9 ms·
Kroger acknowledges that its bet on robotics went too far
- AndrewKemendo 1y agoNotable that the reasons for failure to meet benchmarks was that the locations were too far away, and that they are moving to the “Micro-Fulfillment Center” approach that Amazon is doing at Whole Foods. This is exactly what everyone predicted when Amazon bought WF - turn it into a grocery FC. That makes sense to me. Feels like we’re going to have warehouse scale vending machines in cities, and delivery bots taking them from the warehouse-vending-machine to the customer.
- recursive 1y agoI like being able to see the thing I'm going to get and holding it in my hand.
- aerostable_slug 1y agoI like not going to the store more. Because tips are important to the income of delivery shoppers, I find that I generally get good produce selections. It might be difficult to transition that particular incentive to robots, but the point is that delivery items don't have to suck. The only thing I really still pick out by hand every time are beef briskets. Pork shoulders tend to be uniform enough that randomly picking a cryovac works out, but there's a good bit of variation in brisket that makes a difference with the final product, at least when the brisket is prepared with a smoker. YMMV
- recursive 1y agoDelivery shoppers wouldn't be able to pick out the good stuff if it's delivered by drone or whatever.
- aerostable_slug 1y agoThey could if there are human pickers. In any event, delivery doesn't always mean the worst of the produce aisle, and while I noted that the incentive of tips might not transfer to robots, keeping repeat customers might be enough incentive for a way to be found to not make robots and grocery synonymous with only frozen food. That might mean human pickers; better automation on the food selection system; pre-inspected, washed and packaged fruits & veggies; etc.
- mlrtime 1y ago>Because tips are important to the income of delivery shoppers, I find that I generally get good produce selections Wait, you tip to get a good selection of produce to be delivered to you? This is very bizarre to me.
- aerostable_slug 1y agoYep. Instacart. I work from home and sometimes I don't want to go to the store (or it would be difficult because I'm on Zoom/Teams a lot), but I need vegetables, meat, milk, etc. for cooking. With Instacart & Costco memberships and also ordering from the local discount grocers, I can get food delivered for less than it costs to actually go to the mainstream grocery stores like Von's, and I don't get bruised eggplants or cilantro that's already going bad. The drivers/shoppers are generally quite good at picking out items that can lead to higher tips (that or they're just in it for the love of good produce, but either way you can often tell they're not randomly loading the bags).
- simmonmt 1y agoI'm not normally a fan of tips, but this seems like a reasonable use of one to me. The picker isn't paid on the shininess of the apple they bring you -- they're paid to pick as quickly as they can from what's on offer. The potential for a tip incentivises them to go beyond that requirement -- to pick the nicest/freshest rather than the most convenient.
- AlotOfReading 1y agoThe grocery industry relentlessly optimizes for implicit choices over expressed preferences. Nobody is asking for misters, colored lighting, skeumorphic veggie bins, and wide open sightlines in the produce aisle. Stores do it because customers buy more when they do. The same thing will happen to in-store shopping if consumer preferences swing ever swing that way instead.
- acessoproibido 1y agoI'll believe it when i see it
- cgriswald 1y agoThis isn’t what Amazon has done at least here on the Peninsula. My WF orders come from Brisbane just like my overnight shipping and Amazon Fresh orders do. Before that they were coming from San Jose, possibly from a WF there but there are closer WF stores in both directions and none in Brisbane.
- mosura 1y agoSounds like they just put them in the wrong places. > Fenyo added that Kroger’s decision to locate the Ocado centers outside of cities turned out to be a key flaw. > “Ultimately those were hard places to make this model work,” said Fenyo. “You didn’t have enough people ordering, and you had a fair amount of distance to drive to get the orders to them. And so ultimately, these large centers were just not processing enough orders to pay for all that technology investment you had to make.”
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jlarocco 1y agoBut I think in the cities Kroger grocery stores serve as the fulfilment centers, so they don't need robotic ones. There's probably still room for automation, but it might have to be different than warehouse automation.
- michaelt 1y agoIt depends on your business model. If a basket of groceries brought online costs $15 more than the in-store prices, then you can pick in-store profitably, very easy. That's the instacart model. But if a basket of groceries brought online costs about the same as buying in-store? With the retailer bearing the costs of picking, packing and delivery instead of the customer? Well then you need something more efficient than a store.
- cudgy 1y agoEven $15 more isn’t enough on account of delivery time, transpo costs, driver time, picking items, and bagging. Current model is for drivers to subsidize by being tricked into taking unprofitable orders.
- mothballed 1y agoFrom what I've seen, for grocery the model is they'll give you the least desirable or near expired stock that the walk-in customers won't grab. So they're basically saving spoilage. This happens so reliably I'm absolutely convinced this is how they 'pay' for it without raising prices. I've also noticed this with hardware stores like Lowes. If I place a pickup order they more often than not will pawn off on me their broken, returned, or even used and damaged stock. Items like building wrap will have soil and rips on it, concrete mix will be spoiled from moisture, lumber will be all the most warped pieces (if you don't order a whole pallet, expect every last piece of fractional pallet will be knotted to hell, split, twisted, and badly warped), plumbing valves will be open package and leaky, etc etc. It's like clockwork, even if the stock sitting on the shelf doesn't have these problems. Due to this there are some stores I will never do a pickup/delivery order from.
- liquidise 1y agoGood news for blue collar workers, tough for investors. The bean-counting dream of LLM's and Robotics remains, but until ChatGPT is placing your order at Mcdonalds drive-thrus and Amazon is laying off warehouse associates en masse, i'd say that last 5% is still taking 95% of the time.
- markbao 1y agoMcDonald’s is an interesting example because they’re increasingly replacing cashiers with kiosks. Robotics/LLMs seem to have diminishing returns compared to that in the order taking realm.
- glitchc 1y agoSure, but not the kitchen staff, which is where the robotics dream is supposed to take you.
- markbao 1y agoTrue, that’s a good example of the commenter’s “last 5% is the 95%”
- al_borland 1y agoI watched a show over 20 years ago that showed a fully automated robotic kitchen at McDonalds. I can only assumed they have continued to evolved it and perfect it as the technology has improved. I think it’s simply a question of when it hits the tipping point on cost. There may also be an issue with logistics when it comes to making sure the machines keep running if there is a problem. They can barely keep the ice cream machines running.
- SoftTalker 1y agoI imagine kitchen robots are harder than they might sound. Kitchens are rough environments for machines. They are hot, greasy, and steamy. And everything that comes in contact with food needs to be able to be taken apart, washed, and sanitized at least daily.
- bombcar 1y agoI remember a glowing video about this thing (by Tom Scott maybe?) and being confused how it could ever compete with humans being paid slave wages. Guess I was right.
- petesergeant 1y agoYou were not, this works just fine in the UK
- slashyellow 1y agoI mean, it's a fiercely competitive market and they've managed to stake out a position, which is great and all, but to be blunt they have a market share of ~2.1%, and they've consistently unprofitable. And they've been at this for like 20 years. Honestly the main problem seems to be most people just don't like buying certain items online, and that doesn't seem to be changing quickly. If Covid didn't break people out of that, I can't think of anything that will. And FWIW, I think for an online only supermarket you'd expect their website to be pretty amazing, but their competitors are just as good.
- gurumeditations 1y agoHaving FCs an hour away from your customers, packing groceries into a tiny truck with one or two employees per truck, the trucks alone would never pay for themselves let alone the FCs. This was obvious from the get go and it’s why Walmart has been the only one successfully doing grocery pickup and delivery for 6 years. Every store is an FC and they’re all within 20 minutes of their customers.
- sethhochberg 1y agoThere are examples of the warehouse-based model working, but they clearly require both density _and_ mindshare. Its not clear Kroger had either based on the other comments in here. FreshDirect in NYC has been operating since the early 2000s with a fleet of tiny trucks with a couple of employees in them and a giant FC with essentially zero retail footprint. (As an aside, they also have some of the best meat and produce you can get in the city without going to a farmers market. So many retail grocery stores here lack loading docks, the food handling getting from the truck to the sidewalk to the basement of the store to the shelves is really, really rough especially during the summer months. Skipping that and going warehouse-to-home has advantages)
- Havoc 1y agoTIL Ocado is supposed to be an automation/robotics co. I associate it more with delivery vans that seem to be in no particular hurry (unlike uber eats / DPD / UPS etc)
- nextworddev 1y agoit's just a wheeled bot that's driven by a joystick by some offshore person /s
- rcxdude 1y agoThey see themselves as a tech company, but fundamentally they've only really cracked their own grocery business, I think.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11mo ago> Ocado has delivery vans that seem to be in no particular hurry (unlike uber eats etc) True. the difference is that Uber eats takes an order and immediately aims to deliver it as soon as possible. Ocado takes a grocery order, stores it and aims to deliver it e.g. "next Wednesday, between 6pm and 7pm", and you can modify the order until midnight on Tuesday. Given that UK Urban traffic levels are unpredictable, the vans will occasionally be in position before the start time. There also is some time where the guy is in the back of the van finding the current order. But you're right, as the public interacts with them, Ocado's role is "Deliver groceries in a van" not "automation/robotics". The latter is an implementation detail to us. Also, several people's groceries in 1 van is more fuel efficient and less traffic congestion than all of those people each driving to a big store and back. So it's a win.
- da02 1y agoHere in the Houston areas, supermarkets like Kroger/Walmart/HEB/etc always have single floor buildings. Why can't they build multi-floor buildings for storage upstairs and retail walk-in sales on the ground floor? On the above ground floors, they can create an automated or semi-automated system for employees to gather up items for online/delivery orders.
- tacker2000 1y agoI would guess that having everything on one floor optimizes the unloading, restocking and logistics. Also construction is cheaper.
- poguemahoney 1y agoGood construction is not cheap and takes many quarters. Land outside the urban area is far too cheap and probably subsidized (directly or with free oversized infrastructure) because local government always wants jobs, even small numbers of shitty jobs.
- AngryData 1y agoProbably because you then need pillars throughout the entire building to support the second floor which you are loading down with a ton of weight. The average forklift weighs 3x or more the weight of the average car, and then adding racking and stock on top of that. Yeah if you completely redesign your storage system to not require forklifts you save weight there, but you end up adding the weight back with all the heavy duty track systems and extra heavy duty racks that are required to eliminate the forklifts. Plus there is liability of having that weight up top, a rack failure on a second floor could take down half the building. It is possible, but you end up spending 10x as much on the building.
- alphabettsy 1y agoThen put the warehouse on the first floor and put the store on top. Lots of big cities have grocery stores with parking garages under them, doesn’t seem much different.
- omgJustTest 1y ago3 CFCs (robotics centers) closed, 5 continuing operating [1]. Initial commitment was 20 & Kroger is paying 350m$ to compensate the partner. I don't know what success looks like but it's probably fair to say they were over-extended by roughly 30-40%. https://chainstoreage.com/kroger-pay-350-million-automation-partner-it-scales-back-robotic-warehouses?#:~:text=The%20retailer%20previously%20closed%20three,a%20wider%20range%20of%20applications.%22 https://chainstoreage.com/kroger-pay-350-million-automation-...
- websiteapi 1y agothis kind of stuff is still probably a few orders of magnitude too expensive per unit cost. I'm also skeptical it'll ever work in America due to the general lack of density.
- trebligdivad 1y agoI sometime use Ocado in the UK, and it's 'OK' but it's certainly not at the cheap end of the market. I more often use a traditional supermarkets home delivery service where it's manually picked; those supermarkets have the advantage of having very little infrastructure overhead in the picking - they mostly use their existing stores and pick at quiet times/over night. Ocado has to run entire warehouses just for this task. Ocado can only work with packed goods - not weighed vegetables for example - which the hand pickers in store can do, albeit whether they do it well is down to luck and the mood of the picker.
- calcifer 1y ago> Ocado can only work with packed goods - not weighed vegetables for example Not quite. Packed yes, but for many vegetables they have both item count and weight-based packages, e.g. "4 potatoes" vs "1kg potatoes". I think that strikes the right balance.
- trebligdivad 1y agoInteresting, however in my case we have someone who eats a banana each day with breakfast. There's no way to buy 7 bananas in your weekly shop!
- markus_zhang 1y agoI had a wonderful retro futuristic dream about an automated Costco warehouse a few weeks ago. It was one of the less weird dreams so I still remember it clearly. Basically, each section is like a closed areas with some windows. Customers order at the computers by the windows and flash their membership cards. Robots glide left and right to move 10 samples to the customer, in an arm with rotating clips. Customers can press a button to rotate the samples, observe them, and place an order by pressing a button. Samples not chosen are temporarily stocked at the window as a “stack”. In each closed section, there are humans who monitors and maintains the robots, and occasionally fetch samples when robots stop working (hopefully it too often, you know those 9s). At the exit, a human worker assembles the packages and hand them to the customers with a smile. Customers have a last chance to return unwanted items. Why was it a retro futuristic dream? Because the customers have the option to go into a bakery to enjoy a cup of coffee/tea, some cake and socialize with fellow customers. All of them looked like the men and women from advertisement from Fallout 4. I’d like to shop or even help build one of these.
- CPLX 1y agoYou’ve just described B&H in New York City.
- aerostable_slug 1y agoNow I'm picturing Hasidic robots.
- defrost 1y agoBeing pushed about on trolleys and puppeteered by gentiles every Shabbat?
- whynotmaybe 1y agoSomething like this? https://www.untappedcities.com/automats-cafeterias-nyc/ https://www.untappedcities.com/automats-cafeterias-nyc/
- Frye 1y agoAlso worth mentioning Kroger just lost a multi million dollar lawsuit in Florida after one of their delivery trucks hit a cyclist. I wonder if this has anything to do with it as well.
- rolandog 1y ago"Something, something, ... omelettes ... few eggs" -- mouthpiece from corporation that lobbies to cut regulations
- Dylan16807 1y agoI can't find the story, but if it's a human-driven truck there's nothing special about a vehicle hitting someone. Everyone that drives a vehicle is accepting that risk. It's not heartless to have vehicles. And I don't even know what particular regulations you're trying to imply.
- Frye 1y agoImplying that Kroger announced that it would shut down its Florida operations shortly after losing the lawsuit with the cyclist. Nothing more. Here is the story https://www.facebook.com/100064532630592/posts/pfbid0DYoPXety4CkqB2qytAuycE1pKFg9SoYhcGzQEXcnTYTPxuM78mAeNgeHMB3KKNNSl/ https://www.facebook.com/100064532630592/posts/pfbid0DYoPXet...
- Dylan16807 1y agoI wasn't saying you implied anything. I was saying rolandog seemed to go beyond general cynicism about corporations to an unreasonable complaint. Looking at the details, I could say Kroger shouldn't have hired her but I'd rather say that if she was dangerous enough to not hire as a driver then her license shouldn't have been reinstated in the first place. (Though that's if "couldn’t recall if her driver’s license was suspended just months before he hired her" means it actually was suspended, and Bike Law isn't doing some trickery with wording.) Either way good they paid out. For the shutdown, I do think it's a coincidence. They're shutting down facilities in multiple states and that lawsuit isn't even a tenth of a percent of the relevant costs.
- danpalmer 1y agoThis is a failure of business model and logistics, not a failure of the robotics. > Fenyo added that Kroger’s decision to locate the Ocado centers outside of cities turned out to be a key flaw. They over-spent on automating low-volume FCs. You could draw comparisons to Amdahl's law, they optimised the bit that wasn't the issue, the real issue was delivery distances and times. Ocado has had good success with the robotics approach in the UK, because the UK is very high density compared to a lot of the US. Plus Ocado put a lot of work into creating good delivery routes, whereas it sounds like that wasn't a component of the automation stack that Kroger bought.
- martinald 1y agoI think we are mixing up two things here. Robotics for picking and the general feasibility of grocery delivery in the US. Ocado is good because their stock levels are far more accurate than the other supermarkets for online ordering, so you don't get as many substituted/missing items. This is sort of a side effect of having dedicated picking facilities Vs "real" supermarkets. I would not be surprised if they "lose" less stock as well compared to in supermarket fulfillment. Then you have "is online grocery good in the US"? There's a lot of areas of the US that have reasonable density for this kind of service imo, and the road infrastructure is generally far superior to the UK which negates any loss of density (as you care about time between deliveries, not distance per se). I imagine the much better parking options in most suburbs in the US also helps efficiency (it's an absolute nightmare for a lot of the online delivery cos when there isn't off street parking in the UK and they have to park pretty far from the drop). It sounds to me that Kroger just messed up the execution of this in terms of "marketing" more than anything.
- themafia 1y ago> failure of business model and logistics Just the model. They optimized for tax outcomes. They obviously wanted in on the "Amazon race to the bottom" game. https://www.leesburg-news.com/2025/11/30/kroger-took-incentives-and-tax-breaks-and-its-exit-leaves-taxpayers-with-a-huge-burden/ https://www.leesburg-news.com/2025/11/30/kroger-took-incenti... > the real issue was delivery distances and times. Which they could care less about. Where else are you going to go?
- 1y ago
- brookst 1y agoWeird headline, totally unsupported by the article. According to the article, there were several strategic blunders, including trying the model outside of cities where lack of density cut against it. Plus the apparent dismissal any value their 2700 retail locations could provide. As far as I can tell, Kroger didn’t acknowledge anything except a change in strategy.
- irjustin 1y agoDoesn't that support the article? their bet was massive robotics in centralized warehouses, but that turns out not to be profitable. Unsure how the headlines doesn't align. Maybe it's different than what I'm seeing: > Kroger acknowledges that its bet on robotics went too far
- brookst 11mo agoPoint me to where in the article Kroger, as a corporate statement, “acknowledged” that it “went too far”? I just re-read and it’s not there. A proper headline would be something like “facing disappointing results, Kroger shifts robotics strategy”. It’s a subtle but important difference. Main thing being that good writing does not put words in its subjects’ mouths. Unless Kroger actually acknowledged it, you don’t say they did.
- adxl 1y agoWhenn I lived in Atlanta the Krogers each had a nickname. There was disco Kroger because of its disco ball. There was murder Kroger that purportedly had been the site of a murder. This I guess is Robo Kroger.
- softwaredoug 1y agoIn Charlottesville all the Krogers are quite different. A weird, dark, maze-like warehouse-feeling Kroger that just closed. We have a really nice Kroger a bit outside town. I always think of it as the Gucci Kroger. A college-kid, cheaper Kroger close to the center of town. The cheaper version of the Harris Teeter nearby. There's as much variation in individual Krogers as between other grocery chains!
- bediger4000 1y agoA common practice in Denver. Kroger's local brand is "King Soopers". There's Scary Soopers, Queen Soopers, and ironically El Safeway and Soviet Safeway.
- pinkmuffinere 1y agoI like to imagine that whenn is like iff -- ie, when would mean "when and only when", lol
- rsynnott 1y ago> There was disco Kroger because of its disco ball. ... As in the supermarket had a disco ball? Was it spinning?
- nacozarina 1y agoall it takes is one junior executive gets caught by one chinese robot saleswoman, and the next thing you know…
- analog31 1y agoIt looks like they got the robots together but forgot the groceries.
- fma 1y agoOr their online groceries didnt succeed because people can p4ice shop. I am of the belief Kroger does well because they obfuscate their prices and their tags which make it seems like they are sales truely are not. Unlike Publix if I see a discount I know it is a discount. Every other item in Kroger has a yellow tag and a red price to make you think you are getting a deal when in fact the red number is higher than regular price at normal stores.
- petesergeant 1y ago> Or their online groceries didnt succeed because people can p4ice shop. Ocado does just fine though, and are rarely the cheapest choice.
- itopaloglu83 1y agoIt’s a great convenience though, we’ve been using it over a year now and it solved most of the bulk purchases, we then visit the store for other detailed items and get done quickly.
- georgefrowny 1y agoOne of the reasons I kind of gave up on deliveries after COVID was the the experience of having a friendly but slightly rushed bloke clearly politely itching to get on to the next stop turn up at some random time in the evening (it's booked to a slot but the variance was large). Then he holds your door open and either helps you unload it watches you unload a bunch of randomly packed loose items from a large handful of his plastic crates, some with a single item in them, as fast as possible into laundry baskets in the hallway so you can transfer it to the right place at leisure. That was actually somehow really annoying to me. Tesco used to use plastic box liners which you doing just hoick out, but those were quickly stopped due to bring plastic. I'd rather they just handed over the crates or something and I could return them for a deposit the next time. Obviously I'd also rather all the supermarkets could share the same crates so I don't have to babysit piles of each brand separately. Maybe Ocado have a better system then Tesco here?
- joncrocks 1y ago
- imroot 1y agoI've always said that in the back of my mind, the most successful grocery store would be the 'walls' of the store -- bakery, deli, produce, meats, floral, cheeses, dairy and having a little selection of store brands in the middle where consumers can pick up (and vendors can pay a premium for endcap space, because they're the only non-branded products out there), with the rest of the SKU's behind the walls of the grocery store in a fulfillment only model. Kroger should have pulled a Wal-Mart and turned to their shrink-heavy stores in urban centers to online fulfillment only -- basically only their delivery drivers can retrieve items for an order, and everything's shopped by an associate (Look south of the MicroCenter in Dallas if you want to see what one looks like: it still has the Murphy USA in the parking lot and is basically an unbranded walmart building with 'driver' and 'associate' entrances -- and then deployed the robotics there: less retail space, more online/fulfillment capacity (have humans grab produce and custom sliced/packed items, robots pick the dry goods), and while you lose some cashier jobs, you'll probably have net improvement in terms of time waiting to be picked.
- zrobotics 1y agoSo what grocery stores used to be ~90 years ago, when the norm was you would give the clerk a list and they would grab your items from the back? The only stores I'm still aware of that are setup like this are auto parts stores, where 90% of the inventory is in the back.
- ZeWaka 1y agoOnly other places I can think of is weed dispensaries and pharmacies. You could also count shoe stores and high-end jewelry and watch stores in that the clerk has to go in the back to fetch the non-display model.
- gambiting 1y agoIn the UK you have a whole chain of stores called Argos where you have a catalogue of items, you pick the items you want and the clerk brings them to you. Also Screwfix and Toolstation are both hardware stores that operate the same way.
- karamanolev 1y agoI work in this exact space (online grocery retailer in Europe). We're profitable and one of the few companies to be so in the sector - many online divisions are losing money and being bankrolled by the parent company with physical stores. Alternatively, burning VC money. The thing that's wrong with Ocado's technology is that it's ridiculously expensive and tailored for huge FC's (fulfillment centers). The problem with that is that it needs to serve a large population base to be effective and that's hard - in dense metros, the driving times are much longer despite smaller distances. In sparse metros, the distances are just too long. In our experience, the optimal FC size is 5-10K orders/day, maybe up to 20K/day in certain cases, but the core technology should certainly scale down profitably to 3-5K. Ocado solves for scaling up, what needs to be solved is actually scaling down. There are a lot of logistical challenges outside the FC, especially last mile and you need to see the system as a whole, not just optimize one part to the detriment of all others.
- algo_trader 1y ago> FC size is 5-10K orders/day, maybe up to 20K/day in certain cases, but the core technology should certainly scale down profitably to 3-5K. deja-vu from the e-scooter business. even with a good product, its just not profitable/scalable enough
- karamanolev 11mo agoOurs is profitable enough. And it can scale but covering more area with FC's of a profitable size. Additionally, market penetration of online grocery shopping is growing rapidly and has no reasons (that we see) to stop growing (as a % of all grocery shopping).
- bob1029 1y agoThe grocery business has razor thin margins. There is no dry sponge remaining to absorb this kind of massive fixed cost. The business is highly variable. I think scaling up would be the only way out of this problem. Scaling down only makes it worse.
- 1y ago
- skeptrune 1y agoIt's interesting that the problem had more to do with poor decision-making related to warehouse location than robotics limitations. The title is a red herring.
- rimbo789 1y agoIsn’t that the same thing? Robots without good decision making and working business model are nothing
- iambateman 1y agoI’m regularly surprised by how important physically picking out groceries is for a large segment of the population. We have done grocery pickup for years but the pickup lanes are almost always empty while dozens of shoppers walk into the store. To me, shopping for groceries by hand is a waste of time but it clearly has some utility for a lot of people. I wonder if that inertia is making traditional grocery shopping stickier than it should be and disincentivizing optimization. I hope consumer tastes will change because there’s no reason for us to all walk into a giant warehouse every week.
- j_w 1y agoI like to browse what is there and make decisions on what I'll be eating based on what I see. Purchasing online feels more narrow and has me thinking more about things I've cooked before vs what I might want to try cooking/eating.
- marcosdumay 1y agoYes, it's not only pickup. Online retailers UIs are all extremely bad for browsing. One would imagine they would be better, because they can reorganize any way they want, without any limitation, personalize it to each customer, and have several different organizations at the same time available for people to pick what's best each time. But no, browsing universally sucks.
- tart-lemonade 11mo agoMy grocery store's website (Jewel-Osco) doesn't even work on Firefox; searching for anything just gives me a loading screen that never goes away, even on a brand new profile with all cookies accepted and no adblocker or other extensions. On Chrome it works, but it's comically slow, and the mobile app is somehow even worse. The really confusing part is the parent company's website (Albertsons) works just fine, though it is also slow.
- marcosdumay 11mo ago
- nunez 1y ago> Speaking during an earnings call, interim Kroger CEO Ron Sargent — who took over in March after McMullen’s sudden departure following an ethics probe — said the company would conduct a “full site-by-site analysis” of the Ocado network. Sounds like there were some politics involved in the original decision.
- VLM 1y agoAll delivery services so far, have been partial emulations of a concierge service including the high cost, but have made the user suffer thru the friction instead of the human concierge. I don't see a way around this using mere technology. Either the service quality will have to be low, or the cost will have to be prohibitively high, or the people providing the service will have to be very poor. We have solutions going back centuries that work. If you need more than an occasional concierge service you hire a chef as an employee. At some point it makes more sense to hire a part time chef than to pay enormous extra fees for giant shopping robots. Perhaps the economic decline from AI will make the idea of having house servants more acceptable to the very few people still having an income. Most strategies to replace high labor cost people with technology miss the point of long term permanent economic decline. We don't have a problem of too many financially successful people LOL if anything the problem is a severe lack of them. Its kind of like cars. You have to unperson poor people who know how to drive if you want success with computer driven cars. This is the same concept but for hiring a servant to cook. Also its very hard to scale royalty. If only the local equivalent of royalty can afford to pay to make the effort required to shop and cook and drive disappear, its going to be hard to dotcom scale that to billions of customers if there's only a couple multimillionaires who don't care about the price. Trying to automate food shopping is like trying to go back to full service gas stations. Nobody wants it so its an uphill battle to sell.
- throw7 1y agoAround me, the online grocery shopping and pickup is still pretty popular post-covid. There's always a worker or two going around the store picking up for the online orders, so there's room here for some type of site-local automation (not remote robotic fulfillment centers, i could of told you that would be way too costly comparatively). However, robotics that can navigate an existing retail grocery store is not here. yet.
- kaluga 1y ago[dead]
- wayeq 11mo ago> Kroger said on Tuesday that its decision to close the three robotic facilities, along with other adjustments to its e-commerce operations, would provide a $400 million boost as it looks to improve e-commerce profitability. Amazing that both opening and subsequently closing the facilities could provide a boost to profitability.
- bunabhucan 11mo ago>Sargent also said Kroger would refocus its e-commerce efforts on its fleet of more than 2,700 grocery supermarkets because it believed that its stores gave it a way to “reach new customer segments and expand rapid delivery capabilities without significant capital investments.” Someone didn't read the 26 year old Webvan case study at CEO-school. https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=26728 https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=26728
- DoctorOetker 11mo agoThose robots consume quite a bit of energy, I think racks hanging on linkages constraining their orientation (so they don't tilt) and constrain their translational motion to cycloids, so that a hanging rack can be let loose, swing across the lowest point and be caught at approximately the starting height but on the other side. From wikipedia, "The cycloid, with the cusps pointing upward, is the curve of fastest descent under uniform gravity (the brachistochrone curve). It is also the form of a curve for which the period of an object in simple harmonic motion (rolling up and down repetitively) along the curve does not depend on the object's starting position (the tautochrone curve)." So swinging a rack along the cycloid is the fastest motion without having to contribute energy (apart from that to overcome friction etc.). So you can have a large number of racks in the "left" position, choose to open a passage between racks 34 and 35 by having all racks >=35 swing to the right position. In this way all N racks can be accessed with only the loss of space of a single planar passage. If everything which enters is weighed before insertion, the loading and unloading could happen near reversibly by arming or releasing appropriate counterweights. Kinetic energy can also be stored gravitationally: accelerate (by dropping the weight) and decelerate (by lifting it again) for quick motions. Better design for the ultimate cost center, energy consumption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cycloid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cycloid