30 ms·
Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fears for ad-blockers grow
- erklik 5y agoIt's time for mass-migration to Firefox. Only losing users is going to tell Google that this is a horrible solution to enforce.
- vadfa 5y agoThe only browser that's been losing users for years is Firefox. That already tells Google all they need to know. (It also tells Mozilla what they need to know; pity they are deaf.)
- erklik 5y agoMozilla annoys me. Truly it does. However, it's the organisation. Firefox as a browser, especially dev tools, seems better in every day use than Chrome does. I am really not sure why they keep losing users. I do remember being massive performance issues in the past, but that's really not the case today (at least in my experience)
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoThey just can't compete with Google and their massive marketing budget and shady bait & switch business practices.
- vadfa 5y agoAlmost all wounds Mozilla has are self-inflicted.
- josefx 5y agoOn Android Chrome has to be installed as preferred browser or the phone manufacturers get blocked from Googles other services. As much as I like to bash Mozillas leadership, Google has taken every shady (and sometimes illegal) shit 90s era Microsoft pulled and turned it up to eleven.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey could, if they stopped doing all of their hobby stuff.
- chii 5y agoi dont think it's merely marketing budget, thought that helps. People who got marketed to convert, and hence, the product is indeed good based on this metric. Firefox does seem to lag behind in terms of performance, esp. on mobile. Firefox also has poorer video rendering speed i think - i get more skipped frames than chrome. I tolerate it, but many users don't. Firefox has some difficulty being deployed in an enterprise environment (aka, an organizationally managed profile, which chrome has). This has led to enterprises adopting chrome as a primary browser (over firefox), and this may lead to familiarity which causes them to also use chrome at home. There's a myriad of issues with firefox, and it is rooted at the organizational level, rather than the technical level, but these issues bleed down into the technical level.
- rejectfinite 5y ago>Firefox also has poorer video rendering speed i think - i get more skipped frames than chrome. I tolerate it, but many users don't. I do not have this problem in Firefox anymore. I used to but i updates fixed it. >Firefox has some difficulty being deployed in an enterprise environment (aka, an organizationally managed profile, which chrome has). This has led to enterprises adopting chrome as a primary browser (over firefox), and this may lead to familiarity which causes them to also use chrome at home. GPO exists for Firefox now and works great, I have implemented it. But what I actually see for enterprise customers is a move to MS Edge. The Windows account integration, control and the fact that on Windows 10 it has really good performance means there is no need for Chrome or FF unless Edge breaks (have had some issues with antivirus breaking it)
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>I am really not sure why they keep losing users. Because, number one, they keep constantly making radical UI/UX changes that frustrate and alienate their long term users who would rather they keep the "older look" which they got used to and works just fine for them, and number two, most websites are lazy so their devs only optimize for Chrome, even going the extra mile to explicitly state that "For best experience use Chrome" <face_palm> Edit: changes in tone and corrections after getting off the bus
- quonn 5y agoI think the UI is finally good on macOS. The only thing I find strange now is the button-like tab style. Which seems like a minor issue.
- RheingoldRiver 5y ago> Because they keep making stupid UI)UX choices than alienate their users Cannot overstate this enough. They keep randomly changing their UI constantly, and it's especially frustrating when you have a bunch of custom CSS. I'm a bunch of versions behind & dreading updating because I don't want to spend the hours it'll take to fix my shit for their new version. I honestly hate this browser so much at this point, but everything else (i.e. Chrome) is so much worse that I'm stuck....
- hutzlibu 5y ago"Firefox as a browser, especially dev tools, seems better in every day use than Chrome does. " Cannot confirm at all. I do not know any feature in ff dev tools I am missing in chrome, but the other way around lots of it. Mainly: editing and saving directly in the debugger! Could also be my ignorance, but I regulary do debugging in FF and it works, but way less efficient. Meaning I browse with FF, but work with chrome.
- maddyboo 5y agoI mostly agree, but one really nice feature FF has is the ability to see a diff of the CSS properties you've changed in the inspector: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Tools/Page_Inspector/How_to/Examine_and_edit_CSS#track_changes https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Tools/Page_Inspecto...
- yfkar 5y agoOne thing where I've used Firefox devtools instead of Chrome is when debugging font usage (which is not very often). Chrome tells you the used font for a single element on a pretty generic level, e.g. "Lato — Local file" or "Lato — Network resource". Firefox Inspector has a Fonts tab that lets you list all the fonts used on a page. It tells you a more specific font name, e.g. "Lato Regular", the relevant @font-face rule and also the font URL if it's a network resource.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> Mainly: editing and saving directly in the debugger! Hum... Firefox does that. I know because every time I mistakenly start saving I ask what is the point of it. But well, looks like it's useful for somebody.
- hutzlibu 5y agoErm, it can edit and save code live in a debbing session? Also, how can I edit code? It is non editable for me.
- marcosdumay 5y ago
- maccard 5y agoBut you're ok with google the organization?
- krageon 5y ago> dev tools Chrome's devtools have been superior (faster, more reliable, more featureful) for years near as I can tell (and everyone I work with). I am curious what makes you feel firefox's devtools are better.
- k_ 5y agoAlternative take: [dev]tools are only as powerful as how well you know them. I'd like to think both firefox devtools and chrome devtools as highly capable, but you'll get way more out of the one you're used to, whichever it is.
- Jach 5y agoAnother alternate take: everything since Firebug has been cake icing, what differences there are now on top of that base feature set are minimal.
- krageon 5y agoThe two devtools purport to do almost the exact same things, with a practically identical interface. The details are where the usability differences lie, such as chrome's vastly superior formatting/debugging story. I only moved to Chrome after working with firebug (!) for years and then working with firefox's builtin devtools. If anything, I should hate Chrome's devtools the most because I know them least well.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI wonder why. It's not like Firefox is a bad browser.
- prox 5y agoNot only is it not bad, it’s pretty good. I have been using it for a decade and its fast, superior privacy above Chrome, devtools do everything I need. I test on Chrome, and I personally don’t think switching is that big a deal that some commenters make it out to be. It’s just as fast as Chrome or faster, the UX is similar enough not be stalled for long if you need to switch. It’s really worth a shot!
- chii 5y ago> It's not like Firefox is a bad browser. compared to chrome, firefox no longer has an edge. Chrome's restrictive addons is what made firefox stronger. But ever since firefox removed the old XUL style addons, their utility has drastically dropped against chrome. I was very angry at their poor choice, as some really excellent, but unmaintained addons no longer work. I put up with firefox, just so i can give them some boost (whatever that might amount to), but obviously not that many users would sacrifice their browsing experience for such purposes. Firefox should be the premier customizable browser, with more addons than chrome. Instead, firefox chose to copy chrome. Thus, it is forever relegated to being second.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoYes this is true. Mozilla neutered extensions on Android. I'm using Firefox nightly and I have to jump through hoops to get the extensions I want. Far too complicated for most users I'm sure.
- progval 5y agoI also hate they had to kill XUL addons, but they had good reasons to do so: https://yoric.github.io/post/why-did-mozilla-remove-xul-addons/ https://yoric.github.io/post/why-did-mozilla-remove-xul-addo...
- 5y ago
- feketegy 5y agoThey don't have any coherent marketing strategy, most people still think that Firefox is this sluggish browser that don't support anything. Also, most non-technical people use the default browser that's installed on the OS whether that's Safari or Edge. When manifest v3 kicks in and we'll see the true ad horror that's the Internet today without ad blockers, maybe then we'll jump to a more privacy first browser. Until then nothing will happen.
- hutzlibu 5y agoI pity anyone, surfing the web without adblockers. I am regulary shocked, when I use a browser without one.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIt's because Chrome is preinstalled on Android, Internet Explorer all over again.
- chucky 5y agoWhat does it tell Mozilla that they need to know? Because I certainly don't understand, but I'm a happy Firefox user so obviously I'm not part of any exodus.
- dobladov 5y agoIs v3 an horrible solution or the deprecation of v2 in 2023? I ported one of my extensions to v3 and while the process was not completely trivial it did not took more than a few hours, in my opinion the change is worth it this makes extensions more secure. As far as I know Firefox is also moving to v3, maybe not enforcing it for now, but they will probably deprecate v2 at some point.
- kevingadd 5y agoAn extension API that can't implement ad-blockers properly is an extension API that is broken by design. So yes, it's a horrible solution.
- input_sh 5y agoWhile they're interested in maintaining compatibility with Chrome's v3, there's no standard that forces them to make every single v3 change Chrome does. v2 also already differs in some ways in which Firefox thinks it makes sense. I'm not scared at all that they're gonna deprecate webRequest.BlockingResponse in favour of declarativeNetRequest, which is the specific API function that adblockers rely on. After all, that function has nothing to do with security, best you could argue is that it's related to performance due to filter lists becoming absurdly long.
- dotancohen 5y agoIn the context of `webRequest.BlockingResponse` being a performance bottleneck due to filter lists becoming absurdly long, it does in fact become a security issue. Filter lists are as long as they are because that is the amount of domains that have demonstrated an interest in harming our security (and for many people, online privacy _is_ physical security). Filterlists are blacklists, not whitelists, so they only grow when well-known entities play foul.
- selcuka 5y agoIt's not only a simple Manifest version change. They have also deprecated the webRequest API, which is essential to implement any type of content filter or an ad blocker.
- echelon 5y agoIt's time for antitrust breakup of Google. America's top search engine and America's top internet ads company has the America's top browser and pays to be the default search engine for America's top cell phone?
- gman83 5y agoThe day that adblockers stop working on Chrome is the day we'll see that mass-migration.
- mda 5y agoWhich will probably never happen.
- mrkramer 5y agoYea because of legal antitrust reasons but Google will try to disrupt Ad Blockers as much as they are technically and legally allowed to do.
- soundnote 5y agoPeople already use Chrome on mobile for the most part, and it has no adblockers whatsoever. A depressing number of users use the web via the Chrome search bar on their phone, and even if they use a browser they go even to familiar sites by googing them.
- chinathrow 5y agoI am already here since the Phoenix times. Come over guys! https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/firefox_releasenotes/en-us/firefox/releases/0.5 https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/firefox_...
- kovac 5y agoThe only reason I don't use Firefox is mozilla. I will never use it as long as it's under mozilla. I use Vivaldi, choosing to support a smaller, genuine business with no bullshit. I hope they'll eventually to develop their own engine.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoWhat... Is the appeal of brave ? I hear it has crypto and shit but why not install Firefox with ubo and be done with it? I feel the "cool" factor of brave is silly as they are just fueling chromium. Why don't these chromium forks base on Firefox instead and do some leg work with the benefit of helping the internet as a whole ? I hear someone said on hn a long time ago, building on ff is a pita. Well guess what, Firefox folk do nightly builds of a boat load of versions and flavours and shit. Why can't you change a theme and call it a day?
- cinquemb 5y agoAs someone who wouldn't mind if Mozilla post Eich can die under a metadata drone strike (doubly so for google) and will still use my FF fork and avoid chrome/chromium based browsers like the plague, brave, seems like they are willing to build in support for decentralized (to me at least) and p2p web directly into the browser (rather than leave it up to potentially less performant 3rd party extensions which may be ok, but not ideal in ff) than all the crap I have to compile out of ff occasionally.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agowhy cant brave build on top of firefox?
- cinquemb 5y agoSee Brendan's response to me last week[0], which I think comes down to feature set they want to support rather than do all the work it would require to build that in servo now (they went from gecko [no public info on this] -> electron -> and now chromium. they would have to migrate from chromium -> servo). I wish they did, and just cared less about all the other features that were missing from gecko (but that's just be being selfish and not wanting to build out native stuff myself lol) [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28605711 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28605711
- 2Gkashmiri 5y ago
- sneak 5y agoFirefox is a lot less secure than Chromium.
- axegon_ 5y agoMany years ago I published a small extension for common functions I use on daily basis(hashing, url encoding and decoding) for quick access as opposed to either opening a random site or some scripting language. If my memory is correct, I can kiss it goodbye(no idea where or even if I have a copy of the source code). Oh well... As for ad-blockers, funny enough I used to be firmly against them until not that long ago - many sites and blogs rely on ads as a source of revenue so in order to support them I was putting up with them. But then youtube pushed me waaaaaay too far and I started using Brave so... It's your fault Google,
- wow00 5y agoTotally agree on that, I used the web without an ad blocker for years before going back due to having too many ads on YouTube, Google is slowly closing their walls and I may end up on Firefox at this rate
- axegon_ 5y agoFirefox has always felt a bit clunky to me hence the reason why I went with brave: it's built on top of chromium but with a built-in adblocker, also some crypto rewards if you are into that(I'm not). Give it a go if you ask me.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe web without an ad blocker is essentially unusable.
- soraminazuki 5y agoConsidering all the shady practices that online ad companies engage in, there is zero moral responsibility for users to support it. As an example of such shady practice, here's an instance of the biggest ad company in the world caught exploiting browser bugs in order to circumvent privacy protections: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/02/time-make-amends-google-circumvents-privacy-settings-safari-users https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/02/time-make-amends-googl...
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoThis is great news for Firefox. I switched a year ago and was forced to use Chrome once or twice (lack of call support in Teams web app; I'm unwilling to install the native (?) app). The main difference between Chrome and Firefox is that Chrome feels passively (and sometimes actively) user-hostile with things like not-so-intuitive Chrome-vs-Google login and many other things that may seem trifle details but are in fact well-thought-out features with very specific purposes. In Firefox it's the opposite: I can start with containers right away, for example. Some extensions like Ad Nauseam (and many others) are simply removed from Chrome Store and if you insist on using them with Chrome, you need to re-enable them with the developer mode each time you start the browser. Why torture yourself if you can simply use Firefox?
- zorr 5y agoTo address the (?) in your comment: The downloadable Teams app is electron-based.
- OldTimeCoffee 5y agoNot for much longer, it's moving to Edge Webview2 instead. https://twitter.com/rishmsft/status/1408085784016539653 https://twitter.com/rishmsft/status/1408085784016539653
- jimmydorry 5y agoBecause Firefox will most likely follow the same path?
- smaddock 5y agoAs someone who is intimately familiar with the Chrome extensions internals and is not employed by a big tech company, I believe most of the changes seem like a step in the right direction.* I've been working towards implementing greater support for Chrome extensions in Electron which has involved reading and interacting with Chromium code [0]. - Using service workers instead of a hidden background webpage is more idiomatic for web developers. - Forced non-persistent extensions guides developers to a better implementation which relies on less resources. *The deprecation of webRequest's blocking behavior is what's most concerning. The implementation in Manifest V2 requires sending a message back and forth between processes with JS processing for each network request which seems to be in part why they redesigned it. However, that optimization costs so much for innovative ad blocking technologies as gorhill of uBlock Origin has mentioned. When ad blocking begins requiring new methods of detection or filtering, it'll now be up to Chromium maintainers to implement support for it in the new declarativeNetRequest API. This is a tradeoff of performance for reduced flexibility where it is absolutely needed. [0] https://github.com/samuelmaddock/electron-browser-shell https://github.com/samuelmaddock/electron-browser-shell
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoI just disabled javascript and see no ads whatsoever. No idea what problem gorhill found to solve, but ad blocking seems to be easy.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoThe problem of not disabling JavaScript and not seeing ads. I.e. granting users control over the code their browser runs that's finer-grained than "nuke it from orbit".
- square_usual 5y agoYes, if you crush your computer into a cube you won't see ads again either. But people want to keep their computers and block content they don't like, so there's "problems to solve" there.
- 5y ago
- Barrin92 5y agoif you haven't already use Firefox and recognize that this is a fundamental question of freedom and whether you want the internet to be controlled by dystopian corporate advertisement monoliths or institutions that care about your rights. Every time this comes up and 80% of discussions is about whether the tab bar in firefox is flat or three pixels wide instead of five makes me more depressed
- jacquesm 5y agoFair criticism of Firefox is that it is dependent on Mozilla 'the org' which is a pretty shaky foundation to base such a critical component on. Witness the exodus of even die hard supporters over the last couple of years. That has nothing to do with minor UI details.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoI’d prefer Firefox, but some functionality works inarguably better in chrome. One example is YouTube, which slams my processor due to the lack of hardware decoding.
- maccard 5y agoSo swap to chrome for those 1-2 websites that require it and use Firefox for everything else?
- jacquesm 5y agoThis is exactly how I work and it works quite well.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoYeah the user is DEFINITELY wrong here and it’s not the browsers fault for being mediocre.
- Gareth321 5y ago"Don't use the product" is ALWAYS a poor rebuttal. Few people like having to utilise multiple browsers.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI have a stupid idea. But first, a bunch of questions: - Can you legally advertise a product you're not affiliated with? Is this OK by the ToS of major ad networks? - Is it possible to target ads by user's browser? I'm thinking, maybe we should crowdfund a public interest ad, targeted at people browsing from Chrome, with some attention-grabbing art or distracting colors, and a clear message: "Want to stop seeing this ad? Stop using Chrome, install a different browser and an ad blocker. Click here to learn more.", which links to a site directing people to install Firefox and uBlock Origin (and linking to crowdfunding campaign to keep the ad going). Alternative for A/B testing: "Don't click this ad, it costs us money." Come to think of it, maybe someone like EFF should do that - they're well-known and reputable enough that people wouldn't immediately assume it's some weird Firefox ad, avoiding the effect being the opposite from intended.
- chippiewill 5y agoEven if it's not against TOS I would imagine most ad network just refusing to serve ads that encourage people to install ad blockers.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYeah, I guess. But I imagine there's so much volume of ads that they can't all go through human review. Maybe it could sneak in undetected and work for a short while, until the first tweet mentioning it goes viral.
- hutzlibu 5y agoIt would probably work, until it really works - when it will be stopped. But if done right, it has the potential to create lots of attention. An add, that wants you to see less ads, that was finally taken down by the big corporations? Very clickbait article stuff - it is just that (almost) all those news networks live on ads so have no incentive to push up this news.
- eitland 5y agoI can put up a "pretend ad" on my two blogs and maybe I can be a bit creative and get it feqtured elsewhere too if someone provides "artwork" and somewhere to point it too. Anyone else in? PS: If you do it later, send me a mail (it is in my profile, click my username to see it.)
- radiKal07 5y agoGood. I hope this will push people to stop using Chrome. I am all in on Safari and don't miss Chrome one bit.
- irjustin 5y agoFor me (I imagine a lot of others as well), it's simple. If Chrome removes adblock, I'm going back to Firefox. HN ilk don't represent a good target market. Can't really make money off traditionally tracked ads off of us. FWIW, I love Chrome, still do. I've been here since those entirely useless but super viral and catchy speed test ad/vids. It worked on me. I love the debugger as a web developer, more so than Firebug. Overall, will be sad to go. Pour one out for Chrome when the day comes.
- nottorp 5y agoI don't see the point in using an ad blocker but running Chrome. It's not like Google would allow the ad blocker to filter their own tracking. Sadly, the only option seems to be Firefox and the niche browsers.
- A_Venom_Roll 5y agoNot OP, but the main reason for me to use adblockers is not to prevent tracking, but to block ads. This alone makes websites load significantly faster and it sometimes prevents dozens of annoying ads per webpage.
- jefftk 5y agoAd blockers on Chrome block Google's ads too. The ad script doesn't even run, so it's not getting as far as collecting any data. (I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- vehemenz 5y agoIn Chrome and Safari, Google search injects analytics via the ping attribute on <a> tags. This sends some additional ping-to and ping-from headers. So Google is still collecting data from who use its search, provided they are not on Firefox. I would assume it does the same for its other products, such as Google Analytics, but I haven't checked.
- jefftk 5y ago
- jokoon 5y agoI realized that a lot of non-programmers don't know about installing an ad blocker, or when do have one, it's not ublock origin...
- glanzwulf 5y agoI've always used Chrome but recently I've been trying out Brave and its been quite interesting. I still use chrome, but if they were to remove adblock i'd move for good.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoEveryone should use the last bastion of free Web: Firefox. (which is actually pretty great, and I have a way better browsing experience with it that with that chrome monstrosity)
- glanzwulf 5y agoHaven't used Firefox in years, would need to check what's new. But I've been enjoying Brave. Built in blockers for ads and trackers, built in tor, and a very interesting rewards system to help content creators and honestly, so far I recommend it.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoFor the sake of fighting browser engines monoculture, I'd recommend you NOT using Brave, even for all the goodies and niceties in the world.
- aembleton 5y agoWhat's wrong with a browser engine monoculture? It'd make development simpler as you could just test against that one engine.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoWe have been down this road before in 2000, so we know it leads to the total opposite of "make development simpler". When IE6 became the engine mono culture, it was the best. But then it stopped innovating, because it didn't need to. It also pushed moves that were only for the good of Micorosoft, since they had monopoly, trying to make the web a less open place. It was a pain to develop for, a pain to debug, and a capricious master. Google has shown they can be very naughty as soon as they got power over something. Learn from history. Do not give them that power.
- trabant00 5y agoThis will not cause Chrome to lose market share, it is in fact the exact opposite. The move is _required_ for market share. Castrating extensions prevents average Joe from shooting himself in the foot. It is easy for us to forget how bad most non IT people are with these things. It's OK to have browsers aimed at different markets. I will continue to use Firefox but will not push it to my aging parents for example. I feel the same for Linux on the desktop discussion. I don't want Linux to become another Windows or Mac OS. The DIY always tinkering with it is a feature not a bug. It's like a car you keep for track days. Sure you work on it all the time and would not want your grandma taking it shopping, but that's not it's purpose! Of course family cars will always have a huge market share compared to track day cars. And you would not want to change that because it would mean destroying what a track day car is in the process of making it user friendly, reliable, maintenance free, etc.
- nomercy400 5y agoWould you like to have random companies tracking your grandma wherever she goes, because of the GPS that's now in every family car? Would you like supermarkets real-time adjust (=increase by 2ct) the prices on products your grandma usually buys, based on when your grandma's family car is taking the "I'm going shopping" route?
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIt's the opposite, only power users can use Windows, everyone else don't know hygiene and quickly get stuffed with viruses.
- MrPatan 5y agoIf you don't want to use Firefox (why not?) just use Brave or Edge. Each has its own quirks of course, but it's better than the google cage chrome is. (Undeleteable google cookies? Come on)
- square_usual 5y agoEdge is just a Microsoft Cage. It is far and away the worst browser from a privacy standpoint: https://brave.com/popular-browsers-first-run/ https://brave.com/popular-browsers-first-run/
- coffeeling 5y agoSadly also a really damn good product otherwise.
- maccolgan 5y agoA Blink monoculture destroying "the web", like the one we almost already have.
- yborg 5y agoThe only thing preventing a Blink monoculture is Safari, thanks to iOS platform lock-in. Firefox has negligible market share, if that was all that was left, Gecko would have to become a Blink clone to survive, nobody would code exceptions for it.
- droppedTheBox 5y agoIMO the Web was better in the Trident days, when IE6's dominance allowed a single defacto web-wide standard (vs today's WHATWG clusterfsk) but alternative browsers like NetCaptor could still provide all the shiny UI chrome, from tabs to integrated popup blocking. Having a single renderer but multiple browsers on top of it would vastly simplify the web for users & developers, resulting in one consistent engine to develop, test, and fuzz against. Rather than being the irrelevance it is today, Mozilla focusing on Blink development & governance would have way more impact for billions of users, rather than some obsolete and forgotten build of Firefox. Then all it'd take is for something like the E.U. to cripple Apple's Webkit-on-iOS monopoly for Blink to take over there too. Having multiple renderers is just a waste of everyone's time...
- ximm 5y agoSo my understanding is that both chrome and firefox will eventually switch to manifest v3 and for the most part, this is probably a good thing. I understand that chrome also wants to remove the API that is used for ad blocking, which is bad. But apart from that, what is the migration path? Will there be a window when both browsers support both versions?
- Liquidor 5y agoLast I heard Mozilla said the following: Developer testing in Q4 2021 and v3 submissions early 2022. So both browsers should support both v2 and v3 for a year.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoGoogle makes it's money from advertising. Connect the dots.
- shadowfaxRodeo 5y agoRemoving webRequest's blocking will completely destroy my web extension. It helps people get work done by blocking website's they're addicted to. I've just started out on a new version, not sure what to do.
- matkoniecz 5y agoDevelop it for Firefox and recommend people to remove Chrome as part of using it? Though it has Leechblock already.
- shadowfaxRodeo 5y agoI have a firefox version, and a safari one in the works. It has about 50 users on firefox and 1500 on chrome. It works a bit differently to most content blockers, you can take a look here if you're interested: https://prodtodolist.com https://prodtodolist.com Anyway, the whole point is to allow people to get out of addictive loops, to take control of how they use the web, and most people aren't that tech savvy — they deserve to not be addicted to facebook too.
- jefftk 5y agoIs there a reason you can't use the declarative API to block these websites? Isn't that what you're doing on Safari? https://developer.chrome.com/docs/extensions/reference/declarativeNetRequest/ https://developer.chrome.com/docs/extensions/reference/decla... (Disclosure: I work at Google, speaking only for myself)
- shadowfaxRodeo 5y agoI wrote that previous comment before I fully understood the new specification. I'm still not entirely sure, but it looks like you're right. I thought the rules were static, I see now they can be updated dynamically — which works perfectly for my use case.
- HWR_14 5y agoSo, if I read this correctly, there's no way to modify the results of a request anymore? I can just redirect to a new URL, block or allow? I' m not even sure, upon reading that, if I can use JS to redirect based on the full URL not just the matching snippet to a new URL.
- est 5y agoI am using an old version of Chrome for it's sweet net-internals. All back channel traffic can be monitored btw.
- emptyparadise 5y agoNow I wonder how long we've got until Firefox kills them off too...
- everyone 5y agoA lot of Googles income comes from running ads, of course they want to stop people from blocking them.
- anothernewdude 5y agoGoodbye Chrome
- romanovcode 5y agoThe moment uBlock Origin stops working on Chrome is the moment I will switch to a different browser. Fortunately I have no loyalty to a browser.
- rejectfinite 5y agoYou might aswell switch today. https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-best-on-Firefox https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
- hakube 5y agoThere's Brave with built-in ad-block. Also uBlock works well with Firefox. uBlock on Chrome crashes the browser in my experience
- visskiss 5y agoWouldn’t touch chrome with a ten foot pole. Why would people who know about explorer go to chrome? Stockholm syndrome? Jeez
- joelthelion 5y agoI don't understand why this (and all the rest) is not driving people back to Firefox. Are we really going to wait for Mozilla to die, and then lament that Google has taken over the web?
- aembleton 5y agoProbably because v2 extensions haven't been switched off yet. It might be different in January 2023; or maybe the limited adblocking of v3 will be enough for most people. Time will tell.
- mmis1000 5y agoAd providers are obfuscating domains to bypass blocks. Currently only ublock origin deobfuscate and block based on the original domain.(It is supported on firefox only anyway) But after the change... I guess no one on chrome can do. And ad blocking will be totally useless at that point. See also: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dashboard:-Settings#uncloak-canonical-names https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dashboard:-Settings#u...
- xwdv 5y agoWhat about first party domains
- XorNot 5y agoBehavior-based blocks take care of those largely. I think only Facebook is reliably staying ahead?
- Stephen304 5y agoIf you mean ublock origin cosmetic filters, yeah facebook is really putting up a fight. The status quo has been randomized css classes, identical html structure, interspersing hidden junk characters in between the "Sponsored" text, and the latest I've noticed, anchors that link to # until you hover over, preventing blocking href=^/ads. That and turning on or off or changing behavior between users and regions makes collaborating on rules really difficult.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- melbourne_mat 5y agoBrave has ad blocking built in - you don't need extensions.
- krono 5y agoBrave is just crypto adware, they even went so far as to automatically append crypto exchange referral codes to urls [0] Funded by Palantir Technologies by the way [1] Their ad rewards system analyses and modifies the original webcontent, replacing existing ads with their own (and who knows what other code they inject) [2] Then there's their hidden tracker URL whitelist [3] No thanks. [0] https://twitter.com/cryptonator1337/status/1269201480105578496 https://twitter.com/cryptonator1337/status/12692014801055784... [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/fe37ml/exclusive_brave_browser_funded_by_dod_contractor/ https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/fe37ml/exclusive_b... [2] https://brave.com/brave-launches-user-trials-for-opt-in-ads/ https://brave.com/brave-launches-user-trials-for-opt-in-ads/ [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19129309#19129642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19129309#19129642 Edit: Nearly forgot about their partner promo headers that they can and do update on the fly https://laptop-updates.brave.com/promo/custom-headers https://laptop-updates.brave.com/promo/custom-headers
- Danieru 5y agoDon't enable ads if you do not want them. Personally I think avoiding ads is important so I don't enable them. Thus Brave acts like what Firefox should be had its organization not become so broken.
- krono 5y agoThe custom ads for crypto rewards (which they've not been paying out) is probably the least concerning thing in that list. The URL modification was silently enabled by default, and the tracker whitelist and marketing headers are not configurable at all. Mozilla isn't what it used to be, but at least they're not acting like the Russian mob.
- 5560675260 5y ago
- Glench 5y agoI run a service that lets browser extension developers take payments in their extensions without needing to run their own servers* and it's been frustrating watching the MV3 rollout. The documentation isn't good, there are unresolved issues, and every developer making an extension adopts it because Google says that's the new thing everyone has to use. And sigh, I hope uBlock Origin continues to work — the web sucks without it. Maybe Mozilla could hire the devs and integrate it into Firefox. * https://extensionpay.com https://extensionpay.com
- IanSanders 5y agoCan we crowdfund a carefully worded firefox advertisement?
- mrkramer 5y agoI feared this day would come.
- kqvamxurcagg 5y agoWill this new manifest v3 API also be forced on chromium browsers such as Brave?
- whichdan 5y agoI've been working on a lightweight Chrome Extension and it's been really, really frustrating. The documentation is all over the place and it's sometimes unclear what's for v2 vs v3, and there aren't any deep-dive guides for solving non-trivial problems. There also isn't really any tooling for development besides "reload the extension in Chrome and see if it works."
- breezeTrowel 5y agoThis is particularly amusing considering Google's extreme lack of v3 documentation. Their samples and examples Github, for example, has only 2 examples, iirc. They also introduce a lot of silliness like the inability to nest content scripts within folders. Not to mention all the limitations of the Chrome browser. The continuous difference between console.log and console.dir. The former only shows you a very limited view of JS objects while the latter is what Firefox uses as the default for console.log - a full view of the object you want inspected. Then there's the inability to edit and resend network requests. The only workaround is to copy the request as a fetch request, dump it into the console or snippets, re-edit it there, and then send it through the console. Of course you'd have to parse the response in the console too instead of being able to see it in devtools. And then there's Chrome's complete lack of proper proxy support. You could start the browser with command line flags in order to enable a SOCKS5 proxy, for example, but that requires you to close your existing browser session and open a new one. Finally, how is it that we have nearly exact dates (2022-01-17 and sometime in January 2023) for V2 sunsetting but the dates for implementation of actual features needed to migrate away from V2 have no solid expectation date? Isn't that putting the cart before the horse? From the article: "In the coming months, we'll also be launching support for dynamically configurable content scripts and an in-memory storage option, among other new capabilities." "In the coming months"? The v2 sunset date is just a few months away! Why not ensure that the current feature set is fully functional and adequate to replace v2 before blocking v2 extension submissions?
- fregante 5y agoIt's interesting that you mention Chrome’s silliness when I find Firefox’ dev tools to be severely lacking, especially for WebExtensions. Examples include: - complete inability to run code from the console into the content script context - content script errors are not shown in the console, you have to open a separate Browser Console - overall buggy dev tools (I don't remember anymore because I stopped using them a long time ago) I guess every browser lacks something, it's just that we notice when we compare "my browser" to the next one.
- thioordc 5y ago
- tablespoon 5y agoChrome really needs to be divested from Google, even if it dies as a result. Pretty much the only two still-extant cross-platform browsers (Chromium and Firefox) are funded by ad company money. In a lot of ways, this is worse than the Microsoft/Internet Explorer situation.
- cm2012 5y agoIt's amazing how many security conscious companies allow unrestricted chrome extensions while restricting every other vector ad nauseum.
- mrieck 5y agoAre they still planning to block <all_urls> for content scripts? Website blocking extensions like my Productivity Owl (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/productivity-owl/eoagmdboiealblmpaahjlhajggndaahi?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/productivity-owl/e...) would be completely pointless if you have to allow it on every page you visit.
- freediver 5y agoFrom Google 2018 10-K, page 17 [1] "New and existing technologies could affect our ability to customize ads and/or could block ads online, which would harm our business. Technologies have been developed to make customizable ads more difficult or to block the display of ads altogether and some providers of online services have integrated technologies that could potentially impair the core functionality of third-party digital advertising. Most of our Google revenues are derived from fees paid to us in connection with the display of ads online. As a result, such technologies and tools could adversely affect our operating results." https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000165204419000004/goog10-kq42018.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000165204419...
- lenkite 5y agoCan Mozilla please make an Electron replacement ? Call it Neutron or Proton or whatever. Surely a Servo based engine can beat Blink ?