16 ms·
GM says it's dropping Apple CarPlay and Android Auto because they're unsafe
- sandmn 3y agoI wonder if CarPlay and Android Auto is not safe on GM cars because they are just bad at implementing it. I had my share of issues with Android Auto on my last car - initial setup was not easy and just for Android they were blocking touch screen unless car was in "parking" mode. All of that was entirely on car manufacturer and it was one of the reasons I got a different car without such issues.
- aviat 3y agoLarge touchscreens and non physical controls are very dangerous for motorcyclists
- xnx 3y agoGM should go the other direction and ditch their software entirely in favor of Android Automotive.
- internet2000 3y agoThey've done that. That's what this is about.
- xnx 3y agoAh, thanks. I assumed GM was just using Android Auto, I didn't realize they had models that used Android Automotive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_Automotive#Vehicles_with_Android_Automotive_(with_GAS) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_Automotive#Vehicles_wi...
- MBCook 3y agoThey’re using that as the base of their system. But they are still disabling Android Auto and CarPlay despite the fact it works perfectly. Other car makers have proven that. They appear to think that using Android Automotive will give them access to a good App Store (?) and thus things will be good enough for people. I await the fallout.
- warbeforepeace 3y agoWith the cheapest processor and touch screen possible.
- vondur 3y agoI won’t consider a car that doesn’t support CarPlay. This is going to backfire on Gam big time.
- ungamedplayer 3y agoI imagine quite a lot of people will be. There might be room for after market head unit replacement for these new models.
- dylan604 3y agoare you basing that on the entire history of after market replacement head units, or did you just make up something in favor of your preference?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ungamedplayer 3y agoThe entire history is more than I think any sane human is willing to commit to for something as mundane and out-of--my-hands department. If you are the modern czar of in car entertainment units, perhaps you can enlighten us on how you think this will affect the market.
- Bluecobra 3y agoProblem is that a lot of vehicles have displays that stick up like a wart on the dashboard now. Though it would be great if you could reuse the display and just replace the internal components.
- MBCook 3y agoIs that really possible anymore on modern vehicles that come with fancy screens?
- worthless-trash 3y ago
- alsodumb 3y agoWait, so they're saying CarPlay and Android Auto are buggy on their cars, most likely because of their errors in getting the mirroring part right, so instead of fixing the issues, they think switching to their in-house system that they will design from scratch, that'll probably have hundreds of bugs, that's most likely gonna suck, is a better option? They could've just said we're out of excuses we just want to make money on infotainment system lol.
- NewJazz 3y agoMaybe they can go find rastermon and revive Tizen lol.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoMy Samsung fridge is running Tizen! It's awful!
- makeitdouble 3y agoIt's still baffling to me why Samsung fridges aren't just an API server exposing info to Samsung apps to present it on any other (potentially Samsung) device. Leaving a space on the door to attach a Samsung tablet could even work, and the user gets to update the tablet whenever they want.
- rezonant 3y agoActually my Samsung Bespoke fridge is just that. The REST API docs are even in the printed manual! To be fair it doesn't actually do much. (We got the one without the in-door tablet so we could use the glass front as a whiteboard!)
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 3y agoThis way they can wrap the errors in try..catch blocks and suppress their output. Boom - error free code!
- ungamedplayer 3y agoCall it what it is.. they like the control of their in car entertainment systems and they don't want external companies taking that part of the pie. It's okay gm, we understand. Let's hope you are able to make a compelling competition to this, otherwise your sales will suffer. Traditional car software is very very poor for whatever reason. I don't think that car manufacturers have the mindset and capability to make even passable software, let alone competitive software.
- Kurd 3y agoCalling it car software is very generous. More like abandonware.
- mulmen 3y agoI want abandonware in my car. Don't include alpha-grade software in a mid-five-figure product. If you can't get it right don't ship it. The navigation/infotainment space is a thoroughly solved domain. We don't need biweekly OTA updates to add the latest trendy thing. I don't want controls moving around or menus changing based on a perverted engagement metric. BMW "pathced" several mechanical features of my car. This is called a "recall". Auto manufacturers try to avoid them.
- viraptor 3y agoI've got abandonware in my Ford. It's got a bug in the Bluetooth stack which makes it unusable with my new phone. It's never going to be updated, so out of 2 users of that car, one can't play media and the other needs to deal with occasional infosystem crashes that require a full reset and re-pairing. You may be lucky today, but as years go by, you'll find some bugs too. As Bluetooth standards evolve, you'll want non-recall updates in your car.
- mulmen 3y agoWell the car is a 2010 model year and still works as well as the day it was new. The Bluetooth might stop working at some point but 14 years seems pretty good. The infotainment system might not even have been new that year and could go back as far as 2007.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoDon't worry, they'll launch it as a monthly subscription service that ensures that you get the latest version of their software, which is going to be decades behind Android Auto and Car Play.
- mike_d 3y agoThis is just nonsense to justify locking consumers into Ultifi, their new Android based infotainment system. GM has stated they expect to generate $20-25 billion in app and subscription revenues by 2030 [1]. GM is about to figure out people are more loyal to their phone than their car. 1. https://gmauthority.com/blog/2022/08/gm-ultifi-to-generate-20-to-25-billion-in-annual-software-and-services-revenue-by-2023/ https://gmauthority.com/blog/2022/08/gm-ultifi-to-generate-2...
- chrisdbanks 3y agoYep. Never buying a GM now. It would never pay for a subscription to have something just in my car that I also have on my phone.
- AmVess 3y agoThese people are certifiably insane. How are they not aware that people carry their entire digital lives in their pockets and purses and aren't going to swap that for whatever pile of garbage GM will come out with? Further, how are they going to handle rental fleets? Do they think people will fork over $20 on top of a rental fee just to use their junk service?
- mattmaroon 3y agoYeah, bullshit. You know what’ll really many people just pick up their device? Whatever second-rate voice to text GM licenses from god knows who. Or all the things GM’s software can’t do because iOS won’t let them. I wouldn’t buy a GM car anyway since they’re consistently low quality (they’re the Detroit Lions of auto making) so I won’t act like they just lost my business, but I especially wouldn’t buy one after they inevitably bungle the software. My Stellantis car nearly never has some sort of Car Play bug. Third party Car Play apps can be extremely buggy but this won’t solve that problem except to just have no ability to use such apps without again picking up my phone. Look GM, if you insist on owning the in car experience, fine. You’ll lose a ton of sales but that’s your call. Just don’t act like you’re helping us when we all know it’s not about that.
- KerrAvon 3y agoI’ve been pretty impressed with the Bolt for the price. It’s a shame the next generation one won’t be on my list due to lack of CarPlay.
- MBCook 3y agoI agree. I’ve had them as rentals before, they’re pretty amazing. The latest is the Bolt appears to be dead, only the Bolt EUV will survive. But it doesn’t matter. Like you the lack of CarPlay makes it a non-starter and I wouldn’t recommend it in the future to anyone for the same reason.
- system7rocks 3y agoI like Apple CarPlay. I like that it simplifies things and I don't have to login with my Google account. But, the head unit I have is super laggy, because it is just a dumb android tablet. Imagine an iPad with an M1 processor. Gosh it would rock.
- MBCook 3y agoIt really shouldn’t matter much. My 2016 car wasn’t laggy with CarPlay. I promise you that thing wasn’t fast. Or are you using wireless? I don’t know if other vehicles are better but the only times I’ve gotten to try wireless CarPlay the lag drove me nuts. If I plugged it in instead it was great.
- warbeforepeace 3y agoHaving rented a dozen different cars with car play i can say some manufacturers make car play feel just as painful as their in house infotainment systems.
- MBCook 3y agoOuch. I guess I’ve been lucky.
- beretguy 3y agoSo, they will completely remove infotainment system/touchscreen and replace it with physical buttons? Right? Right?
- nichos 3y agoGM is one of the few manufacturers that still has physical buttons for almost everything (climate, volume,etc)
- mgarfias 3y agoyou know whats unsafe? Getting rid of physical buttons and putting everything on a touch screen with no tactile feedback and constantly changing the position of things - looking at you tesla. All things considered though: im not likely to buy any new car. I'd rather buy an old and busted early 70s boat, and stuff in modern running gear.
- epistasis 3y agoI was sort of convinced by this argument, theoretically, until I actually experienced the alternative. I've had a Toyota for four years now with all physical switches, but the complexity and number of controls is absolutely mind bogging large. I can't operate these physical switches without looking at inscrutable, small labels in awkward places. A centralized screen which allows clear view of the road at the same time is much safer than stalks with arrays of switches that have 4+ settings. At least when I'm operating it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- slantyyz 3y agoI dunno, my 18 year old Honda (and wife's Toyota of same age) is pretty much all physical switches (and that's not counting all the cars I've driven since the late 80s). Outside of the occasional manufacturer idiosyncrasies, my Honda's controls pretty much behave the same way that all my prior cars did too. Yes, there are a lot, but I only use a handful of them at any given time. They work predictably, without any random lags related to CPU load or any other weird stuff that could be related to running a -large- complex operating system. Everything just works, and all the time. -- edit: might want to add that they don't need software upgrades either I would prefer that over a touchscreen any day.
- epistasis 3y agoBetween cruise control, volumes controls, front wipers, back wipers, camera controls, interior light controls, HVAC, the array is truly bewildering, and I've never been in two cars that were similar unless they had the same manufacturer and were manufactured relatively closely. Now, on my Toyota, though I find the controls bewildering and worse than a well-done screen, I would never ever want Toyota to make a screen based control for these. Their 2019 screen system is laggy, looks like it was built in 2008, and is really not even fit for the purpose of selecting radio stations, much less the wholly inadequate map navigation system they put on it. Or the choice is having a traditional auto maker have switches or a screen, give me switches. If the choice is to have a halfway competent UI and hardware designer give me switches or a screen, give me the screen.
- antoniuschan99 3y agoI went ahead and googled if tesla uses android auto or carplay and apparently it doesn’t either. Neither does Rivian.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoIn almost every car I turn the screen as close to off as possible and just use my phone for navigation and music. The Tesla is the only exception: Their software is good enough to use rather than automatically ignore.
- mullingitover 3y agoEhh, hard disagree. I rented a Tesla for a few days. I didn't have time to spend an hour learning their UX before driving off in it, and I expected the Coca Cola of EVs to have intuitive controls. Huge mistake, I came away with the impression that Teslas are designed by people who don't actually drive cars, and I was thrilled to get back to Carplay and sane Honda ergonomics.
- brandonagr2 3y agoWhat were you unable to figure out? To navigate you tap the large NAVIGATE text box and enter a destination.
- mullingitover 3y agoI was able to figure everything out fine eventually. I'm just accustomed to normal car UX. It doesn't matter if it's a Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford, whatever: I can get in a car, take ten seconds to have Carplay working, and the rest of the controls are completely intuitive without any mental effort. I don't have to navigate through on-screen menus to do literally everything. The established auto manufacturers learned these ergonomics lessons over the past 50+ years, and things are designed based on that experience. Teslas just don't have that ergonomic finesse that you don't notice until it's not there. If you feel like you're doing sysadmin work to operate your car, the designer screwed up. Tesla didn't cram everything into a screen because it's the superior ergonomic design, they did it because it's cheap. It definitely feels cheap and very mentally cumbersome.
- jrsj 3y agoIf this was actually about safety they would just get rid of the touch screen entirely. You really don't even need a display at all anymore, HUD + physical controls could cover all essential functions.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoIf it were up to me, I'd mandate that all cars are required to have a HUD. HUDs are insanely useful, mainly because it doesn't require the driver to take their eyes off the road for directions or for checking their speed. Elon refusing to put a HUD in the tesla's is one of the reasons why he shouldn't be the CEO of anything, let alone a car company.
- ageitgey 3y agoOnce you've owned a car with a decent HUD, it really does feel insane to go back to a car where you have to look away from the road for something as basic as checking your speed. It's a great feature.
- slantyyz 3y agoI'm probably in the minority of the minority, but I don't want a touch screen in my car. Or even any big LCD screen in my car. I would prefer my car to be relatively dumb, and free of distractions where possible.
- Saris 3y agoThe only screen that would be nice is a small diagnostics one that shows trouble codes, and some live info like temperatures and sensor voltages.
- YPPH 3y agoThe major advantage of AA/CP is they are simple screen projection protocols capable of being supported for decades. The "brains" of the system, namely the phone, can be easily upgraded as technology changes. People will get new phones. Operating systems will be upgraded. Apps will come and go. Maps will update. The system will keep working flawlessly. This can't happen with fixed hardware in vehicle - the firmware and apps will be promptly outdated.
- yborg 3y agoThat is a feature as far as the manufacturers are concerned.
- MBCook 3y agoYep. I got my first car with CarPlay in 2015. That’s 8 years ago. iPhones are always faster than the infotainment systems in cars due to development cycles and cost. Now my iPhone is eight years newer than the one that was already better than my car. So it’s obviously faster. Apple has delivered numerous new features in those eight years, the car never received a single update. That wasn’t even an ability on the car. As John Gruber is a fan of saying, the phone eats everything. You can’t compete with it. It has better specs, it gets updated more often, it’s more customized to the user. It has better connectivity (I’m not paying $30 a month or whatever to give my car cellular service). It has the apps I want to use, not the ones who gave the car company a payoff. If I have to get a rental car on a vacation, all my same stuff is right there. GM will suffer. I’m curious how long it takes them to reverse this. Just one year? Or more? I’m willing to bet a nontrivial number of people just flat walk out of dealerships when they hear the car they’re looking at doesn’t have CarPlay (or Android Auto).
- overgard 3y agoI dunno, I got my first car with Car Play a year ago. I'm not super impressed. It's buggy and slow and the interface is clunky. It's better than using my phone directly, barely, but I still would have bought the car if it didn't have it. All I really want is music and maps anyway, and I can just get a cheap phone mount for my dashboard like I did with my old car so I don't have to look down at it.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agowhat will win; the best ux design teams in the world or the finance bros that have become GM. No question mark because it’s not a question. The sooner that realize they’re a tape deck aux in with a motor attached, the better for everyone involved.
- DannyBee 3y agoThey think people are willing to pay 135 a month in software subscriptions for their car. That's what they think their research shows. They are so far gone it's astonishing
- wannacboatmovie 3y agoThen why can't "the best ux design teams in the world" design CarPlay apps that work? Regardless of GM's ulterior motives here (follow the money), they're not wrong. CarPlay stinks. It indeed has caused me distracted driving while I execute a complex task such as, oh I don't know, choose a song/playlist. The worst offender by far is Amazon Music, which is nearly unusable, though Apple isn't too far behind. The mapping apps are just as bad and getting worse. Want to report a hazard etc. in Apple Maps? You have to tap a chevron and wait for a fold-out menu to appear, it's like 3 taps deep. By this point you have passed the hazard and become one yourself as you fight these terrible UIs designed by... you guessed it, "the best ux design teams in the world". And yes 90% of it are the apps but at its heart CarPlay is just display mirroring. The UX of most CarPlay apps is downright TERRIBLE.
- seydor 3y agogoogle and apple should pay for it. You can get $200 car units that run android and support both
- kelnos 3y agoI've never owned a car made by GM, but a decision like this guarantees I never will. I don't buy their take that the safety issues are because Android Auto and CarPlay are buggy and have connection issues and other crap that cause people to use their phone directly. I've only had a new enough car to use Android Auto for a year and half now, but I've literally never encountered a bug that required me to touch my phone. If there are bugs on GM's cars, I expect that's an issue with the car's software, not Google's or Apple's. Obviously GM is putting forth a bad-faith argument to justify their real reason, which is that they just want full control over the experience, and likely want to find ways to monetize things that people can do with their own interface. Good luck with that, GM. Even if GM somehow manages to build a nice, performant, featureful, non-buggy infotainment system (yeah, right), guaranteed they're going to stop releasing updates for each car's version of it within 5-10 years of the car's release. Meanwhile, as long as my phone keeps getting updates, Android Auto will keep getting updates.
- evanelias 3y agoMy GM-made car does indeed have connectivity issues with CarPlay at least a few times a month. Turning my phone's Bluetooth off and on again fixes it, which makes me wonder if the problem really is on the phone side. On the other hand, it happens more often when switching between a built-in car app (like the 360 cameras app) and the Carplay app, which probably implicates the car's software more? In any case, it is pretty annoying. It sometimes happens at really inopportune times, which can be a distracting safety hazard just from the loss of connectivity/functionality alone (i.e. not even considering needing to touch the phone, which is illegal while driving in many US states.)
- darrylb42 3y agoI thought I wanted a new car, but all I really wanted was Android Auto. Added a new touch screen to my 10 year old car, wireless Android Auto is great. I do wish there were a few more app icons at the bottom of the screen. I tend to switch between three apps and there are only buttons for two that are not maps or making calls.
- s3graham 3y ago"s3graham dropping GM vehicles because their infotainment system is garbage."
- chrisdbanks 3y agoWhy don't they just add a dock for my phone so I can use my phone's screen and control the car through their app. That would cut their costs and make me happier. There's no way I'm paying a subscription for my car. This is as stupid as the BMW idea to charge a subscription for aircon.
- conk 3y ago“Essentially, the thinking is that if a car’s in-built infotainment system is good enough, drivers will be less likely to use their phone for what they’re trying to do while they’re behind the wheel” If the car company makes me pay for another subscription to get Nav data or stream music then by default the infotainment system is not good enough. I’m tired of companies thinking just because I bought their product I’m ok with another ~$20/mo subscription service.
- MBCook 3y ago> the thinking is that if a car’s in-built infotainment system is good enough Everyone knows they lost that battle > drivers will be less likely to use their phone for what they’re trying to do If you’re trying to claim safety, saying that your thing that no one has seen that was developed by a company that doesn’t know what they’re doing and probably runs way too slow is safer than the thing the customer is already used to seems like a stretch. For safety you want people not to do it in the first place. But that’s not an argument for making them use your software is it? —- This is just so incredibly blatantly self-serving. It’s like a two-year-old telling you they won’t ruin their dinner by eating five more cookies. They couldn’t even come up with a plausible reason? I’m with you. I don’t need to pay for a cellular connection for my car. I don’t need to pay $200 a year for map updates. I don’t need to pay $20 a month for SiriusXM when I already have a streaming subscription on my phone. Nothing they want to sell us is something we want. Maybe that’s what they should fix first. IF a someone was able to make something better than CarPlay or Android Auto then you don’t need to cut them off. People will choose to use your better system even with AA/CP available. IF.
- DannyBee 3y agoIn this case they think you are okay with 135/month. "Alan Wexler, GM’s senior VP of innovation and growth, said previously the automaker’s own internal research indicates that most new vehicle owners would be willing to pay up to $135 per month for various subscription-based apps and features for their vehicle."
- rightbyte 3y agoThat is lunacy? Unless "engine starts" and "release handbrake" is a subscription and there is a hefty discount on the upfront price. But then you can just as well lease.
- mullingitover 3y agoTheir dealers must be furious. This is clearly going to harm sales, and they probably expect they're going to trade up-front revenue for subscription. Auto manufacturers famously produce excellent software so I'm sure they'll rake in the money. I wonder what this will do to their fleet sales. Rental companies probably won't be thrilled about customers turning up their noses at GM vehicles that don't have Carplay. I wouldn't be surprised if they have to start renting them at a discount.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigtunacan 3y agoMy last 3 cars have all supported Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. First a Honda, then a GM, now a Hyundai. All three had some issues with cord becoming disconnected. In all cases this was a car manufacturer problem because they aren't giving enough thought to the sizes of the phone and how they will lay in the inadequately sized phone compartments. I had periodic Android Auto crashes on the GM. Since it was only on the GM I chalk it up to bugs on GM's side. If they can't even properly integrate to the Android Auto standard why on earth would I believe they can build an entire enfotainment center that is safe, stable, and anywhere equivalent to Apple Carplay or Android Auto? Ridiculous. I hope they enjoy not getting any of my money in the future. GM stock short coming in hot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xnx 3y agoSource article: https://www.motortrend.com/news/general-motors-removing-apple-carplay-android-auto-for-safety-tim-babbitt/ https://www.motortrend.com/news/general-motors-removing-appl...
- rasz 3y agoUnsafe to subscription based profits.
- clipsy 3y agoGenuine question: Are there any auto manufacturers that do a good job of just supporting CarPlay and Android Auto and getting out of the way?
- noirbot 3y agoI haven't had any real issues with Mazda over the years? I got it installed by them on a 10 year old car a few years ago and had no issues that weren't "the entire system wouldn't turn on" issues with a flaky battery or heat/cold extremes. The initial load time isn't stellar, but it loads into the phone interface cleanly and all the physical car buttons interface well with the phone. No complaints.
- nneonneo 3y agoSecond this, I am extremely happy with CarPlay on my Mazda. There are lots of physical controls that just work naturally with CarPlay. No need to use touch controls!
- ausaus 3y agoVW Passat 2019 is very good with Android Auto and Carplay, now that I've got it connected. Pixel 4a needed a specific cable which did not work with a Pixel 6a. No cable worked so I now use a Motorola wireless connector and it works well with both phones.
- tirant 3y agoBMW has wireless support for both and even displays navigation instructions in their HUD. I still consider the native infotainment system, iDrive, a much better experience.
- pkulak 3y agoI don’t like hooking my car up to my phone. And I generally like in-car nav. Google Maps has ads, bugs me to report accidents, routes through neighborhoods to save 30 seconds, and won’t show up in a HUD or binnacle. All I want is a good way to enter a destination, Bluetooth support, and I’m happy. I remember hearing that Audi can use What Three Words, or some similar scheme? That’s my ideal. My Volvo has a phone app that can send an address to the car. It’s a bit slow sometimes, but it works great and gets me where I need to be every time. If GM has something similar, I’m down with dropping the complicated phone support.
- nneonneo 3y agoGoogle Maps for CarPlay has never shown me any ads nor bothered me to report any accidents. The phone app does, but never when I'm driving. For what it's worth, if Google Maps isn't what you like, you can use any other maps app with real-time directions; Apple Maps (obviously) works fantastically well on iPhones (and in suitably large cities), and you can also pick others like Waze, OSM, TomTom, etc. We previously had a car that required the in-car nav to be updated at the dealer annually, as part of their service package. It felt like a quaint thing to have to do. I guess the alternative is that the car has some connectivity so it can download updates by itself?
- user3939382 3y agoIf it doesn’t have CarPlay I’m not buying it so thanks for making things simple.
- AmVess 3y agoGM is the very same company who recently bricked nearly all of their new model Colorado mid-size trucks with an OTA update that drained the car batteries. That they think they have the chops to roll their own system is rather laughable at best. Oh well, at least they are used to losing billions by now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gumby 3y agoI am sure they will be as successful as VW's software revolution, cariad, that's ejected a couple of CEOs and almost brought down the CEO of the parent. Here's a link in English: https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/05/volkswagens-troubled-software-division-is-getting-new-leadership-again/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/05/volkswagens-troubled-so... but the full story is utterly scandalous. I've seen zero evidence that GM is even slightly more competent in this area.
- ageitgey 3y agoThe funny part is that while VW's bad software has been the main negative review of their otherwise great EVs, the general perception online is "Carplay/Android Auto works great, so who cares?" I own a VW EV and use Android Auto with it. It's great. I would not have bought the car if it didn't support that. The real miracle is how well Android Auto/Car Play integrate with the car itself - speakers, microphones, steering wheel controls, heads-up display for directions - it all feels like a native experience.
- valgaze 3y agoJuly 2022: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/22/apple-carplay-could-be-a-trojan-horse-into-the-automotive-industry.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/22/apple-carplay-could-be-a-tro... Not sure how they arrived at the number (maybe only new vehicles), but there was a claim that 79% of US carbuyers would insist on carplay support Apple engineering manager Emily Schubert said 98% of new cars in the U.S. come with CarPlay installed. She delivered a shocking stat: 79% of U.S. buyers would only buy a car if it supported CarPlay. “It’s a must-have feature when shopping for a new vehicle,” Schubert said during a presentation of the new features.
- jwells89 3y agoI certainly would insist on it. CarPlay and its Android counterpart are a far sight better than the infotainment systems the majority of cars ship with to begin with, plus they won’t have problems like their navigation data becoming outdated with updates costing money. My car dash should be the “dumb TV” to my phone’s “streaming box”.
- tristan957 3y agoWhat is the benefit of CarPlay or Android Auto if you have Bluetooth audio? Navigation and music go through the car's speakers.
- jwells89 3y agoVisuals for navigation, a bigger screen that can be more easily viewed while sitting upright in the driver’s seat, and UI that’s designed for use while driving.
- rezonant 3y agoI have to assume they meant 79% of US consumers who use iPhone, since only about 60% of the US uses iPhone, and Carplay specifically is useless to the remaining 40%. Or perhaps they were grouping in AA under the covers.
- 3y ago
- foogazi 3y agoWas looking at the Bolt EUV or the new Blazer, but I need CarPlay
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- larusso 3y agoDuring 2020/2021 I was on the lookout for a new car. It was important to me that it support Apple CarPlay. My last car was the last model in the lineup that didn’t support the first wave of back then tethered CarPlay support and I hated to use my old iPod classic as a media device because loading up new music was kinda laborious. Tesla etc fell out because I actually use Apple Music and a switch to Spotify just so I can listen to music in the car was and is still a no go for me. I also stayed away from the new android based systems. So this move just means that another car brand is out as a potential option. Not that GM is big in Europe. I guess that also means Opel/Vauxhaull is out of the picture too.
- nneonneo 3y agoWe had narrowed down our car choice to one of two vehicles a few years back - and the deciding factor was which one came with CarPlay standard. It's so invaluable for us - navigation is great, voice input is excellent, my wife and I can pick the media we want by plugging in our own phones, etc. GM is going to lose this fight, I think. Maybe they're hoping that other auto manufacturers will join them in rejecting CarPlay/Android Auto, and I sincerely hope they won't.
- bastard_op 3y agoAutomobile companies tried for years to make a decent infotainment system in cars, and almost universally they were all terrible no matter how expensive the vehicle. Finally Android Auto and CarPlay gave everyone what they wanted - decent access to music on their phone, call capabilities that actually work, and program integration with things they actually use with internet service they already have. Then manufacturers realized they were losing control to Google and Apple, and want it back. So now I guess we're back to random garbage half-baked solutions that no one likes, just so they can sell subscriptions for seat heaters and music players. Back to the walled gardens everyone, move along. I'll never buy a new vehicle again, particularly GM now, and simply stick to something older I can either put any standard double-din deck into, or a vehicle with 3rd party mods that then add Android Auto like my Infiniti that shipped with the worst infotainment system ever.
- sublinear 3y agoFor what it's worth, most vehicles still have aftermarket dash panels and wiring harnesses so you can install whatever you want. Way less of a compromise than buying an older vehicle, but I wouldn't expect some of the control integrations with the steering wheel and other displays to work though. Really in retrospect nothing has changed from the days double-din was standard apart from some extra steps. Does anyone know if there are projects that reverse engineer these misc integrations for various manufacturers? Is it all just CAN bus or something proprietary?
- askvictor 3y agoDo they really? Most recent cars I've seen have a touchscreen LCD popping up out of the dash and it all looks rather custom. Are there some kind of standards like double-DIN?
- equalsione 3y agoOne option is standalone CarPlay and Android Auto head units - search for carpuride or Atoto for examples. There’s other manufacturers as well. I recall seeing model specific replacement head units for the pop up type display you describe but can’t find them now
- daft_pink 3y agoGM was created by financially engineering a bunch of car companies together and stamping different name plates on the same vehicles and my whole life they've made terrible cars in the USA. They are run by accountants not car people. From not bothering to make quality vehicles, because they claimed the majority of new car buyers don't drive a car past 100,000 miles to not offering Supercruise on any of their other models, because they had to wait for the Escalade refresh. Dropping the features we actually want is another in a long line of terrible decisions consumer not friendly decisions by their company.
- justinator 3y agoRivian said nope to CarPlay and Android Auto from Day 1.
- RagnarD 3y agoI use CarPlay everytime I drive and haven't had any of the mentioned supposed problems. Then again I don't drive a GM ...
- stpe 3y agoWhy, oh why, is in-car infotainment so bad? And I don't mean bad as in subjective opinions about user interface. I mean the fact that my 2 year old high-end Audi A6 still show Yelp ratings in the navigation system in Europe - Yelp pretty much shutdown in Europe 2016! It feels like there is somewhere an hierarchical organization somewhere completely lacking product management and a connection to what is expected in the digital world.
- laichzeit0 3y agoUh, yeah.. no. I want a dumb display that lets me use wireless CarPlay and physical knobs for everything else. It's like the people making these decisions don't actually drive cars.
- tybulewicz 3y agoYou're right, they are being driven by their limo drivers.
- peterlada 3y agoIt's nice to see GM and Ford (cutting back on F150 Lighting production) leading the sales at Tesla. What a self own.
- xyst 3y agoGM is a company known for laying off workers when their quarterly projections are not met or exceeded. Usually starts with their in house tech side because you know they are a CAR company after all. Have worked with many former GM employees through boom and bust cycles. GM, Ford, and any auto manufacturer need to stay in their lane. They can build physical cars. But building anything in the digital world and they fall flat. For decades these companies had their own "infotainment" systems and each no better than the competition. From what I have heard from former employees, before AA/AC, the work for maintaining and building those systems was often farmed out to bottom tier contracting companies
- stakhanov 3y agoAre they also removing cupholders from their cars then? I'd imagine that, in the name of safety, you wouldn't want a driver faffing around with a hot drink while driving the vehicle either.
- hooby 3y agoI don't know about cup holders - but it's been definitely shown, that replacing actual physical knobs and buttons with a touch-screen does hurt safety. The thing with media controls is, that you can use those only when it's safe to do so. You're not gonna change the radio channel or music-playlist while going through a busy intersection. But many of the functions car manufacturers are moving from actual buttons to their touch-screens, aren't that time flexible.
- hyperliner 3y ago[dead]
- perlgeek 3y agoCurrently when I go into my car, I can resume listening to the podcast, or I can listen to my music (different app), or whatever. I doubt any car manufacturer will be able to offer the same seamless experience when they build their own entertainment system, because now they'd have to scale to all relevant apps, not just one (or two) standard ways to interface.
- rezonant 3y agoOh they've already solved for that years ago! It'll just automatically send a Play signal via Bluetooth when your phone connects to it! And for good measure, there will be no way to control this at all. Enjoy having random content from your phone's recent media sessions forced into your car audio because the car company thinks it's "convenient"!
- ranguna 3y agoYou can just connect to Bluetooth and resume your podcast naturally by continuing to play the current media, or switch to a different app (using your phone in hands free mode).
- Neil44 3y agoYay, let's wait for GM's latest stab at an interface, no doubt running on an out of date OS off an underpowered embedded processor and a flash card they got off ebay in 2005, using an icon pack they found on a chinese pirate site and apps nobody needs. Oh and it will cost them $1Bn to develop. Then they'll open it up to the internet and spam your phone with instructions to go spend money at the dealers again.
- gertrunde 3y agoI don't disagree that they are unsafe - but I'm more inclined to blame touchscreens as a whole for taking attention off the road, rather than bugginess of the software, when generally the built in car system tends to be more buggy than Android Auto or Apple Carplay.
- bArray 3y ago> GM is now claiming that Apple CarPlay and Android Auto actually cause safety issues. I remember when I first saw these in-cockpit infotainment mobile integrations deployed and thinking "man, that's dangerous". I have a car with physical buttons, and even then I struggle to dial numbers for example whilst driving. > And when CarPlay and Android Auto have issues, drivers pick up their phones again, taking their eyes off the road and totally defeating the purpose of these phone-mirroring programs. A number of times I have had to pull up at the side of the road just to get bluetooth music playing correctly. I dread to think how people solve that whilst driving. This software is for sure dangerously awful. > Essentially, the thinking is that if a car’s in-built infotainment system is good enough, drivers will be less likely to use their phone for what they’re trying to do while they’re behind the wheel, — though Babbitt admits that GM hasn’t exactly tested this in a controlled setting to see whether or not it’s true. My suggestion to GM would be not to compete in the same way. When driving you need a simple, clean, reliable interface. Nobody wants a steering wheel to change location or the numbers on the gear stick to randomly change. Ignoring the private video on the web page [1]: > Designed in-house by GM engineers, Ultifi has been designed with third-party developers in mind. It runs on Linux and the Red Hat in-vehicle operating system, allowing GM to grant access to external developers to create apps and programs for customers. I really hope it's all sandboxed to the heavens with external monitoring (they'll probably want to re-write the OOM and scheduler to ensure their processes are always given priority). Don't make the same mistake as Tesla with logging to flash [2]. [1] https://gmauthority.com/blog/gm/general-motors-services/gm-ultifi/ https://gmauthority.com/blog/gm/general-motors-services/gm-u... [2] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/flash-memory-wear-killing-older-teslas-due-to-excessive-data-logging-report https://www.tomshardware.com/news/flash-memory-wear-killing-...
- MandieD 3y agoFor occasional drivers like me, it’s much safer to have our mobile OS as the infotainment interface, because it’s the same set of apps we use in most other situations - less cognitive load and time spent glancing at the screen.
- kozikow 3y agoThose systems when they work are OK. But connectivity is so annoying. 1/4 times Android Auto fails to connect. I have to restart the phone, restart the car and it connects. And I'm not surprised it's all ducktape security.
- rpz 3y agoThe fact that we have touch screens in cars in the first place is an abomination.
- ghusbands 3y agoThere are many comments here saying that Android Auto is not buggy - in my four years of experience, it certainly has had major and minor issues. Here is a non-exhaustive list of issues and oddness: 1. When you plug it in, it fiddles with bluetooth settings, because although the screen is sent via the cable, the audio and similar is sent via bluetooth. This sometimes results in odd behaviour and requires unplugging/replugging. 2. For a long time, when I plugged it in already navigating, the phone would show an "Android Auto has stopped working" dialogue and the car screen would go blank. I eventually found it was a conflict between Android Auto and the mini-map overlay feature of Google Maps. 3. Currently, whenever I try to use the voice assistant, it says approximately "Sorry, there has been a problem. Please try again later." Trying again later doesn't work. So now I have to pull over to change or add destinations. 4. When you choose to navigate somewhere from another app, it navigates to a place that's like 10m-100m away from it in some direction, which is sometimes an entirely different road. If I unplug the phone, set the destination, then plug it in again, then it navigates correctly. 5. It doesn't support sending messages via anything other than SMS, which is a pain when you're wanting to tell someone on WhatsApp or Messenger that you're five minutes away. 6. I made the mistake of playing a podcast through Google Podcasts (which is built in to Android Auto). Now, it just always plays it when I get to my car. I can't make it forget the podcast, and it plays from the start if it finished. I can only replace it with another podcast for it to keep playing unprompted. 7. Occasionally, it will switch destination to one from an older navigation session. Best hope you notice before you drive too far the wrong way. 8. This might have been fixed, recently, but whenever I would restart my phone, it would have as many Google Maps sessions as I'd had journeys since the last restart; however Android Auto was taking over Google Maps was leaving zombie activities/processes. 9. There have been a good few more, besides. I still prefer it over what car manufacturers might provide, though.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoDid they not learn from Ford's Sync experience?
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWhat will GM use for maps?
- JeremyNT 3y ago@dang it seems like the jalopnik article is a blogspam/repost of the original: https://www.motortrend.com/news/general-motors-removing-apple-carplay-android-auto-for-safety-tim-babbitt/ https://www.motortrend.com/news/general-motors-removing-appl...
- nkotov 3y agoCarPlay has been amazing. Almost all the rental cars support it, connect and you're good to go. The most annoying part nowadays with it is figuring out if the car you're renting supports wireless CarPlay or not. I carry an extra cable for that reason. Pretty stupid and if they were honest, it's only about control.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoAll I need is Bluetooth please!
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- TradingPlaces 3y agohttps://www.wsj.com/video/ford-ceo-on-apple-google-and-elon-musk/B6D8BC45-1C4A-45D3-97AC-933A57B76E31 https://www.wsj.com/video/ford-ceo-on-apple-google-and-elon-... Transcript: WSJ Joanna Stern: GM recently announced that it's ditching Apple CarPlay. Ford CEO Jim Farley: Yeah, how about that? JS: How about that? How does Ford think about this? I mean, are you going to follow suit? JF: Okay, so I guess you've got two camps in the software interior car OEMs. Tesla, and now it turns out GM, and then others. We're in this other group. I think the first three software shippable content that's going to be cool for customers is not the interior digital experience. Although that will always be super important because it's a safety critical device and there's going to be a lot more going on inside a car than your phone. So the interior has to be really well done. But in terms of content, we kind of lost that battle 10 years ago. So get real with it because you're not going to make a ton of money on content inside the vehicle. It's going to be safety, security, partial autonomy, and productivity in our eyes. So that relationship for content is between you, the Wall Street Journal, and the customer. I don't want to get in the middle of that, but Tesla and other companies believe differently. They want to have a complete control over the interior experience, and we don't think it's differentiating. 70% of our Ford customers in the U.S. are Apple customers. Why would I go to an Apple customer and say, "Good luck"? That doesn't seem customer-centric. And Apple does a really good job.
- ElijahLynn 3y agoI feel for the guy running this program: https://www.linkedin.com/in/edwardkummer/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/edwardkummer/ Chief Digital Officer at General Motors I can't imagine he has a large budget or a fancy allure to hire a team of software engineers that can pull this off well enough. I could be wrong...
- crossroadsguy 3y agoI have never owned a car but have connected my phone to car systems too many times. My assumption is — when you do that via an Apple CarPlay enabled console you are guaranteed a level of privacy as well, isn’t it? I know cars do not have Internet connection on their own but what stops them from making you install an app on your phone that would handle all these connections (BT profile work etc) and then upload whatever they want to their servers.