26 ms·
U.S. workers have gotten less productive – no one is sure why
- droptablemain 4y agoWell, what has being more productive gotten them?
- gitfan86 4y agoThe best way to understand this is to compare Tesla's R&D expenses to Twitter's R&D expenses. If you got into the details you would see MANY MANY meetings at Twitter with literally nothing was accomplished.
- flashgordon 4y agoQuoting a quote "The only way a business is successful and productive is if employees feel that sense of empowerment, that sense of energy and connection for the company’s mission and are doing meaningful work" So companies are giving the intrinsic motivation spiel. Fine. Who doesn't want to gaze at the majesty of creation from the peak of the Maslow pyramid/hierarchy? Yet this year has shown that at the first sign of trouble, even with billions parked in the bank, shareholders and not employees come first. Or if you are a startup then leadership mismanagement and bad decisions are absolved with layoffs (and some tiers). That bottom unsexy part of the Maslow pyramid where basic needs exist are looking very shaky. Hats off to you if you can keep the company and vision your number 1 goal at the looming expense of your family's well-being!
- osipov 4y ago
- uni_rule 4y agoAnecdotally, overall morale isn't great currently. I doubt that helps.
- kennend3 4y agoPerhaps people are at the point of revolt over the ever widening productivity vs pay gap? https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ Productivity kept on climbing and wages stagnated post ~1980 Time for the workers to reap some of that benefit.
- fazfq 4y agoIt's supply and demand - the supply of workers has doubled the last decades while demand has remained roughly the same. I think it's a miracle that salaries are so high currently.
- ianai 4y agoThis is actually contrary to Econ theory and empirical data. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33394486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33394486 The trend is towards less immigration and thus lower demand for goods/services and lower supply of labor.
- cma 4y agoI think he is mainly talking about woman entering the workforce since 1970ish, which massively increased the labor pool.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoAssuming that's true--and I'm not sure it is--mass retirement of baby boomers, which has already begun due to forced retirement during the pandemic, is going to absolutely decimate the labour supply, which has enormous knock-on effects (including a rise in inflation).
- scruple 4y agoYou can go back to the year 2000 and find Fox News and CNN talking heads warning us about the impending doom of baby boomers retiring and taking the economy with them. Any year now... What has actually transpired in the meantime has been record breaking bailouts, corporate handouts, and profits, while workers pay remains in stagnation and housing market inflation goes through the roof (because of slow development, IMO, attributed to NIMBYism, mixed with a nationwide inability to build densely or build public transportation infrastructure). edit/ And let's not forget, there have also been 2 disastrous, major wars, one of which inarguably never should have occurred.
- sylens 4y agoPerhaps people have had to expend more energy just keeping their personal life together in the last few years. People with children have had to deal with the constant school closings, childcare facility closings, etc. and that has taken its toll. They may have family members who got Covid or had treatment for other ailments delayed by the pandemic's rush to treat Covid patients. They could've experienced a huge shift in the switch to remote working in 2020, and are now expected to make another huge shift back to in-office working. This doesn't even account for the incredible decline in civility from customers if you work a customer-facing job. The slightest inconvenience or mistake can end up in a tantrum by an American adult that only sometimes gets captured on video. And in the meantime, a bunch of people walk around opining that "Nobody wants to work anymore" as if they deserve to be waited on hand and foot regardless of circumstance.
- ep103 4y agoDuring Covid, people were hiding in their homes, quarantined, with nothing to do but work. This year, companies expect workers to return to office, despite little change in conditions, except now we have to deal with all of the above issues you've just mentioned, AND the fact that employees have now proven they can work remotely perfectly well. It should neither be surprising that in a system where healthcare is tied to employment, that productivity jumped while people were locking themselves in their houses from a plague, or that productivity dropped afterwards, or that it might drop given the complete callousness of our current system.
- cestith 4y agoAll of what you've both said, plus the number of people who thought or still think COVID-19 is "no big deal" who now have a pulmonary deficiency and long-term mental fog.
- AnthonBerg 4y agoIndeed. In support of this—part of it!—here’s one paper of many: “The Neurobiology of Long COVID” by M. Monje, neurobiologist at Stanford, and A. Iwasaki, immunologist at Yale. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2022.10.006 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2022.10.006 People with measurable neurobiological issues will show a measurable productivity drop.
- ep103 4y ago> In the first half of 2022, productivity — the measure of how much output in goods and services an employee can produce in an hour — plunged by the sharpest rate on record going back to 1947, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. > The productivity plunge is perplexing, because productivity took off to levels not seen in decades when the coronavirus pandemic forced an overnight switch to remote work It also comes at a time when many employers are shifting back to hybrid schedules and RTO, despite employee claims that remote work allowed flexibility helped them work more efficiently . What a mystery.
- dahfizz 4y agoIf this is true, why was productivity so high pre-pandemic when everyone was in an office?
- cma 4y agoWhat everyone is ignoring is that financial speculation leaks into productivity numbers, and we went into a speculative boom during covid and have been in a speculative bust during this recent period.
- dml2135 4y agoThis article and the chart within it reference the rate of change in productivity, but not the raw productivity number. Without seeing those numbers, my assumption -- and what seems to be implied here -- is that productivity rose in early 2020 with remote work, and it is now dropping to pre-pandemic levels.
- vlozko 4y agoI'm of the opinion that WFH has been a net negative to productivity. Measuring productivity was much easier for managers to do when everyone was in the office as employees would find it more difficult to hide attempts at slacking off. Those who are less productive when WFH are less willing to admit it and I believe it's the reason why whenever the topic of WFH comes up, it's drowned by the voices of all those who say it's been absolutely great for them. I don't think anyone is going to argue about the conveniences this WFH culture has brought. And I'm certain there quite a number of people who can prove how much better their work has been because of this shift. Those who are being far less productive, though, are kinda ruining it for the rest of us and lots of managers know it. I think Satya is on point when he talked about what employers say about productivity and what their managers think is actually happening.
- eppp 4y agoMy productivity has decreased simply because of delays and shortages. I can't get things when I need them or sometimes at all. Everything takes so much longer when you can't plan for anything.
- bdw5204 4y agoI think there's a very obvious reason for the "productivity drop": Return to Office I remember tons of studies showing that remote work had caused unprecedented increases in productivity so it seems plausible to me that companies ending it caused the productivity drop which caused the minor recession earlier this year (the big one due to the Fed's rate hikes is, I believe, still in the future). The article itself even acknowledges that remote work increased productivity yet ignores the 50 foot tall elephant in the room that is RTO.
- switch007 4y agoAnd yet my company likes to remind people on a daily basis that it's a privilege to be allowed to work from the offices (because they just refurbished them). Literally their wording. Completely detached from reality
- SauciestGNU 4y agoYeah no kidding. If it were demanded of me to RTO after this time of working remote, they wouldn't get quiet quitting, they'd get active sabotage while I search for a new job. There's no excuse for torturing ICs with RTO for reasons of executive vanity.
- rtp4me 4y agoWait, are you saying you would actively sabotage your place of employment because they asked you to work in the office? Did you have the same feeling before WFH was even a thing? Edit: Also, what does "torturing ICs with RTO for reasons of executive vanity" even mean? Have we come so far that working from an office is now "torture"? If so, the level of privilege is simply astounding...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI am not the parent, but I believe I can answer, because my thoughts on the few days that I do venture into office border on postal. In my defense, I hate people who invented mornings with a passion reserved for people, who hurt puppies for amusement. When I see phrases like "executive vanity", I immediately picture a manager, who saw the productivity numbers gained and decided that those do no matter ( and some of us did go above and beyond specifically to show that there is a benefit to WFH for companies ) and instead opted for butts in chairs for no other reason than "I want to feel like I still matter". Some executives refers to this as management by walking. << Have we come so far that working from an office is now "torture"? It is kinda like this. We all know WFH is possible. We know it results in good results for the company and yet management opts to RTO. They want me to commute, force me to get up extra early, almost kill people on the way two work if I do drive by car ( because I am sleepy; not because I am postal ) and somehow match the productivity that was happening precisely because we implemented WFH? Yes, by comparison it is torture. I had a glimpse of heaven and it was forcibly taken away from me ( it wasn't taken from me, but please understand that this is the mindset ). edit: And, if you buy into one specific poem I will not name, hell is everyone but heaven and therefore torture. Whether you agree with it or not is irrelevant. Put yourself in their shoes. See the world through their eyes. If not, a good chunk of the people, who managed to keep the companies afloat during covid will bounce ( and some did ), because those are the people that actually knew what to do when SHTF.
- caseysoftware 4y agohttps://archive.ph/fTkHI https://archive.ph/fTkHI
- FearlessNebula 4y agoIt’s the phones. Our attention spans and ability to focus have been destroyed by constant little hits of dopamine.
- thebigspacefuck 4y agoBut why now? It seems like that would have happened sooner.
- FearlessNebula 4y agoI suspect that phone usage went up substantially during the pandemic, and that had somewhat of a lag effect to show up in these reports.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoPhones were invented this year? Or why did they have an effect only just now?
- netsectoday 4y agoThis! All of the companies kept shortening their dopamine cycle to compete with each other and now people can’t focus in real life for more than 5-10 seconds before they are mentally searching for the scroll button to find a new interaction.
- hooverd 4y agoPhonebad isn't just a city in India.
- mark_l_watson 4y ago+1 I find watching TikTok or YouTube Shorts to be damaging to my concentration compared to what I consider (for myself) to be healthy activities like reading a book, watching or listening to an interesting interview or educational like philosophy, etc. I try to fight back by only having TikTok installed on a Chromebook that I don’t often use and for YouTube Shorts, I count the number I have watched. On my cellphone, if I want to waste time, I prefer a quick game of Chess. I strongly recommend the https://freedom.to https://freedom.to service as well as their podcasts.
- ianai 4y agoYesterdays post about interest rates and expected returns seems related from an aggregate and opposite side of the market: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33394486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33394486
- nonameiguess 4y agoGoing to speak for my organization only, but I know exactly why we have become less productive. And it isn't even a bad thing. It's security. We played loose and fast and took risks. We got lucky (as far as I know) and it never bit us, but it certainly bit adjacent organizations and mandates started coming down from higher up to no longer play fast and loose and to prioritize security. There is inherently a tradeoff here. Don't trust and verify takes longer than trust and don't verify.
- exabrial 4y agoA couple of reasons I can see, just my opinion * My buddies in trade-based fields say they are working harder than ever, as their backlog has only increased in size * Less scrutiny when working from home, more fooling around, less work * Feeling that "grass is greener" elsewhere, therefore no longer being committed * Polling has shown that their ideal job for Gen-Z is being a CEO of a company, but few seem motivated to start their own business as those stats have been down. Clearly there's a gap in motivation or understanding
- notfromhere 4y agoBusiness formation surged since the pandemic, but Gen Z is going to have a hard time with it because they’ll be more broke than millennials
- Kon-Peki 4y agoOnly if they need a lot of capital. Everything else about starting a business is far, far easier than ever. Almost every state in the US has streamlined the business formation process, made it cheaper and faster, etc.
- sylens 4y agoExcept for the fact that you won't have healthcare
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThey have access to the same health insurance, it is just expensive, which goes back to needing capital. It is trivial to go to healthcare.gov and buy the same health insurance an employer subsidizes for employees.
- runnerup 4y ago> It is trivial to go to healthcare.gov and buy the same health insurance an employer subsidizes for employees. This is so shockingly false in most states that I don't understand how you feel you have enough personal experience to state this so confidently. Neither California nor Texas have any PPO-style plans available on healthcare.gov. For all the public / self-employed plans, "Out-of-network" means "Pay for it yourself, this is not covered at all." That's a huge barrier to care when you need an urgent care and it's not clear which doctor at which urgent care might be covered. Additionally the rates aren't just different due to subsidy, but due to quality of the participant pool. Many large employers are self-insured / self-funded, and the insurance company just administrates the fund, reimbursements, etc. However, the unsubsidized rates (made known to us via COBRA) are still much, much lower than the healthcare.gov rates because the participants are generally healthy, wealthy, and young. When you buy healthcare.gov you get the shitty rates. This isn't just a difference of degree ... having a $100 deductible vs. a $6,000 deductible, or a $1,000 OOP max vs. a $22,000 OOP max literally makes the difference whether I can get my gastrointestinal cancer kept in check every year or not. I can afford the COBRA premiums for that $1,000 OOP max, but I absolutely cannot afford the healthcare.gov plan with >$15,000 in premiums on top of the $22,000 OOP max that I'm guaranteed to hit every. single. year. to get the care I need. Anyone who is pro-business, pro-entrepreneur, should generally be for good public healthcare. This would relieve businesses of a LOT of administrative burden and overhead to let them focus on their core value proposition. It would also facilitate a lot of good startups by freeing people to go build something great. A lot of potential capital growth, innovation, and disruption is being wasted because the people who can do this are stuck in place.
- pydry 4y agoWeird that energy / natural resource costs werent mentioned given the way that productivity is calculated.
- throwaway22032 4y agoI'm pretty sure I know why... The working environment changed. Bit by bit I moved from an environment with gentleman's agreements and so on towards something in which everything was codified, safetyism became rampant, etc. In the UK over the past few years I went from going into a nice office in a number of beautiful old buildings, getting my stuff done with cameraderie, having lunch together and playing board games, having a laugh in the board room, perhaps a pub visit after work - to sitting alone at home for 8 hours staring at a screen. So I quit. My productivity - gone. And I fear it's never coming back unless that environment comes back; because I can't effectively function at a "job" with zero human interaction for an entire day, I've had to replace traditional work with other activities. But is it just me? My friends in retail and other low skill jobs - half the workforce seems to have disappeared so they're all being asked to do far more than is realistically possible. My friends who are in education - the entire job changed, no more giggling and laughing children, you were playing a video game with half the class absent. Perhaps they're back now - but they're dysfunctional because their development was neglected for years. My friends who are in law - the entire job changed, no more travel, no dressing up, sit at home with a screen. My friends who are in medicine - christ, let's not even go there, eh? I can't speak for those people. But I know that I need a reset, because this "new world" is one I'm just not built for.
- coldpie 4y ago> But is it just me? No. I go into the office every day because I feel the same. I need to get out of the house and see people. (It is OK if you, reader, do not feel this way! People are different!) There's a handful of other folks who come in every day. I'm starting up a project this week to revive our office culture a bit, to try to spring back from the COVID devastation.
- throwaway22032 4y agoHello fellow space traveler. I appreciate your message. Good luck.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI think a lot of us work-from-home preferrers also like (good) offices better than WFH, just not to the tune of hundreds of dollars and tens of hours lost per month.
- refurb 4y agoMy guess is Covid. I don’t know about anyone else but I was so burned out focusing on work isn’t a priority. It’s going to take a year or more before people feel like they’ve recovered.
- lambdaba 4y agoI feel like what we're hearing about excess mortality etc. is also related. The pandemic has been exhausting for so many people, and the multiple sources of uncertainty that have popped up in its wake have made things even worse. I do hope we find a way to recover.
- togs 4y agoThis article doesn’t do a good job of defining its basic terms to make its claims. They admit knowledge worker productivity if ‘tricky’ to measure, yet are somehow sure it has decreased drastically, with no link to evidence.
- pipingdog 4y agoWithout understanding precisely what is being measured, it is useless to try to understand why the metric is moving in whatever direction it is moving. This is hand-wringing and trying to blame the workforce for a collapsing bubble.
- atkailash 4y ago
- cestith 4y agoIt's difficult to be productive when you're waiting on a shipment of parts, for one thing. We've been working for decades to make industries work with more advanced logistics and less stock on hand. Now there are supply chain issues, and you can't assemble and sell something if you don't have the parts whether it's a car, a computer, or a rose hip half skim gigante honey latte. Real wages are up a bit, but revenues are way up despite the supply chain issues. People are being forced back into offices who don't need to be there. Maybe morale is low. I know of concrete instances of low morale, and I'm sure there are others. People's life changing because of RTO requires attention. People are often looking to move or to change jobs recently, which requires attention. Millions of people have been ill with a respiratory/vascular virus which sometimes causes long term damage. More than a million in the US have died from it. Survivors often have pulmonary issues and long-term mental fog which may be permanent or take years to recover. They have less energy and stamina. It's harder for many of them to concentrate. Some of those who died were in the workforce, and whatever knowledge they had about their job died with them. Other deaths were people's family and friends. Funerals, cleaning out houses, donating their belongings, and the grief itself aren't exactly good for worker productivity but they are things humans need to do. Lots of micromanagers exist. For people who haven't returned to office with no open floor plan to walk around, many of them use a messaging app like Slack to micromanage. Water cooler conversation is in Slack channels. Meetings are in Slack, Teams, or Zoom or something else, and everyone's supposed to be engaged rather than working on their laptop until it's their turn to speak. There are often more officially designated meetings because people can't drop by one another's offices. Lots of work is concentration-based work, or "flow" work. Constant interruptions are bad for anyway, but when it takes 20 or 30 minutes to get all the context in your head to solve a problem and a three-minute interruption to lose all of that, more interruptions can be catastrophic for productivity. Some types of business have minimum staffing requirements. You can cut staff and try to "right size", but you need enough staff to keep the place open if that's your goal. If orders are down enough, your staff will sometimes have less to do. If because of the shortages mentioned before your ability to fill orders is down, the same thing applies. You have a choice of eating some less profitable quarters until the supply chain levels out or just closing shop. You can't lay off 100% of your trained staff and count on rehiring them later.
- covidiot5 4y ago
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoThey ask just about everyone you can think of in this article about what's up with the US worker. They even ask Larry Summers, even though the only thing Larry Summers has to teach us is how to fail upwards consistently. Of course, they don't think to ask a, you know, US worker about what's up with them.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis is what happens when you measure GDP using services. The tail wags the dog with demand Being the tail. I suspect you see different results if you looked at physical Goods.
- gausswho 4y ago'Productive' is such manipulation is this usage. In the modern economy, products shipped per employee often has little relation to how hard an employee works. Does not this metric speak poorly upon leadership's decision-making, the increase of onerous busywork and surveillance, and a dislocated world economy? If you believe Zuckerberg chasing the Metaverse has misallocated resources, his company has shipped less 'product' per employee. Does that really mean employees have been less 'productive'?
- bm3719 4y agoIn addition to the other good reasons listed here: Inflation. Most of us are now paid less in real terms for our efforts than we were 1-2 years ago. If you convert your labor to something invariant, like carrots, you just aren't given as many for a day of hard work. So, to the degree that we are rational beings and have agency on the matter, we scale our output accordingly.
- vt85 4y ago[dead]
- psychoslave 4y agoAre they happier? Great. Otherwise well, less crap produced and reaching the global market is already something nice to hear I guess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rr808 4y agoLots of people are productive WFH, but loads are taking it easy. Often in my team Fridays people barely dial in, maybe are connected a few hours max. Thursday afternoons now are dead as people get ready for the weekend... Job market is still strong so no one really cares that much as we know we're difficult to replace.
- whateveracct 4y agoMy remote employers have - and continue to - effectively subsidized a lot of my personal ventures in the last decade. Personal projects (software and art), learning skills (programming, instruments, video editing), improving at video games and sports. Not to mention leisure. All done "on the clock." To be honest, maybe the majority of the 40hrs I get "paid" for is actually used for this instead of company output?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eat 4y agoJust one guy's opinion, but to me it sounds like you're making intelligent, healthy, and entirely logical choices about your life and how you choose to spend your limited time.
- whateveracct 4y agoabsolutely - your consciousness is your most precious resource! the hardest part is the tension with the external guilt - but that is the point of the guilt after all
- lotsoweiners 4y agoMy in office employer (prior to covid) was subsidizing these things for me. Your tax dollars hard at work.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoExcellent, this provides productive evidence for a 4 day work week if everything still runs with folks checked out on Fridays and they’re not in the office performing work theater. https://www.4dayweek.com/ https://www.4dayweek.com/ Labor power in the face of a recession comes from dwindling labor supply. 360k boomers retire each month in the US. 1.8 million people over the age of 55 die every year. Not enough folks to backfill. https://archive.ph/2022.10.27-015740/https://www.businessinsider.com/great-labor-shortage-looming-population-decline-disaster-global-economy-2022-10 https://archive.ph/2022.10.27-015740/https://www.businessins... https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/11/09/the-pace-of-boomer-retirements-has-accelerated-in-the-past-year/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/11/09/the-pace-of... https://www.daytondailynews.com/local/rising-number-of-baby-boomers-retirements-may-create-eye-opening-changes/LOW7HBDJZBDB3M42EMUVYA7YX4/ https://www.daytondailynews.com/local/rising-number-of-baby-...
- stormbrew 4y agoThese things always really need a giant flashing neon note that "productivity" doesn't mean how much workers get done but how much money is made off of what workers get done. They're only loosely connected, and most productivity gains have come from workers having to "do less" to "make more".
- qeternity 4y agoThis is not how productivity is defined or measured.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoThen perhaps you'd like to enlighten us?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoWorkforce productivity at the national level is typically defined by some measure of output, the amount of goods or services produced (typically GDP), over some measure of input, the number of hours worked/workforce participation.
- mcguire 4y agoSo, how much money is made off of how much workers work?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoNo, not at all: for example, you can be a non-profit and still contribute to GDP, since you're still creating economic activity. Heck, even what the government does contributes to GDP, and that's not making money for anyone.
- BobbyJo 4y agoI think this is exactly what parent meant. "How much is made" doesn't strictly mean "profit" in terms of a for-profit institution. The net output of a non-profit is directed somewhere, either internal or external to the entity, and that can loosely be considered "making money", or at least in the sense I believe parent meant.
- m00x 4y agoITT: A bunch of people convinced they know why, with 1-2 anecdotal datapoints, mostly their own experience. Come on people, be at least somewhat scientific.
- dml2135 4y agoDoes anyone know how productivity for knowledge workers is actually measured? The article only goes so far as to mention that measuring productivity is "particularly tricky", but what datapoints exactly are these statistics even pulling from?
- stormbrew 4y agoThe economic concept of productivity has nothing to do with anything you can measure about a single employee (or kind of employee), the article is just conflating two very different meanings of the same word. In aggregate you measure it based on how much the company spends vs how much it makes off sold product. It's a measure of the efficiency of the company to its holders of capital.
- dml2135 4y agoOh, that's very interesting. Can you get more specific? What's the difference between productivity in this sense then, vs profit margin?
- stormbrew 4y agoI'm abstracting a bit more than I should really, because yeah the way I put it comes off as too close to just profit. But there are a bunch of ways to measure it, that generally comes down to some comparison of inputs vs outputs and those inputs and outputs have to be measurable in some way in aggregate. If you Google for "economic productivity" or "labor productivity" you can find better explanations of the details than I'm likely to give.
- highwaylights 4y agoJust came into the thread for the comments and am not disappointed.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThe lowering of standards, shortages, expensive fuel, food inflation are all reminiscent of Communism. People don't feel like working for a system when it seems to be failing them. A million dollars for a new home, when the lower bracket still makes under 50k, and get raises in cents. Just kind of kills incentive to work hard, when even if you do starve and penny pinch your way into some savings, inflation will eat it away anyway.
- kbelder 4y agoThanks, that is interesting, and you've given me something to chew on for a while. The similarities are there, and the causes are plausible.
- ravenstine 4y agoThere's a strong motive to deny that people operate on incentive. If people are incentivized by profit and attaining greater things, the idea that wealth distribution doesn't disincentivize workers completely collapses. Numerically, I make substantially more than I did 5 years ago. In terms of relative value, while I do have a fancier title, I barely make more than I did when my job was easier. If someone were to ask me "what are you career goals", I'd struggle to tell them any at this point because I have little reason to do more than what I already do. What, I'm supposed to want to take on more responsibilities only to find the economy adjust itself so my lifestyle barely changes? I know some people have a frankly ridiculous form of workaholism that allows them to persevere, but I see them as the horse from Animal Farm. Eventually they will lose the energy to do what they do effectively and the system is not going to support them in proportion for their loyalty, to say the least.
- UncleSlacky 4y ago"Communism is when capitalism". What you're describing are literally failures of capitalism.
- TechBro8615 4y agoThere is rising incompetence everywhere.
- eat 4y agoThe thing is, Bob, it's not that I'm lazy. It's that I just don't care.
- bell-cot 4y agoQuippy Answer: Bloat-tastic manager/worker ratios, plus meetings and other busywork.
- lkrubner 4y agoI've read that doctors now spend as much as 50% of their time documenting their work. Companies such as Epic, which provide the software that hospitals use to build databases of patient data, have been big winners in the new world of hospitals-depending-on-software. But did the doctors become more productive? By almost any measure, they became less productive. People in tech keep thinking more tech will solve problems and they keep underestimating the flexibility of the old models. For instance, most large companies used to be run by armies of secretaries, and the senior secretaries functioned as what we would now call "project managers" -- they made calendars, oversaw who was working on what, followed up to keep track on whether work was being done, and kept a close eye on what money was being spent. The crucial thing about having humans overseeing such work is that humans can take a flexible approach to the rules: they know when to break them. By contrast, systems that are highly dependent on software tend to be more rigid. Software doesn't know when its rules should be broken. The flexibility of the old system is constantly underestimated, the rigidness of the new systems is often misunderstood. In his book "The Design Of Design" Fred Brooks talks about the power of trust, and he contrasts that situations where everything needs to be first negotiated and specified in a contract. High trust systems are flexible and fast, whereas a system where every detail needs to be specified in a contract is slow and rigid. We should stop and ask ourselves, our favorite Agile methodology resembles which of these? Are specifying things with needless detail?
- happyjack 4y agoI agree to a large extent with your comment. The "office" structure has changed a lot. Secretaries ran the show, and pretty much hand-held everyone in the office and kept the ship pointed in the right direction. Law firms and political offices still have this "outdated" model because if it ain't broken, don't fix it. Now, your company pays insane amounts of $ for software, systems, and data! You have to do your job, schedule your meetings, keep up with the ungodly amount of email, instant message, SLACK, enter the data in your CRM, talk on the phone, schedule the video meetings, etc. while also keeping track of your personal phone because your partner called or the school called and your dog is sick. There's just so much distraction now by not having "office hours" and having our whole lives in our pockets and constant reach that I think productivity has to go down. It's impossible to focus on anything for any amount of time anymore with how accessible we are expected to be.
- whalesalad 4y agosystemic burnout, overstimulation in all dimensions of life, the rat race is getting harder and harder
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willio58 4y agoAs technology develops, we need to work less. In 2050 I doubt we'll all be on a 40+ hour work week.
- RomanPushkin 4y agoMy guess it's a game against inflation. People understand they're getting paid less for their hard work, and not motivated enough to work harder every day. For comparison, I'm spending x1.5 more on groceries than 1 year ago. Some items even x2 more expensive, comparing to last year. Salaries aren't growing that fast. Personally, I love what do, and this fact didn't affect the ability to work. However, I can imagine some people can get seriously affected by that.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoWhile Groceries have been impacted by inflation, the big chains in the US have also been just raising prices as indicated by their increased profits recently: https://www.wcpo.com/money/local-business-news/kroger-profits-soar-despite-rising-expenses-inflation https://www.wcpo.com/money/local-business-news/kroger-profit...
- lotsofpulp 4y agoProfit margin would be the relevant metric, not profit. And as you can see, profit margin has not increased: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KR/kroger/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KR/kroger/profit-m... Of course, a business with sub 3% profit margins maintaining sub 3% profit margins is hardly news, but inciting anger for no reason does result in more clicks.
- richardknop 4y agoCould be a factor at tech companies where lot of compensation is in a form of equity options. Especially smaller / medium sized tech companies have had their stocks go down by 50-80% in some cases. So now you’re earning much less than you thought you did plus inflation is out of control further reducing your real income.
- _jvqe 4y agoIts simple. The healthy people moved away. Its obvious that much of the GDP is based on low aptitude/low skilled products and services (i call it fat juice and fat juice filtering, looking at buffetts investing advice). An unhealthy environment is not something to grow old with. In the states, we can see that the illegal migration dumping is caused by the unskilled labor needed to support archaic GDP numbers. As a technology native, I was too young to work when the H1-B economy started to spring up, but the linear from that is easy to see. And somewhat off-topic, it looks like with the UK's PM, we get to see more of the effects that infosys played on the economy. Businesses that outsourced gave away their whole business model is an easy conclusion, so now they all have lower quality/priced competition (obviously speculation, but plausible remains entertaining). Looking at Walmart, I could never understand why they left their workforce in servitude, without paving the way for a future. The irony that "merica'" is filled with products from a communist country still astounds. They have no prospects for the future and supplement incomes with foodstamps and welfare. Even quiet quitting is easy to decipher. Its an unhealthy environment. Its simple. The healthy people moved away.
- nebula8804 4y agoMaybe i'm too stupid to decipher your message entirely but the healthy people moved away? To where?
- lob_it 4y agoNot to you, obviously. It was a reference to participation (the lack thereof) And I should have linked a source, but business outsourcing was more of referring to manufacturing in china and the counterfit goods. Software is obviously easier to hijack too. It is cool seeing the karma go up and down on this post. Its back to (1) :) A global forum is always fun :p Its simple. The healthy people moved away.
- nebula8804 4y agoYour post is a mish-mash of thoughts that might be coherent independently but put together is just indecipherable. Consider re-writing your comment to get the point across. But let me try to respond anyway even though I am unsure of your point: >In the states, we can see that the illegal migration dumping is caused by the unskilled labor needed to support archaic GDP numbers. The native population's costs to maintain those jobs locally would make the underlying business untenable. Perhaps this is the end state of all these businesses taken by illegal immigration. Maybe robotics might save the day. People are not going to pay for 14-20$/hr picked strawberries. Maybe they will but that 20$/hr will eventually become 30$/hr and so on. >As a technology native, I was too young to work when the H1-B economy started to spring up, but the linear from that is easy to see. H1-B was a miracle program that allowed numerous non-white people a sliver of a chance to experience the fruits of the western empire. A large portion of the white population came over to the new world without any papers and/or none of the roadblocks that current immigrants face. After they established themselves, they slammed the door on everyone else. At the same time, the third world is recovering at a snails pace from decades of exploitation and wealth extraction by the western nations. Put yourself in the shoes of people who want to experience a kind of life that westerners live. What options do they have? They can't easily just waltz into the western countries like their white counterparts did...meanwhile they were born into an environment that was fundamentally destroyed and stripped bare by those same western powers. They can't fight back to take that wealth back because the western military might will crush them, they can't improve their countries in any reasonable timeframe because there are too many forces working against them. But then comes along H1-B and it gives many ambitious people an opportunity to get exploited by the ownership class in exchange for an economy class seat into the first world. Who are the healthy people in this scenario? The white American working class whose ancestors walked into abundance with much less effort than people today and whose descendants couldn't muster up the effort to fill those in demand tech jobs? From the point of view of the ownership class, they were never in the game to begin with. From my point of view, the healthy people are the H1-B people. >Businesses that outsourced gave away their whole business model is an easy conclusion, so now they all have lower quality/priced competition (obviously speculation, but plausible remains entertaining). Maybe the ownership class is smarter than you. China and the rest of the Asian workshops are aging much faster than the US. China is projected to drop to 600 Million by the end of the century. The current state of them taking all the healthy people is a mirage.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- unity1001 4y agoSurely, it cant be financial insecurity, uncertain future, and not getting anywhere regardless of how much work they put in. It definitely cant be that the capitalist system has already squeezed the last drops of productivity from people in the last few decades and there is no more. It definitely can't be that what Marx predicted already happened and the majority of people don't have access to means of generating wealth/income, being unable to consume, therefore putting the economy into a crisis of growth and profitability. No one is sure why. Its just a mystery.
- otikik 4y agoThe "quiet quitting" strategy was not well accepted and now they are trying this. > Since the pandemic started, “the link between hard work and reward has been broken” More like "since the 1970s"
- mcguire 4y agohttps://www.bls.gov/productivity/graphics/2022/graphic-4.htm https://www.bls.gov/productivity/graphics/2022/graphic-4.htm "Real compensation" is "Employer costs for wages, salaries, and employee benefits", adjusted for inflation.
- dcolkitt 4y agoThe very important context is that productivity sharply rose in 2020, in the middle of the Covid recession. The recent drop in productivity is mostly just a return to pre-pandemic baseline. The simplest explanation is probably just that the workers who were laid off during Covid were the least productive, and so average worker output went up, then fell as they re-entered the labor force. Or maybe even just there was some sort of abberation with how the complex statistic or productivity was calculated (e.g. inflation was actually here earlier than measured by CPI, and output was deflated incorrectly). Either way, this is much more likely a pandemic related disruption and return to normalcy, rather than an indication that anything fundamental is "broken"
- nradov 4y agoThere is a similar effect in some countries with strict labor laws which make it difficult to fire employees. Unemployment rates end up being high, but productivity is also high because companies are only willing to hire the most productive workers and won't take a chance on anyone else.
- aeternum 4y agoI'd argue it was also due to lack of alternative options for leisure time. When everyone was stuck at home there's only so much Netflix the avg person can watch. People likely spent some extra time on work because it was something to do. Now with everything reopened there are many more options.
- chasd00 4y agohours worked went way down but dollars made stayed the same because of the handouts. The productivity metric had nowhere to go but up.
- fintechjock 4y agoMaybe an even simpler explanation is that productively is roughly calculated as GDP / employed workers. Productivity almost always goes up in a recession, especially one accompanied with massive layoffs (like early COVID). Productivity is going down right now compared to 2020 because we are pretty much at full employment. These productivity measurements aren’t really tracking individual productivity at all.
- arberx 4y agoCan I be naive and argue a simple explanation? Cheap money the last 13 years = hire more people who do less and get paid more. Or even hiring people for positions that aren't needed.
- renewiltord 4y agoLike everyone here I would also like to propose an explanation. I think it's because Mercury is in retrograde.
- thrilled2behere 4y agothis is not the time the time to start a new love this is not the time the time to start a lease
- hedora 4y agoI'd be curious to know how long people have been in their current job vs. pre-pandemic. Many people are now returning to work, or finally getting around to switching to a new company. They need to be trained.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago
- logicalmonster 4y agoThe reason for anything large and complicated is very nuanced and probably has a lot of small causes that we might all disagree on, but I'd say that the overarching reason for this social malaise might be that a lot of people are feeling a lack of hope for their future. If you think you're working towards something good: a family, home ownership, kids, a reasonable amount of life enjoyment in terms of leisure, a stable society, and a pleasant retirement where you can enjoy seeing your grandkids and participate in some hobbies for a decade or so before your mind or body collapse....you might be willing to push yourself to achieve as much as you possibly can, even if you're a lowly cashier or janitor. But who wants to go the extra mile for this degenerate and hopeless society where your money is being destroyed and you have grave concerns about many things? Whether rightly or wrongly, everybody is seeing fucked up things in the world and many people are feeling much greater concern about the future than we've ever seen before. This isn't a recipe for going the extra mile at work or harnessing the energy of society to achieve something great.
- coinbasetwwa 4y agoYou’re 100% right. That plus the fact that my employer tried to fire me for not taking an injection, I’m good on chilling.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoOur past productivity also came with some of the longest working hours per year of any nation, iirc. Our pay never got improved and our living conditions worsened, we work too long, and we're sick of killing ourselves for corporations to become insanely rich. Of course we're not productive, we're sick of the bullshit.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qqqwerty 4y agoI feel like supply chain issues are worth a mention here. The labor market has been super hot, and finding new employees is a chore. At the same time a number of sectors outputs have been rate limited by supply chain issues. Do you reduce shift work and lay off salaried staff while you wait for the supply chain to catch up, or do you use a combination of stimulus money, cheap debt, equity sales, etc... to bide your time until things are back to normal? In the last year or two, at the peak of the employment boom, the answer was almost certainly to bide your time. If and when the supply chain returned to normal, you would then be in a good position to restore output to meet demand. If you had laid off a bunch of folks, you would have found yourself scrambling to rehire in one of the worst employment markets (for employers) in history. However, with interest rates rising and a potential recession in the near term horizon, that equation might change. We could (and already) seeing more layoffs. I think after a year or two, we are going to start seeing productivity snap back as a result.
- ScottBev 4y agoHeavy push to go from WFH to in office in the last six months. Decrease in productivity in the last six months. It must be all the remote workers! Ignore the return to office push, inflation, burnout, and every other possible factor.
- trollerator23 4y agoIt's the opposite. It's the working from home that's the problem.
- trollerator23 4y agoWhy, it's the working from home of course.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoPeople going back to the office with 2 hours of commuting won't be more productive than people who work from home.
- grumple 4y agoThis headline is alarmist and the article itself is designed to manipulate people unfamiliar with the productivity metric or its recent movement. Note that the article and the graph are about the % change in productivity... which spiked sharply during the pandemic and has now returned to the growth line it was on prior. Here's the fed numbers: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OPHNFB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OPHNFB The productivity drop the OP is referring to is that little blip downwards at the end. Hell, here's the Fed asking a year ago if the pandemic boosted productivity: https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/07/has-the-pandemic-boosted-labor-productivity/?utm_source=series_page&utm_medium=related_content&utm_term=related_resources&utm_campaign=fredblog https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/07/has-the-pandemic-boo... Basically all the chatter in these comments are irrational speculation, based on a false premise, and flatly wrong.
- benrow 4y agoThere should be a name for the logical fallacy where direction of travel of a statistic is taken out of context. Local fluctuation being taken as the beginning of a trend. Perhaps just "short-sightedness", but it's more specific - inference of future events based on short term signals. It's really common in news about the economy. I guess the outcome is really important, but we only have these instantaneous signals. So something like superstition kicks in (when we're not carefully considering what is stated).
- naikrovek 4y agoif I had to guess, I might guess that it's because large (and even a lot of small) employers put profit above all else, including employee compensation. for a while, employees observed themselves working hard for zero benefit, so they simply slowed down. not everyone can just pick up and move to another job that treats them better. if I had another guess, and I pulled from my experience as a software developer, I would say that the desire to have continuous productivity from all employees has created environments which throttle talented employees and asphyxiate those who are learning because they can't contribute immediately. I see this all the time in my own life. I can contribute a great deal if I am left alone to do work that I see needs done, and I have demonstrated this multiple times. but if you don't understand this about me and you want daily stand-ups where I explain what I am doing, all I get is challenge from everyone on the call. "why are you doing that? we want you providing value. you should pair more." I promise, and I have delivered previously, that if you just leave me alone I can do great things, but when every last person on a call gets a say in what I work on, you render me completely ineffective, and that's where I am now. this is a direct consequence of technical leaders having MBAs and no understanding of people or the work they are doing.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoWe should blame it on return to the office.
- Xcelerate 4y agoThat plot in the article showing “percent change in labor output” looks like pure noise to me. Are they sure that’s measuring what they think it is?
- bilsbie 4y agoI’d say it’s an incentive problem. Not many employees get extra pay if they’re individually more productive.
- AntiRemoteWork 4y ago
- jimcavel888 4y ago
- shams93 4y agoreact
- karaterobot 4y ago> The productivity plunge is perplexing, because productivity took off to levels not seen in decades when the coronavirus pandemic forced an overnight switch to remote work, leading some economists to suggest that the pandemic might spark longer-term growth. We're talking about a 4% change? That's the "plunge"? When it spiked during the pandemic, they were ready to conclude that it would always be like that, forever and ever, if not continuing to grow higher and higher? Both these positions are ridiculous, given how small the differences in both cases are, and how squishy a measurement productivity is in the first place. "If these trends continue, nobody will be doing any work in twenty years, and we won't even be able to tell you about it because we won't be working either!!!"
- anotherrandom 4y agoThe more you measure productivity, the less productivity there will be. Employees spend a good amount of time documenting their productivity for nonsense like performance reviews, and that is a lot of time that could have been spent doing actual work
- robocat 4y agoClassic counterintuitive anecdote where measurement increases productivity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect “The Hawthorne Works had commissioned a study to determine if its workers would become more productive in higher or lower levels of light. The workers' productivity seemed to improve when changes were made, and slumped when the study ended. It was suggested that the productivity gain occurred as a result of the motivational effect on the workers of the interest being shown in them.”.
- throwaway5959 4y agoWe’re fucking exhausted and there’s never an end to work (agile). That’s probably part of it.
- coinbasetwwa 4y agoYes!!! Waterfall could solve this in many ways.
- cableshaft 4y agoI like Agile in theory but you're totally right about there always being something else, no proper breaks, you fix or make several things and then two weeks from now you're doing the same thing again but a different feature or fix, pretty much no change in the pace of the routine, just go go go. At least when I worked in fast food, sure there'd be the nightly dinner rush, but that only lasted about two hours, then everything would quiet down and you'd get to take a breather, take your time, goof off with coworkers, put a movie in the VCR in the breakroom (it was a long time ago), etc. Usually I at least take it a little easy the day we finish a sprint, but I still have to 'report what I did yesterday' in the sprint meeting the day after, so I have to have done enough to have some progress to report the next day. And then it's off to the races again. It's fucking exhausting.
- atlgator 4y agoMerit is no longer rewarded at my firm. Why be more productive than you have to be?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pnemonic 4y ago>>no one is sure why HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
- rglover 4y ago"Rushing makes messes." - Robert C. Martin
- KingMachiavelli 4y agoFrom the actual BLS report: > Labor productivity, or output per hour, is calculated by dividing an index of real output by an index of hours worked by all persons, including employees, proprietors, and unpaid family workers. This metric IMO seems to be sensitive to other macro indicators. The recent economic slow down means less real output while the tight labor market means the same or more nominal hours worked. The slowdown in any industry sensitive to interest rates means a lot of people talking and waiting on how to adapt but fewer projects and products developed and delivered.
- raydiatian 4y ago> no one knows why $7.25
- Kon-Peki 4y agoMy local Aldi is advertising $16.50/hr + benefits. Average rent for a 1BR in the general area is $1000-1200ish. As for me personally, I don't think I could be more productive if I tried. I finish work and then look to pick something up - are there isn't anything ready. If I try to make something ready, people want everything run past a committee to gain consensus. Twice in the past 6 months, I've spent 2 weeks developing a plan, running things past people, and then I come to a single question and the response is "hmm, you know, let's not work on this right now". This morning I was on an email chain in which one executive had committed us to paying $$$$ for some consultants to do something, and he wanted the CTO to do some checks to make sure our system could handle it. But what exactly? The CTO had no idea what he was asking for. They went back and forth, and I'm nearly positive that they were both acting in good faith, but for the life of them they couldn't communicate. And so a bunch of workers are going to sit around with nothing to do, collecting their paycheck. I've been doing this now for over 20 years, I'm fairly senior, and I deal with executive-level people a lot. I've never seen anything like what's going on, and it's totally unfair to blame this entirely on workers (they aren't blameless either, tbh).
- raydiatian 4y agoI mean $7.25 is completely inaccurate, and that’s my bad. What I really mean to say here is that it feels like the whole non-C-level part of the work force is disincentivized to try hard, because C-level pay is hyper-inflated. Workforce get stiffed on ownership of the companies they participate in. Completely. 1) the first start up I ever joined, I ended up owning 10% of the platform and grinding frequent 70+ hr work weeks. I desperately wanted to spread my wings and make suggestions (you know, career advancement type bullshit) but I was consistently treated like I had only been hired because there was a talent shortage, and that I was expected to follow orders and shut the fuck up. Execs sold the company 3 years later for $50M. I got $6,000 from the deal. 2) Amazon is a multi trillion dollar company, with huge talent sourcing issues. Why? Employees are grist for the mill. When I interviewed, beginning SE’s were salary capped and offered a tops of $40k in stock options that vested over 4 years. Most devs don’t last more than 2. These can’t be unique stories. I’m of the opinion that money and control need a fierce decoupling. I’d give a shit about implementing big visions if I were treated like it matters that I care and if I were presented a fair stake in the company. Until then, I’m going to worry about pursuing my personal projects more often than not.
- d--b 4y agoI bet my shirt that the measure is flawed. I mean look at the chart showing the change in productivity. It's all over the place. Productivity is a cultural thing that doesn't suddenly jumps up and down.
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoWe need to urgently optimize Boomers and GenXers know-how transfer to millenials or we're toasted.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- krisroadruck 4y agoCosts went up like 20-30% but we didn't give out 20-30% raises. Perhaps workers are leveling their productivity to the purchasing power of their salary?
- spikefromspace 4y agoMy 2 cents (although a bit of a salty take): In my last 3 roles, rewards like promotions go to those who create their own personal brand and win the popularity contest. While sometimes that correlates with actual productivity but often does not. So often I see folks do the bare minimum in these work cultures which seem to be getting more prevalent.
- yrgulation 4y agoAt least in tech, no one tell them its filling in all the jira nonsense and irrelevant agile ceremony.
- subsubzero 4y agoI have a hunch, The past 10-15 years has seen a large slew of mergers in all industries, (tech, telecoms, pharma, food, grocery, etc) that have created shared monopolies in most sectors of the economy. Given that news, monopolies function is not to deliver productivity for productivity's sake, but to extract profits from inside that sector. Most of these companies are sprawling behemoths where managers are encouraged to grow headcount(as it makes them look more important) while still keeping the profit machines flowing. I'm not the least bit surprised as if we had a country where smaller players were duking it out in their respective sectors, you would get faster innovation. Bottom line, more competition is good for end customers, and good for productivity as well.
- heavyset_go 4y agoPerhaps it has to do with the fact that businesses run on skeleton crews these days, and stretching a low number of employees thin decreases their productivity. I'm sure that employees say the same thing if they were directly asked. That and being forced back into offices after working remotely for 2 years.
- umvi 4y agoIf you directly asked me I would probably say: "Well, working from home the temptation to watch YouTube and stuff on my second monitor is much higher and sometimes I find I've wasted a lot of time procrastinating my tasks because there are essentially no consequences for doing so"
- forrest2 4y agoAnecdote: I'm a midwesterner and half of my siblings, most of my wife's siblings, and some of my friends' siblings are in their late 20s, have no jobs (or <10 hrs a week), and live with their parents. From the outside, they look nervous / afraid to try to get into the job market or to date people. Men & women, but it leans men. The ones in poorer families stay home all day and play video games, and the richer ones venture out to spend their parent's money at restaurants or on trips but otherwise do the same. Half of them were doing minimum-wage work and left at the start of the pandemic and the other half have never had jobs. I could just be in a local pocket of people like this, but I'm worried about how many people must have fallen off of the wagon and will never get back on. Trying to get a skilled entry-level job after having done literally nothing for 5 years is hard for a lot of reasons. One being the mental hurdle you have to get over: you know you'll face a lot of rejection, you're out of practice, and your work peers will be a lot younger. -------------- Controversial opinion: The whole thing has burnt me on UBI. I am afraid that the average American doesn't have the discipline to be productive if we introduce too much free income / free state of subsistence. A great counter-argument is "well why does someone have to be productive? why should anyone have to work?". I don't know anything, but I suspect that we get to ask that question because of how dominant/rich the US is, and that is bound to end if we aren't more than competitive against countries that work their asses off. Another counter is something like: exceptional people are responsible for the 10x-1000x outcomes that carry the economy, but those individuals are only the catalyst and do it on the backs of the rest of us. Takes all parts to make the machine work. -------------- Back on topic. Here's some graphs: FRED Graphs: Hours worked by full-time and part-time employees by year: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/B4701C0A222NBEA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/B4701C0A222NBEA US Pop: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/POPTOTUSA647NWDB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/POPTOTUSA647NWDB Median weekly real earnings: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q Employment-Population Ratio - 25-54 Yrs.: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300060 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300060 Real gross domestic product per capita https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A939RX0Q048SBEA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A939RX0Q048SBEA -------- US Employment rate by age 2000-2021: https://www.statista.com/statistics/217899/us-employment-rate-by-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/217899/us-employment-rat...
- 4y ago
- brink 4y agoWar, shortages, incompetent / corrupt government, bad behavior being incentivized while good behavior is being punished, and inability to trust people are all really discouraging. What am I working for?
- phendrenad2 4y ago> Since the pandemic started, “the link between hard work and reward has been broken” for many workers, Buber said, resulting in “curbed ambition.” Over the course of my 10+ year programming career, I've seen this effect steadily increase. Promotions seem to come or not come regardless of how hard you work. Looking back at older books about the tech industry (and comics such as dilbert), it seems like this effect isn't new, but could be something that ebbs and flows over time. > Productivity tends to move in cycles of 10 to 20 years See this is what I mean. Perhaps there's a megatrend going on here. Promotions go to those who don't deserve it, so companies self-destruct in their own incompetence, and a new crop of companies rise up, promoting those who are actually productive, and they reign supreme for 10-20 years, before they too become bloated and start promoting under-performers (who look good on paper). And the cycle repeats itself.
- bparsons 4y agofacebook
- baron816 4y agoWouldn’t labor productivity be impacted by really low unemployment and a low real minimum wage? That should mean lots of people who would not otherwise be part of the labor market are getting low wage/low productivity jobs. So in an aggregate measure dollars of output over hours worked, you’re raising the numerator at slower rate than you’re raising the denominator. Early in the pandemic, high wage white collar workers stayed home and kept their jobs. Low wage service workers were furloughed. -> labor productivity goes up. Service workers get hired again-> labor productivity drops.
- VLM 4y agoFor many years, for political reasons we'll never have another "great depression", and this has possibly now extended to reporting recessions. Its worth pointing out that the economic indicator of productivity is basically GDP divided by worker-years-equivalent worked. So if its double-plus ungoodthink to ever report a decline in GDP, we can still, for now, report a decline in productivity while also reporting unemployment remains mostly constant, as long as no one makes the connection and cancels them for reporting disinformation. Its not a "recession" of course, that would be badthink of the highest order, its just a mysterious decline in the productivity metric, and nobody can talk about why while remaining politically correct. Its a good demonstration of how effective censorship can be. Why, I hear times are so good, the party is increasing the chocolate ration.
- mattacular 4y agoLook at any data comparing wage growth with productivity since the 60s and that should go a pretty long way to explaining it.
- blululu 4y agoWittgenstein's ruler comes to mind: what is 'productivity' measuring? A quick glance at the chart in the article suggests that the variance of this metric is huge. It is more or less a white noise source with a small DC offset. Given the formula the BLS uses, I would be hard pressed to calculate my own productivity (outside of lawyers and people working on assembly lines or at fast food establishments most people do not keep track of their hours). If I can't measure my own 'productivity' then I have no idea how the hell the BLS is going to do it.
- shtopointo 4y agoI was wondering the same thing -- how could one measure my productivity? (as a software engineer) The best connection I could think of is something related to the company output, but in a market downturn I could be working 12 hour days, and the company would still be doing worse...
- shadytrees 4y agoAgreed. This seems like a newspaper trying to squeeze an article out of a weak signal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- downrightmike 4y ago$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
- lumost 4y agoThis shouldn’t be surprising. For the majority of us workers - output no longer correlates to remuneration. Working hard just means that you have slightly more money to live paycheck to paycheck on.
- cashsterling 4y agoThe article doesn't talk about how productivity is measured and the actual sensitivity and accuracy of the measurement(s). As others have pointed out, measuring productivity is a little hazy and probably is influenced by subjective bias (hey a recession might be coming... hmm, I feel like less work is getting done at my office). I wonder how much bias affects the reported measurements? I doubt businesses outside of manufacturing can actually discern a 2% change in productivity, when screening for other factors, and some of them can't discern a 5% change.
- qeternity 4y ago> I wonder how much bias affects the reported measurements? They don’t, because productivity is not self-reported. It’s also not measured the way you imply.
- m1el 4y agohttps://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/productivity-2 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/productivity-2 Mystery solved by an comic author with economy degree :)
- Kiro 4y agoI mean, it's obviously WFH. You might be more productive working from home but most people aren't. Any productivity boost was due to the novelty of it all but disappeared once the honeymoon was over. My friends who had never worked a single day from home before the pandemic were ecstatic and felt really motivated. Nowadays, not so much.
- nonasktell 4y agoHow about a giant freaking pandemic.
- smeagull 4y agoProbably their terrible labour laws. You can only grind people down for so long.
- jjk166 4y agoUS Worker productivity is 0.7 standard deviations below its average over the last 3 years. It is 3.6% below all time high. It is higher now than at any point before July of 2020. YOY Productivity growth has dipped negative and then went back to positive 20 times in the past 22 years. To be concerned about the current level of productivity requires either the attention span or the intelligence of a goldfish. https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/productivity https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/productivity
- fnordpiglet 4y agoShut up and work harder nerd.
- topspin 4y agoAlways read the comments first.
- rory 4y agoIt serves the important function of giving journos an opportunity to interview business consultants about what CEOs think of their employees' poop breaks. Which, in generating lots of hate clicks, is a huge economic boost in terms of Nonfarm Business Sector Labor Productivity!
- dfxm12 4y agoIt's just the corporation friendly mass media trying to combat calls for better worker treatment/compensation. This is just the next single from the album that brought us "quiet quitting", "the great resignation", "millennials are lazy", etc. It's important for the backers of these media outlets to float these stories out there, lest anyone become sympathetic to workers in light of the facts that minimum wage hasn't kept up with either inflation or productivity, that corporations are engaging in profit inflation, that the fed is intentionally raising rates to wrest back some power from workers, and so on.
- paulpauper 4y agoThe supplied chart looks like noise. Maybe the supposed loss of productivity is cyclical. It does not seem too concerning, imho.
- maerF0x0 4y agomy 2c is nihilism and cynicism are why. Why bother, nothing means anything anyways? Why bother chasing the dream, if it doesn't come true? People have increasingly been losing meaning and purpose in their lives. Old dreams like home ownership, family (including extended), close knit friendships, and eventual financial freedom/security have been supplanted by travel (broken by inflation & lockdowns, made fake by social media), fur babies (due to gender disparagement and estrangement), workplace politics / friends for a season (as we move for work, and have increasingly tighter requirements for friend groups due to technology (ie you can find people who agree with you online, so no need to befriend the neighbor with slightly annoying political beliefs), and life time of debt and little investment value[1]. So people are simply burned out being asked to pursue a long run strategy w/ a "promised" dream. The people delivered on their end of the bargain, but the dream makers didnt. [1]: https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-data https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-dat... From late 1999 to 2016 returns on .inx after inflation have been down or flat. People no longer believe the "Buy the index and you will see profits" after 20 years of contrary evidence. Over the past 30 yrs the index using the "8% per year" usual claim, should have returned 10x but it actually only returned 1/2 that. Why try, it's not going to work anyways?
- teawrecks 4y ago...and yet everyone is sure why.
- shtopointo 4y agoThis might be a very stupid question, but how do they measure productivity for knowledge workers? What does it mean that a software engineer is less productive? Or a stock trader? Or various other knowledge jobs?
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoMy paycheck only goes ¼ or less of the way it went just 5 years ago. Maybe that's why.
- chrismarlow9 4y agoIt never trickled down, if anything it trickled up. Pretty obvious why in my opinion.
- lupire 4y agoIf my conpaby doubles staff at same pay, for internal whatever, but generates the same product, what happens to productivity? Now, what if instead my company hires some other external business, to perform the same function with the same people at the same price? What happens to productivity?
- fnordpiglet 4y agoBecause burnout is pervasive?
- Ptchd 4y agoSome people are sure why, they just dont listen to them...
- mejutoco 4y agoThis is a bit abstract, but I think this has to do with processes and liability. Whenever there is a problem people look for someone to blame. The easiest thing is to create a new process to avoid this in the future, and be protected against blame. If this proceeds unchecked, the process grows and grows until every little thing takes forever. The processes need to be pruned sometimes too, not just added onto.
- nostrademons 4y agoThis could easily be an accounting anomaly. Productivity is defined as real GDP / hours worked. If you shrink the denominator - say, by causing 25% unemployment with lockdowns - while also boosting the numerator with government spending, you get high productivity, which we had during the pandemic. If you then shrink the numerator (say, with high inflation, which translates a given nominal GDP to a smaller real GDP) while increasing the denominator (through record low unemployment), productivity will drop. IMHO traditional economic metrics are not well adjusted to an economy where output is largely independent of effort or hours worked, particularly not when measured on a quarterly basis. I work for a (remarkably slow and bloated) tech company. If I choose to do nothing other than post on Hacker News, that will not become apparent in company performance for ~2 years, because that's the median time for a project to make it out to market and start having an effect on consumer behavior. The company could lay me off and it wouldn't affect the bottom line at all, but it'd boost productivity. Conversely, if I hire a new person, I don't see significant gains in output for ~2 years, but employment and hours worked has gone up, and so productivity is down. The limiting case for this is algorithmic cryptocurrency trading with mark-to-market accounting (of which there was plenty in 2021). Here, you have computers trading virtual assets back and forth at ever increasing prices. Because prices are going up, the value of everyone's assets increases, and with mark-to-market accounting you'd show a profit. And yet nobody is employed and no real work is being done. Productivity is effectively infinite, but it means nothing.
- paulpauper 4y agoPer-capita wealth probably a more accurate, better indicator of how well the economy is doing compared to productivity.
- twotwotwo 4y agoSo, the economic value measured for a piece of code drops if fewer people buy the product that it's in or its price has to be cut, entirely separate from how fast anyone is coding. Similar logic applies to a lot of sectors, not just software. Macroeconomic changes are going to work their way back to these stats eventually, independent of any changes in how workers spend their day or the concrete stuff they produce. (Kind of like stormbrew and nostrademons said!)
- mesozoic 4y agoRTO
- d_sem 4y agoThe article focuses on the drop of productivity measured in 2022. Personally 2022 was the first out of 2 years I could take a meaningful vacation. Perhaps the reduction of restrictions allowed people to improve their work-life balance in favor of more "life".
- d_sem 4y agoThe article focuses on a productivity drop observed in 2022 as compared with the past two decades. Anecdotally, this is the first year I've been able to take a meaningful vacation since the pandemic started. Perhaps, the reduction of covid restrictions allowed individuals to improve their work-life balance in favor of more "life".
- omgwtfbyobbq 4y agoMy guess is it's related to inflation. Changing costs can cause people and companies to adjust to different economic conditions, and that adjustment can hurt productivity. Something similar happened in the mid-seventies. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OPHNFB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OPHNFB
- anm89 4y agoLot's of people know why. Academia hasn't been able to find a way to frame it that is palatable. We live in a society where every single thing is a rent seeking and nobody believes in anything besides winning because everything of substance has been hollowed out.
- rvba 4y agoManufacturing productivity has dropped due to broken supply chains, in fact manufactuers of sub-components have own issues with missing components and so on.
- LatteLazy 4y agoProductivity is like pornography, we know it exists but there is no single definition or measurement of it. But people treat it like a bank balance...
- rajeshp1986 4y agoIt is surprising how no one is talking about the productivity loss due to social media & entertainment. I feel most people now spend a considerable amount of time on social media, entertainment on both personal & work time. I am not saying companies should impose restrictions on employees but we are living in a generation of 24x7 entertainment. We are definitely less creative and productive compared to workers 20 years ago.
- dathinab 4y agoA small anecdote: During industrialization "extended" rests where added before they where required by labor protection because they increased productivity. Multiple experiments have shown that in some situations software companies can be nearly as productive with a 32h week then a 40h week. As far as I can tell the US has been moving in the opposite direction, dismantling or avoiding labor protection and sometimes outright forcing people to work multiple jobs. Similar having long term health issues you can't treat because you can't afford it isn't grate for productivity. One of the more successful (non-private) health insurances in Germany is also one which also covers comparatively many precautionary health checks/things. As it turns out making it easier for people to less likely get serious sick is cheaper in the long run. Add to this that a lot of IT systems where added but in my experience many of this IT systems are designed for middle/high level management to look nice, instead of being designed with and for the people which use them. Lastly add to it that the future prospects look not so grate for a lot of citizens (not just limited to the US) which kills motivation (positive motivations works in general better long term then threads). So I'm not surprised.
- wetpaws 4y ago>washington post >bezos newspaper of course they would be concerned about productivity of all folks
- Cupertino95014 4y agoWhen you look at this graph, it just screams "noisy number." In other words, "worker productivity" is a nonsense metric. It'd be more instructive to graph the variables that go into it, going deeper until you find something that makes some intuitive sense.
- insane_dreamer 4y ago"less productive" compared to when? Last year? Historically? Is this a return to the mean? Just a brief glance at the first chart in the article, and last year was a bigger increase (6%) than this year's decrease (4%), and 2020 had the largest increase ever (10%). I didn't even bother reading the rest of the article after seeing that.
- bushbaba 4y agoCould the shift to hybrid/WFH be attributed?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 4y agoI don't know how this is measured: Could the effect be caused by the US onshoring industries that have lower productivity?
- cosmiccatnap 4y agoThis reminds me of a study where purses would be dropped with < 20 usd equivalent in them at random places around the world and the sociologists, psychologists and economists couldn't understand why most of them were returned given their understanding of human nature and the answer that they didn't want to accept was that their understanding was wrong. People don't work harder because their work is unfulfilling, their pay is underwhelming, and their hours are exhausting. Inflation just went through the roof and half of all price increases in domestic product are directly corperate profits and even the most uneducated among us are aware that every single part of this system is rigged. and the Washington post claims "no one is sure why" but in reality they mean "nobody in a position of privilege that we would hire or talk to has an excuse that doesn't point out the obvious things we can't say about class struggle and income inequality"
- zaps 4y agoCome on… we know why.
- lookagain 4y ago
- revolvingocelot 4y agoRelevant SMBC: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/productivity-2 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/productivity-2
- whodidntante 4y ago"The productivity plunge is perplexing, because productivity took off to levels not seen in decades when the coronavirus pandemic forced an overnight switch to remote work, leading some economists to suggest that the pandemic might spark longer-term growth. It also raises new questions about the shift to hybrid schedules and remote work, as employees have made the case that flexibility helped them work more efficiently. And it comes at a time when “quiet quitting” — doing only what’s expected and no more — is resonating, especially with younger workers." Perplexing,really ? I do not find this perplexing at all. Maybe productivity increased at the beginning of the pandemic because people were afraid of losing their jobs. Maybe once people realized they could work from home and not worry too much about getting fired, they are simply letting gravity take its course and finding out how little they need to do to keep their jobs, or if they even care if they keep their jobs. Look what has happened to remote education. We may now have a damaged generation. Yes, for certain people in certain jobs, working from home can be a productivity boost. This is not true for the general population.
- etempleton 4y agoI will tell you why: People are changing jobs a lot. When you start a new job you are usually slow at almost everything. You don’t know where files are, you don’t fully understand what you are working on, you don’t know who to go to for a particular question and so on. Worse you slow everyone else down too. Companies decided employees weren’t worth raises. Employees left. Companies need to value employees more with pay if they want them to stick around and keep all that institutional knowledge.
- fleddr 4y agoThe article is garbage. It just throws lots of things at the wall.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Trisell 4y agoI would propose that part of the loss of productivity is the lack of staying power in employees. Employees are getting trained working a year or two and then moving on to something else. The efficiencies derived by working 10-20 years in the same field and even the same position are lost with the modern workforce that barely gets trained to competency before leaving let alone staying long enough to build true efficiency and thus greater productivity.
- Dblue 4y agoThere is no enough workers
- civilized 4y agoMy theory: increasing dominance of bad productivity ideas that seem good on paper. The execs love how cheap their GCCs in India are, but they're somehow unaware that these folks can take months to do tasks that should take less than an hour. That and the exponentially growing parasite of tech-enabled bureaucracy, but we already knew that.
- mbrodersen 4y ago“Productivity” is as useless as “GDP” when it comes to measure anything important.
- headsoup 4y agoVC cash and cheap debt, oodles of it. Workers are reaping the benefits of 'growth.'
- alexfromapex 4y agoIt’s quiet quitting? Gallup polls suggest as much https://www.gallup.com/workplace/398306/quiet-quitting-real.aspx https://www.gallup.com/workplace/398306/quiet-quitting-real....
- RadixDLT 4y agoIf you want to know why please read this article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33395667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33395667
- bravetraveler 4y agoJust think back to that Office Space scene where he's explaining he has eight bosses The circumstances make it so that we're incentivized to do enough to not get fired
- cersei 4y agoProbably the long-term effects of COVID which causes exhaustion, brain fog, depression, etc... Combined perhaps by people having had time to reset and reflect on their life. Combined by the fact that the planet and democracy are dying. These are theories of course, but I don't think one has to always look for very complex or technology related answers.
- rpmisms 4y agoI haven't noticed any direct effects from my three bouts of COVID, but I have noticed a general decline after not being allowed out of my house for 8 months straight.
- aliqot 4y agoproductivity is scaling according to pay. system is working as intended.
- princevegeta89 4y agoToo many things and tools to deal with. For example, my manager uses a shitload of apps/services that he keeps inputting information to, rather than spending time to work with my team. It's not to say that he is wasting time - he is just literally following the protocol. The protocol of working and the order of things is just more fucked up these days than it was in the past.
- douglee650 4y agoConcentration of wealth has made most work seem … pointless
- rogerkirkness 4y agoAs a CEO I have learned this one the hard way: ask the workers like an adult what things are wasting their time. Economists out here like 'how do we solve the vexing problems that ail us' meanwhile the top comment is about how doctors spend 50% of their time doing paperwork. we could double the amount of doctors by hiring secretaries again! Duh.
- sokoloff 4y agoYou should ask what’s wasting their time and then do some studying to confirm or correct it. People aren’t very good at objectively reporting how they actually spend/waste their time.
- lifeplusplus 4y agono carrot -- before people thought if they worked hard just for little longer they will escape the trap, now with housing doubling in 2 years, it's become hopeless. With no end goal, only thing left is acceptance and survival, and survival as is doesn't require me putting in 200%, or even 60%.
- rhaway84773 4y agoWhat makes no sense is looking at pandemic increases in productivity and ascribing it to remote work. There were 2 obviously much larger reasons for that increase. 1. At the macro level, the increase was heavily driven by the fact that the least productive jobs were simply not being done. Blue collar workers were not working while white collar workers were. 2. At an individual level a massive increase in productivity was a result of people not having anything else to do so they were working a lot more. Remote work might have led to an increase in productivity but these 2 factors definitely did. Yet people have been talking as if all the productivity increase was entirely because of remote work when it was almost certainly behind at least these 2 factors.
- oneoff786 4y agoThe productivity chart is very spiky with values changing direction all the time. I’m not convinced this is note worthy
- davidork 4y agoPeople realize endless growth is impossible on a planet with finite resources and are tired of working for peanuts pretending like it is.
- causi 4y agoThis is not a mystery. 2022 is the peak year of retirement for the large baby boomer generation. People approaching retirement are at their most skilled and thus most highly productive. As they retire the average age and hence average skill level drops. I suspect if you separated the statistics into blue collar jobs and white collar jobs, the blue collar worker output began dropping a decade ago as the boomers aged out of their physical fitness prime.
- steve76 4y ago
- Yawnzy 4y agoYawn. We all know this stems from the open discrimination against straight white men in the hiring process
- PointyFluff 4y agoSeriously? Fuck off, Jeff. Pay your FUCKING TAXES, Jeff. You are an asshole, JEFF.
- xyst 4y agoPast US workers had the benefits of unions and collective bargaining. 40 hour work weeks. Overtime pay. Paid time off. 5 day work weeks. Decent benefits and pay. You could be the sole source of income for a family of 4 and pay for a suburban lifestyle. Keep your worker bees happy and they will be productive. Today, workers have shit pay compared to the CEOs and other C-level executives with multimillion dollar salaries, bonuses, and golden parachutes. Many people work multiple jobs just to pay rent. Unions mostly busted. Erosion of safety nets, and other public services. Those same CEOs even work with other companies in the same industry to artificially keep worker pay as low as possible by having an informal agreement to not recruit and hire from companies that have this agreement.
- kkfx 4y agoIMVHO the reason is simple: we all use IT stuff to do pretty anything. The original IT was *information* technology in the sense of tools to manage information. Then they involve for business purposes into crap try mimicking old paper-based tools offering their limits AND NOT their advantage but allowing those who sell crapware to profit. The current involution is even deeper: most people nowadays own really nothing in IT terms since they live on someone else computers at someone else rules. IF we came back to classic desktops, with their document UI, their end-user programming concepts AND classic HUMAN networking and organization in a far less near-flat pyramid than productivity will skyrocket. Oh in other philosophical terms: free people are FAR more productive than slaves, since the modern world is more and more based on slavery...
- black_13 4y ago
- Aleksdev 4y agoSmartphones.
- xtiansimon 4y agoSmartphones.
- peter_d_sherman 4y ago>"U.S. workers have gotten less productive – no one is sure why" U.S. media has gotten less informative -- no one is sure why
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoWhat is this nonsense "productivity" and how does one assign a number to it? I think it's largely a monetary artifact. A bunch of money sloshed around the system. Those transactions inflated GDP. Then, with a lag, official inflation numbers caught up. Now "productivity" is lower than it had been at the peak, just because transients pass through our measurement systems. Something about using the word "productivity" for this particular measurement feels borderline evil. So much that is productive in the vernacular sense is not productive in the GDP sense, and vice versa. Having and raising children is productive (of human beings!), but it only enters GDP stats insofar as you buy formula, diapers, and college tuitions. If you care for your own ageing parents, or if you raise your own children, GDP goes down. But if you take a job and pay somebody else to be a caregiver, then GDP goes up. Consider the extreme example of two women who pay each other to raise each other's children. In Ukraine, wheat production is down. Some unmeasurable production of defense services is way up. Since the soldiers don't pay their squadmates to lay down covering fire, that working-together isn't captured by GDP. We call it "productivity", but it's just a measure of intermediation by money. It'd be like measuring "social activity" as aggregate Facebook likes across the country.
- TomMasz 4y agoProductivity rose year over year while wages stagnated and layoffs were frequent. Workers have discovered the hard way there's no payoff for hard work.
- concomitant 4y agowfh
- dragonwriter 4y ago“No one knows why”: No, lots of people know why, but many of them refuse to acknowledge it because it contradicts the orthodoxy. The first sentence lists cause and effect (though it makes the same mistake of fact that leads to the mystification here): “As workers slowly return to offices after the pandemic, productivity has been dropping in the U.S. economy.” It is not “after the pandemic”, it just after everyone has decided to quit acknowledging the pandemic. But COVID doesn’t give a rats ass about whether people acknowledge it, so when you stop control measures (by having “workers return to offices”) and stop accommodation measures (like additional paid sick leave) you get more people catching COVID at work, and more working hours where workers are impacted by the effects of acute or long COVID. There are lots of people out of the labor force due to long COVID (which is part of the reason for the tight labor market), but there are also even more people in the labor force, and working, with long COVID; see, e.g., https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-data-shows-long-covid-is-keeping-as-many-as-4-million-people-out-of-work/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-data-shows-long-covid...
- stuaxo 4y agoCovid (Long Covid) and getting poorer relatively over time will all factor in.
- michaelcampbell 4y agoThe common wisdom is more workers are "acting their wage".