31 ms·
Lead exposure in last century shrunk IQ scores of half of Americans: study
- yalogin 5y agoIs IQ really quantifiable and measurable and is it comparable across different people, different geographies and races? I didn’t think it was, may be I am wrong. How is IQ even defined?
- krustymeathead 5y agoThere is a great Radiolab series about this: G. The IQ test is an effort to measure "general intelligence", or "G", but the test has had biases over time with regard to race. The landmark study by Herb Needleman on the link between lead exposure and IQ only studied white children to reduce any doubts about the validity of its claims [1]. [1] https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/g-problem-space https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/g-pro...
- extant_lifeform 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)
- amelius 5y agoAnd what about crime rates?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoFrom what I've read the removal of lead from gasoline is partially a factor in the sudden reduction of crime during the latter half of the 20th century, but it's not enough to explain the entire trend... which seems to be a preponderance of factors.
- bpodgursky 5y agoPeople say this about lead, people say this about abortion, people say this about building more prisons and 3-strike laws. Nothing is monocausal, don't trust anyone who makes such a claim unless they provide extraordinary evidence.
- ch4s3 5y agoObviously nothing is monocausal, but it seems like the link with lead here is best supported by evidence among the things you've listed. It holds constant across several countries and cultures where those other factors are quite different. Western Europe wasn't throwing up prisons and enacting 3-strike laws, but saw similar declines in crime. You can find similar counter examples around abortion access as well. Those thing probably contribute, but the effect size of removing lead from the environments seem really large!
- jeffbee 5y agoThe lead hypothesis is supported by particularly strong evidence: there is a natural threshold experiment where school children with blood lead levels over a certain amount are treated to remove lead from their home environment (and their bodies) while other children just below the same lead level were not treated. The difference in later life outcomes are stark. There is no such natural experiment for abortion. It's just an idea. https://ftp.iza.org/dp10872.pdf https://ftp.iza.org/dp10872.pdf
- bpodgursky 5y agoI'm not in the slightest challenging that lead is terrible for IQ; it's the link to national crime stats that I think is more tenuous.
- pessimizer 5y agohttps://jabberwocking.com/has-the-lead-crime-hypothesis-been-debunked/ https://jabberwocking.com/has-the-lead-crime-hypothesis-been...
- DethNinja 5y agoPerhaps past lead usage in fuels will indirectly lead to collapse of the civilisation: Lead is known to decrease empathy and increase crime. I don’t want to generalise an entire generation but boomer generation was heavily poisoned by lead and perhaps this made them more selfish and less emphatic. Maybe this is the primary cause of many current problems? I wonder if humans were supposed to be more emphatic in past before all lead poisoning happened.
- Buttons840 5y agoMaybe, but the events that proceeded the boomers weren't always empathetic. [Rephrased] Was leaded gasoline being used in WW2? I presume so?
- mschuster91 5y ago> Were Nazi's eating lead for breakfast or something? German here. The root cause for Nazism was not just a widespread acceptance of antisemitism, but especially the economic hardships following WW1 that gave rise to populism. A poor and desperate population is always liable to fall for a skilled demagogue.
- watwut 5y agoAnd loss in WWI which was considered unfair along with wish to report it and win this time again. Stab in the back myth, the militarization of all government services and so on and so forth. The antisemitism was not unique to Germany. It was all around the Europe for centuries.
- fullshark 5y agoCrime rates have fallen historically until COVID. I think it's more likely the post WW2 and post Cold War (perceived) eras were periods of irrational exuberance culturally in the west with uncommon optimism in western lead globalism and its future (What you consider civilization I take it). The last few years were a big time reality check on the collective interest in that future.
- veltas 5y agoDidn't we have a previous study debunking this research on statistical grounds?
- bsedlm 5y agothere's this thing about the modern internet era which makes it possible to find a study to debunk (or support) pretty much any idea/theory you want. specially in the midst of an information/propaganda war all I'm trying to say is that I have decided not to think in the way you just did e.g. "where's that study which supports what I already believe?". It doesn't seem like a good tactic anymore
- veltas 5y agoI'm sort of asking if anyone remembers this as well, was posted on HN, I probably could find it myself but since I don't have the time right now I thought I'd make the comment!
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt also does not help that many scientific papers suffer from a reproducibility problem. But I hate to sink into defeatism and assume that there is no such thing as objective fact unless I do the experiments myself (and get them right...).
- Verdex 5y ago> all I'm trying to say is that I have decided not to think in the way you just did e.g. "where's that study which supports what I already believe?". Hmm. It looks like you're ascribing to the above comment the thought process: "I'm only looking for studies which only tell me that which I believe." However, the above comment doesn't seem to be saying this. They thought there was more to the story and are querying for the rest of the story. Meanwhile, you seem to ascribe to yourself the quality of not searching for data that supports what you already believe. However, it seems to me that searching for more studies (even if you're only looking for data that confirms your bias) is a better outcome than assuming (without more proof) that people who aren't you are thinking "the bad way"TM. I mean, if you had searched for additional proof to discover that what you already thought was true about above commenter (ie they were thinking the bad way) you might have discovered that they in fact were simply looking for additional context due to recalling past events that indicated that there might have been additional context.
- softwarebeware 5y agoIt makes me angry to think of how wreckless the generations before millenials were. Lead's risks and damages were well-known long before 1996. And they still didn't ban it until then.
- SimplyUnknown 5y agoI agree that people have been reckless with population safety in past, but your comment seems to imply that the Millenial generation are somehow flawless with regards with this subject. While safety is now more stringent than in the past, I very much doubt that this is the case.
- qorrect 5y agoYeah if anything millennial's were _taught_ to be less reckless. They didn't just come out of the womb that way :/.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoPhysical safety is more stringent. You can't swing a dead cat without a horde of people with safety vests and clipboards writing you up for it. However, the planet is arguably the most ideologically polluted it's ever been. First world cultures have developed an aversion to individual and organization/group responsibility. Democracy is not doing great. Many institutions are bankrupt. Hardship is looming. We're in for a wild ride.
- banana_maker 5y agoAs of 2021, out of 432 members in the house of congress, a scant 31 are millenials. In the senate, just 1. Millenials are -not- the ones responsible for disastrous policies (yet). They haven't been around long enough yet. It's mainly boomers, some gen x, and a few silents. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/02/12/boomers-silents-still-have-most-seats-in-congress-though-number-of-millennials-gen-xers-is-up-slightly/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/02/12/boomers-sil... edit: Added "(yet)" because it's not obvious, I suppose. My point here is that the actual policymakers in congress, right now, are majority "not-millenials". So stop blaming millenials and/or gen-z when they're not the ones currently writing legislature...
- jaboutboul 5y agoWell, this explains a lot...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 5y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29043518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29043518
- webkike 5y agoIQ doesn’t measure intelligence so for all we know this just shows that IQ tests measure how little lead you’ve been exposed to
- gordian-mind 5y agoAdding this to the list of things IQ tests accurately predict: 1) school performance 2) job performance 3) income 4) crime rate 5) health and mortality 6) quantity of lead exposed to 7) NOT intelligence
- throwaway-m3232 5y ago>3) income Hm, I know some obvious contradictions. Just saying.. not interested in discussing this.
- imoverclocked 5y agoevery rule has its exception(s)
- gordian-mind 5y agoIndividual cases do not invalidate statistical trends...
- catchclose8919 5y agoThat's one hard to parse sentence there... or maybe I've been exposed to too much lead as a child :) In all seriousness, IQ is an important component of intelligence, mainly "fluid intelligence" that correlates well to learning speed in science and technology field, so for anyone that needs to do lots of learning/unlearning and career/domain hopping like we're all going to do more and more in the future it matters a hell of a lot! I a world where someone could pick a job/domain and stick to it for life, IQ would matter but less... but it's not the world we're living in, everything is accelerating and our kids are likely to go through quite a few career changes / professional re-conversions etc.
- ascii_pasta 5y ago
- thenerdhead 5y agoWe're definitely smarter now though and know better...or are we?
- legitster 5y agoI have a strong worries that our current generation will have a similar huge reckoning with marijuana. We are already seeing studies that show regular marijuana use is correlated with permanent decreases in intelligence, memory loss, motivation, and mental health. And anecdotally, this seems very apparent in my peer group. And Americans are using copious amounts of the stuff right now, and younger than ever before. I'm not against legalization by any means, or free of my own vices. But the risk in 50 years of people saying "we should have known better" seems really high.
- scythe 5y agoKids aren't smoking weed when they're eight. Or four, for that matter.
- mark-r 5y agoSecond-hand smoke?
- sethammons 5y agoI was at my 3rd grader's outdoor field trip and saw a puff of vape come up from a trio of kids. Someone had gotten a small juul cartridge and they were puffing away on it. The dispenser makes it much easier to hide, but it is not a new phenomenon. My mom started smoking cigarettes when she was 10 years old.
- scythe 5y agoI doubt SHS would ever cause the effects described, unless the exposure was truly massive. The complaint about marijuana affecting intelligence re: brain development hinges on the central effects of THC itself, while lung cancer from SHS typically involves DNA damage caused by contaminants in the smoke (ranging in size from nitric oxide to benzopyrene). DNA damage is typically considered with a linear-no-threshold-model[1] because any incident of DNA damage can have long-term effects on cancer risk, but neurotransmitters likely do have a threshold for long-term damage, because the rate of neuronal receptor activation has a natural range of variation, and disturbances within that range are unlikely to cause any kind of long-term effect, because they simulate the natural conditions. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model - I should add that the way we deal with the LNTM in radiation protection is quite similar to the neuron model I just laid out: we look at the natural variation of radiation exposure and don't worry (much) about exposure less than that range.
- traveler01 5y agoIt explains a lot...
- JohnWhigham 5y agoAnd plastics/PFAS/pththalates being everywhere has brought down sperm counts as well. They all need to be outlawed.
- frazbin 5y ago[flagged]
- mardifoufs 5y agoHere I thought the word "whataboutism" could not be possibly be more overused. You realize that drawing parallels in a discussion is not whataboutism?
- pessimizer 5y agoWhataboutism is when you discuss the content instead of just bickering over the headline.
- jodrellblank 5y agoWhataboutism is not every time someone says “what about X”. It’s when you are asked a question and you dodge it by saying “What about X”. e.g. “Lead is bad for health”, “sugar is bad for health”, “marijuana is bad for health”. Not whataboutism. “Mr Senator what’s with your taxpayer funded holiday?”, “What about YOUR broken election promises?”. Whataboutism. > “Whataboutism or whataboutery is a variant of the tu quoque logical fallacy, which attempts to discredit an opponent's position by charging hypocrisy without directly refuting or disproving the argument” - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- ck2 5y agoLead exposure isn't over by a long-shot. Anywhere there is an airport with prop aircraft there is leaded fuel/exhaust spew for miles around it. Can't believe we just don't have the care to protect people, write it off as their problem and then let the poor/ignorant suffer in "pollution zones"
- cpncrunch 5y agoThe EPA is planning on issuing a proposed endangerment finding for leaded avgas in 2023, and there are already a number of unleaded avgas replacements available that can be used in the majority of aircraft (other than some high compression engines). https://www.epa.gov/regulations-emissions-vehicles-and-engines/regulations-lead-emissions-aircraft https://www.epa.gov/regulations-emissions-vehicles-and-engin... In terms of actual lead, the amount used by aviation is a tiny fraction of that used in cars.
- ouid 5y agoThis headline is very bad, because it sounds like the observation you would get if there were no effect.
- munk-a 5y agoHow does "Thing decreased in half" sound like the effect you'd expect from population independent variables? If, in the last century, the average number of toes had decreased in half I'd have a hell of a lot of questions.
- ouid 5y ago"the average number of toes had decreased in half" is very hard to parse. I have no idea what you intended by this proposition, but here is my interpretation, and yes, I believe you do expect to see one half of the population average a lower number of toes. Say I measure the average number of toes in the population twice. Once in 1990, and once in 2020, and there is no difference in the average number of toes between these two populations. Now instead imagine, for my second measurement, that I sort the people by how many toes they have, pick midpoint of that list, and take the average number of toes in each group. The average number of toes has now indeed decreased in this half. Mind you, I'm just responding to what you said. I have no idea what you meant.
- cf141q5325 5y agoIts one of the really bad part about many regions in Africa at the moment dealing with e-waste. https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2021/10/29/toxic-charge-how-batteries-are-poisoning-kinshasa-children https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2021/10/29/toxic-charge-h... Besides people melting lead batteries everywhere for recycling, much of the cooking dishes are made from recycled aluminum auto parts. Often laced with lead.
- frontman1988 5y agoDR Congo has been exploited so much it pains my heart. Sadly in coming years it's probably gonna get worse for them given they have so many minerals and both China/US are gonna tussle over them.
- jcranberry 5y agoHow did they calculate IQ loss due to lead exposure specifically? https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2118631119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2118631119 I don't have access and the abstract isn't very informative in terms of sample size control group etc.
- jeremyjh 5y agoIt reads like they made some assumptions based on earlier research and did some math.
- krob 5y ago
- programmarchy 5y agoAnd so few capable of nuanced discussion.
- russellbeattie 5y agoThanks for taking the hit from the "HN isn't about politics" crowd, this is something that needs to be said again and again. Right wing conservatives and their followers - aka Republicans - are the number one threat facing the world today, hands down. Beyond their abhorrent legislative agenda based on their shared hatred for various parts of society, their complete disconnection from reality and traitorous attacks on democracy itself have essentially disqualified them as a legitimate political party. In terms of lead's influence: My assumption has been simply that lead and mercury in the air caused a minor, yet statistically significant, impairment of cognitive ability which has robbed Boomers and much of GenX of their ability for both empathy and critical thinking. This has led to a swath of the population who is more susceptible to totalitarian messaging which always include intense hatred of others, conspiracies and wild accusations. To paraphrase an old cliche: All Republicans are NOT lead-poisoned racist sociopaths that think Putin is a great leader, the virus is a hoax, the election was a fraud, etc. However, the reverse, is obviously quite accurate.
- teknopaul 5y agoIndependent of the effect of lead on intelligence isn't it impossible to reduce the IQ of half the population because IQ is a comparative calculation across that population. Ie as intelligence goes down the definition of 100 IQ points changes? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient
- redleader55 5y agoThe IQ should be defined for the human race, in a time independent way, not for a specific nation or group. This allows us to make comparisons between different times, between different societies, etc. Otherwise, if the IQ is redefined to always follow the current mean, it can only be used to classify people between smarter than average and "dumber" than average, which is not so useful.
- quercetumMons 5y agoI'd imagine that it is nearly impossible to control for time with tests like IQ.
- cutemonster 5y agoAuto generate IQ tests, so cannot be learned by trying many times / cannot learn by heart. And have people in the next generation do the same auto generated tests. This won't be perfect, but, using mathematics, Id think it would be possible to know how (im)precise the comparisons would be (confidence intervals of the differences). Also, might not work for really bright people (they'd learn how the auto generated tests get generated? They might sort of "disassemble" them and find the answers quickly?)
- darawk 5y agoThis doesn't work because of the Flynn effect. Raw IQ scores have been consistently increasing over time. So much so that the average person in the 1920s would be considered mentally challenged today, if you used their raw IQ scores. However, we know that obviously the average person in the 1920s was not mentally challenged in the sense that someone with that same raw score would be today. This is all a pretty big mystery and suggests we really don't understand this "IQ" thing we are measuring. However, one big consequence is that we definitely cannot meaningfully compare scores across time.
- programmarchy 5y agoPresumably there's an epigenetic effect from this i.e. having dumber parents would have negative effects on their children. But over time that should improve with the removal of lead from the environment. So we can at least take solace in that things ought to get better: > Blood lead data were instrumental in developing policy to eliminate lead from gasoline and in food and soft drink cans. Recent survey data indicate the policy has been even more effective than originally envisioned, with a decline in elevated blood lead levels of more than 70% since the 1970s. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/about_nhanes.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/about_nhanes.htm
- hash03x 5y ago
- dqpb 5y agoBe careful buying kids toys from china. Many of them contain lead. In fact, it's probably best to not buy anything from a culture of people who hate you. Also, get a lead test for your child at every checkup, not just the ones where they offer it to you. The finger prick doesn't bother them nearly as much as the vaccinations do.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> The finger prick doesn't bother them nearly as much as the vaccinations do. On the contrary, my kids have definitely figured out the cold hard truth. Finger pricks suck much more than injections.
- breakyerself 5y agoBlack children had an adjusted 0.73 to 1.41 µg/dL more blood Pb (p < 0.001 respectively) and a 1.8 to 5.6 times higher odds of having an EBLL ≥5 µg/dL (p ≤ 0.05 respectively) for every selected risk factor that was tested. For Black children nationwide, one in four residing in pre-1950 housing and one in six living in poverty presented with an EBLL ≥5 µg/dL. In conclusion, significant nationwide racial disparity in blood Pb outcomes persist for predominantly African-American Black children even after correcting for risk factors and other variables. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7084658/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7084658/
- fkfkno 5y agoThis recent case seems to correlate closely with that research: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-55330945 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-55330945 (Ella Adoo-Kissi-Debrah: Air pollution a factor in girl's death, inquest finds) https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/dec/16/girls-death-contributed-to-by-air-pollution-coroner-rules-in-landmark-case https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/dec/16/girls-de...
- kukx 5y agoIs it certain that the Pb causes the lower IQ or maybe there is some other factor and poorer people happen to have higher concentration?
- LordDragonfang 5y agoIt's been pretty well accepted for decades that this is the case: >A highly significant association was found between lead exposure and children's IQ (P < 0.001)... There was no evidence that the effect was limited to disadvantaged children and there was a suggestion of the opposite. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8162884/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8162884/ That's a 1994 meta-study that turned up in 30 seconds of googling, and I'm sure more recent evidence also exists.
- raegis 5y agoIt one of the most impactful studies on how lead affects intellectual development, the researcher (who is white) restricted the study to white people only because he assumed (correctly) his results would be ignored if he included African Americans who are disproportionately affected by lead poisoning.
- ivanech 5y agoThe Lead Exposure Elimination Project (https://leadelimination.org/ https://leadelimination.org/) is an organization that's working to solve this problem internationally. I've been giving money on a monthly basis and have been blown away by their progress.
- Krasnol 5y ago> Experts suggest that lead paint is now one of the most important current and future sources of lead exposure, as well as the most tractable source to address. https://leadelimination.org/factfile/ https://leadelimination.org/factfile/ Why is it so popular in the US? Is it better? Cheaper? I'm quite shocked to see it's still happening. Lead in pain has been forbidden for interiors in Germany since 1921 (exterior since 1989)...
- istjohn 5y agoIt was banned in the US in 1978.
- Krasnol 5y agoSo this is all historical and not being removed because of the cost?
- aidenn0 5y agoCorrect. Though note also that lead paint was being phased out already earlier than 1978, so single-family homes built after 1960 or so are less likely to have lead. That still leaves a lot of dwelling units, particularly those that were not renovated recently (i.e. cheaper places).
- mkr-hn 5y agoI still remember the school shutting down the playground to get rid of lead paint back in K-12. In the 1990s.
- leecarraher 5y agoand then i thought, well look who is telling us that
- Workaccount2 5y agoWait until everyone finds out about what COVID is going to do...
- munk-a 5y agoAye, in twenty years when we fully understand long covid a lot of people are going to regret not putting in the blood sweet and tears to convince ignorant family members that the vaccine is actually a good thing. We're also going to probably look back on the lack of continued remote learning as a dire mistake.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hash03x 5y ago
- jccooper 5y agoFor context, leaded gasoline phase-out began in 1973, based on the 1970 Clean Air Act. It was largely gone in the US by the 80s but not officially eliminated (except for General Aviation) until 1996. Other countries continued to use leaded gasoline, largely in Africa and the Middle East; the UN started an effort in 2002 to eliminate it in those places still using it. In July 2021, the last stocks of leaded gasoline (in Algeria) were exhausted (probably literally).
- hadlock 5y agoYeah in the US I recall in 1991 or 92 the pumps had "UNLEADED" in great big letters running up the side of them. My dad's '77 chevy had a gas gauge near the center console that said "UNLEADED FUEL ONLY". There's been another push to get rid of leaded gas in aviation but studies show that it's virtually undetectable in the environment.
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoI remember the UK in the 90s/00s had unleaded written on the pump too, but there was no leaded option. Actually, I think I have a vague memory pre-millennium of there being leaded pumps (typically red handle vs the green unleaded)
- mark-r 5y agoThey made the gas tank filler hole a smaller diameter for unleaded gas cars, so that the leaded nozzles wouldn't fit. https://uiobservatory.com/2010/how-intelligent-design-saved-a-car-engine/#:~:text=Pumps%20for%20unleaded%20fuel%20were,catalytic%20converter%2C%20rendering%20it%20useless https://uiobservatory.com/2010/how-intelligent-design-saved-....
- 09bjb 5y agoSource? I have no reason to doubt you but would love to see where those data. Most of what I heard is that "lead exposure above zero is significant" and "if you're living near an airport, especially one serving smaller plans, you are being exposed".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hateful 5y agoThomas Midgley Jr can be thanked for this. He also played a role in developing CFCs (Freon). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Midgley_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Midgley_Jr.
- pklausler 5y agoMidgley can be blamed for leaded gasoline, but not lead paint or lead plumbing. (He also came to a famously ironic end, strangling in a rope contraption of his own design.)
- brain_staple 5y agoNot so ironic, that's exactly how I'd expect Midgley to die.
- Borrible 5y agoWho would have thought. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_Needleman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_Needleman 'The Removal of Lead from Gasoline: Historical and Personal Reflections' https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.547.9785&rep=rep1&type=pdf https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.54... 'Lead, IQ and Social Class' https://academic.oup.com/ije/article-abstract/18/1/180/616820?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/ije/article-abstract/18/1/180/61682...
- jhoechtl 5y agoI really doubt that. While I am aware of shrinking IQ, as far as I know its a thing of the last 30 years, leaded gas in most developed countries was already outlawed.
- kikokikokiko 5y agoIQ reduction is totally expected from the moment contraceptive methods became fully available. Common sense seems to be out of fashion these days, but Idiocracy was spot on: the dumber you are the more prone to "unexpected" pregnancies you'll be. The future will not be Star Trek.
- maerF0x0 5y agoyou never know. We might be able to hit a critical mass with Authoritarian regimes regulating reproduction, and through gene editing. Perhaps when we finally translate "unintelligent people" into "vermin" we'll do what many previous iterations of society have done... genocide. Part of this is literally possible. A big part of made stark to point out that we should be careful in the way our language dehumanizes people of below average intelligence. They're still part of our species, and biological history.
- 09bjb 5y agoUntil we treat "unintelligent" people in our society with compassion and respect I think "intelligent" is a misnomer for the remaining demographic.
- marcusverus 5y agoMany things are true simultaneously. Genocide is a moral abomination, and we should be vigilant in guarding against it and its precursors. And folks with below average intelligence are just as human as everyone else, deserving of the same respect and the same rights. And there are many contemporary factors that would seem to make high IQ people less likely to procreate low IQ people--including the high cost (including trade-off costs) of children and the ready availability of contraceptives. And long term downward pressure on IQ would be a disaster for our civilization and a danger to our species. We can't let the ghosts of eugenicists past scare us away from asking important questions. Avoiding the awful mistakes of the past will require care and diligence, and can be (must be!) done without embracing the easy path of reactionary "moral" ignorance.
- MrYellowP 5y agoI guess that explains a lot, but let's not ignore the horrendous education system.
- nicolas_t 5y agoI was recently horrified to learn that the baby glass bottle I had been using with my baby had lead paint on it. https://tamararubin.com/2021/12/sailor-themed-glass-nuk-baby-bottle-2021-bpa-free-and-only-15400-ppm-lead-in-the-paint-jk-90-ppm-lead-up-is-unsafe-for-kids/ https://tamararubin.com/2021/12/sailor-themed-glass-nuk-baby... Apparently, it's considered to be acceptable by current standards. Despite the fact that babies will obviously touch the bottle (and the paint) and then put their hands in their mouth. I bought glass bottles because I wanted to avoid plastic thinking it'd be safer and I was reassured by seeing that they were manufactured in Germany :( I think we still have very far to go in terms of toxic substance exposure.
- zapataband1 5y agolearned about teflon via the movie 'Dark Waters'... it was horrifying
- fkfkno 5y agoThere's also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titanium_dioxide#Possible_carcinogenicity_by_ingestion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titanium_dioxide#Possible_carc..., which is used in many glazes and coatings, but also as a whitener in health supplements and toothpaste!
- nsajko 5y agoTitanium dioxide is also widely used in cosmetics because it blocks ultraviolet light. Together with zinc oxide, it's the basis of sunscreen. As a pigment, titanium dioxide also seems like it's currently the go-to less toxic replacement for the lead-based pigments in lead paint.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- screye 5y agoHas widespread use of lead been exclusive to the US ? I'd imagine that there are other countries which still haven't transitioned off lead, and that they can be used as control. Alternately, are there states that never embraced widespread lead use and if they can be used as a control too ? Some also attribute the removal of lead to substantial decrease in violence over the last few decades. So, I am not surprised that the effect size here is so large. Might an impolite question to ask, but is there a known correlation between IQ and propensity for physical violence ? (controlled for socio economics and protected classes of course)
- thinkcontext 5y ago> Has widespread use of lead been exclusive to the US ? No. Leaded gasoline was used throughout the world. Leaded paint on the other hand was in some cases banned in other countries 50 years before it was in the US.
- sacrosancty 5y ago> Might an impolite question to ask > controlled for [...] protected classes I hope not. This fear of not fitting in with contemporary politics is toxic to science. Social science is already badly broken and is filled with it. If somebody can't be objective because of fear of being labelled a heretic for not deferring to the law to decide which factors must be controlled for, they have no business doing science on that topic. Are you aware that genetic information is a protected class in America, despite the fact that it influences IQ? Why would you arbitrarily control for that, but not for other factors that influence IQ such as maternal care? It's complicated to decide what to control for, but the law is absolutely not the place go to make that decision.
- krrrh 5y agoOne of the most heartbreaking things I ever learned about was the high levels of lead in Mexican candy. This is apparently mostly due to the inks used in the packaging. https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/articles/10.5334/aogh.2754/ https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/articles/10.5334/aogh.2754/ The following paper also pegs pottery as an issue. Just devastating. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214999614000794 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221499961... > Our results indicate that more than 15% of the population will experience a decrement of more than 5 IQ points from lead exposure. The analysis also leads us to believe that lead is responsible for 820,000 disability-adjusted life-years for lead-induced mild mental retardation for children aged 0 to 4 years.
- nebula8804 5y agoAh crud...in years past I have bought large bags of Mexican candy from Amazon...and subsequently eaten all of it. :( Does anyone know if there is a test that can tell "historical" levels of lead? It sticks around in the blood right? So if I get a regular lead test will it account for any historical consumption? Has there also been any research into devising a test to determine if IQ has fallen due to lead poisoning? I guess I don't see a way for this data to be collected after the fact?
- alar44 5y agoEating a few bags of candy isn't going to do it. It's going to take years and years of constant exposure. People in this thread need to calm down. Even if you did lose 5 IQ points, it's not like Flowers For Algernon here... No one would even notice. The only reason we can is due to large sample sizes over decades and decades.
- sizzle 5y agoAte so much Lucas powder growing up :(
- sgfgross 5y agoIn case anyone is interested in the article itself: https://oa.mg/work/10.1073/pnas.2118631119 https://oa.mg/work/10.1073/pnas.2118631119
- downrightmike 5y agoSmall airports have more smaller prop planes, fun fact, they almost exclusively use leaded gas because it gives them more power. So if you live near one, you're getting a dusting of lead everyday. Like this one in the middle of $500k+ homes suburbs: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Chandler+Municipal+Airport/@33.271614,-111.8154887,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x872baafcb69fb1b3:0x6347ef40ce6a7333!8m2!3d33.271614!4d-111.8133 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Chandler+Municipal+Airport...
- dmitrygr 5y agoThis has been disproven so many times, it is tiring to even try. Small amount, dispersed over huge distances. Current measurements indicate NO more lead in the blood of people near airports than not. It is only heard nowadays from land developers seeking to capitalize on a few acres among "the middle of $500k+ homes"
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoDon't forget the part about "gives them more performance" which is just an overt lie. They use it because aviation is regulated to high heaven and there are no approved alternatives yet.
- Ancalagon 5y agoYeah I believe it’s more of an maintenance deal. The leaded gas causes less wear on the cylinders and pistons, so generally makes the plane safer and less risk of a major malfunction during a flight. There aren’t many alternatives with similar characteristics to leaded gas. We used to use it in cars for the same reason, but decided the maintenance/safety/health trade offs were worth banning it.
- mfkp 5y ago> there are no approved alternatives yet Not exactly, you can get STC approval to use mogas in most piston engines, it's just a hassle and expense so most people don't do it: https://www.autofuelstc.com/ https://www.autofuelstc.com/
- nwellinghoff 5y agoA 150 USD RO/DI filter can remove all of this stuff. Black, white, poka dot. Buy one and run your drinking water through it. Also comes in handy when the water goes out. You can turn off from the mains and have clean water. Also pure enough to use in your radiator or water your venus fly trap! Highly recommend.
- erosenbe0 5y agoThat covers water not dust, which is thought to be the bigger culprit if we are talking about kids.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoNot only boomers got exposed to lead, they also got exposed to dioxin from trash burning, asbestos from construction, and who knows what else.
- phlipski 5y agoThis message feed reminds me of the (excellent) book "Cradle to Cradle". It's about sustainable design/manufacturing and one of the lines that has stuck with me since I read it years ago was (summarizing here), "In the US we regulate how much poison is acceptable per person rather than just outright eliminating the poison!"