19 ms·
America desperately needs more air traffic controllers
- ceedan 2y agoHonestly surprised that airlines don’t have options to tip the air traffic control crew, with how tipping culture is these days
- RandomBacon 2y agoI don't think we're allowed to take bribes. We are not even supposed to own stocks in any of the airline companies. I give everyone "direct" equally, to the best of my ability barring any restrictions.
- ceedan 2y agoI would have expected by now that tipping air traffic control would have been seen as a way to boost wages, and create more interest for the job… but I could see how travelers of different airlines might tip more/less which could influence behavior
- ranger_danger 2y agoThen start paying them
- Ekaros 2y agoOr cut down on flights. You could easily ban private flights until there is enough capacity.
- jmount 2y ago1000 times this. Fly as much as one can safely, not more.
- eterm 2y agoDon't ban. Tax. Never ban. Tax low capacity flights more. That both reduces the number of flights and raises money which can be put toward paying ATCs more and increasing the headcount. You then have a lever available to dial up and down to further reduce flights / raise money. Banning is expensive and increases legislative and judicial burden. Taxing is a much more efficient way to stop people doing things. You have to be careful not to only lock the poorest in society out while the rich enjoy carrying on regardless, but in the case of low capacity private jets, I don't think that's a significant problem. If the tax doesn't put off people enough, just raise it more until either it does start to dampen demand or you're raising so much money through it you no longer care and have a new revenue stream to spend on fixing whatever problems they're causing.
- ranger_danger 2y agoI say private flights from the rich should be subsidizing ATC costs... whether that's as a tax or whatever. You could even base it as a percentage of the net worth of the individuals on the flight.
- adrr 2y agoInstead we allow private jet owners to fully write off the cost of a jet purchase(new or used) in the first year on their taxes. Can't even do that with a normal sized car.
- cj 2y agoSource: https://nbaa.org/flight-department-administration/tax-issues/depreciation/bonus-depreciation/ https://nbaa.org/flight-department-administration/tax-issues... "Bonus depreciation" exists for cars too, but is capped around $20k. From quick reading, seems like the bonus depreciation for planes was a tax break to incentivize people to, well, buy more planes.
- ryandrake 2y agoCareless and hamfisted taxing/banning of "private jets" can have the unintended effect of also killing light piston general aviation, flight instruction, and the whole pipeline of training the next generation of airline pilots. Flight training is almost always low capacity (one-on-one) so uncarefuly-crafted legislation could catch it in the blast radius. Piloting is already one of the more expensive careers to train for.
- JSteph22 2y agoExactly. The article enumerates all the ways to improve hiring, except for compensation.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoWith so many billionaires, the country certainly can afford paying more to people whose tasks are crucial for others' lives.
- ta1243 2y agoThe reason there are so many people worth $1b instead of a poor $100m is because of the tax cuts diverting money from crucial jobs.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoWaiting for the first trillionaire, that's when all billionaires will unanimously say "we have enough, let's start paying people more".
- ta1243 2y agoIn the 1880s, Vanderbilt was worth $230m, or $7b today 1910s Rockerfeller peaked at nearly $1b. That's $33b today, or chump change. He, like Gates after him, gave away a lot of wealth. Come 1995, Bill Gates took the mantle with a net worth of $15b, or $31b today. So from 1910 to 1995 there was very little inflation in the super rich. By 2000 Gates reached $60b ($110b). By 2010 he'd dropped to $56b ($81b today), still nearly 3 times richer than Rockerfeller By 2015 he'd recovered to $105b in today's money, despite giving away lots of money. In 2018 Bezos took over with $140b, a 40% real-terms increase on the "richest person" in just 3 years. 2022 Musk took over with $236b, but lost out to Arnault in 2024 when Musk was worth a mere $210b, but today he's nearly doubled his wealth. Maybe Musk is a special case due to the excessive corruption, but Bezos has increased 30% in 12 months. in the last 30 years, the inflation rate of super-rich-wealth has increased on average 10% a year even ignoring the Musk outlier. Inflation meanwhile was 2.5% At those rates, in the next 30 years the super-rich will be worth $4.2 trillion, but someone more normal with a net worth of $1m will be worth $2m.
- runako 2y agoSeems like a colossal error to have asked them all to quit. I wonder -- if half of the air traffic controllers took the offer to leave their jobs, do we have a Plan B? The deadline they have been given to decide is Thursday; I have not seen any communication as to whether ATC (and TSA, etc.) will be operational Friday.
- taeric 2y agoI'd be interested to see the daily staffing levels over the past couple of weeks. If anyone knows where that could be found.
- RationPhantoms 2y agoI couldn't find anything immediately definitive but this 2023 survey of federal workers was quite eye-opening: https://ourpublicservice.org/fed-figures/a-profile-of-the-2023-federal-workforce/ https://ourpublicservice.org/fed-figures/a-profile-of-the-20...
- taeric 2y agoGood find. I'm curious what facets were eye opening for you? This is a ton of data that I find hard to 1-shot learn anything from. :(
- lenerdenator 2y ago> if half of the air traffic controllers took the offer to leave their jobs, do we have a Plan B? In theory you could do what Reagan did and tell the military to do ATC. Whether or not this is a good idea is another matter.
- robert_foss 2y agoReagan taking away collective bargaining rights for ATCs seems to be what have led to the shortage and the helicopter accident last week.
- Apreche 2y agoHow many of those nerds who role play as air traffic controllers on flight simulations at home qualified to do it for real? How much extra training would they need?
- psunavy03 2y agoThe irony of someone on THIS site of all of them scoffing at other people for being nerds . . .
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 7speter 2y agoFrom what I understand, if they are over 30 and have less than 20/20 vision, they aren’t qualified.
- wry_discontent 2y agoDo you have a date when that policy was instituted? I've known a lot of air traffic controllers, and most of them wore glasses.
- dgfitz 2y agoFirst result in google for "air traffic controller training" https://www.faa.gov/air-traffic-controller-qualifications https://www.faa.gov/air-traffic-controller-qualifications Edit: I didn't take a stance on this topic, if you think I did, you are incorrect. I was simply linking the website that outlines the requirements instead of postulating as to what they were.
- Ichthypresbyter 2y agoAIUI that requirement can be met with vision corrected to 20/20 by glasses.
- 2y ago
- hansvm 2y agoThis should be easy enough to solve. Cut the hours back to something sane, and as much as possible time the airport closures in ways that affect the ruling class. You get bonus points if their jets are also delayed during normal taxiing and clearance requests -- explain that it's for their safety, since they're more important than everyone else and can't slot in to the same sorts of back-to-back landings that the common folk use.
- wry_discontent 2y agoThe ruling class makes the rules, though. That's their whole deal. That's why nothing works right.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoIt works right for them though. Curious question: Shouldn't those with a bigger stake in the economy have a bigger say in how it's ran?
- johnnyanmac 2y agoNot in a representative republic, no. Those with more money don't need the safety net that all us governments spend the majority on the budget on. That's why the current coup is so terrifying. But yes, it inevitably devolves into that in practice. Because money gives you more time to make your voice heard, or delegate it to someone else representing you. Or simply bribing others.
- _jss 2y agoYou'd have to change more regulations, because airports don't close when ATC closes, it regresses to an untowered airport environment (and related airspace designation). ATC is there to provide specific services that increase safety and throughput (mostly by sequencing and separation). If you did this with the ruling class, they'd likely pass regulations that would benefit themselves disproportionately and hurt general aviation (the small little Cessnas flying around). There is already a bunch of problems with privatized ATC, don't make it worse.
- wry_discontent 2y agoMy dad was an air traffic controller until the mid 10's and this has been a problem easily since like 2005. They struggled to recruit people who could do the job at all, and when people got into the building to be trained (after an initial training) most of them would quit because they couldn't do it.
- fatbird 2y agoIs there no way to restructure the job to be less onerous to the individual? I don't mean software that automates things, I mean things like more staff, shorter hours, etc. Or is there an irreducible complexity to it that mandates a single person handle everything in a given sector?
- toast0 2y agoI'm not an ATC, but I think there's a clear need for awareness of potentially conflicting traffic. If you divide that traffic over more people, you need to add communication between the controllers in a way that you don't when it's all handled by a single person. That's not to say there's not ways to divide it up, but it's not always easily divisible. Well implemented technology can help, but poorly implemented technology can hurt, so everything needs to be done slowly and carefully.
- kccqzy 2y agoWhat if you divide the work by time? Give each person a two-hour workday. Would that reduce stress?
- toast0 2y agoThat works in theory. Again, I'm not an ATC, but might be better to have reasonable length workdays (maybe two hours is a reasonable shift though) and more time off between workdays. Similar to shift work in hospitals, where more hand offs means more opportunities to fail to hand off successfully. But I suspect it may be easier to hand off an airplane than to hand off an ICU patient.
- ArlenBales 2y agoI fear this will lead to Trump pushing OpenAI to use AI for air traffic controllers, which is going to result in a lot of deaths. Could AI eventually do the job? Maybe, but it will be a bloody road to get there.
- xnx 2y agoWrong! He'll push to use Grok. /s
- SideburnsOfDoom 2y agoIf you mean the current fad for LLMs, then yeah it's absolutely the wrong tools for the job. But "planning what best goes where when" could very much be algorithmic, yes. AI in the sense that A* path finding, and Kuhn's Hungarian algorithm for optimisation are "AI".
- butterlettuce 2y agoFellas, I got a question. Is it really safe to fly these days if this is now a national discussion?
- psunavy03 2y agoIt has always been and will continue to be more safe than driving to the airport. The fact that something extraordinarily safe is potentially less safe is a topic for discussion, but not at the expense of realizing the relative risks of everything else. Prior to the midair at DCA, there had not been a fatal (edit) airliner crash in this country since 2009, and there had not been a midair collision involving an airliner since the 1970s. The fact that some people have an irrational fear of flying does not justify that irrational fear dictating policy any more than people who have an irrational fear of clowns wanting them banned.
- iancmceachern 2y agoBut is it as safe today as it was a year ago today?
- psunavy03 2y agoStatistically, yes.
- jjk166 2y agoBased on what data? In 2024 there were 0 domestic airline collisions in 16 million flights, in 2025 there was 1 in 1.3 million.
- bluGill 2y agoWhich is statistically the same number.
- iancmceachern 2y ago
- trunnell 2y agoTo those who know more about ATC: is there any hope of automation?
- kelseyfrog 2y agoI don't know more about ATC, but it looks like a field ripe for disruption and innovation. AI should be able to handle the coordination of flights without the downside of the delays and limitations of the human training pipeline, worker fatigue, and stress - all for less expense. The more I think about it, the more I feel like I could have something tangible at the end of a weekend or two - at least a prototype.
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoone that you would trust the lives of thousands of humans to every day? It seems unlikely we are anywhere close to a point where we can ensure that any AI won't hallucinate and cause an issue.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoSure, AI can spit out nonsense, and that’s a real concern. But in engineering, we deal with imperfect tradeoffs every day - it’s baked into the job. If we insist on a flawless solution before shipping anything, we’ll never ship. There’s always an optimum where we uphold safety standards without sacrificing forward progress
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoYes, however, we need to hold different bars depending on the consequences of the failure. AI in a game that randomly spins around and breaks emersion for a player is fine, an AI that crashes a plane is not fine. I have zero issues with research into AI research into those areas, but I think it does a major disservice to claim that a weekend is all it takes to get something close to ready for life or death decisions.
- ta1243 2y ago
- harimau777 2y agoHow much do they get paid?
- mooreds 2y agoFrom https://www.faa.gov/jobs/career_fields/aviation_careers https://www.faa.gov/jobs/career_fields/aviation_careers : > The approximate median annual wage for air traffic control specialists is $127,805. The salaries for entry-level air traffic control specialists increase as they complete each new training phase.
- duxup 2y agoSeems like reasonable pay for what is a very important job. Wouldn't object to paying much much more.
- RandomBacon 2y agoI'm an Air Traffic Controller and I'm required by the FAA to say these opinions are my own and not necessarily of the FAA. Some fully-certified air traffic controllers cannot afford to live where they work, not to mention the trainees that have the added stress of training and making less money. At my first facility, to live within 45 minutes of work, my whole paycheck went to rent, thank goodness I had savings from my previous job. With regards to stress, other controllers have told me about how they arrive at home after work not remembering their drive home, or driving slowly in silence. I remember trying to open my apartment door with my car fob/remote one time wondering why it wasn't working. And that pay is on par with M-F 9-5 desk jobs that don't kill you mentally and physically. ATC is 24/7 and is notorious for leading to drinking problems, suicide, etc. Entry-level pilots for major airlines make more per hour than us, and we're pay-capped by law and will never make as much as their captains.
- duxup 2y agoMost people don't make that much and live lots of places. Not sure that "can't afford to" is quite on the nose, but terminology aside I wouldn't object to paying them more.
- bloopernova 2y ago(this is going to sound like I think this can be fixed with a technical solution. I don't) I wonder what the software UX is like for ATC, and if there's room for improvement? Is the software/hardware ancient? I'd hope that it is absolutely rock solid but knowing big custom projects I'm not very hopeful!
- perihelions 2y agoThey have fascinatingly ancient UX: https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/tfdm/efs https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/tfdm/efs (Image caption: "Paper flight strips currently in use")
- everybodyknows 2y agoLook up deployment date of upgraded tech at your local airport here: https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/tfdm/implementation https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/tfdm/implementati... Notable entry: Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport (DCA), Washington, D.C. July 2028
- gamedever 2y ago> this is going to sound like I think this can be fixed with a technical solution. I don't) Why? It's seems ripe for technical solution. Technical solutions have solved tons of things in the past. What's special about air traffic controlling?
- bloopernova 2y agoOh I just don't like the tendency of tech folks to reach for technological solutions before they consider social/organizational ones.
- ggm 2y agoThe time to certify life-or-death changes to systems exceeds the time to train more people, or pay better to retain existing staff. "do both" is actually a good answer. The Manhatten project did this. Thermal diffusion and other forms of concentration were initially put head-to-head in competition. It took a while for people to realise both worked, and should be run in parallel or even enriching feedstock. A competitive A or B not both position would not have worked out better. So yes. research tech replacement, but expect it to be a 15-20 year project with the same costs as other 15-20 year projects. At the same time, don't assume tech will solve social issues, and pay ATC better and increase richness of training programmes by cloning the schools.
- joshuaheard 2y agoSeems ripe for disruption with AI.
- ryandrake 2y agoIf you live in the Bay Area on the Peninsula, you'll be excited to know that the San Carlos airport and the FAA are in a pissing match over their air traffic controllers' pay, threatening to un-staff the control tower and leave that very busy airspace without tower control. The tower was set to go dark on Feb 1st[1] but it looks like there is now a temporary extension[2] keeping it staffed. Why these guys need to play a game of chicken when lives are at stake, I have no idea. 1: https://www.kron4.com/news/bay-area/bay-area-airport-losing-air-traffic-controllers-amid-pay-dispute-with-faa/ https://www.kron4.com/news/bay-area/bay-area-airport-losing-... 2: https://www.kron4.com/news/bay-area/san-carlos-airport-reaches-agreement-to-keep-its-air-traffic-controllers/ https://www.kron4.com/news/bay-area/san-carlos-airport-reach...
- schmookeeg 2y agoI still don't understand why KSQL is a contract tower and not a full FAA-managed tower.
- jjtheblunt 2y agoDid the call sign go to KSQL because of Oracle being right there?
- kccqzy 2y agoNo it predates Oracle, including when it was still called Software Development Laboratories.
- vdqtp3 2y agoContract towers in general are a terrible idea. The level of service is consistently lower than FAA towers.
- Melatonic 2y agoFrom what I heard the San Carlos controller were pissed that their pay was being drastically reduced - especially considering its not a cheap area to live in.
- tim333 2y agoThere's a lawsuit going on: >FAA embroiled in lawsuit alleging it turned away 1,000 applicants based on race — that contributed to staffing woes https://nypost.com/2025/01/31/us-news/faa-embroiled-in-lawsuit-alleging-it-turned-away-1000-applicants-based-on-race/ https://nypost.com/2025/01/31/us-news/faa-embroiled-in-lawsu... The guy behind it is quite interesting. Got 100% on his exams but told they were only hiring 'diverse' folk https://archive.ph/ixmFB https://archive.ph/ixmFB
- legitster 2y ago> When Mr Brigida tried again to become an air traffic controller under the new tests, he said he failed the biographical questionnaire because he “didn’t fit the preferred ethnic profile”. This dude leading the lawsuit is incredibly unreliable. The ATC biographical assessment didn't have any race-based questions - it was just a decision making questionnaire: https://123atc.com/biographical-assessment https://123atc.com/biographical-assessment It was a questionable assessment, but the idea that he failed it for being white is peak self-victimization. The risk of DEI was fast-passing under-qualified candidates, or that they were misplacing their recruitment efforts. But the idea that they would not be filling necessary positions with qualified white people continues to be something of a polemic myth.
- RandomBacon 2y agoI don't know anything about the lawsuit, but I do know that someone leaked the "answers" to members of a group representing people of a specific race. (Opinions are my own and not necessarily that of the FAA.)
- legitster 2y agoI literally linked to a study website for test, I don't think you had to be a member of a secret racial kabal to get answers. Furthermore, the bias was literally baked into the test - certain minority candidates got to skip the test altogether. Although it's still not evidence that qualified white people were prevented from filling in vacancies.
- legitster 2y agoEveryone is going to make this about money or unions or etc, but my employer briefly worked with some ATC employee groups and I can tell you exactly why they are short staffed: - The FAA has strict hiring requirements. You have to be mentally and physically capable, and by their own admission less than 10% of applicants are qualified for the job. https://www.faa.gov/air-traffic-controller-qualifications https://www.faa.gov/air-traffic-controller-qualifications - The training and onboarding process is incredibly long, and turnover is high - The fundamentals and technology of the job have not changed in decades, despite air traffic exploding in recent years - Most people are just not capable of the amount of stress and risk associated with the job - Seriously, it's a really freaking stressful job I would argue an ATC employee is worth every penny, but I also don't think there is a magical amount of money where you are going to suddenly double your pool of candidates willing to do this kind of work. These people are already very well compensated, and at a certain point you are just going to be cannibalizing other talent pools. The real need is new and modern technology that automates much of the mistake-prone, human-centric tasks. But nobody wants to risk introducing changes to such a fragile system.
- Justsignedup 2y agoMy uncle did ATC in the soviet military. They were allowed to do 2 hour shifts max. The mental work is so intense that the human brain can only sustain it for a short time.
- RandomBacon 2y ago> I also don't think there is a magical amount of money where you are going to suddenly double your pool of candidates willing to do this kind of work. There would be more people interested in aviation choosing to be ATC than a pilot if our pay matched that of major airline pilots. There are people going through the training and then quiting when they realize that can't get an opening in their hometown because that spot is reserved for a random person one week behind them in the FAA academy, and the pay won't make it worth moving away from their family. There are more examples, and appropriate pay would fix most of them. (Opinions are my own and not necessarily that of the FAA.)
- 2y ago
- deathanatos 2y ago"US ATC System Under Scrutiny" "Fatal crash brings attention to shortage" "There are simply not enough air traffic controllers to keep aircraft a safe distance from one another." Like, perhaps there is merit in arguing for more controllers or more pay for controllers, and perhaps that would lead to a safer airspace, but the attempts to implicitly tie the fatal crash to ATC in this case seems pretty poor form, here. What we know from the ATC transcripts[1] already tells us that ATC was aware the helicopter & the plane would be near each other well in advance of the crash; ATC informed the helo, the helo responded that he had the aircraft in sight. Time passed, the ATC gets a proximity warning (labelled as "[Conflict Alert Warning]" in VASAviation's video), ATC immediately acts on it, again reaching out to the helo, the helo again confirms they have the aircraft in sight, and moments later we can hear on the ATC transcripts the crash occur as people in the room witness it and react in horror. To my armchair commenting self, the ATC controllers seem to be exonerated by the transcript, and I'm going to otherwise wait until an NTSB report tells me why I'm wrong to break out the pitch forks on them. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3gD_lnBNu0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3gD_lnBNu0
- bombcar 2y agoI’ll bet the final NTSB report lists as a contributing factor that there was only one controller that night; a second controller might have had the time to notice the altitude was too close, or vector the helicopter behind.
- bilbo0s 2y agoNo. There are also rules on who can do what. Put another way, military aircraft, especially certain military aircraft, can do things that civilian aircraft can't. If I were piloting a helicopter in that airspace, that ATC transcript would have been significantly different. We should be looking at root causes. Which means we should ask the uncomfortable questions about the deference given to some military/government aircraft. But we don't want to ask those questions. So we keep quibbling around the edges by talking about ATC or Reagan firing everyone or even the ridiculous suggestion that maybe the civilian airliners could be in a hold pattern at certain times. It would be humorous if it wasn't so tragic.
- arghandugh 2y ago[flagged]
- ApolloFortyNine 2y agoWe have planes moving hundreds of miles an hour being managed exclusively by audio channels. Does this not blow anyone else's minds? This seems like a clear case of 'because we've always done it that way'. There's no way if a system was being developed today they'd say to hell with screens, lets just give them instructions over audio and assume they'll follow them to a T if acknowledged.
- bobthepanda 2y agothere are already a lot of screens and things to look at in a cockpit. and in emergency situations, screens can fail. audio has the advantage of being highly backwards compatible and extremely reliable, so long as the pilots are alive and conscious (and if they're not, the plane is most likely SOL anyways: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522)
- ryandrake 2y agoAlso, you can process and respond to audio without taking your eyes off of whatever they are on, and without taking your hand off the stick/yoke. I hear in my headset "Clear for the option runway two-five-right, number two behind a cessna, two mile final, on the go make right traffic" and I know exactly what is expected of me without having to look at a screen. A digital display would be a step backwards.
- dickfickling 2y agoIt doesn't sound like GP is saying we have to do away with audio, just that it's absurd to stick to _just_ audio. Great to have a screen that shows "Clear for option 25R etc etc". I think I saw the latest Cirrus planes have something like that, doing live transcription of tower/ATC calls. EDIT: I will add I get that adding something like that to a general aviation cockpit is much easier than putting it on a commercial 787, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try.
- 2y ago
- deadbabe 2y agoIf you’ve flown in any capacity you probably owe your life to an ATC, you’ve probably been on a plane that would have suffered a collision if not for the ATC.
- bluGill 2y agoSort of. Without ATC you would still be safe - but airplanes would be much less common as no sane pilot will get anywhere close to other planes without someone in control to watch separations. That means instead of planes landing every 30 seconds they will be once every several minutes to make sure everyone takes turns - this isn't just about the runway, it is also the patterns around the airport, with many airplanes refusing to join the pattern because they are not sure they can fit in that close. Airports with more than one runway (which is nearly all commercial airports) will have issues trying to get patterns to work and so likely some runways won't even be used. But if you do manage to get in the air you will be safe and get there. You would get used to long waits in hubs and 3 transfers to get there unless you live in a hub and are going to a hub. (Boston to Salt Lake city would be fly to NYC, then to Denver, then to Salt Lake. Even Boston to Atlanta would be a transfer in NYC). Those transfers would also involve long waits, right now airlines plane everyone to arrive at the hub and leave again more in about an hour and then little traffic for several hours. However after airlines will not coordinate schedules as they can't land so layovers will be several hours.
- nimbius 2y agodisingenuous headline. America desperately needs to reform ATC hiring. This is the same headline as the professional trucking shortage in the USA and glosses over the real reasons no one will take these jobs. mandatory overtime, low wages, miserable benefits, high stress and a well documented history of retaliation against organized labor.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoCertain immigrants actually seem to excel in trucking and even enjoy it (Punjabi truckers especially in California - I always see the Sikh logos on the back of their trucks between LA and SF!). A quick policy adjust would resolve any shortage in truckers with other people who'd probably also enjoy the work. However, there isn't a massive pool of people abroad who can handle US airspace demands (which now seems to include helicopters flying in the approach pathways of active runways in VFR while wearing night vision goggles and ignoring their radar altimeters all so some DC asshat doesn't have to sit in a car for 20 minutes, and also includes people like my former college hallmates who take handheld aviation radios, ask for permission to depart, and run on the taxiways with their arms extended, to great dismay of ATC)
- 10000truths 2y ago> and also includes people like my former college hallmates who take handheld aviation radios, ask for permission to depart, and run on the taxiways with their arms extended, to great dismay of ATC You can't just drop a tidbit like that without elaborating.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoThe airport was in southwest Virginia and most of the traffic was Cessnas so they got away with it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- nimish 2y agoThe kind of person who can do ATC can make much more in tech and have a much better lifestyle. Market problem requires a market solution.
- ConanRus 2y agoOh noes, what happened?
- Khaine 2y agoIt should be noted that the FAA is facing a lawsuit alleging it discriminated against capable candidates[1]. If this is true, this surely must factor into the shortage of air traffic controllers. Admittedly, its a big if, and second even if it is true it is not clear to me how much of a factor this is in the shortage. [1] https://mslegal.org/cases/brigida-v-faa/ https://mslegal.org/cases/brigida-v-faa/
- Graziano_M 2y agohttps://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-faas-hiring https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-fa...
- DangitBobby 2y agoIt truly boggles my mind that Trump may have a legitimate basis for alleging that DEI policies have contributed to issues with ATC staffing. > First, to liberals: > I dislike Trump as much as anyone. Maybe I’m not supposed to play my hand like that while reporting a news article, but it’s true. I’ve wanted him out of politics since he entered the scene a decade ago, I voted against him three elections in a row, and I think he’s had a uniquely destructive effect within US politics. So I understand—please believe, I understand—just how disquieting it is to watch him stand up and blame DEI after a major tragedy. > But Democrats did not handle it. The scandal occurred under the Obama administration. The FAA minimized it, obscured it, fought FOIA requests through multiple lawsuits, and stonewalled the public for years as the class action lawsuit rolled forward. The Trump administration missed it, too, for a term, and it’s likely most officials simply didn’t hear about it through the first few years of the Biden administration. No outlets left of Fox Business bothered to provide more than a cursory examination of it, and it never made much of a dent on the official record. Even when the New York Times ran a thoroughly reported article on air traffic controller shortages late last year, it never touched the scandal. It was possible to miss it.
- userbinator 2y agoEither he's a broken clock that's right twice a day, or a Stallman equivalent who was just dismissed as crazy until the truth was too big to ignore.
- gtsop 2y agoIf you don't have air traffic controllers, the air traffic won't be controlled... who knew?
- smath 2y agoI might have missed this in the article - how is the pay level set for ATC staff? In a free market economy price is the magical signal that is supposed to increase supply when there is unmet demand.
- RandomBacon 2y agoThere is a formula that is negotiated with the union. See Appendix A in the collective bargaining agreement: https://www.natca.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/2016NATCACBABookmarks.pdf https://www.natca.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/2016NATCACB...
- smath 2y agoAh interesting - a formula. To me it seems that makes it not a free market. Ie the formula is producing numbers that are too low, than what the current demand supply imbalance would otherwise produce.
- wNjdbfm 2y agoIs this a US ONLY problem? I'm not trying to start a flame war, I'm genuinely wondering for example: European air travel doesn't seem any less safe than the US so whatever they are doing seems to work just as well. Do they have trouble hiring and keeping ATCs? Is their comp/work life/training/etc very different than ours? Would appreciate any insight from folks that know.
- kalleboo 2y agoIt looks like Europe also has staffing issues, but they're more likely to cancel/delay flights rather than overwork their ATC https://skift.com/2023/08/22/europes-air-traffic-controller-shortage-delays-flights-slows-recovery/ https://skift.com/2023/08/22/europes-air-traffic-controller-...
- Symbiote 2y agoYes — it reached a point where Ryanair made a website on the issue: https://www.atcruinedourholiday.com/ https://www.atcruinedourholiday.com/
- Jtsummers 2y agoThere was a mass firing in the early 1980s (~90%) which led to the development of a bathtub curve in ATC staffing. By the 2010s this had become a critical issue but was met with a hiring freeze (not the first). Now we're seeing the outcome of those poor decisions paired with the slow hiring/training process to fill the roles.
- dblohm7 2y agoThe Canadian system is much better. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nav_Canada#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nav_Canada#History
- ggm 2y agoThis is a worldwide problem. ATC staff under 35 would be a rapid visa approval for Australia, if trained to world-class standards.
- 2y ago
- analog31 2y agoI realize it's not a complete or immediate solution, but I wonder how much buses and trains would help. I think about this, in a town with a regional airport, ~ 100 miles from a couple of "hub" airports. Flying to the hub is often slower than driving when all things are considered, and with the risk of delays. A bus or train could work a lot better if the locations of the stations were coordinated, and if there was a coordinated system for handling baggage. And, if the ticketing were consolidated. The bus is never delayed by weather.
- mcmcmc 2y agoNot sure why you’re getting downvoted (minus the false claim about buses and weather), if we don’t have enough have enough ATCs to satisfy air traffic demands the other level to pull is to decrease air traffic, either by offering substitutes for cross country travel or just straight up making it more expensive to fly. A flat per flight tax, say a flat ATC fee on each ticket, would marginally decrease demand for air travel and could be used to fund recruiting/retention programs for ATCs. Or call it a public transit fee and use it to subsidize high speed rail and other mass transit.
- analog31 2y agoWith apologies to Captain Corcoran, "Well, hardly ever."
- ctrlp 2y agoAnyone remember the movie Pushing Tin with John Cusack and Billy Bob Thornton?
- mjmsmith 2y agoThe article it was based on is worth a read: https://web.archive.org/web/20091213233937/http://www.nytimes.com/1996/03/24/magazine/something-s-got-to-give.html?pagewanted=all https://web.archive.org/web/20091213233937/http://www.nytime...
- ctrlp 2y agoWow. Just, wow.
- RandomBacon 2y agoATC here, I love that documentary :-) (Opinions are my own and not necessarily that of the FAA.) I have some wild stories, but unfortunately sharing them would dox me. The most inaccurate thing though is a transfer CPC (fully-certified controller at their previous facility) plugging in and being able to work without months of training in that area.
- ctrlp 2y agoIf that's a documentary, I'm never getting on a plane again :)
- Yeul 2y agoThe Netherlands has a shortage too. But they just cancel flights or even entire airports if they are understaffed. As an employee it is your duty to refuse orders that potentially risk lives.
- mrweasel 2y agoThat brings up an interesting solution: Figure out how many flights can be services with the current number of air traffic controllers, take away 5 - 10% to deal with illness and unforeseen issues, cap the number of flights to that number.
- silvestrov 2y agoThen you have the problem that Congress overrules you. > The number of flights at Reagan National is capped because of its congestion. But lawmakers have an interest in boosting direct flights to their states – for themselves and their constituents – because the airport is more convenient to downtown than Dulles International Airport https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2025/01/30/safety-delta-lobbyists-reagan-dca-flights-congress-crash/78059396007/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2025/01/30/safety-... So the knew the airport was already at max number of flights that it could handle safely and yet they still increased the number of flights in pure selfishness.
- mrweasel 2y agoThat not just selfish, that's irresponsible. Why not ensure better transportation links for Dullas instead. Aren't the two airports less than an hour away from each other?
- silvestrov 2y agoPentagon to Dulles Airport is 20 miles in direct distance. It takes 1 hour by subway as there is no direct connection and the lines have a lot of stops. The real solution would be a direct subway with no stop between Dulles and Pentagon. 20 miles using a fast subway should be no more than 25 minutes in travel time. The subway could then continue making a loop in central DC, serving all the offices next to the White House etc. But that would be good public transportation and that is outside of Congress' Overton Window.
- searealist 2y agoYou can take the biographical assessment that rejected scores of applicants because reasons like they did well in Science in High School: https://kaisoapbox.com/projects/faa_biographical_assessment/ https://kaisoapbox.com/projects/faa_biographical_assessment/
- barbarr 2y agoI failed the assessment, RIP
- numba888 2y agoSounds like we need more typists and horses. Will hordes of traffic controllers help, or there is a better way?
- fhe 2y agothis seems a domain that's distinctively suited for AI
- xyst 2y agoWith the dismantling of the federal government [1, 2, 5], foreign multi billionaire “special government employee” running amok in US Treasury and other agencies [3], and current administration giving no-confidence signals of FAA/ATCs [4] Trust in federal gov is vanishing before our eyes folks. And the billionaire class is getting what it wants — no regulations, “network states” (delusional libertarian concept by Balaji and backed by billionaire shitheads like Thiel), limited power to the people and labor force. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/04/politics/education-department-trump-executive-order/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/04/politics/education-department... [2] https://apnews.com/article/coast-guard-homeland-security-priorities-committees-trump-tsa-d3e4398c8871ada8d0590859442e092c https://apnews.com/article/coast-guard-homeland-security-pri... [3] https://www.finance.senate.gov/chairmans-news/wyden-demands-answers-following-report-of-musk-personnel-seeking-access-to-highly-sensitive-us-treasury-payments-system https://www.finance.senate.gov/chairmans-news/wyden-demands-... [4] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-dei-diversity-policies-plane-crash/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-dei-diversity-policies-pl... [5] https://apnews.com/article/trump-buyout-offer-federal-workers-doge-bdb6cd89e383ff1120eeb262904b4060 https://apnews.com/article/trump-buyout-offer-federal-worker...
- kgilpin 2y agoToday, hacker news solves air traffic control with either: a) More money b) Video game technology To truly get this problem, you really need to be in it. Either as a pilot or as a controller. Watching threads like this reminds me that I have expertise within a couple of specialized domains and that’s it. Beyond those, I’m a tourist.
- vdqtp3 2y agoIt's refreshing to see someone say it. As a (non-commercial) pilot it's honestly infuriating watching people who have never tried to fly a plane, never tried to locate and identify another aircraft from the air, and never controlled (or even sat with a controller or toured a tower, tracon, or center) make these claims and statements about how easy these problems they don't understand are to fix as if they're experts on the topic.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoWelcome to hacker news! The confidence is strong amongst the readership here and often confidently wrong at that!
- wand3r 2y agoA lot of naive uninformed people who had no expertise and were told by experts how they could never contribute to a problem or field have successfully built businesses funded by the very people who created this community.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoIf you were to design a modern way to solve this problem, you wouldn't end up with a pile of nineteen sixties era equipment and some very stressed ATC people and pilots trying to communicate over a noisy VHF radio channel. The challenge: - electrical planes are coming and are going to cause an influx of pilots who can now afford to own and fly their planes. Teslas with wings basically. Cheap to buy, cheap to fly, lower noise, no emissions, what's not to like? It will take some time but early versions of these things are being certified right now. The 100$ hamburger run becomes a 5$ coffee run. It's going to have obvious effects: more people will want to get in on the fun. Way more people. - a lot of those things will be used to fly medium distances for work in bad weather; which creates an obvious need for some level of ATC interaction. - Likewise, cheaper/sustainable commercial short hops are going to increase traffic movements. - Autonomous drones and planes are going to be part of the mix of traffic ATC has to factor in. Autonomous operation is key to operating safely. Especially in low visibility situations. Shuttle flights between city centers and terminals, short local hops, package deliveries, aerial surveillance, etc. On top of regular planes with way smarter auto pilots than today. The volume of this traffic will be orders of magnitudes of what ATC deals with today. There's some time to prepare for this. Certification processes move slowly. But a lot of this stuff is being experimented with right now at small scale or stuck in the certification pipeline already. We're long past the "will it work" moment for most of this stuff. Technically, this would be happening right now if the FAA would allow it. They'll be fighting a losing battle to slow this down and delay the inevitable here. But the end result is that ATC needs to be ready for orders of magnitude more movement in their controlled air spaces. And right now they clearly aren't. In short, all this requires new, modern tools. It's obvious. Training more ATC people to do things the way we have been doing them for the last 50 years is not a good plan for the next 50. It's a stop gap solution at best. With a very short shelf life.
- zer0zzz 2y agoJust waiting for this atc thing to become overly politicized like every other aspect of life in America. I swear over politicization and polarization is going to strangle this country and destroy it if it hasn’t already.
- V99 2y agoThe first problem is that everybody who wants to do the job needs to go through the FAA academy in Oklahoma, which is seriously limited by physical & instructor capacity. So only a couple thousand people a year can work their way through there, no matter how many are willing to do the job. So first we need more training capacity, and they already have trouble hiring and retaining instructors. This is a more direct place you can throw more money at now. A start would be moving some of the primary training to the control centers. There's more than one of them, spread around the country, and they already have their own significant training departments. A significant fraction of people who get into the academy end up not making the cut. Then another good fraction "wash out" during extensive training for the specific airport/center they end up in. It's a very difficult job and nothing they've tried before is very good at predicting who's going to be successful at it quickly/cheaply.
- xeonmc 2y agoWould StarCraft ladder rank be a good predictor of suitability?
- daveguy 2y agoSo, you're saying the FAA is struggling because we don't fund them enough to hire instructors? Seems like a Republican problem.
- vdqtp3 2y agoRealistically, because standing up a new academy isn't fast, and everyone wants fast solutions and won't invest long term. That isn't a party line thing, both parties have that issue.
- V99 2y agoThis has been a snowballing problem since Reagan fired 11,000 controllers for striking in 1981... so sort of, but not the one you're thinking of, and there's been plenty of both sides of the aisle doing nothing to solve the problem in the meantime.
- 2y ago
- wellthisisgreat 2y agoAir traffic controller seems like one of the least rewarding job there are out there
- bilinguliar 2y agoWait, I thought we had AI.
- egberts1 2y agoToo bad that we have some 2,000+ already-qualified FAA ATC of certain persuasion that are "just sitting" around waiting for their stress-free class-action money in the Brigida vs FAA 2015 reverse discrimination lawsuit. Think they'll now work as ATC after they win? Doesn't help to tie up 900+ more potential qualified ATC (again of certain persuadion) when FAA tried reverse discrimination AGAIN in 2021 in Brigida vs Buttigieg lawsuit. Will they ever learn? Source https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-faas-hiring https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-fa... https://casetext.com/case/brigida-v-buttigieg-1 https://casetext.com/case/brigida-v-buttigieg-1
- metalman 2y agoAs part of my student pilot training, our class was taken to the air traffic tower, to meat and see the air traffic controllers at work and build some trust as in many emergency situations fir a pilot, its ATC who can save your sorry lost ass. There were a bunch of them working,handling local and international flights,multi screen work stations. One guy stood out, he was directing several flights during the landing phase, while talking to us, then it became clear that he was also directing planes on the ground, a collegue of his came up to confer, he started telling us a joke, but of couse had to pause here and there while he attended to these other trifles but his timing was so impecable, that the joke was still funny. So thats who you want, and you cant train THAT, whatever it is, but perhapps can identify and foster those that have...IT. The controll tower itself is strait out of a sci fi movie, with a glass walkway ,the only way in, to find a completely blank stainless wall, that then opens to reveal a completly blank elevator
- farceSpherule 2y agoTHE PAY SUCKS... Head over to https://www.reddit.com/r/ATC/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ATC/ and have a look. Entry level ATC salaries are about $50,000 (~$23 an hour). And you do not get to "choose" where you land on your first assignment. Try living on $23 an hour in a HCOL area.
- farceSpherule 2y agoYou can thank Reagan for mess we are in with ATC's... Reagan was looking for a reason to break up the government unions and the union overplayed their hand. So, Reagan fired all of the striking ATCs -- 11,359 -- and banned them from federal service for life (later lifted by Clinton).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- asdefghyk 2y agoRE ".... America desperately needs more air traffic controllers ....." or THE TRAFFIC at some airports NEEDS TO BE LIMITED to SAFER levels .... I'm looking at the recent airport crash of the Helicopter and plane as an example of where traffic should be limited. Must be other over busy airports too...