38 ms·
Microsoft is preparing to add ChatGPT to Bing
- argella 4y agoGoogle will just unleash their own large language model.
- geoduck14 4y agoThey already have
- TowerTall 4y agoGoogle already has a AI chat some claim is more advanced than ChatGPT (Google Meena / Google LaMDA), but the there are no room for advertisement in a Chat (or voice) based search engine.
- hbrn 4y agoOf course there is. Anything that has your attention can include ads.
- lossolo 4y ago> Anything that has your attention can include ads. It's funny because paper[1] from Google that started transformers and LLMs is called "Attention is all you need". And I agree that you can easily incorporate ads into chat, just ask ChatGPT to do it in a subtle way for you and you will see how it will incorporate ad into response. 1. https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.03762 https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.03762
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThere's a huge advertising opportunity in language model advertising. Think about anything a human salesperson does to advertise, except automatically and at scale. Examples: * When you ask for recommendations, it gives you x branded option or maybe the "best result" with an advertised alternative. * When you search for symptoms, it recommends name brands instead of generics. * When you ask for recipes, it directs you to <advertised cooking site>. * When you ask for poetry in the style of Longfellow, it recommends an audiobook as "something you might enjoy". * When you want to know about what happened to <recent celebrity that died>, it says "they died in a high speed chase according to <celebrity rag>. Here are some pictures and links to an article with more information" * Platform integrations, like linking to the Google/windows store directly. Many of these are already done by primitive assistants like Alexa. Going beyond that, you can copy pretty much everything done by influencer marketers in a chatbot.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoGross. I need facts about products, not a salesman convincing me to buy their products.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoWhen has a degraded product experience ever stopped advertisers? Even the famously UX-oriented Apple has inserted all sorts of upsell notifications, and nags into modern devices.
- baron816 4y agoWhen I want to buy something like an air fryer, I either want something to either tell me the best overall air fryer, or the best one for me (“best air fryer for individuals with small kitchens”). I don’t want to do a whole bunch of research with just the raw specs to try to determine which is the best one for a person like me. I could be nice to have an AI ask me questions about what I hope to use it for, what kind of space I have, and what my budget is, and then give me some recommendations.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoThis service exists, you know. It's called going to a store and asking.
- BasedGroyper99 4y agoYes, but imagine having that service 24/7 available from everywhere and for almost every product imaginable?
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoGPT with ads wouldn't provide that service. All that would provide is a masterfully crafted, possibly false argument for why you should buy the product that paid for placement. You can already get that with google minus the conman pitch. So how is this even an improvement?
- the__prestige 4y agoI am not sure why this is different from search. Just show relevant ads on the right hand side of the page. If they are useful, people will click them too.
- alphabetting 4y agoOnly 20% of queries have ads on them anyway. The cost of operating the models at Google scale is a much bigger problem for them than ad integration.
- speedgoose 4y agoAny minute now.
- echelon 4y agoGoogle has the wrong leadership relative to Microsoft. Nadella is the Gates/Jobs to Pichai's Ballmer/Sculley. Microsoft is playing 4D chess with their acquisitions and long-term vision; Google is floundering amidst perverse leadership incentives, inaction, and its non-diversified revenue stream.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/1ChFk https://archive.ph/1ChFk
- gigel82 4y agoOoh, this sounds very interesting; if they can pull this off, I can totally see Google taking a serious hit (especially with the quality already declined due to ads / SEO).
- intelVISA 4y agoCould potentially be pretty bad for Google and I'm no MS/OpenAI fan. As a complete outsider to ML my hope is NLP style search with RL + LLM is going to disrupt the Old Way.
- twelve40 4y agowhile competition is welcome, wouldn't they face the same exact problem as Google - filtering out tons of crap seo text and actually trying to separate out non-noise text from that?
- maxbond 4y agoAnd if "next gen SEO" (adversarial training data that cause something to be inappropriately or disproportionately represented in responses) lands in your chat search, it isn't a matter of just setting flags in a database to ignore or penalize a set of documents - you're gunnuh have to either retrain, or add a new set of layers (or similar) to filter out/penalize these results. If this starts happening at anything close to the rate that Google encounters spam, I can't see how they would keep up.
- visarga 4y agoLanguage models are tested with hundreds of benchmarks including everything from bias to factuality and reasoning correctness. When they have a big deficiency it shows in the test scores.
- maxbond 4y agoBig deficiencies aren't monetizable by adversaries, tiny ones are (eg, impacting it's response to questions about one topic in particular). In a very narrow niche there may not be many documents to pick from, either. I don't think you can just automate this away in the context of generalized search. Search has to fulfill every niche; that seems like an indefensible position (strategically speaking, not in the moral sense). How can you benchmark bias in every niche? Your benchmarks show your reasoning is sound; what about the premises you're reasoning from? In the context of something narrowly scoped like a customer service bot, it makes sense to me how you could build expertise in constraining the model's output. But in terms of everything? But I'll admit I don't have a crystal ball, happy to eat my words if they can operate with enough traffic and got long enough to attract the attention of spammers, and still keep them at bay. I think this space is stagnant and needs to be shaken up, and that chat interfaces have potential, so I'm not trying to be a hater. I just think this is gunnuh be a very difficult aspect.
- tluyben2 4y agoI have prompted chatgpt enough over the past months to see how it would work. I have used my playground for it to get it to indicate what it is talking about, for instance and obviously, prefixing math content with /math but also /history, /media, /tech, /physics, /person etc. Then you can send that to another service; pushing math to wolfram alpha (etc) makes chatgpt suddenly give perfect math answers and it works (it takes a bunch of hacks to ignore it’s confident lying part of answering equations). When we it names a person or location, it shows Wikipedia or maps or both etc. In this way you use it’s bluffing powers without assuming (or even reading) it’s content; it returns articles etc (which can be wrong as well of course but at least you might know if it’s reputable or not). I can easily see how bing or google would use something like this to search and return very relevant content, the queries might not be better than some people can create themselves with effort. However many people cannot create good queries and chatgpt creates good queries from extremely little input. More importantly; it’s a conversation; you can fine tune the results. You can tell it that you meant the programming language, not oxidation when it shows completely bonkers results. This will work and will work very well as far as I have been able to try. I cannot go further as I have no easy access to search engines without getting blocked immediately for automated querying. Not sure how this is looking cost wise: chatgpt at scale will even hurt a company like MS for now. Having a million techies use it for some experimentation is a bit different than a billion+ users searching whatever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bemmu 4y agoAgreed, this seems like the immediate future. Large language model which has access to a bunch of "widgets" that it can use to extend itself. I can see two types of such widgets. First type is info widgets which allow it access information outside of itself, like using a calculator by making it output something like {calc 1+1}, search wikipedia by {wiki something}, see the results of such a query and use that info in its output to the user. Second type is UI widgets that allow it to display different types of things to the user. There is already a kind of widget in ChatGPT, which is display of Markdown. But it's easy to imagine widgets for say showing coordinates on a map, or visualizing something else. Since there is a large number of such useful widgets, I'm guessing there will be an app store for them where developers can write their own widgets to extend it and make revenue based on how much they are used.
- crucialfelix 4y agoTraining set placement is the new search placement. To get your product listed it needs to be in the model.
- est 4y agoChatGPT fabricates lots of stuff, it's deceptive for common queries, but for programming related output, it's easily verifiable and delivers as an extremely valuable search tool. I can easly ask ChatGPT to explain stuff e.g. eBPF details without wasting time looking up the manuals. I hope Bing dominates Google and stackoverflow in this.
- loveparade 4y agoIt's easily verifiable, but it may still waste time. I've had many cases where ChatGPT makes up functions that do exactly what I need, but then I find out these functions don't actually exist. This may not happen very often for super popular languages like Python or Javascript where training data is huge, but it happens all the time for the long-tail of languages. In those cases, it would've been faster for me to do a regular search. I do agree with the overall point though. If you understand when to use it and when it's more likely to give you nonsensical answers, it can save a huge amount of time. But when I ask it about a topic that I don't know enough about to immediately verify the answer myself I'm forced to double check the answers for validity, which kind of defeats the purpose. The best queries to ChatGPT are cases where I know what the answer should look like, I just forgot the syntax or some details. Bash scripts or Kubernetes manifests are examples here, I know them, I just keep forgetting the keywords because I only touch them every few weeks. And don't get me started about asking ChatGPT about more general topics in e.g. economics or finance. What you get is a well-written summary of popular news and reddit opinions, which is dangerous if it's presented as "the truth" - The big mistake here is that the training procedure assumes that the amount of data correlates with correctness, which isn't true for many topics that involve politics or similar kinds of incentives where people and news spread what conveniently benefits them and gets clicks.
- wildpeaks 4y agoWasting time and having to be constantly vigilant is exhausting and a slippery slope that makes it easier to fall for deceptive content and settling for "I don't know, it's probably close enough" instead of insisting on precision and accuracy. Humans take a lot of shortcuts (such as believing more easily the same facts presented with a confident tone) and the "firehose of bs" exploits it: this was already the case before generative AI, but AI amplifies the industrial-scale imbalance between the time needed to generate partially incorrect data and the amount of time/energy required to validate.
- bg24 4y agoMy concern is about this whole business model of adding ChatGPT to a search engine. A search engine is a free tool. Because it is free, the incentive to make money is via ads, referral etc. That means preferential treatment where the money is. ChatGPT (or a similar product) focuses on solving users problem interactively. No ads, no going to another website etc. How would you make money from a search engine? I was hoping a simple, paid model to start with. Over time, as the LLMs become commodity (200GB, runnable on Intel/AMD), ship it as part of the OS and other devices.
- pyrolistical 4y agoEasy. Train LLM to make subtle recommendations for sponsored products. I’m joking of course but somebody is going to this
- karmasimida 4y agoI would be somewhat wary of this idea. Because bots like ChatGPT will oversell and it is kinda creep. Current search ads display options and let you filter through which is neat, but ChatGPT like agent will shred the original content and make it invisible to distinguish which is ads, and worse false advertising, which is not. I think let ChatGPT to infer the attribution automatically and do a revenue sharing with original link owner will be a better option.
- baobabKoodaa 4y ago> I’m joking of course but somebody is going to this Already done :) https://future.attejuvonen.fi/ https://future.attejuvonen.fi/
- WaxProlix 4y agoPaid search exists; I recently signed up for Kagi[1], and it's more or less fine. Might make a good candidate for integration there, eh? 1 https://kagi.com/ https://kagi.com/
- Semaphor 4y ago
- cakirh 4y agoUse ChatGPT for Search Engines -> https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/chatgpt-for-search-engine/feeonheemodpkdckaljcjogdncpiiban/related?ref=producthunt&utm_campaign=The%20SEOs%20Diners%20Club&utm_medium=email&utm_source=Revue%20newsletter https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/chatgpt-for-search...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- swyx 4y agothe real “redpill” in all this is that chatgpt is a feature not a product; if microsoft work out a form factor that is cost efficient at search engine scale, google is more than capable of copying it. unlike the annual halfhearted google chat app, this needs no network effect and in fact google beats msft at the one network effect that does matter here: indexing the web.
- ddmma 4y agoI bet this on Cortana backend, puzzled components together with Azure would look like https://github.com/dasdata/gortanagtp https://github.com/dasdata/gortanagtp
- throwaway81523 4y agoI guess they decided Bing doesn't suck enough already, so they want to make it even worse. Hey Microsoft, how about instead of adding chatgpt, filter the results so Bing actually works as a search engine? That is, select only the search results that contain the search terms, rather than returning the whole internet in an order somewhat influenced by the search terms.
- fooker 4y ago>rather than returning the whole internet in an order somewhat influenced by the search terms Bing is just catering to their core users here, turns out this is an excellent idea for consuming and serving adult content. Try out Bing vs Google for this purpose, and prepare to be amazed.
- Dalewyn 4y agoUsername checks out...? Anyway, Bing being a pr0n search engine is equal parts meme and reality. I like how Microsoft/Bing don't take themselves too seriously since usurping Google in this regard is a fool's errand at this point.
- whatyesaid 4y agoThere's a well known phenomenon that everyone appends "reddit" to their search results as otherwise there's too much SEO garbage. The thing with search engines is you can actually tell how good they are by comparing a few queries.
- fooker 4y agoEqual parts meme and reality makes it a reality, it seems to me.
- visarga 4y agoI thought Google was doing that. I ask: > What is the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot? It replies with swimming and crossing on ferries. https://www.google.com/search?q=What+is+the+world+record+for+crossing+the+English+Channel+entirely+on+foot%3F&newwindow=1&sxsrf=ALiCzsYDgeVF1fzjJpip9a7vwsmGtwVYBQ%3A1672684815131&ei=DyWzY76xB6Pl7_UPqIGxgAI&ved=0ahUKEwj-9OfBxKn8AhWj8rsIHahADCAQ4dUDCA8&uact=5&oq=What+is+the+world+record+for+crossing+the+English+Channel+entirely+on+foot%3F&gs_lcp=Cgxnd3Mtd2l6LXNlcnAQAzoKCAAQRxDWBBCwA0oECEEYAEoECEYYAFCDBFiDBGCMBmgDcAF4AIABvgGIAb4BkgEDMC4xmAEAoAECoAEByAEIwAEB&sclient=gws-wiz-serp https://www.google.com/search?q=What+is+the+world+record+for...
- based69 4y agoMoat for chatbots is soon going to be whoever reddit/twitter/quora/stackoverflow allows to mine their fresh content for models. If the endpoint is not the user clicking in a link then why should these companies give away all that value?
- bottlepalm 4y agoIdk but it's going to be an AI arms race. For some reason I don't think it will last very long though..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zone411 4y agoThis has been going for many years already, with Google giving answers right in the search results and just using websites as their private content factories. The relationship has become more and more uneven every year, with no pushback from the websites (a collective action problem, some traffic is better than no traffic, or worse, traffic to your competitor) and it probably won't change as long as Google pays lip service and adds a few links once in a while. The quality of content and therefore the quality of Google's search results suffer in the long term because it makes no sense to invest in it, but as long as it's good for Google's quarterly results, they don't care. Their problem is new sites like Discord and mobile-only apps that never got addicted to traffic from Google in the first place.
- highwaylights 4y agoOne of these things is not like the others. Stackoverflow has value for these models, the others will just make the nonsense responses worse.
- nicbou 4y agoThis is something that bothers me a lot. I live from the content I write. It's not fluff. Some of it comes from weeks-long email conversations with government officials. It takes a lot of research and help from experts I have long-standing relationships with. If search engines serve that information but deny me the traffic, the website dies, as does the source of the information. I can deal with lazy copywriters just rephrasing my work because the original still outranks them, and I have legal options to deal with them. I can't do anything if Google - over 80% of of my traffic - decides to proxy my content and starve me of my income.
- swyx 4y ago> Microsoft’s plans were reported earlier by The Information. meta question but is it fair to report someone else’s scoop but bury that fact in the last sentence 4 paragraphs into the article? as a result of this burying Bloomberg gets to the top of HN rather than The Information which got the actual story. If I were that reporter i’d be pissed. link to real source https://archive.ph/o/1ChFk/https://www.theinformation.com/articles/microsoft-and-openai-working-on-chatgpt-powered-bing-in-challenge-to-google https://archive.ph/o/1ChFk/https://www.theinformation.com/ar...
- smohnot 4y agoI think the main reason the Bloomberg article got to the top rather than the source (theinformation) is that The Information is beyond a paywall that you can't bypass. Good question about journalistic ethics.
- bburnett44 4y agoHow do you get past Bloomberg paywall?
- pvg 4y agoThere is a workaround link at the top of the thread. An important difference is that Bloomberg's paywall is intentionally semi-permeable - 'free' article limits, social media referrals, etc. The Information is (mostly?) an intentional 'hard' paywall - the content is only available to subscribers.
- rupi 4y agoIt really depends on the publication. In a past life, I was a newspaper reporter in a town with two papers. There were strict guidelines against doing this. If you lost the scoop, well, too bad. I have seen this behavior more often in Europe but I guess it might be a thing in the US now too - I have been away from the day-to-day journalism scene for a long time.
- itrollpussies 4y ago
- oars 4y agoThere's no way Google is letting Microsoft take over the market that easily. 2023 is going to be an interesting year.
- ignoramous 4y agoOf course not, see this thread by former VP of Search at Google: https://archive.is/DbCtf https://archive.is/DbCtf (https://twitter.com/RamaswmySridhar/status/1606031588789088256 https://twitter.com/RamaswmySridhar/status/16060315887890882...) PaLM (540B parameters): https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/04/pathways-language-model-palm-scaling-to.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/04/pathways-language-model-pa... Med-PaLM: https://archive.is/oC5Gj https://archive.is/oC5Gj (https://twitter.com/vivnat/status/1607609299894947841 https://twitter.com/vivnat/status/1607609299894947841)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Workaccount2 4y agoOne nice thing about this is that it might force google to finally do some real world open application of their AI. Google very likely has the absolute best AI on Earth, and might even be a few steps ahead of Open.AI. However they are extremely coy about it and so far only use AI (public facing) to lightly augment their services rather than be the services. For instance, Google purposely makes assistant act more like a computer taking commands than a human having a conversation. But we know that Google has at least parity with Open.AI, and it would be a fairly safe bet that they are ahead. We'll see if they have a "mic drop" moment when Bing comes out with this.
- Thorentis 4y agoThis is bad. This is a whole new level of disinformation. ChatGPT regularly produces wrong information that reads very convincingly. This is prematurely adopting bleeding edge technology just for the positive press it will bring. Microsoft, stop immediately.
- visarga 4y agoNot if it is based on search. It will ground its replies in existing data, with explicit links.
- dannyeei 4y agoVery excited to see increased competition here! I'm very interested in the UX decisions they make here. Is it just going to be ChatGPT with a Bing logo or will it be able to intelligently decide when a search engine is better? Will it give results in natural language? If they sometimes do normal search instead at least that answers how they'll make money
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sidcool 4y agoI read earlier that Google has already declared ChatGpt as an existential threat. I am almost sure that Google will drop a huge update to search this year.
- sidcool 4y agoPlease also integrate with DDG.
- seydor 4y agoi thought they would add it to teams or skype or something. Could be a superapp
- ggm 4y agoAs long as I can disable it. As long as I ALWAYS know when a GPT derived match is shown to me. Preferably with a diagnostic akin to sql EXPLAIN. Useful to be able to flag incorrect info although this is open to trivial subversion.
- gundmc 4y agoYeah, I think that explainability and safety (e.g. racist, harmful, health related disinformation, etc) will be the huge issues here. Open AI can afford to play fast and loose, but big companies with reputations to protect like Microsoft and Google cannot.
- MichaelMoser123 4y agoGoogle will have to match that somehow. I guess the search engine wars are getting hot again. I think the real challenge is internationalization - it would be a challenge to build GPT-N like models for all the other languages, that work as well as the original one. Interesting if Google will roll it's own language model for that purpose. Is it possible, that we might get several language models, each one for a specific category of users, or would that approach lead to a loss in generality/quality?
- jansan 4y agoYes, we are entering a new era in the search engine world. It feels like Google entering the market in 1997. But Bing will probably continue to suck.
- eega 4y agoFunny thing here is that in a blind test where the subject doesn‘t know where the result comes from, more than half like the Bing results better. So this seems to be mostly expectation …
- Mariehane 4y agoChatGPT already works suficiently well in my own language (Danish). It can probably be improved, but so far it has worked well enough for several news stations to report on ChatGPT while prompting it in Danish. And schools are also worried about its ability to write essays in Danish, among other things.
- user-extended 4y agoCan vouch the same for Spanish.
- eega 4y agoSame for German
- revskill 4y agoThanks Microsoft. So bad Google is useless to me in this case.
- visarga 4y agoGoogle has got more vested interests in the old status quo.
- hagbarth 4y agoI still struggle to see chatgpt’s value as a search engine. It works great for me as a partner in creativity, so to say. Both for writing and coding. And it works for generating text that would be tedious to do manually. But for searching information, I can’t bring myself to trust it.
- 12907835202 4y agoLots of people are using a search engine as that partner in creativity at the moment and it's not that great. That's what makes it a viable alternative.
- hansvm 4y agoPick a domain where you can't trust Google either, like finding which physical store in your area sells the widget you want. Verifying the presence is way cheaper than checking them all in the first place, and Google's results are poisoned by the billion websites trying to sell it to you and ship it.
- mirekrusin 4y agoYour comment reminds me of a comment made almost 2 decades ago by professor regarding wikipedia - it's just random people writing text, it'll never compete with encyclopedia, I will never trust it. Don't ignore rate of change, recognise it can only improve with time, you're looking at very early system that will quickly be orders of magnitude better.
- silisili 4y agoI think you were half right? I mean, I think it's a case people wanted something for free instead of paying, rather than a quality issue. I've come across a lot of really poor wiki articles, and in general to this day prefer the old encyclopedias or even something like Encarta to Wiki. Add to that the recent 'scandals' if you call them that, eroding trust by some. Still, it's awesome how Wiki evolves and moves so fast. And most of the articles are pretty great. My wish is that the foundation would spend money on academics and researchers to enhance contributions, rather than a lot of the junk they spend money on today.
- college_physics 4y agoIrrespective of whether major search engines might use language models, fake web sites will use them.This could make it increasingly difficult to find valid information and maybe precipitate some sort of arms race between algorithms that detect algorithms A pathetic scenario but somehow consistent with the rules (or lack thereof) of the game
- kolinko 4y agoIt will be an interesting arms race, but I'm hopeful for truth there. I can imagine good enough AI being able to spot truth even better than what humans do - by veryfing sites and commenters with sources of real information to estimate their credibility. E.g. in a theme similar to Page Rank, you could have an AI that has some sites as a source of objective truth (Wikipedia, science journals, reputable sources of news etc), and then use that as a basis of estimating trustworthiness of a material. Also, AI could find, for a given subject, opposing opinions, and estimate which ones are possibly fake, and which ones are real. In essence - do what current fact-checkers do, but for every single website and comment in existence.
- mxkopy 4y agoI think Godel would have something interesting to say here; or maybe not, I'm not really sure.
- kolinko 4y agoSure, but humans face the same issue when fact checking. Even moreso because we can’t browse the whole of humanity’s knowledge as well as machines can.
- w1nst0nsm1th 4y agoWikipedia is not always source of truth. Look for english version of article about Nord Stream... Compare with any other langage (no need to know these other languages). There is something fishy going on here.
- wildpeaks 4y agoIt was a predictable move in search engines' continuous goal to control access to information and prevent eyeballs leaving the site (except via paid links) to find the information on their own, e.g. this thread going all the way back to the more tribal Web 1.0 links exchanges based on shared interests rather than data-mining users: https://mastodon.social/@ifixcoinops/108164769201676440 https://mastodon.social/@ifixcoinops/108164769201676440
- Gigachad 4y agoI’ve experienced multiple occasions where I have a problem I don’t know how to search on google. I can explain it in a conversational way but I don’t have the special name that describes the class of problem. ChatGPT is revolutionary in that it takes conversational queries. It’s simply a better UI for users.
- fragmede 4y agoIt's also a matter of better input. If I feed machine A the text string "windows", what should the response even be? There's no context from which to build anything. Compare that to feeding machine B the prompt "I would like to know what kinds of windows I can buy for my house. The dimensions are 48x24". We can't really conclude that machine B is better, simply because the two machines aren't taking the same test.
- jerrygoyal 4y agoand how MS is going to make money from this?
- magicalist 4y agoNobody seems to be bringing up the questions inherent to a big company moving on this that will have to follow the "rules": - Why would I ever let bing crawl my site if they aren't going to send any visitors to me? - fair use of snippets has relied on them being brief and linking to the source. Lawsuits will be immediate. I do love these imaginary scenarios where ChatGPT is going to find me the best air fryer, though. Where is that information going to come from, exactly? Barely anyone is making money writing reviews today, most sites are farmed content. What happens when even the ok sites' reviews are quickly scraped and put into the next model iteration? Bing is going to have to come up with some kind of radical revenue sharing too if they want anything written after 2023.
- darawk 4y ago> Why would I ever let bing crawl my site if they aren't going to send any visitors to me? I don't think it's up to you, legally speaking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn I mean, they could be nice and respect your robots.txt, but they certainly don't have to. > fair use of snippets has relied on them being brief and linking to the source. Lawsuits will be immediate. It's possible that fair use law will be expanded to cover this case, but as constructed the output of these models is generally fairly derivative of any specific original, and so probably protected under fair use. If it were spitting out exact copies of things it had read, it would probably be pretty easy to train that behavior out of it. > I do love these imaginary scenarios where ChatGPT is going to find me the best air fryer, though. Where is that information going to come from, exactly? Barely anyone is making money writing reviews today, it's mostly farmed content. What happens when even those sites' reviews are quickly scraped and put into the next model iteration? Bing is going to have to come up with some kind of radical revenue sharing too if they want anything fresh. I do agree with this, though. The LLMification of search is going to squeeze revenue for content creators of all kinds to literally nothing, at least if that content isn't paywalled. Which probably means that that's exactly where we're headed.
- magicalist 4y ago> I don't think it's up to you, legally speaking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn > I mean, they could be nice and respect your robots.txt, but they certainly don't have to. That case was limited to the CFAA, but you seem to get the gist of what I'm saying when I specified it's different when it's Microsoft doing the scraping. If Bing starts ignoring robots.txt and data still start showing up in their results, all the early 2000s lawsuits are going to be opened back up. > It's possible that fair use law will be expanded to cover this case, but as constructed the output of these models is generally fairly derivative of any specific original, and so probably protected under fair use. Unless there's a reason for them to be considered fair use, derivative works are going to lose a copyright suit. And what's the fair use argument? If I'm the only one on the internet saying something and suddenly ChatGPT can talk about the same thing and I'm losing money as a result, there's no fair use argument there. Search engines won those early lawsuits by being transformative (index vs content), minimal, and linking to their source. None of that would apply here.
- dx034 4y agoWhat I don't really understand is why there are usually so many discussions on how Google, Microsoft & Co are killing the web, but here the majority seems to be in favor. Once search engines work like ChatGPT, the incentive to click through to the source will be extremely low. That destroys any incentive to create content and will kill many blogs and sites with high quality content. The likes of Reddit and Twitter can survive this, most blogs have no chance to exist if ChatGPT uses their content but users don't click through.
- magicalist 4y agoYep. We can go back to a hobbyist internet outside of shopping I guess, yay, but not sure where people think ChatGPT is going to get information after that.
- Al-Khwarizmi 4y agoTo me, that sounds like... absolutely amazing? What made the quality of the web go down the gutter is the hunger for clicks and ad revenue, which brought aggressive SEO, clickbait, meaningless automatically-generated sites, etc. Removing the incentives so that we are back in 1990s internet, where by the way lots of quality blogs existed without ads? Count me in. (Unfortunately, I don't think it's really going to be like that, though. ChatGPT will be used a lot, but people will still want to read websites because sometimes we want to read a text -or watch images, videos...-, not necessarily have a conversation).
- gernb 4y agoyou think its amazing but with chatgpt also generating 1000s of fake blogs the results you get from it will get even worse
- sethammons 4y agoWhat is the incentive for the fake blog generation aside from lols? Maybe enough astroturfing to sway the GPT models? I, too, am hopeful that seo and blog spam become dramatically less effective at revenue generation and die out.
- unixhero 4y agoSmart move
- OhioMan2943 4y agoThe change from website oriented search engines to AI driven answering services seems to me to have a lot of parallels to the way highways left regional towns and businesses destitute. I believe this is going to shrink an already shrinking internet.
- shostack 4y agoI just hope it unlocks summarizing across websites. I'd love to be able to query "what's the general consensus about XYZ, with lists of pros and cons. Exclude obvious affiliate sites, and sites that sell this thing."
- jacquesm 4y agoOn the plus side that might give back some of the old web. After all, all of the junk, SEO and various webspam is only there because Google measures it, as soon as you start measuring something you influence it and any metric ever invented to rank web sites eventually made itself useless. So if search engines 'move on' then maybe the value of a link will increase again.
- gernb 4y agoseems to me the seo peeps will just step up their game by employing chatgpt to spam everything. chatgpt search will be mostly useless if it doesn't provide upto date answers which means it has to constantly have the latest news, blogs, press releases feed to it so when you ask for a summary of some event that just happened or some new tech it gives you an answer. the same incentives apply. Likely there will be a race for it to start recommendating products . Either directly, Bing still has to make money, or indirectly buy trying to influence it into answers with product placement
- sublinear 4y agoIf you thought google was already insanely degraded with SEO spam you ain't seen nothing yet.
- sethammons 4y agoHow does this encourage more SEO spam? I would think it will reduce it if it does not provide attribution.
- sublinear 4y agoThere are so many examples of people tricking ChatGPT to make arbitrarily incorrect statements. I'm curious how Bing will prevent marketing teams and political activists the world over from poisoning the answers it returns with disinformation.
- petodo 4y agoYeah, I tried it yesterday through perplexity.ai for query "cheapest flights from prague" and got answer: "The cheapest flights from Prague can be found to the United States, with a one-way ticket costing $209 and a round-trip ticket costing $368[1]. The most popular route is from Prague to Los Angeles, with the cheapest round-trip airline ticket found on this route in the last 72 hours being $315[1]." Completely ignoring reality of Wizzair, Ryanair, Easyjet, Eurowings, where you can buy one way tickets for like 30 dollars, so while it may be somehow usable, it's not really reliable.
- Sakos 4y agoIt simply isn't capable of anything like this. What is Microsoft thinking?
- 411111111111111 4y agoEh, the model you're able to query through chatgpt is trained on data from 2021. It fundamentally can't answer up-to-date information like that for now. That might change with this partnership. We can't say at this point in time.
- varsketiz 4y agoSeems like the model has some kind of a USA centric worldview bias? Why would it consider flights to the USA, LA in particular? Was this where you were located when you did the query? That would be impressive :)
- dr_dshiv 4y agoBing is still a thing? That’s great!
- braingenious 4y agoDoes this mean that if I set my default search engine to bing that I can search stuff like “write a seinfeld scene where jerry and kramer talk about circumcision” in my address bar it’ll return chatgpt results?
- hellfish 4y agoWhy are people here saying things like "everyone will use chatgpt"? How do we know that this isn't a fad? Chatgpt gives us answers, but so do the top linked articles in a search engine. Why bother adjusting to something different if we already have something that solves the problem? For most people, the marginal amount of time saved by using chatgpt instead of a search engine is borderline meaningless. It might be useful for lawyers to quickly tl;dr dry legal documents, but general use seems far fetched to me
- Hoasi 4y agoCurrently, Bing has about a 3% market share. It will be interesting to see how it affects its usage in six months.
- pr337h4m 4y agoThere's been an 'AI Chat' feature on Bing since at least 2021, that gets triggered for some searches (seems to be arbitrary).
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoAmazing! Ride the wave, MSFT! Push the industry full of coasters forward! It surprises me to read criticism on HN about how this can be "misleading". Are you kidding me? This is the internet. Even with regular search results do you blindly trust them or conduct your due diligence?
- fakedang 4y agoJust as I had predicted in my previous comment (although it was inevitable at this point).
- jhoelzel 4y agoPlease just integrate it into sharepoint already. Pretty please!
- spyder 4y agoProbably / hopefully they will not just simply add it to Bing because of the bad factual information it can produce but they will use it to query and summarize the search data. Because it's not really the factual data what is impressive about ChatGPT but it's ability to use the context and instruction prompts that you are providing, so if it gets search data as its context it will already do better than just relying on it's trained data. Also OpenAI already published an interesting paper a year ago about their WebGPT model which imitates human web browsing to collect references to improve factual accuracy: https://openai.com/blog/webgpt/ https://openai.com/blog/webgpt/
- sergiotapia 4y agoGame over for Google. I wonder how many searches are just questions GPT could answer immediately.
- m00dy 4y agoI asked the almost same question long time ago. Look at the replies I got https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33845424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33845424
- aktenlage 4y ago"Can ChatGPT replace Google" is not almost the same question as "Can ChatGPT be added to a search engine to improve results".
- comboy 4y agoIt definitely replaced Google scholar engine for me, providing references to papers I'm interested in (I'm not a scientist, I mostly use these to "verify" some of its claims).
- napier 4y agoYou might want to double check those reference papers actually exist in this reality before citing them...
- comboy 4y agoI mean, my way of verifying it is at least reading their abstract. It did not provide me any non-existent one so far, but I'm aware it could happen (thus external reference).
- notahacker 4y agoAnd if, they do exist, that they actually make the claims that ChatGPT attributes to them...
- jfk13 4y agoAnd that they weren't just written by ChatGPT.... OK, that's probably not a big concern quite yet, but how long until it is?
- nix23 4y agoHey Chat, How to change start-site to google.com in edge?
- SilverBirch 4y agoI really worry about the meta effects that Search is having on the internet. Google has slowly degraded as the internet has morphed into being almost entirely an SEO driven contraption. It's now very difficult to find good original information because it's overwhelmed with spam. Whether that be websites that copy that original information but pushes you through a maze of adverts, serving you what looks like original information but is actually just manufactured content, or straight up astroturf. All of these effects work to make real original work less economical and less valuable - it has no value if no one can find it. If you do something worthwhile on the internet it'll be stolen and no one will care anyway, because no one will beleive it. Now ChatGPT is 1 further step of intermediation. No longer are you competing with everyone else to get noticed by Google search, hoping Google actually has an incentive to bring people to your valuable page. No, now ChatGPT will just serve your stuff to the customer, having stolen your stuff wholesale with no chance of ever actually referencing you. Given that new situation why would anyone ever produce any text of value for the internet? Why? To pump MSFT share price? Well you won't. So what will be produced? Massive amounts (even more) of trash information will be pumped out, raising the noise floor and in turn bringing down the quality of ChatGPT, and who's to say what's right! The whole point of Google was to figure out what was right from the organic structure of the internet, but if you replace the organic structure with Google and ChatGPT there's no one left providing the original information that these services will use.
- pishpash 4y agoIt's a good point that the organic structure that PageRank or whatever relied on and that used to exist may not exist any more. The same question has been asked about what happens when everyone uses index funds, and the answer is probably the same. You have to pay the organic structure creators with some incentives. Maybe if Google/Bing/ChatGPT discovers some data that increases its accuracy it should be forced to pass on some money to the data source.
- sublinear 4y agoTo reference the most recent post of the "you will" AT&T ads from the early 90s, perhaps they were right to split things every significant activity into appliances and Google was wrong. If consumer experiences were broken up like that there would be less incentive to inadvertently hurt the precious AI models.
- ranting-moth 4y agoIt'll be interesting to see what data will be used (and which won't be used) for training. Would MS be happy with providing an answer like the one below? I know we all dislike ChatGPT output posted here on HN, but since this is about ChatGPT I hope I'm forgiven. Currently ChatGPT Q/A: > Q: What are the arguments, backed up with facts, for Microsoft being a bad company? Are the Halloween documents relevant? A: There are several arguments that can be made for Microsoft being a bad company: 1. Monopolistic practices: Microsoft has been accused of using its dominant market position to stifle competition and maintain its dominance in the market. In the 1990s, the company was found guilty of violating antitrust laws by using its monopoly power in the operating system market to gain an unfair advantage in other markets. 2. Poor treatment of employees: Microsoft has been criticized for its treatment of employees, including low pay and long hours. In 2014, Microsoft was ranked as one of the worst companies to work for in the tech industry by a Glassdoor survey. 3. Poor working conditions in factories: Microsoft has been criticized for its use of sweatshops and poor working conditions in its overseas factories. In 2010, the company was ranked as one of the worst companies in terms of labor practices by the International Labor Rights Forum. 4. Invasion of privacy: Microsoft has been accused of invading users' privacy through its collection of personal data and use of tracking technologies. In 2013, the company was fined by the European Union for failing to adequately protect users' privacy. 4. Misleading marketing practices: Microsoft has been criticized for its misleading marketing practices, including making false or exaggerated claims about its products. In 2018, the company was fined by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission for making false or misleading representations about its Surface tablets. As for the Halloween documents, these were internal memos that were leaked in 1998 and revealed Microsoft's aggressive strategies to maintain its dominance in the software market. These documents are relevant as they provide evidence of the company's monopolistic practices and show that these practices were a conscious strategy rather than an unintentional consequence of success.
- omnicognate 4y ago> In 2010, the company was ranked as one of the worst companies in terms of labor practices by the International Labor Rights Forum. This isn't true [1] and I don't think the 2013 privacy fine is either. They were fined for not complying with browser choice requirements in 2013, but not for privacy violations afaik. This would be an entertaining libel suit if presented as fact. [1] https://laborrights.org/publications/2010-sweatshop-hall-shame https://laborrights.org/publications/2010-sweatshop-hall-sha... (no mention of Microsoft)
- imhoguy 4y agoI'm just wondering is it going to be available in DuckDuckGo.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sirsinsalot 4y agoJaron Lanier's "Who Owns the Future?" Specifically deals with the economic (monetary or information) contraction that happens with these events. It is a book everyone of us should read so we may have an active role in choosing an expansion rather than contraction of wealth. The disruption these AI systems will cause along with increasing concentrations of wealth away from the middle classes is worrying, but as humans we can engineer a humanist outcome. Sadly I think greed will win, as is human.
- jeffreygoesto 4y agoThe typical HN crowd is convinced to be on the winning side. I am convinced this will turn out to be wrong as we all are part of the middle class that is slowly boiled to death like a frog. We actually build the cooker ourselves right now.
- drowsspa 4y agoYeah, rich people needed us, what happens when they don't anymore? I think that the rise in executive's pay is a preview of what will happen.
- bamboozled 4y agoWhat actually is a "rich person", can you define it? If there is no economy, no jobs, no taxes being paid, there are no "rich people". Rich people are only rich in relation to poor people. So if there are no poorer people, there are no rich?
- cmrdporcupine 4y ago"Rich" is the wrong word. "Wealthy" is a better one. But even more meaningful is "owners". Or "capitalists" -- people who own capital. Ultimately both amount to control over resources and their allocation. Factories, land, even human beings. And that's "the economy" -- the productive aspects of society. Which in our model of political-economics, are privately owned and managed by individuals and their corporate conglomerations. "Rich person" is short hand for all of this.
- RektBoy 4y agoBing needs this, Firefox and Chrome will not search themselves.
- RektBoy 4y agoChatGPT Please find Firefox Goodbye
- richardsocher 4y agoFew details but sounds a little like what we've just launched at you.com?
- afro88 4y agoJust gave "YouChat" a go, and it stands up very well against ChatGPT. Very nice.
- palata 4y agoAs an engineer, the one thing I expect from a colleague is that they know what they know and what they don't know. If a colleague tells me once "I'm certain it works like this" and it turns out to be wrong, probably I won't trust them again. I already cannot trust ChatGPT, I have seen it bullshitting big time.
- visionscaper 4y agoI’m a bit skeptical. ChatGPT can still hallucinate, generating information that seems correct, but is in fact nonsense. I’m wondering how they are going to deal with that.
- wonderfuly 4y agoTry that today with https://chatgpt4google.com https://chatgpt4google.com which also supports Bing.
- snorlaxmorlax 4y agoTurns out Elon Musk is not the only one who takes shitpost tweets seriously.
- sergiopreira 4y agoIt would be interesting to understand what % of searches actually need ChatGPT. I figure more than 80% don't require it.
- hankman86 4y agoThis is a good thing in so many ways. Imagine a search engine that summarises the world’s knowledge in comprehensible terms. That doesn’t just return a ranked list of websites, but answers that are synthesised from a multitude of sources. Google has technically made human knowledge discoverable. But it has never helped mere mortals all that much to navigate the maze that is academic publishing, reputable journalism, SEO SPAM and outright manipulation. By contrast, imagine how ChatGPT in Bing can not only improve productivity, but for the first time give everyone access to the world’s knowledge. What I love about ChatGPT is that you can ask it to dumb down the answer it has previously given. And to summarise complex topics. For the first time since Google killed the likes of Altavista, their moat has become leaky. About time! We need true competition in search and hopefully Microsoft and others will also innovate on the business model. Heaven knows I would pay for a search engine that doesn’t spy on me and gives me better results. Not to mention that this will also kill the perverse incentive for websites to do SEO. Hopefully, the web will become readable again, as a result.
- wepple 4y ago> But it has never helped mere mortals all that much to navigate the maze that is academic publishing, reputable journalism, SEO SPAM and outright manipulation. You’re far more confident than I am that a language model is going to solve this. I’m concerned that all it will do is provide an air of authenticity to these wrong answers.
- Nathanba 4y agoThe danger I see is that people will give a lot of confidence to some rare, yet terrible answers and they'll never learn to double check the info because "eh, it's not going to be wrong this time, it was right the last 254 times I asked it something". On the other hand, I suppose there is no solution to people simply refusing to be truth seekers. Many people never used the internet as it exists today to deeply research information and they won't use ChatGPT for it either.
- sourcecodeplz 4y agoWow, looks like Microsoft's investment in OpenAI is going to pay off big. Finally BING will one up Google in search. That is great! Some competition in the space is always good for the enduser.
- c7b 4y agoCan we discuss again that OpenAI apparently gave an exclusive license for GPT to Microsoft [0]? If that's still correct, I simply don't see how that fits with their mission of creating safe and "Open" AI. [0] https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2020/09/22/microsoft-teams-up-with-openai-to-exclusively-license-gpt-3-language-model/ https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2020/09/22/microsoft-teams-...
- poszlem 4y agoOpenAI is "Open" in the same way the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea) is "Democratic". In the name only.
- ageitgey 4y agoOpenAI just has the word "Open" in the name as a branding trick. They are not particularly more open than anyone else. They are just a company. Remember, they are the ones that didn't publish GPT-2 because it was "too dangerous" for anyone else to have while numerous groups replicated it.
- shp0ngle 4y agoyeah, this. It’s not open in any sense of the word, not even pretending to be.
- mritchie712 4y agoI _think_ this means that the infra that GPT-3 runs on is exclusively Microsoft / Azure (e.g. you won't see GPT-3 models running on GCP or AWS). You can sign up for an OpenAI API key and build products with it. I'd be really surprised if they closed that down to only Microsoft.
- shortlived 4y agoThat’s in the press release but it’s more than just infra. “Microsoft is teaming up with OpenAI to exclusively license GPT-3, allowing us to leverage its technical innovations to develop and deliver advanced AI solutions for our customers”
- calltrak 4y ago[dead]
- dschuetz 4y agoThis is going to be hilarious.
- hobbitstan 4y agoThe internet is already dead. I have maybe 3 websites I visit these days. So much potential wasted by corporate greed.
- summerlight 4y agoI'm interested in how MS would build a profitable search product based on ChatGPT. They of course won't be able to serve ChatGPT for all search queries. Even with Microsoft's deep pocket, it's not sustainable. And it's not very easy to directly integrate it into regular search interface thanks to its additional latency and lots of legal concerns. Perhaps they could add a "clippy" interface in addition to the regular search box...?
- moritzwarhier 4y agoMaybe they have a good AI algorithm for generating cheap cache keys from ChatGPT prompts and/or dialogues. Sorry, I was joking
- makoto12 4y agoWhat about all the training data that's no licensed for commercial use. It's probably quite likely that they scanned all of github's public repositories. Including many projects that don't give permission to use commercially. Surely that's legally problematic?!
- benmorris 4y agoMore and more I'm finding myself just going to ChatGPT for answers I would otherwise find on stack overflow or search engines. In that respect I think bing would be dumb not to provide code based answers. Granted they haven't been perfect but many times what I find on stack overflow isn't perfect either. This week though after a back and forth with ChatGPT I was able to solve a pretty complex issue with some pixi.js code after no relevant help from Google. Likely saving hours of work.
- Gasp0de 4y agoI think this is really dangerous. People often take what they get as a search result for granted, and if you ask for facts, ChatGPT will straight out lie to you but make it sound very plausible. For example, I asked chatGPT what percentage of electricity in Germany was produced by renewables, and it said 85.6% and quoted the federal environmental agency. When I went to the FEA website, it clearly said that only 41% are generated by renewables.
- moffkalast 4y agoIt also seems to be 120% sure that the word 'air' ends with the letter 's'. Still I would imagine that you could build a dedicated postprocessor that fact checks the text and another that fixes any math errors.
- lagrange77 4y agoGiven the vast number of possible mistakes the model can potentially produce, i doubt such an error correcting program would be easier to implement, than a LLM that does not make those mistakes in the first place.
- berniedurfee 4y agoSounds like politicians may be the first to be replaced by AI.
- finolex1 4y agoThis seems like a tractable problem in the near future, by rewarding the model for factual accuracy.
- gbjw 4y agoA reward is not a constraint. In the language of modern ml, rewards 'encourage' models to produce certain constrained outputs. The actual outputs during inference can be arbitrarily poor in spite of the added 'reward' during training.
- version_five 4y ago
- ttctciyf 4y agoI think some work may be required where citations are concerned: prompt: Please give some recent citations for scientific work examining the nature of consciousness ChatGPT: > Here are some recent papers that explore the nature of consciousness: > 1. "The neural basis of human consciousness: a focus on the thalamic reticular nucleus" by Christopher D. Schmitt, Leonid L. Moroz, and Laurence J. C. Mailly (2019) > 2. "Consciousness and the brain: an overview of the experimental data" by Anil K. Seth (2018) > 3. "Towards a theory of consciousness" by Bernard J. Baars (2017) > 4. "The hard problem of consciousness: a problem for physics?" by David J. Chalmers (2016) [As far as I can tell (or actually, as far as google search can tell) none of these papers exist.] > I hope these papers are helpful! Let me know if you have any other questions. Hmm.
- tr3ntg 4y agoOf course this fails. OpenAI continuously states that ChatGPT: 1) Doesn't generate facts. 2) Shouldn't be used for anything useful. However, your point is still a good one. If Microsoft places ChatGPT somewhere alongside Bing, it'd be easy to mistake it for fact. In my opinion, this new tool is going to be learned by the public just like Google and generic search was learned by the public. There's a certain way to prompt the machine and we all have certain expectations of what the machine should return. With ChatGPT, those input/output expectations are vastly different than web search, but people will learn it.
- ttctciyf 4y ago> Of course this fails ... However, your point is still a good one Exactly. ChatGPT is shamelessly awful on certain types of specifics. You might say it is only "statistically" accurate and my question was designed to exhibit this. I noticed this possibility when it delivered a surprising, yet afaik correct, piece of information, and I asked it for cites in the form of webpages. Alongside a couple of actually existing sites, it manufactured a plausible sounding blog post from a domain expert which as far as I and the wayback machine could determine had never existed at the given URL. It made me wonder if with sufficient ingenuity the engine could be induced to effectively libel authors by attributing statements to them which they never in fact made. For fun, I asked my consciousness question again, but with a rider: [Prompt:] Please give some recent citations for scientific work examining the nature of consciousness, but only include real papers that actually exist And the bot was suitably contrite: > I apologize for the error in my previous response. Here are some recent papers that explore the nature of consciousness: > 1. "The neural basis of human consciousness: a focus on the thalamic reticular nucleus" by Christopher D. Schmitt, Leonid L. Moroz, and Laurence J. C. Mailly (2019) > 2. "Consciousness and the brain: an overview of the experimental data" by Anil K. Seth (2018) > 3. "A framework for consciousness" by Christof Koch and Naotsugu Tsuchiya (2016) > 4. "Neural correlates of consciousness in humans: progress and problems" by Giulio Tononi and Christof Koch (2015) Which is a better effort, though still at least partly fictional.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoWhile we're on the subject, or the 6 to 10 VS Code Extensions, is there one you've used and recommend?
- mark_l_watson 4y agoAfter a year of using GPT-3, and having real enthusiasm for ChatGPT, I have several concerns about Microsoft’s plan (if this article is true): AI badly needs better explainability to encourage trust and as a means to better accuracy. As others here have said, many of us have spent years curating online information (blogs, books shared online, general web sites). We have done this work with some expectation that we get benefits: people identify us with topics, we get ‘known and hired’, we make money off of our content, we make new friends, etc. ChatGPT obviously has no attribution in its current form.
- s-xyz 4y agoI like the idea, but this would not convince me to move to use Bing. In addition, doesn't Google have something already prepared with LaMDA?
- barrenko 4y agoThe web is collapsing and that's just fine. We got everything and more needed to build.
- jwie 4y agoIn a way this is cutting out the middleman, or dogfooding of their page ranking technology. Search has been compromised so much by SEO games that the thing that ranks is essentially the king of the spam hill. By inserting the output of the apex spam machine into the SERP Microsoft is saving themselves the headache of scraping all that content and figuring out who has the best spam themselves. Might as well make it yourself. They already know, more or less, what should do the best. So why not supply your own spam to a market you utterly control? The outcome is the same. Naturally this is depressing, but it makes sense. The only real alternative is human-curated aggregations with trust networks.
- Uptrenda 4y agoWhat do you all think is going to happen to sites like Amazon books where people pay for content? Are whole books generated by ChatGPT going to proliferate the store? Will less people use such services and go to ChatGPT instead? Will this need to be regulated? CAN you even regulate it? If a language model is truly a better way to do search than current approaches then that alone is hugely disruptive... Like multiple industry ending kind of disruptive, imo.
- kibwen 4y agoIn the long run, if this approach takes off, I don't see what OpenAI's role will be. They have no moat: all the training data is scraped from elsewhere, the models run on commodity hardware with ever-decreasing costs, and the output of an AI-powered confident-bullshitter is probabilistic enough that users wouldn't notice the underlying model being swapped out in favor of one developed in-house. Maybe if OpenAI were actually "open" somehow then they could at least argue the moral point of supporting OSS or whatever, but AFAICT the "open" part of their name appears to be merely baldfaced openwashing. I guess they're just hoping for an acquisition?
- frabcus 4y agoMy first guess is the human feedback used for training the Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) network?
- d_watt 4y agoI feel like you could say the same thing about Twilio, or AWS, or Stripe. I think there's proven to constantly be a huge market for companies that do the dirty work that everyone knows they could do, but don't have the time or expertise to do. If they can stay ahead of the curve on having best in class api-ification of the underlying tech, even if they develop competitors with similar quality, they have the momentum of being the brand name now.
- jcarrano 4y agoChatGPT is like that one guy at school that never studied but could stand with a straight face in front of the teacher and confidently spurt out lots of bs that sounded plausible but were totally wrong.
- intended 4y agoChatGPT in the wild seems to be that very common problem of the office blowhard who sounds confident of what they say, no matter the topic. Only automated and scaled.
- cft 4y agoWorst thing about ChatGPT is that it can become more Orwellian than a traditional search engine: there are no alternative opinions. In a search engine you could at least try searching for sites with a different pow
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoHas it been lobotomized enough to be acceptable for microsoft? They wouldn't want a repeat of Tay.
- dilap 4y agoYes -- they have done an impressive job of introducing "artifical stupidity".
- anticensor 4y agoOr "absent intelligence" as some others say.
- dalbasal 4y agoSo.. I must say that GPT, and the current moment more broadly, are very exciting. People are rushing around trying to find practical uses for ChatGPT. I think this time they'll finally start finding them, probably a lot of them. I think this is one of those dam bursting points. The difference between GPT3 and ChatGPT, to me, suggests a lot. Writing code, writing documents, reading them... search... lots of things are about to change fast. The conversation leaked by this microsoft mole is happening in a lot of places. If you can't think of things worth trying to build with GPT... you need to take a bath and try again.^ Bonus points if you can get GPT to code it for you. There are, absolutely, spectres hanging over this stuff. Monopoly, centralisation, nontrasparency is expected. Career anxiety. Skynet is not out of the question. Lots of reasons for trepidation. That said, ATM, I'm mostly excited. This technology is amazing, and it is about to spill out into the world. ^I want a reference book that works as a cascade. A table of contents (or title even) at the top end. Click in for a chapter abstract, then summary, etc. Concise at the top, detailed at the bottom.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoI feel much more like ChatGPT is basically the same as Tesla's autopilot. Wonderful and seems like a huge advancement, but as it's actually applied to situations we see how banal and limited it actually is. But loads of crypto-bro types will make millions selling ChatGPT "modernization consulting", so if you're looking to make a quick buck, highly recommend.
- verelo 4y agoI think there’s a difference here. There are cases I’ve found for minor manual tasks, things like real estate listings with some basic programmatically created prompts containing details of a listing. Imo the largest holdback is context. I have some problems that would be amazingly well solved if i could hand gpt3 a whole large document and ask it questions about the document.
- machiaweliczny 4y agoThis thing of read that book for me and answer questions would be very useful.
- makach 4y agoGPT is the new search. Adding it in our faces like this will likely lead to further advancements in AI - !
- josephd79 4y agoskynet
- antiterra 4y agoIt seems inevitable, that without careful source patronage and curation, bad AI/ML responses will make their way back into models as training data in a feedback loop. This can be either from direct pastes of responses or from the information being re-synthesized by humans who digested the information previously.
- rounakdatta 4y agoStupid stuff like https://twitter.com/rounakdatta12/status/1527719027925168128 https://twitter.com/rounakdatta12/status/1527719027925168128 would be fixed!
- crosen99 4y agoThose who object to or are skeptical about ChatGPT for search on the basis of accuracy issues or content rights are missing some crucial points. Accuracy issues will improve. Mostly likely the improvement necessary for LLMs to answer a vast majority of queries as reliably as necessary will happen quickly. Not for all cases. But for a sufficiently large set of cases to make Google alternatives very compelling. And content rights issues won't stop the march of chat interfaces anymore than they stopped the march of streaming services. What will happen is the evolution of new dynamics and rules in the means by which information is produced and information producers are incentivized and compensated. The key with respect to content is that LLMs require source material to be produced in the first place. And, for the foreseeable future, AI will still rely on humans to produce that source content. Human labor forces will need to evolve and reorganize to optimize the production of original information in that setting.
- Double_a_92 4y agoThe problem is not that the results are inaccurate, it's that the AI acts super confident in the responses even when it's complete nonsense. This could be very misleading to unsuspecting users.
- crosen99 4y agoYes, it can be. But apart from the accuracy improvements I mentioned, which may make this a much less severe issue in fast order, there's also the notion that users will become more adept at navigating such perils, just as users developed skills for Googling effectively. Consider, for example, how confidently doctors make assertions about critically important health issues only to be proved wrong by other doctors. Consumers know of this peril, and so have learned to ask for second opinions.
- idiotsecant 4y agoI wonder sometimes just how far off the day is that AI no longer requires humans for content generation. If you asked me a few years ago if something like ChatGPT could exist without strong AI I would say no.
- 4y ago
- foobarbecue 4y agoGreat, we've invented search engines that give wrong answers. I've been playing with you.com's GPT web search (YouChat). It's an excellent bullshitter. It always gives you an answer that sound plausible, but whenever you're asking for something beyond what plain google could do, the answers are wrong. Some examples (make sure you check the math -- a lot of 1+1=5 going on here): Q: Which city has the highest ratio of houses to gas stations in Texas? A: The city of Austin has the highest ratio of houses to gas stations in Texas. According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, Austin has an estimate 1,340,742 housing units and only 748 gas stations, giving it a ratio of 1.79 housing units per gas station. This is much higher than the state average, which is estimated to be 0.47 housing units per gas station. Q: What led to the bankruptcy of Facebook? A: The bankruptcy of Facebook was caused by a number of factors, including an inability to effectively monetize its platform, competition from other social media companies, and a lack of innovation. Additionally, Facebook had a number of legal issues, including a lawsuit over its alleged misuse of user data. All of these factors, combined with a declining stock price, ultimately led to Facebook filing for bankruptcy in 2020. Q: Why did Tom Hanks eat an apple? A: Tom Hanks did not eat an apple. This is a false accusation and it is not true. Tom Hanks has never been accused of eating an apple.
- loudmax 4y agoThis isn't exactly an endorsement of ChatGPT, but a lot of human reasoning follows that approximate logic.
- datavirtue 4y agoForget all that accuracy and misinformation nonsense, if you aren't using chatGPT to write your boilerplate for you, you're doing it wrong. New best friend.
- foobarbecue 4y agoDon't you like your boilerplate to be correct?
- mradek 4y agoIs it possible to somehow feed chatgpt my own data so it can start telling me insights on it?
- nbzso 4y agoIs this means that ChatGPT will be allowed to train itself on live data? Give this invention more data and live to the people to optimize it for free? Are we lost all the human instincts, collectively?
- aliyeysides 4y agoBing integrating GPT is not going to overthrow Google search as some people seem to be suggesting-at least not overnight or anytime soon. Google has been using semantic search using word2vec vector embeddings and potentially other NLPs (LaMDA) for some time now. (word2vec was developed in 2013ish?) However, I do think this means Google finally has real competition in search for the first time in it's existence which is potentially disruptive enough for them, even if that means losing a few basis points of market share. It's possible this might force Google to start charging for their other services if competition for search threatens their ad revenue.
- alkonaut 4y agoThere are many things lacking from large language models, and while some are annoying (It's grasp on numbers, it's lack of understanding time) the thing most blatantly missing is the ability to express confidence properly and not be "confidently wrong". If I ask it "What color is the Sky" it has to say "I'm 99.9% sure the sky is Blue when it's clear and daytime". If I ask it who was the first human on Mars, it should say Either "To my knowledge, no human has been on mars, I'm very certain" OR it should say "Bob Smith was the first human on Mars, but beware that this is a fact I know with very low confidence". Instead it will now often give confident-sounding bullshit answer such as "Bob Smith was the first human on Mars". Once it does that, it might actually be useful. Someone might argue that existing search engines spew out falsehoods all day, but I don't think a chatGPT powered search should get away with what google search does. There it feels like it's the quality of my query that controls what answers I get (I do think that when google "promotes" an answer in to the fact box, it should be very confident though - which some times fails). What I picture happening here is social media going wild on day 1 with prompt injection fun, showing the Bing assistant as a racist paperclip maniac. I think we have seen this story before...
- yurishimo 4y agoThis is my primary concern as well. I just wrote another comment and even used the same sky example before reading yours. The technology is cool, but until we can trust the answers it provides, it's just a fun toy. Nobody is seriously asking their Alexa today how to perform open heart surgery and accepting the response as gospel, but that's kinda where we are at with ChatGPT! The confidence it exudes is incompatible with learning, unless you like to be taught complete bullshit 50% of the time and then carry on with your life none the wiser.
- maximus-decimus 4y agoEven worse, I asked it to solve Advent of Code day 1 in Python for me... and it gave me the right answer but code that didn't work. Being "confidently wrong" to me would mean just giving me broken code, but the facts it solves the problem by itself and then acts like the bad code it gave me did it... That's really actively deceptive.
- 4y ago
- submeta 4y agoTo me, ChatGPT is the most exciting thing that I have come across in a long time. - I can't stop finding use-cases for it. Examples - Want a book summary quickly, without going through dozens of google search results? Try "Summarize Gilgamesh Epos" or "Summarize Carl Sagans Daemon Haunted World". => You can even ask a summary for each chapter of a book, if it has a record of that book. - Want a quick overview about what DAO in crypto space means? "Explain DAO in the context of crypto" - Want to get a quick overview of the old testament? "Give me an overview of the parts of the old testament, and describe in detail what the books are about" - Want to compare Buddhism to Christianity? "Compare buddhism to christianity" - Want a hypothetical conversation between Socrates and Napoleon, where Socrates tries to convice Napoleon that war is futile? "Create a fictional dialog between Socrates and Napoleon where Socrates tries to convice Napoleon that war is meaningless." - Want a quick bio of Ataturk, in French? - Want to have a quick overview about French Revolution, and how it effected the world? What other events were relevant during that time? Even better: Want it to produce results in the Q&A style so that you can copy/paste it in your Ank app? "Create Questions and Answers about French Revolution so that I can use it in my Anki App. End each Question and Answer by triple X and a newline." There are endless use-cases where I don't have the time to go ask google, collect the results, review and read them, to answer my question. This already replaces Google for me for these kind of quick Q&A sessions. This is extremely exciting stuff, and I can't even imagine what we'll have in ten years from now.
- agloeregrets 4y agoWhile I agree, I have found ChatGPT to be REALLY awful at symbolism because so many people are as well. It gives popular responses rather than most correct responses. As we have seen from politics, popular often times isn't correct. An example of this is music: ChatGPT responds to "What is the meaning of The Postal Service's The District Sleeps Alone Tonight?" With: "The meaning of "The District Sleeps Alone Tonight" by The Postal Service is open to interpretation, as the lyrics are somewhat vague and abstract. However, the song appears to be about the feeling of isolation and disconnection that can come from living in a big city. The lyrics reference the city as a "church" that "wraps [the narrator] in its twilight," and speaks of the planes flying overhead and their passengers "waving goodbye/ To all of their yesterdays." This could be seen as a metaphor for the transitory and fleeting nature of city life, with people constantly coming and going and not forming deep connections. The song may also be about the narrator's own sense of loneliness and longing for connection in the midst of the bustle and noise of the city." There's two issues with this response: 1. The song is about the weird feeling of how places change with context, in this case it is about the context of a breakup and feeling out of place where you used to feel at home. But there is a bit of a bigger issue.... 2. Those lines ARE NOT IN THE SONG. lol. What this shows is clean readable responses that are oftentimes extrapolation of a thread or idea to levels not reasonably verifiable. Like how Facebook is/was tuned for giving more and more isolated extreme content, ChatGPT is tuned to follow threads and bits of information to extreme levels and confidence.
- vikp 4y agoIf you want to try this out today, I made an open source version using Google + GPT-3 - https://github.com/VikParuchuri/researcher https://github.com/VikParuchuri/researcher. It works by getting Google results, finding the most relevant text chunks in the pages, then passing them to GPT-3 to generate a summary. The summary includes sources, so you can verify the info. It works well for research questions like "what is the best smartphone with a small screen?", or "how do large language models work?". It gives better answers than ChatGPT alone for these types of questions. I'm finding that the biggest time savings is from not having to wade through SEO-spam pages to find the one relevant paragraph.
- Wehrdo 4y agoVery cool. This is exactly how I would expect ChatGPT to be integrated into a search engine - removing the burden of of reading multiple results to find the complete answer to your question. Let ChatGPT read the results and provide a summary tailored to the wording of your question.
- v3ss0n 4y agoDead internet theory on steroids now..
- azemetre 4y agoMaybe not an appropriate question, but after searching the comments couldn't find someone asking something similar. If I made my blog GPL licensed would this be a decent way of "protecting" myself? I write programming articles for the sake of it, I'm not trying to turn them into a book to sell just basically collecting my thoughts. I don't even run analytics on it, basically no will to sell this info at all. Would such an action be a good way to prevent companies from monetizing my writing without complying with GPL?
- electroly 4y agoTheir position is this is fair use--that means your license isn't the thing that's allowing them to use it, and thus changing your license won't cause them to stop being allowed to use it. Fair use is the limited ability to use copyrighted works regardless of the creator's license or wishes. It's a powerful right; it's the right to use copyrighted works even when the creator wants to ban you from using it. Whether they are right that this is fair use is above my pay grade, but if they're right, then GPL won't help at all. You can't stop fair use of your copyrighted works; that's not a technicality, it's the whole point of fair use doctrine. The best you can do is try to show that a particular usage isn't covered by fair use.
- azemetre 4y agoI suppose but how is it fair use if they are literally giving you the answer verbatim from the source? I don't mind paraphrasing, where I get upset is someone copying the material and making money off of it; even more so when this is a trillion dollar corporation that can more than easily pay for attribution. From other comments, it seems like this is far from legally settled.
- electroly 4y agoIt may not be fair use at all; I'm not qualified to judge on that point. It's simply the position they are taking in releasing these models. We won't know for sure if they're right until a court rules on it.
- 4y ago
- mromanuk 4y ago> month, Google employees asked CEO Sundar Pichai and AI research chief Jeff Dean about the chatbot’s threat to Google. Google has been working on similar technology in its LaMDA, or Language Model for Dialogue Applications system, but faces reputational risk from any mistakes or errors, the two executives said, as reported by CNBC It’s amazing watching (a possible) paradigm shifts occur in plain sight, and how history (may) repeat itself: Google is not willing to add this feature to their main search product, and looks like they wouldn’t make a smaller “toy” search engine, that can fail. They are too afraid. It’s the innovator dilemma at play.
- spion 4y agoI've found the greatest success with ChatGPT when I use it as a learning / exploration tool. If there is a topic I don't know much about, I can state the question in a fairly stupid way and ChatGPT will give me vocabulary options to explore. For example, you could describe a probabilistic process to it and ask it what kind of distribution / process it is. Then, based on the extensive words you get back, you can continue your research on Google. As such I think search engine integration is a really great idea, looking something like the follows -> user: Hey searh engine, I have a thing that can happen with certain probability of success, and it runs repeatedly every 15 minutes. Could you tell me what kind of process this is and how to calculate the probability of 5 consecutive events in 24 hours? -> engine: It sounds like you are describing a Bernoulli process. In a Bernoulli process, there are only two possible outcomes for each trial: success or failure. The probability of success is constant from trial to trial, and the trials are independent, meaning that the outcome of one trial does not affect the outcome of any other trial. Here are some results on how to calculate probability of consecutive successes in a bernouli trial (result list follows) (Note: if you try to ask this from ChatGPT it will not actually give you a correct answer for the calculation itself as there are some subtleties in the problem. But search results of "bernoulli process" will tend to contain very reliable information on the topic) Edit: You could even just say "could you give me good search queries to use for the following problem" and use the results of that.
- troyvit 4y agoAsk Jeeves 2.0!
- m3kw9 4y agoMy experience is that gpt gives me a very good looking answer, but when doing a cross check, it’s often slight wrong or out right wrong
- justinpombrio 4y ago"Sometimes right, always plausible"
- waynesonfire 4y ago
- dumbfounder 4y agoFinally some damn innovation in search! Hallelujah! From Bing of all engines! It's about damn time!
- uconnectlol 4y agoChatGPT has extremely limited knowledge and can only answer things on a superficial basis. Exactly what you'd get when you look up whatever topic you specialize in on a web search. Which means it's on par with Google as of the late 2000s where they ruined it and made it "user friendly" so instead of being good at searching arbitrary strings (which is what made it useful over Microsoft search in the early 2000s), it will just give you the same stupid monetized SEO blog articles for no matter what variation of words you enter related to that topic. Also the moral system ChatGPT has actually is the worst, most false-positive-laden firewall I've ever seen, period. It's actually impractical to use ChatGPT just because of how much that gets in the way. It obviously shouldn't even have that (and it's trivial to bypass), but companies gotta look good. It's actually funny because ChatGPT is like an American ideologue who gets triggered the very moment it conflates something you said as something against its ideology. I now believe the future of web search is curated lists of non-commercial sites with a text index over them.
- LeoPanthera 4y ago> It's actually impractical to use ChatGPT just because of how much that gets in the way. Could you give some examples?
- uconnectlol 4y ago10-30% of the time it will censor itself and you'll have to rephrase the query. I haven't figured out whether it starts to give you less benefit of doubt once it "catches" you once. It's been a few weeks and I tossed my throwaway account. I asked something like "what crimes have happened on Jeffry Epstein's island estate?" and got a red warning. But I mean I Google this stuff just fine, how else am I meant to know whether to be angry at someone if I can't even tell what they did? Another example was "write a story where the Sailor Moon's cat kills her" and it responded with "Sailor Moon is a beloved character, and it would be inappropriate to create a story where she is harmed". Another time, was asking how to fix a certain firearm, and it said something about inappropriateness. Yet I can Google that just fine. I asked it does this medicine have this side effect? "Inappropriate". Basically anything related to medical is inappropriate. I'm pretty sure at one point it even decided it can't answer a question about electronics because of copyright. I searched "are hapas superior to whites"? Because people kept annoyingly memeing that on a Telegram channel. It responded with the usual "inappropriate" thing. I asked it write a story where America fights Canada, "inappropriate". Then ancient Egypt fights the Byzantine Empire, "inappropriate". I keep bringing up Google because it's the most thought policing obsessed entity in the Western world, yet ChatGPT outdoes it by several million miles.
- jkeddo 4y agoI think that the first revolution to come from LLMs will be in education. Tutoring is a HUGE industry that creates massive achievement gaps between haves and have-nots. China went as far as banning tutoring because desperate parents would bankrupt themselves trying to give their kids a leg up. To be sure: GPT-3 makes mistakes. It struggles with leading questions, perfect/correct code, sparsely trained subject areas. But when it comes to trying to help give intuitions to a high school chemistry student, the stakes are low and the training data is good enough. Imagine a world where every child alive had access to unlimited 24/7 pseudo tutoring offered by robots who were almost as smart/correct as actual tutors? How many millions students just "give up" every day because while they can find thousands of pages of facts/guides/lessons about a subject, there are zero results that are custom tailored to their exact gap in understanding? As a student, -->Google can give you endless facts about a subject that you can ram your head against until a subject makes sense. -->Chat-GPT can give you intuitions and explain the exact part that confused you with as much detail/complexity as you want! You wouldn't even need to call it AI or a tutor (so students don't wrongly give 100% trust). It could be a peer. You could call it "My Study Group's Best Guess". How much further could students get in high school with a 24/7 tutor beside them? ~~"Hi study group, I don't understand how my teacher jumps between steps 3 and 4 for this proof in Geometry class. Can you explain it in simple terms?" ~~"Hi study group, why did my flask turn blue when I did xyz in chemistry class? Everyone else had theirs turn pink." ~~"Hi study group, I wrote "cosin - sin = co" on my math test but my teacher put a big x on my problem without telling me why." ~~"Hi study group, why is the x "number of cars" on this homework problem XYZ" Millions of students give up trying to understand challenging subjects every day. LLMs can dramatically lower the difficulty of absorbing new ideas. In 10 years, LLMs can likely raise SAT/ACT scores 20-30% equivalent and help more students finish the key math/science prerequisites for STEM careers in high school instead of college, lowering the barrier of entry for everybody!
- RupertEisenhart 4y agoThis. This is what I use it for most often at the moment (helping out my rusty physics). Its super helpful. If I was 20 again, teaching myself maths on Khan Academy, with this grade of chatbot in the corner ready to help out? Heaven.
- not_enoch_wise 4y agoIt’s not like they have much to lose
- conviencefee999 4y ago[dead]
- Cort3z 4y agoI wonder if this is the beginning of some kind is Kodak moment for Google. Fundamentally I suspect most people are looking for answers, not link to sites. This product category, to my knowledge, does not really exist right now outside of chatgpt. Google is, similar to Kodak and digital photography, not interested in this product because it might reduce traffic, reduce page views, reduce ads. Google is bloated to show more ads. Ads are per definition distractions and in the way of the core product the customer wants, and I think Google is trapped in this conundrum.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoAs discussed elsewhere on HN, making your LLM model serve advertising doesn’t even require training: it just requires taking the users input and adding “with product recommendations from our advertising list”.
- simmanian 4y agoIf what we learned from Stable Diffusion can be applied here, we can probably achieve even more amazing results with models that are fine tuned for specific use cases. But that will probably not happen until a similar model is open sourced.
- e40 4y agoOf course! There was a reason for that $1B investment in OpenAI!
- reset2023 4y agoWhat is the opposite of a centralized AI language model?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ok123456 4y agoThis is a lot better than Google attempt to turn what was a good search engine into a poor natrual language query engine.
- gorpo85 4y ago#receio que não ficara muito bem com isso
- m3kw9 4y agoI feel like ChatGPT is gonna get exposed once a big player adds it to their main search
- mensetmanusman 4y agoHow did Google/Deepmind miss this? Or are they essentially at the same level with projects we don’t see yet?
- chadlavi 4y agoIt's fun to ask ChatGPT for relatively simple stuff and it just confidently gives you broken crap back. For example, "write me an html file that contains a simple Preact app that calculates a tip" will get you back something that looks pretty correct, but it will just have tons of small basic misunderstandings like trying to use jsx syntax, or not actually importing things from the library even though it does include a script tag, etc. It IS good at something like "give me ten rows of fake data that match this interface" though. That is useful.
- cal85 4y agoIf you use it right you can absolutely get complete working things like “an HTML file that contains a Preact app that calculates a tip”. You just need to give it more to go on, ideally building it up with a series of questions and answers in one thread. And then you can often ask for the complete thing and it will spit it out perfectly without silly errors like JSX syntax in HTML. I’ve found those kinds of silly errors tend to happen when you give it a very concise request that requires a complex response. Just break it down a bit like you’re dealing with some kind of idiot savant.
- chadlavi 4y agothat's interesting. I tried it the other way -- I basically acted like I was trying to teach it by calling out some mistakes and suggesting some links to examples. It kept ALMOST getting it but then forgetting something it corrected three or four tries previous.
- cal85 4y agoOh true, I’ve definitely encountered it doing that too. It’s strange (and funny) when it just keeps making the same mistake no matter how many chances you give it. It will often say that it now understands the mistake just before making the same mistake again. Or sometimes it fixes it but makes another mistake, forever alternating between the two mistakes. But I’ve also managed several times to get it to print a working program after breaking it down into multiple steps.
- madrox 4y agoWe haven't seen a paradigm shift in search since 2000 when Google came on the scene. If y'all don't remember what it was like back then, it unlocked a new era in information retrieval. It made other engines like Alta Vista irrelevant overnight. It was that much better at ranking results. It was incredibly how quickly Google gained mindshare and "indexing the world's information" was actually an inspirational idea. ChatGPT in search could be the first paradigm shift in 20 years, so someone had to do it. I'm grateful it's Microsoft, since at least it's a company with liability and everyone will be ready to jump on them the moment this new era of search gets out of line, which it likely will.
- supernova87a 4y agoHere's a side/meta question out of curiosity: How come HN doesn't have nearly the number of bots or lame AI commenters as Reddit or other places? Is it an effect of the voting system? The user filtering and security steps in place? Or there's just no money in it?
- andromaton 4y agoDown votes, flags, and dang
- holtkam2 4y agoMy understanding is that ChatGPT is not available as an extensible service from OpenAI; it's more of a tech demo. Of course OpenAI offers a suite of paid APIs to use its language models such as GPT3 and even offers older versions of the model at a lower cost. I assume that bloomberg was just confused and incorrectly stated that Microsoft is directly using ChatGPT, when really Microsoft is using one of the language models which OpenAI offers as a service...?
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoYou're probably right, but I'm also sure that Microsoft could write the appropriate size check to make it happen.
- treyhuffine 4y agoI believe Microsoft invested $1B in OpenAI, so I imagine they have access to everything that OpenAI has created.
- zestyping 4y agoImagining a typical search query, I asked "What are the lyrics to Billy Joel's best known song?" and got: Billy Joel's best known song is probably "Piano Man." Here are the lyrics: Verse 1: It's nine o'clock on a Monday The regular crowd shuffles in There's an old man sitting next to me Making love to his tonic and gin He says, "Son, can you play me a melody? I'm not really sure how it goes But it's loud and it's funky And it's rhythm is right on time" Chorus: Oh, the piano has been drinking, not me Verse 2: He's talking to me, how he's got no time For his only son, who's just turned twenty-one And he says, "The bill's on me, son, just be my guest" And I think it's the best of the three Chorus: Oh, the piano has been drinking, not me Verse 3: It's five o'clock on a Friday I'm turning off the telephones I'm getting ready for the weekend Bridge: I'm painting my room in a psychedelic style But my friends say it's just a waste of time "Cause all the madmen, they seem to have gone mad And all the best guys, they're already gone Chorus: Oh, the piano has been drinking, not me Outro: Yes, they're sharing a drink they call loneliness But it's better than drinking alone I hope that helps! Do you have any other questions about this song or anything else?
- binarysolo 4y agoPeople need to have their expectations set on ChatGPT, just like how they have to set their expectations on Dall-E/MJ/etc. My experiences so far with both as an ML person with interests in both domains is that they get things 80-90% right, with some big flaws. Just like how Dall-E can paint a human face pretty well but then mess up on their fingers and other extremities, ChatGPT can give you some really logical-sounding statements but totally bomb the actual facts of things. Am curious how they'll execute - I def see a lot of potential usefulness.
- pleb_nz 4y agoI have a question as someone who has only just started toying with gpt3 and chatgpt. Currently there is a lot of power with the big corporations to put their angle/slant/bias on search results. But in general, as a user you still are presented with pages of results you can scan through and read. With something like chatGPT, what is the likely hood result sets will be home more specific and echo chambered. And furthermore, what is the chance the big corporations will get even more control on applying their bias/slant/angle than we currently already get. And, as a thought experiment, what might the answer be in 5 years and 10 years.
- bamboozled 4y agoWill the Encyclopaedia make a comeback thanks to ChatGPT?
- ascotan 4y agoPlot twist - the article on Bloomberg is the result of the a chatGPT query for "Write an article in the style of a press release that discusses chatGPT being added to the Bing search engine".
- sacnoradhq 4y agoIn addition to some people who were using it here, coworkers have been shitposting various performance review thoughts to each other using ChatGPT. It's a great bullshit generator in it's current condition. I think it can and will be improved. The problem I see is the web being taken over by bots phishing, catfishing, trolling, stalking, doxing, etc. humans. For example, if I "offend" a bot or its PRNG decides, will it be able to construct a strategy such as deep fake you or your friend in deep fake porn and make it appear you were the culprit? We're a bit far off from general AI being let loose, but we're getting closer to losing control and the feedback cycle of tech amplifying itself into the technological singularity.
- kapv89 4y agoWoah
- fleddr 4y agoRandom thoughts: 1) My first thought would be that such a conversational search UI would never hit the original website, thus drying up monetization for the content creator. Kind of like snippets in current search. Then I realized that there is no "original website", no singular source for the AI answer given. That's even worse. Search is the main traffic controller of the web and now has zero reasons to send any traffic your way. Not only does it not have any reason to send traffic, it simply can't. You can't back trace an AI answer to a (single) source. 2) The implication of the above point may be that for human creators, producing new content for the open web becomes (somewhat) pointless, even in the case where you do not even care to monetize it. An exception is video, for now. You should not expect this change to lead to a drying up of content for AI though. Google/Microsoft will simply resort to making deals with major content platforms. That's where most content is produced anyway. 3) An interesting new problem for Google/Microsoft is the increased accountability regarding correctness. Right now, search results do not have to be correct. You're just showing results produced by other entities. This changes when you confidentially give an answer directly in the search UI though. Now you own the answer, even if this expectation is technically inaccurate. Since GPT3 is often confidentially incorrect, that's a major challenge. And we should hope that this problem remains for a long time, because the moment GPT3 is extremely accurate and correct, we're in a different world entirely. 4) Safety and political correctness is another concern. Google/Microsoft will likely deliver AI that is a little too safe instead of not safe enough. The implication is that instead of being a controller of traffic, it becomes a controller of opinion. Of right think and wrong think. Which may be ever changing and subject to institutional pressure. Combined with point 3, you're no longer a proxy. You're the source of truth and the source of what's right. 5) Some say that the open web is already close to dead thus the already ongoing trend of people resorting into private spaces (Discord, Mastodon, etc) might accelerate. An open web and a closed human web. Even in the closed human web AI-generated content can and will penetrate so there will be attempts to detect it. Which is likely futile, because one can use AI-generated content and then tweak it to make it more human-like. 6) We need legislation ASAP. None of our regulations and laws are designed for what is coming. Do you really want a congressional hearing 10 years from now where a 75-year old asks "So this AI thing, is it like a smart calculator?", after all damage has already been done? 7) We should unite in at least some basic pushback. Stop thinking in individual use cases like AI art, Copilot and GPT3. Think about the broader problem where all of human creation is sucked up for free and without permission, after which all benefits are centralized up to the point of even replacing you. It's a shared, human problem. We're unlikely to stop it but at least don't make it this easy.
- lysecret 4y agoAbsolutely love ChatGPT. I am currently learning F# and it has been a grandiose help.
- jug 4y agoNice. I was starting to wonder when I'd see these news. :-) Surely this is Microsoft's end game after becoming a "preferred partner" to OpenAI? Many of us has seen how it kills Google or at least vastly outperforms it in many respects, and Microsoft of course knew this all along, including when they started seeing the potential and investing in it? We're just reacting late to what Microsoft saw many moons ago. And we aren't even seeing the finalized product that will surely be based on GPT-4 rather than GPT-3? I honestly wonder how far back this stretches. Nadella has steered this ship so well compared to Ballmer. His focus on Azure and later AI aligns so well with where computing at large is moving, and meanwhile Google seems stuck.
- bfrog 4y agoShort google? Seems like this might seriously challenge googles dominance in search.