14 ms·
Debt-related driver’s license suspensions in Ohio
- foxyv 3y agoThis is yet another argument against car centric city design. Cars represent shackles that allow city and state debt collectors to get their claws into the most vulnerable Americans. If we had a working public transit system and pedestrian/cyclist friendly cities then this would be a non-issue. However, by forcing people into cars, we suddenly have significant problems. Especially considering the housing crisis that makes cars the primary residence of a couple hundred thousand people who can't afford a parking ticket. Much less a $1500 reinstatement fee. It's absurdly expensive to be poor. Cars are yet another reason for that.
- mjhay 3y agoI am in 110% agreement with everything you are saying here. There's a quite bizarre thing here, though: In typical American car-centric areas, suspending someone's license because of debt takes away their ability to pay back debt. This seems just as counterproductive to creditors as debtors prisons were (and sometimes are).
- tanseydavid 3y agoI agree. It is a Debtor's Prison in everything but name.
- WheatMillington 3y agoIf you take away the licence of someone who is ALREADY not paying their debt, what has changed in that respect?
- sterlind 3y agothe potential for future repayment?
- superb_dev 3y agoYou’re assuming they aren’t trying to pay their debts in the first place, which isn’t true for most people.
- vuln 3y agoYou’re assuming they’re only like a month behind, right?
- superb_dev 3y agoNo
- willcipriano 3y agoIf you've seen what they have done with cars you probably aren't optimistic about what's going to happen when they take those away.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoI don't think anyone is arguing that the cars should be taken away - well, OK, someone probably is, but there's someone arguing everything on the internet - it's more about having options where losing your car doesn't stop someone from getting to work so that they can pay off the debt that is keeping them from using their car.
- willcipriano 3y agoThe government is draconian with cars. They use car ownership as a tool to turn the screws on poor people. Now step into the shoes of that poor person, who has had the screws turned on them. Whould you give up your car and trust the government? That's why they don't trust public transit, they don't trust the government and rightly so.
- foxyv 3y agoPoor people don't use public transit because it has been dismantled to the point it's unusable. In fact, it has been demolished explicitly because poor people use it.
- vuln 3y agoPeople don’t use public transportation because there is people with mental issues on them causing fights, teenagers causing fight, addicts causing a ruckus. Public transportation isn’t safe for a majority of the population
- foxyv 3y agoI have yet to have a single issue with public transportation. In addition, all the people fighting on public transit aren't crashing into each other in multi-ton vehicles. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JgukjFWlcc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JgukjFWlcc https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/URLs_Cited/OT2021/20-843/20-843-15.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/URLs_Cited/OT2021/20-8...
- NovemberWhiskey 3y ago>This is yet another argument against car centric city design. If there were debt-based suspensions of the right to ride public transport, would you categorize this as an argument against public transport centric city design? This is a plain ridiculous assertion. EDIT: the point here is that bad policy that involves something you happen to dislike doesn't lend strength to the viewpoint that the thing is bad. I mean, I happen not to like pitbull-type dogs, but I acknowledge that a putative law which prevented debtors from getting dog licenses would not be an argument against owning pitbulls.
- foxyv 3y agoYou do not need a license to ride the bus or train. Just a couple bucks and a good book.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoYou're continuing to miss the point. The license is an irrelevancy. If you can have your license suspended for <stupid reason> you can also be banned from public transport for <the same stupid reason>. Banning people from using transportation that they probably need for work is dumb, bad policy, and bad economics. It tells you nothing about the merits of the kind of transport from which they're being banned.
- foxyv 3y agoCan you ban someone from walking to the store if it is less than a mile away? Or riding their bicycle to work if it is less than 4 miles away? If your government can do that, cars are not going to save you from the totalitarian dictatorship you are living under.
- sokoloff 3y agoBe sure to let us know when people are barred from using public transportation because of unpaid child support.
- 3y ago
- seoulmetro 3y agoNo. Cars aren't the problem here. This is targeting the clouds for raining on your clothes. The problem is you put your clothes out to dry when it was raining. Car, bike, walking, they are all means of transport that the government can restrict easily. Cars are just good to travel in low density areas.
- howenterprisey 3y agoWalking? Easily?
- seoulmetro 3y agoWhere were you during the years 2020-2021? Most places on Earth this restriction was in place for quite some time. And all they had to do was say so.
- macintux 3y agoI’m unaware of any walking restrictions in my part of the world. I’m very, very skeptical about the “most places” claim.
- seoulmetro 3y agoLookup the word "lockdown". It's fairly common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_lockdowns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_lockdowns
- Swizec 3y agoAt least here in SF, walking was explicitly allowed during the lockdowns. As long as you said it's for exercise or for a necessary activity like grocery shopping.
- seoulmetro 3y agoThat's not what was meant by the comment. Walking as a means of transport doesn't exist if you have no legal destination. It's not rocket science. Unsure how many of you are struggling here. Suspending your license doesn't stop you from sitting in, using or driving your car, just stops you from driving it onto the road.... you know, like walking and lockdowns.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWhy would a better public transit system make this a non-issue? People could be banned from it just as easily as people could have their driver's license banned.
- shiroiushi 3y agoHow exactly do you ban someone from public transit? And why would you? In every major city I've visited, there's no way to track who used the system: you either pay with cash (buying a ticket), or you put money on an anonymous stored-value card and use that in the fare gates. Anyone with cash can ride.
- int_19h 3y ago> And why would you? To punish them. For all the talk about rehabilitation and compensation, our "justice" system is fundamentally still about making some people happy by letting them watch other people get hurt.
- SoftTalker 3y agoPublic transit is public. I.e. the government controls it. They could implement a transit pass tied to identity and prevent anyone with debts owed or other poor "social credit" from obtaining one.
- foxyv 3y agoPolice have much more legal power to stop, identify, search and harass you if you are in a car. For instance, your 4th amendment right against unreasonable search and seizure is nullified by forced identification laws and implied consent. A simple pre-textual stop for "Possible intoxication" makes it easy to target undesirables for searches and forced identification. This is not nearly as easy on public transportation or for pedestrians. Terry stops have much less power when you don't have a hundred traffic laws and licensing requirements that you can get a car driver for. In addition, you can't revoke someone's walking license if they don't pay child support.
- 3y ago
- daveoc64 3y agoI don't entirely understand the concept - in Ohio (or is it the whole of the USA?), they can suspend your driving licence because you have unrelated debts?
- mordechai9000 3y agoAs usual, it varies by state. Some states only suspend licenses for moving violations, either because they are unpaid or sometimes as a direct penalty for serious infractions.
- pksebben 3y agoOhio has a reputation for being particularly rules-y, and it's not undeserved. Two points of anecdata, sourced from a cross country trip that took me through ohio: - we went to a beer garden at the end of a long day of driving (>12 hours). We sit down to order and know exactly what we want. The waiter comes to take our drinks, but patently refuses to take our food order because "that happens next". He had a tablet to put orders in. Would've saved everybody time. It was ~30m before the next waiter showed up. - the next morning, we stopped at a diner to get breakfast to-go. They had eggs, bacon, and toast on the menu but no egg sandwich. We asked if we could get a bacon egg and cheese to go, off menu, offering to pay an extra couple bucks for the trouble. A 15 minute back and forth with the kitchen ensued culminating in a frustrated and confused register person grumpily handing us two styrofoam containers with the various ingredients (not assembled, because I guess this counted as "on the menu"). We end up building our own sandwiches right there, on the counter, and throwing out the bits and pieces that didn't make sense in a sandwich because they also refused to "hold" anything like the apparently obligatory fruit cup. This completely awkward state of affairs paradoxically seemed to bother nobody. There was more weirdness throughout the state, all along the lines of "technically correct but actually awful" from the airbnb to the highway toll booths (they wouldn't take anything other than exact change and we had to cajole them to keep the difference because who the hell keeps nickels in this day and age?).
- nickthegreek 3y ago
- ianbicking 3y agoFrom my read, many of these suspensions COULD result from bad driving, because they result from a ticket that may be a moving violation that is unpaid. That is, my interpretation is that if you get a moving violation, don't pay the ticket, have your driver's license suspended, you got a suspension due to "bad driving". Their interpretation is that only if you have your license suspended for a specific incident that it would be due to "bad driving". But, I have no idea how many of these are parking tickets, driving without insurance, repair issues or whatever. But fines do have a public safety purpose, it doesn't seem right to lump them all in as "debt".
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoSuspending a driver's license because of debt is an absolutely bone-headed idea. Who the hell thinks it makes sense at all to punish a debtor by making it hard to get to work and earn money to pay off the debt? Who the hell signed this into law? It just seems like a complete "fuck you" to the poor, designed to kick them while they're down and punish them for being poor. I don't even care if the cause of the debt was outright tax fraud. Make the punishment fit the crime. If someone owes a debt to the government, garnish wages. If the debt is due to fraud, throw them in prison. But to make a sweeping law that takes away driver's licenses and most of the people affected are poor has no logical basis. It does nothing to solve the problem of unpaid debts, it merely makes them worse. EDIT: Re-reading, I notice the article doesn't state the source of the debt. If it's unpaid traffic tickets, then I do think it makes sense to suspend the license, but an afternoon of traffic school should suffice for most moving violations. If it's unpaid taxes, hell no.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> Who the hell thinks it makes sense at all to punish a debtor by making it hard to get to work and earn money to pay off the debt? > Who the hell signed this into law? It just seems like a complete "fuck you" to the poor, designed to kick them while they're down and punish them for being poor. People who govern by inflicting suffering instead of leveraging data to encourage rational and data driven outcomes. We see this as a bug, others see this as a feature.
- feoren 3y ago> It just seems like a complete "fuck you" to the poor, designed to kick them while they're down and punish them for being poor. Yes, that is exactly the point. A huge number of laws exist only to punish people for being poor.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoIf you'll allow a quick gripe, at the social scale, we hold an inconsistent view of work, morals, and economics. 1. Does the economic system allow for full employment. 2. If not, then it stands to reason that among the unemployed, a portion is temporarily unemployed and a portion is chronically unemployed. 3. Is it moral to blame the chronically unemployed for their unemployment if fill employment is unattainable? 4. If full employment is unattainable, and it's immoral to blame the chronically unemployed, then what purpose do unemployment punishments serve? Why make a system where someone is guaranteed to lose, and then punish the loser?
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago[flagged]
- nickthegreek 3y agoOhio enshrined the right to abortion in its state constitution after this nonsense. So no, Ohio does not think that.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI stand corrected. Nov 2023. This was so recent I had not realized. 2-3 years ago I though Ohio was one of the crazy right wing states. I guess things have shifted. (and not just reading about it, I was traveling there at the time of the miscarriages issue, and there were ton of Trump flags in yards, so guess I can assume some) https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-constitution/section-1.22 https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-constitution/section-1.22 https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2023/11/08/abortion-is-now-a-constitutional-right-in-ohio-but-the-work-isnt-done/ https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2023/11/08/abortion-is-now-a-...
- vuln 3y agoThat’s called contempt before investigation. Lots of assumptions, imagine what else your could be wildly wrong about due to your lack of knowledge, understanding and research.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoCalm down, this was passed a few months ago. You do realize people don't keep up with the ballot initiatives in every state on every election. And that there is an overwhelm stream of information to digest? I was in Ohio just a year ago and it did seem radical, and that was first person observation. So not a huge 'contempt before investigation'. But, to be fair, I was in the countryside, and I did not run my own state wide Gallup Poll.
- exabrial 3y agoI'm trying to wrap my head around this... Ohio law allows the suspension of drivers license over and unpaid _private_ debt? Or are these unpaid traffic fine debts?
- rgbrenner 3y agothe private debts are failure to pay court ordered child support; and failure to pay for damage or injuries caused by a motor vehicle crash that you were found responsible for by a court.
- BizarroLand 3y agoToo poor or bad with money management to pay your child support? We take away your ability to legally drive to work in a state that is heavily dependent on private transportation for financial success. Hope you can get that sorted out in the next 15 years or so!
- sokoloff 3y agoIs the alternative "child support is now paid entirely on-time as a result of working"? (It seems not, as there is a judgment in place to show otherwise.) The more likely alternative seems to be "Too poor or bad with money management to pay your child support? Just don't pay it and there are no consequences that puts money towards the support of your child."
- rgbrenner 3y agoOne of the ways you can get your license restored is to just show you are employed -- yes, so the court can issue a wage garnishment order because the person apparently won't pay on their own. And if you aren't employed, you can attend a seek work program. https://support.franklincountyohio.gov/Support-Order-Enforcement/License-Suspension https://support.franklincountyohio.gov/Support-Order-Enforce...
- lancepioch 3y agoChild support is a percentage of your pay, so it has nothing to do with poverty. So that just leaves people who are bad with money management. Yes, threaten to take away their driving privilege instead of jail time. Put them in a position that forces them to meet their legal obligations. Child support is not some tax or fee or fine. It pays for food and shelter for children. The poorer spouse is usually the one that gets it. So if you don't enforce it, then you are directly punishing the poorer spouse (with the children) because the other one is "too bad with money management".
- rgbrenner 3y agoThis link from the footnotes has more details[0] and in the PDF we learn the following are the "debt-related suspensions": “License forfeiture suspensions” occur when a person is charged with certain driving-related misdemeanors and either fails to appear in court or fails to pay a court fine. “Judgment suspensions” occur if a court issues a judgment finding a person responsible for property damage or personal injury caused by use, care, or maintenance of a motor vehicle, and that person fails to pay the amount owed. “Child support suspensions” occur when a driver fails to pay child support or fails to appear in response to a subpoena or warrant for child support issues. “Noncompliance suspensions” occur when a driver does not show proof of insurance at a traffic stop or at the time of an accident. “Random selection noncompliance suspensions” occurred when a vehicle owner did not provide proof of insurance in response to a request from the BMV mailed to randomly selected drivers. “Security suspensions” occur when an uninsured driver causes an accident that results in more than $400 worth of damage or injury and the other party submits a crash report to the BMV. “Court registration blocks” can be imposed by a court for unpaid fines or fees and prevent a vehicle owner from renewing their vehicle registration. “Warrant blocks” prevent a person from obtaining or renewing a driver’s license or vehicle registration and can be imposed by a court for any person who has an outstanding warrant. This changed the impression I had after reading the link. 0. https://lasclev.org/wp-content/uploads/Road-to-Nowhere_hirez.pdf https://lasclev.org/wp-content/uploads/Road-to-Nowhere_hirez...
- joe_the_user 3y agoYeah, the thing about this list is each item is able to sound reasonable to a substantial portion of (maybe vindictively-thinking) voters but whole net of constraints results in a trap for the poor as well-described in the article. Perhaps this is an incentive for people to think twice about the sanity of having random punishments of one form meted out for a violation of a different form.
- janice1999 3y agoI don't think that is the 'gotcha' you think it is. It's still a debt trap for poor people that destroys lives. Robbing people of their ability to drive and earn a living for failing to make child support payments is so self-defeating and malicious it's crazy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sneak 3y agoAmerica doesn't have debtors prisons by design, but we seem determined to try to reinvent them at every opportunity.
- pierat 3y agoWe very much DO have debtor prisons. They're just through a judge who signs off. We also very much DO have slavery. They too are through a judge or jury signing off.
- falcolas 3y ago> We very much DO have debtor prisons. They're just through a judge who signs off. Yup. I'm always reminded of the gentleman (Joseph Prudente of Florida) who was put in jail without bail for failing to upkeep their lawn to their HOA's standards. The legal reason was contempt of court for not following the judge's order to upkeep their lawn. As an aside, contempt of court doesn't have a sentence length, nor does it require you to be found guilty of any crime.
- FireBeyond 3y agoNot really the same thing, but I'm reminded too of the HOA in Texas that foreclosed on a woman in her late 80s from her home for $180 in unpaid HOA dues (apparently her husband had managed finances and died recently). Egregious enough. Then the real details hit, and made a bad thing worse: - A member of the HOA Board had moved to foreclose on this home despite the small arrears (even relative to other members of the community) - Someone made a very short offer on the house (IIRC, in the order of $125K for a $4-500K home) - HOA Board voted to accept the short sale offer (You might have seen this coming) Spoiler alert: The HOA board member who lead the vote to foreclose, the person who made the short offer, and the board member who voted to accept that offer? All the same person, who had a healthy little business as a landlord.
- nijave 3y agoHow does this guy ever get out? Hire someone else to mow his lawn from prison?
- liquidise 3y agoI'll share a lengthy anecdote (from CO, not OH), of how absurd these suspensions can get in strange edge-cases. Also, i think this shows how most processes have "bugs", but people don't think of them that way when it isn't in software. One day, while helping someone get their car out of an impound, i was informed by the officer on duty that my license was not showing as valid. They couldn't tell why though, said the status/notes listed made no sense to her, and i should contact the Denver office to find out what is going on. I was rather confused, as it had been many years since i had last been pulled over, for a minor speeding ticket. Denver was similarly confused by the details. After some research, they tell me what appears to have happened was i paid my ticket years ago by check, in person. They recorded they received the check on time, but either due to a clerical error or something (they aren't sure), a late fee was assessed on my ticket prior to the payment being processed. The fee was, i think, $5. Around this same time, i moved, and while i changed my address with the USPS, i didn't with the DMV. The DMV was thus sending my "you owe us $5" letters with "Do Not Forward" instructions via the USPS, who were knowingly delivering the mail to the wrong address (my old place). When i discovered all of this, years later, my license had been suspended for 54 weeks due to delinquency. In CO, if your license has been suspended for over 1 year, you may not just satisfy the debt, you must also retake your driving test. But since i didn't take my original test in CO, i would also need to re-apply for a permit and pass a written permit exam before being allowed to schedule my drivers test. The poor lady i spoke with in the Denver office recognized the sheer absurdity of everything she was telling me, but could do nothing to fix it. She also let me know the outstanding debt was now $15.
- mattpallissard 3y agoI had a similar thing except on a much longer timeframe. When I turned 21 I went to renew my license and register a truck I bought. I paid by check. When the lady told me it'd be one sixty three (or something like that) I wrote a check for $1.63. She took it, gave me my paperwork and sent me on my way. Fast forward 10 years the state must have digitized everything and I received a collection notice in the mail. I hadn't even lived in that state or owned that vehicle for several years. At least my license wasn't invalid.
- macintux 3y ago
- xyst 3y agoIn a car centric country like the United States. Having a suspended license because of debt is just wrong. It has wide implications against the poor. Poorer people will probably ignore it. Won’t pay it. Drive with suspended license. Have to pay higher premiums or just dropped completely from their carrier. If that person gets in an accident, they will be fucked in the form of medical debt. One can abuse the ER EMTALA for only a short time. Forgo medical treatment and physical therapy. Temporary injuries then translate into permanent disabilities. Can’t drive. Can’t get insurance. Can’t get a regular job. Can’t afford health insurance. Can’t afford food. It’s a vicious cycle and it’s amazing how most people are able to get out of this situation without doing anything illegal.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThe article isn't clear on it but a debt related suspension only applies to legal debts to the court like fines or unpaid child support. Medical debt isn't considered in this equation. Still assinine however and is a debtor prison in all but name.
- indymike 3y agoFalse. As soon as a medical debtor has a judgment against them, they can be subject to DRS.
- alberth 3y agoChild Support Important missing context, failure to pay child support is the most common “debt-related drivers license suspension”. This is about creating incentives that help ensure children get the financial support they are entitled via court rulings on their case. https://www.bmv.ohio.gov/susp-other-points.aspx https://www.bmv.ohio.gov/susp-other-points.aspx
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snypher 3y agoWith needing a vehicle being an important gateway to income for most, this might be a step too far.
- m463 3y agoIt is sort of amazing how debt can lead to all sorts of consequences. The book "Debt: the first 5,000 years" by David Graeber is a pretty eye opening book. It used to be possible for a man's wife and children to be sold into slavery because of his debts. The spanish conquistadors had a whole debt pyramid starting with the expedition funding and leading to the oppression of millions of conquered people trying to repay it. You would think we were more enlightened nowadays.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> You would think we were more enlightened nowadays. Why? We're the same species.
- dudul 3y agoThere is this strange pervasive myth that everyone who lived before current_year-20years was an idiotic barbarian and current society is peak human evolution.
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoThe End of History.
- nobody9999 3y ago>There is this strange pervasive myth that everyone who lived before current_year-20years was an idiotic barbarian and current society is peak human evolution. Even just some cursory thought should put the lie to that. As Steven J. Gould ruminated[0] upon quite some time ago: ... But if we laugh with derision, we will never understand. Human intellectual capacity has not altered for thousands of years so far as we can tell. If intelligent people invested intense energy in issues that now seem foolish to us, then the failure lies in our understanding of their world, not in their distorted perceptions. Even the standard example of ancient nonsense -- the debate about angels on pinheads -- makes sense once you realize that theologians were not discussing whether five or eighteen would fit, but whether a pin could house a finite or an infinite number. -- S. J. Gould, "Wide Hats and Narrow Minds" [0] https://motd.ambians.com/quotes.php/name/freebsd_fortunes/toc_id/1-0-2/s/125 https://motd.ambians.com/quotes.php/name/freebsd_fortunes/to...
- rootusrootus 3y agoMaybe they should just use treasury offsets instead. That way people can still drive and earn money, and the debt is more likely to be paid.
- matt3210 3y agoDebt to a private corp causing this is so wrong, but I think these are debts related to courts
- _8j50 3y agoWow, another post I can relate to. This was me many moons ago, except I was actually arrested. I give it a 2/10 rating, rude staff. I did learn to sleep comfortably on cement with toilet paper as pillow. I can also resist horrible toilet stench while sleeping. The recent family murderer in my cell was joyful and friendly and I made heroin addict friends. There was commotion in a nearby cell, others told me it was rape, good thing I avoided that. Also, an interesting fact, apparently it's not just abu-ghraib type torture prisons that keep prisoners in very cold concrete only rooms and move you around to different holding cells and cellmates every few hours (i assume it is to sleep deprive and freeze you so much you cause less troubles?). I suppose prison is supposed to be unpleasant but they could have waited until I was tried and convicted. Seems a bit much as well for expired government documents where the reason is debt instead of safety, at least for America. I now hate car ownership (likelihood of police interaction being one of many reasons).
- xyzelement 3y agoYikes. between the article and the underlying legal aid society paper: 1.7 million Ohioans have a suspension in a given year. Meanwhile the state has 8M licensed drivers, so 20% of the people in the state are suspended at a given time? Wild. Unfortunately, the legal aid society betrays the "bullshit" angle that the Fed article obscures. On page 5 they talk about the types of "debt related suspensions" in their dataset - the biggest single category with over 50% of the "affected" drivers is "non compliance suspension" - which is drivers which fail to produce proof of insurance during a traffic stop or accident. The second biggest category is "forfeitures" which is people who were charged with a traffic violation and didn't bother to show up to court or to pay the fine. The article makes it sound like most "license suspensions do not stem from bad driving; instead, they arise because the driver owes an unpaid debt" - and then opaquely bucket "not having insurance DURING A TRAFFIC STOP OR ACCIDENT" as "unpaid debt" rather than "bad driving." The Fed article doesn't make any reference to the insurance thing at all, but that's literally the largest bucket. It feels a bit of a stretch to me to then portray the data as discriminatory towards the urban poor - the article works very hard to make these suspensions seem punitive towards those communities where it seems that the real causality is "urban poor have a low rate of having insurance" -> "not having insurance causes a license suspension" both of which are kinda predictable and reasonable, and would make for a dull article. The 3rd largest group of "suspensions" is unpaid child support - behind "didn't show up to court for traffic violation" and "no insurance." This is indeed a "debt related" suspension but conveniently the Fed article doesn't feature the term "child support." We can still debate whether unpaid CP is grounds for license suspension, but for an article that relies to much on emotional flavor (eg describing affected communities etc) it seems remiss to ignore that the subset of those communities most impacted (besides those who fail to show up to traffic court and those who don't have insurance) are child support deadbeats. It's funny that the authors of this debt and payment related article on the Federal reserve website are called Kyle FEE and Brian MikelBANK.
- mlyle 3y ago> 1.7 million Ohioans have a suspension in a given year. Meanwhile the state has 8M licensed drivers, so 20% of the people in the state are suspended at a given time? Wild. In a given year, not at a given time. It's the kind of metric that's likely to overcount people with multiple suspensions in a year, too.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoThe very best way I know to get someone to pay a debt they owe is to remove their ability to drive to/from work, and add impounding fines to the vehicle, after it's towed, since the driver can no longer legally drive it home again. Well done, Ohio! That'll learn'em.
- kazinator 3y agoThe problem with constitutional, parliamentary democracy is that the bulk of the government is an bureaucratic, administrative structure which is not elected, and doesn't change. Thus, the entire government, as such, actually isn't democractic at all. Most of it just cares about its job security more than anything else, and also about ensuring the most funding for its own division. If you understand this one thing, a lot of politics falls into place.
- supertrope 3y agoPartisan bureaucracies are even worse. Imagine the new governor firing most government employees and replacing them with party loyalists. It was called the “spoils system.”