31 ms·
Facebook said my article was false – now the fact-checkers admit they were wrong
- young_unixer 5y agoThe problem with fact-checking is usually not the fact-checking. The problem is giving a label as simple as "true", "false", "misleading" to some assertation that can be more complex than that.
- rgrieselhuber 5y agoInternet Fact-Checkers with de facto censorship capabilities funded by shady corporate interests. What could go wrong?
- baq 5y agotakes a look at facebook no moderation at all could happen
- criddell 5y agoLots of things could go wrong but nobody realistically expects perfection. Do you think the fact checkers have ever taken down anything that was total bullshit and potentially harmful? Probably, right? So some things could go wrong, but hopefully many more things go right. I also hope the process isn't static and evolves after failures like this one.
- josephcsible 5y ago> So some things could go wrong, but hopefully many more things go right. I think way, way more things go wrong than right with "fact checking".
- rgrieselhuber 5y agoThis was all figured out in 1517, letting the clergy be the sole arbiters of information does not end well.
- mannanj 5y agoIt couldn't have been figured out, because we kept the 1st Amendment for a reason. We figured not having the ruling class/big corporations/government/big media be the sole arbiters of information truth doesn't end well either.
- IshKebab 5y agoYeah and they figured out how to deal with disinformation on social media too, which existed back in the 1500s.
- criddell 5y agoI bet most of what they take down is bullshit claims like Bill Gates put a tracking chip in the COVID vaccines.
- bdhska 5y ago> Do you think the fact checkers have ever taken down anything Aren’t the people who take things down censors (not fact checkers)?
- rvz 5y agoSo fact-checking has become a new way of distorting and censoring articles that have credible sources but seem to disagree with the overall bias of the platform (Facebook, Twitter, etc.) Maybe one should just go back to the age old saying: 'Don't believe everything you read on the internet.' Given that even these so-called 'independent fact-checkers' can also be wrong. Who checks the 80+ so-called fact-checkers? Or the 'trusted news initiative' [0], which Meta (Facebook) is part of? [0] https://www.bbc.com/mediacentre/2020/trusted-news-initiative-vaccine-disinformation https://www.bbc.com/mediacentre/2020/trusted-news-initiative...
- Clubber 5y agoUnverifiable theory, but I think when the news was just the few media companies who ran TV and newspapers, selling a narrative was easy. Look how easily we got tricked into going into Iraq and staying in Afghanistan for 20 years. Now that news is more distributed (as originally intended) by independent journalist on things like YouTube and substack. Not only do these independent journalistic outlets exist, they are more popular than traditional news (TV/print), making various propaganda efforts much more difficult to stick. This is one of several strategies to regain control of that propaganda channel.
- rmellow 5y agoSorry but there was enormous international pushback against it (curiously this is when they started calling French Fries "Freedom Fries"): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governmental_positions_on_the_Iraq_War_prior_to_the_2003_invasion_of_Iraq#Opposing_U.S._Position https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governmental_positions_on_th... I'm sceptical that the population that was "tricked" back then wouldn't be just as easily swayed nowadays. Political affiliation is largely an emotional matter to a great mass of people, and rationality has a limited role in it.
- Clubber 5y ago>Sorry but there was enormous international pushback against it Sure, there was domestic pushback too, but the "trusted" news sources actually countered that pushback by not questioning the government line and bolstered the whole WMD fear mongering. The NYT actually apologized for it after the fact to try to save their reputation. https://www.theguardian.com/media/2004/may/26/pressandpublishing.usnews https://www.theguardian.com/media/2004/may/26/pressandpublis... The NYT, et al also refused to publish the Snowden revelations until they absolutely had to (after the guardian pushed it). Same with the Clinton/Lewinsky thing. They refused to report on the Hunter Biden laptop either, which, like it or not, is "fit to print." There were also quite a few anti-Assange articles if I recall.
- rootusrootus 5y ago
- Clubber 5y agoIsn't FB also now a political rag?
- seibelj 5y agoIt does appear that any half-assed study, done on the quick with obviously poor data, is trumpeted immediately as "trust the science!", but completely obvious facts, like that no one in Florida is wearing masks even in tight spaces (I'm in Florida now, and bars / restaurants / beaches / streets are packed with no-maskers), yet their covid rate is lower than New York, California, and Massachusetts which have very strict requirements. It's hard for me to trust any official statement on covid anymore.
- czzr 5y agoWhat’s your explanation for the difference between New York and Florida?
- seibelj 5y agoFlorida accepted that everyone will eventually get covid, and the statistics for death / hospitalization rates for the non-immuno-compromised and non-elderly are very low, so they just did the "Keep Calm and Carry On" ethos and it became endemic much sooner. However they did have strict requirements for nursing homes. Basically, let everyone choose their own risk tolerance, and accept that we can't control this. Very slowly, after years of trying to fight the inevitable, liberal states are understanding this. But they are still pretending that a force-field surrounds you the moment you start eating food or drinking which makes masks not required at that moment, which is obviously absurd.
- floren 5y ago> But they are still pretending that a force-field surrounds you the moment you start eating food or drinking which makes masks not required at that moment, which is obviously absurd. Here in SF the force field comes into effect the instant you sit down at your table and only dissipates when you stand up to leave... but God help you if, after a 90 minute maskless meal, you don't put your mask back on for the 15 second walk to the door.
- huitzitziltzin 5y agoNone of this should be taken as an argument against fact-checking either in theory or in practice. There is no set of fact checking policies that will be free from errors. (Indeed nor are the journalists who write the articles infallible, as they would surely admit.) What’s important is that the fact checkers accept corrections and recognize that they are fallible too.
- huntertwo 5y agoAfter they’ve already imposed their biases and censored information. It’s ok that I ran over your dog while driving blindfolded - I owned up to it after all. Fact checking has no benefits other than imposing the biases of the fact checkers. Sometimes imposing those biases is “good”, sometimes it’s “bad”. But let’s call a spade a spade - this isn’t fact checking. This is bias imposition.
- DarylZero 5y agoWhatever, better to block the spread of medical information from uninformed sources even if a stopped clock is right twice a day. Censor everyone without an MD for all I'm concerned. The misinformation is worse.
- hattmall 5y agoLots of MDs have been censored lately.
- brightball 5y agoWell, the article highlighted above was censored and fact checked for calling out a bogus study used to support nationwide medical policy…
- Nextgrid 5y agoScience does make mistakes but the process in general is thorough enough that they are rarer than idiots dishing out medical advice & spreading fear on Facebook.
- tomohawk 5y agoInternet fact checkers are merely enforcing their opinions over other opinions. Facebook, for example, makes the claim that their fact checks are just opinion in trying to defend themselves in a lawsuit. https://nypost.com/2021/12/13/facebook-bizarrely-claims-its-misquote-is-opinion/ https://nypost.com/2021/12/13/facebook-bizarrely-claims-its-...
- triceratops 5y agoI don't get why that's contradictory or bad. It's FB's website, FB's property. They're quite free to say "In our opinion, this is factual and that is false". They're under no obligation to allow others to say whatever they want. We wouldn't say anything about a restaurant or bar owner kicking out patrons because they offend other patrons or staff. Why is FB any different?
- john_moscow 5y agoBecause it has become the only bar in town with free booze sponsored by the local hospital handling drunk driving accidents. Make the social media platforms interoperable, and force them to charge the costs directly to consumers (so that the platforms could compete on price/quality) and people will run away from it like rats from a sinking ship.
- triceratops 5y agoSo all this "censorship" talk is really an XY problem[1], then. My honest opinion is that most people who cry "censorship" don't care about truth or actual freedom. They just want their shit to go to the widest audience possible. I'll change my opinion when more of the "censorship" crowd acknowledges that while they strongly disagree, FB (or any other website) has every legal and moral right to "censor" them, because that's also what freedom is about. You can't be for freedom only when it favors you. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_problem
- josephcsible 5y ago
- programmarchy 5y agoAre the fact-checkers actually real people? I'd imagine if Facebook wanted to clamp down on Coronavirus-related "misinformation", they'd do a sentiment analysis on any phrase with CDC, FDA, etc. and if the sentiment was negative or "bad", then it'd automatically get flagged. If there is a human in the loop, I doubt they are reading the full article, or have any meaningful expertise. Probably just reading the headline, and clicking approve.
- antattack 5y ago"they ignored important factors like varying vaccination rates; and they counted outbreaks instead of cases." As masks are supposed to lower outbreaks - focusing on outbreaks makes sense to me.
- CountDrewku 5y agoNot the point of the posted article, since it specifically deals with the ridiculous reasons for Facebook censoring the post. However, you seem to have stopped reading the Atlantic article after sentence you took out of context. "The authors defined an outbreak as being two or more COVID-19 cases among students or staff members at a school within a 14-day period that are epidemiologically linked. “The measure of two cases in a school is problematic,” Louise-Anne McNutt, a former Epidemic Intelligence Service officer for the CDC and an epidemiologist at the State University of New York at Albany, told me. “It doesn’t tell us that transmission occurred in school.” She pointed to the fact that, according to Maricopa County guidelines, students are considered “close contacts” of an infected student—and thus subject to potential testing and quarantine—only if they (or that infected student) were unmasked. As a result, students in Maricopa schools with mask mandates may have been less likely than students in schools without mandates to get tested following an initial exposure. This creates what’s known as a detection bias, she said, which could grossly affect the study’s findings. (Jehn and McCullough called it “highly speculative to make the assumption that identified close contacts are more likely to be tested than other students.”) McNutt believes that masks are an important prevention tool in the pandemic, but she maintained that the Arizona study doesn’t answer the specific question it purports to answer: whether mask mandates for students reduce the spread of SARS-CoV-2."
- antattack 5y agoYour quote is not in the reason.com article linked here. Anyway, text quoted points out incomplete identification of outbreaks, not that it was not right to track them. In fact, it would have made no difference tracking cases because of school district's policy of testing only 'unmasked' individuals.
- 5y ago
- persona 5y agoThese are early symptoms of a Truth-Market-Fit approach[1] where "fact-checking" is defined by the financial benefits in keeping a following or customer base. The "Fact checkers" have become Trust Providers. Different groups of people will choose to 'believe' different Trust Providers according to their own views. [1] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/truth-market-fit-unbundling-trust-from-platforms-lucas-persona/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/truth-market-fit-unbundling-t...
- destitude 5y agoThis is my biggest problem with the response to Covid in the USA.. the very "loose" information provided/parroted by officials that are designed to manipulate public perception without simply providing the facts for people to make their own judgments. One of the current ones is how you keep hearing how hospitals are "overwhelmed" and we are running out of beds.. they neglect to tell you the impact of all health care providers that had quit because they refused to take the vaccine. So in affect it was the hospitals own policies that caused this issue. This is why Minnesota has called on the National Guard to help replace all the nurses that quit. There are plenty of beds/ICUs just not enough employees to cover them.
- VikingCoder 5y agoHi, I have friends and family who are doctors in Minnesota. They were overwhelmed even before the hospitals decided to fire the health care workers who don't listen to health care advice. Your "biggest problem" is not based on fact.
- mannanj 5y agoYour local hospitals in Minnesota are not hospitals nationwide. I have many hospitals in Northern Virginia, DC, and even LA that have been nothing close to "full" for many months of the last year, the media portrayed them as full. Your "biggest problem" is not based on fact.
- VikingCoder 5y agoThe person I was responding to specifically cited Minnesota. You said "have been nothing close to 'full' for many months of the last year." A reasonable interpretation of your words is that there was at least one month last year where the hospitals in your area were "close to 'full'." How long does a hospital need to be "close to 'full'" for the people who work there to feel "overwhelmed"?
- VikingCoder 5y ago> So in affect it was the hospitals own policies that caused this issue. CITATION NEEDED Are you talking about the 53 Allina employees (out of 27,000) who were fired? https://bringmethenews.com/minnesota-news/allina-says-it-parted-ways-with-53-of-its-27000-employees-over-covid-vaccine-mandate https://bringmethenews.com/minnesota-news/allina-says-it-par... The 0.2%? That's what you think did it? And the National Guard - is this what you're referring to? > The Minnesota National Guard will deploy 400 members to reinforce nursing staffs at long-term care facilities https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2021/11/22/minnesota-national-guard-to-reinforce-nursing-home-staffs/ https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2021/11/22/... They were deployeed to long-term care. Not ICU. If you want to make the argument that it was losing staff to vaccine mandates that resulted in hospitals being overwhelmed, I think you have a big hill to climb to make a credible argument.
- hereforphone 5y agoFact checking has been laughable from the beginning. It is inherently biased. The heavy political leanings of those in direct control of the organizations' verdicts are brought up time and time again, and even memes are being made about sites like Snopes. My favorite meme goes something like: Did x member of y political organization get arrested for hitting some in the head with a baseball bat? FALSE. [big block of text] X member of y political organization was arrested for hitting someone in the head with a cricket bat. [big block of text]
- stjohnswarts 5y agoTheir hit rate on truth is probably 95/100 though as opposed to far left media which has gone flat out bonkers. I'm glad services are there.
- yaomtc 5y agoWhenever I see a Snopes article where the claim is similar to the facts, but some parts are off, they use "Mixed", not "False".
- zimpenfish 5y ago> baseball bat? [...] cricket bat. In my experience, Snopes would have rated that "Mostly true" or "Mixture". Do you have examples where they've given a clearly misleading rating?
- hereforphone 5y agoAre you questioning the veracity of memes sir?
- shadowgovt 5y agoNo, just checking facts.
- _dain_ 5y agoFor example, this whole article just should not exist: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/feb/15/facebook-posts/keystone-xl-suspension-probably-wont-boost-oil-pri/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/feb/15/facebook-p... There is a whole genre of "fact-check" articles of the form: "X says that Y will cause Z to happen. Here's why experts say that's wrong." i.e. "fact-checking" a prediction about something that will happen in the future. Unless you're clairvoyant, that isn't a fact-check because the facts literally haven't happened yet! So any rating at all is misleading. I mean yeah, maybe you could fact-check something that can be predicted with high accuracy, like whether a solar eclipse will happen. But they do it for economic and social and political issues. They just shouldn't, at all. "Fact-checking" is just clever marketing label for meta-journalism, i.e. journalism-about-journalism. It isn't some category that has magically different standards or incentives than ordinary journalism. It perplexes me that smart, skeptical people think that Snopes or Politifact are somehow free from the exact same bias-producing incentives and motivations of every other news outlet.
- cletus 5y agoWhen I first heard about this plan to "face check" articles on Facebook, I was actually floored because it's just such an obviously bad idea. There is always going to be a point where reasonable people disagree about what is correct and what isn't or what should be fact-checked and what shouldn't. And you're not even dealing with reasonable people. Even if you limit it to the most egregious cases that just shifts the problem. What's egregious and what isn't? I actually believe it was well-intentioned. Just... completely misguided. You know what they say: the road to Hell is paved with good intentions. Second thought: it's weird to me how many conservatives and conspiracy theorists (it's interesting that there's so much crossover between these two groups) are so keen to dismantle Section 230 when they benefit the most. In an effort for platforms to remain neutral, this nonsense is allowed to exist. If platforms were responsible for this "content", it'd be shut down so fast. But here's a good thing to keep in mind: from a narcissist an accusation is actually a confession. Trump is a textbook narcissist. Go back and look at his accusations through that filter.
- newsbinator 5y agoI think it can be implemented well: there will always be a point where reasonable people agree about what is correct. That point is obviously very, very conservative (lower case 'c'). Reasonable people can all agree that Covid is a thing that exists, for example. I don't mind Facebook fact-checking against flat-earthers, "it's just a flu bro", or "Bill Gates put 5g microchips in vaccines". Reasonable people from any place would agree those are counter-factual. But I tend to get banned from subreddits as an anti-vaxxer because, for example, I say my first 2 shots were Pfizer and I refuse to get Moderna for my third one (Moderna is the only one my government currently permits my age group to get). There are facts for and against this position for reasonable people to weigh. It's still often a ban on social-media for spreading anti-vax misinformation though.
- mannanj 5y agoThere are always casualties to policies of "fact checking". You have witnessed yourself being one. I think it would have been nice to have some better policy or conversation in place for what happens when you become the one erroneously fact-checked, because instead what's happening now is it just happens in the shadows and by the time it happens to you it's too late and you're stuck with this system that actually just works counter-intuitively to the issues that are the most important to you. It's sort of like the slow eroding of freedoms and transition to fascism that people seem to be fine with because "protect us against COVID" which we're all fine with it until that policy is flipped on them and happens to impact them.
- jerf 5y ago"Fact checking" is one of the best scams in the past couple of years. In this case I scare quote it because it really is that specific phrase that I am referring to, not the process or the people. Somehow, labeling something a "fact check" gave whatever was so labeled immense authority and gravitas, merely by virtue of being a "fact check". It also proved it was Platonically Non-Partisan, because Fact Checking is just intrinsically non-partisan, because it's a Fact Check. Do you not trust the Facts? It was a good gig, but political partisans can't help but spend all the gravitas and authority they can find as quickly as possible, and what you see here is the account drying up. It'll take a while longer to complete that process but I don't expect people to have any more trust in "fact checks" than anything else in 5 years. "Fact checks" are nothing special. Political partisans have been "fact checking" each other forever, complete with misrepresentation, failures to even read the thing they're fact checking, all the usual errors. They just didn't call it a "fact check". Merely labeling something a "fact check" changes nothing, and quite obviously did not impose any sort of higher standard on the so-called "checkers" either. Nor does Facebook have any authority or capability in any sense of the term to bless any particular "fact checker" with them being anything more that Facebook's official opinion. (In this, their argument in their lawsuit is completely correct.) Of course, that causes problems. If Facebook indeed somehow has direct access to the Fountain of Truth, they can perhaps be justified in decorating the speech of other people with the Truth from this fountain. If, on the other hand, they're just opinions, that raises a whole host of questions. Why do they feel like they can decorate other people's speech with their own opinions? On what basis do they declare these "facts"? How amazing it is that Facebook, a corporation whose purpose is to serve ads and incidentally provide a service to people to gather information for those ads, are also medical experts, political experts, and experts of all sorts of other things. What accountability will Facebook have when it turns out their opinions, which again I remind you include very strong medical opinions, are wrong? (Don't get too caught up on Coronavirus specifically; having started making medical decisions we can believe they will continue to do so. Even if you believe they have the perfectly correct balance of Truth today, there is no reason to believe that will continue indefinitely. And with their leverage, they have the capability to multiply the consequences of error hugely, perhaps more than anyone else.) If they are not lofty, impartial experts graciously spending their money to guide the masses to the Truth, then they almost immediately collapse into something more like arrogant jerks who bully their particular biases onto people with the threat of kicking them off the world's largest platform if they don't conform. One imagines that Facebook would not prefer to be seen that way. They've really bet rather a lot on the Fact Check mythos.
- m1117 5y agoPlease don't use facebook. Use twitter.
- shortstuffsushi 5y agoWas a /s intended here?
- abernard1 5y agoOne day, humans in the future will look in awe that a role such as Fact Checker was viewed with anything less than contempt. They will also remark on how odd it was that a small little dot in Northern California felt themselves capable of this task, and simultaneously did not understand why they were unpopular with everyone but themselves.
- briffle 5y agoColion Noir has a similar tale [0] with fact checkers at politifact, and gives timelines of emails, etc that is pretty interesting. He is all about guns, and of course, the person that 'investigates' him is completely against guns. He was also doxed by politifact. The overall process seems disturbing. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0ASAxY0Roo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0ASAxY0Roo
- VikingCoder 5y agoSee if you can spot the difference in these two headlines: "A Study That the CDC Used To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science." "The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science." Which one makes it seem like some evidence used should be discarded? And which one makes it seem like Mask Mandates have been proven to be a Junk Science? See that word "The" in the headline the author used? That sure makes it sound like the single source of evidence was wrong, and so therefore the conclusion is wrong. If you want to be really safe, and not clickbaity, you could even go for, "Mask Mandates May Be Effective, But One Study the CDC Used Had Deeply Flawed Methodology." That's only four characters longer than the original one: "The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science."
- hunter2_ 5y agoFlagging content with is_clickbait actually sounds quite a lot nicer than is_false ... You might be onto something.
- VikingCoder 5y agoFacebook makes money by hosting click bait. Facebook is worried about public perception if they host false information. The financial incentives are all wrong, and people make money with click bait headlines, so we're going to watch companies like Facebook wrestle with this, and sometimes make what we consider to be "the wrong call."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- strenholme 5y agoWhile I’m a moderate Democrat, and no libertarian, [1] I have a lot of respect for Robby Suave, the author of this piece. He has been very good about pointing out the abuses of the radical left destroying people’s lives for things like wearing a costume at a 2018 Halloween party which the radical left woke mob decides is politically incorrect in 2020. [2] In addition, he has supported due process during the #MeToo “believe all women” moral panic when many on the radical left wanted to get rid of presumption of innocence and due process. [3] [1] Certain problems require big government to solve: Police, military, roads, and, yes, health care [2] https://reason.com/2020/06/18/washington-post-blackface-halloween-costume-cancel-culture/ https://reason.com/2020/06/18/washington-post-blackface-hall... [3] e.g. https://reason.com/2017/11/16/dear-prudence-meets-due-proces/ https://reason.com/2017/11/16/dear-prudence-meets-due-proces...
- xwolfi 5y agoI don't know the guy but he looks very preoccupied with facebook drama, with inflammatory titles, and mounting scandal on top of a scandal. There are people who would rather see the liberal left burn alive than convince a few people not to vote for them for this boring reason 1, and this boring reason 2 and... It's fun to troll online, but respect... I wouldn't ask for it, I don't think he should either :D
- strenholme 5y agoIt’s fun to troll online Without more context, I have to assume you’re talking about the articles he wrote which I linked to in the grandparent. I am not sure how pointing out it was unfair to get a woman in her mid-50s fired because she wore a costume in 2018 the Washington Post retroactively decided was politically incorrect in 2020 is “trolling”. More like, standing up for fairness, compassion, and justice.
- xwolfi 5y agoI was referring to my own post. That person trolls like I do. I wouldnt ask for respect, I wouldnt give him any: he's exacerbating drama rather than solving the problem with the CDC, simply by using emotions rather than rational proposals. Something I respect surprisingly is the wapo article https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/blackface-incident-at-washington-post-cartoonists-2018-halloween-party-resurfaces-amid-protests/2020/06/17/66f09bde-af2e-11ea-856d-5054296735e5_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/blackface... full of various points of views, explaining the issue clearly, taking no special position itself, even going to tell that person felt so bad about her idea of a joke or the reactions to it she left in tear, causing compassion for her in me... So maybe it's trolling to say the wapo calls an old incident politically incorrect ? :p As an amateur troll myself I get why she found it funny to fight fire with fire and why some people just cant go that many levels of irony and it's hard to sometimes face the reactions to your own trolling. The Wapo itself seems completely innocent of any position and I appreciate the further attempt to paint it as such as good trolling, when they were trying to untroll the debate. Just like wearing a blackface to criticise defending blackfaces.
- djoldman 5y agoI'm interested in the eventual outcome of this case: > "This case presents a simple question: do Facebook and its vendors defame a user who posts factually accurate content, when they publicly announce that the content failed a 'fact-check' and is 'partly false,' and by attributing to the user a false claim that he never made?" wrote Stossel's attorneys in the lawsuit. "The answer, of course, is yes." I hope there is no settlement if it proceeds.
- akersten 5y agoThe mental gymnastics to contort labelling of posts as defamation is so laughable. There's nothing defaming about "we had X group review this post and they found it was False." It doesn't matter if X group was incorrect in their assessment- what matters is that statement ("group reviewed and their finding was --") is purely true. That's not defamation of character (which would be "this poster is lying"), it's a true statement about an opinion that was reached ("fact checkers consider this article False information"). It's a subtle, but critical distinction. They don't have a case, IMO.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- djoldman 5y agoThe text generated and written by Facebook says: > False information next paragraph: > Checked by independent fact-checkers If you want to get to subtle and critical distinctions, a straightforward reading of the above is: "this is false information. the fact that it is false was checked by independent fact-checkers." A reasonable reading is that facebook labels the information as false and that that was *confirmed* by fact-checkers. If they mean to say: "fact checkers labeled this as false and so we are hiding this information" then they should say so plainly, no?
- xwolfi 5y agoQuestions for the guy would be: - did the title had to be THAT inflammatory (did it have to say "JUNK", did it have to make the link to the CDC reaction to it rather than the main point) - was Facebook the right place to share such important insight, rather than a research paper, or even a letter to the CDC - is it the right reaction, in a sensitive period with sensitive misinformation, to further inflame the whole thing saying that not only masks are junks for schools (at least his title makes you think so on facebook), that now it's even fact checkers that are wrong... I don't know why this guy can't solve problems and just create new ones, but damn he's wasting a lot of people's time and produce very little value outside of more anger, more doubt and more division :D
- mannanj 5y agoNot the OP, but my reasoning for all your points. 1- All posts are competing for attention. You live in a society where if you don't get someones attention right away, you're speaking to a wall. 2- The CDC is overworked, behind on response, has a clear agenda, and would likely not do anything. Often making a public outcry or outrage is the best way to reach this bigger slower beaurocratic agencies. Unless you're saying you know someone on the inside and could actually contribute to having a discussion with the right person? Or are you just saying you're good at providing "solutions" without any ability to actually help? 3- Sounds like you are making an opinion that the OP made the wrong reaction, that is your opinion, not something based on fact. Opinions about right/wrong are by their definition opinions, not fact, to be paraded as talking points by "fact" checkers. His discussion did not waste my time. I for one like to be challenged. But if you don't like going to a place where you have your opinions challenged or strengthened, then maybe you should go to a place with opinions more like yours. I would argue you complaining about someone posting an opinion article online and calling it divisive, is the mere definition of an attack that is divisive. Your post reads divisive and passive-aggressive angry to me (you literally read the entire post and then complained about it wasting time).
- xwolfi 5y agoI dont disagree with your point entirely: it's important to discuss perspectives. But I disagree he's challenging opinions, he's triggering emotions. It's not wrong when it's on the latest movie, but maybe he could understand he's talking about health policies for children at school, maybe that could be done with care to avoid blanket statements at risk of deviating the debate from: should they or not wear the damn thing, to: is the CDC a bunch of elitist incompetents wasting our tax money, something I think is uncalled for. And imagine the damage if he manages to convince there are no fact, that fact checking is impossible and that anyone is entitled to publishing wide reaching random idiocies under the blanket of a sacro saint right to be an idiot :D
- 323 5y agoPeople trusted media. But then media was exposed as partisan, and then as outright liers. So fact checkers were invented. Now fact-checkers are exposed as being partisan, and sometimes outright lying (see BMJ vs FB fact-checking fiasco). So we need to go deeper, we need to invent something new, above fact checkers, which will be trusted again. What could such a thing be?
- mannanj 5y ago> What could such a thing be? I think we need a fact checker for the fact checkers. I propose we let the fact checkers fact check themselves.
- baq 5y agoslashdot did just that 15 years ago.
- neop1x 5y agoMaybe soon people will "trust" some NFT or the owner of that NFT in the Metaverse...
- reaperducer 5y agoSo fact checkers were invented. No, fact checkers existed for decades before social media. Even before the internet. I've worked in newsrooms as recently as the 1990's where there were fact checkers. Usually nice people with many very large, expensive books to double-check things. But when the media companies became beholden to Wall Street instead of the public, the fact checking departments were the first people cut in the name of "maximizing shareholder value." That was followed by consultants ( * cough * Broadcast Image Group * cough * ) who constantly pushed for more and more "breaking news" hype and convinced news managers that it was more important to be first than to be right. The public ate it up and it became a feedback loop. I could go on, but this isn't the place for it.
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoOr, we can just educate our population with albeit dry, but acceptable methodology to identify what is and is not fact. Teach us to fish.
- nottorp 5y agoNot that i would trust Facebook with fact checking generally, but these people sound to me like antivaxxers who got away on a technicality.
- mannanj 5y agoYour post is an Ad hominem style based of reasoning to shut down discussing any of the actual uncomfortable truths behind the post. You used antivaxxer as an ugly label to ignore discussing any of the points.
- nottorp 5y agoI guess some people believe Facebook can be fixed. I don't so any honest discussion about moderation processes is pointless to me.
- paul7986 5y agoWhat to believe nothing just live by my intuition which says ignore all for profit biased media and only believe in long term science..years and years of data.. cause an example the CDC in December recommending against the Johnson and Johnson shot which they previously recommended in early 2021 ..omg ..they are still trying to figure this all out out. My intuition says China knows a lot to all and Covid will further accelerate them to becoming the super power of the world... the world just sits by and let's it happen..has helped them get there too. Ughh
- mannanj 5y agoWho fact checks the fact checkers? Why we fact checked ourselves and found nothing wrong. Let's not forget the fact that those teams are also severely understaffed.
- foverzar 5y agoThe whole concept of corporate censorship is such a BS. How can you possibly build a system that could dissect truth from lies on such a scale? And yet for some reason people demand more and more censorship and blame Facebook for "not doing enough". How come?
- baq 5y agoit isn't a question if it can be built. we know it can't. the question is whether it can result in a better outcome than no moderation whatsoever.
- p2p_astroturf 5y ago[dead]
- rapind 5y agoMy guiding principles reading news stories: 1. Fact checking is usually biased. 2. The more sensational the headline, the higher the chance of garbage journalism and bias. 3. The more boring nuance the better the chance of accuracy. If I was building a news ranking engine I would use these principles. It would probably be at least somewhat useful in filtering out the garbage, except no one would use it because the articles near the top wouldn’t get people to click, and the only possible revenue stream would need to be paid since it can’t be optimized for engagement and still function.
- MrsPeaches 5y agoMight still be worth prototyping though?
- timr 5y agoI once heard someone on a podcast (forget who) propose that the #1 thing that the social media platforms could do to promote accuracy is to establish a "moderation filter" -- something that looks for extreme language, and down-weights it. It's interesting to think about what the unintended consequences of this might be. An entire media of passive-aggressive political intrigue?
- dredmorbius 5y agoBoring can also have bias, frequently in the form of damping bad news or a painful action. On HN, shutdown and departure posts tend strongly in this direction. It's a general and widespread PR tactic. There's also the distraction (or bread-and-circuses) model of propaganda. The former Page 3 Girl in the Sun, sport, celebrity gossip, or horse-race political coverage come to mind.
- mc_woods 5y agoMany see just the headline, draw conclusion and may then repost / share, many more read only the headline. Click-bate headlines will fall foul. Robby (article author) - just write more accurate titles and the fact-checkers can't argue.
- pharke 5y agoHuman nature never changes, for an entertaining take on our current situation see part 3 of Gulliver's Travels published in 1726 https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jonathan-swift/gullivers-travels/text/single-page#part-3 https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jonathan-swift/gullivers-t...
- raverbashing 5y agoFact checking is a blunt instrument against the lack of subtlety and polarization going in internet discussions In fact, about the article concerned, even if correct in essence (and I don't see a reason why not) it is probably not conductive to good discussion. Because it wants to set a tone at the headline level (amongst other things). > For these and other reasons, Zweig argues that the study ought to be ignored entirely: Masking in schools may or may not be a good idea, but this study doesn't help answer the question Exactly! (from the article in question). But it's beside the point. If the study is good or not is a perfect valid discussion, if the CDC has made a good decision it is a perfect discussion, except discussing this in a magazine article is BS. Because it is assigning blame and picking a side. Wearing a mask in a pandemic is a tiny issue, but it's being blown out of proportion. That study is one of the inputs the CDC takes to take a decision (again, in a pandemic, under pressure and under changing scenarios). And if the CDC is wrong then revert it. Again, nobody is dying for wearing a mask. So, if fact-checking it was petty, the article itself was petty as well. Nothing of value was lost.
- nova22033 5y agoIt's their platform. They have a right to decide what's misleading and what isn't. You'd expect the editor of the Libertarian magazine Reason to understand this.
- polote 5y agoOne of the biggest issue with fact checking, is that fact checkers don't try to see if something is true or false. But they guess what people are going to understand from a post and then says whether or not those understandings are true or false. For example if you say "There is no evidence that mask has helped reduce the spread of covid". You will probably be fact checked as false, because they think people will understand "Masks don't work".
- lostcolony 5y agoWell, that would be a valid thing to note as false. Perhaps you meant "in this particular study, there is no evidence that mask use helped reduce the spread of COVID", in which case, yes; people will understand it as "this study showed that masks don't work" rather than "this was a poorly conducted study"
- andybak 5y agoSigh. Comments in this thread are predictably polarized. I personally think that fact checking is potentially damaging to society but so is the ability of social media to spread misleading claims. It's difficult to predict which is going to be worse in the long run. As in many things we'll probably learn to tolerate a degree of both and aim to find a "least worse" outcome. Anyone claiming here either that no fact-checking would be the best outcome or it's inverse (I can't quite formulate what that would be right now) is probably wrong and the messy middle is probably correct.
- bdhska 5y ago> fact checking is potentially damaging to society Why do you think this? I am struggling to understand.
- andybak 5y agoThe argument would be along the lines of "It will stifle debate and silence voices on topics outside the orthodox view. A simple glance through the history of science shows many ideas now regarded as fact were initially heretical and outside the mainstream. Open discussion of controversial ideas is healthy." which is obviously reasonable. However it needs to be balanced against the other problem we face - widespread dissemination of inflammatory misinformation, in many cases by nation states deliberately sowing dissent.
- dundarious 5y agoFact checking as it is currently practiced is counter-productive: unknowable things are called "facts", and "pinocchios" are given even if you're factually correct just because (being charitable myself here) the checker things you're not being charitable enough to their political faction.
- unclebucknasty 5y agoI keep seeing allusions to this bias. Can you point to any mainstream fact checking organizations that are consistently biased and any specific fact checks that illustrate this?
- nu11ptr 5y agoI am 44 and if I had to sum up what I've learned in my life into one concept it would be this: The truth, real truth, is EXTREMELY hard to ascertain. Therefore, be open to new ideas, but slow to accept anything as absolute truth. Those in power push narratives. Conflicts of interest make data questionable. "Experts" are just people with their own inherent biases. And often we simply learn new things. Therefore, I can think of very few things more damaging to society and free speech than "fact checkers". Almost always I find that their "facts" are nothing more than the "opinions" of the most powerful and influential group at the time, and are usually entangled with politics. In short, "fact checkers" don't actually understand the definition of what a fact is, but are quick to declare them, and this is contrary to my experience of real, actual truth.
- new_stranger 5y agoYou're over-complicating this. Facts come from studies that have been published which are disproven four years later when finally repeated. So for a couple years at least, it's always clear what the truth is.
- nu11ptr 5y agoTruth, real truth, never changes - which is why it is so important to be slow to declare it. Our best collective understanding at a particular time is exactly that, but that is different than truth or fact, because often that understanding turns out to be wrong, which is why it is so crucial that dissenting opinions are heard.
- aficiomaquinas 5y agoI think it would be interesting if you could share some examples of what you believe to be real truths that never change.
- new_stranger 5y agoTruth that never changes is not beneficial for planning. I recommend you find a more useful, relative truth. Don't get me wrong, it's important you know the real truth, but that isn't often the one you gain much from promoting. Promoting actual truth can be rather damming at times.
- mannanj 5y agoMy problem with these fact checkers is it feels too much like the ruling class/big corporations/government/big media becoming the sole arbiters of information truth again- and we know that doesn't end well.
- davidw 5y agoFact checking is imperfect, but what's the alternative? Social media where people rampantly share "Pedo lizard people firmly in control of Democrat party" type articles, and various and sundry other garbage. Combine that with Brandolini's law, and the whole thing is just a sewer. As we've seen during the pandemic with anti-vaccine nonsense, this has cost people their lives. It's easy to point out flaws, but like anything, it's trickier to build something better.
- rytcio 5y agoBack in the olden days, they were looked at as weirdos and ignored.
- davidw 5y agoRight, back in the olden days, you'd have a couple of drunk guys at the end of the bar ranting about their BS, and at most, you'd just kind of give them some room. Maybe people might start avoiding the bar if it regularly filled up with angry loons. Now their rants get spread far and wide across the internet.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Social media where people rampantly share "Pedo lizard people firmly in control of Democrat party" type articles, and various and sundry other garbage. How do you feel about telephones, public spaces, or even private spaces that allow information like this to be spread? What about books? It's a lot easier to just go along with things that nobody asked you permission to do anyway than to point out flaws. Also, by "flaws," are you including the opinion that "fact-checking" as practiced is bad and shouldn't be done? That rings strangely; you wouldn't say that somebody telling you not to eat cyanide is pointing out a flaw in your eating of cyanide.
- davidw 5y agoYou're arguing in bad faith if you think that books or telephones have the same kinds of dynamics that social media does. And if you want to pick examples from those, no one forces local book stores to carry some racist screed calling for the extermination of a group of people. They can choose to not do that, the same as Facebook can choose to not publish something. The problem is that there are multiple, competing bookstores, so while it's unlikely that most of them are going to publish the racist screed, there certainly exist stores that will carry books with varying points of view. Facebook, on the other hand, benefits from positive network externalities to the point where for some people it becomes 'the internet'. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/06/rohingya-sue-facebook-myanmar-genocide-us-uk-legal-action-social-media-violence https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/06/rohingya-... - this stuff has real world consequences. What's the best way to deal with that? I think we all agree that "quash all debate and dissent" is not good. But "just let people post whatever, wherever with no consequences" is not great either. I don't have all the answers.
- JPKab 5y ago>"Climate Feedback, a subgroup within Science Feedback, labeled two of his climate change–related videos as "misleading" and "partly false." Stossel's situation is similar to mine in that the fact-checker attributed to him a claim—"forest fires are caused by poor management, not by climate change," in this case—that his video never actually made." ...... >"Stossel eventually succeeded in getting two Climate Feedback editors to admit that they had not watched his video—and after they had watched the video, they agreed with him that it was not misleading, having noted that both government mismanagement and climate change have contributed to forest fires. But Climate Feedback still did not "correct their smear," according to Stossel." This is the new regime we have created for ourselves. Many of you folks reading this are extremely high IQ, and yet you have supported this system that delegates the responsibility for the ideas you are allowed to consume to knuckle-dragging morons. Somebody should stop and think about the kind of people that a job like "fact-checking" will attract. It's not high-paying, is inherently boring, and reminds me of a security guard kind of position. I can think of two categories: 1.) Hardcore ideologue hall-monitors who passionately believe in a "cause" and, based on my extensive interactions with activists and religious fundamentalists as a kid, have thinking patterns based in tribal, overly-emotional narratives and tend to be quantitatively illiterate. (You will not find many people who ever took calculus/statistics in either a Pentecostal church OR a social justice protest.) My father is one of these activists, has surrounded himself (and by proxy, me) with these people for decades. The ends always justify the means, and the only information they accrete from the digital firehose is content designed to monetize their confirmation biases. 2.) ne'er do well types, often from privileged backgrounds. You know the type: That person who has travelled to all sorts of very interesting places all over the world (on their parent's dime), provided they had a beaches, nightclubs, and hordes of other western hedonists. They kind of fall into these relatively unsupervised, non-demanding, low-paid but not low-status jobs at non-profits. (I used to do pro-bono work for various DC non-profits, and more often than not my work would be wasted because teaching one of these trustafarian idiots how to use the web apps I built for them was harder than writing the goddammed app ever was.) We can't trust these people to be in charge of what is true. We can't trust ANYONE, and that's the entire point of the Enlightenment era philosophy from hundreds of years ago. We're just relearning these lessons now.
- 5y ago
- kyleblarson 5y agoThese "fact checkers" are nothing more than a means for big tech and big media to push their increasingly authoritarian "progressive" narrative. Until more people realize this and just walk away from FB and other platforms it's going to continue. There's hope though, look at the relative readership / viewership of independent journalists and podcasts relative to mainstream media. When CNN has a clip of a reporter standing in front of a bunch of burning buildings with a chyron that reads "fiery but mostly peaceful protests" even the dimmest among us has to see that they are not a news organization. There are plenty of examples for every other mainstream media outlet as well.
- lostcolony 5y agoAh yes, the complaint of "progressive big media". You know the first time I decided a media outlet was pushing an agenda? When Fox News famously asked its audience as it went to break if Obama's fist bump was "a terrorist fist jab". This isn't a "progressive" narrative; it's whatever narrative fits the interests of the company. Sometimes it's progressive, such as when it comes to social issues. Oftentimes it's conservative. I've yet to see CNN etc laud unions, higher taxes on the rich, universal healthcare, etc, even in stories they were reporting on where it would make sense (such as the high cost of private healthcare, or times it didn't cover something ludicrously expensive for someone because reasons, etc)
- kyleblarson 5y agoI anticipated the typical "But fox news but fox news but fox news" which is exactly why I added the last sentence to my comment.
- finite_jest 5y agoThe "complaint" is on point. Most of the major US mainstream media outlets are indeed biased in a particular direction. See for yourself: find a list of major news outlets [2] and check their political leanings [3][4]. Fox is mostly an outlier. You could perhaps argue that they are more "woke" than "progressive". [1]: And many other institutions, see https://richardhanania.substack.com/p/why-is-everything-liberal https://richardhanania.substack.com/p/why-is-everything-libe... [2] e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=News_media_in_the_United_States&oldid=1060446870#Major_news_sources https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=News_media_in_the... [3]: https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/ [4]: https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings
- upofadown 5y agoWhy would you want to fact check a social media site like Facebook anyway? The vast majority of the communications there are ultimately expressions of feelings. There is no way you can fact check such a medium into a source of objective fact. It makes as much sense as having fact checkers in pubs and restaurants. Sure, there is going to be misinformation spread in those places but ultimately the people involved understand that things spread by random people might not actually be true.
- arminiusreturns 5y agoIf you arent thinking and talking about Operation Mockingbird and its inevitable successors we dont know the name of you will be missing the plot on this topic.
- Zak 5y agoThe underlying problem in the case this article describes is one of classification. Fact checking every claim is a lot of work, so fact checkers find a widely-circulating claim to check and generalize it from whatever various specific claims are in circulation. In this case, it was generalized to "there's no science behind masks on kids". That claim is easy to check, and it's false; there are multiple scientific studies showing that requiring masks in schools reduce covid rates among students. The author's article did not make that claim or anything that could be reasonably reduced to "there's no science behind masks on kids". Instead, his claim was that the CDC made a recommendation based on a specific study, and that the study in question has serious methodological flaws (the headline phrase "junk science" is a bit sensational). That's a more narrow claim, most of which probably falls into the category of opinion or analysis rather than fact-checking.
- godelski 5y agoI think what many here and the writers of the article are missing is that you can both be truthful and misleading. These are not mutually exclusive. Let's start with the title: "The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science". If you just read this (titles are very important and most people only read these) what will you take away? What the authors are trying to say is that this one study has problems. But reading further in the article they rise doubt about masks in general, which is something we know is highly effective (purely from a physics point of view). They don't say masking is effective, they continually question if it is. This is really problematic. The study being wrong doesn't question _if_ masking is effective, but _how_ effective. There's a major difference in these statements and they can have readers, who are not experts and don't know scientific vernacular, to doubt and distrust more science than the article _technically_ draws into question. The article is suggesting that this is the norm and because this study is bad we get to question all the others. So the problem here really is that while yes, the article only questions the one study they do so in a way that questions more fundamental knowledge that we have. Masking works. How much? Harder to say. There's a few old sayings such as "the devil never tells a full lie" or "the devil sows doubt" (often with truth). These are the errors that the authors are making here. I would conclude that they aren't inaccurate, but are misleading.
- goodluckchuck 5y ago
- crisdux 5y agoYou are coming to this article with your own biases. You seem to be basing your analysis that we "know" masking is highly effective. That is not true. The evidence used to justify this policy is low quality(don't you remember the CDC hair salon study) and dependent on the precautionary principle. High quality evidence on masking has either low effect sizes or is inconclusive. It is certainly not settled science.
- flerchin 5y agoWe do know masks prevent the spread disease. Look in any Operating Room. If masking by the general public is shown to be ineffective, that only argues for further education on how to mask properly.
- literallyaduck 5y agoIt would be nice if a case was brought for libel and all Facebook and the fact checker communication was subpoenaed to show a clear instruction and bias to mislead. Without paying a price they will continue to gas light, lie, influence elections with funding from foreign powers.
- MarkLowenstein 5y agoIf a fact-check is ever found to be wrong, isn't that proof that the fact-checker is claiming things to be fact, when they aren't? I'd support a licensing system for this, at the individual and company level. If Facebook fact checks are ever wrong, even once, they lose the ability to call anything they do a "fact check". Same reason certain ice creams are now "frozen dairy desserts".
- nathias 5y agoAs an epistemologist I can only say I never imagined things will get this retarded in my lifetime.
- maxdo 5y agoThis all stuff reminds of two kids fighting in front of teacher. What's your opinion on how a person should crack an egg :) So much drama about such a basic concept. Yes it helps in general to stop the spread, maybe in some cases it's less effective, or not needed at all. Why on earth people dedicate so much energy to discuss a tiny subset of mask application? How's that a big deal?
- maxdo 5y agoThe most funny that whatever you call a media bias... Media is catered towards what people want to discuss. Sadly that's what's people think is important.
- vixen99 5y agoAs another example of Facebook's 'expert fact checkers', here's the letter recently written to Mark Zuckerberg by the editor in chief and others of the British Medical Journal - which is, as they say, one of the world’s oldest and most influential general medical journals. https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2635/rr-80 https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2635/rr-80
- dagmx 5y agoIt's depressing that the majority of the comments here are just reiterating the same trite arguments of authoritarianism. Whenever even mildly political posts show up on this site , especially regarding US politics, it becomes a shitshow. For example, you'll find the anti-maskers/covid-deniers arguing that this is proof that masks are ineffective and just another step towards government control. That's despite the author actually saying anything to that effect. Then you'll have the libertarians (with some Venn diagram cross over) saying that fact checkers don't allow individual thought, without acknowledgihow damaging false information spreading on social media is. You'll also have well meaning progressives completely fumble the nuance of the situation. in the end, the issue here is the author wrote a clickbait blogspam specifically to exacerbate emotions, got the expected result and then followed it up with another to capitalize on it. Their original article had a specifically written title or "Junk Science" to seem more incindiary than the source they quoted (which used "shaky science" instead). That's a dog whistle of a title. Perhaps Facebook needs more nuance in their fact checking classification with the ability to label something as clickbait , requiring authors to pick less inflammatory titles for their content. I suspect that would go a long way to improving social media anyway. Perhaps it could put the post behind a clickbait warning clickthrough or a strong clickbait text below the article. Or perhaps, like on HN, the post titles could be altered to directly represent the content.
- mr_tristan 5y agoFact checking just seems like another business we haven't hired to solve a problem generated by the platform itself. I find that the problem here isn't fact checking, it's just the control of these private social media platforms is too broad. This points to why there needs to be a clearer mechanism of rights for an individual's content. Meta owns a free license to not only repost your work, but also to modify and generate derivative works from it. What I don't understand is what they own when it comes to public content shared via links. Given the success of AMP, I suspect the answer is "you don't own much of anything on the internet". DRM so far has been successful at allowing content generators to counteract the control of content providers. I sometimes wonder if we need easier personal DRM. Then, if some provider decides to misrepresent you, you can just yank the license. Or at least, there should be some kind of contract between the license holder and the provider. Maybe web3 helps here? I'm still leery of putting all your eggs in a centralized blockchain system. But other than PDFs, I can't think of other approaches you can take.
- stevenalowe 5y agoImagine you’re having a conversation with a friend at a coffee shop, and an employee interrupts you by shouting “that’s false!” “Fact checking” should be opt-in, at the very least. And blockable, like an uninvited troll
- nova22033 5y agoStossel, it should be noted, is currently suing Facebook, Science Feedback, and Climate Feedback. He acknowledges that a private company has the right to ban, take down, or deprioritize content as it sees fit. Moreover, different individuals and organizations can disagree about basic factual questions like the science of climate change. But he says that in attributing to him a direct quotation that he never uttered, the fact-checkers committed defamation. Seriously?...Stossel is a contributor to Reason.
- fortran77 5y agoThe "actionable" part is that Facebook is mis-attributing statements to some sources like "Reason" and John Stossel that they never made. > But [Stossel] says that in attributing to him a direct quotation that he never uttered, the fact-checkers committed defamation. I think someone may be able to get a judgement against Facebook if the "fact-checkers" err in this manner.
- snowwrestler 5y agoMany people on social media read only the headline, not the full article. (Including here on HN.) So, it’s arguable that this should be taken into account by fact checking. A title that is misleading is a problem even if the article body itself is scrupulously accurate, since way more people will see the headline than read the article. This is known and weaponized. A site will intentionally publish an accurate article with an inaccurate or misleading headline. If it is flagged by fact-checking, they get several more cycles of engagement out of complaining about the “unfair” or “biased” fact check, and especially if they get it reversed, as in this case. In this case the original headline was “The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science.” That is misleading because a) the CDC considered far more than one study, b) which study “convinced” them is impossible to prove and a matter of opinion, and c) “junk science” is an uninformative pejorative. If the headline had been “One Study the CDC Referenced When Considering Mask Recommendations Had Problems,” it would have been more accurate and less likely to be flagged. But also less useful to Reason in attracting attention and advancing a narrative.
- unholiness 5y agoFact-checking sets up a seemingly-circular definition where "a trustworthy source is a source trusted by trustworthy sources" It reminds me of a similarly recursive definition in Google's original pagerank algorithm: "A popular site is a site linked prominently by other popular sites". for pagerank, there was a nice way around the issue: apply popularity iteratively. You can imagine starting with some initial guess (perhaps that every site is equally popular), then score sites which are heavily linked higher to update the score. Then, use those scores to weigh the value of their links (unpopular sites' links matter less, popular sites' links matter more) and evaluate popularity again, and again... Of course, this is simply a matrix multiplication applied infinitely many times. If the matrix is not singular (which, if your system is sufficiently connected, is vanishingly unlikely), then the final solution will converge to the eigenvector with the largest eigenvalue no matter what your initial guess was. The definition of popularity which seemed which recursive, wasn't. It doesn't matter who you assume is popular to start with, if you apply the definition enough times, you will arrive at the same result. It makes me wonder if there is a possible computational aid to some of these fact-checking dilemmas, where we don't need to trust anyone a priori to have trust in the whole network. In areas where we can't look at truth as some absolutely thing, that doesn't mean we should we throw our hands up and say "everything depends on who you ask". We can still have a goal of evaluating things that are incredibly likely to be true, false, misleading, etc. Society has lots of imperfect tools for evaluating information from those who know more than us: We can look at their past performance, we can understand their incentives (e.g. brand harm if discovered), we can check if others disagree, we can use quality heuristics (e.g. superficial flaws can be a sign of deeper flaws), we can gain some small expertise to help evaluate the greater experts. None of these things are perfect signals but they are strong signals. Currently fact-checking is cobbling together these signals informally, with responsibility spread out culturally among the organizations' internal hierarchy, the fact-checked victims complaining, some outsiders who bother to fact-check the fact-checkers, everyone's subjective trust of brands, etc. I wonder if there could be a more formal way to do this, where sources fact-check each other in a decentralized way. The ultimate score of trust would come not from one single source of authority, but from a global evaluation, which anyone could calculate, of this recursive definition of trust. It would come with its own set of problems (google-bombing was a common thing in that era for rarely-searched terms) but it still seems like a massively useful tool, and one I've never seen an attempt to formalize.
- kazinator 5y agoI don't see how Facebook could staff a fact-checking operation with a high quality army of nothing but sharp, critical thinkers who have excellent reading comprehension. Those kinds of people will tend to be educated and have real jobs.
- zuminator 5y agoI'm curious as to whether the people on this thread who are adamantly against fact-checking and censoring of any kind also on principle refuse to downvote individual posts or threads on online forums. A downvote is akin to fact-checking, marking a post with your disapproval (generally of its veracity, although it could be its attitude, logical coherence, or other reason). And enough downvotes can cause a post to disappear, to be effectively censored.
- nllsh 5y agoWas the study bogus? Reading the article (https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/12/mask-guidelines-cdc-walensky/621035/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/12/mask-gui...) from the Atlantic that this article is truncating as well as the original study (https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7039e1.htm?s_cid=mm7039e1_w https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7039e1.htm?s_cid=mm...) you might find that the Atlantic article presents the following arguments towards the point that the study has serious flaws, they are as follows: 1. The author (David Zweig) points to https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/09/school-mask-mandates-downside/619952/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/09/school-mas... as proof of skepticism about the costs and benefits of mandating that children 2-12 wear masks in school. That article begins with the statement "The potential educational harms of mandatory-masking policies are much more firmly established, at least at this point, than their possible benefits in stopping the spread of COVID-19 in schools." but ends with the statement "Do the benefits of masking kids in school outweigh the downsides? The honest answer in 2021 remains that we don’t know for sure." The author has failed to present a coherent thesis for their skepticism, and as it reads it appears that their view actually softens by the end of the piece. 2. David Zweig begins their second critique of the Arizona study with, "This estimated effect of mask requirements—far bigger than others in the research literature—would become a crucial talking point in the weeks to come." yet this is a fundamental misread of the study that happens often in science reporting. They study actually says, "In the crude analysis, the odds of a school-associated COVID-19 outbreak in schools with no mask requirement were 3.7 times higher than those in schools with an early mask requirement (odds ratio [OR] = 3.7; 95% CI = 2.2–6.5). After adjusting for potential described confounders, the odds of a school-associated COVID-19 outbreak in schools without a mask requirement were 3.5 times higher than those in schools with an early mask requirement (OR = 3.5; 95% CI = 1.8–6.9)." This is not a causal statement, it is a correlative one. This is to say that the study does not make the point that the mask mandates cause reduction in covid outbreaks, but that those schools with mask mandates clearly experience fewer outbreaks. This conflation is made many times throughout the rest of the article. It matters because, like most science, the study adds to our understanding of reality, and if we misunderstand the science it's likely we are misunderstanding reality. 3. Jonathan Ketcham is quoted, at first without an actual point, as saying: "You can’t learn anything about the effects of school mask mandates from this study". This isn't really an argument so it's interesting that it's made it into the an article on the science section of the Atlantic. It also shows that Jonathan Ketcham may have conflated causation and correlation as well. Without naming them or providing any other attribution, the article then makes an implicit argument from Ketcham's quote: "His view echoed the assessment of eight other experts who reviewed the research, and with whom I spoke for this article. Masks may well help prevent the spread of COVID, some of these experts told me, and there may well be contexts in which they should be required in schools. But the data being touted by the CDC—which showed a dramatic more-than-tripling of risk for unmasked students—ought to be excluded from this debate." So the experts interviewed all agreed that masks "may well help prevent the spread of covid" and that there "may well be contexts in which they should be required in schools", but the data in the study we are citing should be excluded from the public discourse. To me, this section requires a lot of brain twisting work. The experts (even those critiquing this study) say masks help (this is not a may well statement). The experts say we might want to mandate masks in schools. But for some reason, this study that finds some valid correlations shouldn't be talked about in the public debate. I find this nonsensical considering the article that wants the public to not use this research in debate must use the research to achieve its goal. If the author really wanted that data to go away it should be doing what any good scientist would do, which is more science. Get some more data, show that the models presented by the study are in fact wrong. 4. Noah Haber is quoted as saying that the research is, "so unreliable that it probably should not have been entered into the public discourse." Great quote for a science article. It's got a lot of information to sink your teeth into. At this point in the article I find that I'm very annoyed by the lack of actual science reporting. It mostly reads as shit stirring to me. ...continued
- golemotron 5y agoWhen these platforms were just exercising editorial control it was enough to make them liable for defamation and libel. Now that they are representing points of view, it's time to consider breaking them up. A duopoly of FB and Twitter isn't enough diversity for a rich ecosystem.
- mikotodomo 5y ago> The article in question was this one: "The Study That Convinced the CDC To Support Mask Mandates in Schools Is Junk Science." Shouldn't be surprising that something so close sounding to anti-masking is automatically blocked. Just tell them if it's an error and they will fix it.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI don't actually like the idea of fact checking. That said, just because it makes X (or X%) mistakes doesn't make it a bad system. Not in isolation. Arguing against it because it isn't perfect is bad faith.
- kmeisthax 5y ago>But that doesn't mean the status quo is particularly satisfying. It's good that the fact-checker reversed course in my case, but needless to say, Facebook should revisit its formal, contractual relationship with an organization that routinely misquotes the people it scrutinizes. The problem is that Facebook is using fact checkers as a crutch to deal with the problem that... 1. They have a monopoly on the attention of gullible old people 2. As a result of this, anyone who wants to exploit said demographic goes through them The easiest way to actually fix the problem of gullible old people would be to just ban them from the platform so everyone else can enjoy their free speech[0] in peace. Instead, Facebook deliberately targets them. This is not limited to fake news, misinformation, or right-wing political screeds that you might disagree with; they are also one of the biggest platforms for scammers to sell fake products to that same group of people. Facebook, like everything else these days, optimizes for "whales" with high value to the business, and that just so happens to be gullibility. Fact checking in this sense is like the "drink responsibly" they whisper at the end of a beer ad. It's not for actual safety, it's to have something to throw at critics during a crisis. [0] "Free speech" in this context refers to a private platform, not the government. Yes, this is a slightly different definition and Facebook isn't bound by the 1st Amendment.
- dkn775 5y agoI was always taught in political science courses that the think tanks did research favoring the right or the left. This was instilled in me long ago - That experts will be used by politicians to do research (on what is a choice) that has findings (again - another choice being made) - which the politicians can use (whether they do and how are choices). Choices abound in a scenario like this, each one are the typically hidden sources of bias. I just don’t understand why the fact check thing is seen as credible, to me it’s just a new age version of the think tank dynamic but for a different time. Note that I’m not saying it shouldn’t be used, as I still will rely on think tank research here and there. But knowing the source of their incentives is important. “Follow the money”
- jquery 5y agoThis thread sure attracted the racists, no surprise. They’re furious social media doesn’t let them call people racial slurs online, or let them spread wild conspiracy theories.
- jenkstom 5y agoReason.com has added way too much suffering to my life to have any positive opinion of. Lies like this are still available on their website https://reason.com/1996/06/01/sick-of-it-all/ https://reason.com/1996/06/01/sick-of-it-all/
- jquery 5y agoThe fact checkers didn’t admit they were wrong, they merely unflagged the article. If this is what the author think passes for logic no wonder they flagged him. Article was garbage clickbait for anti-maskers anyway.
- IsThisYou 5y ago
- bena 5y agoAnyone who talks of "the fact-checkers" as a sole, unified entity is a complete and total moron who is incapable of having a relevant opinion on anything. No discussion with them is going to lead anywhere interesting or useful as they continue to talk in circles. There are multiple organizations that check facts. Hell, even news outlets do this. Even we do it. When we check the veracity of a claim, we're being "fact-checkers". The only reason to cast people who check the veracity of claims as a monolith is to then say we should throw out the whole group.
- harry8 5y agoIf false then anything. If you exist then something inconvenient. You can't prove you exist so given that any fact can be rated as anything truthfully. You little-endians are all hopelessly deluded and your total unwillingness to be reasonable and your constant lying is all the justification required for the behaviour of big endians who are Noble, righteous and completely truthful in that context and i say that objectively. Fact check: true!
- worker767424 5y ago> There are many Republicans and Democrats who want to scrap Section 230 entirely: President Joe Biden, former President Donald Trump, Sen. Josh Hawley (R–Mo.), and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D–Mass.) have all denounced [Section 230's] protections for Big Tech companies. That's a scary list of people to agree on something. I think all their arguments boil down to "big tech isn't censoring people the way I want them to."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- randomNumber7 5y agoFact checking is stupid, but if you are serious about it you should fact check religions.
- charlieyu1 5y agoPost something genuine, then someone with bad intentions shared it with something fake. Now you are who is contributing to fake news.
- camdenlye 5y agoHumans are never the loyalty fans of truth (especially when it comes to social or political issues). Fact-checkers or selective reports or anything else like that is all an outcome of that the majority of us choose to believe what we stand for rather than the simple truth. People become more and more divided until there is no common area, then there is war. History has shown us many times.