34 ms·
Lithium-free sodium batteries exit the lab and enter US production
- downrightmike 3y agoLower capacity in the same form factor, but inputs are common and cheap as dirt and will be able to do the hard work of supporting grid scale battery storage. We've learned that there are many applications that do not need to capacity of lithium.
- hcarvalhoalves 3y agoEven if it isn't as high-capacity, a longer-lasting and safer battery over a thinner smartphone isn't a _bad_ trade-off, specially considering chips and screens get more efficient. This might have more market than stationary batteries.
- rich_sasha 3y agoAre they safer? Sodium is also very highly reactive. Otherwise agreed, I'm very happy with form factor of 5-10 year old phones.
- majoe 3y agoOne of the claimed benefits of sodium based batteries, that I remember from the press statements of CATL, is that they don't burn, even when you but them in a fire. The also should work in a wider temperature range, which is especially interesting for cold regions. In the article it says, that they are using a "patented Prussian blue". Isn't CATL also using Prussian blue in their first generation sodium batteries?
- demondemidi 3y agoNaCl is pretty safe. ;)
- ash__ 3y ago[flagged]
- tharkun__ 3y agoDepends on the quantity and who you ask what the safe level is ;)
- strangattractor 3y agoMy cardiologist doesn't think so :(
- pkaye 3y agoLow NaCl in a human body is also really bad.
- hcarvalhoalves 3y agoThe battery made by the company mentioned uses an aqueous electrolyte construction which is theoretically safer from what I read, but I don't know if it can be made small for a portable. The fact it supports more cycles and tolerates a broader temperature range than Lithium counts points towards safety too. Lithium isn't happy above like 30 Celsius, which a fast charging portable device can _easily_ reach.
- justinclift 3y ago> Lithium isn't happy above like 30 Celsius, which a fast charging portable device can _easily_ reach. Sounds pretty bad for people living in warmer climates then, as they tend to be above 30 celsius anyway. ;)
- cesarb 3y ago> Sounds pretty bad for people living in warmer climates then, as they tend to be above 30 celsius anyway. ;) As a data point, the ambient temperature right now where I live is 33°C. I just walked home from a quick grocery trip a couple of blocks away. And that's not an atypical temperature (at least for the warmer months of the year; we're supposed to be in the colder months now, but the climate's been all wonky lately). If my phone's battery didn't like ambient temperatures above 30°C, it would have failed long ago. There's no air conditioning in the street.
- hcarvalhoalves 3y agoIt doesn't fail abruptly, but it doesn't achieve optimal performance either. It has pretty strict optimal temperature range, something like 10C to 30C.
- troymc 3y agoHere's Natron's page about safety: https://natron.energy/our-technology/safety https://natron.energy/our-technology/safety I don't think the battery is a big block of pure sodium. That would be unsafe. The battery electrolyte contains sodium ions, but the same is true of salt water and Gatorade. I think the industrial source of their sodium is sodium hydoxide, a common industrial feedstock. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_hydroxide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_hydroxide
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thejohnconway 3y agoFor iPhones, at least, I believe that period was when they were thinnest (the iPhone 6 is the thinnest one, 2014).
- rini17 3y agoSince na-ion cells are available on aliexpress, youtubers already did puncture tests, and indeed they did not catch fire. Seems like sodium is better "hidden" in the cathode/anode so it won't react witth the air so quickly as lithium when battery innards are exposed.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoWere they actually sodium batteries? Maybe they were fraudulently labeled Li-ion. Also it's my understanding that neither sodium batteries nor li-ion batteries have metallic sodium/lithium in them (besides small amounts which build up in heavily used li-ion cells or something).
- rini17 3y agoThey have specific discharge curve which would be too much effort to fake.
- pfdietz 3y agoI believe sodium here is always in the oxidized +1 state, like the lithium in Li-ion batteries. It's not present as a metal. The things being oxidized/reduced are transition metals in one or more electrodes.
- addaon 3y agoIf customers were supportive of this trade-off, why would we not already see companies exploring it with LTO batteries?
- GuB-42 3y agoBut who wants a fat smartphone with lower battery life? Smartphones are where people want as much energy density as possible. Smartphones are also expensive devices with a relatively small battery, so it makes sense to add a few dollars for more energy density. Also most smartphone manufacturers are very much into planned obsolescence, so much that countries are starting to legislate, they don't really want long lasting batteries, especially not if it compromises the user experience. There could be a market for power tools, where having more batteries of lower capacity for the same price can be desirable. Also maybe for hybrid vehicles.
- MrDrMcCoy 3y agoPersonally, I wouldn't mind a fatter phone. It actually might be easier for me to hold. I've never seen the appeal of phones so thin I could shave with them.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> never seen the appeal of phones so thin I could shave with them For people who wear slimmer-fitting clothing, this matters. Also, it’s more about the weight: you want a phone light enough that holding it up isn’t tedious.
- MrDrMcCoy 3y agoI suppose. Then again, so long as it's not so heavy as to cause pain, I think there would be a least some market for such devices. I thought the Steam Deck would be prohibitively heavy to use for it's weight, but the ergonomics made up for much of that.
- craftkiller 3y agoIf I use the steam deck for more than a couple of hours then I feel it in my wrists the next day. I still love the steam deck but it could go on a diet. (There are lighter alternatives, but I bought the steam deck specifically to financially support Valve's Linux gaming efforts)
- barfingclouds 3y agoWell I think for as amazing as this technology is, we probably don’t need it in a cellphone.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoNot only that: > Natron says its batteries charge and discharge at rates 10 times faster than lithium-ion, a level of immediate charge/discharge capability that makes the batteries a prime contender for the ups and downs of backup power storage. Also helping in that use case is an estimated lifespan of 50,000 cycles. So you take up more space, but the storage system is better in every other way (agility, conflict mineral free, longevity, cost). Feels like this puts a nail in the coffin of fossil generation. Edit: Assuming 1 cycle per day, that is a lifetime of ~137 years. More aggressive cycling is still very favorable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- addaon 3y agoThe challenge with interpreting statements like this is that there isn't just one lithium battery chemistry in widespread use, and even within a single chemistry the detailed structure of the anode and cathode can greatly change both achievable charge/discharge rates and longevity. For example, compared to the most commonly available energy-storage-optimized NMC cylindrical cells, LTO cylindrical cells charge and discharge at rates up to 10x faster, and have an estimated lifetime of tens of thousands of cycles... in exchange for have half or less of the energy density. Which is to say, depending on the exact details of the sodium cells being discussed, it's extremely likely that their entire performance envelope is achievable today with some combination of NMC, LFP, and LTO cells; although they may yet prove to have a cost advantage.
- idontwantthis 3y ago> Natron says its batteries charge and discharge at rates 10 times faster than lithium-ion, a level of immediate charge/discharge capability that makes the batteries a prime contender for the ups and downs of backup power storage. Also helping in that use case is an estimated lifespan of 50,000 cycles. From everything I've read about existing Lithuum battery storage, this is already their strongpoint. Is it helpful to be 10x faster that the current speed?
- 3y ago
- nightowl_games 3y agoHopefully we can continue to lower the power requirements of our every day items and the lower capacity of these batteries will become less of an issue.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoLowering the power we use, is the only realistic goal. I wear an Apple Watch. On my wrist, is a small, Lithium-ion battery, that contains a great deal of power. That power is trickled out, over time. If it were to all release at once, I'd no longer have a left hand. Packing all that energy into smaller and smaller form factors, increases the risk; no matter what tech we use. Energy is energy. When it comes out quickly, we call those "explosions."
- AustinDev 3y agoOne little point I want to clarify is that if your Apple Watch battery did indeed short and none of the protections against shorts worked, you'd likely just have a burn on your wrist. 309mAH isn't all that much energy assuming a full charge. I once bridged a ~2,500mAH 18650 battery that was in my bag when my keys created a circuit between the anode and the cathode. The result was a small fire inside my bag that was quickly stamped out. Now, if I'm carrying batteries capable of dumping a lot of current quickly, I use cases. What excites me most about this new battery tech is home and commercial backup energy storage that's much 'greener' and cheaper than lithium. There is a lot of space in rural and grid settings, so the density of Li-Ion isn't really needed.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoWell, shorting out is a fairly realistic scenario, as opposed to a flash-boom, but it is still a relatively slow release. I was really talking about how much energy potential is stored in batteries. In batteries, the energy is generally stored as potential chemical reactions, so it isn't realistic to have a flash-boom. Supercapacitors, on the other hand, may have more of a boom potential.
- 3y ago
- api 3y agoGrid storage is dominated by $/kWh. For land and sea transport it's mostly volume/kWh. For electric aircraft it's kg/kWh.
- londons_explore 3y ago> cheap as dirt There are lots of things left to make grid battery storage cheap. As well as the cells needing to be engineered to be cheaper, there are lots of changes to the battery packs that can be made, together with changes to inverters. For batteries, I'd like to see research into less consistent manufacturing and higher failure rates. Current packs the entire pack is unusable if just one cell fails in a way that leads to lots of heat production. If pack balancing circuits had the ability to take a cell or a parallel group of cells 'out of circuit' while still using the rest of the pack, then battery lifespans could be dramatically increased and it would be possible to manufacture cells far cheaper. For inverters, we should go for a direct-to-10kV inverter process. No transformers. At 10kV, currents are far lower and therefore wires can be far thinner (and cheaper). Consider making batteries ~15kV too - that reduces by ~30% the amount of expensive silicon needed, together with big reductions in copper costs, at the expense of extra design effort for much higher voltage batteries. At these higher voltages, you'd either use oil cooling, or you'd have ~10 separate coolant loops, one at each ~1500 volts of potential.
- garbageman 3y agoWhile it would be neat to build batteries that handle manufacturing defects akin to a CPU with 4 cores but 3 useable, I suspect the additional complexity, wiring, and circuitry is limiting. Batteries today are almost (or actually?) a commodity. Detecting and simply replacing the entire battery is probably cheaper and easier at grid scale.
- londons_explore 3y agoThe wiring and complexity isn't very much - you simply need a contactor that can 'short' the offending set of cells. It only needs to close once, so can simply be made from a spring and meltable material. And you need ~100 of these per 400 volt battery. Beyond that, all the complexity is in software. Software needs to monitor cell voltages and currents to detect a self-heating cell. Software then needs to stop balancing that cell up (ie. let it discharge). At the moment the cell voltage hits zero, software needs to close the 'short' across the cell, permanently taking it out of the circuit. This design might occasionally prevent charging the entire battery for a few minutes during this process. Specifically, when a cell is midway through being taken out of circuit, it can only be discharged, and would be dangerous to recharge. But a few minutes of downtime per year seems acceptable to me.
- moffkalast 3y agoIt'll be a good day when we can finally ditch lead acid.
- Havoc 3y agoKeen to see these enter the hobby market as well. Not super keen on yoloing DIY with lithium but sodium seems a bit safer
- gorpy7 3y agoMost diyers are using LFP at this point and that’s considered quite stable. a smaller group try to reuse old ev batteries and those are generally considered more risky because of the runaway effect that’s possible- which still seems relatively low. regardless, more stable chemistries are always welcome and i agree with others that the discharge recharge and cycles would be amazing!
- dtx1 3y ago50 Thousand Cycles would make replacing batteries unnecessary for almost all usecases. I would love such a battery in an electric bike. Max Range would be quite limited compared to a Lithium Version but with 10x discharge capacity and functionally unlimited life you could make a beast of a commuter e-bike. 50000 Cycles would realistically mean you can charge the bike every day for a hundred years
- analognoise 3y agoThe first generation will work like that. Then they will introduce various defects into the manufacturing process to decrease the lifespan (and they'll say it's cost) and the batteries will last 10 years max. Maybe 15 if you're lucky.
- hackernewds 3y agoWhy so cynical
- MrDrMcCoy 3y agoI mean, look at what was done to lighting. There are some original Edison bulbs that still work, yet you'd be lucky to get a year out of a modern incandescent. Same thing happened to LED bulbs.
- bmicraft 3y agoThe tradeoff with conventional light bulbs is efficiency vs. lifetime. This is not the usual planned obsolescence it is made out to be, you are actually getting more efficient bulbs that way.
- dtx1 3y ago> There are some original Edison bulbs that still work, yet you'd be lucky to get a year out of a modern incandescent. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zb7Bs98KmnY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zb7Bs98KmnY > Same thing happened to LED bulbs. Because LED Bulbs cook your LEDs and are stupid design. Get a permanent LED fixture with decent passive cooling and they will last for decades. Adapting LEDs into the same Plug as Incandescent lighting just does not work.
- tmaly 3y agoI remember seeing a post on HN a few years back where a professor at MIT figured out how to make a battery out of more abundant materials. Does anyone recall this post or have a link?
- ancorevard 3y agoZero dependency on China is a pretty significant bonus.
- specialist 3y agoHuh. I just checked. Swiss-based company Arxada supplies the (battery grade) prussian blue that Natron uses. Though I didn't quickly determine where it's actually made. Probably UK.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThey've been out of the labs for a while. CATL has been producing sodium ion batteries for a few years already. They are used in some of the cheaper cars there. But nice to see more companies getting sodium ion to production.
- YeBanKo 3y agoIs there any car with sodium batteries sold in the US? I am ok with cheap, 100-mile range small sedan that I can commute in and charge overnight.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoProbably not or not yet. Import tariffs are keeping a lot of the cheap cars out of the US. And part of their low price comes from not being assembled in the US where labor is relatively expensive. There might be some models coming in via Mexico in the next years as several Chinese manufacturers are starting to build factories there. But if that's what you are after, get yourself a nice second hand Nissan Leaf or similar. With the older ones, you might have to replace the battery. But that's not the end of the world in terms of cost. Some of the older ones are selling well below 10K$. A battery replacement would set you back 3-5K$. But it would also increase the resell value of the vehicle. And with a good battery, these things can last a long time.
- specialist 3y agoSodium-ion compliments Li-ion in the marketplace. Each battery variation is better suited for various niches. eg Sodium is a better fit for stationary storage. Though CATL and others are using sodium for down market vehicles too, which should free up Li-ion capacity for other use cases. To reach net-zero 2050, we'll need an installed base of 2 terawatts of battery storage. Annual production is ~30 gigawatts. (IIRC.) So mfgs will still continue to scale up and make as many Li-ion (eg LFP) batteries as possible. -- Also exciting are the misc thermal solutions just now starting their own cost-learning-curves. Advanced geothermal (generation and storage), box of rocks (heat batteries), geothermal heat pumps (commercial and residential).
- pfdietz 3y agoGlobal battery making capacity is now around 1 TWh/year.
- specialist 3y agoThanks. I'm confusing both myself and the conversation. I probably (mis)took the terawatt figure to be the cumulative installed amount. And some quick forraging didn't set me straight. (Any helpful links?) Being just a simple bear, I want both a burn down chart for (human) GHG pollution and "burn up" chart depicting our progress towards our glorious renewable energy net-zero future. (Turrible names, I know, esp wrt climate crisis, but I don't know what else to call them.) Add some milestones, if we want to get fancy. As you can see, I struggle to make sense of the whole domain. And I'm sure I'm not alone.
- pfdietz 3y agoI actually understated it. Global battery manufacturing capacity last year was 2.6 TWh. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2024-04-12/china-already-makes-as-many-batteries-as-the-entire-world-wants https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2024-04-12/china-...
- XorNot 3y agoBig if cheaper - which is the crux of the issue. LiFePO4 loses money in every analysis of putting in a home battery I've done: if sodium is more common, the question is does that meaningfully reduce the price of the battery.
- RetroTechie 3y ago> the question is does that meaningfully reduce the price of the battery. Battery manufacture isn't rocket science. The cost of raw materials weighs heavily. Also: safety, and raw materials that can be sourced anywhere. Nice to see sodium battery production scaling up.
- cryptonector 3y ago> if sodium is more common What. Of course sodium is more common. Hundreds of times more common. You can get it from the sea, salt lakes, and salt mines. You buy it all the time in the form of table salt. It's crazy cheap by comparison to lithium, and just crazy cheap, really (though it wasn't always crazy cheap).
- vegetablepotpie 3y agoWe’re undergoing a Cambrian explosion of battery chemistries at the moment. Other startups, such as From Energy is scaling up production of Iron Air batteries in West Virginia, which will be an order of magnitude cheaper than lithium ion and will provide grid scale power [1]. North Harbour Clean Energy Promised to build a manufacturing facility in Australia to build Vanadium Flow batteries, which have very high charge cycle in their lifetime and can store energy for longer durations [2]. The advantage with Sodium Ion is that, although energy densities are lower than Lithium Ion, it could still be used to power mobile devices and electric vehicles. [1] https://www.wesa.fm/environment-energy/2024-02-19/weirton-form-energy-battery-manufacturing https://www.wesa.fm/environment-energy/2024-02-19/weirton-fo... [2] https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2023-02-02/vanadium-redox-flow-battery-and-future-of-grid-energy-storage/101911604 https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2023-02-02/vanadium-redo...
- bjornsing 3y agoInteresting. Is there a public spreadsheet or similar summarizing the most important properties of these new battery types? It takes forever to just research one of them in enough depth to understand their basic properties, and I’d like to compare many.
- fwungy 3y agoDOE puts out comparison papers at times, but I haven't looked in a while.
- ForOldHack 3y ago"The energy density of sodium ion batteries is low.It is only 100-150Wh/kg, while the energy density of lithium energy is 120-180Wh/kg. This means that for batteries of the same size, sodium-ion batteries can store much less energy than lithium-ion batteries.Jan 2, 2024" https://www.dnkpower.com/will-sodium-batteries-replace-lithium-batteries/ https://www.dnkpower.com/will-sodium-batteries-replace-lithi...
- 3y ago
- throwitaway222 3y agoHopefully long term, this can help us dismantle unnecessary high voltage transmission lines, and let people trickle store power at 48volts and discharge it at 110 through inverters.
- bobthepanda 3y agoWhy would it? Moving these batteries would be more work than having transmission lines and we still need long distance power. There is a reason why pipelines are popular even though we have the capability to move oil using normal transportation.
- proee 3y agoHi Voltage transmission lines are completely necessary. Running on 48V would require ridiculously large cables over any significant distance. Is there a reason you want to "Dismantle" high voltage transmission lines? They are the greatest invention since sliced bread. edit: Sliced bread was invented in 1928, and the first high voltage transmission line was apparently tested in 1889. Therefore my statement needs revised to be historically accurate.
- gabrielhidasy 3y agoI imagine the idea they were proposing is ~most energy being locally generated, 48v should be fine from solar panels to batteries. But I can't see that working on denser cities, or factories, or less sunny climates.
- throwitaway222 3y agoThis is what I'm referring to. Houses mostly, the reason we need such high voltage is because someone can turn on an oven and consume 5kw. But that oven only runs for 1 hour, or more averagely, 30 minutes. So in the context of 200kwh battery systems at EVERY house, and inverters at every house, that oven can easily run off the inverter, and the house would never need to pull down heavy wattage from the grid. In this scenario, the grid's variability goes down dramatically, thus, reducing the voltage requirements... Instead every house would have small solar and a trickle feed of, lets say 800w-1kw consistently during the day. Additionally, for places that have a shit-ton of sun, can do much better with microgrids and generators.
- conradev 3y ago> We haven't seen a weight-based energy density figure from Natron itself, but a 2022 article from Chemical & Engineering News put its sodium-ion batteries at 70 Wh/kg, around the very bottom of the sodium-ion energy density scale. That aligns well with the company's stationary-only business plan, as sodium-ion batteries being pursued for potential mobility use have more than double that density. CATL showed a 160 Wh/kg sodium-ion battery in 2021 and has plans to increase that density over 200 Wh/kg to better meet the needs of electric vehicles. CATL’s sodium batteries were more than twice as dense three years ago
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoYes, but since the US is becoming extremely protectionist/nationalist with its energy infrastructure, the only relevant bit from this story is that this production is occuring entirely within the US. Though it is good news that this company can produce much denser batteries in the future!
- gpm 3y agoEnergy density isn't a particularly interesting target for stationary energy storage applications. I'd assume that they just aren't optimizing much for it (yet).
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoIs this battery's design patented or a secret? If patented, what is the lifetime of the patent? If not, how easy will it be for others to replicate?
- _yb2s 3y agoI had an early EV with only 80 miles of range, and found it extremely useful for most in town travel and commuting. Now that EVs are pushing ~400 miles range at about 300Wh/kg, assuming sodium is about half that (from what I've seen), you'd still get a respectable 100-200 miles in a car. For me, and I imagine a lot of people, that would be totally acceptable if it means lower cost, and batteries that effectively last forever without replacement.
- alemanek 3y agoFrom the article it claims charge speed 10x that of lithium and 50,000 cycle lifetime. I don’t know about you but a EV that can go 150 miles and charge to 80% again in 2min would be super compelling to me. Solid commuter car but not too annoying on the rare roadtrip. But, I am guessing grid frequency regulation use cases are going to make these too expensive for a car for a long time.
- _yb2s 3y agoI missed the 10x charge speed- that is a killer feature that more than makes up for the reduced range.
- xaellison 3y agoI wonder what that will mean for charging infrastructure that suddenly has to deliver 10x power to enable that. Not sure that sort of charging could be as ubiquitously placed as gas stations
- gpm 3y agoJust have the same batteries in the charging station to smooth out power usage? Seems a lot cheaper and operationally less complex than a gas station.
- chabons 3y agoThis assumes that the same number of vehicles use the charging station. Lower charge times means potentially higher steady-state throughput.
- aidenn0 3y agoIf I'm reading this page[1] correctly they are playing fast-and-loose with the power-density numbers. Compared to Li-Ion shows 4x the power-per-Wh, but is about 1/4 the energy density, so the power density (in Watts/g) is about the same as Li-Ion? [edit] That page links a data-sheet that claims ~500W/kg which is much better than LFP, I couldn't find any reliable numbers for NMC, but I suspect its more than half of that?
- mlhpdx 3y agoIt seems like these could have some great advantages for use in sailboats, both house and propulsion (weight matters a lot less in a bit). The fire safety, rapid recharge (from engine), and higher power than lead-acid are pretty great. What am I missing?
- jvdvegt 3y agoSo, with about 10.000 kg of these in my basement (2MWh capacity), I should be mostly self-sufficient? Nice! (4MWh electricity usage per year, with solar panels producing slightly more)
- margalabargala 3y agoWhy would you need storage for half of your annual electricity usage to be self-sufficient? It seems like you could achieve that with far, far less battery, perhaps combined with slightly more solar.
- jvdvegt 3y agoOur panels produced a mere 60kWh in december. We've got 6 months where we use more than we produce. Storing 50% was a quick estimate as for what we'd need. Anybody got better numbers for that?
- jvdvegt 3y agoThese numbers are easy to compute myself. For the 6 months my panels did not produce enough electricity, we used a total of 2.1MWh from the grid. So my 50% guestimate was actually spot on :)
- margalabargala 3y agoWell there you go :) If you have the land for it, you might find it mildly more cost effective to ground-mount solar panels at a steeper angle to optimize for wintertime production, which would allow you to shrink the battery. Installing 10000 kg of batteries in a home isn't something likely to ever be super easy.
- genewitch 3y agoi use between 1 and 2 MWh a month... Do you live underground and not have anything electronic? 1000KWh is 1MWh. I guess if one has all natural gas appliances and no need for air conditioning it's possible to get down to 333KWh a month. i have owned and ran computers that used more than that a month, for goodness' sake.
- cryptonector 3y agoSodium is quite plentiful, and it doesn't need mining. Sodium batteries, if competitive, would be quite a revolution.
- NegativeK 3y agoI was under the impression that sodium is produced from salt, which is mined.
- cryptonector 3y agoIt's also just extracted from the sea. And where salt is mined, the environmental impact is minimal.
- sohamgovande 3y agoReally excited to see that the battery is entering production. Feels like every year we hear about new batteries in the lab that are "2x-5x as efficient as Lithium ion" but they never seem to actually hit production. [1] https://www.yahoo.com/tech/engineers-created-revolutionary-battery-could-130000011.html https://www.yahoo.com/tech/engineers-created-revolutionary-b... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltaylor/2021/05/13/ev-range-breakthrough-as-new-aluminum-ion-battery-charges-60-times-faster-than-lithium-ion/?sh=709fea676d28 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltaylor/2021/05/13/ev-ran... [3] https://news.mit.edu/2022/aluminum-sulfur-battery-0824 https://news.mit.edu/2022/aluminum-sulfur-battery-0824
- cogman10 3y agoNa batteries are going to be a huge deal. Assuming everything pans out with manufacturing, this will be a game changer for grid storage. Natural gas likely won't be cheaper than doing a battery plant which will be a big deal for peaker plants.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blkhawk 3y agouh... you could buy them for at least a year now from Chinese productions - prices started high and were at maybe 3x of similar sized lifepo4 cells about 2 months ago when I grabbed 2 for experiments.
- can16358p 3y ago> can be procured through a reliable US-based domestic supply chain free from geopolitical disruption. The same cannot be said for common lithium-ion materials like cobalt and nickel. This is good... only for the US. The world doesn't need another industry where US solely is a monopoly.
- philipkglass 3y agoMost countries in the world don't have their own cobalt or nickel mines, so it's good for all those countries too.
- Foomf 3y agoI think the article was saying that these batteries are buildable with easy-to-find materials for anyone, USA included. I don't think there's anything in them that can only be found in the United States.
- margalabargala 3y agoThe article is written from a US point of view. Most other countries also have access to the relevant materials, since most countries are not landlocked. Sodium battery production may pair nicely with desalination plants.
- agrocrag 3y agoAre we still a ways out on being able to buy these for consumer use? Looks like most of the sales partners are industrial/commercial use. Couldn't dig up anything on their site about home use.
- topspin 3y agoAll of the initial production from this plant is spoken for. Part of the deal that secured the funding, exemptions, fast-tracking, tax breaks, etc. is a big public utility battery facility in the state (MI).
- EasyMark 3y agodo these batteries burn in a mostly uncontrollable way like lithium ion?
- philipkglass 3y agoNo, they are not flammable. Here's a datasheet for one of their products (from the Wayback Machine, because this link is now dead on their website -- maybe resource moved and not indexed yet): https://web.archive.org/web/20230402215314/https://natron.energy/wp-content/uploads/natron_collateral_BluePack_Industrial_Power_Battery_021723.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20230402215314/https://natron.en... Highlighted points include: Nonflammable Chemistry & Construction UL9540A ‘Champion’ rated nonflammable with no thermal runaway under any condition Safe and Fault Tolerant: No Fire or Explosion During - Heating - Overcharge - Short Circuit - Nail Penetration
- contemporary343 3y agoThis is a great entrepreneurial story too. Colin began this company out of his PhD research at Stanford a decade ago. A long, steady grind and finally out to production. Kudos to him and his team - a very rare accomplishment, and inspiring to see.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoGreat video about sodium batteries (including solid state) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yRAJSH_raW8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yRAJSH_raW8
- shadowgovt 3y agoExciting stuff! How does it compare to lithium if a battery is punctured or exposed? More or less toxic / flammable?
- squigglydonut 3y agoInspired by Breaking Bad no doubt.
- gregwebs 3y agoChina is already scaling their sodium battery production from MWH plants to GWH plants. The US has the largest sodium reserves in the world. In depth interview about sodium batteries with a professor that has researched sodium chemistries for a decade: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRAJSH_raW8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRAJSH_raW8
- WalterBright 3y agoI remember a 60 Minutes segment some time back on batteries made out of saltwater and dirt. They would be ideal for grid scale batteries, because although the energy density of those batteries is low, that's irrelevant because very large batteries could be cheap and easy to make. The batteries don't have to be portable. This is what baffles me about Li batteries for grid use. Using high energy / weight is very costly and completely irrelevant for grid batteries.
- cogman10 3y ago> This is what baffles me about Li batteries for grid use It's not super baffling when you realize the other properties of Li make it way better than pretty much anything currently on the market (the important part). Li has amazing cycle life with a wide operating range. Li like LFP and LTO have insane cycle life. Pair that with the superior capacity and the fact that Li doesn't have problems like the memory effect and it quickly starts to become apparent why it dominates grid storage. There's simply not been a better available rechargeable battery tech on the market. Sodium will change that.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe cycle life is not an issue with a battery made of seawater and dirt, because dirt is - cheap as dirt! Capacity comes from making an arbitrarily large such battery - it's not like it has to fit into a car.
- IshKebab 3y ago> 600 megawatts annually No.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gwenckatz 3y agoI'm so excited about this. Cratering the price of batteries for solar arrays will be a huge benefit for solar homeowners.
- WoodenChair 3y agoWhat's the best way to invest in sodium batteries? Is there a publicly traded company that is helping Natron Energy bring this to market?
- XorNot 3y agoSo I re-ran my battery spreadsheet on this, and the short version is: if the claimed reduction in cost of 1/3rd current LiFePO4 can be achieved - at retail (so I just knocked my LiFePO4 figure down to 33%) can be achieved...oh my does that change the economics. In a "the repayment period of installing peak-shifting capacity at my house would be under 2 years, and the lifetime yield would be 50% on the installation cost". So if they can hit that sort of cost reduction...that's revolutionary for grid batteries.
- barfingclouds 3y agoI could see sodium ion being a good use case for cars even. I just did a little perplexity search and it seems that lithium ion is maybe 50% more energy dense than sodium ion. So instead of a 300 mile car, I could get a 200 mile car that can charge 10 times faster, and has a longer lifespan battery. That’s a trade off that doesn’t sound bad to me