26 ms·
The tech sector teardown is more catharsis than crisis
- carride 5y agoHere is the republish without the paywall https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2022/05/the-tech-sector-teardown-is-more-catharsis-than-crisis/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2022/05/the-t...
- austinicholas 5y agoThanks!
- forgotmypw17 5y agohttps://archive.ph/TeJGf https://archive.ph/TeJGf
- JCM9 5y agoThere’s a whole generation of tech employees that have never seen a down market. All indications are that these folks are woefully unaware of what’s on the horizon now. It’s going to be all about cash flow. If you’re burning cash and not making much of it from operations then it’s going to be a bumpy road ahead. Buckle up.
- stackbutterflow 5y agoI've heard the argument that the dotcom crash was so catastrophic because the Internet as a market wasn't proven at that point. That'd mean a dotcom like crisis is the lowest point this industry can reach. Which in some way is reassuring.
- JCM9 5y agoThat was a factor, but more fundamentally it was companies with wild valuations and no realistic prospects of becoming a profitable and self-sustaining business. There is some of that out there right now. Market corrections exist in part to flush those companies out of the system.
- tluyben2 5y agoSome of that? There are a lot of companies that raised 20m+ without any hope of ever paying that back and actually heavily depending on new rounds of funding to survive at all. This was all wrapped up as ‘pump everything in growth’ which works as long as it works and that was no different in 1999 when companies were also just buying users (one of my clients at the time gave away free groceries the first month of your membership; guess what the retention was after that month) with investor money. When that dried up, all users left in a a few months and the companies were gone. This will happen again. Everyone I know (business and personal) uses a lot of freemium services from startups they will never pay for; they will simply leave the second they have to pay or when ads appear. And that has to happen for these companies to have a chance at all.
- RandomLensman 5y agoNot sure that follows. If (big "if") interest rates go up a lot, then a lot of investors might not reach for VC or PE to enhance their returns at even close to current allocation (and growth would be heavily discounted). Look at how the telecoms industry looks now compared to the heights of 2003 or so.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThis. What happened in 2000 was that interest rates got up and money became scarcer, so there was nobody willing to put any money into more risky investments like VCs. Today we are in a completely different realm of money availability, but it is becoming scarcer again.
- DebtDeflation 5y ago>If (big "if") interest rates go up a lot It's not a "big if" at all. Zero nominal rates and negative real rates are an anomaly in economic history over the last few centuries. Rates are headed higher, much higher. The Fed has been holding off in the hope that inflation would be "transitory" but it's now been a year and a half of >7% CPI increases with no sign of abating.
- RandomLensman 5y agoAgreed on the long history. I'd still argue there is sizable "if" as one way to reduce government debt would be to use inflation (just like in the 1950s). So while rates will go up, the question is how much they will go up and if the level they reach will be high enough to cause substantial portfolio reallocations.
- weatherlite 5y agoAgreed. It's not only government debt - everyone is indebted (people, businesses) at a historical high. How much can you raise interest rate without crushing them I don't know. On the other hand how much can you let inflation go up without crushing the working class and emerging markets indebted in USD? It's an impossible situation.
- version_five 5y agoIn the dotcom boom in Canada there was a sub-boom in fiber optics and related stuff in the Ottawa area. Nortel et al were hiring and paying big salaries right out of school, and people got used to it and thought that was how much money they could earn. For years afterward there were people who had mentally anchored themselves at a certain salary bracket that couldn't find anything (especially in Ottawa) that paid anywhere close. I always assumed this will happen any time with machine learning, I don't think it will be as bad for software overall though.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> and thought that was how much money they could earn But they were right.
- DebtDeflation 5y ago>There’s a whole generation of tech employees that have never seen a down market. Indeed. I lived through both the 2008 financial crisis and the 2000 dot com implosion (also graduated high school and went off to college right during the 1991 recession). People who entered the job market after 2015 and know nothing except recruiters constantly hitting them up with mid six figure+ job offers are in for a rude awakening IMO.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoWhat advice would you give to people who've not been in the tech industry during a recession yet?
- nemo44x 5y agoSave money and have enough to live on for awhile. If you don't have savings then immediately cut your cost of living down. If you do lose your job then don't just accept anything (remember, you have savings + unemployment + severance to live on for awhile) and use this time to sharpen skills and learn new things. Make yourself more valuable. I can't see the future but I don't think it's going to be a bloodbath like the .com crash. Engineers in particular are valuable assets for a company and expensive to recruit. Expect companies to cut back on perks and possibly raises for awhile if it gets bad. But I don't think we're going to see massive layoffs across the board. There's still a ton of money in the VC world. They just aren't spending right now.
- csmpltn 5y ago> "I can't see the future but I don't think it's going to be a bloodbath like the .com crash." The world has gone ever more dependent on tech since then. Tech is used everywhere now, pervasively. They're not re-introducing cash in cash-free economies. People aren't going back to carrying physical documents around and stashing them in high cabinets. Shopping online has only gotten more popular. Hanging out online, too. Agriculture, warfare, industry, you name it... it's not all "Uber, but for %s" out there. Somebody has to keep the lights on, right?
- plaidfuji 5y agoMy biggest question behind all of this is how interconnected is the tech bubble, and how self-perpetuating will a downturn be? The venture-backed startups that I’ve worked at have themselves utilized tools built by other venture-backed startups. It seems like there’s an entire cottage industry of SaaS tools designed to make it easier to scale up small companies. What will the effect of a startup downturn be on companies like Carta (high revenue but no profit from what I could find, and whose revenue likely comes from other companies with no profit…) How many Cartas are out there, whose customers are primarily unprofitable startups?
- LewisVerstappen 5y agoYeah, the same applies doubly-so for crypto markets (the other area where VCs have been going crazy). A drop in the price of BTC and ETH has massive ripples in the rest of the crypto ecosystem.
- kbos87 5y agoThe idea that there’s money to be made not in industry X, but supporting industry X has been taken to the extreme in spaces like crypto where that’s pretty much all the space consists of. I can’t think of more than a few examples of successful, scaling companies that are actually using blockchain as a means to an end that doesn’t come back to “building the infrastructure for the use of blockchain” in some way.
- Apocryphon 5y agoWe’re experiencing a glut of shovels.
- munificent 5y agoIt's like selling shovels to miners who are mining iron that is only used for manufacturing more shovels.
- lumost 5y agoThere are many B2B SaaS which have been negative gross on the theory that they are LTV positive. If their customers start cutting expenses, we may see the LTV theory break.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoThe only reason there is a recession is because people believe there is a recession
- kqr 5y agoThis goes for any social construct, and is just about meaningless to say. The only reason you have a family is because you believe you have a family. The only reason you have a manager is because you believe you have a manager. The only reason you're in a soccer team is because you believe you're in a soccer team. The only reason you have a grocery store is because you believe you have a grocery store. And so on.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agowtf you are totally 100% missing my point, the current recession is a self-fulfilling prophety that is auto-amplified in mediatic echo chambers and by sell feedback mechanism on stock values.
- idealmedtech 5y agoI think it's clear from the pandemic that stock values do not correlate with the economy.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agooff-topic: Since you made idealmedtech, you should be interested in publicising the effect of ALCAR on glycemia/insulin. Since it nudge the mitochondria to increase the ratio of lipids/fatty acid consumption and reduce the consumption of glucose, it is very positive for the protection of both kinds of diabetes, in a side effect free manner. The number of lives/quality of life that could be saved if this information was more widespread is astonishing, especially since your website help to measure the impact.
- idealmedtech 5y ago
- tjpnz 5y agoThere's been a lot of posturing here over the years about how <insert famous tech company> doesn't do layoffs, but we're starting to see that not even they are immune anymore. I hope everyone has some savings put aside if things really do turn to shit.
- chrisseaton 5y agoA hiring freeze isn’t pausing to stand still - as people continue to leave normally. So Meta’s ‘hiring pause’ is really shrinking the company rapidly.
- kasey_junk 5y agoHiring pause/freeze are not strictly defined terms. Some firms mean true freezes with no further hiring, others allow back fill for any position and still others allow backfill for nominated positions. I don’t know what Metas rules are but generally speaking strict hiring freezes are the rarest form.
- chrisseaton 5y agoMeta’s is so hard they’re revoking promised offers I’m hearing.
- dado3212 5y agoI don’t think that’s true, that’s based on one LinkedIn post that had some extenuating visa issues. Also hiring is still open for E5+ ML and E6+ generally.
- tjpnz 5y agoWasn't singling out Meta specifically, but based on how relentless they had been with their recruiter spam there must be a lot of disappointed folk out there.
- notacoward 5y agoI predict that some of these companies will try to avoid the taint of layoffs by doing them in sneaky ways. One classic method is using "performance" reviews to reduce/deny bonuses and equity awards, or in some cases simply terminate people whose objective performance is fine. Another is to cancel projects or reorganize, offering the "opportunity" for an internal transfer except that many will be surprisingly unable to find a "fit" before time runs out. Zealous (but selective) enforcement of previously ignored policies is a third. If you currently have a "handshake deal" for a 10-on/4-off schedule, or "business" travel that's really about getting to see your girlfriend more often, or an exemption to some IT policy, watch out. Driving "natural" attrition isn't hard, as companies like IBM and DEC realized long ago. Anyone working at a FAANG or similar company should get used to watching their steps very carefully, and consciously aligning with the "in" crowd even more than was already the case.
- bearjaws 5y agoI think this is just the correction that was inevitable as hiring had become a cargo cult. Everyone was hiring so everyone felt compelled to hire, creating a feedback loop of insane wages and offers. Now its time to pay the bills and many organizations realize the engineers they hired cannot possibly provide the value necessary to keep their job. I know one individual who got hired as a Sales Engineer for a platform and they have almost no work lined up for him... for 4 months now... He just sits making north of 200k for monitoring slack and answering community questions. You can tell which companies actually had a cost benefit analysis for their hires and they continue to hire for the roles they need, where as others over extended and have to layoff.
- gitfan86 5y agoI has a phone screen at Coinbase and they just threw out 380k as the salary without me saying anything as far as expectations. This reminds me of the dot com bubble. In 2000 people who had no software background and were making 50k would get offers for 80k, just for showing up at an interview and saying they know Java or HTML
- jonwachob91 5y agoDid they offer you the job or did they just state the expected compensation? b/c those are two different things. They could have told you the position paid $380k, and then assessed you were not qualified for the position and not extended an employment offer. And when I say you, I don't actually mean you. I mean anyone they held interviews with and stated the expected compensation.
- koblas 5y agoActually just had a discussion about this and putting the dollars out in front in the hiring process is something that more canidates are looking for in this competitive market. I'm sure it was said something like "this title (grade) pays 380k, is that's what you're hired at". Since levels.fyi has this all documented it still comes down to the interview and your ability to pass the interview and meet expectations for the level. What they're trying to do is get you to continue with the process and potentially slow down any other interviews by putting the total compensation out there at the start.
- nemo44x 5y agoThere’s nothing being funded right now. If you didn’t raise before earlier this year (and really late last year) and your runway is < 2 years then you’re in a very precarious position. If you’re hunting for a job, it has gotten very tight over the last month. Lots of pausing on hiring plans as companies adapt. Reminds me more of 2016 than 2k though.
- kasey_junk 5y agoI switched jobs this month and found it to be the hottest job market I’d ever encountered. That can change quickly but it hasn’t (hadn’t) happened as of a few weeks ago.
- anthropodie 5y agoI think we will need another 3-6 month to see full effect of whatever happened in last month everywhere.
- nemo44x 5y agoI think a month ago was a totally different time than today. I know of a few companies that froze most hiring (including in cases where an offer was about to go out) temporarily with the last couple weeks. Of course I haven’t sampled every company. Just a very sudden defensive position springing up more and more.
- ctvo 5y agoMeta very publicly announced a hiring slowdown, Netflix is introducing levels and slowing down hiring, Coinbase is slowing down hiring, etc.. Even with the above names slowing down hiring, I would guess big tech uses this opportunity to stockpile even more engineers to come out of this stronger. I don't see the competition for engineers that can pass those interviews slowing down. Startups? Yes, the cohort that raised 20+ million Series As in the last two years and spent lavishly at the height of this bull run will start being much more defensive.
- 5y ago
- gadders 5y agoSomeone needs to dig out the VC letters from 2007-8 and just change the date and re-publish them.
- htormey 5y agoThe macro economic setup doesn’t look good for small tech or growth stocks in general. Big tech I’m less worried about. We have central banks rising interest rates to fight inflation, caused by wars and massive monetary and fiscal stimulus to fight Covid. these hikes impact valuation multiples used to value tech and unprofitable startups. We have a supply chain shock caused by war in the Ukraine, the aftermath of Covid and Chinas second lock down which could lead to stagflation. The only silver lining I see is that big tech prints money, is in many areas essential for cost reduction and has excellent balance sheets. In summary Im more worried about the general economy tear down than the tech tear down, especially in the later half of this year and 2023.
- crate_barre 5y agoSomeone needs to explain to me why our tech companies are so tied to interest rates. Are VCs borrowing with home mortgage equity??
- wutbrodo 5y agoWhen interest rates are low, there's a lot more money sloshing around in search of better return, instead of just comfortably getting a high, low-risk return. When more money sloshes around, higher-risk investments like VCs get more money.
- kooshball 5y agohere are the basics https://www.investopedia.com/investing/how-interest-rates-affect-stock-market/ https://www.investopedia.com/investing/how-interest-rates-af... I think the dynamic for private (VC) money and public markets are different VC money will dry up as endowments look to shift more money into safer asset class when interest rate is high public markets company valuation models change with interest rates changing. when rate is close to 0 investors are willing to buy asset with a very long term view for expected future profit (say 10 years). when rates go up that time frame shortens since opportunity cost of buying that stock today is now much higher.
- tyrfing 5y agoMost of these tech companies build business models around giving away money, with a plan of eventually making a profit. They are affected by interest rates because the higher interest rates you have today, the more attractive it is to have money today instead of tomorrow. Interest rates available today are the discount rate for those future cash flows (profit).
- gsibble 5y agoThis. Historically, a company is fundamentally valued by the discounted rate of its free cash flows into the future. The discount rate is decided by several factors including the risk free rate.....which is frequently tied to interest rates. So interest rates go up, the risk free rate goes up, cash flows become worth less, and corporate valuations go down.
- kriro 5y agoI think the market is just normalizing. The overall climate was pretty insane. Free money (interest rates), stimulus money etc. I found it pretty fascinating that during a time that was pretty tough overall (global pandemic + supply chain issues) the stock market was basically saying we are in a golden age. That felt "wrong" to me but if I had acted on it, I'd be broke now because the market certainly outperformed my wildest expectations. As a value investor at heart, I still cannot rationally fathom some valuations (Tesla >100 PE). However, most tech companies seem pretty solid fundamentally and not close to .com bubble times. I cannot speak for crypto since I live in a bubble were I ignore it completely.
- nemo44x 5y agoIt's really about interest rates. The idea was that there's no way the Fed will be raising rates anytime soon so everything went on sale. Yes, an over extension is a lot of things is probably fair. Snowflake is not a 100B company today, for example.
- warent 5y agoPeople are calling this a correction... I don't understand the first thing about economics. Over the last quarter, the Nasdaq is down 25%. That's a correction? Seems pretty serious
- francisofascii 5y agoAnd the Nasdaq is still up 116% over the last five years. So some would argue, that yes, it was and maybe still is overvalued.
- ticviking 5y agoUltimately probably. There's a lot of "value" that isn't linked to any work someone is actually doing. Eventually the price of companies depending on that illusion has to come down to reflect the reality.
- lumost 5y agoPeople have called Tech bubbles since 2012, There have been at least 2-3 similar sell-offs over the last decade that simply lead to higher tech valuations within a year or two. Hence the term "correction" is used, this also helps assuage nervous retail investors that another '01 or '08 crash isn't around the corner. The difference between then and now is that interest rates are blasting through the roof along with inflation. The underlying question that CEO's need to think through is whether this is a long-term shift in the funding environment, or a short-term blip. If the latter, actually taking the foot off the gas instead of saying that you will could lead to missed growth relative to competitors. Now, in the event that its a long-term shift - there will certainly be firms who run into the wall from not taking their foot off the gas.
- __alexs 5y ago> The difference between then and now is that interest rates are blasting through the roof along with inflation. The effective federal interest rate is 0.33% today. It was 2.4% before COVID...
- 5y ago
- greenglass 5y ago
- qiskit 5y agoWhat teardown? Why do newspapers all parrot each other and spout the same fearmongering nonsense? Stock corrections happen. Life will go on.
- Animats 5y ago"Following a series of “super clarifying” meetings with shareholders, Uber’s chief executive Dara Khosrowshahi emailed(opens a new window) employees on Sunday night with an arresting message: “we need to show them the money”." So the stockholders finally got fed up with Uber's "lose money on every ride and make it up on volume" approach. No surprise. Uber's stock is at an all-time low since the public offering. This isn't really about the "tech sector", though. It's about Uber. Uber is an over-funded cab company. It's not a tech company. It's a labor-intensive service company with a huge number of low-skill workers.
- _tom_ 5y agoIf they get the self driving cars working, they become a tech company. Of course, then they won't be able to shift expenses to drivers.
- Animats 5y agoIf they get the self driving cars working, they become a tech company. Uber sold off their self-driving operation years ago.[1] They still issue press releases once in a while, and do some stuff with self-driving startups, but it's not serious. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/12/07/cars/uber-sells-self-driving/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/12/07/cars/uber-sells-self-driving/...
- EricE 5y agoUber is the epitome of modern day sharecropping - shift all the risk and expense - many of which are hidden because they are long term or rolling expenses (insurance, maintenance/car replacement/physical security, etc) - to drivers. Waive the allure of immediate cash at people and damn the longer term consequences.
- twirlock 5y ago[dead]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]