20 ms·
America will soon see a wave of bank mergers?
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoI worked at a large bank. There were so many regulations, we were like permanently in trainings and yet the bank paid 9 figures in fines every quarter ... wonder how small banks can afford to navigate that at all.
- cyclecount 4y agoAll of the rules put in place after 2008 are being ignored; the number of banks in the US pre-2008 financial crisis was about 31k. Now there are close to 3000. After this wave of mergers, there might be around 1000! And a few will be so large that they can make insane bets, betting on risky and novel new investment vehicles that will (maybe initially) pay off handsomely before ultimately failing dramatically. This will make "too big to fail" look quaint by comparison and the banks will end up owning everything.
- Mistletoe 4y agoAm I too tinfoil hat to think the big 4 planned it like this all along? I guess one could ask why WOULDN’T they have meetings trying to engineer exactly what is happening?
- theseatoms 4y agoIf I had to guess, it's less so "planned" and more so that the various institutional and regulatory incentives make this sort of outcome extremely likely.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoI think this hits the nail on the head. I think after 2008 they setup a system (set of regulations/rules/policies not some group of monocle wearing dudes in a room scheming) where the BigBanks will eat the SmallBanks, the FDIC will insure what they do and some Federal agency will eat the SmallBank failures and then BigBank can swoop in as a "savior" essentially consuming SmallBank but all that is left is the profitable parts at that point. Use a local credit union instead of a bank.
- DonsDiscountGas 4y agoThat doesn't really explain anything though. Every business is always trying to gain marketshare. The question then is why they are succeeding now and not before. Nobody forced SVB to put all their money into 10-year treasuries, nor did anybody engineer the tech-industry recession we've been going through (JPMC is big but Apple, Microsoft and Amazon are each bigger), both of which contributed to SVBs demise. Also the big banks tried to rescue First Republic a few weeks ago; not impossible that was some weird 4-D chess move but much more likely it was just a bailout that failed. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- mandmandam 4y agoWell, to accomplish something like that, they'd have to have hundreds of (past, present, and future) employees, dotted over dozens of institutions (media, regulatory and political). They'd need the tacit permission of the other industries their owners are invested in. And, they'd need tremendous amounts of capital. Plus a history of grand collusion and unethical behavior. And leverage against anyone that might call them out. So... I've got nothing. I will say that failing to investigate this possibility seems naive; as would expecting a genuine investigation.
- govolckurself 4y ago[dead]
- smeej 4y agoI'm willing to take my downvotes on this, but as someone who works in an industry that has been working for 14 years to set up an alternative to this system, and which feels like it's under systemic, engineered threat at the very same time this is happening, I think your tinfoil hat is stylish, and appropriate for the season and weather.
- 0zemp2c 4y agoyes, and now they are "attacking" PacWest, whose stock is plummeting like First Republic its an easy cycle - find a bank you want for nothing, feed bad press through the usual outlets, watch it fall, then watch depositors get spooked, then buy it for nothing First Republic is probably just one of many banks intended to be undermined, trashed, and then sold for nothing and remember all the times First Republic's CEO came out and defended his business as it was collapsing? me neither...makes you wonder...
- than3 4y agoAm I wrong in thinking that all banks should have no exposure to the stock market period? The whole being able to trigger aggregate indebtedness violations through synthetic shares (options), seems like a systemic risk that no ones paying attention to. Also, its hard to say we still have a fractional reserve system when required deposits have been set at 0% since the pandemic. There's no fraction, its 0 unless you change the definition (i.e. Basel III which uses capitalization as deposits).
- SamReidHughes 4y agoWhat exposure to the stock market are you talking about?
- than3 4y agoAny bank with a ticker on a market. Technically no security on the market is safe from this mechanism. Banks are particularly vulnerable. With a properly timed news drop, shorting, and forcing the market maker to exit delta-hedging (due to volatility) you end up having them create synthetic shares that in addition to the loaned shorted shares push the price downwards (because there will always be more shares since they were created via the contracts and are not constrained by short limits/availability and float). The market maker may even participate to offset losses. Once the capitalization rate falls below a certain threshold you get aggregate indebtedness violations. At which point any loans they might have had create a liquidity event (i.e. frozen), which must be paid back and price levels returned to normal within 30 days (Basel 3), or 2 months (Nasdaq). It creates a spiral which can't be recovered from, they will bleed deposits, and then the regulator will seize them, and sell their assets to one of the survivor banks for pennies on the dollar (with guarantees). Another form of bailout. This is what largely happened with FRC, and now its starting to a lesser degree (a/o last night) other regional banks.
- HWR_14 4y agoI think you are too tinfoil hat to think they planned it. They don't need to engineer what is happening, it was obviously going to happen at some point. They could have targeted some banks (active, hard), or they simply could have realized that a percentage would fail when rates went up, so they got in a position to do well picking up the pieces. And then they acquire whatever fails.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoFinancial speculation is zero sum, isn't it? So the fewer banks there are the more each one gets exposed to both sides? Your bank provides services for a person who monopolises some commodity, you have billions to loan out; but all your millions of other customers are hit by the price of that commodity and all deposit less, wiping out any increase in deposits. Doesn't that mean unless they are specialised banks, that they necessarily must lose? Maybe an economist can correct or confirm my instinct here?
- scotty79 4y ago> Financial speculation is zero sum, isn't it? Only if you play fair. If you can be bailed out it's no longer zero sum.
- RandomLensman 4y agoWhy would financial speculation be zero sum (or how do you define financial speculation here)?
- misja111 4y agoSome financial speculation is zero sum, other is not. E.g. if a bank takes on a lot of clients with risky mortgages, both risk and possible gains are only on this bank. (Barring possible bail out, contagion risk etc)
- wesapien 4y agoYou guys should be flipping cars when bank execs didn't get jail time for the financial crisis
- jrs235 4y agoEh. We still have our entertainment and comforts to distract us. But with the greater and greater divide between the haves and have nots flipping cars might look tame when things change.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoWell America has plenty of outrage, but they're utterly divided and most that outrage just goes into poopooing the other side, instead of something productive like real demonstrations and protests with a real purpose. Instead we get outrage protests mainly designed for extremist groups to waste their time fighting eachother and playing at civil war.
- newswasboring 4y agoAmerica needs a leader who can inspire people to work with each other even when they don't agree on everything. I am quite sure you can build a significant coalition around financial issues, maybe even bigger than a super majority. But somehow people are not willing to work with each other unless they pass each other's purity tests. Thus, nothing changes and the status quo wins every time.
- gorbachev 4y agoThat will never happen in our lifetime. Democrats can't do it, because Republicans will never cooperate with a Democratic Party president. Republicans can't do it, because they will continue to nominate a culture warrior whose only job is to fight wokeness, so they aren't even interested in it. This thing will keep escalating, relatively slowly, until it finally crosses the line and even the Republicans will figure out that maybe they ought to have some accountability. My guess it will take minimum of two generations.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoAs an outsider, can you help me put your post in context - is 31k banks posit as good or bad state of things? (it seems an insane state of things to me, with incredible overhead and inefficiency but again, I'm an outsider. I've lived in USA for a while in late 90s and state of banking from consumer perspective in USA seemed a decade behind Canada and Europe, but that was a long long time ago)
- stefncb 4y agoI see less banks as being strictly worse. It's the same as with any other company. Yes that's less efficient, but it's the only way to prevent individuals from having too much power. Because almost anyone with that kind of power will eventually give in. Just look at tech companies; I, for one, am not satisfied with the status quo. There are two ways to have a functioning society. One is to have very few very powerful people, and only choose the right leaders. The other is to have very many people with very little power. That's less efficient, but it's also much less risky. We currently run on the first. It's not going well. I'm not aware of a time when we ran on the second. In my mind that's the only way.
- Waterluvian 4y agoCanada has like 40 banks and strong regulation has kept them out of crises like in 2008. What’s the right number of banks per capita?
- tormeh 4y agoEasy to keep banks out of crises during good times.
- digging 4y agoThat seems a bit backward when banks can so easily be the cause of bad times.
- lowkey 4y ago> Canada has like 40 banks and strong regulation has kept them out of crises like in 2008 Canada secretly bailed out their banks to the tune of $114 billion CAD in 2008. If you compare Canada's secret bank bailout to the US equivalent on a per capita basis it looks even worse. [0] The reason we didn't hear about it at the time is that the big 5 Canadian Banks have so much power over the government and the media that they were better able to control the narrative. Concentrating power in the hands of a few banks is a bad idea. [0] https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governments-during-recession-1.1145997 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governm...
- thehappypm 4y agoI have trouble following this logic. Monopolies are obviously bad, but, 1000 banks sounds like an extremely diverse ecosystem.
- zaphod12 4y agoWhere did you get these numbers? It's wrong and presents a misleading picture of a 10x implosion in 2008. There were never even close to 31k banks in the USA. It peaked at about 14k back in the '80s and has been going down ever since. It did drop precipitously after the 2008 crises, going from around 7K banks to today around 4500 banks, but this is a very far cry from 31k to 3k. https://banks.data.fdic.gov/explore/historical?displayFields=STNAME%2CTOTAL%2CBRANCHES%2CNew_Char&selectedEndDate=2022&selectedReport=CBS&selectedStartDate=1934&selectedStates=0&sortField=YEAR&sortOrder=desc https://banks.data.fdic.gov/explore/historical?displayFields...
- alberth 4y agoYour numbers are wrong. 1974: ~14,000 banks 2008: ~7,000 banks 2023: ~4,000 banks This has been a steady decline since 1974 (not 2008) in the US. https://banks.data.fdic.gov/explore/historical?displayFields=STNAME%2CTOTAL%2CBRANCHES%2CNew_Char&selectedEndDate=2022&selectedReport=CBS&selectedStartDate=1934&selectedStates=0&sortField=YEAR&sortOrder=desc https://banks.data.fdic.gov/explore/historical?displayFields... As a comparison, Canada only has 34 banks. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banks_and_credit_unions_in_Canada#:~:text=There%20are%2034%20domestic%20banks,as%20of%20December%2031st%2C%202022.&text=Owned%20by%20Laurentian%20Bank%20of%20Canada https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banks_and_credit_uni.... EDIT: In case anyone is curious, these are the credit union numbers. 1981: ~7,000 credit unions 2010: ~7,000 credit unions 2023: ~5,000 credit unions https://ncua.gov/about/historical-timeline https://ncua.gov/about/historical-timeline
- Naga 4y agoMore importantly, there are really only five major banks in Canada - RBC, TD, Scotiabank, BMO and CIBC. National Bank is a close #6, but is really only big in Quebec. Those five are the lion's share of the banking industry, especially when you consider that they own a number of the other banks (Scotiabank owns Tangerine, for example). The other banks are niche regional banks or for specific purposes (i.e. Home Bank business is largely selling GICs and lending mortgages, without much else).
- smnrchrds 4y agoThe list only includes "bank"s, that are federally-regulated entities. The biggest provider of banking services in Quebec is Desjardins, but it doesn't appear in the list because technically it's not a bank and it is regulated provincially not federally. Also depending on how you want to count it, Desjardins is either one entity or an ensemble of 210 credit unions. Similarly, ATB gets an honourable mention, but other non-bank providers of banking services such as First Calgary Financial or Vancity (both credit unions) are not shown in the list. It's interesting that in the US, even small banking service provides are banks. But in Canada, small ones tend to be provincially regulated entities such as credit unions. It's not that small entities don't exist. They just belong to a different list.
- 015a 4y agoAll numbers approximate: - Number of banks in the US: 4,844 (69,500 people / bank) - Number of banks in the UK: 365 (184,000 people / bank) - Number of banks in Australia: 95 (272,000 people / bank) - Number of banks in Japan: 199 (628,000 people / bank) Let's cool it with the doomsday talk. Every major economy (except maybe China, but they're weird so not counting them) has 2.5x+ the number of people per bank than the US. The US is the weird one. If you want to look at this from a "return to fundamentals" perspective: the US is only a few hundred years old, and was built on some of the most virgin, rich, plentiful, resourceful land on the entire planet. That fueled 300 years of economic development the likes of which the world has never seen; and the nice thing about growth is that it really helps cover-up bets that were far too risky for any reasonable risk-taker. We're not going to see big banks take on increasingly higher risk over the next decade. In fact, we'll see the opposite. Fewer banks, more regulation, and less risk taking, as the US begins to regress more to the worldwide economic growth rate.
- lmpdev 4y agoI know there are regulatory rules which partially explain the fragmented banking sector in the US compared to other nations: four example in Australia we only really have 4-5 proper banks Are there other reasons that small banks have seemed to thrive in the United States but no where else?
- Mistletoe 4y agoSQUIRE: When America was in its earlier days, we had a - kind of a populist suspicion about big banks. SMITH: So states looked for ways to support and protect local banks. SQUIRE: A lot of states passed what were called branch banking laws, which made it illegal to operate a bank out of more than one building. It's hard to imagine it now. And so every little town in America had its own local bank. https://www.npr.org/2023/04/30/1172957377/small-banks-are-dealing-with-the-ripple-effects-of-two-prominent-failures-last-m https://www.npr.org/2023/04/30/1172957377/small-banks-are-de...
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI feel like they could bring back that law and it would not make a difference because there is not much reason to go inside a bank.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIf they did pass this law, hyper loop would definitely be built so that banks across the states could still be the same building.
- toast0 4y agoI live on an island with 25k people. And we've got 13 bank branches, and had one credit union branch (they close this branch, but their outdoor ATM remains). One branch is closing soon, because two banks merged and they don't need to keep both their branches.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoIs the idea that 'one building' means banks in other states won't open a branch in your state, and so you keep all the taxes?
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]
- DonsDiscountGas 4y agohttps://archive.ph/ctmG4 https://archive.ph/ctmG4
- passwordoops 4y agoI've said it before, I'll say it again - "too big to fail" should be recast as "too big to exist" I'm not sure what the best solution is here, but making the big banks even bigger is not it. This is just going to make the banking system more concentrated and no concentrated market is good for anyone. Least of all because the past decade+ has set the precedent that the banks will be bailed out... If they're big enough
- nonethewiser 4y ago> This is just going to make the banking system more concentrated More concentrated. More highly regulated. Closer to being absorbed by the state. I'm not saying that's necessarily going to happen someday. But that is the direction it is (and has been) moving.
- brianmcc 4y agoAlso closer to absorbing the state. I'm not a tin foil hat person, but corporations growing larger than nation states just doesn't seem remotely far fetched. Which corporation will be first to sit at the UN table?
- nonethewiser 4y agoBut who is creating the regulation? The answer to that is funny. It is literally the state, which is to my point, but it is also shaped by the banks, which is to your point.
- RestlessMind 4y ago> But who is creating the regulation? You know who writes our laws? Lobbyists. Politicians are not the ones drafting the bill. They merely take the drafts produced by lobbyists and then pass them. Do you also know who runs various government agencies tasked with regulating different sectors? Again, it is a revolving door for private sector execs. > It is literally the state True, but the state is, to a large extent, influenced by corporations.
- KWxIUElW8Xt0tD9 4y agogo read "The Creature From Jekyll Island" -- great book with lots of information about how we got where we are with American "banking"
- jmyeet 4y agoConsider these three pieces of information: 1. There is not a bank in existence in the US that could survive a bank run where 25% or more of the deposits leave. Not even JP Morgan Chase; and 2. There's a lot of evidence to suggest that the bank run on SVB was created by the direct actions of relatively few people, most notably Peter Thiel; and 3. The FDIC usually solves such bank runs by seizing the bank and selling the bank for parts. The banks all actually have more assets than depositor funds. So far at least, all depositor funds have been protected through assets and the FDIC (side note: the FDIC is funded by banks and receives no appropriations from Congress). It's expected that these asset sales are at a significant discount (eg CSFB acquiring UBS for a song although that's Switzerland not hte US obviously). So perhaps we should be asking if these bank runs are being deliberately created to profit from the collapse of smaller banks. In an ideal world, if true, people would end up in prison.
- kirbyfan64sos 4y agoThis falls apart a bit when you consider that several larger banks did try to prop up First Republic for a bit, specifically because: > the FDIC is funded by banks and receives no appropriations from Congress So banks going down can certainly cause other banks money, too. That being said, the "significant discount" is usually because, when you acquire the assets, you also acquire the bank's liabilities, and AIUI roughly speaking you're paying the difference between what you gain and what you lose in the process. More specifically, the FDIC helped fund JP Morgan's acquisition of First Republic because, if JP Morgan simply acquired the assets & liabilities directly, they would not be enough liquidity for it to be safe. I.e. acquiring a smaller bank has some advantages but also some downsides, and it also destroys trust in the system which hurts the big banks too...so it's not really something that's exclusively beneficial and definitely not worth trying to trigger intentionally.
- lvl102 4y agoPeople simply got used to not getting paid interest for their deposits. Bank business model needs to change or there will be new business models where deposits are fully guaranteed. That’s probably what the crypto people should have done but sadly they are too stupid (and greedy/scammy) to take on the traditional model.
- allie1 4y agoThere are exceptions. Ally bank has been paying reasonable yields on deposits, being a digital bank with lower operating costs. The bank model works, it’s the “too big to fail” model that is broke. The one upside of TBTF banks is you forfeit any deposit earnings to get “insurance” on the full amount.
- lvl102 4y agoWhat we need is a “boring” banking model where deposits are fully guaranteed by a bank. No lending. In digital age, that should be ridiculously easy to do.
- no_wizard 4y agohow do you propose they make money to keep the bank open? Charge for accounts? I don't think such a draconian rule is needed here. Free checking is nice. There's nothing wrong with being a low risk lender. Thats not the central problem with the banking system in the US. Its that bigger banks take riskier and riskier bets with money that they really shouldn't be, and when bad times hit they often don't have proper risk management in place to cover it, or its unpredictably catastrophic. It used to be that these activities were separated, limiting risk to the average person significantly as a result. Simply forcing that separation again would be more than enough to get some stability back into the banking system.
- 0zemp2c 4y agothis is how the Apple bank accounts can work Apple makes money selling phones, not mortgages the funds deposited can be reinvested in Apple stock as long as Apple is not loaning at interest, they could pull it off I think people are underestimating the blast radius of these accounts...imagine an entity engaged in "fair" banking (and only banking) that is too big and powerful to be undermined by JPM, BofA etc
- jliptzin 4y agoIt’s too late now, but the FDIC should just guarantee all deposits with no limit. If they did it with SVB they should do it for every other bank too moving forward. It is ridiculous to expect the average person to dig into bank balance sheets and try to determine whether their bank is managing risk properly. That would have prevented these runs, which counterintuitively means fewer FDIC payouts, not more. Then couple that with stricter rules to prevent risky gambles funded by deposits.
- senectus1 4y agowith what money will they guarantee all deposits? Governments dont have much money, they have taxes. when they can't tax their current voters they tax future voters by printing money. If you told the banks that you will protect their business regardless of what corrupt, stupid or greedy behavior's they practice... what do you think they'll do? this is so very screwed up.
- jliptzin 4y agoDid you read my last sentence? Make the law such that bank failures can only occur in situations of outright fraud/criminal behavior. Most failures occur because of bank runs or stupid/risky bets, unlimited FDIC takes care of runs and stricter rules would stop bad risk management.
- mrep 4y ago> If you told the banks that you will protect their business regardless of what corrupt, stupid or greedy behavior's they practice... what do you think they'll do? That's not what the FED is doing though. They are protecting the depositors not the business. The equity holders are getting completely wiped out and most of the employees at First Republic Bank are probably going to lose their jobs so the business is definitely getting screwed.
- CrimsonCape 4y agoBut people don't really understand the nuance between "let First Republic fail and let the FDIC step in to protect the depositors" versus "let's sell First Republic to Wells Fargo under orders of USGov to protect the depositors." Why not the former? I agree that in both of the above cases, First Republic shareholders and staffing suffer. But the latter introduces the conspiratorial angle and the unjust-ness.
- senectus1 4y agoThese banks are counting on "Too big to fail"... and the politicians will back it. To back it they will print money, which will devalue the currency and drive up inflation. this is a sick and twisted collapse of multiple economies. It has only one direction. down. its not too late to stop it, but nobody will, because the cost to those in power will be too great.
- IAmGraydon 4y ago>These banks are counting on "Too big to fail"... and the politicians will back it. To back it they will print money, which will devalue the currency and drive up inflation. Bailing out depositors isn't going to increase inflation - you're just giving people the same amount of money they already have. The big problem with it is that it prevents the natural process of wealth destruction from occurring, so it may just drag out inflation for longer.
- brodouevencode 4y agoThe only tool the fed has at the moment is the printer, so it very much will increase inflation by its very definition.
- helsinki 4y ago>Bailing out depositors isn't going to increase inflation - you're just giving people the same amount of money they already have. That’s not how it works. The original funds do not evaporate out of thin air. They transferred to the opposite side of the trades that the banks are making, meaning customers’ funds are melting into the pockets of hedge funds, etc. So, in effect, it is the opposite of what you’re stating. The money is not replaced; it is duplicated, thus causing inflation.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoI’m afraid you’re the one who doesn’t understand how it works. The banks are buying treasuries from the US Govt with customer deposits, which are then being devalued as bond yields rise. They are then being forced to liquidate those devalued bonds before maturity to cover withdrawals. There isn’t a hedge fund on the other side.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoWhat would be so bad about having bank monopolies? Think about how much profit they could make, and as a society, isn't that what's truly important.
- theK 4y ago> In a gravitational system you have to make heavy things explode with grand force. Otherwise you just end up with a big lump of matter floating in oblivion. Don't know where I read this but it changed my view of economics and capitalism.
- yalogin 4y agoHow does one decide whether 1 bank for every 77k people is a good thing or bad? What metrics go into such an evaluation? It feels to me that banks can be a bit bigger to reduce risk given the global nature of markets these days.
- kwere 4y agoROA in the banking sector average 1.21% now, a lot of smaller/scantier operation will feel the heat https://www.fdic.gov/news/press-releases/2022/pr22082.html https://www.fdic.gov/news/press-releases/2022/pr22082.html
- rqtwteye 4y agoI think this is just a continuation of a trend that has been going on for a long time. The money people (banks, private equity, VC) will play an ever larger role in the economy and industry mainly exists to serve the money people.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s funny how the laws related to fixing “too big to fail” just meant that small banks go away in practice.
- gms 4y agoThis is always the case with regulation. It cements established entities at the expense of smaller/new players.
- red_trumpet 4y agoExcept when it prevents merging companies.
- HWR_14 4y agoRemember when SVB lobbied to not be hamstrung by the "too big to fail" fixing laws because they weren't that big?
- dahwolf 4y agoSame with regulating big tech: only big tech can afford to comply.
- dehrmann 4y ago> At the end of 2022 more than 400 banks with nearly $4trn in combined assets had unrealised losses on their securities portfolios worth at least half of their core equity capital. Anything where a large amount of its assets aren't marked to market should be seen as a risk. For things like VC, this isn't such a big deal because it's the nature of the game. For banks, it leaves a lot of room for shenanigans,
- siliconc0w 4y agoThe big banks are terrible if you fall outside their algorithmic expectation. My partner and I were trying to get a mortgage and despite near perfect credit, large incomes, etc our apps were auto-denied because I never opened multiple open loan lines. Never needed them, just used CCs I immediately paid off for points as I always had a job/savings and bought cheap used cars for cash. We eventually got one but it took far too much time, effort, and spraying our personal info to providers. Once you get an algorithmic denial or even cant access your money because their garbage site isn't working and you can't even get someone on the phone who can tell you why much less fix anything, you immediately see the need for breaking these banks up.
- tester756 4y agoIs this why some people recommend to take loan for something that you have money? Like - you wanna spend 30K on a car and you have it in cash? take loan you'll lose a some $$, but you'll be building your history.
- JohnFen 4y agoI think that the usual rationale for taking a loan out to pay for something you can afford without a loan is that you can take the money you have and invest it in something that pays more than what the interest on the loan is. It's a kind of arbitrage. If you're losing money overall, you're doing it wrong.
- drivebyhooting 4y agoThere’s no free lunch. You will be taking additional risk by doing this even if the downside seems unlikely or remote.
- ericpauley 4y agoIf the loan % is lower than a savings account then there is no/0/zero risk, so long as you stay under FDIC limits. Your deposit earns money and is backed by the full faith and credit of the United States government.
- Invictus0 4y agoI'm fine with mergers in times of crisis, but in times of stability, the TBTF banks need to be broken into smaller pieces.
- rr808 4y agoI'm not convinced that USA needs the thousands of banks it does. Most countries survive with a small set of national banks. There seems to be little downside, and makes sense not to have all the duplicated overhead.
- intrasight 4y agoI agree. It's very inefficient. And as a result, it personally costs me money - in the form of higher taxes for that very inefficiency. And all banks should be subject to the same regulation. Them saying that they "can't afford it" is just further evidence that consolidation is necessary.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoit's sort of a US thing to let alternatives proliferate so they compete with one another, or are supposed to do so, rather than collude and whatever else goes on.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoI find it's difficult to keep track of. At one point I had money of one retirement color or another (traditional, Roth, HSA) being held by six different institutions in nine different accounts. Navigating the maze of who needs to send checks to whom has been a tremendous pain and I'm worried that I overlooked something in the consolidation effort.
- fredgrott 4y agoWe are still ignoring the original problem.... The original problem behind these regional bank failures is that there is not enough diversity in those having extra cash in accounts and so when a FED rate change comes along that is big enough, those excess funds seek higher rates of interest thus leaving said bank with a problem of legacy assets tied to the old FED rate. We see the same pattern with Apple getting $! Billion in new savings account, yes that is Billion with a b due to their interest rate offering. In short words a product problem with on one side products tied to the old FED rate and not being nimble enough to offer a product for the excess cash customers have that offers the higher interest rate. Or in short a virtual replay of the S&L crisis in the 1980s without all the corruption behind it. And one should note that MMA products were suppose to fix this issue.
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoWhy exactly should banks be private companies at all? Theyre just skimming middle man between the government and end consumer. Sure, the government would know your bank balance and spendings, but that could be worked around If youre in trouble with the irs or the law, the government will have all the insight they request. Sounds crazy? We the people had to bail them out and never get anything of their profits. Too big to fail? As in systemic risk? Well, only the state should be too big to fail. And if they fail, the fdic needs to cover, also tax payer funded. Any input is appreciated. I know the interest rate should be set by banks and not the politicians, but yeah, is that really it? Addendum, this post has triggered an interesting discussion, it appears I am not alone with my thoughts. So far, I do not see any ovewhelmingly convincing argument on why the banks shouldnt be run by the government. It doesnt have to be senate, it can be something relatively neutral like the irs.
- HissingMachine 4y agoGovernments are even worse than banks with money, if they were private companies every government would be bankrupt ages ago.
- imtringued 4y agoThe house hold sector wants to save net. The corporate sector wants to save net. The government wants to save net. Tell me, where is the money supposed to come from? Will you drop it with a helicopter? At some point some people have to spend off their money.
- kornhole 4y agoYes banks should be better regulated to avoid letting them make risky moves. That aside, many regional banks rather than a centralized government controlled bank is critical to our freedom. Government controlled banks or CBDC will give government total surveillance and control over us since you cannot do much without money.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago
- jadbox 4y agoPlease visit your local credit union, post haste
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- renewiltord 4y agoBefore you read any of the comments, you would be better served learning what a GSIB is and the constraints on them, the role of the FDIC, bond pricing, and what regional banks can bring to the table. GPT-4 answered quite well, but Google is a good supplement. This comment thread appears to be software engineers saying things about stuff they don't understand.
- scoobydoobydrew 4y ago[flagged]
- timcavel 4y ago[dead]
- ricardobayes 4y agoI wonder if there are any anti-trust measures controlling unlimited mergers.
- RadixDLT 4y agoof course, the same as in 2009.
- alexfromapex 4y agoJust what we need? Centralize the banks even more?
- drumhead 4y agoBanks are a terrible investment. To get above average rate of growth they have to do something risky like lending too much to people they shouldnt be lending to or playing timing games with assets and liabilites. With the bonuses to their staff exceeding returns to shareholders its seems that banks are configured for their senior staffs benefit rather than their owners.
- reso 4y agoHighly recommend the economist Richard Werner for his defense of small banks as the most productive and resilient financial institutions.
- phendrenad2 4y agoI think banks are having their buggy-whip moment. There simply isn't a huge need for banks anymore, as most transactions are digital. They mostly serve as a vault of safe-deposit boxes where people keep their important documents and a place for businesses to trade their paper scrip for digital numbers. That trade-in function could be provided directly by the federal government for probably leas than a trillion dollars, and it's only going to get cheaper in the future as people continue to move away from paper currency.