33 ms·
Declining quality of consumer-grade products – 2009 fridge compressor autopsy
- mancerayder 4y agoWhat about textiles? I'm ready to open my wallet wide for quality t-shirts that fit, and yet I'm faced with some low quality crap from previously reliable brands. Talk about survivorshirt bias.
- didgetmaster 4y agoThere are some things that you don't want to last more than about 10 years. Big CRT TVs and laptop computers come to mind. My elderly parents have a bunch of things that still work, but once they pass the kids are taking them straight to the landfill.
- donohoe 4y agoAnecdotal, but I’m currently dealing with a broken fridge. It’s less than 2 years old and the compressor failed. Repair tech said to contact a Frigidaire even though it has no warranty. He said he’s seen a stack of compressor failures on relatively new fridges.
- 43920 4y agoThis just happened to me too - 3 year old Frigidaire, failed compressor. Would be interesting if this really is a trend rather than just anecdotal, but I suppose we'll never know. What's ridiculous is the lack of reasonably-priced replacement parts. I tried to get the fridge repaired, and the cost of a new compressor + the cost of having someone swap it was more than the cost of an entire new fridge.
- donohoe 4y agoSame! I complained (nicely) to Frigidaire and they are covering cost of full repair.
- slowmovintarget 4y agoFrom the notes: "These marginal design choices are not the only way to get an efficient unit, since the fridge compressors from the 1940's and 1950's era were very efficient, while having consistently longer lives. This failed unit is purely an example of doing just enough to get by until it is someone else's problem." I've been seeing this as a common issue throughout most of the household appliances we've tried to buy in the last ten years. They just don't last.
- jackmott 4y agoCould it be because the information age causes companies to compete on price much more aggressively? You can’t easily prove that your fridge really will last longer, but easy to price the price is low.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willis936 4y agoI have the internet at my fingertips. I know a thermostatically controlled toaster is feasible to make into a cheap product because it existed in the 1960s and we now have transistors. Every single toaster is exactly the same with cosmetic differences. They're priced from $10 to $500 with no distinguishing features in the first $200. The market is not working, we just have the tools to realize how badly it's broken.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThe market works fine. For any category of good you can think of there will be producers that make a high quality version of it. Consumers who care about that quality (according to however you’re measuring it) will make their decisions accordingly. Consumers who reveal a preference for caring less about that quality will make decisions based on other criteria. If your complaint is that this requires effort from the consumer, then that’s not something any market could fix. The consumer will always have to consider what their preferences are and how the offerings in the market align with them, if the want to end up purchasing goods/services that align with their preferences.
- nimbius 4y agosounds like a lack of proper QC and insufficient or the wrong grade of oil was added...but, home compressors are this weird sealed monstrosity that can never be properly serviced without a byzantine amount of hacky gizmos anyhow so... ¯\_ (ツ) _/¯
- jjcm 4y agoThe server seems to be having some issues. Here's the video the article discusses: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DpnnLQNgUiQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DpnnLQNgUiQ
- kube-system 4y agoIt was a premium product at the time and it was priced accordingly. Only 85% of Americans could afford one at that time. Appliances today are dirt cheap for a reason. The reasons everyone has a fridge today isn’t because everyone is rich, it’s because fridges are cheap.
- kingTug 4y agoWhat if I'm rich and just want reliable appliances? It's a wild goose chase.
- s0rce 4y agoI found a company called Unique based in Canada that makes ovens and stoves without all the electronics (which are really the only part in stoves I've ever had issue with, the rest is very simple mechanically and either doesn't fail or is easily repaired). My brother got one and is really happy.
- kube-system 4y agoPremium/commercial brands exist.
- hardolaf 4y agoHeck even without going "premium", you can pretty much just buy LG or low-end Bosch models of most things and be fine. But if you buy Samsung, you might as well budget for a replacement ASAP.
- kube-system 4y agoAgreed. Bought all new appliances 10 years ago, and the only ones that have given me trouble have been Samsungs.
- tekno45 4y agoi wonder if samsung products in Korea are better? How did they get so big outside of phones?
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoRecently read "The Waste Makers" (published in 1960, I believe). Nothing too mind-blowing since the advertising tricks used in that era are quaint compared to today's, but it definitely opened my eyes to how long the decreased quality/planned obsolescence phenomenon has been going on.
- mc32 4y agoOne thing I’ve noticed compared to childhood appliances is plastic mechanisms (gears, actuators, brackets, etc). These tend to become brittle or soft with age or exposure to chemicals and lead to early failure. Of course metal also suffered from fatigue and there are quite strong and durable thermoplastics but today I see cheap plastic used liberally.
- rubidium 4y agoThis is something I’m interested in. There are strong plastics, but a lot of stuff nowadays seems to be the cheapest plastic imaginable. Anyway to know if what you’re getting?
- mc32 4y agoI don't think so. MFGs are likely to swap in new parts without notice --they may keep track through serial numbers, lots or similar, but not something they would expose to end users.
- s0rce 4y agoTake it apart and see? If you have experience you can usually roughly tell what kinds of plastics are used, although some are nearly indistinguishable.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoWalk in to an appliance store or website, or someone's house or a car park if secondhand, with your tool kit and expert knowledge and do a full teardown on anything your considering purchasing. Sounds time consuming.
- e40 4y agoThis. The times I’ve fixed my appliances rather than replace them, the cause was most often a broken plastic part!
- prawn 4y ago
- verisimi 4y agoWhy make a good product, when you can make a good advert or public relations campaign instead and gain repeat customers in a shorter timescale? (As your product will need replacing sooner.) If all the corporations collude in this way, everyone is a winner. But of course the customer is at fault for this environmental misuse of resources.... right? We should shoulder the expense of cleaning up the mess that corporations and governments create. ^ That is the corporate/governmental plan - spin the problem as an environmental issue that the consumer pays for! (Again.) And extract even more money from the customer in the process as they get rid of servicable products in favour of echo-friendly ones. Make laws to force them to do this too! It's a win win for the corporations!
- verisimi 4y agoMass production is only profitable if its rhythm can be maintained.. that is, if it can continue to sell its product in steady or increasing quantity. The result is that while, under the handicraft or small-unit system of production that was typical a century ago, demand created the supply, today supply must actively seek to create its corresponding demand. Edward Bernays, 1930 I believe that competition in the future will not be only an advertising competition between individual products or between big associations, but that it will in addition be a competition of propaganda. Edward Bernays, 1930
- rglover 4y agoWhat you're attributing to "evil corporations" is really just mimetic theory playing out. Most people want (in general, but specifically here, those working in corporations) to play it safe and in turn, end up copying "the other guy" in the form of product focus, strategy, and culture. The sad truth is most people in most companies are just lemmings which creates the illusion of collusion, when really, it's just a whole lot of unoriginality.
- verisimi 4y agoI think it's a strategy, as per the 2 quotes I also provided by Edward Bernais from 1930 - it's not even a new strategy! Bernays is the father of public relations, he got women smoking, gave us egg and bacon for breakfast, initiated throwaway culture via advertising, etc - he helped shape the culture we find. This was by design, as he says. You should read some of his other quotes - it's all very conspiratorial before that was even a term: https://libquotes.com/edward-bernays/works/propaganda https://libquotes.com/edward-bernays/works/propaganda Here's a good one: > The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society. Those who manipulate this unseen mechanism of society constitute an invisible government which is the true ruling power of our country. We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, our ideas suggested, largely by men we have never heard of. This is a logical result of the way in which our democratic society is organized. Vast numbers of human beings must cooperate in this manner if they are to live together as a smoothly functioning society. Edward Bernays Obviously, it's not a strategy that will be much discussed, as its such an unappealing prospect. But the situation we find makes far greater sense as a conspiracy than companies merely stupid (which I agree is a part).
- andrewstuart 4y agoYeah my stupid Hisense fridge that I bought only four years ago is already flaking out. I has Whirlpool washing machine that lasted more than 20 years. When it finally gave up the ghost I bought a Fisher and Paykel that literally within 2 months of the 2 year warranty expiring. To their credit, Fisher and Paykel replaced it but even so.....
- replygirl 4y agore: fridge, hisense is a tv company re: laundry, did you ever consider getting a second whirlpool? either way, what about the paykel outweighed 20 years of reliability?
- cwillu 4y agohttps://www.hisense-usa.com/home-appliance/explore-home-appliance/refrigerators/all-refrigerators https://www.hisense-usa.com/home-appliance/explore-home-appl...
- replygirl 4y agoi'm not denying gps lived experience lol i'm saying why buy the cheap tv company's refrigerator
- andrewstuart 4y ago>> why buy the cheap tv company's refrigerator I've now decided to buy the very cheapest possible fridge in the future. Expensive still seems to be shit, so it may as well be cheap and shit.
- andrewstuart 4y ago>> re: fridge, hisense is a tv company Damn that explains why it didn't keep food cold. >> e: laundry, did you ever consider getting a second whirlpool? either way, what about the paykel outweighed 20 years of reliability? Can't recall why I didn't get another Whirlppol - maybe they are out of business now because their products lasted too long? Regardless, no doubt in the 20 years sense then they would have switched to the same cheap crap manufacturing as everyone else.
- jollybean 4y agoThey didn't necessarily think about lifetimes back then. LEGO bricks used to be made to withstand nuclear holocaust because, well, the Engineers though they should be 'durable'. It was hard to convince them to scale back a bit. They are still 'durable' as anyone walking with bare feet near children can attest, but just not quite as invulnerable as before. They saved a lot without compromise. Fridges may not need to last 30 years, it costs a lot to do so, so let consumers decide. What should happen is something about 'lifetime and warranty'. Some people might want 'long lasting things' in which case we should be able to clearly differentiate.
- ricardobeat 4y ago“let consumers decide” is a dark joke. In practice, the market will race to the bottom, and the only quality items left will be at the other end of the spectrum, unaffordable for 99% of consumers. You see this everyday, it has become very hard to find great manufacturing quality on every kind of product, from appliances to phones, cars, even mundane stuff like a lemon juicer or a light fixture. Everything at market prices is not built to last more than a handful of years.
- jollybean 4y agoI don't think it's a scam, 'lower price' is such a hugely powerful thing as a first order issue. Wallmart + China has changed the world, middle and lower class people now have material abundance that was unthinkable in the past. I mean 'too much stuff'. If we can get to the point of being able to recycle materials effectively, I'm fine with it becoming normative. "The Robot made me this really great cappuccino machine it breaks in 6 years but that's fine because I want the new one, with the newer features" Or "The Robot made me this 'metric' wrench system for really cheap, which won't last long, but that's fine, I use it literally not even once a year around the house, but I really do value having it around and available"
- ggm 4y agoNot all Lego bricks. Some early bricks were a weak plastic which deformed in the little "cups" underneath. Had 1960s lego, some was good, some wasn't. They definitely had a pre-stable window (and these were real Danish lego, not some 3rd nation knock off)
- newaccount2021 4y agoThere aren't even good options anymore. An appliance repair guy I know says even venerable Bosch dishwashers are a shadow of their past reputation. Expensive appliances share most guts with cheaper models...spending more doesn't mean higher quality anymore
- AvocadoPanic 4y agoSo much of what you pay for is Perceived Value, rather than real value.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoThings have definitely changed. These appliances used to last decades but not anymore. The reason brands like Bosch had a famous name in the first place was the quality, it wasn't just ads.
- techsin101 4y agomy grandma house has stuff STILL running, it's been running for 40 years. Fans, AC, Fridge, Sewing machine, Grinder, Juice Machine. Everything built like a tank and works non-stop. Heck even the light bulbs.
- f38zf5vdt 4y agoHugged to death, go here. https://archive.ph/hOrqv https://archive.ph/hOrqv
- swayvil 4y agoIf the quality of things goes down. And your wealth remains consistently such that you can just afford to pay your bills (that is, keep yourself supplied with all the necessary things). Then poverty is happening. And it is being masked. Food and shitty food are both called food but they are not the same thing. Their sameness is a trick of language.
- replygirl 4y agopipe and representation of pipe are both called pipe but they are not the same thing. their sameness is a trick of language
- inferiorhuman 4y agoAs I'm in the middle of replacing a one-year-old LG fridge I've been doing a bit of reading. Apparently rotary compressors like this require exceptionally precise tolerances to achieve any manner of reliability. Thirteen years doesn't strike me as particularly bad. Not great, but not bad. That 80-year-old fridge the repair shop guy is bragging about is almost certainly not an auto defrost unit. So, sure, it's probably close to a modern fridge in power consumption but the tradeoff is you'll have to scrape ice out of it periodically. https://hbr.org/1989/03/cold-competition-ge-wages-the-refrigerator-war https://hbr.org/1989/03/cold-competition-ge-wages-the-refrig... Edit: Pretty early on I got a couple wireless temperature probes and used rtl-sdr to pipe the data into a TimescaleDB instance (and slapped Grafana in front of it). I have no idea what the actual problem was because LG was keen on a refund over a repair. The symptoms were failure to cool and ice buildup on the evaporator getting into the fan and making a racket. The tech diagnosed a bad thermistor which brought the freezer temp during defrost down from 50°F to about 30–40°F. Even though the tech took a steam gun to the evaporator, it took about two weeks before enough ice built up and fell into the fan again. At this point the fridge wasn't getting below 40°F either and my landlord decided to take them up on the refund offer. Could've been a bad compressor as one of the failure modes is inability to pump refrigerant. The compressor itself sounded like a ringing bell. I stopped caring because nobody at LG cares and they are not positioned to actually service their appliances. It's likely a design flaw they either already know about or don't want to know about. Getting through to a person empowered to do anything is nearly impossible and their techs have a miserable time trying to get parts from their poorly run warehouses. I'm a bit apprehensive that other companies have joined the race to the bottom, but for now LG is solidly in never again territory for me.
- bombcar 4y agoAuto-defrost is nice for the first X years, until it starts to ... not defrost as much or as well. Sometimes the simpler ones are nicer, even if they require a bit more thought/work to use.
- inferiorhuman 4y agoMost full sized residential fridges are auto defrost these days. I think it's been that way since the 80s or so. I've a 2003 build Whirlpool fridge that's been just fine. In that era the defrost logic is usually mechanical and if/when the defrost timer fails it's a $30 part that's fairly easy to replace. The LG that I just junked uses electronics to control the defrosting. That gets expensive to fix but (I think) that's also not what failed in that piece of crap.
- hollywood_court 4y agoWe have completely remodeled both the exterior and interior of our last 70's home. But we haven't replaced a single appliance. I have made far too much money repairing newer appliances for clients and friends.
- nabakin 4y agoLooks like the website is down. Here. https://archive.ph/hOrqv https://archive.ph/hOrqv https://youtube.com/watch?v=DpnnLQNgUiQ https://youtube.com/watch?v=DpnnLQNgUiQ Maybe we can switch links? @dang
- cwillu 4y agocgi-bin: haven't seen you in a long time.
- legitster 4y agoFor newer appliances, I've weirdly found that spending less money is key to achieving longevity. Smaller, fewer features, less moving parts. Avoid gimmicky features that your grandparents never needed. I'm a real cheapskate when it comes to appliances and have yet to have one crap out on me.
- yojo 4y agoPCBs, sensors, and switches seem to cover most failure modes of modern appliances. I try to minimize the number of each in every purchase. My favorite recent buy was a Victory range hood with mechanical switches and no PCB. More like this please.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's triply annoying as the computers in these devices absolutely pale in comparison to a Raspberry Pi - it would be nice if all appliances used one general purpose board that could be easily sourced; as it is nobody will pay $750 for a control board to fix a washer when a brand new one is less.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThe $750 price tag means that either someone is getting ridiculously rich and/or the prices are artificially inflated in order to discourage repair. There's no reason a board with a few relays or MOSFETs and the processing power of a pocket calculator should cost much more than a Raspberry Pi.
- sudosysgen 4y agoIt's probably because the new models have incompatible boards and there is a small stockpile of that model left.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's exactly this - once the line stops making the boards, they stockpile the remainder for warranty support and as that supply dwindles the price begins to skyrocket.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoThese studies never account for survivorship bias. There were plenty of crappy appliances decades ago, but they’ve all long since broken, so we only have the very best old appliances to compare against today. Also, the inflation adjusted cost of a fridge in the 50s was something like $10k. A $10k fridge today (e.g. Sub Zero) will easily last for many decades. A $1k Wal-Mart special will not.
- e40 4y agoSub Zero fridges are terrible. The people I’ve known that had them rued the day they bought them. They are a status symbols, that’s why they cost so much, not because they are top quality.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoThat is not what I’ve heard from speaking to appliance repair techs, or builders/architects, or the Sub Zero owners I know with 15+ year old refrigerators that have never had any issues (except the ice maker, which is an inherently unreliable piece of technology). My guess is your friends aren’t maintaining them properly (they know they have to clean the condenser coils every couple months, right?) Either that, or they have those “integrated” models with no visible vent for the condenser, which of course will overheat the compressors and electronics.
- AnonymousPlanet 4y agoAh, the fridge equivalent of "you're holding it wrong"
- e40 4y agoSee this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32464782 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32464782
- liminalsunset 4y agoI've worked on one from ~2008. The fridge has a decent build quality, and two (!) compressors inside of it. It uses more metal components, more structural supports, etc, compared to most other fridges I've seen. So it's "better". It also is designed such that you absolutely cannot clean the inner layers of the fan-cooled condenser coil without major disassembly of the fridge. The service panel on the front can be removed, but there is a metal fan shroud that is difficult to remove and turns what ought to be routine maintenance into an ordeal involving taking things apart and taking the built in fridge out of the wall. Whether this was deliberate or just an oversight, I don't know. There would have been many other simple and cost-neutral ways to implement this cover.
- tejohnso 4y ago> an example of doing just enough to get by until it is someone else's problem Sounds like what I've been noticing in grade school education. Perfect grades for everybody! Just please move on and don't check for any actual knowledge acquisition.
- ProfessorLayton 4y agoWithout numbers it's really hard to say how good or bad these engineering choices were in regards to the consumer to come out on top or not. In my experience appliances are a lot more efficient and cheaper than they used to be. My new stainless steel fridge has much more capacity while using the same amount of power than the 20yo one it replaced (Which didn't actually fail, but the white coating was rusting all over the place). My HE washer doesn't fill the entire tub compared to the old upright ones, so my water heater is used less, and spins at ~1,200rpm, greatly reducing dry times for my electric dryer. The recessed lighting in my house went from 90 watts per bulb to 12 watts for LED, and saves me $$ on cooling when needed. My tankless water heater heats up only the water being used, no more, no less. I'm paying roughly 32¢/KW all-in (after taxes, fees etc.) for electricity in the Bay Area, so efficiency gains build up quickly over time. Anecdotally, the only issues I've had so far have been with poorly engineered Samsung refrigerators, where the fans would seize due to ice buildup, not mechanical wear.
- nabakin 4y ago> In my experience appliances are a lot more efficient and cheaper than they used to be. turbokinetic agrees modern refrigerators are more energy efficient but at the expense of longevity and not worth it > I am saying that this compressor, and its application, show clear engineering choices made, which sacrificed its life span in the name of some modicum of energy savings.
- ProfessorLayton 4y ago>turbokinetic agrees modern refrigerators are more energy efficient but at the expense of longevity and not worth it Without numbers to back up that claim, that's just their opinion, as is mine. I my experience the energy savings have been significant enough for that to not be a big concern. There may be an environmental argument here of course, but that's a separate argument than what consumers feel in their pocketbook.
- nabakin 4y agoIf our goal is to minimize cost (ignoring the environmental side of things), longevity must be taken into account. If energy savings at the expense of longevity truly makes refrigerators cheaper in the longterm then that's awesome, but I worry planned obsolescence is ruining the appliance market and increasing consumer expense.
- leashless 4y agoMy company is working on changing the economic incentives for manufacturers, so that they will make high quality durable goods. Here's how it works: 1) Each item has a unique serial number, and a database for storing maintenance records about the item. 2) When the item is going to be resold, third parties including the original manufacturer sell warranties on the item to protect the new owner. A manufacturer would inspect, refurb, and re-warranty on each iteration. 3) The new buyer pays more for the item, and the warranties on top of that, because they're getting goods closer to new goods in performance. 4) The manufacturers are profiting every time the goods are resold, possibly as much or more than selling a new one. We think this model of the circular economy is a lot more likely to succeed than the current model which involves ripping things down to their raw materials then reusing those materials to manufacture new things. https://mattereum.com/circular-economy/ https://mattereum.com/circular-economy/ <--- more here
- matrix_overload 4y agoYeah, sure, buying "physical asset NFTs" from you will suddenly convince major appliance manufacturers to change their ways and part with millions of dollars in profit. Sorry, the problem you mentioned is 100% valid, but the NFT-based solution you are offering is a pure grift.
- tehwebguy 4y agoAnyone know if Allstate (seems to be the primary warranty parter on eBay) or Asurion (Amazon) sell their add-on warranty data to third parties? Someone could beat Consumer Reports by just purchasing & publishing the raw data (warranties sold, claims made, claims paid).
- vermilingua 4y agoIf I’m understanding correctly, you’re asking the manufacturers (and/or other warranty writers) to take on liability for unknown damage that may have been accrued over the lifetime of the item. The only way to make this damage known would be to return the item to the factory to be inspected, which would be considerably more expensive than “ripping things down to their raw materials”. How do you solve this problem in a way that consumers aren’t paying for all these externalities? EDIT: didn’t even see the crypto connection, that answers that question.
- 1270018080 4y agoWhy can't a new competitor come in, make non-shitty products, and make billions? Is there really a grand planned-obsolescence conspiracy, or is this a mixture of survivorship bias, recency bias, and a strong imagination?
- bombcar 4y agoBecause it's hard to make non-shitty products and be known for it. By the time you have a reputation for quality products, you're often acquired or out of business. There are actually cases of this in some specialty equipment.
- rubidium 4y agoBecause everyone buys your product once and never thinks about it again. Really: I’ve talked to commercial product managers who bemoan the fact that all their customers are perfectly happy with the 10-20 year old instrument they have. There’s no revenue there.
- Nextgrid 4y agoBecause how can you tell apart a brand that makes durable appliances from a brand that merely claims to make durable appliances? Not to mention that any money you invest in making durable appliances will give you better short-term results if you just dump it in some advertising & marketing, and short-term results are all that the current "system" rewards.
- AngryData 4y agoEstablished companies will use their massive advertising budget to shit all over your product and get exclusivity contracts which make it very difficult for you to spread because you spent your money on engineering. Your repeat customers will be decades away and surviving decades until that point is difficult. You could offer good repair and part replacement services to help but that has a lot of overhead and organizational costs itself.
- jope12 4y agoPeople get what they pay for. If you want industrial-strength stuff, you have to pay, a lot. People also forget or don't know how expensive things were back then.
- booleandilemma 4y agoI expect nothing less from a culture of people who buy a new cellphone every 2 years. Longevity in consumer products is not something we optimize for anymore.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoCell phones are new enough that they still change noticeably in a couple of years. Refrigerators are not.
- midoridensha 4y agoModern fridges are much more efficient than ones from 20 years ago. They're not changing as fast as phones, sure, but they're not static.
- matwood 4y agoI recently replaced a basic washer and dryer that had lasted 20 years. I went to buy new ones and asked the person for basic models that would last 20 years again. He laughed and said nothing he sold would last that long anymore. I’m glad he was honest, but it made me sad.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- flir 4y agoIt's called Value Engineering. How do you increase total profit on an item? You either increase market share, or you reduce unit cost. When you start out, the first of these is the better choice (not least because you're trying to build a reputation). When you're mature, the second is. There's a guy called AvE on youtube whose tool teardowns illustrate this really well. The top-end tools obviously have different design goals - stuff like easily replaceable sacrificial components that are designed to fail, so expensive components are saved.
- stevehawk 4y agoYou mean it's market demand and manufacturers are competing on price to maximize sales and not some conspiracy about planned obsolescence and "things were better in my day!"? i refuse to believe such a logical argument
- juve1996 4y agoThings that break lead to greater sales. How do you deal with this? If they're competing on sales, then they need to optimize for the point at which it can break without losing brand confidence.
- xxs 4y agoI'd give an example with a printer. Refillable Ink-jet - a very low cost per page, indeed. After some time (approx 2y - warranty time in the EU; 5-6k pages/year), it started having an issue feeding paper, press the button to retry, it may work - frustrating, I know. 'Till one day it stopped altogether. It took me some time to figure it out - in short the tension springs were anemic to a high extent. So no tension on the paper rolls - no feed. Replacing the springs with imported ones (around 5-6 times more tension force) has made the printer not skip a page. The original springs like 1 cent together. The replacement cost was like 40cent for 10 - retail. There is no way the manufacturer was unaware.
- xxs 4y ago>There's a guy called AvE I think his name is Chris, actually. Other than that, the infamous inverse bathtub curve.
- throwbacktictac 4y agoNot that fast food is a hallmark of quality but I've also noticed that fast food quality has gotten worse. I may have you matured away from the flavor but I used to enjoy a good Carl Jr/Hardy's burger, a Chipotle burrito and some Mc Donald's menu item. Now it taste like the oils is never cleaned or cleaned with some chemical that leaves an after taste. This is a good thing because now I gotten pretty good at cooking some of the dishes at home.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WrtCdEvrydy 4y agoI've had this issue with McDonalds fries... I swear they did something to them because from one day to another they became worse.
- ethanzh 4y agoI believe they switched from frying them in beef tallow to vegetable oils
- bluGill 4y agoThey have switches oils several times that I know of. Some of the early veritable oils didn't taste too bad, but were probably worse than beef tallow for your health. Now the oils are as healthy as you can get for deep frying, but the taste isn't as good.
- disfadbish 4y agoIs it a chemically/almost tinglingly after taste? I have found that with so many fast food places, McDonald's fries and nuggets have it the strongest. I chalked it up to either very dirty oil (save money by changing it more infrequently) or some sort additive to the oil these massive operations produce that I am sensitive to.
- symlinkk 4y agoWhy are people so ashamed to admit they like fast food online? “I matured away from the flavor” Dude McDonalds is fucking good, I don’t care how old you are.
- hindsightbias 4y agoWhat’s the lifespan of modern software compared to a fridge?
- supernova87a 4y agoIt's almost like some constant of retail appliances. You pay now, or you pay later. And you might pay both. The problem is that not only is the longevity hard to assess from reputation any more, it's that replacement parts and labor are so problematic as well. I (and others I know) have had a simple washing machine circuit panel burn out because of simple overloaded pumps, etc. (or you might experience this with a dishwasher, refrigerator, etc). Just to get the part is now several $100s, and another $150+ for any kind of labor visit. I am rapidly thinking that home warranties where they cover a certain set of your appliances is starting to be worth it.
- bluGill 4y agoHome warranties are not worth it because they do their best to not pay. . Most home warranties are bought to sell the home, so the buyer just wants low cost and doesn't care about service at all. A home warranty with good service is possible, but it won't be cheap.
- pbuzbee 4y agoWe bought a house recently where the sellers left behind the fridge. The fridge had a handful of broken plastic shelves: things like broken clips and cracked frames. I thought it would be cheap to repair. Wrong. Fixing every broken item (~15 in all) would have cost over $400. Just for some plastic.
- sega_sai 4y agoI don't think this is surprising. If the utility function that is optimized by companies is profitability, the typical lifetime just above the warranty time is the result. In some sense that's expected from companies that have shareholders and so on. Whether one can do something about it ? I guess one can enforce warranty times to be longer for example. For sure that'll make things more expensive, but probably not by much. Maybe there are other solutions (like asking to collect statistics on life-times of appliances for easier comparisons), but the key is to put that factor in the company's calculations.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wilg 4y agoAn angle I rarely see in these sorts of discussions is how efficient is the construction of newer devices – i.e. do they use significantly less material? Like do new toasters use half the material of old toasters, or something. This would make it cheaper, but also potentially more environmentally friendly. Also, perhaps newer items are more mass-producible and therefore allow more people to have them in the first place.
- akagusu 4y agoIn the past, one way of choosing a brand was to compare how durable were its product against the competition. Today, corporations sell products that will break just to force you to buy another one. And they do this while spending millions in marketing to tell people how environment friendly they are.
- downboots 4y ago> in the past what changed? Hard to believe that can't be done today.
- xxs 4y agoAlmost all of them have to race to the bottom to survive. Most folks would just buy the cheapest/shiniest of them all. I mean there are fridges w/ a touch LCD on the front panel. Buying quality appliances and tools is a form of art and pretty much you have to tear them down to check about the said quality. It's quite disheartening. Then buying spare parts is another major issue.
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoI just had to pay $300 to repair a washer that was like 18 months old (I started trying to repair it myself but wife got impatient as we had tons of kids clothes to wash). Really frustrating. Contrast with the 40 year old crockpot we only retired because I cracked the pot while cleaning it.
- stevehawk 4y agonot to be "that guy" but comparing something with moving parts to something without is not exactly a fair comparison.
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoIt wasn't intended to be a fair comparison, but you're right. I reasoned that they are both fairly simple machines and a washer shouldn't break after 18 months.
- thegrimmest 4y agoHigh quality, easily serviceable appliances still exist. They're usually made for commercial markets and are 3x the price. There's nothing stopping anyone from putting a commercial fridge/dishwasher in their house - they're just expensive. Am I missing something?
- switch007 4y agoI've read more than one warranty for such appliances that do not cover domestic use.
- ropable 4y agoI think that there's always an element of survivor bias in these stories; everyone remembers the relatively-new appliance which broke and had to be returned, but not the many similar appliances which hum on for years. To draw any broad conclusions from a small sample size is silly.
- sunpazed 4y agoMy 15 year old Sony LCD TV is built like a brick, and has never had an issue (nor a firmware update). Meanwhile, my 6 month old Sony OLED Smart TV has given me nothing but grief. Recently had to replace the entire OLED panel — understandably it’s not a repairable part — which is 80% of the TV itself. In another example, we replaced our 20 year old microwave with a modern LG (we moved house and the old microwave didn’t fit). The LG faulted within 15 months of use.
- jl6 4y agoMises proposed that in a planned economy, there is a fundamental flaw called the economic calculation problem: essentially, it is almost impossible to calculate optimal resource allocation because doing so amounts to knowing every single person’s needs, and every detail of every factor of production, at all times. The information is too hard to get. Only markets can sufficiently simplify the problem by providing price as a universal point of comparison. That was his theory. Unfortunately, the success of price as a simplifying mechanism also hides all of the information from which the price emerged. This makes it almost impossible to determine whether the price is low because the materials are poor quality, or because the labor was underpaid, or because environmental standards were bypassed through offshoring, or because the manufacturing process was particularly efficient. Clearly we hope it is due to the latter, but determining so amounts to solving the economic calculation problem. But, rather than abandoning all hope, I believe the answer lies in consumers demanding supply chain transparency. This isn’t going to enable an efficient planned economy, but it might enable individuals to make better decisions about the purchases for which they care most.
- sudosysgen 4y agoGood supply chain transparency is about as difficult as an efficient planned economy, actually. Supply chain transparency was by very very far the biggest issue. Actually planning the economy is a polynomial time problem to solve exactly for linear situations, and ~n*log(n) to approximate fairly well both for linear and nonlinear situations. Consumer demand is solved by using markets for everything except capital. And so revealing accurate information turned out to be by far the most difficult task, at which planned economies routinely suffered catastrophic failures. For example, the USSR overestimated grain production by around 2x for the Holodomor due to misreporting and lies at every single level (the ensuing catastrophic and tyrannical resource distribution is a whole other topic). Until the 1990s, Soviet planners highly valued US spy informations on their economic situation as it was vastly more reliable than their own. Planned economies are far more reliant on this data of course, and that is why they are far more affected. Actually finding a sufficiently efficient organisation of production is not that big of a challenge either in theory or in practice, the issue is mostly figuring out exactly what you've got to organize. Unfortunately Mises did not have the algorithmic intuition to figure out that the calculation part is completely doable (even when you assume a perfect efficient market which is theoretically impossible unless P=NP and entropy stops existing and even then only for linear systems, the exact solution can be found at worst in cubic time to the number of industries).
- adrr 4y agoEasy solution. Charge a 25% recycling VAT style tax on products that don't offer a 10 year no strings attached in-home pickup warranty.
- clord 4y agoI call this inflation by other means. Constant quality items are increasing in price.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoIf you like old consumer products, let me tell you about cars from the 1970s and 1980s. Not fun.
- trimbo 4y agoGE appliance repair guy told me not to give up my 2006-era washer/dryer when he was replacing the drain hose. Unfortunately I had to. A year later an LCD screen went bad and would cost $1K to fix. So I bought a new LG. The problem is they aren't built to last well nor be economically repairable. I'd take one or the other (or both!).
- fomine3 4y agoGenerally agree for topic, but OP article isn't good. They should test efficiency of 50s compressor for refrigerator workload, and also consider auto defrosting that is evolutional feature. 50s is the decade that many inefficient cars run.
- cebert 4y agoI think one of the challenges is changing the consumer mindset of always going with the least expensive item. This encourages a downward spiral of cheapened products. There are still some high quality appliance brands, but you have to pay more. For example, I purchased a SpeedQueen washer and dryer combo last November. My TR7 model had a premium compared to units available at Home Depot or Lowes, but I love it. SpeedQueen is still manufactured in the US, they offer long warranties, and their products are solid. You get what you pay for.
- enragedcacti 4y agoUnfortunately a lot of people don't have that luxury (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory). Of course manufacturers often trade quality in favor of margins, but I wonder how much the decline in consumer products has to do with the proportion of people on the 'poor' end of "Boots Theory" for goods like refrigerators, blenders, dishwashers, etc. With income in the US practically stagnant for going on half a century and the sheer number of categories of "required" goods going up (e.g. phones, computers, TVs), everyone has a whole lot less to spend on a fridge and making a quality unit most people can't afford isn't a way to do business.
- havblue 4y agoI had a washer horror story personally: my Samsung high efficiency turned out to be great at trapping mold under the agitator plate. I realized that the drum was also covered with mold and I'd never be able to clean it without aggressive disassembly and scrubbing with a toothbrush in winter. Some of the plastic components were basically guaranteed to have mold forever. No way to get a brush in. I replaced it with a Maytag commercial 2 years ago, the cousin to the speed queen, and have been very happy so far as there's no longer dozens of hidden compartments to trap mold, as far as I know...
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoIf you want to see the true cost of quality items look into commercial versions built for high uptime. They are often 5x the price or more of consumer versions. For some things this is worth it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoAnd tend to be much more easily serviced, and parts more readily available, and even when parts are no longer available, or there's a long lead time, a maintenance contractor will be able to conjure one up from a wrecked machine or have a new part fabricated.
- adolph 4y agoOne bright spot is the supply of parts for older units is strong and YouTube tutorials are generally passable. I feel like we are in a DIY appliance repair renaissance.
- Axien 4y agoI bought a house in 2011 and am currently on my third refrigerator. We originally bought a Samsung and it kept on breaking until the warranty expired. We learned our lesson and bough an extended warranty on an LG. That broke so many times, and as part of the extended warranty contract, they gave us our money back. We took the money and bought another LG and over the last two years have not had issues. I have a dorm refrigerator that was purchased in 1986. It survived numerous moves and ex-girlfriends but is still going strong. I currently have it sitting in my office as my drink fridge. Wife has been asking I throw it out. Hell no.
- linuxftw 4y agoSamsung and LG make poor quality appliances with fancy techno junk features. GE, whirlpool, and other US brands are a much better value. I'm sure they don't last as long as the ones built prior to the 1990s, but they're worlds better than Samsung and LG.
- stephen_g 4y agoYeah, I'd stay well away from Samsung for appliances. There was a big thing here about a big recall because of their washing machines catching fire here a little bit before I bought my house, and I'd heard about their fridges breaking. I bought an Electrolux fridge and a Bosch washing machine instead and they're still going strong after six years. The fridge was on the recommendation of my parents who had bought one five or so years before, and theirs is still running well, never having needed any repairs.
- lnauta 4y agoMy Bosch fridge from 2011 is still going strong. Cheapest model of the big fridges at 400€.
- dghughes 4y agoI changed a fluorescent lamp ceiling fixture this evening at my parent's house. The light was probably made in 1970 or early 70s. It fell on my head when the last screw let go unexpectedly. And it was far heavier than I was expecting about 15 pounds for a 24 inch by 12 inch light frame. I think it's made of steel I was expecting flimsy light tin. So yeah that was one durable light 52 years of operation.
- diogenescynic 4y agoWashing machines are considerably lower quality than 20-30 years ago. New washing machines have issues with "scrud" and other weird moldy build ups. Not sure if this is because everything is designed for lower water usage leading to the soap not being filtered out enough or what but I know some of the issues I have seen with my modern appliances simply didn't ever happen with much older machines. It seems like the only thing that improved was looks and marketing.
- coffeeling 4y agoI have a new washing machine and it just can't seem to get rid of soap in the gasket.
- diogenescynic 4y agoI researched machines and ended up with an LG and I have to run it for double rinse cycles. It's an HE machine and when I use HE detergent, the issue is even worse so now I just use a tiny splash of regular detergent. It's so bizarre to me that this is an issue for a modern machine. Every washer and dryer I had before this was an old school analog machine and they never had issues.
- pmarreck 4y agoSurely, the fact that all US manufacturing seems to be going to China must have nothing to do with it
- FpUser 4y agoThings with the manufacturing have degenerated way too much. My strategy - I either buy industrial stuff (preferably second hand so I do not have to re-mortgage) or the cheap which of course happens more often. Surprisingly cheap sometimes lasts way longer than the expensive consumer brands.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- g42gregory 4y agoSo have Inflation, Shrinkflation, and now Qualiflation?
- downboots 4y agoDon't forget wage stagnation :)
- basicplus2 4y agoIts a race to the bottom on cost
- semerda 4y agoI heard that one way to check quality is to look at the type of capacitors used on the board. Capped are cheap and don’t last long (they have a vent on top) and when they blow they spread white residue on the board. The solid capacitors don’t suffer from this, last much much longer but do cost a bit more. Ps. Maybe someone with more electrical knowledge than I can confirm or debunk this?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- j45 4y agoIt's often worth buying the first few generations of a new appliance - they are often over-engineered to some degree - or the MTTF isn't quite known to swap out parts. A few years ago I replaced my dishwasher with a European one. It was great, quiet. Then, it wasn't. I learned because it doesn't have a heating element and you have to load the dishes in a particular way to have a chance at maximum drying. I listened to the service technician go on about the particular way to use this machine for about 20 minutes and asked them if I bought a decent dishwasher to think about my dishwasher, or to never think about my dishwasher again. Since then, I've has had to replace the key convector to open and close it for it to run. Based on other well engineered products and European brands, I'm comfortable that the failure is engineered to ensure my LTV to the brand is longer. Perhaps a European car that falls apart after a certain amount of mileage is a status symbol for some. They are wonderful to drive, but I have better things to do.
- rightbyte 4y ago> I learned because it doesn't have a heating element Is it so humid that you need one? I find the need for one absurd since I never used a machine with one and place everything in the correct orientation subconsciously.
- j45 4y agoNorth American brand dishwashers come with a heating element and you have to pay little attention to how not to load the washer so dishes don’t stay wet.
- libpcap 4y agoCould be due to the "chabuduo" mindset: https://www.sourcingallies.com/blog/cha-bu-duo https://www.sourcingallies.com/blog/cha-bu-duo
- jcadam 4y agoHouse I bought recently came with samsung kitchen appliances (great /s). I shouldn't have had to crawl inside a 2-year old gas oven to replace a bad igniter, but... I did. I remember when a range could be expected to last a couple of decades at least. They aren't... complicated.
- tsol 4y agoCan I just say-- I'm fascinated that there is a community of "experts, collectors and fans" of automatic washing machines. Despite it's somewhat dated appearance of the website, it's no simple operation-- it contains an in depth database of manuals, photos, adverts, information, audio/video, and brochures. This is a true passion project. The best part, of course, is the forum. A surprisingly active community of men and women nakedly unashamedly delighted by automatic washing machines. I don't know why, but finding these little communities of people is amazing to me. That there are so many people who derive true enjoyment from this random thing I've never really bothered to think about much. To me it's just a means to an end, nothing more than another object in my life. It's amazing to think there are probably communities around all sorts of things I hardly notice nor think about. Like doors to worlds I've never seen, hidden all around me in plain sight.
- octoberfranklin 4y agoI'm sure the heavy lifting is by people who run/own/work at independent appliance repair shops. Those still exist. It's like the Terry Love forums, which are an outstanding resource for septic/well owners. But the forum regulars are all professional plumbers and well drillers. https://www.terrylove.com/forums/index.php https://www.terrylove.com/forums/index.php
- osigurdson 4y agoYou would think there would be room in the market for a brand that makes stuff last as long possible and/or easily repairable.
- londons_explore 4y agoI suspect this fridge compressor has been misdiagnosed. Yes, the bearing has failed. But I suspect it was caused by a substantial DC electrical current running through the motor on top of the AC current it was designed for. A DC current in many motor designs causes a large sideways force, and that caused the bearing to wear. DC currents can be caused by improper wiring or another faulty device in the house (or even in a neighbour's house)
- atoav 4y agoHow could DC happen through faulty wiring? If the ground impedance of the null/PE is too high?
- londons_explore 4y agoTypically there is some device that uses a lot of power but only from half the AC cycle - for example an 'inverter' air conditioner where one of the four rectification diodes on the input has failled open circuit. Normally this DC current will mostly be absorbed by the utility pole transformer, which has a very low impedance at DC. However, if some of your house/street wiring has a few ohms of impedance, then the current can end up doing through more local devices like fridge compressors. Normally this causes them to overheat pretty quick if the current is large. But a smaller current will eventually cause bearing failure.
- atoav 4y agoMakes sense, thanks for the explaination.
- _nalply 4y agoThis concerns the video linked from the website: I wonder why some Youtube videos have subtitles disabled? There are people needing subtitles! A few years ago I did an experiment: I downloaded the video and re-uploaded it to Youtube just to enable the subtitles, but I got a warning because of copyright violation, so I don't do that anymore.
- baybal2 4y ago
- switch007 4y agoI made yet another trip to the garbage dump the other day and it really highlighted how much we throw it out because of poor quality goods. I got pretty angry to be quite honest. All the damage to the environment! The labour wasted in installing, attempting repairs, throwing out etc. Even worse if you paid lots of $$ to have the thing installed by a professional. And don't get me started on new fan-dangled plumbing connections that involve large amounts of rubber adapters that shrink over time and causes untold damage. One thing I decided is to try to avoid plastic, favouring timber every time (e.g. seating, boxes)
- alkonaut 4y agoWe get a LOT more years per dollar now than we did in the past, simply because things are costing a fraction now. We can buy those ten compressors and still come out ahead. The thing is though, we don't WANT to do that. If we knew we could get better quality by paying more, I think many would. But I don't trust that, so I just accept that my new fridge will last not very long, and I get the one that's recommened. And the problem with this is of course that you can't win by making a fridge and claiming it lasts longer because it would be decades before anyone trusts you. A brand that bet on being the long life fridge brand selling expensive fridges would have a hard time building that reputation.
- dirtyid 4y ago500+ comments and no one seems to be discussing the first reply in the OP by small appliace company that alleges new compressors rarely fail (and he guestimates possibly less than compressors from decades ago) and are one of the better components of new refrigerators.
- dark-star 4y agoIf you scroll down to the comments, there's a repair technician stating that they repair 2000 devices a year and don't come across more than maybe 1 or 2 broken compressors each year. So maybe it's not as bad as the post seems to make it.
- someweirdperson 4y agoSome hardware stores offer tools for rent. However, there is zero overlap of between those and the tools they are selling. But it helps to decide what to buy elsewhere. Was trying to buy a table. Wasn't satisfied with what I could find in the shop. Went to the restaurant embedded within the shop. Nice sturdy tables there. Unfortunately, not for sale. The good stuff is out there.
- nycdatasci 4y agoWhen expensive products fail early and companies are unhelpful, I file formal complaints through the state attorney general’s consumer rights office. It’s usually just a matter of filling out an online form and perhaps uploading a few supporting documents. Companies become much more helpful when their lawyers are providing customer support instead of a minimum wage employee.
- niffydroid 4y agoI don't think most manufacturers go out their way to make sure a part breaks down and it's cheaper to buy a new one. If I had something that broke after a year and can't be fixed, I certainly wouldn't buy that brand again for that item. I think it's purely a trade off with doing its job and be cheap as possible but having a spare part available for it. I remember reading somewhere about the cost of something in a VW engine bay, maybe an air intake box, they designed it to last X long,like the entire life span of the car, but it costs more to achieve, but it would have been cheaper to just design it for less life and if/when it did break you'd just replace the part and it's cheaper overall.
- type0 4y agoSome apparent changes in recent years have been how bad certain manufacturers been riding the praise of older products and greatly decreasing the quality of components in microwaves. Are there any brands that still produce good micros? Does Toshiba or Panasonic still produce good microwaves or do they also suffer from decrease in quality?
- vendiddy 4y agoAre there any websites out there that list what to buy and what to avoid based on durability?
- AuthorizedCust 4y agoThe reply comment, where another repairmen shared convincing experience-based evidence of good reliability of modern compressors, eviscerates the argument. Also, the assertion that mid-1900s compressors were efficient is absent any facts to back it up. If the main power-consuming part of old refrigerators was so efficient, how can newer refrigerators be so much more efficient? Sure, better insulation can help, but I don’t see how you get around that newer compressors need so much less power to get the job done.
- greyhair 4y agoI think that most of the horror stories I hear on new appliances are control board failures, more than physical hardware failures. I have a washer and dryer from 1993 that are still going strong, but over the years I have had to replace belts, or idler pulleys. I have had to replace hot surface igniters, and the fan impeller in the dryer. But over all they have held up well. But neither one has any digital logic. They both use old school mechanical timers. Our washer acted up briefly about ten years ago. Was making a hammering noise during agitation, and we called an appliance repair guy to look at it. He told us to run it until it quit, and left us with recommendations for two manufacturers of washer/dryers that still build units with mechanical timers. He said those will run as long as our current units. The noise sort of went away after a few months, and the washer still runs. Flip side, I have helped two friends diagnose controller board failures on touch pad controlled ovens. One was the relay driver. The other was actually a failed membrane push button in the display, it was stuck active. In both cases, the ovens were less than five years old. And the guy the looked at our washer said basically the same thing. The vast majority of his service calls are for failed control modules.
- fleddr 4y agoI think the speed of product turn-over has a lot additional harmful side effects beyond things just breaking down. Reviews have effectively become meaningless. There's so many contenders in each category releasing so many products frequently that reviewers are playing catch-up but are also overwhelmed. They can only spend a short amount of time per product which makes most reviews superficial. As a shopper, it's become impossibly hard to find good products. Most reviews just read out the specs, they explain what it is, not how good it is. In the rare case that you do find a good one, its production lifespan is very limited, so you can't buy it again. Or it can't be repaired as nobody knows how, or there's no parts. Most products can't even be serviced at all, as not only is there no knowledge, the repair cost would exceed the production cost. Even the idea "buy local for better service" no longer applies. They can't fix it either, they'll handle it exactly the same way as a larger retail channel. There barely is a distinction anymore between A brands and B brands. Same limited lifespan. Even A brands get away with gross usability defects as effectively there isn't much of a feedback loop. By the time a product is widely considered to be bad, the next one is already there. Even if you were to consider boycotting a brand, you'll soon learn the other brands are no different, exceptions aside.
- smileysteve 4y agoI'm not seeing several new technologies covered in the threads - inverter compressors versus scroll compressors - defrosting cycles - multi airflow technologies (there have been posts of Arduino controlled fans to circulate air in 90s) In the last decade we've gone from a poor airflow, static compressors to normal consumer features including door alarms, thermometers, dynamic compressors, and multi flow fans
- coryfklein 4y agoI disagree that consumers are to blame. Believe me, I would be willing to pay 50% more for my fridge if I could know for certain that it would last decades longer than another. It is incorrect to say that consumers have a choice between "high quality/long lasting" and "cheaper but dies sooner", and for multiple reasons! 1. An uneducated consumer cannot distinguish between the two. Both products will bear labels reading "Extremely high quality, we take pride in our work, energy efficient AND better quality than all our competitors!" 2. Brands and manufacturers are taking these shortcuts uniformly. So consumers can't simply rely on buying a machine of a certain brand. 3. These issues don't show up for (apparently) 13 years! Even IF a consumer identifies a brand with a strong evidence-based reputation for quality, that brand may have lowered standards sometime in the past 13 years and they would have no way of knowing.
- rascul 4y agoMight be kind of related. Some years back I worked delivery at Lowe's. We would sometimes replace appliances that had an issue and were under our warranty still. For Samsung and LG appliances if there was any issue at all the manufacturer would generally tell us to junk it. So we would load up perfectly good $4000 fridges with a noisy ice maker into the junker trailer and they would be sold for scrap. I don't know if these things were so cheap to produce that it wasn't worth repairing or maybe the shipping was too high but I got the impression that they're selling way overpriced cheap junk that isn't meant to last.
- juanani 4y ago
- Night_Thastus 4y agoFrom what I have observed, there seem to be three major driving forces in consumer and commercial appliances: 1: Energy regulations 2: Transition from high-cost luxuries to being more common (Similar to air travel) 3: Massive increase in global competition The first one is really easy to see in the commercial space especially. Do things like plastic fan blades and VFDs make units more efficient? Yes. Do they also make them more likely to fail/add new failure points? Yes. The energy regulation on consumer and commercial appliances is very strong in the US. If you compare even things like washing machines, you can see energy usage dropping hundreds of watts in some cases. However, that has come at the cost of reliability. As for #2, airplanes are a great comparison. At one time they were a luxury and you expected a certain level of service. As they got more affordable, that dropped away and people get packed in like sardines. That's the price of making it available to everyone. Today isn't like the period when a washing machine was a luxury good. Now everyone has one - so the motivation is to produce them as cheaply as possible to undercut competition. Reliability and energy usage aren't mutually exclusive, but because of #2 a cheap, less reliable way of saving power will almost always be taken over a more robust yet still efficient design. These two explanations combined with a bit of Hanlon's razor explain almost all of modern appliance unreliability. There is no active attempt to make units less reliable - but there's no motivation to do otherwise for most manufacturers given the shear amount of cheap competition present.
- Ava433 4y ago