28 ms·
Why isn’t new technology making us more productive?
- uejfiweun 4y agoI have a hard time believing this thesis that modern technology doesn't help productivity. Think about CRM software. Could you imagine having to go through hundreds of filing cabinets and massive systems just to get information about a customer? What about 100 SDRs doing this at the same time, every day? How about trying to meet with someone on the other side of the country? Or having to hire hundreds of assembly line workers to do the job of a single robot? No, we are more productive than ever before. But the BENEFITS from these enormously productive technologies only seem to go to the richest of the rich, which is why we live in one of the most unequal times since the gilded age. I hate this term but I honestly think it's just "FUD" put out by these uber-rich people, this sentiment of "oh the economy isn't becoming more productive". It is most definitely becoming more productive, but the only benefit Joe Average sees from that is slightly lower consumer prices (which of course is offset by skyrocketing asset prices). IIRC the only way society got out of this gini-out-of-the-bottle situation last time was through multiple cataclysmic wars, a great depression, and trust busting, so I'd be lying if I said I wasn't concerned.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoAll the productivity gains are nullified by a drop in risk-taking.
- adolph 4y ago+ increased "compliance" measures
- jstarfish 4y ago> Think about CRM software. Could you imagine having to go through hundreds of filing cabinets and massive systems just to get information about a customer? A Rolodex used to be enough. Advancement replacing it with "hundreds of filing cabinets" should tell you something.
- sharemywin 4y agoAct 2.0 was the desktop version of CRM. and alot of old systems had built in customer databases. had contact info in them. and zoom is cool but phones work in a lot of cases.
- kylecordes 4y agoIf your team was sitting at desks on a fast network, Act! probably obtained 80% of the productivity benefit of the best available, most expensive CRM available today. Or maybe even better than that; because (again assuming a fast network locally) it could be operated with keystrokes quite a lot faster than many of today’s CRM system. I worked in a place where we had phone, email, and FAX (!) integration set up also. A rep could be on a phone they didn't dial, configuring a quote for what their contact asked for, click a button and it emailed or faxed to the contact. Over 20 years ago.
- smegsicle 4y ago1000x increase in capability coupled with 1000x increase in waste
- DANK_YACHT 4y ago> Advancement replacing it with "hundreds of filing cabinets" should tell you something. A rolodex was enough because that's all that could be managed by an individual. If the number of names needed by a person grew past the size of a rolodex, they were simply out of luck because no system existed that would allow them to efficiently handle that much data. That's my takeaway at least.
- jstarfish 4y ago> A rolodex was enough because that's all that could be managed by an individual. If the number of names needed by a person grew past the size of a rolodex, they were simply out of luck because no system existed that would allow them to efficiently handle that much data. That's my takeaway at least. Yes, absolutely true. Given "hundreds of filing cabinets" though, how many of those leads can or will even be contacted in the salesperson/company's lifetime? How many leads will themselves have died before you even get to their number? It's "advancement" only in the sense that we've made hoarding more efficient (which is a technical achievement in itself).
- sharemywin 4y agospecifically they said since 2004 productivity increases were only 1% per year. cloud computing/saas probably adds to productivity but not as much as converting from files to desktop computer systems.
- wvenable 4y agoI'm not sure how they're measuring productivity. From my own experience as a software developer, I've seen how software makes individuals more productive. But the end result of this productivity is not 2x as much output overall but 0.5x as many people to achieve the same level of productivity. We're decreasing costs but maybe the market doesn't need 2x or 5x more productivity. There just isn't that kind of demand anywhere -- especially with fewer people working.
- gumby 4y ago"Productivity" means "amount of input required to get a given output." I think you might be thinking of "productivity" as a synonym for "output". Usually in economics the input is labor hours, but for example "energy intensity" is the productivity of how much energy a process uses. In the macroeconomic case it's GDP divided by total energy used, but some industries are more energy intensive than others -- they have lower productivity from their energy use. Thus 2X the output and same output with 1/2 the people are identical: both describe doubling productivity.
- tshaddox 4y ago> "Productivity" means "amount of input required to get a given output." I think you might be thinking of "productivity" as a synonym for "output". Okay but surely we're only talking about average productivity with some assumptions on the approximate employment rate and hours worked per week. No one is going to be impressed by a "5% increase in productivity" next year if unemployment rises to 99%, the 1% of remaining workers only work 10 hours per week, but the average hour yields 5% higher output than the previous year.
- gumby 4y ago> Okay but surely we're only talking about average productivity with some assumptions on the approximate employment rate and hours worked per week. No. Productivity is simply output divided by some input factor. Employment rate, hours worked per week, wage: none are involved in that calculation (unless you're measuring productivity of the wage, i.e. COGS). > No one is going to be impressed by a "5% increase in productivity" next year if unemployment rises to 99%, the 1% of remaining workers only work 10 hours per week, but the average hour yields 5% higher output than the previous year. On the contrary, investors and managers will be very impressed by that.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI think the non-super rich see a lot of advantages from the modern economy. As an example, just yesterday, I was picking up an order at Walmart. The guy who brought the bags to my car had Airpods in. The existence of Airpods (and phones, Internet, Bluetooth, streaming services, etc) may not have made this guy more productive, but it probably improves his life somewhat.
- tobr 4y agoAm I missing something, or is this like the first time you see a guy with AirPods? What’s the significance?
- EarthLaunch 4y agoIt’s that people working boring or unpleasant jobs can have an audio environment of their choice. Music, podcasts, audiobooks. This wasn’t possible when it required a huge device, but AirPods are so unobtrusive and socially acceptable that workers can wear them without it attracting undue attention. Pranksters on YouTube use it for the same reason; people are used to seeing it and don’t associate it with receiving voice instructions.
- kylecordes 4y agoOne significant thing here: this is a piece of technology which no one in the entire world, at any level of wealth, had a couple decades ago. But today a person in a relatively low-ranked job carrying orders out at Walmart... casually has this technology for fun. This does not measure as a productivity improvement, but it’s pretty great. Most non-positional goods are like this. You getting Airpods doesn't make mine any worse. Statistically, you getting Airpods makes mine better, because it increases the chances of there being more content I like.
- evan_ 4y agoand when he gets home he can eat bread and watch the circus on his phone!
- 4y ago
- bombcar 4y agoA massive CRM was possible in the early 90s on easily obtainable hardware. Earlier if you wanted to spend the money. It’s not immediately clear what Salesforce adds that literally couldn’t be done with 1995 tech.
- throw8383833jj 4y agoIt sounds plausible: all the benefits have gone to the rich. So, I set out to see what a world would be like if we "redistributed" all those "benefits". So, simply take the entire wealth of every billionaire in the US and divide it by the number of citizens and number of years required to acquire that wealth. It's a relatively simply equation: Billionaire wealth / Citizens / 30 Years = Yearly Redistribution 4T / 300 M/ 30 = 500$ per year (not exactly life changing wealth) So, if you stole every last dollar from every last billionaire in the US and redistributed it for the last 30 years, each person would only get 500$ per year. I have a different theorey. The US and other developed countries have been loosing ever greater amounts of wealth. Wealth per capita has decreased dramatically over the last 50 years. The causes are too numerous to go into, but there are MANY. *https://ips-dc.org/u-s-billionaire-wealth-surges-past-1-trillion-since-beginning-of-pandemic/ https://ips-dc.org/u-s-billionaire-wealth-surges-past-1-tril... At the end of the day, humans want simple solutions to simple problems and the "wealth going to the top" theorey is super easy to understand and super easy to solve. There's only one problem: it's not true. it's debunked now. The real problem of decreasing wealth is much harder to solve and has many causes
- mbrameld 4y ago> it's not true. it's debunked now Where has it been debunked?
- dahart 4y ago> So, if you stole every last dollar from every last billionaire in the US and redistributed it for the last 30 years, each person would only get 500$ per year. Loaded use of the world “stole” there. This is a faulty analysis. It’s well studied and well known, for example, that the top 10% of people income wise have ~70% of the wealth in the US. Similar patterns exist globally. This has been reproduced many ways by many people and squarely contradicts your calculation.
- throw8383833jj 4y ago"stole" or redistribute. the math works out the same in the end. the reason I used "stole" is because if you "redistribute" every ounce of someone's wealth, I imagine you might get some push back. You can re-apply this formula to various top N% but you get similar numbers: both for income redistribution and wealth redistribution. The reason all those articles of top 10% have 70% of the wealth seem so impressive is not because the top 10% have so much, it's because the rest of the 90% has so little. and so even a modest amount in the top 10% is much greater than the tiny bit the bottom 90 has.
- DeWilde 4y agoThe gap between the richest and the poorest is probably the largest ever, but today people are also living far more comfortably than ever: electricity, heated water, food and water at a press of a button, generally good transportation to pretty much everywhere. What is lacking, for the less privileged, is mostly lack of access to affordable housing and a bad diet (arguably this is mostly due to the enticing nature of fast food and lack of education about how bad it is). Other than that the basic life necessities don't differ too wildly for the rich and the everyone who is not homeless.
- pdimitar 4y agoI believe it needs to also be said that bad diet is a side effect of everyone trying to produce with cheaper and cheaper materials. I shudder to think what kinds of ingredients are some of the foods I see in cheaper shops made from. This is not sustainable. It cannot last for that much longer IMO. Literally and metaphorically, people are getting sick of it. They notice. They are not dumb. They might be in denial (people just LOVE their chips and cola for some reason) but they are not dumb. I see more and more people in my neighborhood going to the local market and negotiating with vendors coming straight from agrarian villages for a "monthly subscription" of sorts -- you bring me one huge basket with fruits and veggies every weekend, I pay you, say, $200 a month. The vendor gets a stable income, you get actual bio food and don't have to pick and choose every tomato and parsley leaf every damn time. The vendors have a vested interest not to cheat their most stable and profitable customers. Sadly all these societal changes are glacially slow, giving the opportunists plenty of breathing room to swindle people and get rich for decades but oh well, until we develop collective consciousness it seems that this won't ever change... :|
- tstrimple 4y agoI think it's a little to easy to overlook the abject poverty which still exists in this country. More than two million Americans lack access to clean water or sanitation. I personally know millennials who didn't have hot water in their house growing up. They would heat water on the stove for baths, at least when their utilities were turned on. There exist towns where literal sewage is running out of people's houses in areas where kids play. Hookworm for example is still rampant in parts of the US. Half of our rivers and streams and one third of our lakes are too polluted to swim or fish in, much less drink from. 99% of households having a refrigerator doesn't mean these folk are living comfortably. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/05/hookworm-lowndes-county-alabama-water-waste-treatment-poverty https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/05/hookworm-low... https://time.com/longform/clean-water-access-united-states/ https://time.com/longform/clean-water-access-united-states/
- thewarrior 4y agoBecause software cannot produce resources just because it exists. Productivity refers to being able to actually manufacture more widgets and things like food, roads. Yes technology has made things cheaper. By moving things across the globe and creating a complex supply chain that can produce more goods for less energy and raw material input. But the per Capita availability of energy and minerals is a fundamental bottleneck that things like CRM software can only go so far in helping. The article talks about software that allows a call center employee to handle more customers better. This is great but how does something like this help society produce more heating and food which are currently in short supply ? It makes the company more profit and saves customers some money. But if they try to actually get more food it will cause inflation. I would highly encourage people to read the work of Vaclav Smil. In the grand scheme of things iPhones are irrelevant. Half the world depends on natural gas and ammonia fertilizer so they don't starve to death. We are living through the consequences of this as we speak. Software simply isn't on the scale of things like coal, oil, natural gas, electricity or even washing machines. Computers might be more like the printing press. Perhaps centuries from now we can look back and say what innovations came about due to multi century second order and third order effects. We in the industry have become lost in the world of bits and "productivity" in producing TikToks and targetting ads for mobile games doesn't help as much as we think towards supply. These are fundamentally ways of aggregating and coordinating demand. The problem is now on the supply side. We need software that runs on robots eliminating workers and working 24x7 doing things like mining, agriculture and warehouses. We also need eliminate middle men and deliver directly to the consumer. Beyond that we need fundamentally new energy sources. Software can help here but increasing digitization mainly creates fat middlemen who don't add as much productivity into the world as they take. Hence I think Chinas new approach to tech regulatuion that curtails middleman platforms and encourages startups on the supply side makes a lot of sense.
- gowld 4y agoServices are also productivity.
- thewarrior 4y agoYes but only to an extent. We cannot have an economy only of rappers and influencers.
- bennysomething 4y agoLost me at the bit about fud from rich people. I really doubt there is a conspiracy.
- Aunche 4y agoOf course regular people are seeing benefits to increased productivity. The question is whether these benefits are really benefits at all. The average adult spends over 12 hours a day consuming media [1]. It's worth noting that much of this is passive consumption like radio in the background, but active consumption is undeniably increasing as well, most notably smartphone usage. I think the problem is that the more optimized our society becomes, the less true the economic assumption of rational human behavior becomes. Google Maps, for example, saves me time looking at maps rather than doing browsing Hackernews. However, when I think about it rationally, I was no less happy spending a few minutes planning my route before a trip instead of browsing HN during that same time. [1] https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/report/2020/the-nielsen-total-audience-report-august-2020/ https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/report/2020/the-niels...
- lkrubner 4y ago“”””But the BENEFITS from these enormously productive technologies only seem to go to the richest of the rich”””” You misunderstand how labor productivity is calculated. It’s simply the the total amount of wealth generated by a worker per hour. So for instance, a worker at a McDonalds restaurant generates $150 in wealth per hour, and gets paid $12 per hour on average. Total wealth is created by productivity and is then divided between labor and capital. Where labor unions are strong, more of the total wealth goes to labor, and where labor unions are weak, more of the total wealth goes to capital. It’s the total wealth per hour that has seen slow growth in recent decades. If you doubt how much computers destroy productivity, then simply visit a hospital and you can see it with your own eyes. My mom was recently in the hospital so I got to see this myself. Mistake after mistake because of bad information either put into the computer, or codes being misinterpreted. In the old days, an army of secretaries kept the world in order. Despite your intuitions, they did in fact have ways of quickly finding one file out of millions of files. And secretaries offered a flexibility that we’ve lost with computers. It is the loss of flexibility that causes computers to damage productivity.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> Mistake after mistake because of bad information either put into the computer, or codes being misinterpreted. To note, in the olden days, mistakes written in your record or misinterpretations (e.g.took the wrong record from the cabinet) would just have been a fact of life and nobody might even notice. Ms Wilson and Ms Wiston just shouldn't have been in the same hospital at the same time. As you say everything was more flexible, more fuzzy. If you wanted the world to look orderly you'd quickly sweap under the rug the misaligned bits or disappear what you don't want there. This is also why you use cash and paper register if you need your restaurant's finances to look pristine on paper while still racking in money that doesn't need to be accounted.
- njstraub608 4y ago> If you doubt how much computers destroy productivity, then simply visit a hospital and you can see it with your own eyes. My mom was recently in the hospital so I got to see this myself. Mistake after mistake because of bad information either put into the computer, or codes being misinterpreted. I would argue this isn’t necessarily because of computers but a byproduct of an antiquated system and process being codified into a computer. The reason for this seems to be that there are structural inefficiencies built into our healthcare system that create a ton of added complexity that is near impossible to unwind because of legal (contractual and privacy-related) risks. For example, any attempts at improving efficiency in patient care creates potential liabilities for medical professionals. People are scared to innovate in this space, so the programs are just digital translations of an existing process. This requires a time investment to learn the “new way” of doing the same thing, and builds inherit laziness because steps are still require that should have been automated away. Medical notes are a good example of this; it’s required to be documented in an extremely specific way and of a certain length because of insurance so it just ends up being copy and pasted, free text, by the physician to meet this requirement.
- drewcoo 4y agoConsider bullshit jobs. Yes, there's "work" being done, so it's "productive," but is it really? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs
- throw0101a 4y ago> I have a hard time believing this thesis that modern technology doesn't help productivity. See Solow paradox: > The productivity paradox, also referred to as the Solow paradox, could refer either to the slowdown in productivity growth in the United States in the 1970s and 1980s despite rapid development in the field of information technology (IT) over the same period, or to the slowdown in productivity growth in the United States and developed countries from the 2000s to 2020s; sometimes the newer slowdown is referred to as the productivity slowdown, the productivity puzzle, or the productivity paradox 2.0. The 1970s to 1980s productivity paradox inspired many research efforts at explaining the slowdown, only for the paradox to disappear with renewed productivity growth in the developed countries in the 1990s. However, issues raised by those research efforts remain important in the study of productivity growth in general, and became important again when productivity growth slowed around the world again from the 2000s to the present day. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Productivity_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Productivity_paradox
- mikewarot 4y ago>Could you imagine having to go through hundreds of filing cabinets and massive systems just to get information about a customer? Yes, things are much faster now. But having to manually scan an entire office of files sequentially was never a thing. The files were alphabetized, indexed, collated. Clerks knew what they were doing. In digging through my home state of Indiana's Marriage records, they had an ingenious system that did a fair bit of error correction and sped up retrieval of information by orders of magnitude. This system goes back to the 1800s, consists of an index, and sequentially recorded Marriage Licenses, bound in the same book. Entries were indexed by both the groom and brides last name, which meant in most cases, you could recover from a single error. Worst case, you had to scan that one book for the County, for that year, or fraction thereof. If you knew the date, that made it much faster as well.
- mikewarot 4y agoRichard Nixon had a plan for dealing with this, but changed his mind at the last second. [1] 1 - https://thecorrespondent.com/4503/the-bizarre-tale-of-president-nixon-and-his-basic-income-bill/173117835-c34d6145 https://thecorrespondent.com/4503/the-bizarre-tale-of-presid...
- kylecordes 4y agoWhere did all the productivity benefits go? The answer is probably: to competition. If one company got CRM, wow, huge productivity boost! They would sell so much more per unit of salesperson labor input. But it's a competitive world, so a lot of companies get CRM. The additional sales productivity gets competed back out; perhaps with the recipients of sales efforts (who now have a large increase in the amount of incoming contacts) losing/wasting as much productivity in aggregate as the companies using the software have gained. The same dynamic applies to many other areas. Not to all areas of course; there are also real massive, long term benefits to productivity. Famously it used to take over half of all human effort just to keep us fed. It doesn’t anymore.
- iskander 4y agoMedical record digitization seems to have had a neutral-to-negative impact on hospital efficiency. It's hard to believe since the alternative sounds mind-numbingly inefficient but there are tons of low-tech streamlined processes (like having a whiteboard in each patient's room) which are being undermined by having a constellation of disconnected staff all dumping information into Epic and not having time to read other entries.
- gumby 4y agoI was rather disappointed in Lohr (author of this piece) as he is smart and was around in the 1990s for Solow’s famous quip “We see the computer age everywhere except in the productivity statistics”. In the age of the desktop computer the iPhone would have been a flop (especially in the US’s then-backwards wireless environment). It takes time for people to understand a new capability and for it to reach the point where it’s worth ditching current practice. My aging parents still like to have a meeting (with their lawyer for example) that could have been a phone call or even email; they still visit the bank in person etc. I can’t be bothered with any of that. The call center makes a good example: I have seen a company that uses machine learning to make the outbound call: it can wait patiently on hold and even do some transactions with the human in the call center. Things like that don’t show up in the stats yet; the real change will be replacing most of the call center ppl with an API, and with the humans there to handle the really hard problems.
- mikkergp 4y agoThe call center seems to be like the standard MBA case of a cost center to optimize but where efficiency is only half correlated with positive customer experience. I mean if you can route people to the right place, and get peoples questions answered quickly it's great, but that leaves a long tail of people in the nightmare situation of digging through phone trees, dealing with untrained staff, or having someone try to cut a call short rather than give you the best experience.
- bombcar 4y agoThe only real advance in call center tech in the last twenty years (imo) has been the “press 1 to be called back in the order your call was received”.
- I_dev_outdoors 4y agoMy dentist has a PBX setup so that when you call and you don't get anyone or leave a voicemail, you get a link in a SMS with a link to schedule a call back.
- 4y ago
- sharemywin 4y agoI would think globalization and the shift from manufacturing to services is like a slow tax on productivity. so for every increase in productivity at some office there's a huge negative productivity impact when a factory moves overseas.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAfter a certain threshold, it is clear that human behavior exhibits many types of compensations, risk compensation as one, but I’m sure (from my personal experience) that there is productivity compensation. Analysis done over the last century across many countries show that everyone is working fewer hours per year as we transition from an agricultural to a knowledge based economy; this likely means that people want to relax and that new productivity gains will be compensated by fewer working hours and more relaxation.
- dbtc 4y agoPerhaps because too much of it is designed to turn people into products, rather than producers.
- gz5 4y agoThe gains are there but are mainly realized by the winning companies - I don't think they could have scaled like this otherwise? + Microsoft went from about $25B in annual revenue to ~200B in the past 20 years. + Apples currently holds about $200B in cash.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoBecause it is the wrong technology. Take project managent Saas for example. Every single one of them don't focus on the big picture. Not a single one tries to make users effective instead of efficient.
- partiallypro 4y agoIt is, it also gives us more downtime during the workday that isn't reflected in the numbers.
- corrral 4y agoI'm not sure this is true. There are accounts of incredible waste and normalized, office-wide work-dodging-while-pretending-to-work in the earliest years of the post-war white-collar office. They read like they could have been written yesterday, with a few of the details changed. It could be that as more people moved into white-collar work, though, the fraction of the population experiencing and participating in that kind of thing has gone up.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoI am actually writing a book about this - and my thesis is "software literacy". Software is a form of literacy and people need to a) be literate b) have tools and permissions and culture to allow people to basically code their own solutions. Most large companies have a sort of process-killing-glass-ceiling where only excel spreadsheets can pass through.
- deanCommie 4y agoThere is an infamous anecdote from the turn/mid of the 20th century: People believed that innovations in vacuum cleaners, washing machines, etc would cause people to have more leisure time because of how much time it saved in cleaning. But it didn't happen. Why? Because people's expectations for hygiene and cleanliness went up. And as it became easier to clean houses and clothes, people were more comfortable with having larger houses, and more clothes. Technology innovation is much the same way. As capabilities increase so do expectations. And the "economy" is all about expectations and aspirations.
- throwaway1777 4y agoexcept it did save a lot of time. Have you ever tried to wash clothes by hand? Increased standard of living counts in terms of increased productivity.
- lordgrenville 4y agoExactly. We have a lot more free time, we've just raised our leisure standards (dining out more frequently, traveling more) and come up with more forms of entertainment (social media, streaming platforms, gaming). That this sounds to most of us like a wasted opportunity might be because these things are not very fulfilling, or it might just be the hedonic treadmill.
- jimmydeans 4y ago
- mikkergp 4y agoI mean, technology making us more productive seems obviously true on it's face, so what gives? --> Productivity, which is defined as the value of goods and services produced per hour of work. Seems like an interesting measure. So as companies become more efficient and the cost of goods goes down, so does productivity. So you might be able to argue we were more probably productive per unit of work building mainframes than we are building iphones.
- 127 4y agoBecause nobody wants to make themselves or their friends obsolete. In fact, technical debt is a feature, not a bug. Invent a highly functional, durable tool: nobody will buy anything related to it from you again.
- sascha_sl 4y agoGenerally, this seems to be rather asyncronous in large companies / "enterprises". I've seen entire departments that are not doing anything relevant. In less severe cases, there are still mostly a few people that do a lot of work, and many that are doing very little. Sort of like the pareto principle of productivity.
- kansface 4y ago1. Technology is making us more productive! Way, way more productive. More or less all of the gains are captured by tech companies who make the technology. 2. Technology is not necessarily adopted for productivity. It is often adopted to facilitate legibility into the day to day activity of the organization. This is often at the expense of productivity! Moreover, this is often acceptable to management!
- smilebot 4y agoWhy Isn't _every_ new tech making us productive. Some definitely are, diff tracking like github, any comms software, accounting software etc do make us a lot more productive.
- FredPret 4y agoHave a look at our GDP per capita graph and tell me again we're not more productive. We're working less and less and making more and more. Some of it is commercial and social innovation, but a lot is technology as well. I work as a specific type of tech consultant to medium-sized companies, and it's wondrous to behold how easy we can make many aspects of business. Critical functions that took multiple handshakes, paper mail, multiple mistakes, and at least a week now take pre-arranged agreements, API's, and they happen in maybe two seconds, almost always perfectly, and before anybody even realizes.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWriting or titling an article with an obviously false premise is an easy way to invoke emotions and get clicks. Sort of related to this: https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/
- pcthrowaway 4y agoThe phenomenon is also called Cunningham's Law: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, for the lazy, there's a nice summary here: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=US-XD-1W&name_desc=false https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location... I've pre-selected a few lines because the problem is supposed to exist on the data of rich countries. You can deselect them at the blue bar at the top of the page (it's not obvious). I couldn't cut the data in any way that showed the issue ever existed. There is an half decade long decrease on the wealth of the poorer countries but nothing else on this graph. Anyway, "productivity" isn't GDP per capta. It's close to the GDP divided by the total worked hours. The fact that the GDP per capta is increasing (I didn't expect this) really puts the productivity problem in an entirely new light.
- DANK_YACHT 4y ago
- rybosworld 4y agoThis is such a dumb article.
- orcul 4y agoA much better question would be: given all this new tech, why aren't we working less?
- jaqalopes 4y agoThe rich people who own the tech are, you and I are not.
- supertrope 4y agoYou're free to retire early and move to a country with a lower standard of living.
- LatteLazy 4y agoProductivity is poorly defined and basically impossible to measure. So when discussing it forget any facts and just accept that you will have to talk about it like you do art...
- morninglight 4y agoIf you regularly visited China over the last 30 years, you would have a clear and dramatic understanding of productivity. .
- LatteLazy 4y agoNo, I'd be even more confused: I'd look at huge building projects and millions of resulting apartments that were built but now had no buyers and were sat empty on some zombie bank's balance sheet. And I would not know whether they were worth sticker price (and China was very productive) or nothing (and China was very unproductive) or anywhere in between. I'd look at FoxConn with >350000 workers making some of the worlds most popular and profitable consumer electronics, but then I'd see they only make 3.6% profit in a country with >3.7% risk free rate of return and think: they're wasting their time and would be better being liquidated. It's almost as if big chunks of China are run to keep people busy and employed and meet arbitrary central targets and not to make things people want at a price they will pay... Actually understanding what productive means, and how to measure it is really really hard. And at every step companies and governments have all sorts of perverse incentives to disguise it.
- pessimizer 4y ago> I'd look at huge building projects and millions of resulting apartments that were built but now had no buyers and were sat empty on some zombie bank's balance sheet. And I would not know whether they were worth sticker price (and China was very productive) or nothing (and China was very unproductive) or anywhere in between. That's just being confused by propaganda. If you look back at all of the Chinese ghost city stories and note the names, virtually all of those cities are full and productive now. I always thought the stories were a line to make excuses for US lack of investment in infrastructure.
- parentheses 4y agoCapability != Productivity Increasing capability means we can do more with less. So we choose to use less resources.
- sascha_sl 4y agoThen why is my attendence still required for 8 hours a day, in a field where working 4-6 hours would not significantly decrease my overall productivity, but increase my well-being and capability to build something on my own. The limiting factor for productivity in the knowledge economy (or any work requiring creativity) hasn't been time for a while, why do we insist on keeping it where it has been since the tail end of the industrial revolution (or slightly earlier / later, depending on where you are).
- pdimitar 4y agoReplying only to the title: Because nobody wants to be "the idiot who pays for innovation from which all our competitors will also benefit". It's like the arms race that the countries all over the world do; you might swear to everything that's holy you're peaceful but you don't know if your neighbor is an a-hole so you arm yourself just in case. The amount of handy scripts and clever engineering solutions I've come up with in personal and freelance projects beats any salaried work creativity by 10x, if not 50x even. Regularly. But after 20 years in the profession I learned not to offer these solutions in my regular work. The other programmers will mercilessly rip apart any of your ideas and will ask for literally every other way for you to do it and not the one you suggested. Nevermind that it's none of their damned business how I deliver the end result (I mean if it does NOT involve code to maintain in the future -- obviously). It's weird. Guess we have some very common and stereotypical weaknesses? But whatever the case, I gradually learned to keep my mouth shut and get the job done by any means necessary. It's better to ask for an apology than for permission, I have found empirically.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/gbNj2 https://archive.ph/gbNj2 http://web.archive.org/web/20220524170241/https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/24/business/technology-productivity-economy.html http://web.archive.org/web/20220524170241/https://www.nytime...
- doubleocherry 4y agoGenerally, because of Conway's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law
- lmkg 4y agoAlso, because of Sturgeon's Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon's_law
- pwthornton 4y agoAnd my axe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoWe are more productive. We are doing more with less people. It doesn’t seem like we are more productive because most people are overworked which creates an illusion of unproductivity. Most of those jobs that were lost in 2008-2009 were never replaced, everyone left just had to pick up the slack which tech helped facilitate The other aspect is that a lot of our tech is vapid entertainment. As buzz aldrin said, “They promised me mars colonies. All we got was Facebook” or something along those lines.
- chii 4y agoI think somehow people have managed to conflate higher productivity with better quality of life. There's no such connection imo. The quality of life of a lot of people might have decreased, and because they mentally have a connection between productivity (of the country) vs their own quality of life, they feel that productivity increasing not leading to their own quality of life increasing, is a bad sign.
- ipnon 4y agoThe right side of the bell curve can now program an application worth many dollars per month and zero marginal reproduction costs. The left side of the bell curve is incapable of extending these technologies but increasingly consumes them due to their low cost. This can explain the seemingly paradoxical phenomena of the rich becoming fabulously richer, wage growth stagnating on average, and productivity barely improving. The inventions of the last 50 years were of smart people for smart people. We wanted flying cars on Mars, we ended up exchanging Amazon warehouse jobs for free TikTok.
- npc12345 4y agoThere's also people with no high school diplomas making 6 figures from advertising on those very same social networks.
- vkou 4y agoA good hustler can make six figures in a sales job without any diploma. Sales doesn't care about your credentials, all your boss wants to know is if you can close deals.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoEmotional intelligence is still intelligence. You need high EQ to be a good salesman. So still on the right side of the bell curve.
- theteapot 4y agoDifferent bell curve.
- avgcorrection 4y agoSiri, give me the most HN comment on productivity development. (Golly gee, this consumer technology sure is swell)
- tonguez 4y ago
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoIt is. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/11/productivity-workforce-america-united-states-wages-stagnate https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/11/productivity-workforc...
- _oghd 4y agoMarx had a lot to say about this over 150 years ago... the answer lies in that technology absolutely does make us more productive. the benefits of that reduction in cost, however, tend to move upward rather than downward, at least when it comes to labor value. this is basically chapter 1 from das kapital. of course, these kind of articles serve as propaganda by comflating ideas and watering down the critical analysis.
- koliber 4y agoProductivity has grown! But not for everyone, sadly. Some people are now magnitudes more productive than they were before. But that requires an understanding of technology, and a drive for improving tools, process, and themselves. The people who can do this effectively are reaping the productivity benefits. Sadly, not everyone is. Some people don't want to do it. Many don't have access to the the instruction that would allow them to unlock these productivity gains. Many productivity tools continue to suffer from usability issues, which limit who can harness them. I'm an optimist. The past has show that eventually, most people can benefit from productivity gains. It takes time for tools to become easy enough for the majority to benefit from them. It's happening all around us.
- ausbah 4y agois this something limited to software engineering ? other specific fields? practices like communication?
- spullara 4y agoI think that productivity per actual second worked has drastically increased and people just don't work as much as they used to, at least in office jobs.
- kkfx 4y ago...Because new technology is not build for us but against us for a little group of IT giants interests... Simply. Classic desktops are for productivity BUT they do not generate enough lock-in nor give their main devs such a tight grip as actual systems and so on. Unfortunately to understand people need to know both models, witch is highly unlikely outside IT techies community and even unlikely inside it...
- Barrin92 4y agoBecause new technology is as Thiel often quips limited to the world of bits rather than the world of atoms. Paul Krugman once asked, if you go into an average house right now and you take out all the screens, could you tell that you're not in the 80s? Gordon in the Rise and Fall of American Growth gives a similar example, what if you went into a time capsule between say 1890 and 1950 compared to 1960 and 2010? In one case you're going to see skyscrapers, commercial airplanes, nuclear power plants, electricity everywhere, cars going at amazing speeds. In the latter case what's the difference, people paying with their phones and different fashion mostly. 'Innovation' in the internet age, say the last 30 years has mostly been limited to enable hedonistic digital consumption with very little impact on how we fundamentally move through the world. The difference between a car right now and a car 30 years ago is that you can now play angry birds on a tablet. A 100 years ago to 50 years ago meant going from horse carriages to trains and from weeks on a ship to hours on a plane. Today the average person crosses the Atlantic no faster than we did decades ago. That's why productivity growth is low, the world hasn't changed that much. There's still marginal improvements obviously which do add up over time but the 'unprecedent pace of innovation' you hear about from tech evangelists is nowhere. Another interesting thought experiment is, how many digital services, modern tech and so on would you be willing to trade for something mundane, say your dishwasher, a hot shower, the toilet, a car, soap, if you could only have one or the other? I think it really puts into perspective how much or rather little value those 'innovations' add.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoThere's a weird disconnect with computers. The software we use is 1000 times more complex than it was 20 years ago, leading to performance that really have not improved a lot, and a lot of functional stagnation. Many applications are slower to start today than they were 10 years ago, because back then they were binaries and today they are Electron apps. Your average web based word processor with cloud storage performs about the same as Microsoft Word did on Windows 3.1 on a 486 saving onto a floppy. Screens are bigger, resolutions are bigger, but the content is largely the same because the limit is human perception not technology. If you actually keep things simple, you can build absolutely ridiculous things off modern hardware. I'm running an Internet search engine out of my living room. You could not that 20 years ago. What makes it possible is modern SSDs and the absolutely mind-boggling computing power of modern CPU.
- angarg12 4y agoOne thing I don't see mentioned often is that productivity in software development has skyrocketed, but it's hard to appreciate. Today's services are much more sophisticated and complex than just a decade ago. Even if some of that complexity is incidental and undesirable, it's undeniable that today a small team can pump out a much more refined app that entire companies did back then. This isn't only guess work, here is a real example: when I joined my first shop we had 2 sysadmin working full time to maintain a couple dozen servers. Over time they started introducing virtualization, automation, devops... by the end of my 7 year tenure, we had 250+ servers and only one sysadmin part time working on them. That's between 1 and 2 orders of magnitude improvement, and my company wasn't special by any means.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoYou could also less charitably read that "growth" as using 250 servers to do the same job you previously did with two. I guess that's growth for sever manufacturers, but I'd expect with more powerful hardware we'd need fewer servers, rather than more.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agowhat you're missing is customer numbers. If you go from 20 servers to 200, and have 100x the customers, that's a massive win.
- angarg12 4y agoI'm not sure what part of my comment made you draw that conclusion. This was a science team and we used servers mostly for scientific computations. Sysadmins jobs was to operate and maintain the servers e.g. make jobs run, upgrade, patch, fix, etc. Virtualization massively simplified this, and automation decreased human intervention. With 250 we were definitely running bigger tasks faster e.g. a project that required 3 months of computing now takes 2 weeks instead.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYes, but a person can write a paper just as well in Wordperfect 5 as the latest Google Doc or Office365 Word. How many millions of dev-hours have been expended on stuff that fundamentally doesn't do anything new? Edit: saying they don't do anything new isn't right. They do, especially with regards to collaboration. What I really mean is that they don't make the essential task -- the actual writing -- much easier. That's still human/mental work. Once you have come up with the words, putting the words into a document is the easy part.
- bmitc 4y agoMost of today's technology keeps us busy but does not make us more productive. Productivity via the hand of technology requires a true commitment to develop technology that augments human activity rather than replace it. Since that is most certainly not what we do with modern technology, we end up with systems that poorly replace humans and provide terrible interfaces between humans and those systems. Thus, it keeps us busy but not productive. With regard to consumer technology, it is explicitly designed to keep consumers more busy than productive. A productive consumer gets in the pool and gets out. A busy consumer gets in the pool and stays there until the skin wrinkles and still lingers.
- greggman3 4y agowhat is the definition of productive? In 1985 I had a one month $1200 phone bill (well, the bill was to my dad) from calling my girlfriend on the other side of the country. I wrote letters to her on paper and sent them via snail mail. Today I video chat and play network games with my friend's 7yr old son 8000 kilometers away. In that same time I had an Atari 1200XL and it took several minutes to run the assembler to cross compile the C64 game I was working on. Today I can do far more impressive things from any browser just using jsfiddle/codepen and things run instantly. Today I can make music in Garageband, Ableton, and all the alternatives in minutes. In the mid 80s my dad had to use a 4 track reel-to-reel with overdub and he had to be able to actually play all the instruments. Today I can grab blender/resolve/fusion and compete with almost any TV show on quality and broadcast my stuff for free on youtube. Vs in the 80s/90s when that would have taking a huge team of people and $$$$$$$$ in equipment plus access to either retail and VHS copies or access to broadcast gate keepers. Unreal/Unity have vastly increased productivity in games. Just go to any gamejam and look at how far people used to their tools can get in 2 days vs what they could make in the same amount of time in the mid-80s. Or look at the explosion of games on places like itch.io. Even typing documents. Typing in this textarea in HN is way easier than typing was on my Atari 800 in Atariwriter and the moment I press "add comment" it's published for all to see. Same with twitter/facebook/google docs/blogger/wordpress. Consider how much work and how many people it would have taking to do anything similar in the 80s. Write document, typeset document, get printer to print 1000s of copies, mail them to people, have mail people carry and deliver them.... Contacting people in general and being able to send them documents, photos, videos, is free and trival today. Would have taken 10s of people and days to weeks just 40 yrs ago. Maybe "jobs" in general have not but lots of things have gotten incredibly easy, raising what is possible to produce (in otherwords, be productive)
- jacobedawson 4y agoAnother poster compared 1890 to 1950 - jumping from one to the other would be obviously shocking, from 1960 - 2020 perhaps less-so, physically. Still, I find it amazing that in 2022, I: - Work from home via the internet with people I've never met - Visit places I've never been in simulated 3D to build familiarity - Receive exact routes to virtually anywhere from a computer in my pocket - Video call with my family in real-time literally from one side of the planet to another. - Have Copilot autocompleting repetitive lines of code for me with (ok, 60% - 70% of the time..) incredible prescience - Get real-time translation of foreign text from a printed page Those are just some of the the most common examples from my daily life. The productivity gains are real, at least for me personally.
- commandlinefan 4y agoI'm still inclined to mostly agree with OP who said that a visitor from 1880 to 1950 would be far more in awe than a visitor from 1950 to 2020, but it is funny sometimes how incredulous my kids are when I tell them that, for example, there was literally no way to open up a device that told you where you were when I was growing up.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoNot a device but maps were a thing. I recall riding a motorbike with a backpack half filled with a book of maps. Heavy to have in a backpack for hours on end. Also, before mobile phones at all, just meeting up with people required more time and you had to be specific. Now, get in the area and if you don't see them, message or call.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoManafacturing productivity is though the roof. PCBs are incredibly cheap now, and lead times are in days. Micros that can do almost anything, bristling with peripherals and programmable in C or even just running Linux, rather than hand assembly or discrete circuits. Dedicated devices that cost cents handle tasks that used to take organisations months and months to design. All sorts of materials make things that used to be impossible routine. Machine control of all sorts is mind-blowing in precision, reliability and speed. You can get things lasered, printed, sintered, cast, moulded, routed, milled, waterjetted, EDMed, whatever, at prices and turnarounds that would have been complete fantasy in the past.
- ryukoposting 4y agoI was thinking something similar (if narrower). In my universe (embedded systems), we have entire BLE stacks-in-a-box shipped to us by manufacturers now. That would have been inconceivable 20 years ago. Now more than ever, peripherals can be interconnected using a little bit-twiddling, automating a lot of the system logic that would have been handled explicitly in the past. To be fair, none of that matters if we aren't actually doing useful things with the fancy microcontrollers.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoWe are doing useful things with them. The price of manufactured goods has plummeted, driven largely by automation and control. Maybe we don't really see that because first world cost of living has largely risen to match, driven mostly by housing and energy costs and healthcare. But in the less developed world, people can afford a lot more manufactured goods than they could 30 years ago. Which is at least partly because in absolute terms, those goods cost very little. Sure, a TV 30 years ago was still "just" a rectangular screen, but if you lived in rural Slovenia, you still probably couldn't afford one. Now, it's probably still expensive to you to get a basic flat panel TV, but it's not as wildly unaffordable as it was - adjusting for inflation, TVs are 10x cheaper today then 1985. And this doesn't only go for electronics, loads of things cost less and are more available. The only things that might not be are things like raw materials and energy where supply, demand and other factors keep prices high over time. For example aluminium was $0.60/lb in the 80s, now it's $1.40. This is actually a slight drop in price after inflation ($0.60 then is $1.61) but certainly not as cheap as you'd expect if the only factors were production efficiency. Of course a lot of micros do end up in complete junk. Which is sad for a lot of reasons, not only the environmental costs but also the wasted human effort of designing the disposable Bluetooth-enabled dog toothbrush in the first place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- meow_mix 4y agoWhen I think about the productivity adds from tech from the last 20 years, I'm often left wondering why we aren't working less . Others have mentioned us navigating faster, having neat new gadgets, etc, but fundamentally what I and many others want is more free time
- andrekandre 4y ago> I'm often left wondering why we aren't working less isn't that in direct conflict with expectations of compounded annual growth? what does our economic (and political) models say about that? because less work == less growth to many people...
- b0rsuk 4y ago
- turzmo 4y agoCurious how productivity is measured. Tried skimming the associated government PDF from the article, but it is lost on me: "Nonfarm business sector labor productivity decreased 7.5 percent in the first quarter of 2022, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today, as output decreased 2.4 percent and hours worked increased 5.5 percent" How is this "output" measured, and what does it include? Has it kept up with the times? If I produce more Furbies for cheaper, does this productivity number go up? What if I create an ad-supported iPhone game as a solo developer that reaches millions of people? Does that factor into "output" somehow? Is the accounting different if I sell the game on the App Store, without ads instead? Did an educational company that recorded VHS tapes of science lectures for schools count into productivity before, but now that there is high-quality "free" (ad-supported) content on the internet, that no longer is a producing segment of our economy?
- akrymski 4y agoWhat a joke, I'm literally reading this while my robot vacuum is cleaning the house.
- amelius 4y agoBecause we now have the equivalent of a TV set on our office desks.
- smcleod 4y agoPersonally I've put it down to: - We _are_ actually far more productive, but capitalism means that the demands, rewards and expectations have scaled along side - e.g. mass inflation, house prices etc... meaning we haven't been able (allowed) to scale back out working hours. - We are increasingly living in a world of increase choice and consumption pressure - we have more options and pressure to obtain goods and services than ever before - this is often not a good thing. - Diminishing returns as we ratchet up optimisation over time, technology becomes more complex over time, not less.
- tonguez 4y agobecause there is no “us”; the people who run the world don’t want to lose their grip on power, so they use tech to make people stupider and thus less capable of challenging authority
- meristohm 4y agoWhat's the point of increasing productivity? Does higher productivity mean higher resource-conversion?
- supertrope 4y agoJust to keep up with population growth the economy needs to grow so there will be enough jobs, goods, and services per capita. If per capita wealth is to increase, not only do there need to be more workers but also more output per person. It's very hard for an economy to be steady state. You're either growing or dying. Productivity growth is efficiency. 3% of people work in agriculture when before 100% of people were subsidence farmers. The entire modern economy is possible due to productivity gains in food production.
- ww520 4y agoThere's a paper (forgot the title or author, sorry) that gives the conclusion that it takes exponentially more resource to advance technologies forward in a linear fashion. Technological advances are not moving forward exponentially but rather it takes exponentially more resource to just keep progressing in linear scale. This applies to different disciplines across the board, in CS, in physics, chemistry, medical research, etc. It might relate to the productivity debate. It might take exponentially more advances in technologies to improve productivity linearly.
- nanomonkey 4y agoSpeak for yourself. I feel like I have riches of new tech at my disposal. Currently have 10 gbs fiber internet for $45/month, in one second I can download the contents of my first hard drive. My laptop has 64gb of ram and 8tb of ssd. I don't even know what to do with that much compute as I mostly use Emacs and Firefox for everything. Meetings are completely online, so I no longer need to travel to visit other offices to exchange data. My phone is an embarrassment of riches, it covers most of my digital needs (music, hd video, note taking, internet, email, etc.) but is mostly ignored because it's really just a distraction. In the garage, a tig welder, cnc mill, vacuum casting table, burn out kiln and countless other tools. Due to the previously mentioned internet connection I can watch videos that teach me how to use all of this equipment. Most of the software to run the CNC mill, do CAD design or CAM is all open source and free. I can also purchase solar panels, heat pumps, lithium iron phosphate battery banks for ridiculously low costs compared to what I would have had to spend back in the 90s when I first wanted to get off the grid. All in all, it's all there for us to live the solar punk lifestyle we've all wanted...just takes doing it.
- bovermyer 4y agoBut humans are still limited. Until we accelerate our evolution, we'll be stuck at the speed of glaciers in terms of our potential.
- machinerychorus 4y agoMemetics is much more potent than genetics. We're about to achieve much more than people could 2000 years ago, not because humans have genetically evolved to be that much smarter, but because we have memetically evolved much more sophisticated social structures. Genetics is still important, and augmenting individual intelligence should still be pursued, but memetics is in the driver seat now.
- watercooler_guy 4y agoCould you expand on what you mean by this? What kind of new social structures are enabling progress in this way?
- cratermoon 4y agoProductivity has climbed steadily for decades. Wages, not so much. https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/
- AussieWog93 4y agoI've always wondered how much of this has to do with sweeping social changes that put people last. Your average worker 50 years ago came home to a clean house, a homecooked meal on the table and an expectation of stability (both at work and at home). To "win" at life, all the engineer would need to do was engineer things to the highest standard. Now, the average worker is competing with their spouse, competing with their colleagues, optimising a path between 15 different companies because that's the only path to rise the ranks, all with the constant threat that the rug could be pulled out from underneath them at any time with minimal warning. Point is, the game we're playing now is different.
- space_fountain 4y agoI don't mean this as a call out, but just want to highlight that this was never the experience of the average worker. It might have once been the experience of the average white male worker, but really you'd need an econ degree to say with something like certainty and it certainly wasn't the experience for minorities in this country
- mr_tristan 4y agoI suspect the hyperactive hivemind culture that's been one result of new technology. Sure, there's a lot more passive consumption going on, but really, what I see is a non-stop communication stream where nobody really gets to that moment to really let the mind rest and get properly bored to put together the bigger ideas. When I try to isolate, even for a couple of hours, I get criticized by coworkers or my spouse about not responding quickly. So I end up spending my time mostly communicating or trying to get back on track. It's rather sad. Ideally AI could offload these constant distractions, so unnecessary communications just don't need everyone's immediate response. But, well, I'll believe it when I see it
- bitwize 4y agoWhen we come up with the potential to do more with less, we invent shit to fill the gaps. I remember discovering a video of an executive from Symbolics stating that the company's goal was to make software development of all but the largest projects feasible by a single person, with the rest done by small teams. And then I looked at my own Agile-encrusted, Scrum-addled, Node-encumbered team, which could barely get a simple web app deployed in half a year, and I was like uhhhhhhh...
- syntheweave 4y agoTechnology is popularly misunderstood as "gadgets and lab science". But the root of the word is shared with technique. That is, if I have a technique for applying leverage, and I use it to make a lever, that's a simple technology. If I define a new system of organizing my home according to some principles, that's a technology. And so on. It is certainly the case that we have found new techniques and technologies in recent decades. But in defining a "tech sector" and relating it to measurements of GDP growth we have tokenized a particular mode of it, one which some parts of society propose is increasingly irrelevant to the quality of our existence. It's often pointed out that wars are "good for the economy" in that more stuff is manufactured, overlooking the destructive aspects of war. And so the definition of productivity is also worth questioning, because it's tied to a model of society based around the firm and its capacity to produce quantities of assets and trade them for money. This model has been in place for a few hundred years now(see early merchantalist writing) and is in need of reassessment. Much of what the economy has done since the beginning of industrialization is simply in the realm of creating more monetizable spaces and optimizing towards the "frictionless" everything-for-sale optimum. It worked for a while, but at this point, we're basically hindered by the frameworks used to define value and enforce sale. There are huge realms of technical innovations that don't get explored because we don't have a place for them. Instead we have to aim to "fit in" with the legacy system.
- wolverine876 4y ago> Technology is popularly misunderstood as "gadgets and lab science". But the root of the word is shared with technique. Yes, and as you say, one is as good as another (given the same ROI). I remind myself of that by using the word 'tech' and, inwardly at least, repeating 'tools and technique'.
- rramadass 4y agoWell said! Are your ideas from Jacques Ellul's The Technological Society? - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Ellul#On_technique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Ellul#On_technique Would appreciate some sources.
- jwmhjwmh 4y agoThe article is paywalled, so I'm just going by the title, but one thing holding back labor productivity is low wages. When wages are low, labor-saving technology is less likely to be cost-effective. It's funny when Hacker News' innovation-loving capitalists oppose minimum wages, since by doing so they are holding innovation back.
- dredmorbius 4y agoFor one strong argument, see the current thread on Symbian source code, and practices at Nokia and within the mobile phone industry: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31491744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31491744 Turf-wars, naked competition, monopolistic practices, and secrecy all have much to answer for.
- seanhunter 4y agoNew technology is very obviously making us more productive in several different ways - the metric in the article is just wrong. I'm going to pick on something that people in the thread haven't mentioned that much: Logistics and online infrastructure. I get every kind of thing possible delivered right to my door and this is made possible by improvements in logistics. Not having to spend my time going out shopping for these things gives me time which I can spend productively or on recreation at my option. 1) Medicine: When in the 80s or 90s if I needed medicine I would need to wait for a doctor's appointment, get a prescription, wait at the pharmacy to collect, now my doctor knows when I need a repeat, sends it electronically to my pharmacy and it's ready when I arrive (or I could have it delivered). 2) Groceries and household goods: Everyone from Amazon down to my local deli and bakery has a website where I can request goods, pay online and have them delivered within days or sometimes even same day. This wasn't possible in the 80s at the scale we have today. You had to shop in person or some companies used to have paper catalogues where you had to send in a form to order, wait days or weeks for goods to arrive. Not only that but repeat/subscription orders were extremely limited. Now I have repeat orders for everything from my dog's food to my razor blades. THings which were subscription services in the 80s are still available but have a much wider selection. 3) Services: Lots of "in person" services can now be delivered by video. My wife and lots of friends are professional musicians. In spite of the pandemic they were able to continue teaching over zoom. Their productivity would literally have been zero during the lockdowns as they would not have been able to work at all were it not for new technology. Likewise things like video consultations allow people access to doctors etc without the time that would otherwise be wasted on travel etc to get to the appointment.
- throwaway892238 4y agoI literally don't even want to use a computer at all. I want a cheap powerful rototiller, and an herbicide that only targets bamboo, and a robot laser to zap snails and cabbage moths in my garden. But here I am like a schmuck putting out little bottle tops of beer for the snails to drown in, running around like a doofus with a butterfly net to catch moths, and breaking my back to dig up 2-foot-deep bamboo roots over 2 acres. Fuck modern technology. I don't want to sit in front of a screen. I want to live life in the real world. Give me solutions to my problems, not distractions from them.
- _trampeltier 4y agoBecause now for ex. everithing needs at least one or two klicks more. You wanna save a file in office. Now they try to force you to use Onedrive. If you wanna save it local, extra mouseclick. Windows menu, the animations are so slow .. I often clicked already a second time and the menu close right again, after it showed slowly up. Don't even start with Browser based apps ..
- zigzag312 4y agoBecause as tech stack increases, complexity also increases. Just move it to the cloud :P
- alaricus 4y agoTechnology is making us more productive. If your metric tells you it isn't so, then your metric is wrong.
- itsgrimetime 4y agoIt is, we're just not being paid for it. https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/
- blitzar 4y ago> Productivity, which is defined as the value of goods and services produced per hour of work The technology is a quality of life improvement, not a $job improvement.
- nathias 4y agoIt has, but not many have taken advantage of it. It is an incomprehensible leap in self-education that has happened for my generation. People used to read by reserving books in libraries and waiting for them to arrive, taking weeks or months now you can download them immediately, able to search them and find the relevant pieces. Similarly learning of all possible skills, programing cheif among them has never been as easy. These are real productivity boons, but the article seems to be asking something completely different, more like why haven't BigTech giant profits trickled down and the answer doesn't have much to do with productivity.
- lnxg33k1 4y agoBecause I think brain is the bottleneck, like I am feeling that there is people that is working today 12 hours a day, That has optimised notes, tools and workflow, but how much more work do you want to squeeze from humans, and then for what, so that they can be laid off when they’re not needed anymore? :0
- mypastself 4y agoPer the article, productivity has been growing at 1% a year for the past decade, compared to 3% in the decades prior. So the headline is misleading, technology is making us more productive, just not at the same rate as in the years before. The author claims this is worrisome, but his reasoning seems flawed to me: > a less productive economy is a smaller one with fewer resources to deal with social challenges like inequality But again, we are not getting “less productive”, it’s the increase in productivity that’s getting slower. The author then presumably wants to make us as productive as possible as soon as possible to solve this particular issue. His preferred candidate for this seems to be AI. The remainder of the article essentially an ad for advances in that specific technology.
- usrbinbash 4y agoWhat "new technology" are we talking about exactly? Because new technology as in better robots, better medical/agricultural/transportation technology, better network tech, better electronics, more efficient power generation technology, faster chips, improved algorithms for things like logistics etc. etc. HAVE made us much more productive. The problem is, as with almost all developments that actually matter for our progress as a species, these things kinda fly under the radar. They just work in the background, keeping the ship afloat. They usually don't get big shiny sparkly stage presentations. They are, simultaneously, the most important things happening to our technological and scientific progress, and the most ignored.
- aj7 4y agoIn evaluating stocks, I always view a well-written analysis that is signed by a person who has obviously put some honest work into it, and I know, from my own research TO BE OBVIOUSLY WRONG, as an extremely bullish indicator for that stock. Put more simply, if a smart person gives one or more COMPLETELY WRONG reasons for avoiding a stock, buy it. Treat this article in a similar vein. Moreover, I remember articles in the 80s, with an almost identical analysis about how Windows PC’s, which were by then ubiquitous, also lead to zero productivity growth. What happens is that the new technology is extremely productive to a group of experts, who aren’t particularly interested in disseminating their proprietary advantages. Eventually, “regular programmers” are tasked with writing similar applications, the good ones of which spread like wildfire.
- animal531 4y agohttps://archive.ph/7BmzY https://archive.ph/7BmzY
- fennecfoxy 4y agoAs always I think this problem is down to some people being producers and some people being consumers. We all produce and consume, but individuals do so in differing ratios. I think it's especially something that happens as we age, too. I've noticed I've become more of a consumer as I get older, I work on fewer personal projects and spend less time thinking of things to build compared to consuming the work of others.
- sunstone 4y agoOn the other hand productivity in the developing world has been spiking markedly.
- zcw100 4y agoWe have created something like building 1M pyramids of Giza on a piece of silicon the size of your thumbnail and people don't think it counts as progress because you can't see it.
- kcexn 4y agoFrom what I see, a lot more productivity can still be extracted from existing technology if only people would try to use it more. Configuring software is regularly more complicated than it needs to be. And software developers are tied in to using the 'language of software' (visual and written language to describe widgets, disk space, bandwidth, latency, whatever) in their applications, leading to many users being unable to understand the capabilities of the tools they use. Education of the next generation of kids to better understand software will tremendously help this. But so will, I think, design that pays more attention to sensible defaults when releasing software to market to solve specific problems, rather than leave it to users to configure things to their needs.