24 ms·
An explainer post [1] connected to that Tweet is something I found extremely informative (assuming it's accurate): "- In 2021 SVB saw a mass influx in deposits
by somenameforme 4y ago
An explainer post [1] connected to that Tweet is something I found extremely informative (assuming it's accurate):
"- In 2021 SVB saw a mass influx in deposits, which jumped from $61.76bn at the end of 2019 to $189.20bn at the end of 2021.
- As deposits grew, SVB could not grow their loan book fast enough to generate the yield they wanted to see on this capital. As a result, they purchased a large amount (over $80bn!) in mortgage backed securities (MBS) with these deposits for their hold-to-maturity (HTM) portfolio.
- 97% of these MBS were 10+ year duration, with a weighted average yield of 1.56%.
- The issue is that as the Fed raised interest rates in 2022 and continued to do so through 2023, the value of SVB’s MBS plummeted. This is because investors can now purchase long-duration "risk-free" bonds from the Fed at a 2.5x higher yield.
- This is not a liquidity issue as long as SVB maintains their deposits, since these securities will pay out more than they cost eventually.
- However, yesterday afternoon, SVB announced that they had sold $21bn of their Available For Sale (AFS) securities at a $1.8bn loss, and were raising another $2.25bn in equity and debt. This came as a surprise to investors, who were under the impression that SVB had enough liquidity to avoid selling their AFS portfolio."
[1] - https://twitter.com/jamiequint/status/1633956163565002752 https://twitter.com/jamiequint/status/1633956163565002752
- BlandDuck 4y ago"This is not a liquidity issue as long as SVB maintains their deposits, since these securities will pay out more than they cost eventually." But that's exactly the problem. With higher interest rates, those deposits will be looking for a higher deposit rate. With their assets tied up in low-paying long-term bonds, SVB will not be able to pay that higher rate. It would only work out "eventually", if the depositors would accept a below-market rate until the bonds matured. EDIT: This is indeed a solvency issue, not a liquidity issue, as also pointed out below.
- lkbm 4y agoHe meant solvency issue. Someone else called this out downthread and he confirmed. Definitely felt like it should've been corrected more prominently, though.
- zzleeper 4y agoAnd yet he is wrong! They were stuck with assets earning <2% for 10+ years, meanwhile depositors were demanding higher returns (else they would put their money in other banks, in 6m tbills, 10yr treasuries, etc.. all of which paid a lot more). And thus, "it's not a solvency issue as long as depositors are stupid and don't realize they can get more $$$ from other banks" ends up being quite misleading
- jamiequint 4y agoYes, I mis-spoke. If only there was some way to edit tweets or to pin your replies to the top of a thread :P
- lkbm 4y agoIf you reply directly to your initial tweet with your correction (perhaps QTing the person who asked), I think it will appear at the top, or at least get higher ranking. I often see replies "boosted" via the original author QTing them as a reply this way.
- benlivengood 4y agoSo they didn't require the deposits earning 2% to be in term CDs like sane banks and credit unions do?
- danpalmer 4y agoIt's never a liquidity issue as long as no one tests the liquidity!
- blantonl 4y ago“Eventually” The markets can stay irrational longer than you can remain solvent.
- pishpash 4y agoAll liquidity issues are solvency issues when marked to market.
- actionablefiber 4y agoThat's true in a tautological way, but there really is a difference between liquidity and solvency. If a firm's assets will eventually mature and be worth more than the current liabilities, then a private rescuer can make a lot of money by bailing them out. If the assets will never recover or pay out, then someone will be holding the bag.
- kgwgk 4y agoBut it's important that they are eventually worth more. Enough to provide the rescuer with a substantial gain that compensates them for their troubles. Solvency in a "breakeven" sense is not enough.
- pishpash 4y agoWe've just seen there is no difference with SVB, because they tried to get a private rescuer to bail them out. Didn't work. Because why would a private rescuer lose liquidity to a lower paying assets (SVB's book) when they could lose liquidity to a higher paying one on the market (e.g. Treasury bonds)? Mark to market is real. If you need liquidity immediately from the market, whether through a rescuer or otherwise, you do your accounting using that value and in SVB's case they were insolvent.
- actionablefiber 4y agoI think that is a difficult call to make this early on. The FDIC's job here is to recover value for depositors and find buyers for its assets. It is hard to organize bank takeovers on short notice, and even in a private rescue there is a lot of regulatory involvement. The story isn't even close to over yet. There are some possibilities. Perhaps there was no single buyer that also had the (potentially hundreds of billions of dollars of) liquidity you would need to rescue the bank. Perhaps there were buyers who could come up with that liquidity reasonably quickly (on the order of a week or a month) but certainly not in the 48 hours it took for the bank to be completely vaporized. SVB was intending on raising liquidity from the market, and just the act of announcing their intent to do so triggered the bank run in the first place.
- davidw 4y ago> 10+ year duration, with a weighted average yield of 1.56%. > the value of SVB’s MBS plummeted. How much 'plummeting' did they do in numerical terms? Something with those kinds of yields doesn't sound like it ought to be a super risky asset. The mortgage lending market tightened up a lot after the great recession...right?
- Someone1234 4y agoThat has to be an inflation adjusted yield, right? Why would anyone do anything remotely risky for such terrible returns? You can almost find government bonds with similar average yields.
- Macha 4y agoWeren't the rates on government bonds negative if you were a large investor like a bank?
- zzleeper 4y agoNope! I got a 2.0% mortgage in 2021 (no points or anything) and the bank then turned around and sold it to Freddie who paid them 1.7% (so the bank made a nice 0.3% just for originating the loan). Then Freddie packed my loan and sold it to others for something likely to be below 1.7%...
- dahfizz 4y ago>You can almost find government bonds with similar average yields. Not a few years ago. T-Bills were paying like 0.1% in 2021[1] [1] https://home.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/TextView?type=daily_treasury_bill_rates&field_tdr_date_value=2021 https://home.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/...
- kgwgk 4y agoAnd 10-year bonds were well below 1%. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DGS10 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DGS10
- 4y ago
- JumpinJack_Cash 4y ago> > 97% of these MBS were 10+ year duration, with a weighted average yield of 1.56%. But why didn't they just hold money at the Fed given that they are a bank and they can? It's literally splitting hairs between what the Fed Fund Rate is and what they got on their MBS. Explainer post says end of 2021 they made that trade, in March the Fed raised the Fed Fund Rate to 0.20%, and by April it was 0.77%. Had they waited just 5 months they'd have got a better Risk adjusted return by just keeping the money at the Fed
- jwozn 4y agoYeah, but banks don't profit by holding money for months.
- gerad 4y agoIf they could have forecasted the future at that point, they could have made even more money than that!
- BobbyJo 4y agoIf you could forecast even 6 hours into the future, you'd be the richest man alive in weeks. Nevermind months.
- zenlikethat 4y agoBecause people can’t see the future and you’re talking do we forgo $1b a year or not in that spread. It wasn’t the MBS that got them into trouble, they were supposed to hold those to maturity. It was something else they did that led to that forced liquidation
- duxup 4y agoI have some family who (with some other partners) founded a small community bank that has grown over the years. They expanded in some areas by buying other small community banks, specifically in areas where there was a big increase in income in the local area (from mineral rights, etc). The smaller banks that they bought were in a situation where suddenly they had large amounts of cash incoming, and customers who were paying off / not taking out loans like they used to. They didn’t have the reach (mostly confined to a small rural region) to use that cash to give out loans elsewhere so they looked to merge or be bought by someone who did. Until I heard about those banks I hadn’t considered “too much money” was a problem.
- kccqzy 4y agoActually if you think about the balance sheet for banks "too much money" is a problem for them because deposits are liabilities not assets. The money belongs to customers not the bank. The bank must pay back the customers on demand. That said, I think historically many banks can easily avoid the "too much money" problem by setting the interest they pay on deposits to be low, and maybe even negative.
- duxup 4y agoAgreed. Also too much money is hardly an automatic existential crisis. They can do what I described, get bought, merge, etc. Of course if you dump it all into unwise investments, that’s a problem.
- joosters 4y agoAt first glance, bank balance sheets are unintuitive and feel 'the wrong way round'. When someone deposits $1m at a bank, the bank doesn't have $1m more assets, it has $1m more liabilities. (Yes, this is a gross over-simplification)
- missedthecue 4y agoAnd to make matters more confusing, deposits are called assets on the balance sheet!
- andromeduck 4y agoWhy even chase 1.5%.
- postalrat 4y agoIf you could make 1.5% off other people's money how much would you "invest"?
- pirate787 4y agoOn $80B that's $120 million a year
- snewman 4y ago1.5% of $80B is actually $1.2B
- berkeleyjunk 4y agoThey got too much in deposits very quickly and could not originate loans at the same speed. If they kept the money uninvested their operating costs would have eaten up their principal (even if they had to pay 0% in interest to their customers)
- chii 4y agobut operating costs don't rise linearly with deposits (i imagine it rises sub-linearly, at most), esp. if they can choose to pay 0% interest for deposits. It really is just a matter of money making. They didn't want to accept the low yield, but certain safety, and accepted a higher yield, but with risk. It caught up to them.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago1% of 100 billion dollars is a billion dollars. They would rather have 1.5 billion than .5 billion.
- itissid 4y agoNoob Questions: How do banks typically diversify their investments so that this kind of thing does not happen? Also don't they have to have some kind of liquidity cushion? Can't they just cover their short term costs by borrowing(I thought there is an overnight facility for lending between banks to borrow at low rates)
- LanceH 4y agoWith only a look at the summary numbers above, it looks like they tied up 40% or so to 10+ years. I don't know what the right percentage should be, if that much is going to be tied up in hold-to-maturity, you would expect it on a rolling basis which reflects the long term liquidity of your deposits. On its face, such a purchase would only be done assuming rates and markets will remain the same. I wish I could say that accusing a bank of making such a naive purchase means that interpretation is wrong, but these banks keep doing things like this since it's always worked out before. I'm sure it's much more complicated, but sometimes that's because it should have been a lot less complicated.
- EMM_386 4y agoI don't understand why you would lock up that much money for 10 years at 1.5% interest. Did they expect interest rates to stay at 0 for 10 years? That is illogical.
- rvnx 4y agoEspecially illogical, considering it's not their own money that they locked, but customers funds (that they owe to the customer in the short-term).
- abm53 4y agoIf that was the market clearing price, then to the extent that rate expectations set the bond price (which of course is debatable) this would have been the consensus view at the time.
- 4y ago
- rsync 4y ago"97% of these MBS were 10+ year duration, with a weighted average yield of 1.56%." I'd like to learn more about the dramatic drop in MBS - elsewhere, downthread, it is asserted that they have dropped 30-50% ? I understand the inverse relationship between bond price and yield ... ... but I am surprised that an asset yielding ~1.5% drops 30% in value when treasuries of similar duration rise to 3-4%. Are there other factors at play with MBS in early 2023 - such as increased delinquencies - that are putting downward pressure on their price ?
- boosting6889 4y agoThere’s a misconception that bonds are safe investments. They are not. You’re just trading one kind of risk for another. You can do the math, compare 4% and 1.5% compounding for 10 years and that’s why no one wants the bonds yielding 1.5%. Dumping 90%+ of your liquid funds into a single thing other than cash is completely insane especially when it’s not yours.
- snuxoll 4y agoTreasury bonds are "safe" in the sense that you will (because the US Government will not default on her debt) get your money back. The caveat is you will get your money back at maturity; if you need it before then, well, market value adjusts based on current yields. If you're investing in bonds without building a ladder you're honestly doing it wrong. With the past 15 years of easy money and low yields it might have seemed pointless given rates barely moved, but completely giving up on any ability to capitalize on higher yields if rates move up is just poor investing :/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 4y agoBond ladders are the CPU pipelines of finance ;)
- SmartJerry 4y ago
- walrus01 4y ago> As a result, they purchased a large amount (over $80bn!) in mortgage backed securities (MBS) Do we now have people making decisions on stuff like this who are too young or clueless to remember what happened with the 2004-2007 mortgage backed security bubble that popped in the 2008-2009 financial crisis? Seriously? Did nobody learn the lessons on this? Countrywide and other originators of MBS and CDOs?
- SilasX 4y agoThe error wasn’t that the mortgages defaulted too much (like in the ‘08 crisis) but that interest rates went up, which is a distinct problem, and, from the comments in these discussions, not something that the capital requirements adequately capture.
- alexlesuper 4y agoThe problem is with MBS but not for the same reason.
- mason55 4y ago> Did nobody learn the lessons on this? I'm not sure you learned the lessons. Other than MBS being coincidentally involved, this has literally nothing to do with 2008.
- dahfizz 4y agoDo you think MBS are always and forever a bad investment because of a bubble 15 years ago? The MBS wasn't even the problem here. If they had 10Y corporate bonds or Treasury notes paying the same rate, they would have had the same problem.
- walrus01 4y agoTo be clear, I think MBS are morally wrong in how they're implemented in the market, yes. A bubble 15 years ago? We're in a massive housing price increase bubble now. Buying $80bn of MBS in the middle of a well-known housing price bubble is catastrophically stupid.
- 4y ago
- voisin 4y ago> - 97% of these MBS were 10+ year duration, with a weighted average yield of 1.56%. This is a pretty insane bet. Why didn’t they ladder the maturities to have a lower average duration and less risk?
- makestuff 4y agoMy pessimistic view is that bonuses were paid out on invested cash not on cash just sitting there. So they had to buy something to get a fat bonus.
- voisin 4y agoShocking portfolio design isn’t regulated given how much of banking is regulated.
- rvnx 4y agoAs a bank, parking the money into long maturity bonds, especially when it's not your money, and your customer can take the money back anytime, and the current rates are 0% (so can go upward only...). Sounds like an insane investment decision.
- baremetal 4y ago[flagged]
- athammer 4y agoWhat does ESG have to do with this? Seems like your politically motivated to see the world through one lens.
- kimbernator 4y agoHow is that relevant at all?
- baremetal 4y ago
- DiscourseFan 4y agoI don't get it. I'm no expert in finance but even I knew the fed wasn't going to stop raising interest rates because I had the common sense to know the fed would fail to trigger a recession by doing so.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- riazrizvi 4y agoWhen I set my ‘Hindsight Goggles’ to 100, I too saw that the Fed would keep raising interest after the initial rounds, because unemployment would stay low despite massive layoffs, somehow, and that prices would keep rising. And I am an expert in finance.
- synu 4y agoI, too, am a genius in hindsight. It's great to be in such rare company.
- DiscourseFan 4y agoThere still a war on, inflation wouldn'tve gone down until that ended. And you have to take the temperature of things in your daily life, its like Keynes said, people are driven by the "animal spirit", the market doesn't always (or ever) make sense, you have to get a feel for it and use specific data to support that feeling, not the other way around. Jesus am I the only one taking out more lines of credit with the expectation of an extended period of inflation? If everyone else is doing that (which they should be), the money supply will continue ballooning, the economy will stay strong and unemployment low.
- boosting6889 4y ago[flagged]
- KptMarchewa 4y agoBecause, as described in the link, the gap between deposits and liabilities is likely to be over 25B.
- FireBeyond 4y agoBecause most of the potential investors are sophisticated enough to realize they wouldn't be 'investing' as plugging holes in what would be rapidly turning into a Ponzi scheme.
- 323 4y agoI had the vague impression that after the 2007 crisis, banks holding retail deposit accounts were not allowed to invest in stuff like MBS, only investment banks (without retail accounts) were.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I had the vague impression that after the 2007 crisis, banks holding retail deposit accounts were not allowed to invest in stuff like MBS, only investment banks (without retail accounts) were. You are confusing the Great Recession with the Great Depression. The 2007 crisis and subsequent Great Recession was contributed to by the 1999 repeal of that rule, adopted in response to the Great Depression; there were several efforts to restore it after the Great Recession, but none succeeded.
- incompatible 4y agoThe Glass–Steagall rules? I think the financial crisis ended in 2009, when at the time there was fear that Citibank would be the next to collapse. A rule change was made to allow banks to value "hold to maturity" assets at the purchase price instead of the current market value, so that they could avoid an insolvent balance sheet. The problem for Silicon Valley Bank was apparently that they needed to sell some of the assets and take the loss. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legisla...
- ohgodplsno 4y agoInvesting in the exact same kind of unsafe assets that brought the 2007 crisis, as well as assets that cause house prices to stay unaffordably high. Yep, all of SV is truly made of bumbling idiots. That whole solution is truly hilarious and watching all these clowns lose their money is going to be fun.
- berkeleyjunk 4y agoActually not. The kind of asset they invested in does not really matter. If they invested in super safe government bonds at <1% at the same time, they would have had the exact same issue. It is the rapidly rising interest rates that did them in. If they were smarter they could have done a rolling ladder of short maturities but probably someone there was lazy.
- dahdum 4y agoThey could have stopped offering the very high savings yields that attracted that capital, but profits and exec comp would have dipped. So...this instead.
- darkerside 4y agoThat would have resulted in just as much of a flight, to higher yield instead of safety.
- CydeWeys 4y agoNo it wouldn't have. The company would still be solvent and have a large number of total deposits, just less in total than they could've had otherwise. What they did literally destroyed the entire company; not doing so would not have had that result. The outcomes are not comparable.
- darkerside 4y agoWhat? Anybody with financial sense has noticed that rates have skyrocketed, and if you're still earning less than 1%, you're throwing money away. The more money you have, the bigger a deal that is.
- dang 4y ago(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35097120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35097120, which contains "that tweet".)
- mcenedella 4y agoGreat moderating dang! Appreciate your tireless work to make hackernews great.
- tempsy 4y agohonestly disgusted by the blatant PR moves by YC and Founders Fund yesterday in leaking their “advice” to their founders to get out of SVB Very blatant weaponization of FUD to drum up deposits for their investments in Brex, Ramp, and Mercury.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zdbrandon 4y agoAs someone who was considering using one of those "banks" in the coming months, this whole ordeal makes me want to stick with Chase, Wells Fargo, etc. Stripe integrations be damned.
- hef19898 4y agoIf you are outside of B2B, you do not need Stripe. You need a solid business bank, ideally multiple ones. And if B2B is relevant, well, have an accoubt, or multiple, at a bank with Stripe integration to handle customer payments anf refunds. And keep everything else at different banks.
- hef19898 4y agoOr just some, as it turned out, valid business advice. That being said, I would never let my investors choose my banks (as in more than one bank) holding my company's cash. And I definetly wouldn't use some not-to-big-to-fail, not international bank to hold my multi-millions in VC money, which is the only yhing keeping my company a float.
- tempsy 4y agoGiving the advice is not what I’m referring to. I’m referring to intentionally leaking the advice to the press so they run the story about how Peter Thiel is warning everyone which accelerated the outflow.
- 4y ago
- weego 4y agoWhen the fuck are retail banks going to be ring-fenced away from being able to trade in MBS. They're consistently cancerous to our banking systems.
- zomglings 4y agoI do not think this is a problem of mortgage-backed securities. The problem is that SVB tied up their liquidity for 10 years at a yield far lower than they would get with more secure investments after the FED's rate hikes. The specific assets they invested into are immaterial.
- snuxoll 4y agoAye, the mistake was the duration, not the instrument. I hope nobody would take 60% of their brokerage account and invest it in a 10 year bond either, ladders exist not just to manage liquidity but also to limit the duration you have to suffer low yields with.
- mannerheim 4y agoYep. Let's not forget this same thing pretty much happened last year in the UK - pension funds got margin called because they borrowed money to buy gilts (UK gov bonds). Low interest bonds, money tied up, messed them up when interest rates rose.
- tertius 4y agoThis isn't an MBS problem. It's just a poorly performing asset problem.
- walrus01 4y agoThis is a symptom of the problem of middle class single family home residential real estate being treated as an unreasonably-price-increasing bubble inflated investment and not a place for people to live in. The irrational exuberance in price increases in this segment of the market over the past 4-5 years is not sustainable. It is not logical, sane or normal for houses that were valued at $150k five years ago to now be valued at $400k in some suburbs and metro areas.
- lapcat 4y ago> An explainer post [1] connected to that Tweet is something I found extremely informative (assuming it's accurate): [1] - https://twitter.com/jamiequint/status/1633956163565002752 https://twitter.com/jamiequint/status/1633956163565002752 That tweet is unattributed verbatim from https://www.livemint.com/news/world/explainer-silicon-valley-bank-crisis-what-led-to-stock-crash-what-lies-ahead-11678419807090.html https://www.livemint.com/news/world/explainer-silicon-valley... [EDIT:] See the thread, it seems that the story may have stolen from the tweet! Pretty shocking for one of India's biggest business publications (and with 2 million Twitter followers).
- rvnx 4y agoHe is correct, but he is blaming the FED raising interest rates. The responsible is not the FED, but the negligent management of SVB that purchased such products because of greediness. When interest rates raise, previously issued bonds lose in value because there are more attractive ones available. It's like if they missed the Chapter 1 lesson about investing into bonds.
- baremetal 4y agoIf you inspect the values of SVB here: https://www.svb.com/about-us/living-our-values https://www.svb.com/about-us/living-our-values You can see that managing money responsibly is not one of their values.
- generj 4y agoSo because they have one webpage giving lip service to diversity and the environment, they automatically don’t value their core competency? I’ve seen a few conservative tweets trying to tie DEI and ESG into SVB’s collapse in a weird attempt to tie it to a cultural war. It just doesn’t make any sense. DEI and ESG are side shows for just about any company and probably pay for themselves as marketing and employee retention for a Silicon Valley focused bank. The values “We keep learning and improving”, “We take responsibility”, and “We speak and act with integrity” would all play into managing money responsibly.
- jamiequint 4y agoI hope it's accurate. What I should have said though is "This is not a *solvency* issue as long as SVB maintains their deposits", it's obviously a liquidity issue.
- kypro 4y ago> - The issue is that as the Fed raised interest rates in 2022 and continued to do so through 2023, the value of SVB’s MBS plummeted. This is because investors can now purchase long-duration "risk-free" bonds from the Fed at a 2.5x higher yield. Let's be clear, the issue wasn't that the Fed raised rates to a historically average level, it was that they were manipulating the bond market in 2021 with trillions of dollars of QE. Over the last few years the Fed has basically done a pump and dump on the bond market, and SVB being a bank was basically forced by regulation to buy long-dated bonds for yield. I've seen a lot of people speak critically of SVB and I get it, but I think people should take a minute to ask why the hell bonds were yielding such a low amount in 2021. I just wonder how much longer we're going to blame, banks, crypto investors, bond investors, equity investors, home buyers, etc for what's happening to the value of their assets. When central bankers make government bonds trade like meme stocks this is what happens. Perhaps if we didn't do that, SVB and many others wouldn't be in this position.
- highwaylights 4y agoNah, the bank is responsible for their decisions. They bought $80b of fixed-rate bonds at historically and artificially low interest rates in a time of massive QE. Even based on the information available at the time, this is not a surprising outcome at all.
- abfan1127 4y agothat doesn't excuse the Fed's behaviors.
- nerdponx 4y agoTwo wrongs don't make a right!
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIt's easy to criticize the fed, but they did a pretty good job during COVID and they did a pretty good job during 2008. The charge of "manipulating bond markets" is pretty absurd - their mandate is to influence inflation and employment via interest rates. Of course it has an impact on bond markets.
- rqtwteye 4y ago"to generate the yield they wanted to see on this capital." Sticking to unrealistic goals seems to to be the downfall of a lot of financial institutions (and probably a lot of other companies). Same happened with Deutsche Bank in the 2000s. The CEO declared that they wanted to achieve higher ROI and to achieve this they had to start doing ever riskier stuff until it blew up in their faces (and the taxpayer generously bailed them out so they could keep their big bonuses).
- ahmedbaracat 4y agoExactly that. I am wondering why the “pressure” to generate more yield or any yield at all. It is counterintuitive to me to view the startups deposits as investments and not as saved money to be used later, hence no need for a risky or any yield (even if part of the savings will be washed by inflation year over year)
- rqtwteye 4y agoIt's not clear under what conditions the startups gave money to SVB. It could be they just put into a checking account and SVB then invested it in a risky manner.
- nemo44x 4y agoWhy would a bank take your money and go to the trouble of managing it if they didn’t plan on using it for something? The purpose of a bank is to lend money. They need deposits to do that. In this case you’re sort of right in that they found have hedged a bit more by diversifying into more shorter term assets. Hindsight and all.
- rqtwteye 4y agoI think there is a little more to it. I don’t know about SVB but Deutsche Bank had a solid business doing pretty unexciting banking. Then the CEO got a big ego and pushed for larger returns which made them do more risky stuff and eventually fail. So it’s basically a big ego or just plain greed
- Eumenes 4y agoThe team making these poor choices at SVB should be criminally charged ... The tax payer shouldn't have to bail out banks.
- paulddraper 4y ago> should be criminally charged For what crime? If someone unintentionally but ineptly writes code that crashes Amazon on Black Friday, did they commit a crime?
- chippiewill 4y agoIt's possible to be criminally negligent. If you took unnecessary risks then it can carry a criminal element.
- zenlikethat 4y agoMBS are literally one of the safest looking bets imaginable, most likely Silvergate blasted a huge hole in their books and set off a cascade of trouble
- HDThoreaun 4y agoLong term fixed income at near 0 percent interest when you might have to give the money you used to buy it back is very risky, as we see here.
- paulddraper 4y agoWhat's a safer investment?
- berkle4455 4y agoAnother bank will acquire the company and make depositors whole. Government won't actually do the bailout, just facilitate/force it.
- bluetwo 4y agoThere are some big parts to this story we don't know. Yes, they sold the treasuries and took a bath. But if that was their best option, it speaks very poorly to the other "assets" they held on their balance sheet. We may find out in the coming days that they had a big position in Silvergate, which went bankrupt yesterday, and they had to mark their position to zero, creating the need for liquidity.
- PhaedrusV 4y agoI heard elsewhere they were extending loans to startups with pre-IPO shares as collateral, so yeah, that was their best option apparently.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoSomething like 60% of their assets were these bonds in December. They very well may have seen the other 40% withdrawn already by startups that can't raise anymore leaving them with this pile of 10 year 1.5% bonds.
- resource0x 4y agoAckman panics, appeals for a bailout https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/billionaire-investor-bill-ackman-calls-on-the-us-government-to-consider-a-bailout-of-silicon-valley-bank-if-private-investors-wont-step-up/ar-AA18sgt0 https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/billionaire-investor-b...
- abhiminator 4y agoBailout? Sounds like an '08 déjà vu again. It's crazy to realize how brazen Wall Street bankers and Hedge Fund managers are when it comes to asking for taxpayer dollars during distress, while decrying any attempt to add to that taxpayer dollar pool from their billions in earnings when the times are good.
- notShabu 4y agoOne of the differences between a central bank and regular bank is that the regular banks should do the riskier stuff and offer the higher interest rates. This in theory creates a diverse non-correlated system of capital deployment with the best projects winning over the bad ones. However when the central bank offers interest rates that a private bank cannot match even when it's deploying into safe and endorsed assets like MBS then some weird stuff happens... The Fed can promise risk-free returns at whatever rate they want but once it exceeds the private banks', then the banks no longer serve any purpose. If there were a way for individuals to hold accounts directly w/ the Fed, they'd all do that. Money will be sucked away from banks that deploy capital in the private sector and squeeze into ones that just passthrough to the Fed's like money market funds. With high enough interest rates, the Fed can end up sucking up liquidity even from good and safe projects and cause widespread asset collapse b/c the entities that are supposed to be doing price discovery can't compete anymore.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AviationAtom 4y agoRelevant Bits About Money article on FDIC and bank failure: https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/deposit-insurance/ https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/deposit-insurance/ I should add: apart from 2008, bank failure has historically been quite rare
- bjornsing 4y ago> - This is not a liquidity issue as long as SVB maintains their deposits, since these securities will pay out more than they cost eventually. You mean it's not a solvency issue? It sounds like a textbook liquidity issue.
- the88doctor 4y agoEven if SVB maintains their deposits, that IS a liquidity issue, it just isn't a solvency issue.
- dools 4y agoWhat’s interesting is that this bank failure as well as the failure of a neo bank Xinja in Australia despite taking in deposits both illustrate that it is not the case that banks make money by “lending out deposits” but rather by issuing loans and then attracting enough deposits to make their lending operations profitable.
- mooreds 4y agoAffecting stripe payouts too: https://support.stripe.com/questions/important-information-about-silicon-valley-bank https://support.stripe.com/questions/important-information-a...
- MattyMc 4y agoStripe stopped payouts to SVB bank accounts. Seems reasonable.
- ahmedbaracat 4y agoThis logic is counterintuitive to me “As deposits grew, SVB could not grow their loan book fast enough to generate the yield they wanted to see on this capital.”. Startups are not depositing the money in SVB to invest it, they are storing it for future use. Why the pressure to generate yield and grow the loan book “fast enough”? https://twitter.com/AhmadBaracat/status/1634293096639787008?s=20 https://twitter.com/AhmadBaracat/status/1634293096639787008?...
- adam_arthur 4y agoThere was no explicit need or requirement for SVB to buy MBS at 1% yield, yes. Poor management handling too much money. They also could have hedged the interest rate risk. Likely there will be policy change as a result of this. Banks over some AUM requiring stricter regulations The Fed is complicit in encouraging moral hazard through distortion of the bond market. Pretty much every crisis in the modern era is precipitated by fed policy from years earlier
- bryfb 4y ago"The yield they wanted to see on this capital" I imagine is some combination of money needed to run operations of the bank, interest paid on the deposits and profit. They could have just stored the money in the proverbial vault. But if they do that, then they have to charge the depositors a fee to be a customer. And competition has pushed in the other direction. And probably more importantly that whole "profit" goal.
- brightstep 4y agoBecause the bank, like all capitalist entities, exists to make a profit. Why else?
- ahmedbaracat 4y agoCan they make profit by charging customers a monthly fee in return for their services instead of investing the money?
- zenlikethat 4y ago
- drawkbox 4y ago> "- In 2021 SVB saw a mass influx in deposits, which jumped from $61.76bn at the end of 2019 to $189.20bn at the end of 2021. Would be interesting to see where that money came from. That has all the markings of a pump before a dump, the dump being 2023. They didn't even have to dump, they just had to stop the pump to auto dump once the interest rates went up. SVB opened themselves up to an attack vector and one thing the banking industry likes to do now and again is consolidate and shakeout. That amount of inflow in good times can make you do funny things. The better way to go about it is be scrappy always, and expect the attacks. There were way too many companies in this bank, it had too much concentration of startup/VC/PE money. Regulations will probably have to be made around this now more robust. HBS is even realizing too much optimization/efficiency is a bad thing. The slack/margin is squeezing out an ability to change vectors quickly. This is happening from supply chain to credit to food and more. The High Price of Efficiency, Our Obsession with Efficiency Is Destroying Our Resilience [1] > Superefficient businesses create the potential for social disorder. > A superefficient dominant model elevates the risk of catastrophic failure. > *If a system is highly efficient, odds are that efficient players will game it.* [1] https://hbr.org/2019/01/the-high-price-of-efficiency https://hbr.org/2019/01/the-high-price-of-efficiency
- bdangubic 4y agoall other details aside - if you purchase $80bn of “mortage-backed” anything you deserve everything that will eventually come your way
- zenlikethat 4y agoIn general people pay their mortgages. Just because a financial crisis has happened around it once doesn’t mean the asset class is inherently bad. It’s more regulated than ever, the problem was rising interest rates and not being able to keep their head above water with the position.
- bdangubic 4y ago“in general” is not good enough when you are pouring in $80bn mate. would you mortgage (no pun intended) your family’s entire financial health on something that works “in general”?
- MichaelMoser123 4y agofifteen years ago we had simpler explanations of why things are going to pieces. Nowadays everything is more complicated - but the results are the same... (i think HN needs a black bar, we are all screwed)
- lightbendover 4y agoPretty much the only outcome when reprehensible greed meets company structures indistinguishable from scams and charlatans masquerading as leadership.
- anshumankmr 4y agoWhy would someone buy an MBS after 2008?
- ripper1138 4y agoAll banks still buy and sell MBS.
- anshumankmr 4y agoThat sounds like a bad idea,but I am no investment banker.
- donedeals 4y agoMBS is a critical part of the american economy. You wouldn’t be able to buy a house without it.
- caddemon 4y agoThe problem in 2008 wasn't really MBS it was the way they were packaged. You take a collection of n mortgages and rank them by how likely they are to default, and then you divide them up into say 5 different securities each containing n/5 mortgages. The top 20% will be considered the least risky and the bottom 20% the most risky, and yields will reflect that. There are also rules on what risk level different asset managers are allowed to take on, so random retirement accounts wouldn't take the bottom 20%. No problem yet. But then some "spherical cow" style math was applied to these things. If mortgage defaults are independent events then mathematically you can smooth out the risk even from the high risk ones by just grouping a bigger number together. So they took say 5 different shit tier mortgage collections, lumped those mortgages together to create another pool of size n, and repeated the process. Now the top 20% of that pool was given a very low risk rating, yet it still paid a greater yield than the original pool's top 20%, so why wouldn't an investor want to get in on this high yield safely rated security? And it didn't stop from there, the bottom say 20% of those pools were again pooled together to create more supposedly safer securities. This could've held up for a long time in a vacuum, as long as mortgage default rates didn't change too much. But part of what incentivized this system in the first place (and in turn what this system incentivized) was to hand out mortgages like candy basically. So it was a house of cards waiting to fall, and once some of these securities faltered it also caused a bank run on a wider set of MBS structures that probably could've held out if not for the panic. Plus big failures like Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns had impacts on firms that went beyond MBS activity, so there were some crazy cascade effects too. Anyway, there's nothing inherently wrong with MBS, it's just important to know what you're buying. This situation is weird because it's not that the security itself is unsafe, it's the context in which they are using it that is risky. Though I suppose it relates on the high level that they probably thought "this security is rated very safe and it gives relatively high yield" without an actual understanding of the risk involved in their use case.
- robertwt7 4y agoPlease correct me if i'm wrong since i'm not a finance guy, apart from the loss of $1.8bn and the delta of the interest - growth from their assets. Isn't everyone still going to get their money back - the percentage of the loss that SVB has which should be less than 5-9%? Sure FDIC has to liquidate all the money from the assets and it takes time. But at least the impact is not going to be as hard as losing all the money like FTX or Maedoff in 2008 right.
- jcmontx 4y agoNot if they’re forced to sell at a low. I don’t know how big are the losses though.
- gst 4y ago> But at least the impact is not going to be as hard as losing all the money like FTX or Maedoff in 2008 right. The recovery rate for the Madoff Ponzi is 88.35%: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-total-distribution-over-4-billion-victims-madoff-ponzi-scheme https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-...
- zenlikethat 4y agoI mean. If you’re a startup that just had $10 million locked out and can’t make payroll. It doesn’t matter that you’ll “get your money back”. You’re toast.
- leoh 4y agoGood grief. Simplifying this to “they took on tons of deposits and felt the need to make risky unchartered investments to retain their existing level of returns” is just so stupidly greedy. JFC, I think here of a ship with a heavy keel; only for the captain to order cargo many multiples the weight of the keel to sit above deck. Why can’t so many folks who are doing well enough just act with basic common sense and integrity these days?
- emkemp 4y agoNitpick: The Fed isn't selling bonds. Maybe they meant the Treasury?
- zenlikethat 4y agoYea that bugged me too ha ha. The Fed doesn’t issue any bonds.
- stephen_g 4y agoIt’s probably not material to the overall picture, but just for accuracy, the wording of this is inaccurate - “As deposits grew, SVB could not grow their loan book fast enough to generate the yield they wanted to see on this capital” Capital has a special meaning to banks, and deposits are absolutely not capital from their point of view of the bank (they are from the point of view of the depositor). To the bank, deposits are on the liabilities side of the balance sheet. A bank’s capital is only equity put in by shareholders and retained profits from previous years. This is important, because how much a bank can lend is only determined by the amount of capital they have, not the amount of deposits (since deposits are on the wrong side of the balance sheet for lending from).
- wankle 4y agoIf that's even mostly true, it sounds like the SVB was set up to fail. It almost sounds like like Biden is trying to crash the US economy.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoLincoln Savings and Loan, LTCM, Bear Stearns, and now: SVB.
- chewz 4y ago> - This is not a liquidity issue as long as SVB maintains their deposits, since these securities will pay out more than they cost eventually. This is exactly a definition of liquidity issue... Owning enough assets but not being able to cover short term liabilities. In opposition to not owning enough assets to cover liabilities.
- gigatexal 4y agoHedging maturity and interest rate risk is literally the only thing a bank needs to do. (Okay not literally but come on you have more or less one job: assure assets are secure and generate some yield safely).