25 ms·
Paris votes to ban rental e-scooters
- Raed667 4y agoDespite a massive lobbying effort, and paying French influencers to push a pro e-scooter narrative (illegally) https://archive.ph/Pz4uj https://archive.ph/Pz4uj
- ddmma 4y agoCities must upgrade as well in order for this to work out. Must be a transition period but without public measures to implement the urban mobility this won’t work.
- gpvos 4y agoWhy would you if bicycles exist?
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoTry using a bike on a steep hill, or in a hot summer. Not everyone has showers at work.
- ostenning 4y agoGreat, lets now move to ban them from other EU capitals. Its an issue in Berlin, so many youths ride these scooters recklessly on footpaths, hurting pedestrians or worse.
- bluescrn 4y ago'E-scooters have safety risks, let's encourage people back into 2-ton fossil-fuel-burning cars instead!' If we want a future of EVs, we need to figure out how to include personal light EVs, not just very expensive full-size-car replacements for the wealthy.
- snakeboy 4y agoIn Paris and Berlin the alternatives are probably bikes, metro, or walking...
- bluescrn 4y agoThe 'Bicycles are fine but e-scooters are awful' argument comes up a lot, but doesn't make much sense. E-bikes are often ignored or just effectively invisible. (I'll agree that rental scooter services have unique problems, but we shouldn't allow personally-owned scooters to be banned along with them)
- mcv 4y agoThe big question on whether e-scooters are great or awful really depends on what they're replacing. Bikes? Then they're awful. But cars? Then they're fantastic. But which is it? In Amsterdam, my impression is that fat-tired e-bikes have become the standard replacement for mopeds, which I think is an improvement.
- woodruffw 4y agoMy read of the article is that it’s only about rental scooters. Personal scooters aren’t covered, and remain allowed.
- bluescrn 4y agoThis is good. In the UK, personal scooters are still illegal, and the problems with rental schemes seem to be being used to keep it that way :(
- srott2 4y agoSo sad that metro workers go on strike so frequently.
- simplotek 4y ago> 'E-scooters have safety risks, let's encourage people back into 2-ton fossil-fuel-burning cars instead!' You somehow believe that the only options on the table for personal transport is either "2-ton fossil-fuel-burning cars" or the miraculous selfless service sold by a couple of multinationals. It must be hard to intentionally ignore all the public transportation services in all shapes and forms, like railway, bus services, metro, trams, ride share, and even municipal bike sharing services, and also ignore other personal transportation modes such as motorcycles, bikes and personal scooters and also ignore e-car sharing services and also ignore ride share services like taxicabs and etrikes. For you, the only choice is either a gas-guzzler or the glorious service provided by a multinational.
- greggsy 4y agoI think private ones are still relevant, as they’re less likely to recklessly endanger their investment. In Australia at least, the police can and do fine people using them where they shouldn’t, and at speeds that they shouldn’t [1]. [1]https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-12-23/man-caught-riding-e-scooter-100kph-canberra-positive-for-meth/101805332 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-12-23/man-caught-riding-e-s...
- john_the_writer 4y agoBetter bike paths, and personal ownership. I wonder.. count the number of pedestrians hurt, vs the number of car deaths. I'll take the broken arm over massive internal damage. I suspect if you were given a choice: Get hit by a car doing 40, or a scooter doing 40, you'd pick the scooter.
- News-Dog 4y agoPerhaps this regulatory action will induce rental Companies to develop e-scooters that auto-return to a set place for recharge?
- shtopointo 4y agoExcellent vote from the people of Paris! It's too easy to take these things on the sidewalk, go 20mph and disregard the people around you. Those things also weight quite a bit, so getting hit with that may be life altering.
- fsh 4y agoThey are electronically limited to 20 km/h in Paris and weigh no more than a bicycle.
- bombolo 4y agoGetting hit by a bycicle at 20km/h can severely injure you.
- FpUser 4y agoSo prohibit bikes then? I think government is more concerned about scooters competing with paid for transportation and hence reduction of revenue
- trog 4y ago> So prohibit bikes then? I think government is more concerned about scooters competing with paid for transportation and hence reduction of revenue If you read the article you'll see this is based on a decision by the city's residents, 90% of whom voted against keeping them around. The article seems to refer to two main things: "reckless and drunken driving, as well as clutter on pavements". In my Australian city (I think we were the first to legalise them) they are wildly popular but I can attest to both of these things being a huge problem. I literally just walked to grab a snack and on the way back I stepped onto the road and was nearly wiped out by a scooter coming out of nowhere - illegally riding on the road. I have a collection of photos on my phone of scooters being left randomly around the streets, including across the footpath and even on the road in some cases. There is an entire class of people who use these that are just completely selfish fuckwits and do not stop to consider everyone else when they abandon them wherever they finish. I am 100% pro electric scooter. They need to have infrastructure like cars, for parking and storage and riding. My state has just announced pretty harsh laws for riders that violate them but they are not being enforced enough yet.
- FeistySkink 4y agoI hope this becomes EU-wide. Every season it seems like there's a new generation that discovers and abuses them to no end, endangering everybody around.
- hackerlight 4y agoCars are far more dangerous, no?
- Manuel_D 4y agoOn a per mile basis, likely not.
- that_guy_iain 4y agoYea, but we're used to that danger. In fact, we're trained to deal with that danger from being a few years old. E-scooters are a new danger that while far less dangerous is far more annoying because we're not used to it.
- bigbillheck 4y agoI'm happy to ban those, at least in city centers.
- Gigachad 4y agoI'd be quite happy to ban all commuter cars from cities. And then use the space reclaimed for scooters and bikes.
- Raed667 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- FeistySkink 4y agoCars have a dedicated space. Most cities don't have a dedicated bicycle infrastructure, or at least not enough and not well connected, so scooters are forced to share pedestrian paths. And, again, people treat them like somebody-else's property and misbehave, for which there are no consequences.
- eternalban 4y agoDuring the transport strike in December 2019, these e-scooters were a life saver. I rode those all over Paris (would never do the same in NYC, even though I used to bike the city) and it was great and perfectly safe. [I never used the sidewalk.] That thing even almost made it up the hill to Montmarte. On the other hand, my cousin was struck by an irresponsible scooter (who was zipping on the sidewalk) when walking by the Seine, and had to have surgery on her foot. She absolutely hated those things and likely is more representative of how Parisians feel about them than my tourist self.
- outside1234 4y agoThese things are just not safe for anyone involved. Good for them.
- elicash 4y agoIf there were dedicated lanes and parking specifically for e-scooters, like we do with cars, it'd be pretty safe. I don't favor such a thing (separate lanes and parking individually for motorcycle, for bikes, for ebikes, for skateboards, for unicycles, etc), so my point isn't to advocate for it here, but I do think keeping this in mind changes the way you frame the safety issue.
- prepend 4y agoI had a really nice time using escooters to get around Paris a few years ago. It’s too bad that time is over.
- cuteboy19 4y agoWhy not just go with e bikes
- Raed667 4y agoBlue Vélib’(electric) are a staple of Parisian (and many other cities) transportation system. https://www.velib-metropole.fr/en/service https://www.velib-metropole.fr/en/service
- twelve40 4y agoSo this website says 14 years is the minimum age. Honest question, how is a 14-year-old safer in Parisian traffic on an e-bike than a scooter? You can easily go on sidewalks with bikes, too, if you are so inclined, and falling off into the traffic or hitting someone doesn't seem any less problematic?
- conradfr 4y agoI live in Paris and my observation is that 14yo don't use the e-bikes (or the cheaper non-electric bikes) as much. It's probably just less fun and also one criticism is that they use it in pairs (well look at the photo in the article) which I guess is less ideal with bikes in a urban settings. Twitter is all about how it's old people who went and voted (7% turnout). Well, their loss. Personally I didn't have an opinion so I didn't vote :)
- deanc 4y agoThe weight distribution in a scooter is all at the base. People have life changing foot and shin injuries from being impacted. People usually don’t cycle as quick consistently through cities, pressing a button on a scooter gets you to over 20km/h in moments.
- twelve40 4y agofirst, rental scooters in Paris are very commonly geofenced and restricted <10km/h in dangerous areas (or automatically completely disabled in some areas) second, regarding this: > People usually don’t cycle as quick consistently through cities, pressing a button on a scooter there are at least 8000 electric bicycles for rent scattered throughout Paris, how in the world is pressing a button on an electrical bicycle any different from pressing a button on a scooter? And I highly doubt your claim that people are e-biking any slower than scooters, too.
- flak48 4y agoLondon meanwhile, continues to ban personally owned e-scooters - allowing only rental e-scooters!
- muyuu 4y agomaximising revenue and control from the authority it makes sense in a way
- twic 4y agoExcept the streets are still littered with them. While cycling to work a while ago, i came across one parked in the middle of a segregated bike lane, in between a fence and a lane of heavy traffic. If this is the authority maximising control, i dread to think what uncontrolled use looks like.
- tomatocracy 4y agoThe rental escooters in London are terrible. You need a driving licence to use them, unlike rental ebikes. Yet they are slower than an ebike or even a regular bike. They are also really expensive. Then add to that the fact that'll they all have geofencing which (i) forces you off the less occupied bike lanes or roads in many cases (eg in/near the Royal Parks - including roads which are open to cars) and (ii) doesn't work properly so that if you're just near to a "slow" area but not on it then you end up having to push them. This is all entirely down to government enforced regulations - honestly I'm not sure why the companies bothered putting them in at all as they must have pretty well zero repeat custom. Meanwhile there are plenty of non rental escooters on the bike lanes which seem to work pretty well for people, despite being technically illegal.
- samastur 4y agoOn the other hand, I enjoyed using them last year while in London for work. Could get to our office quicker than using public transport, it was more pleasant than stuck in hot boxes moving around and only slightly more expensive (at least in my case).
- mherdeg 4y agoBird and Lime will always have a special place in my heart for inspiring the last silly season political debate before covid in our town. The very first day rental escooters were legal in town the company hosted demonstration had someone fall off in the town hall parking lot and require hospitalization. It was all so silly and things only went sideways from there. I saved tens of minutes over the course of a summer taking them on one route and I got two free helmets in the mail. Leafblowers, historic districts, rental scooters... There has to be some focal point for the nervous municipal energy whether or not there's anything to focus it on. Things got deadly serious during the school reopening discussion and they never really went back to the way they were before. Pour one out for the micromobility startups' dreams and may whatever comes next be as delightfully odd as those things were.
- davidw 4y agoBird Bikes were a regular feature on Nextdoor where I live. Lots of hand wringing about them while completely ignoring the lifted pickups with hoods taller than most children.
- Fatnino 4y agoYou mean taller than many adults.
- Freedom2 4y ago> Pour one out for the micromobility startups' dreams and may whatever comes next be as delightfully odd as those things were. Could you elaborate on this? I'm not sure what Homebrew has to do with rental scooters...
- rolenthedeep 4y ago"pour one out" is a reference to pouring an alcoholic drink on the ground to respect the memory of someone who died and can't take the drink. Poster is implying that startups like bird and lime are dead or dying. This is basically just "Fs in chat for rental scooters"
- 4y ago
- publicmenace 4y agoE-Scooters are a public menace. They're way to fast for the sidewalk, dangerous on the road, litter the sidewalks and cause people to trip, and are almost always ridden unsafely, with no safety equipment at all. Get these death traps off the streets.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI think cars are a lot worse, if we just took those off the street there's be no problem with people scooting on the streets
- publicmenace 4y agoSo that's a whole other debate (and I disagree), but even if you're right, getting rid of cars would be a gradual, multi-decade project. It's just not possible to get around modern American cities without cars. You can't just abandon the city. These cities represent trillions of dollars of investment. Otoh, you could ban e-scooters tomorrow and after dramatically improving various urban areas, the biggest effect would be a few scooter companies going bankrupt.
- pm90 4y ago> It's just not possible to get around modern American cities without cars. Well but it is. Restricting/Eliminating cars in city centers especially would do wonders to promote them as places that people want to live in.
- yladiz 4y agoToo many American city centers aren’t really set up for non-car usage, so even if cars went away, people would need to walk pretty big distances to get to where they’re going. Modern American cities need to be fundamentally redesigned to support a car free or reduced system.
- pcthrowaway 4y ago
- twelve40 4y ago> She said on Sunday that their business model was "very expensive -- five euros for 10 minutes -- it's not very sustainable, and above all, it's the cause of a lot of accidents." It must be great to have a wise mayor in the government who calls out "expensive business models". > currently be hired by children as young as 12 When I went there, I read the Lime, Dott, etc rules and they all said 16, some 18+. Where did they get 12 yo from? It was a great way to get around the city, especially in the dedicated lanes along the Seine. Not sure how it is more dangerous than biking? But, people who actually live in that city apparently hate it, so here we are.
- delusional 4y ago> When I went there, I read the Lime, Dott, etc rules and they all said 16, some 18+. Where did they get 12 yo from? I don't live in Paris, but this random website that seems to offer scooter rentals say 12 years old: https://rentngo.fr/en/home/ https://rentngo.fr/en/home/
- twelve40 4y agoThis seems to be a scooter-tour-type thing. If you walk around the city, most of what you see is Lime, Tier and Dott, the ones the article talks about.
- jen729w 4y ago> When I went there, I read the Lime, Dott, etc rules and they all said 16, some 18+. Where did they get 12 yo from? Kids find a way. I live in Canberra, Australia. We have a couple of competing e-scooter hire companies. They're pretty good. There are always kids on them.
- slowmotiony 4y agoKids "find a way" to have a working credit card? Maybe that's on their parents then...?
- lannisterstark 4y ago
- aluminum96 4y agoParis has such well-built bike infrastructure, it's a huge shame to ban scooters, which fit into bike lanes perfectly well.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoYou've never been to Paris, have you? It's a death trap for cyclists.
- jeffbee 4y agoSounds like you haven't been there for a few years.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI found it very bikeable when I was there 5-6 years ago
- mlok 4y agoI beg to differ. I've been biking in Paris regularly for the past 10 years. It has always been a great experience. And it is getting better year after year.
- Keenuts 4y agoThis. The last 10 years have seen so many improvements: - Around the Seine, Rivoli, or left-bank, 3 streets went from almost-highway to cycling friendly shared road. - Many 2 lanes streets got reduced to 1-lane + 1 protected bicycle lane. - many large "roundabouts" offer a safer path. The right bank clearly lags behind the left bank, but it's getting better every year.
- gpvos 4y agoWhen were you there last? I hear the city has almost completely transformed itself when it comes to bicycle infrastructure in the last two to three years.
- elbigbad 4y agoI nearly get hit by someone on a bicycle every time I’m there. Hopefully bicycles are banned next.
- alamortsubite 4y agohttps://momentummag.com/paris-to-become-100-percent-cycling-city/ https://momentummag.com/paris-to-become-100-percent-cycling-...
- londons_explore 4y agoRental scooters are often competing with walking. A 10 minute walk might perhaps be a 2 minute scoot. Great. But in my city, for every 1 scooter ride, you will see 100 pedestrians walk past. Ie. they have a sub-1% market share. And the scooters are idle >95% of the time. I suspect, the friction of needing an app is too high. The complex signup process needing a driving license is too complex. The pricing (multiple dollars just for a 2 minute scoot!) is too expensive. The rules about not taking them out of the area and locking them properly or risking a fine are all too scary. I think these scooters would do far better if they were entirely free and appless for the first 5 minutes use. If you want to go further, scan the QR code and watch an ad and get 5 more minutes. Pay money, and get more time yet.
- londons_explore 4y agoThe scooter companies should also add screens to the scooters, and use them for promotions. Eg. "Ride me to XYZ bar for free!". These promotions can be paid by businesses who want traffic, but also help the company redistribute the scooters back to gaps in coverage. The promotions should again be appless and authless. Friction is what prevents people using these things.
- twelve40 4y ago> Friction is what prevents people using these things No, in this case it's the outright city ban that prevents people from using them. > The scooter companies should Lime and dozens of others have been around for about 6 years by now, they are doing just fine* and they can probably figure out the promos if they manage not to get banned? * https://www.li.me/blog/lime-becomes-the-first-shared-electric-vehicle-company-to-achieve-a-full-profitable-year https://www.li.me/blog/lime-becomes-the-first-shared-electri...
- londons_explore 4y agoBut they're not doing just fine.... They have captured under 1% of the short journey market...
- arijun 4y agoI would like to provide a contrasting viewpoint. I can’t speak to the situation in Paris, but in the city I live in, scooters are amazing. They reduce car usage which is better for both pedestrians and car users. They turn a 45 minute walk/30 minute bus ride/20 minute cab into a 10-15 minute trip, which opens up much more of the city (the city I live in was not built for the number of cars it has in it so getting anywhere is a slog). When they first came there were a bunch of scooter on pedestrian collisions, but between an aggressive ticketing campaign, adding bike lanes, and adding slow zones, these numbers have gone way down. (I rarely use them as I tend to cycle everywhere, I’m just glad my city has them)
- acomjean 4y agoI used the lime scotters in Paris 4 years ago, in the pre pandemic times. Oddly useful the few times I used them. Though some Vandal was drawing over the qr codes, make some of them unusable. I see them in Cambridge where Harvard students own them and zip across the river to the athletic center. The can go quite fast and as a biker then can be annoying when the try to go past you at 20 mph, but honestly in the bike lane is probably the best place for them
- rhaway84773 4y agoThe real problem with scooters is cuties unwilling to provide them with proper infrastructure. Bike lanes in most cities (out of the better European cycling cities), tend to be narrow and about 1/4 - 1/3 the size of a car lane. If a city were to dedicate a single car lane sized lane for “micromobility” and responded quickly to damage to this lane (which wouldn’t be as frequent for the obvious reason that damage is proportional to weight, and scooters and bikes are way lighter than cars), scooters would not be a problem at all. A city may decide it doesn’t want dockless scooters, but even that problem could be resolved by replacing 1 car parking spot on every street into a scooter/bike dock.
- meghan_rain 4y agocuties ^_^
- mkl95 4y agoI've lived in a couple of large cities where scooters and bikes shared the same space. I see little to no advantage over bikes, and scooters are way more dangerous.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe main advantage imo is you can bring them on trains and in elevators much easier than bikes. And for the rental ones, you don't have to worry about bringing anything or having to secure it on the other end.
- Freak_NL 4y ago> The main advantage imo is you can bring them on trains and in elevators much easier than bikes. Like a folding bike.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 4y agoFolding bikes are much more expensive, especially electric.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe fact is, I see countless people using electric scooters every day, I can’t think of a single instance seeing a folding bike in person, despite them existing for a whole lot longer. Clearly scooters have won.
- GoToRO 4y agoInstead of banning cars, they banned rental e-scooters...
- officehero 4y agoYes, I get sad when I read most comments here. The way people have been indoctrinated with car-culture is just astounding. E scooters are like a drop in the ocean compared to the damage caused by cars: the space they occupy, the pollution they cause (mostly noise pollution). Cars have killed city-life and people are blind to it.
- lozenge 4y agoThe difference is e scooters kill the pavement, the last refuge for people who aren't driving. Even if it's illegal to ride there, people do because they don't feel safe riding a slow e scooter on the road.
- HHC-Hunter 4y agoHonestly, I can get behind this. I'm no NIMBY but; E-scooters were recently put into my city here in Perth. All I have seen is downsides. People acting dangerously on them and so forth.
- ultrarunner 4y agoIs street parking allowed in Perth?
- MandieD 4y agoSo far in Nuremberg, the main problem is that even if their users don’t park them directly in the sidewalk, they’ll still occasionally fall over into the sidewalk, which is anywhere from annoying to dangerous for able-bodied pedestrians and stroller pushers, and a serious barrier to people using mobility aids - think wheelchairs and walkers. Also, many of them are hard to roll a few meters to get them out of the way - no, I’m not trying to steal your scooter, I’m trying to prevent an accident. They were an absolute plague in Lisbon a few years ago. Good for Paris. I hope that gives Nuremberg and my adjacent suburb courage to act.
- ihaveajob 4y agoLow turnout elections are antidemocratic by nature. I'd venture there are many more e-scooter users in Paris than voters in this referendum.
- parineum 4y agoNot voting is a "whatever is fine with me" vote. Turnout doesn't matter as long as there isn't mass disenfranchisement.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> low turnout elections are antidemocratic This is a feature. Democracy is government by the people. Not by their whimsy. If it isn’t worth the inconvenience of voting, that might be a sign.
- imoverclocked 4y agoSometimes what is being voted on is unclear. Names/monickers are often misleading. The description text of bills can seem contradictory to the advertising about them. This is all before we get into gerrymandering and other patterns to shape voting outcomes. It’s not always about apathy.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> what is being voted on is unclear. Names/monickers are often misleading. The description text of bills can seem contradictory to the advertising about them. Which is why direct democracy rarely works. And again, if someone is dissuaded from voting on the basis of how a bill sounds versus taking the time to learn what it is, I’m still chalking that up as a feature. Gerrymandering is a problem, but not an excuse for apathy—not every issue, local to national, is gerrymandered.
- least 4y agoIt's a ban on the rental companies, not e-scooters themselves.
- 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoGood. These are just a menacee. At least people (mostly) ride bicycles on the road and bike lanes not sidewalks. Scooters are often left to litter sidewalks and most of them are too narrow to share with pedestrians safely.
- zhoujianfu 4y agoI feel like maybe they should ban e-scooter companies parking them on the sidewalk or something like that (or did they)? Why would it be illegal to rent e-scooters, but not own or ride e-scooters?
- samtho 4y agoYou are more likely to lock up your scooter at a bike rack or carry it with you than you would with a rental scooter.
- htag 4y agoE-scooter rental companies are in a contract with the city to allow the scooters to be parked on city property. Paris just ends the contracts. This isn't making anything illegal.
- sshine 4y agoIt happened in Copenhagen, too: E-scooters were restricted to a few areas. When you park them, a GPS has to agree that the e-scooter is within bounds. This can take forever. I came late to appointments and eventually gave up using them. The apps often have problems processing credit cards. It feels like society is rejecting them, and so they become less valuable. Renting a car is the same price, but with fewer problems.
- mnfx 4y agoThey already had regulations that meant that they had to be parked in specific areas or fine the person who left it somewhere they shouldn't. But that didn't stop someone uninvolved in renting one walking by, picking one up and moving it. Nothing stopped people just riding along the paths at top speed hitting people or randomly darting into traffic. Soon as you entered any pedestrian square you had to be on the constant lookout for being smashed into by a scooter. Anything near the Louvre was particularly bad.
- stingrae 4y agoThey did have parking zones.
- htag 4y agoI hate these types of rented vehicles. I hope more cities follow Paris' example. 1. There is questionable quality and reliability. They always feel worse than a mid-range private ownership model. 2. Ownership is cheaper for regular users. 3. Parked vehicles litter sidewalks, making the city less pleasant for pedestrians, bicyclist, and even people actively riding an e-scooter. 4. You need a cell phone to interact with them. Maybe I'm a luddite, but I think this is bad for society.
- mrbombastic 4y agoI went to Paris a couple years ago and it was a mess. There were like 4 or 5 different companies offering e-scooters, they were left everywhere, tourists were driving them in the middle of the road in high traffic areas, I saw 3 people on a single scooter, one guy riding 2 at once, areas along the Seine were restricted and scooters would start to slow down when you entered, instead of leaving people would just get off and drop the scooters, the ground was littered with them. It is not surprising they were banned with how they were rolled out. That said, I love e-scooters, they really add a degree of freedom and make getting around the last mile in cities much easier. And they are just fun. I hope there is space for them in city transport but letting people leave them wherever was always obviously a bad idea.
- Tarrosion 4y agoThe discussion around shared e-scooters (and similar micromobility) tends to have a ton of hidden status quo bias. For example, one of the most common complaints about e-scooters is that people leave them all over the place and they clutter sidewalks. This can be a true and valid complaint! But people do that, in part, because cities don't provide good alternatives. A city the size of Paris probably has literally millions of on-street parking spots, or at least hundreds of thousands. (E.g. NYC has ~3 million [1]). Each car-sized parking spot can fit 12 scooters. So replacing 5% of parking spots with micromobility parking would provide space for something like 500,000 shared micromobility vehicles. For context, that's order of magnitude larger than the number of e-scooters in Paris. (FWIW, Paris is maybe not a perfect example here; it's a relative leader in reclaiming space from cars for shared mobility and biking and such. Also when I was there last summer the scooters weren't a nuisance at all because they were overwhelmingly parked in marked areas, not littering sidewalks. YMMV.) But especially in the US, we're so entrenched in thinking that only cars can be real mobility that we can't imagine shifting even 1% of the space and money we spend on cars towards more shared and less polluting forms of transportation. It sucks. [1] https://gothamist.com/news/how-else-could-nyc-use-its-12-central-parks-worth-street-parking-space https://gothamist.com/news/how-else-could-nyc-use-its-12-cen...
- msla 4y ago> Each car-sized parking spot can fit 12 scooters. So if you take someone's parking spot, they just have to destroy a dozen scooters to get it back? Can do!
- eesmith 4y agoPlease use the right name. These are rental e-scooters. It's not like a scooter shared between friends with no profit motive involved. > because cities don't provide good alternatives Strong counter-point. In my city there is a decent amount of bike parking. Yet I've often seen scooters not parked at a nearby bike parking area, even though there's space. I got very angry with a guy last summer who left his rental e-scooter in the middle of the park pathway next to me, when available bike parking was about 30 feet away. Anyone with a stroller or walker would have had to go on the grass to get around it. And e-scooter parking seems to take up more width than bicycles. I've seen people park their (non-shared/non-rental) bikes at the edge of the sidewalk, either against a building wall, or against a sign. They often leave a lot of space between the rental e-scooter and the wall, because people get off a scooter with feet on both sides of the scooter, and because it's too bulky to scooch over to the side, thus blocking more of the sidewalk. Certainly cars take of an undue amount of space. But that doesn't mean you can assert that cities like Paris only have car parking as the alternative, when they also have bike parking, and have been active in switching away from cars.
- theonlybutlet 4y agoI think with perhaps less scooters and a more formal parking system akin to bike rental lockstands, the escooters could've continued to work in Paris. Problem was the place was littered with them, often piled up like fallen dominos on pavements blocking the walking path. They were really navigating a city that size.
- jacquesm 4y agoI always wonder what's going on in the mind of someone who leaves their scooter to block the sidewalk. Besides the obvious example of blind people having to navigate this obstacle course the same goes for the elderly, people in wheelchairs and so on. And these scooters are the things that block the sidewalk even in a city with plenty of bikes (such as Amsterdam) because there is no sense of responsibility associated with their use. When you're done you just need to get rid of it as though it is a disposable rather than a vehicle.
- camillomiller 4y agoIt was actually already like this. Unlike Berlin, in Paris you could only park the kickscooters in designated areas.
- theonlybutlet 4y agoYeah but often those designated areas are very large, allowing people to block the walkways and them all piled up, when they fall over isn't visually appealing. (Yes, people get upset over silly things). Like actual bike stands, something to keep them upright and away from the walking paths would've been helpful.
- p0w3n3d 4y agoNow Paris needs to ban electric vehicles. The same story. They started it, the will ban it. After a few building will be burnt beyond repair, of course
- petre 4y agoWhy not just ban parking them in underground garages instead? Some LPG powered cars do have such a restriction in some EU states. Gas powered vehicles catch fire and burn as well. I've seen countless burning cars during the last heatwave.
- pawelk 4y agoThe reason to ban LPG cars from underground garages is that propane is heavier than air, and in case of a leak the gas has nowhere to go (other than drainage, which sort of highlights the problem).
- solatic 4y agoHere in Tel Aviv, they'll never get rid of them for at least one reason: they're the only form of at-least-semi-public transportation available on the weekend (Shabbat) and Jewish holidays, when the law forbids buses and trains from running. Meet a date at 10 PM on Friday night? Scoot. Catch the Saturday 5 AM tour bus to a day-hike that's meeting on the other side of town? Scoot. They've also helped boost demand for better bike-lane infrastructure, which has gotten much better in the last 5-10 years. I rarely use them, but I'm glad they exist.
- Lapsa 4y agoI don't roll on Shomer Shabbos
- pharmakom 4y agoWait, so on weekends you can drive a car around but you cannot get the bus or a train? if so that's crazy.
- aflag 4y agoThe public transport is operated by the government. They consider no one should work on Saturdays so they don't run their services then. I think if using your private car was forbidden it would've been even crazier.
- hoseja 4y agoWell, it IS forbidden, no? Just not banned by the government.
- midasuni 4y agoIt’s forbidden to carry the car keys, let alone drive the car. But Jewish people do seem to be good at creating loopholes — it’s forbidden to press the button for the elevator, so the elevator stops at every floor so you don’t need to. It’s forbidden to turn on the oven, so the timer will turn it on for you. It’s forbidden to push you child in a buggy, so there’s a wire out up around the neighbourhood to make it not forbidden. It’s quite amusing really
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoThat's some great environmentalists you guys have in Europe. Between that and constant Metro strikes, guess I will just stick to gas-powered taxis.
- eastbound 4y agoEnvironnementalists use city bikes (Vélib’), not rare-earth-filled hight technological products with very short lifespan like scooters.
- camillomiller 4y agoThese scooters are all but sustainable. They’re just a sick byproduct of VC-fueled startups that will potentially never turn a profit. To me they’re just like a meth sore of late stage urban capitalism. I’m confident that money getting more expensive with higher interest rates will have the positive effect of clearing the field from a lot of this BS that provides absolutely no added value to urban life in most cities. Also, here in Berlin these things are insanely expensive for what they offer. We’re talking about prices comparable to a carsharing car ride for the same stretch. If anything, carsharing is actually cheaper sometimes. (Yes, I know that’s also a problematic VC-fueled hallucination, especially here in Berlin).
- jalada 4y agoWhen I was in Paris in 2019 I tried to use their e-scooters and it was nearly impossible because angry locals had sharpie-d over every barcode so you couldn’t scan them. I’m surprised the companies haven’t left already.
- rekoil 4y agoHuh, that would be pretty effective I imagine, and sounds like a classic French approach to the problem, low effort, high impact. But wouldn't the rental companies just switch to NFC-scanning? I know most of the bikes in Sweden technically have it, even though I don't think many actually use it because our QR codes aren't being defaced and it's just easier.
- greenicon 4y agoThe QR code is usually just for easier use, you can also unlock them in the apps via selecting the vehicles on the map.
- Kuinox 4y agoThe situation has well changed since 2019.
- petodo 4y agoThanks for tip! We are flooded by these also in Prague, can't walk normal on sidewalk, as if cyclists riding on sidewalks was not bad enough.
- jonasdegendt 4y agoBlame your government for not creating adequate bike lanes or curbing car usage, instead of people just trying to get around. Nobody wants to be in each others way, it's just that most of the time cyclists have nowhere else to go.
- Toutouxc 4y agoE-scooter (my own) rider from Prague: the cycling infrastructure here ranges from okay to pretty-nice-actually, and it's slowly getting better, so that's good, but there's a LOT of drunk tourists using the rental e-scooters in the [medieval, cramped] center.
- apichat 4y agoWith 7.45% turnout, it's more of an elderly's bad joke. Elderly and wealthy people who have been brainwashed by television and want to continue using their murderous and polluting cars and taxis. Other people are more concerns by ecological problems and the rise in the pension age.
- TylerE 4y agoRental escooters are a MENACE - and i'm not old either - just been nearly mown down by one several times.
- fsh 4y agoI have never had an issue despite living in a large european city. Maybe the reason is that, unlike some people, I don't blindly step into bike lanes.
- anhner 4y agolmao this guy thinks scooters only ride on bike lanes
- TylerE 4y agoUsual HN cycling c-j on full display.
- johannes1234321 4y agoWhere there is proper infrastructure this works relatively okay. Where there is no infrastructure scooters take the pedastrian way as roads are dangerous.
- Symbiote 4y agoCopenhagen banned rental scooters from the city centre. For some reason, people were finishing their ride and leaving the scooter in the bike lane, across the sidewalk, across a pedestrian crossing etc. The rental companies were intentionally blocking the sidewalk in the city centre, arranging the scooters in neat lines overnight. Presumably for visibility/advertising. All this happens to a much lesser extent with the SV-style ebike rental companies, though it's still not unusual to see those parked badly. It happens rarely with the manual bike rental company. I think they make you photograph the parked bike when you finish, so they are almost always in a bike rack.
- bmikaili 4y agoThis is ridiculous. They should ban cars first.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- franky47 4y agoOne major annoyance with these e-scooters is their "take it from anywhere, leave it anywhere" rental model. Sure, it's practical for the user, but it litters the pavement for everyone else with scooters badly parked, sometimes even lying on their side on the floor, requiring teams of maintenance people to patrol the streets (with petrol trucks) and set them back up in an orderly fashion and grouped at strategic locations. Same thing goes for (e-)bike rentals. Paris also has a non-private bike rental service (Velib'), which uses fixed stations. You can still park the bike temporarily anywhere (eg: pop into a shop), but you have to return it to a station. The market supremacists might pile on in the replies, but having a well-subsidised, self-service public transport system with fixed stations is much neater in a tight city than a free-for-all model.
- Sander_Marechal 4y agoI agree. It's just e-scooter companies trying to externalize the cost of parking. Tragedy of the commons and all that...
- HPsquared 4y agoThey have such great utility value that I think they're worth keeping, but should be regulated more. Things like parking should be controlled, and a crackdown on misuse of the scooters. But they can be incredibly handy.
- bjackman 4y agoMy market-supremacist response: I wish that instead of banning them they just fixed the negative externalities: a system where anyone can report a poorly parked scooter to the city govt and the owner of the scooter receives a significant fine. That way the market will soon be forced to find a solution to parking enforcement, or stop renting out scooters. In the former case we keep the benefits of scooters. In the latter case, we learn that they aren't actually economically viable (Admittedly the focus in Paris seems to be more on bad driving than bad parking, which seems even easier to fix: just reduce the max speed and/or tie usage to a driver's license...)
- franky47 4y ago
- detrites 4y agoLived in a small city which had mixed use of cars, bikes and shoes for many years. Never saw an accident of any kind. Generally mature and sedate drivers and bikers, but a culture that widely enjoyed adventure sports etc. E-scooters introduced. In one year I saw three accidents where someone was hurt to the point they require attention, and multiple close misses - one of which would have been extremely serious but for a split-second stroke of luck. All involving e-scooters. My observation is the combination of silent operation, effortless acceleration, and the impulsive enabling of randomly deciding you need to go faster right now both at rental and on the scooter, is a hot mess. I'd frequently have people whizz past me at high speed, inches away, and have no idea they were coming. Had I happened to move slightly, say to avoid an obstacle or bend around to reach for my bag, we'd both have been screwed. While this can happen with a bike, it's much less often - as the effort and room required to pedal doesn't lend well to instantaneous impulse, nor the "sneak through a tight gap" temptation, it's all simply louder and slower. I'm sure different demographics and cultures experience scooters differently, and maybe some safely, but where I was, and I can presume in Paris (given how they drive...) it was not a good mix, at all.
- vladvasiliu 4y ago> While this can happen with a bike, it's much less often - as the effort and room required to pedal doesn't lend well to instantaneous impulse, nor the "sneak through a tight gap" temptation, it's all simply louder and slower. That's interesting. The scooters I've tried here in Paris (Lime) were extremely anemic. They also only have token brakes which, apart from skidding, don't really do anything. Therefore, my reasoning was that since they take forever to pick up speed, and can't reliably slow down, people will tend to take chances and slalom around "obstacles". The local bike sharing schemes have electric models that accelerate much harder than the scooters do, and as far as I'm aware, they don't have the level of traffic issues scooters do.
- extr 4y agoI visited Paris last year and had a very cute midnight scooter ride with my girlfriend down the Seine. It was like out of a movie. But the ride costed like $17 each, it would have been cheaper to just get an Uber directly back to our hotel. And I no doubt caused some french drivers/pedestrians some grief because I had no idea where I was going most of the time. So frankly I get it. But this makes me ask the question: who uses these? Looking at my own behavior I never touch them in the city I live in. They would be far too expensive to rely on for commuting or predictable use. And I'm not usually traveling alone in my own city, so the economics of splitting an Uber are way better. Plus I have my own bike here for shorter distances. Very limited use cases. Is the entire industry sustained on the usage of tourists riding for the sheer novelty of it in a new place? If that's the case it makes sense why they get such a bad reputation.
- Shorel 4y agoYep. I tried them once, in a different country. It was fun and safe. Price is the reason I have not repeated the experience. It is as expensive as a taxi, without the convenience of it.
- epolanski 4y agoStats show that escooters don't even curb emissions, as the people who use them are pedestrians who would've walked anyway.
- seu 4y agoIn Berlin, it's mostly youth having fun, tourists being touristy, or people with enough money that they could either rent a bicycle or purchase one, but find it cool, don't want to sweat, or share public transport with others.
- SCUSKU 4y agoSame here in San Francisco, I took a Lime scooter to go home about 2 miles and the ride cost me $16, whereas the Lyft bike I took to go out cost me a flat $3.50. Not to mention the scooter ride was terribly bumpy and much slower than the bike.
- wtcactus 4y agoThree main reason e-scooters and even bicycles take to the sidewalks, is that they are totally unsafe sharing the road with the cars, and that there's a lack of bicycle lanes. Once again, the absolute worst offender when it comes to safety inside towns - the car - gets spared from any responsibilities.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoOh poor users of e-scooters and bicycles, they feel so threatened by cars, but have no problem to mown people on sidewalk.
- wtcactus 4y agoWhen a bicycle mows down a person, they both get a bruise and go on with their life. When a car mows down a cycle, the cyclist usually dies.
- _ph_ 4y agoIn all fairness, Paris seems to be the one big city which is strongly reducing cars and consequently creates room for bicycles.
- personomas 4y agoThank God. They were/are horrible in Berlin.
- cba85 4y agoBan rental e-scooters, not rental e-bike
- rob74 4y agoI'm of two minds regarding e-scooters: on one hand they are undeniably practical and I use them a lot, on the other hand many users obviously have zero experience using them or similar vehicles, so put themselves and others into dangerous situations, and many of them are parked on sidewalks so they are annoyingly in the way. But, besides all that, I think this is a "First they came for the e-scooters" situation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_...). Most people don't care about e-scooters because they don't use them. I wonder how a vote to ban bicycles woult turn out - most people don't ride bicycles either?
- HPsquared 4y agoIt's a shame they are being banned in many places, because they are such a great idea. It's the equivalent to a taxi, but a small fraction of the price. It's such a great utility to be able to pick one up and go directly to your destination. All the advantages of having a bike, but without most of the downsides. People just needed to be somewhat polite and disciplined - too many ride fast on sidewalks, leave them in bad places, etc. As often happens, something nice is ruined by a small fraction of people.
- capableweb 4y agoWhat exactly are the downsides of owning a bike that you don't have owning a e-scooter?
- 444Duarte 4y agoSpace if you live in a very small apartment and don't have a garage. Also probably easier to take with you on public transports.
- maest 4y agoThe vote concerns rentable scooters, not private ones.
- ljf 4y agoFirstly you need somewhere to keep the bike, inside is great but outside space can work, though you are at risk of having it stolen. The main advantage is having it where you need it - maybe you got the metro or the bus to work and now you want to go on somewhere else. Your bike is at home. Then you want to head to a friends house, but there is nowhere safe to leave your bike but you'd be happy to leave the rental scooter outside, then two other friends want to join you on a trip to a pub, this time you have your bike but they don't, so you cycle alone and they get a cab. I love cycling, but scooters (rental and private) def have some advantages
- capableweb 4y agoBut those same arguments can be made for rentable bikes? Nothing unique with e-scooters in particular.
- seren 4y agoJust a precision, (private) e-scooters are still allowed. The vote was on renewing or not the contracts of free floating solutions like Tier, Lime, etc
- czechdeveloper 4y agoThis is quite important. While e-scooters are very eco-friendly, in hands of large rending companies they usually have extremely limited lifespan and are not fullfulling this place.
- simplotek 4y ago> This is quite important. I'd go a step beyond and claim that e-bike sharing services like Lime are extremely detrimental to an urban space while adding nothing to mobility and sustainability. They are mainly gimmicks used to litter urban spaces whose only purpose is to serve as a kind of coin-operated joyrides. These operators come in and dump truckloads of things onto the public space, scatter them around, and pretend that this is ok. This ban has nothing to do with e-whatever, environment, mobility, or even economy. It's getting rid of an abusive practice that was a net loss for everyone involved.
- M95D 4y agoHere in Romania, THE CARS litter the urban spaces. There are cars parked everywhere: on the sidewalks, on the side of the road in parallel with those on the sidewalks, in bus stops, on all the green spaces, on no-access markings of the roads, etc. I wish people would use more e-scooters & e-bikes. 8-10 rental e-scooters fit in the same sidewalk space a car would occupy and a car can't be moved if the owner isn't there.
- simplotek 4y ago> Here in Romania, THE CARS litter the urban spaces. Cars are indeed a cancer on all urban spaces, and one which has been granted too much privileges for decades. The Netherlands' Jokinen Plan[1] is widely used as the epitome of idiocy that we get by designing cities around cars. But the fact is that services provided by multinationals like Lime do nothing to address this issue. People do not drop their cars for ebikes just because a multinational dropped one on the sidewalk. Also, it's a red herring to portray services provided by multinationals like Lime as synonyms for replacing cars with alternatives. They do nothing of the sort, and it misrepresents the problem. Companies like Lime scatter crap around cities with impunity and expect the public to just suck it up. Any small business owner who did a fraction of the abusive practices of occupying the public space would be fined into bankruptcy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jokinen_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jokinen_Plan
- Fradow 4y agoParisian here, for context I've been cycling to work for about 10 years now (before Paris transformed into a cycle-friendly city). There are a lot of speculations and hypothesis from people who don't live in Paris and try to apply their experience in a different city to Paris, so allow me to offer the experience (obviously I'm biased) of someone living there. The first big misconception is that this ban is only due to elderly going to vote. While the 90% percentage is indeed skewed, recent polls from before the vote showed that about 60% of the population approve of this ban. It's not as overwhelming, but still a majority. People are fed up with rental e-scooters, but why? Not because they are littered everywhere. It's not longer the case. There are dedicated e-scooters parking spots, that are overall used properly (though they are often on the floor due to wind or being knocked down). The article talks about "tightening regulations", I'm pretty sure there are rules enforcing that. The real reason is that anytime you see someone egregiously disregarding rules in a way that endanger others, it's more often than not a rental e-scooter, with rental e-bikes coming behind. They are perceived as dangerous, plain and simple. And it's not a lack of cycling infrastructure. While it's not up to Netherlands-level of bike-friendliness yet, it's quite good lately overall. Now a last misconception is that this ban is bad because people will revert to cars. No they won't. In the first place, people riding rental e-scooters do not replace a car trip by a rental e-scooter trip, they don't even own one for the most part (or even have a driving license). What is replaced is a subway, bus, bike, or walking trip. Perhaps on some rare occasions a taxi/Uber. Apart from that last rare occasion, all other alternatives are MORE eco-friendly than the e-scooters.
- tallanvor 4y ago> What is replaced is a subway, bus, bike, or walking trip. Perhaps on some rare occasions a taxi/Uber. Apart from that last rare occasion, all other alternatives are MORE eco-friendly than the e-scooters. I firmly believe that people running the scooter rental companies know that they can only succeed by destroying public transit. A survey in Norway showed that over half of the trips on rental scooters replaced public transit, and less than 10% replaced trips in private cars. The detrimental affects on public transit, the relatively high injury rates, the disregard the riders have for the blind and handicapped who have to navigate around the scooters being left in the middle of the sidewalk, and just the sense of urban blight from them being left everywhere all add up to enough reason to ban the things.
- pimpampum 4y agoSo they make a referendum for this but they force on them changes on retirement age. Illusion of democracy.
- xuhu 4y ago103,000 people voted out of 1.38M registered voters.
- seb1204 4y agoDemocracy sucks if no one is exercising their democratic minimum duty; to vote. This will lead to smaller groups being able to mobilise easier for their agenda. Also happens one level up in Germany or Australia - lack of volunteers for judiciary committee or duties opens the door for right wing or other nutters that are organised and push into these openings.
- another2another 4y agoI was quite surprised by the strength of opinion on this one, but now I see the numbers it makes more sense. Those that hated the public scooters turned out, but nobody loved them enough to turn out and vote in support. As they say, History is made by those that turn up (or somesuch).
- elric 4y agoI wonder if there have been any social studies done regarding the apparent sense of entitlement that comes with operating any kind of vehicle. E-scooters are an absolute menace nearly everywhere I've seen them being used, with their operators weaving between pedestrians and cars alike, and littering the kerb when unused. But the same is often true for bicycles, especially the fast electric kind, and it's certainly true for many cars. Only, cars have been given a special kind of kerb where they can take up space. For some reason, we've come to accept the dominant position of cars and the absolute entitlement (and douchebaggery!) that comes with it. But we seem to be unwilling to accept the same from bikes or scooters. I'm happy to accept the scooter menace if it means fewer cars on the road. And given how much of a nightmare traffic is in Paris, I'm surprised that Parisians don't seem to agree. But then I guess thes ones who voted against this probably feel entitled to their preferred mode of transport over all others ... ?
- luxcem 4y agoMore than the usage, a lot voted against the business model and the nature of e-scooters. There are a environmental disaster, they get destroyed / lost after only a few months. They are found everywhere and especially in canals / the Seine. They also need a fleet of precarious workers at night to get recharged. The private e-scooters are not banned.
- wink 4y agoI think you're missing the fact that car infrastructure with curbside parking has evolved over decades, and cities have not managed to even provide ample parking space for standard bikes, as they have been in use for decades as well. Now these scooters just came into existence and over the course of 5-8 years have managed to clutter everything. They're not individuals' property (who would pick them up later) but they're owned and operated by a for-profit company and just being dropped anywhere by people. That's what makes it so very different. Not that I have a good solution for this, but we have some bikes by the local public transport org, and they have dedicated "parking stations" - if there were more of those (and the bikes wouldn't be more expensive than other rental bikes), or if they'd just nab a few car parking spaces for it.. then it would be nicer. Yes, it is very convenient to leave your scooter next to your door, but I don't think it would be outrageous to walk the last 200m.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoEuropean cities are clamping down on shared scooters quite a bit, but in different ways. Vienna for instance is now asking for a lot more geo fencing, if there is a specific drop-off location within 100 meters a ride cannot be ended unless it's parked on such a drop-off location. Companies are also forced to report scooter locations in real-time to the city government for monitoring and enforce speed restrictions based on map data. I'm super curious if this will end the availability of the scooters as the cost of this is probably quite a bit higher now.
- john_the_writer 4y agoI loath the rentals. But love the personally owned. I think if you own it, you take care of it. You want to be trusted with it. And you don't leave it in the river.
- theGeatZhopa 4y agoAbsolutely. Unbelievable, that the property of other's doesn't count for a lot of people, so it's handled without care. If you own it, you take care of it. So, one step to mitigate the voters results could be renting the scooters for long time with monthly fees. But then, you don't need the apps anymore. So,the whole idea is dead for Paris.
- Neil44 4y agoEven around the small towns here I've had more than a few instances of black-wearing people flying between cars at night on these things. Your only defense is to have a dash cam to defend yourself when the inevitable happens I guess.
- mrtksn 4y agoLiving in a major city which also has a buzz about banning scooters and scooters being banned in some more posh neighborhoods already, I have problem with this. The problem is obviously not the existence of scooters but how people would pile them up or ride them carelessly on sidewalks. IMHO, the solution would be to create infrastructure and usage rules. Seize the scooters from those who do not comply. Eventually, either the scooters would stop causing problems or they will no longer exist.
- simplotek 4y agoThe issue is that the Lime-like business model of scattering around e-scooters is fundamentally broken. They don't operate between pickup/dropoff spots nor can that be enforced. They intentionally expect these scooters to be dropped off in random places by riders. It's economically unfeasible to have employees constantly move around cities to gather them, and they'd have to license and pay for the occupation of public space to have dedicated dropoff/pickup spots. The only shot at profitability of e-scooter sharing services depends on their ability to abuse public space without cost and dump all externalities on the communities they operate.
- isaacremuant 4y agoThe whole argument about "they clog the streets" and annoy me is absolutely contrary to the actual incentives to cheaper and more ecological transport. It's a very NIMBY type of thinking. Hey, Citizen, if you don't have the means to buy, store and charge your own and occasionally would need one to deal with the craziness and unreliability of public transport, we are going to make it harder on you. Many countries in Europe keep punishing people who don't own cars or other vehicles while pretending they care about the environment. They do the same with bikes or e-bikes. See also the insane cost of train tickets Vs flights. If govs were honest about the environment they would create incentives (positive, not punitive) to foment good forms of transport with good quality of life. Instead, it's a very classist system. HN will probably not get this due to the demo that either owns cars in the US or is on a more privileged class in Europe and likely also owns vehicles and property.
- ramblerman 4y agoThis rant is is very off base. European countries are in aggregate extremely pro bike/pedestrian. The scooter issue is particularly in focus, because in big cities the competition to become the main player has created a ton of competing companies trying to place their scooters all over the place. I don't mind it myself - I use them in the summer. But I have had to literally step over, or move around a pile of scooters on more than one occasion.
- isaacremuant 4y agoMy rant is really ON base but it reflects a demographic very different from the one in HN and will get downvoted as always when something goes against a narrative. It's very easy to parrot the typical points. > European countries are in aggregate extremely pro bike/pedestrian Lol. This is just an ignorant talking point from someone who compares everything to the US. It's like saying healthcare is good (and generalizing as if every country in Europe belonged to a monolith) just because healthcare in the US sucks. The reality is that having options like these empowers people who don't belong to the tier that owns cars and has sheds or places to store their e-vehicles. In many cities, these non car options keep getting worse and more expensive and everything seems geared to those who have more money and privilege and people just have to 'take it'. But hell, let's call it a rant, simplify the issue and outright ban stuff so that people who don't benefit from something can feel more comfortable. With that logic, Let's ban motorcycles. I don't like their noise and don't have one. They're definitely unsafe and cause accidents. Oh, but we're not going to that. So there's bad etiquette around scooter placement and you ban it. The same thing can happen with free parking e-bikes. Why can't you find a solution that doesn't ban e-scooters? You just admitted use them "on occasion" so they're not really useful to you, so you're fine with removing them from others that actually might take advantage. It's the thing I keep pointing out. People from certain positions screwing over others because they're inconvenienced instead of requesting the gov to do better if they want better order or something. It's all rather classist but it happens with everything. Lesson for people: have more money, have cars, live in suburbs, have spaces where you can store your vehicles. Or get screwed by decreasing quality of public transport.
- bluecalm 4y agoMore victim blaming from car obsesses culture. Problems with e-scooters come from them being forced to narrow and unusable infrastructure. Allow them on the road, let them park in places cars park and it will be better. As usual it's easier to ban people trying to avoid driving a 2-ton smelly and dangerous metal box everywhere instead of actually solving the problem.
- jFriedensreich 4y agothe one city i have seen e scooters work perfectly is Tallinn. after hating them in berlin, it took some getting used to, but it takes a certain balance of smooth and wide enough sidewalks/ streets, limit of pedestrian and car density, commonly accepted rules like parking spots and maybe some mentality. you see way more scooters than bicycles here and it seems to be the standard transportation mode after cars. even children mostly have little (non e) scooters instead of little bicycles.
- eloisant 4y agoThe vote wasn't very well known so only 8% of parisians voted. In addition is was only open to the resident of Paris itself, all the people working in Paris but commuting from the suburbs couldn't vote. Basically less than 200 000 people voted, for a city of 2 millions inhabitants and 7 millions if we include the commuters. And I'm not even talking about visitors.
- aa-jv 4y agoI'm a strong adherent of electric transportation, having recently upgraded from an electric moped to an electric motorbike. I've also used these rental scooters all over my city (Vienna, Austria) to get around and I find them very convenient when, in a pinch, the excellent public transportation doesn't work out. That said, I think there is a major modification required to these devices that will radically decrease the accidents: they need to make a sound. Seriously, riding an electric vehicle is one of the most pleasant, enjoyable experiences around - but getting hit by one is easily one of the worst surprises imaginable. Every week, I count the number of people I could've hit full-force with my electric motorbike, if I hadn't been paying EXTRA attention to the street - on average I have one to three near-misses every week. I don't blame the pedestrian - after all, I'm keeping EXTRA attention for them, since I know my weakness: I am silent as heck in a city full of pedestrians whose survival skills have been honed on hearing whats around the corner. Those days are over. We need speedo-synthesizers now. I've half-considered writing one myself (synthesizers are my thing) but I'm pretty sure its something that needs to be so reliable that it has to be built into the OS. I wish Apple would address this. It'd be so much safer on the roads if we had great sound design alerting pedestrians to the hooning idiot coming around the corner. And thats the issue with these electric scooters - too often they are being operated by idiots. And yes, I class anyone riding a scooter without at least a bike helmet on, to be a full idiot. tl;dr - Scooter companies need to start hiring sound-designers to keep ignorant pedestrians on the pavement before they get demolished by the silent, excellent transportation options hitting the scene ..
- ljtill 4y agoHope to see the same in London.
- acd 4y agoI think the main issue is use private companies of common shared space. Its not certain that a private companies has the right to use public communal spaces. Secondary issue physics. A person riding an electric scooter is a danger to other pedestrians especially vulnerable are children and eldery. Kinectic energy calculation KE = 0.5 × m × v² Let's calculate the kinetic energy for each speed: 5 km/h (1.39 m/s): KE = 0.5 × 70 kg × (1.39 m/s)² ≈ 67.5 J (joules) 10 km/h (2.78 m/s): KE = 0.5 × 70 kg × (2.78 m/s)² ≈ 270 J 20 km/h (5.56 m/s): KE = 0.5 × 70 kg × (5.56 m/s)² ≈ 1080 J Chat gpt explaining the above impact energy "67 joules: This amount of energy is roughly equivalent to the energy required to lift a 6.8 kg (15 lbs) weight one meter off the ground. Imagine dropping a 6.8 kg object from a height of 1 meter; the impact would be relatively small and generally tolerable. 270 joules: This energy is comparable to lifting a 27.5 kg (about 60 lbs) weight one meter off the ground. Picture dropping a 27.5 kg object from a height of 1 meter; the impact would be more significant and might cause some discomfort or minor injury. 1000 joules: This amount of energy is similar to lifting a 102 kg (about 225 lbs) weight one meter off the ground. Imagine dropping a 102 kg object from a height of 1 meter; the impact would be substantial and has a higher risk of causing pain or injury" Third issue is blocking of pedastrian spaces, this is a danger to visually impared. A form of littering.
- raelmiu 4y agoI don't understand how people end up banning things like this. Yes, people are using them, mainly parking them, poorly. But that's always true with new things. Norms have not been established yet. But it's getting better fast. Bicycles are still a huge problem in many cities but seen as morally good. The fact that people are using scooters so much is clearly an indicator of usefulness. I don't think this is a problem. It just takes longer. Seeing bans like this always makes me sad.
- pasc1878 4y agoIts not only the parking - in London I have nearly been knocked over several times. They are far too fast to be on pedestrian areas.
- throwaway22032 4y agoI love e-scooters. The simple problem with them is that too many people don't ride them on the road and instead act unpredictably on the pavement. If people drove cars on the pavement whenever they felt like it was a shortcut it would be absolute madness. IME, cyclists _occasionally_ detour onto the pavement in order to get around an obstruction e.g. pass some slow moving cars at a bottleneck. Almost always they cycle reasonably slowly and give a ton of space to others. Where I am, invariably there's some sort of hood rat flying up and down the pavement at max speed the whole length of their journey not giving a toss about the people around them. I see this more often than I see people actually using the things responsibly in the road. Some people just have, well, really bad manners, and if there's enough of them then we can't have nice things.
- swah 4y agoI remember hating on cyclists a decade ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBFFrsvgu1Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBFFrsvgu1Y Nowadays I would love to live in a flatter part of town so I could have a bike!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robbywashere_ 4y agoWhat's the alternative for short distance traveling then? Honest question. Does one hail a cab? Or ride hailing apps still banned or looked down on?
- regularjack 4y agoOn foot, metro, bike, bus. Paris probably has one of the best metro networks in the world.
- slowmotiony 4y agoIts also one of the most sketchy and dangerous. If you hop on an escooter, you're not going to find a homeless dude there jerking off, there's no vomit anywhere, noone will assault your wife and you're not getting stabbed nor mugged. Can't say the same about the Paris metro.
- regularjack 4y agoI'm sure what you describe happens, but I've used the Paris metro everyday for years and never had any of those things happen to me, nor have I witnessed it happening to others.
- Xerox9213 4y agoI remember the first time I visited LA, seeing them piled up on sidewalks and blocking foot traffic was so bizarre. Not to mention people whizzing past me on sidewalks. It was very detrimental to the walking experience.
- ta988 4y agoIt is a good thing I was in Paris recently and those things are littering sidewalks (sometimes by piles of dozens all mangled), and people are driving them recklessly. Really a big annoyance.
- yamtaddle 4y agoSame everywhere. It's the kind of business it'd never have occurred to me to start because I'd have assumed "e-waste littering, at scale" was illegal, but as often happens I guess the "at scale" part somehow made it OK.
- foobarian 4y agoAre these things not valuable? I was wondering how they don't get grabbed up by the dozen and scrapped for parts.
- balls187 4y agoThey have gps tracking. While petty criminals probably steal and scrap them, turning it into some sort of enterprise seems like it would not be worth the ease of being caught.
- yardie 4y agoI can't remember the blog but I read somewhere (IIRC) a e-scooter needs about 45 days to break even. So if 1 scooter can survive 2 months on the street it's a net profit. Also, these things are ubiquitous enough that there is no demand and the internal parts are customized so that you can't break it down for resale. Early rideshare models were rebadged Ninebot and Xiaomi scooters. And you could replace the motherboard. They learned their lesson and almost everything is bespoke.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoI think electric personal mobility vehicles are such a missed opportunity in terms of climate / traffic reduction. Certainly in the UK the fact that they started by being basically illegal for years and means they are, for the most part, ridden by people who don't give a shit or people who's parents don't give a shit.
- resoluteteeth 4y agoLuckily the headline is misleading and they're just not banning escooters, they're just eliminating the rental ones.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoIn fairness, I wasn't commenting specifically on the situation in Paris. More a general comment on e-scooters and similar devices.
- jprete 4y agoI don’t think illegality filtered for people who don’t give a shit. I think it filtered for risk-takers. It’s risky to one’s safety to ride a personal powered vehicle on city streets. I think the median rider is less worried about safety compared to either the pedestrians or the cars.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoHow are you defining the difference between non-risk-averse and not giving a shit?
- rejectfinite 4y agoThis is about those rental ones. Are they replacing cars or are they replacing a walk or bike ride?
- yodsanklai 4y agoWhat's wrong with your regular old bicycle? what problem these e-scooters solve than the more ecological bicycles don't?
- 0xAFFFF 4y agoNote that this only applies to e-scooters operators: their licence won't be renewed. Privately owned e-scooters are still legal and allowed. The irony is there has been a lot of efforts from the mayor and operators to regulate the e-scooters: licensing to a limited group of operators (3 afaik, instead of virtually every operator under the sun deploying scooters), designated parking spots, better communication of rules to the users, automatic speed limits in walking areas. As a parisian that mostly walks and uses public transportation, most of my gripes with those services have been addressed by the aforementioned measures, but I guess that the early deployment chaos pissed off enough people to have them voted out.
- nolok 4y agoTo be clear: it's not all e-scooter, it's the free service ones. Parisian can still own and use their own, but they're done with the ones being left on the ground randomly, being used in poor fashion (on the sidewalk, or with two/three people standing on one), being thrown in the river, ... And that's mostly caused by free services ones that you don't own and thus don't care if anything happens to it. I don't live in Paris anymore but I fully agree with that decision. Especially since this is a city that is working its way into reclaiming the outdoor space for bicycle and pedestrians, you can imagine how poorly received are e-scooter abusing the sidewalk and making people unsafe.
- ohwellhere 4y agoI don't live in Paris but we have them in our small city in the US and they are a nuisance. We're only a rather small < 60k population city with a ~200k population metro area, but we have a university and these scooters are everywhere. They're left on sidewalks, in parks, in the road. College kids fly by you going far faster than is appropriate. Life altering injuries from crashes have been reported. There are numerous problems and it's not just the scooters, obviously, and I know I'm a curmudgeon. But I find these companies to be abusing the commons. The scooters are left everywhere because these companies have no parking or maintenance infrastructure and actively rely on users leaving them on sidewalks.
- ck2 4y agoI'm glad scooters are not banned outright, every non-car person on the road is a bonus IMHO because it makes people care more about the road safety and air quality. I don't know why governments in so many cities decide that scooter "litter" is acceptable in the slightest. I don't blame startups for trying to get away with using everyone else's public and private property as their cost cutting "free storage" solution but come on now, no way in heck that can be done in society. Nothing wrong with making them have official racks and bays around town, people can walk a block after they park.
- jwestbury 4y ago> I don't blame startups for trying to get away with using everyone else's public and private property as their cost cutting "free storage" solution Don't you? I do. Just because something is technically legal doesn't mean it's good behaviour, and we can absolutely blame people for exhibiting bad behaviour.
- RegnisGnaw 4y agoThe title is wrong. They voted to ban rental e-scooters only. If you have your own scooter, you are still allowed to use it.
- NickHoff 4y ago> City Hall said on its website about 103,000 people voted... The population of Paris is about 2.1 million according to Wikipedia, meaning ~5% turnout.
- differentView 4y agoFrom the article: >The result wasn't close. City Hall said on its website about 103,000 people voted, with 89% rejecting e-scooters and just 11% supporting them. >Turnout was very low. The vote had been open to all of Paris' 1.38 million registered voters.
- yardie 4y ago103000 votes out of 1.38MM voters. Less than 7% of registered voters even bothered. So we can say 6% were firmly against. <1% were supportive of e-scooters. 93% didn't care either way but were more than likely against. I am pro micromobility but some of these companies business models is a complete disservice to public order. It's a real tragedy of the commons. The companies that could implement scooter pens would lose marketshare to the ones that don't since a scooter on any corner is more convenient than a scooter stored more than a block away.
- lm28469 4y ago> The companies that could implement scooter pens would lose marketshare to the ones that don't since a scooter on any corner is more convenient than a scooter stored more than a block away. Make it a condition for operating in the city, just like being capped to 20 or 25kmh is an obligation. Take a car parking space every x00m and make it a e-scooter parking space. That would solve a lot of the nuisance
- yardie 4y agoMy city did exactly that. They created scooter pens from public parking. Cars and delivery trucks would park in them regardless. The scooter parking signs and stickers disappeared. And scooter riders just parked in and around those occupied spaces. Apparently some of the nearby businesses were upset "their" public parking was taken way. So they intentionally damaged scooter pens or parked in them. Rumored.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoNationalise the scooters like we did with urban rail systems?
- ilikerashers 4y agoYou can rent but not own one in London which is bizarre. Random person on scooter they don’t own is safer to TFL.
- lbriner 4y agoNot really bizarre. You can regulate rental companies and insist on certain safety requirements, max speed etc but as soon as you let everyone ride their own, it's all out the window and the Police have enough to do without arguing about whether your scooter is going 3mph over the speed limit. There is also the "taxi" argument that it is better to have 5000 shared scooters than 50000 private ones but I don't know whether one is really better, I guess scooters are designed to take inside at your work/home so maybe not as bad.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoTfL seems to be focused on ensuring the devices are safe, rather than ensuring the devices are used safely. The operators were chosen after an open and competitive process to assess their ability to meet strict safety requirements and high operating standards. (For example, the scooter batteries can be monitored to ensure they meet fire safety regulations.) Also, AIUI this is a trial, and people might not buy their own scooters if they knew their right to use them was only temporary. So it would be a difficult test to run. Also: data.
- kevviiinn 4y agoThat's because property is more important than people of course. Are you new to capitalism?
- d--b 4y agoThis mini-referendum is a joke. These cause some minor problems for parisians, and are used by a small minority of people so obviously any kind of referendums will overwhelmingly be against it. Especially since there is no "I don't care" option. What would be the answer to: - For or against dogs in the city? - For or against smoking in the street? - For or against mosques? This is pure demagogy.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoI haven't seen this take in the thread yet, but I support the ban because the kick-scooter form factor is inherently more dangerous than the alternatives. There are several ways they are more dangerous than a bicycle: Smaller wheels means a smaller obstacle brings the rider to a dead stop- once you hit something that is at the height of the axle of the wheel, it's the same as hitting a brick wall. That's compounded by the fact that such falls use the scooter as a lever to smash the rider's face into the pavement. It's a very rare bicycle accident that throws the rider's head/face directly into the pavement- which means that bicycle helmets aren't designed to protect the face! So even the most common form of protection is much less effective for scooter riders. The electric scooter is much closer in safety profile to the electric unicycle, but the electric unicycles feel dangerous to riders, so people give them respect. The scooter seems like a child's toy, so people overlook the danger.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- endisneigh 4y agoThough this is certainly their right and I agree with the decision, I think this was sort of overplayed. What I personally would have liked to see is a "deposit" tax of $10- or some amount included in each rental. Then, if scooters are brought back to specific areas, determined by the city, the person who brings it back gets back their $10. I'm confident an appropriate deposit tax would've satisfied both parties and perhaps gave passerbys an incentive to pick them up.
- Treegarden 4y agoSomething vaguely similar happened in Berlin: They banned parking rental 50cc scooters on the pavement, they have to be parked on the street, competing for parking with cars. To me this is a terrible rule, completely out of touch. Scooters improve the city as they are electric, small, and less dangerous to others. I have a car and in the summer I often pay a few euros to rent those electric 50cc scooters because they are really nice. However, one of the major benefits is that you can park anywhere. There is a designated strip on the pedestrian walkway where it used to be allowed to park them, currently its only allowed for bicycles. There is more than enough room there and as its on the side it bothers no one. So banning them from there is not necessary. The real problem we have is not even about these specific 50cc scooters but about the smaller ones that are mentioned here. Which have not been affected by this ban. The real problem is that some bad people, maybe its the tourists, literally park them in the very middle of the walkway, blocking people and being terribly annoying. And for this, the solution would be harsh punishments. Eg. when someone parks their scooter this way they have to pay a massive fine or get banned or whatever. Maybe users could report them and get a bounty. So, while there is a real problem, the politicians, where I live, made this terrible decision. And when I came home, exhausted from work, there was actually parking right in front of my doorstep, but it was blocked by two rental scooters.
- Treegarden 4y agoSomething vaguely similar happened in Berlin: They banned parking rental 50cc scooters on the pavement, they have to be parked on the street, competing for parking with cars. To me this is a terrible rule, completely out of touch. Scooters improve the city as they are electric, small, and less dangerous to others. I have a car and in the summer I often pay a few euros to rent those electric 50cc scooters because they are really nice. However, one of the major benefits is that you can park anywhere. There is a designated strip on the pedestrian walkway where it used to be allowed to park them, currently its only allowed for bicycles. There is more than enough room there and as its on the side it bothers no one. So banning them from there is not necessary. The real problem we have is not even about these specific 50cc scooters but about the smaller ones that are mentioned here. Which have not been affected by this ban. The real problem is that some bad people, maybe its the tourists, literally park them in the very middle of the walkway, blocking people and being terribly annoying. And for this, the solution would be harsh punishments. Eg. when someone parks their scooter this way they have to pay a massive fine or get banned or whatever. Maybe users could report them and get a bounty. So, while there is a real problem, the politicians, where I live, made this terrible decision. And when I came home, exhausted from work, there was actually parking right in front of my doorstep, but it was blocked by two rental scooters.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoCan't say I'm surprised or disappointed by this. I tried a Lime in Paris in 2019 and it was a hair-raising experience. I'm accustomed to bicycling in city traffic but my overwhelming feeling on the Lime was "one slight mistake by me or a car driver and I'll instantly be dead." It seemed ridiculously dangerous compared to a bicycle. The danger factor plus all the dead Limes I saw in the Seine made the whole idea appear unsustainable.