7 ms·
How bad are satellite megaconstellations for astronomy?
- 29athrowaway 3y agoNow we are left without a way to detect if an asteriod is coming our way.
- tetris11 3y agoI know it's a blessing for people who live out in the sticks to have internet.... but is that really such a large use-case to justify entire fleets of these things? How hard is it to run km of wire from the nearest town? To me, these were built for the sole purpose of surveillance, and internet is an afterthought. Edit: yes yes it's expensive, but the easiest solution the world came up with was for some guy to invest billions in a satellite program?
- philomath_mn 3y ago> How hard is it to run km of wire from the nearest town? Very hard, especially when the towns are much more dispersed than a km apart.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoYeah, no one is going to "run a wire" out to Umiat, Alaska. In places like that it's satellite or nothing.
- astrodust 3y agoThe hardest part is not the cable, or even the installation thereof, it's finding a contiguous right-of-way you can install it on, or having to fuss around with thousands of land owners who want their cut for the rights. This is why most cables are laid alongside train tracks, not unlike telegram wires of years past. You negotiate with a handful of entities and can get permission relatively easily. Of course, this presumes there's tracks, which is less and less likely as they keep getting ripped out. If there's anything modern infrastructure build needs, it's more right-of-way access where you can provision dark fibre without getting mired in the legal issues.
- LeoPanthera 3y ago> How hard is it to run km of wire from the nearest town? If it's not hard, why hasn't it happened already?
- oh_my_goodness 3y agoTo be fair, people are already using wire.
- digging 3y ago(in the US) It may be hard for a new company but easy for existing telecom giants. But existing telecom giants don't give a shit about national internet infrastructure quality, so if connecting rural customers simply appears less profitable* than focusing on current operations[1], they won't do it. [1] Current operations include the obviously profitable "send monthly marketing materials via mail, email, and live salespersons to homes who canceled your services the day they had an alternative," among other idiotic practices.
- FredPret 3y agoSuper hard. You have to dig a trench or span the wire. Either way you need to clear it with numerous property owners over a vast distance, get approval from dozens of authorities along the way, coordinate work crews, and then do maintenance on the whole thing for decades. And then you discover that the wire used 50 years ago contained lead and we don't like that anymore, so now you have to pay for massive lawsuits (look up AT&T & Verizon) and rip up all that wire. More coordinating work crews and property owners! And then they invent a new kind of wire and you have to do it all again. Launching 1000's of satellites isn't easy but I can see wanting to do that rather than wire up the whole planet.
- ajford 3y agoBecause telecoms keep pocketing the money instead of actually building out broadband. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/the-book-of-broken-promis_b_5839394 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/the-book-of-broken-promis_b_5...
- ericd 3y agoYeah, I’m not sure why trenching is so expensive, I think PG&E was quoting something silly like millions per kilometer. I’m planning on doing like a tenth of a kilometer in a day with a $400 trencher rental pretty soon. I’m sure it’s not apples to apples, but the delta there seems pretty baffling. For me, the biggest hang up has just been that I’m required by the state to get it inspected before I put in the conduit, and that ramps up the complexity of coordinating things quite a bit, because I’d rather not leave it open too long. If they have to deal with a bunch of bureaucratic coordination, then I could see the actual labor becoming a relatively tiny part of the difficulty/cost.
- iwontberude 3y agoIt might cost money to figure out where to prioritize resources
- ericd 3y agoYeah, but if the planning that’s meant to make things efficient is using up almost all the money, seems like maybe we need to rethink how we’re doing things.
- oh_my_goodness 3y agoHard enough that some people are putting up satellites instead. EDIT: Say there's some way to put in fiber at $10k per km. Even then, ten million users at 1km per user makes $100 billion.
- bmitc 3y agoTo me, these are capitalistic solutions looking for problems. It's the whole startup mentality. Let's just throw a bunch of shit in space and see if it ends up being useful for anything. This idea of connecting the world is as false as the other hundred millions times that's been sold.
- oh_my_goodness 3y agoYeah, fair. Just because stuff is expensive doesn't mean it's worth anything.
- FredPret 3y agoIf you paid attention, "this time" and also the "other hundred million times" are true, not false. We're massively more connected than ever before. Homeless people in the third world have phones now. They should be able to get on the internet too.
- palata 3y agoStarlink is not there to bring Internet in places that don't have it. It's here to bring fast Internet in places that already have slow Internet. The question is: how fast an Internet connection do we need? Do we really need to swipe 4k videos on social network, or to download 50G of docker containers for every build? I don't think so.
- FredPret 3y agoIs there some maximum level of development you want? And what is that level, and why? Where do you want to draw the line? The wheel, fire, hand tools, struggling to survive in the middle ages, slow internet, fast internet? I say there is no line.
- Starlevel004 3y ago[flagged]
- a2l3aQ 3y agoNot a great point of view when the cities don't grow all that much food.
- Starlevel004 3y agoNeither do most ruraloids and especially not the ones actually paying for the satellites.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoThat's nice. No one put you in charge of this.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoISPs were paid billions to do this in the US and then stole the money and didn't do it thanks to regulatory capture.
- shadowgovt 3y agoIn many cases, the issue isn't cost to run but cost to maintain. Consider South Africa, where the largest threat to installation deployment is inability to police the entire deployment coupled with massive wealth inequality... People just dig the cables out of the ground for the copper. Cellular radio has ameliorated the issue some (harder to steal the repeater antenna out of the back yard of a shotgun-owning resident), but Internet can still be a challenge.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoThat specific problem should go away as more lines get replaced with fiber, which has minimal scrap value compared to copper.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoNo one can tell before they cut if they are outsiders
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's getting to the point it's not even worthwhile to run power lines to remote locations.
- palata 3y ago> To me, these were built for the sole purpose of surveillance, and internet is an afterthought. Growth! Growth no matter the cost! Why would anyone question the need for always faster internet connections everywhere? /s
- Turing_Machine 3y agoLet us know when you switch back to a 300 bps audio modem.
- palata 3y agoSure, because that is the only alternative to fiber. /s
- delichon 3y agoOn the one hand the constellations are doing considerable damage to surface based astronomy. On the other hand they are funding an enormously lower cost of access to orbit and beyond for astronomy up in the sky.
- marcosdumay 3y agoYes, the future of astronomy is in space. If the satellites don't disrupt it, light pollution will anyway, or best case, it will be disrupted by atmospheric pollution. There's no lack of clear skies in space.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoThe future of astronomy is both on the ground and in space. There are so many things that you can only conceivably do from the ground. You can build vastly larger telescopes on the ground, you can install far heavier instruments (like cameras and spectrographs) on them, you can upgrade and repair components much more easily. You can build massive arrays of radio telescopes. You get the point. There are some things you can only do from space, or that are better in space, but saying that everything will be done in space is like saying we only need laptops and don't need datacenters. You need both.
- mercutio2 3y agoAre there really a lot of ground based telescope components larger than Starship's fairing? I'm just not seeing the argument for there being any telescope function that wouldn't be better done in orbit, at Starship payload prices.
- Retric 3y agoYes, though I guess it depends on what you mean by lots: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_optical_reflecting_telescopes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_optical_reflec.... Critically the 30+m monsters under construction have only recently become feasible on the Earh let alone in space, and much smaller instruments still provide significant value today. There’s a much longer list of large radio based telescopes which have minimal advantages in space to the point where we haven’t launched any, and they are also negatively impacted by constellations. Also, several types of observations don’t really benefit from being in space. If you want to track killer asteroids space doesn’t provide much advantage even if you could get there for 100$/kg. IMO the issue here isn’t satellites, it’s that they can harm multi billion dollar investments at zero cost to themselves. If you’re very clearly causing 10’s of millions in damages you really should be compensating the people affected.
- chankstein38 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 3y agoFrom the paper: >> Astronomy is also engaged in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, a classic example of a program that might proceed for many years with little or nothing of interest to report, but that might someday provide one of the most profound discoveries in human history That is all well and good. Most HN readers are probably well aware of that project. But if you want to alter policy at a national or international level, don't talk about extraterrestrial intelligence. It stirs the hornets next of faith, politics and cultural conflict. It opens the door to ridicule. Talk about the search for life, the search for a second life-supporting world. And maybe some of that life runs a radio station. Just avoid mentioning ET by name.
- jonplackett 3y agoIs this a bit of a temporary problem, in the the very technology causing the issue - substantially cheaper access to space - will presumable ultimately put a frikkin massive telescope, or many massive telescopes into orbit where they’ll also not have to deal with the many other issues ground telescopes have to deal with. I get that this still sucks for any individual with a Telescope though.
- runeofdoom 3y agoIt's not just "any individual with a telescope" though. It's stuff like the Simonyi Survey Telescope, a set to map the southern sky down to below 27th magnitude that's in trouble.
- jonplackett 3y agoHow would a telescope like that compare to Webb or Hubble in its capability? Eg, if we had to trade the loss of that for many Webb scale telescopes, or presumably something much much bigger once starship can start launching - is that worth the trade?
- ajford 3y agoOk, who funds it? National Science Foundation doesn't allocate nearly enough money as it is, let alone enough to replace the tens to hundreds of active telescopes producing scientific data every night. And those telescopes are already oversubscribed with people waiting in line for available time. So unless we're slowing astronomy to a halt, we'd need similar numbers of telescopes. And none of that takes into account that many of these telescopes are used specifically as experimenter telescopes where a given scientist can use their own equipment to perform unique observations that cannot be easily done with space-based telescopes. It took over a decade to produce the Webb telescope and get it into space, and still is a massive feat of engineering not easily reproduced. We're not nearly to a point where we can just write off ground-based observatories in place of space-based ones.
- runeofdoom 3y ago
- Havoc 3y agoAs much as I sympathize this feels like a necessary evil to me in a sense vaguely accerlationism like. I do think starlink can do more to help the situation though. Sure they tweaked some of the satellites to minimise it, but they could do more. Presumably the know the precise location and orientation of each sat. Surely that can be packaged into a data stream that helps unfk the images? Maybe with a sprinkling of that AI musk has going? Astronomers is a pretty small crowd...can't be that hard for someone like musk to throw them a bone that acknowledges that they're getting the short end here
- LeoPanthera 3y agoThere's no need to predict them in advance. Astronomy photos taken from the ground aren't one long exposure. They're lots - hundreds even - of short ones, which are then "stacked" to reduce noise and increase dynamic range of the final image. It should be trivial to identify streaks in the stack and just throw out those images. I'd be surprised if they're not already doing that for the older satellites up there, and things like planes flying across the shot.
- throw_pm23 3y agoWhen you are driving towards a wall or a cliff you don't necessarily want to accelerate.
- Havoc 3y agoYou do if you think the gap between this cliff and the next can be jumped
- schiffern 3y ago>they could do more. Presumably the know the precise location and orientation of each sat. Surely that can be packaged into a data stream SpaceX already does that. https://youtu.be/MNc5yCYth5E?t=1717 https://youtu.be/MNc5yCYth5E?t=1717 https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.11123 https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.11123
- trothamel 3y ago30 years ago, it was possible to be lost - not because you wanted to be, but because you had no way of figuring out where we are. GPS and other GNSS networks have solved that problem. It used to be possible to not have high-speed internet, and now high-speed Internet is available everywhere in the world that has an amenable government. Right now, it's possible to be in a location where it's impossible to call for help. In a few years, when LTE-in-space is available and the 911 mandate applies to it, anyone with a charged phone will be able to get contact. SpaceX has been working to mitigate how its satellites affect astronomy - see https://api.starlink.com/public-files/BrightnessMitigationBestPracticesSatelliteOperators.pdf https://api.starlink.com/public-files/BrightnessMitigationBe... and https://new.nsf.gov/news/statement-nsf-astronomy-coordination-agreement https://new.nsf.gov/news/statement-nsf-astronomy-coordinatio... . But fundamentally, to limit space to astronomy will be to limit the benefits it can give all mankind. a
- shadowgovt 3y agoIncluding, notably, better astronomy. Imagine a radio telescope as a satellite constellation, with an aperture the diameter of the orbit if you can synchronize the incoming signal with the right math...
- StellarScience 3y agoThere certainly is a real concern for astronomers, but the photo illustrations used in the article are selected to make things seem worse than they really are. They're wide field of view, long-duration exposures. That used to be the way astronomers imaged space, with film systems a century ago. But these days astronomical telescopes tend to have much narrower fields of view (like tiny soda straws peering into one particular spot in space) and use image stacking, a technique where many individual images are processed to form the final image (very simplistic overview: https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/astrophotography/astrophoto-tips/a-guide-to-astrophotography-stacking https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/astrophotography/astropho... .) Using image stacking and armed with accurate catalogs that predict precisely where every satellite will be at any time, enables the removal of satellites during the image stacking process. Or they can just use that information for better scheduling: wait a minute or two to image a particular spot, so there won't be satellites in the field of view. The article definitely gets this part right: > “Some astronomers see this as a true ‘hair on fire’ emergency, heralding irretrievable losses to space science; others present a more sanguine face, depicting this as yet another challenge to be surmounted in surveying a decreasingly pristine sky,” Koplow remarks. Being involved in both space and astronomy plants me squarely in the latter camp. It takes a bit more work and software, but having so many satellites in space is a surmountable challenge for terrestrial astronomers. (Not to mention, these days some of the best astronomy is performed by telescopes in space, so astronomy overall benefits by having easier access to space.)
- shadowgovt 3y agoForget satellites; you can't do raw long-exposure for "serious" terrestrial-based astronomy anymore because you'll get planes in the way.
- gammarator 3y ago> They're wide field of view, long-duration exposures. That used to be the way astronomers imaged space, Sorry, but one of the two example images (https://noirlab.edu/public/images/iotw1946a/ https://noirlab.edu/public/images/iotw1946a/) is a single 333-second exposure with a modern survey camera, the Dark Energy Camera. This is not particularly long nor does it represent some outmoded observational strategy. Large, wide-field imaging sky surveys (such as the upcoming Rubin Observatory) are among the highest-profile ground-based astronomy projects today. Masking and stacking can mitigate the problem but it does not of course compensate for the lost area and sensitivity. And the brightest satellites (like BlueWalker) saturate the readout electronics and spoil the whole exposure. Narrow field instruments (such as spectrographs) have less geometric chance of seeing a satellite but tend to take longer exposures (tens of minutes), so there is a greater loss of telescope time when a streak does happen. Even space telescopes are affected by streaks (https://www.space.com/hubble-images-spoiled-starlink-satellite-steaks https://www.space.com/hubble-images-spoiled-starlink-satelli...). > It takes a bit more work and software Equivalently, it takes more money and time. That just means less science, given flat to declining funding from Congress.
- FredPret 3y agoIt'd be so cool if we can put up a huge antenna / scope on the far side of the moon. You'd be completely shielded from all human noise
- amelius 3y agoUntil we put satellites around the Moon.
- FredPret 3y agoI wonder if it could be made practical to have a radio interferometer made up of several spacecraft flying in various directions.
- martinky24 3y agoDoesn’t the moon rotate
- ooterness 3y agoNo. The moon is tidally locked to the Earth, so its rotation exactly matches its orbital period. If you put a telescope on the far side, it'll always be pointing away from Earth.
- joshuakogut 3y agoThis is the principle behind the lagrange point chosen for the James Webb Space Telescope. It's occluded from the brightness of the sun by the earth.
- shadowgovt 3y agoI'm sure it's inconvenient, but it's hard for me to believe that this isn't a solvable problem. Satellites have extremely predictable paths and are very well-tracked by every government with a space program. If you can know a source of noise is there, you can trim the noise out of the signal. Sure, this impacts the fidelity of your signal for the three-dimensional coordinates of image where the noise was present, but "We're getting less science per day" isn't a reason to stop the low-orbit satellite boom. What am I missing here? Can we not do the signal-subtraction? Is the problem unsolved or unsolvable? And if it's unsolved... Where are the grants to solve it?
- SaberTail 3y agoWhen counting photons, the noise in your signal scales with the square root of the total count. If the satellite is dumping 100 ± 10 photons in every pixel it passes through, you can no longer distinguish objects so faint that they'd only leave 10 photons in a pixel during your exposure.
- shadowgovt 3y agoBut in two dimensions of space and one of time, that's only a momentary occlusion right?
- rickydroll 3y ago1) Most research is performed on the thousands of smaller telescopes (0.5-2 m.) scattered worldwide at private and public institutions. Even with the multitude of telescopes in the size range, there is still significant contention for scope time. 2) Space telescopes will never be disposable and will always require some form of service, even with high-reliability construction. 3) low Earth orbit is a limited resource and should be managed as a worldwide Commons. Allowing private corporations to occupy space is another way to privatize profit and push losses onto the public purse. Do you think any of these private companies will clean up the orbital messes they create, or will they act like they have to date? 4) Satellite Internet solves the billionaire's problem of extracting more money from users. Terrestrial methods for Internet access are good enough in all but the most remote communities. The main problem with terrestrial Internet is funding buildout Via private companies in a natural monopoly environment.
- bythreads 3y agoI always thought spacex should stick a 5 dollar webcam to each sattelite pointing upwards and create the worlds largest telescope to just shut everybody up
- martinky24 3y agoCan you expand on how sticking a $5 webcam on each starlink satellite would quell concerns? I’m in the astronomy community and I can’t quite figure it out. If you could expand on what you’re thinking and some of the science behind it, that’d be great.
- bythreads 3y agoHalf baked for sure, but : I thought given the ultra precise location and clocks, combined with the laser coms you could build a large array, or a inferometer with a baseline the size of the leo orbit. Could be used for whole sky surveys, transient detections, wide angle monitoring, and high res imaging (granted this last one might require more operational finesse than a 5 dollar webcam c ould give you since you'd need fractional wavelength accuracy (right?). A radio antenna pointing outwards would in all honesty probably be better. But 42.000 x X mega pixels in orbit pointing outwards at least will give you some nice big piles of data to play woth - and the downlink is baned in
- NikkiA 3y agoThe image quality would average to that of a $5 webcam, ie, it'd still be shit quality.
- briandw 3y agoMega-constellations also mean that access to space is getting cheeper. Bigger and more plentiful space telescopes should offset the loss from ground based astronomy in the long run. It's no consolation in the near term. But imagine the possibilities for a Starship sized telescope, or many of them.