67 ms·
Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan to make shots compulsory
- rchandna 5y agoI don't know if you guys are history buffs but...
- rasengan 5y agoThis doesn’t make sense. What about antibodies? What about the fact that vaccinated still catch and spread the virus? None of this adds up and it’s likely it all goes back to Wikileaks.
- arrakis2021 5y agoWhat about antibodies? How will Pfizer get paid with your antibodies? You sound ridiculous.
- detaro 5y agojust FYI, previously infected don't count as "unvaccinated" in this regulation.
- ipspam 5y agoIt's not meant to make sense. You are being told that your body is no longer yours. It's owned by the state.
- yladiz 5y agoAs of right now people are not forced to get vaccinated in Germany, so you still "own your body". This is mainly making those that choose not to get vaccinated to make a choice - don't get vaccinated and basically be restricted from doing most nonessential things, or get the vaccine.
- mythrwy 5y agoI didn't force the teller to give me the money. I only head a gun to his head and told him to give me the money. He was free to refuse at all times.
- elmerfud 5y agoGermany classifying certain groups as undesirables and restricting their movements. This seems very reasonable.
- nazinazinazi 5y agoIt is almost like Germany did this at one point in time, sometime in the 1930s? What was that one guy's name? Schitzler? Blippar? Nitler?
- TechBro8615 5y agoI’m confused. I thought vaccinated people can spread the virus. Why are they not locked down too?
- bigyellow 5y agoBecause this was never about any virus, it's about social control and covering up for political failures of the last several decades.
- lillecarl 5y agoBecause the risk of transmission is understood to be significantly lower, and since unvaccinated people are more likely to cause the virus to mutate it's in the governments best interest to get people vaccinated, a way of accomplishing this could be making life inconvenient for the uncompliant.
- nradov 5y agoThe current thinking is that new variants are most likely to evolve in immunocompromised patients who experience prolonged infections. While I encourage everyone eligible to get vaccinated, the vaccines aren't very effective in people with malfunctioning immune systems. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/covid-variants-may-arise-in-people-with-compromised-immune-systems/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/covid-variants-ma...
- adamiscool8 5y agoThe link references a specific response to remdesivir, but I don't see how the selective pressure isn't the same in the broader case of low-level or asymptomatic illness persisting in a vaccinated person, particularly when they'll be mingling more and taking less precautions.
- angelzen 5y agoA paper, while not specifically addressing vaccination in immunocompromised patients, documents pretty clearly the phenomenon of runaway mutation chains in such patients. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsb2104756 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsb2104756 Edit: Another piece, specifically addressing immunocompromised + covid + vaccines: "Studies have shown that immunocompromised people are more vulnerable to being hospitalized or dying from COVID and less likely to develop strong protection from vaccination. But there are also some hopeful signs: additional doses of some COVID vaccines, strategic timing of immunosuppressive treatments and prophylactic COVID treatments may boost protection among some immunocompromised individuals—and restore at least some of the freedoms they have lost." https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-immunocompromised-people-without-strong-vaccine-protection-are-coping-with-covid/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-immunocomprom...
- shoto_io 5y agoAs a double vaccinated German, I am very disappointed and angry about this move. Our politicians have failed to prepare the country for the Winter (who could have known...). We lack a basic strategy how to cope with Covid. And now they try to fix this by dividing the country in two. This will have no effect whatsoever on the infections, it will just continue to drive a divide that is already existing and will make anti-vaxxers even more convinced that this is a big conspiracy.
- voidr 5y agoWhy aren't you angry at the anti-vaxxers instead? If they would have gotten the jab, this would be mostly under control. > We lack a basic strategy how to cope with Covid. Getting everyone vaccinated is the only strategy, everything else is either worthless or swaps COVID deaths with mental health an economic casualties. > And now they try to fix this by dividing the country in two. It was already divided, it's just that the government stopped caring about the side that doesn't care and fails to listen to the actual professionals. > This will have no effect whatsoever on the infections Look at literally any statistics or read any paper made by any credible person. > it will just continue to drive a divide that is already existing and will make anti-vaxxers even more convinced that this is a big conspiracy. They'll cave eventually and accept that their stubbornness is not above other people's well being. This is not just a stupid debate about which politicians each camp likes, anti-vaxxers make everybody's life miserable and even kill people for exactly no benefit, they have no arguments other than Facebook conspiracy theories and other fake news.
- yladiz 5y agoGenuine question: given the current situation, what's the alternative? A lockdown for everyone? Vaccine mandate? Doing nothing and removing restrictions? Something else?
- musicale 5y agoIs it worse than last winter?
- 5y ago
- nazinazinazi 5y agoTotal fucking NAZIS! In Austria they are arresting and throwing into prison people who refuse to get the vax. In Australia they have concentration camps for people who are testing positive. Anyone cheering this on is on the WRONG FUCKING SIDE OF HISTORY. You all will perish and if it is war you want - WAR IS COMING! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS! NAZIS!
- nazinazinazi 5y agoDownvote all you want you FUCKING NAZIS! I hope you all FUCKING DIE!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nazinazinazi 5y agoFauci funded gain of function research in the Wuhan Lab and repeatedly lied about it to Congress which is a federal felony. His own agency admits this. Fauci must face execution for his war crimes.
- musicale 5y agoWhat are the major root causes for the surge in Germany? Low humidity/temperature? New variants? Something else? IIRC last winter in the US at least, health officials and the media were quick to blame irresponsible citizens and social gatherings – but the major root cause seemed to be a new, more transmissible (delta) variant.
- chinathrow 5y agoYes, Delta combined with cooler weather and high percentage of antivaxxers.
- shmel 5y agoDelta emerged in late spring 2021 though. You must be thinking about Alpha. However, it became dominant in the US only in late March 2021 according to Wikipedia[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS-CoV-2_Alpha_variant#Spread_in_North_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS-CoV-2_Alpha_variant#Sprea...
- musicale 5y ago> You must be thinking about Alpha Yes, unfortunately I couldn't correct it. I wish HN allowed corrections for weeks rather than hours! Hmm, as I understood it alpha was circulating in the US in December, but perhaps you are correct that it didn't actually surge until later?
- 5y ago
- danieldevries 5y agoOverrun healthcare system and lack of ICU beds is serious cause for concern. No, the vaccine is not sterilizing but it will improve your chances of not getting seriously ill / dying. simple
- disneygibson 5y agoScary stuff. I think all of the authoritarian actions over the last two years can be traced to a single event: the fall of the Soviet Union. Without an enemy to compare itself against, the Western world has forgotten the value of freedom. If East Germany had implemented this forty years ago to fight X disease, it would have been painted as evil, something we don’t do in the free West. Edit: flagged in 8 minutes. I guess this website isn’t the place for intelligent debate and discussion anymore. That’s disappointing.
- dang 5y agoYour comments are correctly getting flagged because you're taking the thread further into generic ideological flamewar. That's off topic here and clearly against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. If you'd please review them and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it. Edit: actually, it looks like you've been using this account primarily for ideological battle, and we ban accounts that do that, regardless of what they're battling for or against. I've therefore banned this one. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. It will eventually get your main account banned as well.
- beanjuice 5y agoThank you for continuing to do such an excellent job.
- throwaway224466 5y ago...of blatant censorship sitting in his ivory tower? smdh
- throwaway224466 5y ago"Idealogical flamewar" a.k.a. any non-leftist talking points so downvoted into oblivion. You are a terrible human being and there will likely soon be consequences for people supporting this non-logical persecution.
- nzk 5y agoWhat we're seeing here is one of the wealthiest countries in the world with a population of > 80M people crumbling over a few thousand ICU patients because of long-standing issues that were never addressed. The staffing problems in hospitals (and nursing homes) have existed much longer than Covid. I heard a lot about them myself when I did my FSJ (volunteer work) back in 2004, and it's only gotten worse since then. Our government is in full CYA mode, and doing everything they can to blame a scapegoat for problems they themselves have willingly created over decades. It's despicable, and nobody should support it. FSJ is a year-long volunteer program for young people typically organized and funded by NGOs like the Red Cross and similar. I worked with small children, plenty of the other volunteers I met regularly worked in hospitals and nursing homes. They all talked at length about how atrocious the working conditions were and how they were asked to do things they weren't legally allowed to (e.g. taking blood, handing out medication) because the staff shortages were severe enough that people didn't have enough time to adhere to very reasonable safety rules anymore. That was 17 years ago. This is a well known, widely publicized[0] and not at all new problem, and the unvaccinated are not to blame for it. Let me repeat, we're talking about one of the wealthiest countries in the world with a population of 83M people crumbling over a few thousand ICU patients. [0]Some random articles from 2018/19 (German): https://gesundheit-soziales.verdi.de/themen/mehr-personal/++co++735e8160-764a-11e9-9a3c-001a4a160100 https://gesundheit-soziales.verdi.de/themen/mehr-personal/++... https://www.tagesspiegel.de/politik/wenn-aus-notstand-panik-wird-was-in-der-pflege-passiert-ist-ein-skandal/25066882.html https://www.tagesspiegel.de/politik/wenn-aus-notstand-panik-... https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2018-05/pflegenotstand-jens-spahn-grosse-koalition-sofortprogramm https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2018-05/pflegenotsta... https://www.rbb-online.de/kontraste/ueber_den_tag_hinaus/bildung/pflegenotstand-krankenhaeuser.html https://www.rbb-online.de/kontraste/ueber_den_tag_hinaus/bil...
- wsc981 5y agoI don't know why you are voted down. This is very much true for The Netherlands as well. Ever since the year 2000, possibly before, ICU beds have been scaled down. Diederik Grommers, one member of the Dutch Outbreak Management Team (OMG) states: "it doesn't matter if you're vaccinated or not; 60% of the beds are occupied by vaccinated people; the problems we will encounter in the coming weeks are caused by the fact that we totally hollowed out our health care" [0]. The Netherlands has about 6 ICU beds per 100.000 citizens. Germany has almost 30 ICU beds per 100.000 citizens [1]. Now I know Germany did accept patients from The Netherlands on their ICUs and perhaps Germany is doing the same for other countries, so perhaps that is causing a capacity problem in Germany as well. --- [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFg78PgDgu0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFg78PgDgu0 [1]: https://cdn.nos.nl/image/2020/03/30/640384/3840x2160a.jpg https://cdn.nos.nl/image/2020/03/30/640384/3840x2160a.jpg
- exabrial 5y agoThis is pretty danged sad.
- dempseye 5y agoThis is wrong, evil and authoritarian. One would think Germany would have learned some lessons about that kind of thing. Evidently not.
- lbj 5y agoIn Denmark we have now reached 90% vaccination rate. We have more infected, the same number of admissions in hospital and a 15% higher death rate than all of 2020. I really fail to see why we are blaming the unvaccinated and not Pfizer/Moderna.
- joshuamorton 5y agoAre hospital admissions and mortality rates similar among vaccinated and nonvaccinated individuals?
- berkes 5y agoNo. Not at all. .dk is similar to .nl in this, and in .nl its 55/45 unvaccinated/vaccinated (on a 12/88 ratio of vaccinations).
- liversage 5y agoThere is a dashboard (in Danish) with current numbers: https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/aa41b29149f24e20a4007a0c4e13db1d/page/page_5/ https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/aa41b29149f24e20a40... The number of hospitalized patients per 100K are as follows: Unvaccinated: 24.7 Started vaccination: 10.5 Fully vaccinated: 5.9
- throwntoday 5y agoNo you don't understand, the unvaccinated are the reason the vaccinated are getting the virus /s
- more_corn 5y agoThis is simply not true. Don’t get me wrong. I fully support everyone getting vaccinated, and requiring it broadly. But your statement is just not true. Omicron is thought to have evolved in an immunocompromised person. Vaccinating that person would not have helped. COVID-19 is also known to cross easily between humans and other animals. An alternate theory is that the startling number of mutations in the Omicron variant evolved in an animal host. This variant appears to defeat previous immunity both from prior infection and vaccination. The willfully unvaccinated, while idiots and selfish assholes are not to blame in our current troubles and vaccinating every person on earth would not have prevented the Omicron outbreak. Furthermore we need to take a global view. Just because we have sufficient doses to fully vaccine everyone in Europe we’re not protected unless everyone everywhere gets vaccinated. (And even then pockets of virus can mutate and overcome the vaccine) I’ll worry more about idiot Texans (who are frankly mostly hurting themselves and their families) when we provide enough doses to Bangladesh to vaccinate their whole population. (And rinse and repeat for every developing nation)
- sarsway 5y agotime to flee ...
- blub 5y agoVery thought-provoking this mistreatment of the unvaccinated. The process started with demonizing them to the point of being singled out and blamed for how the disease is impacting society. When the discrimination started, there were very few willing to speak for them. Particularly malicious was the expansion of the term anti-vaxxer typically used for a fringe minority which “rejects all vaccines for everyone” to all of those that “reject one single vaccine for themselves”. Now a measure that will come too late and impact the entirety of society is sold as a means of finally forcing them to conform. From the outside, this may look like a perfectly executed propaganda campaign. One can’t exclude that the government (like the Canadian gov which actually got caught I believe) took advantage of the chaos and flexed its propaganda muscles a bit. But the more scary possibility is that a frightened and manipulated population + incompetent government in CYA mode is enough to try to override the constitutional principle of bodily integrity. And it’s precisely this principle which seems to be the last thing preventing the state from forcing or punishing the unvaccinated too hard, limiting them to a fine.
- joeman1000 5y agoI’m not vaccinated, this is how I feel. I am not militant or political about it. My wife and whole family are vaccinated and I helped them to do it. As a young man, the risk of heart issues does indeed outweigh the risk of hospitalisation from the virus (as I’ve weighed it, anyhow). Victoria, Australia has hit 90% double vaccinated and case numbers have not changed here. To see this underwhelming effect in light of the anxiety the mandatory vaccination has caused, it is sad. I am lucky enough to be studying remotely, and so I just stay at home, I don’t go out other than to exercise in a park. I am not able to go anywhere with my wife right now (shopping, restaurants etc.), which is difficult, but it was my choice. If I am further forced to undergo vaccination I’m really not sure what I would do. I would want to leave Australia and live somewhere that I can have my own decisions. I don’t care if you think I’m selfish. Where did freedom of choice go? I’d like to move where it’s gone.
- ceesharp 5y ago"Das Recht, mit der Faust um sich zu schlagen, hört auf, wo die Nase des Mitmenschen anfängt."
- fabian2k 5y ago71% percent of Germans support mandatory vaccinations for COVID, this is from a poll published today. Our governments failed pretty hard in this wave, which is why we now need to take more drastic measures again when the entirely predictable course events would take this winter became apparent even to our politicians. But at a point were planned operations for other diseases like cancer get cancelled all over the place, when people requiring acute care get long delays until they find a free intensive care bed somewhere, you can't ignore this any longer. Requiring vaccinations for non-essential activities with many people is something we should have done much earlier, it's long overdue. It's the least restrictive measure that has a good chance of doing both, reducing the spread and encouraging more people to get vaccinated. The failure to organize the vaccine boosters is another big issue. It is clear now that the vaccines require 3 doses to be effective, the delays here cause increased load in intensive care and were to some degree avoidable.
- caeril 5y agoI bet on the order of 71% of Germans supported mandatory discrimination against undesirables in 1940 too, but here we are yet again, claiming that what a majority of the population supports is indicative of moral correctness. If these measures don't work, like literally every authoritarian measure undertaken by governments so far, maybe Germany can put all the un-vaccinated into camps, too. We need to keep the unpure away from us. Sure, the R0 value of the contagion amongst a 100% vaccinated population is still >1.0, and there are early indications that Omicron has a sufficiently mutated spike protein as to render the vaccine immune response ineffective, but why let epidemiological facts stand in the way of exercising power over one's inferiors?
- jjoonathan 5y agoIt's really hard to sympathize with people fighting for the "right" to infect me with a disease.
- bavent 5y agoAnd really hard to listen to people compare vaccine mandates to the holocaust.
- sto_hristo 5y agoThe sooner common stupidity is penalized, the better. Then you wouldn't need to worry about anti vaxers and compulsory shots.
- _Understated_ 5y agoThis is pure bullshit of the highest order. The science is crystal fucking clear: no one is dying from COVID![0] [0] - https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/deaths?areaType=overview&areaName=United%20Kingdom https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/deaths?areaType=over...
- lolsal 5y agoCan you explain what you mean? The link you provided shows over 150k deaths in the UK alone.
- _Understated_ 5y agoThe daily death rate is at around 100 people per day and that's "100 people dying within 28 days of a positive COVID test" - a meaningless statistic that does not tell you a single thing. Plus, the stats only show deaths with covid on the certificate. That means they could have died from something else. This whole thing is a farce. A charade. Make no mistake: they're coming for your children. Also, there are approximately 450 deaths per day from cancer - where is the government push to fix that?[1] [1] - https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/cancer-statistics/mortality#heading-Zero https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/cancer-...
- wolverine876 5y agoI would be very happy if my government did the same. What a relief it would be! It's a public health measure, like public sanitation requirements, and driving a car that meets safety requirements. Unvaccinated people should be free to do whatever they want, short of risking infecting other people. Your freedom ends where your fist ends and my nose begins.
- tonfreed 5y agoSo your vaccination only works if others are vaccinated too? That sounds like you're getting scammed,bro
- hunterb123 5y agoYou might have a point if the vaccine fully prevented transmission or infection, but it doesn't.
- hadem 5y agoMy understanding is it's not going to prevent transmission but it can help in reducing transmissions, thus reducing infections.
- idiotsecant 5y agoIf your goal is exclusively to prevent transmission in itself vaccines aren't always they best way to do it. Isolation or biohazard suits are the way to go there. If you require society to still keep working and for people to not die vaccines generally do a pretty good job of that. If your goal is to prevent mutation of dangerous new variants vaccines are wildly effective. I'd say just having the last 2 is pretty good.
- hunterb123 5y agoVaccines generally DO prevent transmission, just not this one, coronaviruses mutate too fast, and the vaccines only target the spike. This vaccine can spark new mutations since vaccinated people can get it and the virus would mutate to attempt to work around the vaccine immunity. GPs main point was people's freedoms should be restricted to stop the spread. My point was it doesn't stop the spread. So why restrict freedoms? Vaccinated people will continue to spread the virus, whether it's slower or faster doesn't matter in the end, it will spread until it's endemic. (I believe it already is)
- LatteLazy 5y agoGod I wish we (Brits) could do that.
- guilhas 5y agoMe too, also other government mandated medical procedures like abortions, to combat the climate emergency!
- locallost 5y agoAs a foreigner living in Germany I could live with it if there were otherwise sound measures, but it's mostly been a bunch of wishful thinking. There was a rush last summer to open everything up despite it being relatively clear it was way too early and a lot of people really understood it as "corona is over". Even this I could understand, but this year they do the same thing again! Surprise, surprise that there is a record wave now. People have mostly given up and follow no rules other than the most basic ones (masks etc). I am also starting to think this country is not really built to work in a crisis like this. Regulations are maybe good in general, but this tendency to regulate every possible detail does not work when you have to change the rules every month because almost nobody really knows how to fix this.
- lbj 5y ago"open everything up despite it being relatively clear it was way too early" It probably wasn't. There have been 2 major studies on the effects of covid-lockdown measures, they show a small increase in total mortality. So we should have done as the Swedes and kept everything open from beginning to end.
- howinteresting 5y agoMortality isn't the only negative outcome.
- bobthechef 5y agoIndeed, and the lockdown and other impositions have introduced numerous ills that don't necessarily register, at least not immediately, as deaths.
- spookthesunset 5y agoWhat about all the negative outcomes from continuing all the restrictions?
- xg15 5y ago
- acd 5y agoIts a global pandemic where a small percentage follow antiwax conspiracy. I mean an iduvidual choice might endanger others. Thus its induvidual choice versus the good for the masses.
- vibrato2 5y agoHow does it endanger others when both populations transmit the virus, what may be equally
- hogFeast 5y agoWould love to see stats on what parts of society this is going to impact? In the UK, the govt would have had to produce stats on the impact on minority groups. Based on what is happening on other countries, this looks like an outright assault on the poor, disabled, and recent migrants. History tends to repeat...perhaps the unvaccinated should be forced to wear badges? To protect the vaccinated ofc. I am in the UK, in a part of the UK that has a badly malfunctioning health service. Waiting time for ambulance two weeks ago was twenty minutes (and that was just travel time), no issues at ICU (not for me, it was a relative the ICU was precautionary), no issues getting a bed...strangely, the experience was much better than the pre-Covid...significantly so. Germany has the same vaccination rate, Germany has a better health service...it is strange. No-one places any value on their freedom because it is something that is freely given to everyone today, our ancestors shed blood for it but we didn't...is this worth it? It is a huge change in freedoms for something that is unlikely to change things (I am not sure how this kind of thing is legal, if it is legal for a govt to essentially quarantine citizens in their own home if they refuse to have a medical procedure...that is alarming).
- aarobot 5y agoIf you don't wear a life jacket someone else will drown..
- periheli0n 5y ago... and this is where the analogy breaks down...
- dewert 5y agoYes, because you're all tied together for some reason? Really, this analogy is too much of a stretch to be meaningful.
- frockington1 5y agoThe vaccine is so effective everyone should get it but stay away from the unvaccinated even if you're vaccinated because its not that effective.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoThis reminds me of the "no, not like that" meme.
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoNo no, it's because you're all in the same boat... It's your choice to bring a life jacket or not. You know that you risk drowning if you don't bring one, but you also know that the risk is low for where you are going, are allergic to the material that PFDs (personal floatation devices) are made of, think you know better because you can swim, or have some other ideological reason for not wearing one. But on this day, your little crew encounter some unexpected rapids that cause your boat to capsize. One person was a guide who knows how to treat this, and quickly gets as many people as they can onto the flipped boat. Despite this, there isn't enough room on the upside down boat for everyone to fit, so some people are left grabbing the edges of the boat. Those who can hold on survive, as do many with life vests and those on the boat. Unfortunately, since the boat was so small and the rapids so strong, some were swept away - some with life vests and others without - never to be seen again. The rapids eventually calm down and you are able to flip the boat right-side up again. Now, you are joined by another boat coming in from another river that didn't experience the same rapids as you did. Now, a few of the life jacket wearers are pointing fingers saying that those who didn't wear life jackets "effectively killed" those who wore life jackets but didn't make it. Since by not wearing lifejackets, they "took up too much room" on the boat and weren't contributing their fair share for the greater good and survival of everyone. The other side counters by reasoning that this is theory-crafting much like how pundits argue that Jack could have fit onto the wooden plank alongside Rose from Titanic if they shifted their bodies in the right way. Even though the acclaimed director JAMES CAMERON says that Jack was going to die anyways. When in reality, no one was to blame except for the natural cause that was the rapids. All the while, life jacket manufacturers line their pockets with money from the increased sale of life jackets.
- dbkal 5y agoCases in super vaccinated Portugal are also rising. If one is looking for scapegoats, how about locking out Romanian migrant workers, who are everywhere in construction and cleaning inside family's homes? Look how the Romanian outbreaks precede the German ones multiple times: https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explorer?zoomToSelection=true&time=2020-03-01..latest&facet=none&pickerSort=desc&pickerMetric=new_cases_smoothed_per_million&Metric=Confirmed+cases&Interval=7-day+rolling+average&Relative+to+Population=true&Align+outbreaks=false&country=DEU~ROU https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explor... Also look how fast the Romanian numbers dropped. The same will happen in Germany in some weeks and politicians will take the credit.
- president 5y agoAfter 2 years of Covid, I find it extremely suspect that the covid vaccines are still touted so hard as the only way to manage or exit the pandemic despite it clearly not being the silver bullet it was originally promised to be. The fact that the media and government can't talk about anything other than vaccines tells me people are not really interested in solving for anything other than selling more vaccines.
- csee 5y agoIt's close to a silver bullet. Yes they don't completely stop transmission but who cares about that? All we should care about are severe cases and deaths. Add the new therapeutics on top and we actually do have the silver bullet. Vaccine + Paxlovid, if widely distributed enough, ends the pandemic, barring some new, more severe variant.
- president 5y agoMy point was not so much about the vaccine itself but the fact that almost all conversation and chatter about the pandemic is centered around the vaccine and having to get it in order to get anything done (job, travel, etc). People act as if there is literally no other way for life to function like it did pre-2020 without vaccines.
- csee 5y agoIt's not surprising that all convo is around the vaccine, it's our strongest tool against it.
- president 5y agoPersonally, I don't think there has been a good faith dialog by our media and politicians about risk assessment, at-risk staying home (instead of everybody), therapeutics, treatment, or voluntary vaccinations. And maybe there has been some but the mRNA vaccines have completely dominated mindshare to a such a degree that leaves a bad taste in my mouth and has made me very cynical.
- Animats 5y agoUnderstand, we're in the second epidemic and headed for the third. Plans made on the basis of the original virus may not be valid. "The enemy get a vote", as the military says. The original virus had a R0 rate of about 3, that is, in normal conditions, each infected person infects three others. That's about what the first generation of vaccines could control well enough that eventually the virus would die out. The delta variant has an R0 of about 8. The current vaccines can slow down the spread, but not stop it. Which is why we've had a second epidemic. By last August, delta variant cases were 90% of the cases seen. We don't know enough about the omicron variant yet.
- krater23 5y agoWhich means, vaccination doesn't works. Sounds like the antivaccers are right(?) When you want to see it like this, we will never know enough to do anything. The only thing we can do with things that we can't change is to accept it. It's time to do...
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoNo, vaccinations prevent you from getting sick. It’s the choice between a mild illness and potentially being admitted into the hospital. What we’re starting to see is potential for further variants to evade antibodies, reproduce inside you and thus you spread it. Your immune system is still able to fight the virus easier because the vaccine has trained your immune system to look out for contagions like this virus but for a while you’re still actively spreading the virus before you’ve cleared it from your system. Someone correct me if I’m wrong though.
- felistoria 5y agoFully vaccinated people still get hospitalized and some times die. If you are old or have comorbidity, even the vaccine won't save you. We need to get off this vaccine obsession and start working on early treatments. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(21)00258-1/fulltext?s=08#%20 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7...
- 0x_rs 5y agoA recent submission[0] makes me think politicians, media and so-called TV experts should refrain from promising things that are misleading, deceiving and may have disastrous results in the short future. Vaccination shouldn't mean giving up on basic measures, but I believe it has been broadly advertised as such in this current year with, in a personal conclusion of mine, devastating results. In a few countries (such as Italy) in an ironic twist unvaccinated individuals were significantly more monitored due to mandatory testing every 48hrs for any work, while new spread and emerging variants seem to close the gap in transmission between vaccinated and unvaccinated people, as everyone minded their own business in overcrowded public transportation, gatherings et cetera. As others have mentioned in this discussion, hospitals and health services must still tend to a large pool of vaccinated people (significant majority of population in Western countries) that require medical attention and can overwhelm systems in place. Even if everyone in these countries that are rolling third doses did get wholly vaccinated in a short amount of time to attempt to halt transmission in its tracks, the majority of the world where some of the latest VoCs originated (Delta, Omicron) are largely unprotected. Everyone wants this to end but most people are also led to believe, willingly or not, something as basic as a vaccination will bring everything back to normal. It doesn't, it hasn't so far, has it? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29412681 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29412681
- rwaxm 5y ago'"We have understood that the situation is very serious and that we want to take further measures in addition to those already taken," Merkel told reporters at Thursday's news conference. "The fourth wave must be broken and this has not yet been achieved," she added.' You do not need special measures. Florida and Sweden didn't have any and have the best graphs right now. Outbreaks stop by themselves. Of course, if you lock down the unvaccinated right when the bell curve is at its natural top, you can take credit when the numbers go down. This is exactly what is happening right now.
- throwaway47292 5y agoin the netherlands they just implemented measures to shut down non essential things at 5pm.. that lead to gyms/restaurants/swimming pools PACKED with people.. half the space, twice the density. in the very same day they implemented the measures the cases stopped growing.. the fact that a scientist can recommend "lets shut down gyms at 5pm" instead of "lets make gyms 24/7" makes me distrust the whole corona committee when i look at the lockdown+cases graph, i dont think there is any causal link between them. e.g. https://www.uni-konstanz.de/polver/zuber/covid-19-student-wiki/wpg_7415.html https://www.uni-konstanz.de/polver/zuber/covid-19-student-wi...
- lambdaba 5y agoIt was myopic cargo-culting since day one. I used to think that over the years I'd gotten smarter and subtler from my initial libertarian leanings, but this has opened up my eyes on how bad authorities can mess up, and more worryingly convince their people they're doing the right thing.
- MadSudaca 5y agoAs libertarian leaning and someone who wants the state at a good distance, I believe that in many cases people are doing what they can, sadly, it fails to be enough. However, what’s the alternative?
- deleted 5y ago
- anotherPerson67 5y agoInstead of believing the science, why not actually read and understand instead? For example: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(21)00258-1/fulltext?s=08#%20 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7...
- timdaub 5y agoTons of misinformation and bullshit numbers as top comments here. Scary to witness. HN, be aware, this is how fake news spreads. Please stay safe and double check numbers in case the sources are dubious or missing.
- basisword 5y agoIt’s pretty shocking the number of contradictory comments from people on both sides of the argument. I wonder if this is a case of a lot of “smart” people knowing a little but thinking they know it all.
- guilhas 5y agoThe future looks grim with governments mandating health procedures on the population against their will
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoI'd rather be vaccinated than someone force Covid on me. To me, if you choose to be unvaccinated, you are showing how little you care about those around you and how little you care if they die.
- guilhas 5y agoThose around me, or are vaccinated so it does not matter, or chose not to be vaccinated in which case also does not matter I would rather no one forces anything on anyone
- disambiguation 5y agoIs an unlisted side effect of the vaccine self righteous bottom feeding? Seriously have you donated blood this year? Or anything you all? Being vaccinated is not a free ticket to make value judgements on everyone else's sense of compassion.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoI'm not sure how I'm supposed to have more than basic compassion - the same I have for humanity - for folks that aren't showing compassion for others. It is a free vaccine. I do not extend this judgement to folks that aren't healthy enough. I'm judging folks by choices, just like you are judging me by my choice to speak my mind.
- disambiguation 5y agoI'm not telling you to love anyone. I'm saying that equating those that choose against the vaccine to being "selfish and lacking compassion" is wrong and dangerous.
- throwaway47292 5y agoI am double vaccinated, pro vax, would get booster if I can, but if this happens in my country I will join the riots. I dont have solution, but if people dont want to get vaccinated they shouldn't be forced, period. I am afraid this pressure will create people that are against all vaccines, and when we get like 20% of new parents not vaccinating their new lockdown babies (which are a lot, everyone i know who can be pregnant is pregnant), the Pandora's box will open, measles and polio and shit will come crawling back. I feel we could do more to incentivize people to be less packed, like taxing working from the office and incentivize working from home, or subsidize working longer hours in retail and gyms. And possibly we could do better with masks and more tests, e.g. send families 1 test per week so they can stop the spread quicker.
- nitrogen 5y agosend families 1 test per week so they can stop the spread quicker This is a great idea, and I'm really curious why we don't have something like this, just mail a free mask and a free test to every address once a week, with a form to request more for larger households, or to request that they stop.
- DoktorDelta 5y agoThe US postal service isn't nearly robust enough to handle this. We saw that with physical unemployment checks last year when nearly everyone became eligible.
- nitrogen 5y agoSomehow I get junk mail delivered reliably every week. Maybe put the tests and masks in with that, rather than individually addressing and labeling every shipment.
- mritchie712 5y agoThe people not getting vaxed voluntarily are the same ones that would never sign up or take the test
- 5y ago
- yosito 5y agoAt least they're not making the same move as Austria and locking down literally everyone, 24/7. What's the point of vaccines if we all have to sit at home anyway?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoRealistically: 1) Mandatory vaccination, all age groups, boosters etc. AND 2) permanently reconfiguring our society to reduce social contacts such that with the vaccines, COVID is suppressed. If the vaccines work well, then small (maybe no) changes will be needed. If they don't, then large changes. WFH, no indoor hospitality etc. We can cycle through lockdowns, we can wring our hands about vaccinating children, we can even pretend it isn't happening, but the formula is the same: vaccines+restrictions=suppression We don't know what the LHS needs to add up to, and we don't know how much vaccines can give us, but this equation must hold, as the alternative to suppression is complete failure of our healthcare system. To put another way, suppression is the only steady state. If you allow the virus to run unchecked, then eventually restrictions have to be reimposed. If you release restrictions, then the virus ramps up again. Either you tailor restrictions to suppress, or you bounce up and down around that point. Vaccines move that restriction point down.
- pokepim 5y agoNah, what you saying is not realistical. This is more like wishful thinking and would only work in suppressive utopia (if that’s a thing). We as a society had only one shot at doing a lockdown that could work and it was at the beginning of march 2020. Some countries actually managed to have almost no cases but they had to do harsh lockdowns and everyone needed to comply. After that with 2nd and 3rd waves we have seen less and less countries do lockdowns and people already worn out stopped to comply. Now everything is half assed and on top of that vaccinated people are extremely unwilling to participate in lockdowns as it was promised that vaccines will help us avoid the disaster of lockdowns we have seen earlier (i got vaccinated based on that as many of my friends). So no. This is not realistical, nope.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoWell this is what is being seen in Germany right now - restriction fatigue -> case explosion -> overwhelmed hospitals -> restrictions. People may be unwilling, but at some point (i.e. when healthcare systems start failing) restrictions will be enforced, and people will comply.
- timdaub 5y agoI find it ironic that there are plenty comments that paint the picture of how mandatory vaccinations divide the country. Hello? Have you been awake for the last month? How much more divided can a country already be when the absolute democratic majority has made their decision months ago to take the shot but 30% are holding everyone back. Anyone in my family or from my friends that has taken one for the team (and got vaccinated) could receive worse-than-usual ICU treatment because of some egoistic anti-vaxxers. Hell, even anti-vaxxers benefit from better ICU treatment if vaccination numbers are higher. Yes, this is a democracy and so it can also be deemed legitimate and representative to govern according to the majority decision. Besides, it's in everyone's best interest to get vaccinated.
- throwaway12409 5y ago> it's in everyone's best interest to get vaccinated. Except the few who die from it. About ~20 per million will die after having the vaccine (although there are not exact numbers on whether vaccine was the cause). There are lots of well-documented cases.
- worik 5y agoI agree that everybody should get vaccinated. Let's make this virus extinct. But what you describe is majoritarianism. It is a form of democracy but a very weak form. For a lot of people, who are from minority groups, it is indistinguishable from totalitarianism. Why do 30% of people refuse to get vaccinated? (here in Aotearoa it is 5%). Something is happening, people are getting left behind, in vast numbers. Forcing them to comply is probably a cure worse than the disease - even a disease like COVID
- prohobo 5y agoYou cannot make this virus extinct. These vaccines do not accomplish this goal, the end.
- Swenrekcah 5y agoThe goal is to keep serious cases to a minimum so they don’t clog the healthcare system thus making people die of all sorts of other things because they couldn’t be treated. Vaccines do help with that, tremendously.
- The_rationalist 5y agoI sense a disturbance in the force..
- pezzana 5y ago> Many hospitals are struggling to cope with the increasing number of intensive care patients. There could be around 6,000 Covid-19 patients in intensive care by Christmas -- regardless of any measures implemented by Germany's leaders -- the country's Interdisciplinary Association for Intensive Care and Emergency (Divi) warned Wednesday. The article doesn't really talk about the rate of change to date. An article from The Guardian puts this into perspective: > Daily new infections in Germany have broken records in recent weeks, with many hospitals operating at or over capacity. Authorities said 73,209 new cases were recorded in the past 24 hours. Deaths have surged from a rolling seven-day average of just over 10 a day in August to nearly 300 this week. To enforce something like this policy requires: - laws and penalties - a method for identifying those who get special treatment - verification procedures You'd think a country like Germany would be especially sensitive to the idea of segregating 1/3 of the population for special treatment. I'm going to assume this isn't lost on anybody there. The question then becomes: what if this doesn't work? What if biology overtakes the law (i.e., a new variant begins sending the vaccinated into hospitals as well)? What if biology has already overtaken the law? If it does work, when does it end? If it ends, under what circumstances is it Ok to re-impose? What precedent does this set and what unintended consequences might result (e.g., a new strain of a virus with a vaccine emerges)?
- monksy 5y agoJust a heads up about what is happening in Germany: (Just got back Monday from Hamburg) 1. Entry restriction: You must be vaccinated to enter from nonEU countries (Vaccation must be in the approved list) 2. Most restaraunt/bars/outdoor gatherings are either 2G/3G. The bahn is 3g (so testing as well). Nearly everything else is 2G. This includes the food hall in the airport. Enforcement is at entry. You must show your personal|lebenlingsausweiss and your coronapass. (identity license, and vacination evidence.. CDC vaccine card can work.. but get it converted and your life will be easy) 2g = genesen, geimpfung / recovered, vacced 3g = 2g+ gettestet 3. Many restaurants expect or require you to use Luca to participate in contact tracing. If that is not possible they do a manual collection of info. These rules are even enforced at outdoor gatherings such as weihnachtmarkts. Denmark/Coppenhagen: Only ate inside at one place. They only wanted to see my coronapass.
- detaro 5y agoJust to clarify on the 2G / 3G labels, since I don't think it's 100% clear in your comment: 2G is recovered (PCR-validated infection in past 6 months) or vaccinated 3G is that or (quick-)tested 2G+ is 2G and tested (exception: I've once earlier seen it used for 2G or PCR-tested) Quick-tests at test centers (which are all over the place) were free for residents for a long time, then that got removed (IMHO a mistake), then made free again. Actual proper checking of requirements was pretty terrible for a long time, from what I hear that's gotten a bit better.
- monksy 5y agoNearly everywhere I went required a few or test of the Coronapass app. Some scanned, some saw, and most required to see your id. Went to St Pauli Weihnachtmarkt and the person I was with was rejected because he didn't have his id, but he did have his bank card with his name on it.
- ostenning 5y agoDoes this vaccination entry requirement exist for residents?
- atsaloli 5y agoI was born in Soviet Russia, where the party line was: there is no God, there is no Soul, there is no Truth, and truth is what we tell the people. My family came to America to get away from that savage society and to live in a free country, based on voluntary cooperation (free market) not force and violence and coercion. In communism, the group is all and the individual is nothing. I do not believe it is okay to violate my individual liberties (such as forcing me to undergo a medical procedure) for the common good.
- purerandomness 5y agoI was also born in Soviet Russia. It's hard to unlearn toxic ideas and relearn to trust in rational thinking, but it can be done. Don't let your upbringing fool you.
- xafnuaetrf8764 5y agoДругими словами, когда все вокруг сосут хуй ради общего блага, не западло и самому пососать, так выходит?
- standardUser 5y agoVaccine mandates are already ubiquitous across the Western world (and the non-Western world). In most cases, it is infants and children having a "medical procedure" forced on them. Your point still stands, but in reality an overwhelming consensus exists that vaccines are an acceptable exemption to bodily autonomy. EDIT: I didn't make an argument, I only stated uncontroversial facts. Would love an explanation of downvotes.
- honkdaddy 5y agoYou think there’s an overwhelming consensus that bodily autonomy ends when a vaccine is concerned?
- standardUser 5y agoIn practice, yes. It is codified into law in countless nations and there are no major movements to change those laws. So in terms of the reality of being a living human being in any given society (free or not), yes, bodily autonomy is limited by many, many things by the state, one of those being vaccine mandates. You may not like it, but that is simply the reality.
- jasonhansel 5y agoGood. Here's hoping the US follows suit. Thankfully the Supreme Court has already settled the constitutionality issue: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1449224/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1449224/
- UnpossibleJim 5y agohttps://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality This is "A law that authorizes mandatory vaccination during an epidemic of a lethal disease". Now, I'm vaccinated and support vaccination (though, I'm on the fence about forced vaccination - though I do think it can be a fire-able offense, if you can't telecommute). However, does 1.6% reach the bar of a "sufficiently lethal" disease, especially now that our medical system has regained its footing and is more capable of handling the number of patients now that vaccination rates have reached 70%? Bodily autonomy is an important right. Forced sterilization, as referred to in the article, was a nightmare. Forced mental care facility commitment, was/is fraught with abuse, especially when we consider lobotomies. Granted, this is nowhere near that, I will agree. But, as you say, precedents will be set about what is or is not legal to circumvent for body autonomy due to an epidemic of a lethal disease. Is social unrest use a lethal disease, caused by social media? Should steps be taken to "inoculate" us from ourselves?
- jasonhansel 5y agoKeep in mind: chickenpox is almost never lethal, and many school districts already require the chickenpox vaccine.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoAgain, I'm fine with it being a fire-able offense if you can't telecommute. That's a business policy and not a state mandate with punishment for noncompliance. I say this as someone who supports vaccines and is vaccinated. As far as schooling goes, the infrastructure has been set up for tele-schooling already, should someone choose to not be vaccinated. There are inconveniences with choices, of course. I wore a mask and stayed at home to "stop the spread". It was an inconvenience, but it was a choice I made. The right choice, I think, but it wasn't a choice made at the end of a gun where I'd be put in a cage if I didn't comply.
- lispm 5y agoas a German I agree, since I don't want to see another 100k people die too early and see many more people suffer after being rescued by long ICU treatments
- johnteller 5y agoI'd be more open to getting vaccinated when I see people actively making use of hand sanitizers in stores. When people learn to cover their whole faces with their masks. When they learn to keep distance. Vaccinated people who are old, sick or born with bad luck in the genetic lottery are still at risk. Vaccination doesn't mean people can go back to doing whatever they want. The vaccination itself can be a risk to certain individuals too. It's ludicrous to expect everyone to get the shot for the rest of their lives and call that situation a success because "at least everyone is vaccinated". If you want to force vaccination, start with the people that have a history of covid infection. Why piss the people off that have been actively avoiding to come into contact with the virus and carrying it around?
- MaxHoppersGhost 5y agoHand sanitizer? We’ve know for over a year now that hand sanitizer does nothing against covid because that’s not how it spreads.
- casperc 5y agoNews to me! Could you provide sources for this?
- Invictus0 5y agoDude, it's nearly 2022. How do you still not know that covid is an airborne virus and hand sanitizer doesn't help anything?
- vax1nat0r 5y agoJust keep in mind that these shots cause heart attacks[0] and nervous system damage[1] for a non-trivial amount of people. So if you are ok with casually murdering a few hundred thousand or million people - murder away. [0] https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.144.suppl_1.10712 https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.144.suppl_1.107... [1] https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/over-42000-adverse-reaction-reports-revealed-first-batch-pfizer-vax-docs https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/over-42000-adverse-reacti...
- throwawaysea 5y agoBodily autonomy and health privacy are fundamental human rights. No just society should be able to violate a person's body in this manner or coerce them through methods like lockdowns. It is simply not compatible with a free and just society. And I say that as a pro vaccine person with my booster.
- MrDresden 5y agoMy partner was diagnosed with cervical cancer a couple of months ago and is now on the brink of starting radio- & chemotherapy. Due to the covid situation here in the Netherlands the treatment may not go ahead as planned, and treatment might get delayed, due to the new measures. I then know of people who's heart surgaries have been delayed 5x times due to the stress covid is putting on the health care system in another country. Please, get vacinated/boosted and if possible convince a close one to do too.
- bruce343434 5y agoWith the recent evidence of spiking infections and other events, I am no longer convinced vaccines are a good measure. The Netherlands is 85% vaccinated. They said we would get herd immunity at only 70%, and yet here we are with talks of "boosters", at the brink of yet another lockdown, due to yet another spike in infections. I think we need to simply get sick at large, get better and stay immune. We need to get it over with. Yes, some will die. People are mortal. Can we get over it and end this madness? It's nature. You are not going to win against it. Let's get mass sick. It will suck for, what, 2 months at most? And then the strong have survived and we can get back to normal. Covid is inevitable. Let's face it.
- ikrenji 5y agono thank you. you let your body be ravaged by an exotic viral disease from asian bats. I will take my booster
- bruce343434 5y agoWould it be less bad if the virus was bred on Dutch grounds by another animal? Otherwise I am not sure what your are implying or why you bring it up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- throw8965 5y agoAdditional problem is that when doctors that are against mass vaccinations (like inventor of the mRNA vaccine) want to debate no-one mainstream want to talk with them besides anti-vaxxers[0][1]. [0]: https://stevekirsch.substack.com/p/my-team-of-vaccine-safety-experts https://stevekirsch.substack.com/p/my-team-of-vaccine-safety... [1]: https://stevekirsch.substack.com/p/wed-love-to-have-a-debate https://stevekirsch.substack.com/p/wed-love-to-have-a-debate
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI think the biggest unsung problems in this saga, is actually one of marketing. The average person has experience with vaccines that have 3 properties: (1) long lasting, (2) prevent contagion (3) and major symptoms. By calling the mRNA shot a vaccine , the WHO and CDC transferred such properties to the shot. That may have been great for encouraging adoption, but also comes with consequences particularly if two vaccine properties fail to hold, and a 3rd is not flawless. This was never made clear by anyone of relevance - instead the mantra was "take the shots and all will be well". We oversold the solution. People took the shots, then behaved as if nothing else mattered. Dropped masks. Started going nuts. Now we see the results.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe flu shot needs to be updated yearly, and it mostly prevents hospitalizations and deaths. Seems pretty similar. The flu vaccine is about 70% effective against getting flu[0], but it varies wildly by year. The Pfizer mRNA vaccine is about 50% effective against catching COVID five months later[1] (for the delta variant, anyway), but the third dose seems to push that up substantially. [0] https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/how-effective-is-flu-vaccine https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/how-effective-is-flu-vaccine [1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02183-8/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- crooked-v 5y agoRegarding 2 and 3, it feels like a major factor here is the huge number of people who have forgotten (or never knew) that vaccines as a category aren't automatically 100% effective, because all the hard work to wipe out diseases like measles from the general population has already been done.
- cblconfederate 5y agothis has been a worldwide problem - the fact that it even happened in germany is concerning. Governments were looking for easy way outs left and right, but more importantly, did not take the time to create an international scientific task force to research treatments. The Manhattan project started 2 years after the start of WW2. Maybe the time is right to consider large-scale responses to this war as well. Or at least to realize that epidemiology isn't really as good as it should be and we need to fix that fast.
- rich_sasha 5y agoIs it, to some extent, a problem of naming and terminology? When vaccines were first introduced in the UK, there was a great deal of discussion about ethics of forcing people to get them. One really cool view was, of course you can’t force people to inject a chemical into their bodies. But if people choose not to get vaccinated, it’s on them to reduce the risk to others - ie basically subject themselves to lockdown. I think this is harder to argue with than “forced vaccination”. Sure, don’t get the jab if you don’t want to, but what are you doing instead to not endanger others?
- TheRealNGenius 5y agowould a mask suffice? or how about staying 6ft apart?
- rich_sasha 5y agoSo without getting into the weeds of it, I don’t think these offer as much protection as just staying away from people, not going to restaurants, cinemas etc. You’re also risking drawing more resources out of hospitals. UK has free general healthcare, but eg a health insurer would charge you more if you’re a smoker. While I sympathise with people who refuse vaccines on grounds of free choice, the question stands: what are you doing instead to protect me?
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoNothing. I shouldn't need to do anything to protect you. You are but a stranger, as are most people in the world. And quite frankly, I don't care about you. Nor you, I would assume, I. Outside of this conversation, we will likely never meet. So long as I am not actively trying to harm you, I would think that would suffice. I hope you too don't burden yourself with protecting each and every being you see on the streets. So long as you've bestowed yourself protection conferred by the vaccine, I see no reason for you to go out of your way to jab a dose of Pfizer at each unvaccinated individual you encounter.
- 5y ago
- jansan 5y agoNote that "unvaccinated" will included all not fully vaccinated 14 years or older. This means that if you have an unvaccinated teenage child, you will not be allowed to meet other families anymore.
- switch007 5y agoThe state of this discussion, dreadful: every challenge to any mainstream narrative gets flagged.
- pronik 5y agoOne thing I've been thinking about lately is the lasting change to the society. I would like to argue that the point of no return has passed a long time ago. A sizeable chunk of people I talk with aren't going back to the office (and by extension to any kind of socialization) for the next couple of months. I understand and accept the sentiment, but I have to wonder why they would ever change their minds. Idealistically speaking, restrictions will be lifted in several months with the pandemic ending. But from an individual point of view there probably won't be a change at all: the virus itself stays by becoming endemic, so there is still a chance of infection; if you are vaccinated already, you are mostly protected just like you'd be after the pandemic -- in a way, we are even safer now than later because of general awareness, masks, distance, smaller crowds etc. So what's the real difference in leaving home now as opposed to after the pandemic? What changes after the pandemic ends? Do we need to complete some kind of coping process? Do we need to accept the coronavirus as we accept the influenza? And what happens if a person can not do that, how many people will fail to cope? How do we help them out? Will we ever be able to?
- NicoJuicy 5y agoGive them one month to take the vaccine. Health care isn't available at cost when they get ill from COVID for those that didn't get the vaccine. Health care is here to prevent if possible and it's currently possible. The governement advices the vaccine. Make sure every minority receives the message clear ( eg. Belgium has a lot of hard to reach minorities concerning the language, the message should be clear for all) It's your option to take the advice or not, but take your responsibility if you ignore it. Don't cry afterwards. Distribute the vaccines ( the better ones) to countries that lack them according to population density and lack of vaccine availability asap. Please, get this done already. Richer countries have their responsibilities too, this is an option that the population should agree with. Everyone can do what they want. If some % of the people don't want the vaccine. Give them what they want instead of the current indecision. All other options will only fuel their anti-governement thinking. Don't force it on to them, it's their fault.
- jl6 5y agoI guess it’s easier to pass a law like this, than a law which puts the unvaccinated at the back of the queue when hospital beds run out.
- detaro 5y agoExtremely so. And hopefully also more effective at reducing overall harm short-term - after all triage rules would only decide who dies, not reduce deaths, you don't want to be in the situation that there is a queue! (And remember, you don't get to make a queue over everybody in the ICU, but only whoever is currently incoming)
- umvi 5y agoAnd yet... if you asked the unvaccinated which they prefer (between being forced to be vaccinated and going to the back of the queue when beds run out), they will probably prefer the latter. It is disturbing to do things against people's will "for their own good"
- dennis_jeeves 5y agoThe unvaccinated doctors can tend to the unvaccinated individuals. May be form their own hospitals.
- dav_Oz 5y agoI wonder as to how far the current crisis is used by 'machiavellian' power players to weaken civil liberties and constitutional rights as was the case with "9/11" to push something through like the "Patriot Act" with its wide ramifications for us all today. I understand the allure just for this damn pandemic, this state of global health emergency, to force everyone to take their jabs already. But even without the imagination of a science fiction writer thinking through every "subtle" implications long ahead of its time, it takes little to see the possible dawning - at the end of this tragic ride of a pandemic - of a less free and more restrictive biosecurity world. Once the shots are compulsory, how many boosters are to come? Is there an expiry date (like 6 months) for natural immunity? Can we say definitively we only need 3 shots? Not more like once or twice every year? For how long? And why not additionally for the flu and other seasonal respiratory infections, now that the mRNA platform has proven its efficacy, its scalibility, its tremendous customizability and the compulsory laws being in place.
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoThat's a good point that I've also been considering. It's easy to see how mandatory vaccination could serve as a stepping stone for simply more government overreach into peoples' lives. First it's a mandatory vaccination against this one disease. Then, why not a mandatory vaccination against all diseases? Next, how about a mandatory serum that keeps you in peak physical condition for your entire life? And then at long last - the holy grail - we will eventually reach the point when a mandatory immortality serum is prescribed. This move would totally be in line with promoting the greater good, as surely death and suffering are undesirable no? And in a similar sense, many who are "vaccinated" will fail to comprehend why anyone in their right mind would choose to remain unvaccinated. Governments of course would surely rejoice at having removed the first inevitability of life that hinders their collection of the second...
- pedopedopedo 5y agoEveryone praising this is going to face some serious retaliation in the near future. You don't know what unholy hell is being unleashed. We'll be dumping bodies out of 747s 30k feet over the ocean and they'll be washing up on Ocean Beach. You all are making a serious fucking mistake.
- rafaelero 5y agoIt's fairly ironic how the demographics of antivaxxers (mostly right-wingers) are very keen to patriotic duties (and will probably recruit you to war when time comes), but couldn't even take a vaccine to attenuate a pandemy. That will be remembered.
- balzy 5y agoMost aren't anti-vaxxers, they just don't like this pretty novel particular vaccine. In Germany, real anti-vaxxers traditionally have a more left/green background. The sort of people who believe in homeopathy and traditional Chinese medicine.
- lopiranti 5y agoWhere I live the most militant anti-vaxxers are from the left (greens / environmentalists / "hippies") This is not surprising at all considering they're generally skeptical of corporations, GMOs, big pharma, etc.
- outside1234 5y agoHonestly this is great. You can continue to be unvaccinated, but you shouldn't be able to fly across country, be in large groups / large events, or otherwise and put us all at risk. You should be at home.
- alex_smart 5y agoJust went through this thread and I have only one thing to say: WE REDDIT NOW
- jazzyjackson 5y agoIt's a kind of bikeshedding Any other thread on HN might only attract comments by people with a genuine interest and knowledge of the subject, because if I don't care about some thread about Rust I just won't comment. Of course, everyone has an opinion on vaccine mandates, so this thread has about 50x the average responses.
- lorenzfx 5y agoI'm surprised to find this many anti vaxxers on hn. I would have expected that the community was a lot more rational.
- JimTheMan 5y agoThe tech community here is pretty good around software and a limited amount of hardware. Once they venture into the world of biology, health etc they are only marginally more adept than the general public. It's also predominately American, so you get a lot 'freedom at the expense of everyone else' ideas floating about.
- kbelder 5y agoDon't conflate 'anti-vax' with 'anti-vax-mandate'. The two positions have entirely different scientific and moral bases. I would think the second group is also much larger.
- drstewart 5y agoThey've changed the definition to obfuscate this very important point. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer >Definition of anti-vaxxer >: a person who opposes the use of vaccines or regulations mandating vaccination
- zapnuk 5y agoThats a lie. It's been the definition since at least 2018 https://web.archive.org/web/20181125060933/https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer https://web.archive.org/web/20181125060933/https://www.merri...
- generalizations 5y agoProbably they made an assumption after the definition of "vaccine" was changed on there earlier this year. https://web.archive.org/web/20210108224740/https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vaccine https://web.archive.org/web/20210108224740/https://www.merri... vs. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vaccine https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/vaccine
- umvi 5y agoSomehow I think these super heavy handed measures toward covid are a big mistake. My opinion: - Remove all restrictions, let people assess their own risk tolerance and voluntarily follow country's health guidance (or not). - If ICUs start getting maxed out, implement bed rationing, with unvaccinated patients having lowest priority. - Tell everyone to go on with their lives and that covid is here to stay. There's no eradicating it. Vaccines will be updated periodically just like the flu for those that want it. Does anyone have a better endgame? I'd love to hear it. Because currently "the plan" I'm hearing from governments is "wear a mask and social distance until the end of time and get boosters every 6 months until the end of time"
- throwaway12409 5y agoFunny was just about to comment the same thing. I think deaths amongst unvaccinated would skyrocket and then they would isolate themselves or get the shot. The difficulty is having people dying in the street while beds are sitting vacant to keep them open in case of vaccinated ICU needs. This is non-tenable and would create outrage. Only really workable in a place like the USA for the uninsured. Also there there would not be the appetite to see huge death stats compared to other countries.
- Apaec 5y agoThat's the most rational plan. However pharma companies can just buy media presence, create panic and criticize their authorities(this happens to Bolsonaro in Brazil for example). Then riots begin, generating a whole other set of problems for the authorities who have no other choice but to save their neck and concede pharma companies demands.
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoI am personally in favor of what you've stated. I don't believe we will ever be rid of covid, it is likely endemic. To add to your list, I would like to see additional measures put in place to provide adequate ventilation and filtering of the air. I am becoming increasingly convinced that promotion of cleaner air would serve well to reduce the impact of airborne diseases.
- zZsFBVZ9bjdJd 5y ago
- Overtonwindow 5y agoRelated: Counterpart, television show from Starz that is now on Prime. Germany, a flu virus, and espionage are the top themes. Made just before the Pandemic, starring JK Simmons. Spooky foreshadows a lot of the mask mandates, vaccines, and anti-germ mentality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterpart_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterpart_(TV_series)
- hncurious 5y agoIf we were a serious society, then the conversation would be about: immune vs non-immune high risk vs low risk infectious vs non-infectious But no, it's jabbed vs unjabbed. It doesn't make sense. Everyone in Germany who wants the vaccine has had it, and if you've had Covid, you're about as protected as the vaccinated. Furthermore, leaky vaccines don't prevent transmission, can't eliminate the virus (animal reservoirs) and may even make it more virulent. See Marek's disease: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15757475/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15757475/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/leaky-vaccines-enhance-spread-of-deadlier-chicken-viruses https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/leaky-vac... This is not a rational, science-based policy. This is about punishing the non-compliant, mostly the under class. As the upper class continues with their events surrounded by masked servants, with endless examples of officials breaking their own rules. Worse, we are normalizing the dehumanization of a group of people who we're told are diseased and dangerous and it's all their fault. Germany of all places should be absolutely allergic to such rhetoric.
- EricE 5y ago>Germany of all places should be absolutely allergic to such rhetoric. You would think! Those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it and all that...
- fragmede 5y agoMaybe we shouldn't want Germany to repeat the 30's? Just a thought.
- disabled 5y agoYour logic does not work. If people in a developed country would simply become vaccinated and boosted, then only the vaccinated or not condition would typically apply in mainstream society--and not the 3 other above conditions. While all 4 are discriminatory, the first 3 are not inherently due to personal choices or preferences. People choose not to get vaccinated harming society as a whole--and make the other 3 above conditions come into play.
- 5y ago
- whycombinater 5y agoYears of life lost to COVID-19 in USA in 2020 [1]: 5.5M Years of life lost to heart disease in USA in 2020 [1]: 8.9M Years of life lost to abortion in USA in 2019 (no stats for 2020 yet?) [2]: 25M = 625,346 * (lets conservatively say 40 years for crack babies etc) Conclusion: Mandating jogging, banning smoking, and treating -4 month old babies as living entities would all have a larger impact than this mass hysteria. Further, if constant sex were mandated for paired humans, which at, let's say 100M eligible pairs (totally making that number up) * 1 output / year * 40 = 4B/y, vastly exceeding any loss to disease. We have to figure out what were optimizing for. Is it "total lives", "man years", "freedom", "happiness"? The "total lives" crowd is not doing a great job putting all their eggs in the vaccination basket, nor basically any other basket except the "fellate Pfizer basket". [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/06/16/americans-lost-more-years-of-life-to-covid-19-in-2020-than-to-all-accidents-combined-in-a-typical-year/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/06/16/americans-l... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/data_stats/abortion.htm https://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/data_stats/abortion.h...
- passing_by_and 5y agoWhat I really like about all these different threads and topics on COVID is the mastery of control that is shown. We have viable treatments that work and could be prescribed en masse. Not discussed, not mentioned. The sole discussion topic is "vaccines" and mask theatre. Totally ignoring any inconvenient data about either. Everyone's focus is to tear each other apart about which level of destruction is best for the non-vaxed. They are the problem and need to be crushed. Just excellent demonstration of media control and emotional manipulation. Here we see the Germans following the leaders of human rights: China, Austria, Australia in preparing further legal frameworks to make the non-vaxed into non-people. Their futures will be fines, imprisonment and hopefully their lives permanently ruined. With cheers from the vaxxed. After this we will be imprisoning or maybe just hanging from lampposts those who don't get enough boosters. For the safety of the children.
- lee 5y ago> "We have viable treatments that work and could be prescribed en masse. Not discussed, not mentioned." Can you explicitly mention what those treatments are? I'm genuinely curious.
- jacobolus 5y agoThere are various antiviral drugs which are orders of magnitude more expensive, have mediocre efficacy and a worse side effect profile compared to any of the main vaccines, and must be started within days of initial infection to work properly. They are a great addition (besides vaccines and non-pharmaceutical public health measures) for treating high-risk patients for whom the vaccines don’t provide perfect protection (e.g. the very elderly and immune compromised), but a poor primary response.
- landemva 5y agoIvermectin has anti-viral properties, has great multi-decade safety history, and is cheaper than a soda. It also has been shown to be an effective treatment when used early in disease.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThis could probably be done with a tax. Just like smoking is a choice and is risky enough to have financial penalties, one could do the same with unvaccinated people (who haven’t caught and survived covid yet, since surviving natural immunity is apparently more protective than the existing vaccines). This is just paying taxes into the system that will help support them later.
- angelzen 5y agoThis is probably the right course of action. However, it is unfeasible to derive a fair tax level in the current climate. Too many people look to force conformity and/or exact punishment, instead of engaging in a good faith tradeoff negotiation.
- aakresearch 5y agoThis is something I would support (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29401254 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29401254). At least for me, and probably for (many?) others this would bring the issue from intolerable "fight-or-flight for your life" level, to a much more manageable "oh well, stupid govt is at it again". It is much harder to get suicidal over an extra tax, so the tension will deflate markedly. An extortion act is quickly forgotten, while physical violence is not easily forgiven.
- guscost 5y ago“ And how we burned in the camps later, thinking: What would things have been like if every Security operative, when he went out at night to make an arrest, had been uncertain whether he would return alive and had to say good-bye to his family? Or if, during periods of mass arrests, as for example in Leningrad, when they arrested a quarter of the entire city, people had not simply sat there in their lairs, paling with terror at every bang of the downstairs door and at every step on the staircase, but had understood they had nothing left to lose and had boldly set up in the downstairs hall an ambush of half a dozen people with axes, hammers, pokers, or whatever else was at hand?... The Organs would very quickly have suffered a shortage of officers and transport and, notwithstanding all of Stalin's thirst, the cursed machine would have ground to a halt! If...if...We didn't love freedom enough. And even more – we had no awareness of the real situation.... We purely and simply deserved everything that happened afterward.” - Solzhenitsyn
- sazz 5y agoGerman government argues that health-care cannot handle all those patients due to shortage of health care personal. In the same moment they are going to remove 10.000+ health care workers on January 1st from their jobs because they are unvaccinated. Everybody knows that vaccination cannot prevent transmission of the virus. That's the "new" german logic.
- gubikmic 5y agoVitamin D still not being promoted and offered to the whole population shows how incompetent western governments are. ".. individuals with Vitamin-D deficiency were 80% more likely to acquire COVID-19 infection .." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7973108/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7973108/