15 ms·
I'd love to see an economists take on the value to a consumer of holding gold in this form, at the price. Investment gold is usually kept in vault, and you tra
by ggm 3y ago
I'd love to see an economists take on the value to a consumer of holding gold in this form, at the price.
Investment gold is usually kept in vault, and you trade ownership arms length. Direct gold ownership is rife with risks: fineness, substitutions and overpriced purchase. Yes, you can always sell at a mall gold trader but that's way way off market price.
So it's an inflation hedge with a lot of cost and risk and demands huge upswing in gold price to pay off. And securing it at volume is a nightmare. Plus Costco wants to limit you to 2, and have a margin.
- 12907835202 3y agoSounds like people who buy currency from a high street currency exchange or bitcoin from coinbase (or a high street bitcoin ATM!) Even if the theory of investing may be sound they haven't really thought through how they're going to sell it later. No doubt they have heard investing in the particular thing is a good idea but lack the knowledge to properly apply it.
- baron816 3y agoI’m not sure an economist (a mainstream economist) would really care that much about an individual holding gold. Maybe there’s an interesting behavioral question about why people become so paranoid about the value of the dollar when it’s proven to be so incredibly stable (yes, even with the recent spike in inflation—it’s nothing close to hyperinflation). But people going to Costco and buying gold doesn’t have an effect on the wider economy. Costco’s business isn’t even really affected. Gold is not money. It’s never going to be money again. So why care?
- mschuster91 3y ago> Maybe there’s an interesting behavioral question about why people become so paranoid about the value of the dollar when it’s proven to be so incredibly stable Because we live in very uncertain times: a land-grab war in continental Europe, a serious and credible threat of both the US and a lot of European countries to fall to fascism, the threat of the US government going into an unprecedented shutdown yet again, and if that were not enough, it's reasonable to assume there will be an actual hot war with China in a few years' time. Historically, people have always fled towards gold in uncertain times.
- Hendrikto 3y ago> why people become so paranoid about the value of the dollar when it’s proven to be so incredibly stable Every fiat currency that ever existed collapsed at some point. > Gold is not money. It’s never going to be money again. So why care? Gold survived all of them. It’s still being used as a financial instrument, after thousands of years, countless wars, changes of government, complete societal collapse and reorganization… Gold is definitely a safer long-term bet.
- baron816 3y agoGold as a long term bet: https://www.reddit.com/r/FluentInFinance/comments/16upmcj/gold_vs_sp_500_over_the_last_3_decades/ https://www.reddit.com/r/FluentInFinance/comments/16upmcj/go...
- Hendrikto 3y agoWhat’s your point? I can also point to timespans where gold outperformed any other currency. If you make the period long enough, it is all of them.
- bondarchuk 3y ago>I’m not sure an economist (a mainstream economist) would really care that much about an individual holding gold. Roosevelt seemed to care quite a bit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 Apparently this lasted until 1974 (not sure about the details though, I always hear about the executive order in 1933 but never about the impossibility of owning gold between 1933 and 1974 - but that's what the articles seem to say) so a lot of mainstream economists have at least implicitly agreed. https://www.nytimes.com/1974/08/15/archives/bill-signed-to-allow-owning-gold-in-us-gold-ownership-in-u-s.html https://www.nytimes.com/1974/08/15/archives/bill-signed-to-a...
- bhaney 3y agoI just think it's neat to have
- iancmceachern 3y agoI've been thinking about this. People invest/collect gold like this and it clearly only profitable for the people who buy and sell gold who charge you to do both. I also think it's a hobby. Like people collect this or coins or stamps or Pokémon cards. I think as far as things to spend your time on for entertainment, you loose the lease amount on this compared to collecting other things or spending the time you spend on this entertainment doing another form of entertainment. It's not investment unless your scrooge mcduck and have a big gold factory, it's really entertainment like collecting baseball cards.
- Ekaros 3y agoPhysical gold might have value in situation where financial institutions and markets start to lose any trust in themselves. Either by manipulation, government confiscation or fraud. But, things will be pretty bad at that point from every viewpoint. As essentially global markets are crashing. On other hand, in even bigger crisis gold won't be that valuable at least for a while. If food and fuel are first priority people are unlikely to trade them for shiny metal...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _8j50 3y agoShiny metal is better for trade than bartering because it is rare and easy to break down into smaller chunks. Its value is that people other than the persons trading with it are also willing to trade with it. Guns and ammo sound like a better alternative but their rarity is unknown and unpredictable and even less people might be willing to trade with them on a regular basis unless it's a literal warzone. Food perishes and it's rarity is also an unpredictable.
- sambazi 3y agopaying with a gun seems like a perfect recipe to get hold up for the things you just bought.
- bombcar 3y agoWhen society gets to that point looters and robbers get bullet. There’s a class of crime that can only really exist in a rule-of-law situation, without that people just get summarily executed.
- _8j50 3y agoBut what if the looters are all armed? Their power in numbers means if you shoot one the resr will overwhelm you so they can expect to not be shot for that reason alone. In reality, the looters become gangs you pay for "protection" and they will be your "police" against others
- dr_dshiv 3y agoIt’s a prepper thing, isn’t it?
- jansan 3y agoBefore 2008 quite a few people around me were purchasing physical gold. I even know of one guy who bought 20000€ worth of gold. AFAIK none of them had any idea afterwards what to with that stuff. I assume it is rotting (or keeps on shining) in their basements and will only be touched when they die or move out.
- oefrha 3y agoI bought a gold bar worth a couple grand just yesterday. It hardly takes up any space in my nightstand drawer. There’s no need to come up with an idea of what to do with it, it’s not like 20k worth of gold is a huge brick or something.
- ifdefdebug 3y agoJust looked it up, if that one guy needs money today his 2008 €20k gold would buy him >€40k today. Not so bad.
- AdamN 3y agoDoubling your money over 15 years is a pretty low ROI. Even conservative investments are expected to double every decade.
- rchaud 3y agoThat would be under 1 kg of gold. For that small an amount, there will only be a small handful of private buyers, and their offers won't be anywhere near the amounts shown on commodities exchange tickers.
- Ferret7446 3y agoOne of the nice things about gold (one reason it is so valuable) is that it doesn't "rot" or degrade, like, at all. Naturally, it does not tarnish. So unless you have a lot of aqua regia lying about in your house, it will remain exactly as is.
- xjlin0 3y ago
- e63f67dd-065b 3y agoYou can see it happening right now in Argentina: the local currency is worthless, and people are flocking to ... US Dollars. Not gold, not bitcoins, but good old benjamins. So gold isn't even a good inflation hedge: if you walked the streets of a failing economy (pick one: Argentina, Venezuela, Sri Lanka, there's plenty more) and tried to exchange gold for goods, you're not gonna get far (and will probably get mugged). You have to figure out how to convert that gold into something somebody will actually take, and that seems like the hard part.
- ArtTimeInvestor 3y agoWhy do you think that people in Argentina are flocking to Dollar and not to Bitcoin or Gold? When I look at the search trends in Argentina, I see Bitcoin in a very volatile longterm uptrend, Gold in a longterm downtrend and the Dollar being constantly a distant third: https://trends.google.de/trends/explore?date=all&geo=AR&q=gold,bitcoin,dollar https://trends.google.de/trends/explore?date=all&geo=AR&q=go... Over the 20 years which the Peso has been devaluing, Bitcoin has outpaced the others by far in terms of searches. What other indicators could we look at to get a better picture?
- defrost 3y agoThey don't think people in Argentina are flocking to Gold, they wrote: > and people are flocking to ... US Dollars. Not gold,
- ArtTimeInvestor 3y agoYup, sorry, fixed. The search trends are the same for Dollar vs Bitcoin. Strongly in favor of Bitcoin.
- mupuff1234 3y agoBecause nobody needs to search "dollar", everyone knows and uses it.
- 3y ago
- cr0pduster 3y ago[dead]
- Puts 3y agoAs an inflation hedge, maybe you don't even care if you loose money on your gold. As long as you don't loose as much money you would have on inflation. Sometimes it's just good to have anything left rather than nothing.
- wodenokoto 3y agoI have some friends who are into owning gold. Their rule of thumb is: You can own gold mines on paper, but gold, only in hand. There is a belief that there exists a lot more paper gold than actual gold. So when the run on the reserves starts, the price of gold will explode as billions of dollars worth of gold in the market disappears. Although I’m not sure if Costco buyers are thinking like that.
- sambazi 3y ago> There is a belief that there exists a lot more paper gold than actual gold. So when the run on the reserves starts, the price of gold will explode as billions of dollars worth of gold in the market disappears. very good sales pitch!
- abracadaniel 3y agoThe same pitch used for GameStop stock.
- cf141q5325 3y agoIts not just a belief. The ratio is something in the region of 100x. Its also not just a precious metal thing, most markets function that way due to long and short positions. The paper market is always quite a lot larger then the actual one.
- japanuspus 3y ago[[citation needed]]
- cf141q5325 3y agoEdit: This should do >The ratio of iron-ore derivatives to physical trading volume was about 25 times, far lower than the 80-100 time for more mature commodities such as gold and copper, according to a study by Hong Kong Exchanges & Clearing. https://www.bloomberg.com/professional/blog/expect-chinas-futures-market-opening/ https://www.bloomberg.com/professional/blog/expect-chinas-fu... Silver is quite a lot worse btw Might be worth pointing out that this isnt surprising given the activity of speculators in the market. Without markets would get cornered for investment and industry would cease. edit1: There is however also an incentive to keep individuals from investing into precious metals due to monetary considerations. Derivate induced volatility is one way to do that. https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/1974LONDON16154_b.html https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/1974LONDON16154_b.html edit2: Also worth considering is that the large central bank holdings can and will be loaned out to maintain price stability if push comes to shove and gold were to rise drastically.
- philwelch 3y agoWhen I looked into this, the consensus seemed to be that the best form of gold, if you want to physically hold it yourself, is gold coins minted by reputable national mints. American Gold Eagles, South Africa Krugerrands, etc. These trade at close to spot. And a 1 oz Krugerrand or Gold Eagle is about $20,000. If you can afford enough volume of those that it’s difficult to secure them, you can afford to secure them.
- ggm 3y agoFunny story: when we bought our second house we found the previous owners had left high in a cupboard a small trumpet case containing a trumpet, a set of freemasons regalia and about 20 krugerrands. We took it round to the old owners new house and passed it all over. They seemed happy. I think I'd have struggled to keep it the law not withstanding. Three months later we found a box of (from what I am told, illegal, modified) small arms bullets hidden behind the wardrobe. We handed that into the police.
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- AdamN 3y agoSort of. You want minted bullion. Usually they're capital gains free too. Nonetheless I don't think gold is a great investment for preppers or for just normal investing. There are also some very serious environmental/human rights concerns with gold that keep me out.
- netcruiser 3y agoIt's $2,000, not $20,0000 (I assume USD). Gold coins are pretty easy to come by in my experience.
- philwelch 3y agoYou are correct. My mistake.
- qp11 3y agoIn most of the under developed world were financial systems are unstable/dont control the economy, they dont convert gold into local currency. They use it as currency. "You want that cow, give me that nose ring". Ofcourse in the "developed world" the problem is, one fuckhead will show up, who wants to own all the cows, for no logically reason other than he just has too. Naturally gold wont work.
- rwmj 3y agoOnly in your fantasy world. In the real world they trade dollars.
- refurb 3y agoNot always. My friend in Vietnam was saying how it wasn’t that long ago (10-20 years maybe?) when property was purchased directly with gold talens. You exchanged Vietnamese dong for gold, then transferred that to the seller. I assume it was done to avoid the crazy inflation and concern over validating that a massive stack of bills didn’t include counterfeits. And the lack of foreign currency to convert to.
- pjc50 3y agoQuite a lot of the "less developed" world has person to person mobile payment systems such as M-Pesa.
- mrweasel 3y agoIt's not actually that stable of an investment vehicle, sure price have generally been going up over the past ten years, but if you bought gold in around 2012, you would have lost money if you where not able to hold on to it for another eight to ten years. Personally I think the prices might be to high and a drop is coming. To keep the market moving someone is now trying to create a new market segment and is attempting to pull in new customers, apparently via Costco. This is either to prevent a slump in sales or to offload gold holdings before the price starts dropping.
- anonzzzies 3y agoThe only reason for keeping it personally would be barter in case of a total economic collapse. I mean; my precious metal ETF, nuclear energy ETF and accidental USD currency purchase at the right time kept me fully clear of any inflation here in the EU, but I doubt physical gold would do anything like it. However for barter….
- leni536 3y agoThat still assumes that gold would hold its value in a total economic collapse. Why would it?
- Ferret7446 3y agoIt's a relatively rare element that has a lot of practical and social value, consistently throughout almost the entire history of humanity. It is also extremely stable compared to things which may have more practical value such as food or water, which grants it a unique value as bartering currency without central governments. It is also fairly easy to appraise to a rough degree of purity due to its stability, softness, and density.
- victorbjorklund 3y agoIf everything breaks down (like not just a blackout etc but all of society disapears) you are probably better off bartering with useful stuff like guns, food, tools etc
- bjackman 3y agoAs well as collapse I think there's a case to be made for hedging against loss of access to the normal financial system. E.g. maybe one day the CIA will believe very strongly that you are a terrorist. In that situation a kilo of gold might be extremely useful! Actually this is probably an even stronger case - gold will lose almost as much value as money in the case of economic collapse. Whereas wanted terrorists can probably still get a fairly decent price.
- AdamN 3y agoI always bring up Somalia. The government crumbled and they continued to use local paper currency even after the printing presses were destroyed and there was nothing backing it. In the actual global collapse scenario, physical cash is likely to be more fungible and still have value than gold. So if you really want to prepare for that (which should be like step 156 in terms of prepping), the right solution after you have all your direct physical needs (canned food, medicine, etc.) is simply a cash stockpile.
- Beijinger 3y ago"Direct gold ownership is rife with risks" Every kind of ownership comes with "risks". It is stupidity not to own gold "directly". Buying a gold ETF is likely a bad idea like having your cryptocurrencies not under personal control. Precious metals ETF charge a yearly fee. A buddy of mine once developed a financial instrument, where the ETF really owns the metal and does not mimic its spot price but also pays a dividend. (And yes, it was legit and a great idea)
- daymanstep 3y agoWhere does the money come from for the dividend? If company profit or gold price goes down does the dividend become negative?
- Beijinger 3y agoNope. But please understand that I can't elaborate this since I still think it is a nice idea. But I give you a hint: I talked about precious metals, not gold. :-)
- frozenport 3y agoIf you heat it up does it expand in volume?
- pjc50 3y agoPlutonium ETF, where you literally can't hold it?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Where does the money come from for the dividend? They loan it out.
- OJFord 3y agoSince GP won't say, my guess is the idea was to explicitly not target capital growth, but a fixed value ('does not mimic spot price') - so you buy in at spot or with some some spread, and the dividend pays out by selling the underlying as spot goes up, with some buffer for fees and being able to buy a certain amount as it falls. If the dividend were also a function of volume & prices of (filled) ETF orders, it could tolerate up to 100% loss. But that doesn't account for the 'I said precious metals, not gold' hint.
- reaperman 3y agoCostco really doesn’t have any appreciable margin on their products. Their net profit[0] is only a tiny bit more than their membership fees - effectively they sell their merchandise “at cost” (including overhead). 0: https://www.reddit.com/r/Costco/comments/16tae6a/how_does_costco_makes_money/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Costco/comments/16tae6a/how_does_co...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I'd love to see an economists take on the value to a consumer of holding gold in this form, at the price Directly-held gold is mostly a scam. In good times, vault gold trades at a premium. (Like diamonds, try to sell your ingot of gold for anywhere close to commodity spot.) In bad times, someone will stab you for it. Unless you have $100+ million, where you can charter your own logistics outside government-sanction lines to e.g. aerolift you [1], your family and your gold across national borders, directly-held gold isn’t doing anything for you. There are vanishingly few cases where your vault-held gold certificates are valueless while your directly-held gold has value. [1] Also, news flash, when dictators flee they carry dollars. Gold is heavy and traceable if you’re using proper bars.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoIf you do not want gold to be traced, surely it is worth taking a hit in value and melting down the stamped ids?
- cardiffspaceman 3y agoFictional Auric Goldfinger made parts of a car body out of gold right? But isn’t tracking metal more refined than just reading a number molded or stamped in an ingot?
- bsder 3y agoI'm really left scratching my head about people who buy gold to hold physically and personally rather than as an investment. In any situation where it might be relevant, how are you going to sell your gold? For example, if you bought one of those bars right now, how would you then sell that bar again right now? And, if things really are completely collapsing, nobody wants gold. They'll want something much more immediately useful--food, clothing, ammunition, etc. I did look at this to see if it was cheaper than any jewelrymaking gold I could buy, but the prices are bang on identical per ounce.
- refurb 3y agoRight now it’s not hard to sell. There are reputable gold traders who will pay cash, usually at market prices (minus some margin). But presumably if the shit hits the fan and the USD is worthless, it’s a form of trade. I don’t disagree not a great one. My biggest issue is if you want to buy food what do you do with a $2,000 piece of gold? Buy $2000 in food? You can’t really divide it up (a random chunk of gold is much less valuable than a minted coin).
- hcks 3y agoI’d guess threat model is less “there is a zombie apocalypse” and more “you need to flee to another country”.
- jonathanstrange 3y agoBut then you need cold coins, not a gold bar. Or, multiple foreign currencies.
- bluGill 3y agoBars can be traded for coins. There are not many who can do that, but you can find them anywhere if you look. You won't always get a great deal, but I'm confident that you can find someone who buy your gold bars for cash most places in the world.
- md_ 3y ago
- cf141q5325 3y ago>I'd love to see an economists take on the value to a consumer of holding gold in this form, at the price. I doubt you will find any unbiased opinion. Its important to remember that economists arent solely focused on the IS state. Its not a science, its perception management. The narrative is self fulfilling. I really enjoy the npr article on the Brazilian inflation on this https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2010/10/04/130329523/how-fake-money-saved-brazil https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2010/10/04/130329523/how-... The tldr is that the economy is what you think it to be.
- brutus1213 3y agoTotally correct. Was watching an interesting town hall by the Fed for educators, and it was interesting to hear JP say "we have so many fine [Econ] textbooks", and in a different sentence say "it takes a few editions to catch up to our innovations". It was perfectly illustrating what I learned in undergrad Econ .. it is the science of explaining what happened. Extrapolation is fine but under no warranty. I have made major personal blunders relying on established econ theory to hold (especially around housing). My new take is the govt will bail out the masses in some instances, so just follow the trend.
- cf141q5325 3y ago>My new take is the govt will bail out the masses in some instances, so just follow the trend. Unless they are too incompetent or corrupt to keep the ship sailing. Which you could also reword into the problem becoming too complex and the process missing means to counter steer. Especially with the later framing it becomes clear that one might have unrealistic expectations for the process the problem got delegated to. Stuff is complicated and checks and balances in form of the fourth estate are currently dysfunction due to a lack of a financing.
- attentive 3y agoEasy buying is great, but it's only useful if there is also an easy and lossless selling. And there isn't.
- Spooky23 3y agoGold is a scam. It’s an awful inflation hedge. Success in the market as far as selling it to retail is more a demonstration at how successful certain elements in society have been peddling fear.
- demondemidi 3y agoTotally. It is 100x oversold on paper. There’s a short squeeze coming. It has nothing to due with the intrinsic value of gold and everything to do with four decades of hype convincing American rubes to buy it.
- kortilla 3y agoNo it’s not, that 100x includes cash settled derivatives.
- tim333 3y agoDunno. For a scam it's been held by an awful lot of central banks, for many decades, who you might think would figure these things out. Re inflation it has historically been good at being fairly constant in value in real terms which is not usually what you actually want in an investment - you want them to go up. Here's the famous graph from Stocks for the Long Run with the 200 year track record https://occaminvesting.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Stocks-for-the-long-run-v2.jpg https://occaminvesting.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Stoc... That shows stocks as the best, though for a reasonably enterprising private investor rental property probably wins.
- gibsonf1 3y agoIn the current market, you can invest and make interest in gold and silver: https://monetary-metals.com/ https://monetary-metals.com/
- Aeolun 3y agoI don’t imagine you’d ever sell these, but what beats having a gold bar in your home? A very tiny one, but still.
- cammikebrown 3y agoAnything with utility? Anything at all?
- caeril 3y agoMost people have things in their home, that they paid for, that have negative utility. Televisions, video game consoles, etc. A 1/2 oz gold coin is a superior investment to a PlayStation 5. Sure, it won't generate any yield, and has some degree of illiquidity, but it won't waste N hours per day of your limited, and rapidly expiring life, that you could have spent on more productive pursuits.
- cammikebrown 3y agoYeah, why have fun when I could be Generating Profit? Sorry I enjoy recreation.
- kortilla 3y agoWhere did you get the impression generating profit is the goal?
- datavirtue 3y agoMany people play games that are not fun and actually make them angry and triggered.
- NavinF 3y agoThat's a skill issue and it's not common by any means
- codq 3y ago
- dahfizz 3y agoLaypeople hear professionals talk about how gold is a good investment, but they don't realize that professionals are trading gold ETFs and futures. Ill informed lay people then go buy a gold bar from Costco.
- bluGill 3y agoFor laypeople there are two reasons to trade gold: to show it off, or in event of society collapse. Both of them require you to have the physical gold in your possession. Professionals can trade gold futures and make money, but that is a very different type of investment that laypeople generally should stay out of because of how complex it is.
- trgn 3y agoMaybe it's better understood as plate, not coin. Dishwear put it in a burghers display case most of the year, that can, in times of war or distress be used as money. It has a sentimental value primarily, nonetheless, it has a veneer (pun intended) of true intrinsic value as well.
- marcosdumay 3y agoPeople value those when they don't trust the finance institutions to keep their paper-gold promises. Why people are distrusting those institutions, and on the US for all places... that's a question for sociology or psychology. I strongly suspect the social network cultural bubbles are behind this, but don't have much to say there. (Anyway, I'm not an economist, but I've studied it a bit. This question is quite simple anyway, and it's something that has happened before, so it's pretty well covered.)