20 ms·
Adobe deletes Bluesky posts after backlash
- jeffwask 2y agoYou don't get to play cute, fun, friend to creators and have the most odious licensing terms in the history of software.
- ikanreed 2y agoActually if you'll read the fine print, you're obligated to be friends.
- teruakohatu 2y agoAnd you cannot stop being friends until the end of the billing year, even if you are on a monthly plan.
- ajxs 2y agoI discovered this for myself while trying to cancel my plan. I told them I'd contact my state's consumer affairs regulator, and they instantly buckled. They ended up saving us both the trouble, and waived my 'cancellation fee'. For what it's worth, the previous time I tried to cancel their support offered me a 50% discount, which I accepted. Once that discount expired I was out. Adobe aren't earning their keep. Their costs are exorbitant when compared to the quality of the software. I mostly used Premiere (on Windows), which seems to get slower with each release. Media Encoder crashes constantly, and Photoshop is as slow as molasses.
- fracus 2y agoI think this is a great one sentence encapsulation of the situation.
- mtndew4brkfst 2y agoAutodesk is at least boxing in the same weight class, but I do think Adobe is worse.
- pndy 2y agoAll big companies do that for few years now - either with used language or graphics (namely Corporate Memphis and its various uncanny variants) or with both. It's enough to look at patch notes for mobile apps: these are exactly cutesy, fake friendly. 99% of the time you won't learn what was changed or fixed but instead you get these unrelated comments trying to show how cool company xyz is. It's unironic "hello fellow kids" meme approach.
- josefritzishere 2y agoWhen companies take actions hostile to their user base obvious things happen.
- shaky-carrousel 2y agoWhat a great idea, scaring companies probing bluesky. That surely won't backfire and will cement bluesky as a Xitter alternative.
- miohtama 2y agoBluesky audience is certain kind, more left leaning, finding corporations evil. Adobe's experiment shows that it is unlikely any big corp could go there any time until the audience is more diverse, less cancel culture.
- pm90 2y agoThe reaction seems specific to Adobe which has (probably) not been a good steward of its role as a tool for creatives. I don’t think other big corps would get that reaction.
- jsheard 2y agoExactly, compare and contrast how bsky users engage with an Adobe peer that creatives are on good terms with. https://bsky.app/profile/procreate.com/post/3llfkv3mqas2s https://bsky.app/profile/procreate.com/post/3llfkv3mqas2s
- slowmovintarget 2y agoThat post seems an awful lot like pandering to the crowd there. More adroit PR, perhaps.
- cosmic_cheese 2y agoThat’s part of it, but it helps a lot that Procreate’s both extremely affordable and a single purchase. That’s a great combo when your target audience are artists, a crowd that is generally pretty cash-strapped. Creative Cloud’s cost is actually pretty steep over time. It also helps that when Procreate adds features, it’s always stuff that’s desired by a large chunk of their users and is broadly useful. Contrast this to e.g. Photoshop, where for many of us eliminating 98% of the new features added since CS2 would make no material difference in day to day usage. Adobe would be well served by building “heirloom” versions of their tools that are single-purchase, affordable, and have a fixed CS1/CS2-ish feature set with all development thereafter being put into optimization, stability, etc. That’d be plenty for even many commercial artists, let alone “prosumers” and more casual users.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoThis was fascinating to see unfold. What if there was a social network that had taste and rejected things that suck? Is it a failure of Bluesky to never become the global town square, if it means being a place where a brand can't find it a safe space to promote itself? Can a social network thread the needle of having enough traffic to be worthwhile but not so much as to attract the Eternal September?
- dimal 2y agoThe problem is the microblogging format. No microblogging site can be a good town square. It’s not designed for discussion. It’s designed to allow people to shout into the void, hoping that someone hears them, so that they feel for a moment that their lives have meaning.
- cryptopian 2y agoMaybe a better question is whether we even need a global town square. I've had Twitter and Bluesky and the difference between them and a real town square is that you're always performing publically to an audience you can't possibly know. I've found far more rewarding relationships posting on niche forums and even subreddits because you get a sense of the people who use and administrate them, and you're safe in the knowledge you can't easily find virality.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoI agree, it's just that the town square will exist regardless because of the billions of people and the propensity of most of them to gravitate to the most mainstream option. It feels ideal that that's quarantined on Twitter so the more niche spaces stay high quality.
- fmxsh 2y agoThe town square is the mainstream's niche.
- Barrin92 2y ago>Is it a failure of Bluesky to never become the global town square, No, because that's an oxymoron. There is no such thing because a precondition for a town square (which in reality is a community of people, not a place) is that there exists shared set of values, context and conduct between its members. The state of nature on a global platform, just like in a megacity is to be an anonymous, atomized individual who ideas or products can be sold to.
- jmclnx 2y agoCharging a subscription fee is crazy for a product that is very expensive. I do not know why they are still around.
- rchaud 2y agoEnterprise-level budgets.
- maxerickson 2y agoAn annual subscription to the whole suite is less than a weeks pay for someone that would be using it in the US, so no need for the Enterprise-level.
- rchaud 2y agoEnterprise can pay the rising susbcription costs without blinking, a solo business will think twice.
- donatj 2y agoMuscle memory. I could probably get by with something cheaper but I have been using photoshop for thirty years at this point, I know hot keys and workflows at a spiritual level at this point.
- ge96 2y agoI have this popup in Win 10 that will not go away, out of nowhere "DING" "Would you like to use Adobe PDF?" It's built into Windows like wth
- adzm 2y agoI pay $20 a month for the educational discount and my kids get access to every Adobe product. It is an amazing deal. When you are an adult not in school you probably don't need "all apps" and it is relatively inexpensive to get just the product you use. Anyway, they are still around because they still have some of the best set of features, and are industry standards, though this may change in the future and in some areas is already in progress (and I welcome that! They need competition to push them)
- megaman821 2y agoAs a lurker on both Bluesky and Twitter, I find Bluesky is a much more hostile place. Twitter is much more absurd but there is not as much anger.
- badapple1 2y ago[flagged]
- sundaeofshock 2y agoI’m bad at hints. Can you be explicit and tell us who the bad apples are?
- badapple1 2y ago[flagged]
- sundaeofshock 2y agoI have a much different experience on Twitter. It has a much higher tolerance for racism, misogyny, gay/transphobia, and wild conspiracies. It got much worse after the election and I finally bailed on it after the inauguration. I have not missed it.
- megaman821 2y agoBluesky has all that but just in the anti direction. I was hoping for a more absolute of not disparaging anyone based on their race, gender, or sexual preference.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mjmsmith 2y agoWhat does "the anti direction" mean? It's mean to racists?
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> “What’s fueling your creativity right now?” Hilarious thin marketspeak. But sure, blame the social platform.
- gradientsrneat 2y agoI've become so disenchanted with internet vitriol that it's surreal seeing these trolls attack a social media presence that's geniunely deserving. Still, I wouldn't invite any of these people to my house.
- d0gsg0w00f 2y ago> Still, I wouldn't invite any of these people to my house. I think this is one of the most profound statements I've read all year. Perfectly sums up all the quiet backlash by middle America against the trolls that have pulled the party into extremes. It's not that they're bad people, they just get over excited and nobody wants to deal with the headache right now. I see it at work in the lunch room conversations where someone starts spewing passive aggressive hate and it really kills the vibe.
- energy123 2y agoNegative people should be terminated after a few days of confirmation that they are negative. The dose makes the poison so you have to get them out quickly.
- bni 2y agoHas anyone actually stopped using Photoshop? What are they migrating to?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vachina 2y agoAny number of AI apps out there can easily replace 95% of Photoshop’s usecase.
- dharmab 2y agoWhich ones?
- vachina 2y agoOne that I use frequently is FaceApp. They seem to on device face touchups. For subject removal Google photos is very good at it, though it needs to upload your photo.
- karaterobot 2y ago95% of use cases is a stretch, even if you mean "a combination of many different AI apps with their own subscriptions, totaling more than the cost of a subscription to everything Adobe makes, not just Photoshop". Photoshop does a lot of stuff.
- masswerk 2y ago1) Switched about 4 years ago 2) to Affinity Photo & Designer (perpetual license)
- coldcode 2y agoI have Photoshop, but I use Affinity Photo for 99% of what I do (make digital art, AP is used for assembly and effects). I use Photoshop for a few special effects, but often it's not worth the effort.
- 2y ago
- sidcool 2y agoHonestly, Adobe deserves it. Their early cancellation fees is atrocious.
- magicmicah85 2y agoI pay the extra cost to make sure I can cancel after my project's done. I only ever use Photoshop/Premiere and After Effects a few times a year, so it's easier for me.
- _kush 2y agoA reminder that photopea.com is a great photoshop alternative and it's web-based
- ThinkBeat 2y agoPhotopea is great, and you can do a lot, but it is not near the functionality of Photoshop. However, most people do not need most of that.
- Suppafly 2y agoThe alternatives are getting better, but it always seems like there is one action that would be trivial in photoshop that always end up being impossible in the competitors, and it ends up being exactly the thing you need for your project.
- doright 2y agoExamples? (I don't use Photoshop)
- mxuribe 2y agoWas about to mention photopea as well...I should add that i'm by no means a person who uses this type of software on a regular basis....But whenever i need it i reach for either GIMP or photopea, and last few years, its been photopea far more often. Honestly, i wish Adobe would still offer the conventional license, but with an additional hosting option that consumer can *choose* to activate and pay more for, or not...so that, basically: * I pay a one-time license to use photoshop offline - and for however long i wish (understanding that after its end of life i may not eligible for security updates, but that's fair) * Now, for storing of files, i would need to of course store them locally on my machine. * But, if i *chose* to pay an ongoing subscription, that is when Adobe would host files for me....so i can still use their product offline, and they only charge me for use of online file storage...and i wouldn't mind if there were a premium on that charge, since i get that i would be paying for an ongoing storage service. That gives me choice, it gives them money (both for licensing and ongoing hosting subscription), and i would figure everyone would be content.... ...but, i guess the current world does not work that way, eh? So, i guess i will continue to avoid their products, heading towards alternatives like photopea, Gimp, etc.
- adzm 2y agoAdobe is the one major company trying to be ethical with its AI training data and no one seems to even care. The AI features in Photoshop are the best around in my experience and come in handy constantly for all sorts of touchup work. Anyway I don't really think they deserve a lot of the hate they get, but I do hope this encourages development of viable alternatives to their products. Photoshop is still pretty much peerless. Illustrator has a ton of competitors catching up. After Effects and Premiere for video editing are getting overtaken by Davinci Resolve -- though for motion graphics it is still hard to beat After Effects. Though I do love that Adobe simply uses JavaScript for its expression and scripting language.
- Angostura 2y agoNow that would have been a really interesting thing for them to start a conversation about on Bluesky. They would have got some genuine engagement if they wanted it. Much better than the transparently vapid marketing-speak
- masswerk 2y agoI think, part of the fiasco is about that engagement posters are not really welcomed on Bluesky. And, "What’s fueling your creativity right now?” is a pure engagement post, contributing nothing on its side of the conversation. Hence, it's more like another attempt to harvest Adobe's subscribers. — For X/Twitter-bound marketing it's probably fine, at least, much what we had become used to, but it totally fails the Bluesky community. (Lesson leaned: not all social media are the same.)
- jsbisviewtiful 2y ago> Adobe is the one major company trying to be ethical Adobe is cannibalizing their paid C-Suite artists by pumping out image generators to their enterprise customers. How is that ethical? They are double dipping and screwing over their longtime paying artists
- multimoon 2y agoThis is I think a narrow viewpoint that assumes the AI will ever get truly as good as a human artist. Will it get good enough for most people? Probably, but if not Adobe then four others will do the same thing, and as another commenter pointed out Adobe is the only one even attempting to make AI tools ethically. I think the hate is extremely misdirected. AI tech and tools aren’t just going to go away, and people aren’t going to just not make a tool you don’t like, so sticking your head in the sand and pretending like it will stop if you scream loud enough is not going to help, you should instead be encouraging efforts like Adobe’s to make these tools ethically.
- simonw 2y agoYeah, they posted this: > Hey, we're Adobe! We're here to connect with the artists, designers, and storytellers who bring ideas to life. What's fueling your creativity right now? > Drop a reply, tag a creator, or share your latest work—we'd love to see what inspires you! That's such a bland, corporate message. It feels totally inauthentic. Do Adobe (a corporation) really "love to see what inspires you" or do they just want engagement for their new account? I'm not surprised in the slightest that it triggered a pile-on.
- magicmicah85 2y agoThey want engagement for their new account, it's what anyone who posts on social media wants.
- simonw 2y agoRight, but you need to be a whole lot less obvious about it. Adobe's message here is a case study in what NOT to do.
- masswerk 2y agoYes, but it's not what social media users want. How about posting tips, small micro courses, behind the scene stories about what motivated some choices in the app, anything useful or endearing? Not just harvesting likes and account names?
- magicmicah85 2y agoI’m talking about when anyone post on social media. It’s all about engagement. People don’t post on social media in the hopes that no one sees or replies to them. So I find it silly that people are upset at Adobe for having the most generic “hey we joined, show us what you’re working on” versus the useless engagement posts that are templates of “most people can’t figure out what the answer is” when the image is “two plus two equals ?”. To your point of useful info, I’m sure Adobe would get there. They just joined the site and got bullied off. I doubt they’re going to care about the site now, but it’d be funny if they tried a second post and just trudged through it.
- Apreche 2y agoI’m always the first one to criticize companies for exploitative and evil business practices. Adobe is far from innocent. However, I will argue their subscription model itself is actually better than the previous model. The reality is that Adobe has a large team of engineers to create and maintain several high end professional digital art creation tools. They also frequently add new and excellent features to those tools. That costs money. This money has to come from somewhere. With the old model Creative Suite 6 Master Collection cost over $2600. They updated that software every two years. The maximum Creative Cloud subscription today costs $1440 for two years. They even have a cheap Photography plan for $20 a month with Photoshop and Lightroom. That’s $480 for two years. Photoshop 6 cost $700+ alone all by itself with no Lightroom. Why would Adobe allow for much lower prices, even considering inflation? Because they get reliable cash flow. Money keeps coming in regularly. That’s much easier for keeping people employed and paid than a huge cash infusion every other year and a trickle until your next release. It’s just not feasible to sell software that way anymore. Of course the argument is that with the old model you didn’t need to update. You could just pay for CS5 or 6 and use it forever without ever paying again. That’s true. And I guess that’s viable if you are want software that is never updated, never gets new features, and never gets bugfixes and support. I would argue that a user that can get by without updating their tools, and has no use for new features, is not a professional. They can get by with free or cheap competitors, and they should. Professional digital artists do need and want those updates. They are the kind of people that were buying every version of Creative Suite in the old model. For those users, paying a subscription is a huge improvement. It keeps the updates and bugfixes coming regularly instead of rarely. It funds development of new and powerful features. It keeps Adobe solvent, so the software doesn’t die. It lowers the overall price paid by the user significantly. Plenty of things we can criticize with Adobe. Bugs they haven’t fixed. Crashy software sometimes. Products they come out with and then give up on. Doing dark patterns and fees to prevent people from unsubscribing. But the subscription model itself is a net positive compared to the old way.
- vachina 2y ago> than a huge cash infusion every other year and a trickle until your next release It’s a very good incentive to keep the entire company on their toes. Adobe will have to keep making new features for people to justify paying for a new version, instead of rehashing the same software, and then rent-seek with a subscription.
- ferguess_k 2y agoThe first comment seems to be interesting: > I don't like subscriptions but that's not the biggest problem. The biggest issue is Adobe's software has been getting worse as the years have passed. It's slow, incredibly buggy, their new features are often an embarrassment, and Adobe seems to do nothing other than increasing prices. And therein lies the issue with subscriptions - the user keeps paying higher prices and the company has zero motivation to fix bugs I wonder how hard it is to create the core functionalities of Adobe Photoshop. Maybe many people have different definitions of what are the core functionalities, thus turning making a replacement software very tough.
- thejohnconway 2y agoThere’s plenty of replacements which are fine. Many are better to use for many tasks. The problem is lock-in in professional contexts. Having a problem with some feature in a PSD? “I don’t wanna pay for Photoshop” isn’t usually an acceptable excuse. If open source projects and other companies had gathered around an open file format, maybe there would be some leverage, but they all use their own formats.
- mattskr 2y agoControversial take: I'm happy they went monthly paid subscription. You think a budding graphic designer of one year could afford the $1,500+ up front cost? The seven seas were the only option. HOWEVER, 60 a month is too high for a product quality that is tanking. I was okay with it the first few years, but PS and Illustrator's performance noticeably have gone straight to shit for absolutely no benefit except for a little stupid gimmicks that offer zero productivity boosts. Indesign, they've mostly left alone, which I'm happy about because it's like Oreos. Stop fucking with the recipe, you made the perfect cookie. There are no more kingdoms to conquer. Simply find performance boosts, that's it. The reliability of my files and getting work done is more important than anything else. Truly. That's what Adobe USED to stand for. Pure raw UI intuitive productivity and getting shit done. Now, it's a fucking clown show that cares about their social media and evangelism. I hear on the video side they've super dropped the ball, but I'm not much for motion graphics outside of Blender. Stop with the bullshit "telemetry" garbage that bogs down my computer and AI scrapping of our data. Old files that used to run fine on my older computers run like shit on my new one. I know damn well there's bullshit going on in the background. That's 80% of the issue. The other 20% of problems are running of the mill stuff. I am perfectly happy paying for functional, productive software. 60 bucks a month for that is fine as a freelance graphic designer and marketer. However creative cloud is quickly becoming dysfunctional and unproductive. That's the problem.
- Suppafly 2y ago>You think a budding graphic designer of one year could afford the $1,500+ up front cost? Yes? It's pretty normal to take out a loan or use a credit card to purchase tools to setup your career for years to come. That budding graphic designer probably spent $2000+ on a new Mac. Honestly though subscriptions only make sense for business customers, they really fuck over the home users that would like to buy the software once and use it for several years. Hobby photographers and such are either priced out of the market, or stuck with old computers running older versions from before the subscription push.
- mattskr 2y agoLol, I started my career during the housing market crash. Even though I had decent credit, especially for my age, my credit cards were reduced due to "market volatility" to $20 above what my balance was. Taking out a loan to start a career? I guess I was born to the wrong parents lol. Not everyone starts out on great footing in their careers. To this day, I still don't buy "new" computer parts to upgrade my computer. It's a waste of money to me because I grew up only being to afford used or, best case, clearance. Also, no Mac. Macs are for rich people with zero taste and sense and too much money to burn. Regardless of what anyone says, Macs dollar for dollar compared to a Windows machine, Adobe doesn't perform better on a Mac. I've tested it against computers where ever I would work, my older laptop versus their newer macs. Side by side, it's like 90% functions faster on Windows. Plus there's this weird ass memory issue where every PS file has an extra ~500mb of bloat on a Mac. No clue why. But yes, subscriptions do make sense for business customers which, a lot of graphic designers do freelance on the side. Again, exactly why Adobe SHOULD be a subscription. Adobe isn't a hobbyist toolset and they need to stop treating it as such. When home users "discovered" Adobe and they started placating to them, that's when it went south. If they bumped up the price to $100 bucks a month and obliterated the "I'm just a quirky creative home user who likes to dabble" pandering, GOOD. I'd keep my subscription. Instead, I'm actively building up my experience in alternative tools so I can get away from Adobe. Not every piece software should be "Karen" easy especially when it's designed for a professional market. I want my software to be brutally efficient and productive. Not "a vibe". My "vibe" is getting away from the computer. Software should help me annihilate my workload as quickly as possible so I can go live a real life more.
- nashashmi 2y agoCompanies should stay off social media … Unless they are social companies. Companies that try to advertise on social media to their consumer base do harm to the social aspect. This is why twitter and Facebook and instagram went from healthy social interactions to just marketing fluffs giving the media companies heavier valuation
- broodbucket 2y agoNotoriously user-hostile companies should, at least.
- bastard_op 2y agoI remember pirating photoshop in the late 90's for the every now and then I need to edit a photo (usually something dumb or screwing around). I was never going to pay anything let alone the real cost to use it for random crap I needed it for, so when they began CS with subscriptions and such, I simply moved to The Gimp. For 25 years Gimp has been "good enough" for me, and now it's truly good enough for professionals too as I have family that do graphic design and now use it where prior they were Photoshop snobs. Adobe ought to be glad anyone still cares about them. Sadly what I know them mostly for now is their vermin web services major eCommerce companies seem to love to use (sad for the consumers stuck using this garbage). I see "adobedtm.com" domain show up constantly in noscript plugins, and I know nothing good can come from them, but NOT allowing it usually breaks the websites. I really, REALLY try not to do business with companies using adobe in their web services for this reason.
- greatgib 2y agoSomehow Adobe can say thank you, for free they get honest feedback about the crap they do without having to hire an expensive consulting firm or a survey company. Now they can know why their sells are platoning at least and people would churn as must as possible.
- broodbucket 2y agoAs per those leaks, Adobe employees are already very aware that everyone despises them.
- proee 2y agoNo love for Adobe. I have fond memories of their Updater downloading 1GB plus "updates", even though my trial EXPIRED.
- waltercool 2y ago[dead]
- fortran77 2y agoBlueSky can be brutal! I wonder how it got a reputation of being the kinder, gentler alternative?
- skyyler 2y agoBlueSky is a very kind place in my experience. I don't get people asking me to justify my existence like I do on Twitter. Seriously, people on Twitter demand I debate them about the validity of my life. That has yet to happen on BlueSky.
- CaptainFever 2y agoI think it depends on your identity. There are some personal identities (no, the identity is not about hating someone) that attract a lot of hatred and harassment on BlueSky.
- skyyler 2y agoI wonder what could attract hatred on BlueSky other than being Adobe...
- broodbucket 2y agoPeople interact with brands differently to how they interact with humans.
- rchaud 2y agoIndeed. Humans dont make you talk to a chatbot for help or have 'no-reply' in their email addresses.
- abhinavk 2y agoIt's kinder to people, especially kind people.
- whimsicalism 2y ago
- lucasRW 2y ago[flagged]
- moonlion_eth 2y agoAlternative social media contains alternative personalities
- sandspar 2y ago"Join our site if you're enraged" users act enraged.
- w4rh4wk5 2y agoNicely done, people on Bluesky! clap
- thot_experiment 2y agoHere's a really great video detailing just how much Adobe (and Autodesk etc) hate their users. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4mdMMu-3fc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4mdMMu-3fc
- paxys 2y agoGood. Keep this corporate PR nonsense away from Bluesky.
- ddtaylor 2y agoHey were a big company here to take your feedback and engage with you. Ogh, nvm, lol this platform has real users that actually engage about their opinions? dips out
- indigo0086 2y agoBluecry is it's name-o #NA
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- neuroelectron 2y ago[flagged]
- seivan 2y ago[dead]
- nullhole 2y agoI mean, the stunt they pulled to effectively release CS2 as free-to-use abandonware was pretty good. Still use it to this day, still works fine.
- chrisldgk 2y agoAnother great reason to drop the great „For Profit (Creative) Software“ video[1] for insight on why Adobe‘s and Autodesk‘s hostile business practices hurt creative professionals so much [1] https://youtu.be/I4mdMMu-3fc https://youtu.be/I4mdMMu-3fc
- bobjordan 2y agoI had to call it a day and cancel this year. Yearly sub approaching $700 per year just to open photoshop files a few times per year and maybe edit a pdf file? Fk it I’ll find another way.
- modzu 2y agokrita is the way
- misswaterfairy 2y agoAffinity Photo is excellent, indeed Designer (Illustrator alternative) and Publisher (InDesign alternative) are excellent as well. Qoppa PDF Studio is a great alternative to Adobe Acrobat. Both offer perpetual licences.
- _xtrimsky 2y agoThey have a photoshop plan for 10$ / month. Like you I rarely open Photoshop, maybe once or twice a month.
- haswell 2y agoAs a photographer, I have a love/hate relationship with Adobe. I’m not a fan of many aspects of their business, but Lightroom is a (sometimes) excellent product. On the one hand, I don’t have much sympathy for Adobe. On the other hand, this whole situation is why I am not on social media these days with the exception of HN and niche subreddits. Even if much of the criticism they receive is warranted, the social media climate is just so incredibly toxic that I want no part of it. Feels like there has to be a better way to be social on the Internet, but as time goes on I’m increasingly not sure if humans can handle it once a certain scale is reached.
- scarab92 2y agoOnline communities have an inherent death spiral dynamic, unless you actively moderate away toxic people. These people drive away normal folks creating an ever more distilled community of unpleasant folks. How many normal people are going to hang around places like reddit and bluesky that are seemingly now filled with hate and conspiracy theories.
- bigyabai 2y ago[dead]
- CaptainFever 2y agoRelated: https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2015/10/14/the-evaporative-cooling-effect-in-social-network/ https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2015/10/14/the-evaporativ...
- sbszllr 2y agoYup, I prefer Lightroom to Capture One, especially for film-related workflows. But I just can't go back to their predatory pricing practices, and the absolute malware of a programme that creative cloud is.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoI switched to capture 1 due to how poorly adobe handles fujifilm raw file even today. Workflow wise it is basically the same functions just in different places. Doesn’t take long to get up and running.
- Peacefulz 2y agoI still use PS7. No adobe creative cloud, and all you need to accomplish some awesome stuff.
- sandspar 2y agoSocial media really brings out the best in people doesn't it? Dogpiling, self-congratulation, mimicry, dehumanization, scapegoating. It's so lucky for society that many people spend hours a day on there!
- stego-tech 2y agoMan, this was fun to see in real time. A site whose earliest adopters were Twitter refugees who hated the crypto/AI/NFT boosters, created actual art, and ultimately left Twitter because of rampant fascism and bigotry, effectively cyberbullied the company and its Head of Social Media so badly the latter left the site entirely. You have to be pretty bad at your job to misread the room so terribly. Just taking a casual look at Clearsky’s block rankings would show how many lists are specifically blocking and targeting brands, griftos, fascists, and bigots of various stripes, and likely dissuade you from approaching the community without some form of battle plan. Treating BlueSky like a “new Twitter” is a dangerous mistake to make, something Adobe learned the hard way. To make matters worse, they also poisoned the community well to the point there’s a fresh witch hunt out for brands and companies to add to block lists, thus harming everyone else’s “engagement”.
- junto 2y agoThis is a spot on analysis. Bluesky and Mastodon are full of people that felt and continue to feel disenfranchised and excluded. They embraced Bluesky because it reminded them of what Twitter used to be and had found themselves what they felt was a relatively safe space. Companies like Adobe and other major tech players have enabled the hostile environment we see growing every day. It’s no wonder that disingenuous posts like this from predatory companies receive such a backlash.
- stego-tech 2y agoYup. The increasing fragmentation of social media means you really need to understand the community you’re targeting before engaging in outreach. More communities are going to be less tolerant of brands and advertisers in general given current events and over-saturation of advertising in general, so every engagement point matters way more.
- 55555 2y agoAdobe runs what must be one of the largest deceptive rebills. The vast majority of users signing up for a monthly plan do not realize that it is actually an "annual plan, billed monthly" and thus that if they cancel after one month (for example) they'll be billed for the remaining 11 immediately. I honestly don't know how they haven't faced FTC action for this, as it's been their primary model for 5-10 years now.
- sepositus 2y agoWasn't there some action around this like a year ago? Can't find it now, but I thought it was investigated at some point.
- 55555 2y agoIt seems you're right. I can't find how big the fine was. ChatGPT says it is still ongoing. Not sure if that's right. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/06/ftc-takes-action-against-adobe-executives-hiding-fees-preventing-consumers-easily-cancelling https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/06/...
- _Algernon_ 2y agoWe all have access to chatgpt. If we want hallucination ridden bullshit, we'll find it ourselves.
- hliyan 2y agoThe phenomenon at work here is: if product being produced by a profit-seeking enterprise can be rented instead of being sold, said enterprise will eventually find a way to do it, then over time, rather than a single bill, it will attempt to rent out individual aspects of the now product-turned-service, followed by cost cutting that degrades the default service level while introducing additional service levels for which the consumer will have to pay additional fees, and finally making switching away to competitors progressively difficult for the consumer. This is a natural outcome of profit-maximization.
- __loam 2y agoThis is the primary reason why creatives despise Adobe despite some people here arguing that it's for the AI art generation. They hate that too but the biggest pain point by far is the toxic business relation you have to maintain to continue to use industry standard tooling.
- _el1s7 2y agoSingle bill for modern software doesn't make sense economically anymore. Do you want updates? You want new versions? New features? Support? Single bill it's like buying an IPhone once and then you expect to get a new one for free each year.
- jspdown 2y agoAll the digital artists I know don't use and want new features in Photophop. And more generally, most non-tech businesses values more stability than having new features. Single bill makes a lot of sense for many users.
- valiant55 2y agoDoes a JetBrains style license not address this exactly? You buy the current version and one year of updates. If you want updates after that you have to renew.
- _Algernon_ 2y ago>Do you want updates? You want new versions? New features? Support? No. This was a solved problem decades ago. Purchase includes minor version updates, then you keep it for life without updates. Upgrading to the next version is a choice. Why did we collectively agree that customer choice does not matter?
- throwaway2037 2y ago> has left Adobe’s standing with many photographers in shambles What does this mean? Do normie photographers have any realistic choice except Adobe products? Are their sales falling? I doubt it. This quote reads like sour grapes.
- Tabular-Iceberg 2y agoWhat did Adobe possibly think they could gain by posting on a communist web site? They really didn’t think this one through.
- isoprophlex 2y ago> “Adobe couldn’t explain why it let its once excellent relationship with photographers and media lapse, only that it is sorry that happened.” Maybe shouldn't have listened to asshat MBAs and overpaid management consultants that infiltrate your boardroom with their "haha number go up" bullshit
- throwaway743 2y agoPirate their shit.
- aktuel 2y agoArtists who hate Adobe should actively support the development of open source alternatives. That is the only way this situation is going to improve.
- somedude895 2y ago> “Go back to the fascist-owned site where they enjoy supporting AI-generated art like your brand does,” wrote Evlyn Moreau. Yeah this is why Bluesky will never be a serious and widely used social platform. It's the same sort of cesspool as the right-wing alternatives that popped up a few years back, just more self-righteous.
- computerthings 2y ago[dead]
- Kye 2y agoThere's a whole mute list for this sort of person: https://bsky.app/profile/mackuba.eu/lists/3kp6zdqoscy2x https://bsky.app/profile/mackuba.eu/lists/3kp6zdqoscy2x You can also run Blockenheimer on likes and reposts for any especially toxic anti-AI takes to catch huge chunks of them: https://blockenheimer.click https://blockenheimer.click
- gs17 2y agoThe block lists presented as a solution are a part of why I didn't care to stick around on Bluesky. 99% of what I did was manually blocking/muting people who I wouldn't want to interact with. The site almost never presented me with people I would want to talk to, and outsourcing the blocking to some stranger doesn't really solve the real problem.
- esseph 2y agoSo what you're looking for is news, but not social media?
- slimebot80 2y agoI don't trust them at all. The amount of traffic to various domains is incredible coming out of their desktop apps. But mostly, when they first started the subscription model I wasn't furious about it - until I realised I was stuck on a yearly plan, and I'm usually pretty good at detecting when I'm being tricked into that. A part of me doubts I was ever asked correctly.
- torginus 2y agoI just don't get how Adobe didn't get dethroned after being so unpopular for so long. There are so many Photoshop competitors, many of which are quite good, they seem to be ripe for disruption. The last version I used was CS6, which came out more than a decade ago, and even that had more than a good enough feature set. Blender is slowly taking over 3D, why can't 2D be disrupted similarly?
- oreally 2y agoI'm pretty sure it's because just about every applicable art school has enforced their student's output to be done in adobe's products - meaning that Adobe has a firm grip on the educator's market. As the saying goes, hook them in when they're young and they'll be too lazy and vested to move away from their products for a lifetime.
- bdangubic 2y agoTo a degree, Oracle was doing the same thing. Years ago I was teaching Data Science courses at the local Uni and Dean pulled me in and asked me if I can teach Introductory course in Web Dev, the current teacher was going on maternity leave. I was like heck yea, LFG. Student reaches out to me few days before the quarter was to start and asks if they need to buy the book since it is $285 (like $500 in today’s dollars). I was taken aback and went to my office and book was actually at my desk, “web development with oracle forms” … :) that was the course that was thought… (I didn’t of course - that was the last quarter I was asked :) )
- karaterobot 2y agoThe problem is that Adobe still makes the best tools in a lot of categories. They also have the whole ecosystem lock-in model that also worked for Apple: their products work together, so if you try to replace Photoshop, you're probably still using Illustrator, and After Effects, etc. except your workflow isn't as smooth anymore, because there's one tool in the chain that works differently than the rest.
- gs17 2y agoAnd on top of that, if your clients are Adobe users, you probably will have to be as well or you risk what they send you not opening properly. Back in the Creative Suite days, my parents (small graphic design studio) upgraded largely because a client upgraded and they needed to be compatible with the newer version of the file format. Creative Cloud "fixed" that, I guess.
- saidinesh5 2y agoNot exactly related, but i enjoyed this tiny slightly funny clip about this topic: Every "AI" artist right now - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Sjnr_tLLKQ0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Sjnr_tLLKQ0
- rpastuszak 2y agoI keep a list of alternatives to Adobe software (for posts like this): https://untested.sonnet.io/notes/alternatives-to-adobe/ https://untested.sonnet.io/notes/alternatives-to-adobe/
- vung 2y agoBluesky isn't representative of Adobe's userbase, so this reaction doesn't really matter. The people who decide to write a scathing reply to Adobe's Bluesky account are irrelevant outside of their Bluesky bubble.
- nomilk 2y ago> Adobe’s unpopularity can be traced back to a decision it made over 10 years ago when it shifted from perpetual software licensing to subscription pricing. My understand is that Adobe deliberately made it difficult to cancel. I don’t even use Adobe, yet am well aware of their antics, indicating how far bad behaviour spreads via word of mouth.
- _7acn 2y agoIn my country, what Adobe is doing is punishable by imprisonment for a period of 6 months to 8 years. Yet, for some reason, they operate in this market without the slightest problem. “Whoever, with the intention of obtaining financial gain, causes another person to enter into a financially disadvantageous arrangement, or otherwise dispose of their own or someone else’s assets, by means of deception, or by exploiting a mistake or their inability to understand the nature of the action undertaken, shall be liable to imprisonment for a period of 6 months to 8 years”
- thiht 2y agoThat sounds like a huge stretch.
- _7acn 2y agoHow exactly? They lead people into signing a one-year contract without any possibility of withdrawal by misleading customers into believing it's a monthly subscription. Personally, I know two people who had to block their payment cards through their banks because it was otherwise impossible to cancel their Adobe subscription.
- nubinetwork 2y agoI'm happy with kdenlive and gimp TYVM...
- djoint 2y ago[flagged]
- djoint 2y ago[flagged]
- djoint 2y ago[flagged]
- mr90210 2y agoI wish it were that simple. As an occasional amateur photographer, I’ve looked for alternatives to Lightroom with a simple UX, and to my surprise the alternatives are far more complex and unintuitive than a old software such as Lightroom.
- danielktdoranie 2y ago[flagged]
- Crosseye_Jack 2y agoAs mush as I enjoy shitting on Adobe, I also want to encourage companies to embrace platforms other than Twitter. Simply because at times it's the best way to get customer service these days. I think I would have had more respect for Adobe if they had left the posts up.
- michaelcampbell 2y agoThey haven't figured out yet that you should make software for customers, not for your MBAs/Product Managers.
- delfugal 2y agoAdobe has perfected digital blackmail. After using and promoting their products for years to create our work, the switch off access to view or print any of it unless we keep paying blackmail monthly fees. I don't want to edit my old work, but to lock me out of viewing it is nothing short of BLACKMAIL. As people change jobs or retire, they lose all access to their work. Sick.
- DeathArrow 2y agoAdobe charging subscription is one of the most asshole moves I've seen in software. I understand that you can charge monthly if you provide a service. You can charge monthly for SaaS or PaaS, but charging monthly for a desktop application can't win the goodwill of the people.
- mrangle 2y agoA company who who has a shiny thing that it charges money for, posting on a site specifically created for the expression of the malcontent characteristic of toxic malcontents, and the output is predictable. Undoubtedly Adobe has legions of users who take a more nuanced view of Adobe and who would also be the type to use Bluesky. And yet. I'd consider the complaints to be essentially the emotions that come up when people covet unaffordable privately created property.
- wildpeaks 2y agoThey'd get a lot less pushback if the annual plan was billed anually like other services, they wouldn't even need to refund part of the remaining time when users cancel auto-renew.
- WalterBright 2y ago> there would be no respite if I paid annually, nor could I receive one of those special invitations for a 35% discount Offering a discount to new customers while no discounts for existing, loyal customers always seemed backwards to me. Back in the Zortech days, we'd offer upgrades to existing customers at a steep discount.
- gs17 2y ago> we'd offer upgrades That's part of the difference. With a subscription model, you don't need customers to want to buy your upgrades (they're forced to pay for them), you benefit the most from locking them into your ecosystem as best you can. Adobe doesn't want to make existing customers happy, they want to make it difficult for unhappy ones to stop paying every month. At that point, discounts to new customers makes sense, since it traps new people into paying you.
- WalterBright 2y agoTrapping people into paying is never going to be a successful long-term strategy. I tried to unsubscribe from Disney+. Their website says all over the place "cancel at any time", but I could not find any place where I could cancel it. I wound up canceling it by getting my credit card company to block their charges. It left a pretty sour taste, and I'd be very reluctant to ever sign up for it again.
- mvdtnz 2y agoWell this seems needlessly hostile.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]