25 ms·
US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
- nadermx 2y agoBizarre, in the land of free speech the government is suppressing it.
- talldayo 2y agoIronic how the EU comes out on top for acknowledging sideloading as a fundamental feature of smartphones. It will take the "it's a series of tubes" guys quite some time to figure that one out.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoI think the main problem will be TikTok to conduct business in America, charge for ads to target American users and pay American content providers. It’s just a free app if they can’t earn money on it.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoGod, I can’t believe I’m saying this, but it’s the perfect use case for crypto to avoid US payment rail controls. Get a16z on the phone, he said with less sarcasm than one would expect.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoUsing crypto doesn’t somehow make you immune to prosecution. If the government says TikTok is banned, no company’s chief counsel is going to suggest getting around the ban by using bitcoin.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIt took forever for the US to do anything about Uber, Lyft, and Airbnb breaking the law. In a post competency, low regulation environment we’re entering, it makes sense to explore creative solutions to extend runway imho (vs immediately folding).
- mrbombastic 2y agoI would argue the lack of action against those was due to lack of political will. At least at the beginning many saw Uber and Airbnb as net positives, American led innovators offering competition to hotels and taxi cartels. TikTok on the other hand is getting hammered by both sides of the aisle. the incoming admin has its contradictions but has been pretty pro tariff / anti Chinese competition so I am not sure games like that are going to play much but we shall see.
- mrbombastic 2y agoI can’t edit this now but I see Trump has changed his tune on TikTok in another comment, so maybe they will have better luck.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://techcrunch.com/2024/12/22/trump-says-he-wants-to-keep-tiktok-around-for-a-little-while/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/12/22/trump-says-he-wants-to-kee... https://www.reuters.com/technology/trump-says-it-could-be-worth-keeping-tiktok-us-little-while-2024-12-22/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/trump-says-it-could-be-wo... https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cre7vdz4npzo https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cre7vdz4npzo
- gretch 2y ago> It took forever for the US to do anything about Uber, Lyft, and Airbnb breaking the law. And yet look how fast tik tok was banned.
- bdangubic 2y agoLand of free speech? Maybe in like a John Wayne movie was this ever true… Like you know other parts of Bill or “Rights” like “prohibiting unreasonable searches and seizures” except like your toothpaste at the airport… Americans are generally too funny thinking it is still “land of the free”
- rodgerd 2y agoHayes Code. Comics Code Authority. And so on and so forth.
- ImJamal 2y agoNone of those were laws?
- kombookcha 2y agoThe Hayes Code exists to have a standardized industry guideline in response to individual states issuing dozens of differing film censorship bills. So while it is not a law, it is a guideline for how to be compliant with a rapidly proliferating number of censorship laws.
- hyperpape 2y ago> Land of free speech? Maybe in like a John Wayne movie was this ever true… What country would you say has stronger free speech protections than the US? I won't say there's none, because there are roughly 200 countries, and I don't know enough about many of them, but I cannot name one. Not the UK, France or Germany, and I'd be surprised to find any other European country. For a sampling of other laws/measures: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insult_(legal) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A8se-majest%C3%A9 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blasphemy_law - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_the_press#/media/File:World_Map_of_the_Freedom_of_the_Press_Status,_OWID.svg Now...if this ban sticks, it will make your snark a lot more valid, starting with the year 2025.
- bdangubic 2y ago
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoWe should be more like China then? I’m confused.
- bdangubic 2y ago[flagged]
- lttlrck 2y agoExplain the GFW then? Because that seems like the flip-side of the very same coin?
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoChina doesn’t officially block any American social media. If you ask your Chinese ISP they say it’s just technical problems. There is probably a list somewhere that is considered a state secret, like the list of banned words and banned books. You do not want to cross China’s broad state secrets law by even pretending to know. Anyways, China should feel proud that this is the first social media app from China that the Americans thought was worth banning. And in China you know that if something is worth banning it must be good right?
- washadjeffmad 2y agoWe shouldn't get into a dick measuring contest over who hides more from their citizens. That the Chinese have used our brain worm factories against us, infiltrated our domestic surveillance and wiretapping systems, and let themselves into our completely volitional infrastructure backdoors should only stimulate us to ask why we created such things in the first place. Where's our canary, again?
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoOh, I agree, the USA shouldn’t ban TikTok like China shouldn’t have banned…almost all of the non-Chinese social media services. Neither is going to lead to a better market, tech landscape, and I don’t believe national security is a valid concern in any case. But I really meant what I said about china probably having pride in TikTok now, being banned by your competitor country really is an achievement. Nobody has even brought up Europe approach to requiring data on shoring and stricter privacy controls, which is the real way to deal with either issue.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y ago"Free speech" is not like the free square in Bingo. You can't just use it whenever. Commerce is already regulated, speech is already regulated, there's no way around those things not being absolute. If you have a specific argument about the nuance of this situation, then make it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nadermx 2y ago"the Act, as construed and applied, is unconstitutional, since it imposes on the addressee an affirmative obligation which amounts to an unconstitutional limitation of his rights under the First Amendment." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamont_v._Postmaster_General https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamont_v._Postmaster_General
- sebzim4500 2y agoThat seems like a very different case since it imposed different rules depending on the content of the speech. The analogous situation to the tiktok ban would be shutting down the postal service, which would be surprising but presumably constitutional.
- porknubbins 2y agoI’m no Tiktok fan but the US has extremely broad free speech protections and its hard to see how this could be constitutional. Individuals posting videos of themselves is clearly speech so we are in the 1st amendment territory. None of the usual exceptions for certain types of content (defamation, threats, fraud etc) apply because the restriction isn’t on specific content. The only way out I could see is saying national security/secrets require us to prevent the Chinese company Tiktok from operating in the US.
- FranzFerdiNaN 2y agoBut their free speech isn’t limited. They lose a platform, which is something completely different. Free speech doesn’t mean having to facilitate it. People can still create a website and post their clips, or move to instagram or Snapchat or bluesky or twitter or whatever.
- unitedscamerica 2y agoThis has nothing to do with speech.
- gamesetmath 2y ago[dead]
- nadermx 2y agoSo banning a public square has nothing to do with free speech? "A fundamental principle of the First Amendment is that all persons have access to places where they can speak and listen, and then, after reflection, speak and listen once more." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packingham_v._North_Carolina https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packingham_v._North_Carolina
- dialup_sounds 2y ago"The First Amendment exists to protect free speech in the United States,” said the court’s opinion, which was written by Judge Douglas Ginsburg. “Here the Government acted solely to protect that freedom from a foreign adversary nation and to limit that adversary’s ability to gather data on people in the United States.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TikTok_v._Garland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TikTok_v._Garland
- pessimizer 2y agoThey've determined that it's not a violation of free speech because China, and that it's not a bill of attainder because China. You could replace "China" with anything. What does it mean to be a "foreign adversary?" When did voters get a say in that? When Democrats (and every media outlet) were accusing Trump of being a secret Russian agent, and people who supported him of being traitors, would it have been legal (and not a "punishment" but a "prophylactic" as the appeals court said about TikTok) for the legislature to limit their free speech by name?
- nickthegreek 2y agoIt’s not a public square. They ban people from their private square all the time.
- hetman 2y ago[flagged]
- BLKNSLVR 2y agoAren't most TikTok videos viewed by americans made by americans?
- epoxia 2y ago"I only believe in flat earthers from the US of A. Wouldn't want to be manipulated by any foreign governments". There are so many useful idiots, they were never going to manipulate you directly, there's too many people. I can't even tell how much of this comment section is astroturfed / bot driven anymore.
- nojvek 2y agoSo much for moral high ground of “free speech and free enterprise”
- hetman 2y agoYes. For their own citizens, not foreign actors who wish to influence said citizens.
- cma 2y agoGreat firewall is one of the worst aspects of China, why do that here?
- brickfaced 2y ago[flagged]
- TheDong 2y agoIf spying and influencing vulnerable youths is the problem, shouldn't we be getting EU-like privacy laws and anti-social-media laws instead? Youths are just as able to get addicted to chinese-produced content on instagram and youtube as tiktok, and all 3 of those apps use algorithms that optimize for roughly the same thing (making you watch more ads and contents, profit). Other companies collect similar amount of our vulnerable youth's private information, also for the same reason (to target ads).
- maeil 2y ago> If spying and influencing vulnerable youths is the problem, shouldn't we be getting EU-like privacy laws and anti-social-media laws instead? TikTok just massively influenced the Romanian elections (in the EU) by intentionally turning a blind eye to $millions of ad spend by Russia for a pro-Russian candidate. Despite all those laws. TikTok is an asset of China that's clear as day. Sure, many times very awful things have been waved away by simply using the phrase "national security". In this case, that phrase is accurate. It's an absurd national security risk to have one of the most influential platforms in a Western country to be an asset of China. This is the reality we live in. It's unfortunate, but it's the way it is. Dancing around the elephant in the room is an incredible waste of time.
- brickfaced 2y agoThis is a laughably naïve view of Chinese-owned companies and the total, I repeat total, amount of control China's one-party state wields over those entities.
- tivert 2y ago
- xiphias2 2y agoSo many decisions are being made during the transition that could have been made before the election. Is this normal / good for the countries in general? Regarding TikTok I agree that it's a national security problem for USA in its current form, so actually it is not even the decision that I oppose.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoThe decision was made a year ago when the bill was passed.
- mattmaroon 2y agoThe date is pretty suspect though.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoNot really
- mattmaroon 2y agoYes, it is. It’s not common to enact laws on the day before one leaves office. Pardons, sure. It’s clearly an attempt to ram it through before the administration changes. Even a year ago they knew there was a good chance of that.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoHow is it rammed through?
- mattmaroon 2y agoDo you think it’s just coincidence that the date was the last day of a presidential term? Can you think of other controversial laws that did that?
- neilv 2y agoA burst of commenting without upvoting is a good way to quickly bury a post on HN.
- ezconnect 2y agoMotto of the powerful. Can't beat them? Ban them. Same thing they did with Huawei they can't steal the patents it owns to use on their 5G network so ban them.
- xnx 2y agoAre Huawei backdoors part of the active telecom control that China has in the US networks currently? TikTok seems much more benign.
- ezconnect 2y agoUS don't need to buy their units, just pay for the patent so they can implement the technology.
- bozhark 2y agoopposite, in fact
- zarzavat 2y agoThe only thing that makes Chinese control of social media seem benign is that the US is doing a far better job of pushing harmful propaganda onto itself than China could ever accomplish.
- betaby 2y ago> Are Huawei backdoors part of the active telecom control that China has in the US networks currently? No. There were audits and fond no backdoors in Huawei equipment.
- tgma 2y agoAudits can only conclusively prove existence of backdoors, not lack of backdoors. At best, you get some assurance.
- rdm_blackhole 2y agoThat's not very logical at all. I believe that a flying unicorn orbits the moon. When no unicorn is found, does that prove that a unicorn may exist? You can't use a negative to prove a point. Either the point is proven and supported by evidence or it is just speculation. If it is speculation, then it can be dismissed since it has no basis in reality. In this particular case, if an audit was done and found no backdoors then as far as we know and until such a time as we find a backdoor, then there are no backdoors. If you want to continue to believe that there is a backdoor, then this is an opinion which does not constitute proof of any sort and certainly should not be used to come up with policies such as banning a company from operating in the US in case of a mythical backdoor which has so far eluded everyone.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42340959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42340959
- xnx 2y ago1) Excellent way to teach millions of people about sideloading overnight. This could be a big win for Android (where sideloading is easy) vs. iPhone were sideloading is impossible (? or only possible only with an annual dev license?) 2) Will this affect apps like CapCut and Lemon8 too?
- soheil 2y agoYeah tiktok is a drop in the ocean for the critical mass needed for people to abandon iPhone. It is already highly censored in the US and no one said let's use Android.
- Gigachad 2y agoTikTok could just release a web app
- dev-jayson 2y agoThey already do, all they gotta do is take out the redirect to App popup and voila.
- dzhiurgis 2y agoIt's not amazing, just like most web apps from big tech.
- darknavi 2y agoIt's not amazing by choice. Web apps for internet video playing would work fine, companies just make their mobile websites hostile as possible to push you towards their mobile app where you can get the same experience but with significantly more data collection on the app's part.
- rsanek 2y agoI wonder what kind of impact this would have on their ability to actually provide good ML recommendations. Based on reporting that would be a lot of data to give up
- AIFounder 2y ago[dead]
- supernetworks_ 2y agoAmericans can’t invest directly in Chinese companies and shouldn’t be obligated to host Chinese companies in their markets or be surprised when political whims ban them, since the lack of shared investment is political too. People clearly enjoy the content on there so the outcome is sad but it’s a complicated economic dynamic that is hard to grasp
- shalmanese 2y ago60% of Bytedance is owned by American investors https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/26/technology/tiktok-investors-bytedance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/26/technology/tiktok-investo... > Susquehanna, a global trading firm, first invested in ByteDance in 2012 and now owns roughly 15 percent of the company, a person familiar with the investment said. The Chinese arm of Sequoia Capital, a Silicon Valley venture capital firm, invested in ByteDance in 2014 when it was valued at $500 million. Sequoia’s U.S.-based growth fund later followed suit. > General Atlantic, a private equity firm, invested in ByteDance in 2017 at a $20 billion valuation. Bill Ford, General Atlantic’s chief executive, has a seat on ByteDance’s board of directors. The company’s other notable U.S. investors include the private equity firms KKR and the Carlyle Group, as well as the hedge fund Coatue Management.
- wordofx 2y agoLiterally does not matter. ByteDance is a Chinese company and beholden to the CCP.
- solaarphunk 2y agoJust like US companies are beholden to national security letters that can compel them to spy on non-US persons who may be users of their product?
- Dylan16807 2y agoIf other countries ban US websites for specifically that reason, I applaud them. Especially if they do it without being hypocritical.
- toofy 2y ago1) this is going to open younger peoples eyes to installing stuff outside of app stores. which i think is a great development. 2) if We believe that social media has the ability to influence to the degree that we’re going to outlaw a company, why tf are we not outlawing all manipulative algorithms, from every country? i absolutely do not magically trust billionaires just because they’re from the US… and i certainly don’t trust them more than i trust any government. there’s reasonable arguments that they’re more dangerous than governments. after everything we’ve seen these social media titans do, it’s absurd to trust them. we have so much actual material real evidence of their societal manipulation in every direction. 3) im not at all convinced outright outlawing is the answer. but i’ll kinda rhyme with 2) again, if We collectively admit it’s dangerous enough that it must be made illegal, then all of these companies are dangerous—all of them.
- gretch 2y ago> i absolutely do not magically trust billionaires just because they’re from the US… and i certainly don’t trust them more than i trust any government. there’s reasonable arguments that they’re more dangerous than governments. after everything we’ve seen these social media titans do, it’s absurd to trust them. What does it mean to "trust" them? Right now you are on hacker news, a social media site which is owned by ycombinator and is run by a board of some billionaires. What are you doing here reading the articles on the front page and posting comments??
- toofy 2y agoi’m not sure which part confuses you—it means what i said. i don’t magically trust them more than i trust any government. if the collective We have decided we don’t trust governments with algorithmic manipulation powers, why on earth are we trusting anyone with concentrated power: billionaires, churches, governments, etc… it would seem We have deemed social media to be incredibly dangerous. i’m not yet personally convinced it is, but We apparently decided already. so why are we ignoring other wannabe kings wielding something we deem dangerous?
- 2y ago
- exabrial 2y agoAs grating as this is to freedom of expression, I’ve been annoyed enough times by ‘tok’ers doing crap like I dunno, licking ice cream buckets in supermarkets, I’m also looking forward to that going away for a few months till the next thing replaces it. Unfortunately, this is pretty bad precedent. While I love my country, these sorts of decisions are as federal level are pretty scary and I question whether the government should wield this power.
- soramimo 2y agoCounter point, how is letting the primary adversarial power (which happens to be an authoritarian regime) massively influence the political views of the future generation a good idea? It sounds to me like the federal government is doing its job here.
- disqard 2y agoI really don't understand why you are being downvoted. I'm baffled at folks wanting to overlook that a Chinese-controlled brainworm is even more dangerous than a US-operated brainworm. Yes, we should steer clear of all brainworms, but we should be exterminating the brainworms run by adversaries ASAP.
- latentcall 2y agoWho’s the adversary? China? China is not my adversary even if the United States government thinks so. I believe many Americans would agree with that. To me it seems China made a superior app that the American youth wanted to use and the American social media apparatus was jealous so lobbied to have it banned.
- OhioMan2943 2y agoChina was supporting russian bot accounts in the recent us election. Sounds pretty adversarial to me
- 2y ago
- drukenemo 2y ago“Free market”. Such a thing doesn’t really exist.
- FranzFerdiNaN 2y agoWhich is a good thing. 19th century England is not something to emulate.
- kelnos 2y agoSure, I don't think it ever has, and that's fine. I'm of the opinion that truly free markets end in massive consolidation, monopolistic behaviors, and rent-seeking. We've been seeing some of this already in recent decades. The current administration in the US was starting to really think about what to do about that, but I expect the next one will allow businesses to do whatever they please.
- lm28469 2y agoIt never has, that's just what they tell you in school so you believe in meritocracy and the american dream
- rbbydotdev 2y agoWould this sort of targeted app ban by the federal govt be the first of its kind in US? Without any arguments of the pros or cons, the precedent I think is worthy of some consideration.
- dthakur 2y agoI think Grindr underwent a forced divestiture from its Chinese owners due to US gov as well.
- nozzlegear 2y agoNot sure about apps specifically, but there's plenty of precedent for banning foreign-owned media (newspapers, tv stations) in the United States. This seems like a natural evolution of those old laws.
- sadeshmukh 2y agoI'm not sure how exactly the First Amendment works, so someone please correct me, but does banning a platform constitute a violation if individuals can choose other platforms?
- gpm 2y ago"It depends" (like every legal question). It's possible to violate free speech rights by banning a platform even when their are alternatives. Most relevantly to this situation, the platform itself is most likely engaging in speech of its own by choosing what to repeat of what other people have said (i.e. it's choice of algorithm). If the platform was being banned for that speech (and that speech didn't happen to fall under an exception) that would be problematic. It's also clearly possible to ban a platform under other circumstances. For instance banning a platform that was used by various parties for (protected!) speech, but was also being used for money laundering... TikTok is a complicated case. It is on the edge of banning a platform for protected speech in so much as it is concerned with a US corporations (relevant because speech by non-americans from outside of the US is not protected) choice of recommendation algorithm, except the algorithm is really dictated by a Chinese corporation under the direct influence of the CPP. There are also however very compelling legitimate concerns the government has, such as the CPP's espionage interests, and the CPP's (not-protected, as a foreign government!) influence over TikTok's speech. It's also notable in this case that the platform is being banned only so long as the foreign adversary refuses to divest. TikTok is free to continue operating in the US, so long as it isn't under China's (an entity without free speech rights) control. I'd encourage you to read the appeals court ruling for a much more nuanced, and authoritative, take then mine: https://media.cadc.uscourts.gov/opinions/docs/2024/12/24-1113-2088317.pdf https://media.cadc.uscourts.gov/opinions/docs/2024/12/24-111...
- sadeshmukh 2y agoThanks for the pointer - I'll definitely read it
- brookst 2y agoI’m not aware of any other platforms that have been banned, without also having criminal cases opened. Are there any?
- geor9e 2y agoApple and Google control exactly what data apps can possibly harvest, via their OS permissions. There are millions of apps on their app stores. If apps are acting like spyware then the government should pressure Apple and Google to fix the issue at the OS level. Otherwise it's just whack-a-mole.
- macintux 2y agoApple and Google can only control the data shared via the operating system. They can’t control what user behaviors that applications record on the server.
- OWMYT 2y agoYeah, it doesn't matter that much if people are voluntarily giving away as many data as possible to an adversarial authoritarian regime. Still, it is disingenuous of Apple to justify its iron grip on iOS apps as a privacy protection measure when it leaves open widely abused API's for years that its users have no way of opting out.
- tivert 2y ago> If apps are acting like spyware then the government should pressure Apple and Google to fix the issue at the OS level. If you think that's the issue, you're mistaken or confused.
- geor9e 2y agoMost people are confused by this legislation. It's specifically going to keep allowing tiktok via mobile browser, which is essentially the same experience and tracking of user interactions, therefore the legislation is specifically about the extra data the apps are able to record.
- soheil 2y agoApps are not acting like spyware on iOS or else you're as clueless as the Reuters "journalist" who wrote this propaganda piece and never probably seen Swift code or looked into how incredibly well app sandboxing works.
- gkanai 2y agoReciprocity is key. Google and Facebook and most Western web services are blocked in China. If that is the case, then there should be no complaint with blocking Bytedance/other Chinese apps in the West.
- solaarphunk 2y agoThey are blocked because they don’t censor content. If they did agree to, they would be allowed - just like Microsoft, Bing, Apple, and a handful of other digital products are not blocked in China. Edit: for those downvoting me, Google literally shut down their China operations because they were unwilling to comply with censorship requirements. Conversely, Google and other US companies seem completely willing to comply with national security letters that compel them to spy on non-US persons, which should make other countries where US companies operate equally uneasy.
- gkanai 2y ago> They are blocked because they don’t censor content. These platforms certainly do censor content. They have large teams globally that do just that.
- solaarphunk 2y agoI agree, but they have clearly not met the standard for what China needs. I mean Zuck literally was jogging around Beijing 10 years ago trying to build goodwill to get in, and it was Google that made the decision to exit the market.
- est 2y ago> They have large teams globally that do just that. You are spreading the misinformation. Google can't keep up with the censorship shit and gave up as stated in their official blog https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/01/new-approach-to-china.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/01/new-approach-to-chin... > a more open Internet outweighed our discomfort in agreeing to censor some results > We have decided we are no longer willing to continue censoring our results on Google.cn People seem to forget Google had a notorious record a terrible customer service. And China always demand more.
- est 2y agoIs it legally possible for Tiktok to provide a "takeout" function, and user uploads the data to a non-bytedance app that happens to work exact the same way as Tiktok do? If so, this whac-a-mole could go on for ever. Feds would practically establish an office dedicated for app approval
- DiscourseFan 2y agoIts possible but unlikely if that data happens to corroborate the suspicions of lawmakers
- rmbyrro 2y agoif their execs want to get arrested the moment they step out of China, sure
- incahoots 2y agoThis was always about running defense for the likes of Israel and it’s ongoing televised genocide…. This isn’t about national security, if it had been this would’ve never gotten as far as it has been, the door would’ve been closed long ago. TikTok and its algorithm isn’t beholden to the US’s government mandate like the other social media platforms. It also just happens to be the one with the largest amount of users and engagement, compared to the others.. Anyone who’s been paying attention to the numerous times TikTok has been on the chopping block (nearly every year it’s existed) understand what’s at play here.
- xwowsersx 2y ago[flagged]
- hiddencost 2y agoA monstrous lie.
- RandomThoughts3 2y ago> Israel targets Hamas, not civilians While HN is not necessarily the correct place for this discussion, note that the ICC strongly disagrees with this after a lengthy investigation and multiple quotes from Israelian politicians and generals indicate that this is not the case.
- ternnoburn 2y ago[flagged]
- suraci 2y agoI like your comment A good example of "I know it's B_S_, but I pretend I don't know"
- hetman 2y agoAnyone who's used TikTok knows the platform is heavily moderated and not at all an "anything goes" paradise for the exchange of free ideas. So, if, as you suggested, the moderation does not favour the US government's mandate, then the obvious question one should be asking is: whose mandate does it favour?
- jaimsam 2y agoToo many elections are being influenced by the free exchange of ideas on TikTok -- best to shut it down if the U.S. corrupt government cannot control it. Who cares what the people think!?
- iends 2y agoIt's not the free exchange of ideas if the CCP can put its thumb on the scale.
- dqv 2y agoRight on, it's only a free exchange of ideas if US alphabet agencies can exclusively put their thumb on the scale. The CCP's "influence" here is just letting content exist that would normally be suppressed on other platforms. Which, obviously, the US government doesn't like - do not intersperse the pro-US military content with anticapitalist rhetoric!!!
- mattigames 2y agoIt's there any sources to support your claim that TikTok is allowing content that is being suppressed in other platforms? I find that hard to believe.
- user3939382 2y agoYes I saw a recording of a congressman literally saying that the reason they were losing influence on the Israel Palestine conflict is because of TikTok.
- arrowsmith 2y agoThat's not a source for the claim, it's just someone else repeating the same claim.
- BeFlatXIII 2y agoIt's a counterweight to the US glow agencies putting their thumbs on the scale for domestic propaganda platforms.
- OhioMan2943 2y agoThis is one of the things in my lifetime that gives me the most optimism, alongisde the IRA Bill. as someone in Australia who strongly supports our recent U16 ban, I hope META gets removed/broken up for you guys soon after, at least for underage users. I'm 22 and often wish I had never been born into a world with social media, with the belief that it is one of the worst things we have ever made as a species. I know the Tit for Tat and privacy optics, and the shutdown of dissenting views on certain proveable crimes in the ME may be bad sometimes, but these are far lesser than the desctruction of the social fabric of a society and the loss of development and inculcation of values of entire generations.
- omnimus 2y agoThis move unfortunately has nothing to do with harm of social media. Its purely about economical war with china. US is simply protecting its interests. So not only the ruling class in US doesnt care about the harms of social media. They are actively protecting the results - the profits and data/spying/control facebook brings. They will surely not limit or break up facebook unless it would result in getting more results. If you are not in US though… this might good. Because the countries will most likely start to look more at their social media independence/s sovereignty.
- OhioMan2943 2y agoI know this, but there is still a massive net benefit for the youth, and I hope it opens the door to more social media scrutiny. People forget how relaxed life was before everyone could point a camera at someone and upload and embarass them in 10 seconds
- ClassyJacket 2y agoI thought America had freedom?? How can they claim to have freedom if the government says they can't even use a video app.
- flohofwoe 2y agoUsing the app won't be illegal, you just can't get it from US app stores anymore (e.g. the personal freedom of users is preserved, only the freedom of some companies to do business in the US is restricted - e.g. a regular tradewar scenario).
- hnfong 2y ago"What good is a phone call, if you are unable... to speak?" -- Agent Smith
- codedokode 2y agoThis is unfair. Apple is not blocked in China now and Americans are getting lot of money from sales in the country, I hope it will become blocked for unfair trade practices.
- flohofwoe 2y agoApple is only allowed to do business in China because they bent over to the CCP. China banning Apple from doing business in China would indeed be an interesting tit-for-tat though :)
- skwee357 2y agoI'm surprised it doesn't come from the EU. On the other hand, I'm not sure if this move is against short form content in general, but rather against China. I wish the entire world would agree to ban short form content and influencer content in general. Things I saw on reels/shorts range from mild pornography, conspiracy theories, medical advice, promoting overconsumption, financial advice, etc. Nothing useful comes out of these platforms.
- _1tem 2y agoThe problem is not with the short-form content medium. The problem is with the culture you live in. As a speaker of multiple languages, I see many different faces of TikTok in different countries. In most Western countries, the content I get is absolute trash, basically OnlyFans promoters and various stupid jokes. In another country I live in (not English-speaking), I get interesting political commentary, everyday useful tips/hacks, interesting views on my city, and of course comedy and dancing.
- skwee357 2y agoInteresting point. I do agree that I consume mainly English-speaking content. I'd still argue, however, for the usefulness of the content you consume from non-English-speaking short form content. - Political commentary -- why would I care for some random person's opinion on politics? If there are people whose opinion I respect, wouldn't it be smarter to just consume their content directly (newsletter, telegram channel, whatever)? - Tips/hacks -- I'm not sure what you get, but I found most of these to be super simple/useless, or promote yet another super specialized tool that you can buy, "using my affiliate link down in the description" - Views on my city -- I found some travel related content, most of it is fake. It showed me "interesting" locations, containing mountains and waterfalls in the... NETHERLANDS, the most flat country in the world. - Comedy -- this one is actually good. The problem is that I can't seem to "train" the algorithm to focus on comedy/memes/fail videos. No matter how hard I try, I end up with conspiracy theories/OF promoters/men-women dynamics. Maybe it says something about me...
- em500 2y ago> I'm surprised it doesn't come from the EU. On the other hand, I'm not sure if this move is against short form content in general, but rather against China. How can you be unsure about that, of course it's a move against China. There is after all an impending ban on TikTok specifically, not on Youtube, Facebook, Instagram or Snap. It's not surprising that it doesn't come from the EU, it's probably challenging to write legislation there that specifically targets TikTok / Chinese corps while excluding American corps.
- codedokode 2y agoEvery time you hear about freedom of speech in US, let's not forget that this is the country that gave 10 years prison term for anti-war speech (and for being a socialist) to Eugene Debs [1]. For comparison, in Russia the maximum term for anti-war speech now is 7 years. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs#Sedition_conviction_and_appeal_to_U.S._Supreme_Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_V._Debs#Sedition_convic...
- xdennis 2y ago[flagged]
- josh2600 2y agoOk so who’s building ZK social networks?
- RandyRanderson 2y agoThe new president is inaugurated Jan 20th ...
- eonmist 2y agoCould they not allow another TikTok variant to be made that doesn't have the problematic ties. (I'm no TikTok fan)
- jacobp100 2y agoI believe bytedance has a US company now
- kelnos 2y agoThis already exists. Several Western-owned social media platforms have cloned many of TikTok's features and much of its user experience. They just haven't done as good a job of it.
- x3n0ph3n3 2y agoThe court's gave TikTok the option of changing ownership amd they declined.
- thinkingemote 2y agoAt root, this topic is about "misinformation". The topic is interesting as misinformation itself may be subject to misinformation! I'm sure most would agree that the topic is politicised at the very least. One thing that we can look into at is just how effective misinformation really is. Another thing is to examine how we approach the topic. Do we see people around us as "the masses" that are easily brainwashed and influenced but ourselves as rational, free thinkers? What are the impacts of a culture that is growing to believe that its own people can be easily brain washed or that its people should be protected from harmful information.
- submeta 2y agoMedia & social media is a tool in the Western World to manufacture consent. Ain't no room for alternative narratives or wordings. That's why the ruling class needs to either have full control over (social) media or ban it altogether. So much is clear after one year of genocide in the ME.
- WA 2y agoThat is observable untrue. Social media thrives because of the lack of consent in the population. Social media amplifies dissent. That is why many people find these places so toxic.
- submeta 2y agoDo you believe that META does not censor content? Or amplify specific views? Or suppress the reach of certain others?
- WA 2y ago> Do you believe that META does not censor content? To some degree for sure, simply because they have to by law. > Or amplify specific views? Or suppress the reach of certain others? They have the technical capabilities and what Meta in particular does: I don't know. But given the social media landscape as a whole (not only platsforms by Meta) and seeing so many nutjobs having tremendous reach with lies and fake content, I really don't think there is a lot of suppression or view-shaping going on. The views would be a lot more homogeneus if you were being manipulated on a large scale. Since you mentioned the conflict in the ME: There are proponents of both sides with tremendous reach and depending on your bubble, you either see more of the one side or the other. But of course, since the immediate conflict has been going on for a while, the sentiment changed.
- submeta 2y agoSome valid points. But seeing how traditional media has been framing certain events, avoiding to name certain agressors, while being very clear with others, it is obvious that our Western media has a strong bias towards certain narratives. You might say "isn't that normal / desired?". No, I would like to have objective reports, no matter who is doing what.
- cakealert 2y agoMaybe they will make the Tiktok website better now? Also Apple may be in an unpleasant position if Tiktok starts to aggressively push Android for sideloading. Children asking for Androids might be really bad for them, Apple needs them young.
- ashconnor 2y agoWill it be available in the EU appstore?
- shafyy 2y ago[flagged]
- x3n0ph3n3 2y agoI am disheartened but not surprised.
- chvid 2y agoMy guess is that TikTok is about to get the Huawei treatment. Like it happened to Huawei, the US State Department will campaign against it in various foreign countries and seek a similar ban. And like it happened to Meng Wanzhou, the US will use its legal system to pursue key figures in ByteDance, many of whom reside in Singapore, a country which has an extradition treaty with the US. (If you think I am exaggerating, hear this week's edition of the All In podcast.)
- hnfong 2y agoMaybe. Meng Wanzhou got caught because she was in Canada, and she was (apparently) a Chinese national. But I cannot imagine Singapore just handing over their own nationals to the US as a political prisoner...
- chvid 2y agoFounder Zhang Yiming lives in Singapore today.
- JeremyNT 2y agoIt's not in the US strategic interests for China to control the most popular social media (aka propaganda) site, so from a realpolitik perspective this makes a ton of sense. Reliance on a foreign power for things that are so prevalent is a risk, and it's not like the US is incapable on a technical level of producing a TikTok alternative - it's "only" popular because of network effects. FWIW I mostly agree that your take seemed to be a likely outcome if Harris had been elected, but I literally have no idea what the new administration will do.
- supriyo-biswas 2y ago> it would "not directly prohibit the continued use of TikTok" by Apple or Google users who have already downloaded TikTok. But it conceded the prohibitions on providing support "will eventually be to render the application unworkable." I have a technical question with regards to this. Typically, censorship* investigation efforts (from academia or elsewhere, such as OONI, Apernet etc.) have tended to focus on non-American countries to map their firewalling infrastructure used to this end. Since the US was never brought up in these investigations, as an outsider, I got the distinct impression that TLS packets were never interfered with, and the US mostly relied on either seizing the domain and its associated resources (such as in the various piracy cases, the raidforums/breachforums investigation etc.) Does this mean that a second-order effect of this directive would be asking the ISPs to block requests based on SNI, and in that case would it be a first in the US? * For the purposes of this discussion, let us step aside the discussion about "censorship" and simply use that term to mean any kind of network filtering used by ISPs.
- numpad0 2y agoWould killing .ipa/.apk distribution not suffice? PWA still sucks, no one knows how to deal with .apk let alone invalid signed .ipa, I think it'll effectively prevent any app from going mainstream. Which is crazy but I suppose okay just this one time?
- meiraleal 2y agoIf tiktok popularizes PWA install it will be a great tradeoff
- aziaziazi 2y agoPWA also offer some advantages that apps don’t. As a personal anecdote, I’m often using a 8yo iPhone and as you might guess many apps don’t work anymore. Not because OS incompatibility (still updated thanks to Apple) but because they laaaaag and crash. Local gumtree (Leboncoin, if some dev here) systematically crash at the first in-app add load. Conter-intuitively, many PWA seems to be way more performant on the field. I know this is not the tech itself but bad dev, but that’s my experience so far.
- fergie 2y agoSo Tiktok becomes a webapp right?
- jingyibo123 2y agoI honestly thought the US already forced TikTok to store all data on a US company's servers.
- grubbs 2y agoLooks like it's mostly stored in Oracle Cloud.
- t-writescode 2y agoAnd the funny part is when they ban it from the United States, one of the side-effects is moving all the data out of the US .... removing ... US Citizen data onto foreign land.
- nani8ot 2y agoData might be stored in the US, but Chinese laws and control still apply to Bytedance, regardless of where the data is physically stored. It's the same reason why multiple data transfer frameworks between the EU and US have been ruled illegal (e.g. Privacy Shield). US law does not care where the data of its companies is stored and allows for surveillance of non-US citizens. Since EU citizens have a right to privacy, no US company can legally handle EU-citizens data. Obviously this is bad for trade and business, so there'll always be a new law made to temporarily allow for data transfers. Until it'll be ruled illegal again, and the cycle repeats.
- lemoncookiechip 2y agoDonald Trump in a recent interview with NBC said he would do what he can to help TikTok since it had played a part in getting him elected. He takes office on Jan 20th.
- sylware 2y agoAnd they should tell Google to be ready to remove the Google mail app since it is blocking ipv4 and ipv6 address literals... wait...
- user3939382 2y agoPro-palestinian content on TikTok that doesn’t support US foreign policy is the only real reason this is happening now. Congressmen have openly and plainly discussed this.
- joejohnson 2y agoAnother win for freedom and free speech! brought to you be the Meta lobbying team.
- flkenosad 2y agoI really hate how people are arguing that it should be banned because of the content being inappropriate in one way or another when the content you see is based on how you interact with the app. We don't all see the same stuff. So yeah China may have more educational content but that's probably just becuase the people there are interested in that stuff. When I travel to the mountains, I get more outdoorsy/hiking videos. When I'm in my hometown, I get things relevant to our community. It's really a beautiful algorithm once you get to know it. And its so sad that the most ignorant in our society feels like they can make decisions like this for the rest of us. This sort of issue shouldn't even be state or municipal issue, it should be a household one.
- libertine 2y agoAre you aware of what happened in Romania with Tiktok? A candidate got funded by foreign agents, paid for influencers, and sprinkled with Russian bot accounts it was enough to make a pro-Russian candidate get 20% of votes when he was an unknown political figure.[0] The app allows this. You can try to distract everyone from an app that enables illegal foreign interference by hiding under the guise of "oh, this is just what people want to hear; the problem isn't Russia but Romanian politicians." - that's a very dangerous stance and a threat to free & fair elections. [0]https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/romania-tiktok-propaganda-campaign/ https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/romania-tiktok-pr...
- olivierduval 2y agoAnd that's why X/Twitter should be banned too... ;-) And Facebook too !! :-D (obviously kidding but... well... not so much after seing https://www.france.tv/documentaires/documentaires-societe/6711838-emprise-numerique-5-femmes-contre-les-big-5.html https://www.france.tv/documentaires/documentaires-societe/67... )
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoNot so much, which is precisely why China does ban Twitter and Facebook. I’d love to have a detente where every country has a permissive policy towards social media apps and accepts some degree of soft power from it, but that’s not where we’re at.
- rsolva 2y agoMany commenters argue that free speech is being infringed upon, but isn't this really about protecting user data and preventing an adversarial and autocratic foreign power from influencing U.S. citizens? Sure, it is hypocritical to not protect the same user from U.S. companies harvesting their data, but you get my point. Shutting down TikTok in the U.S. doesn't prevent people from expressing their opinions. There are countless other ways to share and publish thoughts freely. None of these platforms, like TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and X, are public squares where citizens have any of these rights. They are privately owned and regulated by unending terms of service agreements, with users often moderated or banned for minor infractions by company algorithms. Free speech has never truly existed in these spaces, nor is it likely to ever do so.
- j3th9n 2y agoSure, just before the inauguration, Biden's last convulsion, nothing to be surprised about after for example giving some Chinese pedophile a pardon, or his son etc etc. And the next day, the 20th of January, after the inauguration, everything will be rewinded.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoThis will be interesting. I know how to install apps on my Android. I will keep using tik tok and see what happens?
- pier25 2y agoTikTok should be banned even if it wasn't Chinese. At least for minors. It's an extremely addictive drug.
- iamleppert 2y agoWhat is the mechanism to avoid this? Beyond using the web version. I'm not keen on the government telling me what apps I can and cannot use. I would like to continue using the app, I don't care about what the law says.
- maxloh 2y agoYou can download the APK/IPA file from TikTok’s website, I suppose. They’re just removing the app from the respective app store. The domain and its underlying IP address aren’t blocked.
- _chu1 2y agoThis is excellent news!
- flkenosad 2y agoWho do you people trust more, a national government or a tech company?
- elzbardico 2y agoWell, Chinese users are used to have to use a VPN to access banned content. I think it is now our turn.
- guilhas 2y agoYouTube shorts, worse app, same addiction, trashy content promoted by their banal algorithm, completely fine I even prefer long form YouTube, which is also addictive! I open more tabs every day than I can possibly watch in a week And all social media apps suffer from this (addiction, clickbait title/thumbnails, low quality fluff, propaganda, censorship...) Even Netflix, but we call it "binge", instead of addiction, so that's also fine Progress should be made in interesting relevant content discovery, and addiction prevention But trying to beat China at their own game seems like a shot in the foot
- adultSwim 2y agoTikTok has helped me more than decades of doctors.