11 ms·
A mysterious voice is haunting American Airlines’ in-flight announcements
- TotoHorner 4y agoI’m surprised that no one is considering the possibility that it’s a ghost?
- labster 4y agoRight! Ghosts are a definite possibility. We should dispatch our bravest reality TV stars to find out what’s really going on on these flights.
- krapp 4y agoIt's not a ghost. Ghosts aren't real.
- gumby 4y agoYou only think this because the airlines normally suppress them.
- bombcar 4y agoGhosts go to heaven but that’s high in the sky. Planes fly higher and higher for better fuel efficiency and are starting to capture some of the lower ghosts. Boeing is suppressing this.
- MisterTea 4y agoLost souls on Boeing planes isn't too far fetched. Lord Xenu flew in all those thetans on rocket powered DC-8's which were originally made by McDonnell Douglas who merged with Boeing. Basically Snakes on a Plane but with souls and Tom Cruise.
- gumby 4y agoI love it when Ockham's razor can cut straight through the bullshit and leave us with the simplest answer, like the clear one you provided.
- travisjungroth 4y agoIf I ever write a script it will have this real life dialogue in it. “Do you believe in ghosts?” “No, do you?” “Yeah, a bit. Think about all the times people saw and heard ghosts. Every single one of those times was wrong? Seems unlikely.” “Do you believe in angels?” “No.” “Then what about all the times people saw an angel?” “Those were just ghosts.”
- jrootabega 4y ago"There's no such thing as trolls!" "Then how do you explain all the dead unicorns?"
- xwdv 4y agoAn accidental time traveler traveling slightly out of alignment with their timeline would likely manifest as something we would describe as a ghost, for a brief moment.
- mindcrime 4y agoJohn Titor?
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- pwillia7 4y agoWhy not the alien soul crystals that enable flight trying to break free?
- gumby 4y agoI'm glad you brought that up because (no joke) nobody can actually explain how aerodynamic lift works, much less how a plane can fly upside down: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/no-one-can-explain-why-planes-stay-in-the-air/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/no-one-can-explai...
- Eleison23 4y agoThose crazy bumblebees
- PcChip 4y agoStick your hand out the car window doing 60, and tilt it back. That's how they stay up there!
- site-packages1 4y agoI think this just proves that it happens, not why it happens. Also the last flight I took proved that it happens.
- bombcar 4y agoPlanes fly because of climate change. Which causes us to need more climate change as we get more flights. Sad but true.
- tomcam 4y agopure science right there
- maxbond 4y agoMy understanding is that planes don't fly directly upside down, and they angle the wing slightly to make a kinda-sorta-airfoil. How helicopters can turn directly upside down, and fly that way[1], without reversing the direction of their props, that I don't get. (Thinking about it now, I think it turns from a helicopter to a hovercraft? Eg, this is a ground effect?) [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdDESYBdeSE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdDESYBdeSE Also, tangentially, Magnus effect planes are a thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6geOms33Dk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6geOms33Dk
- kube-system 4y agoWell, at least it wasn't snake noises.
- nrdgrrrl 4y ago
- pid-1 4y agoImagine spending all your afterlife in comercial air travel... That's some cruel punishment.
- phendrenad2 4y agoGhosts on a Plane... starring Samuel L. Jackson
- ficklepickle 4y agoIt reminds me of a story I just heard about the allegedly haunted plane parts from the crash of EA 401. Obviously not the most probable explanation, but I found the story interesting. https://mysteriesrunsolved.com/2020/07/ghosts-of-flight-401.html https://mysteriesrunsolved.com/2020/07/ghosts-of-flight-401....
- mindcrime 4y agoJesus H. Christ, that brings back memories. When I was (much) younger, probably somewhere between 9-13 or thereabouts, I had a brief phase when I really in to "weird stuff." I spent a lot of time reading books about UFO's, ghosts, the Bermuda Triangle, the Philadelphia Experiment, "ancient aliens", the "Oak Island money pit", blah, etc. etc. And the whole Flight 401 thing either figured very prominently in at least one book I read, or it kept re-appearing or both, because I just recalled a whole bunch of profound feelings associated with that story. I remember being really freaked out by it at the time. Enough so that I probably wouldn't have wanted to get on an airplane had I had any reason to fly back then (I didn't). I'd like to say that even back then I mostly didn't really believe all that stuff, but I think maybe I kinda did, at least to a degree. Now I think it's all bollocks, and maybe that's one of the things I miss about being a kid... that sense of fascination with the mysterious and unknown and the sense of possibility that comes with allowing yourself to believe in the Bermuda Triangle, ghosts, yadda yadda.
- copperx 4y agoI'm with you on the last one, and I sometimes wonder whether religious people still have that sense of fascination with the unknown, or with what is possible. I would like to have that again, if only for a few moments.
- sidewndr46 4y agoI doubt the veracity of this account, at all. The liability from flying a malfunctioning, compromised plane is way too high for this to happen more than once.
- amichail 4y agoWhat's the worst that can happen?
- bb88 4y agoYou mean besides creating panic in the passenger cabin...?
- Nextgrid 4y agoSince 9/11 and armored & locked cockpit doors, surely planes would be able to withstand pandemonium in the cabin and still land safely? Also, in the video linked in the blog post there doesn't seem to be much panic visible at all. I bet most people are laughing their asses off once the initial confusion is over.
- ofcrpls 4y agoIt's multiple folks on multiple flights and spread across months.
- maxbond 4y agoNot an aviator, but planes can & do fly with malfunctioning noncritical components all the time. I don't know whether the PA system is considered critical or not, but it also didn't appear to be nonfunctional; the article said the pilots were able to use it & that their signal appeared to have a higher priority. I don't know if this is true or not either, but I don't think we can reject it on it's face.
- copperx 4y agoI have a friend who was a flight attendant for the oldest Mexican airline, and she indeed told me how sometimes, when there's a critical system malfunction before a flight, often managers call the pilots privately and offer a bribe to fly the plane with that malfunction. The pilot can refuse the offer without any problems or losing the job, but it's a bit scary to think that's there's corruption at that level. Fortunately, planes are extremely robust and somehow Mexican airlines have an excellent safety record.
- rx_tx 4y agoFor those interested in the various aircraft systems for PA (public address) and aircraft status system for aircrew, I found this interesting training doc PDF online [1] for the A320/321. I have been looking at section "03-010 CABIN INTERCOMMUNICATION DATA SYSTEM" It does not mention the "medical intercom jacks" in overhead bins that are mentioned at the end of the article [1]:https://caisatech.net/uploads/XXI_3_AIRBUS_H51_A320_O_CCOM_R0_13JUL2012.PDF https://caisatech.net/uploads/XXI_3_AIRBUS_H51_A320_O_CCOM_R...
- bb88 4y agoApparently there is a compact flash card to play music and the pre-recorded announcement over the loud speakers. I wonder if someone replaced the standard announcement with a 5 hour long file with intermittent burps and groans....
- TheBlight 4y agoThey would probably notice that but it does seem like some former passenger most likely installed something that's patched into the system. It may just be a recording from a flash drive. Or it could also be more sophisticated and patch into the wifi as well. You could also imagine it having a microphone for added hijinx but none of the interactions seem to suggest that.
- panarky 4y agoI've flown American six times in the last ten days, and four of the flights had chaos with the entertainment system. No groans or heavy breathing on the PA, but flight attendants had to "reboot the system" once or twice every flight.
- oefrha 4y agoI once captured the Linux boot screen of a United Boeing 737 infotainment system. Apparently I still got that photo. OCRed text for lols: video capture buffer0 40b37460 video capture buffer1 40a8dd60 wideo_capture buffer2 409e4610 geode_: gamma black+csccorrection VAL2: Registered "NSC Geode V4LZ UBI driver" as char device B1, 224 VAL2: Registered "NSC Geode V4L2 Capture driver" as char device 81, geode_v: Unknown standard VAL2: Registered "NSC Geode V4LZ Overlay driver" as char device B1, 16 Warning: loading /lib/modules/realmagichul_kernelland.o will taint the kernel: non-GPL license - Proprietary. Copyright (c) 2002 Sigma Designs Inc. All rights reserved (version 103 with proc pci dolby css macrovision sm2288 osdric_memorycheck), /lib/modules/realmagichul_kernelland.o:init_module:Invalidargument Hint: insmod errors Can be caused by incorrect module parameters, including invalid IO or IRQ parameters PCI: Setting latency timer of device 00:12.3 to 32 geodeoss: disabling PM: PM registration failed geodeoss: version 1.2.0 time 12:37:36 Dec B 2004 geodeoss: use_pm=0 check_interrupt=0 Warning: loading /lib/modules/maspcu.o will taint the kernel: no license usb.c: registered new driver pcu MAS-eFX SEB USB PCU driver version 1.01 usb.c: registered new driver usbccr usb_ccr open is being called (0xc165f000 ) <6›ccrdev.c: Adding credit card reader: input1 input1: Panasonic Avionics Corp PAC USB Keyboard/Credit Card Reader Ver. 1.01 on usb1:2.1 usbccr.c: v0.59:USB HID Credit Card Reader driver mice: PS/2 mouse device common for all mice usb.c: registered new driver pacpcu geode rev-7 pmr-03a834c4 mcr-00030250 using /dev/mtd1 /usr/app --- mount succeeded --- using /dev/mtd4 /usr/app2 --- mount succeeded ---
- duxup 4y agoThe dongle idea is interesting but are we assuming someone is plugging in a dongle and making noises, on all these flights, sometimes for the duration of the flight and nobody finds these dongles?
- upwardbound 4y agoPresumably they would unplug the dongle at the end of the flight while they retrieve their overhead luggage
- bb88 4y agoOr just program them to not do anything until an hour into the next flight.
- nkingsy 4y agoBut then it gets found
- Scoundreller 4y agoOr… Nevermind, I’m not here to help people with this kind of thing!
- babelfish 4y agoAssuming it’s one person with the dongle responsible for all 3-4 instances of this - it would be pretty easy for AA to figure out who’s doing it if this is the case, just check if there’s a common passenger on every flight where the issue was reported
- rthomas6 4y agoMaybe something in there is picking up the guard frequency. People make weird noises on that frequency all the time, including animal noises and screaming.
- Scoundreller 4y agoThat wouldn’t go to the Public Announcement signal though.
- rthomas6 4y agoNot on purpose, but there are YouTube videos of pilots accidentally doing in flight announcements on guard. Maybe there's some plane error that is sometimes causing the error the other way around.
- Scoundreller 4y agoI know Unites Airlines used to make its pilot’s atc communications available on “channel 11”, but I think that all stopped post 9/11.
- philipps 4y agoPretty sure it was channel 9. I used to listen to that all the time.
- repiret 4y agoI’ve heard it long after 9/11, but not in several years now.
- robbiet480 4y agoI was on a 777 SFO-ORD a few months ago that still had Channel 9 available
- copperx 4y agoI loved that so much. And it was enabled well after 9/11.
- alphabetting 4y agoI could definitely be wrong but my go-to assumption when the source originates from Tiktok is to assume it's fake or staged.
- mhh__ 4y ago
- mardifoufs 4y ago>least intelligent Based on what?
- uni_rule 4y agoAge, probably. Young kids aren't that smart.
- mhh__ 4y agoA lot of what I am complaining about is actually people older than me peddling "advise" - how to become a data analyst (no understanding of data required!). It just feels like Facebook-tier people given the content equivalent of a machine gun.
- metadat 4y agoAnd compared to what?
- 4y ago
- phillipwei 4y agoI wonder if AA has cross referenced the passenger list of each of the flights to see if there was a common passenger to all the flights.
- remarkEon 4y agoHad the same thought. This is like “DOOM running on …” but for fart jokes, and I can’t imagine that there’s a whole gang of pranksters doing this.
- dylan604 4y agoThis might narrow it down some, but I have been on weekend flights that I recognized people on the return leg from the away leg. But even going from 200+ people to 10 would help
- mod 4y agoThey have reports going back to June. It'll almost certainly solve the case if it's one individual.
- tzs 4y agoThe person doing it might not be on the affected flights. Instead they plant something on the plane during a different flight (or between flights if they are an insider who can get access to the plane between flights) that is hooked into the PA system and has a recording that it plays after a time delay or perhaps when the cabin pressure lowers or perhaps both (e.g., delay 48 hours than start when the cabin pressure lowers). If the device had a long time delay or a delay based on the number of flights they might have to check many flights before the affected flight. And there is no guarantee the person would use the same delay each time. If they pick flights on routes that have a lot of repeat travelers and the delays on the device make it so the airline has to look at a fews days worth of flights to get the suspects for each incidents then I'd not be surprised if there are may people that were on all the planes sometime before the affected flights. The big problem I see with it being done by someone not on the flight is that surely after the first couple of times the PA system is going to get thoroughly inspected and the device would be found. The mystery would then just be "who", rather than the "how" mystery that we currently (at least publicly) have.
- nemo1618 4y agoAbout to get on an AA flight, will report back!
- dan-robertson 4y agoIt doesn’t sound particularly human and it seems like it would be a weird hobby to go on a bunch of flights and cause these strange sounds. Surely a prankster would get bored and move on to something like music or silly messages. (And if the airline believed passengers were doing it they might correlate flight records or something?) I think I’d probably believe that it’s just some elctromechanical issue. I doubt fixing the PA system is going to be in the pilot’s manual and I’d expect flight attendants to be basically incompetent in dealing with such an issue. I think I would guess either an issue with some prerecorded announcements system (eg playing bits of messages at strange speeds and at random) or some kind of electrical interference or short-circuiting problem (eg some glob of solder bouncing around inside some unimportant component).
- nso 4y agoWe must be listening to different tapes. Sounds very much human, very much male, very much young
- MisterSandman 4y agothe tonal inflections are very human, and in the recording it felt the voice changed a bit after the flight attendant made an announcement, so it's probably live (not necessarily making the sound, but using a soundboard).
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoSounds human to me too but I wonder if we've been primed by the headline to recognize it as such. If it had just been posted as "Mystery sound on American Airlines flights", maybe we would have interpreted it differently. This has worked on me before for backmasking and was quite remarkable how different what I heard between when I was primed and when I listened to the track a week later without priming.
- userbinator 4y agoThe first burst sounds like a grazing animal. Then definitely becomes very human sounding.
- 4y ago
- abeppu 4y agoWhy would there be a "medical intercom" as one quoted redditor suggested? Surely in the event of a medical emergency the crew can communicate about it with the same systems they use for everything else?
- MBCook 4y agoIt may be to allow the flight attendants, taking care of the passenger, to speak directly to a ground crew without having to relay things to other people on the plane back-and-forth to the radio.
- Kon-Peki 4y agoI’ve been on a flight where they used the medical intercom. Nobody is going to use it without a whole lot of people noticing. And yes, it is there so the attendants can talk directly to medical personnel on the ground while attending to the person needing care. PS - “intercom” is probably going to give people the wrong idea. It’s a headset with a thick black 50-foot long cord, and when you plug it in, it dangles down on top of passengers before getting to the aisle. Also, you can’t hear it - only the person wearing the headset hears anything…
- derefr 4y ago> Nobody is going to use it without a whole lot of people noticing. Well, if you make use of the complete system, sure. But if it just takes a regular TRRS jack; and if someone finds the socket and plugs their own headphones directly into it...
- tjohns 4y agoThe medical intercom jack is often in the middle of the cabin (on equipped aircraft). Flight attendants can plug in an aviation headset with a very, very long cord, and the pilots patch it into one of the radios in the cockpit. This allows the flight attendants to talk to a doctor on the ground while they're physically next to a passenger's seat.
- kaetemi 4y agoYou don't need physical access to interfere with an analog audio system. (Remember old cellphones?) Since they're saying it's an issue with the amplifier, I'm assuming someone found a weak spot that readily gets picked up by the system's input.
- Nextgrid 4y agoIs it really analog though? The audio might be analog, but they still have to "key" the mic which would be a digital input at the very least, or something even more complex such as a phone-like system where handsets have actual keypads and internal numbers. I wouldn't expect the amplifier to be active at all unless a "call" is in progress (otherwise you might hear a constant noise, plus energy saving/thermal concerns and all that), so even if there was interference around, it shouldn't be getting amplified to an audible level unless something is actually "keying" the mic.
- mirker 4y agoYeah, I don’t believe the system is analog end-to-end. Moving the audio signal to every speaker across the entire length of the plane with analog seems like a fight against physics.
- nullc 4y agowhat? analog PA systems that cross giant buildings or even campuses have been a thing for a long time. The traditional design uses a 70v or higher bus and a transformer at each speaker. I would be really surprised if the PA speakers we anything but that-- electronics at each speaker is a repair/failure rate headache.
- shon 4y agoPretty interesting. If it’s a hoax, it’s a pretty good one. If it’s a hack of any sort someone is taking their life in their hands because being caught tampering with any commercial airline systems could mean significantly jail time. Cleaning crews and other staff have enough time on the plane to do something… I’m thinking like an Adafruit Waveshield with a timer or something. If it’s a ghost, it seems like a horny adolescent one.
- chx 4y ago> because being caught tampering with any commercial airline systems could mean significantly jail time. not sure. A cursory reading of https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/32 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/32 doesn't mesh with a silly prank. Which law do you think they are breaking?
- BbzzbB 4y agoI doubt courts would interpret "hacked into an airplane's communication system" as a silly prank, but I ANAL.
- Nextgrid 4y agoPlugging in a Bluetooth transmitter into a user-accessible port and using the system as intended is "hacking" now? Sure, passengers weren't intended to use that port, but from a system perspective the system is being used as intended with no interference or exploitation. I'm not sure this system can even be "hacked" short of disassembling parts of the plane and tapping into the communications wiring.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoDo you really trust the government to have a nuanced definition of hacking? https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/10/missouri-gov-calls-journalist-who-found-security-flaw-a-hacker-threatens-to-sue/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/10/missouri-gov-cal... Yes, this is a state government and not federal. I’m sure you can find equally outlandish examples of federal cases.
- socraticmethod 4y ago>Two indicator lights (red/green) serve as attention getters and ensure a far reaching call function when a respective message is displayed. The red light is used for system and emergency information, the green light for communication information. The lights are steady in normal situations and will flash in emergency situations. >The ACPs give a long-range visual indication about the system status (e.g. PAX call active). They are installed at the ceiling in the middle of the aisle between the passenger/crew doors, close to the attendant stations. >The lighted segments are activated either continuously (steady) or flashing. In case of "normal" calls they are not flashing (steady), in case of "abnormal" or "emergency" situations they will flash. Only the blue PAX call field will never flash, this will be always a "normal" indication These indicator lights would be helpful in narrowing down if the emergency system was being engaged or not. Could potentially point to exploitation/hack of the PA system rather than rogue utilization of normal functions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ketanmaheshwari 4y agoThis could be an internal thing done as to arouse curiosity and attract passengers over the Halloween and the following holiday season.
- alar44 4y agoStrong Ken M vibes here.
- drozycki 4y agoPastor said that with the sharp rise in liberols taking the flu shot this year there is bound to be a rise in spooks and frights.
- z9znz 4y agoHaving annoying or disturbing loud human noises over the PA system for the entire flight is not something one does to "arouse curiousity". There's no way this is a sanctioned AA marketing program.
- userbinator 4y agoFar too early for Halloween, and I can't imagine such a company doing this as a marketing stunt.
- yellow_lead 4y agoScare your passengers on an airplane is very festive indeed.
- raydiatian 4y agoAliens That shit is fucking aliens
- seventytwo 4y agoWhen the first explanation fails, it’s aliens!
- fghorow 4y agoPaging Erich Von Daniken.
- mindcrime 4y agoAnd/or Graham Hancock.
- zamalek 4y agoI wonder if it isn't intentional (human or ghost). Maybe there's a common device to blame.
- sneak 4y agoWhy aren’t there logfiles in the system of every access and state change?
- robjan 4y agoAirline intercoms are usually analogue systems with no state or access restrictions other than physical.
- operator1 4y agoI know little about airplane tech, but do these onboard systems such as PA ever get OTA software updates? Perhaps an update got pushed that runs the prank? Could explain it happening on multiple flights and attendants being unable to stop it.
- jonny_eh 4y agoI think some kind of overlooked physical access to the system is the simplest explanation, since it would even effect an analogue system. Imagine there was some kind of mic input in the bathroom for some reason you could hook up a device to.
- exmadscientist 4y agoI've never heard of automatic updates for avionics. It's all under MX or operations control. But that's a moot point if it really is happening on both B737s and A321s.
- maxbond 4y agoThis reminded me of something that happened to me in college. This is a unlikely sounding story, but I swear it's the truth. I started noticing some odd sounds in the Student Union building. One day I had some time and decided to investigate. I realized it was coming from a fire alarm. I stood under the alarm and listened for a while. The alarm was quietly whistling "Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger" by Daft Punk.
- gre 4y agoSomeone in my engineering school opened the elevator panel and had it play a clip from the matrix (the full quote about there being no spoon) when you pressed a floor button.
- piperswe 4y agoWas there an AM transmission station nearby? Sometimes some metal objects can act as an antenna-speaker combo when there's a high power AM transmitter nearby. (some people have even reported this happening with dental fillings!) I'm assuming this is a bell or some other low-tech thing, if not there are probably many other explanations
- maxbond 4y agoNot to my knowledge, but it's possible. There certainly wasn't a radio tower around, but there were antennae all over the place, as there are on any large campus. I don't think that's what was happening; it seemed to be different alarms at different times, but I believe it was always the same song. Which seems to me like they were being randomly selected by a script. These were fancy fire alarms and it was 2014, it's entirely plausible in my mind that they were networked and running a vulnerable embedded Linux. I don't think it'd be a Mission Impossible level effort to make this happen. But, I'm going off of 8 year old memories, so the only thing I can say for certain is that it happened.
- afloyd 4y agoThis gives me an idea of an attack vector. These groans and moans seem rather quiet, and the airline claims its an amplifier issue. Assuming that the amplifier is not shielded from the cabin and that its analog tech, one could theoretically induce intentional interference to play whatever you want, right?
- jonny_eh 4y agoHas no one noticed that this is only affecting a single airline? This implies an inside job by an employee, no?
- gaetgu 4y agoNot necessarily. If I was to run a prank on airplanes, I would probably choose one airline. One one airline it can be dismissed as fake or an employee, etc. If it starts happening on multiple airlines, red flags start to go up all over the place and I would (theoretically, of course) start to be getting uncomfortably close to extremely hot water.
- jonny_eh 4y agoOr the pranker has air miles.
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bentobean 4y agoUnrelated, but brings back memories… Back when I was in college some twenty years ago, we somehow managed to stumble upon a phone number we could call that would connect us directly to passengers in some unknown elevator car in some distant city. We had great fun with that for a while.
- jahewson 4y agoFunny on so many levels.
- tzs 4y agoI was once in an elevator and the emergency phone starting ringing. I answered and it was a telemarketer trying to sell me a newspaper subscription.
- donatj 4y agoBack when I was in elementary school near 30 years ago we discovered we could print to any printer in the district over AppleTalk. We printed so much garbage to so many printers.
- kennyloginz 4y agoThese sounds are familiar to me from using “ pink trombone”, or praat, both vocal synthesizer. I would guess that a text - to - speech system is bugging out. https://dood.al/pinktrombone/ https://dood.al/pinktrombone/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- exodust 4y agoThat is fascinating, but the sounds on the plane a more natural to my ears. Voice recordings for sure. Either way I'd hate to hear that on a flight.
- kennyloginz 4y agoFrightening for sure. I think the clicks and clacks and environment sound from recording from a cell phone could explain the difference.
- canjobear 4y agoModern speech synthesizers don’t use tube models.
- totetsu 4y agoBut it is a fascinating alternative. https://www.hindawi.com/journals/bmri/2008/768232/ https://www.hindawi.com/journals/bmri/2008/768232/
- mintplant 4y agoI was thinking a codec designed for human voice transmission is bugging out.
- MacroChip 4y agoMaybe some test mode is getting activated on accident. And those are the sounds a developer recorded long ago and didn't remove.
- bentobean 4y agoLet’s just hope they don’t program this thing to play the brown note.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoOr that riot dispersal undulating tone meant to cause discomfort like the one used by Gaspar Noe in the beginning of Irreversible. We thought people were bad on planes before yikes!
- ck2 4y agoHow about an open intercom mic in the cargo hold? Stowaways? Pets?
- Apocryphon 4y agoSo that's what Havana Syndrome sounds like.
- JoshTko 4y agoIf that last theory is correct, should be super simple to identify a suspect. Simply find what passenger was on all the flights.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoDamn that guy has an annoying voice.
- tomcam 4y agoListen, pal, that's none other than protean blue checkmark Emerson Collins himself, well-known actor and producer of "Del Shores: Naked. Sordid. Reality" and "Southern Baptist Sissies". The voice you claim to be annoying is the instrument of a trained thespian.
- tomcam 4y agoUpdate. Emerson Collins found my comment in his daily Google alert, created an account, and downvoted me. Devastating. My only consolation is that the master knows who I am.
- pjerem 4y agoInteresting. I heard similar sounds from a rather big French train station speakers recently. For me it looks like it’s just a bug from the amplification system.
- tomcam 4y agoI feel like I'm going crazy when I read things like this. To me that is very clearly a human voice. Does it not sound that way to you?
- arcastroe 4y agoGoats yell like humans and we seem to recognize the sounds as human voices, even when they're not. It's probably a bad example, but maybe we "recognize" human voices even when they're not there. Similar to how we recognize faces everywhere that aren't really faces (e.g. the face on the moon). But anyway, I'm playing devil's advocate with myself. I agree that's definitely a human voice on the intercom.
- tomcam 4y agoNice rejoinder. Cannot disagree with any of it.
- ksaj 4y agoI'm late to the game BUT just in case someone sees this: Not so long ago they found that deep fake voices don't emulate the shape of the mouth and throat very well, and therefore it's easy to tell if a clip is a deep fake, or real. They should be able to run these sounds through the same software to see if it properly emulates a throat and mouth or not.
- Havoc 4y ago>They tell me that maintenance “determined the sounds were caused by an issue with the PA amplifier. There was no external access to the system.” That seems unlikely. Definitely sounds human
- 6stringmerc 4y agoIf it’s this widespread then it either has to be AA maintenance (perhaps a team having a bit of reputational mutiny because AA management pockets tons of cash and exploits cheap contractors and constantly bitches about pilot pay but wouldn’t fly planes without pilots) or it’s remote. As an audio person, musician, producer blah blah, that is totally human. Likely recorded and filtered a few times. By the inflections I think Eastern European. The sound of it reminds me of a Slavic based vocal upbringing. Doesn’t seem like North Korean, Latin, or North American to me. Probably about a couple minutes of audio looping somehow at the source. Far too many for it to be a hardware exploit because honestly who wants to invest that much in this kind of prank? This isn’t Zug Super Bowl level[0]. My guess is they’re coming through the least secure provider for a third party service - probably the WiFi enterprise thru being on the inside of them - and AA is their first playground where people are noticing. How they get from there to the intercom is probably buried deep in a couple audio wires plugged into overlapping sources unintentionally or there is some kind of frequency band that isn’t shielded properly so it’s possible to push the audio signal over something else and cause garbled noise and almost impossible to find. Like, in the past it was funny when picking up FM radio signals through my guitar amp, but it sucked when trying to have a serious jam session and talk between playing. Audio signals can be really powerful compared to other delicate systems IMO. Definitely curious and want to see how this unfolds! [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zug_(website) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zug_(website)
- gorgoiler 4y agoIs it the same audio every time?
- 6stringmerc 4y agoRelated anecdote: Back in 2003 or 2004 I was at University and my best friend went there too, a year behind me so different lives. He’s a brilliant software developer today and we ran amok digitally before the age of 18 and things really got serious. Free Kevin. We had that spirit. I was playing music and hanging out with Mary Jane and he got a job with campus IT. Through his personal explorations he gained access to the Admin of the campus AV system. I mean the entire thing - if it was connected, he could control it. I doubt that was in his job description or assigned permissions, but I didn’t ask. His way of proving it is you could tell him “I’m in Calculus II at 11-12:30 on Tuesday in Building X Room XXX” and at 11:55 the overhead projector would turn on magically but because it wasn’t connected to anything locally it was just the light. Off, then on again, then off for good. A little disruptive but hey it’s higher education and that taught me a valuable lesson about willpower and mischievousness with a Kokopelli spirit.
- hoppla 4y agoOn an airline, the intercom system was accessible from the guest Wi-Fi network. You would not even need to be on the plane to “patch” the system…
- pxmpxm 4y agoI would bet a large amount of money what you mentioned is entirely false. The PA systems are built into the aircraft, where as wifi is an aftermarket addon.
- jrootabega 4y agoUnsatisfying, Hanlon-style prediction: no one involved had any notable malice or competence. Maintenance and cleaning crews love to listen to radio/music on speakers while working. Someone from this staff plugged in a receiver to listen while servicing the plane, and forgot it. Or they left it there for convenience and didn't think anyone would notice. Someone else unrelated, while on the flight, found this receiver on their phone/laptop, and played these sounds, possibly unwittingly. AA may have found these devices after the incidents and just not reported it. Or they didn't take the reports seriously enough to comb the plane for problems. Or they gave up and would rather not lose the money by grounding the plane and tearing it down. (I don't have any aviation expertise, so I don't know exactly how disruptive it would be for them to to do this.)
- Crashbat 4y agoThis seems like the most likely explanation. Whoever left the device in the plane isn't likely to own up to it (if they even remember where they left it!) since they may lose their job.
- tl90 4y agodont know anything about the sound systems of aircrafts, but why can’t they switch off each sound system one by one and see which one causes it and then see the possible inputs to the one where the sound is played? I assume it cannot be that hard to do during maintenance period especially if this happens on multiple planes.
- duckqlz 4y agoThe sounds probably aren't a prank or a recording of a human at all. I am guessing it is just a resonant frequency of a standard part being picked up as a feedback loop due to some component which was recently exposed after a change in maintenance protocols. (or something similarly mundane) I have heard all sorts of ghoulish sounds picked up while tinkering with RF and old microchips. Our brains tend to anthropomorphize such sounds when we have never experienced them before. Going straight to the wildest explanations like "hacking" or "ghosts" is fun for our brains but further reinforces the inaccurate picture we had painted for ourselves initially.
- balex 4y agoI listened to the recording in the article, and it sounds like a human. Further, it sounds like the same human. And I found myself reading the emotional message behind the sounds. So...yeah, it's an interesting theory, but I think it's more likely a prank or someone making a point.
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoThere's a point in the MP3 that sounds possibly non-human at 0:18 to 0:19. The pitch goes quite high in a way that sounds artificial. But overall I agree that it sounds very human. For example, the grunt at 0:13 doesn't sound like random noise at all, it could easily be a sound effect in a movie or game.
- atkailash 4y ago
- dan-robertson 4y agoAnother way to think about it: there are a lot of planes and different ways the PA system could go wrong. You’re much less likely to read an article about a plane being ‘haunted’ by a strange clicking or buzzing or humming or white noise sound.
- ComplexSystems 4y ago
- neycoda 4y agoI just listened to it, and it's obviously some teenager or 20-something that's hacked into it, maybe screaming from the bathroom, or added something to a memory card somewhere.
- toomanyrichies 4y agoSounds like a caveman doing vocal warm-ups before his opera debut.
- zoomablemind 4y agoIt may be a wrong and long-stretch of an idea, but what if this is an audio being played into that headphones jack at a seat? Directly, this should not be possible (input vs output on the amp), but in case the PA mic signal is routed to common amp after keying and preamp, this technically may be possible. Now, if the "keying" includes some specific signal to allow the routing to PA, the question is if the "keying" signal can be sent from the seat's console. Then just play back the annoying track into the headphones jack.
- O__________O 4y agoLinked article appears to state the PA system is physically isolated — which I would assume means only known components of the PA system interact with each other: >> Professional reverse engineer/hardware hacker/security analyst Andrew Tierney (aka Cybergibbons) dug up the Airbus 321 documents in this thread, and is stumped too. https://twitter.com/cybergibbons/status/1573328954517499904 https://twitter.com/cybergibbons/status/1573328954517499904
- zoomablemind 4y agoI vaguely remember that PA messages are heard in headphones, so the PA signal is being patched through at some point. It's not clear how the "seats" bus is isolated. I assume it's a bus, so that seats are addressable. The seats should at least be able to send the "need attendant" signal. I hope a qualified technical analysis already pointed a few possible vectors for this. The question is in remediation and, well, identification of the perp(s). Either way, at this moment the story seems to act more as an attracting magnet than repelling for the airline. Back during summer, it certainly was another level of annoying and disturbing.
- FranOntanaya 4y agoCould it be from a throat mic of someone doing fighter plane training with high G maneuvers? Maybe it just so happens to overlap some frequency.
- O__________O 4y agoIn cabin medical audio jacks [2] are the likely explanation, but it would be easy to inspect those: https://i.stack.imgur.com/5w241.jpg https://i.stack.imgur.com/5w241.jpg * Unless someone had made dongle that once inserted looked like the same plugs, but raised enough to hide the dongle and match the color/texture of the surrounding plastic. The fake plugs on the outside would not even need to be functional and the device could be set to start on a delay, so whoever is placing them is not physically on the flight when it starts. It could even have an accelerometer to turn on after take-off and turn off on landing. If the person intentionally booked a seat at end of the plane, very likely they could easily add it when everyone is trying to leave the plane. Credit card skimmers do something similar all the time: https://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+spot+credit+card+skimmer&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+spot+credit+card+skim... ____________ This guess is based on information provided by two prior HN comments: [1] PDF of flight systems: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32958432 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32958432 [2] Photo of medical audio jacks: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32959686 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32959686
- 20after4 4y agoThis must be the explanation. The one thing I can't quite understand though is how someone could be simultaneously so very technically clever and yet execute such a mundane level of prank. This could be so much more epic if someone got more creative with the choice of audio track. I mean, it could be anywhere from totally hilarious to actual terrorism. Scary to think of the possibilities.
- 20after4 4y agoIf this is truly the explanation though, I wonder if the public will ever get to hear confirmation or if they'll just remove it and refuse to talk about it / threaten employees to keep it quiet.
- thenthenthen 4y agoA lot of technical (practical?) speculation here, anyone any thoughts on the actual content or original source of the recording? To me it sounds like Buddhist chants like from those Buddha machines[0] or possibly some type of throat chanting. Can someone shazaam it? :) [0] https://www.errorinstruments.com/a-51153210/new-synthe-noise-instruments-for-sale/traditional-buddhist-buddha-music-machine/ https://www.errorinstruments.com/a-51153210/new-synthe-noise...
- LennyHenrysNuts 4y agoIf it were 1970 I'd say it was a programmer's test that made it into the firmware and was shipped. We're a little more professional and we actually test stuff properly these days, so maybe it isn't that.