20 ms·
The Long History of Nobody Wants to Work Anymore
- 8bitsrule 3y ago"I wanna be rich, rich, rich. WHY won't anyone give me half of their waking life to help?" Found this quotation on Wiki earlier today, attributed to Jonathan Sudholt: "In the Jacksonian era of antebellum America, class inequality was a major concern as fiscal downturns and the economy's transition from guild-based artisanship to private business sharpened socioeconomic disparity."
- api 3y agoIt's always nobody wants to work anymore at the wages you are presently offering. It's like concluding we've run out of oil because the price of gasoline went up.
- JadeNB 3y ago> It's always nobody wants to work anymore at the wages you are presently offering. > It's like concluding we've run out of oil because the price of gasoline went up. I don't think that these are really perfectly analogous—there really is probably the same, if not greater, supply of workers as there ever was if the wages were right; but, no matter how much we're willing to pay, there's less oil available now than there used to be.
- svachalek 3y agoWe're very close to record highs. https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=mcrfpus2&f=m https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=m... If you're talking about oil in the ground, it's pedantic and not relevant to market pricing.
- justin_oaks 3y agoGreat analogy. Yes, nobody wants to work at poor wages. And these employers usually offer poor wages, but they'll often complain about unqualified people too. Sometimes it's rephrased from "Nobody wants to work" to "Nobody wants to work... for you"
- randomdata 3y agoOf course, when you get down to the heart of the matter, it is really: The customer doesn't want what you have to offer anymore. Not having enough revenue to pay the workers a sufficient rate is just a symptom of that.
- lossolo 3y agoOr not wanting to pay more to your workers because of greed? I mean Louis Vuitton bag costs to produce probably 5-10% of the price that customer pays.
- randomdata 3y agoLuckily Louis Vuitton is a publicly traded company, so we can see that its average profit margin is actually only 12%. Rule of thumb says that a company needs a 10% margin to be considered healthy. This suggests that while they are in a good place at current wages, there isn't a whole lot of wiggle room. People will take anything if you give it away for free, but it is doubtful that their products would still remain desired by the customers if wages went up and they retained a healthy margin. Fashion products aren't exactly inelastic.
- lossolo 3y ago> Luckily Louis Vuitton is a publicly traded company, so we can see that its average profit margin is actually only 12%. It's not 12%, it's 18% as a whole company. 12% is 20 year average. Louis Vuitton owns many companies, I'm specifically talking about bags but you also have things like: > LVMH Moët Hennessy - Louis Vuitton Société Européenne's operated at median gross profit margin of 66.6% from fiscal years ending December 2018 to 2022. Looking back at the last 5 years, LVMH Moët Hennessy - Louis Vuitton Société Européenne's gross profit margin peaked in June 2023 at 68.7%. 68.7%... > LVMH doesn't break out individual brands' financial results, but analysts say Vuitton's profit margin came in at around 50% last year[1] [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/louis-vuitton-bernard-arnault-abloh-kusama-revenue-richest-person-d0c2c7f2 https://www.wsj.com/articles/louis-vuitton-bernard-arnault-a...
- quelsolaar 3y agoTo be called ”Long History” i think it should to extend beyond the current generation.
- shapefrog 3y agoKids these days.
- randomdata 3y ago...are great! I employ a number of teenagers and they are absolutely wonderful. The future is bright. It's really just the late 20/early-to-mid 30-somethings who don't want to work. We have assumed it is because they are the "everyone gets a trophy" generation, but whatever it is there is a markable difference among the hires within that group as compared to those younger and older.
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoThe children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers. Socrates 400BC
- afandian 3y agoFrom the 'long' in the title I was expecing this to be more like 200 years not 20 years. There's good form for this kind of literature. https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/28169/what-is-the-oldest-authentic-example-of-people-complaining-about-modern-times-an https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/28169/what-is-th...
- sjducb 3y agoI was expecting lots of outraged Victorians lamenting the decline of modern work ethics
- cableshaft 3y ago
- swayvil 3y agoModern work is weird. All your energy goes into it. But at the end of the day there's no satisfaction. Just emptiness and exhaustion. So you invest your remaining time in entertainments, drugs and shopping. Frantically groping for a scrap of joy. My friends in carpentry call it "feeding the monkey". The monkey must be fed, one way or another.
- gambiting 3y ago>>But at the end of the day there's no satisfaction. If that's the case then you need to find a different job. Plenty of people are really satisfied with what they do at work. I've accepted lower salary for years because the job I did was really satisfying and I'm still glad I was part of it.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoBlaming workers for their poor conditions is elitist and fragile advice. There are not “good jobs” available for all or most. Your cushy PMC role is contingent on miserable labor supporting it. See the contractor/full time divide at Google or Meta for instance
- gambiting 3y ago>>Blaming workers for their poor conditions is elitist and fragile advice I literally don't see where I said such a thing.
- justin_oaks 3y agoTo be honest, people generally don't want to work. In what way is this surprising?
- goda90 3y agoI think people do want to work when they can enjoy and feel pride for the fruits of their labor. But often the fruits of labor in our economic system either don't pay the bills, aren't worthy of pride, or are almost entirely enjoyed by someone else in exchange for a small wage.
- IMSAI8080 3y agoI think the spirit of the original comment is people don't want to do enforced work at someone else's behest in order to live. I agree a lot of people would choose to do some kind of work voluntarily even if they didn't have to. Many people on here are probably coders. They may grudgingly drag themselves out of bed to go and code whatever their boss says in their day job, but then go home and code whatever they want to code purely for the joy of building something. It's not that people don't want to do work, they just don't want to do work someone else prescribes. Sometimes prescribed work and work you want to do intersect, then great, but often that is not the case.
- ChoHag 3y ago[dead]
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI think most jobs just aren’t the sort that elicit pride in their worker. They still need to be done though.
- michaelteter 3y agoIt comes down to how you define "work". People seem to want to put a lot of energy into doing stuff, sometimes stuff which is very hard labor or mentally challenging. The key is that they are most happy and willing to do this when they have a passion or a goal. But when the "work" you are being asked to do seems pointless, or it seems like the vast majority of the benefit of your work is going to people who are already wealthy and powerful, there's much less motivation. One of the most demotivating things is seeing your work thrown away. In the software world, we experience this often. Sometimes you can even finish a big project, really being proud at having built something great, but then something will change and render that product pointless (at least based on the current business plan). After a few situations like that, one becomes more cautious. Performing heavy tasks on the whim of leader is less attractive.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoSimilarly … The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers. 400BC
- Belphemur 3y agoAlways wondered if it was an actual Ancient Time quote. Doesn't seem like it : > It was crafted by a student, Kenneth John Freeman, for his Cambridge dissertation published in 1907. Freeman did not claim that the passage under analysis was a direct quotation of anyone; instead, he was presenting his own summary of the complaints directed against young people in ancient times. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehave/?amp=1 https://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehave/?amp=1
- mandelbrotwurst 3y agoWhat is "Ancient Time"? Is that capitalization intentional? Edit: Oh, maybe you meant "Ancient Rome"?
- miltondts 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_history https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_history "Ancient history covers all continents inhabited by humans in the period 3000 BC – AD 500."
- mike10921 3y agoAs a long-time software engineer and related positions. When covid started it felt as if the world said "We worked enough we need a collective time off"
- rightbyte 3y agoMore like, people realized how nice their life's were if they spent less time at work. I did not understand how much my 45min x 2 commute was draining my stamina before I stopped commuting, e.g.
- mike10921 3y agoYes, the commute removal definitely added a new perspective to many people who have been working in offices for many years. I ended up renting a small office near my house because working and being in the same place without any change felt dismal.
- cmilton 3y agoAgreed. I will never work a job with a >10 minute commute another day in my life. On top of the time lost, you don’t even get paid for it. It costs you time and money to go to work.
- jader201 3y agoI wonder if workers, at some point, will be able to start demanding compensation for commute to work, when there it is perfectly possible to work from home? E.g. these tech companies that are starting to require employees to return to office. On the other hand, we don’t get compensated (fully [1]) for the utilities cost from working from home. [1] Some reimburse things like internet, but that’s about it. We can’t even claim taxes on expenses from WFH unless we’re independent.
- Borg3 3y agoDude really? The cost of working from home is absolutly minimal. You gain much more than you loss. You do NOT waste time and money commuting. You can eat healtier food. You can take break when you really need it. People who say that they need to get compesation for WFH cant do basic math...
- pelagic_sky 3y agoTo be fair, I've never wanted to "work".
- swayvil 3y agoYou clearly lack "passion". I think there's a drug for that.
- yosito 3y agoPassion fruit?
- m0rissette 3y agoAdderal
- cmilton 3y agoThis. When I started my career it wasn’t just “work”, I actually enjoyed it quite a bit. That passion seems to be fading, and it was put into overdrive by the lockdowns. I can see a day in the very near future of giving up in this whole “work” thing.
- cypherpunks01 3y agoI found 2011 to be the most enlightening quote: > Man, what a weird week. Unless it's on their own terms, it seems nobody wants to work anymore. It's the only one with any acknowledgement that agreeable terms may actually be needed in order to attract people to work. It doesn't take a PhD to figure this out! Utah Phillips, one of my favorite storytellers and all-around anarchist and hobo has a line I was reminded of: That’s when [Fry Pan Jack] told me – you know, he’d been tramping since 1927 -he said, “I told myself in ’27, if I cannot dictate the conditions of my labor, I will henceforth cease to work.” Hah! You don’t have to go to college to figure these things out, no sir! He said, “I learned when I was young that the only true life I had was the life of my brain. But if it’s true the only real life I have is the life of my brain, what sense does it make to hand that brain to somebody for eight hours a day for their particular use on the presumption that at the end of the day they will give it back in an unmutilated condition?” Fat chance! From the track Bum on the Rod off the album The Past Didn't Go Anywhere with Ani DiFranco https://youtu.be/-rw4sd4AuJE https://youtu.be/-rw4sd4AuJE
- shove 3y agoIF I CANNOT DICTATE THE CONDITIONS OF MY LABOR I WILL HENCEFORTH CEASE TO WORK
- cypherpunks01 3y agoYes, thank you! That's the related one I could not think of : )
- shove 3y agoIn a similar vein, this poem by Pedro Pietri: Telephone Booth (number 905 1/2) woke up this morning feeling excellent, picked up the telephone dialed the number of my equal opportunity employer to inform him I will not be into work today Are you feeling sick? the boss asked me No Sir I replied: I am feeling too good to report to work today, if I feel sick tomorrow I will come in early
- influx 3y ago
- mrighele 3y agoThis post on Twitter (pardon, X) [1] by the same author goes back for longer (at least 1912). I guess he crossposted on both and somehow the Mastodon version got truncated. [1] https://twitter.com/paulisci/status/1681790405615173632 https://twitter.com/paulisci/status/1681790405615173632
- winternett 3y agoThe gig economy has worn many out... The promise of services like social media, Uber, Political Parties, and airBnB that promised to create wealthy entrepreneurs fell flat on it's face after making the people at the top of the pyramids very wealthy. I think that social media really tipped the balance of fairness in the working world... With social media, suddenly Trust fund Babies could fake success, and promote schemes that helped them to profit. The Social Media model was set up to raise Trust Funders and Popular individuals far above everyone else, and it killed hopes of upward mobility for people who didn't fall into any fame or wealth category unless they became famous for negative reasons or for ridicule. It's not that no one wants to work anymore, it's that people are tired of weak work schemes, and being used and then thrown away in order to elevate others. It's not until real opportunity for growth, entrepreneurship, and excellence returns that things will begin to get back to normal. Talking about is as "Nobody wants to work anymore" is an injustice... Millions of people are working very hard every day on content creation that rivals TV programming and others are regularly posting their best and fully composed and edited work on Internet sites daily, most without any pay in HOPES of being discovered for their work, as proof of that.
- tetris11 3y agoI think you've really hit the nail on the head there. People are absolutely happy to work dog hours on something they're passionate about, or something that is meaningful (to the world, or to a company, or anything higher than themselves). But to take those same people, use them up, and then discard them... it makes them lose hope that their work is meaningful. Why try, when the world tells you repeatedly that it does not need or value you? The only people I can see being happy with this arrangement might be more libertarian minded, where the goal was never outside the scope of their own self betterment.
- dclowd9901 3y agoIf someone isn’t successful in making money on that work, though, it means it isn’t very good. I know it’s not a 1:1 result, but in reality, if you put in the hours and you make things people want, you will be successful. The problem is everyone who works on something they’re passionate about (even if they suck at it) thinks they ought to be compensated, even if their contributions amount to exactly Jack shit. Meanwhile, I do decent carpentry on the side and am hit up _regularly_ for it, simply because I’m willing to show up. And I make as much per hour as I do in my day job. The work is out there to be passionate and make things and be successful, but you 1) have to show up and work and 2) have to not suck at it.
- z7 3y agoNoam Chomsky: "For two millennia the idea of getting a job was regarded as a fundamental attack against basic human rights and human dignity. Why? Because getting a job means accepting servitude to a master. It means saying, 'Okay, I'll rent myself to you for most of my waking life and I will follow your orders during this period.' That was considered an utter abomination. By now it's sort of taken for granted. But should we take it for granted? Or should we go back to the ideals of working people, classical liberals, Cicero, all the way to Abraham Lincoln, saying that this is not a decent way for human beings to live, that people should be in control of their own work and their own destiny. One of the founders of classical liberalism, Wilhelm von Humboldt, captured the point very lucidly. He said, suppose an artisan creates a beautiful object on command, in a job. We may admire what he did, but we despise what he is: a tool in the hands of others. That was common belief right through the nineteenth century. We now accept that renting yourself into servitude is one of the highest goals in life – an idea that would have been an abomination for 2000 years." Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6MU5zQwtT4&t=3540s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6MU5zQwtT4&t=3540s
- AntiRemote 3y ago[dead]
- bmmayer1 3y agoWhat evidence is there of people 2000 years ago claiming that having a "job" was a "fundamental attack against basic human rights and human dignity."?
- mikestew 3y agoWe may admire what he did, but we despise what he is: a tool in the hands of others. Chomsky can be so full of shit at times. I’d like one piece of writing from before the 19th century, perhaps just a morsel of evidence that this was a “common belief” among anyone but the elite that have time to sit and write things all day.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoWhen did anyone want to actually work? Everybody strives for as much as possible of money at at least possible work needed to get that money. But the question has edge cases where some reforms should be done. 1) On one hand you have businesses that want people to do a lot of work for not enough money and then complain... in my country, that means that either the right government gives them foreign workers, because they "care" about the business, or the left government giving them foreign workers, because they "care" about the people (even if foreign). There are many ways to solve that (eg. minimum wage for foreigners should be higher than the average for local workers in the same field, so if local workers doing job X get paid on average Y amount of money every month, you shouldn't be able to get a foreigner unless you pay that foreigner eg. 10% above average Y.. so you first have to try to get a local at above average local pay to do it, and if there are really no locals available, even at above average pay, only then you get someone from abroad. 2) The second problem is, that in some countries (eg. mine), you still have a relatively large percentage of people not working and getting social benefits... on one hand, social benefits are needed to help people when there is no work available, on the other, with all the benefits possible, some abuse of the system and maybe some under the table work, you're better off than someone actually work 8h per day. Forcing someone to get a job at a company is impossible, since they intentionally act incompetent and no company wants someone who doesn't want to work and just wants to get fired, but community service could still be an option. Depending on the physical capabilities (if you're a paraplegic, you can't be picking up trash by the highway) some community service tasks would be given out, people who should be job-seeking (without that, you can't get the benefits) would calculate that an actual job pays more, and the taxpayers would get something back for the money they pay for "lazy bums", who suddenly wouldn't be as lazy as before, since they'd be keeping the streets clean. Sure, it's not a perfect system, some nuances between the ideal and realistic have to be solved, but social benefits abuse has been rampant in many many countries, not just mine (former socialist one), but even large and "organized" ones, such as germany ( https://www.dw.com/en/duisburg-police-make-arrests-impound-luxury-cars-in-welfare-fraud-operation/a-45353982 https://www.dw.com/en/duisburg-police-make-arrests-impound-l... )
- quelsolaar 3y agoHistorically, the working class movement, did see work as honourable, and the capital as less so, because they lived of the work of others. There was a lot of pride associated with doing a good job and to provide for your family.
- usrbinbash 3y agoIt's pretty simple really. If the reward from working is barely enough to cover the necessities, then there is technically no difference between working as a free citizen, and being forced to work as an indentured servant, other than a vague notion of freedom, which in that case is the freedom to decide between working and living on the streets. And people don't like being indentured servants. History should have made that clear by now. People want perspective. In the past, a working man could support a family of five, buy a house, a car and afford vacation once or twice a year, plus save enough to retire comfortably. Today people, despite burning themselves out in their job, struggle to pay rent in a flat shared with other working people, after loading themselves up with 100k in students debt, and no chance in hell to ever own property of their own. If the powers that be want people to be willing to work, that work has to pay off. If it doesn't, well...we're at the beginning of a retirement wave unprecedented in human history. 2 low-birthrate generations to follow. And our entire economic system is designed around constant growth. I leave doing the math on that as an exercise for the reader.
- red-iron-pine 3y ago> People want perspective. In the past, a working man could support a family of five, buy a house, a car and afford vacation once or twice a year, plus save enough to retire comfortably. Maybe during the 1950s, when two (2) World Wars had blasted multiple empires to dust and essentially gutted a generation of workers aka males between the ages of 18-40. Sure enough the US, still standing after entering the wars late and not seeing huge casualties or direct combat in-country, was positioned to lead a post-war economic boom. Now it's back to pre-war conditions, which curiously enough, resemble the Guilded Age, and its associated strikes
- DropInIn 3y agoWas that for a particular "kind" ot man? Because I can't help but note that in North America that there were plenty of people who couldn't do so but were of the "undesirable classes".... And the reason those who could afford such were able was because they were effectively standing on the backs of those "less privileged". Afaict, even when it's not racial such things still existed in most places at the time.
- 3y ago
- skrebbel 3y agoMy theory is that this is all true, and it’s fantastic. Generally, over the last century, in year X, nobody wants to work anymore compared to year Y (Y < X). This is a success of social democracy and it is a success of technology. We can afford to have people work less hard and still be richer than we ever were. It’s the success story of western progress and the rest of the world is going through the same steps as we speak. That a few old-fashioned managers are surprised they can’t get people at the same bad terms as before is just a symptom of a very positive development.
- BirAdam 3y agoInteresting opinion. I’ll need to think on that for a bit. Thanks for offering it.
- ChoHag 3y agoCorrection: It's the success story of western progress at the expense of the rest of the world, which must find its own way because we've ripped up the steps.
- grecy 3y agoFWIW, we haven't just ripped up the steps, we're actively standing at the top pointing a gun down. Do you know why Switzerland exports the 2nd most processed coffee of any country in the world [1] while Ethiopia (where coffee was "invented" remains extremely poor, only exporting raw beans? Because the IMF and World Bank would send them back to the dark ages if they attempted to do anything different. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1096413/main-export-countries-for-coffee-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1096413/main-export-coun...
- virtuous_sloth 3y agoLook at @paulsci's post history including on X-Twitter. He's done dozens of these tours through the newspapers on many similar subjects.
- sneed-oil 3y agoIt might also be due to demographics in Western countries. If the ratio of workers to total population decreases while the demand for work remains the same, there will be less competition for jobs and workers will be able to demand higher pay. It also depends on how many can be replaced by machines.
- cmdialog 3y agoI will never work to make money for someone else ever again
- DANmode 3y agoMercenary, then? Or looking to start your own thing?
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoAs a tech lead, the big problem I see now is that people are not hungry anymore. The best engineers I've ever worked with were consistently asking for more and leveling up the team at the same time. Now, the post-covid hires, especially the junior engineers, just do the bare minimum to scrape by, and they seem totally unbothered by it. One new hire on my team spends upwards of 2 hours per day "walking her dog." I even called this out during a formal performance review and her behavior hasn't changed at all. (Work-from-home abuse is another component of this observation.)
- nine_zeros 3y ago> As a tech lead, the big problem I see now is that people are not hungry anymore. The best engineers I've ever worked with were consistently asking for more and leveling up the team at the same time. Now, the post-covid hires, especially the junior engineers, just do the bare minimum to scrape by, and they seem totally unbothered by it. Because they see management not pulling their weight for the pay they get. Why should lowly paid junior engineers work harder than management who are just sitting back, dumping poor decisions on them? > One new hire on my team spends upwards of 2 hours per day "walking her dog." I even called this out during a formal performance review and her behavior hasn't changed at all. (Work-from-home abuse is another component of this observation.) Wow, blame someone for having a healthy life.
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoWhat do you consider a fair pay for junior engineers in order for them to contribute at the capacity they're expected to? Our fresh college grads are paid a total compensation higher than $200K. Is that not enough to expect working, at minimum, 8 hours a day?
- nine_zeros 3y ago> What do you consider a fair pay for junior engineers in order for them to contribute at the capacity they're expected to? Our fresh college grads are paid a total compensation higher than $200K. Is that not enough to expect working, at minimum, 8 hours a day? I consider fair pay = $200k + a management that makes $600k pulling their weight by solving cross-team problems instead of pushing everything down to engineers. Juniors want "leadership" to act like leaders and take responsibility. Get laid off first for your own poor decision-making.
- somenits 3y agoOn this, the communists and paleo-conservatives can agree: The bourgeoisie, wherever it has got the upper hand, has put an end to all feudal, patriarchal, idyllic relations. It has pitilessly torn asunder the motley feudal ties that bound man to his “natural superiors”, and has left remaining no other nexus between man and man than naked self-interest, than callous “cash payment”. It has drowned the most heavenly ecstasies of religious fervour, of chivalrous enthusiasm, of philistine sentimentalism, in the icy water of egotistical calculation. It has resolved personal worth into exchange value, and in place of the numberless indefeasible chartered freedoms, has set up that single, unconscionable freedom — Free Trade. Preamble, The Communist Manifesto (Of course, Marx had no love for ancien regime, while the conservatives did.)
- coldcode 3y agoOne of my favorite old songs: Big Rock Candy Mountain (https://genius.com/Harry-mcclintock-big-rock-candy-mountain-lyrics https://genius.com/Harry-mcclintock-big-rock-candy-mountain-...) covers it well. The last verse ends in: There ain't no short-handle shovels No axes, saws or picks I'm a-goin' to stay where you sleep all day Where they hung the jerk that invented work In The Big Rock Candy Mountains
- BirAdam 3y agoI really like the Restarts’ version of this song.
- projektfu 3y agoFrom a small business perspective, turnover is a lot higher, and a lot more of it is because the employees are simply not doing their jobs and have to be let go. I think this is the tight labor market at work, actually. Good workers are being retained because there is enough demand for them. If they move, they are not on the market, they're recruited and cherry picked. The available ones responding to ads have usually been let go before for cause. A single example of people complaining each year does no more to debunk the observation than the complaints do to affirm it. This forum frequently talks about the 10x performer, the 1x performer, the 0.1x performer and the negative performer. In other industries, maybe you won't have a 10x, but you can definitely get ranges from impressive performance to destructive interference in your employees. What we really need is to study engagement and effectiveness in various industries to determine whether there's trends of more hard work or more slack, but in lieu of that we will find journalists interviewing the guy at the diner for the story, and that will become the zeitgeist. I personally feel like things are more hectic and busy than ever before, and I don't know how much of that is due to the increased distraction power of all of our "tools". Or whether it's a symptom of aging or long COVID or whatever.
- spamizbad 3y ago> From a small business perspective, turnover is a lot higher, and a lot more of it is because the employees are simply not doing their jobs and have to be let go. Many of these small businesses were tying up a ton of talent. During COVID, their workers left to go work for larger companies and (in the case of the service industry) took office jobs. To add to this, a number of these small businesses engaged in PPP fraud by taking out loans to designed to keep payrolls going but ended up "spending" it on an owner's draw. This was not the intention of the program: It was to stabilize the workforce. But by shedding headcount, these businesses handed over a ton of labor to white collar employers. They're likely never getting those workers back. And I will also say, especially among younger people, small business owners have earned a reputation for being difficult to work for. So you're right, in a sense, but the other factor at play is that small businesses scare away good workers.
- projektfu 3y ago
- cs702 3y agoBrilliant. It should be memorialized forever somewhere easily accessible by everyone. That way, when silly people complain that "nobody wants to work anymore," they can quickly be shown how uninformed and unoriginal they are. The more things change, the more they stay the same. Or, as The Who succinctly put it: "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss."
- quelsolaar 3y agoI want to live in a world, where no one have to work in order to live a decent life, but I dont want to live in a world that has forgotten how fulfilling work can be. I live for my work because it is engaging, challenging, and is my way of contributing to society. I want to live a life that contributes more to the world then it consumes. The Anti-work movement has a lot of good criticism of our capitalist society, but also throws the idea of work as way of contributing to society under the buss. People who work long hours arent suckers.
- nxx788 3y ago[dead]
- TheCaptain4815 3y agoThis reminds me of the romanticism of the Medieval Peasant I’ve sometimes seen online. The thinking is yes they worked hard, but at least they got guaranteed housing and a wife, etc. America really is the land of opportunity, but if you don’t end up in a higher bracket, life is really really difficult.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 23B1 3y agoThe easiest way for leaders to mitigate the problem of 'not wanting to work' is to make work a more desirable place to be. It's not even hard to do. Some simple rules for managers and leaders: 1. Treat others as you wish to be treated. Remember all the shitty bosses you had, and be the first to break the cycle. 2. Pay people slightly above market rate. Make that your #1 hiring message: "We pay above market rate" and watch the referrals flow. Turn your employees into evangelists and you won't need a platoon's-worth of recruiters. 3. Be very loud and very public about commonsense balance of work and just 'life'. No emails after 5, prioritize social-family events like PTA meetings, or dates, or "Hey I'm gonna take my team bowling Friday afternoon, can I expense the chicken tendies?" 4. You can't build culture; it's created from within. Embrace what your employees bring culture-wise and make THAT your work culture.
- etothepii 3y agoI disagree on #2. I think if you want to build culture you need to find people who value culture over money, and that if you don't live up to your end they can complain about the deal. If you over pay and offer better culture when the culture inevitably falters people are stuck because you over pay.
- poorlyknit 3y agoPay is a part of culture.
- hooverd 3y agoWhat does "value culture over money even mean?" I'd rather get paid more and work with people who are clock punching professionals than somewhere where "we're all a family".
- 23B1 3y agoYeah I wasn't sure how to read that comment either. I think it's fine to have a familial/friendly culture at work, but not in lieu of fair pay – and not in any way made mandatory. Nothing worse than 'mandatory fun time' barf.
- iambateman 3y agoThis pairs nicely with “they don’t make them like they used to” and “kids these days don’t know how good they have it”
- dinom 3y agoThe corollary is, of course, no one wants to pay anymore (-:
- howmayiannoyyou 3y agoThis is not a simple issue of wage inadequacy. There is work for survival, work for wealth and work for satisfaction. Worker availability varies greatly in different cities and regions. The drug epidemic today impacts the workforce to a greater extent then decades ago. The kinds of low-skill jobs that compete favorably against welfare (eg. manufacturing) were mostly exported to Asia; though this trend may be easing if not slightly reversing. A rush to college for liberal arts and social science degrees has produced several generations of workers whose skills are highly sensitive to economic & political; cycles, and to an impending AI replacement. The same may soon be true for several tiers of web and software engineers. Small business in America, the largest employer, faces costs and challenges that leave little room for investment in new workers. I'm talking small business - not Verizon, Costco or Yellow Freight. Government has grown substantially at the federal, state, county and municipal levels in many parts of America - competing with business for workers. Boomer retirement. Etc., etc. As tempting as it may be to sloganize the issue and blame employers - the reality is nuanced and complex.
- flappyeagle 3y agoBasic needs seemingly get more expensive over time. Luxuries get cheaper over time. If basic needs become affordable they turn into perceived luxuries (food, clothes). At once point a good quality handbag was a piece of equipment.
- fnord77 3y agoI found something from 1936. heh
- catlifeonmars 3y agoCherry-pick the data to prove a point? There are better ways to prove a point than this.
- calibas 3y agoIn general, people want money, they've never wanted to work.
- adr1an 3y agoTo be fair, employers never stopped extracting surplus.
- xyst 3y agoSome quotes appear to be from agriculture sector. A sector known for hiring immigrants because of the long hours, low pay, abusive environments (threats of ICE detention, …) Some quotes appear to be from the service industry and during the pandemic. In the US, the minimum wage is STILL $7.25/hour. If you are a server the minimum wage is $2.13/hour. No shit, nobody wants to work. No way I am risking dying because a Karen does not want to mask up or get vaccinated for minimum wage, no benefits, no prospects. All in all, when a business owner or hiring manager says “people don’t want to work anymore”. That’s really code for: we abuse our employees, pay is shit, hours are probably long.
- throw9away6 3y agoGuarantee you will earn more begging on a street corner in any liberal city.
- ricardobeat 3y agoAnd here we have a thread that made the rounds on Twitter a few weeks back, being plagiarized on Mastodon for clicks. This is the equivalent of content farming on the web, and absolutely sucks, how do we stop it?
- thrillgore 3y agoFor me, the issue is there's work, but nobody wants to hire me because I: * Have been off the job market for a while because nobody would interview me let alone consider me * The last job I had was a month long, and it ended with my termination for performance in a setting where I arguably could not succeed. And my run of bad luck has led to difficulty keeping work for the past two years. Its not fair, and I can't blame anyone for not wanting to do it anymore. The juice isn't worth the squeeze.
- jrsj 3y agoThe problem is cultural rot as much as it is economic. If your only objective in life is to advance your career, buy things, eat takeout, and watch Netflix, then why bother? It’s just a slow suicide while you keep capitalism going. The collapse of family formation and any sense of duty, community, or really any human relationship beyond a transactional one has made it mostly not worth succeeding. And it probably doesn’t help that basically everyone is placed into 1 of 2 categories and told that either their merit shouldn’t count because they have an advantage due to being an “oppressor” or that they’ll never get ahead because everyone is out to get them and discriminating against them. Working people are becoming increasingly demoralized, and letting them spend half their time pretending to work from home and giving them a raise isn’t going to change any of that.
- nitwit005 3y agoDifficult to prove, but I suspect this complaint is one business owners make when they realize their business is going to fail. They know they could get more workers if they paid more, but they also know they can't afford that. It's always easier to blame the people below you.
- supertrope 3y agoIt’s the fundamental attribution error in action. When other people fail they can point out some individual flaw. When they themselves fail it was external forces.
- wonderwonder 3y agoNobody wants to work anymore [at terms that are only beneficial to me]. The worst jobs pay the lowest salary. Employment rate is low enough many don't have to put up with it. So we now have immigration, legal and otherwise. Jobs have to be done, so either raise pay, hire desperate immigrants or go out of business.
- mercurialsolo 3y agoBeyond the usual rationale of I don't want to work for pennies, I think hard work as a cultural vibe has fallen out of the times. It's also what we have designed our reward systems around. Today's reward systems are tuned not around hard work, but around being smart. The disintermediation of media makes it feel like we are all in a celebrity lottery and we just need a lucky break. We don't need to compound our skills or put in the grind.
- commonlisp94 3y agoFinding historical quotes seems like a gotcha, but stating the actual conclusion that's implied makes it appear much less plausible: > The level or kind of work ethic in the population has been about the same over time. Or > Children have been about as well behaved over time. Can anyone justify why these things should remain identical? That would suggest that environment is not an input into that equation.
- quietthrow 3y agoI think this post and some of the comments confuses work with job. Work is a means to a kind of satisfaction that cannot be achieved via leisure. And people need that and need work. Job on the other hand is everything most of the comments is talking about. Job is what you end up with when you working in a capitalistic system where profit is the sole motive (competition is what drives the need to keep costs down and labor is part of cost. We need capitalism to evolve so that practices are more sustainable call it capitalism 2.0 or whatever). So unless you are the job creator which very few of us are we are resorted to having a job. This is the case generally unless you are part of the smaller segment of people who have been lucky enough to call their job also their work.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoNot sure if anyone will see this but here is my advice if you really don't want to work and are smart: get a high paying job like programming or data science, work for 6 years, save up a ton of money by being frugal, then quit and go live somewhere cheap while working part time for 2-3 hours a week. There are plenty of places where you can get a cheap house or a cheap apartment and work on passion projects to pay the bills.
- nilslindemann 3y agoI wonder what this dude does for a living. It is definitely not running around ten hours a day – not self-determined, but externally determined – and in the evening the feet literally bleed. And that for 8.50 net an hour. That is what I did and since then, I admit, I do not want to work anymore.
- glimshe 3y agoWorking in most jobs sucks. Some people are lucky to have jobs they love, but that's the minority. I know that to be the prevalent sentiment even in top notch, AAA, "I can't believe they pay me to do this" companies such as Google, Apple etc. If people had, for the sake of a thought experiment, a guaranteed 20K/month income and free healthcare no matter what they do with their life, it's very unlikely they will choose to work on regular jobs. They will instead generally pursue arts/crafts (including the craft of building computer programs in areas they are interested in), learning, exercise etc.
- nktrnk 3y ago> They will instead generally pursue arts/crafts Didn’t we have this experiment during Covid where many people found themselves being paid, sometimes for 2 years, to just wait till their job comes back? I don’t think many became artists (surely, some did). But there were also a lot of stories of increased depression, addiction, and despair. I’m not saying it’s better to do a bullshit job that getting paid to do nothing. I’m just saying it doesn’t seem to be as simple.
- wetpaws 3y ago[dead]
- laurels-marts 3y ago> They will instead generally pursue arts/crafts (including the craft of building computer programs in areas they are interested in), learning, exercise etc. I always hear this argument about UBI and it almost sounds too good to be true. Like utopian. And I wonder what segment of population will actually become artists and craftsmen with renewed sense of purpose and fulfillment vs. the folks that will accelerate even further into melancholy and feelings of deep meaninglessness.
- lanecwagner 3y agoSome might. Most would watch TV, hang out with friends/family, scroll TikTok, workout, and play videogames
- coldtea 3y agoOne problem with such disprovings is that they don't get into the actual case of what's happening, just stay on what people say. People could say the same thing for 200 years, but they might not say it at the same numbers or with the same intensity over those 200 years - and of course even if those were stable, the thing might or might not be actually happening during some of those years. As an example (not making a X-to-Nazi comparison, so Godwin has no power here): People have been complaining about fascism from 1920 all the way to 2023. But there are still periods with hugely more actual fascism, say 1993-1945.
- ddmichael 3y agoI really think we are modern slaves in a pseudo-liberal capitalistic wrapper. It's going to become clearer to future generations looking back, similar to how we are now able to detect and understand mistakes of the past. Male toxicity and patriarchy for example only recently began to surface as a mistake. While we still jobs and offer our services to society there are a number of things that need to fix and delete from our collective consciousness. All these stem from the same root of evil: the office. Similar to plants, we, the workers are gathering there, under some occult organizational umbrella which sometimes resembles a "family". We need to be there on a specific time, do specific things, we are being monitored and controlled. We need to behave in a certain way and leave our true self at home. We need to blindly obey a person called "the boss" or "the manager" and act under some military discipline executing commands. We need to climb some ladder of promises, most of which fail to deliver. This is a dark place full of lack of trust, insecurity and control. Diversity, flexible working, remote working, shared vision and mission are some of the things that we have realized and applied. I am glad that we did but there is still a lot of work to be done. Working needs to be more like the freelancer/consultant type where possible: get the job done and you're paid attitude, rather than a weird let's have you around stand-by just in case. Similar to how an electrician comes to your place fixes the damage and immediately leaves, where possible workers need to do the same. Can you imagine your electrician spending her day at your place, 9-5? Sitting there just in case? And you will get to threaten, trash talk, be the boss and give orders. We are still in the Palaeolithic era when it comes to how we work, with some improvements indeed but with also the heaviest pressure from the most powerful people globally.
- mihaic 3y agoWhy would anybody want to work as a default? Work is a trade of your time for some financial security. It's a sacrifice that doesn't need to be glorified. I do understand that a functioning society needs to good work ethic where this transactional aspect is not in the mind of the worker while he's actually doing the work, since it's a hinderance. When we're discussing work as a topic though it needs to be considered as a core truth. Conflating salary work and personal activities (cooking, cleaning, fixing something around the house) is part of the definition of work as well.
- overgard 3y agoOne thing that's funny to think about is in the distant past, one of the big selling points of automation and industrialization was that we could have the same things but work much less. That didn't quite work out. Now we work more, for more things. The tragedy though is there isn't a great option for trading luxuries for time. You're either 40+ hours a week invested in a career, or you're barely scraping by on a bunch of part time gigs with no health insurance or retirement plan.
- kfk 3y agoWe will see what statistics say and what the trend will be in a few years, but if labor goes up for the same output then mathematically productivity has to go down, which has a variety of consequences, but I can think of 1) less capital market yields; 2) less tax income from governments. Both 1 and 2 have nasty impacts on pensions. I am not saying one way of thinking is better, I am just pointing out the obvious fact that there is no free lunch. Workers might get a better deal now, to be handed a bad one when they retire. Unless technology comes to the rescue and helps us keep increasing productivity, but it’s not realistic to rely only on tech.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoThere is such a thing as a longterm trend.
- wslh 3y agoIf we only take the title without a context and that and this HN thread we can go far from the employer and employee relationships. There are political and cultural systems where lazyness exist even at a high pay.
- kelnos 3y agoI do enjoy things like this, but from a statistical standpoint, I don't think this really tells us all that much? I'm sure if you search hard enough through news archives, you can find at least one person saying something every year that validates your position. But it does matter if only one person is saying that thing in a particular year, or thousands of people. As an aside, I also find the idea that work is somehow virtuous to be pretty gross. That's something humanity has invented, not some natural truth. Sure, basic survival does require some amount of work, but beyond that, it's all unnecessary. Some people may want to continue to work more and more, in order to make it possible (in today's capitalist system) to do more than just survive, but we shouldn't look down on people because they've found a particular lifestyle or quality of living that works for them (as long as doing so isn't negatively impacting others). Beyond that, I think choices like working toward financial independence early are fantastic, and I wish more people could have the opportunity to achieve that. The idea of working for even the old-school expectation of around 45 years (starting work after high school or college, and then retiring in the mid-60s) sounds awful to me... and these days people Not only are there plenty of ambitious people who want to work and build new things (to compensate for those who don't want to), but there are so many bullshit jobs that just don't need to be done, but exist mainly just to feed the self-imposed fiction that work is a virtue.
- xyzelement 3y agoI often think about the stark difference in outcomes between American[0] and immigrant kids that I went to high school with, 20+ years post graduation. A big differentiating factor is that the immigrant kids - I am sure with a lot of influence from their parents - were willing to take on just a bit more work than their American peers. Try for the harder classes, try for the more selective college, try for the more rigorous major, etc. Nothing seemingly extraordinary but just a series of choices, at each step being willing to put in a bit more work than one could superficially get away with. Consequently, the immigrant kids "fell into" careers in law, medicine, engineering, etc. at much higher rates than our American friends and their lives resemble the classic American dream: good job, nice house, bunch of kids. To be fair, a bunch of the Americans I grew up with achieved the same thing - still impressive although they started with a ton of advantage over us immigrants. But the rate of immigrant kids' success dwarfed this. In retrospect, the immigrant belief in the connection between input and output - and perhaps this being less clear to our American friends - made a tremendous amount of difference. Our American pals had the same opportunities and could even go after them much easier, but they just didn't have the same motivation to kick their own ass to launch themselves a few rungs higher. The culture of cultivating talent and being willing to put in work was a "secret" weapon of these immigrant families, and itself was a cultural attribute of the countries we had come from. And of course it's also very much the historic American ethos although in 2023 it seems gauche to speak to the virtue of working harder - I am sure this post is going to be controversial, for example. The inability of the culture to sing the virtues of work openly has got to be a net negative, at least for those who take it seriously. The more traditional families are still teaching these values to their kids behind closed doors. And I am pretty sure that while there has always been a large group of folks not interested in working and certainly not in excellence through work, I suspect this group has a greater share of the public "voice" than ever before. There's a classic Futurama quote: "no one drove in NY, too much traffic" and I think of it often when someone says that you can't get ahead or afford a life nowadays. While that message is popular, it kinda misses the question of: who do you think is bidding up these houses? Why do you think there's a waiting list for the pre-schools? etc. Who do you think is buying these family sedans and minivans? People don't often talk about "actually, I worked hard and it paid off" but it's kinda all around us if you look. To be fair, there's no guarantee of success in life. You can work your ass off and get nowhere, especially if you work on the wrong thing. But there's definitely a guarantee of failure if you don't work, and it's sad to see people locking themselves into that. [0] when I say American, I mean kids of Italian, Irish, and black ancestry who were born in the US. The immigrant kids were Russians and Asians primarily.
- Pent 3y agoas the current economic situation accelerates, the resource owners do not need consumers, that is why the workers are increasingly devalued