12 ms·
An e-waste dumping ground
- 4ndrewl 2y agoYou can't throw things away. You can only move them somewhere else.
- riskable 2y agoImbesi's Law of the Conservation of Filth: In order for something to become clean, something else must become dirty.
- tomrod 2y agoReminds me of entropy.
- schrectacular 2y agoCorrect. Some friends and I started saying "throw it aways" instead. I think it much better describes the actual situation. It didn't really catch on, though I wish it would.
- Mistletoe 2y agoThis is really heartbreaking to see and dystopian.
- worldsayshi 2y agoIt is indeed heartbreaking. But I don't see moral outrage solving the issue any time soon. People will rather forget about this reality than stop the consumption. If anyone wants to actually work towards solving the issue they should probably go there and try to invest in ways to clean up the practice. Better tools, better profitability. Education. Etc.
- greedylizard 2y ago> go there and try to invest in ways to clean up the practice. You think the problem that needs to be solved is “there”? This sentence makes me question whose consumption you’re referring to in the previous sentence.
- XorNot 2y agoIt is literally only there. This problem exists because the governments of these places allow it to happen. The reason it doesn't happen here is because we have strong environmental regulations here.
- ta988 2y agoFor now
- mrguyorama 2y ago"Strong environmental regulations" would make it impossible to just ship to someone without.
- worldsayshi 2y agoSolve the problem at whatever junction that is exposed for a solution is my point. Being outraged about stuff seems to not magically solve problems. Rather it often has a similar effect as ruminating about problems when being depressed. It often enforces the idea that the problem is somehow unsolvable. Not saying outrage doesn't have a place. Just that other means might be more efficient.
- BirAdam 2y agoA bit of a controversial take, but I think the reason that this won’t get solved is the AGW movement. Rather than addressing things like pollution, waste, strip mining, environmental toxicity, and so on the green movement was hijacked to care about a single aspect of environmentalism because rich people could get even richer trading carbon futures.
- gosub100 2y agoTrillion-dollar companies that produce this crap are sitting back in their skyscrapers saying "not our problem, something-something the market "
- carlgreene 2y agoIt’s so easy to just mindlessly want and consume until you see pictures like these. They show that although my streets are pristine, with everyone having the latest “stuff”, it’s really only possible because we sweep all of the “bad stuff” under the proverbial rug
- paulcole 2y ago> It’s so easy to just mindlessly want and consume until you see pictures like these It’s still incredibly easy. If you could magically make every person in the United States look at these photos for 30 minutes, nothing would change about how we live and consume. All that matters is that my streets are pristine.
- maeil 2y agoThis is of course untrue, given that we know that there are people who have changed their behaviour after learning about realities through articles such as this one. And a huge percentage of people still haven't learned about them. In one's highly-educated HN-reading savvy bubble, it might be easy to assume that surely by now everyone knows the realities, has seen all of them, and if they behave a certain way it's simply due to the degree to which they care. I've been prone to such biases myself, but the truth is very different. Billions of people, including hundreds of millions in wealthy regions, still simply do not know about this. They genuinely do not know that e.g. plastic recycling is a fantasy. They have not seen these images. Of course, many have and just don't care as long as their streets are pristine - the people you're talking about very much exist. But there's even more people who are simply unaware. It's very easy to take a nihilist view that nothing matters, as it completely absolves oneself of any potential responsibility whatsoever. But it doesn't reflect reality.
- paulcole 2y ago> It's very easy to take a nihilist view that nothing matters, as it completely absolves oneself of any potential responsibility whatsoever No! I actually do take personal responsibility by: • Living in a small apartment in a dense city • Never having driven a car - I never even learned to drive • Never flying in an airplane – last flight was 10+ years ago and have no plans to fly again • Eating a plant-based diet • Not ever having kids But I will concede that none of those things matter. > This is of course untrue, given that we know that there are people who have changed their behaviour after learning about realities through articles such as this one. That is neat! People in general will not change their behavior.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoI would rather call this: the receiving end of planned obsolescence. The other end is... you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- exitb 2y agoA lot of the items on the pictures look like 15+ years old equipment. People don't use CRT TVs or cassette decks, but not because they broke down on schedule. Not saying that planned obsolescence is not an issue, but even if a piece of equipment serves you for decades, you still need a good plan on how it could be disposed of properly.
- tivert 2y ago> The other end is... you. Not really. The other end is the manufacturers. It's a pretty common pattern in capitalist democracies that powerful business interests attempt (often successfully) shunt responsibility away from themselves onto consumers, who just so happen to be in one of the weakest position to actually affect a change. It works because (in America at least) individualism is such a powerful force that all kinds of social problems can get re-contextualized into questions of individual morality, and people won't bat an eye. Also, from a PR standpoint, if someone does not want to solve a problem, it looks a lot better to acknowledge the problem but insist on an unworkable solution (e.g. all consumers must coordinate to change their preferences, so the manufactures never have to bother themselves with anything beyond market forces) than to straight-up insist the problem remain.
- Nasrudith 2y agoIs the manufacturer really the best default handler for waste? Companies are incredibly mortal and the 'big corporation that is guaranteed to outlive you and can be counted on for things like pensions' days are gone. Trying to get the CRT factories to take back the old sets just doesn't work when they have been out of business for decades. This is starting to sound like the place for a government to ensure that the disposal is some sort of tax stamp/deposit and carried out by some entity, whether direct government, manufacturer while they are still around to reclaim their deposit, or paid recycling contractors.
- BirAdam 2y agoYeah… In 2019, the world wasted more than 59.1 million tons of electronics. That's the equivalent of around 350 large cruise ships that are completely filled with e-waste. Most of it used to be due to slow and/or bloated software, but more of it is now batteries. There’s also a bit of just poor manufacturing/design where a device was never good, and therefore as soon as its owner could get better he/she did get better. Edit: and let’s not forget the deprecation of older standards like 2G and 3G cell networks, or the rise of USB-C.
- imiric 2y agoRegarding batteries specifically, it should be illegal to produce any device without user-replaceable batteries. The EU is at the forefront of these initiatives[1], as usual, so hopefully this trickles out to other governments. Batteries in EVs are also a growing problem, for both production and disposal. Hopefully we'll have similar regulations there as well. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/24/23771064/european-union-battery-regulation-ecodesign-user-replacable-batteries https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/24/23771064/european-union-b...
- hbossy 2y agoUsed batteries themselves are not that much of a problem, because most of their value is in raw minerals used to make them. Recycling them is basically the same as processing raw metal ore, except the concentration of valuable stuff is much higher than in any natural deposit.
- reginald78 2y agoI think the goal here is to allow you to easily fix a device that only has a worn out battery, keeping it out of a landfill. The batteries could still be recycled and the process might be even easier if they were all user replaceable.
- FredPret 2y ago59 million tons is a cube 390m on a side, or a square pile 10m high and 2500m on a side. It’s a lot, but let’s not hyperventilate.
- o-o- 2y agoI know a large retailer that sells electric screw drivers for €19 a piece. I also know from the chinese manufacturer's backwaters that it's deliberately designed to last for 12 minutes. That's roughly two years in the hand of an average non-professional, who will probably go back and buy another since it was so cheap. These tools don't have a second-hand market. The expensive built-to-last ones do.
- nolist_policy 2y agoI don't know, I recently saw electric drills for €29 at Aldi and to my surprise they used brushless motors! They will probably last an eternity for hobbyist (minus the batteries).
- o-o- 2y agoThe company that deliberately destroys its own market hasn't been born yet. They will find ways to build customer retention.
- imiric 2y agoThis is awful on so many levels. These images should be postered around the headquarters of all major electronics manufacturers. They should be used in courts as prosecution evidence to force these companies to comply with repairability regulations, and force governments to enact stricter regulations and higher fines. They can start by making planned obsolescence illegal.
- XorNot 2y ago[flagged]
- imiric 2y ago[flagged]
- kergonath 2y ago> /sigh Typical pedantic contrarian HN response It is not pedantic or contrarian, though. The points they are making are real issues. The right to repair is important, but from an environmental point of view it is not that relevant. Besides, what the current demographic and economic trajectory of the world, huge populations are accessing the middle classes, with the associated increase in consumption. Even with perfect repairability (which does not solve the issue of discarded parts or plain broken devices, the amount of which is proportional to the number of devices in use), things physically cannot get better. The best lever we have right now is to reduce consumption. It’s about as credible as perfect repairability, but is much more effective. “Do we really need these 6 phones, 3 computers, 2 cars, and microprocessors in every light bulb” is a more pressing question than “can I fix my phone with a torx screwdriver”? Repairability is a good thing, but it is only part of the battle, and not the most critical.
- imiric 2y ago> The right to repair is important, but from an environmental point of view it is not that relevant. The quote was "completely irrelevant". How is that not contrarianism? > The best lever we have right now is to reduce consumption. Ah, consumerism. And what magical lever do we have to reduce that?
- rraaffff 2y agoThere's a BBC documentary by Reggie Yates "A Week in a Toxic Waste Dump" from 2017, it is about the same Agbogbloshie Scrapyard in Accra: https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p05dmmns/the-insider-reggie-yates-series-2-1-a-week-in-a-toxic-waste-dump https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p05dmmns/the-insider-r... The BBC player only works in the UK, but you can easily find the episode on Youtube.
- farceSpherule 2y ago[flagged]
- blitzar 2y agoTrickle down economics at its finest.
- roenxi 2y agoI'd like to see an arial photo of this site, because these images paint an awful picture without actually showing us how big this dump is. 15,000 tons/annum in one area shouldn't be all that much in the grand scheme of things but the photos manage to make it look like this is some sort of boundless hellscape. I'd hazard the actual problem in this picture is Ghana's GDP/capita being in 4 digit territory and not the badly disposed of waste dump.
- throwgfgfd25 2y ago> I'd hazard the actual problem in this picture is Ghana's GDP/capita being in 4 digit territory and not the badly disposed of waste dump. But if Ghana became a wealthy country and chose not to accept this waste, it will end up in the next one. The waste exists regardless, and the economic incentive for the original market "export" it, that is, hide the problem, and the receiving country to reluctantly accept it for some other consideration, whether it be money or state aid or tariff-free export of something else, will always exist while the waste does. Re: "badly disposed of waste dump", the difference between this and landfill anywhere in the west is largely just the soil on top. Staggering amounts of recyclable and dangerous stuff still gets thrown away in inappropriate ways right near where you live, I imagine. And if the global North exports waste to the global South, sooner or later the scale almost inevitably overwhelms the receiver.
- roenxi 2y agoThere are a finite number of poor countries. At the rate wealth is being generated it is conceivable that they all get wealthy enough that the waste gets handled well. And this stuff all started out in heavy metals deposits, it is already present underground somewhere. The only real question is how serious the effects on humans are with any method of disposal. It isn't at all clear there is a problem as long as it is buried fairly deep and not leeching into the water table.
- throwgfgfd25 2y ago> There are a finite number of poor countries. This is a bit of an imaginary solution to the problem, is it not? And there will always be poor_er_ countries, which is the thrust of my point. The economic incentive does not go away. Not least because it is clearly already cheaper to float it away on a huge boat than bury it where it is used. One problem is land cost: it's extremely difficult to safely build new houses on top of landfill. But that doesn't explain everything, does it? After all the USA has plenty of room to bury all its consumer waste. Why is it exporting it? > And this stuff all started out in heavy metals deposits, it is already present underground somewhere. It does not start out all in one place, though. It starts out in small, dispersed concentrations of heavy metals, and ends up all in a few giant landfills in poorer countries. It's not clear what the risk is, but the lack of clarity doesn't mean there's no risk.
- wruza 2y agoScavenging e-waste for components feels so cyberpunk. Sometime someone designed an IC, lithographed it on a high tech factory, soldered it onto a PCB and now it lies under your feet like billions of other rusty sharp parts, as if they were potato skins or plastic bags. Just a few decades ago nations would start WW3 over this alien technology dump. Now they try find cheaper ways to sneak more waste into it.
- ta988 2y agoWe did war over energy, now we burn energy just to find out who can burn the most and give them a token (bitcoin) or get neighbors to fight each other on which can get the biggest SUV or sports car that guzzles like 2 or more optimized cars.
- DJBunnies 2y agoOk I’ll bite, higher hashrate (bitcoin) means it’s more secure from attacks. So it’s not being burned, it has a purpose here.
- userbinator 2y agoWorking conditions in mines have never been great. These are basically the mines of the future.
- steviedotboston 2y agoI've wondered if it would be better for electronics to be just thrown out in regular trash. I know they have some hazardous materials in them, but when spread out in low levels across landfills maybe its better than concentrating them in places like this...
- agentultra 2y agoThis is one reason I believe "right to repair" laws are so important. The environmental damage of producing the device is already done. Make it last as long as possible. Reduce, reuse... then recycle. Re-using devices helps us also reduce the number of new devices needed... which is what probably scares the corporate oligarchy. If we're not buying new phones every couple of years how will the stock prices keep going up? Never the less, the devices we make these days can last a long, long time. I've been repairing and maintaining iPhone 5's, 7's, and 8's that are no where near their end of life. The iPhone has a couple of small electrolytic capacitors which should have a useful life of at least 20 years. And can be replaced! The batteries and screens can replaced. These devices can last much longer than we give them credit for. But tech companies have been struggling to make it illegal or difficult to repair for a long time. I've been seeing photojournalist projects such as this since the late 90s at least (longer perhaps). In North America we had a culture that valued repairing and building things that lasted. It's as good a time as any to push for this to return! Support policy makers that are pushing for right-to-repair and environmental protection! And pick up a new hobby if you are able. Support your local tech geeks if you can!
- echelon_musk 2y ago> Re-using devices helps us also reduce the number of new devices needed... which is what probably scares the corporate oligarchy I agree with you. Reusing and repairing appliances flies in the face of current capitalism. We don't need new models of phones, laptops or cars every year. Sadly I'm not optimistic that we will be able to dial back greed any time soon.
- amelius 2y agoWe need to reinvent capitalism. (Why does my phone need to be upgraded every year, while capitalism is kept at version 0.1beta?)
- knowitnone 2y agoYOU CHOSE to upgrade your phone every year. I don't see a gun to your head.
- superultra 2y agoI’m thankful I saw these pictures, if deeply unsettled. We can’t (just) take an individualized approach to a solution, which is an artifact of the 80s and 90s when corporations and governments shifted responsibility to the individual to recycle a water bottle, for example. It seems like the best solution is to impose a waste reduction fee that is built into price that pays for ewaste reduction. This could empower Ghanaians to build out this as a safer industry. How much would that fee be? And who would spend the political capital to enact such a tariff? That’s the part that feels impossible.
- naming_the_user 2y agoCounterpoint to most of the posts here - I don’t see this and think “wow we should stop using things”, I see this and think “wow, we need to sort out governance / fix poverty”. A well run landfill looks nothing like this and these are in no way a foregone conclusion of someone throwing away an old iPhone 3 or whatever. There is no more correlation here than with, say, Newton has the apple fall and then we cut to scenes of firebombing.
- yunohn 2y agoThis not “well run” landfill literally exists because the companies/countries dumping their e-waste here do not want to pay for the “well run” ones.
- naming_the_user 2y agoSure, so let's make them pay for it, job done. If I go to the loo and my water company decides it's cheaper to dump human faeces in the middle of the M1 motorway than to dispose of it properly, the solution isn't for me to stop going to the loo, it's to force my water company to stop doing that.
- netsharc 2y ago> make them pay for it Which in turn will mean more expensive products. Products of imaginary Company A, which is responsible, will be more expensive than products of Company B, which can use all the tricks to be cheap (e.g. conflict minerals, child/slave labour, bribing^W lobbying government officials to take their e-waste). And which products will the consumer buy? The better priced one...
- naming_the_user 2y agoYes, just like I use the cheaper electricity producer that burns coal. Actually, no, my government doesn't allow this.
- bastawhiz 2y ago
- Workaccount2 2y agoPeople should understand that proper clean electronic waste recycling does exist. This story isn't so much about "we need to stop consuming new electronics" as it is "we need to ensure that electronic waste doesn't end up being dumped on random impoverished towns in Africa". These guys are burning off the insulation from wires when there are simple cheap machines that automatically strip it all off. This is more a portrayal of extreme poverty than anything.
- HermanMartinus 2y agoI second this opinion. Here's an older article which is less dramatised and talks about attempted interventions such as trying to get the recyclers to use wire strippers instead of burning: https://www.worstpolluted.org/projects_reports/display/107 https://www.worstpolluted.org/projects_reports/display/107
- sweeter 2y agothe guy doesn't have any shoes, where are these tools going to come from?
- HermanMartinus 2y agoThey were supplied with wire strippers. That was the intervention, not just the suggestion of wire strippers.
- moffkalast 2y agoI'm pretty sure at the rates they get paid they'd be better off selling the wire strippers and keep burning the insulation. Like this is Marie Antoinette tier behavior of someone so out of touch with reality from their own privilege they can't even see it. "Hello, I, a benevolent westerner have bestowed upon you a dirt cheap tool so you can keep digging through cancerous muck for pennies. Am I not a gracious god? Thanks bye"
- 2y ago
- rrrix1 2y agohttps://maps.app.goo.gl/LS4xWeuewBqwUNuN9?g_st=com.google.maps.preview.copy https://maps.app.goo.gl/LS4xWeuewBqwUNuN9?g_st=com.google.ma... That waterway is flowing directly into the ocean, and upstream from a fishing village.
- sva_ 2y agoMaybe I shouldn't have eaten that tuna from Ghana
- jl6 2y ago> "There’s a whole generation of young people that are building their society from e-waste work." This is hard, dangerous, indecent work by any first world standard, but it's still work, it's still opportunity, and it's still an industry for people who otherwise might not have one. I don't wish to see this kind of pollution and suffering exist, but I also don't wish to take away something that despite its awfulness is still someone's livelihood. Ladders need bottom rungs. When they closed sweatshops in Bangladesh, the children had to resort to prostitution.
- hcarvalhoalves 2y agoThis rhetoric is outdated by more than 200 years, when kids worked at coal mines in 18th century Britain.
- jl6 2y agoAnd yet coal wealth was tremendously beneficial for those communities. Kids-in-mines was ended by better labor regulation, not by cutting off the source of the wealth. Ghana has an amazing opportunity here. The world is literally shipping gold to their doorstep. There has got to be a solution that improves standards without cutting them out of the loop.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoAny law that improves standards will increase cost and then they don't get the scrap anymore, someone else without laws will. The market will find a place.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- DrNosferatu 2y agoThe EU (and the US, and others for that matter) should increase the compulsory warranty from 2 years to 5 years. Not only it would reduce e-waste, but it would also disincentivize the lowest-margin, sweat shop production.
- ErikAugust 2y agoI'm a software idiot, but why couldn't you do the Goodwill of Cloud Infrastructure? Build affordable cloud services out of "junk" electronics?
- crote 2y agoTotal cost of ownership. First you need to spend an absolute fortune on sysadmins to hack together functioning machines from heaps of mostly-broken parts. Then you need to deal with an admin nightmare as every machine will be different, so you need to manage them as individual machines rather than hundreds of identical clones who all behave exactly the same. Then you need to deal with tons of random hardware failures, none of which can be easily solved by hotswapping a standard fan or harddrive you've got lying on the shelf already. And to finish it off, you're also using 5x - 10x more power for the same compute. Whatever money you're saving on hardware purchase, you're spending many times more on all the other stuff. Free junk electronics are just too expensive.
- blitzar 2y agoTotal pollution of ownership would likely be lower with new hardware vs old when you take into account the higher power usage vs lower performance.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThis cannot be true forever. Transistors are still shrinking yet we're fast approaching physical limits. Hence the ever larger and hotter and more power hungry GPUs and CPUs. There's also the waste involved in continuously producing those more efficient models. Their lifetime emissions, including manufacturing, may actually be worse compared to certain older generations.
- penguin_booze 2y agoDumping yards reminds me of a scene from the Office, where Dwight says (IIRC), "humans are the only animals capable of this".
- lr1970 2y agoUser swappable batteries will extend the life of mobile devices big time. I am old enough to remember that you could easily pop any phone's back cover and swap the battery.
- nfriedly 2y agoI've replaced batteries in a handful of newer smartphones. It's certainly more of a pain in the rear than on devices who's batteries were meant to be swappable, but it's still do-able. iFixit has parts, guides, and difficulty ratings for a lot of devices. https://www.sustaphones.com/ https://www.sustaphones.com/ has a list of Android devices with up-to-date community ROMs and iFixit battery replacement guides.
- adolph 2y agoI think one of the exciting byproducts of future long term space travel is how it will change people's expectations of the material world. Currently humans generate a significant amount of material which does not have a downstream constituency, and thus is stored, sometimes in less aesthetically acceptable ways like the pictured scrapyard. Since the topic of TFA is e-waste, many comments here promote "right to repair" legislation as a panacea. I don't think that "right to repair" addresses the root issue in a broad enough way to make a dent. It only addresses a subset of material, operates at hobby scale, and may mandate certain things, like socketed components, that make full-scale automated recycling more difficult.
- Narishma 2y agoI'm confused. What does space travel have to do with this?
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoI like to buy (some) used hardware when I have need to. Either the ones that people sent back because they thought that it would be simple and was not (my Cisco home switch), or older tech that is completely fine for my needs. My personal experience is that when electronics work for two weeks, they will work "forever" - I like someone else doing the test :) Of course it depends on the hardware. It will be different for a switch and a UPS, or an SSD, ...
- M95D 2y agoThe article mentions repairing some of the electronics. There's even a photo with something that looks like a repair shop. I would buy vintage electronics and PC parts, but these guys are not selling on ebay. So, where do they sell them after they fix them?
- Loughla 2y agoMy guess is at the city they are in? Wouldn't that just make sense?
- M95D 2y agoI was hoping that they sell them back internationally. I mean, how many '90s amplifiers can an african city buy?
- Loughla 2y agoMaybe this is just a massive stereotype and a blind spot that I have, but it feels like the business they showed in the article is not equipped for international sales.
- t0bia_s 2y agoYet, we made and buy crappy devices like Niimbot printers, that are not working without proprietary app that collect your data and asks for paying for using different, then default font. What a wonderful e-waste.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoGhana long been the example held up by reporting and exhibitions of the global e-waste problem (alongside Tanzania, and China). But one thing I've noticed in recent years' reports is a further twist: as countries' policies have started to shift (and their modernization/attitudes have grown perhaps), like in China for example, they are increasingly re-exporting the incoming e-waste further abroad to other Southeast Asian and African countries. The continued global migration of e-waste as it were. :/
- hettygreen 2y agoHere's the actual site on google earth: https://maps.app.goo.gl/mjCvuMaUaZ3154eD9 https://maps.app.goo.gl/mjCvuMaUaZ3154eD9 There's a river that runs through the e-waste garbage dump, straight into the ocean less than 1 Mile away.
- Abismith 2y ago[dead]
- dools 2y agoThe only thing that can help this is an enormous export tarriff on eWaste unless it is shipped to a foreign processing centre run by a company that complies with the exporter's labour laws.
- imoverclocked 2y agoI just replaced an electric stove top unit because the old one had a burner that wouldn’t turn off. I still haven’t figured out what to do with the old unit; a local e-waste recycling group doesn’t want it, I don’t know anyone that wants a partially functioning stovetop, I don’t want to fix it myself… but I guess I can pay to bring it to the local landfill. Anyone claiming that “right to repair” fixes any of this is missing the part where people don’t want to spend their lives repairing everything they have. Also, the new stovetop is far more energy efficient than the old one with is yet another balancing aspect of replacing old tech.
- knowitnone 2y agoyou just admitted that you're the problem. "new stovetop is far more energy efficient than the old one" how so? does it magically produce more heat from nothing?
- squidgedcricket 2y agoInductive heating can be more efficient than resistive heating because less energy is lost to the environment.
- bastawhiz 2y agoThat's a nonsensical thing to say. An electric cooktop using heated rings is indisputably less efficient than an induction cooktop. It simply doesn't get all of its energy into the cookware. What's the parent commenter supposed to do? Live without a stovetop because the old one can't be fixed?
- kalessin 2y agoI don't want to fix it myself either, and I don't see how a repair industry could exist without the right to repair.
- jabbany 2y agoRight to repair just means for those that do want to repair it, they can without any undue burden. If you don't want to repair it, nobody is forcing you to! Just throw it away like you would have done anyways. The point of right to repair is that there is a non-zero amount of people who want to repair stuff and it shouldn't cost the people who don't anything extra... It's a "right" not an "obligation"...
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- komali2 2y agoEwaste makes me super sad. I was in an electronics stores recently and found myself bored and even a little bit disgusted - new macbooks! new ipads! new laptops! new phones! Every year, new new new. But I have a lot more fun in the used electronics shop in my city (Guanghua digital plaza in Taipei). I find it a lot more fun to find good deals on parts punching above their weight for the price, e.g. if I find a used computer with a great processor in it that's selling for cheap because the specs are otherwise bad or whatever. And, in general, I find the thrill of the project much more fun than new new new. Can't wait to install linux on this used laptop, oooh a used pixel phone, the camera is still pretty good, maybe I can use this for a pet camera for my lizard, etc. New phones especially I just don't understand anymore. My phone's been able to do everything I need it to do since like, 2016. New AI "feature," better processors, bigger screens, I don't get it. I have an excellent camera (fuji xt5) so better cameras don't excite me.
- sweeter 2y agoThis is just one of many ways us in the "first world" exploit the poverty of poorer nations. Wait until you all see what the labor conditions we solicit from these nations look like and all the countries we sell our literal garbage/waste to... knowing full well it will just be dumped in the ocean... but hey, "we didnt do it" y'know? they did. which in reality is just a shallow abdication of responsibility and everyone covering their eyes and ears and pretending like it doesn't exist
- bibelo 2y agomy 24" screen is a iiyama from 2008. Still working perfectly.
- misiek08 2y agoI have iPad 2 Retina. Screen still is great, battery allow for hours of playing, but it stays at iOS 12. Even Github doesn't work correctly there, because we moved onto super-extra-required-new-crazy-stuff in JS area. It's so trashy for me I gave it for 2-year-old on the trip and she pushed the home button so hard it's not working anymore, but iOS 12 allowed to just swipe from bottom, so device is still ok. The only thing I can do with it is to throw it away, because Apple in Poland redirects to some garbage collecting company and even in US the device is worth 0$. I think materials and working Retina screen is worth much more than nothing. Great quality build, great hardware set, 64G memory. Much better than current models. But it still is a trash and waste for planet :( Sad.
- eleveriven 2y agoAt least it’s found a new life as a toy
- nfriedly 2y agoI just sold one of these last year on a local marketplace website. Mine had a working home button but was otherwise similar to yours. I think I got $40 USD for it. I feel like there's probably someone out there who would still get some use out of it if you gave it away, and might even be willing to pay you a small amount of money for it.
- api 2y ago> International laws prohibit trafficking of non-functional e-waste containing toxic substances I wonder if that makes the problem worse by making it hard to ship e-waste to places where it can be more efficiently recycled, so instead it ends up in places where corruption lets it in but there are no recycling facilities beyond "pickers?"
- randlet 2y ago"Emmanuel Akatire traveled about 500 miles from his home in Zorko, Ghana, to Accra, the nation’s capital, to find the only work he could — sifting through vast piles of discarded electronics to find valuable scrap metal. A week’s worth of painstaking, often dangerous work, earns him the equivalent of about 60 U.S. dollars." I just finished The Grapes Of Wrath and this opening sentence feels like an odd futuristic parallel to that story.
- commentor___555 2y agoIsn't the elephant in the room that we are sending new sealed tech to EWaste? https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/jun/22/amazon-faces-mps-scrutiny-after-destroying-laptops-tablets-and-books https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/jun/22/amazon-fa...