20 ms·
Pro-cash movement warns that people could be losing more than they bargained for
- IYasha 3y agoIsn't it great? When one bit in the database can completely ruin someone's life.
- walterbell 3y agohttps://archive.is/FR8Nv https://archive.is/FR8Nv
- jjgreen 3y ago"Paper money" is such a strange expression to use here: it's inaccurate (because coins) and much longer than the obvious word, cash.
- f5ve 3y agoIn the context of the WSJ, cash doesn't mean physical currency. It just means dollars, i.e. not treasuries or any other type of asset. Most people would interpret that headline differently -- to the point of it being inaccurate. [edit: also the wordplay wouldn't work]
- jjgreen 3y agoI'd never heard of that before, interesting, thanks; Rich people speak a foreign language ...
- mulmen 3y agoThat usage is not unique to rich people.
- ericd 3y agoIt’s any investor, not only the rich ones. Typically includes things like very short duration bonds (like t-bills).
- lxgr 3y agoIt's also used in other contexts, e.g. cash vs. stock compensation (and I wouldn't necessarily call everybody offered that choice "rich" these days).
- hnthrowaway8860 3y agoI would. People in the tech bubble don't understand their privilege. If everybody you interact with daily makes less than you then you are rich. Or how does you total compensation compare to that of the Walmart worker, the guy behind the McD counter, you hair dresser, the lady cleaning your office toilets or the waiter at your lunch restaurant or staffer at the bouldering gym? You think they get stocks?
- mulmen 3y agoI make nearly 300k a year and I can’t afford a house. I’m upper middle class at best. That’s an order of magnitude away from wealthy.
- hnthrowaway8860 3y agoI seriously doubt that. I might bot be able to afford the exact house you most desire in the exact location that you desire. But if you restrict the definition of "rich" to only include people that can, then it's a very odd set that's left. I'm sure Elon desires a house on Mars, and he can't afford that either.
- mulmen 3y agoYou don’t know me or my situation. Houses in Seattle are upwards of 750k for something that isn’t a fixer-upper. And if a house meeds work that’s even more money. Being able to “afford” something is more than having the cash to buy it or credit to finance it. There’s a huge difference between being rich (or wealthy, not the same) and simply having more than someone else.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoOk, we've replaced the article title with a bit of its subtitle (edit: plus a representative phrase from the main text).
- mhh__ 3y ago"cash" in your pocket is central bank money. Current president keeps the dead presidents good (in theory). In the bank it is merely a promise of money. Cash can (arguably) mean paper money but there is often a distinction made in capital markets - physical cash is for retail banks. An applied example of a cash position in finance is repo: You need some short term cash - a simple hack financial markets use to do this in an administrative/credit efficient way is to simply sell (say) a bond (the collateral), receive some money (your cash), then agree to buy the bond back tomorrow for slightly more than you sold it for (the interest rate).
- standardUser 3y agoOn a recent trip to Europe I didn't take out cash once over 3 weeks across 3 countries. I brought 50 euros with me and that was all I needed! Everything else was just a quick tap of the phone, including every metro system outside of Paris. My only hesitation to getting rid of cash entirely - how will I buy drugs? I don't gamble illegally or pay for sex, but I imagine those services would also struggle in an increasingly cashless world.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoThe absence of cash should terrify anyone. So ridiculously easy to quash any dissidents if you can cut off their ability to buy anything with a single click of a button. I don't use much cash at all but if my government was planning on ending all cash, I'd go out and buy a bunch of precious metals. Can't trust my basic freedom with Visa and Paypal.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYeah I completely understand a business not wanting to handle cash. It's bulky, dirty, easy to steal, must be secured in a heavy expensive safe, it takes time to count, it has to be physically transported to the bank or picked up by an armored car service, it's error-prone. But in terms of personal freedom, I don't want cash to go away.
- endingworld 3y ago[flagged]
- lottin 3y agoSorry, this is a lot of nonsense. Any government that has the ability to prevent dissidents from paying for stuff also has the ability to employ much more brutal and effective methods of quashing dissidence.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThey have to find you first, which is quite labor-intensive compared to just tracking and/or halting a person's financial transaction ability.
- shishy 3y agoCash is great. Can't be tracked, credit card companies don't get to discriminate against the poor and create negative feedback loop traps that they can't out of, it's easier to be financially responsible with it. Bit unfortunate too that paying with cash just adds a tax onto the poor since the fees are basically priced into goods sold at stores, typically regardless of whether or not cash is used. But yeah, nice to have the option to use both! I also know that credit cards have their advantages, but what are the main benefits of going fully cashless (at the individual and systemic level)? Is it mostly crime related shenanigans?
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Is it mostly crime related shenanigans? Not having to carry a wallet anymore. Never going to the ATM. No need to pocket loose change. Quicker checkout times.
- Animatronio 3y agoAre these really inconveniences? Most of the times I've had trouble paying for stuff were usually at supermarkets or gas stations where the credit card reader would refuse to acknowledge my card. Swiping/inserting/touching, not even cursing worked so without cash on hand I'd have had to surrender my ID to the clerk, take a cab to the closest ATM and return with cash.
- mrtranscendence 3y agoI was an early adopter of (debit) card only, using it for everything in 1999. Your experience has never happened to me, as far as I recall. I don’t think I’ve ever had to go to an atm because the reader didn’t work.
- Animatronio 3y agoWell, it happened to me just the other day - said it cannot read the card or something like that (even though I had used it less than 15 minutes earlier in another shop). There was already a queue behind me so I forked $40 for gas and went on my way.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI encounter more businesses that only take cash than I do those that refuse it. A couple of local restaurants, and my barber. Though one of the restaurants recently also started accepting Zelle. I can't think of anyplace local that refuses cash but there are several others that offer a discount for cash.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoOpposite in my part of the world. Lots of businesses aren’t taking a cash anymore. The only ones I know that deal with cash only are marijuana dispensaries, which are popular targets for thugs as a result.
- walterbell 3y agoIn New York City, San Francisco, Philadelphia: all businesses accept cash, as required by municipal law.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI live in none of those cities, so those rules don’t apply.
- SoftTalker 3y agoMy barber carries a Ruger GP100 357 magnum revolver to discourage thuggery. I'm 100% serious.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThey aren’t allowed to carry guns at marijuana dispensaries, for federal law reasons similar to why they can’t take cash. It’s a weird business to be in, you pretty much have to drop all your cash into a safe as soon as you get it.
- skeeter2020 3y ago>> there are several others that offer a discount for cash This is relatively new; previously Visa/MC prevented their merchants from doing this but it changed recently. Counter example: you can penalize a company you don't like by paying with amex.
- Seattle3503 3y agoMy concerns about a cashless society are the power it hands to a few oligopolistic credit card processors. Look at what happened to Pornhub. Regardless of whether you think Pornhub was in the wrong, it is striking that a business was cut off from global financial system by a small number of credit card companies. This was done without due process and under no countries laws. That should scare us at least a little.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoHow could a website function with cash payments at all?
- walterbell 3y agoNo one is arguing for a cash-only society. Digital has use cases. Cash has use cases. We can have both.
- incone123 3y agoI don't think they were making that argument, more that websites don't usually take cash anyway. (Can't imagine pornhub selling gift cards at the supermarket checkout next to the App store ones)
- walterbell 3y agoIn North America, retail stores often sell prepaid Visa cards that can be used both offline and online. NYC cashless ban law exception allows a fee-free machine to convert cash to prepaid digital payment mechanism, e.g. stored value card. US Coinstar kiosks offer fee-free conversion of coins to Amazon and other gift cards.
- SoftTalker 3y agoPrepaid VISA doesn't get around the payment processor refusing to handle transactions for certain businesses though. Maybe EFT (e-Check) or Zelle does? It's still on line and tracable but is not going through card processor networks.
- walterbell 3y agohttps://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2021/10/war-on-cash-nyc-enforces-its-cashless-business-ban.html https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2021/10/war-on-cash-nyc-enfo... > In 1978, Massachusetts became the first to enact such a law, requiring retailers to accept cash and credit. In passing its ban in January 2020, NYC joined New Jersey, Philadelphia and San Francisco, which all approved such bans in 2019.. Two rationales motivated NYC’s ban. First was the large number of NYC residents – more than 10% – who lack bank accounts, and thus access to credit cards.. Second is general skepticism over the security of cashless transactions, with the NYT noting they raise “the specter of hackers stealing personal data tied to digital transactions.” .. NYC went after the upscale Van Leeuwen ice cream shop for repeated violations of the cashless ban.. In October, the city charged the ice cream shop with 17 violations of the cashless ban and penalized the company with $12,750 in fines.
- DerekL 3y agoI can imagine this scenario: Cashier: Your total comes to $8.45. Customer: All I have is a $20. Is that okay? Cashier: Yes, it’s San Francisco law that we accept cash. Customer: Okay, here. Customer: … Customer: Where’s my change? Cashier: We accept cash, we don’t give change. The San Francisco law doesn’t require that change be given. Be prepared to carry small bills and coins.
- walterbell 3y agoIn a dense urban area, competition for many businesses is a short walk away. Once the playing field has been leveled by a municipal law, there is little to be gained by antagonizing customers who can walk to the nearest competitor.
- wellthisisgreat 3y agoPeople who want to go 100% cashless at the current state of tech progress / society are the enemies of humanity. They are advocates of totalitarian regimes and whatever comes with them, no matter what they glaze their poison with - convenience, crypto, futurism etc.
- ThorsBane 3y agoGood. Keep it that way.
- raincom 3y agoBig brother wants to surveil on everyone, that's the goal of any cashless society. How the big brother can force shutdown a business, say, X, which doesn't comply requests without warrants? Just have visa/master/paypal (third party) to not do business with X, because X violates some TOS. Even though inflation has increased three folds since the bank secrecy act, they have kept the limits so low to track any cash entry/exits out of the financial system. Big brother doesn't want the powerless people to unite--thats the end goal.
- annexrichmond 3y agoGovernments would have loved this power during the Covid lockdowns
- thegrim33 3y agoThe primary benefit of cashless is pretty much just the ability to be lazy. You swipe a card in a reader instead of having to count out cash. That's the major benefit. All things being equal, sure, it's more convenient. But all things are not equal; in my opinion the potential negatives that others in the thread have listed overwhelmingly outweigh the ability to be more lazy. That so many people have the desire to ditch freedom in exchange for the ability to be slightly more lazy is such a disappointing state of affairs and says a lot about society.
- scoofy 3y agoThe fact that getting mugged is so uncommon these days shows how naive this comment is to the second and third order effects of a cashless society. I think cash should always be an option, but I don’t pretend that cards haven’t dramatically improved our lives.
- frfsfgxffd 3y agoBrazil is almost cashless today. first month with central bank digital currency, instant kidnaps were thru the roof. the "solution" lower limits of how much you can transfer. what a joke. now only 100usd per day can leave your pocket. wish i was kidding. even lower at night when traveling i have to wake up at 3am to make payments thanks to timezones. people can raise limits, but if you pay for something expensive once you're probably marked forever as having lots of money in your pocket. with cash, that would be a one time opportunity to be robbed. with cashless, you signaled that forever you're a good target. there's zero benefits for safety. you fell for the oldest trick in the book.
- scoofy 3y agoBank transactions are trivially traceable and reversible by the state. I've been actively against bitcoin and monero exactly because they facilitate kidnapping and other forms of effectively irreversible digital theft. The best part about living in a society with institutions based on trust instead of non-trust, is that it's trivially easy to eject bad actors from the system.
- Animats 3y agoI've been using cash more due to the proliferation of sluggish, badly engineered, or dark-pattern point of sale systems. There are two eateries across the street from each other near me. At both, you go to the counter and order, and they later bring food out. The first has a good system, from Stripe. Big, clear, uncluttered screen facing the customer, with the amount the biggest thing on the screen. When the system is ready to read the contactless card, the contactless card logo lights up, above the screen. The reader always reads the card once it's within about 1cm of the reader. The display immediately changes, by a smooth horizontal scroll, to a tip screen, which needs only one touch on a screen that senses the touch without difficulty. One more smooth horizontal scroll, with receipt options and a big "you are customer #5" display. One more touch and you're done. If I select "Paper receipt", the receipt prints within 2 seconds, and I tear it off and take it. Done. I'll use a credit card there. Across the street, another place has a Veriphone systems. This one is much more sluggish. There's no unambiguous indication of when the system is ready to accept a card. The contactless card reader is separate from the customer display screen. Sometimes, when the display indicates it's ready, it isn't. Or it may take several tries before it accepts the card. This is probably "hosted POS", where the POS terminal is a dumb web client and has to wait for an overloaded server for each step in the transaction. Then the display wants a signature. There's no pen, and a finger touch won't work. Writing with a fingernail is necessary. Then the clerk has to ask if you want a receipt, and they have to do some data entry to get one printed. I pay cash there. Walgreens and CVS are even worse. Half the small screen is full of ads. There are asks for phone number, stuff about "reward points", readers that seem to be out of sync with the screen, and printed receipts two feet long, full of ads. It's easier to order on Amazon rather than go there.
- jachee 3y agoThat second POS sounds like it also matches the colloquial definition of the initialism. :)
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoEven if it weren't a terrible, awful idea from a democratic point of view, it's just silly from a logistic point of view. This means you create a single point of failure for your entire society: electricity provision. Got a power shot down? Suddenly nobody can buy anything. Got a war on your territory? Your trade routes will get destroyed 4 times faster. Want to be a reserve currency? Guess what, now you have to do like China and have 2 currencies cause the rest of the world uses cash. And congrats, a cyber attack can now hurt your economy. Hope nothing in 70000 years of history won't repeat itself cause you are now going down next time something goes wrong.
- danpalmer 3y agoMost stores aren't going to be able to sell you anything with no power, regardless of taking card or cash, because sales need to go into a database via a register, update inventory, etc. Sure a few small family run businesses, maybe restaurants, might be able to take cash, but almost no chains will be able to run and that's most stores in most places.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoFirst days, you don't need all stores, a few is enough. After a few days, I guarantee even the big ones will manage the inventory with pen and paper, with the blessing of the boss and the gov. But even without all that, having the ability to have a black market in a time of crisis is priceless.
- canucker2016 3y agoIt's the network that's the problem. In Europe, the Visa network went down in 2018. see https://www.wired.com/story/visa-outage-shows-the-fragility-of-global-payments/ https://www.wired.com/story/visa-outage-shows-the-fragility-... In Canada, the Rogers network went down in July 2022 for several hours which caused debit card transactions to fail (after the outage, Interac said it was going to add a SECOND network provider - *facepalm*). Many businesses which relied on the Rogers network for credit card transactions were also affected. from https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/rogers-outage-interac-debit-restored-1.6515869 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/rogers-outage-interac-debit...: "Small business owners were among those hardest hit by the outage, which left them unable to process debit card payments. Sharif Ahmed, the owner of Plantforsoul plant shop in Toronto's west end, said the outage left him feeling helpless, as he turned away customers who didn't have cash."
- danpalmer 3y agoSomething often not spoken about (as the discussion often focuses on privacy and "power") is the price. As someone who uses card for most payments (maybe paying in cash a couple of times a year), cash is expensive to use. It requires time out of my routine to take the cash out, unless I can take out an exact amount there I'm then left with change, and then because I don't want the change I normally spend it on things I don't need. If cash in another currency that's very expensive as I have to pay to convert the small amount. On the other hand cards are effectively free to me, even paying in other currencies. I travel a lot and never use local cash. However, for many people, the reverse is true. If your cash flow is primary in actual cash, then paying into an account can be annoying or even cost money, current accounts without sufficient funds in them often charge a fee (in the UK current accounts, checking accounts?, are typically "free"), some users can't even hold a real bank account and are forced to use pseudo-bank-accounts based on prepaid cards with exorbitant fees, and cash could be argued to subsidise card fees (which are rare in the UK). I hope that for the foreseeable future both options are accepted at the majority of places. I'm never going to take cash out for a truly discretionary purchase so only accepting cash limits the market, and some people are rarely going to have a card they can use at card-only merchants.
- ramblenode 3y ago> On the other hand cards are effectively free to me The average card merchant fee in the US is 1.5-3.5%. You're paying that much more for everything you're buying. That applies even if you use cash. So it's effectively a private sales tax. You absolutely pay for the convenience. It's just not on any receipt.
- danpalmer 3y agoIn the EU/UK it's capped at 0.4% for debit cards I believe, and not much more for credit cards. I agree it is a private sales tax, but cash handling isn't free so it's not a perfect comparison. In Australia it's actually very common for the card fee to be applied on top of the charge, especially in restaurants and small businesses. And I actually don't mind. It's about 1-1.5%, which on a $50 bill is small enough that I'd rather have the convenience, and the annoyance (or risk) of cash is enough to not bother.
- piuantiderp 3y agoTo add to the concerns, imagine a small town which mostly conducts transactions within the community. Why should they effectively pay a +2% that will never return to it and go to a processor far away?
- scarface_74 3y agoNow imagine how does that small torn get all of their goods to sell to each other?
- manesioz 3y agoThey're right. Closest electronic alternative is Monero/XMR.
- asdff 3y agoDepending on how big of a whale you are, something like runescape gp or some commodity in game is probably a more stable store of value than most crypto.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoPerhaps, but yearly-wise, have in-game items ever gone up ?
- asdff 3y agoSome things go up over a thousand percent in just six months: https://secure.runescape.com/m=itemdb_rs/top100?list=2&scale=3 https://secure.runescape.com/m=itemdb_rs/top100?list=2&scale...
- motohagiography 3y agoIn Canada, we saw the main use case for cashlessness last winter during popular protests. It was used to track donors to a popular non-violent movement and freeze their bank accounts. That's all anyone needs to know about it, really. Consider that most people aren't smart enough to apprehend how deeply malicious the architects of cashless policies are. They don't care if you disagree, they just need for you to do nothing.
- gedy 3y agoI buy all fast food with cash, don't trust the data won't be used in future for insurance or other data mining :-)
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoI can't believe how willingly people submitted to going cashless. I was at a trendy rivertown restaurant, went to pay with cash, and the shock on people's faces was unbelievable, like I was some ancient alien. It honestly feels pretty forced, like there's a hyper-fashionable status attached to paying digitally. It's not the first time people lapped up a status marker hawked to them by some globocorp, just like iphones, luxury cars, etc.
- sebzim4500 3y agoPaying with a card is not a status symbol, it's convenient. If anything it's the opposite, if you want to flaunt wealth then you normally pay cash and round up to the nearest 50.
- shortcake27 3y agoI'm cashless for none of the reasons you mentioned. It's simply more convenient. I don't have to constantly visit ATMs to withdraw money or carry my wallet, deal with coins etc. And my spending is tracked automatically. People can have opinions - just because you prefer cash it doesn't mean people who prefer cashless are brainwashed by globocorps.
- lisasays 3y agoThey weren't talking about people who prefer cashless as being brainwashed by the globocorps. But rather merchants who insist that you go cashless - and not only refuse to serve you, but look at you as if you just emerged from a swap and learned to walk on land if you don't go along.
- aflag 3y agoIf there weren't coins I could think about the possibility of using cash. Coins are a deal breaker for me
- sschueller 3y agoSwitzerland has cash written into law[1] (You must accept all denominations of notes (that includes the CHF 1,000 note) and at minimum up to CHF 100 in coins) but sadly it is missing any penalties if you don't do it so there are now some that just ignoring it. The law needs to be updated to add penalties and exceptions for businesses that have no physical presence. There is an initiative to prevent cash from going away[2] but it's too little to prevent the above. Also organized by the people that are against vaccines, 5G and don't believe in climate change so the support is probably quite limited. The SNB is also under pressure from the rest of the world regarding the CHF 1,000 notes but decided against getting rid of it. I also don't understand why a CHF 1,000 note today is such an issue when it existed already in 1907 and back then CHF 1,000 was a lot more than in today's money. [1] https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2000/186/en https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2000/186/en [2] https://fbschweiz.ch/index.php/de/ich-zahle-bar https://fbschweiz.ch/index.php/de/ich-zahle-bar
- ForOldHack 3y agoI see that the Wall Street Journal has switched to Artificial Intelligence/Real Stupidity to write articles.
- phendrenad2 3y agoWe already have a cashless society, effectively. Let's say 1% of transactions worldwide are done with cash. Is that 1% really holding back all of these bad things that pro-cash folks imagine?
- twobitshifter 3y ago15% of UK transactions are cash FTA.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elwell 3y agoCredit card fees (arbitrarily chosen by credit card companies) are a source of inflation because they get integrated into sales pricing.
- user3939382 3y agoWhether or not you agreed with the trucker protest in Canada, I hope we all agree it’s pretty terrifying that the method the state decided to use to silence protesters was freezing their bank accounts without due process, any trial, anything. Cash is the best weapon against this.
- jccalhoun 3y agoDo you have a link you can give to explain what you are talking about? I"m familiar with the protest but not the other part.
- doodlesdev 3y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/trudeau-canada-freeze-bank-accounts-freedom-convoy-truckers-2022-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/trudeau-canada-freeze-bank-a...
- billy_bitchtits 3y agoIt seems like being able to do this sort of thing. And being able to make government payments to people that must be spent (use it or lose it) and only on approved things are the big motives. Control.
- soultrees 3y agoThe scariest part of that was people who weren’t necessarily in that group but agreed that the vaccine requirements were going too far so they donated to people who were willing to stand out, in a time when even questioning the office owners five got you called an anti-vaxxer, and got their accounts frozen. I feel like that was the moment the government of Canada let their true colours show and it scared me.
- WeylandYutani 3y agoPro cash movement wants those who never use cash to pay for their hobby. Besides doesn't HN champion the free market and hate regulations?
- jupp0r 3y agoI understand and agree with the arguments for cash as an option. On the other hand, I think it's completely irrelevant if nobody is using it. I'm in my 30s and literally nobody uses cash among my friends. Is this debate even relevant?
- Georgelemental 3y agoI am younger than you, and I use cash.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoNot among your friends. I use cash for every single in person transaction I do, and only use a card for Amazon and whatever other online things o buy every so often.
- petilon 3y agoWhen you pay cash you are paying for the credit card convenience (the fee that is built into nearly all price tags) without benefiting from it. My bank returns 2% of the charged amount. If I paid cash I would forego this benefit.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoI don't have a credit card, and don't know anyone who does - only debit cards. So this might be specific to your bank and/or country ?
- petilon 3y agoMost US credit cards return 1%, some return 2%. Another advantage of credit cards is that the bank acts as a mediator in case of disputes regarding the charged amount. Also, rental cars and hotel rooms are only available if you charge them to a credit card.
- jccalhoun 3y agoIs not taking cash common in the USA? I'm in a small city in the midwest so I wouldn't be surprised if it hasn't reached here yet but aside from a couple of rare stories I haven't heard much about it happening here.
- htag 3y agoWest coastal. I recently made a $1300 transaction in cash, and while the business was able to accommodate me, it took them five minutes, two drawers, and creative accounting to generate $74 in change. They were surprised to see a cash transaction. $1300 probably puts me in the top 20% of their transactions. I once lost my keys to my car, and called a locksmith, he drove a van out to the neighborhood and provided two new locks for a cost of $700. When I started putting cash out to pay he said "holy shit" and his mannerisms changed. He then insisted he is good for repeat business. Considering the interaction happened between 11pm-1am on a Wednesday, and he took no record of my identity, I wonder what type of repeat business he was expecting from me. I often see trendy places with staff running around with a tile or square or whatever, often operating by a teenager. I'm unsure if they have cash, and if they know how to keep a drawer that would count correctly with receipts. I imagine some of them will straight up refuse cash. There aren't all horror stories. Anyone working a cash register in a gas station, convenience store, smoke shop, or grocery store will actually be prepared to take your physical concurrency.
- raintrees 3y agoTwo words for a recent real life example of decisions that can be made by governments about electronic bank accounts: Canadian Truckers. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Whose turn will it be next?
- SergeAx 3y agoUsing cash is a basic human right, like freedom of speech.
- hayst4ck 3y agoI have such mixed feelings. On one hand, it clearly creates a power problem where too few have too much power. On the other hand, you don't run a company without a dashboard of statistics and information to inform the decisions you make and theoretically the higher fidelity of the information you use to make decisions, the better decisions you can make. It's also very convenient. Since people can exercise power without consequences it seems like anything that centralizes power is bad and therefore preserving cash is fundamentally good, but if people could provide consequences to those who abuse power, then things like digital currency could be used for great good. I have to admit, relatedly, I am incredibly skeezed out by square e-mailing me itemized digital receipts for purchases made against a square terminal. What are they doing with that data? Are the regulated? Are they selling it? Are they using it to collude against customers (like the people who suggest rental prices creating a de facto cartel)? Cash doesn't really have metadata.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoIndeed. Recently I grudgingly went to a ticketmaster concert. Shit you not, it was like boarding an international flight. It’s not possible to buy a top performer ticket anonymously any longer, and you are required to present ID and have a smartphone. Who the hell asked for this? I didn’t. It will be my last tm concert, that’s for sure.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoWent to a familiar small venue which has been trying to make a bit of a comeback after covid, but still not weekly live music. Monthly at least for about 6 months now but this month was the first time with a newer "competitive" online ticketing service. I pay cash at the door anyway, often for years which was almost the same price as advance with fees online. Nope this month it suprised me, door man said card only now. So they let me in free, knowing I'm there to support the band and bartenders with good tips anyway.
- qingcharles 3y agoI've just gone several months without access to any electronic money (e.g. debit cards, credit cards, phone etc) and it has been complicated. I've been thrown out of several stores at the checkout because they couldn't or wouldn't take cash. You also lose the ability to take advantage of many special offers that are available only through retailers apps, e.g. McDonald's. You can get the discounts, free items, nor can you accrue any credit (e.g. Walgreen's Cash) or points towards future discounts. I also couldn't ride any of the scooters or bicycles in my city that are available everywhere, because it is incredibly difficult or impossible to use cash to access these forms of transport. You can't even use your cash to buy a prepaid debit card as they won't accept prepaid debit cards to rent the items.
- htag 3y ago1. Why did you lose the ability? 2. What efforts were required to regain the ability?
- qingcharles 3y agoGoing to jail for a long time. When you get out you have no ID, you're a nonperson. It can be very difficult to get things like ID, then Internet connection to try and get bank accounts etc. You have to just spend the weeks and months necessary to reboot your entire life from the ground up to be able to use electronic money.
- no_time 3y ago>I've just gone several months without access to any electronic money (e.g. debit cards, credit cards, phone etc) and it has been complicated. I've been thrown out of several stores at the checkout because they couldn't or wouldn't take cash. What stores? How do they serve kids and old people?
- qingcharles 3y agoAll sorts of stores. These are all regular stores who for some reason suddenly are unable to process cash, including Chipotle, McDonald's, Dollar General and more. They will say "CARDS ONLY".
- friend_and_foe 3y agoIn the US it is catching on, particularly outside of the population dense centers of cities. You see signs now charging surcharges on card payments to cover the processing fees, thus disincentivizing card payments. Personally I do everything in my day to day life with cash. I don't want to use a card, ever, if I can avoid it.
- wiml 3y agoTypically, if a business accepts cards, part of their agreement with the card-processing company is that they cannot charge a surcharge. Card transactions have to be the same price (presented to the customer) as cash transactions. (I forget how gas stations get around this.) I do tend to see "card transactions under $X will have a Y¢ surcharge" handwritten signs in smaller businesses. I don't know if that's permitted or if MegaGloboCorp simply hasn't cared that the dive bar or taqueria isn't holding to their contract.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spookybones 3y agoA cashless society is such a profoundly bad idea. I can’t believe we’re even discussing this.
- seatac76 3y agoI tend to agree, a related concern that I share is with CBDC, programmable money would truly be a dystopian thing. I don’t this some tangible things should go away, cash is a firm contract and it should remain that way.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoHonestly I don't really care about the freedom argument anymore. If the government wants they can just black bag you anyway. And we all know how many time leftists have had someone "deplatformed" from money for thinking wrong. It just doesn't make a difference. What it would make a difference with is crime. All the drug dealing, child prostitution and money laundering from those businesses would be fucked overnight. Sure they can still do it, but it's a hell of a lot harder when everything is recorded. All it takes is one break in the case and suddenly you've got every single financial record and you've wiped out 10b in criminal profit. That would hugely benefit the world.
- walterbell 3y agoyou've got every single financial record Like these records of 7-figure financial flows? https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorgan-chase-caught-laundering-more-dirty-money/ https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorga... > secret documents leaked from FinCEN, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a unit of the U.S. Treasury .. “show that five global banks — JPMorgan, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank, Deutsche Bank and Bank of New York Mellon — kept profiting from powerful and dangerous players even after U.S. authorities fined these financial institutions for earlier failures to stem flows of dirty money.”
- logicchains 3y ago>What it would make a difference with is crime. All the drug dealing, child prostitution and money laundering from those businesses would be fucked overnight. Sure they can still do it, but it's a hell of a lot harder when everything is recorded. "Criminals will stop using cash immediately when we make it illegal" - it doesn't work like that. Criminals would just adopt another method of payment. Even China, the country with the most authoritarian, all-pervasive internet firewall, hasn't managed to stop people using crypto to pay for sex and drugs online. There's pretty much zero chance of the west tightly controlling the internet anywhere near as much as China any time soon, so there's basically no way it could effectively ban crypto either. Even if it did manage to completely ban crypto, however, it still could not stop criminals just resorting to traditional forms of cash, backed by gold/silver/gems/precious metals. Or do you think every country in the world is going to ban all their citizens from owning any precious metals?
- stainablesteel 3y agotrying to remove physical cash is trying to micromanage what people are allowed to use their cash for its obviously a terrible idea, removing it would cause tons of friction that leads to an economic downturn, or people finding new, societally worse, ways of getting around it
- anArbitraryOne 3y agohttps://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-are-we-still-using-cash/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-are-we-still-using-cash...
- balderdash 3y agoI'm torn between the the logical argument that the loss of being to pay in cash would be a huge detriment to society, and the 1-10% discount (if you include points gymnastics to maximize value) that I get by using my card.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoIt's not just car dealers and auctioneers who traditionally said "cash talks and bullshit walks". For cars it boosted your negotiating stance. And auctioneers have an interesting word in their vocabulary, cashthedayofthesaleasiswhereisnowarrantiesofanykind! Pronounced as rapidly as possible with no hesitation whatsoever.
- frankchn 3y agoCar dealers now prefer financing (if you have good credit). They can make more money that way since the banks will give them a kickback for originating the loan.
- freilanzer 3y agoWe don't even need to abolish cash, imo it would be a huge improvement to cull 1 and 2 cent coins and make digital and card payments available everwhere. I'm from Germany and there are a lot pf places where you can't even pay with a regular bank card.
- csense 3y agoThe government should be increasing the size of bills to keep up with inflation. In 1934 gold was $35 per ounce, and a $100 bill could buy 2.86 ounces of gold. In 2023 you'd need about $5000 for 2.86 ounces of gold. There "should" be a $5000 bill to match the status quo of 1934 but the government has never created bills larger than $100.
- clarge1120 3y agoIn the US, the biggest cities are likely to push for cashless, while the rest of the country won't care, or will resist it.