18 ms·
USB inventor explains why the connector was not designed to be reversible (2019)
- hknmtt 3y agoThey didn't have to double the wiring, just add wiring to the other side of the connector. That is barely 2 cm of wiring, at most. Also, manufacturers could have made the connectors in a way that would clearly show which side is the top and which is the bottom. So none of the issues had to happen but lazy manufacturers and gullible inventors caused all of this on their own.
- cheaprentalyeti 3y agoIf they made the connector reversible, you'd have to try to plug it in five times to get the right orientation instead of just three...
- hknmtt 3y ago:D
- OJFord 3y agoI, genuinely, have a USB-C cable which will only charge my phone in one orientation. That's worse than Type-A, since I can't even look at the end to see which side has the plastic bar, I just have to try it and obviously it fits, but see if it charges. Which means it takes about 94 attempts because I only realise the other end's not plugged in, or it's turned off at the wall, on the 92nd.
- baq 3y agoI have an A-C cable which has a reversible type-A plug (basically, it looks like a huge ugly lighting plug) and charges both ways but data only works one way. The first time I wanted to use it for carplay I lost some hair.
- netsharc 3y agoI guess you need to mark the correct sides of the cable (and maybe the port) with a dot from a marker, so you know which way is "up"...
- OJFord 3y agoHonestly I think I just need to get rid of it!
- MBCook 3y agoI’ve noticed that in devices that aren’t truly USB-C but seem to be USB-B with a C connector. They work fine with an A-C cable, even when using that with a C-A dongle. But often only one way up. They’re clearly noncompliant. Not that that stops anyone.
- netsharc 3y agoI bought a JBL headset which USB power cable is reversible, instead of a big plastic piece for half the plug, it has a thin strip of plastic, so the block of plastic of the port side can go in either side of the plug: https://images.nexusapp.co/assets/4a/75/a0/5733575.jpg https://images.nexusapp.co/assets/4a/75/a0/5733575.jpg But I guess it might just have two wires (+5V and ground) and no data wires (I can't check it now because I'm at work).
- nyanpasu64 3y agoI had a USB cable with a reversible A plug, but after a few months/years it would stop charging (because the pins either wouldn't make contact with the A socket, or the wires snapped off the pins).
- Someone 3y ago> Also, manufacturers could have made the connectors in a way that would clearly show which side is the top and which is the bottom The spec almost requires manufacturers to do that. https://fabiensanglard.net/usbcheat/usb1.1.pdf https://fabiensanglard.net/usbcheat/usb1.1.pdf, page 81: “The usb icon is embossed, in a recessed area, on the topside of the USB plug” “Receptacles should be oriented to allow the Icon on the plug to be visible during the mating process” So, there must be a tactile and visual indicator (the recessed usb icon) and it should be visible. They didn’t say “clearly visible”, though.
- nubinetwork 3y agoI've seen people try to connect ps/2 and vga cables upside down, and mash all the pins in the process. I'm fine with flipping a USB cable over a couple times until it goes in. /shrug
- extraduder_ire 3y agoMy personal favourite is people jamming VGA cables into serial ports on the back of PCs. Like, they both have pins sticking out of them.
- tinus_hn 3y agoYou can also insert the USB-a connector upside down, if you use enough force. It won’t really break anything but it will bend the plastic part so it becomes hard to insert the right way.
- stavros 3y agoThis is easily solved by also adding copper tracks on the backside of the connector!
- RandallBrown 3y agoI've seen reversible USB connectors that just have flexible pins that bend up or down depending on how the port is oriented.
- tzs 3y agoBack in the days when 200 MB was a big drive for a personal computer, IBM was working on a 1 GB drive. I worked at a place that was doing firmware for a company that was going to use those 1 GB drives in their product, and that company had access to some of the earliest test units. We were writing the firmware for that product, so IBM allowed them to loan us a couple of the drives. I once put one of the drives into my test system, and plugged in the power connector. It used a standard Molex connector [1]. The way the drive was mounted I couldn't actually see the plug or socket. It's a keyed connector so that should not be a problem. Yet somehow I managed to plug it in upside down which fried the drive. Afterwards I did some tests and found that the plastic on the connector on the drive was very soft. If you tried to plug in the wrong way the parts that were supposed to get in the way due to the keying would just deform out of the weight. It took more force to insert it the wrong way, but not more than was often needed when you happened across a plug and socket combination that were a tight fit so that didn't tip you off. I reported that to the person who had loaned us the drive and he told me he'd fried two of them that way. He said that when he told IBM about that his contact there said that they were losing something like 10% of the drives during testing right after manufacturing due to their technicians getting it backward, and the parts list had already been revised to switch to a connector hard enough for the keying to actually work. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molex_connector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molex_connector
- donatj 3y agoHear me out. The original USB only had 4 pins. I always thought a round ringed TRS style plug like headphones use would have been great. No way to orient it incorrectly.
- oniony 3y agoI think the problem these connectors have is that each ring has to slide over the other contacts to get to its correct location. USB Type-A has longer contacts for pins 1 and 4, the power pins, so they contact first and remain contacted before the data pins make contact. You can see that in this picture https://www.electroschematics.com/usb-how-things-work/ https://www.electroschematics.com/usb-how-things-work/.
- tommiegannert 3y agoMany of the TRS connectors have a built-in switch to (originally) disconnect the internal speaker. It would probably have been easy to extend that concept to isolate all contacts until the tip hits the bottom.
- crote 3y agoThat's not going to save you when you try to plug in the device-side connector with the computer-side already connected (and therefore already applying power to the cable).
- tommiegannert 3y agoWhy? It's also disconnected at the device's socket until fully seated?
- metaphor 3y ago> I always thought a round ringed TRS style plug like headphones use would have been great. No way to orient it incorrectly. Now consider the forward-looking bandwidth implications with that class of physical interconnect.
- donatj 3y agoIt didn't really need to go in either way. It just needed to not be rotationally symmetrical while only going in one way. Firewire only went in one way but it was never an issue because it's shape conveyed a clear orientation.
- jawns 3y agoI agree that there was more that could have been done to signal correct orientation. But an additional wrinkle is that the orientation of the port itself was not static. On laptops and desktops, it was horizontal. On certain other devices, it was vertical. Often these ports were in hard-to-reach or hard-to-see places, and having to reconcile the orientation in each case probably added to the frustration.
- stavros 3y agoNot really, HDMI ports are in weird orientation and mounted in hard-to-reach places as well, but the shape makes it very obvious (even by feel) which way it should (or can't) go. This is much harder with the rectangular USB plug.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoThe "by feel" part is critical. Lots of ports on various devices are deliberately in the back of the device, or otherwise hidden, so that the wiring can be kept neatly out of the way.
- putlake 3y agoHDMI is better than USB but it's still hard to do plug it in in dark, hard to reach places.
- c22 3y agoI have definitely been frustrated by an hdmi port I couldn't see. I almost always have to gain visibility on the port to get the cable inserted correctly. If I happen to already know the orientation of the port on a device I can do it by feel, but I could also do this with the microusb-b to my old cell phone.
- laydn 3y agoIt just had to be non-symmetrical on the Z-axis, that's all. Like an HDMI connector.
- simonjgreen 3y agoOr displayport. Personally I find hdmi almost as annoying as usb, though I can’t explain why that happens!
- jve 3y agoBecause when you have to plug hdmi on a wall mounted tv or monitor that is close to wall and hard to rotate - you end up not only guessing orientation but having a hard time to find that port... :)
- simonjgreen 3y agoI feel like it’s the aspect ratio of the plug too. Being long and thin you have to get it perfectly straight AND the right way round
- opan 3y agoOne problem with HDMI is that it has no clips or screws or similar holding it in, unlike DP, DVI, VGA, BNC... I remember I used to knock the HDMI out of one of my monitors with my foot all the time. It plugged in going straight up and barely could resist a bit more force than gravity, and the cable dangled behind the desk since the tower was on the floor.
- stavros 3y agoThat has not been my experience with HDMI, I've never had a cable anywhere close to popping out because of gravity, no matter the orientation.
- opan 3y agoYes, I hear this a lot, and it's not like it happens to me all the time these days, but it's a clear flaw in the design that there's nothing extra to hold it in like those other things.
- blamazon 3y agoThis page was difficult to read on my mobile due to ads. Here is a link to the source of the interview mentioned in the headline: https://text.npr.org/2019/06/21/734451600/ever-plugged-a-usb-in-wrong-of-course-you-have-heres-why https://text.npr.org/2019/06/21/734451600/ever-plugged-a-usb...
- lesuorac 3y agoI know everybody is still on the high from USB-C but I'm still going to go on the record it will be one of the biggest disasters in cable history. 1) There's going to be video-only cables; low-voltage only cables; etc and this time everything is usb-c so you can literally only tell which ables work by testing all of the dozen cables instead of the 1-2 USB-As you have. 2) The connector is symmetrical but the pins aren't. You can see a wiring scheme of how symmetry is handled [1]; literally manufactures are going to cheap out and not do that and you have 1-way USB-C cables without any kind of orientation markers. An obviously key'd connector like firewire / ethernet would've solved all of USB-A's flip it thrice problems. And this could've been allowed in a backwards compatible where old USB-A cables were basically a skeleton key and the new USB-A cables had a ward that blocked them from fitting incorrectly. [1]: https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/125011/how-does-usb-type-c-handle-reverse-polarity-signal-duplication https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/125011/how-d...
- mbar84 3y agoI wish they would even just have standardised on a colour coding or label system or something, so people could find out what a cable supports.
- slikrick 3y agoUSBC has been out for over a decade, have you ever run into 2)
- hnbear 3y agoMy keyboard came with a usb A to usb C cable which is proprietary in some way. A regular cable doesn’t work for it.
- Izkata 3y agoUp until this year I've had exactly 3 USB-C cables: Nintendo Switch, which is always plugged into its dock; laptop charger, also always plugged in at my desk; and phone charger. No real room for the mistakes they're describing.
- mmac_ 3y agoOne of my earliest experiences with USB was back in the day where I had a PC without any USB front ports that were free. So I grabbed my USB thumb drive and reached around the back of the PC tower and plugged it in without looking. USB didn't show up in the O/S. Thought maybe it wasn't formatted correctly and went through some diagnostics. Eventually went for the remove it / plug it back in technique. Had a look at the back of the PC and noticed I'd managed to plug it into an empty Ethernet port.... yeah they're about the same width give or take some tolerance. Also usually placed right next to each other. Back on topic, I do find those bare/exposed usb keys (like a yubikey) to be quite annoying.
- stavros 3y ago> Back on topic, I do find those bare/exposed usb keys (like a yubikey) to be quite annoying. I guess you trade one annoyance (how to plug them in) for another annoyance (too thick for a wallet/keychain).
- gs17 3y agoDone exactly the same thing. No idea why they sized it that way, at least it usually doesn't break anything.
- Neil44 3y agoI thought the tongue should have a little bump on the right or left, so if you're upside down you can tell straight away because the connector will want to angle over, rather than wiggling and wondering and doing the standard 3 tries thing.
- usrusr 3y agoMaking the part that is PCB on cheap USB sticks protrude a little from the metal rectangle? Would have required slightly deeper sockets, but I like the idea, would have saved some frustration.
- Neil44 3y agoYeah just a little 1mm hump on one side of the plastic tongue, but yeah the 1mm would have to come from somewhere.
- SeanLuke 3y ago> It was in 1998 that USB made some real headway, courtesy of the iMac G3, the first computer to ship with only USB ports for external devices (there were no serial or parallel ports). Um, no? The iMac had an Ethernet port, a phone jack for an internal modem, and TWO FIREWIRE PORTS. And Microphone and Speaker jacks.
- _moof 3y agoThe first iMac was USB only. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac_G3#Specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac_G3#Specifications
- moffkalast 3y agoIt is genuinely surprising that out of all companies Apple was the one to pioneer USB usage. Quite the stark contrast with their current modus operandi of always making something custom so it can be as incompatible as possible with anything non-Apple (and so they can sell more dongles). Well until they were dragged kicking and screaming to USB-C by the EU anyway.
- MBCook 3y agoAre you referring to the 30 pin connector, which did stuff no other connector did? Or lightning, which was smaller and easier than anything else available since USB-C didn’t exist? You already mentioned USB. Perhaps FireWire? SCSI? Those were all standard. Oh. Laptop power connections? There was no standard until USB-C, which they use. People repeat this, but it hasn’t really been true since they gave up all the custom stuff with the iMac.
- dmonitor 3y agoyou’re completely forgetting Apple being the first company to go all-in on USB C with their laptops. https://www.theverge.com/2015/3/9/8174219/apple-macbook-usb-type-c-connector https://www.theverge.com/2015/3/9/8174219/apple-macbook-usb-... It was really only the iPhone that lagged behind, and that’s because they switched to lightning not but a couple years before USB C was finalized, pissing off everyone who invested in the 20-pin connector ecosystem.
- k3vinw 3y agoFrom the article: “Bhatt's idea for the USB was inspired by his own experience as a user dealing with tech frustrations far beyond the scope of a get-it-wrong-the-first-time cable.” Exactly what made USB so awesome when it first came out. I guess you had to be there.
- Ekaros 3y agoD-sub and likes were lot worse. USB is robust and don't need things like screws. Din and mini-din also have similar issues. Compared to either family USB is clearly a more usable design.
- stavros 3y agoTL;DR: Cost.
- tommiegannert 3y agoIf we're not going back to circular slip-ring connectors that allow rotation (like TRS or DC plugs,) then the step after the +-90-reversible USB-C is a triangular one. So you only need to rotate it +-30 if you got it wrong. Now I really want a triangular connector. Like in alien-tech movies.
- polishdude20 3y agoLet's go further and get a hexagonal one.
- jpeanuts 3y agoThis is not so crazy - this was exactly the progression in screw drives. First came slotted screws (2-fold rotational symmetry), then Phillips/posidrive/Robertson (4-fold), and now Torx (6-fold). Going back to slotted now is actually irritating. Of course the constraints and trade-offs are very different... still it would be a piece of cake to plug them in on the backside of a box with your eyes closed.
- perilunar 3y agoWhat's wrong with circular? There's no wrong way to plug it in.
- tommiegannert 3y agoNothing to me, for the same reason you gave. I'd love to see them making a comeback. My guess is they won't come back because modern connectors are so thin that if you made them equally narrow, they'd break/bend easily. (And yes, 3.5mm really is too thick to be a standard size, e.g. in wearables. The outer thickness of the USB-C socket is 3.3mm.)
- standardUser 3y agoThe entire situation could have been avoided with a notch like a thousand other plugs and connectors have.
- sbjs 3y ago> Sometime later, I also learned that "three" is usually the magic number for correctly plugging in a USB Type-A device. It's a maddening dance and it begs the question, why wasn't the Universal Serial Bus designed with a reversible connector from the outset? Honestly when this is the biggest problem you face on a daily basis, your life must be relatively easy.
- devit 3y agoIf you have a reversible connector, then you might be entangled in a dilemma of which way is the "better" or "optimal" or "canonical" way, while with a non-reversible one there is only one way and thus no dilemma. And in fact USB-C is not really physically reversible, because the hardware detects which way it's plugged in and permutes the signals, as opposed to mirroring all the wires, so there is indeed a "right" way of inserting an USB-C plug, except it's impossible to tell which it is without a dedicated hardware tester.
- lisper 3y agoAnd indeed there are usb-c hubs that only work in one orientation so we now have the worst of all possible worlds.
- ezfe 3y agoI would argue those hubs do not work
- hiatus 3y agoIt's the same with usb-c extension cords. Our extension cords now need microcontrollers in them, what a time to be alive.
- mananaysiempre 3y agoGiven those microcontrollers are 0.05 USD at worst, meh, though I acknowledge it sounds a bit crazy if you don’t recognize how cheap micros can be nowadays. Laptop chargers have used similar schemes (perhaps with bare serial EEPROMs instead of MCUs) since forever, FWIW.
- hiatus 3y agoThe absurdity to me is not the cost, but the complexity. Our (or at least my own) intuition of an extension cord is as a dumb cord just relaying signals, but they are more complex than that, now.
- cushpush 3y ago>But in an effort to keep it as cheap as possible, the decision was made to go with a design that, in theory, would give users a 50/50 chance of plugging it in correctly (you can up the odds by looking at the inside first, or identifying the logo). I despise this "design decision." Literally bakes in the 50% of the time you plug it in the wrong orientation and lose seconds of your life. Who cares if the sands of time are moving more rapidly than asteroids? We can save money and make more of these badboys to fill the landfills with once they're obsolete. Hard to argue that logic that clearly won via market dynamics. But where are we now?
- TylerE 3y agoIf they were going to do that they at least could have used a D shaped connector or something so the orientation of both the plug and the port are obvious, even in bad lighting / from an awkward angle.
- chrisco255 3y agoAll I can say is that before USB 1.0, the myriad of connections on a PC motherboard were ridiculous. USB was leaps and bounds better beyond PS/2, and VGA and various serial and parallel ports would require you to physically screw in the plug. Just look at: https://www.electronicshub.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Ports.jpg https://www.electronicshub.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Po... It was a nightmare. And virtually none of those ports would self-install drivers when a device was plugged into it. USB 1.0 was magic when it came out.
- dimal 3y agoAgreed. Everyone forgets how awful it was and even though USB wasn't perfect, it was a huge improvement over the status quo. For that, I can forgive the inventors for making a mistake. Nobody's perfect. The travesty is that it took so long to correct the issue.
- mixmastamyk 3y ago> Someday we'll look back and laugh (or cry) at our early USB struggles. Hah, sounds like the editor is someone too young to have used serial/parallel/vga ports. Early business PCs, for what ever reason[1] were built like tanks. They weighed dozens of kgs/pounds. And the connectors were often screwed in with a screwdriver for good measure. Yes, you could wing it when being sloppy, but they weren't always very tight and cables heavy so you'd want them screwed in for a long-term installation to avoid issues. When USB came out it was a revelation that you just needed to pop it in and were done. Yes, you'd have to look at it first, but that was the same with every other port of before that. I remember PS/2 being perhaps hardest to line up correctly. So USB 1.0 fixed one problem, but not every problem. Not exactly a reason to cry. [1] Probably inertia from main/minicomputers which were serious installations and needed to keep running through wartime. :-/
- jtaft 3y agoBending a pin stunk. I remeber jamming a flat head screwdriver into the port to try and straighten
- Cockbrand 3y agoUSB A to Micro USB cables with reversible connectors on both ends have been available for a few years - much too late, but still useful. I bought some on AliExpress, and while probably violating some specs, they have been working nicely for me so far.
- elondaits 3y ago> But in an effort to keep it as cheap as possible, the decision was made to go with a design that, in theory, would give users a 50/50 chance of plugging it in correctly They overlooked the statistically significant case where it takes more than two tries to plug it in correctly. Knowing you might have been wrong makes you prematurely abandon an attempt where you had it set the right way.
- ghaff 3y agoI used to know one of the people involved in the spec at Intel and he long claimed to regret they couldn’t find a (presumably politically acceptable) way to make it reversible.
- theogravity 3y ago> Making USB reversible to begin with would have necessitated twice as many wires and twice as many circuits Is this still true with USB-C?
- eep_social 3y agoFrom other comments it sounds like no. Instead, every port must detect the orientation and switch to using the correct lines in software. IIUC, each cable also needs a small IC to assist with this.
- Findecanor 3y agoReversibility for USB 2.0 data signals is mechanical: There are data pins on both sides and only one set of pins get connected. The socket side connects both sets. There is only one more wire in a USB-C 2.0 cable: it is used to signal orientation and if an end is a power source, sink or a headphone adaptor. USB-3 signals are more complicated though. There can be up to two bidirectional high-speed channels. The aforementioned sensing pin is used to figure out if those channels need to be swapped or not.
- pmontra 3y agoLooking at the logo on the plug is enough to get it right at the first attempt, but only for horizontal ports on a laptop or desktop. For vertical ports or ports on the top (chargers have both types) it's not so easy.
- snakeyjake 3y ago> Making USB reversible to begin with would have necessitated twice as many wires and twice as many circuits, and would have doubled the cost. This is... not correct. You can make USB reversible with 1 extra pin and 1 extra wire. Grounds on pins 1 and 5, data on pins 2 and 4, and VCC on pin 3. Then have those pins on both sides of the plug and a socket with a single set of contacts on one side. That's BASICALLY what Apple did with lightning. Then you implement auto crossover detection, (edit: Gah! you don't even have to do that just flip the flipping wires) which had been around for years and is dirt cheap, in the hub. It would have been like, six, more transistors in the hub IC. edit: I completely forgot that reversible USB 2.0 plugs already exist and use a simpler (and cheaper) method. They just tend not to be so reliable because of the thinner materials and the fact that they're not spec-compliant so they tend to be grey market jobs made for the lowest price possible. Here is one: https://www.amazon.com/Tripp-Lite-Universal-Reversible-UR050-003-RA/dp/B00ESZIIRU https://www.amazon.com/Tripp-Lite-Universal-Reversible-UR050... No doubling of wires or circuits required, just a thin double-sided PCB. Was the connector form-factor inherited from an earlier project and the players didn't want to design a new one?
- gzalo 3y ago> Then you implement auto crossover detection, dwhich had been around for years Mdi-x/auto crossover for ethernet was introduced in 1999, that is after USB (1996) was designed, not sure of the technique was known at that time
- aidenn0 3y agoI still am more annoyed by it being the same width as an RJ-45 connector. Worse than not being able to plug it in is having it plug in and not work.
- nxobject 3y agoIn the same vein, USB-A has a plugin-nable space barely the same diameter as a headphone jack – there have been a few times that I've plugged a headphone without looking into an adjacent USB receptacle. It happened surprisingly often when MacBooks had USB-A.
- whoopdedo 3y agoAs annoying as this has been when it happened to me, I also have wondered if they did it on purpose to make it easier for assemblers. If the tooling needed for USB, Ethernet, and eSATA are all the same size you can save cost through reuse.
- crote 3y agoEven worse: male USB-C can fit inside female USB-A - and it is quite common for female USB-C ports to be placed right next to female USB-A ports. I learned this the hard way - turns out your computer will just suddenly hard power off when you try to do this.
- chrismorgan 3y agoFun fact: the Nokia 2780 Flip, despite using USB-C, only accepts the cable in one orientation. Put a cable in upside down, and nothing happens. Confirmed with the charger it comes with and one C–C cable that I already possessed. (Additional fun fact: the box says it uses Micro-USB.)
- Animats 3y agoIf the plug actually complies with the spec, and has the metal shroud as it is supposed to, it works fine, and will not go in backwards. It's making USB connectors which are just a piece of PC board that's the problem. Looking at you, Yubikey.
- aranchelk 3y agoMy take on USB-A: aside from audio connectors that have axial symmetry (and have no meaningful orientation), I never used any reversible computer cables prior to USB-C, and that’s not the main issue. Nor is it the axis of symmetry of the casing allowing failed upside down plugin attempts. The shitty part of USB-A is that the tactile feedback of being slightly misaligned is identical to it being upside down. My experience tells me no amount of vigorous jiggling or extreme self-confidence will ever allow for consistent average 1.5 attempt plugins. All the standards before USB were in my memory even less user-friendly — trying in vain to reach behind a heavy computer and unscrew the two jammed retaining bolts holding in a serial, parallel, scsi, vga, or DVI plug with slippery bent plastic jacketed heads. Almost zero clearance from the plug case, that really did suck. Screw it in slightly loser next time, now you’ve got a flickering monitor, dummy. And ps2/mini-din connectors sucked too - having the connector off-center or at the wrong rotation also felt quite indistinguishable.
- postmodest 3y agoAt least PS/2 cables were mostly made with "keyed" rubber jackets where one side was flat and the other rounded, so in the dark you could tell which way was up. (Though, that keyboard and mouse were different ports was stupid, so it loses points there)
- userbinator 3y agoKeyboard was always the one closest to the mobo, since it was there first (and was originally a larger, more robust DIN connector); the mouse piggybacked on top of that later.
- lxgr 3y agoNever have I been able to successfully plug a PS/2 port in by haptics alone. I can totally see how they were designed to theoretically allow for it; practically, the tactile feedback for the correct orientation is just way too subtle. And regarding the two different ports: I can't remember (or rather, I was never motivated to revisit the plugs once connected to experiment, since it was such a pain) – was there a technical reason for that, or could modern mainboards/BIOSes/OSes detect and correct for that?
- dboreham 3y ago"Ajay Bhatt, widely considered the inventor of USB..." Interesting. I had been told long ago that my fellow-Inmosian Dave Wooten was instrumental. And sure enough: "David was principal architect for USB 1.0, USB 1.1, and USB 2.0." from https://ece.ncsu.edu/honor/david-wooten/ https://ece.ncsu.edu/honor/david-wooten/
- jdblair 3y agoI used to "bedazzle" my USB cables. Bedazzling is when you decorate something with little plastic reflective jewel stickers. I always put the jewel in the same side (the "top") so I could feel which way the cable should be oriented. Then I could be confident I had the orientation correct without looking. I called this USBedazzling. The other folks in the office didn't think it was a funny as I did.
- dylan604 3y agowhat if the port was in the opposite orientation, or worse, vertically oriented?
- havefunbesafe 3y agoThen you'd have to close your laptop and walk into the woods forever, I suppose...
- dylan604 3y agogreat, so a tuesday, then?
- deathanatos 3y agoBedazzle the port on the "front" side, whichever way that happens to point. Then just align bedazzling. Or just bedazzle the port if it's wrong. I've only ever once encountered a backwards port. Cough HP cough
- jdblair 3y agoI knew my own gear and how the ports were oriented.
- palata 3y agoI don't really get why people hate USB-A so much. I almost always plug my USB-A in the first try, because most of my devices have a clear up/down (e.g. a laptop or a docking station), and the plastic part always goes down. Of course the vertical ports behind a machine are a bit harder to access, but... well anyway they are. And usually those are not the ones I unplug/replug often.
- LoganDark 3y agoMy USB hub will allow me to plug in a USB-A connector the wrong way. When I do, it has some sort of fault and resets all the ports. I don't know how this is physically possible, but it's somehow worse then requiring 3 attempts.
- sytelus 3y agoMore interesting question for me is what exactly made USB possible? I understand that parallel communication wasn't possible because even for small differences in wire length, data on each wire will arrive at different times and that limits speed. So, people went with serial communication. But what exactly enabled high speed bit transfer? Why wasn't it possible before? Similarly, why USB2 speeds weren't possible before? What technical advances made it possible?
- labcomputer 3y agoWell, high speed serial coms existed before USB, so the premise of the question is a bit wrong. RS-422 officially supports 10 Mbps over short distances, for example, and various serial WAN protocols supported >100Mbps over copper before USB launched. I would argue that what USB (1.1-2.0) does differently from previous serial peripheral ports is mostly software and standardization, and really relate to making it cheap and simple for "normal people" to use: 1. USB 1.1 supports only two bit rates (1.5 and 12 Mbps), which is autoconfigured before device enumeration. 12 = 8 * 1.5, so the clock divider is cheap and easy. 2. USB limits cables to fairly short lengths (<=5m) compared to earlier serial ports (RS-422 supports 10 Mbps at 15m) 3. USB (pre-OTG extensions) rigorously enforced the idea of a "host" (upstream) and "device" (downstream), at both the protocol and physical connector level (which greatly simplifies things--for example, you can't create a loop, and don't need STP to detect it). A child can easily see that a B (device) socket doesn't fit an A (host) plug. 4. USB device enumeration and configuration are extensively software based, and USB defines a number of standard device classes so that many common types of devices (e.g., keyboards, mice) don't need specific drivers. 5. One thing that USB does that's less common among serial peripheral interfaces is to use a single differential pair for data going in both directions (it's time-shared: so the host polls the device then the device responds). The pin-count is less than a "regular" RS-422 port, but you still get the advantages of differential signaling. 6. USB carries power with only one more pin than needed to create a minimal bidirectional serial data connection, so "lite" devices don't need a separate power connector (ignoring very slow protocols like "1-wire"). 7. USB does some funny things with packet framing (like NRZI encoding and bit-stuffing) and some things to help reduce device cost (like the JKJKJK packet preamble to sync the device baud-rate generator and using SE1/SE0 states for device disconnect and bus reset signaling), but none of that is really fundamental to making a 10Mbps-class serial interface.
- omgJustTest 3y agoI think people underestimate how cheaply products are made. > Making USB reversible to begin with would have necessitated twice as many wires and twice as many circuits, and would have doubled the cost. Adding more wires, even if it is a few is not the cheapest one and therefore not the one that wins. The relative convenience of a feature is always trumped in early days by cost-to-produce. USB-C recently introducing the symmetry of the connector does not imply that manufacturers will use it... ie you have a symmetric connector that performs differently based on how it was plugged.
- quickthrower2 3y agoAlso, coming from serial/parallel ports, people are not going to moan that the USB is not reversible.
- pseudosavant 3y agoI think people really need to think about USB Type A in the context of the connectors it was 'competing' with: DSUB9 (VGA), RS-232 (serial), DB-25 (parallel), PS/2 (keyboard/mouse). These were, by modern standards, complete garbage connectors. Huge. Didn't stay plugged in securely unless the connector had screws. Only went one way. USB 1 stayed plugged in, required no screws, had higher bandwidth than any data port you'd find on a typical PC, the wires were much thinner, and it could even power low power devices! Yes, a design that doesn't take three tries (my average) to get right would be nice, but it exceeded every existing port by miles. Audio jacks were the only ports that didn't have a direction back then.
- Findecanor 3y agoAlso, those older plugs were more or less not hot-pluggable. The computer had to be off (really off, not standby) before you plugged/unplugged a cable, or you'd risk damaging the port and/or the device. The only exception I know of is that Apple Desktop Bus (mini-DIN) had been designed (by Woz !) to be supposed to be hot-pluggable but Apple cheaped out on overcurrent protection so it never was. Edit: I forgot: in a MIDI connection there is an opto-coupler behind the receiving end, to electrically separate devices.
- NegativeK 3y agoThe idea of trying to plug a serial, parallel, or VGA cable into a computer blindly seems hilariously unlikely. And I distinctly remember getting excited about upgrading to a motherboard that supported USB for the hot-pluggability. I was overexcited, but still.
- perilunar 3y ago> Audio jacks were the only ports that didn't have a direction back then. On computers perhaps. There were plenty of round connectors in other uses though, e.g. Edison screw, Belling-Lee (TV/FM connectors), RCA, BNC, type C and type N RF, TOSLINK, etc. Most of those wouldn't have been much use for a computer serial port though. Something like TOSLINK, with power and optic fibre would have been great. Too expensive at the time I think. But a round TRRP-style jack would have worked and been cheap. Agree that USB-A was much better than the existing alternatives though.
- quitit 3y agoI think there is value in remembering that this was an era where peripherals were plugged in with a view of semi-permanence, most plugs even had screws. I also remember thinking at the time how much easier USB was to use than trying to align a PS/2 connector. Despite the obvious design drawback, I can't blame intel entirely, a big contributor to the problem was that the ports were still being positioned in hard to access areas by computer makers. The first iMac design was a bit more forward thinking in this regard, whereby USB ports were prominently positioned on either side of the keyboard, this made it very easy to plug in the USB mouse and use the other for something like a USB stick. The problem with the type A design isn't just the orientation issue, the rectangular port design provides very little tolerance for off-angle insertion, having the port in full view helped a lot with insertion.
- nerpderp82 3y agoUSB was a scam from Intel (and Microsoft) to put the PC at center of "your digital life". They both feared that Firewire would be able to send digital streams around and no PC would be necessary. This man was ideal for the job of USB inventor.
- snarfy 3y agoI was always hoping for a 3.5mm jack for a connector. Radially symmetric, it can go in any direction. I've heard arguments this could cause connection issues since it could rotate while connected, causing small contact misses, but I think that could be designed around.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- robin2120 3y ago[dead]
- idonotknowwhy 3y agoI just realized, all this time, i should have known which way the USB ports were on the back of the pc. All I had to do was visualize the motherboard inside the case and I'd immediately and easily know which way to plug the cables in without looking. Wish I'd thought of this 15 years ago...
- pbj1968 3y agoAnyone bitching about USB does not remember the horrors of serial ports. My favorite cables were the ones where the connector housing metal was so soft it was actually indeed possible to plug them in upside down and bend all your pins. Spent lots of time in the 90s with tweezers straightening pins. All he had to do was make one side of the connector rounded. But still a vast improvement.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoBackwards rationalization / cognitive dissonance for a poor engineering tradeoff. The cost of zillions of the same panel mount connector will converge to dirt cheap. Although cents matter, user experience matters more if everyone hates your craptastic cheap design. Thankfully, Apple came along and gave the world USB-C which simply increased the bandwidth and current with the convenience of rotational symmetry. A USB-C panel-mount connector costs $0.492 in bulk. Fancy rugged and waterproof ones are $2.18. Micro USB B costs $0.45 in bulk. 10% increase in cost: big whoop for everything except Arduinos and portable kids' night lights.
- tamimio 3y agoIt’s just a bad (or rather a first iteration) design and no need to justify it, because it’s ok to have that in early designs.
- yieldcrv 3y agoproud to say that I’m almost all usbc my ILEC camera, PS5 game controller, iPhone, laptop, work laptop donglebook, all charge from the same cord and power block when they need to my portable speaker is still microusb on one side and usb 2.0 or whatever nomenclature on the other side airpods are primarily inductive charging, but it has a lightning cable port, along with my apple keyboard and mouse when I need to connect them to a different computer and go wireless again
- monkpit 3y agoThe 3.5mm jack is a triumph of design, change my mind. The tactile sensation of getting it hooked up is a thing of beauty.
- zoomablemind 3y agoI wonder why the USB connector had to be that wide? And with so many tries on the narrow end to follow on?
- somat 3y agoReversible is overrated. what I always liked were the genderless connectors. Actual engineers probably don't like them because making a long cable by chaining a bunch bunch of short cables together is almost always a bad idea so they are very rare. The only two I have ever seen in the wild was the IBM bus and tag cables(a strong contender for the most manly data connector I have ever seen) and some unknown telephone headset cord with a seriously over engineered connector. The bus and tag connector: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_and_Tag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_and_Tag
- hotshoe 3y agoSeems like it always took me 3 steps to plug in a usb-a cable. 1. Doesn't easily insert so assume I've got it upside down. Flip. 2. Still doesn't easily insert so inspect, and realize it had it right the first time. 3. Insert for real this time. I don't miss usb-a, but it was a vast improvement over the rs-232 and parallel port cables that preceded it.
- bschne 3y ago> (…) the decision was made to go with a design that, in theory, would give users a 50/50 chance of plugging it in correctly I love how they write „in theory“
- johnsanders 3y agoHas no one told the one about the USB guy's funeral? They put him in the ground, but realized he was the wrong way 'round so they pulled him out and put him in the other way.
- deathanatos 3y ago> you can up the odds by looking at the inside first, or identifying the logo No, this really only increases your frustration once you find out that some USB manufacturers can't tell their head from their *** when it comes to making the connector. ASUS, I'm looking at you.
- davidw 3y agoSomeone once calculated that a few seconds of fiddling with USB connectors across millions of people was actually entire years worth of wasted time. Actually, I just made that up, but it seems kind of plausible.
- raymond_goo 3y agoThe problem wasn't reversibility, it was not being able to feel the right side in the dark or behind components.
- jongjong 3y agoI don't know if this is common but I've encountered an issue with two different devices with the latest reversible USBs that it would only charge if I plugged it in one way and not the other. I would plug my phone and I had to check the screen to see if it was charging or not; if not, I had to unplug, turn the connector around and plug back in the other way. I remember longing for the older micro USB where the right orientation was obvious. Obviously my phone port must had been damaged; but I suspect that because this happened to me with two different phones, it may be related to fragility of the new ports due to smaller wires or something... Anyone else had this issue?
- kelnos 3y agoYep, probably damage to either the connector on the cable, or the port on the device. Does the connector also feel a bit looser when you plug it in the non-working way? (Not required, but it's a dead giveaway.)
- jongjong 3y agoThe plug held firmly. I believe it was the port on the device as changing the cable didn't resolve the issue.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anymouse123456 3y agoAnd from such heroic beginnings, they've become a despicable cartel that shakes down small businesses for thousands of dollars by selling artificially scarce numerals.
- dehrmann 3y ago> in theory, would give users a 50/50 chance of plugging it in correctly That turned out to be an over-estimate.
- mannyv 3y agoThis is why technical people should not use financial metrics in their decisions. At some point costs drop to near zero. The guy has been responsible for unbelievable amounts of human aggravation.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoReversibility should not have been the question here. The question is why the connector is RECTANGULAR instead of trapezoidal. What a stupid thing to ignore.
- Nomentatus 3y agoThe plug didn't have to be reversible - it could just have had a trapezoidal cross-section. No significant cost.
- oleg_antonyan 3y ago> one of the greatest inventions of all time Seriosly? Overcomplicated protocol to make it very hard to bit-bang and thus pay USB-IF for every chip, every logo. There was already 100mbit Ethernet at that time, just add power wires and use existing network stack in software, but how can you squish money from it?! Ofc they needed something new proprietary, overcomplicated, with terrible reliability. USB is the curse of modern hardware.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nelox 3y agoImagine if “Ethernet” cables weren’t reversible.
- jasonkester 3y agoAs an added bit of genius, it’s exactly the right width to fit snugly into an Ethernet port. (Which most laptops keep right next to the usb ports) So on the rare occasion that you get it right by feel the first try, you’re not actually plugged in to anything and get to spend 10 minutes debugging your printer before noticing.
- perilunar 3y agoMy take: round connectors are the best connectors — checking the plug orientation is a waste of bloody time. Every time you plug something in you waste a few seconds checking the orientation and flipping the plug over. Even reversible plugs are inferior to round ones. USB-A has only 4 wires: they could have easily used a co-axial connector. Hell, they could have used a 3.5 mm TRRS phono cable and it would have been better. Why do we put up with this shit?
- titzer 3y agoI used to struggle with USB-A plugs until I made it a point to actually look and pay attention. 99% of all plugs are labeled and logo side faces up. For devices that have a natural orientation (e.g. laptop), it always goes one way. For mating two cables, just look at where the male PCB in one is. Turns out that plugging in USB-A cables is a skill you can learn in 5 seconds.
- INTPenis 3y agoWhere all my autistic nerds at who look at the connector before they stick it in, and remember which way all their connectors are facing? hands up
- qwerty456127 3y ago> Making USB reversible to begin with would have necessitated twice as many wires and twice as many circuits, and would have doubled the cost Not really. I've got a cable which is USB 2.0 type A one side, Micro-B the other side and both the sides are perfectly reversible. It's already been many years since I've bought it and it still serves me reliably for both charging and data needs. The manufacturer didn't even have to change the standard to produce a reversible cable working great with all the old devices whose manufacturers never heard reversible USB cables exist.
- SergeAx 3y agoThere is a knowledge that you have to hold your USB cable with the logo upwards. Unfortunately, it is too arcane, so lots of cable and even device manufacturers just not aware of it. Also I it becomes quirky when the socket is vertically oriented.
- jalapenos 3y agoI don't know how, but the USB somehow managed to be worse than non-reversible. The number of times I've flipped it around more than once to get it right is absurd. It must look hilarious if you zoomed out to population scale. Thousands of people flipping around USBs at any given second.
- korginator 3y agoRubbish. These are just excuses for terrible & thoughtless design. USB is by far the worst designed thing in the history of humankind, in terms of the cumulative amount of frustration it has caused globally. All common-sense usability principles were ignored, and these are not new principles. Take the old RS-232C or RJ45 jacks, you just looked at it and you knew which way to plug it in. Hell you could do it blindfolded by feel.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FullyFunctional 3y agoThat's of course nonsense as others have pointed out, but I still decry the insane electrical implementation: bidirectional differential[1] pairs. Having instead (like Firewire) a dedicated pair in each direction is so much simpler and leads to much better performance. Instead we got evermore convoluted and complicated USB which has long surpassed Firewire in cost of cables etc. [1] of course USB isn't always truly differential which is part of the problem.
- pastalex 3y agovia Joel Johnson's oral history (https://www.fastcompany.com/3060705/an-oral-history-of-the-usb https://www.fastcompany.com/3060705/an-oral-history-of-the-u... ) 'Okay, but: why wasn’t the plug reversible? Ajay Bhatt: Good question. We had looked at it, but the whole goal here was to make it very inexpensive, and at that point, we were trying to solve all the USB problems with two wires. At that point, if you added wires to make things flippable, you have to add wires, and you also have to add a lot of silicon. Wires and pins cost real money, so we decided to keep it as cheap as possible. With serial port and parallel port, there were versions that were 25 pins and 36 pins and so on and so forth. The cables were very thick and expensive. We were trying to solve all the problems. We went in favor of fewer wires. In hindsight, a flippable connector would have been better. Our goal was to say that this interface should be such that it should work on a mouse and it should also work on a high-end printer or on digital cameras. That’s what we were looking at, the range of products. At one end, we wanted it simple enough, so there could be very low costs. At the other end, we wanted to make sure that it could be scaled and, just as we speak today, we’re running the USB at tens of gigs. The original one was running at 12 megs. We’ve come a long way in scaling.'