20 ms·
The Contradictions of Sam Altman
- gardenfelder 4y agohttps://archive.ph/YTOeD https://archive.ph/YTOeD
- wslh 4y agoSidenote: I just reported to archive.is that it would be great to have the capability to render it throught services such as Pocket.
- eternalban 4y agoNone of archive.* are working for me - cloudflare dns issues. Anyone else has access issues? [thanks to those who replied. strangely stopped working for me since yesterday [US]. can you post the ip you see? Cloudflare returns a 1001 error: "Ray ID: 7b128f151e4b0c90 • 2023-04-01 17:30:15 UTC" ]
- wslh 4y agoNo issue here (Buenos Aires).
- marginalia_nu 4y agoWorks for me
- version_five 4y agoWorks for me in western europe
- mrlambchop 4y agoDoes not work here either. Cloudflare error page is all I get.
- schiffern 4y agoLooks like the media has chosen Sam Altman as the next Elon Musk. This makes sense. He perfectly fits their cliche of a socially-awkward technologist, and he's trusting (foolish?) enough to make complex nuanced statements in public, which they can easily mine for out-of-context clickbait and vilification fodder.
- greyman 4y agoWhat would make him "socially-awkward"?
- schiffern 4y agoSam or Elon? I'll assume you meant Sam. IMO Sam is mostly just shy and cerebral, but to many people that will come off as awkward and robotic. Watch his recent Lex Fridman interview. Personally I thought it was great, but I'm aware enough to realize that (sadly) many low-knowledge people will judge such demeanor harshly. Mark my words: the media will, 10 times out of 10, exploit that misconception, not correct it. "Ye knew my nature when you let me climb upon your back..."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lubesGordi 4y agoI don't know, it seemed to me his responses on Lex were very measured and carefully restrained in a lot of places, calculated and vague in others. He doesn't come off as genuine to me at all.
- drewcoo 4y agoIf you mean the one where the interviewer, Lex, was wearing a suit and Sam was in a hoodie, where Sam droned in a robotic monotone and often sat with crossed arms, staring downward . . . I think the knowledgeable people might also assume he's the next evil tech overlord. Or certainly distant and uncaring. The only things missing were lighting from below and scenes of robots driving human slaves.
- gamesbrainiac 4y agoI think there are some interesting questions: - Sam does not have equity in OpenAI. Does this mean he can potentially be removed at any point in time? - OpenAI's profit arm will funnel excess profit to its non-profit wing. If this is the case, who determines excess profit? - OpenAI's founding charter commits the company to abandoning research efforts if another project nears AGI development. If this happens, what happens to the profit arm?
- whitepoplar 4y agoI refuse to believe that Sam doesn't have equity in OpenAI. It must be some 4D-chess-style ownership structure, which I'm guessing is for tax avoidance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 4y agoIt's nothing special, there's a company under the foundation, he doesn't have share in the company, he's ceo and board member of the foundation. It's just this one non-important detail is now being repeated over and over.
- boeingUH60 4y ago> It must be some 4D-chess-style ownership structure, which I'm guessing is for tax avoidance. How would this even work? If only I got a dollar for someone suggesting that there are Magic ways to avoid tax…”they just write it off!”
- namaria 4y agoMagic is just a word for things we don't understand. As a poor wage slave sap, I'm 100% sure the world is run by magic guilds, i.e. a bunch of powerful people conspiring stuff I could never fathom. Whatever gets to my eyes and ears has been approved for public disclosure. I don't know shit, everything is magic to me. I kinda know how to survive. So far.
- nadermx 4y agoMeh, the contradiction seems to be that creating a source of power, be it via a physical or virtual means is different. It is not. A tool, is and always will be, a tool.
- antirez 4y agoI believe you can't, at the same time, accuse OpenAI of benefitting of ideas mostly invented elsewhere, and also claim that they are in a predominant position. It does not make any sense, and they are not naturally positioned for a monopoly. Just other companies have to move their asses.
- tomlue 4y agoI'm a fan of OpenAI, but this is nonsense. All of human existence is mostly other people's ideas. Among a ridiculously huge list of other things, OpenAI benefits from the mountains of labor that made scalable neural networks possible. Have they had their own good ideas? Definitely. Are they benefitting of ideas mostly invented elsewhere? Also Definitely, just like everybody else.
- antirez 4y agoI don't think you understood me. I'm with you, but given that often OpenAI is accused of using public ideas for profit, this, in turn, means they are obviously not in a dominant position. So far they are just better than the others.
- version_five 4y agoI'm not really a fan of openAI, but I think we're seeing the classic mistake of confusing product with technology. Steve Jobs / Apple didn't anything you'd call new ideas either (obvious cliche but so is the criticism). It's execution and design once the tech reaches a certain level
- tomlue 4y agomostly agree. Though I wouldn't underestimate the tech and engineering work behind OpenAI. That microsoft partnership is no joke.
- poopypoopington 4y agoI've heard Altman (on the Lex Friedman podcast) and Sundar Pichai (on the Hard Fork podcast) say things to this degree. The thing that OpenAI really managed to crack was building a great product in ChatGPT and finding a good product market fit for LLMs.
- m3kw9 4y agoOpenAI getting rich now everyone wants a piece and everyone fighting over it like a billion dollar inheretence fight. In a round about way, if GPT5 is nearly as advertised, watch the govt swoop in under national security guise
- oldstrangers 4y agoUndoubtedly OpenAI already has some very close ties and/or contracts with the DoD.
- jstx1 4y agoAny evidence for this, or are you just assuming that it's the case?
- roflyear 4y agoTo me it overstates what is achieved. This isn't AGI. Unsure how much the government would care about this.
- polycaster 4y agoDon’t now about the DoD, but one of the board members of the nonprofit is Will Hurd, who appears to have had a 9 year career in the CIA before turning to politics. No hard evidence of anything of course, but enough to raise an eyebrow imho.
- reducesuffering 4y agoWill Hurd is/was a managing director at Allen & Company, who runs the Sun Valley conference where this article talked about Satya Nadella and Sam Altman "bumping into each other" to secure the deal. It's looking more and more like OpenAI is the Manhattan project as AGI is to nuclear weapons.
- unshavedyak 4y ago> if GPT5 is nearly as advertised, watch the govt swoop in under national security guise Re: GPT5, are there any .. reasonable/credible sources of information on the subject? I've become deaf from all the speculation and while i am very curious, i'm unsure if anything substantiated has actually come out. Especially when considering speculation from Sam himself.
- mongol 4y agoHow did he become so rich? His Wikipedia page does not have much details on this.
- naillo 4y agoI'd imagine he got to invest early in a lot of successful YC companies during his time there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ftxbro 4y agoPaul Graham is his Les Wexner. "Sam Altman, the co-founder of Loopt, had just finished his sophomore year when we funded them, and Loopt is probably the most promising of all the startups we've funded so far. But Sam Altman is a very unusual guy. Within about three minutes of meeting him, I remember thinking 'Ah, so this is what Bill Gates must have been like when he was 19.'" "Honestly, Sam is, along with Steve Jobs, the founder I refer to most when I'm advising startups. On questions of design, I ask "What would Steve do?" but on questions of strategy or ambition I ask "What would Sama do?" What I learned from meeting Sama is that the doctrine of the elect applies to startups. It applies way less than most people think: startup investing does not consist of trying to pick winners the way you might in a horse race. But there are a few people with such force of will that they're going to get whatever they want."
- version_five 4y agoIf anyone has read "Wild Sheep Chase" by Haruki Murukami, there was the idea of being possessed by the sheep which turned one into a forceful business man. I have only met a couple people like this, but as in the quote it's immediately obvious, and you see why they are where they are.
- gautamcgoel 4y agoIn my opinion, this book is his most underrated book. It's very funny, highly recommend!
- ThomPete 4y agoListening to Sam talking with Lex Fridman about the dangers and ethics of AI while his company destroys entire industries as a consequence of their decision to keep GPT4 closed source and spitting out an apex api aggregator is one for the history books. Well played :)
- nomel 4y ago> destroys entire industries as a consequence of their decision to keep GPT4 closed source Could you expand in that?
- avgcorrection 4y agoLike contemporary language models, some HN commenters read the text itself in isolation and then extrapolate about “what that means” but then immediately jump to the conclusion that whatever real-world (beyond the text) that they imagine will eventually happen has in fact already happened—in effect they’re hallucinating.
- HlessClaudesman 4y agoPerhaps if more CEOs / controlling shareholders were criminally liable for damage caused by their products, like the Sackler family, they wouldn't be so gung-ho.
- leetharris 4y agoWhat a ridiculous take and a slippery slope. Should car manufacturers be liable for drunk drivers? Should kitchen knife manufacturers be responsible for stabbings? Your idea is great if you want your country to be left behind entirely in innovation.
- dclowd9901 4y agoWorth reminding that the slippery slope argument is not a valid argument at all. As with standard slippery slope reasoning, you jump to the most extreme interpretation. Yet reality shows us that you cannot, in fact, boil a frog, because at some point it just gets too fucking hot. Should car manufacturers be liable for drunk drivers? Maybe, if they include a space in their vehicle specifically to store and serve alcohol. Should kitchen knife manufacturers be responsible for stabbings? No. But no reasonable person would ever suggest they should. I might remind you also that “reasonable standard” is a legal concept.
- robertlagrant 4y agoWithout defining the reasonable standard, it remains a silly idea in this case.
- efficientsticks 4y ago> The goal, the company said, was to avoid a race toward building dangerous AI systems fueled by competition and instead prioritize the safety of humanity. > “You want to be there first and you want to be setting the norms,” he said. “That’s part of the reason why speed is a moral and ethical thing here.” Clearly having either not learned or ignored the lessons from Black Mirror and 1984, which is that others will copy and emulate the progress. The fact is that capitalism is no safe place to develop advanced capabilities. We have the capability for advanced socialism, just not the wisdom or political will. (I’ll answer the anonymous downvote: Altman has advocated giving equity as UBI solution. It’s a well-meaning technocratic idea to distribute ownership, but it ignores human psychology and that this idea has already been attempted in practice in 1990s Russia, with unfavourable, obvious outcomes).
- sampo 4y ago> lessons from Black Mirror and 1984 Those are works of fiction.
- efficientsticks 4y agoThey’re dystopian fictions, ie. examples of what not to do. But experience has shown that the real-world often recreates dystopian visions by example. So trying to be the first to show something in a well-meaning way can nonetheless have unfortunate consequences once the example is copied.
- latency-guy2 4y agoTell me, are the dystopian fictions that represent socialism or communism as bad, just as reasonable? Then following up with whatever your answer is: Why are you picking and choosing which fictions are reasonable? Let's dispel the notion that artists and writers are more aware and in tune with humanity than other humans.
- roywiggins 4y ago1984's Oceania is at least as Stalinist as it is anything else.
- tdsone3 4y agohttps://archive.is/YTOeD https://archive.is/YTOeD
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Overtonwindow 4y agoAI is not true AI.. at the moment. ChatGPT is inherently biased by its developers, which means at least half the population may not trust its answers. For true AI he will have to give it autonomy, and I'm more interested if Altman is ready to live with an AI he cannot control.
- washywashy 4y agoOpenAI/ChatGPT seem to be very creative based on variations it can make on “things” that already exist. I’m just curious if we see AI being truly creative and making something “new”. Perhaps everything is based on something though, and that’s a rough explanation for this creativity. Maybe AI’s true creativity can come from the input prompts of its “less intelligent”, but more flexibly creative users.
- iibarea 4y agoThere's tons of extremely effective marketing around who this guy is, what he stands for - and so I'd instead look at what he's done. He took a non-profit intended to offset the commercial motives driving AI development, and turned it into a for profit closely tied to Microsoft. I think he's an extremely shrewd executive and salesman, but nothing he's done suggests any altruistic motivations - that part always seems to be just marketing, and always way down the road.
- startupsfail 4y agoWhat I’m afraid of is that he and Ilya are not as good and smart as they paint themselves. And that a lot of key people had left (i.e. to Anthropic). And that by pure inertia they have GPT-5 on their hands and not much control over where this technology is going. I can’t tell for certain, but it does look like one of their corner pieces, the ChatGPT system prompt which sits at the funnel of the data collection had degraded significantly from the previous version. Had the person that was the key to the previous design left? Or it no longer matters? One could argue that OpenAI is very hot and everyone would want to work there. But a lot of newcomers only create more pressure for the key people. And then there is the inevitable leakage problem.
- bmitc 4y ago> What I’m afraid of is that he and Ilya are not as good and smart as they paint themselves. This describes almost any venture capitalist or high-profile startup founders, as far as I can tell. Most don't realize their either privileged path or lucky path or both had more to do with it than their smarts. I really like James Simons as he mostly attributes his success to luck and being able to hire and organize smart people and give them the tools they need to work. He basically describes it as luck and taste, despite his actual smarts and his enormous impact on the world.
- saghm 4y ago> I really like James Simons as he mostly attributes his success to luck and being able to hire and organize smart people and give them the tools they need to work. He basically describes it as luck and taste, despite his actual smarts and his enormous impact on the world. Plenty of really smart people don't end up having a big impact on the world, and it's possible to make a difference without being an outlier in terms of intelligence. Everyone who has made an impact has benefited to some degree by circumstances beyond their control though, so even if someone is genuinely smarter than anyone else, it's a fallacy for them to assume that it was the determining factor in their success and a guarantee of future success.
- dclowd9901 4y agoAre there any employees of OpenAI around? I had a question: Does anyone in the office stop to contemplate the ramifications of developing technology that will likely put most people out of a job, which will have a whole host of knock-on effects?
- galoisscobi 4y agoMaybe Sam thinks about this at some level. From his New Yorker profile[0]: > "The other most popular scenarios would be A.I. that attacks us and nations fighting with nukes over scarce resources.” The Shypmates looked grave. “I try not to think about it too much,” Altman said. “But I have guns, gold, potassium iodide, antibiotics, batteries, water, gas masks from the Israeli Defense Force, and a big patch of land in Big Sur I can fly to.” This doesn't explicitly talk about him being worried about AI putting a lot of people out of jobs but he is prepping for AI going awry. [0]: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/10/10/sam-altmans-manifest-destiny https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/10/10/sam-altmans-ma...
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoThe fact that his backup plan if things go really wrong is to bug out, damn the rest of the world, is, to put it mildly, not great.
- NickBusey 4y agoSelf checkout machines put people out of a job. Cars put stable boys out of jobs. Light bulbs put candlemakers out of jobs. Are the people who made them also morally culpable? Let’s just make no progress ever in the name of employment I guess. /s
- sammalloy 4y ago> Self checkout machines put people out of a job. Have they, though? Is there good data on this? I haven’t seen anyone lose any jobs over this in my area. They either get reassigned to different departments or get better jobs doing the same thing in companies that refuse to use self-checkouts. And I read here just a month or so ago that Amazon closed many of their "no cashier" stores in NY and Trader Joe’s vowed to never use them. > Light bulbs put candlemakers out of jobs I would guess that such artisans moved on to other niche products. Where I live, candlemakers today make a lot of money, and I had a chance to watch them do their thing in their small commercial space. This was a one person operation, no employees and no mechanization, and judging by the amount of product they were creating and their wholesale prices, they were pulling in about about 300k a year or more, after taking into account supplies.
- balls187 4y agoWhen will we get the “Contradictions of Dang?”
- davidgerard 4y agodidn't know Thiel had helped start this here Y Combinator
- dang 4y agoHe didn't. That sentence was a bit confusingly written but "co-founded" binds only to the second name.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoShould we also talk about the contradictions of WSJ? The only way to never contradict yourself is to never say anything. Now, is AI the right work area to "move fast and break things"? no.
- victor106 4y ago> OpenAI and Microsoft also created a joint safety board, which includes Mr. Altman and Microsoft Chief Technology Officer Kevin Scott, that has the power to roll back Microsoft and OpenAI product releases if they are deemed too dangerous. what a joke. find me one instance where the ceo of a company picked public interest/safety over profits when there was no regulatory oversight?
- dragonelite 4y agoDo people really think AI will go haywire like in the Hollywood movies?
- barbazoo 4y agoI don't think it's about AI going haywire, more about how the technology will be used by people for nefarious purposes.
- benrutter 4y agoI don't for one, but I still think there could be legitimate safety concerns. LLMs are unpredictable, and the possibility for misinformation in pitching them as search aggregators is pretty large. Disinformation can have, and previously has had, genuinely dangerous effects.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoSome do. Personally I think that LLMs will hit a ceiling eventually way before AGI. Just like self driving - the last 20% is orders of magnitude more difficult than the first 80%
- gwd 4y agoNot like in Hollywood movies, but yes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gA1sNLL6yg4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gA1sNLL6yg4 https://www.alignmentforum.org/s/mzgtmmTKKn5MuCzFJ https://www.alignmentforum.org/s/mzgtmmTKKn5MuCzFJ Look around alignmentforum.org or lesswrong.com, and you'll see loads of people who are worried / concerned at various levels about what could happen if we suddenly create an AI that's smarter than us. I've got my own summary in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35281504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35281504 But this discussion has actually been going on for nearly two decades, and there is a lot of things to read up on. EtA: Or, for a fun version: https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html
- sacnoradhq 4y agoSama <3 He stuck to the 99.9% gamble of setting money on fire that were startups and navigated to the big time(tm). Also, he helped lift Clerky, Triplebyte, YC, and may others pre, during, and post Loopt. Not many people (or no one) "deserves" success, but Sama brings a healthy dose of goodwill wherever he goes.
- w3454 4y ago[dead]
- choppaface 4y agoTriplebyte and Loopt both ended up selling / monetizing user data in ways the users really didn’t like.
- jackblemming 4y agoAre you kidding? He had one startup that was more or less a flop, then for some reason was appointed to a high position at y combinator, got lucky allocating capital (plenty of idiots can and have gotten lucky or were at the right place at the right time) and now is the CEO of OpenAI. This man is the definition of it’s not what you know, it’s who you know, and that’s not a good thing.
- boeingUH60 4y agoAltman befriended Paul Graham, and his life blossomed…
- sacnoradhq 4y agoEven with the best ideas, execution, and teams 99.99% of startups are. That's okay. They're assumed to be experiments. There is no such thing as self-made. And there's nothing wrong with friends and networking, especially as some particular help or chance encounter could be pivotal to nudging onto something great. It's the trying and learning that are the gold to try again. Timing, honest perspective, persistence, and a measure of prepared luck seem to be more of it. There is no magic formula. I wish success to all who want it.
- 4y ago
- leobg 4y agoThe contradiction I noticed during his Lex interview was him talking about being attacked by Elon Musk. He said it reminded him of how Elon once said he felt when the Apollo astronauts lobbied against SpaceX. Elon said it made him sad. Those guys were his heroes. And that the wish they would come visit and look at the work SpaceX was doing. I found that comparison by Altman disingenuous. First, he didn’t seem so much sad as he seemed angry. At one point in the interview, he said that he thought about some day attacking back. That’s not at all how Elon had felt about those astronauts. And second, why doesn’t Altman just invite Elon and show him the work they are doing? Wouldn’t take more than a phone call.
- bagacrap 4y agoOn top of that, the astronauts never actually attacked Elon. The interviewer played it up into something it wasn't. (Not sure why Elon went along with it.) Sama reminds me strongly of Elon. Since the new economy seems to mostly revolve around hype I suppose they will be rivals.
- leobg 4y agoOh they did. There was this congressional hearing where Gene Cernan argued against giving SpaceX any missions, saying essentially they, as private enterprise, were incompetent and a disaster waiting to happen. “They don’t know what they don’t know”, he said (to which Elon rightfully said that this applies to anyone anytime). The difference, to me, is this: Elon really did look up to those astronauts. And what they said made him sad. Sam claims that he looks up to Elon. But what Elon says doesn’t make him sad. It makes him angry. Because, I believe, he also sees him as a rival and compares himself to him.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoStop asking the market to look after collective interest. This is the job of the government. The ultimate effect of virtue wanking CEOs and corporate governance is to deceive people into thinking democracy is something that can be achieved by for profit organizations and that they can forsake the formal binding of collective interest through law. It's nice if people are nice but it is not a bulwark of the collective good. It is a temporary social convenience. The higher that niceness exists in the social order, the greater its contemporary benefit but also, the more it masks the vulnerability of that social benefit. It matters if Sam Altman is Ghandi or Genghis Khan in a concrete way but you, as a citizen must act as if it doesn't matter. If AI poses a danger to the social good, no amount of good guy CEOs will protect us. The only thing that will is organization and direct action.
- dantheman 4y agoIn general governments have done far more harm to individuals than anyone in the market. The job of the government is to protect your individual rights not the collective interest.
- majormajor 4y agoThat's just quibbling over what "your individual rights" are; where does the line get drawn between "exercising my right" and "having my rights infringed on by the actions of another." There is no shortage of harm done by "anyone in the market" today, whether it's currently illegal and we call it "crime" instead of just a person exercising their freedom, or whether it's harm that isn't regulated today.
- 7e 4y agoPromoting the general welfare is literally discussed in the first paragraph of the U.S. Constitution. The Bill of Rights came later.
- clarkmoody 4y agoThe Constitution is just a piece of paper. For every thousand steps the Congress, regulators, and state assemblies take in the direction of tyranny, the courts claw back one or two.
- mimd 4y agoHe's begging for regulatory capture. "I can destroy the world but I won't. My competitor's will, so regulate them." A shrewd plan considering he's not offering something beyond what another company with a large nvidia cluster could offer.
- dmix 4y agoThe odds that is the end game of the AI ethics movement is pretty likely: A mega-monopoly AI firm with a wall of gov policy that will cripple any upstart who can't jump through "safety" hoops written for and by the parent company. So any talented dev who wants to do great AI work either has to work for parent company or build a startup designed to get acquired by them (aka don't rattle the cage).
- sebzim4500 4y agoI think that's the goal but there is a reasonable chance that they completely fail and no serious regulation ever gets passed. That's the thing with technology, people get used to it and then trying to ban/control it makes you look ridiculous. It's like how now that Tesla has made it normal to have driving assistance (and calling it FSD) there is little appetite outside of contrarian circles for serious regulation. If, however, regulation was proposed before Tesla shipped then it might have passed.
- dmix 4y agoNever underestimate the pull in politics for calls to "protect the children", stop x-ism/x-phobia/etc, foreign boogiemen, or lack of control by law enforcement/Intel agencies... or merely the revolving door that will start once companies like OpenAI become massive and their ex "AI ethics" execs are the ones writing the policy to protect us all from ourselves. These sorts of "public/private" control patterns and the destruction of competition while maintaining private monopoly control in the pursuit of "safety"/"equity" is America's most reliable religion. HN is always full of people pushing for it in one way or the other, so it's not entirely foreign to us either. Nor something we can merely blame on politicians or some intentional conspiracy by a subset of the population.
- mellosouls 4y agoThere seems a lot of negative perception of the guy here, and OpenAI definitely deserve criticism for some stuff (so as the CEO, so does he), but - even if it was built on the work of others, and with the obvious caution about what may come next - he and they deserve immense respect and credit for bringing in this new AI age. They did it. Nobody else.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anileated 4y agoI for one have nothing against Sam as a person (not knowing him well enough), but I question the sentiment that he and the company deserve respect for what they’re doing—much less by default, for some self-evident reason that doesn’t even require explanation. Do people mean it in a sarcastic sense—and if not, why does OpenAI deserve respect again? — Because it is non-trivial (in the same way, say, even Lenin deserves respect by default—even if the outcome has been disastrous, the person sure had some determination and done humongous work)? — Because this particular tech is somehow inherently a good thing? (Why?) — Because they rolled it out in a very ethical way with utmost consideration for the original authors (at least those still living), respecting their authorship rights and giving them the ability to opt in or at least opt out? — Because they are the ones who happen to have 10 billions of Microsoft money to play with? — Because they don’t try to monetize a brave new world in which humans are verified based on inalienable personal traits like iris scans, which they themselves are bringing about[0]? This is me stating why they shouldn’t have respect by default and counting to get a constructive counter-argument in return. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35398829 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35398829
- okareaman 4y agoThis is a very fluid and chaotic situation so I'd be more concerned if he said one thing and stuck to it When the Facts Change, I Change My Mind. What Do You Do, Sir? - John Maynard Keynes A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do. He may as well concern himself with his shadow on the wall - Ralph Waldo Emerson Do I contradict myself? / Very well then, I contradict myself. / (I am large, I contain multitudes) - Walt Whitman's “Song of Myself”
- PostOnce 4y agoThat's all well and good, but it's not well and good to change what you say because the calculus of what will personally benefit you has changed. It's not the same as "new information coming to light", it is instead greed. We've already seen a charity robbed to no end other than Profit. Commercializing OpenAI was for one reason: to enrich the people commercializing it. Not to benefit society, and with nary a thought given to the consequences. Control of AI serves one purpose, in Altman's mind, I am convinced: to prevent other people from eating the chickens he counted too early. If ten million people lose their jobs to ChatGPT, it's fine as long as Altman & Co grow richer, but if those same people try to democratize AI and make his time and investment valueless in the face of a commoditized category of software, all the sudden he has a problem and those people should be constrained by the government -- but Altman should not? This won't be the first time greed failed.
- pffft8888 4y agoAltman is v2.0 of Zuckerberg, with 1000X more parameters. I'm worried about v3.0
- femiagbabiaka 4y agoThe discourse about lost jobs is necessary but a little odd: leveraging VC money and software driven automation to take over sectors ripe for the picking is the startup model in a box.
- 4y ago
- breck 4y agoI love what OpenAI has built and it's awesome to see them succeed on the AI front (also I'm forever amazed to see SamA live up to the Lebron James early level hype about his entrepreneurial skills). This article sheds more light on how the non-profit front failed. I find that to be a very hard and interesting problem. IMO, it points to a larger problem with our current laws, where trying to do good and compete fairly is made much harder (near impossible?) when you compete against companies that exploit unfair monopolistic laws.
- ur-whale 4y agohttps://archive.is/Quo4t https://archive.is/Quo4t
- moron4hire 4y agoI'd be very happy to see existing regulation on safety critical software systems updated to put a moratorium on AI integration for at least the next 5, maybe 10 years.
- molodec 4y agoAltman "hadn’t been to a grocery store in four or five years". He is so out of touch with real world, people needs and desires, and fantasies about the future world based on the assumption that most people want to be free "to pursue more creative work." I think most people don't actually dream about pursuing creative work. Being absolutely "free" of work doesn't make one more creative. Real problems and constraints force people to come up with creative solutions.
- hackerlight 4y agoHe's closer to the truth than you're letting on. People do want to be free from being forced to work to meet rent and buy food, and all the associated stress that comes with it.
- molodec 4y agoSure, some do, but this is not universal truth. Here is what ChatGPT4 has to say about the subject "As an AI language model, I don't have personal experiences or opinions, but I can provide a general analysis of the topic. People's preferences and attitudes toward work, financial security, and stress vary greatly based on their personal beliefs, values, and experiences. Many people do express a desire for greater financial freedom and independence, as well as relief from the stress of meeting basic needs like paying rent and buying food. The notion of a Universal Basic Income (UBI) has gained popularity in recent years, which proposes providing a fixed sum of money to every citizen regardless of their employment status. Advocates of UBI argue that it could help address issues of poverty, income inequality, and stress related to meeting basic needs. However, people's perspectives on work and financial stress are diverse, and not everyone shares the same view on this issue. Some people may find satisfaction and purpose in their work and might not want to be completely free from it. Others may be more focused on career advancement, personal growth, or contributing to their communities through work. Ultimately, people's preferences regarding work, financial security, and stress are influenced by a wide range of factors, including their cultural backgrounds, socioeconomic status, personal values, and life experiences."
- pylua 4y agoWe need legislation that is opt-in only when data is to be used to train models. If users feel like their work has been stolen to use in non human models then they should be able to sue and get a list of the training data . This is a good way way to start democratizing ai.
- ftxbro 4y agoWhat if the contradictions arise from efforts to hide a Manhattan scale government project racing to superhuman machine intelligence but which requires help from talented researchers outside of Fort Meade?
- d1l 4y agoThis is a straight up puff piece and very weak journalism. ChatGPT might as well have written it.
- polycaster 4y agoTrivia: I just noticed that sama left the very first comment on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1
- muzani 4y ago"Tensions also grew with Mr. Musk, who became frustrated with the slow progress and pushed for more control over the organization, people familiar with the matter said." Imagine if this happened with OpenAI instead of Twitter.
- Julesman 4y agoLarger corporations, profit and non-profit, DO NOT CARE ABOUT PEOPLE. Period! Some of the people in them do. There are good people all around us. And knowing some of them we may be fooled into thinking that the system we are all a part of has a conscience. It does not. I'm not talking about small or even medium sized business or non-profits. Some great things happening out there. But past a certain size all businesses simply serve a profit motive and the status quo. And for those paying attention, the status quo is post-imperial decay. Putrified late-stage capitalism that we can only really ignore on big doses of entertainment and our legal or illegal drugs of choice. Large corporations do NOT regulate themselves in any way. They are not able to serve any public good. Before the '80s our government did serve several regulatory purposes. But the military/industrial intelligence apparatus has dismantled that effectively for so long that our government is simply a means of placating the populace with the thin illusion of balance. These are basic historical facts. Facts that the public, on either side of the political spectrum, are ever more able to argue against due to declining literacy and media echo chambers full of simple lies and convenience logical fallacies. Both corporations and our government do not serve the public good except to an ever smaller degree required to maintain the social order. </endofrant>
- dinvlad 4y agoIt's not really AI we're talking, they haven't achieved an artificial Intelligence. The sooner we realize that, the sooner this overhype dies and we don't end up with another massively over-valued trillion-dollar company.
- csomar 4y agoIt's funny how no one sees it. Sam Altman is a "successful" entrepreneur, yet he never had a successful company. He made loopt, a defunct company which raised serious money at the time, and then he suddenly made it to YC as a partner. He, then, quickly rose through the ranks to become president of YC. Think of that for a second. OpenAI is a company that can barely ship a functioning website, or have proper security for basic stuff. You'd not expect this company to be the future of AI, do you? OpenAI is not doing anything particularly special compared the LLM we have out there except they were a bit ahead and they spent more money on training. Other LLMs are catching up fast in a very short period of time. Sam Altman is a master of pump&dump. He is very successful at creating hype and based on the number of people here who thinks OpenAI is the legit future of AI, I'd say he is pretty damn good at it too. See you in 5 years.
- davidatbu 4y ago> OpenAI is a company that can barely ship a functioning website, or have proper security for basic stuff. You'd not expect this company to be the future of AI, do you? In case you didn't know: ML researchers are infamous for being bad at traditional software engineering. That's why, I personally don't think whether a company can "proper security for basic stuff" has much correlation with probability of achieving AGI.
- indus 4y agoAs a society we increasingly focus on who is providing the input rather than what the output is for the society. When Otis designed the elevator that would not do a free fall in case of a power failure—-he was looked from the lens of a charlatan rather than a significant output that helped society climb the tallest skyscrapers without effort. Whether Sam is Dr Jekyll or Mr Hyde hardly matters, but can he concoct a potion that prevents the society from transforming into evil.
- theGnuMe 4y agoI think GPT5 will have voice probably as input and output and maybe generative diffusion. You probably need some fact checking on that output though, maybe you can feed that output into GPT4 module fine-tuned for reality vs make believe.
- fijiaarone 4y agoYou can tell a fraud by the quality of their photos in the sycophant press.
- braindead_in 4y agoAs a fellow believer in the equivalence of Bramhan and Atman, I can't help but think that the only ones amused by the current situation with AI are the Nondualists. Sama seems to be one of them [1]. So, I say to sama, be fearless and invent the future. After all, it's not something new, and in the end, everyone is destined for liberation. Let's enjoy the ride and see where it takes us! [1] https://twitter.com/sama/status/1607482407770554373 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1607482407770554373
- beatehester 4y ago[flagged]
- quattrofan 4y ago[dead]
- moomoo11 4y agoThey should figure out how to upload people into the AI so they can be programs that ensure everything is working fine.
- noduerme 4y agoTo all the detractors of work ethic and the supporters of UBI: What freedom will exist in a world where everyone is reliant on their government for survival, and all mass communication is mediated by or written by opaque AIs? In trading the yoke of labor for free time we would also trade our independence, and any hope of changing the structure of power that had been set in place. I'm so sick of our new style of wannabe rulers/overlords who use the promise of freeing humanity from labor as the appeal to grant them total power. It's an appeal, among other things, to the basest sloth and laziness. "Imagine what you would do if you never had to work" is a daytime talk show hook, and a way to lure people into gambling and playing the lottery and investing in crypto. It's not a revolutionary slogan, it's the oldest con in the book.
- arrrg 4y agoEveryone (to a close approximation) is already reliant on their government for survival. Taking yourself out of society and its interdependencies is already basically impossible. (This is not an argument against all points you are making, I just wanted to say something to that aspect of your comment.)
- zarzavat 4y agoThere’s a big difference between being indirectly dependent on the government to maintain society, and being hand-to-mouth dependent on the government for food/welfare. As most people who have been in the latter situation can attest (at least outside of super rich countries like Norway), it is a distinctly less dignified existence. You live in constant uncertainty that your source of food, source of existence could be withdrawn at any time by government fiat. This is the future our dear thought leaders want for us.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoCurrent state of the world: You live in constant uncertainty that your source of food, source of existence could be withdrawn at any time by corporate whim Question: Who do you think the police work for? Hint: It's neither "citizens" nor is it "the government" They work for corporations. Go look at how they act. The whole goal is to provide security for private property holders (aka not you) and increasingly they are private mercenaries that have day jobs as city/state/county policeman. Ask a cop where their "overtime" pay comes from and it's typically protecting some business. Economic and political power should be dispersed as much as possible into the hands of the citizens, not anyone who was able to wrest as much control as possible from others - which is how we apportion it. Do you ask "how did this company I'm applying to get to this position?" If not then you're not doing anything different than picking a political party without due diligence. The act of consolidating power destroys the ethical standing of the institution
- ChatGTP 4y agoJust a heads up, Sam will likely be running all these comments through “the machine” and learning how to influence his next blog post. Stay tuned.