, in particular open ai. Microsoft doesn't think you're a real product line til a billion plus ARR but still, it's not nothing.
- bushbaba 3y agoHundreds of millions of UNPROFITABLE ARR and only through spending many billions. Apple has rarely been first to market with technology. However they often are first to have a cohesive user experience that integrates it in.
- mbreese 3y agoI think it's still pretty early to know how lasting these ARRs are. We are still early on the hype cycle here. Chat based language models have definitely found good uses, so I don't think we'll ever see them go away, but I'm just cautious about how much net revenue these will really generate (particularly when the expense of the cards needed to train/run them is so high).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 3y agoIt amazes me that more don't follow the example of the most successful company in the world, maybe in the history of the world (hard to make comparisons across eras).
- alsodumb 3y agoI think Adam D'Angelo has a very strong conflict of interest and shouldn't have been on the board of OpenAI. I'm sure Quora views took a hit after ChatGPT. Not like Quora was any good before ChatGPT, they just managed to get to the top of Google results for a lot of common questions. Now, Poe by Quora was trying to go big on custom agents. The GPT Agents announcement on DevDay was a fundamental threat to Poe in many ways. I'm convinced that Adam D'Angelo probably had some influence on the other two board members too. He should've left the board of OpenAI the moment OpenAI and his own company were competing in the same space.
- dereg 3y agoDon't forget Tasha McCauley's husband, Joseph Gordon Levitt, has been vocally anti-AI during the SAG-AFTRA strike, an event for which AI was a huge point of contention. It's a poisoned board.
- zombiwoof 3y agoTheir whole board is a joke The smartest white hot startup on the planet has the smallest board and most inexperienced How did that even happen on Sam’s watch? My take: he always thought Ilya would have his back with Greg and the 3 overrule ruled anybody , so they kept it small Bad idea
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y agoOpenAI was not founded to be a white hot startup: https://archive.is/Vqjpr https://archive.is/Vqjpr
- sangnoir 3y ago> How did that even happen on Sam’s watch? What do you imagine he could have done about the board of a non-profit as CEO and fellow board-member?
- ytoawwhra92 3y ago> What do you imagine he could have done about the board of a non-profit as CEO and fellow board-member? As board members, both Altman and Brockman would have presumably had to vote on any changes to the board - including reduction in number of members and appointment of new members. Do you think the composition of the board before Friday could've been reached without some level of support from Altman and Brockman?
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- jaimex2 3y agoHow is this company structured?! Founders with no stake or control, rogue board members and Microsoft somehow in the mix.
- frabcus 3y agoIt's a non-profit. It isn't a Silicon Valley company. https://openai.com/our-structure https://openai.com/our-structure
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TechnicolorByte 3y agoI still cannot process what’s happened to one of the most prominent and hyped companies of the past year in just one weekend. If it’s true that Altman won’t return to OpenAI (or alternatively: that the current board won’t step down) then where does that leave OpenAI? Microsoft can’t be happy, as evidenced by reporting that Nadella was acting as mediator to bring him back. Does OpenAI survive this? Will be super interesting when all the details come out regarding the board’s decision making. I’m especially curious how the (former) CEO of Twitch gets nominated as interim CEO. Finally, if Altman goes his own way, it’s clear the fervent support he’s getting will lead to massive funding. Combined with the reporting that he’s trying to create his own AI chips with Middle East funding, Altman has big ambitions for being fully self reliant to own the stack completely. No idea what the future holds for any of the players here. Reality truly is stranger than fiction.
- tempsy 3y agoYeah Emmett Shear seems like an odd choice if they’re worried about retention because 1) Twitch was never known to be a particularly great place to work and 2) he stepped down for some reason and not because Twitch was in an amazing place or anything at the time
- himaraya 3y agoEmmett's just a placeholder after Murati turned. I suspect he won't stay in his position for long.
- PepperdineG 3y agoRecursive Interim CEOs. Will there be a Mandelbrot set of Interim CEOs?
- sgift 3y agoThe new research focus demanded by the board in the name of safety will be an CEO AI, which will be aligned to humanities interests - the benchmark to show this will be if it does whatever the board wants. It's the only way to make sure they cannot be stabbed in the back again by a pesky human.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sofaygo 3y agoSometimes fantasy feels more real than reality itself…
- ilaksh 3y agoAssuming that's the end of the story, what hardcore ML people do Altman and Brockman have now for their new AI startup? Or are they just going to focus on the hardware thing?
- meroes 3y agoGuess they didn’t miss, or he wasn’t a king
- valine 3y agoNot a word from Ilya. I can’t wrap my mind around his motivation. Did he really fire Sam over “AI safety” concerns? How is that remotely rational.
- bufferoverflow 3y agoBecause that's not the actual reason. It looks like a hostile takeover. The "king" of, arguably, the most important company in the world, got kicked out with very little effort. It's pretty extraordinary, and the power shift is extraordinary too.
- voidfunc 3y agoKicked out is a bit hyperbole. They don't have their champion anymore but the deal and their minority ownership stake are inked. They still get tech and profits. They might not have a path to owning OpenAI now but that was a problem a few years down the road. They can also invest in Altmans new thing and poach OpenAI talent to bolster their internal AI research which is probably going to get a massive funding boost. The PR hit will be bad for a few days. Good time to buy MS stock on discount but this won't matter in a year or two.
- sdwvit 3y agoMaybe someone from higher up called the board?
- borissk 3y agoChatGPT-5?
- yreg 3y agoThe board firing a CEO is hardly a hostile takeover.
- surrealize 3y agoIf you fire one board member (Altman) and remove another from the board (Brockman) it's not exactly friendly either
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoI find it kind of funny that Altman got into this kind of trouble when presumably he is an expert on startup structure after having advised startups for so many years at YC.
- lysecret 3y agoThis is the guy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cw_ckNH-tT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cw_ckNH-tT8
- nilkn 3y agoAt this point, is there any reason to think this arrangement will last longer than 24-48 hours?
- skygazer 3y agoI would think that the board would have tried to (or is still continuing to try to) pick someone to try to placate Microsoft, other than Altman.
- SeanAnderson 3y ago:s Am I getting up early to sell my MSFT at the bell? What a ridiculous end to this chapter of the story.
- zombiwoof 3y agoI can’t what to see how these backstabbing stewards of AGI align our future overlords.
- roddylindsay 3y agoContrarian prediction: OpenAI will be just fine. The board will bring in an adult CEO who can balance the nonprofit charter with Microsoft and the commercial business, and who doesn't have a million side projects taking his or her focus away. Some employees will leave but the vast majority will stay for the usual reasons (i.e. inertia), the business will keep growing because ChatGPT is already a worldwide brand at this point and the vast majority of users don't give a hoot about any of this palace intrigue as long as the product works. And the board will ultimately be vindicated for acting as fiduciaries for the nonprofit's mission and bylaws -- and not for the financial interests of Satya Nadella, Vinod Khosla, and the like.
- bufferoverflow 3y agoIf they don't get Altman back, Altman starts a new company AkshuallyOpenAI and most talent moves there. They quickly get the funding and the contracts with MS. OpenAI is left in the dust.
- azurezyq 3y agoYou know, we are dealing with people and people think differently so they won't move altogether. Moving to a new company under Alt is not an easy choice, at least the new company: - Does not yet have a big model (need $$$ and months to train, if code is ready) - Does not have proprietary code OpenAI has right now - Does not have labeled data ($$$ and time) and chatgpt logs - Does not have ChatGpt brand...
- bufferoverflow 3y agoI thought GPT-4 was not trained on labeled data, but simply on a large volume of text / code. Most of it is publicly accessible: wikipedia, archives of scientific articles, books, github, plus probably purchased data from text-heavy sites like Reddit.
- enigmurl 3y agoAssuming it's a reference to RLHF? Not sure
- voidfunc 3y agoI'm expecting lawsuits in the next day or two from Altman for libel and defamation. I'd be surprised if OpenAI investors don't go to the courts also ASAP.
- dmitrygr 3y agoSurely, not being on the board you cannot just assume that you know all there is to simply assume that there is only one side to a story? Just because they aren't tweeting a storm does not mean they don't have reasons...
- nicce 3y agoAltman has no case. Board protects their legal responsibilities of non-profit company. Same goes for investors.
- poink 3y agoThe board said he was fired for being insufficiently candid with them. Good luck getting a US court to call that defamation.
- mcpackieh 3y agoYou mean Sam will be suing all the HN and twitter commenters who called him a sister rapist? Remember, the board never said anything like that.
- jumelles 3y agoThat's not at all how the law works. No one has been defamed.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y agoIf they didn't reinstate Sam, Microsoft already threatened to cut off all future funding from OpenAI, (they've only paid 1 out of 10 tranches so far), then sue them, then help Sam poach OpenAI talent at his next venture.
- ytoawwhra92 3y agoWhat's your source for that?
- zombiwoof 3y agoCan’t wait to see how many staffers who said they would quit sheep their way into the office tomorrow to collect their million dollar salaries Thanks Sam we bluffed but no way we quiting
- siva7 3y agoThose few with million dollar salaries can start tomorrow for even much higher salaries in the current market.
- ergocoder 3y agoMost employees are on the profit-sharing-esque compensation. And guess what OpenAI will not be focusing on? Profit. They are not gonna quit tomorrow. They will leave over time due to the low compensation.
- sgu999 3y agoCapital seems to be on Altman's side, they may make a good deal by jumping ship...
- ryanSrich 3y agoYeah it does seem Ilya was smart enough to realize the overwhelming majority of people get caught up in the emotion of these things, but rarely act on their promises when money is involved. I guess we'll see in the coming weeks who quits, but I doubt it'll be significant. Perhaps once Altman gets another company stood up and has billions in the bank to pay people it'll be a different story.
- jatins 3y ago
- losthubble 3y agoHopefully this leads to a lot of internal dissent and someone leaks the models
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maxlin 3y agoWould be fun to see the training material, source code (engine & training data scraping systems), and models all leak. With Sam not returning that would be the double tap the now-zombie OpenAI'd need.
- jessenaser 3y agoBetting on Snowden part 2…
- daguava 3y ago[dead]
- seanhunter 3y agoThis saga highlights something that I found challenging when I was on the board of a startup, and which the board has completely misplayed. The difference between authority and autonomy. If you're on the board of OpenAI which is doing fantastically well etc you're a big deal. You have a great deal of authority. You may well think that the structure of the company and how the votes on the board work etc means that any motion you can carry at the board is within the sphere of things you can achieve i.e. that you have autonomy to do anything you can secure the votes for, but that's rarely the case. In actual practise people like the investors and other stakeholders can change the rules if they need to, exercise soft pressure, bring legal suits and do other things. Your autonomy to act is effectively pretty narrow. However this finally plays out, whether Sam comes back or not, whether openAI's board changes, the people who orchestrated this have seriously damaged themselves and they will most likely have less of both authority and autonomy in future.
- cjbprime 3y agoThis would normally be true, but this is the board of a non-profit that has no investors. If the board actually lacked autonomy, then the article we're commenting on would have been about Altman being re-hired today.
- seanhunter 3y agoThere have been a few stories which sound like he may have had the opportunity to come back but that negotiations over board control etc (which is pretty unsurprising) broke down[1]. Even setting that aside for a second, that doesn't change my essential point that the board doesn't necessarily have all the autonomy it thinks it has. There are for sure repercussions to this - they may have to make concessions. Some of the seemingly committed funding may be unpaid and the donors may have the ability to invoke MAC clauses and similar to pull it. Even if that turns out not to be the case, the way this has played out will certainly affect decisions about future donations etc. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/20/sam-altman-openai-ceo-wont-return-chatgpt-talks-fail-emmett-shear-twitch?ref=upstract.com https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/nov/20/sam-altma...
- mupuff1234 3y agoWhich character is Gordon Joseph Levitt gonna play when the movie comes out?
- mschuetz 3y agoA board member's husband?
- jxi 3y agoIt's certainly telling when you're more known to be an actor's wife than anything to do with AI or the company you're on the board for.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gregcoombe 3y agoHe'll probably be relegated to some minor role like "Husband of Board Member #6"
- cryptoz 3y agoNew AI startup announcement in….10 hours? Maybe they’ll take their time announcing, I dunno.
- icy_deadposts 3y ago[flagged]
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoI don't think a VC techbro is the best bet for humanity's future. A strong non-profit with clear goals and full transparency is 100% better.
- skinpop 3y agoso are you in some kind of doom cult?
- blockwriter 3y agoI can’t understand this perspective. Why? What’s one guy being fired going to mean in the grand scheme of ai’s development?
- icy_deadposts 3y agoThere are 10s or 100s of thousands of programmers working on AI, but only one team under the guidance of Sam has been able to make the progress we've seen with ChatGPT and that is massively jeopardized now by this drama.
- jazzyjackson 3y agopro tip: if you don't identify as belonging to human civilization's future, it won't hurt when someone drives a stake through the heart of human civilization's future.
- MenhirMike 3y agoThis breakup is so messy, did Taylor Swift already write a song about it?
- quickthrower2 3y agoBlank Space
- hilux 3y agoI'm sure it's not Emmett's fault, but ChatGPT is having problems right now. It's failing to generate Python code - first time I've seen this in months of heavy usage.
- Tohhou 3y agoEmbarrassing for OpenAI.
- frabcus 3y agoOn the contrary, it shows it is a non-profit. People keep denying it is and pretending it is a normal Silicon Valley startup. This demonstrates clearly it is a non-profit.
- anupamchugh 3y agoBut the Board members of the non-profit company have been leveraging OpenAI's APIs in their other business endeavors -- like, Adam's Poe chatbot for Quora. More details on board's timeline: https://loeber.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-the-openai-board https://loeber.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-the-openai-board Related read: https://www.techtris.co.uk/p/openai-set-out-to-show-a-different https://www.techtris.co.uk/p/openai-set-out-to-show-a-differ...
- cheeselip420 3y agoNon profit != No profit OpenAI will be even less open now. Ilya must protect all of us from his powerful creations. Only he and his alignment team can be trusted.
- yeck 3y agoI'm actually pretty impressed that they are sticking to their (non-profit) charter against so much pressure. While this was not a "clean" maneuverer I'm not really in a position to judge, given my lack of context. Perhaps there could have been a better execution, but it was the willingness to act when it would not be easy that I think matters most.
- benkarst 3y agoOpenAI never found a true identity under Sam. Sam treated pursued hyper growth (treating it like a YC startup) and many in the company, including Ilya, wanted it to be a research company emphasizing AI safety. Whether you're Team Sutzkaver or team Altman, you can't deny it's been interesting to see extremely talented people fundamentally disagree what to do with godlike technology.
- maxlin 3y agoReplaced by CEO of Twitch, one of the most censorship-happy places on the internet where one can build their career and cancel themselves with one word they can't edit out even if they didn't say it themselves. Damn. I hope Sam guts the place and ClosedAI ends up as a "Lostech" fossil and M$ ends up holding the most expensive sack of poo ever conceived.
- alex_young 3y agoIf you’re a CEO for part of a weekend does it count? Doesn’t sound particularly meaningful.
- timetraveller26 3y agoIt seems the problem with the monopoly of AI solved itself!
- Sverigevader 3y agoThis is surreal! Are we watching Silicon Valley season 7? Laurie Breem is this your doing? Are going through every CEO you can find in an attempt to get Sam Altman to realize he was the right person all along?
- wahnfrieden 3y agoMurati walked, so this new ceo is the interim replacement. That’s independent of rejecting sama.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pcbro141 3y agoAndrej Karpathy: (radioactive emoji) https://twitter.com/karpathy/status/1726478716166123851 https://twitter.com/karpathy/status/1726478716166123851 Going nuclear?
- eccentricity 3y ago[flagged]
- alex_young 3y agoFirst strike in the great emoji war of Sunday night.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sigmar 3y agoI'm assuming Karpathy is describing openai as meltingdown/toxic. Tomorrow will be very interesting.
- elfbargpt 3y agoHis likes give you a pretty good idea of where he stands: https://twitter.com/karpathy/likes https://twitter.com/karpathy/likes
- fsckboy 3y agoI'm actually getting tired of this whole story, jeez. they had an interim CEO: why exactly do they need a new interim CEO? it's been a couple of weekend days, zero business days. Not taking sides, none of this makes any sense, so much drama. hypothesis: there's too much money on the table, and inasmuch as some people care more about the public welfare than money, too much of that too (meaning, a lot of money in something usually means it's something important, something of value, and therefore not all bad; so this is all just people trying to steer things the way they want them to go rather than the way other people want them to go)
- Anuiran 3y agoThe other interim ceo turned on the board and supported Sam I think.
- Maxion 3y agoThis just makes the board seem very incompetent TBH, why select a CEO that is not aligned with the board?
- mock-possum 3y agoRight? Can I just check back in a month to hear how it all shakes out?
- paulddraper 3y agoThe former interim CEO was the CTO, and she (along with investors) was trying to get Altman back. By selecting Shear as the new interim CEO, the board signaled they weren't interested in Altman coming back.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stylepoints 3y agoIt's the nerd version of keeping up with the kardashians.
- mrcwinn 3y agoThe best talent will leave OpenAI the moment Sam announces his new venture. Deep down builders want to build, and they want to do it as quickly as possible. OpenAI will represent caution. NewCo will represent opportunity. Opportunity wins. This is human nature.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y agoThat's not obvious to me. Why did so many join OpenAI in the first place, given that its charter prioritizes humanitarian benefit over building as quickly as possible? https://openai.com/charter https://openai.com/charter
- telotortium 3y agoBecause they were the best. Now that they're actually committing to hobbling themselves, why would these employees stay unless they're AI doomers?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dr_dshiv 3y agoWell, it’s not an “AI Pause” but it definitely seems like a speed bump. Of course, now all the money-making energy of Sama will be put into a new entity that, we assume, will be much faster than OpenAI. Curated datasets will rise in value… that’s the main cost of replicating OpenAI models, in my understanding
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- loveparade 3y agoFor a change, maybe it'd be a good idea to get a CEO who at least has faint idea about how ML works on a technical level? Would you like a company that builds rockets to be led by some salesman who doesn't understand basic Physics? Probably not. You don't need to be Hinton or Schmidhuber, but come on, who thinks it's a good idea to have these typical "Silicon Valley VC CEOs" lead an AI company?
- threeseed 3y ago[flagged]
- loveparade 3y agoYou can hate Elon Musk as much as you want, but he absolutely knows a decent amount of Physics and Material Science. That's what he studied and has always wanted to do before PayPal. He even get into a Material Science PhD at Stanford. He drove a lot of the engineering at both Tesla and SpaceX. And without that, probably none of these companies would've worked out.
- kiidev 3y agoAnother of Musk’s lies that keeps being propagated “ In 1995, he was accepted to a PhD program in materials science at Stanford University.[64][65] However, Musk decided to join the Internet boom, dropping out two days after being accepted and applied for a job at Netscape” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk
- loveparade 3y agoMaybe read my comment again? There is no lie. I said accepted, not attended. And if you've ever tried to get into a PhD program at Stanford you'd know that isn't easy unless you have, you know, at least a little bit of knowledge of the field. So the parent claiming that Elon Musk doesn't even know basic Physics is blatantly wrong.
- jessenaser 3y agoLooks like GPT 5 is ngmi. Watered down and GPT-4.5 coming up. GPT 5 coming 2026 at this rate or not at all…
- rawgabbit 3y agoSomeone help me understand OpenAI’s situation. If Sutskever remains at the company, OpenAi can continue to improve its ChatGPT models and produce model 5.0? What leverage does Microsoft does have over OpenAi? Can Microsoft shut off access to their hardware to support Altman? Why would Microsoft want this?
- rain_iwakura 3y agothe biggest leverage is the billions in compute that Microsoft holds over OpenAI. Without this compute they can't run most of the experiments to get number five before others, who are very close, especially Anthropic.
- quickthrower2 3y agoWhich is weird because Nvidia/TSMC must have some leverage over MS there and could ship out containers of their big cluster units. Also AWS could be the sugar daddy.
- sgift 3y ago> If Sutskever remains at the company, OpenAi can continue to improve its ChatGPT models and produce model 5.0? I think the more important question is: Is Sutskever interested in a model 5.0 anytime soon? If he really ousted Sam A. because he thought they moved "too fast" wouldn't he rather work on making 4.0 "more secure" (whatever that means) instead of producing a 5.0?
- AmericanOP 3y ago</removed>
- cthalupa 3y agoMurati was not on the board and had no vote.
- robbomacrae 3y agoI think you're mistakingly thinking Mira Murati was on the board. That is not the case. The board is Adam D'Angelo, Helen Toner, Ilya Sutskever, and Tasha McCauley after Sam and Greg were removed. Mira Murati was not involved except for the fact she was made the initial replacement. For all we know she had no information on what happened when she was asked to step in.
- AmericanOP 3y agoNoted! Thanks
- naiv 3y agoDo non-profits have non-competes? or can the employees now just leave and go to a competitor?
- tibbydudeza 3y agoRIP OpenAI - gone like MySpace but not through fickle customers but self inflicted hubris. Microsoft might as well hire the entire team leaving and give them a Dave Cutler team like deal - do what you folks want in San Fransico - full autonomy reporting directly to the CEO but and make us some god dammed money already. All that compute credits from Microsoft - hasta la vista baby.
- Palmik 3y agoEmmett is a self-proclaimed AI doomer. Given some of his Tweets from the past, it's likely the board indeed wants someone who will takes things slower: https://archive.is/tuf3s https://archive.is/tuf3s https://archive.is/sNvvs https://archive.is/sNvvs This is probably not something you want to hear as a researcher who is motivated by pushing the frontiers of our capabilities, nor as a researcher who is motivated by pushing their compensation.
- rf15 3y agoBut what are you going to do if your ambitions cannot be met with the money and resources they require, especially in the long term? They look like they're tripping over hard limits.
- yeck 3y agoI'd say it sounds like they want to go faster with research and slower with commercializing the outputs of the research.
- Palmik 3y agoAccelerating research on increasing reasoning / intelligence capabilities of AI? That is opposite of what Emmett seemed to advocate recently, so it would be strange to pick him as the CEO if they really wanted to accelerate that.
- yeck 3y agoThose are not the only things to research, but I wouldn't assume that capability-base research would stop. I mean, they want to create AI to perform AI alignment, so their road map includes capability research. The for-profit bender that OpenAI was on appears to have been more of the issue. It's one thing to create greater capabilities for enhancing the rate of research, and another rushing those capabilities to market.
- Klonoar 3y agoThose researchers should be met with restraint. One can ultimately still push the frontiers while also showing restraint - stop acting like it's either-or.
- rf15 3y agoThis entire show will damage Altman and what remains of OpenAI equally - OpenAI because of its unprofessional way of dealing with internal problems, and Altman, well, there's apparently a reason they were unhappy with him.
- astrange 3y agoThey were apparently unhappy with him because he's too good at business, so I think his reputation is intact.
- nicce 3y agoOr he is not doing what the board wants, which is damaging. If I am good at hacking computers, it does not mean that I should hack all of them and get to the jail.
- astrange 3y agoThe board (Ilya) wanted to be a research nonprofit, which is fair, but they accidentally grew a giant business out of it via Microsoft investment and Sam was doing a pretty solid job of continuing that. This is fair that it's a distraction from the mission, but randomly firing him and now having all their staff leave and probably losing all the compute funding is a strange way of dealing with it.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> This entire show will damage Altman and what remains of OpenAI equally The only thing it damages about Altman is the credibility of him using his purported concern for AI safety as a PR lever for regulatory capture.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- russellbeattie 3y agoReality check for those who need it: Altman won't be starting a competing company. First, he may have contractual restrictions and second, OpenAI owns their IP. And even if Altman is somehow free to do what he wants because he was fired (doubtful), anyone who quits to go with him surely do have airtight non-competes. Besides, it's not like Sam and his few loyalists are just going to spin up a few servers and duplicate what OpenAI has done. He'll do something AI-adjacent like the chip startup he was rumored to be pursuing. As for Microsoft, they have a contract with OpenAI and are deeply reliant on them at the moment. OpenAI isn't disappearing just because Sam and Greg aren't there. Nadella may not be happy with the change, but he'll just have to live with it. Nothing will change for the foreseeable future there either. When it comes to lawsuits? Who knows, but I highly doubt Altman will fight, or if he does, it will be discreetly settled as it's in no one's interest to wage some protracted battle. Microsoft may want to renegotiate their deal, but that again most likely isn't going to be anything nasty, as Microsoft needs OpenAI right now. As for developers and consumers of OpenAI's service? They won't care or notice for many months until whatever changes the new CEO and board have in mind are enacted.
- robbomacrae 3y agoWant to bet? Altman has been building himself as the public face of AI and won't let that go so easily. It's not like his world coin is taking off... And non competes can be as airtight as you like.. they are completely unenforceable in California which is where OpenAI's HQ is based and where Sam Altman lives. First the loyal will jump ship. Followed quickly by the mercenaries who see the chance to join a new rocket ship from the ground up. Then as OpenAI's shares tank on the secondary market the rest will decide they've seen enough of their paper money burn and cash out. OpenAI will survive but its going to be a much smaller company and a much smaller valuation. As for Microsoft I'm guessing one of the strings Nadella was pulling was threatening to revoke credits, resources and even use by his teams and I'm sure he would be interested in investing in whatever Altman starts next and dedicating those now spare machines to the new enterprise.
- russellbeattie 3y ago> they are completely unenforceable in California California's non-compete laws don't cover "trade secrets", only your ability to use your expertise to pursue employment in your chosen field. In other words, if you're just a regular programmer, you can go work wherever you like or start a competing company. If you're a principal scientist or architect, you would be in danger of violating your contract. Anyone who went with Altman would presumably have deep inside knowledge of OpenAI's secret sauce and therefore be restricted.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zoogeny 3y agoI’m genuinely surprised that they stuck to their guns. The PR push behind Altman’s return was convincing enough that I had my doubts. Altman will be more than fine, he’ll get a bucket of money and the chance to prove he is the golden boy he’s been sold to the world. He will get to recruit a team that believes in his vision of accelerating AI for commercial use. This will lead to a more diverse market. I hope for the best for those who remain at OpenAI. I hope for the best for Altman and Brockman.
- tempusalaria 3y agoThe whole situation should make it clear that SV media is beholden to VCs and will print anything they tell them to. Bloomberg, the verge and the information all went to bat for Altman in a big way on this.
- zaptheimpaler 3y agoYou could say the same thing if they were rooting for the board instead..
- tempusalaria 3y agoIt’s not the job of the media to root for anyone. The media should dispassionately report the truth. In this case they did not do so.
- _factor 3y agoIn most cases they do not. We haven’t had unfiltered media for a very long time now. Your voice is blocked from a large audience by many many barriers if you mention any forbidden keywords together.
- staunton 3y ago> We haven’t had unfiltered media for a very long time now. When did we have it?
- rococode 3y ago"We fired the CEO for being too profit-driven" is a terrible message to send to your employees when you've lured them in with $1m comp packages that mostly consist of "Profit Participation Units" that are only worth anything when you actually make money.
- plugin-baby 3y ago...unless those engineers are happy with fat salaries and understand that startup equity should be valued at zero.
- ytoawwhra92 3y agoMaybe the executive management shouldn't have used "Profit Participation Units" to attract staff to join a non-profit organisation. Seems like a way to put the incentives and motivations of the staff at odds with the charter of the organisation.
- xcodevn 3y agoEven if OpenAI falls apart, this is still a good move.
- mfiguiere 3y agoTheInformation: Dozens of Staffers Quit OpenAI After Sutskever Says Altman Won’t Return >Dozens of OpenAI staffers internally announced they were quitting the company Sunday night, said a person with knowledge of the situation, after board director and chief scientist Ilya Sutskever told employees that fired CEO Sam Altman would not return. https://www.theinformation.com/articles/dozens-of-staffers-quit-openai-after-sutskever-says-altman-wont-return https://www.theinformation.com/articles/dozens-of-staffers-q...
- intellectronica 3y agoTip for builders: you can use the GPT APIs on Microsoft Azure. Managed reliably, nobody's quitting, no drama. Same APIs, just with better controls, global availability, and a very stable, reliable, and trustworthy provider. (disclosure: I work at Azure, but this is just my own observation).
- Xenoamorphous 3y agoGPT on Azure has become incredibly slow for us in the past few weeks.
- _boffin_ 3y agoQuestion: how difficult is it to get that no retention waiver on prompts and responses?
- intellectronica 3y agoNot difficult. I've not heard of anyone who asked and _didn't_ get the waiver. It's just a responsible stop-gap in case a user does something questionable or dangerous.
- apstls 3y agoThe waiver still allows for logging of prompts for the specific purpose of abuse monitoring for some limited retention period, right? How difficult is it to have this waived as well?
- PeterStuer 3y agoMay I hope that after all those that were seduced by the money leave with Sam, Ilya will see the light and realize the only "safe" way to deal with AI is to have it 100% open, free and public?
- sidcool 3y agoThings just got pretty interesting. On one hand, the board has doubled down on their decision, which lends them some credibility, on the other hand Altman seems out for good from OpenAI.
- senectus1 3y agoTo me this choice feels like a push for monetizing... The guy has very little AI expertise.
- frabcus 3y ago"I specifically say I’m in favor of slowing down, which is sort of like pausing except it’s slowing down. If we’re at a speed of 10 right now, a pause is reducing to 0. I think we should aim for a 1-2 instead." - Emmett Shear, Sep 16, 2023 https://twitter.com/eshear/status/1703178063306203397?t=8nHSsoJp4NmQryez6nFw9g&s=19 https://twitter.com/eshear/status/1703178063306203397?t=8nHS...
- vasco 3y agoRest in peace OpenAI. Microsoft's investment might have just gone from one of the best of the decade to one of the worst in the course of a weekend.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoWouldn't simply others pick up the slack then?
- unsupp0rted 3y agoWe're about to find out
- adastra22 3y agoRIP OpenAI. You’ll be left in the dust.
- siva7 3y agoSlowing down what exactly? This cryptic messages are like a slap in the face for their dev community
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 3y ago"That's great, Emmett. What do the Chinese think?"
- ansk 3y agoThe contrast between the media's depiction of today's events with this outcome demonstrates how much Sam and his aligned interests can influence a narrative. The vast majority of reporting indicated that Sam held all the leverage, the board members were about to be fired, and a new board would be appointed which would be much better aligned with Sam. These accounts took special care to portray the current board as inept, wavering, and eager to backtrack. However, the reality appears to be that the board was steadfast in their decision and focused on moving forward in search of a new CEO. The truth is, we still don't know the real reason why Sam was ousted. His removal may be justified and it may not. But in the absence of information, media speculation was overwhelmingly biased in Sam's interests. If the news that the board did not immediately backtrack and capitulate to Sam's demands seems to be coming out of left field, you've likely fallen victim to this narrative. Chances are the board is not as incompetent as you were led to believe, and any judgement of their competence should be reserved until further details are provided on the reasons for Sam's removal.
- systemvoltage 3y agoThere is one thing that sticks out: Why didn't the board explain itself clearly? There are times when saying anything publicly would be considered defamation and openining themselves to lawsuits, but it seems that they owe it to their own staff in plain words. They didn't explain the situation properly as per leaked internal announcements.
- choppaface 3y agoMaybe for a company of 12-50 there would be more candid discussion internally, but over 100 and especially at OpenAI size (and with Microsoft involved) liability control is at the max. Moreover, if the Board thought the decision would help improve retention, then they would comment, but that's clearly not the case. OpenAI is not a typical LLC or S/C-corp though, so the Board also has to overcome that conceptual hurdle.
- ah765 3y agoI think it's possible that Sam had some secret plans involving deals with external companies, that the board learned about. They can't reveal that information without potentially damaging other businesses and becoming liable.
- nicetryguy 3y agoNope'n AI
- wokwokwok 3y agoHonest question: Other than 1) Microsoft and 2) anyone building a product with the OpenAI api 3) OpenAI employees… …is OpenAI crashing a burning a big deal? This seems rather over hyped… everyone has an opinion, everyone cares because OpenAI has a high profile. …but really, alternatives to chatGPT exist now, and most people will be, really… not affected by this in any meaningful degree. Isn’t breaking the strangle hold on AI what everyone wanted with open source models last week? Feels a lot like Twitter; people said it would crash and burn, but really, it’s just a bit rubbish now, and a bunch of other competitors have turned up. …and competitive pressure is good right? I predict: what happens will look a lot like what happened with Twitter. Ultimately, most people will not be affected. The people who care will leave. New competitors will turn up. Life goes on…
- emodendroket 3y agoIn Twitter's case that's the main product getting worse without any of the wannabes getting that much traction.
- renegade-otter 3y agoIt's different. People spend YEARS building their social media presence, following, and algorithmic advantage. Jumping to a different platform is a huge sacrifice for power users - those who create content and value. None of this is a factor here. ChatGPT is just a tool, like an online image resizer.
- flarg 3y agoIMHO Twitter drove its own need and now that it has pretty much gone no one wants the hassle of serving a new master.
- emodendroket 3y agoI don't really get the social media landscape. Myspace transitioning to Facebook had a pretty clear direction; people moved on from one thing to the other. These days it feels like people are just... getting out of the habit of using certain kinds of media.
- torginus 3y agoThis is wild speculation, but I just noticed whenever I load the ChatGPT page, it will briefly say 'ChatGPT Alpha' before switching to ChatGPT 4. Maybe they created the new model and there's something interesting about it?
- sidcool 3y agoElon Musk has been publicly unhappy with the direction Sam was taking, and seemed liked aligning with Ilya more. Would he have a hand in this?
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoKara Swisher has some additional details: https://twitter.com/karaswisher/status/1726477828072382480 https://twitter.com/karaswisher/status/1726477828072382480
- skygazer 3y agoOh wow, she’s definitely taken sides. I wonder if Elon will be paying their legal bills. She alludes to shadowy machinations. This reaches an end, then gets wackier, and repeats.
- reducesuffering 3y agoKara Swisher is so unhinged, she thinks Emmett Shear, founder and CEO of Twitch, is "being generous here, less than impressive in comparison to" Mira Murati...
- skygazer 3y agoNoticed that. She did soften that stance later. She seemed oddly invested.
- icyfox 3y agoThis will be an interesting test to see how fast you can bootstrap GPT-4 level performance with unlimited funds and talent that already has deep knowledge of the internals. With the initial adoption of ChatGPT alongside Copilot, OpenAI's data moat of crawled data & RLHF is pretty vast. And that's not leaving the walled garden of OpenAI. You can simulate a lot of this using other off-the-shelf LLMs (see Alpaca) but nothing is a substitute for real world observed usage. In a related note, has this meaningfully broken through to the mainstream yet? If a ChatGPT competitor comes out tomorrow that is just as good - but under a different brand - how many people will switch because it's Altman backed? I'll be curious to find out.
- mdekkers 3y agoI would switch, but not because of Altman backing or not. I would switch if their strategy were to be to progress at pace. I’m not big on AI safety as it is parroted these days, I just want more AI, faster.
- tempusalaria 3y agoMany of OpenAIs most talented people left to start Anthropic. They have billions in funding and have not yet got particularly close to GPT-4. I think that illustrates it will be a be a big uphill battle for any new entrant no matter how well funded or resourced.
- leoh 3y agoThe parent post is literally true yet keeps getting downvoted — what a mess HN has become, too
- leoh 3y ago-2 points and a truly shifting +/- situation @dang — any plans to do anything here I mean not like you have to but yeah I can think of some stuff that could make this better probably (or at minimum experiments that could be run) Also not on this post but in general I mean
- 3y ago
- mlindner 3y agoI'm really happy about this. Hopefully this sets OpenAI back on a course toward positive and open uses for AI. Maybe even properly open sourcing things again.
- huxflux 3y agoHN! If I had a recorded phone call, emails and chats I thought it would be the better for the public to know about, how would I go ahead and share such in the best and most anonymous way?
- 8bitchemistry 3y agoNYTimes has the SecureDrop tip submission which uses Tor (see details at https://www.nytimes.com/tips https://www.nytimes.com/tips)
- kolinko 3y agotheverge and theinformation have tip lines/e-mails, and you can message them, or write to one of the reporters writing about that directly. I would trust them to keep the confidentiality
- adastra22 3y agoFirst of all know that California is a two party consent state. You’d be putting yourself in grave legal danger if your identity could be inferred from a leaked recorded phone call.
- quickthrower2 3y agoWould that apply to an international call? Not that I am encouraging the GP. I upvoted the “laaaaaaaawyer” comment.
- adastra22 3y agoNot a lawyer so: “laaaaaaaawyer!”
- FridgeSeal 3y agoI believe most major news orgs have secure anonymous mechanisms for communicating with them. E.g. the guardian etc.
- smitty1110 3y ago
- seydor 3y agoMy takeaway from this is the future of AI shouldnt be left to the american kindergarten
- sschueller 3y agoNo worries, Sam managed to lobby congress enough that they will make research quite R&D.
- esafak 3y agoOr is it an example of American democracy and its culture of dissent?
- Garrrrrr 3y ago> american kindergarten what point are you trying to make here exactly?
- rvba 3y agoIs there anything (law, bylaws, valuation) that is used to decide how many people should be on the board of OpenAI? It looks like the current board (4 people?) can do absolutely whatever they want and they report to nobody? Nobody can replace them? Second question: in a hypothetical situation that they all died, who and how would pick the new board? The CEO? What if the CEO died too? I think a case like this happened after some helicopter crash in Australia - where everyone entered the same helicopter and died.
- gzer0 3y ago@karpathy on Twitter: I just don’t have anything too remarkable to add right now. I like and respect Sam and I think so does the majority of OpenAI. The board had a chance to explain their drastic actions and they did not take it, so there is nothing to go on except exactly what it looks like. https://twitter.com/karpathy/status/1726289070345855126 https://twitter.com/karpathy/status/1726289070345855126
- lajawfe 3y agoI for one thought Karpathy would side with the core researchers and not the corpos. To me, this whole ordeal is a clash between profit motives of Sam vs Non Profit and Safety motives of OpenAI's original charter. I mean didn't HN hate when OpenAI changed their open nature and become completely closed and profit oriented? This could be the healing of the cancer that OpenAI brought to this field to make it closed as a whole.
- wilg 3y agoBut isn't Ilya's thing that open sourcing it is too dangerous?
- vintermann 3y agoKarpathy is a very agreeable guy and a fantastic educator, and he's very respected by everyone including leader-owners like Altman and Musk, but he doesn't seem like he has very strong opinions one way or another about the hot button issues.
- ShamelessC 3y agoKarpathy is a hybrid. He’s smart, but he clearly enjoys both the money and the attention. This is the guy who defended Elon’s heavily exaggerated self driving claims when the impact was actual human lives.
- tempusalaria 3y agoHe spent 5 years at Tesla backing up their self driving lies for money.
- 3y ago
- bmitc 3y agoThrough all of this, no one has cogently explained why Altman leaving is such a big deal. Why would workers immediately quit their job when he has no other company, and does he even know who these workers are? Are these people that desperate to make a buck (or the prospect of big bucks)? It seems like half of the people working at the non-profit were not actually concerned about the mission but rather just waiting out their turn for big bucks and fame. What does Altman bring to the table besides raising money from foreign governments and states, apparently? I just do not understand all of this. Like, how does him leaving and getting replaced by another CEO the next week really change anything at the ground level other than distractions from the mission being gone? And the outpouring of support for someone who was clearly not operating how he marketed himself publicly is strange and disturbing indeed.
- lazystar 3y agostability.
- bmitc 3y agoBut Altman, the ousted CEO, appears to have been adding to the instability. His firing seems like a step in getting back to a desired stability.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mdekkers 3y agoCan you, you know, bring facts and data to this discussion, as opposed to vague handwaving of weird accusations? Altman has been doing an amazing job at running the business he co-founded, and “instability” isn’t something _anyone_ at any side of the discussion is accusing him of. What is this instability, in your view? And how is this “desired stability” going to come back?
- bmitc 3y ago
- metamate419 3y agoI can't believe Meta is now the leader in generative AI because of an own goal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- djha-skin 3y agoAlright, cool, they stuck to their guns about being not-for-profit, and they want to be more mission focused than profit/product focused. Why, then, did they bring in THE CO-FOUNDER OF TWITCH to help them out? Seems like an off-brand thing to do for a group of people focused on "the mission".
- altpaddle 3y agoI mean it's not like there's going to be a huge pool of suitable candidates for something like this on short notice. They probably picked the most capable candidate they knew of who aligned with their values
- TheCaptain4815 3y agoDoes Ilya think he can slow down Zuckerberg, Elon, Anthropic, etc Don’t understand his thought process, especially after all the resignations. Does he really expect OpenAI to maintain its position especially with the threat of Microsoft and pretty much all other investors backing off? Ironically, he might have been better off keeping Sam since he’d have some say in things. But if llama 4 beats gpt5? Zuck won’t even answer his calls.
- Zenul_Abidin 3y agoWhat a clown show. OpenAI write that they have confidence in the CTO to be the interim and then they immediately dump her for another person?
- yieldcrv 3y agoI wonder if employees can sue and successfully get compensation or conditions imposed on the board due to private market volatility in the price of their PPU’s That would be fun case law to keep this soap opera going
- pg_1234 3y agohttps://archive.ph/Berx9 https://archive.ph/Berx9
- cryptoz 3y agoA take oft-said but not oft-discussed decently: where is Google? A whole year after ChatGPT and all we have is a limping-along Bard? Still shocks me. "May you live in interesting times" indeed. I really truely always assumed it was a given that Google would lead the AI future - but...here we are, the talk of the town and Google isn't anywhere.
- zabzonk 3y agois it just me, or is Altman not a dead-ringer for Burke (horrible corporate asshole) in "Aliens"? i mean physically - i'm not suggesting anything to do with chest-bursters and the like.
- fidotron 3y agoIt is quite clear the true purpose of OpenAI is the exact opposite of the name, meaning it is to run ahead of the curve, understand the impact of developments, and ensure they are locked away by any means necessary at least until they can be exploited by groups represented by the board. Altman was trying to play this game in parallel with commercialization, which brings a whole pile of conflicting groups into the picture. People have utterly underestimated the depth of interest represented by the board. It is highly amusing how many of the EA cult are on each side, and how both will portray whatever they are pursuing entirely for personal goals as for the greater good when in reality no one has a clue.
- pug_mode 3y agoDoesn't Microsoft own access to everything OpenAI is working on prior to AGI? Couldn't Sam and his team get hired by MSFT and continue their work?
- pug_mode 3y ago4 minutes after that comment, Satya said Sam and some his people are joining Microsoft! https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/1726509045803336122 https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/1726509045803336122
- chirau 3y agoGood companies are supposed to survive the exit of a CEO. No matter how good that CEO was. If those companies cannot, then perhaps their only value was the CEO and not the product they are offering.
- karmasimida 3y agoUpdate: Sam and Greg, and left OpenAI staffers now join in Microsoft https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/1726509045803336122 https://twitter.com/satyanadella/status/1726509045803336122
- mark_mart 3y agoThis was unexpected.
- dagmx 3y agoIdk it’s been one of the top speculations since the beginning of this drama.
- dagmx 3y agoSeems like a logical choice. Microsoft’s next big play is generative AI, and they’ve put a lot of money into that. They need to show they’re taking steps to stabilize things now that their hype factory has come unraveled. I don’t think they particularly need these people , because they likely already have in house talent that is competitive. But having these people on board now will allow them to paint a much more stable picture to their shareholders.
- exizt88 3y agoI bet "new advanced AI research team" at Microsoft is going to be underwhelming for many, but really, it should be eye-opening. This is what startups, especially VC-backed capital-intensive AI startups, usually are.
- baal80spam 3y agoOh wow.
- LrnByTeach 3y agoThis may be a fair workable solution to all the parties involved. Context: --------- 1.1/ ILya Sukhar and Board do not agree with Sam Altman vision of a) too fast commercialization of Open AI AND/OR b) too fast progression to GPT-5 level 1.2/ Sam Altman thinks fast iteration and Commercialization is needed in-order to make Open AI financially viable as it is burning too much cash and stay ahead of competition. 1.3/ Microsoft, after investing $10+ Billions do not want this fight enable slow progress of AI Commercialization and fall behind Google AI etc.. a workable solution: -------------------- 2.1/ @sama @gdb form a new AI company, let us call it e/acc Inc. 2.2/ e/acc Inc. raises $3 Billions as SAFE instrument from VCs who believed in Sam Altman's vision. 2.3/ Open AI and e/acc Inc. reach an agreement such that: a) GPT-4 IP transferred to e/acc Inc., this IP transfer is valued as $8 Billion SAFE instrument investment from Open AI into e/acc Inc. b) existing Microsoft's 49% share in Open AI is transferred to e/acc Inc., such that Microsoft owns 49% of e/acc Inc. c) the resulted "Lean and pure non-profit Open AI" with Ilya Sukhar and Board can steer AI progress as they wish, their stake in e/acc Inc. will act as funding source to cover their future Research Costs. d) employees can join from Open AI to e/acc Inc. as they wish with no antipoaching lawsuits from OpenAI
- eightnoteight 3y ago@sama @gdb joined microsoft
- eightnoteight 3y agoin hindsight, you got the context pretty accurate i.e importance of microsoft in all of this
- kareaa 3y agoCould Microsoft possibly sue the board for market manipulation? If someone on the board shorted MSFT stock, they could have made millions.
- mcv 3y agoIs there a good article, or does anyone have the slightest inkling, about what the real conflict here is? There's a lot of articles about the symptoms, but what's the core issue here? The board claims Altman lied. Is that it? About what? Did he consistently misinform the board about a ton of different things? Or about one really important issue? Or is this just an excuse disguising the actual issues? I notice a lot of people in the comments talking about Altman being more about profit than about OpenAI's original mission of developing safe, beneficial AGI. Is Altman threatening that mission or disagreeing with it? It would be really interesting if this was the real issue, but if it was, I can't believe it came out of nowhere like that, and I would expect the board to have a new CEO lined up already and not be fumbling for a new CEO and go for one with no particular AI or ethics background. Sutskever gets mentioned as the primary force behind firing Altman. Is this a blatant power grab? Or is Sutskever known to have strong opinions about that mission of beneficial AGI? I feel a bit like I'm expected to divine the nature of an elephant by only feeling a trunk and an ear.
- sainez 3y agoI'm not sure what more information people need. The original announcement was pretty clear: https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transition https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transiti.... Specifically: > Mr. Altman’s departure follows a deliberative review process by the board, which concluded that he was not consistently candid in his communications with the board, hindering its ability to exercise its responsibilities. > it remains the fundamental governance responsibility of the board to advance OpenAI’s mission and preserve the principles of its Charter. So the board did not have confidence that Sam was acting in good faith. Watch any of Ilya's many interviews, he speaks openly and candidly about his position. It is clear to me that Ilya is completely committed to the principles of the charter and sees a very real risk of sufficiently advanced AI causing disproportionate harm. People keep trying to understand OpenAI as a hypergrowth SV startup, which it is explicitly not.
- mcv 3y agoThat original announcement doesn't make it nearly as explicit as you're making it. It doesn't say what he lied about, and it doesn't say he's not on board with the mission. Sounds like firing was done to better serve the original mission, and is therefore probably a good thing. Though the way it's happening does come across as sloppy and panicky to me. Especially since they already replaced their first replacement CEO. Edit: turns out Wikipedia already has a pretty good write up about the situation: > "Sutskever is one of the six board members of the non-profit entity which controls OpenAI.[7] According to Sam Altman and Greg Brockman, Sutskever was the primary driver behind the November 2023 board meeting that led to Altman's firing and Brockman's resignation from OpenAI.[30][31] The Information reported that the firing in part resulted from a conflict over the extent to which the company should commit to AI safety.[32] In a company all-hands shortly after the board meeting, Sutskever stated that firing Altman was "the board doing its duty."[33] The firing of Altman and resignation of Brockman led to resignation of 3 senior researchers from OpenAI." (from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilya_Sutskever https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilya_Sutskever)
- carlosbaraza 3y agoEmmett announced a plan for the next 30 days https://x.com/eshear/status/1726526112019382275?s=46&t=VuyFiu3sc6Gkp--LOMBGVw https://x.com/eshear/status/1726526112019382275?s=46&t=VuyFi...
- anonzzzies 3y agoHopefully only interim https://twitter.com/bindureddy/status/1726482338530693126 https://twitter.com/bindureddy/status/1726482338530693126
- asano 3y ago[flagged]
- asano 3y agoWhy is that so many in this thread state opinions as matter of facts, but at the same time you can tell they don't have a clue? Is this how you guys party here?