15 ms·
Barcelona buys apartment building at center of eviction protests
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/9QHwT https://archive.today/9QHwT
- pestatije 2y agoi have to pay €950 for an apartment 30km from the CBD, why on earth does this guy have the right to only pay €700 to live bang in the middle of the CBD?
- bell-cot 2y agoYou're paying (my guess) a market rate, which scales decently. He's getting a "fame du jour" special deal - which for-sure does not.
- pestatije 2y agowhatever the deal hes getting, why is it on my and everybody elses taxes?
- bell-cot 2y agoMunicipal politics often resembles a Reality TV wheel-squeaking contest. He worked to get on the show, played, and won a modest prize. Was it worth all his time & hassle? I'll guess "no", but I don't follow Spanish politics. Meanwhile, a wide variety of Spanish lotteries offer you chances to win vastly larger prizes, at taxpayer expense, with a quick & easy ticket purchase. Have you bought one? (/s?)
- miguelxt 2y agoWhat do you mean at taxpayer expense? Spanish's National Lottery is one of the few State-run enterprises that returns real money to the taxpayer.
- bell-cot 2y agoNet, yes. But inside that Lottery - ticket sales are income, and collected winnings are expenses. And I'd bet that unclaimed winnings end back up in the government's coffers - therefor, you claiming your winnings means that you benefit at taxpayer expense.
- aziaziazi 2y agoI hate seeing my taxes wasted on roads maintenance, airports and medical facilities for the ones that didn’t bother having a physical activity or eating healthy during they life (the list can go very long). Don’t take me wrong, I’m happy to have roads and hospitals but not at that scale. I pay vastly more for those than what I benefit from. On the other hand I’m very happy to freely use the new cycling roads and benefit from a somewhat stable and secure society where the chances are low to encounter a furious outcast that want to rob me.
- luckylion 2y agoYou've misunderstood the point. Roads, airports, medical facilities are shared infrastructure. Private living arrangements are not.
- aziaziazi 2y agoFair point. I was about to respond: [One could see some similitudes in the occupation of a rented place for some years and the occupation of ~5m2 on the road for some seconds. Also public hospitals are often congested so they are shared but you have to wait... I admit you wait shorter than for an appartement] However as I considered that and what you wrote, I'm not sure about it. I post it for posterity.
- guax 2y agoMaybe the best sentiment is to ask why do you have to pay 950 and not why some small minority can get a better deal.
- titanomachy 2y ago30km? And you commute to Barcelona?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Ambolia 2y agoIt's a publicity stunt to score points while solving nothing. Same issue in Spain with squatters, it allows the goverment to confront tenants with landlords while the goverment does nothing.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ljm 2y agoYour problem still isn’t with the guy paying lower rent, but scarcity amplified by companies repurposing residential housing stock as tourist accommodation. You too could live right in the city at an affordable rate if AirBnB and property owners didn’t force out the locals to make a quick buck on holiday makers.
- glompers 2y agoThe article says that renting residential units for short terms (of less than 32 days) is already banned citywide in Barcelona. Tourists can stay in hotels.
- yes_really 2y agoNo. It seems very clear that his problem is with the guy paying lower rent than him for a better apartment. If the subsidy is done by the government (though regulations, direct subsidy, rent-control, etc), and if he pays those taxes, then his feeling of injustice are perfectly valid. It's one thing for the government to take your money to feed people that are in need. It's another thing for the government to take your money to give someone living conditions better than your own!
- energy123 2y agoOut of all the misdiagnoses of the housing crisis, this is the one I appreciate the most due to its adjacency to the truth. By blaming AirBnB as the root cause, you're implicitly admitting that the problem is too little housing supply. Great. So how can you increase housing supply? Your solution would be to ban AirBnB, which frees up only less than two years worth of new housing stock, while simultaneously reducing tourism revenue. This is a temporary and non durable solution that solves none of the underlying problems that will lead to a lack of supply 5 or 10 years down the road. The durable solution is to increase housing starts by deregulation and financial incentives or public housing. If you double housing starts, in a decade you would have to ban more than five AirBnBs worth of houses to break even. This is the durable solution.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoWe fixate on the easiest things to fixate on, and it becomes an easily attacked effigy for the real problem. When I lived in Mexico City, my friends would complain about gringos causing an increase in rents when the places they wanted to live for cheap were populated almost entirely by every Mexican who makes more money than they do. Yet there was this implication that if you could somehow shut down gringo tourism, there would be no competition for living in the nice apartments in the nice neighborhoods. They would be desperate for your 2000 pesos or something.
- motorest 2y ago> i have to pay €950 for an apartment 30km from the CBD, why on earth does this guy have the right to only pay €700 to live bang in the middle of the CBD? You have to pay €950 for an apartment 30km away because the average rent in the city center is €2000. The average salary in Barcelona is €2800, whereas the average rent is €2000. Do you understand the problem? I mean, answer your own question. Why do you pay €950/month to live in the boonies? Would you pay €950/month to live 30km away if you could pay less than that to live closer to the city center?
- Xenoamorphous 2y agoBut why would anyone be entitled to be in the center? Am I entitled to a €80k BMW too? The most desirable areas to live are not for the average salaries. Don’t get me wrong, I think housing is one of the most basic rights that every human being should have. That doesn’t mean rent should be as cheap in highly desirable areas as in not so desirable ones. If people are living around big populous cities due to work then make public transport good, cheap etc.
- jddj 2y agoThis sounds like the market has reached equilibrium with the average dual income family paying 35% of their gross income on shelter. 35% is a touch high but not out of line with the 30%ish recommendations from banks/estate agents over the years. It might be an issue that the cost of the average 1br flat isn't attainable on a single average income. But I think we can see how we arrived here.
- motorest 2y ago> This sounds like the market has reached equilibrium with the average dual income family paying 35% of their gross income on shelter. You need to redo your math. The effort rate is calculated taking into account all fixed monthly expenses, not just rent. By your own numbers, rent alone is already higher than the maximum admissible effort rate for a household with above average incomes. On top of this you still need to account for your actual cost of living. You're looking at a scenario where a household with an average or above average income has to endure a effort rate well above 40%-50% to afford living in Barcelona. To make matters worse, in Barcelona rents do not drop that much even if you start to entertain commutes of well over 2h/day. There's nothing healthy about it.
- smikhanov 2y agoBut why not?
- bell-cot 2y agoInteresting that the article talks about similar housing crises in other major European cities. But never hints at Vienna having solved the problem a century ago - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-11-08/the-design-history-of-vienna-s-world-famous-social-housing https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-11-08/the-desig...
- aimanbenbaha 2y agoIMO if there is any model to follow to solve the housing crisis it should be Japan/Singapore. Vienna is too unique of a case and its housing market still suffers from negative externalities. Singapore is also hard to achieve but the HDB mandate made it that the government own monopoly on land so they're incentivized to provide maximum land utility to its population. Japan has the best land use zoning in a way it makes it so easy to build and develop. They also have a very practical view on housing and do not see it as an appreciating asset critical to accumulating wealth.
- franciscop 2y ago> Japan has the best land use zoning in a way it's makes it so easy to build and develop. They also have a very practical view on housing and do not see it as an appreciating asset critical to accumulating wealth. I want to note that this is in big part due to earthquakes and nature in general. In Spain 100-year old houses (like in the article) are renovated and relatively easy to maintain. However in Japan, between the earthquakes, typhoons, and the weather in general, not only you need to be actively maintaining it (typhoons), but they become worse over time (earthquake damage accumulates). Source: Spaniard who lives in Tokyo.
- aimanbenbaha 2y agoYeah that would be a factor but there's more to that. For example the Japanese are so crafty with land use they even allow an odd type of development called Zakkyo. Which are multi-storey buildings wherein each floor is owned and managed independently. The foot traffic isn't restricted to the ground floor to enjoy these "third places". IMO geographical constraints should not be the all-in justification for a certain land-use/housing policy. I hear a lot chalk up the fact Barcelona stopped building since the 1980s because they're surrounded by mountains and the sea. Or recently with the LA fires people look at these wrong answers. There's no reason for things being like that other than NIMBYism and lack of long-term political will from local councils.
- mezod 2y agoNever let a good crisis go to waste. If you can use this one to finish the catalan middle class, go for it!
- TacticalCoder 2y ago[dead]
- bombcar 2y agoHas this been tried? Create a non-profit (coop perhaps?) company that owns a residential building and rents at something akin to market rates or near it, but continually invests any profit into producing additional housing?
- pintxo 2y agoIt is a common model in Germany, together with city/state owned companies. The latter have often be privatized in the early 2000s, unfortunately.
- clayhacks 2y agoI’ve heard of this project [0] creating a housing commons that owns the building and sells fractionalized “rent credits” to fund the initial purchase, with the plan of once one building is paid off they can purchase more. Not sure how it’s doing tho 0: https://www.lowimpact.org/categories/economy/housing-commons/ https://www.lowimpact.org/categories/economy/housing-commons...
- carom 2y agoThe problem with rent control policies is the value of properties have gotten away from what the rents justify. For a normal investor this means evicting everyone and rebuilding. For a coop that is trying to keep things rented it means that they are unprofitable. In LA for example, you can never get a rent controlled rent back to market. If someone is paying $600 for a 1 bedroom you're never going to catch back up to $1800. All that said, I don't know why it has to be non profit. What you described is a just a real estate developer. Zoning is a more limiting factor than anything else.
- bombcar 2y agoThe idea would be a real estate developer that has no reasons to extract profits beyond what is necessary to operate. By staying near market rates you’re not “lottery winning” some people. By reinvesting all profit into additional units, you’re going to slowly drive the costs down.
- kjkjadksj 2y ago
- derdrdirk 2y agoIMO it is good that Barcelona bought the building. I don't think regulating rent prices and the housing market helps lower rents. In Poblenou, a district of Barcelona where I live, the city has decided that 50-70% of each property sold has to be purposed for social housing, i.e. limiting the rent to a fourth of the market price and choosing the tenants. Many of the district buildings are abandoned factory halls. I am rennovating one of them to become a house for my family, but am now forced to rent half of it to a poor family. From what I can see from the neighborhood is that there is almost no building activity and that private investments have stopped.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoRent controls don't work because they do the opposite of what would be needed: they reduce supply and increase demand whereas you'd want to increase supply and reduce demand.
- righthand 2y agoHow do you reduce demand on an over populated planet where building happens slower that selling?
- mytailorisrich 2y agoIn specific areas demand is reduced via higher prices. Market 101. Hence why rent controls do the opposite... Now, in Europe the growing demand overall is due to immigration, which is a matter of policy and thus can also easily be reduced/regulated.
- hibikir 2y agoAn overlooked part of Spain's problem is that investing in having a very big apartment is a much better savings vehicle than investing in stock markets. The equivalent of an American 401k has a very small contribution limit, and wealth taxes hit pretty hard and pretty early. So as family sizes shrink, there's a lot of housing overconsumption. A single person, or a family of 2, living in what in the 80s was a family of 6, plus a live-in nanny. So for the same population, you need far more built space. The property tax for owning a pretty expensive apartment are very low by global standards, and housing appreciation isn't a real thing until you sell. My family in Spain is either very house poor, making little and having to rent, or inherited more house than they ever need, and keep it underoccupied because trying to put it to more productive use is pretty risky. Regulations that foster better utilization would make a big dent, but they would be extremely unpopular. Even those that don't own an apartment just want one to be cheap so they can use it as a wealth building tool, as almost nobody wants housing as an investment to be a pretty dubious deal.
- stackedinserter 2y agoIt's not "Barcelona" that is buying it, it's the rest of the city residents.
- rexpop 2y agoOr is it their constituent cells? Or their constituent molecules?
- stackedinserter 2y agoYou can try to be a clown as much as you want, but there's no "city money", it's tax payers' money that city gave to a bunch of assholes that decided they're entitled for $700/mo rent in one of the most desirable city of the world.
- rexpop 2y agoI'm not "try to be a clown," but your choice to recognize some levels of abstraction and not others is absurd to me. > the most desirable city of the world Well it's not like these German residents can teleport to Kuala Lumpur. Why should it be their problem that foreign buyers want to play absentee landlord? Homes should not be an investment vehicle.
- dumbledoren 2y agoEurope builds housing as fast as it can. Barcelona added 100-200k units in the last few years at least. But Europe is small and the regions like Barcelona etc that are targeted by external investors can not cope with the domestic demand and the housing price bubble the enormous quantities of cash those investors are pouring. There is limited space. Texas is half the size of entire Western Europe. Places like Barcelona are just Mediterranean river basins that are squeezed in between mountain ranges and they have even less space. Basically there is no way any European country can handle the real estate bloat that American and other foreign investors are causing and they have no obligation to do that either.
- freefaler 2y agoStrange that the main problem is not even mentioned: The entire process from urban planning to construction completion can take 10-12 years, including about 5-6 years for general urban development planning and 2 years for partial planning and urban development projects. source: https://www.bbvaresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Low-supply-of-housing_Eng.pdf https://www.bbvaresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Low-... So may be if you solve the supply first, then you won't need to try to regulate the pricing. The law of supply and demand is like the Newton's laws of physics, it works. But in Europe, the bureaucrats try to solve the problems created by regulation with even more regulation. It'll end badly when the far left/right use this to win the elections and who knows what will happen.
- guax 2y agoThat's why real estate in New York and SFO is so cheap and accessible. Free market!
- mmiyer 2y agoThe housing market in San Francisco is very much not free. Most areas are single family zoned so you are not allowed to build apartments (which are very much needed to meet demand), and extensive approvals are required to build anything. https://thefrisc.com/how-long-it-really-takes-to-get-a-building-permit-in-san-francisco-and-why-7f00dac3bf79/ https://thefrisc.com/how-long-it-really-takes-to-get-a-build... Although it is true that the problem of excessive bureaucracy is not exclusive to Europe and very common in the US too.
- BobAliceInATree 2y agoWho said a free market must be cheap or accessible?
- appreciatorBus 2y agoIf real eastate in NYC & SFO is a free market, why do homeowners & landowners need to go through a political process & seek favour with neighbours in order to get permission to build a 3 storey apartment building? A world where bakers had to seek permission of other bakers to increase their daily bread production wouldn't be called a market, it would be called a cartel, and no one would be surprised to see bread prices rising through the roof if the cartel members were successful at enforcement.
- atmosx 2y agoThe situation is much the same in cities like Dublin, Athens, and London. The issue lies in voter demographics. Older generations, tend to be homeowners and homeowners have a vested interest in rising property values, not declines. As a result, politicians cater to them because they are the ones who turn out to vote.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jsdwarf 2y agoIMHO the crisis is fueled by the fact that more people want to enjoy the beauty of barcelona short-term (tourists) AND long term (digital nomads moving and working from there). Short term stayers "pay" with increasing hotel&airbnb prices, long-term stayers with low salaries. According to Glassdoor, a software engineer in Barcelona has a 30-40% lower salary than the same position in e.g. Vienna or Berlin. And believe me, hiring in Barcelona is easy.
- holoduke 2y agoFinding good talent is hard. Spain is filled with low grade coders. A bit unrespectful, but I have experienced it already for many many years. And not only tech. Also sales etc. Quality output is hard to find there.
- vrnvu 2y ago> Spain is filled with low grade coders. Are you hiring junior or lower-budget developers? That might explain your experience. I've worked with great engineers in Spain, but of course, like anywhere, quality varies.
- dumbledoren 2y agoThe way I see it, the biggest factor that is amplifying the crisis is that the investors (mostly American companies and individuals) and nomads (Apparently 50% of them American or something), have much more usable cash compared to Europeans due to the bloated investment tools and high cost of living in the US. As a result, they buy the housing under the house of Europeans in multiples, swiftly gentrifying neighborhoods with short-term rentals or just parking cash on housing to make a quick buck.