14 ms·
How to lose a fortune with one bad click
- namaria 2y agoI wonder if there's any one legitimate instance of a company calling you about compromised accounts and requiring your action. It seems to me that anyone reaching out and lighting a fire under your ass can be assumed to me a malicious actor. Any notification asking you to confirm your identity that is not initiated by your actions should be immediately dismissed with a "no" and that should be all there is to such things, no?
- rcxdude 2y agoBanks are pretty good at doing an impression of phishing scams, unfortunately. Almost every red flag for a scammer has also been done by a bank, legitimately.
- athenot 2y agoThis. Also healthcare providers, though they seem to have finally wised up. They would call me from poorly configured phone systems (so unrecognizable caller id) and the first thing they would ask is to confirm full name and date of birth. Patterns like this do a great deal of damage in desensitizing folks and making them accept dangerous patterns that get exploited by scams.
- hollerith 2y agoEven if you recognized it, the number shown by Caller ID is easy for the caller to spoof -- or at least it was a few years ago (the last time I paid attention).
- athenot 2y agoThankfully that part has vastly improved with STIR/SHAKEN, combined with number reputation management.
- ipython 2y agoThe problem with that, at least on my experience with iPhone, is you can only get the authentication signal after you’ve already hung up. The only thing I see is a small checkmark next to the “location” of the call in my recent call log. I can’t find any indication of a stir/shaken status in the active call screen. So asking people to take the step to confirm the call is legitimate won’t work- they can’t tell until they’ve already terminated the call. It’s useless for purpose imo.
- vel0city 2y agoOn my Pixel some calls just get auto-rejected. Others will get through but be marked with a red caution symbol for the picture and say "Scam Likely". Then finally sometimes the call will come through with just the number but still have that red caution symbol. I imagine it is doing something with STIR/SHAKEN along with how many other times similar calls have been flagged as spam calls.
- ipython 2y agoMy carrier has a similar “scam likely” feature but afaik that is not directly tied to stir/shaken. I’ve also signed up to have calls rejected and can see them in the carrier app. I have reported at least a thousand different scam calls over the past two years and so my blocked number list is so large it freezes the phone for a minute or so while it loads. Still the scammers persist…
- ryao 2y agoI remember when I used Ting, I could specify what would appear as caller id. If I had wanted to abuse this, I could easily have had it display whatever number I wanted instead of my name. Since a number of phones would display the caller id instead of the number when caller id was available, nobody would know that the number was not real. I am not sure if this has changed at all.
- nottorp 2y agoBanks maybe, but Google? Google only has "AI" support and that doesn't call us yet. So it's safe to assume that any call from Google is fake.
- SoftTalker 2y agoYeah Google will never call you about your free gmail account, just as Microsoft will never call you about a virus on your home computer.
- adrianmsmith 2y agoThere was a comment on Hacker News, which alas I can no longer locate, where a guy said he'd been called by his bank and the bank wanted him to answer various security questions. He said he was happy to do so, but firstly needed the bank to verify who they were, or to call the bank back on a telephone number on their website. The bank refused, so he refused to give them any details. The bank then blocked his bank account, meaning he couldn't pay his university tuition on time, meaning his student visa was no longer valid as he was no longer "studying", meaning he had to leave the country.
- namaria 2y agoA bank blocked an account because they called someone and that person didn't provide them with personal data? That sounds unlikely.
- ryao 2y agoI am not surprised. I know of a bank that disabled a credit card following a single missed payment for the crime of failing to answer a phone call.
- ElevenLathe 2y agoThis is one of the reasons I use a local credit union with a handful of branches only in my region. I can always re-establish trust by just walking into a branch to do business, and likewise they can always just ask me to walk in with my driver's license if they need to verify that I'm really me.
- michaelt 2y agoA reasonable decision in your case, no doubt. But the mentions of "his student visa was no longer valid [...] meaning he had to leave the country" make me think walking to a local bank branch might not have been an easy option in the post adrianmsmith recalls.
- ryao 2y agoI have had my telephone company ask me to give them a code sent to my device. It is presumably to prove to the company that the representative is talking to me so that bad actors low in the company cannot start randomly messing with people’s accounts. It is the equivalent of the bad click here. The only real defense is to know the difference between a mechanism meant to authorize someone a the company and a mechanism to authorize you. Confuse the latter for the former like the victim did here and bad things will happen.
- braveyellowtoad 2y agoInteresting. Was that after you called them or they called you?
- ryao 2y agoIt was when I called them.
- ipqk 2y agoI called a bank to increase my ATM limit. The agent sent me an SMS code to verify my identity and wanted me to read it back to him. The message said not to give the code to any human. Sigh.
- yorer 2y agoIdeally yes no one would fall for that. But these type of attacks doesn't just rely on solely ignorance. They introduced urgency, the fight or flight situation. Plus the first guy in the article got caught up in bad timing where his mental condition aren't right with his kid crying, his wife yelling etc.
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoYes, but you have to know that. I got a call from "Bank of America," and they smoothly talked me into giving them my debit card PIN. The trick was they had gotten into my online banking beforehand. "We've detected possibly fraudulent activity on your account." Then they read me real transactions from my actual account. "To be safe, let's lock down the account. For this we need more information for authentication, though." Probably started from a phishing thing that I fell for online without noticing. It was pretty clever of them. Not so easy to steal from a checking account without leaving a trail, unless you have the PIN. Then the main risk is to whomever was on camera at the ATM withdrawing as much cash as possible before the account was automatically locked down. The next day, I got a call from "Bank of America" telling me that I'd been had. Fortunately they just credited the money back into my account. About $5000. The main difference is that the first call wanted me to give them information, while the second call advised only "go into a bank branch in person." The article's advice is correct. If someone asks you for info, tell them you'll call them back. It is almost certainly a scam. Calling back the possibly spoofed number at worst wastes a little time being on hold, and at best saves you or the bank a lot of money.
- Majromax 2y ago> Calling back the possibly spoofed number Don't call back the number possibly being spoofed (i.e. using your Caller ID as the source of the callback number). Call an independently-listed number for the company, such as the phone number on the back of a credit or debit card. Using an independent number prevents any failures where the Caller ID correctly reports an attacker-controlled but plausible-sounding number. For extra paranoia and safety, perform the callback from a separate phone line. That would avoid at least some of the more-targeted attacks involving a compromise of the victim's phone connection, which could potentially allow the attacker to redirect outgoing calls.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y ago"Hang up, look up, call back"
- crote 2y ago
- jeroenhd 2y agoSometimes there are good reasons for a bank to call you. The infuriating part is that not every bank has a quickly accessible number to call back if you don't trust the caller. Caller ID may be useless, but me calling the official number for my bank is pretty hard to fake (unless my carrier is part of the scam). My bank has a button inside the app that will confirm that a real bank representative is calling you, or provides a button to call the bank's emergency line if they're not. It's a simple and effective way of preventing scams that I think more banks should implement.
- ryao 2y agoA ss7 attack could make your carrier part of the scam without their knowledge, such that calling back the number will connect you to the scammer and not the bank.
- omoikane 2y agoIf some bank calls you about compromised accounts, the recommended action should be to hang up, find the official phone number for your bank, wait one minute[1], then call back. [1] You have to wait or call from a different phone, because the call might not terminate immediately, and the scammer might still be listening on the line. https://security.stackexchange.com/a/100342 https://security.stackexchange.com/a/100342
- benhurmarcel 2y agoI’ve had my bank call me because of dubious online purchases, asking if it was me. The call was legitimate and my card number had been skimmed.
- c22 2y ago> Unbeknownst to him at the time, Google Authenticator by default also makes the same codes available in one’s Google account online. This sounded absolutely crazy to me so I went to open Authenticator on my phone and lo and behold it offered me the option of linking to my account and "backing up my codes in the cloud" to which I declined. But I had never seen this behavior before, so is this new? It did not seem to be enabled by default in my case.
- criddell 2y agoI use Authy and it does this too. I like that I can get the code on my phone or tablet. I also keep paper copies of the original QR codes in a safe place.
- jeroenhd 2y agoThe trick with Authy is to disable multi-device access unless you're in the process of adding another device, so hackers and scammers can't add their own devices to your account without your aid. If you leave the setting enabled, someone may get your TOTP secrets from Authy before you can stop them.
- tasuki 2y agoNo. That's not "the trick". As soon as it's in the cloud, it's over, it's gone, you've lost the game.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoI feel like attacks like this would be much harder if we had never adopted HTML emails. Then it would make more intuitive sense (for the user) for an institution to write: (1) Go to our website (2) Login and check your account Of course, leigitimate emails do that now, but because of the way we've been trained to "click" (such as "click to verify your email"), this conditioning carries over to phishing and other attacks, whereas that would be impossible with plain text. With plain text, the email verification would have to be "paste this code into a box".
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoEmail clients would probably still parse URLs into links. People would click them. Then people would prefer links that didn't look like gobbledygook, so email clients would start supporting extensions like parsing of [markdown-style links](https://gobbledygook.com/ddkf878dfjlsfd https://gobbledygook.com/ddkf878dfjlsfd). And then we would arrive at HTML.
- mdaniel 2y ago> Then people would prefer links that didn't look like gobbledygook Well, I can say with relative confidence that people prefer those links but _marketers_ prefer hxxps://awsmail.me/b64trustmebro/8675309== that leads who fucking knows where
- drcongo 2y agoThe red-flag he should have spotted was Google "Support".
- coldcode 2y agoThe idea that Google would spend money to help a non-business user for anything is beyond unlikely.
- Atotalnoob 2y agoThey don’t even support businesses. We pay for whatever the highest tier of support is. We have been emailing our TAM (or whatever Google calls them) for weeks (and opening tickets) They keep giving us the same fucking documentation link. Literally useless. Another instance we were using code from their docs and they refused to help saying they don’t look at code ever
- MichaelZuo 2y agoThe highest enterprise support tiers at Google cost millions of dollars per month… you probably mean the highest listed on their website for small to medium businesses.
- Atotalnoob 2y agoNo, it’s in the millions.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoThen it’s pretty suprising considering your company would have a direct line to multiple senior people at Mountain View…
- Dansvidania 2y agoI mean, the email says it's from Google Forms. Is that not suspect enough?
- duckmysick 2y agoMy favorite bit: > More importantly, Tony recognized the voice of “Daniel from Google” when it was featured in an interview by Junseth, a podcaster who covers cryptocurrency scams. The same voice that had coaxed Tony out of his considerable cryptocurrency holdings just days earlier also had tried to phish Junseth, who played along for several minutes before revealing he knew it was a scam. > [...] > Daniel told Junseth he and his co-conspirators had just scored a $1.2 million theft that was still pending on the bitcoin investment platform SwanBitcoin. In response, Junseth tagged SwanBitcoin in a post about his podcast on Twitter/X, and the CEO of Swan quickly replied that they caught the $1.2 million transaction that morning. > Apparently, Daniel didn’t appreciate having his voice broadcast to the world (or his $1.2 million bitcoin heist disrupted) because according to Junseth someone submitted a baseless copyright infringement claim about it to Soundcloud, which was hosting the recording. > The complaint alleged the recording included a copyrighted song, but that wasn’t true: Junseth later posted a raw version of the recording to Telegram, and it clearly had no music in the background. Nevertheless, Soundcloud removed the audio file. DMCA enabling bad actors to cover their tracks was not on my bingo list.
- dessimus 2y agoAre there examples of DMCA being used in a positive manner?
- andrewflnr 2y agoYou mean besides literally all the times when people upload raw copyrighted movies and music to YouTube? DMCA is boring and un-newsworthy when it's working properly. (Unless you're the type who thinks copyright is inherently wrong, but it would then be very silly to ask if DMCA was ever "used in a manner".)
- Thorrez 2y agoSomeone once took one of my youtube videos and reuploaded it with a link to malware in the description. I took down the video with a copyright claim.
- bdndndndbve 2y agoI wonder if people who are "invested" in cryptocurrency are more susceptible to these kind of scams. There's a strong aspect of FOMO in getting people to buy imaginary internet money, and also in getting them to panic and fumble said internet money.
- nine_k 2y agoWhile "Nigerian spam" scams profit off simple-minded gullible people, cryptocurrency scams profit off sophisticated gullible people.
- plagiarist 2y agoI wonder if it is just harder to give away several million dollars of government currency without being able to recover it? This is only an interesting story because it is so much money and because they are able to narrow the suspects down to a small group. Cryptocurrencies are like speedrunning the discovery of why finance is regulated, though, that is certainly true.
- acdha 2y agoI think you’re saying the same thing from the other side: it’s definitely true that it’s harder to get or transfer large amounts of real money because the system has layers of protection due to past fraud, but those fraud protections also mean that most people can’t get the kind of paper profits which lure people to cryptocurrencies. This gives scammers the appealing target of a self-selected group of financially unsophisticated people who have chosen a system designed to make large scale theft easy and safe.
- chimen 2y agoOne of the reasons I stay away from it is that, at least in recent years, every scam that I see taking place involves crypto. I have a lot of acquaintances and I can almost draw a line at this stage: the higher the "shadyness" of the person, the more they are invested or talking about crypto. I am yet, even tho I owned, to have had the need to use crypto in my daily/weekly/monthly/yearly life. It is very easy to destroy lives with it as we can see in this case, and, making it harder to do so will work against the vary nature of this tech. This is a tough nut to crack but I think the space will remain filled with predators constantly baiting prey into the system with the promise of a big reward.
- plagiarist 2y ago> By default, Google Authenticator syncs all one-time codes with a Gmail user’s account, meaning if someone gains access to your Google account, they can then access all of the one-time codes handed out by your Google Authenticator app. When business guys are involved in a security app. Many of us can easily imagine the "user story" that caused this.
- vel0city 2y agoJust look at the probably hundreds or more comments here through the years of people bashing Google for having their authenticator app not sync TOTP secrets to the cloud. For the longest time it was pulling teeth to get the app to surrender the TOTP secrets saved inside. Google listened.
- the__alchemist 2y agoThe start of the article and comments thus far focus on the authenticator/Google account scam. I think a separate topic of note is taking a photo of the wallet recovery words [on an internet-connectable device]. This was, IMO, the primary mistake the user made. (And an easy one to make if you don't consider its consequences)
- andrewflnr 2y agoWhat I want to know is if the attackers knew that the photo was there, and if so, how. Or were they just planning to get into the victim's gmail and exploit whatever they found?
- vel0city 2y agoI had these people call me the other day. I got a text message alerting me of a potential Google account security issue they had blocked and they I should expect a call. I also got one of those emails and an automated phone call. The automated phone call had me dial 1 if I wanted a call back from support to help recover my account. I got a call from a very professional sounding woman assuring me she was with Google and they had discovered some potentially fraudulent activity with my Google account in Frankfurt. They said they had locked down my account to protect it but they would walk me through recovering it. I knew this was impossible, because the Google account in question doesn't have passwords. It has a couple of passkeys which are all physical hardware tokens in my home. But I wanted to see how pushy they would get. Turned into a half hour phone call with me playing dumb (was watching my kid's sports practice, nothing to do for a half hour but cheer him on). Eventually when I was done with it I let them know I was in the process of filing the report with the federal cybercrime department. Immediately hung up from that.
- baxtr 2y agoFrankfurt of all places!
- ffsm8 2y agoFrankfurt is actually notorious in Germany for their issues with drugs. Going outta the train station you can see ppl passed out with literal needles in their arms, taking a shit in public view etc Doesn't really transfer to cyber crime, but it's definitely one of the more "criminal" places in Germany. Still super tame compared to actual slums etc though
- WalterBright 2y agoThe last time I was in Frankfurt was maybe 20 years ago. I suppose things have declined quite a bit since then.
- locallost 2y agoNotorious on social media perhaps. I am yet to see someone in Frankfurt passed out with a needle in their arm. I've been to Frankfurt several times in the last years -- slept once in a hotel near the train station, spent a couple hours until 2-3am at and around the train station because of a missed train, spent a lot of time waiting for my next train connection etc.
- ryao 2y agoI have a simple defense against this. I use a special email account for financial information that only my email provider, myself and my financial institutions know to exist. Even if I tap yes instead of no by mistake on a prompt like this, my financial accounts are safe unless the attacker breaches my bank to find out the email account I use with them first.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> my financial accounts are safe unless the attacker breaches my bank to find out the email account I use with them first. It's entirely possible that someone can accomplish this with a phone call to your financial institution's customer help line. "Oh gosh, I'm sorry, I forgot whether I used my email address or my wife's for this account - can you tell me what's on file?"
- ryao 2y agoI wonder how that would work if they cannot prove my identity first by telling the representative a code sent to my phone number. I would expect the bank to tell the attacker to go into the local branch with identification.
- doublerabbit 2y agoSocial Engineering. You would expect the bank too but not so. These scummy people are good at manipulation. Humans are very exploitable. "Im ever so sorry; but I am unable to get to the bank right now, my mother was in an accident and I need to get to the hospital in 30 minutes. Is there any other way?" "No? Can you do it for me". Playing empathy over the phone gets you places as does wearing a workers Hi-Vis jacket to get in to back stage at festivals.
- ryao 2y agoMy bank would happily say too bad. I have had them insist on getting me into the branch for absurd things in the past.
- Fokamul 2y agoHolding $500k in hot wallet, this man is braindead...
- joezydeco 2y agoAre these spammers just lucky or is there something that lets them sniff blood in the water and specifically target people holding large amounts of crypto?
- samatman 2y agoIt wasn't a hot wallet, he had taken a photo of his seed and then left it in Google photos. So your conclusion is sound but your premise is invalid.
- Dansvidania 2y agoI am maybe missing something obvious here, but isn't it suspicious that these attacks "affecting a small number of google users" happened to "hit" two people with significant cryptocurrency holdings?
- tantalor 2y agoMaybe the attackers already knew through some other means that they had large crypto holdings, i.e., spear phishing.
- pjdesno 2y agoIt seems like the common thread here is that the thefts were of cryptocurrency, rather than real assets in a financial system with safeguards. You can still get robbed of those assets, but it leaves a far stronger paper trail to catch the perpetrators.
- Vegenoid 2y agoIt’s the classic tradeoff of freedom vs. security. It’s the biggest reason I can’t foresee myself storing substantial amounts of cryptocurrency. I just want to hand my hard earned money to a financial institution and not have to think about it too much.
- potato3732842 2y agoThe difference is that we haven't spent a century building up police organizations, bureaucracies, processes and international working relationships to track down crypto crime the way we have for "normal" financial crimes. You would track down this crypto in just about the same way you'd track down a fraudulently ordered wire transfer that was cashed out. Records would be requested, IP's and timestamps recorded, more records would be requested from other parties based on those, and so on and so on. The difference is that it's somebody's job to go after those. It's nobody's job to go after this.
- psychoslave 2y agoHow stressful it must be as an experience to go through. Having nothing to be robbed from is such an underrated means to live in serenity.
- donatj 2y agoAbout a year ago I got an email from an actual Coinbase email address telling me that my account had been compromised. It included a case number. Trying to log in with my username and password did not work. Moments later I get a phone call, the caller id says that it is Coinbase. Guy on the phone with a thick German accent tells me he's calling about my account and gives me the case number from the email. I know damn well never to trust a phone call you did not initiate, so I'm kind of just stringing the dude along on the phone. I remember that I had set up a passkey, and try it. I get in with that and immediately run to the emergency "lock my account" button. I tell the guy on the phone that I have clicked it and after a bit of "uhmmm..."-ing and "hmmm..."-ing he just hangs up. I call Coinbase support and they verify some recent transactions and ask me to forward them the email, and that's that. I still have no idea what the actual attack was or how they changed or invalidated my password. Best I can tell they did not manage to actually get in to my account. I ended up changing my password to just about everything out of caution.
- cute_boi 2y agoLast time I called boss money transfer, i called them and their real agents told me they must call me to verify. I was like, how would I know if it is boss money transfer or scammer. At the end I had to trust because voice was same.
- imp0cat 2y agohow they changed or invalidated my password. Probably just too many invalid login attempts.
- cute_boi 2y agoNever Trust a call you didn't initiate.
- deathanatos 2y agoI wholehearted agree with your mantra. But I need banks and other businesses to learn this. Particularly banks. My bank has literally called me with what amounts to "ur being haxxor3d", and like … who are you? The representative literally would not tell me who he worked for. I was 210% sure it was a scam, and hung up on him. Turned out, it was legit.¹ Companies need to make sure their own operations don't bear the trappings of fraud. ¹(I don't regret hanging up, though. Calling back to a known, published-by-the-business-itself number is the right thing to do.)
- SoftTalker 2y agoYeah I got a similar call once from someone, maybe a credit card company, and the first question was "to verify your identity we need the last four digits of your social security number" and I was like wait a minute, you called me. What are the last four digits of YOUR social security number?
- buttercraft 2y ago“In Soundcloud’s instance, part of declaring your innocence is you have to give them your home address and everything else, and it says right on there, ‘this will be provided to the person making the copyright claim.'” Good job helping the scammers, SoundCloud. WTF
- packtreefly 2y agoThe glaring common denominator here is that the attacker has the ability to send an unprompted, unblockable request to the victim's phone. Pressing the safe-looking green button that shows up, even accidentally, is digital suicide. Google Prompt is supposed to be a safety feature. The account recovery process lets a hostile actor turn Google Prompt into a loaded gun, and Google puts it directly into the victim's hand, aimed straight at their own head. There's absolutely no way to shut off Google Prompt that doesn't involve removing every Google app from your mobile devices.
- Too 2y agoThis is called MFA bombing. Just send prompts until the user accidentally accepts one. Microsoft’s authentication has protection against this, requiring you to manually enter a 2 digit number in your phone, matching what you see on your other device. Very simple, there is no excuse for Google to not have similar.
- panstromek 2y agoHmm. I remember using a code like this with google, too. Seems like they had something similar in the past.
- franga2000 2y agoYou used to have to click the correct two-digit number out of 3 options, but now it's just "way this you? (yes/no)"
- gameshot911 2y agoThat quickly becomes tedious when you need to do it multiple times a day - e.g. logging in to different customer environments. Much prefer the one-click approval.
- wholinator2 2y agoYeah, it's all a balance though. Personally, I'm fine with sacrificing a couple seconds here and there, maybe a minute a day at most to help the rest of the population not have their life destroyed. I do admit though that if we calculated out all the time across all the people it would probably be a less rosy picture. But even the authentication we have now still takes some time, we could save seconds of each person's life if we just rid it altogether. I think i'd need some statistics on time spent vs catastrophes avoided to make a solid determination. Presumably Google has this data?
- VoodooJuJu 2y ago[flagged]
- jlund-molfese 2y agoIt's not really a matter of intelligence, and nobody's smart 100% of the time. Let's take the average person on this forum, who's probably pretty tech savvy. Their odds of falling for a scam on a given day might be 1 in a billion. But when they're exhausted after work, they might be 10X likelier to fall for a scam. Another 10X when they're stressed out about family life, or going through a breakup. Another 10X when they're out drinking with their friends. And so on. Eventually, whether it's due to age or other factors, everyone gets to be in situations where they're susceptible to scams. And scammers are experts at emotional manipulation, exploiting fear and embarrassment.
- bdangubic 2y ago100% - yes - if you follow simple rules
- UltraSane 2y agoThat is one really nasty aspect of cryptocurrency. They make theft cryptographically irreversible. And you can watch the thieves spend your money!
- nytesky 2y agoIt does feel like the security protocols necessary to secure $100k to $Ms of crypto which transfers instantly and non-reversibly is a challenge for the average user. Even as a fairly tech enabled GenX, I have forgotten passwords and had to reset them (usually accounts I haven’t used in a while), had files corrupted without a good backup, lost a Yubikey somewhere in the house (I think at least). From what I can tell I would need to have my crypto seed laser etched into titanium, and then treat that talisman as if it was made of pure platinum as far as securing and tracking it. Versus keeping my money in SIPC and FDIC protected accounts. I will say, the BTC appreciation is a big attraction of course, but long term I don’t see how it becomes widely adopted with so much logistics risk, and appreciation… well who knows about that.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoI have no doubt that at least some especially in the early days envisioned crypto as a legitimate alternative to fiat currency. That being said, in it's mature state as a technology, it amounts to nothing more than a clone of the modern financial system with a different set of oligarchs, except that it has far fewer consumer protections, and the nature of it makes implementing said protections in any way extremely difficult. That combined with the extreme volatility of value that is not only endemic to any coin with meaningful usage, but is generally a goal of most coins, makes it only really useful as a speculative vehicle, and those same properties also make it uniquely bad in terms of a store of value to be used in commerce unless the seller also plans to speculate on the value. And, even if you're good with all of that: Yes, the tech itself is decentralized, but if you don't have at least some background in basic software development or scripting, you're almost certainly going to end up using some product or another to manage your wallets and transactions, and while the wallet is anonymous, the accounts you connect the wallet to are often quite the opposite, and because of the structure of the chains, your entire transaction history is visible to everyone on the network, at all times. So it's private by default, but basically any casual user is immediately and forever doxxable.
- f33d5173 2y agoXmr aims to be a digital cash, and basically achieves that. Btc has goals more akin to digital gold, hence being more useful to speculators than people buying things is somewhat intentional. I don't know who the oligarchs you're talking about are. Buterin? Bankman Fried? In either case, their position is quite different from that of a banking titan.
- tdiff 2y agoSo the attacker has known in advance that the secret was stored in google photos? Is it a common way to store passwords, or is some piece missing here?
- dmonitor 2y agoLikely a common way to store recovery codes. Similar to those bots that scrape github for API keys
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- layman51 2y agoI had read of this attack back in September[1]. It seems very sophisticated because they spoof a phone number that at first glance is associated with Google, but is really just the “uncanny-valley” Google Assistant service that can check wait times or make reservations on your behalf. Does Google even offer live-person support if you’re not their Workspace customer? Also, one other difference is that apparently the attackers may have been using Salesforce to send the emails. Maybe they were using a trial or developer edition? I believe those can send out emails too, but they are very limited. So this must be a very targeted kind of attack. The scary part is that the attacker’s emails pass SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. There’s a technical write-up I found about this aspect of the attack.[2] [1]: https://sammitrovic.com/infosec/gmail-account-takeover-super-realistic-ai-scam-call/ https://sammitrovic.com/infosec/gmail-account-takeover-super... [2]: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xrJsRBcGj9x2mMvRoKLG4ANSs6a4C_rtsDQR7KlXYEA/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xrJsRBcGj9x2mMvRoKLG4ANS...
- darknavi 2y ago> Does Google even offer live-person support if you’re not their Workspace customer? Not really. That's the giant red flag behind committing to a gmail, outlook, etc. account. If it gets messed up you're at the whim of "on-rail" support and if you need anything more all you can do is shout into social media and hope a stray employee feels bad for you.
- smoothgrammer 2y agoYes they do. If you subscribe to Google One. https://support.google.com/googleone/ https://support.google.com/googleone/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ht85 2y agoThe wallet name was exodus, how fitting :D
- simonw 2y agoThe defining feature of crypto - decentralized, irreversible, no "higher power" you can go to in order to get your money back - turns out to be the thing that burns people ALL the time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mouse_ 2y agoLots of people still don't quite understand their debit card. No way they're going to learn how private keys work. Still might some sense as an institutional store of value though I guess.
- stouset 2y agoMaybe but this shit is hard for institutions too. There are so many sharp edges. Even in a well-respected fintech with responsible, talented people I’ve seen: safe deposit boxes get lost (literally no idea where in the world they actually are), go missing (the bank relocates or closes and disposes of them without notification) or become destroyed (fire, flood). I have seen industrial-grade hardware security modules spontaneously corrupt all the internal keys, happily continuing to produce “encrypted” output which can never be decrypted. Building crypto offerings at scale that can survive the myriad unknown unknowns of real world and hardware failures that can affect both paper and hardware wallets is a really difficult problem. Not impossible, but the stakes are extreme and getting one thing wrong that leads to the loss of a cold wallet can easily lead to total ruin. Even if “only” a hot wallet gets popped, the instantaneous and irrevocable loss of those funds needs to be offset by a comparatively large amount of operating profit. At least with the traditional banking system there are a lot of safeguards in place.
- derangedHorse 2y agoSurprisingly, there's also no "higher power" to get your money back from scams using traditional banking rails as well. I have family members who have lost thousands from bank transfers to legally registered companies that establish legitimacy through having a business bank account. It usually takes forever to shut them down, even after hundreds of thousands of reports from people like me who recognize what they are early on. Many haven't actually lost money in significant ways through bank transfers, but when it does happen, the disillusionment of institutional security really falls away. Additionally, governments are slow and ineffective, so when these companies do get caught with class action lawsuits, they usually don't have anything to return.
- Zopieux 2y ago>ultimately seized control over the account by convincing him to click “yes” to a Google [2FA] prompt on his mobile device Stopped reading there. What more can we do to protect people from their own stupidity (and I'm not talking about the crypto "investment" part)?
- o999 2y agoAlmost all scammers use more or less the same trick, they try to trigger a fear or greed rush with their message/call, so you don't get a chance to question authenticity of what you read or hear. That is also what many salespersons do to get you to buy what you don't need nor even want, you cannot miss this limited time discount. Always stop for a moment and be skeptical, caller ID can be spoofed, email addresd can have ä or ē in the domain that you won't notice if you don't look carefully.
- 101008 2y agoI couldn't find it from the article, but how the scammer got access to the Gmail account? How he triggered that prompt in the victim's phone, and what did it mean? It feels something is missing here? Edit: Well, I learnt about Google Prompts today: https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/7026266?hl=en&co=GENIE.Platform%3DAndroid#zippy= https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/7026266?hl=en&co=... Basically someone can request access to your account and if you click Yes, they do access it. This part from a Reddit thread [1] scared me a bit: > The notification pops up on my screen over whatever I am doing, and if I'm using my phone, I worry that I might accidentally hit YES (it almost happened today). 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/techsupport/comments/ccd304/someone_else_keeps_trying_to_recover_my_google/ https://www.reddit.com/r/techsupport/comments/ccd304/someone...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pico303 2y agoI always tell people to take control of the situation and stay calm. If “Google” or someone contacts you about a problem, simply hang up or ignore the email, look up the company’s info online, and contact the company directly.
- megablast 2y ago> Daniel told Tony his account was being accessed by someone in Frankfurt, Germany, and that he could evict the hacker and recover access to the account by clicking “yes” to the prompt that Google was going to send to his phone. Come on.
- can16358p 2y agoWhile this is devastating, the lesson that we should all remember: Never, ever, no matter the circumstances, store private keys (or seed phrases) on photos. Especially if those photos are synchronized to the cloud. Hand-write them, store them in a safe and secure PHYSICAL location. Of course we're humans, we make mistakes, and we usually start with small amounts of money that we can lose where it would be unnecessary to take all these precautions, but we still need to regularly remind ourselves to avoid disasters like this in the self-custody world.
- ipython 2y agoOk but you have to balance that with the risk that your PHYSICAL item will be lost, stolen, or destroyed. What happens then? The problem is that the security protocols required to keep cryptocurrency safe are simply untenable for any mere mortal. But hey, we keep blaming the victims… because they didn’t know the one simple trick to keep their Bitcoin safe!
- zem 2y agoor store them in some encrypted form that you know how to reverse easily but which would take an attacker more trouble than it was worth to break.
- shusaku 2y agoHonestly, that part of the story seemed completely unbelievable. I mean I get that someone might stare such a photo in the cloud, but hackers are really going to run a scam on him and then sift through photos thinking “maybe?”
- panstromek 2y agoI'd assume there's some model for finding those kinds of photos
- ufmace 2y agoI think a lot of people bought some crypto early on when it was really cheap, were kind of sloppy about the security of things, and then left it alone and ignored everything while it went up by 10,000x in value. Now when their account is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, their security is pretty inadequate for something with that actual value.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- consumerx 2y ago[dead]
- tugu77 2y agoEasy for me to be a smartass in hindsight, but I can't resist: > Unfortunately for Griffin, years ago he used Google Photos to store an image of the secret seed phrase that was protecting his cryptocurrency wallet. Um, duh... > "[...] I put my seed phrase into a phishing site, and that was it.” >Almost immediately, all of the funds he was planning to save for retirement and for his children’s college fund were drained from his account. Um, duh. First mistake to put all eggs in a single basket. Second mistake, this basket was a cryptocurrency. Third mistake, pasting the secret key to that _anywhere_.
- chandiceraeni 2y ago[dead]
- yapyap 2y agoLosing a fortune with one bad click is not a new thing or all that rare, stock betting is all the same. Idk I just think the title is pretty lame and generalizes a pretty informative phishing article, in a bad way.
- fortran77 2y agoHow did the scammers know these people were likely to have significant amount of crypto in the first place?
- SMAAART 2y ago45 BTC (as in the screenshots) is not 500K, it's 4.5M
- _heimdall 2y agoI hadn't considered that use of Google Forms to send emails from a Google domain. That's a pretty huge security risk, technically it doesn't risk your zgiogle account but the phishing and impersonation risks for Google are huge.
- sneak 2y agoStop using TOTP. Enable Advanced Protection on your Google account and exclusively use security keys. Problem solved. Total cost: $30 in security keys (Advanced Protection enrollment is free.) It’s just like Canada Bill Jones said: It’s immoral to let a sucker keep his money.
- rolandthomas 2y ago[dead]
- lilianadavis32 2y ago[dead]