15 ms·
Boom announces successful flight of XB-1 demonstrator aircraft
- lupusreal 3y agoSite won't load, but I assume this was just a subsonic flight, gear down, etc? A major technical milestone for sure, but I think the real trick with their proposal is the economic viability of such a plane.
- stetrain 3y agoYes: > XB-1 met all of its test objectives, including safely and successfully achieving an altitude of 7,120 feet and speeds up to 238 knots (273 mph)
- kelnos 3y agoI noticed that bit in the video -- gear down -- why is that? Just to avoid one possible point of failure, the gear failing to deploy properly for landing?
- fgblanch 3y agoI had the same question. I guess too is a common protocol. Any insights on why these flights are gears down?
- pie420 3y agoNot an expert, but I've seen the following commented on other test flight videos: on initial test flights, landing gear is always kept down to minimize risk. If a sudden landing is needed, gear is already down, no risk of equipment getting stuck, less mental load for the pilot to perform emergency landing, etc. Basically, when testing, you want to minimize the variables being tested. When airworthyness is validated, then you can test landing gear systems.
- reso 3y agoYes. The bet is still that the airlines can find viable routes to fly with a vehicle that creates sonic booms.
- mikepurvis 3y agoJapan Airlines is a logical customer then— they'd be flying all over the Pacific where none of that matters.
- jmb99 3y agoTheir website[0] does list Japan Airlines as a partner. [0] https://boomsupersonic.com/press-release/our-partnership-with-japan-airlines https://boomsupersonic.com/press-release/our-partnership-wit...
- mikepurvis 3y agoYes, that's why I mentioned it. :)
- ben7799 3y agoTurn off your ad blocker. For some reason it didn't load till I turned it off. There are no ads on the page, but there must be something nefarious.
- rvz 3y agoGreat company building actual difficult technologies. What engine are they using this time in their supersonic aircrafts? Last time I checked, Rolls-Royce abandoned Boom as their engine supplier. [0] https://simpleflying.com/rolls-royce-quits-boom-supersonic-engine/ https://simpleflying.com/rolls-royce-quits-boom-supersonic-e...
- zitterbewegung 3y agoOn their main page they referencing the following: XB-1’s carbon composite and titanium fuselage is propelled by three General Electric J85 engines. [1] [1] https://boomsupersonic.com/xb-1 https://boomsupersonic.com/xb-1
- TylerE 3y agoIn the prototype, which far from full scale.
- LarsDu88 3y agoHmmm. Augmented reality display, Carbon fiber frame, supersonic intakes... And 3 J85-15 jet engines designed in the 1950s (?) I remember reading about these J85 engines in an issue of Popular Mechanics roughly 20 years ago. This engine was designed to be cheap and small enough to fit in a carry-on suitcase circa 1955. They are best known for powering the F5 "low-budget fighter" from 1959. Crazy that a new aircraft is launching with such new tech, but still rocking engines that were fundamentally designed around 10 years after the dawn of jet aircraft.
- TotempaaltJ 3y agoIf it ain't broke...
- madmask 3y agoIt warms my heart seeing old designs still working just fine.
- KolmogorovComp 3y agoThey are not testing the engines here (which they will not be manufacturing anyway), but the aerodynamics and the systems.
- zitterbewegung 3y agoWell since Rolls-Royce abandoned the project that might be why? This seems like more of a proof of concept of the airframe itself.
- phonon 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boom_Symphony https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boom_Symphony aren't ready yet.
- rbanffy 3y agoMeh... I'll take whatever supersonic passenger transport is offered, but Mach 1.7 is disappointing.
- sandworm101 3y agoWhile I acknowledge the cool factor, I don't like what Boom is doing. We should be looking at making air travel more efficient, reducing the energy/emissions per passenger-mile flown. We don't need to invent ways to make luxury travel by the rarified few ever more expensive and damaging.
- bowmessage 3y ago> Overture is designed to run on up to 100% sustainable aviation fuel (SAF).
- jameshart 3y ago“Designed to run on up to 100%” says nothing about what percentage it will in practice operate on in service. I am capable of running on a sustainable diet of 100% nutrient balanced meals and a strictly controlled daily calorie intake. In practice, I’m operating on a mixture of pizza and Oreos right now.
- rbanffy 3y agoSAF is a good investment - it allows us to use the current airplanes while we transition the shorter distances to electrics. It also allows for a gradual infrastructure transition, because you can run a jet engine with any mix of kerosene and SAF.
- Someone 3y agoAnd even if it runs on 100% sustainable air fuel 100% of the time, that fuel is better used powering more efficient planes. It’s not as if we’re having surplus production of sustainable air fuel, or will have it any time soon.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> not as if we’re having surplus production of sustainable air fuel You want to spur an industry by rationing its customers?
- KolmogorovComp 3y agoAny news on the powerplant-side? Which is one if not the most critical part of the plane for commercial success. Didn't GE dropped the ball a while ago? I still see them mentioned in their website https://boomsupersonic.com/symphony https://boomsupersonic.com/symphony
- stavros 3y agoCan you call it a supersonic aircraft if it hasn't broken the sound barrier yet? I assume they mean it's intended to be supersonic.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoProbably shouldn’t put the throttle to 100% on a brand new airplane.
- apendleton 3y agoIf you're building a submarine, you don't have to call it a "future submarine" until it submerges; people understand that if you say "I'm currently building a submarine," it has yet to go under water, but the thing you're building is still a submarine. I think that's generally true of not-yet-built or not-yet-used things: it's understood that if it hasn't done the thing yet, you're describing what it's going to be/do.
- stephenitis 3y agoI couldn't stop thinking that the name of the company is going to be unfortunate, brand killing, one day if they have a incident
- bambax 3y agoEven without incident, it's a poor choice of brand for a product most people associate with the deafening sound of the sound barrier being broken. It's what killed its predecessor.
- wrsh07 3y agoMy understanding is the the Concorde wasn't profitable to fly (too large!) You can fly subsonic over land and go supersonic over oceans. That would make a trip to Japan much faster! And won't impact humans living underneath the flight path (since it won't go supersonic until it's over the ocean) Flights these days often aren't even traveling close to the speed of sound, so there's room to design a plane more efficient at that speed as well.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> can fly subsonic over land and go supersonic over oceans A supersonic airframe is typically inefficient at subsonic speeds.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago1. If you're flying supersonically, you probably aren't worried about efficiency anyway. 2. If you're flying NYC-London or LAX-Tokyo, the portion you spend over land isn't a big contributor to the overall efficiency.
- wrsh07 3y agoI think boom is aware of this and is planning to make their planes efficient at 90% speed of sound
- 3y ago
- Ekaros 3y agoTo me this just looks like civilian fighter plane... Quite far still to go to any real capacity even as business yet competitor...
- rbanffy 3y agoIt's intended to validate their design models. The next one will be much bigger.
- FredPret 3y agoAs a consumer, the pain-point of flying isn't that the plane is slow (although it'd be nice to go faster) - it's the slap-dash construction of the planes. I know it's safe statistically, but I just can't stomach entrusting my life to a system that lets Boeing's many ridiculous failures through the cracks. The other major issue is having to be at the airport hours early, and the planes can't fix that.
- jmb99 3y agoWhile the planes can’t fix needing to show up at the airport early, business class fares (usually) help. Priority security and priority checkin mean that, while you can’t show up 5 minutes before your flight, you also don’t need to show up 3 hours early. And, if you do, you have a lounge to relax in with as much food and drink as you can swallow while you wait. I would imagine that every seat on these flights would be a business or first class fare (as I don’t see any other way they can make money), and would get you all of those benefits.
- neom 3y agoThe blog post didn't really explain what an XB-1 is or what it's for, but the wikipedia page helps: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boom_XB-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boom_XB-1
- justinator 3y agoFrom the marketing fluff, "Supersonic intakes: XB-1’s engine intakes slow supersonic air to subsonic speeds, efficiently converting kinetic energy into pressure energy, allowing conventional jet engines to power XB-1 from takeoff through supersonic flight." I'm under the impression that's something most jet engines do.
- TylerE 3y agoMost jets aren’t supersonic at all.
- rbanffy 3y agoI don't think the air intake speed of a subsonic plane is ever supersonic.
- justinator 3y agoMost air intakes of jet engines are designed to slow airflow/compress the air (which was my point - my apologies for being oblique)
- pictureofabear 3y agoYes, this is what every supersonic intake does. The leading edge of the intake for supersonic flows is meant to create an oblique shockwave that reflects off the other parts of the intake to progressively slow the flow to subsonic speeds before reaching the front of the engine. Fixed intakes, like the one on the XB-1, are optimized for a certain speed. The gap between the intake and the fuselage diverts the dirty boundary layer air so that the intake is more efficient.
- class3shock 3y agoIt sounds like marketing fluff, which I think alot of their site is, but this is a real thing. As soon as you start flying faster than sound you have to do extra work on the intake for your engine you wouldn't otherwise need to do (put simply).
- pie420 3y agoThis will never make it past prototype stages, unfortunately. Realistically, you need federal involvement to make something like this happen, a la concorde. I could see the US government getting involved for nationalism purposes if China starts actually building jets in large numbers to reassert US manufacturing supremacy. It was sexy marketing for the Concorde to travel between NYC and Paris/London back in the 70s-90s. Today however, with the emergence of the middle east as a major travel hub, would supersonic travel be viable there? Dubai-Singapore? Dubai-Doha? Dubai-Moscow? Europe to Middle east wouldn't work due to having to fly over europe, right? Also, is there enough luxury/high speed travel demand between asia and the north american west coast for something like this? It's nice to leave north america in the evening, sleep 8 hours, and arrive as the plane is landing in tokyo. Is there any demand to be get to Tokyo in 6-7ish hours? It seems like the people that can afford 20-30k tickets can also afford to fly private, and with the internet there's much less need to be in person for making deals. Sadly, until fuel costs become negligible and they can make supersonic airplanes hold 200+ people, i think most people would rather fly private or fly first class on an A380 than on a cramped Overture.
- wrsh07 3y agoWhy assume "cramped overture"? What if overture feels like first class but is ~faster? I suspect fast planes are going to have an enormous amount of demand - people value their time. What's the most important part of travel? The flight cost? The lodging? The days off of work?
- cocostation 3y agoThe Boom website has images of the proposed Overture cabin. Looks like international first class.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoIf people value their time how come there was no serious appetite for upgrading and eventually replacing Concorde decades ago? After all they could have just built improved versions of them and had fleets of them flying across the Atlantic, perhaps even a larger extended range version for trans-Pacific routes. And if time is really the driver how come Boom Overture is going to be slower than Concorde?
- Animats 3y agoThey beat Lockheed's X-59 to first flight. That was rolled out on January 12th, but it hasn't flown yet. There are enough billionaires now to support making supersonic bizjets. They will mostly be a status cymbal.
- wolverine876 3y agoThe question always for the user is, do they want a crash or a ride? :)
- exogeny 3y agoThis is absolute comedy gold and I wanted you to know that I saw it and appreciated it.
- dangoodmanUT 3y agoWhy are the gears still down?
- mnw21cam 3y agoFor the first test flight of an aircraft, it's quite common to test a very limited set of parts of the aircraft, and retracting the gear might not be on that list. Also, if the gear is left down, then that's one less thing that could go wrong while the pilot is still getting used to an aircraft with a very different feel to anything they have flown before.
- jmb99 3y agoOn the first test flight you want to minimize risk as much as possible - there’s many, many things that can go wrong, so adding variables is a bad idea. Landing gear can’t get stuck up if it’s never retracted.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- class3shock 3y agoFrom wiki: "On June 3, 2021, United Airlines announced they had signed an agreement to purchase 15 Overture aircraft with an additional 35 options, expecting to start passenger flights by 2029.[14][15] On August 16, 2022, American Airlines announced an agreement to purchase 20 Overture aircraft with an additional 40 options.[16]" later on... "On December 13, 2022, Boom announced that it would develop its own turbofan engine after "Big Three" engine manufacturers Rolls-Royce, Pratt & Whitney and General Electric, as well as CFM and Safran previously declined to develop a new engine due to high capital costs.[29][30][31][32] Named Symphony, (see § Engines below) the engine will be developed under partnership with three entities: Kratos subsidiary Florida Turbine Technologies for engine design; StandardAero for maintenance; and General Electric subsidiary GE Additive for consulting on printing components.[33]" So not only do they think they are going to finish designing, prototyping, testing, certifying, and moving to production an entirely new aircraft, they also think they are going to design a brand new engine, that the big three didn't think made sense and also get it through all those efforts? All in the next 5 years? If it doesn't come to anything, which seems likely, atleast it sounds like a fun way to spend lots of money.
- OrwellianChild 3y agoOne dynamic that may be at play: Designing a new engine is a gamble. For a company who already makes money with existing designs, there may be little upside on a small-volume new product. This is likely the reason the "Big 3" passed on designing an engine they don't have an off-the-shelf option for. Boom would probably be the primary beneficiary of such an engine existing, so it isn't all that surprising that they will have to fund the development. The second supersonic airframe that can use their engine would be the one to turn that R&D profitable for Boom (and ease the introduction of more supersonic airframe options).
- twobitshifter 3y agoAlso, boom could have asked for exclusive terms that they didn’t like.
- class3shock 3y ago
- 1024core 3y agoI was disappointed by the video. I was expecting more.
- timthorn 3y agoThe undercarriage didn't retract in the video. Was that just an artefact of the stages of flight the film came from or was the undercarriage fixed for the maiden flight?
- OrwellianChild 3y agoPure speculation on my part, but on a first flight when you're shaking out the fundamentals, it's safer to not retract landing gear in case there is a catastrophic failure in, say, your hydraulic system.
- LarsDu88 3y agoYou never retract the landing gear on the shakedown flight. I remember seeing this watching a documentary on the X-35 and X-32 prototype fighter jets.
- pier25 3y agoThe 0.1% have all the time in the world. Why don't they just travel in a super luxurious cruise or something?
- adlpz 3y agoSupersonic flight isn't necessarily for the 0.1%, just the 1% (or whatever other made up number) whose price per hour times the travel time reductions is greater than the added cost of the fare.
- MostlyStable 3y agoTime is literally the one thing you can't buy more of, and therefore, when you are rich enough, is the only thing that has real value.
- pier25 3y agoRight which means you can use it to enjoy quality time. Not hurry up to do stuff as fast as possible and stressed because you're running out of time.
- neom 3y agoIn my experience, wealthy people are typically in one of two modes: 0 to 1 or 1 to 0. That's why they own both jets and yachts, rolls and lambos. Sometimes you're going fast, sometimes you're going slow, but there isn't really a need to do anything between.
- Zigurd 3y agoIt's not just the 0.1% who appreciate amenities over speed. A more-comfortable, reliable high speed rail so I do not have to go to airports would displace a lot of Boston-NYC-DC air travel.
- nemo44x 3y agoBecause sitting in the air is useless. When I take my family to the Maldives or w/e out-there place to holiday, I’d gladly spend $10k more to get there many hours faster.
- cbsmith 3y ago"XB-1 met all of its test objectives, including safely and successfully achieving an altitude of 7,120 feet and speeds up to 238 knots (273 mph)." Seems just a bit shy of the speed of sound (760 mph).
- adlpz 3y agoIt's a 1/3 scale prototype so I guess through some creative maths the speed of sound may as well be 1/3?
- cebu 3y agospeed of sound changes with altitude right?
- cbsmith 3y agoEffectively, yes.
- crznp 3y agoEffectively no! It doesn't depend on pressure. Basically just temperature (Also composition, esp: water content and form). That relies on assumptions (ideal gas, adiabatic compression) that might break down for supersonic jets, but it's pretty close for the speed of sound.
- lutorm 3y agoFirst flights are basically never more than a basic functionality check of take-off and landing configurations. (Note that there were no pictures of it with the gear retracted, because that's also typically something you don't try on a first flight.)
- cbsmith 3y agoYes, I get it. It's just they buried the lede of how far they have to go.
- lxe 3y ago"We need your consent to load the Youtube service! This content is not permitted to load due to trackers that are not disclosed to the visitor. The website owner needs to setup the site with their CMP to add this content to the list of technologies used. powered by Usercentrics Consent Management Platform" The internet has become an unusable joke
- zenlikethat 3y agoThe swarm of negative comments here is both disheartening and unwarranted. How many of you are building ad networks or chat-with-PDF while these folks are working on truly difficult problems? Flying supersonic is awesome, actually. Count me in for one at the first opportunity (25% of the cost of a Concorde ticket would really be something) Congratulations for a successful launch to Boom!
- Solvency 3y agoHN lives in a closet world of React/Angular/Docker/Kubernetes/etc and is so thoroughly jaded and burnt by bland, bloated business technology apps that they have zero affinity or understanding of what kind of exciting technology is happening in other sectors.
- jerpint 3y agoI work on chat-with-pdf and still find this awesome!
- justinclift 3y agoWhat the heck is chat-with-pdf? :)
- kpennell 3y agogpt enabled pdf summarizers
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAgree. In years past the negative comments were because it was 'vapor', just an empty overhyped startup. But It is not just vapor now, they have a flying prototype.
- deleted 3y ago
- oulipo 3y agoWe need LESS planes and LESS speed to combat climate change
- Extropy_ 3y agoThis technology, like all technology, increases humanity's collective capacity to create solutions to problems and implement them. Faster travel means more time to solve problems. LESS planes and LESS speed make the world a worse place.
- oulipo 3y agoAbsolutely not, it means more URGENCY to solve problems because all these behaviors INCREASE the issues
- Extropy_ 3y agoSure, new technology does create new issues, and can make others worse, that doesn't mean, however, that technology doesn't also increase our ability to continue improving and doesn't make the world a better place.
- blastbking 3y agoawesome!!!! love it
- BrokerHans 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- amai 3y agoConcorde 2.0. What could go wrong?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- photonbeam 3y ago“ XB-1 met all of its test objectives, including safely and successfully achieving an altitude of 7,120 feet and speeds up to 238 knots (273 mph).” So really a shakedown, didnt try for supersonic
- cm2187 3y agoI love the idea of supersonic travel, but I can't help thinking that when you see how many things can go wrong in an airliner, how much safety was the result of trial and error, and how Boeing's woes shows how fragile safe manufacturing can get, how safe will an airliner built by a startup be?
- polishdude20 3y agoNarrator: "Not very."
- nemo44x 3y agoBoeings problem is they have junkies assembling their aircraft down south because they cost less. The tech is well understood but the tolerances are tight and the pay isn’t high enough to ensure a competent middle management and labor force.
- acyou 3y agoNot sure if there is basic/core technology development being done or valuable technology being generated. Is supersonic flight essentially just throwing a lot of jet fuel at the problem of wanting to get someplace fast? Are we expecting to see novel insights and spinoff technologies from the development of this plane and industry? I think there's a key, core military angle to this company, where their best and most stable and lucrative customers are sure to be nation-states. I think there is some real value to be generated around super-sonic technology development for missile applications, drone applications, fighter jet applications. I think that this company gets a lot of peoples' backs up, because they don't appear to have any unique insight besides "Rich people and nation states will pay through the nose for wasteful and extremely obnoxious technologies that degrade humanity as a whole." It's a great business, might be nice and profitable, great for rich people and the most developed nation states, might not be so great for the humanity as a whole.
- benced 3y agoPretty disappointing this is the top (edit: 2nd) comment. It asks and asserts several things that are easy to look up. I'd recommend reading their FAQ page: https://boomsupersonic.com/faq https://boomsupersonic.com/faq It's certainly not a guarantee that this works out but that's true of any speculative enterprise. Personally, I think a speculative world where Asia <> West Coast US is as fast as West Coast US <> East Coast US is pretty exciting.
- deely3 3y agoFAQ is mostly marketing with answers to obvious question. Sorry, I have a feeling that you did not read comment to which you replied.
- benced 3y agoThe FAQ page addresses several - not all, that's why I said "look up" - of the OP's objections. OP/you might disagree (it is marketing, like you said) but they should state and explain those disagreements instead of acting like Boom hasn't thought of them. > Not sure if there is basic/core technology development being done or valuable technology being generated. Is supersonic flight essentially just throwing a lot of jet fuel at the problem of wanting to get someplace fast? Are we expecting to see novel insights and spinoff technologies from the development of this plane and industry? See FAQ page entries: "Will Overture use afterburners like Concorde?" and "Why did it take so long to bring supersonic flight back after the Concorde?" > I think there's a key, core military angle to this company, where their best and most stable and lucrative customers are sure to be nation-states. I think there is some real value to be generated around super-sonic technology development for missile applications, drone applications, fighter jet applications. Scholl indicated Boom Supersonic had no interest in a Boom product becoming a weapons platform at this time. From: https://simpleflying.com/xb-1-first-flight/ https://simpleflying.com/xb-1-first-flight/ More broadly, supersonic missiles and fighter jets already exist. > Rich people and nation states will pay through the nose See "How much will tickets cost?" from the FAQ. Business class pricing seems eminently reasonable for this service. > [W]asteful and extremely obnoxious technologies that degrade humanity as a whole See "How is Boom dealing with the sonic boom?" and "What steps is Boom taking to make supersonic travel environmentally sustainable?"
- largbae 3y agoI know the Boeing safety reputation is a bit tarnished of late, but how many people are stepping on an aircraft called "Boom"?
- PBnFlash 3y agoWhat is with the sudden surge of hypersonics? Surely this is military funding on some level?
- vpribish 3y agoit's just supersonic, hypersonics is not involved
- ggm 3y agoBeautifully made promotional film but also very very obviously multiple takes, drone shots, reaction shots, over the shoulder cockpit shots, out of sequence, and regrettably not nearly enough pure flight shots. It's a composite of weeks of takes. Also, the airliner may be glass screen cockpit on screens. This one had eyeballs to the sky.
- resolutebat 3y agoThe flight pretty much consisted of taking off, turning around and landing, it would be pretty boring if they just showed that. In particular, this didn't go even close to supersonic, this time.
- tjohns 3y ago> Also, the airliner may be glass screen cockpit on screens. This one had eyeballs to the sky. I'm not sure what you're getting at with this? The pilot had all glass avionics here. Other than the lack of an FMS (which is just never used in small aircraft), this had everything I'd expect to see in modern systems. But also, even in an aircraft with a glass cockpit, the pilot is supposed to be mostly eyes up. Unless you're inside inclement weather, aviation operates on the "see and avoid" principle. Especially so when you're flying low and in congested airspace like the Mojave MOAs.
- ggm 3y agoThe airliner as described won't have windows for the pilot, it will be rendered on a screen.
- sashank_1509 3y agoThat would be an insane feat of engineering and probably unnecessary. Hope they don’t do that
- signatoremo 3y agoNASA x59 also has that feature: https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/digital-design-multi-material-structures-enable-a-quieter-supersonic-nasa-x-plane https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/digital-design-mult...
- 1letterunixname 3y agoWoah, that's an achievement because most of the SSBJ companies have failed to raise money, much less fly anything. XB-1 reminds me of an F-104 or X-3. NASA's X-59 will be even longer still, but without direct visibility (yikes).
- foxyv 3y agoIt kind of reminds me of a stretched out F-5 with the metal back and painted front... Let's hope it's a little safer than the F-104 though! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-5
- lovecg 3y agoI’m guessing this is the flight? Just a short circuit, I suppose it’s expected on the first flight. https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao=add4b2&lat=34.920&lon=-118.013&zoom=9.8&showTrace=2024-03-22&trackLabels×tamp=1711117980 https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao=add4b2&lat=34.920&lon=-...