23 ms·
Ford CEO says the company 'overestimated' self-driving cars
- dugditches 8y agoIf it allows for development of more systems to to augment a driver's ability or limitations. Rather than relying on some unfeasible HAL dream. Things such as: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collision_avoidance_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collision_avoidance_system BMW has been working on something similar, in the goal of developing new safety/comfort for riders. I tried showing it to some older riders who gave the whole 'they want to automate everything etc etc carburetors drum brakes kick starts points etc' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfGmfV9em1A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfGmfV9em1A
- wetpaws 8y agoThat's what most of people don't understand - self driving cars are evolutionary, not revolutionary. You are not getting a car that can do everything - just a car that does progressively slightly more and more every day, like automated parking on 2019 toyotas or adaptive cruise control, etc.
- slavik81 8y agoIf my car could drop me off at the front door and go park on its own, that would be a significant improvement over the status quo. A personal automated valet is perhaps a little easier than an automated driver that does everything. Low speeds also means stopping or starting on a dime, which would allow it to be more conservative about identifying obstacles than when driving at highway speeds. I don't really understand why nobody aimed for that sort of incremental improvement. Maybe the sensor package is too expensive to use in such a limited fashion?
- twblalock 8y agoThe problem with self-driving cars is you can get most of the way to a working solution but that’s not good enough. If the solution is flawed even a little bit, people will die. That will give self-driving cars a bad reputation and people will be unwilling to ride in them. If you are going to geofence self-driving cars it is questionable whether they are better than trains and buses. I think the best we can hope for in the next 10 years is better driver assistance systems, like GM Super Cruise or Tesla’s Autopilot (if they can make it stop crashing into things).
- mrweasel 8y agoBeyond the geo-fenced solution, and system like Super Cruise, I doubt that we'll see truly self-driving cars for another 30 - 40 years. What fascinates me is that company like Uber believe that they can use their current business model to finance the development of a self-driving car and the start to make profit when those cars a ready. That would mean investors pumping money into the company for at least 25 years more. It makes more sense to slowly develop self-driving cars for technologies like Autopilot and Super Cruise. Gradually improving the solution until one day it can safely navigate a leaf covers dirt road.
- rcxdude 8y agoStrategies like Autopilot are the worst of both worlds: They don't free up the driver and they are still susceptable to faults. Driving aids which engage to prevent an accident are a useful way to improve safety, driving aids which mean the driver is not in control and is just monitoring the system in case something goes wrong increases the likelihood of accident significantly.
- Retric 8y ago> just monitoring the system in case something goes wrong increases the likelihood of accident significantly. That depends on the rate of system failure. I used an early form of autopilot and you quickly started to pay attention to where the system would fail. It was like cruse control where you look for situations where you can turn it on but never stop paying attention. At the other end with really safe systems they are going to default to safer than a human driver. So, there might be a significantly deadlier middle ground, but no company has deployed anything like that yet.
- cr0sh 8y ago> I used an early form of autopilot and you quickly started to pay attention to where the system would fail. It was like cruse control where you look for situations where you can turn it on but never stop paying attention. You may do this, but I bet the majority of people do not. I know that Google has data about it's self-driving cars that they know their "safety drivers" simply don't pay attention. In Uber's case - here in the Phoenix area last year - this inattention helped to cause an arguably avoidable fatal accident. These were people supposedly trained not to do this - yet they did. As far as cruise control is concerned - there've been more than a few accidents of people thinking it did more than it does, and not pay attention to the road in front of them. Tesla's autopilot system, while better than simple cruise control, has - because of this better system (and poor marketing) - caused people to think it does more than it can, and has led them to sleeping in their vehicles while it "drove", to being completely inattentive, etc. It is pretty well known at this point that those "middle levels" of self-driving technologies are things that shouldn't be implemented, because people either misunderstand them, or misuse them, leading to often fatal accidents.
- andy_ppp 8y agoI don’t actually believe this will prove to be correct, it just might take a decade longer and or be on more limited routes but it will happen.
- anbop 8y agoWell a non-owner CEO only cares about the company for the duration of his compensation package. He’s cutting costs now to boost the stock price. Why should he give a flying fuck what happens to the company when everyone but Ford has a self driving car in 15 years? He got his.
- notahacker 8y agoThis assumes that investors look only at programme costs and perceive absolutely no possible upside to a self driving car programme when evaluating the long term value of a company. Which seems pretty unlikely...
- simonh 8y agoAutonomous vehicles operating on limited routes (geofenced) at first is exactly what is described in the article, so it's not clear to me what you disagree with.
- andy_ppp 8y agoI suppose you could say that, but I’m saying it’ll be late rather than not be possible. I suspect roads will start being built with automation in mind for example, and push bikes might be required to have a small transceiver to alert the cars AI to their whereabouts. I think Ford are saying here that it just won’t be good ever, I’m saying it will be better, later and slower to be everywhere but will still exist.
- simonh 8y agoNowhere in the title or body of the article does it suggest it won't be possible. In fact it's simply saying it's harder than many people thought.
- sdan 8y agoInfrastructure, machine learning, sensors, and other components are there. We already got self driving cars. Now human adoption and acceptance is the problem.
- m0zg 8y agoNo we don't. We'll "have" self driving cars when I can ride them in Seattle when it's raining. Right now this is not doable.
- mikejb 8y agoWe have them in very limited settings, and fairly small numbers. Over time, they'll work in more and more environments, and that lessens their limitations. That will then increase adoption, and that will in turn drive acceptance. Resistance against self-driving cars is (in my opinion) based around either fear for loss of job, or fear of an image of self-driving cars that is not very representative.
- mrweasel 8y agoWe have self driving cars, they just can't go where we want and need them to go, and won't change for decades.
- hguhghuff 8y agoGame changing technology tends to be overestimated in the short term and underestimated in the long term.
- Err_Eek 8y agoAny examples?
- hguhghuff 8y agoYeah the first web boom then bust... everyone thought it was over with no way to make money.
- barry-cotter 8y agoPersonal computers, mobile phones, genome sequencing, MOOCs, email, the telegraph, phones, the railway. There are examples where it was just straight up overestimated as well of course, like AirPower in warfare but air travel was definitely under estimated too. A plane is a flying bus and people travel across a continent for a weekend trip.
- Insanity 8y agoPerhaps bitcoin will follow this pattern. (Or well, Blockchain finance more generally).
- hguhghuff 8y agoI agree. Initial boom, then loss of faith, but in the long run probably eventually will all be some form of crypto.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat would require the gov't and big business to jump on board, and it's not clear why they would want to.
- Insanity 8y ago
- alentodorov 8y agoSo we’re entering the through of disillusionment, which is only part 3 of the hype cycle tough.
- person_of_color 8y agoSDCs are a slipperly ope to AGI.
- s_kilk 8y agoThey're really not. Nothing on the horizon right now points to AGI.
- cinquemb 8y agoThat wont stop the latest institute from touting that their latest glorified BLAS reducible ML will take over the world tomorrow if someone doesn't continue to fund their work.
- platzer 8y agoMerely scaling up a GAN and optimizing it's network structure and training procedure allowed GANs to create nearly realistic high resolution faces. If you can generate realistic faces, then you can likely also generate realistic action and thought sequences simply with an even larger model. An action/thought sequence is just a 4D tensor with some outputs controlling actuators. Thinking is just production of actions while actuator output neurons are inhibited, which can simply be implemented by a product with some sigmoid activated neurons. Coherent combinations of such sequences can be produced by feeding both the current sensory inputs and the preceding internal state as conditioning vector to both the generator and discriminator. You simply need to find a way to train the discriminator not only to tell real from fake, but to determine the value of the generator's outputs and make it backpropagate those values in time during training over several generated episodes by TD. As the GAN is conditioned on its own previous state, it can learn by trial and error how to combine the short action and thought sequences it produces, can thus learn to produce coherent ("real") language and logic. Based on such intuitions, I'd say it is impossible to tell when AGI will come exactly, but currently technology looks damn promising.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- esalman 8y agoDriving on the road is about cooperating with the other people so that everyone benefits. Almost everyone underestimated the social aspect of it.
- laumars 8y agoI doubt they underestimated the social aspect of it given I was at a talk about self driving cars about 10 years ago and one of the developers went into detail about how the hardest part they had to work on was the social aspect of driving. I remember at the time being surprised to hear that as it's always something I'd taken for granted but it's something that I've consciously noticed ever since.
- esalman 8y agoThank you for pointing it out. I am sure there were always a few who did focus on the social aspect. I just feel that the direction in which the car industry and self-driving tech has grown obviously suggests that they underestimated it. Everyone would agree that if every car in the road is autonomous, it will be possible to nearly eliminate accidents and casualties and increase commuting efficiency. Unless there is a bug in the system or a rogue actor takes over that is- but that's a different type of risk. However, people are still buying cars with no self-driving capabilities and financing them for next 5-6 years or even longer. Let alone the infrastructure which is crumbling away instead of being readied for autonomous tech. That's why people like the Ford CEO are having to come out and recognize issues like this.
- laumars 8y agoI wonder if we're using the same term to describe different things since I'm not talking about the social stigma of owning an autonomous car. I'm talking about social in terms of reading the intentions of other drivers (eg joining a busy motorway or deciding who goes first on a spot island when all lanes have stopped and waited for the other) and other hazards (eg pedestrians crossing the road without looking properly because they're distracted with young kids, chatting to friends, or tapping on their phone) As a driver you developer an intuition for how other drivers would react in different situations. Sometimes that's based on the speed of a vehicle, the angle of the car or driving style (eg are they bumper to bumper with the car in front?). Sometimes it's based on profiling/prejudice about people who drive certain brands of cars (eg BMW owners do tend to be pushier drivers than perhaps someone in a Fiat 500 - obviously this isn't always the case but you might still be more cautious if you see someone approach a busy junction in a powerful car). Another thing experienced drivers might react to is if they see a series of brief break lights ahead at roughly the same point but cars aren't swerving around an obstruction then that might suggest there's a speed trap. There's even been times when I've been on a motorway and a car has suddenly swerved in front of me however I was already hovering over the break just in case as I was expecting it through a series of subtle clues I picked up from their driving style. I knew that they were about to change lanes without checking their mirror even before they committed to the manoeuvre themselves. There are so many hints and cues that drivers pick up on from other drivers. So much non-verbal communication. And that was the hardest part to train an AI. Sure you can teach them to react to hazards as they happen but having them pre-empt hazards before they happen without having that algorithm react to every false positive is a whole over level of engineering. It's something that takes humans literally years of driving every day to get good at and we already come pre-programmed with more sophisticated hazard detection before we even sit our bum behind that steering wheel than AIs have currently. So this is the social aspect I was referring to. And I'm sure autonomous cars will learn this in time too - or at least get a close enough approximation where they're "good enough" for general purpose driving. edit: I should have added that one good thing about AI is at least it's reaction times are lower. That reduces the significance of pre-emptively spotting likely hazards somewhat.
- EnderMB 8y agoI've often wondered why consumer-level self-driving cars are being pushed as a thing when the logical step would be automating service vehicles first - low-risk vehicles that cover the most miles, which can go much slower if working 24/7. Instead of trying to replicate complex pedestrian routes at standard speed, why not handle established delivery routes instead, and optimise over time for new routes? It's interesting to see how the numerous players in the field, including startups across the globe, are trying to handle this problem, but no one seems to be close. It's a slow race, where everyone is noisy in order to not seem they've been overtaken.
- Heliosmaster 8y agoalmost.. like trains?
- giancarlostoro 8y agoCurious have you ever been on one? Not sure how fast or slow they are for cargo but I have taken a train from Orlando to Hollywood (near the Miami area) approx a 3 hour drive by car. On a good day its a 6 hour train ride, I think I have been on there for 10 hours before. Some people for waaay longer from further up north. I rather be on the road but a train was cheaper than spending money on tolls plus gas. Saving money then was a necessity for me.
- gambiting 8y agoYou speak about trains as if they are some incredibly exotic things? Maybe they are in US, I don't know. But at least UK trains are almost always faster than driving. I could get to London by train in like 2:50h, or 5 hours of driving(and that's just to outskirts of London, not the city centre). Or to Edinburgh in 1:20h by train, or 3 hours of driving. Not to mention proper European trains, where taking a TGV from Paris to say Brussels, Amsterdam or Berlin is in no way or form comparable to driving - it's just much much faster. Now the cost is an issue - in the UK driving is almost invariably cheaper than taking the train, even when going solo. When taking any passengers with you driving will win every single time, sometimes it's even worth renting a car for the journey and it will still be cheaper than the train.
- Wyndtroy2012 8y agoHow come all of us people that drive cars and are not in the car production business ,all knew the predictions Hackett and the rest made was loony?
- pepper_sauce 8y agoI'd rather have frequent, reliable and safe public transport than self-driving cars. Can we pour billions of dollars into that instead, please?
- tobyhinloopen 8y agoSelf-driving cars are the future of frequent, reliable and safe public transport. Why own a car when you can have a self-driving car pick you up from anywhere, bring you anywhere, and drive away to the next customer when it's done. Sure some people would still want to own a car, or drive one themselves, but eventually I can imagine self-driving shared cars will become cheaper and are still a reliable way of transportation. For many people, owning a car will no longer be desirable since shared self-driving cars suit their needs.
- gambiting 8y ago>>Why own a car when you can have a self-driving car pick you up from anywhere, bring you anywhere, and drive away to the next customer when it's done. That's called a taxi and I don't see them replacing personal cars en-masse[0]. Even once autonomous cars are ubiquitous I'd still like to own one, not share it with other people. [0] Taking an uber to work and back every day would already be cheaper for me than what I'm paying for my car + petrol + insurance + servicing, and yet I prefer to have a vehicle and drive it myself.
- erfgh 8y agoSo how did you update your view after reading the article?
- ulldoitforever 8y agoCars that carry less than 4 passengers aren't viable as a replacement to existing public transport in terms of capacity or price.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoBecause where I live it takes at least an hour for a taxi to decide to come get me (and that's being generous: last time it was about 4 hours). Uber simply says "no cars available" and Lyft frustratingly shows cars 10 miles away that simply disappear. Just because the car has no driver doesn't mean that the economics change enough to service a low population density area. The reality is that there are huge swaths of the US where you need personal transportation.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoI don't understand why all these car companies are trying to create it themselves ( doubted it since it was starting to be a hype) Self driving cars is currently a not solved solution ( too complex). Instead of putting in billions of dollars to be the best. Put in billion of dollars to work with the best when a decent solution comes out ( eg. currently that's Waymo) and delegate responsability. Currently, i wouldn't partner up with any of them.
- icebraining 8y agoThey don't want to be in the hands of whoever gets that solution, who will surely gouge them for all they've got. Investing in alternative solutions is an hedge.
- megablast 8y agoBecause it will be huge, like the iPhone. No one wants to be left out.
- kurtisc 8y agoI agree. Machine learning is not a core-competency of a typical car company and, when self-driving is ready, customers will soon stop differentiating on the safety levels just like with airbags, ABS, or tyre treads. Either it will be 'safe enough' (and safer than a human) or it won't be for sale. It will be a commodity. Right now we have dozens of companies spending massive amounts of money on approaching the same problem in the same way.
- bluGill 8y agoThere is a real danger that someone else comes up with a solution that is enough better than humans that governments outright ban anything else. This risk has a huge downside. Car companies need to hedge this risk. There is evidence that self driving cars can work (they already do in some areas), so the amount of effort worth putting in his pretty high.
- toasterlovin 8y agoCar companies are extremely capable lobbyists. They'll probably be fine.
- jimjimjim 8y agoOverestimated? How come anybody that has any history with computers knows how difficult it is going to be but such a vast amount of people, including people with money are so bullish about them. After doing some projects in kuala lumpour and singapore I knew that self driving cars were going to be incredibly difficult. one minute, driving along with no problems, next minute a huge amount of rain got dumped out of the sky, next minute the rain had stopped but some roads were impassable, some merely flooded but still open, others were undrivable on the sides but ok if you drove down the center. How do you code for that?
- icebraining 8y agoThe market for self-driving cars that run everywhere except in places with monsoons is still quite big.
- jimjimjim 8y agoYeah true. Though probably each location will have it's own problems. Fallen branches, missing man hole covers, gangs of window washers.
- bitxbit 8y agoWe know how an autonomous car will drive in a system made up of mostly human drivers. But what we do not know is what that system will look like when autonomous cars take over. That’s a huge leap and I don’t think we have yet to even address that question.
- lm28469 8y agoMost countries don't even fix pot holes in their capitals, I don't see them rebuilding their entire road infrastructure for autonomous cars.
- tspike 8y agoThe idea of self-driving cars being practical somewhere like Bangalore is laughable.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoTraffic saturated cities like Bangalore and Beijing have the strongest reasons to make self driving vehicles work, however. It is laughable that Americans would be the ones to do this, given their relatively traffic light cities (even LA is nothing compared to BJ) and high rates of personal car ownership.
- omosubi 8y agoDon't the traffic saturated cities have a better incentive to make public transportation as good as possible? Less people on the roads seems like it would benefit everyone in that case, whereas most american cities are too sparse to support that kind of infrastructure
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThey do that as well. The problem persists inspite of Beijing’s huge and growing subway system. Take myself as an example, I decided taking a taxi to work was worth it over a subway ride because of the crowded conditions...even though it lived and worked near stations on the same line. American cities has plenty of space to build new roads, that isn’t possible in many Chinese cities. Anyways, roads and private transportation will always be there, why not optimize it along with a decent public transit system to boot?
- dsego 8y agoIf you think that self-driving cars are going to take over anytime soon, I have some bitcoin to sell you.
- erfgh 8y agoIs there a way to short the self-driving cars business? I have found the whole idea of self-driving cars ludicrous since the beginning and it boggles my mind why people with experience in computers do not feel the same.
- fallingfrog 8y agoWhen you add up the amount of money that Americans spend on car payments, auto insurance, and gasoline every year, if that same amount of money were spent on public transit you’d have a really nice system which would also be self-driving from the rider’s point of view.
- ilaksh 8y agoWell it's been a day or two since I've had a comment buried so I might as well not mince words. It's an incredibly difficult problem and Ford is way behind. So it makes sense for him to try to reduce expectations. On the other hand, there are a lot of other companies than Ford doing self driving cars, and some are very advanced. It is really amazing to me that people are still in denial about the existence of self driving cars. They have existed and worked with various limitations for decades. The latest from Tesla and Waymo are still limited in some ways but also extremely capable. Teslas can now do all of the driving from one freeway to another up until you enter a normal street. Waymo is way beyond that. From what the riders are saying at r/selfdrivingcars, the only time the employees actually need to take over are occasions where there are very risky maneuvers in heavy traffic. Now, I believe they could relax the safety parameters and the cars would execute the same as the Waymo employees in those situations. It's just that there is no margin for error sometimes with traffic and if there is an accident at this stage they want to be able to blame the employee. So what's holding Waymo back from removing the employees from the car is mainly just an abundance of caution.
- tyingq 8y agoHas Waymo expanded the list of routes significantly? Last I read about it, the number of disengagements was very low, but the cars were traveling a pretty low of number of fixed routes in areas with good weather and visibility.
- ilaksh 8y agoThey are not fixed routes at all as far as I know. It takes people where they ask to go on the app according to what I've heard. It is a geofenced area. Phoenix pretty much always has good weather and visibility that's why they are starting there.
- linuxftw 8y ago> From what the riders are saying at r/selfdrivingcars, Seems like such a community would be heavily biased towards self driving cars. I wouldn't take much from a place like that, even discounting the shill factor. Self driving isn't going to be a thing any time soon. Luckily for Ford, their CEO is seeing past the hype. And, if such a large company see this, what's a company like Lyft going to do?
- sorenjan 8y agoI don't see the point of every car manufacturer making their own self driving cars. They don't make their own air bags, ABS, transmissions, etc. Leave that to suppliers like Bosch instead.
- deytempo 8y agoIt would be a lot simpler if they just skipped to self flying cars
- w_t_payne 8y agoYeah. Machine vision is hard. Really hard.
- toasterlovin 8y agoIt's that, but it's also that "driving" is a problem with a really large surface area. There are so many edge cases that it's insane. And every single major metro area basically has subtly different rules and baseline assumptions about how people will drive.
- tannerc 8y agoMost major players in the space are not relying solely on machine vision, but rather a combination of lidar, radar, mapping, etc. Vision is just one small piece of the puzzle, and while it's extremely difficult—particularly when considering the complexities of navigating a busy city street—the other parts are just as challenging. This is where claims like that of Ford's CEO really stem from. Looking at the problem and some of the existing approaches to solving it, it's become apparent the way forward is not at all clear. Realistically companies are making progress, but as an industry we may not have a straight path toward a feasible solution for some time.
- mathattack 8y agoDidn’t they fire the last CEO for being too slow to adopt new technologies?
- drderidder 8y agoDriving is fun. Being a passenger is not so much fun. Technical issues aside, for this simple reason I don't see self-driving cars becoming popular.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoDriving is not fun. Being a passenger is much more fun. For this simple reason, I see self-driving cars becoming popular. There are different opinions out there. I for one would rather learn and relax than drive.
- Frondo 8y agoOf course the car companies are all in on an improvement to their devices that would sell more of them; what I really want, though, is far more buses on the road (big ones on the arterials, van-sized ones on the side streets) and a much larger and more intricate trolley system. I don't want to see a world that enhances and entrenches private vehicle movement; that's not necessary. The goal is to get from place to place. I want to step outside, walk a block, wait 3 minutes, and get on a bus or a marshrutka and be on my way without ever thinking about gas, traffic, insurance, or any of that. All this "when self-driving cars..." is missing the point: we can move people conveniently and easily and more earth-friendly with what we've got, we just don't use it well because car companies want to sell everyone a private vehicle.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoI don't disagree with you, but... Follow the money. If there was sufficient profit in what you describe, it would be happening. Since it's clearly not then it has to be done by Government. That means actual people lobbying their local and state government for change. And on top of that, it has to be marketed properly. Where I live there's essentially no taxi/Uber/Lyft service (see my comment above about waiting 4 hours for a taxi), but the County has an on-demand bus service that you can call and they'll pick you up at your home. However, since I've never had to take it, the few times I needed a taxi (e.g., to go pick up my car from the shop), I never even remembered that it exists!
- nrs007 8y agoCompanies that do not figure out a long-term partnership model will definitely not find this sustainable. Spending billions of $$ without a clear revenue mechanism in short-term is definitely not sustainable, even though AV will be trillion $$ industry long term. And if you doubt my last statement about AV becoming a Trillion $$ opportunity, read this book on AVs by Spencer Burns (legit automobile guy) and you will see his reasoning.
- meroes 8y agoAs a total layperson, I think the focus should be on long term car-to-car networking. Skip this visual feedback rut we are in and make every new car broadcast its position, velocity, acceleration, heading, etc. Problem is how to get manufacturers on board en masse.
- blattimwind 8y ago> As a total layperson, I think the focus should be on long term car-to-car networking. Skip this visual feedback rut we are in and make every new car broadcast its position, velocity, acceleration, heading, etc. knock knock -- Who is it? -- Leafs on the road -- What is it now?! -- Raining :>
- asah 8y agoI'm also concerned about security.
- xGrill 8y agoThat doesn't help when there is a pedestrian crossing the street.
- 0xffff2 8y ago>Problem is how to get manufacturers on board en masse. I think security is a much, much larger problem. Designing a safe, secure and reliable system for vehicles to communicate information with each other on an ad-hoc basis and designing a system to make use of that information in a way that doesn't allow bad actors to cause mayhem may be an equally hard problem to solve as the generalized computer vision that we need to make the current self-driving thrust work.
- Mikeb85 8y agoFor self driving cars to actually work, you really need the road infrastructure to support them, and for a majority of cars to be self-driving so they can coordinate with other vehicles. A car run entirely by sensors without receiving outside information will always be doomed to fail.
- gwbas1c 8y agoI'll believe in self-driving cars once the robots start sorting my trash and recyclables for me... And once my Tesla stops driving like it's drunk!
- linuxhansl 8y agoI've been saying this for a while. Truly autonomous cars are decades away. My line has always been that I hope that by the time I can't, or am not allowed, to drive any more, autonomous cars will be ready... But that I am not even sure about that. Many of my friends have ridiculed me. They think their elementary-school-kids will not need to learn how to drive. Perhaps I'll have the last laugh. (But actually I hope I'm wrong about this.)
- alexashka 8y agoUber is ready. It's autonomous for you as a passenger, and you get a free chat buddy if you feel like it. Autonomous cars are interesting for the trucking industry - for everyday driving, reducing traffic via remote work and smarter city planning is what'll make people happy imho. I don't mind a 10 minute drive. It's the 100 minute drive in bumper to bumper traffic that makes people dream of self-driving cars. The real answer is not being in that position to begin with.
- pmart123 8y agoExactly. Hopefully, it can help reduce the cost of goods and highway road safety. There’s going to be a lot of edge cases in Manhattan traffic.
- ghaff 8y agoI actually think even autonomous cars that can safely handle "highway" (for some definition of highway) driving in "good" weather (for some definition of good) is a huge win in and of itself. Both for safety and freeing up human time. What it doesn't do is satisfy the fantasy of those who live in dense cities that they'll never need to own a car or even learn to drive. But hitting the point where a car can reliably drive itself around a chaotic urban landscape in all sorts of weather conditions by itself is almost certainly a much harder problem.
- dv_dt 8y agoUh given that Uber was the most recent autonomous car to kill someone, let me be a little skeptical that Uber is ready. And, I suspect that give a 100 minute drive route now, if self-driving cars lower the bar of being in traffic, that the same commutes will actually get longer with even more traffic.
- bilater 8y agoJust the dip in the gartner hype cycle...
- gvkv 8y agoI think a more fundamental problem here is that self-driving cars are as much an infrastructure problem as they are a technological one. As an analogy, consider hybrid vs electric vehicles. In places like North America with large, open spaces, electric vehicles really only serve a specific type of urban driver. The culture, infrastructure and geography dictate 600km distances which really aren't practical at the moment with current battery tech. Whereas hybrid vehicles can (or could) quite easily reach that range with options to recharge once you get to your destination or have a longer stopover and still use existing infrastructure. The focus on purely electric is a lost opportunity for anyone who needs power or long distance. Similarly, cars could be designed to be self-driving in the easy cases; highways, certain urban thoroughfares, particular times of day and the like where existing vehicle and pedestrian flow patterns eliminate the edge cases. coordinating systems along the aforementioned types of roads could be installed as was done for cellular service and GPS and other protocols could be developed to ensure safety and reliability as well as fallback in case of emergencies. Instead, we've decided on all-or-nothing bets which don't move things forward--or at all--and my worry now is that we'll lose an opportunity to pick the low-hanging fruit and solve the harder problems incrementally over time.
- ljm 8y agoCould you do it without all or nothing? Mixing self-driving cars with humans means the intelligence has to understand irrational behaviour and has to respond appropriately (speed up rather than slow down, ignore the potential threat, account for traffic behind you), which is sometimes counter-intuitive. And it comes in many ways. Will a self-driving car know that you don’t pump the brakes when sliding on snow? What about hydroplaning? If that didn’t exist we wouldn’t have car fatalities or accidents.
- gvkv 8y agoI don't think any of those examples are edge cases. The first set are normal traffic conditions that in the context of self-driving cars are easy to solve, especially in narrowed conditions such as on a highway. Moreover, mid-range cars already have collision warning and automatic braking systems. As to your example of traction issues, pretty much every modern car that I'm aware of has had computer assisted traction control systems for a while now. The edge cases that are difficult essentially boil down to entity recognition; unexpected and moving obstacles, road sign changes, traffic light outages or alternate signal pathways and the like. Some of those definitely would require government level coordination which is about a lot more than technology.
- himanshuxd 8y agoI really really like driving cars and I don't think self-driving cars is the future it could be a small part of the future though.
- qwertywertyu 8y agoIt has been obvious to intelligent observers since the self-driving car hype started that this hype is hugely overblown. My own opinion is that fully self-driving cars capable of competing with human drivers will remain a dream for at least two more decades. What really interests me is why and how the hype became so powerful, even among people who one would think would know better. How much of the hype is explained by stupidity and how much of the hype was created as a deliberate scam? I also wonder if maybe the military is more involved that people might think. After all, even if self-driving cars are decades away, the autonomous technology created as a product of self-driving car research can be already used, now, for military appications. A tank doesn't have to avoid killing people the way that a car on public roads does.
- Animats 8y agoFord's problem may be Argo. Ford spent $1 billion for Argo, and paid for a big building with the Argo name on top. But Argo didn't get their California license to test autonomous vehicles until early this year.[1] Self-driving has had too many "fake it til you make it" startups. Cruise started that way, and suckered GM into buying them for $1 billion. Uber bought Otto, and we now know how fake that technology was. Tesla hyped their basic lane-keeper and car detector into an "autopilot" then repeatedly plowed into clearly visible obstacles and killed people. (Despite all the blithering about edge cases, they haven't been big problems in practice. The serious Uber and Tesla accidents were not edge cases. They were blatantly obvious obstacles: a semitrailer, a fire truck, a fixed barrier, and an isolated pedestrian on an open road.) Waymo, meanwhile, keeps plugging away, driving around, getting their level of disconnects down each year, improving their sensors, and doing large scale tests. Once in a while they get rear-ended. If they don't get killed by Google/Alphabet's attention deficit disorder problem, as happened to Google's robotics efforts, they're going to get this into production. It's not easy, and it's not impossible. It's just hard, like television or xerography. Those took decades from first demo until they worked well. This doesn't fit well with the startup make-money-fast model. It does fit with the big-company R&D lab model. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/29/argo-ai-acquires-permit-to-test-autonomous-vehicles-in-california/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/29/argo-ai-acquires-permit-to...
- lixtra 8y ago> They were blatantly obvious obstacles Each accident you cite happened under supervision of a human driver. Without knowledge about accidents prevented by supervisors it’s difficult to tell how much worse ai is than the average human.
- slouch 8y agoThe supervisor of the Uber that killed the pedestrian was watching Hulu on her phone at the time of the crash. edit: source: https://www.businessinsider.com/uber-driver-rafaela-vasquez-watching-hulu-before-fatal-collision-2018-6 https://www.businessinsider.com/uber-driver-rafaela-vasquez-...
- rjplatte 8y agoHighway driving is the first step. Limited challenges, different problem space. Once that's completely nailed down, we'll start to see workable urban solutions. The reality is that human drivers will be better at interacting with other human drivers in close quarters for the time being.
- jodrellblank 8y agoIn one browser tab, everyone's clamouring for autonomous self-driving cars. In another browser tab, a gamer is streaming himself driving in Euro Truck Simulator 2 for over four hours. If only we had a way to connect people who would willingly do a job, with companies which would pay to have a job done, minus the cutthroat capitalist exploiters/employers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- MR4D 8y agoI think Ford is correct here. Getting the problem 99% right means a lot of people get killed and injured. By tackling small chunks such as geofencing, and things like autonomous busses on planned routes, the industry will move the ball forward in slow, steady steps. But to me, the idea that a real self-driving car would be around the corner (i.e. 2020 or 2021) is just laughable. People underestimate the difficulty of that last 1%. My best guess is that the last 1% is greater than the first 99%. Or, as Yogi Berra might say - the first 99% is the easy part; the second 99% is the hard part.
- md8 8y agoHaving been working in "AI" field and delivered couple of projects. I think, Automation/AI always needs humans. What we see from all these hyped tech, is just the MVP version. You discover the problems when it's in production.
- return0 8y agoI think we all underestimate it. Driving a car in a road without assistance is solving the robot navigation problem forever. Its the answer to life, the universe and everything. There is still great progress and it will probably work in some limited sense.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI'm totally getting one of those: https://www.amazon.com/Karl-Marx-Told-You-T-Shirt/dp/B075CTQ3ML https://www.amazon.com/Karl-Marx-Told-You-T-Shirt/dp/B075CTQ...