36 ms·
Toyota CEO talks about why he isn’t all-in on EVs
- ngcc_hk 4y agoOnly history can tell. But all these are temporary as once the infrastructure is everywhere, the extra baggage and maintenance of gas based car will kill its infra first. And hydrogen … sigh.
- antipaul 4y agoPragmatic. Can anyone say more how the increased electricity consumption by EVs will pressure the existing grid, and what sources (green or otherwise) will generate the extra capacity?
- DangitBobby 4y agoWho knows. Caution is commendable but if we want to avoid catastrophe we might have to start taking steps before everything is 100% ironed out, which might mean having less reliable infrastructure in the short term. Our current system is basically just a bunch of inefficient portable ICE generators running around everywhere. Maybe a short term solution is to install large ICE generators (at existing gas stations, for example). Sounds expensive, but inaction will also be expensive. It helps tremendously that many people will hold on to their ICE cars for as long as possible. I for one plan to run my truck for a long time yet. So we have a long ramp-up time for shoring up the electrical grid.
- zaptrem 4y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/electric-vehicles-could-rescue-the-us-power-grid/ https://www.wired.com/story/electric-vehicles-could-rescue-t...
- Ekaros 4y agoI don't think generation capacity is much issue. Just waste money on renewables and it will be there. Now matching the demand to that production and forcing people not to use their EV-vehicles in certain periods when there aren't enough production... As clearly they should be last ones to get it in high-demand, low supply scenarios.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI charge my EV after 10pm, when demand is so low that I can buy it for 1 cent a kilowatt hour. So first we need enough EVs charging overnight to reach the late afternoon peak before we worry a lot about grid capacity. I also generally charge my EV in 1 or 2 hours, it does not typically take all night. So if grid capacity becomes a problem, a bit of smart scheduling to spread the load should be pretty straightforward. And after that, we just add more capacity to the grid. The electric company exists to sell us electricity, and if we demand more, they will make more. The kind of growth we'd need to see in the grid to support 100% of all new cars being EVs is entirely within the abilities the electric producers have demonstrated in times past.
- missedthecue 4y agoThe average American home consumes 29kwh per day. It takes 62kwh to charge a base Tesla Model 3 once. Of course, not everyone will be charging from complete empty every night, but if every household is charging one car from 50% to 100% each night, the amount of daily electricity demand per household doubles. And most households own more than one car!
- theshrike79 4y agoBut a base model M3 has a 360 mile range. Your scenario would only be true if every household drove their M3 for 180 miles _EVERY_DAY_. EVs can be charged overnight during off-peak hours when the electricity is usually dirt cheap.
- snarf21 4y agoMore and more coal plants have tons of slack as renewables come online. We don't yet have a good system for local generation but that will come. There is no reason that most garage roofs can't be solar storing to banks of lead acid power banks for charging at night.
- ncann 4y ago> Toyoda also believes there will be “tremendous shortages” of lithium and battery grade nickel in the next five to 10 years, leading to production and supply chain problems. This is the main reason why I believe the current all-electric goals are too ambitious and not practical.
- CameronNemo 4y agoLithium is interesting because we could get really creative in how/where we get it. For example, GM is planning to buy Lithium extracted from the Salton Sea. [1] Nickel and Cobalt are, IMO, tougher to solve for. Nickel is rich in places that are not North America, which will run up against certain domestic sourced stipulations in EV subsidies... We have one nickel mine as of 2021 and it produces far less than the Eurasian mines.[2] I think an EV future will really depend on innovative battery chemistries like LiFePO4.[3] [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/05/04/the-salton-sea-could-produce-the-worlds-greenest-lithium.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/05/04/the-salton-sea-could-produce... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1284604/us-nickel-mine-production/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1284604/us-nickel-mine-p... [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate
- panick21_ 4y agoNobody questions if these metals exist or not. But developing a mine in North America takes 5-10 years and often longer. If you want to have a real mine that might actual produce lithium in North America look at Thacker Pass. The Salton Sea is mostly marketing, its totally unproven technology not anywhere remotely close to production. There have been countless junior minors who have made great promises about lithium production in the last 10 years and virtually all of them have failed. It will take much, much longer then most of these companies say to produce anything close to battery grade lithium. Lithium is really tricky to get to the right quality, and each mine needs to go threw a multi year very process to go threw valuation at every car and battery maker. So even if you have a mine partially operating, it takes years and years after that until your lithium might actually show up in a car. Sodium and LFP batteries do help. But LFP still needs lithium and the massive production facilities already built for NMC and NCA can not just be changed. This is a bigger problem then people realize, specially lithium. After all these years there is still only a handful (less then 5) of companies that produce it at the required grade. And of those many are not expanding fast.
- llampx 4y agoI'm a layman but to me its about optics when Toyota doesn't have any EVs but is spending money on hydrogen development, and the aeons-old Prius. Most people are convinced that gas vehicles are not the future, and that renewable-energy powered personal vehicles and mass transit are. BMW and Toyota just look like they got caught with their pants down by not having appealing vehicles, and other companies are now stealing their lunch. On top of that, Toyota has had some shady business too: https://cleantechnica.com/2021/07/30/toyota-actively-lobbying-to-slow-down-ev-revolution/ https://cleantechnica.com/2021/07/30/toyota-actively-lobbyin...
- awer897tyaiurfh 4y ago
- resoluteteeth 4y agoToyota has phevs (plug-in hybrids) that can run fully off of the battery. They have gotten a lot of shit over the past year for arguing that these should be incentivized by the government in addition to full electric vehicles, but I think there is some merit to their position. Right now a lot of people who buy electric cars are wealthier people who also own other cars. This is not inherently bad and, for example, if a household that is going to own multiple cars either way chooses to make one of those electric it may be a win for the environment, but if people are buying extra cars because they are excited about electric cars but also need a conventional car when they go longer distances, that may not actually be that great. Until there are sufficient charger networks everywhere, it might actually be better to incentives phevs to build up the infrastructure and ensure that people who can only afford to own one car but need to travel longer distances can still use electricity for shorter trips in the form of phevs rather than continuing to use conventional cars. It's not completely clear if EV adoption will continue to accelerate or if it's going to hit limits when we run out of people who can easily switch. Toyota may have a point in that the current timetable for full adoption of evs may be unrealistic, and if it is, it might be better to compromise slightly more if it makes it easier to build up the infrastructure on a more realistic timetable rather than risk hitting a wall If we set the goal as 100% of vehicles being EVs in a relatively short amount of time, we're going to run into problems who are currently unable to use EVs because of the lack of a fast charger network. (In reality, battery swapping would probably make sense for longer trips once everyone is using evs, but there is zero infrastructure for that right now.) That said, another issue with electric cars in general is that for the type of short trip where they make the most sense, it might arguably be better for the environment to focus on electric public transportation when possible anyway (especially non-battery-powered street cars and light rail which aren't affected by supply of some of the elements required for batteries). Also, if we can't hit the targets for EV adoption we may have difficulty hitting environmental goals in general.
- dope9967 4y agoToyota does have the most fun to drive hybrid motors though, that is subjective of course. I really thought they would get all in into EVs, but the reasoning around limitations of battery technology does seem to make sense, maybe they will end up as winners in the long term.
- to11mtm 4y ago> Toyota does have the most fun to drive hybrid motors though, that is subjective of course. I can buy that; My Ford Hybrid (drivetrain AFAIR is/was cross licensed from Toyota) has been way more enjoyable to drive than I expected.
- Tagbert 4y agoThe Chevy Volt hybrid was much more responsive and faster than the Toyota hybrids. The Toyota ones tend to fall back on the gasoline engine when pushed. The problem was that is was more expensive for GM to build than a pure EV and they wanted to make a clear break.
- timbit42 4y agoThe Toyota hybrids get better fuel economy in hybrid mode though. The Volt is better than a Prius due to the electric-only range, but not better than a Prius Prime. It's crazy they cancelled the Volt to bring out the Bolt which is short range and slow to charge.
- darkteflon 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Woodi 4y ago+1 Toyota's CEO :) Also when enviromental crisis will ends we can back to smoking oil or something similiar - reverse engeneering of oil engines technology can give terrible results... Also industrial vehicles running on electricity is not even in sight me thinks.
- DangitBobby 4y agoHow do you imagine the environmental crisis ending?
- CodeWriter23 4y ago
- DangitBobby 4y agoThat would be nice.
- svnt 4y agoParent said environmental not global warming though. Do you have a response to that or is the script just s/environment/climate?
- Tagbert 4y agoSure. Are you prepared to wait 10’s of thousands of years for that to happen?
- CodeWriter23 4y agoLook at the chart https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maunder_Minimum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maunder_Minimum
- Woodi 4y agoI imagine all that EV push, etc will bring some results :) Just like doctors helps with health - finally you are healed.
- panick21_ 4y agoHey Toyota, nobody asks you to be all in. But how about you start by no lobbying against climate rules, making advertisements demonizing EV and stop to sell the hydrogen snake oil to the politicians. That might be a good start.
- zumu 4y ago> But how about you start by no lobbying against climate rules The only lobbying I've heard of is against the narrow focus of BEV-only[1] policies and to include hybrid, HEV, etc. What other lobbying are you referring to? 1: https://www.energy.senate.gov/services/files/E2EA0E4F-BAD9-452D-99CC-35BC204DE6F0 https://www.energy.senate.gov/services/files/E2EA0E4F-BAD9-4...
- panick21_ 4y agoThe have been part of various alliances to keep down fuel standards.
- greeneggs 4y agoIn 2019, Toyota also sued California to take away its EPA waiver (dating from the 1963 Clean Air Act) to set its own car mileage standards. Aggressively suing your customers to make their air quality worse goes well beyond lobbying.
- lifeplusplus 4y agoI don’t want ev because I live in a city and dont fancy spending half an hour at electric stations
- rootusrootus 4y agoAssuming it takes you 30 minutes for at least one of your weekly grocery trips, why would you make a habit of sitting in the car waiting for it to charge?
- dangrossman 4y agoTwo reasons: (1) I've been driving EVs for 8 years now and have yet to see a DC fast charging station at a grocery store. Electrify America uses Wal-Mart and Target as site hosts often, but not everyone does their grocery shopping there. Grocery stores mainly have L2 AC charging stations, which only put about 10 miles of charge in a car in 30 minutes. (2) DC fast charging stations on almost every charging network will charge idle fees if you remain plugged in after you're done charging, or after a set time like 20-30 minutes, as they want you to move and let the next customer charge their car. So you need to sit in the car and move it when you're done, or it will become unaffordable.
- rootusrootus 4y agoDefinitely some regional variability there, as this doesn't exactly match my experience, but it's close enough that I concede they are good points. To really get people on board who don't have good at-home charging available, there will need to be progress on both of those points.
- lifeplusplus 4y agoin cities like nyc you are not parking in parking lot, you are parking in the street
- timbit42 4y agoCharge at home. If you can't now, eventually all the landlords will be racing to install charging because demand for it will rise.
- dimitar 4y agoHe is running a business. He says it will be hard to meet regulatory targets, then the incentives are way too low. Given they are such a a global business it makes sense for them to sell EVs and Hybrids in Europe and California for example and conventional vehicles in the rest of the world. The only policy that can make a significant change in the climate is a carbon tax. The effects might as well be less driving and more bussing if indeed the rare earth supply is so limited.
- credit_guy 4y agoI personally like a lot plug-in hybrid vehicles. For example the Toyota RAV4 plug-in has an electric-only range of 42 miles. Very few people commute more than that one way. If you can charge at home, and then charge at work too, you will not need to use gas for your commute. You will end up reducing your gas usage by a factor of 10 easily. And if we reduce all our emissions by a factor of 10, we are net negative (because forests sequester more than 10% of the emissions).
- crooked-v 4y agoExcept now you're lugging around the weight of the gas engine and taking on all the extra maintenance complexity of the gas engine, just on the off chance that for some reason you're going to need to road trip longer than the equivalent pure EV's range and won't be able to rent a more appropriate vehicle for it.
- josho 4y agoFair point. The alternative however is to spend the same amount (or more) on an EV and have to rent a car for weekend trips.
- sircastor 4y agoThat feels all over a better deal to me. I don’t need a long-range vehicle often.
- crooked-v 4y agoWhat weekend trips are you taking that are regularly more than 250 miles and completely out of reach of a 240V outlet for overnight charging?
- nicoburns 4y agoI don't own a car (I only do occasional weekend trips, so renting as required is much cheaper). But both of the two trips I've done this year met your criteria. They were camping trips to campsites without power outlets available.
- svnt 4y agoI wonder why the joint world’s largest ICE maker would argue against a technology they haven’t developed to the same standard as nearly every one of their competitors. Weird. Surely he’s only thinking of the environmental consequences and shared material constraints of manufacturing so many vehicles. Couldn’t be that they planned for a slower adoption and the pandemic accelerated the curve and now they’ve fallen behind. Couldn’t be that they failed to secure critical contracts thinking that this attempt at scaling would fall short and then they could pick up those same contracts later for cheap.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoThe plan to go 100% EV seems odd to me. There are many people who have cars with no place to charge at home because they lack in premise parking. Not sure how that plays out.
- wilg 4y agoPut chargers wherever they park
- deevolution 4y agoHow is California planning to cleanly support the extra electricity load from EVs since they've planned to decomission all their nuclear power plants? The base load is going to be generated with coal and nat gas now. Most people will likely be charging their EVs at night so they'll be charging their cars from coal or gas rather than carbon free nuclear.
- ryantgtg 4y agoThere are substantial efforts in California (at least in SoCal, which I’m most familiar with) right now to supply renewable energy. I’m not sure what’s preventing you from doing a search before asking such questions. Lotta information at your fingertips. https://www.nrel.gov/analysis/los-angeles-100-percent-renewable-study.html https://www.nrel.gov/analysis/los-angeles-100-percent-renewa... https://ceo.lacounty.gov/2021/12/07/sustainability/staying-power/ https://ceo.lacounty.gov/2021/12/07/sustainability/staying-p...
- ekianjo 4y agoEnjoy your substantial power cuts.
- GoldenMonkey 4y agoThe grid needs 30% more power generation. If all cars are EV. CA is doing rolling blackouts as it is. Maybe Californians will be riding horses in the next 10 years ;)
- Gatsky 4y agoWell I live in a very wealthy country by global standards, with lots of space and sun, and many climate concerned people clearly influencing politics, and plans to export renewable energy to other countries. And there is essentially zero charging infrastructure for EVs, and no concrete plan to change that.
- shusaku 4y agoWhy do we need a plan? As soon as the demand gets there you’re going to have a thousand different startups competing to build it. We’re going to see better solutions than we can imagine right now once the competition begins. Countries have spent the past century fighting wars to secure access to oil, but now we’re afraid of being brought to our knees by the prospect of building a charging network?
- Gatsky 4y agoIn TFA he says, to paraphrase, 'We aren't going all-in on EVs and lack of infrastructure is one of the reasons.' What do you think is the fastest way to get ICE cars off the road? Pretty sure what you outline in your comment isn't it. I also don't think that affordable infrastructure actually gets built without government support - but happy to consider any counterexamples. Just to clarify, in case you misunderstand me, I can't wait to be free of ICE vehicles.
- shusaku 4y agoBefore insultingly telling me to “read the fucking article” maybe you should read what I wrote. The article quote is completely unrelated. Of course we don’t have the infrastructure, but what I'm saying is that we can build it, and we don’t need some giant government plan to do it. > I also don't think that affordable infrastructure actually gets built without government support - but happy to consider any counterexamples. You’ve never been to a gas station? This isn’t going to involve blowing holes in mountains. All you need is a wire and a payment system.
- 4y ago
- etempleton 4y agoI believe EV adoption will be slow and then sudden. Yes, there will hurdles and EVs aren’t going to make sense for everyone, but there will be a tipping point. Right now you have EVs that check all the boxes and but are over $45,000. Even with premium pricing, demand already outstrips supply for electric vehicles.
- coffeefirst 4y agoThis is also how it went with smartphones. First it’s a status symbol and a luxury item, then a few years later there seems to be a cliff and suddenly it’s highly unusual not to have one.
- rtlfe 4y agoYou can get a brand new perfectly functional smartphone for under $200. If electric cars drop to even $30k they're still way out of reach for most people, and we'll be waiting a long time from them to hit the used car market.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agohttps://www.recurrentauto.com/research/used-electric-vehicle-buying-report https://www.recurrentauto.com/research/used-electric-vehicle... says 1/4th of EV sales in Q2 2022 were used vehicles. with an average price of 40k although this is all complicated by a shortage in EV production.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 4y ago40k... That is triple what I paid for my slightly used ICE car. With long warranty in country with extreme taxation... That is just bonkers level of pricing.
- 4y ago
- Workaccount2 4y agoAnytime society has an enormous demand for something, especially people/institutions with money, it gets done. If there are hundreds of billions or even trillions riding on upgrading the grid and securing mineral resources/researching alternative solutions, it will get funded and figured out. There will be $20,000 economy EVs with crappy everything but still go A to B. There will be grid upgrades to handle everyone charging (really topping off is more realistic, few drive more than ~25 miles/day, the upgrade to accommodate this might simply be "grid smart" chargers). There will be alternative chemistry batteries that don't need rare earths (like LFP in some Teslas). Toyota is just stubbornly refusing to take the L on their 30 years of research into this. I don't blame them, but I'm not them, so I'll call it how it is.
- mhneu 4y agoYes, exactly. Toyota is refusing to take the L on this because Toyota is the market leader in gas-electric hybrids and Toyota is not the market leader in EVs. This is business strategy 101.
- adventured 4y agoHow to cede an enormous market opportunity to a dozen other competitors 101.
- silisili 4y agoThis type of thinking is what hurt Kodak ultimately I think. They invented the first digital camera, then scrapped it because they made money in film. In fairness, they did catch up decades later...but that's likely at least a couple decades of revenue lost. And never really innovating. If they'd have been more forward thinking, we'd likely see Kodak sensors in every phone today instead of Sony.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoNobody was ready to make use of digital images until computing was enough of a presence in daily life, digital storage was cheap enough, and sensor resolution increased to compete with casual use of film. That wasn't going to happen in the 70s or 80s.
- mhneu 4y agoLet's be clear. The reason Toyota isn't all-in on EVs is because Toyota is the dominant player in a rival technology: gas-electric hybrids. This is extremely clear business strategy: Toyota doesn't want to cannibalize its marketshare in hybrids. Toyota pushed hydrogen fuel cells for years to obstruct EV adoption, just as Elon Musk pushed hyperloop to obstruct high-speed rail adoption. Both hydrogen and hyperloop are fantasy technology: decades away or completely impractical (hyperloop.) Only after EVs were widely adopted in many countries did Toyota start moving towards EVs. That was a logical business strategy for them. Toyota isn't all in on EVs because they make lots of money from hybrids. The end.
- mhneu 4y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/25/climate/toyota-electric-hydrogen.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/25/climate/toyota-electric-h... "Toyota Led on Clean Cars. Now It Works to Delay Them." The auto giant bet on hydrogen power, but as the world moves toward electric the company is fighting climate regulations in an apparent effort to buy time. This is all very clear business strategy. And we shouldn't let Toyota get in the way of a better world for all of us, in exchange for profit for its investors.
- robertwt7 4y agoSounds like blackberry and nokia back then when iPhone was released? If they're not on board the train for the future trend right now, won't they get left behind? I'm not a management guy so I don't know, probably there are a lot of consideration happening and they surely have some strategy, whether it's right or not we'll see
- martin_drapeau 4y agoToyota isn't listening to its customers. We've been asking for EVs for a long time. Took forever to get plug-in hybrids. Then it all stopped. I'm a second generation Toyota buyer, my father before me. 100% of the cars we purchased over the past 20 years were Toyota. We've been asking for electric but Toyota was too stuborn, or dare I say, too pussy to make the leap. Like many, I've decided my next car will be electric. I'm sad it won't be a Toyota. I'm very disapointed in everything Toyoda says. Excuses and no dream.
- grech 4y agoAccording to the posted article, Toyota does have plans to offer several all-electric models in 3 years (in 2025). My main takeaway from what Toyoda said was Toyota's goal to offer as many options as possible to its customers - this includes ICE, hybrids, BEV, and hydrogen cars. What Toyota is refusing is letting go of developing all other types of vehicles and focusing only on BEV, which is fair imo.
- crisdux 4y agoI’m happy Toyota will continue to invest in hybrids. I want a car with sufficient range. Maybe other folks don’t take a lot of road trips, but that’s something I do in the Midwest and it brings me a lot of joy. Honda Accord hybrid can get nearly 600 miles range and is an absolute pleasure to drive. I’m hoping my next car is a PHEV. I don’t want to think about charging. I’m worried it would cause delays and affect my route. Hybrids allow more flexibility. This board goes really hard on EVs. I don’t understand it.
- gonzo41 4y agoI haven't really looked to hard, but does a hybrid exist that's battery first and then has an ICE to fall back on for charging the battery / supplying electricity to the electric motors? All I want is to be able to have an electric car, that if I'm in a real jam and need to run it on petrol I can fill up a 20 litre tank and make a few hours of driving, even if it's in 'limp home mode' until I can get a charge again. My range anxiety is real! The Australian outback is big.
- crisdux 4y agoThe Honda Accord hybrid gas engine has 3 modes. It can power the wheels, power the generator to drive the electric motor and it can charge the battery.
- TheDong 4y ago> does a hybrid exist that's battery first and then has an ICE to fall back on That's what PHEVs are (Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles). Relevant to the article, those include the (Toyota) RAV4 prime and Prius prime. I think the one I see the most is the Chevy Volt, which unfortunately is discontinued, but seemed like a good PHEV.
- assttoasstmgr 4y agoBasically all PHEVs work this way.
- hdra 4y agoNissan's e-Power line is exactly that. The ICE only exist to charge the battery and is not connected to the drive train. I think they call these "series hybrid"?
- Patrol8394 4y agoI am convinced EV will be the future, but given how electricity is produced and how batteries are built the most sustainable technology is hybrid https://youtu.be/S1E8SQde5rk https://youtu.be/S1E8SQde5rk
- timbit42 4y agoAgreed. There are lithium production issues for the near future so plug-in hybrids mean you can make 10 PHEVs with a range of 40 km instead of one EV with a range of 400 km. Making PHEVs instead of EVs will cut fuel usage more.
- alliao 4y agoI'm so sure Toyoda's doing some 4D chess move here, given world's increasing renewable energy meant there's going to be demand for energy absorption at will and hydrogen is their answer to help managing the renewable grid. During the height of renewable energy production the cost of energy would probably even drop to negative, and hydrogen no matter how inefficient can still "regen" it into hydrogen. and the rest is just pricing and betterment of technology. extremely ambitious but if anyone can pull it off it'd be them.
- thehappypm 4y agoI still doubt it because if electricity goes negative you would be far better off storing that energy in a battery which has almost no losses.
- mertd 4y agoThere is no 4D chess. Toyota is the new Research in Motion, pointing at the iPhone and saying "but it doesn't have a keyboard!!".
- max51 4y ago> and hydrogen is their answer to help managing the renewable grid. All of the hydrogen right now used for vehicle comes from the oil&gas industry. It costs over an order of magnitude more to extract it from water. The worst part is that even at the current rates at the pump, it's hard to justify using hydrogen over batteries. If lithium batteries didn't exist, it may have been a good path for the long term future. In reality, it's only gonna be viable for very specific industrial use cases.
- lambda_dn 4y agoMore like tiddlywinks.
- omgwtfbyobbq 4y agoToyota and their engineers were years ahead of everyone else a couple decades ago. Unfortunately they didn't listen to their own engineers. http://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1995235_1995384_1995781,00.html http://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,288... His vision for Toyota's eco-friendly autos goes beyond the Prius line. "The next step is to apply hybrid technology to other models, and to reduce its price," he says. After that, he has his sights on dispensing with CO2-belching gasoline engines entirely: "Ultimately, the future is in electric power." It might sound like an eco-platitude. But if someone is going to bring an electric car to your driveway, there's a good chance Hori will be the one to do it.
- suction 4y ago
- funstuff007 4y agoWhat are we going to do with all the excess gasoline when we only need natural gas?
- timbit42 4y agoWhy will there be excess gasoline? They will reduce production.
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoWell sure, he has to say that, because they have zero foothold in the game and have been campaigning to kill electric ev laws. Toyota also has 200 billion, yes 200 BILLION dollars in debt, they are the second most indebted corporation in the world.
- froh 4y agois that 200bn debt from their annual report?
- alberth 4y agoHydrogen Fuel Cell It’s odd the article didn’t talk about how Toyota is betting big on hydrogen fuel cell winning vs battery.
- olivermarks 4y agoToyota leads the world in developing volume electric vehicles and it's not hard to see the logic of remaining focused on hybrid for the foreseeable future. No one has done more to bring affordable mass market hybrids to market while the BEV world is an endless cycle of hype and overpromising. In most of the world we have massive electricity supply issues and there are huge questions around what problems BEVs are actually solving and the new problems they are creating. 'Here's What It Takes To Recycle 1 EV Battery' https://youtube.com/shorts/Sj5hI_IiQ7A?feature=share https://youtube.com/shorts/Sj5hI_IiQ7A?feature=share
- RockingGoodNite 4y agoI like the idea of an EV, always have, even thought by age now they would be the dominant vehicle. Charging hundreds of millions of cars in the US alone overnight and short ranges compared to a gas vehicle didn't factor into my thinking until recent years. Jay Leno has mentioned several times the numerous advantages steam and electric cars had over gas over 100 years ago but they were not enough to beat the sheer convenience of gas. I once scoffed at the idea of a hybrid (thinking of them as a stepping stone) but today I realize they make much more sense than I realized before. Think of crossing the Mojave Desert in an EV.
- thehappypm 4y agoThe Mojave Desert is not really the kind of driving the average American remotely needs a vehicle equipped for.
- hedora 4y agoI don't buy this argument. Most people can charge during the day. Employers often provide free EV charging, but even if they don't, power will be mostly free during daylight hours moving forward (due to solar). Also, employers that require people to commute almost universally provide parking lots that could be retrofitted with chargers. In the worst case (only charge at night, run battery to 0% every day at sunset, leave at sunrise, power company bans charging at night), someone could install a stationary battery with about 120% the EV's charge. That's overly pessimistic and still only a factor of 2.2 on the price of the battery. Over a 5-10 year period, EVs currently pay for themselves in saved money on gasoline. Crossing the Mojave seems easy enough to me. There would need to be charging stations evey ~100 miles. Finding space for the necessary solar capacity would not be an issue. The stations could charge 2-4x "city' rates and would be very profitable. You can already cross the Mojave in even a low range tesla, for what it is worth. (Victorville -> Las Vegas; they say you need to charge for 20 minutes in Baker, CA)
- admax88qqq 4y agoThe amount of hot takes in this threat with half completed math and reasoning is amazing.
- lethologica 4y agoI would love nothing more than to have an EV, a Tesla battery and solar panels at home. But like most Australians, I rent. And when you rent here you can barely put a hook up on the wall without the owners permission (and usually them saying ‘no’ [and don’t even get me started on how paranoid it makes a renter feel to have to ask the owner for permission for something. There’s always the thought of ‘if I ask too much, will they not renew my lease and will I ever be able to find another rental in these conditions?’… but that’s another story]) And that doesn’t even take into account how expensive EVs are here, either. So for now, it’s my ‘99 Camry all the way.
- hedora 4y agoTwo pragmatic suggestions: - if there are any outlets on the outside of your house, buy the highest amperage charger cable you can (~ $200 US), and trickle charge overnight. This is more than adequate for a reasonable commute in a reasonably efficient car. (Check the miles/kWh or km/kWh of the car, then figure out how many kW the charge cable delivers). - Lobby for "community net metering". The idea is that you buy shares in a non-profit (or other business entity) that owns a solar panel farm near your home. The power company offsets your bill as though the energy your share of the solar panels produced was produced on your roof. In addition to allowing renters and apartment dwellers to save money by buying solar, it allows them to buy things, like wind turbines, that don't scale down as well. It also allows poor people to lower their energy costs (as people that currently own solar panels do). The battery is tougher, assuming you want to use it as a backup. If you just want to time shift power, community net metering (and time of use plans) is good enough.
- Ekaros 4y agoWouldn't it make more sense just to buy solar and wind producing companies and then get dividends from them and use those to buy the power?
- pmarreck 4y agoI’m going to guess, without even reading it, that it’s simply because he’s old and only comes up with poor reasoning.
- keepquestioning 4y agoWhat happens to the grid when we go all in on EV?
- dymk 4y agoWhat happens to coal mines when we all start using steam engines?
- velhartice 4y agoHeaven forbid for anyone like Akio Toyoda to have a pragmatic outlook on the future of four wheeled enclosed personal transportation that departs from the popular narrative.
- RadixDLT 4y agoThe Japanese largely copied European car designs in the 1980s, propelling them into the 1990s and 2000s, but they may no longer be able to do so, stalling the process. just google "Toyota Actively Lobbying To Slow Down EV Revolution"
- systemvoltage 4y agoWhen a large part of society really wants to do something, my natural tendency is become extremely skeptical. The reason being in today's day and age, the bandwagoning effect is so strong; people get outsed, and critics are shamed out of the conversation. When the mechanism of criticism ceases to function; malaise develops and all kinds of bullshit gets propelled into mainstream narrative. Not saying EV revolution isn't the right thing to do; but how can we allow space for steelmanning Toyota or areas where EV's don't make sense; how can we make sure power cuts won't leave people stranded and resiliency of transporation infrastructure becomes fragile; after all, a massive part of the GDP depends on transportation. Without it, nations will fail. We should be a bit more level headed of the EV craze, especially hackers on HN.
- seydor 4y agoI think most of the damage has been done by politicians who used populist rhetoric to set those inane time limits after which "all non-EVs will be banned". That is just stupid politicking that's easy to pass because none of them will be in office by that date. How about having both EVs and ICE? In some european countries, the amounts being paid as subsidies for EVs are insane. In some parts of italy you get a Tesla for like $8000 . But this winter europe will have trouble charging them, and this model clearly does not scale. Let's focus on installing solar and expanding remote work instead
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y ago>But this winter europe will have trouble charging thel No. It's still cheaper to charge EV than fuel ICE during non peak hours. Let's stop pretending EV owners only charge on the highway at expensive, fast charging stations. >and this model clearly does not scale What does not scale? Look at Norway.
- simonebrunozzi 4y ago> In some parts of italy you get a Tesla for like $8000 Completely false. In Italy, in certain periods and under certain conditions, you get "up to" 6,000 euros of incentives if you buy an EV. You still pay north of 30,000 euros to buy a Tesla Model 3 (the basic model of course) even after incentives.
- seydor 4y agoit seems you get additional subsidies from the regions. And then the tax incentives https://modo.volkswagengroup.it/en/q-life/electric-cars-which-are-the-subsidies-available-in-italy https://modo.volkswagengroup.it/en/q-life/electric-cars-whic...
- langsoul-com 4y agoAh yes, whenever the topic that EVS won't be the absolute future comes up. People get ultra religious and evangelical about it. At this point, it should just be a new religion. That is to say, most of the debates aren't founded on logic, but rather hope and belief. Until it's possible to buy a second hand ev as someone's new car for less than a grand (AUD so $600 USD). EVS won't be the future. $20k for a car is fucking expensive, the "mass market" model 3 in Australia is $60-80k. That's a luxury car price, closer to the top end.
- kamranjon 4y agoI’m not sure if anyone read the article but it is incredibly level headed and actually states that Toyota is going to launch 15 full electric vehicles by 2025. I actually owned an electric car and it was amazing and I loved it but I definitely agree with the direction Toyota is going and they have developed some amazing tech with their hybrid systems that I don’t see any reason why they would throw out the window.
- up2isomorphism 4y agoEV is not a well defined term. In US it basically means what Elon Musk sells.
- Markoff 4y agoTo answer the headline: > Toyoda reiterated that he does not believe all-electric vehicles will be adopted as quickly as policy regulators and competitors think, due to a variety of reasons. He cited lack of infrastructure, pricing and how customers’ choices vary region to region as examples of possible roadblocks. > “Just like the fully autonomous cars that we are all supposed to be driving by now, EVs are just going to take longer to become mainstream than media would like us to believe,” He sound like smart man unlike European communist bureaucrats trying to force EVs down the throat at any cost, which could be only explained by being controlled by WEF. I'd say going all in on EV or whatever is as "smart" as putting all your eggs in one basket, world ain't black and white and you gotta be pretty naive to do it, hard to imagine scenario where diversification is not (the more) rational approach.
- incomingpain 4y ago50 years from now there won't be gasoline. You must change. biodiesel will likely be available but not at scale. ethanol will almost certainly power old cars, but gas stations will be rare. hydrogen is a non-starter. 95% of hydrogen comes from fossil fuels already and electrolysis is tremendously inefficient. Not to mention a hydrogen car is really just an electric car with hydrogen range extending. Everything points to it's going to be EVs.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThere are a lot of tractors that use diesel and gasoline. Mine is a 1947, still runs like a champ. I've wanted an EV tractor but with each generation of new vehicle, more and more hostile features are added. - Subscriptions to hardware capabilities - AUP violations for self repair this is slowly changing, maybe - GPS tracking and Remote telemetry. GPS makes sense for geofencing and automation but no need to dial home to a cloud, any more so than a drone - Crazy cost of proprietary batteries / battery packs All of those things are double-red-flags / hard stops for me. Batteries are a topic in and of themselves. Batteries are evolving every few years and yet newer vehicles are being designed to take proprietary battery packs and this is only becoming more vendor locked-in with time. I will buy an EV when the above items are addressed, probably around the time that solid state 3D printed batteries are forced to be in a Standard form factor and battery packs can be quickly swapped by the owner, whatever that may look like. Every part needs to be modular and easy to swap. Bonus would be after-market modules, some being vendor approved and some that obviously void warranties without having to reprogram the ECM like I do with my truck just to replace faulty ignition switches and ABS controllers. Oh right that is another thing. The EV will need to be compatible and writable by my ThinkTool scanner, meaning the EV vendors will need to publish all of their proprietary codes and encryption keys for vehicle diagnostic tools. If I can not enable/disable features from my tool then the vehicle is not mine and I get my money back. I also looked into getting a mid-sized EV excavator. Same as everything above. Nothing but owner-hostile features. In my obstinate view, the market is tone deaf and not appealing to the right people. Backing my view I have not seen any construction workers using EV rigs and vendors won't even list prices yet. I had to call them. The only change I have witnessed is smaller 2-stroke engines going electric like chainsaws, some yard maintenance equipment that used to be gasoline, etc... So perhaps gasoline will be gone in 50 years but I forsee many growing pains in this market and predict blackhat hackers will have to rescue some of the equipment owners, assuming the concept of owning hardware is still a thing. If the concept of ownership vanishes then I expect something better than they existing rental process. e.g. I press a button and the hardware shows up, I use it, then press a button and the hardware goes home and I only pay for the minutes used.
- amai 4y agoToyota clearly doesn‘t need Norway. Their market share in Norway will be dropping to zero, soon: https://electrek.co/2021/09/23/norway-bans-gas-cars-in-2025-but-trends-point-toward-100-ev-sales-as-early-as-april/amp/ https://electrek.co/2021/09/23/norway-bans-gas-cars-in-2025-...
- known 4y ago
- UltraViolence 4y agoI believe he's right. EV's get all the spotlight but 95% of all vehicles still use fossil-fuels. Replacing them in the next 3 decades is nigh impossible IMHO. We might even endure another oil crisis because we're cutting down on our investment in fossil fuels while the transition to EV's is lagging.