17 ms·
Whistleblower details how DOGE may have taken sensitive NLRB data
- computerthings 2y ago[dead]
- giraffe_lady 2y ago[flagged]
- actionfromafar 2y agoCombined with "oops can't get them back" it's very powerful. Combine it with not advertising faces of snatched people on broadcast TV, and it's a very useful tool inded. People will just disappear. It won't be legal or illegal, just a thing that happens from time to time. Police won't search too hard for the missing people, because no good can come out of finding out.
- practice9 2y agoKinda similar in a way to China or Russia “disappearances”
- thrance 2y agoThey've already sent an innocent man there and acknowledged he was innocent, then refused to bring him back when the courts, the opposition and finally SCOTUS each commanded them to bring him back. This was just a test, and it was successful. They can now disappear and deport anyone they want with no repercussions whatsoever. The GOP is a criminal organization and their followers share the responsibility of what happens next.
- xnx 2y ago> then refused to bring him back when the courts It was extra ridiculous/insulting/terrifying to see the heads of both countries in the same room saying that there was nothing they could do about the situation.
- tromp 2y agoSCOTUS granting the president far reaching immunity was an invitation for the president to be in contempt of SCOTUS whenever it pleases him, and to just piss on the constitution he took an oath on defending.
- rescripting 2y agoIt’s possible he is already dead, as he was basically sent right in to the arms of the gangs he fled from.
- defgeneric 2y agoThe fact that no charges have ever been brought against him by the Salvadoran government, yet they still claim to be holding him there lends credence to this. Why would they not simply release him? If he's dead it would be a major problem for Bukele's government as well as the US government. So evidently we're in "disappeared" territory now.
- DaiPlusPlus 2y ago> This was just a test, and it was successful It's too soon to say it's "successful": SCOTUS was 9-0 against and that was still only a few days ago, so far from being a success it's now turning into a constitutional crisis... assuming the administration doesn't fold, or flip-flop, or some combination of the two - which we've already seen plenty of[1]. ---------- [1] the seemingly arbitrary and capricious tariff changes announced almost every day ever since the-day-after-April-fools-day.
- thoroughburro 2y agoSo, he’s being brought back then?
- ben_w 2y agoRoll a D20: if it's even he comes back, if it's less than 10 he mysteriously disappears.
- NekkoDroid 2y agoI wouldn't even put the odds of him coming back at 50% 20: He gets brought back in good condition, 19-16: He is gonna get brought back in terrible condition, 15-11 he doesn't come back, 10-1 he is dead
- ben_w 2y agoNote that I said "even" and "less than ten". Even ignoring damage he's already suffered in the prison, the "good outcomes" are still only 30% (10, 12, 14, 16, 18, 20).
- dionian 2y agoIf you read the SCOTUS ruling, all it upholds from the lower courts decision is that the USG must 'facilitate', not 'effectuate' his release. AFAIK the Court doesn't have a way to order El Salvador to do so
- avhception 2y agoWasn't the argument for the right to bear arms always that it would prevent a criminal government from having it's way? Now, how's that working out so far?
- watwut 2y agoNo. It was what peoppe who want to use guns to force own autocracy say. The people with guns support these measures.
- DFHippie 2y agoThis. The 2A absolutists want guns to pacify their neighbors, not the government.
- readhistory 2y agoThis is nonsense. Plenty of nonviolent, peaceful groups carry arms. Leftists (e.g. Anarchists, Marxists, Socialists, Communists, Queer Liberation, Black Liberation, etc.) groups typically are pro-firearms. Not always, but plenty are. The Black Panthers, famously, were armed, but so are are orgs like the Pink Pistols. Martin Luther King Jr. had many guns for self defense, and carried a revolver at times. Marx famously said that workers should be armed. Centrists (e.g. Democrats, some Labour parties) typically abhor guns, and value the decorum and principle of the instution to keep us all safe. They are a "if society is well ordered, then there's no need for arms" group. Right wing folks (e.g. Republicans, Proud Boys, KKK, etc.) are the folks who you are describing -- by and large supporting these measures and also want to use firearms to exert control. It's really, really important if you consider yourself to be a progressive to ask, "Who will gun control laws in America be used to prosecute? Will that be minority groups dispraportionately?" Historically and presently, armed minorities are more difficult to oppress, and many many leftist groups have historically and presently been armed for the purposes of community defense. By suggesting that arming oneself is a right wing position you erase history and erode current efforts for folks to build community safety systems.
- alabastervlog 2y agoNot “always”. It wasn’t the reason that became an amendment, national defense was. People later emphasized that rather off-label justification when state militias were nationalized and the main purpose of the amendment became wholly obsolete.
- pnutjam 2y agohttps://documentedny.com/2025/04/14/ice-bukele-cecot-tren-de-aragua-el-salvador-new-york-deported/ https://documentedny.com/2025/04/14/ice-bukele-cecot-tren-de... Probably more then one.
- flanked-evergl 2y ago[flagged]
- atkailash 2y agoCite? Really? I haven’t seen an article about the situation or the visit that didn’t mention it.
- ziddoap 2y agoIf you google "innocent man sent to el salvador" you'll get dozens on dozens on dozens of results from which you can pick your favorite news site to catch up.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoI checked the first two results and not one of them said the man was innocent [1][2]. It's okay if the claim is baseless and there is no citation, but asking me to find a citation for someone else's baseless claim is not really okay. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/14/abrego-garcia-trump-administration-el-salvador-nayib-bukele https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/14/abrego-garci... [2]: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-meet-with-el-salvadors-president-amid-questions-over-deportations-2025-04-14/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-meet-with-el-salvador...
- ceejayoz 2y agoOur system deems people innocent until proven guilty of a crime. That has not happened - he is not charged with any. Can you cite anything showing him having been convicted of something?
- flanked-evergl 2y agoI made no claim one way or the other. I asked you to cite a claim.
- 2y ago
- gotoeleven 2y ago[flagged]
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoFunny, because the administration testified in court that it was a mistake that he was sent. Claiming the stay was illegal was retconned after the fact, not the cause for the deportation.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoThis is entirely disconnected from reality [1]. If he was not an illegal alien, he would not have been deported at all. [1]: https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/abrego-garcia-and-ms-13--what-do-we-know https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/abrego-garcia-and-ms-13...
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoThe claim that administration supporters are now using is that the legal 'administrative stay' placed upon him was illegal, That is what 'stay' means in the context of what I said, not his 'stay in the country'. Maybe don't get so righteous next time especially when you don't bother to understand what someone says.
- ltbarcly3 2y agoThis is not an accurate account of the situation. While I don't agree with the actions the government is taking here, I also don't think we are entitled to our own private facts about it. Mr Garcia does not have a criminal record, but he was ordered to be deported years ago. He was able to get a temporary reprieve from this by hiring lawyers and working through the legal process, but he did this by almost certainly committing perjury by claiming there were criminal gangs who would kill him if he returned to El Salvador. If you believe the filings in immigration appeals you would have to believe that 99% of the people in the world are being personally pursued by criminal gangs. Perhaps you believe this but I don't find it to be credible. Regardless, whether the legal process is effective doesn't matter here, it IS the legal process and must be followed. My point is the fact Mr Garcia was deported is not itself the issue, it's that it was done in a way that ignores the rule of law (even though it did respect due process). Legally Mr Garcia should be deported eventually, he was only allowed to stay temporarily until he is not "at risk for his life" if he were deported, but the legal process must be respected. SCOTUS did not command anyone be brought back. They declined to issue an emergency decision blocking an order to 'facilitate' his return, but specifically sent back to the lower court and took issue with the order to 'effectuate' his return. So they are not commanding the government to bring him back, rather they are commanding the government to not prevent his return. Yes this is tedious but reality is often tedious. > They can now disappear and deport anyone they want I think you have not made any case that it is valid to assume that we would go from "one person who has already been ordered for deportation by a federal court" who was very publicly deported to "anyone they want" and "disappear". I basically agree with your sentiment inaccuracy and hyperbole doesn't benefit anyone.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoProtection rackets are pretty big in central america. Look at the publicity about the avocado industry. Protection rackets only work when you go after those people that escape your 'protection' payments. So yes, it's reasonable to assume every person that said no to the racket and fled to the US becomes a pretty big target, it's part of the founding principles/business model of running a protection racket.
- 2y ago
- marcosdumay 2y ago> it'll start with sure actual criminals Have they targeted any single criminal yet? Because they have sent two planes of people here to Brazil and nobody there was wanted by either country. Also, Brazil has a list of wanted criminals at Interpol with known addresses in Florida that they aren't arresting.
- soco 2y agoI'm not american so can somebody please explain me, how is deleting logs and every trace of your actions helping with government efficiency?
- actionfromafar 2y agoTo more efficiently rout trouble-makers and unions.
- lesuorac 2y agoLog storage is expensive.
- skeeter2020 2y agoIt's not the storage, but processing with NR and DataDog is what's expensive. That's why the efficiency team asked to not have their actions logged in the first place.
- phanimahesh 2y agoI can honestly not tell if this comment was intended to be taken seriously, or if it was tongue in cheek.
- const_cast 2y agoI really want to believe it's tongue in cheek because the thought of asking not to be audited in order to save some compute on Splunk queries or whatever is very funny to me.
- int_19h 2y agoWhen in doubt, check the comment history.
- EdwardDiego 2y agoIt is.
- AIPedant 2y agoEven by the standards of this administration...... yikes: Meanwhile, his attempts to raise concerns internally within the NLRB preceded someone "physically taping a threatening note" to his door that included sensitive personal information and overhead photos of him walking his dog that appeared to be taken with a drone, according to a cover letter attached to his disclosure filed by his attorney, Andrew Bakaj of the nonprofit Whistleblower Aid.
- 9283409232 2y agoThis is exactly what I expect from this administration. Mob tactics. Take the silver or get the lead.
- potato3732842 2y ago[flagged]
- 9283409232 2y agoDOGE aren't federal agents. They are cyber criminals doing Elon's bidding.
- AIPedant 2y agoThe reason you are being downvoted to smithereens is that Bryan Malinowski was credibly accused of serious crimes (arms trafficking) wheres Daniel Berulis is accused of reporting serious crimes. You're making a preposterous and immoral false equivalence.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pc86 2y agoYou can't seriously be defending the treatment of Malinowski. The agents did not wear body cameras in direct violation of ATF policy. They conducted an early-morning no-knock raid for a search warrant when they knew Malinowski would be there (having cancelled an earlier one because he wasn't home). This wasn't an arrest warrant, it was a search warrant. They covered up the doorbell camera so if he had checked it he wouldn't see the half-dozen police vehicles outside. They could have done the exact same thing in the middle of the day when nobody was home and everybody would be alive today. They could have waited until daylight and knocked on the door with their warrant and walked right in. They could have worn body cameras as ATF policy and common sense demands. "Arms trafficking" is a funny way to say "buying guns legally and reselling them at gun shows" but let's say every single thing said about him is 100% true. If you think someone is a gun runner why wouldn't you take their house when they're not home to get all the evidence without having to worry about what they're doing? Why wouldn't you arrest him at the airport, where he almost certainly isn't armed, and police presence won't raise any alarms?
- acdha 2y agoThis part is really damning: a real efficiency audit might need a lot of access to look for signs of hidden activity, but they’d never need to hide traces of what they did: > Meanwhile, according to the disclosure and records of internal communications, members of the DOGE team asked that their activities not be logged on the system and then appeared to try to cover their tracks behind them, turning off monitoring tools and manually deleting records of their access — evasive behavior that several cybersecurity experts interviewed by NPR compared to what criminal or state-sponsored hackers might do. The subsequent message about Russian activity could be a coincidence–Internet background noise-but given how these are not very technically skilled and are moving very fast in systems they don’t understand, I’d be completely unsurprised to learn that they unintentionally left something exposed or that one of them has been compromised.
- atkailash 2y ago[dead]
- avs733 2y ago>A real efficiency audit might need a lot of access to look for signs of hidden activity, but they’d never need to hide traces of what they did In fact I would imagine they would do exactly the opposite because they would look at the mere ability to hide what they did as an audit finding.
- Terr_ 2y ago"The new bank-manager has hired some friends of his to improve the security of the bank vault." "We already have an audit from last year, we just need the funding to improv--" "Oh, and they want to turn off all the security cameras next weekend. You'll know it's them because they'll be wearing masks." "Sir, we have a responsibility to our customers, we can't ju--" "Do it or you're fired."
- avs733 2y agomonday morning: manager: "the auditors found all of our money missing" ::silence:: manager: "they are clearly doing an amazing job, and you are all fired for allowing such fraud waste and abuse"
- howmayiannoyyou 2y ago[flagged]
- Planktonne 2y agoDo you have a more independent/reliable source?
- fads_go 2y agoThe parent's russian propoganda post does not mention that the posted savings are full of inaccuracies. Nor does the propoganda define "waste", if one looks at the actual cuts, it seems to be focused on "things Herr M. doesn't like". which is not a good definition of "waste".
- kemotep 2y agoWell it would help if there weren’t numerous issues with the data as presented on that site. Specifically now they are only claiming somewhere around 28 billion saved in cancelled contracts when in early February they claimed like 55 billion. Seems odd that over time the amount saved would go down despite the alleged number being of cancellations going up. Also it is concerning that the largest amount from an individual contract saved is a cancelled deportation facility contract. Seems at odds with the Administration’s goals to ramp up mass deportation but cancel the contract for building a holding facility for unaccompanied minors. My suggestion would be if the goal is to eliminate debt we would need to target social security reform such as raising the retirement ages and eliminating the cap on the payroll tax. Additionally, but far less realistic would be implementing a Land Value Tax. Not cancel random contracts that amount to a tiny fraction of the budget and propose massive tax cuts like the current administration seems to be doing.
- hypeatei 2y agoThere were already people called "inspector generals" which handled waste, fraud, and abuse but Trump fired about 17 of them in his first week. Deploying tech bros to solve the problem is naive at best and malicious at worst. The arrogance in assuming that no auditor before them looked into the SSA database and saw DOB records going back to 1875 is outstanding.
- 2y ago
- pnutjam 2y agoThis checks out because all those DOGE hires appear to be hackers, and they are now state sponsored. Most of them could never pass a basic background check, much less a TS or even public trust from one of the more invasive Federal agencies.
- flanked-evergl 2y agocite?
- ceejayoz 2y agohttps://www.reuters.com/world/us/doge-staffer-big-balls-provided-tech-support-cybercrime-ring-records-show-2025-03-26/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/doge-staffer-big-balls-prov... > The best-known member of Elon Musk's U.S. DOGE Service team of technologists once provided support to a cybercrime gang that bragged about trafficking in stolen data and cyberstalking an FBI agent, according to digital records reviewed by Reuters.
- flanked-evergl 2y ago[flagged]
- bryanrasmussen 2y agoa basic background check would invalidate someone with the described background.
- randunel 2y agoIs the article unclear? Would people who collaborate with known criminal groups pass basic background checks? Granted, the sample size is low, but it doesn't look likely the rest of the gang would be any different.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoOne staffer is not "most of them". The article in no way supportes the claim.
- 9283409232 2y agoIt should be clear at this point that DOGE is trying to create a unified database of all persons in the US for targeting. Every single bit of data that they can get about you from the government or social media will be tagged to you Minority Report style. They were clear about wanting to deport citizens to El Salvador as well. Once you are identified as the other side they will come for you. If you are waiting for it to get worse before taking action and getting involved, we are already at that point. > And Berulis noticed that an unknown user had exported a "user roster," a file with contact information for outside lawyers who have worked with the NLRB. Possibly looking for lawyers for Trump to target with EOs or blackmail.
- wormlord 2y agoHow you are getting downvotes is beyond me. People are finally waking up to the idea that the whole point of the Trump admin is to privatize the government, but haven't woken up to the fact that we are entering an era of state terror. Keep your heads buried HN, you'll be dragged kicking and screaming into reality in a few months anyways.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoIt's extremely frustrating and something I've thought a lot about over the years where we were pretty obviously building towards this outcome. A couple things: First the "average" american is softly but ideologically committed to liberalism¹ & democracy as fundamental values. From that perspective the mind kind of recoils from accepting this. If this is really what's happening, what does civic obligation demand of me? How does that reconcile with my inability to keep my family safe in the face of a motivated & powerful state that wishes to harm me through them? Easier to believe this isn't what is happening, I don't need to take action yet. A powerful example of motivated reasoning. Second a significant part of the userbase here, as with the general population, supports some or all of these actions. Simple as. ¹ Like in the traditional sense, ie "a political and moral philosophy based on the rights of the individual, liberty, consent of the governed, political equality, the right to private property, and equality before the law" from wikipedia.
- dboreham 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tonetheman 2y ago[dead]
- softwaredoug 2y agoSome context as I understand it is DOGE employees are all temporary gov't employees whose employment expires (in June?). Assuming they follow the law there (big If), then they scramble around these agencies with tremendous urgency trying to please Elon (or the powers that be?). And they absolutely should be resisted with this deadline in mind...
- tootie 2y agoThey are using heavy-handed tactics. Per this article, the whistleblower was threatened. At the SSA, a 26-year veteran was dragged out of the building. Similar story at the IRS. DOGE has the backing of US Marshalls and the president. They can resist, but they'll just end up locked out.
- _hyn3 2y agoIf the CEO of your company empowers a team to audit your work, would you 'resist'? And this Chief Executive was elected by the majority of the country, specifically to take these actions that he'd clearly stated he would take. The resistance is actually the violation of federal law. It's no different from contempt of court; within the President's domain, he has a huge amount of power. The President can also modify existing policy (regulations) at any time and literally make new laws (Executive Orders have the force of law) as long as they don't conflict with current law, as well as overturning previous President's Executive Orders. Of course, then the shoe will be on the other food someday, too, just as it was when Biden took over from Trump and then they switched places again. As President Obama said, "I've got a pen, and I've got a phone." https://www.npr.org/2014/01/20/263766043/wielding-a-pen-and-a-phone-obama-goes-it-alone https://www.npr.org/2014/01/20/263766043/wielding-a-pen-and-...
- pizza 2y agoWhat would you do if your CEO tells you to do something illegal? What would you do if your CEO then tells you to intimidate people who refuse to carry out the illegal requests by tailing them and then taping the surveillance footage to their door as a threat?
- josefresco 2y ago[flagged]
- mistrial9 2y ago[flagged]
- josefresco 2y ago> rampantly false Is Abrego Garcia not real?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago[flagged]
- HelloMcFly 2y ago"Disappeared" in this sense refers to the manner in which he was abducted, not his ongoing status. The word is not subject to a strict legalese interpretation in these comments. Though I'd argue both uses are acceptable in common use discussion since even if we know where he is since he's going to be incarcerated indefinitely with no due process, no access to lawyers, no civil rights. How long could he be dead without anyone knowing? Literally indefinitely?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> word is not subject to a strict legalese interpretation in these comments Disappearing has been consistently used to refer to illegal and inconspicuous detention since WWII. The person was there and now they are not. There is no arrest record. There are no lawyers. There is certainly no case record where government officials are being questioned [1]. They may be detained, dead or on holiday. The ambiguity, which permits bystanders to assume normality, is the terrifying key. Diluting the term, particularly on this precipice, is incredibly dangerous. > How long could he be dead without anyone knowing? Going off sworn statements to courts (again, something victims of disappearance do not get), a few hours. [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2025/04/12/abrego-garcia-el-salvador-alive-00287678 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/04/12/abrego-garcia-el-sa...
- ck2 2y agoThat backdoor code is going to lurk for decades. Not only will Musk be able to tap into it for years but foreign governments.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bilbo0s 2y agoThis is the real problem, and the reason we never should have allowed access to sensitive government and societal data in this fashion.
- the_doctah 2y agoPure ridiculous conjecture.
- grandempire 2y ago> particularly when those staffers noticed a spike in data leaving the agency. It's possible that the data included sensitive information on unions, ongoing legal cases and corporate secrets This entire article appears to be speculation about data they MAY have taken with no evidence besides large file size that they are misusing something. The discussion with the “whistle blower” and other experts is only about how serious it would be IF they misused it. Am I reading it wrong?
- 9283409232 2y agoSomeone exfiltrated sensitive data. That isn't in question. The only question is who did it and why. As far as DOGE's involvement, there is no proof but there is plenty of evidence.
- grandempire 2y ago[flagged]
- 9283409232 2y ago> Then, Berulis started tracking sensitive data leaving the places it's meant to live, according to his official disclosure. First, he saw a chunk of data exiting the NxGen case management system's "nucleus," inside the NLRB system, Berulis explained. Then, he saw a large spike in outbound traffic leaving the network itself. > From what he could see, the data leaving, almost all text files, added up to around 10 gigabytes — or the equivalent of a full stack of encyclopedias if someone printed them, he explained. It's a sizable chunk of the total data in the NLRB system, though the agency itself hosts over 10 terabytes in historical data. It's unclear which files were copied and removed or whether they were consolidated and compressed, which could mean even more data was exfiltrated. > Berulis says someone appeared to be doing something called DNS tunneling to prevent the data exfiltration from being detected. He came to that conclusion, outlined in his disclosure, after he saw a traffic spike in DNS requests parallel to the data being exfiltrated, a spike 1,000 times the normal number of requests. > And Berulis noticed that an unknown user had exported a "user roster," a file with contact information for outside lawyers who have worked with the NLRB. And more if you actually read the article. About a third of it is about the data that was taken.
- grandempire 2y ago[flagged]
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> > The small, independent federal agency > I still don’t think this notion holds up. What notion doesn't hold up? That a federal agency can be small & independent? > Which branch are they under, who do they report to? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Labor_Relations_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Labor_Relations_Board > The NLRB is governed by a five-person board and a general counsel, all of whom are appointed by the president with the consent of the Senate. Board members are appointed for five-year terms and the general counsel is appointed for a four-year term. The general counsel acts as a prosecutor and the board acts as an appellate quasi-judicial body from decisions of 36 administrative law judges, as of November 2023.[4] The NLRB is headquartered at 1015 Half St. SE, Washington, D.C., and it has over 30 regional, sub-regional, and residential offices throughout the United States. > Why would real Russian hackers not do anything to obscure their ip? Why would the fox bother hiding the hole someone dug for it under the henhouse?
- grandempire 2y ago> That a federal agency can be small & independent? Yes. They are either in the legislative, executive, or judicial branch. And before you send more Wikipedia links, be aware there is a long history and chain of Supreme Court cases about this question. > Why would the fox bother hiding the hole someone dug for it under the henhouse? Still spreading the Russian asset conspiracy theory? Why wouldn’t they want to hide their crimes from future enemies?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kasey_junk 2y agoYes. And the current precedent is very clear that these independent agencies are constitutional. The current court has not, yet, overturned that precedent. There is lots of reason to believe they will, in an extremely contentious ruling. But for now they haven’t. We are going to find out one way or another though because this admin is pushing hard up against the question. Of course it’s also pushing hard up on the question of if the courts can constrain it at all so the grade school understanding of separation of powers is real.
- indoordin0saur 2y ago[flagged]
- outer_web 2y agoThe "looking at" process is still subject to federal law.
- Sonnigeszeug 2y agoI fixed it for you: "Whistleblower details how a temporary group of very young people, who would never get access to sensitive data, are disabling/hiding what they are doing with highliy sensitive data of an executive, potentially circumventing safety mechanism in place to protect the data of all americans". Btw. there is NO reason why they couldn't do all of that in a sincere way. Trump was voted in for 4 years.
- janice1999 2y ago... very young people, of which at least one is affiliated with cyber criminals (and also happens to be the grandson of a KGB spy). https://krebsonsecurity.com/2025/02/teen-on-musks-doge-team-graduated-from-the-com/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2025/02/teen-on-musks-doge-team-...
- ajross 2y agoI've said this repeatedly, but write this down: before this administration is out we are going to have a major (probably multiple) scandal where DOGE staffers get caught with some kind of horrifying self-enrichment scam based on the data they're hoovering. It could be simple insider trading, it could be selling the data to a FBI sting, it might take lots of forms. But it's going to happen. These are a bunch of 20-something tech bro ego cases convinced of their crusade to remake government along libertarian axes they learned from Reddit/4chan/HN. These are simply not people motivated out of a genuine desire to improve the public good. And they've been given essentially unsupervised access to some outrageously tempting levers.
- potato3732842 2y agoDoesn't matter if they're good people or not "given essentially unsupervised access to some outrageously tempting levers" that scandal WILL happen eventually.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoI think it's worse than that as the DOGE staffers are presumably picked according to Musk's preferences and he's not going to be looking for generous, well adjusted do-gooders, but selfish, arrogant, greedy racists. Presumably, they're also going to be targetted by other countries intelligence services with a mind to getting hold of the same data.
- f38zf5vdt 2y agoPersonal enrichment? There's already an enormous amount of evidence here to indicate that DOGE is working on behalf of a foreign nation state. It is seeming more and more likely that members of the DOGE team are simply secret agents for a foreign military. > Within minutes after DOGE accessed the NLRB's systems, someone with an IP address in Russia started trying to log in, according to Berulis' disclosure. The attempts were "near real-time," according to the disclosure. Those attempts were blocked, but they were especially alarming. Whoever was attempting to log in was using one of the newly created DOGE accounts — and the person had the correct username and password, according to Berulis.
- tlogan 2y agoThe unfortunate reality is that a half of the US population sees the NLRB as a burden on small businesses—primarily because its policies shift frequently, making compliance costly and complex for those without deep legal resources. [1] And the same half of the population do not trust anything what npr.org says. Understanding the above dynamic is key to grasping the current state of discourse in the U.S. [1] https://edworkforce.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=399445 https://edworkforce.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?Docum...
- axus 2y agoSome may claim that NPR is retaliating for getting defunded for the next 2 years.
- brendoelfrendo 2y agoAn odd claim, since NPR getting defunded is itself a retaliation from the current administration for not reporting positively enough about Trump.
- axus 2y agoOh yeah I'm predicting a claim will be made I disagree with. But I can imagine the mental gymnastics, post a prediction and watch for the outcome. Usually there's a shakedown, did Trump ever make NPR an offer they "couldn't" refuse?
- rbanffy 2y agoSimilar to the one he made to Harvard? Do they even have to make such a thing explicitly these days? I would just assume they won't fund anything that's critical to the current government.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tyrrvk 2y agoThis coupled with the hot mike incident yesterday where Trump was saying how El Salvador needed to build more mega prisons for the "home grown..terrorists" is beyond concerning. Sure sounds like DOGE is compiling lists of 'less desirable s' that will soon be swept off the streets in unmarked vans. America has turned fully fascist.
- the_doctah 2y ago[flagged]
- gibsonf1 2y ago[flagged]
- arunabha 2y agoI am not sure how it's possible to defend the kind of stuff DOGE is doing anymore. Even the veneer of looking for efficiency is gone. There have only been claims of 'fraud' with no real evidence backing up the claimed scale of fraud. At this point it simply looks like DOGE is yet another attempt to use a popular trope (Govt fraud and waste) to push through changes specifically designed to give unchecked power to one individual. This much concentrated, unchecked power opens up vast opportunities for fraud and corruption and there are pretty much no instances in history where it turned out be to a good thing in retrospect. Also, very surprised this story made it to the front page. Typically, stuff like this gets flagged off the front page within minutes.
- bedane 2y ago[flagged]
- GolDDranks 2y ago> Typically, stuff like this gets flagged off the front page within minutes. Why would that be, because it's too "political" for tech news? Or are there actual DOGE sympathies within the HN population?
- ethbr1 2y ago> Or are there actual DOGE sympathies within the HN population? I wouldn't mind that so much, except they're minimally-active in the comment section and instead use flagging. At least defend your beliefs. Switching to https://news.ycombinator.com/active https://news.ycombinator.com/active (/active) with showdead is a better HN experience, nowadays.
- bilekas 2y agoThis isn't really a shock to me, but what's more frustrating I guess is that absolutely nothing will come of this. I have zero confidence any of this will even be cleaned up, just the same ranting about "fake news". Really feels like the fox is already in the coop.
- stevenwoo 2y agoThat the intrusion came over Starlink from Russia with valid login credentials would be unbelievable in a tale from speculative fiction. Reality Winner looks like a hero compared to these clowns.
- inemesitaffia 2y agoOver Starlink from Russia. Very evident there's no networking knowledge here.
- deepsun 2y agoPoliticians are only afraid of not being re-elected. So I see that the only way is to advocate voters to hold their representatives accountable. Start a campaign in you state about that, and I think you'll get an answer pretty fast, since they are very sensitive to popularity and competition matters.
- campuscodi 2y agoDOGE staff are just behaving like a foreign cyber-espionage group at this point
- consumer451 2y agoIt is hilarious what does, and does not, get flagged on this website in 2025. The other day on /active, there was a story about a French politician being banned from running for office, due to being convicted of outright fraud for the second time. Absolutely nothing to do with technology or business, nothing to do with the USA. Pure politics in a foreign country. Not flagged. There was a story directly below which involved the USA, technology and business, but had an uncomfortable narrative for some users. Flagged. As someone who still likes this site a lot, this just makes me laugh at this point. I don't know how else to react.
- regularjack 2y agoI wouldn't be so quick to jump to conspiracy theory territory, it could just be that people get tired of reading the same bullshit everyday.
- Capricorn2481 2y agoBecause, naturally, people on here want to harm you. We can't say it out loud, but that's where the U.S. climate is right now. HN is not immune from it, and is likely more susceptible to it given the demographic. They flag to keep people from saying it.
- leotravis10 2y agoIndeed, I'm sure there's a LOT of people, especially in the HN space are pro-fascist.
- belter 2y ago"I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible." - Peter Thiel "We will coup whoever we want! Deal with it." - Elon Musk "Our present society has been subjected to a mass demoralization campaign for six decades – against technology and against life – under varying names like “existential risk”, “sustainability”, “ESG”, “Sustainable Development Goals”, “social responsibility”, “stakeholder capitalism”, “Precautionary Principle”, “trust and safety”, “tech ethics”, “risk management”, “de-growth”, “the limits of growth”." - Marc Andreessen "Democracy is to power as a lottery is to money. It is a social mechanism that allows a large number of hominids to feel as if their individual views affect the world, even when the chance of such an effect is negligible." - Curtis Yarvin
- JohnMakin 2y agoThis seems important and incredibly relevant on a site called hackernews. It's credible and from a credible source. Why are we flagging it?
- AlecSchueler 2y ago[flagged]
- asveikau 2y agoJD Vance is a poster boy for Y Combinator adjacent fascists. Marc Andreessen, when he is not cheering on opiate overdoses in his hometown and praising the British Raj, loves what's going on. We need to accept that Silicon Valley has major culpability here. After all, how much do you see on HN that you should ignore the law because it's better to ask forgiveness than permission?
- computerthings 2y ago[dead]
- remarkEon 2y ago"Fascism" today just means "right wing politician I do not like" or "conservative who is successful at pushing back the left". Plenty of people here can have a problem with this administration and Vance himself, or not, without those who disagree pretending that we're a week away from goose stepping down 5th Avenue in NYC.
- mikeyouse 2y agoThere’s lots of fascism before the goose stepping but in the past week the President confirmed he’d like to send US citizens to a foreign gulag, he continues to ignore a Supreme Court ruling to bring home a previously and illegally deported man, he threatened Harvard that he’d strip their nonprofit status since they resisted his inane demands for conservative-DEI, he initiated several investigations using the state security apparatus of former government employees he deemed enemies and the richest man in the world (who donated 9 figures to get the President elected) continues to illegally impound funding from across the government including every organization that regulates the companies he runs. Oh and they’re planning a $100M military parade for the president’s birthday. Things aren’t great!
- DrNosferatu 2y agoThe “young and inexperienced” staffers narrative is very convenient to perform target operations on (specially) sensitive data.
- DrNosferatu 2y ago*targeted
- vaxman 2y agoThey didn't use StarLink?! ROFLMAO I hope he doesn't think Trump is his boy and will keep DOJ off his back. The problem is that the institutional funds and market makers will not support this level of Watergate/Enron/WorldCom-like risk and Trump isn't going to become entangled in that (since it means the corporate death penalty as far as public equity and access to bank capital is concerned). BUT the Report is from a super controversial NGO that has long been targeted by Republicans and may soon be DOGEd, so it could be filled with speculation, half-truths, innuendo and lies. Still...They didn't use StarLink?! I mean, is that not the greatest evidence you could ever hope for of an obvious NSA backdoor in StarLink? They were willing to risk obscure premises-based (bandwidth) monitoring over holding a mini-dish out the window for a few seconds..Too much! I feel like I owe someone $20 for a ticket.
- vaxman 2y agoNot even 24 hours later, I called it --the Administration IS asking Congress to de-fund NPR: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-administration-plans-to-ask-congress-to-defund-pbs-npr https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-administration-p... Meanwhile NPR has new reporting that DOGE has sent two of its boys back to NLRB, but they're going to work remotely. Is the hope here that this will provide ongoing justification for DOGE remote data access as the Feds sort out what they did in the first visit? Like even though NPR's first report stated that Russia has tried to login remotely using valid DOGE credentials just after DOGE personnel left the first time? https://www.npr.org/2025/04/16/nx-s1-5366851/doge-nlrb-whistleblower-musk-data https://www.npr.org/2025/04/16/nx-s1-5366851/doge-nlrb-whist...
- jonnycomputer 2y agoAnd what is NxGenBdoorExtract?
- jonnycomputer 2y agoI think we should be trying to understand what NxGenBdoorExtract is. NxGen is a system for NLRB. Bdoor is pretty evocative of a back door. He took he git offline or made it private. I can't find it on archive.org.
- snypher 2y agoOr who has access to DogeSA_2d5c3e0446f9@nlrb.microsoft.com? https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/democrats-oversight.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/2025-04-15.gec-to-dol-and-nlrb-ig-re-doge.pdf https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/demo...
- jonnycomputer 2y agoOn the other hand, there are two things about that screenshot of the repo which is a little weird. First, the timestamp of that repo is cutoff, but, the items seem to be in reverse chronological order, which would put that repo sometime in 2021-ish, or before. The owner could, of course, just make it public again, or put it back up, and end all the speculation.
- anthonygarcia21 2y agoI'm intrigued by the "Mission 2" notation. That suggests, perhaps, that DOGE has a "Mission 1" (its public, ostensible purpose) and a hidden "Mission 2" known only to Musk and his minions.
- e2le 2y agoarchive.today has a snapshot taken on 28 Feb 2025, although it doesn't show any repository with that name. https://archive.ph/fUa5Q https://archive.ph/fUa5Q
- jonnycomputer 2y agoThis confuses me greatly. Comparing your link, I can find the repos in that screenshot in the archive snapshot, but as you say, the NxGenBdoorExtract repo is not there, and the repo where it would be is a tinder-react-native clone (updated Sep 20 2020)... I'm trying to think through this: 1. if the screenshot is not doctored, then the implied ordering of last updated would have had it last updated before January 20, 2021; which would mean it has nothing to do with what is alleged in the article. 2. But in the archive.ph snapshot from 2/28/25 doesn't have it at all anywhere. 3. Archive.org's 3/21/25 snapshot shows the same thing as archive.ph 4. The article states that after this tweet (https://x.com/SollenbergerRC/status/1895609294810464390 https://x.com/SollenbergerRC/status/1895609294810464390) dated 2/28/25 (the date of the archive.ph 2/28/25 snapshot), Berulis noticed NxGenBdoorExtract in the repo: "After journalist Roger Sollenberger started posting on X about the account, Berulis noticed something Wick was working on: a project, or repository, titled "NxGenBdoorExtract." Wick made it private before Berulis could investigate further, he told NPR. Of course, if it really only was public for a very brief moment then it might not be in the snapshot, and the article isn't clear exactly how long after that tweet that Berulis supposedly discovered this. All I can say is this: I can't figure out for the life of me what all this adds up to.
- zombiwoof 2y agoWelcome to Elon Musks America
- theteapot 2y ago> ... DOGE employees demanded the highest level of access ... When an IT staffer suggested a streamlined process to activate those accounts in a way that would let their activities be tracked, in accordance with NLRB security policies, the IT staffers were told to stay out of DOGE's way, the disclosure continues. But did they actually "turn off logging"?? How do you even do that? Anyone know what access control system they are talking about?
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoIt sounds to me like there's some application-level logging on this NxGen system, and DOGE obtained permissions to read the underlying storage without going through the application. But the article does also say later on that there are specific controls and monitoring systems Berulis did find turned off.
- DavidPiper 2y ago(Non-American here.) If they weren't already, it seems like private businesses, security researchers, and I suppose the general public, should start treating US government agencies as privacy and security threats, just like you'd treat any other phisher, scammer, etc. If government agencies are compromised - via software backdoors or any other mechanism - any data and systems they can access should be considered compromised too.
- exceptione 2y agoNeoliberalism -> Corporatism -> Fascism/Autocracy You are a Human Resource to be commercialized. Ad tech => Private Intelligence. One is not a person. One has no rights. Unless one can free themself and their loved ones of neoliberal brainwashing.
- garte 2y agothis sounds exactly like that's the goal behind all this.
- MysticOracle 2y agoThe whistleblower and his lawyer gave interviews on CNN & MSNBC: CNN: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsqgXfrSksI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsqgXfrSksI
- tehjoker 2y agoMakes sense, this is a lawless reactionary attack on the republic. Their purpose is to put capital ever more firmly in charge. That means attacking workers.
- billy99k 2y ago[flagged]
- crowselect 2y agoThe security community didn’t ignore hard evidence - the “hard evidence” didn’t stand up to basic scrutiny. These claims may well be false, but they deserve scrutiny, and waving them away while perpetuating a much repeated lie isn’t helping anyone except criminals and corruption. Bottom line: this deserves investigation.
- jokoon 2y agoIt's likely that this team was infiltrated by adversary countries
- autoexec 2y agoI'd always assumed that we had three letter agencies whose entire job was to keep this sort of thing from happening, but it seems that none of them are concerned about protecting our government's secrets or even our democracy. What good is the panopticon if the watchers are asleep on the job?
- IOT_Apprentice 2y agoThey’ve all been either fired or out in a leash as musk collects all the PII and secrets in every agency & department and feeds it into a private subnet of his AI. His minions are certainly doing that.
- jokoon 2y agoThose agency can do their security work as long as there are laws and mandates about that. But those agencies cannot do anything if an elected/named official decides to work for an adversary, since those agencies are under command of the elected/name official. That's why democracy is beyond the scope of those agencies. Those agencies are "fences" to protect a teenager from doing mistakes. But it cannot protect the teenager from setting himself on fire. In my view, democracy was always vulnerable if the people or elected official can be convinced of whatever.
- autoexec 2y ago> Those agency can do their security work as long as there are laws and mandates about that. My understanding was that they routinely do their work far outside of the law. Because such agencies have demonstrated a willingness to violate the constitution of the US, lie to both congress and the president, overthrow the democratically elected leaders of sovereign nations, perform acts of torture, rape, human experimentation, assassination, etc. it seems odd that they'd suddenly shy away from taking any action now.
- g42gregory 2y agoHere is the thing that blows my mind: why is there an implicit assumption that this article is an honest reporting and not a propaganda piece? Don't get me wrong, I am not saying that it is. What I am saying is that, at the very least, this question should always be asked first about any reporting.
- Llamamoe 2y agoBecause this would be very in line with how DOGE has conducted itself so far.
- zelon88 2y agoNPR is a public entity. It's funding, governance, and leadership structure are well known and well trusted. From Wikipedia... .....Regarding financing; >Funding for NPR comes from dues and fees paid by member stations, underwriting from corporate sponsors, and annual grants from the publicly funded Corporation for Public Broadcasting.[4] Most of its member stations are owned by non-profit organizations, including public school districts, colleges, and universities. NPR operates independently of any government or corporation, and has full control of its content.[5] .....Regarding governance; > NPR is a membership organization. Member stations are required to be non-commercial or non-commercial educational radio stations; have at least five full-time professional employees; operate for at least 18 hours per day; and not be designed solely to further a religious broadcasting philosophy or be used for classroom distance learning programming. Each member station receives one vote at the annual NPR board meetings—exercised by its designated Authorized Station Representative ("A-Rep"). Now, I do question the authenticity of your question. Everyone knows that NPR is reputable and everyone knows why. Their reputation precedes them. But I entertained your charade and now I implore you to entertain one of mine. Can you provide me the same detailed information which demonstrates why someone should trust OAN? How about Breitbart? How about Newsmax? Can you please pick one and demonstrate why they are trustworthy using a similar format that I provided for you?
- timschmidt 2y ago> NPR is a public entity. It's funding, governance, and leadership structure are well known and well trusted. Ehhhh... I remember vividly a moment during the Iraq war in which NPR's ombudsman spent 20 minutes justifying the network's use of the euphemism "enhanced interrogation" when speaking about torture conducted by the CIA and others. It was terminology being pushed by the then-current administration, which NPR chose not only to parrot, but to justify. To the benefit of the administration and the detriment of human rights. I haven't had illusions about the network's accuracy, neutrality, or journalistic integrity since. 24 years? I guess you could call that well known. Not in a good way.
- drooopy 2y agoIf there are elections again in the future and more sane, qualified people take office, the Justice Department will have its hands full for decades.
- LadyCailin 2y agoSounds like they need to file a CVE.. oh wait.
- therealpygon 2y agoWhat is that saying they like to say all the time? “If you aren’t doing anything wrong, you should have nothing to fear.” Certainly seems like they are afraid of people seeing what they are doing for “not doing anything wrong”.
- mevin_kitnick 2y ago[flagged]
- mevin_kitnick 2y ago[flagged]
- sherdil2022 2y agoWhy isn’t this considered helping the enemy from within / treason? Why are people being deported for no crimes or for far lesser crimes?
- deepsun 2y agoIt is. But since citizens don't do anything about it, they don't need to care.
- sitkack 2y ago> So what that data spike correlated with was data that was transferred off of an internal record-keeping device that was only used for internal case data. So this system only has the private information about union organizers. The privileged business proprietary, technologies, competitors, those kind of things are in that system only. There's no other data. There's nothing else except that. ... > This is a difficult topic for Dan to discuss, but prior to our filing the whistle-blower disclosure this week, last week, somebody went to Dan's home and taped a threatening note, a menacing note on his door with personal information. > While he was at work, and it also contained photographs of him walking his dog taken by a drone. So…
- jonahbenton 2y agoEvery single DOGE access to any level of protected government data is a security breach. Not snark. None of them have clearances.
- jki275 2y agowhat do you mean by "clearances"? If they're accessing data that requires clearances, they have the required clearances. That's mandatory, and no one is going to show them anything without them. My guess, based on the fact you use terms like "protected government data" is that you don't even know enough about this topic to make up words about it.
- watwut 2y agoNo, access to data does not imply clearance. And they are forcing access to data. No it is not legal, but neither Trump nor DOGE nor Musk care about legality.
- jki275 2y agoYou're making broad blanket statements that have no basis in anything other than media BS. There is no "forcing access". It simply doesn't work that way. If the President clears them, they are cleared. That's perfectly legal. The President is the federal government's OCA.
- cratermoon 2y agoDOGE is a significant security breach.
- keepamovin 2y agoI think it's obvious that some of those affected by these reforms, or by fraud/abuse cutting, are going to come at DOGE with everything they got, so while I think people should review and monitor DOGE's actions, accusations should be taken with a grain of salt (and maybe a kickback).
- tssva 2y agoWhat reforms or fraud/abuse cutting? I haven't seen any signs of either coming from DOGE. I have seen plenty of signs of DOGE creating and participating in fraud/abuse.
- amai 2y agoDOGE might have hired too fast without the necessary background checks. So DOGE might now employ a lot of foreign spies (Russian, Chinese, etc) which take their chances.
- VagabundoP 2y agoYou say its a bug, but maybe thats a feature.
- 1970-01-01 2y agoMore evidence the current POTUS is in cahoots with Russia. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=Trump%20Alfa%20Bank%20&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- casenmgreen 2y agoJust read of this on BSky. Has some of the protected disclosure document from the whistleblower. https://bsky.app/profile/mattjay.com/post/3ln2dgoksce2e https://bsky.app/profile/mattjay.com/post/3ln2dgoksce2e Looks like Elon's staff went in and made a copy of everything - which in this case NLRB, so sensitive stuff, but any state department going to have a ton of sensitive stuff - and sent it who knows where; this after disabling all logging and a ton of security, presumably to try to cover their tracks. This is bad. These guys are looking like bad actors, with State-level authorization for access to everything. Also looks like they're kids and don't have the hang of security, and the professional Russian State run APTs have hacked them.
- Mr_Eri_Atlov 2y agoThe only point of DOGE is to cause as much irreparable damage as possible to American infrastructure. It will go down as the most successful assault on America since 9/11 once the true scale of the damage is understood.