24 ms·
‘With brain preservation, nobody has to die’
- JohnFen 2y agoI think that immortality would be a disaster, personally. That we die is a critically important aspect of life. I'd prefer that we work on ways to make the death process less traumatic.
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- nancybelowzero 2y ago>critically important aspect of life Nothing says "life" like being dead.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoNothing stopping you from dying. You make your personal decisions and let others make theirs.
- vanviegen 2y agoThere are some externalities at play here though... - We currently only have one world that all living humans must share. - Imagine the sickening amount of power some people would be able to gather given a few centuries. That can't be good for everyone else.
- rob74 2y agoWell, people already gather that sickening amount of power - not for themselves, for their heirs, but still - take the soon-to-be-again US president: he probably wouldn't be where he is right now if his father hadn't amassed a considerable fortune which he inherited.
- portaouflop 2y agoSo it’s bad already let’s make it an absolutely alhellish nightmare?
- boogr 2y ago[dead]
- bookofjoe 2y agoYes. I have long believed that all those who applaud death as a good thing — Steve Jobs most memorably in his address at Stanford — will be first in line for life extension once it becomes an option.
- lm28469 2y agoDon't worry you'll die just as they will It doesn't matter how much you like sci fi, even if it was technically possible it would be reserved to the 0.001% and you'd still be grinding your whole life just as you are doing now
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThe future never arrives in an evenly distributed fashion, but it reaches everyone eventually.
- huttyoop 2y agoYou are welcome to die from any number of preventable deaths. I choose life.
- ericmcer 2y agoWhy? We have already decimated any semblance of natural selection so death is no longer a necessity from an evolutionary standpoint. Maybe immortal humans would be more beneficent because they wouldn't be scrambling to get ahead in their short time here. If I didn't only have 30-40ish productive years to achieve whatever I will in this life it would be much easier to donate money or time to charitable pursuits.
- lm28469 2y agoEverything would scale with it, 30 or 300 years, as long as you're running the same system it wouldn't matter Not even talking about the fact that we live in a very finite system
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoI like knowing that the worlds biggest assholes sometimes lie awake at night fearfully pondering their own death. I don't want to deprive them of that.
- portaouflop 2y agoThe Great Equalizer
- 9dev 2y agoWell. How would you like a 290 years old Putin keeping a tight grip on Russia in the 23rd century?
- all2 2y agoI see, so this is where the God-Emporer of Man comes from. purge the xenos
- prometheus76 2y agoWouldn't any change we make to who dies when also be natural? How is that not natural selection? Did earlier generations not attempt to stay alive?
- deleted 2y ago
- wing-_-nuts 2y agoTo be frank, the extent to which the very old now dominate science, business and politics is already unhealthy. I shudder to think what our world would look like if our most important positions of power were dominated by men born 110 years ago. They say science advances one death at a time. Looking at congress, I think you can say the same for politics as well.
- hindsightbias 2y agoWe could just have mandatory brain preservation at 50. Have to be a biologic to be in a position of authority.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jknoepfler 2y agoI don't know why you're getting so much pushback... Planetary resources are finite. If you give up dying, you have to give up reproducing beyond the replacement rate. People like to imagine they'll be part of some small tribe of a lucky few immortals, but the reality is we'd be in exactly the same situation as today, but with a population rapidly screeching beyond all known sustainable limits far faster than it is today. To name just one obvious problem. Success of something like this entails a way to regulate reproduction at a far more draconian level than even China's one-child policy. I don't think any civilized nation could impose a "no child" policy and remain intact.
- portaouflop 2y ago> but the reality is we'd be in exactly the same situation as today, but with a population rapidly screeching beyond all known sustainable limits far faster than it is today I don’t think this is a given. Most developed nations have bad birth rates for example
- marcodiego 2y agoWhat if death is just a 'feature' of how life evolved in this planet? What if we discover life in other planets that are just endless? It just seems too anthropocentric to think that all forms of life must die. Ok, that maybe part of how 'WE' define life, but, for me, that looks a lot like an arbitrary definition.
- lm28469 2y agoIt's a bit like fighting against the ocean imho, it doesn't matter how much you put into it you'll always lose eventually. It's much simpler to accept and live within your constraints than to waste your life and mental energy wishing you could be/do something you will never be/do. If you think about it most of the things we "fix" are extremely wonky, even something such as a bone fracture isn't guaranteed to heal 100%, most medicine have massive side effects, organ transplants have something like 50% survival at 15 years on average, &c. We think we're getting more and more control on things but most of it is a hack job temporarily delaying the inevitable Also, anyone thinking being uploaded to a computer forever is heaven on earth must live a pretty fucking terrible life to begin with
- portaouflop 2y agoIt would be hell on earth literally
- jajko 2y agoImagine people like putin pouring billions in, easily sacrificing millions to achieve such thing for themselves, and ideally nobody else. A truly terrible scenario worth fighting against. Some folks are scared of rogue AI, when biggest threat to mankind always was, is and will be other, properly messed up humans with certain capabilities.
- kajumix 2y agoWhen I look back on my 45 years life, there are spans which feel like a different life altogether. I thought differently, and made choices that I won't make today. I'd say "in my former life" as if that life ended and a new one began. I suspect youthful immortality would be a sequence of many deaths and rebirths. If you had the neuroplasticity of a 25 year old and the experience and wisdom of a 50 year old, I imagine it won't get boring, and perhaps new ideas and modes of living won't require a generation to die, and a new one to be born.
- dtagames 2y agoLike so many scientific pursuits, this one has its roots in science fiction. A terrific trashy futuristic novel from the 70's by Lawrence Sanders called The Tomorrow File[0] features preserved heads that are kept around to spout ideas in the future, when they might become useful, among many other Brave New World-type concepts. [0] https://archive.org/details/tomorrowfile0000sand_t5i1 https://archive.org/details/tomorrowfile0000sand_t5i1
- PaulHoule 2y agoWay older https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rip_Van_Winkle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rip_Van_Winkle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sleeper_Awakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sleeper_Awakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Door_into_Summer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Door_into_Summer and for anything fantastic you can find it in mythology and ancient literature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sleepers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sleepers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muchukunda https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muchukunda https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight_Immortals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight_Immortals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranka_(legend) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranka_(legend) A good recent book series is https://bobiverse.fandom.com/wiki/Bobiverse_Wiki https://bobiverse.fandom.com/wiki/Bobiverse_Wiki might be the most optimistic story of the genre.
- adamc 2y agoSeveral other books pop into mind, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/To_Live_Forever https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/To_Live_Forever
- PaulHoule 2y agoI oughta read this one again https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21617.Buying_Time https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21617.Buying_Time particularly since my esteem for Haldeman has gone up (https://sff180.com/reviews/h/haldeman/worlds.html https://sff180.com/reviews/h/haldeman/worlds.html changed my life)
- 2y ago
- NickM 2y agoI used to buy into this kind of stuff, but I've become more and more skeptical of the idea that you would still be yourself if your brain could be preserved/emulated/transplanted/whatever. Our nervous system extends into our bodies. We feel emotions in our bodies. People with certain kinds of brain damage that prevents them from feeling emotions normally also experience trouble making rational decisions. More recent research has been hinting that we may even hold certain types of memories outside our brains. Humans have always been drawn to neat, tidy ideas, especially ones that draw clean boundaries: it's an appealing idea that our consciousness lives solely in our brains, and that our brains could function independently of our bodies, but it seems unlikely that it's really that simple.
- namrog84 2y agoThere is a bit of research and effort into a head transplants. I wonder if and when that is successful to see how it impacts the individual. Possibly having memories of the body or changing personality.
- mannanj 2y agowhere?
- bookofjoe 2y ago>HEAVEN: The head anastomosis venture Project outline for the first human head transplantation with spinal linkage (GEMINI) [2013] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3821155/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3821155/ ................... >World's first human head transplant successfully performed on a corpse, scientists say (2017) https://nationalpost.com/health/worlds-first-human-head-transplant-successfully-performed-on-a-corpse-scientists-say https://nationalpost.com/health/worlds-first-human-head-tran... ............. First Human Head Transplantation: Surgically Challenging, Ethically Controversial and Historically Tempting – an Experimental Endeavor or a Scientific Landmark? (2019) https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6511668/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6511668/ .......... >No Doctor Has Ever Performed a Human Head Transplant. This Neurosurgeon Says He’s Ready to Do It. (2024) https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a62831709/human-head-transplants/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a62831709/human-hea...
- netsharc 2y agoJeroen Lanier in his book "You Are Not a Gadget" uses the example of a MIDI file: they can describe music, but even though they sound like the real thing, they are limited by the digital world. E.g. according to ChatGPT the minimum interval between 2 MIDI messages is 0.77 milliseconds. And then he asks what sort of limitations might we have if our minds are software, and how would we not notice it?
- latexr 2y ago> according to ChatGPT the minimum interval between 2 MIDI messages is 0.77 milliseconds. Thank you for stating your source. However, ChatGPT isn’t deterministic. I asked it the same thing and it responded it depends on several factors, including the MIDI protocol version and the device or software used, and that the minimum between two messages is between 1 and 2 milliseconds. Which of those is true? Perhaps neither. A quick web search didn’t provide a straightforward answer. Point being that we should avoid propagating even more wrong information, especially since it’s not relevant to your point (which makes sense).
- haccount 2y ago[dead]
- actionfromafar 2y agoMore like, "with brain preservation, almost everybody has to die". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42006265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42006265 https://repaer.earth/ https://repaer.earth/
- portaouflop 2y agoIs that satire?
- kerblang 2y agoAs usual, it must be warned that living forever means you can be tortured forever. Interesting that an article on Dante is getting upvotes today...
- m3kw9 2y agoYep even a life sustaining brain vat that keeps you alive for 1000 years while feeding you some bad stimulation is not very hard to fathom
- Ekaros 2y agoEven worse no stimulation... And with enough trickery maybe avoid your brain going to coma or even sleep.
- portaouflop 2y agoDon’t threaten me with a good time!
- latexr 2y agoEternal life doesn’t necessarily mean being impervious to harm. If you live indeterminably because your flesh brain was preserved or there’s a digital copy of you on a hard drive, a simple drop on the floor could terminate your existence. And if we’re talking about fiction, there’s no obligation to make those lives unbearably immortal either. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlcxokM970M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlcxokM970M > Our flesh is indestructible. Our lives are never ending. But not even in the dumb vampire way where after a while you hate it and you can’t die. We can die whenever we want. We just don’t have to.
- jaco6 2y agoCatholic theology actually justifies the belief in Hell by arguing that an eternity of suffering in Hell is a blessing, because it admits the one benefit of existence itself, while total annihilation has no redeeming factors whatsoever.
- kelnos 2y ago
- discmonkey 2y agoRequired reading for this theme, and one of my personal favorite short stories: https://qntm.org/lena https://qntm.org/lena
- krferriter 2y agoWaking up in a state of confusion looking down at my new body after my own death. "What is this, some kind of altered carbon?"
- hinkley 2y agoI'm kinda surprised everyone in that show doesn't walk around with full neck armor to protect their stacks. Metal gorgets should be all the rage in this universe.
- deadbabe 2y agoI think it’s more likely we can preserve our ego rather than our consciousness. For instance, create an AI replica of yourself that accurately behaves the same way you do. Although you would be dead, your ego can carry on living and responding to changes in the external world, and people could have interactions with you that accurately simulate how you would respond to them long after you’re gone. And as your ego learns about the world, it develops opinions closely similar to opinions you would have based on your life experience. Perhaps in this way people in power could remain in power indefinitely.
- PunchTornado 2y agoI view death as the saviour of democracy and the most democratic aspect of life. Without death, our fragile democracies will die. Tyrants will be in power forever.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoBeing able to preserve your brain after a natural death won't stop you being assassinated. A few bullets to the brain, game over.
- everdrive 2y agoSetting aside the actual physical and technological limitations here, I think such immortality would create a whole new kind of population problem. Population growth, in some sense, would explode. Or, more realistically, you’d have two classes of people: those living, and those “immortal,” those who could afford immortality, and those who were poor and would have to die permanently. That said, I think this is all a pipe dream and totally infeasible.
- mrtesthah 2y agoThe brain is not enough; the mass-spaced effect allows for the formation of memories in non-neural tissues throughout the body. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-53922-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-53922-x https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2024/november/memories-are-not-only-in-the-brain--new-research-finds.html https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2024/novemb...
- nonameiguess 2y agoI wish we'd reframe the way this gets talked about. It's pedantic, but we can't escape death. All matter in the universe will eventually decay or transmute into something very different from what it now is. And my answer to the question posed of when you'd want to die is unknown. I can't say 150 years. I can't imagine a specific age I'd hit at which I'd want to die. But at the same time, while I might want to outlive the Earth, I don't want to outlive all baryonic matter and somehow persist into the age of the universe in which all other matter is black holes, and there is neither light nor sound, nothing to touch, and all I would ever experience is quadrillions of years of utter loneliness. There is no immortality and nobody would want it if they really thought about what it would entail. But cessation of aging would be wonderful. I'd love to live indefinitely and not have my body or mind noticeably decay. Research like this should be done, but we need to be honest about what we're trying to accomplish. Nobody will ever escape death, and when you start getting large enough numbers, I'm not sure it would make any difference to live longer. Even if we somehow achieve brain uploading, which I don't see entails you living longer so much as making copies of yourself with different identities, every storage medium has a capacity limit. At some point, the only way to form new memories to evict old ones, and the experience of living 90 trillion years won't be any different than 1 trillion years if 1 trillion years of experience is all you can store. That said, we need to also be humble about what is even achievable. The very idea of a high resolution scan capturing the entirety of your brain state is already science fiction. We have another home page story right now about controversy over whether the brain has a microbiome. The only reason that's a question is because we have no means of opening up a living brain to see. We can't even accurately measure a person's body fat without dissection. The limitations of non-invasive remote imaging that don't kill the animal being imaged are quite severe and constitute a large reason medicine isn't more effective than it is. There is no technology we are on a known arc toward achieving that will make it possible to capture molecular-level detail of an entire brain as it is still running. I don't see how you can base an entire research project on a premise that doesn't exist and we have no idea if it ever will exist.
- m3kw9 2y agoWhat if the constituent of the brain changes, would you feel you or would it be like another person just go on being conscious. If you don’t know what makes consciousness, most likely you just “die” after the brain freeze. This ain’t like sleeping or coma where your system is kept running continuously
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoPeople have been brought back to life after being dead for more than an hour after submergence in very cold water.
- jryan49 2y agoBut did their "consciousness" continue? We currently have no way of telling.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoExactly whose consciousness would it be, if not theirs?
- m3kw9 2y agoLet’s say you clone yourself l 1:1 who would you see thru?
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoA somewhat different question, but interesting! I assume by clone you mean an exact physical copy, down to a molecular level. In my view, there would now be two separate instances of "my" consciousness simultaneously. "I" would continue to see through the original one, but the copy would essentially feel the same as me, although increasingly diverging as our experiences would not be the same from that point.
- haccount 2y ago
- slibhb 2y agoOne of Don DeLillo's later good novels is about this stuff (Zero K). I always think people's attitude toward possible future worlds is interesting. You can see a wide spread of opinion in this thread -- whether you think functional immortality would be a good thing says a lot about who you are. Ditto for colonizing other planets, automating all work, building AGI, and so on. I suppose I'm on the side of the technologists. I think immortality is probably possible and humans should try to achieve it. But along the way it will mostly be snake oil and cults. And, of course, it's all but guaranteed that everyone in this thread isn't going to make the cut-off.
- bambax 2y agoI'm certain immortality is possible, and it's also likely to be achieved, because we always do everything we can do, regardless of consequences. But I think this is the acme of selfishness. I don't want to be immortal, and I wouldn't want to live in a world with 500-year-old know-it-alls running around "oldsplaining" everything to everyone else. I have, thankfully, a fairly good chance of dying before that happens.
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoIt's funny people always talk about this in extremes. "Do you want to live longer?" "Yes" "OH YOU WANT TO LIVE A MILLION BILLION YEARS?!?!" There are values in between immortality and ~80 years.
- bambax 2y agoOh and when we have defeated death, when will people decide it's time to go? And how will they do it?
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoThey'll decide when they're ready. I would love a little more time on this planet. And when it's time, I'll hop in the nitrogen pod. People are already making that decision in some parts of the world.
- amyjess 2y agoUltimately, I am going to quote one of my favorite writers [0] and say that I am not afraid of a life that ends. I don't want to be a brain in a jar. Or in a computer either. I enjoy experiencing physical sensations and interacting with the world in meatspace. And if I can't enjoy either, then just let me die. And I apply this to not just brain preservation, but any attempt to artificially prolong the quantity of my life at the expense of the quality of my life. I do not want to spend my last years in a hospital bed hooked up to machines and unable to move. That was how my dad died, and even then he was lucky enough his partner (who he had discussed this with before and who had the authority to make the decision) eventually agreed to switch him to palliative care in his final hours. Similarly, I have seen what chemotherapy does to people, and I have long since decided that if I ever get cancer, I will refuse chemo and let myself die. I am also having a living will drawn up that includes a DNR order, multiple scenarios where doctors will be ordered to pull the plug, and a prohibition against anyone amputating any of my limbs or sensory organs even if it's necessary to save my life. I will make sure I die with my autonomy and my dignity intact. [0] Al Ewing. He writes comics. Read his stuff, he's good.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- latexr 2y ago> (…) and a prohibition against anyone amputating any of my limbs or sensory organs even if it's necessary to save my life. > I will make sure I die with my autonomy and my dignity intact. Amputees have autonomy, dignity, and rich lives. To believe that the loss of a limb is so severe that death is preferable is absurd and insensitive. What if instead of requiring an amputation, he loses faculties by accident like suffering from parosmia due to COVID or having a weight crush a body part? Did he suddenly lose his dignity? He certainly lost some autonomy. What’s the next step then?
- gregjor 2y ago> To believe that the loss of a limb is so severe that death is preferable is absurd and insensitive. No. Denigrating someone expressing their personal opinion seems absurd. Since the commenter did not impose their opinions on other people you had to put those words in their mouth to call them insensitive. I prefer to die with autonomy and dignity as well, meaning I would like to pull my own plug. That other people might have a different threshold, or want to die differently than I might, seems neither absurd nor insensitive. The commenter just described their threshold, they didn't judge other people.
- lm28469 2y agoI love how people have wet dreams about living forever by uploading their mind to a computer but put absolutely 0 fucking effort actually increasing their health/life span in real life, and/or waste their days/week/years doing stuff they hate to "enjoy life" later (when their body is already half way rotten). As long as it's sci fi and they have 0 effort to provide they'll suck every single drop of hope but as soon as there is something actually actionable they recoil in horror imho if you're not lean and exercising every day you have no business talking about living longer, you've already refused the only magic pill there is. It makes all the difference between having one foot in the grave at 60 or still chopping your own fire wood at 80, and all it takes besides a bit of luck is to move your ass 45 minutes a day
- hinkley 2y agoThere's no contradiction here. You're talking about people who have already detached the concept of self from their physical body. They think of 'me' as their brain, so why maintain the body they're 'trapped' in. People who try to solve all their problems with intellect tend to suffer from this. And many of them never learned that being in shape makes you feel a whole lot better.
- tj-teej 2y agoI wonder how much of a relief the belief that when you sit on your deathbed you will be woken up again would provide. Even if the tech doesn't work, I wonder how much relief from suffering the idea that it will in a hundred years could be
- kajumix 2y agoThose hundred years won't exist for the dying. I would personally find comfort in knowing that I will feel waking up right away into a technologically much more advanced world
- bdcravens 2y agoIsn't that the main promise of most religion?
- bambax 2y agoIt's really debatable if religious people actually believe in eternal life. If they did, they would immediately see that their behavior drives them straight to eternal damnation. They don't seem to care about that, and the only rational explanation is that they don't believe there's anything after death. They're nihilists. We all are.
- jaco6 2y agoProbably similar to the relief that the belief you will wake up from general anesthesia provides prior to surgery.
- yapyap 2y ago[flagged]
- nancybelowzero 2y agoMaybe you can just put a towel over the jar for those guys. like a bird cage
- idatum 2y agoDo memories and/or brain functionality rely on volatile storage? So if you die, that storage is gone. How our brain works may rely on more than the structure of the brain. When you are brought back (booted?), things may not work the same.
- vundercind 2y agoFrom what I've seen of research on apparently-dispersed storage of memories in worms, I'd not be at all surprised to find that a human brain separated from a body has (assuming we could "boot it up" in that state, as you put it) lost a lot of memories or functionality beyond the obvious, even assuming we could perfectly preserve everything present in the brain per se.
- OscarCunningham 2y agoPeople get struck by lightning or have epileptic fits, and it doesn't wipe their personality.
- tim333 2y agoNot volatile storage for most of it. If you get knocked out or similar you have most of the memories. It probably is partly down to the structure of what's connected to what and parly chemical changes at the synapses, although I don't think it's fully understood. It'd make it pretty hard to get memories out of a brain sample as it's hard enough just to see the structure in an electron microscope. I don't think they have any way to log the chemical changes in the synapses presently.
- SapporoChris 2y ago"1918 when diabetes had no known treatment" What nonsense. A history of diabetes shows knowledge and treatment for the disease for thousands of years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_diabetes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_diabetes
- hinkley 2y agoOne of the absolute best short movies I've ever seen is The World of Tomorrow. The whole thing is cute, but every time I read about brains in boxes I can't help but think of this scene about grandpa's consciousness being uploaded into a cube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PUIxEWmsvI&t=88s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PUIxEWmsvI&t=88s We are also able to download correspondence from him. [...] I will read one of his letters to you now. "Oh. Oh God. Oh God. Oh my God. Oh Holy Mother of God. Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh God."
- Nux 2y agoOnce the brain has been powered off and the back on, is it even "you" anymore? Hasn't that person died and a new one was "born"? Used to go a little bit crazy thinking about this when watching people getting transported in StarTrek.
- apitman 2y agoSee the Bobiverse books for some fun sci-fi on this.
- augusto-moura 2y agoIf all the theory is correct, yes you are still you. Maybe damaged you, but you nonetheless. Imagine the ship of theseus thought experiment, but instead of replacing part by part you store it on a dry dock (lost its function), some time after you put it in the sea again (recover the function), for all effects this still is the ship of Theseus
- lordnacho 2y agoLOL, "we're not married, your husband died in the transporter". "Ah can I have his laptop? He's got some saved games he wanted me to have"
- jryan49 2y agoI like how the video game Soma showed it. If you fork a brain you kind of have a 50% chance of it continuing into the copy, and 50% chance of you being "left behind". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x790AjID0FA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x790AjID0FA
- jprete 2y agoI get the point, but I think the most self-consistent answer is that your conscious experience has a 100% chance of staying in the original body. (And similarly for destroy-and-remake teleporters.)
- ddq 2y agoIndeed, the coin toss explanation "Catharine" uses on the Simon copies is merely a manipulation to ensure he continues following her instructions so that the ARK is launched, obscured to the player by the necessary mechanic of always controlling the surviving Simon copy. The only "real" Simon died in Toronto.
- dabreegster 2y agoJust want to plug Pantheon as a TV series exploring this idea with excellent storytelling. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon_(TV_series))
- ragnot 2y agoReally can't recommend this show enough. As soon as they brought out the dining philosophers problem I was hooked.
- giantg2 2y agoI don't want to live more than 100 years and I don't want to come back from the dead either. Make way for the next generation and their wants.
- audunw 2y agoYeah, I find the need to live forever kind of.. juvenile? You can’t let go of your ego for long enough to realise that at some point it’s better to make room for a new human with new perspectives and new ideas? I like to think of it this way: if life was a game would you want to play the same character forever? No.. if you’re gonna keep playing the game it’s more interesting to start from scratch now and then. I don’t believe in reincarnation. There’s no need to. What you really are deep down is an instance of humanity. Almost all your genes and all your culture comes from and is shared with other humans. Any new instance (new human) is you playing a new character, essentially. If you’ve contributed to shaping the world you’re leaving behind this is even more true. Unless you’re believe in a soul in the christian/jewish/muslim sense I guess, but then why would you fear death? IMO the pursuit of immortality is far more dangerous and far more likely to kill humanity than AI. At least it may make us deteriorate to insignificance. Humanity is a super organism and we have a name for the phenomenon where parts of an organism figures out how to die and yet still replicates: cancer
- tim333 2y agoWe don't need to live forever as shown by the fact we've got by without it so far but death is kind of depressing. I've never really got the distinction that say killing millions in the holocaust is terrible but similar millions dying through age is desirable.
- wutwutwat 2y ago“Take very high resolution scans of brain structure to characterise how someone’s neurons work, recreate it in a digital format then put it in another robotic, virtual or biological body.” This isn't preserving, it's copying. A copy of your brain/personality/you... isn't you... it's a copy. It's a cassette tape playing back the radio you recorded onto it. It's really kind of odd that people talk about brain transplants, or living forever, and then talk about uploading your mind to the cloud or swapping someone else's healthy brain into your healthy body, or scanning your brain and recreating it, and make it sound like it is going to help you to live forever. If my brain is scanned and uploaded to the cloud, a copy of me would live on forever, but me, literally, me, will still deteriorate and die, then rot away into nothingness. My mind, my personality, my essence, me, will not live forever under any of these solutions. I'll die. A copy of me, a point in time snapshot of who I was when it was taken, will continue on, with my memories, mimicking who I was. That gives me no comfort at all. I don't care if a copy of me lives on forever if I still die. That's not immortality, not for me personally, not if I die.
- nickisnoble 2y agoSome people never learned about pointers / pass by value vs reference and it shows
- vagab0nd 2y agoLet's not pretend that we understand consciousness. It's like talking about the movement of stars without understanding gravity.
- cg5280 2y agoNot that it makes things any better for the original you, but the copied you would presumably feel and believe themself to be the real you. From their perspective, "you" really are living forever. To proceed with the copying would be a sort of act of kindness for yourself.
- suzzer99 2y agoSuppose you died every night in your sleep and were replaced in the morning with a perfect copy of yourself with all your memories intact. Would you know the difference?
- leobg 2y agoWhen was the last time you read a book from the 1960s? Or browsed files from a hard drive from the 90s? I guess the same will happen with brains.
- maxwell 2y agoI'm reading a book from 1974 right now. The book I read before that was a 2013 adaptation of a book from 1605. The book I read before that was from 1956. The book I read before was from 1985: I started it while the author was still alive but he died before I finished it. The book I read before that was from 1998.
- Balgair 2y agoSo, I've seen Bredo Morstoel, the Frozen Dead Guy of Nederland, Colorado[0]. The 'tour' you could go on was ... something. But, at the end, we were asked to help keep Bredo frozen and helped pile on dry ice. So, they had to open the sarcophagus and get the CO2 in there. And, yeah... Bredo looks like Otzi the ice man [1]. He's just a dead body, there's no saving him, he's gone. It was a good lesson in any thoughts I ever may have had about cryopreservation. Unless you pay someone a LOT of money, for a very long time, and somehow manage to get them to actually really truly care about you, you are just having a really strange and long funeral. Good excuse for a party though. Those dead salmon tossers are something else. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_Dead_Guy_Days https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_Dead_Guy_Days [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%96tzi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%96tzi
- defart 2y agoA fun way to die, would be to transition digitally into the cloud as data for some sort of future "humanity LLM" that would be inquired in the future. The Council of Elders
- btbuildem 2y agoI really hate this idea. The wrong people would get to persist indefinitely -- the malignantly greedy who hoard majority of the resources and make life miserable for billions of others.
- ciconia 2y agoEven if this worked, I find this idea morally repulsive. It just seems utterly selfish.
- antegamisou 2y agoNext level transhumanist absurdity..
- evanjrowley 2y agoWithout spoiling too much of Cyberpunk 2077, that game offers an intriguing exploration of how this could go horribly wrong.
- amiga386 2y agoSimilarly true for the game SOMA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soma_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soma_(video_game)
- tqi 2y agoLeaving aside whether or not I think this is A Good Idea[1], I am fascinated by what other limits people would run up against, if this were possible. Memory, for example. Is it even possible to retain a first person memory for hundreds of years? Is there some upper limit above which you can no longer form new memories? Would it become much harder to motivate yourself, without the pressures of a limited existence. How would it affect our psyche? [1] I do not.
- scotty79 2y ago> Memory, for example. Is it even possible to retain a first person memory for hundreds of years? It's not. But it's fine, because it's not even possible to retain memories of typical lifespan or even short one or even a decade or even a year. You lose way more than 90% of it and the rest gets largely altered anyways.
- helf 2y ago[dead]
- xyst 2y agoWe can barely even do “artificial intelligence” correctly. Let alone mapping the human brain to a digital representation. It’s an interesting concept but in order to “preserve” the brain, wouldn’t one have to get their brain dissected layer by layer and thus killing the subject in the first place? Then storing all of that information without any loss would likely well exceed current technological limits. Then the computing power need to run the brain would have to be immense.
- akira2501 2y ago> We can barely even do “artificial intelligence” correctly Even if we could the brain is an amazingly efficient mechanism for computation. It uses such a low amount of power that it's hard to imagine a computer based AI model ever genuinely competing with it. If the environment and entropy are human scale concerns than AI is decidedly a dead end for us.
- tim333 2y agoIt'd be a long way into the future to do brain uploading type stuff. We are not close yet but maybe in fifty years?
- owlbynight 2y agoPart of personality lives inside of our stomachs as well, apparently, and so much of who were are is driven by our interaction with our nerve endings. I think even with a perfect copy of consciousness, it's pointless without a perfect copy of our bodies as well. I think that AGI, when and if we ever reach that stage of technological innovation, will enable us to live in a utopian world where our bodies are impervious to biological defects or age and we have little to no reliance on food and water — where we can control all aspects of how we feel with a slider, or a thought. Like the Lotus-eaters from Homer's Odyssey, some alien tribe will eventually show up and decide we're imperiled instead of living a perfect life in blissful stasis, and kill us to stop whatever afflicts us from spreading to them. Anyway, I don't want the brain preservation thing, thank you.
- scotty79 2y agoPerfect copies are overrated. > Part of personality lives inside of our stomachs as well Is it the part of your personality that you like or maybe it's the part you hate?
- groos 2y agoThere are so many ifs and buts in this idea of resurrecting the brain that it's laughable, yet "brilliant scientists" make press with it. What about the completely unknown mind-body problem that scientism pretends doesn't really exist but each one of us knows is very real? What if you wake up 500 years later but plugged into a matrix? Who guarantees cryo-maintenance of the frozen brain?
- roland35 2y agoAlastair Reynolds wrote some great books which touch on this concept - the Perfect series has a AI character who originally started out as a fatal brain scan of a person who eventually escaped...
- hannofcart 2y agoAlso in 'House of Suns' by Alistair Reynolds. The most revelatory idea for me in it was the idea of how a human being could plausibly become a near god-like entity. This isn't even the real premise of the book but a brief detour over a few pages where the author expounds this idea. The man, Valmik, starts off as a human much like any other. As the first stage in his metamorphosis he replaces his brain neuron by neuron, with mechanical parts. Once this is done he no longer needs his body. This now frees him from his mortal shell which he discards. He now lives purely as an electro-mechanical device for centuries. He shuns all his human contacts since they are unable to keep up with him. At this point he starts adding more artificial neurons till his count surpasses several orders of magnitude of his starter human brain. But he realises that he is still subject to the vicissitudes of the planet that the machine that's him is located in. This he couldn't abide by. At this next stage, the already superhuman intelligence formerly known as Valmik sets off on a space faring vehicle. The endlessness of space is no bother to this entity, because he has no bounds on his longevity. And so he travels the cosmos for millennia in this state, free from the erstwhile shackles binding him to Earth. But he realises that even this is not enough. Just one well aimed shot would destroy him. Not good enough for an immortal. So he transforms each of his neurons into an independent self-sustaining machine. Each of these machines communicates with each other via light/EM beams. The formerly comet sized machine that housed his consciousness was now split across these self sustaining machines. These machines can now drift apart. As far apart as he wanted. His brain was now a cloud consciousness that could span the size of solar systems. But this expansion came at a cost. The cost was this: transmission between his independent neuron nodes, now each far apart from one another, took time, limited by the speed of light. Thoughts that would formerly take him micro seconds would now consume days. But that was no matter to this entity that had left all his companions behind and only needed to talk to himself. And thus, Valmik, once man, now a cloud consciousness came to disperse himself all across the Oort cloud. An immortal who can outlive the sun.
- jmull 2y agoCool idea, but it's science fiction. If this intrigues you, try some really good science fiction on the topic, like Neal Stephenson's "Fall; or, Dodge in Hell".
- tim333 2y agoI've been thinking a bit about how living on could play out without being too futuristic with the technology. Coming back from cryopreservation is probably many decades out but we are quite close to being able to make a virtual AI version of you, working a bit like an actor playing you. Tech like Heygen is quite good with avatars and voices, and chatgpt type AI could pretend to be someone in a pretty terrible way just now but that stuff will get better and the virtual you could act as an assistant, learn your ways and help out. Then when the physical you passes and maybe is cryopreserved the virtual you could conduct the funeral type service and say hey guys physical tim333 is gone but I'm still here and you can chat to me on the web etc. Virtual you could maybe have some investments and could buy gifts for the grandkids and post on HN etc. Then in a few decades virtual you could get data from cryopreserved you and incorporate it. Perhaps it could be done as a startup?
- nayuki 2y ago> our societal acceptance of death comes from an inability to imagine anything otherwise CGP Grey captures this sentiment nicely in this animated essay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY "Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant" [2018-04-24]
- Vegenoid 2y agoI thought that was a very poor allegory. 1. It starts with the humans being deathless, and then death showing up. This is not how things are, all life we know of since the very beginning dies. It may well be a "feature" of life in that death is necessary, or at least useful, for life to adapt and grow - unlike the dragon, which showed up after life was already doing fine. 2. It very conveniently and explicitly frames death as an evil black dragon, anthropomorphizing it and pulling it out of the mechanical process that it is into a morally evil villain. 3. The difficulty and novelty of the discoveries we must make and engineering problems we must solve to beat death are several magnitudes smaller in the fable than in reality. It seemed very pandering, and sets up death (and those who propose accepting its inevitability) as a straw man and those who want to beat it as a steel man. I would have been more sympathetic if the black dragon were some illness like cancer, but it seems to be an allegory for death itself. I'm not against research to improve health and slow aging, but I also think that there are much more important and realistic problems to solve than defeating aging.
- onetokeoverthe 2y agoThose with eternal souls see the deception.
- matj1 2y agoEven with transferring minds, as long as physical beings are in charge of that, all people will surely die because accidents happen and entropy rises. If I live for a hundred or a billion years, I am still mortal, so there will still be existential problems related to mortality. It doesn't matter how I likely die, by cancer or by a star collapse.
- mydriasis 2y agoPlease let me die.
- Nilofersyed 2y agoIf this really happens, its going to take human kind to next level.. Can't image the pros and cons
- metalman 2y agoMONEY !! GIVE MONEY !! GIVE MONEY NOW !!
- pigeons 2y agoWouldn't you need to preserve non-brain systems that relate to "mind" such as gut neurons, maybe microbiota, other parts of the nervous system, etc?