14 ms·
GM’s decision to ditch Apple CarPlay, Android Auto sparks backlash
- 1970-01-01 4y agoShort term, this is stupid. GM pulled out too quickly, and without a superior drop-in replacement. Long-term, this is smart. GM will gain complete control of the software stack, and they won't be bullied into anything. Tesla knows this. Others like Rivian know it too.
- fzzzy 4y agoWell ok, but this is why I will never buy a tesla, rivian, or gm.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Long-term, this is smart. GM will gain complete control of the software stack… CarPlay (I’m not familiar with Android Auto) doesn’t require that GM cede any control over their software stack. As Wikipedia puts it, it just “enables a car radio or head unit to be a display and a controller for an iOS device”. What GM wants is to charge you $30/month for services, since phones have mostly killed their OnStar cash cow. What they’re going to learn is the extent to which “doesn’t work with my phone” is going to be a deciding factor for vehicle purchases.
- chrisjc 4y ago> cede any control over their software stack Except, from what I understand they'll use Android Automotive (not to be confused with Android Auto).
- SoftTalker 4y ago> CarPlay ... just “enables a car radio or head unit to be a display and a controller for an iOS device”. Then why does it demand that Siri be enabled in order to complete the connection?
- MBCook 4y agoAt least in some markets (I think Japan may be one) there are laws mandating interaction via voice after a very small number of taps to prevent drivers from constantly looking at and poking at the screen.
- boringg 4y agoDid carplay a couple days, no siri requirement. Not sure what you are talking about.
- ak217 4y agoI find it incredible that GM (or Rivian, or anyone else trying this) will be able to develop something that works as well as carplay/android auto and maintain it for the life of the vehicle. Phone manufacturers are known for better software departments than car makers and they routinely fail miserably at this. Even Microsoft has failed at embedded a number of times despite knowing how to maintain software over time. It takes a lot more resources and talent than people assume. It took Tesla 15 years, a headquarters in Palo Alto, and tens of billions of dollars to get to the point where maybe they have a chance to pull it off. I don't see these competitors getting ready to invest those kinds of resources.
- autoexec 4y agoPersonally, I wont ever connect my phone to my car at all (if my next car doesn't have an aux port I'll install one myself), but I have to assume that GM is doing this because their own software siphons more data off of our devices than even carplay or andriod auto does. > "GM is looking to monetize more software and services within its vehicles and is taking a page out of Tesla’s playbook," Since they're only doing this because they want to take even more of your money after you've already spent a small fortune buying their vehicle, consumers pushing back against this is a good idea even if you don't have strong feelings about what software your car uses.
- mritun 4y agoCarPlay and AndroidAuto don’t give the car any access to the phone data and that’s the “problem” GM seems trying to “fix”. CarPlay and AndroidAuto protocols basically treat car’s display as a remote framebuffer.
- majormajor 4y agoThere's been some controversy about data collection going the other way the Android side. https://www.motortrend.com/features/13-cool-facts-about-the-2017-porsche-911/ https://www.motortrend.com/features/13-cool-facts-about-the-... > As part of the agreement an automaker would have to enter with Google, Porsche said certain pieces of data must be collected and transmitted back to Mountain View, California. Stuff like vehicle speed, throttle position, coolant and oil temp, engine revs—basically Google wants a complete OBD2 dump whenever someone activates Android Auto. > Google, for its part, disputes some of our source's assertions. Liz Markman, a Google spokesperson for Android Auto, said in a statement that Google does not collect some of the data listed by Porsche, such as throttle position and coolant temp. She declined to provide a full list of what data is collected, but emphasized that Android Auto users must opt in to share any information upon their first connection of their phone to a car. She said some of that data is used for safety (restricting typing and allowing only voice input when the car is not in "park," for example) and some is to used to optimize the app's user experience. So seems like Android Auto requires at least some data from the car, as of 2015. Porsche ended up adding it in 2022, though, so maybe they stopped fighting that battle. I'm not sure which I want less - the phone company getting data from my car, or the car company getting data from the phone.
- travisporter 4y agoRivian doublding down on this is also a bit disappointing. Not that I can afford one
- Tagbert 4y agoIt’s not clear yet if Rivian is really doing this on principle or if they are trying to get subscription fees like GM or if they just have a lot to deal with right now and don’t want to bother with it.
- hamburglar 4y agoRivian can’t even deliver on floor mats and spare tires. I’m not holding my breath for actual product improvements for quite a while.
- MrMetlHed 4y agoI haven't truly felt the need for Android Auto or Car play in mine, but then it's my first vehicle in a long time so I'm not married to either. The navigation is mostly okay and I can send locations from my phone to the screen. I can use Alexa to play music from a bunch of sources. I wish they had more internal media applications, but it's fine as a first attempt. Maps seemed to be mostly cached (other than the satellite view) as I can use them offline. Would I turn down AA/Car play? No. But it's not a need for me. And I'm not even sure how they'd scale to the giant center console and lovely dashboard display.
- jdlyga 4y agoCar infotainment systems are terrible. That's the reason why everyone wants CarPlay and Android Auto. It's kind of like going back to flip phones after using smartphones for years.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI also trust Carplay and Android Auto security since no data is sent out of the phone.
- ghostpepper 4y agoAre you sure about this? I seem to remember connecting my iPhone to a rental car and realizing that it had transferred my contact list into the car somehow.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoMy iPhone has asked me before if I want to give my contacts to a car, it’s never done it unless I said yes.
- Axien 4y agoThat is a Bluetooth feature.
- kalleboo 4y agoThat's if you connect it over old-school Bluetooth, and it shows a permission prompt asking you if you want to do it or not.
- pornel 4y agoEven if the infotainment OS was better than my phone’s OS, I’d still prefer to connect my phone. It’s because I already have all the apps and data there. I don’t want to retype addresses into the car, I want to click them in my email or calendar. And I don’t want to set up my emails in my car’s OS, especially not one that has a lucrative contract with Google.
- lockhouse 4y agoI don’t understand why they can’t have their own system and still support CarPlay. They are not mutually exclusive options.
- scarface74 4y agoAnd Android Automotive supports CarPlay.
- Tagbert 4y agoBecause GM wants to charge subscriptions for all kinds of software features and don’t want any competition. They are mainly looking at this as their maps vs the phone’s maps. They are ignoring all of the other reasons on why people choose AndroidAuto and CarPlay. That is often as much about personalization as anything else.
- SoftTalker 4y agoIt's not like it stops people from just using their phone in a standalone way, which is what I do even with CarPlay. Bluetooth and I don't get along, and I was prompted to activate Siri and all kinds of other stuff that I have disabled on my phone when I tried it. No thanks, it works fine on its own.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoSoftware features? Isn't GM primarily responsible for the OnStar network? It seems to me that what they want to do is create an android-powered internal system that requires a subscription to their cellular service to use.
- mikestew 4y agoPicking up our Hyundai Ioniq 5 this afternoon. We were seriously going to wait for a 2024 EV Chevy Blazer[0], but… [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35391283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35391283
- SkyPuncher 4y agoYou’re going to love it. We have a Palisade. Hyundai has done so much right on their recent cars. I’m sure they’ve made even better EV’s
- fullsend 4y agoMy partner just got an Ioniq and it is pretty sweet. It’s a brand I never thought twice about that seems to be killing it recently.
- pg938hkd 4y ago[dead]
- urbandw311er 4y agoI do have some sympathy for GM — as much as the public might want it, continuing down the current path is certainly ceding a fair amount of control over their customer base to two large third parties.
- scarface74 4y agoYes instead of merely supporting Android Auto, they are now fully dependent on Android Automotive. Meet the new boss…
- WorldMaker 4y agoExcept that in this case GM is still using Android Automotive the kernel (not to be confused with Android Auto, the user feature they plan to disable; thanks Google marketing for two easily confused brand names here). GM is still ceding a fair amount of control to Google and Google apps even if apparently Google is promising GM far more user data sharing. (Which leaves me somewhat wondering how much Google is paying GM to eliminate Apple CarPlay from the picture? Apple seems the only company inconvenienced here. Most of the inconvenience is born by the users of a loss of key user-facing features.)
- lotsofpulp 4y agoOr…GM can try to make quality vehicles that are reliable and can compete with Toyota and Honda.
- exabrial 4y agoThe better option is: remove infotainment completely and _require_ a smartphone for anything other than FM/AM radio. * Support an open protocol for rendering images/video/animations on the screen. Sorta like... you know, CarPlay. * Have controls for what events are allowed to be sent to the connected device. Don't want your phone to know your Throttle Position? Turn that shit off. Don't want your phone to know whether it's dark/light outside? Turn that on/off too.
- chrsstrm 4y agoSure, if you live somewhere with constant cellular connection or you're not sharing a vehicle with someone else. What really irks me is when a connected device is required to do something trivial. My dad's 2021 GMC truck recently got an OTA update that removed the built in map. I discovered this when I was driving in the country and came upon construction with closed roads. I tried to pull up the map and look for a road that would go around and I couldn't, that feature is gone. I would have had to stop, pair my phone with the head unit and then fire up CarPlay and open Google maps - none of which I wanted to do since it just wasn't necessary. Not to mention there was no guarantee after pairing that I would be able to use Maps due to shoddy coverage in the area I was in. Graceful fallbacks used to be a thing but it feels like today if you don't have a connection then everything is just dead and your SOL. The world's population doesn't all live in modern connected cities. Why is it anytime I go off-road I become a QA tester? Kind of sick of it.
- exabrial 4y agoI guess I grew up in an era where built-in sat-nav was a luxury good.
- nocsi 4y agoPretty crazy that 5 years ago, many cars went with an offline first approach to maps. You had to manually update the map database every year. I don’t even see that business model ever returning. Companies have figured out there’s way more money in running a map service. Ftr, teslas stream map tiles and if your car loses connectivity, you’re not going to see anything
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThey will either write something workable, or this endeavor will fail, and they will go back to the tried and true.
- qball 4y ago>They will either write something workable Since when has a car company ever created workable software? The screens still lag, and the in-car integration systems are so garbage that they found it worthwhile to farm them out to tech companies. And CarPlay/Android Auto aren't much better; Google employees are specifically hired based on their expertise of data structures and algorithms so they have zero excuse for the abysmal quality of the software they turn out. If this is what tens of millions in salaries buys I'm suddenly a lot less disappointed in the fact that AI can do a better job.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThey're going to have an app that requires excessive permissions and relays your driving data back to the mothership.
- Tagbert 4y agoI got my first GM vehicle when I got a Volt Gen2. It is very good and that surprised me as I had always had somewhat negative opinions about GM. I’m starting to shop around for a full EV now and had been interested in the Chevy Blazer and Equinox EVS. With this recent announcement, all that is out the window. I would have been a natural customer for GM but now I’ll be looking at Ford, Hyundai, VW, or any of several other manufacturers who will allow me to connect my phone to my car. I am more loyal to my phone than I am to my car.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoSame here. I drive a Gen2 Volt and have loved it and the engineering in it is solid, and because of that was considering going GM for my next EV. Not anymore.
- ireflect 4y agoMe too. Love my gen2 volt. And CarPlay. I don’t mind having to plug in my phone for CarPlay. It’s one of the only times I remember to charge my phone!
- brocket 4y agoI'm in the same boat but GM converted me with the Bolt instead, driving experience and build quality really surprised me. Although, this announcement has completely killed what little brand loyalty the Bolt had began to kindle.
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: GM plans to phase out Apple CarPlay in EVs, with Google's help - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35389021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35389021 - March 2023 (377 comments)
- thegeneralist 4y agoThis is truly a foolish idea. Do they not see how their customers use their car? And carplay? Will definitely hurt GM sales, big time, and probably take several years to undo the damage. The innovation and speed to launch new services on carplay dwarfs whatever GM can do on its own, even with google, given the slowness of OEM software development and testing.
- mlsu 4y agoHow does this business decision make sense? A car is a high-margin item, so the impact of even a handful of consumers choosing not to buy must be huge, right? Whereas, they would need to "monetize" (ugh) many many more units to turn back that lost profit. And as the shakeup due to EVs begins, even loyal consumers will be considering other makes. My girlfriend bought a car recently. CarPlay was not negotiable for her, very high up on the list. What are they putting in the water over there GM?
- cced 4y agoProbably a joke of _poor taste_ but my guess is lead.
- maxerickson 4y agoThey may well be more or less production limited on the EVs (not saying that they are, pointing at the possibility). If it actually works good people might not care in the medium term. Generally the problem people have with the automaker systems is that they sucked, not that they weren't CarPlay.
- vineyardmike 4y agoYea except now that CarPlay exists, my definition of “not sucks” includes working flawlessly with my iPhone. Obviously apple ensured that the only way this could succeed is through CarPlay, but that’s not my fight, it’s GMs.
- rainsford 4y ago> Generally the problem people have with the automaker systems is that they sucked, not that they weren't CarPlay. I think that's part of it, but definitely not the entire story. People have a lot of their life on their phone, so the tighter the integration between their phone and other products, the more appealing the experience with that product is. No matter how good the automaker system is, if it's not basically your phone with a different screen, it's going to feel like an awkward disconnect, especially when there are plenty of alternative cars that do offer that seamless experience.
- 4y ago
- jeremy_wiebe 4y agoI haven’t looked into this for a long time but is the aftermarket head unit market still thriving? Seems like there’ll be lots of plays for folks like Alpine to cater to all the frustrated folks whose factory unit is trash.
- macintux 4y agoInfotainment systems are increasingly inseparable from the car, with vital controls moving into them. Not sure how an aftermarket head unit can compete.
- gedy 4y agoYeah if I cared that much about this, I'd likely just mount an iPad on my dash. (Understood it's not as nice as CarPlay or the integrated car controls)
- jacobsenscott 4y agoAndroid auto and car play are both really bad user experiences. They are just better than what most car companies can build, which is a very low bar. Here's the android auto experience: Take my phone out of my pocket (not that easy when you are already sitting...), turn on bluetooth (I often have it off because it grabs my headphones etc when I don't want it to) and connecting it to usb (where'd the damn cable go? An apple using family member swapped it out for a lightning cable, and tossed the usb c cable in the back, or on the floor...) Every now and then it won't connect anyway - or the usb cable is defective (it lives on the car floor so it has a short life), or the usb slot in the car (especially a rental) is defective. A passenger might have a higher priority bluetooth device and it steals the connection. When I get to my destination I forget my phone in the car because it is in my pocket most of the time - but not if you are going to use android auto! If GM manages to do as well or better than Tesla on their infotainment system it would be a win. Unlikely for a dinosaur company like GM, but if they are using an android product there's a fighting chance.
- irq 4y agoThe majority of the problems you listed here are not possible with Wireless Apple CarPlay or Wireless Android Auto, which are the latest incarnations of the product. Adapters exist for many vehicles that don’t support the wireless versions as well. You may want to make sure you’re familiar with the latest incarnation of the two products before you blame them for issues that have been solved.
- mortenjorck 4y agoI even have only wired CarPlay and haven’t had any of the problems more than once or twice. For connection failures, I had to de-lint the Lightning port (easy to forget when you charge wirelessly) and I’ve forgotten the phone in the car when something interrupted my routine.
- leetcrew 4y agothe wireless versions bring their own tradeoffs and connection issues. transferring control from one phone to another is not a seamless experience in any vehicle I've been in. automatically connecting to my phone (and locking me out of google maps on the phone) is not desired every single time I turn on my car. I doubt GP would be satisfied with those either. wireless android auto uses a lot of battery, so typically I end up plugging my phone in anyway (although personally, I never end up forgetting the device). that said, I don't agree that it's a "really bad user experience". it meets or exceeds 95% of my expectations for an infotainment integration, and I trust google to keep it working 5-8 years down the line much more than I trust the software dev team of my car's manufacturer. the only thing that really pisses me off is how google voice assistant uses zero "common sense" when interpreting street addresses and song names. no, I don't want to navigate to a similar street name 1000 miles away. I want to navigate to my parents' house, same as the last 50 times...
- Waterluvian 4y agoDetaching the entertainment system from the car and making it just a dumb touchscreen and speakers must have really grinded the gears of auto makers. I can now upgrade my entire entertainment system, GPS, phone, etc. by replacing a phone. They’d prefer you get another car when your system is feeling old. I don’t even understand why my 2020 car had an optional GPS add-on for thousands of dollars. Android Auto / CarPlay is one of my favourite evolutions in cars. It could have gone so much worse for the consumer.
- userbinator 4y agohad an optional GPS add-on for thousands of dollars I guess it's for people who don't know better. Even a standalone GPS won't cost that much, and as a bonus, you can take it with you.
- iamerroragent 4y agoCorporate contracts. Cheaper to have everything wrapped up in one vendor sometimes than having a third party install and service gps. My guess at least. I don't really know. However unrelated to this computer vendors I've noticed charge a ton for more data and memory relative to buying from part stores. So perhaps maybe just taking suckers for a ride.
- m463 4y agoI have a standalone garminGPS and it's superior to most every nav system - but it's a pain to plug and unplug it all the time. (it's even better than tesla's nav system - you can plan your routes, avoid specific places, etc)
- muro 4y agoBuilt-in GPS has telemetry access and can be much more precise - e.g. in tunnels. 15 years ago, drove a BMW 1 series that was more precise. Today, driving a Volvo XC90, it gets confused in an underground garage and doesn't reset using GPS signal fast enough.
- 4y ago
- macintux 4y agoImagine renting a car in a few years and getting stuck without native CarPlay. I’d be upset.
- el_don_almighty 4y agoWhen the EPA rules that consumers cannot own lithium batteries because you won't handle or dispose of them properly, then car manufacturers must have infrastructure in place that remotely monitors and manages the battery assets, i.e. hazardous waste. They are all working towards the inevitable future when you sign up for personal EV transportation using a monthly subscription just like your phones... Is it me, or does this tinfoil make me look fat?
- userbinator 4y ago[flagged]
- Axien 4y agoThis is how I ended up with a Honda over a Toyota. At the time Toyota did not offer Apple Play. While I would have preferred a Toyota … that was a deal killer.
- Bud 4y ago[dead]
- yeukhon 4y agoBNW tried to make money off of carplayby a subscription model. It back fire so much within a year they folded and dropped that plan. This will repeat in GM’s move.
- jacobjjacob 4y agoGuess I’m not buying a Chevy EV after all
- kanbara 4y agoi was heavily considering getting a Bolt but with the CarPlay news instead went for a BMW /shrug
- ho_schi 4y agoRemember Nokia? They were not greedy Big IT. Instead the defined Bluetooth as standard. The Result? My iPhone can talk with me in my Audi A4 (B8,2008). And even music because refit Bluetooth. And? Because the screen is set back in the center console (luckily no touch) I can place my phone there and use it for navigation. Need for CarPlay? 0 Need for Android Auto? 0 :) Carmakers should tell Apple and Google that they should come again with a free of charge standard remote protocol. SPICE or something similar. And carmakers with repeating fees? Don’t buy.
- 8ytecoder 4y agoAny pointers to how much Apple and Google charge the carmakers? Considering a car giant made this deeply unpopular decision, I was sure it should be easy to find. But I’ve had no luck so far.
- mikestew 4y agoApple doesn’t charge, I do not know about Google. No source handy. That’s what make the decision more galling: free wasn’t good enough, we demand recurring revenue!
- growse 4y agoI'm very on-board with the phone-in-cradle-plus-bluetooth setup. That said, there is something ergonomically appealing about taking the display that the car designers put in a useful (and usable) place and projecting the phone through that. Phones in cradles / perched on bits of the dash car sometimes be a bit awkward to interact with or set up (depends on the car though).
- explaininjs 4y agoAnyone else much prefer just mounting your phone on the dash, instead of a separate carplay system? Bonus points if the mount has wireless charging. This way there’s no new UI to learn, and you never are stuck using a subpar carplay-variant UI (looking at you, Gaia)
- copperx 4y agoNope, not here. My phone has a minuscule 6.1" screen, but if you have a regular sized phone, mounting the phone might work.
- explaininjs 4y agoI’m rocking a 4.7” screen but still have no problems with size. I prefer a small screen with just the critical information right in my prime field of view versus a large screen with a bunch of junk on it that I have to turn my head to look at.
- jterrys 4y agoI'm finding myself in the odd position of desiring an older car to not put up with the bullshit. I don't need OnStar, I don't need lane assist, I don't need self driving. I don't need my fucking car to brake for me when it thinks I'm in danger. Just let me drive. Now they're trying to monetize heated seats and connecting my phone. It never ends. I don't need cars as a service. I just need a car. The joy of seeing car bro gearheads with their LS swaps get humiliated by normies in Teslas wasn't worth it. Take me back.
- bagels 4y agoDon't buy a GM, onstar has been around for decades now.
- explaininjs 4y agoYep, that's why I drive a 20 year old truck. Interestingly, I've driven 60k+ miles in this truck (and others like it) and maybe 1-2k in all other vehicles, including those with auto breaking/etc. The only times I've been in incidents where auto breaking was needed was when I had it. No clue why, perhaps something about all the features lulled me into a false sense of security where I took my eyes off the road for much longer than I would in my truck.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- helij 4y agoCar without these two is useless for me today.
- shoulderfake 4y ago[dead]
- philsnow 4y ago> The impact has not been felt yet. GM's Cusinato said reservations for the new Blazer EV have not diminished in the last few weeks and continue to grow. This statement would still be true if just one person per week makes a reservation.
- poisonborz 4y agoThe ship has sailed for car makers in terms of software. They lost the trust and what we are seeing are futile attempts. The only way they could win back control if some conglomerates would back some internally vetted Linux-like platform with industry third party/community support as a viable third alternative in addition to providing CarPlay/Android Auto. No single car maker can do this alone. I know it's unrealistic to expect this but there is no other option. I wish at least Android Automotive would be developed with an AOSP-like model.
- bborud 4y agoIdeally, my car would look like a BT speaker, possibly with a microphone and some controls, to the phone. I don't want a dedicated satnav, I don't want an elaborate in-car entertainment system. The reason is twofold. The first is that all of these in-car systems are pretty dated even after a couple of years. The second is that they tend to be fairly low quality to begin with. The system in my car that integrates with the phone is a piece of junk. Not only is the microphone system completely useless and the connection procedure so badly implemented it'll fail regularly, but I've recently learned that the system in my car tends to break after a few years. Which has happened in my car. Which makes one of the car's ECUs confused so my dashboard now has a flashing indicator that isn't going to go away until I've spent a pile of cash to either replace the system or rip it out in a manner that isn't documented or supported. The only thing I want in a car is the simplest for of integration possible, preferably using components I can rip out and replace with something better and a system for mounting my phone without having to buy all manner of silly dodads.
- riffraff 4y agoThis is basically what I have in my 7yo Kia, and I'm definitely happy with it, and hope the same setup will still be available in my next car. Also, physical buttons!
- bombcar 4y agoAll I've ever wanted is a head unit I can dock my phone into, either as a faceplate or just like it was a cassette, so it plays music and stays charged.
- JoBrad 4y agoI do think that navigation which takes into account your car’s battery is a good feature. But ideally there would be a way to expose that to your navigation app.
- avereveard 4y agobut you can easily do that with a dedicated navigation app on your phone, which will have more current recharge points, and will also allow you to bring your favorites easily to one car to another (or each driver can has it's own)
- AniseAbyss 4y ago[dead]
- osigurdson 4y agoI believe on my 7-8 year old vehicle, the fancy NAV system with larger touch screen was a $700 option. It is, of course, almost completely useless. I don't want to go through its hokey menu system to enter an address or attempt to use its horrendous voice assistant. Even when new I probably only used this once or twice since the iPhone ~4 was so much better at the time. A UI that is an extension of the phone makes the most sense. PS I have two data points. My wife's car is slightly newer and a different brand but equally horrendous in different ways.
- comandillos 4y agoThere is a problem with using CarPlay on an EV, and that is battery preheating. In a Tesla, Rivian, Mercedes, etc. EV, if you plan your route using the built-in satnav, the car will preheat the battery for charging which is extremely important when you are on a road trip. Unless CarPlay includes a new interface for these kind of things, I would not be able to consider using CarPlay on a EV I am afraid.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoyou can’t plan your trip in the built in stanav then switch?
- comandillos 4y agoDepending on the car the route on the integrated one gets replaced! I remember this from my days with a Hyundai IONIQ.
- HPsquared 4y agoPlanned obsolescence
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI've gotten used to CarPlay, in my cheap-ass Subie (I can certainly afford better, but why?). No way that I'll buy another car without it.
- dboreham 4y agoOh wow. Obviously this was a dumb idea when announced (I think I posted "No they're not" here) but until reading this I had no idea Tesla did not support phones and that had been GMs inspiration.
- throwawayapples 4y agoI guess I'm a Luddite. I drive old (but still nice!) cars for security reasons, and they typically have only basic radios+bluetooth (or I add bluetooth or Avantree Roadtrip) and lighter plug chargers, so I can run audio through the car speakers. I don't care that much about nav except when I'm traveling, and then a Garmin GPS stuck on the dash works out pretty well.
- cwales95 4y agoMany car manufacturers actually want you to pay for apple CarPlay / android auto now via a subscription. I won't be buying cars that ditch CarPlay or require a subscription for it. I'd sooner buy a dumb car and fit the necessary components for CarPlay myself. As noted in other comments, the standard infotainment systems in cars are so poor. Why would I opt for them in place of CarPlay / Android Auto? This is just greed. Plain and simple.
- joezydeco 4y agoI'm a little confused by all of the uproar here. From what I read, it's this: "GM said it will gradually shift to built-in infotainment systems that use Google's Android Automotive platform." I'm driving a new Volvo that has exactly this, and it allows CarPlay. In fact, the next software update looks like it will support CarPlay2. https://www.xc40forum.com/threads/carplay-access-to-driver%E2%80%99s-display-in-2-8.6237/#post-67683 https://www.xc40forum.com/threads/carplay-access-to-driver%E...
- nashashmi 4y agoAn example of a well thought-out dashboard is the Mercedes dashboard [1]. One screen spans the entire view of the driver replacing the speedometer, etc. Another screen spans the middle dashboard replacing the radio. The screens are not iPad like proportions that jut out. In fact, it is designed to seem like it is just one screen spanning from left to right. And it is well-proportioned. I mentioned this before in an a previous post in April[2]. Car Dashboard designers are not good at software innovation. But they are good at positioning buttons into the right places. or move stuff around here and there. It's what they do. Like moving radio controls onto the steering wheel. In the case of Mercedes, they move the maps feature right into the driver's view. And they offer it in different formats, like text view, Augmented reality camera view, or map view. The same goes for radio content. Hate to say it, but the flexibility the Mercedes dashboard offers makes it a more superior option compared to the built-in CarPlay and Android Auto that is also. I rarely use this superior option (or whenever I don't feel like connecting my phone by wire) because I am satisfied with CarPlay, and less satisfied with Android Auto (it crashes satellite view map). Dashboard designers want more of the OS apps to be configurable and stretchable across the interface they install. [1] http://canadianautoreview.ca/images/car_photos/2017-mercedes-benz-e300-4matic/normal/mercedes-benz-e300-dashboard.jpg http://canadianautoreview.ca/images/car_photos/2017-mercedes... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35391235 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35391235
- sitkack 4y agoThis is indicative of a larger malaise in American capitalism where MBAs have infiltrated all levels of organizations and burn an asset to "optimize" some internal business metric. It really isn't whether CarPlay or Android is better. The fact that it is a choice that the auto manufacturer would make at all and b) it wouldn't listen to their customer base. If I was on the GM board or a major shareholder, I would have huge questions about leadership.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoInvestors demand MRR. Period. Get over it and get used to it. Everyone on here works for or owns or manages or is planning a startup that wants MRR. Don't like it, walk out. Let investors know enough is enough.
- gigatexal 4y agoI want my next car (probably an EV) to be just the best physical thing it can be and as much of the interface to be CarPlay powered like they showed in a WWDC before where even the speedometer was powered and rendered by Apple.