20 ms·
Study finds link between 'forever chemicals' in cookware and liver cancer
- elil17 4y agoThe study didn’t actually find anything related to cookware. Modern Teflon in the US doesn’t expose people to PFOA/PFOS like old version did due to new regulations. The chemicals could also be entering peoples body’s through drinking water or bioaccumulation in meat or plants. You should throw away nonstick cookware from before 2013, but new nonstick cookware sold in the US does not have PFOA. I believe the EU followed suite recently. Edit: After doing more research based on many comments here, I realized I was wrong. The brand Teflon replaced PFOA with GenX, a different fluorosurfactant that's probably worse than PFOA. From what I can tell, fluorosurfactants are more or less required to make PTFE and it seems quite likely that all fluorosurfactants are toxic. Personally I choose to use Teflon for eggs and stainless or cast iron for everything else. That feels like a decent trade off to me comparing years of life lost from liver cancer to time spent scraping scrambled eggs off of pans. I want to add that a lot of cool startups are working on PFAS remediation. One I know of is Cyclopure, they make a Brita filter replacement that filters out PFAS (it's very expensive at the moment, though). Probably worth it if you live near a chemical plant, airport, or US military facility (airports and military bases both use PFAS fire-extinguishing foams which they typically fail to contain).
- gilrain 4y agoI assume they switched to a less studied but very similar analog, like happened with BPA? Edit: Yep, of course they did. > Another potential concern is that other PFAS are now in use. For example, hexafluoropropylene oxide (HFPO, also known as a ‘GenX’ chemical) is often used to replace PFOA in manufacturing processes, while perfluorobutane sulfonic acid (PFBS) is used as a replacement for PFOS. New PFAS also continue to be developed. These chemicals haven’t been around long enough for researchers to fully understand if they might have the same (or even different) health effects. https://www.cancer.org/healthy/cancer-causes/chemicals/teflon-and-perfluorooctanoic-acid-pfoa.html https://www.cancer.org/healthy/cancer-causes/chemicals/teflo...
- amluto 4y agoI think the end goal is to not use a similar analogue. The problematic chemicals are fluorosurfactants used in production, and they are not actually useful in the final pan. Manufacturers are working on getting rid of them: https://www.solvay.com/en/article/eliminating-pfas https://www.solvay.com/en/article/eliminating-pfas As far as I know, PTFE itself is also a “forever chemical”, but it’s an extremely inert polymer and is unlikely to be particularly dangerous as long as it doesn’t get too hot. (PFOA and PFOS are water soluble. PTFE is not.)
- gilrain 4y ago> Manufacturers are working on getting rid of them. It might be more ethical to stop selling the dangerous product until a replacement can be found, but I’m not a huge chemical manufacturer.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoMany stopped selling a generation ago, but the chemicals last longer than a generation…
- arcticbull 4y ago> ... but it’s an extremely inert polymer and is unlikely to be particularly dangerous as long as it doesn’t get too hot. You mean like on a stovetop?
- 124816 4y agoUsually beyond the range you normally cook at, but definitely achievable if you leave a pan unattended for a minute, or use it with insufficient coverage. Pet birds are extremely vulnerable, and there's plenty of stories of them dying due to nonstick cookware. I get little benefit from nonstick cookware, so for me the "canary in the kitchen" aspect was enough reason to eliminate it from the house.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alfor 4y agoWhat is replacing PFOA? Is it something already present in what we eat or is it a ’new’ molecule that living organisms have never seen before?
- californical 4y agoI am far from an expert, but there are hundreds of extremely similar but slightly modified versions of PFOA that haven’t been proven unsafe, so are still allowed, but they’re all so similar it’s hard to believe that they’ll have different affects. We’ll see though in another 30-50 years how much they’ve hurt us again! Some info & includes links to other sources: https://www.consumerreports.org/toxic-chemicals-substances/pfas-chemicals-should-you-be-concerned-a2708998896/ https://www.consumerreports.org/toxic-chemicals-substances/p...
- stjohnswarts 4y agoPTFE is still perfectly safe. This is a scare tactic and click bait. PFOAs have been out of vogue for a long time.
- nerdawson 4y agoWhy take the risk for a minor convenience? Get stainless steel cookware and you’ll quickly learn how to avoid sticking by controlling temperature.
- daniel-s 4y agoI know nothing about this, please explain.
- wahnfrieden 4y agonyc restauranteur frank prisinzano explains it well on his instagram highlights (a kind of mini, continuous cooking course). start with learning his crispy egg technique
- harrydehal 4y agohttps://www.instagram.com/frankprisinzano/ https://www.instagram.com/frankprisinzano/ Watched his cacio pepe. He doubled down on reminding to always use dry pasta. Not bad. Subscribed.
- wahnfrieden 4y agotry his limone if you liked that one. another expression of simplicity and straightforward principles. I don't know what he currently has up though because he deletes his videos routinely
- Panino 4y agoI cook with stainless steel, including eggs (probably the most challenging food here, IMO). For an over-easy egg, it's sufficient to simply pre-heat the skillet until butter will sizzle and quickly melt (but not brown) when added. For scrambled eggs I do the same, but also continuously rotate the eggs off/on heat. This not only cooks the eggs to a beautiful custard type texture, but also mostly if not entirely prevents sticking. Almost everything else doesn't require particular consideration on stainless steel IMO. Potatoes can be more difficult than others though. Hash browns are easy, but little stir-fried potato cubes tend to stick. With meat, generally, the food will unstick when it's sufficiently cooked, which is a handy coincidence if you ask me. I'd love to get any pointers, too.
- oblib 4y agoMy wife and I tossed out all the Teflon cookware we had about 25 years ago and replaced it with cast iron and stainless steel. We've not missed it at all.
- enraged_camel 4y agoThe thing I dislike about cast iron cookware is that it is extremely heavy. I sprained my elbow last year and couldn’t use any of my cast iron pans for three months. My mom hates them too, and avoids using them whenever she visits.
- oblib 4y agoSome of ours are pretty heavy too. We also have some stainless steel pots and pans we use a lot and they're quite a bit lighter. But I should also mention we stopped using aluminum cookware back then too.
- dd36 4y agoUse carbon steel.
- Pxtl 4y agoGod, this. I've got tennis elbow and I dread lifting heavy cookware.
- nathanvanfleet 4y agoThis is like "BPA is bad, here is a new kind of BPA..."
- rajeshp1986 4y agoThere are tons of cheap chinese cookware on amazon that probably still uses older Teflon. There is no way this can be regulated. I'll stick with iron skillet.
- pier25 4y ago> I want to add that a lot of cool startups are working on PFAS remediation Just use cast iron stuff. Done.
- bpodgursky 4y agoThis is about removing PFAS from your tap water. Using cast iron does not fix this. Reading the rest of the paragraph would have made that very clear.
- elil17 4y agoOr from ground water. Or from all the leachate once everyone throws out their Teflon pans.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pmulard 4y agoI cook eggs on cast iron without them sticking, but it requires maintenance on the seasoning. The trick is to use some butter when cooking with eggs, and they slide right off. A quick wipe with a paper towel and the pan is clean (leaving butter residue helps keep it oiled for next time). Cast iron is a pain to clean if you burn food and the burnt pieces stick, but the investment into learning how to cook with it is worth the reward imo.
- christkv 4y agoI find boiling the pan helps unstick stuff
- BenFrantzDale 4y agoAlso: chainmail scrubbers are amazing. I can’t recommend them enough.
- stjohnswarts 4y agojust don't scrub hard with them, they absolutely will remove/scratch up your seasoning. had to re-season a pan recently because my roomie doesn't understand you need to preheat cast iron to pretty hot before you cook a bunch of cheese and egg omelets in it. He felt guilty and went to town with the chain mail scrubber when you just need to gently scrub with it.
- krono 4y agoJust scrub with a bit of salt and a paper towel when it's still warm and rinse with a bit of cold water.
- aceazzameen 4y agoYep! A small amount of thick kosher salt and a paper towel is all I ever need if something sticks to a cast iron or carbon steel pan. Do it while it's still hot and it's easier. And if it's stainless steel, I boil some water with a drop of dish soap and baking soda. Whatever is stuck lifts off by itself.
- Zigurd 4y agoThe risk from burning a Teflon pan is enough reason to avoid it. I first heard about this from a person who kept rescued birds. Apparently birds are especially susceptible to toxic fumes. People overheat pans all the time. It seems crazy to not take that failure mode into account in evaluating Teflon's safety. I also do not FW fluorinated ski wax.
- sudosysgen 4y agoI personally use a temperature-control induction stovetop to make sure it can never overheat.
- nrjames 4y agoGenX contamination in the Cape Fear river (from Chemours) has been a problem for years. There's more info on this page: https://deq.nc.gov/news/key-issues/genx-investigation https://deq.nc.gov/news/key-issues/genx-investigation
- jahewson 4y ago> scraping scrambled eggs off of pans. Wait, what are you doing to your eggs to get them stuck to the pan? Welding them?
- hombre_fatal 4y ago> The chemicals could also be entering peoples body’s through drinking water or bioaccumulation in meat or plants. I was curious about bioaccumulation in plants vs meat and chanced upon a study that looks at PFXX presence in vegans vs omnivores: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1438463921001231 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S143846392... Meat, fish, and water showed the highest correlations, though eggs and fruit seemed to have lowest.
- DevX101 4y agoI appreciate you updating your comment with an informed update that contradicted your initial argument. When a consumer chemical is discovered to be harmful, there's a tendency from companies to ask their research chemists to come up with a new chemical that shares the same beneficial properties but without the baggage of the provably dangerous chemical. There's a VERY good chance that the new chemical simply hasn't been studied enough and that long term study will show comparable biological properties (harm). I personally don't trust 'BPA-free' plastics for this reason. And try as much as I can to use steel/glass containers for liquids. At this point, I'm assuming anything 'teflon-like' will have negative impact on humans, until it has been proven safe in long term studies. You don't want to be an early adopter for industrial chemicals.
- elil17 4y agoI do not trust BPA-free plastics either. I have switched from cans to tetrapaks where possible. My confusion came from some misleading industry documents I read which suggested that PFOA/PFOS/C8 had been replaced with a process that did not require fluorosurfactants. I feel like the information about these chemicals is so confusing, it's hard for a non-chemist like me to understand.
- CorrectHorseBat 4y agoWould it not be better to switch to glass? Isn't tetrapak lined with plastic too?
- elil17 4y agoGlass packaged tuna and tomatoes are very expensive compared to tetrapaks. They are lined with plastic but it doesn’t use hardening agents as I understand.
- CorrectHorseBat 4y agoIs there any technical reason why cans use BPA and Tetrapak not?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- retcore 4y ago>That feels like a decent trade off to me comparing years of life lost from liver cancer to time spent scraping scrambled eggs off of pans. Are you sure you meant that just how it reads like? I mean your life isn't something I want you trading for a while scraping your frying pan. Please forgive my impertinence, but if you're so down on your own value I can't help but stop and ask.[edit] ask if you're ok?
- julianlam 4y agoI don't what to be that hipster guy needlessly advocating for cast iron, but why don't you use that pan for eggs? I don't properly season my pan, and while my eggs don't slide off like they would on nonstick, they usually come off in one piece, albumen and all. I clean my pan with a stiff bristled brush, no soap.
- purpleblue 4y agoI use stainless steel pans, which are great. They are pretty much indestructible and not as expensive as I imagined. I think it's less than $100 for a stainless steel frying pan and I just use butter or olive oil to oil the pans and it's great. Sometimes things get burnt but an SOS pad a little elbow grease and it's back to normal.
- stjohnswarts 4y agobarkeeper's friend is your friend with stainless steel.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI pointed this out on reddit and got downvoted all to hell lol. Thanks for taking one for the team. I love my hexclad set.
- lr4444lr 4y agoYou can do eggs in cast iron without breaking thr yolk: it just takes practice.
- js2 4y agoI use cast iron skillets for eggs, fried, omelettes, even scrambled. A well-seasoned pan at the right temp with a bit of butter or ghee and my eggs basically don’t stick. I use a silicon spatula. I won’t lie: it takes a bit more care than a Teflon pan, but I ditched my Teflon pots and pans years ago and haven’t looked back. Everything in my kitchen is cast iron, stainless, ceramic or glass.
- acchow 4y ago> to time spent scraping scrambled eggs off of pans. At the right temperature on a stainless steel pan, there’s not much scraping needed to clean it off. Just a dash of water after you take the eggs off and some light scraping with your cooking utensil
- sva_ 4y agoSo I take it, I should throw out my nonstick pans and just use my cast iron pan from now?
- m3kw9 4y agoI cook scramble eggs in cast iron and while it sticks a bit you wash it right away while it’s hot in water, takes less than a min. Given that you seasoned it and you don’t burn the egg
- smohare 4y agoIt’s exceeding easy to cook eggs on stainless steel or cast iron. If it’s a compelling reason to stick to Teflon this implies to me you’ve never bothered to spend 5 minutes learning to cook eggs on these substrates.
- caned 4y ago> Personally I choose to use Teflon for eggs and stainless or cast iron for everything else. OT, but are you trying to avoid cooking eggs with fat? Once I started making mine, over easy, with well-seasoned cast iron...I just could not go back to non-stick. Less than half a tsp of butter for two.
- _8j50 4y agoWould brita help for drinking water?
- daniel-cussen 4y agoMy attitude to Teflon is any harm to the pan is a kick in the balls to me. Because of the incredibly harmful effect on testosterone, it mimics testosterone hormone--almost identical shape, so what it does is it gets in the testosterone receptors and makes men less masculine. And it gets lodged in there. I suspect it's a driving factor in the surge of transexuality and male infertility (low sperm counts etc) because it's fucking everywhere and can impede masculinization very directly. Because the thing is, if you're going to be a man, you better be a hell of a man--then you get all the rewards--but if you're defective, not quite as resourceful, tolerant to pain, audacious, quick (testosterone increases your brain speed a bit), or like have a weaker frame, receding jaw, any one of dozens of signature flaws you get treated so much worse. So compromising masculinity--in particular what's called the brain waves, what that is is partly brain waves, which determine frequency of the brain, so you end up a bit slower, like 6 Hz instead of 7 Hz. Huge role in determining how much respect you get as a man. Second testosterone alters the brain, so more risk-seeking more pain-tolerant, and frequently, toxic masculinity ie plotting ways to take advantage of women, or more violent, or more dead-set on premeditated crime. Teflon is also bad for women, who also produce and need testosterone in their own smaller quantities, it eg helps them be toned and thin, and is insufficient to trigger eg facial hair development. And I think when they are expecting a boy, there's something going on there, their testosterone helps that boy develop properly, not sure. It's just a remarkable chemical that is great for bacon and eggs. So just super conservative with it, never put it under anything, only cook with a dedicated plastic thing, never permit anyone do anything with it. And guess what? It's just as effective--exactly as effective--as it was when I bought it, I successfully protected the surface and my masculinity with my conservative attitude toward it.
- tresqotheq 4y ago> The brand Teflon replaced PFOA with GenX, a different fluorosurfactant that's probably worse than PFOA "regrettable substitution" as they call it, https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/harmful-chemicals-removed-from-products-often-replaced-with-something-as-bad-or-worse/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/harmful-c...
- ce4 4y agoI switched to enamel non-stick pans and iron pans, and for me eggs work best when cooked with lard instead of vegetable oil. Lard went somewhat out of favor but i find it better for pan cooking than oil: probably due to the higher viscosity it creates a stabler lubrication film that doesn't break down as easily as that of cooking oil. Works even with stainless steel pans. Downside: different "lard" taste and the grease is harder to wash off your hands.
- sbochins 4y agoThis comment and the subsequent edit is the usual result when looking deeply into the actual chemicals we consume and knowing whether or not they’re safe. The various ways toxins are in our food supplies and things we interact on a day to day basis is almost unavoidable at this point. Hopefully there will be a major shift at some point.
- eatbitseveryday 4y ago> scraping scrambled eggs off of pans Use a dollop of butter to cook the eggs and a lower temperature.
- abrokenpipe 4y agoYou should try ceramic coated cookware, I have found it to work great for cooking stuff like eggs.
- nikau 4y agoAnodized pans perform similar to teflon without the risk. There are copper based ones that have good heat retention/distribution.
- ranguna 4y agoThe earliest ban I could find for the use of PFOAs in the US was early 2021. For the EU was mid 2020. > I believe the EU followed suite recently. Seems the US is the one following suite in this case. I've found earlier laws in the US that companies need to report on the use, but no global ban earlier than 2021. I could be wrong though.
- guerrilla 4y agoI saw "Dark Waters" [1] years ago and found that whole thing really horrific but I kept cooking with a Teflon pan until this week because I figured the process and result are distinct things (honestly how many industrial processes today don't have nightmarish byproducts...). Just this week though my pan totally died though and I happened to have this really beautiful cast iron pan with a ceramic handle of exactly the same size, so I switched. It takes a little bit of learning but so far I love it. It retains and transfers heat way better than whatever the Teflon pans I've been buying are made out of. Also I think the weight helps it make better contact with the plate (electric stove.) This YouTube playlist [2] pretty much sorted me out, combined with Adam Ragusea's video [3] I just happened to see a while ago (If you're a nerd you should watch his channel anyway.) 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Waters_(2019_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Waters_(2019_film) 2. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-Q53k5K1cN5HKCwhCsUVEZOQ6g07HxMx https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-Q53k5K1cN5HKCwhCsUV... 3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zGR-pyLHz1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zGR-pyLHz1s
- Ancalagon 4y agoI read about PFAS years ago (didn't have teflon cookware then). Eventually a friend of mine gave me their old non-stick pan set. I had forgotten about PFAS, then re-learned about them and heard about their effects and pretty much instantly threw all the pans away. I bought three ceramic/cast-iron pans and haven't looked back.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoNot to create further panic but you should know that the bright coloured paints in the enamel of those ceramic/cast iron pans will often contain lead and/or cadmium, which are both carginogenics. The whole thing is obviously sealed but who knows what happens when they chip. As far as I see it with my paranoia hat on, there are only three safe options: 1. Cast iron unseasoned (and you do the seasoning) 2. Stainless steel (w/ no coatings) 3. Borosilicate glass (with no painting or markings)
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oldstrangers 4y agoThey're finding PFAS in everything now. https://www.consumerreports.org/bottled-water/pfas-in-bottled-water-new-study-finds-a1111233122/ https://www.consumerreports.org/bottled-water/pfas-in-bottle... https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7gban/rainwater-everywhere-now-considered-too-toxic-for-safe-consumption-study-finds https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7gban/rainwater-everywhere-... https://www.dcourier.com/news/2022/aug/11/prescott-valley-shuts-down-4-wells-after-positive-/ https://www.dcourier.com/news/2022/aug/11/prescott-valley-sh...
- Synaesthesia 4y agoI just read that rainwater around the world is unsafe to drink because of PFAS contamination. https://phys.org/news/2022-08-rainwater-unsafe-due-chemicals.html https://phys.org/news/2022-08-rainwater-unsafe-due-chemicals...
- bilsbie 4y agoRainwater pretty much distills itself as it evaporates. I didn’t read the article but it seems like they’d new some new physics to get it into rain.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe PFAS that show up in rain get there by also having a vapor pressure sufficient for atmospheric transport. They evaporate and condense with the rain. These chemicals aren't Teflon itself but other polyfluorinated molecules, used as intermediates in Teflon product production or for other purposes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 4y agoI just googled it. PFAS are simply emitted into the atmosphere and then brought back, rain precipitation being one method of "atmospheric deposition" (something to google). i.e. water doesn't need to evaporate with something in aerosol suspension for that thing to be found in precipitation.
- smm11 4y agoWhere do you think that non-stickiness has gone when it stops working as well as it did when new?
- moffkalast 4y agoWashes off in the dishwasher, clearly /s
- daveyjonezz 4y agoCast iron pans are cheap, will outlive you, and work nearly as well with enough seasoning / butter :)
- dsr_ 4y agoIf you spend the time sanding them down to glass-smoothness before seasoning them, you won't need that much fat -- although fat is tasty.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoYup. Chefs rarely use nonstick cookware outside of baking or specifically making omelettes. For the majority of their uses, it's either stainless, cast iron, or enameled cast iron. Non-stick got its foothold when the feds went on their "fat is bad for you" kick. They took all the fat out and added sugar to products to fix the texture. Proteins stick to steel when the steel isn't sufficiently hot before food is placed on it. If you toss a bead of water into a pan and it doesn't dance along the surface in the Leidenfrost effect, your pan isn't hot enough.
- Aachen 4y ago> Chefs rarely use nonstick cookware outside of baking or specifically making omelette. Citation needed? It sounds implausible to me that a majority of professional cooks seek to make their own job harder when they've got seven other dishes to make by tending a nonnonstick pan.
- surfpel 4y agoThese pans are only not nonstick if used incorrectly. Carbon steel is often used in professional kitchens which develops a nonstick coating called “seasoning”. And if stainless is hot enough, it’s also not very prone to sticking.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoThe main reason I know of is that a nonstick coated pan will not survive long with the bulk way they wash their dishes. You'd also have to keep a separate set of non-metal spatulas and such.
- tylerFowler 4y agoThe usual line that I've heard on nonstick pans is that the leaking process happens at very high temperatures. In general one shouldn't use very high heat on a non-stick pan & certainly not an _empty_ non-stick pan. David Chang's podcast has an interesting episode on this specific topic, though he brings on a domain expert who definitely has a lot of bias (but expertise nonetheless). https://open.spotify.com/episode/7joCX2xx4GU50myfbtVm44?si=46759c3761d04f20 https://open.spotify.com/episode/7joCX2xx4GU50myfbtVm44?si=4...
- makeitdouble 4y agoWith two major caveat that make it way less practical: - those tests aren’t against ageing pans. To be the safest, you’d need to buy pans on a short cycle - chipping is still dangerous (physical degradation, including regular wear) Basically, there is a specific case (new, perfectly intact, low-regular temperatures only) where it’s probably safe, and everything else is potentially harmful.
- bergenty 4y agoPFAS has a boiling point of 189C. That’s not very high at all.
- codysoyland 4y agoFor those looking for an alternative, carbon steel pans are stamped or spun from steel sheets and are seasoned like cast iron, but are typically thinner and have longer handles. These have been a game changer for my home cooking and I never heard of them until recently. I highly recommend getting a small one for your morning eggs. De Buyer is a popular high quality brand.
- surfpel 4y agoHealth issues aside, speaking as someone who uses only carbon steel and stainless steel cookware, I still wouldn’t recommend it for most people. It’s a lot of work just to maintain and learn how to work with these pans. That being said, I love how much more forgiving, durable, and long lasting these pans are compared to Teflon coated pans and I’ll never go back.
- hackerlight 4y agoI'm a novice and find it easy to maintain. There's no need to clean it extremely well between cooks, just with tap water and your fingernail. Some small amount of leftover seasoning is okay.
- sudosysgen 4y agoThe seasoning of pans is also a cancer risk in some cases. The seasoning is basically a polymer you're bodging together from random organic chemicals in your food.
- andrekandre 4y agoyea.... its a shame cause i love cooking in my cast-iron wok.... one alternative i use is to heat the oil but not to smoking (also use an oil with a high smoke point) on low heat for a couple mins, swirling around, then dump the heated oil, then cook on a low heat from there... its quite non-stick and it reduces the oil content in the food and hopefully reduces carcinogen risk as well... another thing is to just use water (plus maybe a small trickle of oil) as a non-stick agent (though its hard to reproduce a lot of recipes this way) for fish/meats and vegetables if you can get away with it
- spaetzleesser 4y agoI think in the future people will view all the pollution and toxins in our environment as crazy (and avoidable) as we view people working directly with mercury or lead in the past. It’s just nuts that we can’t find the will to say that it’s not ok to pollute.
- samstave 4y agoIt set us up the DOCUMENTARY for great justice https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7689910/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7689910/ Teflon is the most biologically sinister chemical. We need to hold the entire petrol-chemical industry to account. A dear friend of mine is the niece of one of the most successful board members of Shell. Shell is likely the most corrupt-environmentally-speaking companies on the globe. (history of When we went to dinner, they were sharing all their big-game hunting trophy pics from Africa where they were able to kill endangered species and had no qualms about sharing their exploits (think the EDIT -- it was Don Trump jr. (I totally dyslexia-'d the presidents sons, I did not do that on purpose. Sorry Hunter. (Crack is whack) Hunter Biden pic with the tail of a rhino/elephant? type pics. and it wasnt just one... NUMEROUS animals.) https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=don+trump+jr+elephant+tail+pic&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=don+trump+jr+elephant+tail+... Petro-chems are boon and bane. This industry needs a reckoning.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoHumanity probably needs plastics, I can’t see how we go back. Also, it’s interesting to consider whether >50% sugar induced obesity rates are having a larger effect on quality of life…
- samstave 4y agoOMG - I was on a flight with one of the biggest lobbyists in DC for the sugar industry. This lady opened up to me about just how evil that industry is, and how the family emmigrated to the US via cuba by falsley claiming they were religious refugees and needed to establish a foot-hold in miami (but they werent cubans, they were criminals, and she spoke about how she helped set this family up and how she manages their accounts) Y'all may not think there is money laundering on every level - but there is. The sugar industry run by this family is unpluss-good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fanjul_brothers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fanjul_brothers These motherfuckers posed as religious refugees. They are the biggest drug dealers you have ever not known. She was their personal lobbyist. And for whatever reason came clean to me on a flight to DC.... Reduce your sugar.
- 4y ago
- ars 4y agoThis title is editorialized, it does not say "cookware". This study is about PFAS, NOT cookware.
- dataangel 4y agoNot sure that counts as editorializing, isn't cookware where most people would get PFAS exposure?
- blablabla123 4y agoMost yes, although the far higher intensity was near chemical plants through the water supply I think especially in the past.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoI don't think so, since it's found everywhere like in your water and meat. In fact, focusing on cookware seems to understate the issue and leads people to just argue about which pan is the best while missing the point. I'm sure it was editorialized by TFA because cookware is more concrete for readers to latch onto than "PFAS", an initialism people are only learning about this week.
- ars 4y agoNo, there's basically no PFAS in cookware. "Studies show that this coating contains a negligible amount of PFAS capable of migrating to food." https://www.fda.gov/food/chemical-contaminants-food/questions-and-answers-pfas-food https://www.fda.gov/food/chemical-contaminants-food/question... You get PFAS from things like paper straws, and other paper dishes (always ask for plastic dishes, not paper). PFAS is also in waterproof coatings, and things like oil for the bottom of skis. Cookware is the last thing you should worry about as far as PFAS.
- mdavis6890 4y agoI think there is very little meat on the bone here. Possible? Sure! Certain? Hardly. Of course we’re going to start turning up chemicals in our bodies that weren’t there before we started using them. And the increased prevalence guarantees that they will be there more often when you look for them in people with e.g. liver cancer. But so what? And taking about a rate of a disease is easily confounded by more frequent and more sensitive testing. Likely this is just in the very large bucket of studies that pick up spurious correlations. But like all of them - maybe it’s not spurious!
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThis is actually very poor statistics. Take a look at the actual study: https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(22)00122-7/fulltext https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(22)00122-7/fu... And look at table 3. They are testing 6 different types of PFAS, and only 1 is statistically significant. They need to be using the Bonferroni Correction because they are checking multiple hypothesis. To do that, you divide the required p-value (0.05) by the number of tests (6). If you do the Bonferroni Correction, none of the PFAS is statistically significant. Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/ Thus the real conclusion is that the study did not find any statistically significant link between 'forever chemicals' and liver cancer.
- dataangel 4y agoWhether they need a correction depends on how they calculated the p-value. If they only ask one question, "Is the total of these 6 chemicals correlated with liver cancer?" then they only did one test and don't need to correct. The fact that 6 chemicals go into the total doesn't mean they asked more questions, it just means there results only speak to the total amount of that whole class of chemicals in the blood rather than any one of them.
- 2020aj 4y agoEach of the 6 have unique p-values, they did 6 tests. The GP is correct.
- rendang 4y agoHow does a mistake so basic get past peer review?
- lend000 4y agoSo, what's the solution nowadays? Is the cookware really the greatest source of these chemicals in the human body when properly used? It seems like lower hanging fruit is avoiding Teflon dental floss, "compostable" straws/bowls, cosmetics, using an activated carbon water filter, etc.
- hackerlight 4y agoI use a Stainless Steel pan with no coating for cooking, and a microwaveable glass for drinking. Worst case scenario would be some excess nickel from the cheap alloy that they use for the steel.
- Zigurd 4y agoTeflon will prove to be one of those planetary scale "Oops, we poisoned everything, everywhere, to sell cheap pans" mistakes, like tetraethyl lead in gasoline.
- PeterStuer 4y agoI only use pure lard for cooking in (high end https://www.zwilling.com/us/demeyere/cookware/atlantis/ https://www.zwilling.com/us/demeyere/cookware/atlantis/ ) stainless steel pans. No sticking problems wathsoever. Heat the lard enough before starting the frying.
- jadams5 4y agoFor folks having issues with food sticking to cast iron or carbon steel, try learning to cook on stainless. It's much more prone to sticking, but if you can get the technique down well enough to not have eggs stick on stainless then switch to cast it's a walk in the park.
- novaRom 4y agoTomatoes+Onions+Eggs, anything watery or sour = stainless with some drops of olive oil Meat, Potatoes = cast iron with sunflower oil anything else (crepes, pan cakes) = carbon steel with either canola or sunflower oil To prevent eggs to stick putting some onion rings or slices of ginger helps. The most difficult is to get good non-oily crepes.
- bruce343434 4y agoeverything = ceramic/enamel coated pan
- pgt 4y agoSunflower oil & canola oil (rapeseed oil) = PUFAs. Avoid seed oils!
- aceazzameen 4y agoThere's also blue steel, which I think is just a fancy carbon steel. We have a crepe pan made out of it, and the crepes never came out oily. Truth be told, it doesn't get much use anymore. But it was definitely the easiest for crepes.
- flutetornado 4y agoI have been using oil infused Ceramic cookware from Calphalon (Classic). The handles are made of stainless steel which stays cool despite all the cooking. Quite convenient. Works very well as a replacement for Teflon based non stick cookware I used to use earlier. It's not perfect but using a bit of butter or oil when cooking gives good results. More details about various varieties here: https://www.calphalon.com/supportShow?cfid=cookware-use-and-care https://www.calphalon.com/supportShow?cfid=cookware-use-and-...
- jongjong 4y agoMy mother always told me that coatings on non-stick cookware were carcinogenic. She also told me the following (which I follow but never actually fact-checked): - When doing dishes by hand, make sure to always rinse the soap off completely. - Do not consume hot water straight out of the tap; always take it out cold and boil it as a separate step (because hot water carries more lead and other metals from the inside of the pipes?) - Do not eat burnt (or partially burnt) food (carcinogenic). - Avoid induction kitchen appliances (radiation). - Avoid chewing plastic (pthalates/endocrine disruptors). - Avoid cooking with seed oils or other polyunsaturated oils - These are good raw, but not heated as it breaks the bonds in the oil and turns bad. For cooking, use saturated fats (but mono-saturated fats like olive oil are OK too). - Avoid processed foods as much as possible (and chemicals such as coloring agents and preservatives). - Avoid eating too much instant noodles (due to coating on noodles). - Avoid soaps and shampoos which produce a lot of foam (avoid sodium lauryl sulfate and cocamidopropyl-betaine). - Avoid any medication which affects the brain. - Make sure that bedroom gets plenty of sunlight during the day to prevent dust mites. - Don't over-sanitize your environment; lack of exposure to germs can lead to allergies? - Rinse your mouth out well after brushing teeth (don't consume too much fluoride). - After taking antibiotics, eat yogurt and/or probiotic supplements to rebuild gut bacteria. I was told this long before research about gut microbes was mainstream. - Avoid eating too much predatory fish like Tuna (mercury). - Swimming in the sea is good for you. It has healing properties? Anyway, kind of random but I've always wanted to share these in case it helps anyone. I do think it helps to be cautious even when the science is limited or has gaps. Our modern society tends to err on the side of reckless consumption instead of cautious consumption. Remember, the financial incentive of all companies in a capitalist system is to deny all downsides because it mitigates legal liabilities. Think of Big Tobacco 'doctors recommend smoking' campaigns in the 1930s to 1950s; it makes sense to assume that every industry we have today is similar. So the science (which is funded by these companies) will always be biased towards neglect ("don't worry, it's totally safe and effective") rather than caution ("It's probably safe in small quantities but you may want to avoid it anyway just in case"). The media will never promote the second approach.
- rvbissell 4y agoSeems like a lot of good advice, with one notable exception being induction kitchen appliances.
- cassepipe 4y agoThere's a fiction movie about it : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Waters_(2019_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Waters_(2019_film)
- cassepipe 4y agoIt does not look cool but vapor cooking is a miracle. It is fast, it is clean, it preserves nutriments. People who like to "cook" don't like it because they can't perform their magic rituals. Cooking has always seemed something very religious to me... Cooking some stuff for a long time, adding secret ingredients supposedly to give "extra" taste... Putting stuff on the pan, then turning on the oven jsut to melt a layer of cheese.. Seems to be so much work, so little efficient. Most of my cooking talents consist in adding salt and pepper, spices, olive oils, seeds, lemon juice to good produce with delicious bread. You can taste the things you are eating, it takes less time and it's healthier. It's even healthier for your indoor air. Come to the bright side.
- diogenescynic 4y agoJust don't buy nonstick. It's not necessary and there are better alternatives. Use cast iron (vintage/used pans are cheap and great!), carbon steel (Blanc Creatives), enameled cast iron (Le Creuset), or stainless steel (All-Clad or Viking) . I cook eggs in all of these and it's not difficult. You don't need nonstick for anything... it's not more convenient at all.
- k8si 4y agoHow do people feel about the GreenPan products?
- yeeeloit 4y agoI've not heard of GreenPan before, so I took a look at their website [1] There is not a whole lot of information available on their site. From the Thermolon™ page[2]: > ...contains zero harmful chemicals. > PFAS, Lead, Cadmium, etc., are not put into it. > Thermolon is based on a derivative of sand that is transformed into a sprayable solution through a sol-gel process. Zero harmful PFAS chemicals are involved in that process. Great, but what chemicals are used in their products? What do they ACTUALLY put in the coating? Why trust a company like this? If you're worried, then just learn to cook and use cast-iron, copper, stainless steel. 1. https://greenpan.com.au/ https://greenpan.com.au/ 2. https://greenpan.com.au/pages/thermolon https://greenpan.com.au/pages/thermolon
- Calms 4y agoI own a few GreenPan products and started to wonder so I did some digging - seems they were subject to a class action lawsuit [1] which was voluntarily dismissed since it reached settlement[2]. Hard to know if it had much merit since it was unsuccessful though. [1] https://www.classaction.org/news/class-action-seeks-to-debunk-numerous-allegedly-false-greenpan-product-claims https://www.classaction.org/news/class-action-seeks-to-debun... [2] https://truthinadvertising.org/class-action/greenpan-cookware/ https://truthinadvertising.org/class-action/greenpan-cookwar...
- royaltjames 4y agoI just learned so much from this post's comments. Thank you all for sharing in this.
- rblion 4y agoCast iron skillet is the way to go. Don't use too much oil, when heated high enough it creates carcinogens.
- yuan43 4y agoThere isn't a human alive today whose blood is free from PFOA and/or PFOS. The question to answer is what are the major routes by which this is happening. There is a lot of discussion in this thread about cookware. The problem is that these chemicals are now found throughout the environment and used in countless products. The stuff is found increasingly in drinking water and foods. Maybe cookware is a major contributor, but the truth is nobody knows yet. Nor does this effect appear limited to liver cancer. The paper notes: > Studies examining associations of PFAS exposure with risk of other cancers, such as kidney cancer, in the general population have found similar associations to those reported here. For example, in the only existing nested case-control study examining the prospective association between PFAS levels and risk of renal cell carcinoma, PFOS levels >50 μg/L were associated with more than two-fold increased risk of developing renal cell carcinoma (OR=2.51; 95% CI: 1.28-4.92), and similar associations were reported for PFOA and PFHxS [[52]]. These findings are notable due to the similarity in PFOS concentrations associated with risk of HCC in our study. ... https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(22)00122-7/fulltext https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(22)00122-7/fu... For its part, the paper never mentions the word "cookware" and is instead focused on the link between blood concentrations and cancer. Edit: Wikipedia has the following paragraph on the topic of cookware: > Despite DuPont's asserting that "cookware coated with DuPont Teflon non-stick coatings does not contain PFOA",[91] residual PFOA was also detected in finished PTFE products including PTFE cookware (4–75 parts per billion).[87] However, PFOA levels ranged from undetectable (<1.5) to 4.3 parts per billion in a more recent study.[48] Also, non-stick cookware is heated—which should volatilize PFOA; PTFE products that are not heated, such as PTFE sealant tape, had higher (1800 parts per billion) levels detected.[92] Overall, PTFE cookware is considered an insignificant exposure pathway to PFOA.[93][94] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid
- stjohnswarts 4y agodoseage makes the poison, no? has there been an explosion of liver cancer?
- _delirium 4y agoThere's been a significant increase in the U.S. [1], though there are multiple possible causes. Besides environmental pollution, two factors often quoted are increases in viral hepatitis and obesity, which are both risk factors. [1] "Liver cancer death rates jumped a startling 43 percent in the United States between 2000 and 2016" https://www.mskcc.org/news/what-s-behind-rise-liver-cancer-deaths-and-what-can-be-done-about-it https://www.mskcc.org/news/what-s-behind-rise-liver-cancer-d...
- frankfrankfrank 4y ago[flagged]
- andrewstuart 4y agoI threw out all my "surfaced" cookware years ago and replaced everything with stainless steel. "Surfaced" cookware loses its surface after a period of time. Where did it go? Well into your food of course, and into you.
- bergenty 4y agoSame. I do miss the non stickyness when making certain things though.
- rasengan0 4y agoDay late and a quintillion healthcare dollars short https://youtu.be/NJFbsWX4MJM https://youtu.be/NJFbsWX4MJM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Devil_We_Know https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Devil_We_Know
- martingoodson 4y agoAnyone know how I can replace a non-stick wok? Carbon steel doesn’t work unless you have gas. Induction and electric hobs don’t heat up the sides enough to maintain the seasoning of a wok, which has very high sides. I would rather not use non-stick coatings but I can’t find a good alternative.
- peanut_worm 4y agoI have a bad feeling millennials and gen z people are going to have a dramatically lower life expectancy than the previous few generations from how many chemicals they are in contact with
- wolfv 4y agoFrom this 2019 study: Serum concentrations of PFASs and exposure-related behaviors in African American and non-Hispanic white women https://www.nature.com/articles/s41370-018-0109-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41370-018-0109-y Flossing with Oral-B Glide was associated with 24.9% (95% CI: 0.2–55.7) higher levels of PFHxS Exposure to these chemicals and draws attention to coated cardboard prepared food containers and dental floss as modifiable sources. Fast food packaging show that fluorinated chemicals are detected more frequently in paper wrappers than in paperboard containers. Eating food prepared with nonstick cookware had no significant association with PFAS levels.
- kurupt213 4y agoPfas are absolutely everywhere. Everyone is constantly exposed even if they eat organic and cook in cast iron
- elzbardico 4y agoI use ceramic coated pans most of the time. I do have cast iron stuff, but my wife or I wouldn't want to use it every day as we both work. We cook every day, and being able to put it all in the dishwasher is a big time saver. I also doubt that the polymer coating due to seasoning my cast iron stuff is kosher in terms of carcinogenesis, so another reason not to use it too frequently. In general, organic stuff + very high temperatures are always a potential source of all kinds of nasty molecules. So, we try to limit this kind of cooking for the weekends.