16 ms·
GitHub is sued, and we may learn something about Creative Commons licensing
- amarshall 4y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33457063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33457063
- breck 4y ago[flagged]
- iinnPP 4y agoThank you. After pondering for months on this I have come to the same conclusions as you and reading your link made perfect sense. We are fighting to work harder because we value currency above humanity. What a silly fight. Most jobs can already be done by an AI and we should work towards that, not the other way. What is the point of free software again? The tech is out of the bag. The hard part is done, the part where you are learning the unknown is infinitely harder than copying it afterwards. Nobody will ever control it. Time to set ideas free.
- npteljes 4y ago>What is the point of free software again? The point of the free software movement, and the licenses, is to make sure that in the future, they will still be free software. It's the Paradox of tolerance[0], expressed in legal language, for software source code. Digital goods, while often posing as tangible goods, actually have near zero replication cost, unlike tangible goods. This, combined with the special circumstances provided by free software licenses, enable a special economy, where the barrier to entry is the lowest possible, and the contributions to it are maximized for further enabling the special economy, for all current, and future participants. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- jacquesm 4y agoExcellent. GitHub is in my opinion crossing a whole pile of lines here that should not have been crossed without the authors explicit permission, regardless of the utility of the tool they built. Copyright is not something that can be signed over by a terms-of-use change of a hosting provider, the expectation is that your host does not automatically claim the rights to anything that you store there. Such projects should always be opt-in, not just because it is the law but also because it is common sense and the right thing to do from an ethical perspective.
- amelius 4y agoI just hope it doesn't end in Microsoft paying some (from their perspective) small fine that is just the cost of doing business.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe range of possible outcomes is enormous, I'll just wait by the sidelines but cherish the thought that moving out of GitHub when Microsoft bought it was the right decision. They can't be trusted, this has been proven over and over again and yet people keep falling for it. It's the fox guarding the chickens. I wrote about my misgivings at the time: https://jacquesmattheij.com/what-is-wrong-with-microsoft-buying-github/ https://jacquesmattheij.com/what-is-wrong-with-microsoft-buy...
- hnbad 4y agoThis seems to ignore the widely repeated claim that GitHub's terms of service explicitly grant them a license beyond the actual open source license attached to the code and thus transfer the burden of liability to the uploader when it comes to code they can not control the licensing of. So either this is about code authored by people who did not use GitHub (in which case GitHub would be immediately liable, though they could try to sue whoever uploaded that code to GitHub for damages) or it's going to have to argue that the terms of service can't smuggle in a provision that effectively sidesteps even the most permissive open source licenses.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marmetio 4y agoI think they're challenging the validity of what's in the user license agreement. Companies can put whatever they want in there, but not everything is enforceable.
- hnbad 4y agoI think it wouldn't be enforceable in a consumer service (at least in my jurisdiction, see a German court ruling against WhatsApp banning a user for using a third-party client by claiming doing so violated their ToS). But given that implicitly or explicitly GitHub users act more like users of a commercial service (remember: commercial doesn't mean paid or b2b), things might be different given that consumer protections don't necessarily apply. Personally I'd love to see the same "you can't hide surprises in your ToS to obtain 'consent'" yardstick be applied here though, commercial service or not.
- marmetio 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the result varied by country.
- NicoleJO 4y agoI suggest reading the actual complaint. Your interpretation is wrong.
- MetaMalone 4y agoI’m surprised it’s taken this long to see something like this on HN. Maybe something like this could be a propellant for legitimate copyright reform.
- mellosouls 4y agoThere have been plenty of discussions of this subject here. Eg https://hn.algolia.com/?q=copilot+copyright https://hn.algolia.com/?q=copilot+copyright
- AlexandrB 4y agoGiven who has more money for lawyers, I worry that copyright reform will take the form of small creators being given weaker protection than large entities - for example by making formally registering a copyright on a work necessary to get "full" protections, while self-applied licenses are treated as merely suggestions.
- rvz 4y agoWell I clearly saw this miles away. [0] [1] Effectively you can't even use the code since it has trampled on licenses which are incompatible with each other. But it is more of a problem for Copilot. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27725322 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27725322 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27772446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27772446
- ergonaught 4y agoIf it reaches a decision, I’m curious how it will affect “education”. If you study a hundred repos to learn how to do a thing, and then produce something of your own that happens to be similar (because that’s how you learned), are you under any particular obligations? One hopes Oracle et al are not further inspired by such an outcome.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoLearning from others is copyright infringement, better make sure none of your code contains any sequences longer than 150 characters that match any other code ever written.
- Sateeshm 4y ago> Learning from others is copyright infringement Isn't this the reason for clean room implementations?
- throwaway4aday 4y agoThat's specific to reverse engineering a product that has the same features as an existing one though. Part of the concept of open source is allowing others to learn from your implementation. In many cases one doesn't want to include an open source project directly in their code base for a variety of reasons, maintainability being a big factor. I don't see a clean room implementation being a good solution to the problem of wanting to use accepted standards and practices which must be gleaned from experience working with or learning from other people's code. I don't think you can get far arguing that all code should be written in a vacuum with no ability to learn from outside sources.
- NicoleJO 4y agoHumans aren't machines, so it won't affect education at all. This argument is a distraction.
- naasking 4y ago
- brezelgoring 4y agoSteve Ballmer once called Linux and the GPL License a cancer because to copy a portion of code from a copyleft project, minimal as it may be, would make the whole project require a copyleft license. If Github Co-Pilot includes GPL code then produced works should have GPL too, right? It is known that it produces verbatim copies of sections of code, so the 'derivative' explanation doesn't hold water. Alternatives may be to copy CC0-only (which can't be guaranteed, also who'd believe you lol) or target license-only - as in, if my project is MIT, go with MIT projects to source from, if I'm GPL, include GPL and so on.
- asddubs 4y agoit's not just trained on GPL code. it's trained on code of incompatible licenses, which means that the code is produces is potentially unlicensable in general. There's of course also the question of attribution, which many licenses require
- brezelgoring 4y agoI wonder who's decision was it to train the bots in 'code that is accessible to our scraper' and not in 'code we can sell derivatives products of'. I can tell the second group is quite small, so I understand the incentive, at least. Maybe they chose the Uber strategy of 'What we are doing is bordering on illegal but by the time the bell rings we'll be valuable enough to write the law ourselves'.
- belorn 4y agoMicrosoft chose to not use all code that is accessible to their scraper. All proprietary closed repositories on github that large companies use are excluded. I can easily image all the lawsuit that would had happened if paying customers that kept company secrets hosted at github had been used and leaked by copilot. The decision to only train it on "open" repositories was one of self preservation.
- tjpnz 4y ago>It is known that it produces verbatim copies of sections of code, so the 'derivative' explanation doesn't hold water. For reference it's been shown to cough up code from Quake verbatim. This from John Carmack(?) also includes his profanity laden comments: https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309 https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309
- distcs 4y ago> “Your honor, we needed so many works that it was simply not practical to ask permission of the creators.” I don’t find this argument convincing given the ability today to license many content types at scale for TDM, including images, music and yes, journal articles (See “Full disclosure” above), but it is an argument often offered by infringers. Why is this type of argument even valid? Isn't this fundamentally saying, "The cost of not infringing copyright is massive, so we will glibly infringe!" So it is not okay to infringe copyright at a small scale but okay to do it in a large scale? How can such a line of argument be sensible in court? But apparently infringers are using this line of argument. So how? Is it not absurd?
- intelVISA 4y ago>So how? Is it not absurd? it is. "Your honor, I've been drink-driving so many times I honestly can't tell you an accurate estimate any more so in both our interests let's agree it was basically uncountable, or 0." wait a minute...
- JamesSwift 4y agoOr after a crypto heist: "Your honor, it would have been onerous to ask each account owner if we could have their tokens so we just took all of them at once"
- judge2020 4y agoOn the other side, they could argue that it's like a human learning how to code over a decade of looking at the internet, and that human doesn't need to DM every code author to ask if they can learn from their content (and the risk for the author is similar given the human might one day recall some author's code verbatim and not give attribution).
- distcs 4y ago> On the other side, they could argue that it's like a human learning how to code over a decade of looking at the internet And that would make sense and it would be argued on its own merit. The judge/jury will decide if this argument is correct and legal. But the article implies that there are lawyers and infringers out there who are arguing that they could not have possibly afforded the cost of not infringing, so they were justified in their infringement. Since when did the massive cost of avoiding infringement become a valid reason to carry on with infringement? This seems just plain absurd by common sense. How do lawyers and infringers make this argument? How is it even entertained in court? What am I missing?
- azeemba 4y agoHas there been a law suit filed on the image generation side? Dalle and Stable Diffusion trained on images on the web, a lot of which weren't even freely licensed. So I would think similar legal arguments would apply there.
- Karunamon 4y agoThe big difference there is that you never get a 1 to 1 copy of the source content out of the image models, where you often do with copilot. Whether your use is transformative is a part of the fair use legal test.
- rvz 4y agoExcept that not only Stability AI have already admitted to training on copyrighted images without the permission or attribution of many artists [0], they already have a commercial SaaS API platform which uses the model [1]; effectively throwing out the sloppy 'fair use' or 'transformative' purposes claims as any artist can see all the digital art that Stability trained on without permission or attribution [2] and even producing outputs of famous copyrighted images verbatim. There is no difference between the two. Given that another project called Dance Diffusion was trained on public domain music and audio and permission by musicians, it is clear that Stability knew that they would be sued to the ground if Dance Diffusion was trained on copyrighted music. [3] They already seem to have admitted and felt guilty into trampling over the copyright and watermarks of images and knowingly avoided doing the same with music. My point is, use and train on public domain content only and content that has the permission of the creator. This applies to all of them; DALL-E, Copilot, Stable Diffusion. Clearly wasn't a problem to use public domain music with Dance Diffusion was it? [0] https://venturebeat.com/ai/stability-ai-to-honor-artist-opt-out-requests-for-stable-diffusion-3/ https://venturebeat.com/ai/stability-ai-to-honor-artist-opt-... [1] https://platform.stability.ai/ https://platform.stability.ai/ [2] https://twitter.com/EMostaque/status/1603147709229170695 https://twitter.com/EMostaque/status/1603147709229170695 [3] https://techcrunch.com/2022/10/07/ai-music-generator-dance-diffusion/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/10/07/ai-music-generator-dance-d...
- Kiro 4y ago
- hnrodey 4y agofull screen popup/overlay "Sign up for daily email alerts" This popup appears within a half second of the page loading. It's so abrupt and disruptive to my mind. My eyes have JUST located where to start reading and then BAM THIS GIANT POPUP TAKES OVER THE SCREEN. I'm exiting your page immediately. I don't care if you have a free recipe for alchemy. I wish I had an easy way to outright block the domain so I could keep track of the offenders. Popups and overlays have ruined the modern web.
- samwillis 4y agoI think one of the interesting things that will be covered in this lawsuit is whether the licence under which the code is released applies at all in the case of screen scraping. The current understanding of screen scraping is that it is allowed, despite what is in the websites terms. Effectively if a human can access the content freely without having to actively agree to a license or terms you can scrape the content. You can't republish verbatim, but you can data mine and perform an analysis and publish that. This is how the legal status of all AI training data scraped from the web is being interpreted. When it comes to open source code I suspect it will be found to be similar, if the code is freely visible on the web by a human without an active agreement to view it, then it will be possible to "scrape" it. I don't think the license the code is under will apply if that is the case. Obviously in this case is GitHub "scraping" its own site for the training data? Probably not, that may come back to bite them. This then also opens up all sorts of interesting questions of whether you can copy paste code from a website and use it internally (not republishing), despite the license attached to the code. If it is freely visible. Clearly a test case, this one, is needed to clarify the situation. And just because it's legal, it doesn't mean it's moral or ethical. We may yet see the outcome of this case change the current interpolation of legal screen scraping, it's going to be an interesting time. On top of all this there is then the question of an AI model reproducing code (or and image or music) verbatim. That obviously needs to be clarified by the courts too.
- ascagnel_ 4y ago> When it comes to open source code I suspect it will be found to be similar, if the code is freely visible on the web by a human without an active agreement to view it, then it will be possible to "scrape" it. I don't think the license the code is under will apply if that is the case. I don't see the scraping case applying here -- the idea that all human-readable code accessible on the public internet can be ingested into such a system without regard for its license would effectively mean that anything posted to the public internet is entered into the public domain, which seems ridiculous on its face (especially when the author(s) is including an explicit license alongside that code, which the scraper can theoretically also read and account for).
- 4y ago
- throwaway4aday 4y agoIf the model is being trained on the code and is not copying and pasting it or including it directly from the various repositories then I would think a blanket attribution that covers all material used to train the model, basically a giant list of all of the authors, added to the Copilot repo should cover the attribution requirement. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out, to my understanding, these language models are strictly statistical in nature so they aren't creating a database of code that they paste snippets from. They're looking at all the examples and encoding the statistical likelihood that one token follows another and are then just feeding in the pre-amble (the code you wrote) and generating the chain of tokens that most likely follows that. It seems like it would be the same process if a person were to read a lot of code, identify patterns e.g. an <a> tag has an href= attribute or other more complex configurations, and then writes code based on that understanding. If you can prove that is infringing then you could potentially prove that the act of reading other people's code and then writing your own based on what you have learnt is infringement even if it doesn't exactly match the code that other people have written! I hope this can be effectively explained in court.
- mattstir 4y agoThe main sources of discomfort come from when Copilot really does copy-paste code blocks verbatim. It doesn't happen all the time, but there are still many examples like the following: https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309 https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309
- core-utility 4y agoWouldn't this kind of ruling effectively put a halt to ChatGPT and other AI's training on publicly accessible data? What's the difference between Copilot creating output based on code on Github, and ChatGPT giving answers based on a NYT article (without attribution)?
- judge2020 4y agoIMO it should be treated like a human. Your output is 99% similar to this <code/article>? Copyright infringement, you should have mixed your own thoughts and reasoning into your output. Humans can plagiarize just as easy as ChatGPT/CoPilot can generate verbatim text from its training set.
- core-utility 4y agoAt what point can one say that the source is unique enough to qualify for protection? Otherwise, I can't use `print "Hello world"` because I didn't mix my own thoughts and reasoning into the output.
- judge2020 4y agoIt's no different from how current copyright works for us humans. Something is only copyright protected if it's a "sufficiently original" work and "possesses at least a minimal degree of creativity" https://www.copyright.gov/comp3/chap300/ch300-copyrightable-authorship.pdf#page=5 https://www.copyright.gov/comp3/chap300/ch300-copyrightable-...
- core-utility 4y agoSo (just thinking out loud), if Copilot suggests something only seen in one codebase, the code owners have a decent copyright case. But if copilot suggests something that's frequent across multiple, there's really no case to be made.
- judge2020 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- white_dragon88 4y agoI consider it a derivative work, it’s using statistical models to string tokens and has no ‘knowledge’ of a given block of code.
- mattstir 4y agoThe issues stem from Copilot frequently regurgitating code verbatim, as seen in examples like this: https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309 https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309
- ianbutler 4y agoI've produced a few pieces of software that has user generated content as a feature and every lawyer I've used to draft the ToS has added provisions that gave my organization explicit rights that extend beyond whatever other licensing may be applicable. Both in being able to improve our own features or create new ones with that content and other rights that would indemnify us from a wide range of legal issues. I'm curious to see how this will be litigated because of that. The difference here seems to be how publicly Copilot's use of user generated content has been, the wide range of licensing that content falls under and the fact this is an entirely new product produced by a third party with a partnership versus a 1st party tool.
- mellosouls 4y agoIt will be a real shame if the fantastic achievement of OpenAI with copilot etc is smothered by ego. Innovation in code should be heralded but if in the majority of cases the coder using Copilot and similar tools is just saving time on bog standard functions they could write themselves, it's difficult to understand why that needs to be attributed.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt's very easy to be generous with other people's property, intellectual or otherwise.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's also very easy to invent supposed "intellectual property" rights out of thin air that conveniently last for a century or more (!) for your own work. But instead of either of these views that focus on selfishness, it's much more productive to instead think about what benefits society as a whole.
- pessimizer 4y agoMicrosoft has been one of the most aggressive enforcers of intellectual property rights ever known, and it can be easily argued that their stranglehold retarded the development of computing and the internet as a whole. It's so bizarre to see these prima facie bad arguments being used by someone who isn't being paid by Microsoft to make them. If Microsoft puts all of their code in, requires anyone who uses copilot to share their code with the algorithm, and allows anyone to run the model on their own platform complete with updates, you'll see all of the FOSS objections dry up in an instant.
- sebzim4500 4y agoIt's also pretty easy to be generous with your own when it comes to copilot. I have not been damaged in any way by copilot learning from my code, and no one else has either.
- visarga 4y agoCopyright covers expression, but not the ideas themselves. So it should be ok to mine ideas from projects, open or not, as long as the model doesn't reproduce expression. And even expression can be copied if it is small enough, trivial, public knowledge, the only obvious way to do something or an API call. If you want idea protection you need to look at patents.
- elil17 4y ago>And even expression can be copied if it is small enough This is what I would argue if I was Microsoft's lawyer. You can't win a copyright lawsuit over one bar of music, one dance move, or a few words. Similarly, copilot can't be considered to be infringing on anyone's copyright because the snippets it might copy verbatim are too short to be copyrightable.
- jcranmer 4y ago> You can't win a copyright lawsuit over one bar of music, one dance move, or a few words. Actually... The smallest successful copyright claim is I believe over 10 words or so.
- elil17 4y agoYes, this case: https://fkks.com/news/can-borrowing-ten-words-be-copyright-infringement https://fkks.com/news/can-borrowing-ten-words-be-copyright-i... However, this definitely pushed the boundaries of copyright law. Audi never appealed the $1m verdict, so it's hardly settled case law.
- pantalaimon 4y ago> You can't win a copyright lawsuit over one bar of music Actually, Kraftwerk did https://www.factmag.com/2019/07/30/kraftwerk-sample-lawsuit-metall-auf-metall-verdict/ https://www.factmag.com/2019/07/30/kraftwerk-sample-lawsuit-...
- elil17 4y ago
- jefftk 4y agoWe've discussed the suit here before a few times (ex: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33485544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33485544) and also whether something like co-pilot even needs a license (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27736650 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27736650). There's a prediction market on this suit's success, which is currently at 35% (https://manifold.markets/JeffKaufman/will-the-github-copilot-litigation https://manifold.markets/JeffKaufman/will-the-github-copilot...).
- NicoleJO 4y agoHere's a link to the case itself so you won't have to guess about anything. https://githubcopilotinvestigation.com/ https://githubcopilotinvestigation.com/
- kmeisthax 4y ago> Does the attribution requirement mean that the author’s information may not be removed as a data element from the content, even if inclusion might frustrate the TDM exercise or introduce noise into the system? > Does the attribution need to be included in the data set at every stage? The above two questions seem identical. My gut feeling is no; you don't need to intentionally train on attributions nor do you need to ensure that the data set columns have attribution data in them when provided to your training code. The attribution requirement of CC-BY and CC-BY-SA triggers when you do any of the things copyright law says you have to get permission in order to do, and the license further restricts that requirement to public instances of such. So privately shoving Creative Commons data into a neural net trainer is probably fine. Not having attribution on the data the model sees does not foreclose the possibility of providing attribution alongside the model at the time of publication. > Does the result of the mining need to include attribution, even if hundreds of thousands of CC BY works were mined and the output does not include content from individual works? This is an active legal question. My personal opinion is that if you can draw a line from a particular output to something in the training set, then you're either copying or creating a derivative work, and you need to follow any relevant licenses. Generative models are capable of outputting their training set data, especially if overfit; so using them exposes you to the licensing requirements of anything the model saw that matches its output domain. I'm actually considering this as part of PD-Diffusion; which is my attempt at building an art generator trained on public-domain images. Since I'm scraping Wikimedia Commons to get both images and labels, the labels are CC-BY-SA[0]. This means that my trained models will also need to be CC-BY-SA and ship with a very, very long text file listing attributions for all the labels I used[1]. But, notably, because this is an art generator and not a label generator, I don't need to worry about attributing model outputs. None of the label data will make its way into the final image. If I did have a reliable way to attribute model outputs, then I could make "CC-Diffusion", trained on all CC-BY and CC-BY-SA images on Wikimedia Commons. But even then there's noncopyright ethical concerns with doing that. I'm not even using the full public domain as-is, just the PD-Old category, because Wikimedia Commons has a lot of uncopyrighted Italian images of living people that I do not want in my model. > Also sued were a confusing mishmash of for profit and non-profit related entities all using a variation of the name OpenAI (OpenAI, Inc., OpenAI, LLC, OpenAI Startup Fund GP I, L.L.C.; you get the picture). OpenAI received one billion dollars in funding from Microsoft although they seem “officially unrelated.” OpenAI's ownership structure is hilariously convoluted, even by the standards of, say, Mozilla having separate 501(c)(3) and for-profit arms. The goal of the company is to launder noncommercial research into commercial products, and they even have a laughable "capped profit corporation" explanation for this. [0] There are two exceptions to this: - Structured data, i.e. the caption field and Wikidata, is considered to be copyright-free and explicitly has a CC0 license applied to it. - Some public domain images have contradicting copyright terms applied to their wikitext; i.e. CC-BY-NC-SA. Those will need to be detected and filtered out of the label set, but I haven't written the code to do this yet. That's also why I haven't released any trained models. [1] Currently this is going to be in the form of Wikimedia Commons usernames, specifically all the users that were in the revision history for the images. I believe there are also some wikitext attributions that I need to write code to find and reproduce.
- ZhangSWEFAANG 4y ago[flagged]
- ZhangSWEFAANG 4y ago> Some open code carries relatively light requirements, for example: “Don’t use my code commercially (don’t sell it or use it in something you sell)” and, very basically. How can anyone even enforce this? Why can't I take some code, create a SaaS product for drug dealers, and then go sell it to my Opp Daquavion Marshawn III down the block? Who will ever find out?
- Hugh95 4y ago[flagged]
- npteljes 4y agoThe reality is that open source license violation is rampant, even in big, recognized names. Enforcement, as you feel, is sparse. Usually an entity has to notice, and then make the effort to react to the situation, which doesn't happen often. There are entities who specifically work on licence violations, for example, you can report them on gnu.org[0]. Because there are large cases like TikTok using OBS code, and not contributing back[1], I'm sure there are lots of cases where the community simply doesn't find out in the first place, similarly to how software piracy is rampant in some places in the world, even among commercial entities. In case you're interested in more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_source_license_litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_source_license_litigation [0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/enforcing-gpl.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/enforcing-gpl.en.html [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/20/22847213/tiktoks-live-studio-obs-open-source-policy https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/20/22847213/tiktoks-live-st...
- chrismorgan 4y agoI don’t understand the author’s position in this article. It spends a long time talking about details of the licenses, but I can’t see any way the suit will actually be about licenses, because if it’s about licenses then it seems patently obvious to me that GitHub will lose very quickly, because they have undoubtedly violated the terms of the licenses. As I see it, the only leg GitHub can possibly stand on is the “fair use” exemption of copyright law—that the license is irrelevant, because they weren’t using it under that license. So then you get to the last paragraph of the article, and the “fair use” claim is finally mentioned—as something the plaintiffs seem to be seeking to avoid bringing into it because that would make things messy. But… GitHub’s defence must be “fair use”, I can see no other response. Yes, the plaintiffs “chose to focus on something that is beyond factual dispute”, but how are GitHub ever going to do anything other than bring fair use into it? So I don’t see how they could expect it to “still provide the same damages” without bringing fair use into it. (And I can’t imagine GitHub will settle for anything other that total vindication here—even settlement would doom Copilot.) Returning to the title: I cannot imagine any way that We May Learn Something About Creative Commons Licensing from this suit. About the interactions between copyright law and machine learning, maybe. But about CC-*, GPL, Apache-2.0, MIT, whatever? Nah, there’s nothing interesting about them in the suit, because if they were involved, it’d be cut and dried.
- mukesh610 4y agoIMO fair use is still not a strong argument for Microsoft. They commercialized the product and made money out of it. Fair use is only allowed if the work you're doing is purely for the greater good. I might be wrong though, IANAL.
- chrismorgan 4y agoYou are wrong, though public interest is certainly the basis of the purpose of fair use doctrine. But the simplest way of demonstrating that fair use still allows commercialisation is probably this example: search engines absolutely depend on fair use if they include any content from the linked pages. (And some countries have even tried to call the act of linking copyright infringement, though they’ve tended to back off at least a little, to requiring at least the title or other content for it to be infringement, and not just the URL.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use, lots of good reading there.
- amflare 4y agoI don't understand this case. Is Copilot copying code wholesale and presenting it as its own? Because if not, then it doesn't need to attribute anything more than I need to attribute John Go or Edward PHP everytime I use a trick I picked up by reading their code. Obviously, if they trained Copilot on private code repos, that a whole other discussion. But I assume they didn't, so you don't even have the argument that they should have paid the repo authors to be able to train on their code.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mattstir 4y agoYes, Copilot has had issues with copying entire blocks of code verbatim. There's a decent number of examples like the following: https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309 https://twitter.com/mitsuhiko/status/1410886329924194309.
- kache_ 4y agoyeah that's great but we still unlocked tons of productivity who cares man just build stuff if you don't want people to learn off your code just don't share it!
- mattstir 4y agoInterestingly, the same companies who made the paid service by analyzing all of that open-source code would never, ever consider open-sourcing the code for that service. > if you don't want people to learn off your code "Learn" is a strange verb to use here. No one at Microsoft or OpenAI was scraping all of GitHub so that they could learn. They took people's licensed works, fed it into a very sophisticated copy-paste machine, and started making money off of it. > just don't share it! It's almost like licenses and copyright exist to protect the rights of their holders or something. The entire point of licenses is to be able to share your work in a way that respects your wishes. "Just don't share it" is completely non-productive.
- kache_ 4y agothe cost of training is exponentially decreasing. It's only a matter of time before a codex-like model is released to the open.
- api 4y agoFOSS licenses need to add provisions that only 100% open and free to download AI models can be trained on works licensed under them. They need to add this yesterday.
- sebzim4500 4y agoThat's almost certainly not enforcable though. See any of the cases where people have succesfully defended webscraping while violating TOS.
- sadpasture 4y agoDoesn't sound very Free to me...
- gus_massa 4y agoDo you consider WTFPL a FOSS license? The polite versions are MIT0, BSD0 and CC0. I guess anyone using them is fine with Copilot been close and doing whatever they want. But people using AGPL may have a very different opinion.
- npteljes 4y agoI can see that in like GPLv4, they could consider AI training and such as derivative work.
- verytrivial 4y agoIsn't it strange how Microsoft GitHub is now finding itself party to source code licensing lawsuits after its 'association' with the SCO Unix cases of yesterday. [1] https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/fact-and-fiction-in-the-microsoft-sco-relationship/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/fact-and-fiction-in-...
- drstewart 4y agoWould love to see an overlap of the commenters here versus the ones in the "piracy is totally okay!" thread with people saying it's morally just fine to pirate videos and music just because they wanna.
- sebzim4500 4y agoI think MSFT will regret not using some kind of bloom filter to avoid producing existing code verbatim. If they could show that it will never reproduce a long sequence (unless that sequence appears in more than x independent repos) they would have a much stronger argument of being transformative.
- poulpy123 4y agoThe article is once again mixing up the production of copyrighted work, which is illegal and the training on copyrighted but publicly available work, which afaik isn't illegal. And I don't see how it could be illegal when the code is public (although I don't doubt that lawyers will find a way).
- layer8 4y agoThe lawsuit is about attributions and licenses, not about copyright infringement.
- molly0 4y agoI just skimmed through the case and liked how they defined Artificial intelligence “Artificial Intelligence’ is referred to herein as ‘AI’. AI is defined for the purposes of this Complaint as a computer program that algorithmically simulates human reasoning or inference, often using statistical methods. Machine Learning (‘ML’) is a subset of AI in which the behavior of the program is derived from studying a corpus of material called training data.”
- Sateeshm 4y agoIf i create a news website that creates articles by scrapes all the major news websites across the world and charge people via ads, would that be legal? Not rhetorical.
- ChoGGi 4y agoGood, I put all my code on GitHub under the MIT license because I'd like people to be able to use it as they see fit. That doesn't include not giving me credit.
- ghaff 4y agoI suspect that a lot of the people lining up on the other side against GitHub/Microsoft won't be so happy if the courts further lock down permissible uses under copyright across the board. More specifically, if Copilot breaks the "rules," so too does (probably--IANAL) pretty much every generative AI project out there. Restricting training to public domain datasets would be very limiting.
- pessimizer 4y agoAll copyrights and patents slow progress. If the desire for generative models is greater than the desire to hoover up cash, refine or end copyright and patent laws. Free Software people would build a statue to Microsoft if they started campaigning for an end to software copyrights.
- ghaff 4y ago>Free Software people would build a statue to Microsoft if they started campaigning for an end to software copyrights. Some might. But FOSS licenses can exist because of copyright. So if, hypothetically, there weren't software copyrights, anyone could take any code and monetize it however they wanted with no restrictions. That might or might not be a big deal--the general trend has been towards more permissive licenses anyway.
- tmtvl 4y agoI consider myself to be kind of a Free Software person and I wouldn't cheer for the end to software copyright, I worry that the abolition would harm the cause I care for, which is preserving the freedoms of users. Getting rid of copyright wouldn't stop bad actors from trying to circumvent their users' rights, and with no recourse to copyleft it would become harder to fight that.
- elforce002 4y agoThere has to be an option or something like "repositoy opt-out from copilot" type of button.
- layer8 4y agoThis needs to be opt-in, not opt-out.
- eriner_ 4y agoEven if it reproduces (proportionally) small sections of code it's been trained on verbatim, its function is transformative and will likely be deemed fair use. This lawsuit is going nowhere other than the HN front page.
- jrm4 4y agoI'm still baffled as to why people treat Github like a public library despite being owned by what was at one time the greatest enemy of free and open source software in existence. Not saying they haven't changed their tune somewhat, but a library owned by Barnes and Noble is going to have very different incentives than an actual library. Made all the more silly by the fact that it's Git. You could just host it yourself for five bucks a month and that's probably overpaying.
- TAForObvReasons 4y agoGitHub built goodwill over the years. There were many controversies, but there were also many die-hard fans. That didn't evaporate overnight. Microsoft bought GitHub (and minted 3 billionaires in the process) specifically to acquire that goodwill and monetize it.
- aliqot 4y ago> acquire that goodwill and monetize it Embrace Extend <-- here Extinguish
- fluoridation 4y agoThat's not what EEE refers to. "Embrace" does not mean "buy".
- jrm4 4y agoIt can, I think. The EEE concept is useful enough to go slightly outside its original intended use.
- fluoridation 4y agoSo the idea here is 1. Acquire company for tens of billions. 2. Intentionally ruin own investment. 3. ??? 4. PROFIT! ?
- reset-password 4y agoEthics aside, By the time this case is resolved it won't likely matter anymore. I see models getting more granular and specific (and thus smaller) while typical personal computer resources are getting larger. At some point you'll just download the largest 'javascript inference model' that will run on your hardware and be done with it. There are a huge number of motivated developers that want this to exist, the techniques themselves are not novel, and the code itself cannot be kept from whomever wants to train a model. It's a lost cause.
- tremon 4y agoThe actual class-action lawsuit page, curiously not linked from the article: https://githubcopilotlitigation.com/ https://githubcopilotlitigation.com/
- partiallypro 4y agoThis is going to have ramifications for things like ChatGPT as well.
- dmitrygr 4y agoThought exercise: How can GitHub claim ANY license to my code that was uploaded by someone else without my permission or even notification? Lots of my code is there, uploaded by others.
- hgs3 4y agoAI advancements are shining a light on how warped our society has become. We _should_ invent technology to better our lives, but instead its become something to fear as it might destroy our livelihoods. I understand the threatening feeling AI brings, but rather than squashing innovation we should be rethinking the role of our economy, copyright, and intellectual property.
- N_A_T_E 4y agoI agree with the sentiment however given the current political realities it seems we are happier to let people lose their livelihoods without any clear replacements , training or economic plan of any kind. See manufacturing in the rust belt for an example of what happened in the last two decades when we moved to the knowledge worker economy without a plan for the workers.
- EamonnMR 4y agoAI had enormous potential for interesting artistic effects. Instead it's being used to make (for now) shoddy knockoffs, and maybe someday better-than-the-original knockoffs. I was hoping for the invention of a car, but all we got was a faster horse. Would anyone have been able to sell a car if faster horses were already clogging up the streets?
- 99failures 4y agoSo really it boils down to attribution, therefore if GitHub were to disclose attribution to all the copyright owners of the code used to train the model, then this issue will be mute. It will be a long list, but just a list.
- gibrown 4y agoAnd there is a list right? https://github.com/search?q=license%3Acc0-1.0&type=Repositories&ref=advsearch&l=&l= https://github.com/search?q=license%3Acc0-1.0&type=Repositor... All repos with a particular license.
- paulclinger 4y agoIt would be very difficult to track what record in the training set contributed to what weight adjustment, especially after all the tokenization that is done. s/mute/moot/; moot: having little or no practical relevance, typically because the subject is too uncertain to allow a decision.
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoIs encrypting your code and pushing that to GH an option or am I missing something obvious.
- baby 4y agoThis is why we can't have nice things.
- skc 4y agoI hope people hoping this lawsuit succeeds will also accept any ruling favorable to Github.
- rglover 4y agoThis may be of interest to others here. After reviewing the existing OSS licenses, I decided to write my own (SAUCR: Source Available Under Commercial Restriction—pronounced "saucer"). I'm still working on formalizing the details of it so others can use it, but if you're curious there's an example here [1]. tl;dr it gives specific permissions as to what derivative works are and are not permitted while making the source available for others. The key being: you can be as permissive or as limited as you want in how your code is used. [1] https://github.com/cheatcode/joystick/blob/development/LICENSE.md https://github.com/cheatcode/joystick/blob/development/LICEN...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoRelated. Others? The lawsuit against Microsoft, GitHub and OpenAI that could change rules of AI - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33546009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33546009 - Nov 2022 (5 comments) An open source lawyer’s view on the copilot class action lawsuit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33542813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33542813 - Nov 2022 (175 comments) Microsoft sued for open-source piracy through GitHub Copilot - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33485544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33485544 - Nov 2022 (288 comments) We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33457063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33457063 - Nov 2022 (781 comments) GitHub Copilot may steer Microsoft into a copyright lawsuit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33278726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33278726 - Oct 2022 (11 comments) GitHub Copilot investigation - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33240341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33240341 - Oct 2022 (1219 comments) What Copilot means for open source - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31878290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31878290 - June 2022 (137 comments) Should GitHub be sued for training Copilot on GPL code? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31847931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31847931 - June 2022 (300 comments)
- nickv 4y agoI see lots of anti GitHub (really Microsoft) sentiment here, but doesn’t a ruling against GitHub have massive implications for any “all powerful ML trained AI model” period? Like, we’re all swooning about ChatGPT, but how can chatGPT be legal if this isn’t? I literally can ask it “write me a song about cryptocurrency in the style of Taylor swift” and it will. It can’t do that it it didn’t train with Taylor Swift song lyrics. Doesn’t this kill chatGPT? Doesn’t this law suit potentially kill lots of training models?
- yakubin 4y agoGood riddance.
- int_19h 4y agoIt very much depends on the exact ruling. Judges usually don't like to make rulings broader than they need to be, so it may well be something decided on a technicality. Or the ruling may rely on some particular property of the Copilot model that does not apply to ChatGPT.
- saint-loup 4y agoHere is a dedicated website from the plaintiffs team. https://githubcopilotlitigation.com/ https://githubcopilotlitigation.com/ Interestingly, Matthew Butterick (of Practical Typography fame) is co-counsel on this. Programmer, lawyer and typesetting expert, damn. https://matthewbutterick.com/ https://matthewbutterick.com/