16 ms·
1. 90% of the Application's Data are already in my LinkedIN, or my CV / Resume. Why the heck do I have to fill it in again. 2. Some companies even / still requ
by ksec 4y ago
1. 90% of the Application's Data are already in my LinkedIN, or my CV / Resume. Why the heck do I have to fill it in again.
2. Some companies even / still requires you bring your University Certificate or whatever as proof. For Pete sake. That was decades ago. Can I pay $5 to LinkedIn or whatever so once and for all they can verify it from there.
3. The other 8% of the application that I have not included details in my CV/ Resume or LinkedIn could have been reused across all applications. Why do I have rewrite it again.
4. You are not fucking suppose to verify or reference check on me before I even had my interview or offer. So now my boss / management knows I am job hunting?
5. By the time I get to the end of the application I am already exhausted depending how bad the day I had. And some form of PTSD from previous interview where i had to contain my thermonuclear anger or else going absolute animal against the HR / agent / interviewer. Because I have to be professional.
6. My thought on why all these are so bad is because job application, listing site, social network ( LinkedIn ) all work for hiring companies, they are the ones who pay them. And not job seekers. Someone needs to figure out a way where we can turn this around and empower ( I hate this word, but I dont have anything better in my vocab ) employees.
- mozman 4y agoEmployment is a relationship. If you can’t be bothered to do mundane work to apply how do I know you will dutifully complete those menial but necessary tasks that come with all jobs?
- jstanley 4y agoEmployment is a relationship. If you can't be bothered to treat me as a human being when I apply, how do I know you will dutifully treat me as a human being when I'm working for you?
- hobs 4y agoDo you normally fill out a 1 hour questionnaire with bizarre drop outs for your first dates? Don't accept the power imbalance that is the status quo.
- happyopossum 4y agoThat's a complete straw man. TFA we're discussing is about a 5 minute application process. Five. Freaking. Minutes. If you can't fill out a 5 minute form to get a job, that's a problem.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoIf their recruiter is "super impressed with my resume" and thinks I'd make great things happen at ${COMPANY}, then why can't they enter my experience into their proprietary system? I mean, they were so confident in their initial email to me. Were they not actually as amazed as they stated?
- hobs 4y agoMost job applications are not five minute processes, even for day laborers. Source: me, doing payroll for thousands of staffing companies.
- noirbot 4y agoIf the 5 minute form got me a job, sure. But it's a 5 minute form to chuck a bunch of my personal information into a black hole where, most likely, I'll never hear anything, or will get a form letter back in two weeks telling me they're not interested in me for the role I already have at a different company. So really, as OP put, it's 20-50 5-minute forms that are all exactly the same, so that you might get a single interview. Or you just know someone who works there and skip the whole thing because woo nepotism.
- registeredcorn 4y agoAren't the most valuable employees the ones that hate mundane and repetitive tasks, who find a means to make their work easier? A job is of little value if the man performing it has no interest in improving it. If I pay a man to move boxes from here to there, should I fault him for asking where the pallet jack is? Certainly not! When he was done with that, I had other things which he could be doing for me instead. I'd rather pay one man handsomely, than two adequately. A man who doesn't have a disdain for the inefficiency of the thing is the one I aim to replace.
- Y_Y 4y agoBecause I passed through the education system? Because I managed to hold other jobs previously? Hopefully you were joking, but it does seem like over and over you're required to go to the trouble of running little experiments on claims for which there already exist ample evidence in well-documented parts of my life.
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago>Can I pay $5 to LinkedIn why should you have to pay? They're the ones that want it.
- mingus88 4y agoI would prefer that they charge me for the service, if that means they keep my data private and don't sell it to any number of shady brokers who aren't acting in my best interest.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoOk good point, on the other hand I believe most modern corporations respond "Why not both"
- conviencefee999 4y agoIt's a legal requirement for termination if you lied about anything it's not legally bound. Linkedin can never solve these problems because well, it's impossible to. As for the background checks, that's usually done because of agreements with other companies to not poach other employees without forewarning. Which technically isn't illegal unlike the stuff Apple and the others used to do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- club_tropical 4y ago> 6. My thought on why all these are so bad is because job application, listing site, social network ( LinkedIn ) all work for hiring companies, they are the ones who pay them. And not job seekers. It is even worse: They work for HR departments in those companies, whose primary goal is 1) to produce automated reports and statistics about their “pipeline” so they seem important 2) have an auditable paper trail for legal risk, and a distant 3) hire people. Ultimately, there are only 2 kinds of companies: owner/majority shareholder operated or manager/minority shareholder operated. Owner operated companies have far quicker and more painless procedures- so you can prioritize those. For manager-run companies, you need to find an inside human recruiter first, before applying. This is more legwork, but it will ensure that 1) your application is not in vain, a human will take a look 2) none of the pre-calling references 3) might even let you talk to some teams informally.
- gadders 4y ago>> 1. 90% of the Application's Data are already in my LinkedIN, or my CV / Resume. Why the heck do I have to fill it in again. Not only that, but the terrible Taleo software consistently fails to import a CV without completely failing to parse it and leaving you to manual update what was imported.
- BeFlatXIII 4y ago…and it's not like it goes to some centralized Taleo tracking system when all the inane details can be pre-populated on the next application you send.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoWhy isn't there a json based schema standard at this point? At the very least you import once, clean it up once, save the clean version, and then upload that one going forward? There's got to be a smarter way.
- stevekemp 4y agoThere have been several attempts, such as: https://jsonresume.org/schema/ https://jsonresume.org/schema/ But nobody uses them, because nobody uses them. LinkedIn and other proprietary recruitment services like TeamTailor want to keep all the details locked in - there's no advantage to them to allow you to mass import/export candidate details.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoNo one uses them because I don't think I've even seen an application process that offers it. Mind you, I rarely get to the end of those because that's why I have a CV. That said, why doesn't LinkedIn throw its weight behind this? In that context, it would make sense to have and maintain my CV there. With some sort of authorization confirmation that would let a 3rd party import it into their system?
- jabroni_salad 4y agoMaybe google can come up with a way to profit off indexing resumes so it becomes desirable to do so. As fun as it is to rip on recipe blog it's really nice how standardized they've gotten so your plugins can yoink them easily.
- trentnix 4y ago4. You are not fucking suppose to verify or reference check on me before I even had my interview or offer. So now my boss / management knows I am job hunting? Many years ago, I posted my resume on a job site to see what my options were. An enterprising recruiter called my current (at the time) workplace asking if they'd need help filling the position I might be leaving. To make his pitch, he asked to speak to the "hiring manager", which happened to be me. He quickly hung up.
- danjoredd 4y agoThis is what terrifies me about leaving. My current job almost called the place I was working at to verify my employment, but I requested them to wait until the interviews were over, because my last boss was the kind of guy to fire people arbitrarily. Once he fired a guy for not working on his house...that employee was hired as help desk. Thankfully I passed all my interviews and they called him right after I was almost guaranteed to get the position. Took a few insults from the guy, but haven't heard anything from him since I left thankfully.
- number6 4y agoWhat stops your boss from lying to the company: danjoredd? Never heard of this guy. Never worked here and if he did, he would have done a lousy job. Glad I could help!
- sidewndr46 4y agoWhy would he need to lie? Couldn't he just tell the caller to stop wasting his time and hang up?
- selectodude 4y agoThe fact that it’s a slam dunk lawsuit for the plaintiff. https://www.justia.com/employment/defamation/ https://www.justia.com/employment/defamation/
- 4y ago
- cj 4y agoWhile I sympathize with the OP's complaints, as an employer (small 15 person company) I would defend most of these practices (employment verification, reference checks, university degree verification, etc) I've (literally) employed people who were working 3 jobs without any of the other employers knowing about one another. We were being scammed. This happened not just once, but with 2 people (1 full stack engineer who is a HN regular, and another was an account manager). This was at a 15 person company, and 2 out of the 15 were working multiple full-time W-2 jobs all with full time benefits. At the end they were both let go once we discovered the deception (their downfall was neither of them were meeting productivity expectations, not getting their work done) After this, we heavily beefed up our pre-employment screening, which is all of what this person is complaining about. Unfortunately there are people in the job market who scam companies. To find and weed these people out before they make it in the door, we need to do things like verify your degree (even if it was 20 years ago) not because we care whether you have a degree, but as a test to see if you were truthful on your resume. Edit: Also, if anyone requests reference checks from your current employer, you should say no. It's not standard practice to check current employer, only prior employers (at least in the US).
- imwillofficial 4y agoHow is it your business if your employee is moonlighting? If they are delivering, what’s the problem? If they are not delivering, other jobs are irrelevant, they aren’t meeting the bar.
- dinkleberg 4y agoMany of these people aren’t moonlighting, they are working both jobs in the same 40 hour work week. They are just half assing two (or more) jobs and putting in the bare minimum. Look up the overemployed subreddit.
- photochemsyn 4y agoHow is that different from a corporate board member who sits on several different corporate boards, which is a very common practice?
- chiefalchemist 4y ago> 4. You are not fucking suppose to verify or reference check on me before I even had my interview or offer. "We just met...You know very little about us...Now give us the personal details of 3 people that you know but we do not. Just trust us..." WTF? Really?? What kind of fool would go for that? This is another perfect example of my 1st Law of Hiring: How you hire is whom you hire. Full stop
- ukFxqnLa2sBSBf6 4y agothermonuclear rage? go to anger management
- pc86 4y agoSeriously, if you're raging out at unrelated people because you have a bad day, as an interviewer and potentially coworker I really want to know that, because I don't ever want to work anywhere near you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gumby 4y ago> 90% of the Application's Data are already in my LinkedIN... Why the heck do I have to fill it in again. Why isn’t LinkedIn providing this info as a glob of structured JSON for pay to the ATS sellers? Or just offering their own ATS for that matter? They could own the whole process from search (most recruiters just use LinkedIn anyway) to hire, as a springboard for expanding beyond there? They could go the other way too: fill out the application and it generates a LinkedIn profile for you. When my gf worked there there was a push to expand LinkedIn beyond “professionals” to trades.
- 542458 4y agoLinkedIn does have a jobs platform. I’m not an HR person, but the bits of it I used were pretty good. I liked the AI bit that auto-filtered-out people with nothing at all relevant on their resumes (which was pretty accurate from my spot checking).
- pc86 4y agoThese are all things that LinkedIn could and probably would do if it were its own company. But unfortunately it's owned by Microsoft, and there's just not enough revenue in these to justify it.
- gumby 4y agoThe purchase of LinkedIn made and makes no sense to me unless they increase its integration with other services. I know they are trying to integrate github and linkedin but that doesn't seem particularly useful or significant.
- twawaaay 4y ago
- the_only_law 4y agoYeah I guess a mindless drone who will exert themselves any tedious and inefficient thing is something companies may want.
- twawaaay 4y agoYou are getting paid for work done. Complaining that you actually have to do your end of the contract is just stupid and is why the job market is so broken. Remember, those hiring managers and HR are the same people as you -- got the paycheck, try to do as little as you can to just slip under the radar.
- ROTMetro 4y agoWait, are people getting paid to fill these applications out in your mind? Or are they not getting paid to do the work that hiring managers USED to do but are now TOO LAZY to do and have automated away? And why are businesses not cutting lazy management salaries now that their work has been moved to be automated?
- mjhay 4y ago> Remember, those hiring managers and HR are the same people as you -- got the paycheck, try to do as little as you can to just slip under the radar. Sounds like these companies should hire better HR people, because they aren't doing their jobs effectively. Also, remember applicants are not getting paid and they owe nothing to you. You seem to have a very entitled attitude towards applicant's time.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI know not everybody is going to agree with this, but cover letters are in most cases a complete waste of time. If you MUST see my writing then ask for a personal statement, I have that templated and ready to roll at a moment’s notice. You will clearly be able to tell if I can write.
- sibit 4y ago> You are not fucking suppose to verify or reference check on me before I even had my interview or offer. So now my boss / management knows I am job hunting? I've changed jobs 3 times in about ~10 years and this has happened to me both times. I want to leave my current position but the anxiety of dealing with this again is one of the primary reasons why I haven't started looking yet.
- happyopossum 4y ago> Some companies even / still requires you bring your University Certificate or whatever as proof What? I'm in my mid-late 40s and have NEVER been asked for a diploma (in the US). Is this a regional thing? What country are you in?
- idontpost 4y ago
- UncleOxidant 4y ago7. The websites for entering your application are across the board very buggy and there's apparently no incentive to fix them. The employer is unaware of the bugs and wonders why they're not getting "quality" applicants. The company that creates/manages these sites doesn't hear about any problems and is blissfully unaware. There's no way for an applicant to tell anyone about a bug they've encountered in the application process.
- piinecone 4y ago> Someone needs to figure out a way where we can turn this around and empower ( I hate this word, but I dont have anything better in my vocab ) employees My friend and I are trying to do this with a matching tool we've been working on lately. You describe what you're looking for (pay, schedule, etc.) and then you only hear about jobs that match your criteria: https://polyfill.work https://polyfill.work If you like the job, you can accept the match, and then you and the employer are introduced. It's early days still and we have plenty to iron out, but we've started making matches, so please check it out and let Ryan or I know what you think (at team at polyfill dot work).
- noirbot 4y agoIsn't this essentially what Hired does? I've actually had decent luck with them in the past.
- twblalock 4y agoYou must think you are special and that employers should be coming to you, or should suspend their normal hiring processes for you. Maybe you are -- but the vast majority of people are not. Most people need to jump through the hoops to get seen.
- noirbot 4y agoOr they think this situation and the "normal hiring processes" are stupid for everyone? The fact that all this redundant work, manual data entry, and hoop-jumping is the status quo doesn't make it good or fair or reasonable.
- twblalock 4y agoYou would have a different view of this if you were posting job offers and got hundreds, or thousands, of unqualified applicants and fraudsters piling on to every single one.
- noirbot 4y agoBut do almost any of the OP's complaints actually help with stopping that? Do fraudsters and the unqualified not have references and form-filling capabilities? I get that there's problems these things are trying to solve, but it doesn't seem like it's doing anything to solve them and it's frustrating all the people who aren't the ones you're trying to run off.
- user_named 4y agoThey're getting too many applications already. Making it difficult to apply its a feature, so they have fewer applications to sift through. But I am convinced that they do not look at incoming online applications anyway, or they down value them significantly. Applied online for a role - nothing. Got referred for the same later - instantly hired.
- plumeria 4y ago> 2. Some companies even / still requires you bring your University Certificate or whatever as proof. For Pete sake. That was decades ago. Can I pay $5 to LinkedIn or whatever so once and for all they can verify it from there. It would be ideal if universities could agree on an ISO standard for an XML document that could be used to emit digitally signed certificates. Also, on another one for transcripts. Then you could simply upload that to your LinkedIn profile and get a verified mark along your credential, you would see something similar like when you click to view an HTTP certificate (e.g. document verified by someuniversity.edu). One complication would be that university degrees need to be revocable. Digitally-signed documents, I believe, are all irrevocable. So perhaps just a standard XML format (no need for it to be signed). Then a graduate could just share a link like https://certificates.someuniversity.edu/<certificate-id>.xml https://certificates.someuniversity.edu/<certificate-id>.xml or something more sophisticated that supports some way of sharing expirable pre-signed URLs (you may not want to share it indefinitely).
- rushils 4y agoHey everyone, I am the founder of Simplify (YC W21). We have an extension that autofills job applications for you: https://simplify.jobs/autofill https://simplify.jobs/autofill Our thesis was the same: we want to make the job application process easier for everyone, and to prevent repetitive processes. We're looking to build a common application for jobs, and that starts with making your data work nicely with all ATS!