25 ms·
History's deadliest air raid happened in Tokyo during World War II (2020)
- Torkel 5y agoHardcore History podcast, ”Supernova of the East”. Chances are most HN readers who upvote this story has already listened to this, but if there’s someone who missed it… go listen :)
- ramesh31 5y agoLiterally checking every morning for episode 7 at this point.... come on Dan.
- joshgachnang 5y agoI'm pretty sure he said episode 6 was the finale.
- ramesh31 5y agoWell that just ruined my day.
- PostOnce 5y agohe's going to do an ancient world one next since we've been on ww2 so long, he said. There are new episodes of HH addendum very often though
- joshgachnang 5y agoI'm sorry! Though it did feel very wrapped up with the end corresponding with the end of the war. Personally I hope he does the Korean or Vietnam war eventually. I had very little insight into WWI until listening to his podcasts, and I think those could lend themselves to very interesting episodes.
- TheHypnotist 5y agoPretty sure the series ends at 6.
- Rels 5y agoI thought that the series was done? And I'm adding my recommandation to Hardcore History, it's a great podcast.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoSeconding this recommendation. I’ve read a lot about World War 2, but this podcast was such a fresh, impactful presentation. Amazingly well done. And useful context for articles like this one.
- huevosabio 5y agoAnd specifically on the atomic bombing: Logical Insanity, https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-42-blitz-logical-insanity/ https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-42-blitz-...
- cushychicken 5y agoMalcolm Gladwell's 2020 season of Revisionist History mostly focused on Curtis LeMay, the development of napalm, and the firebombing of Tokyo. https://www.pushkin.fm/episode/the-bomber-mafia/ https://www.pushkin.fm/episode/the-bomber-mafia/ Fascinating and horrifying.
- BasilPH 5y agoI came here to post this, glad you already did. It's honestly one of the best things I've ever listened to. I find it amazing how he can paint such a nuanced picture of such a complex and horrific topic which lends itself so easily to taking a black-and-white view.
- cushychicken 5y agoLeMay knew exactly how horrid of a thing he'd spearheaded, too. "If we hadn't won, I'd have been executed as a war criminal."
- tpowell 5y agoThey turned this podcast into an excellent book, and the audiobook gets all of the same treatments as the podcast: https://books.apple.com/us/audiobook/the-bomber-mafia-a-dream-a-temptation/id1560431588 https://books.apple.com/us/audiobook/the-bomber-mafia-a-drea...
- Wheaties466 5y agoThanks for the Rec!
- onychomys 5y agoIt's totally bonkers that the Japanese leadership didn't surrender after this raid. Or at least after the next ones that showed that the US could do it basically at will anywhere in Japan. I just will never understand how they could sit around and watch their citizens burn and continue to fight. Think of how many Japanese lives they could have saved if they'd surrendered in June instead of August.
- chrisseaton 5y agoDid they think at the time that their people would suffer more under occupation than they would trying to continue to fight? (Actual question, not rhetorical.)
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- dairylee 5y agoThe Japanese Government didn't want an unconditional surrender as it would have meant the Emperor (Who was seen as quasi-divine) would have potentially been tried for war crimes and executed. They didn't care about their citizens, just the Emperor. Fantastic video which explains everything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCRTgtpC-Go https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCRTgtpC-Go
- s1artibartfast 5y agoHappiness utilitarianism is so pervasive today that people forget alternatives even exist, but there are a wide array of value systems. For at least some, the suffering was irrelevant. Many held that it would be better for every Japanese person to die than loose the war.
- CPLX 5y agoIf the Japanese had done it to New York City would you have surrendered?
- 5y ago
- q_andrew 5y agoMalcom Gladwell did a great segment on his podcast Revisionist History about this. He talks about the schools of thought in the US military about who and what to bomb that lead to these campaigns. It is extremely tragic that these citizen-heavy areas were absolutely pulverized. There's evidence that the US military used similar techniques in the Korean war.
- trasz 5y agoIt's extremely tragic that American war criminals never got punished.
- q_andrew 5y agoYes. There's even some evidence that chemical warfare via bombing was done in Korea, something they really should have known was a terrible thing to do.
- dundarious 5y agoI'm quite excited for the Blowback podcast season 3, coming out this summer. The new subject is the Korean war. Season 1 and 2, on the Iraq wars and the Cuban missile crisis respectively, are my favorite podcasts.
- throwaway984393 5y agoVictors never do. But they do write history books.
- refurb 5y ago
- Ancapistani 5y agoThe most egregious war criminals among the Japanese - who obviously lost the war - weren’t even punished. Shiro Ishii, the leader of Unit 731, among them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shirō_Ishii https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shirō_Ishii
- pinephoneguy 5y ago
- bannedbybros 5y ago[dead]
- petermcneeley 5y agoApparently there was actually a 1000 plane raid AFTER japan had surrendered. https://youtu.be/SDSemU3gjSQ?t=260 https://youtu.be/SDSemU3gjSQ?t=260
- onychomys 5y agoWiki says that raid was the day before they surrendered. See the final paragraph in this section: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_Japan#Atomic_bombings_and_final_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_Japan#Atomic_bomb...
- drocer88 5y agoChomsky is likely confused about Washington time and Tokyo time.
- codechad 5y agoMy grandfather flew a B-29 in the March 10 raid. His war journal noted that even with his mask on (oxygen/air-filtration), he could still smell the burning flesh from the destruction that had been unleashed from bombers sequenced ahead of his group. Operation Meetinghouse[1] is/was the single most destructive bombing raid in human history. I really hope that record is never broken. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo_(10_March_1945) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo_(10_March_194...
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt drives me nuts that the same story about Hiroshima and Nagasaki gets dragged out every year without any contextualization of just how bad WWII was.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoWhy? That atrocities were common during the war doesn't make nuking civilian targets acceptable.
- PaulHoule 5y ago(1) Because it's part of a general hatchet job against nuclear energy (2) It erases history. Really crazy stuff went down during the Korean war and people don't know about it. If the Japanese had spent 1% of the effort making amends for their crimes against China and other Asian countries that's gone into hand wringing over Hiroshima things would be very different in Asia today. It's nearly forgotten that the U.S. was slow to demobilize after WWII because it thought war against the Soviet Union was likely, and it was just as much a goal to intimidate the Soviets as it was to intimidate the Japanese.
- nradov 5y agoThose weren't civilian targets. Both cities contained military facilities and factories.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoYes, I'm aware of the doublespeak used to justify bombing major civilian population centers. I still would object to being bombed merely for living in a city, so object to bombing others for the same reason.
- panick21_ 5y agoPlease tell me how the US should have reacted to how they would have won the war while considering your moral principles. Please explain this when you make comments like that. And please also explain how many additional US soldiers (not to mention soldiers and civilians in China and other Asian nations) would you think acceptable to fight the war according to your moral principles. If for example the Nazi put a single German child into the guard house of the synthetic fuel production facility, would you not destroy it? Its easy to be critical, but please actually explain what your moral principles would have been and how you would have applied them. And can you make a credible case that these principles would have lead to less overall suffering. I am gently curious what your logic is and what alternative strategy you would advocate.
- dandare 5y agoI use this example when discussing the context of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki atomic bombing. While any bombing is tragic, the atomic bombs are not worse than other. This single air raid killed more people than Little Boy or Fat Man, and while hundreds of thousands of people died in the March-June strategic bombing of all major Japanese cities (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_Japan#Firebombing_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_raids_on_Japan#Firebombing..., the military dictators of Japan did not plan to surrender. I am not the only one who believes that in the long term the atomic bombs saved millions of Japanese lives.
- wozer 5y ago> While any bombing is tragic, the atomic bombs are not worse than other. Maybe I misunderstood, but I think atomic bombs are much worse because using atomic bombs you can destroy a whole country in a matter of minutes.
- InTheArena 5y agoThe Bomb was unique in that it was purely psychological in nature. It was a weapon that removed any chance that the Japanese leaders could sacrifice their own people to buy their escape from the war. This was literally the policy of the Japanese government - "The Glorious Death of One Hundred Million". Sacrifice every Japanese life to preserve the Emperor, and more importantly, his militaristic governments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall There is a awful lot of moral relativism in these threads. Frankly, I strongly recommend that people who think that there was some sort of equivilent between the Nazis and the western powers, or between the Japanese and the Americans in World War 2 put down youtube videos, and really do a deep dive into what these states were really about.
- mmustapic 5y agoAnd the US was fine going along. "We'll keep killing civilians till you surrender".
- 5y ago
- redleggedfrog 5y agoIt's a good lesson from history that if you as a nation or its leader decide to start a war take a good look at your people because you may be condemning them to death. Don't expect mercy from your newly made enemy.
- jleyank 5y agoThe number of people estimated to be killed in the two invasions of Japan > the number of people killed in the atomic bombings. Worst-case predictions were O(million casualties). As was point out, the firebombing of Tokyo did more damage and killed more people but was less "efficient". The Navy's option was to mine the harbours and blow up the trains and let them all starve. Not the quickest but possibly the harshest. The problem was war weariness and a desire to play with the toy and to show it off to others. I don't have a good feeling as to the actual levels of these three positions because I don't favour political history but they were real concerns. They had already used bomb them back into the stone age to little effect. Yeah, maybe it would have been sufficient to add "and you can keep the Emperor as a symbol of Japan" but the behaviour in the war in the pacific was far from civil.
- greg7582947 5y agoThe article fails to mention that at this phase of the war, when we were trying to convince the Japanese to surrender, we were warning target cities of pending raids by dropping leaflets a few days beforehand. These leaflets advised civilians to evacuate the cities. Unfortunately few did, since it was unfashionable if not dangerous to heed such a warning in a militaristic society like Japan was at the time. Still, we put our bomber crews in danger to reduce the number of civilian casualties while bringing the war to an end.
- champagnois 5y agoLike it or not, the civillian bombings of Japan were absolutely necessary. Japan was a very sick and diseased nation and culture at the time. They had made a national, media broadcasted sport of beheading children. They had turned deadly human experimentation into science. They had waged wars of aggression on all of their neighbors, no matter how distant. They brought their cultural disease to American shores and attacked my family. All of their civillian science and industry and culture brought about the war machine that came to American shores to murder us in a time of peace, on a continent far away from their own. The bombings of Japan should stand as a warning to all nations and cultures for all generations. If your culture gets sick with that totalitarian ideology, it is a lot better if you fix it at home on your own terms than if you bring it to our shores and make us fix it for you. You can all enjoy the peaceful world that resulted from American sacrifice, and posturing after WW2. Criticize us however you like, you have that right and luxury regardless of where you live. Regardless, you would be wise to learn this one lesson from history: Don't start nothing, won't be nothing. Germany and Japan learned that lesson the hard way and they deserved every thing they got in response.
- shakezula 5y ago
- champagnois 5y ago>>citations needed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contest_to_kill_100_people_using_a_sword https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contest_to_kill_100_people_usi... I am not on HN to confront warcrimes denialism from foreign extremists, so this is about the extent that I am going to go. >>At the time periods in question, de-facto segregation was still the norm across the entire U.S. and yet you're implying we were some sort of beacon of morality and human rights. Hell, the U.S. was performing horrific human experimentation before and _after_ the war. No where near comparable to the horrors of what Japan was doing and not even close to relevant to this thread. This is pure whataboutism from a denialist. The axis powers were not the same as the allies in some "weird and wacky" grey morality. >>This part is just straight up racism. No. Describing fascist cultures engaged in genocidal wars of extermination against the whole world as "diseased" during that time period is being polite and succinct. Maybe your view is that such a culture was healthy at the time? Tell us. >>You're either a troll or you truly have bought into the entire breadth of American Propaganda. I have seen the horrors of fascist Japan first hand. I have seen the devices and torture chambers they built. I have lived in Nanjing and heard the air raid sirens with my own ears. I, for one, am not an ignorant denialist that wants to pretend none of this ever happened. Fascist Japan had a problem back home that needed fixing. America fixed it.
- samstave 5y agoI have always been aghast at the destruction of Japanese history/culture/artifacts that occured due to this... Japan is one of the most unique histories in the modern human civ timeline... So much was destroyed during the fire bombing of Japan that humanity will never get back. https://youtu.be/RceLAhPOS9Q https://youtu.be/RceLAhPOS9Q Watch this.
- GuardianCaveman 5y agoI can’t help but find a sick satisfaction from this article after recently reading rape of Nanking and a recent pacific war book about Japanese rape and cannibalism of Captured US marines and a book about the OSS in Burma and the Japanese routinely cutting off penises of young boys and shoving them in their mouth as they lay bleeding to death while the Japanese raped and bayoneted young girls and the village burned.
- golemiprague 5y ago
- throwaway73838 5y agoI’ll throw in mine. I think if we look at Japanese culture and actions, Kamikaze, suicide, honor, they were highly averse to surrendering. I think once two of their cities were completely disappeared, they realized that they, and everything they loved could be evaporated at any moment. It would be utterly insane to continue under these circumstances. The question of would they have surrendered otherwise - i don't believe so. I don’t think that’s something we should have had to find out, either. I think people were exhausted by that point and just wanted the war to end.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoI just posted this in the commentary about safety of nuclear power in America: "Of course there's a worst one, there has to be. Well Hanford didn't principally produce energy, so much as just plutonium, so really its mission was weapon production. So now we're changing the subject a bit, no longer is it about electricity, but defense. So we can address that immediately: without the Hanford site, Japan would not have surrendered without an invasion of the home islands. Maybe not even then. It was the "new and cruel bomb," as the Emperor of Japan described it while citing it as the reason for surrender in his speech. That "new and cruel" bomb meant an alternative to reenacting the Battle of Iwo Jima (which I would describe as "fucked up" for both sides without question) a thousand times. Battles to the last cartridge. Forgetting completely about the lives of Allied and Axis soldiers, you realize the death toll that would have on the civilians of Japan? They were on the hook for all kinds of atrocities all over Asia and the Pacific, in the context of total war they pissed off the rest of the world way too hard for the Allies to declare a truce. Just in Korea alone, the stories are just...let's not talk about that, let's stick to what is fucked up within nuclear science. Japanese were subscribed to the idea that their genocide was preferable to surrender. So that's why the bomb, and by extension the Hanford site, were so important. In practice the nukes in Japan explosives second, fireworks first. Napalm was a much better explosive for the money, in terms of the destruction it could produce. The really bad bombings in WWII were in Tokyo and Dresden, a hundred thousand dead per bombing, a new climactic event called a "Firestorm," terrible burns, pavement getting goopy, high winds--I claim those bombings were worse. But they weren't as flamboyant as a star." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30362668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30362668
- anonygler 5y agoThese bombings were almost as tragic as Japan's treatment of China and Korea. Luckily they hastened an end to the war and Japan's exit from the rest of the Asian continent, and spared many GI's from needing to invade the main Japanese island.
- jmpman 5y agoMy grandfather was a US army tank commander who was part of the Okinawa invasion prior to the end of the war. As much as I’d like to criticize the atomic bomb, I probably wouldn’t be here had it not been used. My grandfather would have been required to continue the fight through the Japanese home islands, and likely perished.
- bonsoir 5y agoIt’s way more complicated than that, I know that the US narrative is quite strong, but taking a step back is a good thing here, there’s way more ambiguity than some may realise: https://www.atomicheritage.org/history/debate-over-japanese-surrender https://www.atomicheritage.org/history/debate-over-japanese-...
- lmilcin 5y ago> As many as 100,000 Japanese people were killed and another million injured, most of them civilians, when more than 300 American B-29 bombers dropped 1,500 tons of firebombs on the Japanese capital that night. Most bomb raids during WWII did absolutely nothing. Only very rarely a bomb strikes a target and does any damage. Here you have an average of over 300 kills per aircraft and 60 per bomb. Absolutely mind blowing.
- jeromescuggs 5y agotl;dr https://twitter.com/crackconnoisser/status/1485077866849218562 https://twitter.com/crackconnoisser/status/14850778668492185...
- sitkack 5y agoHN is incapable of discussing this topic in any remotely intelligent manner. Any post that is one or two hops away from dropping the atomic bombs on Japan should be banned on this forum.
- fargle 5y agoYou read this and, unless you have no trace of humanity left, will be left sympathetic to the civilians and children of Japan. But you must remember that another group of Japanese were busy raping, and bayoneting babies, and killing and torturing captured soldiers, and instigating suicide attacks. https://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/1m523p/this_is_a_japanese_soldier_bayonetting_a_chinese/ https://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/1m523p/this_is_a_japan... This is not the Japan of today or even 50 years ago. But its just sad that the innocents had to pay for the depravity of their military.
- walkhour 5y agoIt's hard not to feel sympathetic for any group of civilians subject to air bombing. In WWII this happened mainly in Germany and Japan, which were massively punished after 1941, specially in 1944 and 1945, when virtually no bombs fell in allied territory, and they were a punching bag for the allies. Even in 1940 and 1941 more bombs were dropped in Germany than in England, who incidentally started the air raids, given Churchill thought this was a highly effective way of mining the morale is the enemy. This in addition to purely sadistic expeditions like the bombing of Dresden, when the war was already over.
- fargle 5y agothe war was mostly over, but Germany didn't surrender until May 8th. Last bombs fell mid-April. I don't think it was at all sadistic. Both of these cases show the impossibility of humanity decency when confronted with such extremely powerful and totalitarian militaristic dictatorships. Even the opposing forces, in many ways, are forced to resort to the tactics and morality of their enemy. So you loose your moral high ground real fast if you fight dirty. Or you fight fair and loose the war. Either way the worst is inevitable.
- mrtri 5y ago