20 ms·
Almost half of cancer deaths are caused by smoking, alcohol, or obesity
- hamiltonians 4y agothen why do doctors do cancer screening by age and family history and not lifetyle? hmm. except for smoking, a lot is unkown about who gets cancer.
- robobro 4y agoRead the two lines of the article: > Data show that smoking, drinking alcohol and obesity are the biggest contributors to cancer worldwide. > Nearly 50% of cancer deaths worldwide are caused by preventable risk factors, such as smoking and drinking alcohol, according to the largest study of the link between cancer burden and risk factors Interested to see what your response is to the article once you finish reading it :-)
- toomuchtodo 4y agoLife causes cancer. :) The symptom is cancer, the problem statement is a fix is needed for the human immune system to be more targeted and aggressive in purging cancer from the body, as well as more robust cellular repair mechanisms. The human body can take enormous amounts of environmental abuse, but there’s clearly room for improvement.
- kingkawn 4y agoA more aggressive immune system can cause cancers, such a myeloma or lymphoma. Gotta watch what you wish for
- toomuchtodo 4y agoImprovements should be designed to balance self preservation with self destruction. Immunotherapy, gene therapy, and CRISPR are still in their infancy.
- fredgrott 4y agoahem metabolism by animals in of itself does not cause cancer. Biology wise cancer is the miss fire of a nature aging process.
- blacksmith_tb 4y ago"Approximately 39.5% of men and women will be diagnosed with cancer at some point during their lifetimes (based on 2015–2017 data)."[1] Many lives will experience cancer, but not the majority. So it seems to be more complex that immune inadequacy (unless 60% of immune systems are working really well, which would be noteworthy). It seems like a reasonable hypothesis that environment is playing a larger role than individual genetic variations. So encouraging people (or even scaring them) to not smoke, not drink, eat better and exercise more seems like a reasonable approach - it won't cure cancer, but it could reduce rates? 1: https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/understanding/statistics https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/understanding/statistics
- hamiltonians 4y agodoesnt change my point. docs screen by age, not lifestyle unless u smoke
- explaingarlic 4y agoAre the majority of these risk factors not predictable epigenetically or genetically?
- AdrianB1 4y agoI read somewhere (I don't remember the source, but it was some medicine journal) that 4% of smokers are genetically more inclined to die from lung cancer; while lung cancer is correlated with the number of cigarettes (intensity and length of time), these people will have lung cancer even with a very low number of cigarettes. I know a few anecdotal cases where entire families of smokers died from lung cancer, while their partners, also smokers, had no problem, but I don't put much weight on that. Also I heard that smoking can cause other cancers like colon cancer in specific genetic conditions, but I don't know more details.
- explaingarlic 4y agoI like to blindly attribute these things to bodily chemistry. Anything you put in your body now will affect everything from now on in your material world :) That approach works for me, anyway.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoThere are all kinds of carcinogenic compounds we know are avoidable but people are exposed to nonetheless. The article points out several examples. Some cancers are more likely to occur based on gender and more predictable gene expressions, but these aren’t mutually exclusive. You can be more likely to get cancer without doing anything special while still vulnerable to an increased risk of cancer through exposure to carcinogens (like alcohol, smoke, processed meats, etc).
- sxg 4y agoThis article is saying a lot less than the title leads on. The article states half of all cancer deaths are caused by smoking, alcohol, and obesity. Nearly every patient in the developed world is aware that all three of these are bad, but the struggle is in changing course on these three behaviors rather than a lack of knowledge that they're bad.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoIt seems possible that articles like this which help quantify the risk might do more to change behavior than the vague understanding that smoking, drinking, and being overweight are "bad for you". Many people will have had family or friends who developed cancer and if lucky, endured harrowing treatment and lived. Or did all that and didn't survive. Connecting those dots is a powerful motivator.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoIs it? I think in the US that connection is quite well known, and yet I have seen people lose parents and grandparents that way and keep eating McDonald’s at a prodigious rate.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWorkplace exposure to carcinogens is another major factor, as the article notes: > "In 2019, half of all male deaths from cancer, and more than one-third in women, were due to preventable risk factors including tobacco and alcohol use, unhealthy diets, unsafe sex and workplace exposure to harmful products, such as asbestos. From 2010 to 2019, global cancer deaths caused by these risk factors increased by about 20%, with excess weight accounting for the largest percentage of increase — particularly in lower-income nations."
- loeg 4y agoIs unsafe sex an oblique reference to cervical cancer, or is there some other known connection I’m not aware of?
- visava 4y agoThe solution to obesity is simple. People want tasty food . It is possible to make it with healthy ingredients. But market is flooded with white flour,sugar,wheat and milk products. It takes effort to prepare it yourself.
- loeg 4y agoI think tasty food (regardless of composition) might be the problem. If food was less tasty people might moderate their consumption better.
- vorpalhex 4y agohyper-palatable is the word that has come to be used
- pengaru 4y agoIt's a sort of arms race. Unprepared plain raw organic produce is delicious, if you haven't been eating prepared food covered in salt and other seasoning for years. Once you start adulterating your food with flavor crystals, you require that stuff just to move the needle. A flavor tolerance develops, similar to drug tolerance.
- mod 4y ago> Unprepared plain raw organic produce is delicious Yeah, although I doubt it was as delicious before modern farming. Or even if it was, we didn't have most of it. But an animal roasted over a fire is equally as delicious; just ask an Alone contestant. One woman ate the gut contents of a rabbit and said it was one of the best things she'd ever eaten. Hunger is the best condiment, as the saying goes.
- bowsamic 4y agoI don't think so, I think it's more that we grew to live in a "feast famine" environment, but suddenly we are now in an environment with infinite food. It goes against our instincts to not eat food that is there. Instead we have to hope we have the willpower to overcome it with our rational thought processes. Most people, if they are not busy with other things, will want to eat. "Thankfully" we have capitalism and so people are busy and pushed to be even busier. I think without that, if we really had time to sit and relax without those mental pressures of progression, we would be much fatter. It is just one of the ways that human material conditions has quickly changed way faster than the human animal has managed to evolve for it, and so it is unsuited for such environments. I think we might eventually have a technological solution (everyone on appetite suppressants)
- jjallen 4y agoI think it should be postponable. If everyone wasn't obese and didn't smoke or drink guess what... we would still get cancer or die of heart disease or dementia. At least this goes for the US and much of Europe.
- AdrianB1 4y agoIt is preferable to die of "old age" (including heart disease or dementia) at 90 than from cancer at 35. Yes, eventually everyone dies, but some early deaths are preventable, it seems to be half of cancer deaths, some car crashes, suicides etc. This means we can and should do something about it.
- colechristensen 4y agoNot always, if you’ve been close to someone who lived into their 90s and were barely there for a decade due to mental decline you wouldn’t necessarily think it was the best way to go. Rotting in a nursing home confused and suffering for a couple of decades isn’t luxury.
- AdrianB1 4y agoYou are completely right. In the few cases of dementia I know, people lived just a few weeks after they completely lost memory and awareness, not long term.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoThats unusual, if I'm understanding your description right. Severe dementia (requiring 24 hour care/supervision) lasts a couple of years on average. Even moderate dementia, the level at which people can live in memory care units but have trouble communicating and understanding their surroundings, can last ten years.
- BeetleB 4y agoYou were lucky. Some forms can last several years, and those are not unusual.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoFollowing on the discussion yesterday about "science is political and that's bad" (and posters saying "no, it's not"): Nature Magazine has soiled itself irrevocably with its political stances. Now when you read anything like this, you have to ask, "was this written because of some new scientific information, or was it just in furtherance of their agenda?"
- freeone3000 4y agoFurtherance of their agenda to... Get people to stop smoking, drink less, and lose some weight? Is this even an agenda or just good advice?
- Cupertino95014 4y agoIt's certainly good advice. However, Nature is there to publish new science, not to provide generic advice.
- oaktrout 4y agoAhh yes, the evil big vegetable lobby is trying to undermine the good that has been done by poor old Philip Morris.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoIt's certainly good advice. However, Nature is there to publish new science, not to provide generic advice.
- AnonCoward42 4y agoThe obsession that you can live longer by doing this healthy trick is not really helpful. Ultimately you are going to die of cancer if you avoid any other cause of death (and even that is impossible). What's annoying me is the survivor bias. How do you know that people wouldn't have died earlier if they didn't do what supposedly caused the death over decades? Let alone that you cannot actually pinpoint what caused the cancer (but guess of course). I think you shouldn't smoke and you probably should avoid alcohol or only consume in considerate amounts and don't eat like it's your last meal over and over, but you can't just say don't drink, smoke and overeat (or even don't eat this, but that) and pretend that it is better.
- onion2k 4y agoThe obsession that you can live longer by doing this healthy trick is not really helpful. It's not simply a matter of 'avoiding cancer' but more 'avoiding a slow, painful death due to cancer'. It's not even a matter of "you have to die of something!" Most forms of cancer are not a nice way to die. If you can avoid getting it so that you die of something else, especially something really nasty like lung cancer, you definitely want to give that a go. I'm old enough to have seen friends and relatives die of cancer and I really don't want to go that way. Seeing the affect on those people, and even more on their families who had to watch them fade away, was $^&%ing horrible.
- Otek 4y agoWhat I really want is more approachable Euthanasia. I’m not afraid of dying, it will happen to all of us, but I dont want for me or my relatives a months of pain when everyone knows it will only lead to death.
- autosharp 4y ago> you can't just say don't drink, smoke and overeat (or even don't eat this, but that) and pretend that it is better. Okay then, nothing you can do I guess. You're hereby absolved from behaving responsibly towards your own body. Is that better?
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoIt could be argued that smoking, alcoholism, and obesity are all means of coping with a high stress lifestyle. I wonder how many more people would die from other reasons if they were no longer able to use those coping mechanisms. Or maybe more importantly, how much total happiness would they have in their life if they had the extra time. I say this as a fairly recent cancer survivor if that matters. edit: Does anyone know if psychologists or sociologists have a formula for quantifying happiness? Something like mechanical advantage. It seems intuitive that certain behaviors can act like a fulcrum by increasing happiness now at the expense of sadness later, either born by you or those close to you. I'm sure we've all had smokers joke that you can keep the last 20 years of life, maybe they're on to something.
- oaktrout 4y agoI think if people didn't have smoking / drinking / overeating as coping mechanisms they might find healthy alternatives like exercise / altruism / creativity. Look at seventh day Adventists in Loma Linda (not a member myself), they live a long time and are very happy. For many, the last 20 years are only miserable because they didn't take care of themselves. It's possible to be 80 and active / healthy/ happy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- siftrics 4y agoAs a cancer survivor and former alcoholic, I am one example of a person who has found healthy coping mechanisms. Instead of coping with alcohol, I read math textbooks and do problems. This has improved my life dramatically. I feel good. I feel proud. And despite optimizing for happiness as opposed to wealth, this coping strategy has made me loads of money. I should mention my cancer occurred in my childhood, so it's not as though my drinking was a cause.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>For many, the last 20 years are only miserable because they didn't take care of themselves. Considering that about 40 million adult Americans are on anti-depressants (smoking and drinking aside), it seems like more of an issue then just failing physical health of the elderly.
- surfsvammel 4y ago"In 2019, half of all male deaths from cancer, and more than one-third in women, were due to preventable risk factors including tobacco and alcohol use, unhealthy diets, unsafe sex and..." How does unsafe sex cause cancer? What is unsafe sex in this context?
- retSava 4y agoProbably cancer from HPV virus, which (at least in Sweden) is vaccinated against in 10 (11? 12?) year-olds, before their sexual debut. HPV is so transmissible and so common that on average, if you have had 2-3 partners, you can kind of count on having HPV.
- yieldcrv 4y agoIt’s been a decade since 12-18 year olds were getting the vaccine You can just stick with adult Gen Z people now Finally a good excuse to not hook up with older people
- geysersam 4y agoThe other direction is rather more interesting in my opinion: No matter what you do, you can only reduce your chance of getting cancer by 50% compared to the average population.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoFitter, happier, more productive Comfortable (Not drinking too much) Regular exercise at the gym (Three days a week) Getting on better with your associate employee contemporaries At ease Eating well (No more microwave dinners and saturated fats) A patient, better driver A safer car (Baby smiling in back seat) Sleeping well (No bad dreams) No paranoia Careful to all animals (Never washing spiders down the plughole) Keep in contact with old friends (Enjoy a drink now and then) Will frequently check credit at (Moral) bank (hole in wall)
- wikitopian 4y agoThank you, fellow nineties emo kid.
- quadcore 4y agoCareful to all animals (Never washing spiders down the plughole) Whats that?
- thenerdhead 4y agoRinsing insects down the drain which drowns and kills them in the process.
- quadcore 4y agoDont get me wrong I hate to terminate any life, but whats the issue regarding health I still dont get it.
- thenerdhead 4y agoIt’s a song that talks about the perfect person.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- retSava 4y agoAnyone know what the curve for alcohol looks like? I know no amount of alcohol is "safe", and a lot of alc is very bad, but in between, what does it look like? Is it a cliff after more than 2 drinks a week? 10? Does it matter if it's beer or whiskey?
- acidburnNSA 4y agoI don't know, and that is very hard to measure definitively due to confounding variables. In the nuclear industry we have a similarly hard question for ionizing radiation dose. Since the 50s we just use a dumb linear no threshold curve, assuming every little bit hurts.
- laurencerowe 4y ago> Adults drinking seven to 14 drinks per week could expect, on average, a six-month shorter life expectancy as of age 40 > Those drinking 14 to 25 drinks per week could expect a shorter life expectancy by one to two years > Those drinking more than 25 drinks per week could expect a shorter life expectancy by four to five years https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/sorting-out-the-health-effects-of-alcohol-2018080614427 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/sorting-out-the-health-e...
- delecti 4y agoEven the lowest of those seems like an astronomical amount to me. I'm not sure I have 14 drinks per year. If increasing my drinking by 52x would on-average lose 6 months of life, seems like I probably shouldn't worry.
- laurencerowe 4y agoTo put it in perspective, life expectancy for men in the US is about 4 years shorter than in Europe.
- beefman 4y agoVirtually all deaths from solid cancers are preventable with routine scans to find tumors before they metastasize. Doctors have for decades refused to learn to use this technology.[1-4][5-9] * Meanwhile, population studies like the one this article is based on[10] are horseshit because they are subject to unknown degrees of sampling bias, rely on enormous assumptions (such as linear relationships which may not hold at all being applied over many orders of magnitude), and cannot in any case establish causality. [1] https://www.pocus.org/ https://www.pocus.org/ [2] https://www.butterflynetwork.com/ https://www.butterflynetwork.com/ [3] https://www.exo.inc/ https://www.exo.inc/ [4] https://vavehealth.com/ https://vavehealth.com/ [5] https://ezra.com/ https://ezra.com/ [6] https://www.halodx.com/ https://www.halodx.com/ [7] https://www.prenuvo.com/ https://www.prenuvo.com/ [8] https://www.simonone.com/ https://www.simonone.com/ [9] https://www.lifeimagingfla.com/ https://www.lifeimagingfla.com/ * Compare the experience of getting an x-ray from a dentist to getting one from a doctor. Or getting an ultrasound from an OB to getting one from any other doctor. [10] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35988567/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35988567/
- picture 4y agoRoutinely scanning people without symptom or otherwise cause for concern is not a good idea. The human body is very messy and variable, and it's hard for anyone or anything to reliably spot thing that are actually worth acting on. If the doctor spots a vague blob - how can they know what it is without any symptoms? The course of action is then "come back in three months for another scan." Subjecting a population to unnecessary routine full body scans, especially with radiation, will cause harm statistically. There are also countless examples of people undergoing unnecessary operation and suffering complications, like losing a perfectly fine healthy heart and requiring transplant.
- dan00 4y agoYes, the breast cancer screening already has quite questionable results.
- landryraccoon 4y agoWouldn’t the skill of analyzing scans improve if they were done more frequently? It seems like you’re promoting a self fulfilling prophecy. Doctors aren’t good at reading scans, so scans will cause false positives. But doctors are capable of learning and improving their skills. They will surely rapidly learn to screen a lot of false positives, thereby saving lives.
- solidist 4y agoEverything in moderation. Those who are conscientious achieve longevity but trade off with less than ideal experiences of anxiety.
- mmaunder 4y agoInteresting seeing alcohol appear more often as an underlying cause of disease. It used to be that alcohol in moderation was going to save us all.
- skeeter2020 4y ago"Alcohol in moderation" is far less than most think. Depending on study, closer to 3 drinks per week or 4 oz of red wine daily. How many people do you know who drink, but only 1/2 a beer a day?
- mod 4y agoI own a bar. I don't know any customers who drink 3 only drinks per week. We definitely have some that don't drink, or only a couple times per year. They come in and play pool, etc. But I would guess 95% of our customers drink close to 5 drinks per DAY, averaged. (It's a local regulars bar, so we see the same faces every day).
- wbc 4y agoAnyone know of promising cancer startups? Was listening to a podcast that mentioned pancreatic cancer mortality rates and it's basically a death sentence (stage 1 85%+, later 95%+) I don't drink or smoke but would love to avoid cancers. Wife was working at a great one but it basically shutdown cause clinical trials are so expensive.
- xtracto 4y agoWe need more advanced clinical trial /organ-body simulations. That's what we as Computer Scientists can do... if we could have a sufficiently good virtual representation of the human body (at least enough parts of it)the cost and time of human trials would be reduced so much... it would be revolutionary.
- giantg2 4y agoYeah, and 100% of automobile deaths are preventable too (by not driving, which is the same logic applied in the study).
- pimlottc 4y agoOr by improved road design and better transit alternatives. The point is, we can do something about it.
- giantg2 4y agoTheoretically you might be right, but feasibly/politically that claim is tenuous.
- defterGoose 4y agoThis isn't at all borne out by the data yet, unless you're talking about the purely tautological case.
- yomkippur 4y ago
- viktorcode 4y ago> Data show that smoking, drinking alcohol and obesity are the biggest contributors to cancer worldwide. Does this mean that the predominantly muslim states have far less cancer cases?
- UIUC_06 4y agoThe argument that "more knowledge is better, always" is just not viable. Not when you look at all the people driving alone in their car, or walking alone on the street with a mask on. There are, as any doctor will tell you, large numbers of people who will see their doc for any questionable data and demand treatment. Preferably a pill they can take once a day. They are not willing to be reassured and will happily go to a different doctor who gives them what they want.
- darepublic 4y agoEarly detection important but in Canada you aren't going to get it unless you are very lucky
- anonymous344 4y agoIt's funny how cr is still billions / year, but there has been this natural clinic that has cured thousands of people.. .from 1970. was it something like gerrison miracle etc.. of course big pharma does not like "free" medicine
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nativecoinc 4y agoMy paternal grandmother got dementia and eventually died. My oldest uncle got dementia and eventually died. My father (the middle one) has dementia now. Now my youngest uncle is afraid that he only has a few good years left. My fortunate paternal grandfather just had a heart-related incident and died quickly at a much younger ager than his wife. I follow a good lifestyle to the degree that I do only because I want a good quality of life in my middle years and a bit beyond that. I am not interested in subsisting on carrots, cauliflower and exercise bands so that I can become a fit 75 year old with dementia. Hopefully I’ll be lucky and die in early old age or I’ll get cancer. Dementia can fuck off.
- irrational 4y agoMy brother in laws sister was recently diagnosed with cancer. Before she was diagnosed, she quit her job with benefits to stay home and take care of her father with advanced Parkinson’s. Her cancer is treatable and has a high probability of being curable, but she doesn’t have and can’t get insurance and doesn’t qualify for government help. Her choice is death or go into such incredible debt that she will never have hope to pay it off. She is 29. She has chosen death.
- synaesthesisx 4y agoI'm not following. Can't she just take on debt and eventually file bankruptcy and get it discharged? Bankruptcy only has temporary repercussions, and is objectively preferable to death, which is permanent. Medical debt is the leading cause of bankruptcy in the United States. Things like cancer can easily result in 7 digit bills, even WITH insurance.
- deltaonenine 4y ago
- neilv 4y agoThis is in the US? Has she worked with hospital staff, social workers, and lawyers (and maybe even federal/state representatives/officials) on all the possible ways to swing this? (Examples: maybe there's some way to get into ACA marketplace insurance soon, or to get onto Medicaid, or to do asset protection?) Stress, and being in the mode of taking care of someone with advanced illness, might have her feeling down, and approaching and thinking about this differently than she would normally.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>Her choice is death or go into such incredible debt that she will never have hope to pay it off. She is 29. She has chosen death. What about going into debt to get healthy and just flipping her debtors the bird? Or bankruptcy? Or waiting for hyperinflation to render her debts moot? Or moving to another country where those debts are effectively meaningless?
- kazinator 4y agoWhen speaking about cancers attributable to lifestyle, why does it have to be deaths? Why not incidences of cancer? Not all incidences of cancer lead to death. When a death is prevented, that can be at any stage, from avoiding the lifestyle choice like smoking and drinking, to the doctors spotting the cancer early and intervening in time. So if we are talking about cancer deaths preventable through lifestyle changes, that is just mixing in too many variable. Some incidences of cancer attributed to lifestyle may have been prevented from becoming deaths due to medical intervention, which clouds the numbers.
- sgjohnson 4y ago> Data show that smoking, drinking alcohol and obesity are the biggest contributors to cancer worldwide. I’m aware that all of those things are bad. If they get me in the end, I’m fine with that. I’m not going to change my lifestyle just because it’s going to increase my life expectancy by a couple of years.
- iwanttocomment 4y ago... and what I've learned from this is that half of cancer deaths have absolutely nothing to do with smoking, alcohol or obesity. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
- Pr0GrasTiNati0n 4y agoWifi/Routers,Mobile phones & masts...... All cause a lack of oxygen...silent weapons for quiet wars....Covid was cover for their upgraded network with even less safety done than the last gen.. You all know it...we all grew up learning the same tech..your just scared shitless by the implications of it!!.. Covid should have woken you all up...instead your playing with the devil for a last round---god speed!
- cwillu 4y agoAlternate title: less than half of cancer deaths are caused by…
- perlwle 4y agothe Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse and Addiction just released a new report[1] on Low-Risk Alcohol Drinking Guidelines. > Among healthy individuals, there is a continuum of risk for alcohol-related harms whereby the risk is: > • Negligible to low for individuals who consume two standard drinks or less per week; > • Moderate for those who consume between three and six standard drinks per week; and > • Increasingly high for those who consume more than six standard drinks per week. standard drink is the equivalent of a bottle of beer (12 oz., 341 ml, 5% alcohol) read more on the old report [2] I know I will watch my beer intake more closely now. [1] https://ccsa.ca/update-canadas-low-risk-alcohol-drinking-guidelines-final-report-public-consultation-report https://ccsa.ca/update-canadas-low-risk-alcohol-drinking-gui... [2] https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/substance-use/alcohol/low-risk-alcohol-drinking-guidelines.html https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/substance-us...
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThe only three things worth living for kill you.
- joshxyz 4y agoIts a good life anyway hahaha damn
- _8j50 4y agoHow do alcohol and obesity cause cancer? Is it a correlation or patients not being strong enough to fight cancer as a result of these?