29 ms·
Starlink Direct to Cell
- treebee33 2y agoHow will ISPs respond to this level of leverage. Will it still need ground station amplification?
- kylebenzle 2y agoSo they now offer direct cellular coverage whereas before only offered internet? This is great for regions that need to be connected and the power elites, but for the rest of us it wouldn't change much. I disagree with almost all of Elon's "politics" but Starlink still has huge potential. Hopefully, he doesn’t abuse the power too much and focuses on making the world more connected, in the hands of the us government and given away like GPS it could be the way to go to get the whole world connected.
- jxf 2y ago> Hopefully, he doesn’t abuse the power too much The best possible outcome for Starlink is that he gets distracted with something else and doesn't meddle in it whatsoever.
- travisjungroth 2y ago> This is great for regions that need to be connected That's at least a billion people. I don't know what the intersection of that with the affordability is, though. I'm writing this from an Ayahuasca center in rural Peru connected with Starlink. Before, internet was a ten minute drive into town away. We're now connected when at one side of the center. It would be nice to have it all the way into the jungle. And when you want to be disconnected, just turn your phone off or leave it behind.
- nordsieck 2y ago> I don't know what the intersection of that with the affordability is, though. My understanding is that the monthly cost for Starlink varies pretty wildly across the world. Presumably the same would be true for this cell service - idle satellites have the same huge fixed cost and don't generate any revenue.
- threeseed 2y ago> That's at least a billion people a) Based on what we've seen in China, India etc many of those will shift towards densely populated cities or will stay and those locations will become industrialised, densely populated cities. b) In densely populated cities it doesn't make sense to use Starlink when fibre is far cheaper, has limited congestion issues and can provide gigabit speeds at a minimum. c) It's great that you're writing this in rural Peru but that is a declining use case and should not be extrapolated to the rest of the world.
- travisjungroth 2y agoIt's not gonna decline to zero. There's just a really strong tendency for people all over the world to focus on their own experience. And you can actually reinforce this by zooming out too far. If you live in San Francisco, this seems like a pet use case and you can be like "What is it, 10% of the population?" But "the population" is quite the fucking denominator. I mean, it's already happening and obviously Starlink has run the numbers. So I'm largely just reacting to the tone here.
- threeseed 2y agoNo one is saying it will decline to zero. But it will decline such that Starlink is likely to be more of a niche product similar to how satellite internet services are today.
- signatoremo 2y agoNiche? Millions of airline and cruise passengers have been using Starlink. Industries, militaries and governments are Starlink customers. Millions of users in the rural areas. That’s some interesting definition of niche. Are you really that ignorant?
- threeseed 2y ago0.07% of internet users are on Starlink. By every definition that is niche.
- hedora 2y agoI’m writing this from starlink ten minutes from Silicon Valley. Until recently, most of what you wrote applied to us too (our previous options were 128kbit theoretical dsl, 1 sec latency, or extremely flaky cellular). Now that a double digit percentage of people on our street have starlink, the phone company finally ran fiber to the home. Being able to make emergency calls from the many dead spots around here would be nice.
- shafyy 2y ago> Hopefully, he doesn’t abuse the power too much Haha, good one.
- bhauer 2y agoI switched to T-Mobile at the last upgrade interval because of this. My family looks forward to no longer relying on Garmin InReach devices when out hiking.
- jebarker 2y agoInitially I thought the same re: hiking, skiing etc. The only issue I see is that cellphone battery life is terrible compared to inReach like devices. Not sure I'd want to depend on it for longer than a few hours.
- blinded 2y agoSame. Done a few trips to alaska and had to coordinate pickups and food drops via garmin inreach. Battery life on those is way better and more durable.
- nordsieck 2y ago> The only issue I see is that cellphone battery life is terrible compared to inReach like devices. Not sure I'd want to depend on it for longer than a few hours. I think it depends on the application you're using it for. If you're constantly using the gps - yeah, I'd definitely agree with you. But if you're using it purely for emergency communication, you can just turn off the cell phone, and it should be fine. It's also possible to pursue a hybrid approach by bringing a battery to change the phone.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago> It's also possible to pursue a hybrid approach by bringing a battery to change the phone. Or, as I have done on multi-day trips, a solar panel and a battery.
- threeseed 2y ago> you can just turn off the cell phone, and it should be fine Cell phones are far more sensitive to temperature issues than dedicated devices. And when you do have an issue no external battery is going to help you because they are also sensitive.
- rscho 2y agoStarlink: Direct to Target
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- charliebwrites 2y agoI wish I could pay Starlink directly and have global satellite based LTE instead of having to go through a specific carrier and be limited by other carriers’ reciprocity to specific countries and bands One space based cell plan for the whole world
- hackernewds 2y agoIt will happen over time
- nordsieck 2y ago> It will happen over time I'm optimistic. I think that, once SpaceX starts launch Starlink satellites with Starship, they'll be able to increase their globally available bandwidth by a factor of 5-10x (although it might take 5 years to roll out). A lot of that bandwidth will be eaten up by existing demand. But hopefully some of it will enable novel services like global cell service through a single provider (even if it's limited to low bandwidth applications like text and voice).
- lxgr 2y agoThat's still many orders of magnitude too little. We're currently talking data rates on the order of (optimistically) 5 Mbit/s for a cell with a diameter of 15 square miles, i.e. something like 0.1 Mbit/s per km^2. In very rural areas (which is the use case!), that's infinitely better than nothing, but anywhere people live, this is effectively nothing, and there is currently no way around ground-based infrastructure.
- Retric 2y agoIt’s not going to work inside buildings, and they would need to charge you a fairly astronomical fee per minute. However, a Starlink mini dish can let you cheaply make calls from basically anywhere with some minor setup.
- christophilus 2y ago
- innagadadavida 2y agoDoesn’t Globestar still have more satellites in orbit? With Apple supporting them, hoping there will be some consumer choice. This looking like regular cellular will become the new landline company.
- grecy 2y agoGlobestar have 48 Satellites in orbit [1] Starlink has 6,426 [2] (Though that number is likely out of date by the time you read this) [1] https://www.groundcontrol.com/knowledge/calculators-and-maps/globalstar-coverage-map/ https://www.groundcontrol.com/knowledge/calculators-and-maps... [2] https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-satellites.html https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-satellites.html
- sebzim4500 2y agoI think his point is that most Starlink satellites do not have this technology, but he's probably still wrong quantitatively.
- grecy 2y ago> I think his point is that most Starlink satellites do not have this technology Ah, thanks, I missed that. Wait another month, there will be at least another ~500 in orbit.
- nordsieck 2y agoTo put some numbers to it, it looks like SpaceX started launching direct to cell satellites at the beginning of the year[1], and by July they had over 100 in orbit. Not sure how many are in orbit right now, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were close to 200. --- 1. https://spacenews.com/spacex-deploys-direct-to-smartphone-satellites-in-first-launch-of-2024/ https://spacenews.com/spacex-deploys-direct-to-smartphone-sa... 2. https://www.satellitetoday.com/connectivity/2024/07/03/spacex-now-has-more-than-100-direct-to-cell-satellites-in-orbit/ https://www.satellitetoday.com/connectivity/2024/07/03/space...
- tremarley 2y ago
- yfw 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lupusreal 2y agoYou don't have a clue what you're talking about, so from what did you derive these harsh feelings? Starlink satellites are in LEO, without active boosting they decay in mere years.
- goda90 2y agoA decayed satellite doesn't just disappear though. There's particulate pollution from it burning up, not to mention the pollution from rocket launches. There's also the light pollution that the astronomy community has been complaining about for years.
- lupusreal 2y agoAh, "unsustainable" meaning it annoys earth-bound astronomers. Cell phones in general must be unsustainable then, since they annoy radio astronomers. Actually, we can sustain this just fine. The public derives virtually zero measurable benifit from astronomy, particularly the sort done from Earth.
- inglor_cz 2y agoFor astronomy, sinking costs of space launches present an opportunity to move the actual telescopes into space, where the atmosphere doesn't stand in the way at all. I read a long description of an astronomer's journey to a prestigious Chilean observatory deep in the desert. He wasn't particularly happy about either the isolation or the bloodsucking bugs that could not be entirely exterminated and carried diseases. Compared to that, remote work on a space-based telescope might be preferable from the human perspective, too.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- reizorc 2y agoDoes this mean they can track the location of specific IMEIs from orbit?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kylebenzle 2y agoThey always have been...
- kortilla 2y agospacex? No, the direct to cell sats require much larger antenna to pick up cell signals. The regular Starlink sats aren’t capable of that.
- bushbaba 2y agoIt’s interesting as Apple randomizes the MAC address but not imei number.
- anticensor 2y agoIMEI randomisation would actually make them unusable in Turkey.
- lupusreal 2y agoHawkEye 360 has been doing this for a few years.
- maxrmk 2y agoThis is really interesting. Based on their wikipedia I can see they collect a lot of RF traffic - are IMEIs identifiable with the raw data captured that way? I'm surprised they are not encrypted. I say this as someone who knows nothing about the space.
- 2y ago
- mrtksn 2y agoWhat I wonder about the Starlink constellation is, how secure it is physically? There are people burning down 5G towers. How plausible would be for a conspiracy nut to create a rocket to take out the satellites? Maybe starting a cascading effect?
- panick21_ 2y agoIts expensive to build rockets. Most rocket startups require at least 100 million $ to get a rocket into orbit. But a rocket into orbit is a far cry from an anti sat weapon. That technology is gone run you another 10-20 million $. And then that kills 1 sat. SpaceX has many 1000s of sats. So a small rocket like Electron cost around 8+ million $, lets say 6 million $ in cost. Plus lets say 1 million for the anti sat. So you need to invest a couple 100 million $ into the development and produce many rockets. So you can calculate 7 million times * 6000, that gone be around 42 billion $. Of course you would need to launch them from somewhere without a government that can stop you. Taking out vital infrastructure used by the US military tends to make people a bit angry. And neither China, Russia or Europe will want you anywhere close to them. This is likely gone make this much more expensive. Maybe you can make a deal with the Taliban? But they likely don't want that heat either. So this is just a pure fantasy scenario. > Maybe starting a cascading effect? That's not gone happen. Far to low in orbit. As soon as they don't have propulsion they will drop lower. Until then the others can slightly raise their orbit. There is not even a single nation state who has the capability to take out Starlink. And no amount of people who burn down 5G towers could ever pull this off.
- bitmasher9 2y agoIf you can make a rocket that reaches a Starlink Satellite then there are many other targets the same rocket can hit that would be more damaging. Rockets are a military technology, and are treated as such.
- mrtksn 2y agoLot's of conspiracy theorists have become quite wealthy with the raise of Bitcoin, as it was very popular among them early on. Military tech or not, its just atoms. Very interesting people are quite rich now, they will have access to precision machining advanced materials and chemicals if they have the motivation.
- daRealDodo 2y agoCan anyone explain how upload would work? How can an unmodified cellphone upload data to a satellite?
- mise_en_place 2y agoYour cell phone uses the nearest base station, the base station will handover to the satellite infra.
- rblatz 2y agoNo, that’s just satellite backhaul for a cell tower. That’s not hard, but also typically if you can get power to a base station you can run fiber along the same poles the power runs on. This is direct from handset to satellite, it’s clearly explained in the link.
- Gare 2y ago> That’s not hard, but also typically if you can get power to a base station you can run fiber along the same poles the power runs on. Or a directional microwave link to the next station in sight.
- Gare 2y agoWhy do you need satellite if you can connect to a base station? This makes no sense. No, they claim direct phone to satellite link.
- navigate8310 2y agoAren't those satellites going to generate simulated cell tower signals so you won't require any modification whatsoever?
- maccam94 2y agovery slowly, with the radio at maximum power, and no obstructions
- 2y ago
- rafram 2y agoI feel so, so mixed about this. It’s going to be unambiguously good for wilderness rescue and disaster response. But I like camping and hiking in remote areas in order to remove myself from the world. And I think the lack of connectivity discourages unprepared people from taking on more than they can handle in the wilderness. If the wilderness becomes fully connected, will it spoil that feeling? Will it lead to the last few truly remote places in the US suddenly being overrun with TikTok crowds? I honestly have no idea, and it’s a little scary. But it feels like an anachronism that we don’t already have worldwide connectivity, and I guess this was just bound to happen.
- Gare 2y agoThere are virtually no unconnected places in most of Europe yet wilderness is still dangerous. It is good that rescue services can help you if accident happens (and it can happen even to the adequatly prepared).
- rafram 2y agoDefinitely. But when Apple released their Satellite SOS feature, I expected that to remain the cutting edge for a while, and for all devices to eventually gain very limited satellite emergency call capabilities. Instead, it seems like we’re going straight from most devices having zero connectivity in the (US) wilderness to all devices having connectivity everywhere in the world, as soon as next year. That’s a lot of change to come all at once.
- okdood64 2y agoSounds like the future. And a good one at that. The pros far outweigh the cons. If someone can't disconnect purposefully to be with nature, then that's on them.
- growt 2y ago„There are no unconnected places in most of Europe“ Then you haven’t traveled with the German railway yet!
- cj 2y ago> ENGINEERED BY SPACEX It would be very interesting to see some kind of diagram depicting all of the corporate entities Musk is involved in and how each entity does business with one another. xAI just raised billions to help Tesla build out FSD (or at least that was part of the pitch). His empire is divided into so many corporate entities, but they all cross-pollinate and are clearly under his direct control for the most part. The closest comparison I can think of is Berkshire Hathaway (one person/group controlling multiple wide ranging private and public companies).
- lupusreal 2y agoStarlink and SpaceX have an even closer relationship than most other Musk companies; Starlink is a wholly owned subsidiary of SpaceX.
- tgma 2y ago> Starlink is a wholly owned subsidiary of SpaceX. Starlink is not a separate entity — it's a division of Space Exploration Technologies Corp. From Terms of Service[1]: > Your order for two-way satellite-based internet service (“Services”) and a Starlink antenna, Wi-Fi router and mount (“Starlink Kit” or “Kit”) is subject to the terms (“Terms”) of this Starlink agreement for the United States and its territories. These Terms, those terms incorporated by reference, and the details you agree to in your online order (“Order”) form the entire agreement (“Agreement”) between you (“customer” or “user”) and Space Exploration Technologies Corp. (known as “Starlink” in these Terms). [1]: https://www.starlink.com/legal/documents/DOC-1020-91087-64?regionCode=US https://www.starlink.com/legal/documents/DOC-1020-91087-64?r...
- jazzyjackson 2y agoI didn't realize SpaceX was just a nickname for Space Exploration Technologies Corp, TIL So the Terms of service is with SpaceX but apparently there is such a thing as Starlink Services LLC, but I'm just going off Wikipedia, all this corporate structuring is opaque to me.
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoI really wonder if anyone is going to be able to catch up to SpaceX anytime soon. Kuiper seems dead in the water, the legacy operators seem unwilling to expand into LEO constellations.
- FL33TW00D 2y agoRocket Lab and Peter Beck are your best hope!
- Culonavirus 2y agoI think the potential comptetitors in this business (low latency satellite internet megaconstellation) missed their opportunity. Starship is very close to being able to put next gen Starlink satellites into orbit ("very close" as in most likely within a year or so). Once that happens, it's over, there will not be competition for at least a decade. Before Bezos and others (and/or EU/China) build their own Starship copies (and if you've seen recent EU/China concepts, you can't call it anything else...), it's going to be the 2030s.
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoNot to mention that the existing Starlink fleet is about to be old technology. The larger satellites launched by Starship is projected to dwarf the terminal speed available now (gigabit+ downlinks to consumer dishes).
- FL33TW00D 2y agoI don't think so. Listen to the most recent RKLB earnings call. Constellation on the way, Neutron launching in 2025. There will be competition.
- threeseed 2y agoHonestly not sure why they would want to. The world is continually moving towards being centred around cities where it makes sense to simply rollout fibre. Especially with gigabit speeds being the new standard. And even in Australia they are starting to move remote areas onto fibre.
- CtrlAltmanDel 2y agoHow can it be that a LTE smartphone, costing ~$100 and doing all the things a smart phone can do, and being designed to connect to a cell network via a tower a few miles away, can somehow also function as the pizza sized $500 Starlink dish?
- maccam94 2y agoIt uses a different transceiver on the satellite which is broadcasting a ~standard LTE signal, at a miniscule data rate
- kortilla 2y agoIt doesn’t. The throughput here is multiple orders of magnitude lower than what you get from Starlink
- CtrlAltmanDel 2y agoI keep coming back to the comments waiting to see how many orders of magnitude lower. 1 Mbps would be quite different than 10 kbps. Is this for facetime while camping, or send an SOS if your car breaks down in the backroads?
- Mashimo 2y agoIt will start of with text messaged only. That should give you an idea about the throughput.
- verzali 2y agoIt's much closer to the SOS. They start with text messaging, which is much easier because it's low bandwidth and tolerant of delays. Voice can also be done at low bandwidth but its a bit harder to ensure things sound smooth. And then data, but I think this will only ever be low bandwidth like internet browsing, not tiktok or facetime. There's probably a reason they aren't boasting about the bandwidth they can achieve...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tedd4u 2y ago>E-UTRAN Node B, also known as Evolved Node B, is the element in E-UTRA of >LTE that is the evolution of the element Node B in UTRA of UMTS. Thanks, wikipedia! [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENodeB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENodeB
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoMy question is how the laser backhaul works. If the satellites are constantly moving how do they adjust since lasers require line of sight?
- Polizeiposaune 2y agoThe constellation is subdivided into orbital planes, with ~20 to ~60 satellites in each plane chasing each other around the planet. The following is somewhat speculative: The bearing to the next satellite ahead or behind you in the same plane should be roughly constant; likewise, the bearing to satellites in adjacent planes orbiting in the same direction will change slowly during most of the orbit. Near the poles the required slew rate will likely be too high to keep the side-to-side links working but that's also a part of the planet where subscriber density will be low so losing that capacity for periods of a few minutes when near the poles likely won't matter.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoDoes the laser pointer have azimuth and elevation as free parameters like ground receiving antennas?
- faebi 2y agoWhich bandwidth can a phone reasonably expect given nobody around for kilometers? Are we talking kbits or mbits? Is there some kind of theoretical maximum?
- heywoods 2y agoDoes this allow the ability to circumvent LTE networks in countries like China? Do we have the capability to send messages to any/all phones in China if we (USA) wanted to?
- IshKebab 2y agoTechnically, yes. But there's no way they would actually do that. Good question about the emergency message feature...
- pyrale 2y agoFor that, Starlink would have to use the frequency band that the phone (and, therefore, the relevant operator) is using. Such frequencies are assigned by states to operators, and using them from space would be extremely easy to detect. That is why Starlink either has to make a deal with in operators, or acquire a licence to use a frequency band in every country it wants to operate. I assume that if Starlink was trying to do this without agreement, in violation of the interational treaty on radio regulations, the USA would have to prevent them from doing so. If the USA did not, I don't see what would prevent China from shooting down Starlink's constellation. As a side note on the technology, since Starlink satellites orbit 340km from earth, I wonder if they emit a directed signal. If they don't, I don't see how they intend to respect borders when sending messages down.
- wmf 2y agoYes, the beams are highly directional.
- shepherdjerred 2y agoDoes the US/China have the capability to shoot down satellites? I mean, Starlink has a lot of satellites; could they really all be destroyed?
- nradov 2y agoChina has demonstrated ASAT weapons. They don't have enough in stock to take out the entire Starlink constellation but just the threat would be enough.
- Reason077 2y agoThis is supposed to launch in New Zealand during 2024, in partnership with a local carrier. Was being heavily hyped a year or so back, but I haven’t heard much recently?
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe Commerce Commission charged One NZ for making false claims around Starlink: https://www.teslarati.com/starlink-criminal-charges-new-zealand/ https://www.teslarati.com/starlink-criminal-charges-new-zeal...
- mkl 2y agoThere are a few stories in the last week. Seems like it's in testing but has been waiting for lower satellites with appropriate capabilities: https://www.interest.co.nz/technology/130898/telco-one-nz-betting-big-spacex-starlink-improved-coverage-here-some-more https://www.interest.co.nz/technology/130898/telco-one-nz-be... Probably not happening until next year: > But in September the telco (and Optus across the Tasman and other Direct to Cell exclusive partners) removed “launching 2024″ references from its website. -- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/commerce-commission-takes-one-nz-to-court-over-spacex-claims-telco-fights-back/7ERYIHGM7NCH3JQC7AD2XGH6UM/ https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/commerce-commission-take...
- dools 2y agoI love how libertarians are willing to use a communication network controlled by a billionaire oligarch who bought a presidency to further his business and personal ideological interests, but are worried about government overreach.
- smbullet 2y agoWhat's your concern with people choosing to use Starlink?
- dools 2y agoI'm not concerned that people are choosing to use it. I'm pointing out the hypocrisy of libertarianism.
- hedora 2y agoIn the 90’s, libertarians were against any consolidation of power (including corporations) that could infringe on individual rights. (This was roughly in Ron Paul’s time.) That’s been replaced with corporate libertarians, which are against any government power that could infringe on the rights of corporations. See also Rand Paul, and the corporatist movement (which is sadly mainstream in the US, an offshoot of fascism, and essentially indistinguishable from modern libertarianism). Anyway, they are many things, but I wouldn’t say they’re hypocritical.
- dools 2y agoIt's massively hypocritical, even if the people don't realise it right away. If you take libertarianism to its logical conclusion you wind up with feudalism, which is anything but free. Whenever libertarians try to take their philosophy through to its logical conclusion in practice they just wind up reinventing government only worse (or reinventing banking only worse in the case of crypto).
- hedora 2y ago
- bilsbie 2y agoHow do I get this with cricket wireless?
- wmf 2y agoHeh, you don't. This will be one of the benefits of using a real carrier.
- bilsbie 2y agoIs iot useful if it needs a clear view of the sky? Also why does my cell phone not need a clear view of the cell tower? It works in my brother in laws walk in closet just fine. Same frequency.
- Alex-Programs 2y agoBecause you aren't 350+ miles from the cell tower. Direct to cell is only possible because it's an almost entirely unobstructed view.
- GoldenLox 2y ago*350+ km
- cprayingmantis 2y agoIf anyone from Starlink or SpaceX is reading these comments here’s what you want to do: Sell your own branded trail cam with solar charging and LTE from orbit. You can charge $25-$40 a month for unlimited pictures sent from the cam. This would open up hunters, nature enthusiasts, and researchers to be able to place their hardware anywhere in the field without worrying about connectivity. Here in SWVA we have deep hollows that can’t get LTE without dense tower coverage that we don’t have the population to justify, but you can grab a satellite connection. After writing this out I’m beginning to doubt the market would be big enough but I know at least 20 people with 2 or more LTE cams for deer season.
- bilsbie 2y agoSurf cam would be amazing too. Just tie a solar, starlink cam to a pier and check in.
- geepytee 2y agoI see a lot of surf cams online, are those usually custom hardware?
- bilsbie 2y agoThe only one in my area wants a subscription fee :-( I guess they need to contract with businesses or parks? It would be cool to buy a cheap one and just tie it to a tree or something.
- nbap 2y agoTen years ago I installed one cam for Surfline and at that time it's was an off-the-shelf but expensive outdoor camera (stock firmware) connected to a locally-based broadband.
- geepytee 2y agoInteresting idea. I can build this and open source it. I imagine there is equivalent hardware over LTE already?
- 2y ago
- gigatexal 2y ago[flagged]
- geepytee 2y agoMeh lines the pockets of Tim Cook. Hard pass.
- gigatexal 2y agoWe each have our champions. Yours got a faux king elected and mine convinces me to buy 1k phones every 4 years. We are not the same. ;-)
- jedberg 2y agoIf I have to choose, I'd rather line the pockets of the gay man who believes in people's rights and whose only ambition is to get me to buy into his ecosystem of well engineered but overpriced hardware, instead of the man who just bought himself a President so that he can direct government spending towards his businesses and away from his competitors while disowning his own child for their sexuality, and whose ambition is to rule the planet.
- irusensei 2y ago> I'd rather line the pockets of the gay man Maybe its about time people stop mixing sexuality with identity and character.
- seanieb 2y agoIs this a flying imsi-catcher network? Could it spoof cell phone carriers in foreign countries to MITM their calls, sms and data?
- carimura 2y agothis is listed under the "business" section. must not be planned for direct-to-consumer initially.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y ago[flagged]
- ks2048 2y agoI wish there was a competitor. I guess Amazon has project Kuiper, but sounds like it's way behind. https://www.aboutamazon.com/what-we-do/devices-services/project-kuiper https://www.aboutamazon.com/what-we-do/devices-services/proj...
- lupusreal 2y agoDon't underestimate Bezos's ability to spend money. New Glenn's development has been extremely slow and dull, Blue Origin has never put anything into orbit after nearly 25 years, but despite this they've managed to produce engines that work (evidenced by a single Vulcan launch) and New Glenn may actually fly soon, in the next year or two maybe. If New Glenn works, with first stage reusability, then Blue Origin could be a few years behind in launching Kuiper as a Starlink competitor. Outside of what's going on in China, Blue Origin is probably the most likely to succeed in competing with SpaceX. Don't get me wrong, I like RocketLab. But going against SpaceX will be a long race requiring deep pockets that can fund years of unprofitable development.
- shepherdjerred 2y agoCan you elaborate on Musk being a nazi, or is that just hyperbole?
- csomar 2y agoBoth sides have become ridiculous and unreasonable. Neither have any of the morals they are talking about.
- hedora 2y agoNazi might be a bit much, but he’s pretty clearly guilty of treason. He blocked a US funded military strike that would have sunk Russia’s navy a while back. (The definition of treason in the US is extremely clear, and he obviously crossed the line.)
- rawgabbit 2y agoI was all excited and was thinking I should switch from ATT to T Mobile so I can access Starlink. Then I read it was for T Mobile for Business. You need 6 lines to qualify for T Mobile for Business? https://www.t-mobile.com/business/industry-solutions/connected-vehicle-network/direct-to-cell-communications-in-remote-areas https://www.t-mobile.com/business/industry-solutions/connect...
- yieldcrv 2y agoAST Spacemobile has contracts with ATT and Verizon to do the same so just wait
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoI am skeptical AST will be able to really compete. SpaceX has a massive cost advantage. I hope that they will, but the engineers at SpaceX have made me a believer. If the gen 1 direct to cell sats don’t perform (it seems like they do), they’ll just launch another batch a couple weeks later. I don’t think AST will have this ability, so I hope they get it right.
- JayPalm 2y agoAfter seeing this post, I went over to the ATS subreddit to see how they’re tracking the news. The denial is palpable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- yieldcrv 2y agoWhat do you mean compete? In the US SpaceX just announced a contract with Tmobile, AST has contracts with Verizon and AT&T For service it works, and for business viability AST just has to launch more satellites, which they will for a business case thats their only overhead cost and they dont need cellular partnerships in a bunch of countries to be viable They have to raise capital for more satellites but it all looks possible
- acrophiliac 2y agoA quick glance at these comments indicates the majority are excited about Starlink. I must be in the minority. Is anyone else here on HN very unhappy with the prospect of having no place to escape internet access? I love the idea of no-rescue zones. https://www.pennstatelawreview.org/print-issues/hike-at-your-own-risk-in-support-of-no-rescue-wilderness-designations/ https://www.pennstatelawreview.org/print-issues/hike-at-your... Not trying to change anyone's mind, just wondering if I'm a complete outlier.
- paxys 2y agoYou already have the option of escaping internet access, anywhere in the world – by turning off your device.
- acrophiliac 2y agoGee, thanks, I hadn't thought of that. (Seriously, did you read the article?)
- mmaunder 2y agoAnd you’ve already had comms in most places in the world including the polar regions for some time now. This is about lower cost and ubiquitous access.
- MBCook 2y agoBut we don’t have the option of opting out of trains of satellites in the sky ruining the view.
- monkaiju 2y agoSo true, its depressing...
- leoh 2y agoHeroin addicts have the option to escape heroin any time they want. Just ignore the heroin.
- marcus_holmes 2y agoThis is the nomad dream. Have a single phone service and wander anywhere on the planet with it. No more having to swap SIMs out on every border, being unable to use text-based 2FA, forcing friends to contact only via messaging apps, system messages in a foreign language, etc. It's not the coverage; that's mostly good. It's not the price; mostly SIM cards and plans are cheaper when travelling than they are at home. It's the hassle of swapping SIMs every time you cross a border.
- papa_bear 2y agoIt's been possible to solve these problems by using Google Fi for many years now.
- piyh 2y agoGoogle Voice crowd still waiting for an annoucement that they're either going to start supporting RCS or shut us down.
- mr_toad 2y agoYou need to activate the plan in the US and return to the US every 90 days (or lose your mobile data). So it’s not really an option for people outside the US.
- paxys 2y agoStarlink isn't meant to be your primary cell service, and likely will never be, considering people are rarely within direct line of sight to the sky when they need to use their phone.
- taeric 2y agoMost nomads don't really care for cell phones? This is the facsimile of the idea for people that want the benefits of travel without the negatives of no fixed relationships. Which isn't really a negative to this. Indeed, if you have the means, I'd say go for it.
- ianburrell 2y agoDirect to Cell is not usable LTE service. It doesn't have the bandwidth. It is effectively 2G or satellite phone, with messages, voice calls, and slow data.
- mmaunder 2y agoVertical integration by Starlink of the cheapest launch capability in the world (by far) is the reason there are no competitors, and there will be no competitors. The pace of innovation at SpaceX is not THE reason - it’s an additional reason that no one has a snowballs chance in hell of ever catching Starlink. I’ve seen talk of competitor satellite networks or a possible competitor emerging. Folks it’s game set and match, the trophy has been handed over and the crowd has gone home. SpaceX and Starlink have the same owner, both are private companies, with SpaceX launching 80% of the global space payload last year and rising, and Starlink has a constellation two orders of magnitude bigger than any competitor. It’s over. And IMO it’s awesome.
- itsoktocry 2y ago>Folks it’s game set and match, the trophy has been handed over and the crowd has gone home Has this ever been the case in the history of business? It won't be easy, but forever is a long time.
- jorvi 2y agoWhat a ridiculous comment. You must still be holding long on IBM?
- barfingclouds 2y agoWell competitors are going to have to use SpaceX rockets to get their satellites up. So no matter what SpaceX is winning
- LoveMortuus 2y agoYou don't think that Blue Origin could be a competitor? They are quite behind, but they are backed by quite a lot of money, I feel like I remember even hearing news about Blue Origin placing their own internet satellites.
- nehal3m 2y agoAre you Elon? Also monopolies are never awesome.
- 2y ago
- bastloing 2y agoIOT coming soon. Nice!
- hedora 2y agoAm I the only one thinking I need to upgrade my TV before they start including cell modems that use this to upload surveillance data and download ads?
- elteto 2y agoDoes your house not have a roof?
- notpushkin 2y agoUnless you have no cell coverage at your house, they can do this right now. I assume ads aren't economically viable unless the viewer pays for the traffic here.
- mproud 2y ago[flagged]
- mensetmanusman 2y agoDo you just Ku band radiation?
- PeakKS 2y ago[flagged]
- est 2y agoWell if you are able to launch junks into space extremely cheaply, I've got good news for you
- car 2y agoI heard that Google's project Loon was having issues with LTE time outs due to the distance of the balloons LTE antenna from the ground. How does this square with the much larger distance of LEO satellites?
- aabhay 2y agoWhats the latency lmao
- wmf 2y agoPretty low. Maybe 20 ms higher than normal cellular.
- uf00lme 2y agoI would be surprised if it is worse than the audio latency in any of the standard video conference software. I expect it would have a ton less processing and less hops.
- positr0n 2y agoReally good. It’s faster to send a packet from NYC to London via starlink than fiber because the speed of light in air/vacuum is c and the speed of light in fiber is roughly 2/3 c. Even just going straight up and back down to a ground station within the same cell adds minimal latency. 350 miles * 2 / speed of light = 4ms
- Animats 2y agoDo you have to have line of sight? Are trees a problem? Valleys?
- chipolinapolina 2y ago[dead]
- diimdeep 2y agoImagine butthurt of US hawks if this were China or Russia based product, think about American Exceptionalism.
- 71bw 2y agoAll three of them pose an actual security risk but I'm more than sure I'd want the American one out of the trio as a 1st world country citizen.
- loandbehold 2y agoCan anyone explain how it's possible given that Starlink satellites are at 500 km altitude while LTE tower has coverage radius of only around 5km?
- hmottestad 2y agoDunno if that’s maybe a typo? Could be that the signal strength is really weak so they have to use a very directional antenna to transmit and receive signals. I would bet that receiving a signal from a cell phone is the hardest part. You can always omf up the transmit power, but to receive you really need to have a sensitive and directional antenna
- ablation 2y agoI am by no means an expert on this, but I think it works because satellites at 500 km altitude have a much wider line of sight than ground-based LTE towers. Throw beamforming and steerable antennas into the mix and I think you’re then getting to why. It’s a “cell tower in space” optimised for wide coverage, not urban capacity.
- cess11 2y agoLots of people in the comments are talking about Starlink as if it was a civilian project, it's not, it's military. Similar to mercenaries and perfidy it's not presented as military, but it is. And as such it's an action against every other state. Much like the War on Terror, some NSA activities and so on it's the US making aggressive moves against everyone else.
- GoldenLox 2y agoi totally agree. i have never thought of the nsa as an action against all states, very interesting.
- jbverschoor 2y agoSite doesn't work on iOS (lockdown mode)
- davej 2y agoTangent: my understanding is the Zuckerberg wanted to do something similar and even paid SpaceX to launch a satellite (which was unsuccessful). It seems Musk liked the idea so much that he decided to do it himself. To me, this (along with Zuck's issues with Apple over the app store) explains a lot about why Zuck 2.0 has been so focused with avoiding platform risk with recent endeavours.
- azaslavsky 2y agoIf that's actually how events played out, one hopes that Zuck would at least be able to appreciate the irony of his idea being stolen by a vendor he hired to implement it.
- baalimago 2y agoWould it require a starlink terminal to work?
- ljlolel 2y agoNo
- micheljansen 2y agoAwesome proposition, but good grief what a terrible website. It looks like some dodgy knockoff site and scrolling is broken. Not really inspiring confidence.
- spaintech 2y agoIf we consider President Javier Milei’s perspectives on monopolies, as articulated in his address at the World Economic Forum [1], we can apply his reasoning to the case of Starlink’s potential dominance in direct-to-phone satellite connectivity. In his statements, Milei challenges the traditional view that monopolies inherently lead to market inefficiencies. Instead, he assumes that monopolistic positions, when achieved through “innovation” and “without government interference,” can drive significant technological advancements and economic growth. Applying this to Starlink, its emergence as a leading provider in satellite-based mobile connectivity could be seen as a result of substantial innovation and investment. Such a position enables the company to offer services that were previously unavailable or limited, particularly in underserved regions. Considering Milei’s argument suggests that in the absence of government-imposed barriers, a monopoly like Starlink’s can maintain competitive pricing to deter potential competitors, ensuring consumers benefit from both advanced technology and reasonable costs. Milei emphasizes that market failures are often the result of state intervention rather than the natural outcome of market dynamics. In the case of Starlink, minimal regulatory interference could allow the company to operate efficiently, maintaining an environment where innovation thrives, and consumers receive enhanced services. Its the potential drive of the market (competitors) and innovation to keeps them in check with pricing and perceived consumer value. [2] [3] [1] https://www.hoover.org/news/market-ourselves-argentine-president-milei-explains-his-approach-freedom-hoover https://www.hoover.org/news/market-ourselves-argentine-presi... [2] https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/01/special-address-by-javier-milei-president-of-argentina/ https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/01/special-address-by-j... [3] https://lexfridman.com/javier-milei-transcript/ https://lexfridman.com/javier-milei-transcript/
- philipwhiuk 2y agoYes because when I look for rational management of a sovereign country my first thought is Argentina.
- leshow 2y agoWhat a warped world view. Libertarianism today just means supporting massive concentrations of private power, I guess.
- spiffycat 2y agoStarlink, Starshield and X.ai together sounds like Skynet. There's the Tesla Optimus bot too..
- arrty88 2y agoso they are copying https://ast-science.com/ https://ast-science.com/ space mobile
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pabed007 2y ago[dead]