46 ms·
The data are clear: The boys are not all right
- MrStonedOne 5y ago
- commandlinefan 5y ago> As men’s unemployment rises, their romantic prospects decline. Conversely: as young men's potential future employability rises, their romantic prospects also decline. That is - the men who'll grow up to be stable and reliable have lonely teenage years.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI'm one of these men and I hope this actually works out in the end. I sense that men also have a biological clock but we can reassure ourselves that we can keep putting off settling down because of the biological reality of male reproduction. If I just get a little more successful, then I will be more attractive in courtship. But the thing is, you lose track of time really quickly. And, it is quite the bootstrapping problem to catch up on romantic social skills that you didn't cultivate earlier in life. Being awkward around women in High School is a given, but as a thirty-something it can be profoundly uncomfortable and off-putting.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Being awkward around women in High School is a given, but as a thirty-something it can be profoundly uncomfortable and off-putting. Males should be fixing that by making some female friends. Don't go the "creepy incel who hates all women and Chads" route.
- birdyrooster 5y agoTry that in a town with double the men that there are women. Easier to switch hit.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoWhere is the ratio that skewed?!
- birdyrooster 5y agoSan Jose
- BitwiseFool 5y ago>" Don't go the "creepy incel who hates all women and Chads" route" Absolutely. I am on the autism spectrum so part of the difficulty I have can be attributed to that. However I accept that my social shortcomings are my own responsibility. I think a big part of the problem is finding new friends now that I am in my 30's and life is very stagnant.
- betwixthewires 5y agoAnecdotal, but I had this problem for many years, I stuck to my existing (small) social circle which included no single women, and that social circle got increasingly small over the years as people moved away, settled down, etc. I moved somewhere where I didn't know anyone at all, and after a few months of just spending every waking moment alone, I just started going to the same place where people are and doing the same thing every day. I think all it takes is going somewhere where people are and being friendly, somewhere that doesn't include existing friends and acquaintances, just sticking with it and not really caring who thinks what about you. Anywhere but a bar would be my criteria, and ideally not a commercial establishment. For me it was the local swimming pool in my community.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoWould you be open to advice? Regardless I wish you luck in your endeavors.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoYes, I welcome advice and would be happy to reflect on it.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI found myself in a similar boat until I started doing something that had a high community dependency that is also less extremely gendered. So, for example, biking and hiking are not gendered activities and a variety of humans do them. Foodie things, business things, specific crafts will also do this. Consistently appearing in them helps a lot. This is dependent on how “evident” your autism is though. There is a good amount of therapy that can be done to mitigate some of it, but there are also groups (fandoms for example) that are both less obviously gendered and also more open to awkwardness (like writing fantasy novels). Once you’re in an activity for the fun of the activity, friendships and the like also tend to form organically, like sewing seeds in a field and then allowing rain to trigger sprouting.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe problem is people, including women, get to pick their friends. If you're branded as awkward or ugly all women will avoid you leading to a self-perpetuating cycle. Since women can pick their friends and generally pick gregarious, outgoing, and socially competent men for their friend groups, they ignore and do not understand the type of man who is labelled an incel.
- _bkr9 5y agoNo, these are false premises. All of my female partners have had the feedback from someone that "you're just like a guy". The so called "girl next door" wearing sweats, and rocking a bad-hair-day ponytail because she's late for her lab may be way hotter when she dresses up than the median film actress. She may be an awesome friend. She may be a frickin' monster in bed, without giving off any porn-star vibes. Incels are fundamentally working off a broken model of women, attraction, dating, and sex. EDUT> Not getting "Stacy" is making them crazy, but they don't realize that they don't want Stacy. Stacy's frumpy-seeming neighbour will rock their world.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Incels are fundamentally working off a broken model of women, attraction, dating, and sex. That broken model is unfortunately widespread in both genders. Some "girls next door" can basically feel like failures in the dating/relationships sphere, which ends up making them even less appealing to others. It's worth trying to fix this of course, but it's not always easy.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThey're not usually working off of a broken model, they legitimately get no positive interaction with women.
- acdha 5y agoThe former part is the cause of the latter. The guys I've known like this were trying to treat it like a game and/or had unrealistic expectations, and that ended about as well as it always does. Once they started being genuine and realistic, things changed dramatically.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoGood luck to you. I'm in the same boat and it's comforting to not be alone. I've sacrificed a social and romantic life to get to this point (20 year old, fairly well paid DevOps guy). There are days that I immensely regret leaving school at 16 and terminating my youth early but financially speaking it was the best decision ever. I just push onwards, hope for life to become fun, and hope that I won't become a cautionary tale.
- recuter 5y agoPlease please please try to find good outgoing non-techy roommates that you can tolerate while you are at this age. Even better if they are good with girls. Do not live alone just because you can afford to do so. Try to spend as little as possible of your salary and regardless of the market buy a house/apartment as soon as you can. Live in the smallest room. There are plenty of excellent places in the world where you can have a reasonable quality of life for about $10k/year, your goal is to have that covered from your real estate income. Go do that as soon as you can, travel slow. Overnight trains, house/pet sitting, couch surfing, 'etc are all good things to try. Try to find a remote job and never touch your salary income again, keep investing it. Do not mention your net worth to anyone. You will find in a few years that "DevOps" is a very finite skillset so there is no real need to push so hard as you'll know most of what you need to know in about 3 more years if you do not already. No reason not to have a social and romantic life and great weekends. I'm quite confident your employer and less talented peers are exploiting your age and willingness to put in long hours. Don't be available after hours and avoid being on call as much as possible. You only get your 20s once. Make memories. Money is important but you need less than you think and is never a worthy goal in and of itself. You can convince yourself of this by reading up on behavioral economics. Optimize for quality of life. Have a FU-money number, reach it, and bail.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoAppreciate the advice. It is a bit harder than it sounds though. Building a friend circle from scratch is harder than any technical challenge I've faced before. I overcame my social anxiousness for the most part but that doesn't mean I can cold approach people and build a conversation up to a friendship. Anyway, HN is hardly the place for this kind of topic but thanks again. I'm giving it my best but it's not a piece of cake.
- zozbot234 5y agoSurely one's romantic prospects should not be set in the teenage years. Or even be affected all that much by contingent employment status, when future potential might be far more relevant.
- cedws 5y agoAs another reply touches on, there's a developmental process to romance. A guy in his thirties dating for the first time will have a seriously hard time because of his inexperience. I'm not saying that it's impossible at that point but missing the boat in your teenage years can stunt this development. I think Jordan Peterson has described this in one of his lectures (it's an interesting idea regardless of what you think of his character).
- johnny22 5y agoa guy in his thirties dating for the first time will have troubles IF he didn't have good friendly social interactions BEFORE that with both women and men.
- tomjakubowski 5y agoInteresting. I'm just one person, but: I've enjoyed stable employment as a programmer since I was 23, and my teenage years and early 20s were easily my most socially (and romantically) active, and I rarely felt lonely then. I've felt most lonely in my late 20s and early 30s. I sometimes wonder if my career destroyed my ability to make and keep friends.
- jeffrallen 5y ago> wonder if my career destroyed my ability to make and keep friends You spend thousands of hours at your job. It is inevitable that it will change your personality. Choose wisely.
- peterangular 5y agoYeah anecdotally same experience. Social groups just dry up when you get to your late 20's as people are marrying off, having kids, and only maintaining the utmost of friendships. I know it's brutal but it's a time thing... significant others and families take lots of time if you're doing it right so socializing time becomes of higher value/expense. It was way easier to meet people when I was younger - not just romantic partners. Social groups were much more cohesive and much less based around couple activity. People were just down for whatever and would jump at something just for the experience. I had tons of friends I could just call/SMS like "hey I'm bored let's go find a show" whereas I would feel inappropriate doing this as an adult.
- brandall10 5y agoI think late 20s is when most people lose touch w/ remnants of their college social circle if they're not naturally outgoing. Usually everyone has moved away or married off at this point. It's fairly normal.
- ceasesurthinko 5y agoI would say even the extroverted outgoing people lose touch with alot of their past friends. It happens to everyone
- UncleMeat 5y agoIs this actually true? This feels a bit like a post-facto generalization from specific situations. "I was a nerd and didn't go on dates. Being a nerd got me into software and now I make a lot of money. Therefore people who are on the path to high earning are not getting dates." My experience has been that a lot of the stereotypical jocks ended up in finance and are doing quite well and that software is no longer dominated by social loners.
- babyshake 5y agoA lot of popular kids and jocks end up in management in tech while the loners and kids of immigrants are the ones actually creating the software.
- humanrebar 5y agoMaybe true but there's a lot of survivorship bias in the population. Software shops are often hurting for clear communicators. Winsome folks tend to get bumped into leadership roles even if they start out slinging curly braces and semicolons.
- UncleMeat 5y agoEven if this were true (jocks go into management and management is useless), it would be the opposite of what the parent was saying about the people on the path to high pay rarely having romantic relationships since management tends to pay well.
- sulam 5y agosource?
- acheron 5y agoI don’t know where you went to school. I guess I know a “jock” type who was running a meth lab, I guess that is a kind of management, at least until he went to prison.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoPeople who have strong social skills will tend to do well. The premise seems very doubtful.
- rhino369 5y agoA lot of stable and reliable men have really good teenage years. There is definitely an arc-type of socially awkward boys who grow up to be engineers, accountants, etc. But within that group, romantic prospects are positively correlated with employment prospects. An awkward guy w/ a job is better than an awkward guy w/o one.
- mrtksn 5y ago> men who'll grow up to be stable and reliable have lonely teenage years. You are describing nerds having high paying tech jobs, right? I find that little bit short sighted, there are huge number(probably the majority) of people with balanced lifestyles who are employed in stable jobs, just not really in a trendy high paying or high status sectors. There are also a sizeable number of people who don't posses the nerdy characteristics at all and still are good in academics and business. Colleges are actually full of that kind of people, they all end up in good jobs.
- bitwize 5y agoHey, sports teach valuable life skills -- life skills the socially awkward often miss out on. Things like grit, teamwork, and not being a sore loser, as well as the importance of keeping your body in shape. In fact we are having a crisis of not enough boys doing sports, and as a consequence elite military units can't find enough recruits who meet the baseline physical fitness standards. A reasonably intelligent person with an athletic background probably did well socially in HS, and will probably do well in the working world.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> That is - the men who'll grow up to be stable and reliable have lonely teenage years. Wouldn't that be nice? That sort of karma is not really guaranteed to exist. Chances are the ostracized lonely introvert will be worse off due to poor networking and if he finds any success at all it will be despite many disadvantages. Meanwhile, asshole bullies could very well go on to become their bosses because sociopathy is often found in powerful people.
- rajeshp1986 5y agoI went to a local college few days back and I noticed that there were more girls than boys. I think part of the reason is due to high college debt many young men are choosing to take jobs and skipping college all together. This will translate to less men in the knowledge based/corporate jobs.
- justinpombrio 5y agoThere have been more women than men in college in the US since the 80s. It varies from college to college and from subject to subject (e.g. STEM is much more male, MIT more male, humanities-focused colleges more female). A graph from a random internet search result: https://educationalpolicy.org/hello-world/ https://educationalpolicy.org/hello-world/
- urthor 5y agoThere's a huge body of education research about this, this has been the case for of years. There's even data from the pre-1900s, especially in the primary school years. Only recently have we stripped away a lot of the sexism however, providing a successful transition to higher education. It all boils down to: Girls are more likely to do their damn homework when the teacher tells them. Therefore they out-perform in formal education.
- scarmig 5y agoTeachers also give boys lower grades and girls higher grades when their gender is evident; anonymous grading greatly reduces the gender gap in primary and secondary school.
- diordiderot 5y agoDo you have a link to a study etc? V interested
- scarmig 5y ago
- Santosh83 5y agoEffect of dwindling & non-existent male role models and more importantly, fathers.
- paulcole 5y agoWhy is this an issue? Aren't good role models good role models regardless of gender/sex?
- jaywalk 5y agoA woman simply cannot be a role model in all of the same ways as a man, and vice-versa. This belief that men and women are the same and contribute in exactly the same ways is a big part of the problem that this article discusses.
- paulcole 5y agoThe opinion article you mean, right? I agree that a woman can't be a role model in the same ways as a man, but I believe this is not necessarily a bad thing.
- valdiorn 5y agoIt isn't, in fact it's great that we have different kinds of role models. The problem being discussed is that some people lack certain types of roles models (i.e. male ones)
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's an assured-sounding statement, but what is it based on? I have role models that aren't my gender; it makes no difference to me.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoI recommend the book 'Families and how to survive them' which covers human developmental psychology and has detailed sections on gendered role models. It may push a few woke buttons, but doesn't everything?
- fdgsdfogijq 5y agoI think the root cause is that society no longer needs "beta" males. Or rather, men in the middle of the distribution. This here is a symptom of that broad effect in society. Technical leverage, automation, premium on intelligence in the workplace, and technology more broadly are pushing out average men.
- zapataband1 5y agoHyper-concentration of wealth means no upward mobility so it's no surprise America is having this crisis. Turns out in capitalism if the goal is to hoard the most resources, once you're winning the game it's no longer profitable to educate the masses, better off to leave them poor and dying in wars that make even more money. Can you imagine a library or a modern public computer lab being built in cities? We make kids go into debt for food at school.
- decafninja 5y agoPossible unpopular opinion, but my wife and I want just one kid, and would greatly, greatly, prefer a daughter for reasons that include some mentioned in this article. I feel a son would be so much harder to raise in today's world.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI think individual differences are far more important. I have a boy and a girl both, and my son is far, far easier to raise. I do not fear for his future, socially or economically. My daughter, on the other hand, keeps me awake at night worrying.
- AlgorithmicTime 5y ago
- epx 5y agoI have a son, and am moderately optimistic this has peaked already. As the other commenter said, we see different families in very different mindsets. I have been personally affected by sexism type B: was expected to work, to be a provider someday, to pay my own way to university, if you want a car you buy it, etc. etc. My sister had the second family car at disposal and the tuition was paid for. There was this undercurrent interpretation of feminism that "women will eventually suffer so they should be pampered when possible". There were other factors at play: I have a tendency to self-indulgence, my sister does not, so it is prima facie difficult to separate what was proper, individualized upbringing and what was sexism. But sexism was a part; many male friends of the same generation have the same complaint and some could be better off today had they have more support at home. Then there is this relative of mine, that simply threw his daughters out at 18, since they are supposed to get a wealthy boyfriend and marry rich, so they don't need any further support. BTW they are disowned, too. This is sexism type A, and make it a big A. Not necessary to say this strategy did not end well: both are stuck with less-than-optimal partners and careers. We are in 2022 and a nice, wealthy and rational guy won't commit to someone without a career and finances in order.
- bradlys 5y ago
- frankbreetz 5y ago>>Median wages for men have declined since 1990 in real terms. Roughly one-third of men are either unemployed or out of the workforce. I wonder how much of this is because more women are joining the workforce. If men are leaving the workforce by their own free will because their wife is working and they are staying home with the kids, both of these facts could be true, but seems like a win in both gender equality terms and allowing men to have the life they want. This seems better then having two working parents. I don't really like how "out of the workforce" is coupled with unemployed. "out of the workforce" implies they don't have to and don't want to work, as opposed to unemployed
- rhino369 5y agoI think its more that they are dropping out and playing Xbox than dropping out and watching the kids. I'm not sure I blame them. If I had no prospects of a wife or kids, I'd quit my job and argue with people on the internet in my dad's basement too.
- 0_____0 5y agoThe effect of womens' labor participation should be easy to suss out. Look at professions where womens' share of employment is still very low in the US (building trades perhaps), and compare it with the rest of the economy.
- decafninja 5y agoDo many married men really want that kind of life though? It's one thing to be single and roaming the world carefree. But my observation has been that most men who are married, especially if with children, have some innate desire to provide for the family and not being able to do so (due to unemployment, underemployment, etc.) causes them stress even if the wife is earning more than enough. Those that don't seem to be an outlier. Is it biological? Is it social pressure? I don't know.
- ok_dad 5y agoPersonally, I would love to quit working and take care of my family at home. I find much more joy in that than working a programming career. I think a lot of men have been conditioned to think we have to be the provider much like women have been conditioned to think they have to be a homemaker.
- neonate 5y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20220209170553/https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/08/andrew-yang-boys-are-not-all-right/ http://web.archive.org/web/20220209170553/https://www.washin... https://archive.is/47R8y https://archive.is/47R8y
- dang 5y agoHere's the full Orwell quote. People are wrong when they think that an unemployed man only worries about losing his wages; on the contrary, an illiterate man, with the work habit in his bones, needs work even more than he needs money. An educated man can put up with enforced idleness, which is one of the worst evils of poverty. But a man like Paddy, with no means of filling up time, is as miserable out of work as a dog on the chain. That is why it is such nonsense to pretend that those who have 'come down in the world' are to be pitied above all others. The man who really merits pity is the man who has been down from the start, and faces poverty with a blank, resourceless mind From Down and Out in Paris and London. (Someone should have known better than to try to link to Google Books from a mass media piece.)
- gtsop 5y ago
- vixen99 5y agoHow about saying why instead of assuming your 'Wow' point is so obvious everyone will agree?
- lph 5y ago"No country, however rich, can afford the waste of its human resources. Demoralization caused by vast unemployment is our greatest extravagance. Morally, it is the greatest menace to our social order." -FDR
- redisman 5y agoThe thing is - we’re at 4% unemployment. Which is probably about as low as a service based economy can get.
- beefman 5y agoPresently in the U.S. about 60% of people have jobs; 55% of women and 65% of men. In Feb 1962, 56% had jobs but it was 36% of women and 78% of men https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EMRATIO https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EMRATIO https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300002 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300002 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300001 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12300001
- alphabettsy 5y agoPurely anecdotal, but it was uncool, dorky, nerdy, etc. where I grew up for boys to be interested in math or even English, but “more manly stuff” like working with your hands was highly encouraged. It seems that kind of culture will result in men being less likely to end up in higher paying careers.l than girls who are being encouraged to pursue STEM.
- bmj 5y agoYou do realize that a career in the skilled trades can lead to very good pay, right? Yes, the work can be hard, and the hours sometimes long, but there are very clear paths to working independently, or for small shops/contractors that provide a nice degree of independence and good pay. I think high school kids in the U.S. should be exposed to STEM, the humanities, and the trades. We have pushed college/academic achievement long enough, and I suspect that some of the data we are seeing represents a backlash against it, particularly when you consider the cost of university and the job prospects for new graduates.
- zozbot234 5y ago> You do realize that a career in the skilled trades can lead to very good pay, right? Only if you can start your independent business, which few can do pretty much by definition. That's still a recipe for bimodal outcomes. And the U.S. has pushed "college achievement" on paper, but their K-12 education still sucks. There's no way that this isn't a drag on college outcomes.
- jeffbee 5y agoI knew people who started oilfield welding businesses at the age of 18 right out of high school, bought houses and started families. Yeah that is a boom-and-bust business but then again so is machine learning.
- bmj 5y agoThis isn't necessarily true. I know a wide range of folks that work in union trade positions, and they make very good money. Now, sometimes, those jobs can be unpleasant for awhile (building is behind schedule, etc, etc), but they also last a finite amount of time. To be clear, I'm not suggesting that the trades are a gravy train for everyone, but the idea that you will barely make ends meet is also not the case.
- Spooky23 5y agoOf course. We treat females like they are a marginalized minority. My son’s school has a “Girls Can Code” program. All collateral features women and girls. (Boys are welcome though) I worked at a place where a C-level executive hosted company endorsed dinners at her home for female managers to mentor them for executive roles. If I setup a boys club for computers at school or hosted a men’s IT society at work, that wouldn’t end well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 5y ago> If I setup a boys club for computers at school or hosted a men’s IT society at work, that wouldn’t end well. Maybe not, but nearly every <Subject> Users Group I've attended may as well have been a men's IT society for all the women I've seen attend, despite specific outreach efforts to get them there.
- jimbokun 5y agoAre you implying that women were banned or explicitly discouraged from attending those groups? EDIT: my bad, think I got you confused with a different comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 5y agoWhile I share your first hand observations here, I'll note that (from my limited perspective) there was nothing obviously catering to non-females or any particular gender in these groups. Many of the groups I've attended also had 'professional standards'. So what is the discrepancy? What has changed and what is being done differently between the groups where 'boys' can optionally attend and ones that 'girls' appear to self select against attendance? We should reach for a world that doesn't require discrimination.
- ramesh31 5y agoMen's comparative advantage, throughout human history, has always been their physical strength. It was the one thing a man could count on to provide value to society. That is no longer the case in our modern economy. You need intelligence, emotional intellect, and analytical skills. All of which men and women are on an equal footing at. So when you remove the ability to generate a viable income through physical labor, it's pretty obvious why a good portion of men are now left without anything useful to contribute.
- philipkglass 5y agoI agreed with this until the last sentence. If men and women are on an equal footing, why are a good portion of men left without anything useful to contribute? I suppose this could hinge on the definition of "good portion." I personally don't think that a "good portion" of prime working age men or women are left without anything economically useful to contribute. American unemployment is currently low, hiring is up, wages are rising, and the coming AI revolution where robots do every job now appears more distant to me than it did 10 years ago.
- ramesh31 5y ago>If men and women are on an equal footing, why are a good portion of men left without anything useful to contribute? Point being that not everyone can be a doctor or a lawyer or a physicist. There will always be a good portion of the population that really has nothing to contribute economically but their labor. For women, these labor positions are the ones that have survived our transition to a mostly service based economy; healthcare, childcare, cleaning, food service, etc. For men, they mostly have not. The days of a man being able to use his comparative advantage of physical strength to earn above the median wage are long gone.
- astrange 5y agoHigh physical strength is useful for several modern jobs we’re desperately in need of - in particular nurses and home health aides. There’s still construction too, once we defeat the NIMBYs. Most of this “running out of work” thought is just excuses for the US’s bad economic management in the 90s-2000s; as the GP said, now we’re at 4% unemployment and anyone with skills will be able to find a way to use them. Anything can be a skill if it's unique enough - if AI took all the jobs, "being human" would be a skill. That's comparative advantage.
- awinter-py 5y agogreat book on this topic is friedan's feminine mystique (1963). She wrote about the spiritual crisis affecting a generation of young women who were more likely to be 'homemakers' than their mothers. worth reading at least the intro IMO for anyone who feels dissatisfied with their work / life / contribution not sure how yang made this his topic. my sense of his random walk is 'had a job at yahoo' -> future of work -> UBI -> numbers guy -> times square -> ? really miss the andrew yang policy bot on twitter though
- klodolph 5y ago> great book on this topic is friedan's feminine mystique (1963) Another is “The Will To Love: Men, Masculinity, and Change” by bell hooks (2004) There aren’t a lot of authors that I feel get it right about issues relating to men and masculinity. Bell hooks is one of the few. > not sure how yang made this his topic. my sense of his random walk is 'had a job at yahoo' -> future of work -> UBI -> numbers guy -> times square -> ? I live in NYC and spend a lot of time online, so we got kinda saturated with Yang during the last year because he was in the mayoral race. As far as I can tell, he’s a passionate self-promoter, and engages on a shallow level with tons of different topics as some kind of cynical way to promote his brand. If he were at least more skilled at it I would respect him more, but he’s made so many obvious PR blunders and it’s obvious he doesn’t listen to advisors. He pokes around at sensitive topics like race and sexism, but as far as I can tell it’s so he can stay in the news, because he rarely has anything interesting to say on those subjects. It seems like a random walk because he’s doing whatever will get him in the news online.
- muh_gradle 5y agoI also live in NYC, and completely disagree with this take on Yang. I can't think of anyone who gets hated more unfairly than him. He provides actual substantive policy suggestions with evidence to support his claims. He doesn't resort to dirty muck-raking the same way that the other mayoral candidates and the NY Times did. In fact, NY Times and the NY Daily News spent so much time focusing on bashing Yang that it's literally the reason why Eric Adams of all people ended up being our mayor.
- ausbah 5y agoI know in some areas like declining college enrollment men are definitely disproportionately effected, but can you be so sure for other areas that the article cites as evidence? like more men being raised by single mothers, or declining wages - I imagine phenomena like this would be effecting both genders roughly equally? I do not know - but without knowing for sure, I am more skeptical of the article's premise
- lph 5y agoAndrew Yang makes some good points in this piece, particularly about positive masculinity and role models. Whether fair or not, the perception that the left is hostile to men has driven recruitment for the far right, and that merits some reflection. But he's also really facile about underlying economic causes. It's easy to blame problems on "our culture has been broken by the wokes!", but many of the problems of young men are not unique to them. Fewer women are entering college, also. Women are dropping out of the workforce, also. More young women are living with their parents, also. Is that because they lacked strong masculine role models? Or is it because the rising costs of college, housing, healthcare, and living have made the traditional path much less attainable? Absent fathers didn't do that. These are the same patterns you see in any country with a shrinking economy; it's just a shock to Americans who feel they were promised better. (In summary: Maybe Andrew Yang should spend more time talking to Bernie Sanders)
- jimmyjazz14 5y agoI didn't really get the sense that he was placing all the blame on "the wokes" as you put it though that is most certainly a factor in my opinion. The data he points out is relative to the state of things for women in most cases and shows that men are falling behind in dramatic ways. I don't think he is necessarily trying to say its the only issue of the day.
- Zigurd 5y agoAs with any challenged population, blaming the victim is unfair in the majority of cases, is unproductive in finding solutions, and it creates division where it is unwarranted. But the phrase "positive masculinity" is fraught. Ease in befriending and reaching real camaraderie with women does not depend on masculinity at all. It depends on seeing others as equals. I sure don't think about masculinity and whether I'm doing it right. What would that do? I doubt the kind of masculinity advice Jordan Peterson is slinging helps any of the men who listen to him. Instead, they find comfort and self-justification in that advice. It isn't changing their outcomes. It isn't the on-ramp to good relationships. It is the on ramp to the "intellectual dark web" and that will keep your dick dry more reliably than anything.
- photochemsyn 5y agoI wonder if social media technology is as much at fault as the neoliberal program of exporting well-paid manufacturing jobs overseas and replacing them with low-paid service jobs (with the difference going into the pockets of the shareholders) is. If children are being raised on TikTok, okay, the average video length on TikTok is a couple minutes. Advertisements are now 5-15 seconds. This is not conducive to 'long attention span'. Now, imagine popping these kids into a classroom and expecting them to pay close attention for, say, 15 minutes, without any breaks. What to do... diagnose them with ADHD and dose them with amphetamines, what else? Of course this is the same issue for girls and boys but is generally going to create more of a dumbed-down population. Kids are probably better off playing video games instead, those require more attention. Even better, encourage them to read actual books. I wonder if the WaPo would be interested in publishing any critiques of social media effects on children, given their ties to Big Tech... Let's see... "New report: Most teens say social media makes them feel better, not worse, about themselves (2018)" Corporate media claims... remember this one? "NAFTA and China WTO will raise the standard of living for all Americans!"
- tablespoon 5y ago> I wonder if the WaPo would be interested in publishing any critiques of social media effects on children, given their ties to Big Tech... Let's see... "New report: Most teens say social media makes them feel better, not worse, about themselves (2018)" Oh come on. You're either being misleading, or have been mislead. What you wrote doesn't make any sense: 1. Why would the existence of an example of one type of article show the absence of a different type? It's not like the Washington Post cannot report on multiple sides of an issue. 2. A single article from five years ago? How is that supposed to support such a sweeping statement? 3. It's not hard, at all, to find examples of the WaPo "publishing any critiques of social media effects on children": "Instagram is even worse than we thought for kids. What do we do about it? (2021)" (https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2021/09/17/instagram-teens-parent-advice/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2021/09/17/instagra...), probably all the articles in this search https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Awashingtonpost.com+%22facebook+papers%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Awashingtonpost.com+%2..., etc. > Corporate media claims... remember this one? "NAFTA and China WTO will raise the standard of living for all Americans!" As far as I can tell, you just made that up. Literally no Google hits: https://www.google.com/search?q="NAFTA+and+China+WTO+will+raise+the+standard+of+living+for+all+Americans!"&tbs=li%3A1 https://www.google.com/search?q="NAFTA+and+China+WTO+will+ra... (at the time of this writing, it looks like your comment hasn't been indexed yet). So, no, no one "remembers" that one. And even if if the WaPo did publish an article claiming exactly that (most likely some kind of advocacy on the op-ed page), what's the big deal? Do you think they should censor articles like that? Perhaps by using their precognitive abilities to know who the future will prove wrong? It's kind of ironic that many people's who criticize the media for being some kind of propaganda rag issue critiques that implicitly advocate for it to be a propaganda rag.
- thrway99 5y agoMy observation is that we are going to have a radical rebalancing of who reproduces and who doesn’t. Lot of men and women who are generally not too motivated to seek out a companion, lose weight, put in the work to make it happen just…won’t pass on genetics. Children are a lot of work and energy. I’m highly introverted and high earning. My wife was the aggressor in my case. She pretty much made it all happen. I think the ball is firmly in the woman’s court now. Women have most of the advantages (education, societal promotion, fit in better with our institutions) yet i see so many women who are generally apathetic about getting into a relationship at all. There is also a massive obesity problem. If people have trouble getting attracted to each other versus the alternatives, makes it really challenging to find the motivation. I wonder what all these effects will have over the next 200 years? If you play out the changing “relationship market conditions,” it seems like men and women with different personalities and dispositions towards seeking out relationships in order to reproduce will have a significant effect on the species. Will people who were genetically predisposed towards being thin, hard working, open minded to approaching members of opposite sex and forming deep attachments resulting in children become more frequent? On a genetic and evolutionary perspective I’m super interested - we know that IQ has been rising, but what else will change? In some societies such as Korea I am told, women are sometimes or more frequently the aggressor. I wonder if this becomes more common.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoThe very rich by ability and the very poor by inability to attain family planning, and everyone else in TX. I maybe in a skewed population (FAANG) but women are much more aggressive here in urban areas. While I was walking downtown, a woman pulled her Mercedes over in traffic and shouted an offer at me. I thought she was hilarious and bold but not attractive enough. In the past, this was sometimes a thing too: in 1943, my grandmother (15) decided to have my grandfather (21 - war vet at 17 by lying). Their 70-year marriage was technically illegal too.
- humanrebar 5y ago
- 5y ago
- uejfiweun 5y agoProbably unpopular opinion: men having it tough is actually a good thing for men, if you make the most of it. Yes, in modern times as a man, you pretty much don't have any programs specifically designed to benefit you. And yes, men get shat on by pretty much every corner of society. But it's still possible to succeed in these conditions, and some people most definitely do. And those who were able to find their way and make it in a very unfriendly system tend to be extremely competent, not just intellectually but socially and emotionally as well. It's that old saying - "hard times make strong men," yada yada. Having just gone through the whole school process, I am very confident in my ability to solve a problem / achieve a goal on my own, and I don't need some special program or exception to the rules in order to succeed.
- ketzo 5y agoMen – and people – should not need to be exceptional just to be happy. Hard times make a few strong men and a lot of very, very miserable ones.
- jbay808 5y ago> I am very confident in my ability to solve a problem / achieve a goal on my own, and I don't need some special program or exception to the rules in order to succeed. Picture a distribution, like a bell curve or something. The programs are meant for the side of that distribution that need it. You can talk about how the other side of the distribution doesn't need the help, but don't lose sight of the fact that many do.
- TrackerFF 5y agoNot too different from the "I earn $xxxk/year, and don't need any help from welfare programs. Why do we even have them? They make people lazy" crowd.
- skinkestek 5y agoJust as long as you know you have succeeded in spite of it all and do not buy into the "almost failed despite being wildly privileged" idea that gets pushed. (To be clear: I am wildly privileged to live in a Western country now instead of living almost anywhere else at any other time. I'm also generally happy to be a strong and healthy male. My thoughts are best best explained by the fact that 1. all else being equal I'd prefer to recruit a woman rather than a man to the company I work for because that gives me more "social credit" at work 2. Boys systematically do better on anonymous tests, at least in the western world.)
- jeffbee 5y ago
- caeril 5y agoYes. However, the number of years people complain about societal decay is irrelevant to the question about whether it's happening or not. The Roman Empire was "going to hell in a handbasket" for centuries prior to 410, according to the social critics of the time. It doesn't make them wrong. Applying one's personal normalcy bias on timescales of a single lifetime to societal evolution that happens on the scales of tens of generations is rather short-sighted.
- kevinob11 5y agoI'm a white straight male, grew up middle class near Seattle. I'm now in my mid-30s and have 3 kids. Semi-recently I had an (maybe my first?) experience where I wasn't the favored party in a situation. My kids have made focus more difficult, and I work in an industry (tech consulting) where focus is a big deal, and the idea that I'm not the perfect person for the job was a foreign feeling. I no longer felt "I was made for this" or "I'm perfect for this". While I hate that things are getting worse for anyone (and want to fix it!), these findings are good reminders for me that almost everyone else has dealt with similar circumstances much more often than I have. Often the cause is out of their control and that they are just trying to make the best of it, with varying results. It gives me good perspective and reminds me that peoples choices / actions include inputs that I'm not exposed to. That all being said I hope we can find a way to make these situations less common for everyone. I'd settle for quick fixes (adjust taxes, better welfare, etc.), but I'm excited for the societal changes that I hope are the eventual long-term fix.
- marcellus23 5y ago> Semi-recently I had an (maybe my first?) experience where I wasn't the favored party in a situation You're mid-30s and you might have just experienced your first thing like that? Man or woman, that's hard to believe. And more importantly, I'm not sure your experience can be generalized to all men. As someone who has experienced situations like that frequently, and knows other men who have, it's a bit frustrating to see the implication that we all feel like "we're perfect for this" or "we're made for this" all the time.
- uoaei 5y agoYours is an argument of kind in reply to an argument of degree.
- marcellus23 5y agoThe degree is irrelevant. I don't doubt that men have privilege — but the "but women have it worse!" comment often shows up on articles like these, and since it's just whataboutism, it feels like it's suggesting that we shouldn't care about these issues. Shouldn't we care about how society is treating people, no matter who they are, instead of getting into a pissing contest about who society is _really_ screwing over the most? Not to mention, frankly, it's ridiculous to imply that a 35-year old male software engineer's experience is at all representative of that of the average male (who is far, far worse off).
- cosmiccatnap 5y ago
- RadixDLT 5y ago
- Beltalowda 5y agoIn what way? I've worked with some people with some fairly, ehm, extreme takes on things, and had a fair share of disagreements, sometimes with some words that were harsher than I thought were professional, but I've never been subjected to or observed anything I'd call close to "bullying".
- wbsss4412 5y ago“Most”?
- RadixDLT 5y agomost jobs with an office environment
- tmnstr85 5y agoWhite, straight, male, 37 with two kids. One who is severely disabled and under the age of 5. In the past couple of years, its become clear to me that I will probably become a caretaker to my daughter at some point in my life. The prospects of keeping a full time job, in my field are quickly changing - I am no longer desired. Doing this in a financial services setting is especially stark because there's no empathy. Its been really rough the past couple of years. I am trying to find my peace with the idea that I've done a good job, I did everything I was supposed to do, but there were forces outside my control that will dictate the future. My wife just made partner at her firm, and I was told by a c level executive, of color, that I'm "no longer part of where the firm culture is headed". I see this issue every day, it gets harder as we get older. As we head towards 2024, that sentiment on the other side of the fence gains momentum from this type of isolation, regardless of race. It will be interesting to see how many men vote in 2024 vs. previous elections.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ninja3925 5y agoWhat are a terrible thing to say. I am deeply saddened by your experience and I hope you will find fulfillment somewhere else. All the best.
- emerged 5y agoWhite, straight male in my 40s who worked hard to build a decent career. The feeling that this culture hates me based on each of those categories, completely without knowing me, is hard to ignore much longer without a response. The feeling comes from being on the losing side of every action the government and popular culture takes. Being told that you can’t even be involved in a conversation about that fact.
- bestouff 5y agoWhite, straight male (too far) into in my 40s, but in France: for now I don't witness that. There is overall concern for women and minorities, but no hate towards my "category". Reading what happens elsewhere, I'm happy to live in a more cohesive society.
- paulpauper 5y agoThe crisis, if there is one, is that society has less use for males who have IQs between 90-105 or so, who cannot cut it in STEM, and who are finding it hard to cope with increasingly competitive economic conditions and higher overall costs like rent, and is why many men are delaying family formation or moving back with parents (but also due to careerism for women). Men are just dropping out rather than doing low-paid work and having to deal with political correctness at the office and other inconveniences.
- ceasesurthinko 5y agoAutomation will essentially keep the top percentiles of intelligence employed while everyone else suffers immensely. 80% of the country is going to be fucked in the coming decades while we automate everything. It's why UBI is so crucial in the future.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway6532 5y agoThis is my analysis too. We're hitting a phase-shift where behavior of the system becomes non-linear due to these types of factors.
- notacoward 5y agoThis kind of withdrawal seems to be happening in many cultures. In Japan it's called hikikomori. I forget what it's called in Italy, but I know I've read about it. Here it's the same, except ours tend to be more violent.
- ceasesurthinko 5y agoUsually referred to as a NEET (Not in Education, Employment, or Training) in the western world.
- frontman1988 5y ago
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoYour reminder that having disenfranchised young men with nothing to lose in your society is like keeping kindling next to a munitions factory and has never ended well. It’s kind of like a Maslow’s hierarchy of needs but for a society. If your higher needs are only being met at the expense of your lower needs it’s all going to come crashing down. The lower needs in this case are channeling the energies of those that can commit the most violent atrocities away from committing violent atrocities and into something constructive like jobs and families.
- sleepingadmin 5y agoI like Yang, he's certainly intelligent and his reality/algorithm is certainly separate from mine, yet parallel. So I find what he talks about is very interesting. The first part of the article clearly lays out the reality that men/boys are under attack. One of the key roles that the political left-wing should represent is fixing disenfranchisement. Unfortunately for about the last few decades, that not only is untrue, the opposite is what is happening. It has been the left-wing who has been disenfranchising boys and men. >Yes, men have long had societal advantages over women and in some ways continue to be treated favorably. But male achievement — alongside that of women — is a condition for a healthy society. Here it is coming from Yang. The right-wing are obviously where traditional gender roles are still represented. The equality or rather attack on traditional roles started many decades prior but for example it's the left-wing who has attacked the boy scouts. It's the same reason that homelessness is in vast majority men, but the vast majority of homeless shelters are women's only. >Our media, institutions and public leadership have failed to address this crisis, framing boys and men as the problem themselves rather than as people requiring help. This is intentionally being done by those groups. Hard to address the crisis that they themselves are intentionally creating. >Resources that keep families together when they want to stay together, such as marriage counseling, should be subsidized by the government — a much more cost-efficient approach than dealing with the downstream effects. What's more important. This isn't zero-sum, women benefit from men being strong. >On a cultural level, we must stop defining masculinity as necessarily toxic and start promoting positive masculinity. Strong, healthy, fulfilled men are more likely to treat women well. This was intentionally done and in fact, it's trending in a worse direction. This is about to get worse before it gets better. >The above is, of course, a prodigious undertaking. But I see the need around me all the time. Toxic masculinity isnt a thing on the right-wing. When the left-wing says 'toxic masculinity' the right-wing rolls its eyes. He sees this around him all the time because of where he stands politically. If you're interested in some right-wing positions on this subject. https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2019/01/the_lefts_war_against_white_males.html https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2019/01/the_lefts_w... https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2018/01/why_leftists_hate_masculinity.html https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2018/01/why_leftist... https://mises.org/library/marxism-and-manipulation-man https://mises.org/library/marxism-and-manipulation-man Oh and if Yang continues this push. We shall never hear from him again.
- darkr 5y agoWhilst there may be a few nuggets of truth buried somewhere in this cynical mine for male votes, this is pretty low even for Andrew Yang.
- trabant00 5y agoI pitty todays boys. The entire world from school to internet has something against being playfull, hyper active, agressively competitive, and all the other things that boys are by nature. One fight and here comes therapy and even meds. I would be crucified for what I did as a youth even though nobody got hurt and I turned out to be a top 1% productive member of society. Today being a docile beast of burden is the only acceptable option. If not completely in practice at least ideologically. Most comply but increasingly more choose to opt out of society or worse: become hypocrits and schemers that comply in appearence but cross any boundary in secret practice. If most rules are stupid they might all be. Rational conclusion for a boy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimmyjazz14 5y agoabsolutely agree I would say that rough sports games and even fights were pretty important to my growth as a child. I've tried to figure out what exactly I got from that kind of stuff as a child but I think its just kinda how males bonded back then.
- ytwombly 5y agoUS-based cis-hetero white man here. The data reinforce the impression you get glancing at the headlines or spending a day out anywhere in America observing other men. Dare I say it even reinforces what I know from painful firsthand experience as a man, at the lowest points in my life. I was lucky though, with a supportive family who helped me through the confusing years of early adulthood. You can point to the decline of organized religion and with it traditional gender roles, but then what explains the relative stability in post-Christian Europe? The China Shock combined with America's threadbare social safety net starts looking more salient. We have inherited a much less trusting, much more alienated society than you are likely to find overseas. Whatever the cause I fully reject the lazy conclusion this is somehow women's fault. The "Lump of Labor" fallacy is just that, a fallacy. Economic gains are not zero-sum.
- skinkestek 5y ago> Whatever the cause I fully reject the lazy conclusion this is somehow women's fault. Of course! The problem is not women! The problem is media, schools, companies, everyone buying into this in a collective delusion. Men also think this, but unlike women we are even encouraged to strengthen these insane ideas that we are somehow inferior (gets imprisoned more often, less academic success despite supposedly being extremely privileged.)
- adriand 5y agoRight. It’s our fault, that is, men’s. We live in a society in which we we have disproportionately had the power. And this is the result. But I don’t think it’s really a gender thing, I think it’s a power and money thing. That is, I don’t think mainly white, rich and powerful men set out to disadvantage other men. I think they were more focused on advantaging themselves to the exclusion of everyone else. What I find interesting isn’t so much why men are doing poorly. Why are women doing better in certain areas? Although progress has been made towards institutional equity, men still have the advantage in most places. Why are women succeeding despite that?
- _ktx2 5y ago
- pc86 5y agoIs there a generational thing that causes people to say "data is" vs. "data are" in this context? Because to me "data are" sounds so egregiously wrong it takes me seconds to focus on anything else.
- humanrebar 5y agoThe singular is datum, technically. Though real pedants will also point out that the plural of octopus is octopodes.
- analog31 5y agoI once wrote an article and the editor changed all "data are" to "data is." I asked her if I was being old fashioned and she said yes.
- wahern 5y ago> I asked her if I was being old fashioned and she said yes. Google Ngram seems to agree: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=data+is%2Cdata+are&year_start=1900&year_end=2009&corpus=0&smoothing=3 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=data+is%2Cdata...
- layoric 5y agoI get stuck on it as well, I'm probably wrong but to me "data" is the collective noun like "team" or "family". This is why I think it sounds wrong to use "Data are" when it is being used as the singular, eg the "data" being clear. If the data was unclear or split you would usually use something else to contextualize the difference. Eg, the time-series data disagrees with our event data.
- ask_b123 5y agoIt also took me a few seconds to focus on something else, but not because it sounded egregiously wrong but because it sounded quite cool. Like something you'd find in a bit-sized "fun fact"... "Did you know that data is the plural form of datum and [...]?" and so on :)
- astrange 5y ago
- amriksohata 5y agoEveryone is just a commodity in the Kali yuga
- errcorrectcode 5y ago
- urthor 5y agoThe Bay Area is a skewed microcosm of transplanted misfits. I'm not sure this is a great surprise to anyone. But the Bay Area is filled with people who: 1) Move cross country to live in the most bohemian region in the entire United States (San Francisco). 2) Often pursue a technology profession. An industry which has an entire nation of career guidance counselors steering introverts to work in. 3) Sticks with it when remote work lets them move home, at little cost. New York also has major "self-selection" for its inhabitants (wannabe high functioning alcoholics). It's not necessarily a bad place. But I wouldn't treat is as a fair and balanced cross section of humanity. Yang's article is a far more national/global perspective.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe people drawn to these places tend to be materialistic as well. People dump their social connections to move, in pursuit of wealth. Not going to be the best people socially, on average.
- TrainedMonkey 5y ago> wannabe high functioning alcoholics Heh, now I really want you to characterize LA, Vegas, Seattle, and Miami inhabitants in one sentence.
- urthor 5y agoLA: Spent about two weeks in LA, don't remember having any significantly deep and meaningful conversations. They're probably all stuck in traffic. Seattle: people are just like Europeans. Except Europeans have excellent food and are great company as soon as you pump some liquor into them. In Europe fun time = alcohol time. This rule is observed very strictly. Seattle manages to be glum post-ethanol. Miami: Why would I go to Miami?
- dang 5y ago
- e2e4 5y agohttps://archive.is/zl0O6 https://archive.is/zl0O6
- nojs 5y agoThere used to be a “web” link in the header that gave you a Google referrer for paywalled articles like this, has it been removed?
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y agoI don't see how we'll be able to make people care about this issue at the current zenith of The Future Is Female zeitgeist in the West. Given the current cultural and moral fashions, I can't think of many things that would be harder to empathize with than the laments of straight working-age men. There are so many more groups that are higher on the oppression totem pole that there's no way anybody will ever make it far enough down to care about boys. People have been sounding those alarms for years to perfectly deaf ears, and there's nothing in the current culture that would indicate that we are ready to start listening anytime soon. Nobody cares, and help is not coming.
- azhu 5y agoI feel you bro. I've felt that same way and I have empathy. You have solid points and a valid perspective. You could also really use an attitude adjustment. We're here as a society because of mishandled social responsibility. Women have only started to take up their own personal care because they can't rely on established conventions any more. We as individuals likely have not done much, if anything, to contribute to this social circumstance. Just like women as individuals have not done much, if anything, to contribute to it. It is none of our faults. Yet they are taking personal responsibility for their wellbeing in this situation anyways. They are "manning up". Men on the other hand... are we just sitting around crying with our thumbs up our asses? Yes. Yes we are. That shit is weak. That perspective on the situation is what's hard to empathize with, not the situation itself. Change your attitude, take personal responsibility, and bask as love and empathy showers onto you. We can do better than looking to others to solve our problems for us. It just takes seeing an example of how. They are in short order, but they exist if you dig hard enough. I encourage any men who resonate with this to dig deeper. There is sweet sweet fruit to be had if you do. And tons of pussy.
- scarmig 5y ago"Taking personal responsibility" is always an option, and it's usually the best option in terms of maximizing personal wellbeing. At the same time, it's important to recognize the social forces that constrain different groups and limit the power that personal agency can exert over outcomes. The masculine gender role is extremely narrow, and if you deviate much from it, society will punish you: so-called "personal responsibility" plays the role of telling men to shut up and fit their role. As a man seeking a female partner, if I want to be a homemaker who teaches belly dance part time, I'm going to be in for a really hard time, no matter how much personal agency I embrace. That also ignores the shittiness that even people who do manage to fit neatly into the masculine gender role still have to experience. It's worth calling out these things in the hopes of driving social change, and it's something both men and women must participate in if we want to see a change.
- wolverine876 5y ago> On a cultural level, we must stop defining masculinity as necessarily toxic and start promoting positive masculinity. There is no need to tell people how to behave 'on a cultural level'. It has nothing to do with anything other than some people trying to impose their beliefs on everyeone else.
- throwaway212135 5y agoWho are you to define what masculinity is positive or negative? You are playing right into this narrative that masculinity is toxic.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhere did I define anything?
- Animats 5y agoSome people say a man is made outta mud A poor man's made outta muscle and blood Muscle and blood and skin and bones A mind that's a-weak and a back that's strong "Sixteen Tons", Tennessee Ernie Ford There are few Real Men jobs like that any more.
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoHow can civilization cope with the fact that those jobs might never come back? A cognitive surplus [1] can be dumped into projects like Wikipedia, but where does the physical surplus go? Supposing we are omnipotent deities who want to make people happy and free and avoid unrest. Encourage people to build henges and pyramids for the hell of it? We can't pay them to do that without a global welfare system... Russia would just race us to the bottom. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_Surplus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_Surplus
- Animats 5y agoHow can civilization cope with the fact that those jobs might never come back? Don't know. It's the underlying cause of much of the unrest in the US.
- nicbou 5y agoStrap a GPS on their back and have the surplus go to OpenSteetMap. Or give them a bin bag and have them clean their environment. Or fix bicycles. Or volunteer. I have a lot of time on my hands, and I always find ways to use it. However I suspect that most modern men don't enjoy such a privilege. They're just as busy as they ever were.
- orik 5y agoHopefully not “another day over and deeper in debt / I owe my soul to the company store”. Great song though
- AussieWog93 5y agoNot disagreeing with the main point of this article (boys are struggling), but I don't think men's losses have been women's gains. (I'm aware this wasn't stated in the article, but this type of article invariably brings up "Men vs. Women" debates in a way that ignores how intertwined our successes and failures are.) Rather, the pissing up the wall of men's potential in the name of "equality" has made life more arduous, stressful and anxiety-inducing for everyone.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- su6652 5y agoThe only problem I see if that white, straight men are far more likely to be armed and use violence in response to their perceived plight. If I had to pick one group to not be subject to declining economic and romantic opportunities, it would be straight, white men, but only out of fear.
- nervlord 5y agoWhat absolute rubbish. White males commit much much less crime per capita than Hispanic or black males. Fbi statistics demonstrate that with absolute clarity. It's been the case forever and has actually gotten Worse since the 1960s so please spare me your systemic racism argument. How is the country more racist now than the 1960s? You are a bigot with no empathy and hate in your heart. Please grow as a person.
- pl0x 5y agoI am a trans but seeing the attack on cis-hetero men in the last few years is jaw dropping.
- ReactiveJelly 5y ago> we must stop defining masculinity as necessarily toxic I know "toxic masculinity" is a dumb academic term that never should have become a slogan, but Andrew, Mr. Yang, that's not what it means. It's like "async functions". Not all functions are async. It's okay if a function is sync. Adjectives modify nouns to make them refer to a specific subset. It's fine to be masculine. I don't know what it means to be masculine (are monster trucks masculine? I like them anyway), but if it's safe, sane, and consensual, it's fine to be very very masculine and I support boys being masculine.
- cperciva 5y agoThere's a difference between "toxic masculinity" and "asynchronous functions". Asynchronous functions are still functions, but there's nothing masculine about "toxic masculinity".
- antisthenes 5y agoYou're right. It's a little hard to dehumanize a societal cohort by name-calling them with "asynchronous functions". It just doesn't roll off the tongue.
- Spivak 5y agoToxic masculinity is literally masculine behaviors that end up harming the doer or the people around them — that’s why it’s called toxic. If you think it’s too politically charged then unhealthy masculinity is fine too. Toxic masculinity is not solely men’s fault. It’s a systematic issue that is perpetuated by everyone. Unhealthy independence is a good example. From the individual it’s “I don’t need anyone”, refusing help, and not forming connections. The worst manifestation of this is having to literally fight the men in my life to see a doctor for like glaringly obvious issues. It’s infuriating how many guys see it as emasculating. But from society it’s “glad to hear, because we’re not gonna offer you any help”, make you out to be a failure if you dare ask, and all media portrayal is going to make macho lone wolf archetypes seem cool and something you should strive for.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- somewhereoutth 5y agoThe bakery has lots of bread today. Bread is very tasty! The bakery has lots of bread rolls today. Bread rolls are very tasty!
- 3minus1 5y agoRegarding manufacturing jobs I really loved this freakonomics podcast[1] > Interviewer: Ah, the lovely language of economics once again. “Costlessly reallocate to their next best opportunity,” meaning that some American who loses his manufacturing job just hops over to the next good job, which just happens to be available, near where he’s already living, and for which he just happens to be perfectly qualified for… > Economist: That’s not what we see. We see those falls in manufacturing employment correspond to about equally large falls in overall employment rates over the first 10 years in those trade-impacted locations. So every half a point that manufacturing falls, we see a total decline of about a half a point. So some people are leaving the labor market, some people are going into unemployment. Some people are going on to disability. And so the reallocation process seems to be slow, frictional, and scarring. [1]https://freakonomics.com/podcast/did-china-eat-americas-jobs/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/did-china-eat-americas-jobs...
- rdtwo 5y agoWell if your looser your job will your wife and kids follow you to the next one? Mine probably won’t so what do I do? Live alone and send money home or do I hop Between low wage jobs?
- snowgrove 5y agoIt gets bad. In Janesville, Wisconsin when the GM plant closed: >The fabric of hundreds of families unravels, as an itinerant class of fathers — “Janesville Gypsies,” they call themselves — start commuting to G.M. factories in Texas, Indiana and Kansas, just so they can maintain their wage of $28 an hour. Those who stay home invariably see their paychecks shrink drastically. One of the men Goldstein follows, Jerad Whiteaker, cycles through a series of unsatisfying, low-paying jobs, finally settling in one that pays less than half his former wage and offers no health insurance. His twin teenage girls — to whom I’d also like to send awed notes — share five jobs between them, earning so much money for their family that they compromise their eligibility for student loans. https://www.reddit.com/r/Foodforthought/comments/67lg2q/in_janesville_when_the_gm_plant_closed_havoc/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Foodforthought/comments/67lg2q/in_j...
- joshthecynic 5y ago
- supergirl 5y agowe'll fix all these gender inequality problems once parents stop making such a big deal about gender. girls are not respected because they are raised to be shiny princesses with no real power while boys often have violence issue as in the article because they are raised to be "tough". the parents need to fix this because it starts from day 1
- rpmisms 5y agoThis is so hilariously wrong. Let's dig in to why: > we'll fix all these gender inequality problems once parents stop making such a big deal about gender Citation needed. Gender matters. It's possibly the most fundamental component of the ego. Different genders react differently to stimuli. > girls are not respected because they are raised to be shiny princesses with no real power Massive, massive generalization here. Girls are respected (among men, which I assume is your grievance) when they show up and work hard. My wife was raised in an ultratraditional Christian environment, wasn't allowed to wear pants until she was 18, and had to wear a headscarf whenever she left the house. Talk about taking someone's agency. She's the blue-collar worker between the two of us, and she's well-respected at her job because she puts in the work and is helpful. > boys often have violence issue as in the article because they are raised to be "tough" You need to hear this: boys tend to be more violent. That's what testosterone does. It raises aggression, lowers empathy, and lowers agreeableness. This is normal, boys fight. This is where the phrase "boys will be boys" comes from—not rape apology. Boys have anger issues at a higher rate than girls, but oddly, it happens more when they don't have a good father figure, one who will teach them how to bottle it up when it needs to be bottled up. I'm sick and tired of women with no experience of being male trying to tell men how we should deal with our emotions. Sometimes, being raised to be "tough", as you so eloquently put it, is absolutely necessary.
- fooblitzky 5y agoI'm a mid-30's white male. While I agree that large numbers of males unemployed, failing in education, not going to college etc is bad for society, it's uncomfortable to read a call for more funding for the purpose of helping men succeed. Women are still paid less than men, and hold fewer positions of power in politics or business. They still far outnumber men as victims of sexual assault. They are still expected to carry the burden of unpaid domestic work and care. If women as a whole are achieving more than men, despite the disadvantages they still suffer, then good on them. That funding should be going towards educating men so that women can walk down a street at night without a completely reasonable fear of violence. The tone of the article comes off uncomfortably close to the whole incel thing.
- hall0ween 5y agoI hear what you are saying, and I believe you are correct under the perspective I assume you are taking. That said, I would propose to you to start thinking of men (and importantly boys) in smaller groups than by those of age and race: a significant portion of men/boys are not involved in the achievements you noted, and are not doing well at all. One area I think this is evident is mass shootings in US schools: primarily carried out by boys, mainly white (oof, walked right into grouping by age and race). What is happening to boys to lead them down that path? Another area are deaths-from-despair [1] (the graph is from the UK*). What is leading men towards suicide? One more stat, violent deaths are, by a wide margin, mainly carried out by men on men [2]. What is driving men to be involved in violent deaths. Altogether, and I think you agree here, men are not doing well in important areas. Above is collection of red flags and calls for direct help. And the current public conversation revolves around balancing opportunities for women (which is necessary, good for society, and I give credit to those that have brought the subject to the fore). But men and boys need more as well, perhaps in different ways than wages, positions of powers, etc. (granted how much can be determined by income bracket). Homicidal boys are likely different from the ones that grew up in households of mental/emotional/financial/stability. And men dying by despair are likely different than those in positions of power or wealth. The crux of my argument is this: there is a difference between boys and men of wealth, power, and privilege. And ample attention by governments or communities should be offered, for a better overall society One last point, on the point of incels: what is happening to boys to create a large enough group for a label (and the ridicule) of incels? [1] https://archive.ph/xW50c https://archive.ph/xW50c [2] https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-and-analysis/global-study-on-homicide.html https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-and-analysis/global-stud...
- tonguez 5y ago“ Not just coincidentally, “deaths of despair” — those caused by suicide, overdose and alcoholism — have surged to unprecedented levels among middle-aged men over the past 20 years.” The vast majority of those suicides are coming from a specific “ethnic category”. But if you say which one, it makes you a domestic terrorist. What is the motivation to live in a world where you’re not even allowed to talk about what’s happening to you? We are living in idiocracy. Up is down, the only morally righteous thing to do is to cheer on censorship and beg for Patriot Act 2.0, 3.0 etc to be passed. Agreeability wrt the decrees of big brother is the only virtue. If you don’t have kids you are going to die by getting abused by minimum wage nursing home employees who quite possibly have been brainwashed their entire lives by every large media company to believe that you are racist and evil because of your “ethnic category”. But if you get married, your wife can take everything from you, and big brother will lock you in a cage if you don't want to pay your ex wife to fuck some other guy in the house you bought that she now lives in. So why would an intelligent person get married? And yet what is the national conversation about? It’s only about how all straight men of a particular “ethnic category” are racist and evil and they all need to focus on giving more to people in other “ethnic categories”. It’s a complete nightmare to anyone with a brain. It has nothing to do with anything that is going to lead to a better future. Race-based ideologies are a dead end. And nothing ever gets better. Epstein gets arrested, assassinated, and you have to listen to talking heads on news say he committed suicide year after year even though everybody knows its not true.
- selfportrait 5y agoThis comment really takes you on a roller coaster. To mirror the title here, this comment is clear: this boy is not all right. Domestic terrorists? Social justice warrior nursing home staff? Patriot Act? Incel-oriented divorce court angst? Epstein? > And yet what is the national conversation about? It’s only about how all straight men of a particular “ethnic category” are racist and evil and they all need to focus on giving more to people in other “ethnic categories”. I just am never convinced by this reactionary argument when I hear it. The internet skews people’s perceptions of the world, and this comment is exemplary of it. These Twitter-fueled “culture war” distortions have not done us any favors. In the most polite way possible, I recommend you go outside once in a while.
- quickthrower2 5y agoI would guess this is yet another side effect of the rich gaining more and more power, controlling the government, the law, law enforcement, the money supply, and employment. It's not about men, but you can point at men as a group that suffer, simply because most people suffer, as the minority are rich. HN-ers, in terms of wealth, are probably hanging around either side of the event horizon.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noetic_techy 5y agoSorry WP, too little too late. I don't think the "mainstream" has fully caught on yet, but all those disaffected men are getting nothing from these empty "we see there's a problem" articles and empty half-acknowledgements, because the entire political and academic system is now fully aligned against them. Lots of men these days are all turning to Red Pill content online whether you agree or not because its the only counter to the "masculinity is toxic" narrative. You better hope that people like Jordan Peterson succeed because his message to men is way more centrist and reasonable (watered down some would say) then the Red Pill elites like Rollo Tomassi, Fresh and Fit, and anyone else in the Rule Zero crowd. I'm sure many of you will gasp in horror if you've never heard of or seen their content on youtube, but realize this IS the backlash and the pendulum swinging the other way. WP and outlets like it (I'm looking at you NYT) created this culture and now you have to live with the backlash. I actually think that the mainstream will catch on to this pretty soon and label it the new boogie man at some point but by then nobody will watch or read their content so it will be too little too late. Pretty soon the "all masculinity is toxic" crowd are going to find themselves labeled as the "uncool" crowd just as the religious evangelicals who were trying to censor south park back in the 90's were. And the pendulum swings... I'm homeschooling my own son to keep him sheltered from both sides crazyness and plan to teach him to be a reasonable centrist who doesn't get caught up in dogma.
- rpmisms 5y agoAnecdotally, Jordan Peterson didn't fix my mental health, but I had a good dad and a sense of direction growing up. He's seriously helped my friends who have absent or abusive fathers. Teaching men about their duties in society and to themselves is crucial.
- skinkestek 5y agoAnother anecdote: Jordan Peterson helped my brother too. Went from being raging mad at his family and others to start taking responsibility for his own life. I still disagree with him but we can now speak together.
- 5y ago
- spoonjim 5y agoThe biggest threat to men, and by consequence social stability and peace, is the rapidly increasing fraction of them who do not have sex. This is going to be a major risk to world peace.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoThis is a big chunk of what ISIS was about.
- fouc 5y ago> Many boys are thus often growing up raised by single mothers, the share more than doubling between 1980 and 2019, from 18 percent to 40 percent. This is surprising to me when the reduction in crime in NY in the 1980s/1990s is often attributed to allowing abortions, i.e. a reduction in single mothers.
- remarkEon 5y agoThe mechanism of action here is that a bunch of males who would otherwise exist and perpetrate crime ... don't exist.
- mcguire 5y ago"The data are clear. Boys are more than twice as likely as girls to be diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; are five times as likely to spend time in juvenile detention; and are less likely to finish high school." Sounds like a biological problem.
- kazinator 5y agoUnfortunately, this article takes it for granted that you must go to college to be anyone, and to have a good job: that no other activity or path through life has any value. That idea has itself done harm to several generations.
- RickJWagner 5y agoI'm generally conservative, but I find much of what Yang has written here agreeable. If we looked even farther and studied how many fatherless boys grow up to have legal problems (i.e. become incarcerated), the scope of the problem becomes even more alarming. Kudos to the author. I think the area is ripe for bipartisan study and hopefully constructive change.
- paulcole 5y ago[flagged]
- da39a3ee 5y agoInteresting: the 4th sentence shows Andrew Yang publicly acknowledging that many "ADHD" diagnoses are spurious, i.e. in those spurious cases it's just a fancy medical-sounding term for students who are struggling academically: > Boys and men across all regions and ethnic groups have been failing, both absolutely and relatively, for years. [...] The data are clear. Boys are more than twice as likely as girls to be diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder [...] I agree that the massive increase in the US and UK over the last 20 years in the use of medical jargon such as "dyslexia" and "ADHD" in high school educational contexts isn't a helpful strategy for society to be taking.
- klysm 5y agoThese spurious “cases” are also incredibly damaging to those who have a legitimate and innate case of ADHD that persists into adulthood. I also think Yang’s writing here doesn’t help on that front - there are lots of real people with a real disability that goes way beyond just a short attention span.
- dannykwells 5y agoThis is 100% true and is at the core of many issues in our world. But not something you hear discussed by current political leaders. Obama got it, not sure any leader since has.
- mbfg 5y agoI think a big part of the despair is the obvious difference between what children are taught is the american dream vs what the american reality is. We are told america is the best place on earth with all the doors open to you to be rich. That all other forms of government are flawed and we have excellence here everywhere you look. And then you look at reality and see something else. Sure there are pockets of excellence and the dream still lives in fits and starts, but for the general person, they are likely shut out from any real hope of this grand vision. You add in COVID and the lockdowns, and economic turmoil, and then people start realizing that the whole race is kind of pointless. I can be poor busting my butt at a crappy job i hate, or i can be poor moving in with family and being 'unproductive' (for some definition of societal unproductivity). Women, on the other hand, haven't been given the same advertising on the American dream that men have, which obviously is a terrible thing, but in this one sense probably helped them survive and prosper even when life sucks in a modern world. I'm supposing the sell-job of an equivalence of the 'american' dream in other countries is not nearly so commercial, and blaring. And so kids are likely not so shocked at the difference between expectations and reality. Throw in that many other countries are flat out better in many social structural ways, and i think that explains why, it's especially troubling in America.
- javajosh 5y ago>Women, on the other hand, haven't been given the same advertising on the American dream that men have There is a documentary, "Born Rich" [0]. It's interviews with the children of very rich people, done by one of their peers. I noticed that in the film there is stark difference between the girls and the boys: the girls were all well adjusted, enjoying their wealth, happy, satisfied, seemingly well-aware of their good fortune; but for ALL the boys wealth meant having a full-blown existential crisis. This is oblique support for your claim: the classic American dream for women results in being taken care of by a wealthy man in a nice house, maybe with kids, where even house duties become negligible if he's really rich. But men and boys are supposed to work, first at learning then finding something you like then getting good at it. Your work defines you in a very profound way - a profundity that is reflected in our last names. If you're a rich boy, it's like you've been denied an identity. (I recall one of the young men who, to save his sanity, disavowed his inheritance to take a job as an oil field worker. And he seemed the best adjusted of the boys.). 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_Rich_(2003_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_Rich_(2003_film)
- hungryforcodes 5y ago
- gotomgogo 5y ago
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoIf you really want an entertaining night, grab some wine and read this side-by-side with /r/femaledatingstrategy.
- ianai 5y agoYou’ve got to give people a way to live out their lives with some minimal amounts of dignity, self respect, and some basic life necessities like those. If they can’t find those they’ll turn to all the evils of humanity to obtain their semblances or numbness. Society was formed because it was better for all members than all members being left to do it all themselves. Fail to fulfill the basic needs of its members and those members lose their incentives to abide the social contract.
- dougmwne 5y agoI think you really get it. Once enough people find themselves on the outside of it, the social contract disintegrates. Has happened many times before.
- rank0 5y ago> Many boys are thus often growing up raised by single mothers, the share more than doubling between 1980 and 2019, from 18 percent to 40 percent. The study he sites at https://www.statista.com/statistics/276025/us-percentage-of-births-to-unmarried-women/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/276025/us-percentage-of-... is titled "Percentage of births to unmarried women in the United States from 1980 to 2019" I think it's quite dishonest to present this data as "2/5 men are raised without a father." I simply do not believe that claim. Maybe my perception of the country is detached from reality so please correct me if my intuition is wrong.
- MathCodeLove 5y agoInstead of stating "I dont believe that" how about you post some data to the contrary?
- rank0 5y agoSure. My data is the same study that Yang cites. Being born to an unmarried woman != raised fatherless.
- hjadal 5y agoI think they misinterpreted the statictics which they linked. According to a https://www.census.gov/newsroom/stories/single-parent-day.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/stories/single-parent-day.ht... it is 23%, assuming that the share between boys and girls is the same, which is still a lot but not 40%.
- rank0 5y agoYeah that's pretty rough at 23%. But still, I think it'd be a stretch to infer that all those children are being raised by one person. Many parents are divorced, but still actively participate in raising their child. Further, some of those 23% are bound to be temporary situations. My initial gut reaction to your link just says "whenever this census was conducted 23% of minors had only one adult in the house." Not trying to downplay the issue of single motherhood, but the statistics available just seem fuzzy.
- t-3 5y agoIt's strange to me that most of the comments here seem to be focused on gender relations rather than what the article was talking about - educational and occupational attainment. I don't think romantic aspirations have anything to do with why young men are not achieving. Rather, we have grown up in a fearful and repressive society, with 9/11 and the wars, 2008, Snowden, and now Covid. Many have grown up being drugged and told they are broken for behavior that was considered normal once. The broken economy that rewards only capital and resigns the rest to drudgery offers no incentive to participate or care. On top of all this, we are still expected to be "men" and never complain, never mention a feeling that isn't lust or grand ambition, and never show weakness. Faced with all this, why not drop out and find refuge in a bottle, pipe, or needle?
- native_samples 5y agoWell, partly it's because discussing that means discussing the causes, and the most robust claims out there about what's going on boil down to "it's the fault of female teachers". For example why are boys being diagnosed with ADHD so much more than girls, why are they on so many more drugs, well, supposedly it's because female teachers - who have very clear and proven biases towards girls - are much more likely to react to normal boyish energy by getting frustrated and being unable to handle it. So once the psychiatric world gave them this neat excuse-in-a-box that let them blame boys, and even better, an off switch for children, instead of learning how to handle boys they started just telling parents their children were neurotic and broken. A related issue is grading. Girls get better grades than boys. There's a neat experiment out there that appears to show this is caused by teachers having a built-in bias towards children of their own gender, but, the bias is much more extreme in women. This would be totally expected - feminism practically insists that female-female loyalty is a a moral virtue and to NOT give the sisters a helping hand makes you a bad woman. Women routinely discriminate in all sorts of ways against men and in favour of women, so much so that feminism is currently ripping itself apart through debates on whether trans women should be treated as women or not (often, for the purposes of allocating perks!). That it happens in education too is only to be expected. Until people start routinely classifying feminism as an unacceptable form of hatred, boys outcomes won't start improving. Going back to gender segregated schools might even help, although I'm a bit shocked to see myself typing that, because I never supported such schools before. It's just so unclear what can be done about these sorts of cultural problems except keeping vulnerable boys away from places where women can discriminate against them.
- antishatter 5y agoYeah well no shit, school is taught mostly by women in manners that reinforce attributes of young girls. Coupled with the constant assault on masculinity and this pressure to put women forward you get young men trapped in a system not built to their strengths. Then you add in progressive gibberish and here we are.
- TeeMassive 5y agoAs a F'ing "straight cis White male", here's my experience: WTF can I do? Work is sparse and obtaining one is never clear. Being stronger is not even an advantage now. Now I'm a programmer and now workers are in short supply but that was hell back in the days. In primary school a lot of female teachers would explicitly felicitate the "girls for being better than the boys" and give them privileges for being "better". School is clearly designed for girls. 8 hours on a chair listening patiently and being nice? Please. Most things that seems fun and worth doing are "dangerous for you and others". Lifting weights is "dangerous" Nothing to do except eating and playing video games (if any). When young, being strong, resilient and stoic is boring and even frowned upon. Being a victim or in a victim group is celebrated and pretty much the only way to get attention and getting ahead. Violence and insults are always bad, including rough and tumble play that could go "too far", but somehow girls will go for these kind of assholes. "Who hurt you? / You can't see because you're privileged (except for those with the proper ideological goggles) / You're angry, your emotions are invalid / You're mad because you can't get women" If you get abused nobody will believe you as a boy/man (we were explicitly told this by the social workers making speeches at school). If you get accused everybody will believe you are guilty as charged however. The dating market has been ruined by dating apps and OnlyFans. I'm in my 30s and it's getting easier, but man I wouldn't want to be a 20 years old guy in my parents' basement. Saving for having a house. Haha. There's a limit to the number of men ruined by family courts that you can see before simply giving up entirely on relationships and starting a family. As a personal anecdote, I have met and befriended a few Africans over the years. They more or less express the same concerns about their children growing up here and dating North-American women. They all tell me I should go in Africa, make great money and have "beautiful metis children in a traditional marriage". Somehow I'm tempted haha.
- dillondoyle 5y agoA lot of these grips are on you, not women or society. How has onlyfans ruined dating? Who said lifting weights is dangerous? It's very healthy even in old age! There is a HUGE amount of things to do besides eating and playing video games. Perhaps you lack the motivation or imagination to do literally anything else. No school has children sit for 8 hours at a time and any gender at almost any age would have a hard time having the patience to do that. Also implying that men can't go a whole 8 hours being nice? I'm not sure what you think is fun, but yeah if it's actually legitimately dangerous for others you shouldn't be doing it unless in an environment where everyone consents to it. In what situation - besides war - is violence good? + Insults, what function do those have and how will that help you live up this idea you have in your head of your role in society or get the partner you want? Perhaps it's the other ways around and it's your perception that's wrong and in fact most women aren't attracted to those behaviors. Yes it's wrong that men aren't believed and don't report abuse. It's also the exact same for women and other genders. But, there's a person for everyone, no matter how different or however they view gender roles. But yeah if you have strict, unchangeable views and behaviors that do not meld with the majority of potential partners you might have to go somewhere where women have less options and will settle for money/more stability. I for one am happy that people do not have to make those trade offs and get stuck with 'traditional marriage' as defined by the viewpoints above.
- asdffdsa 5y agoThe lack of emphasis, in both this and the article's comments section, about the cultural messaging we send boys is very alarming. As a kid, we were told to sit down and be quiet when all our psyche was limitless energy and activity. Now it seems like just slap on a medical addiction and drug young boys into inactivity. Girls on the other hand are told "you can do anything", "break the glass ceiling", and flourish in a social environment (which is good!). It's time we focus more on how do we appeal to boys, and how do we get the most potential out of them. The cultural messaging is "girl power" while the counterpart is "toxic masculinity". The great heroes of the past (even the present, see how Arnold Schwarzenegger was cut down for the affair with his maid) have been merely reduced to "misogynists" or "terrible fathers" rather than reflecting on both their merits and weaknesses. Liberal philosophy does not even try to understand what motivates and drives young men to success: it's building, exploring, and accomplishing. Instead it blindly assigns any flaw as a result of "toxic masculinity" while also ironically applying the same "toxic masculinity" it preaches against: "you need to grow up and get over yourself, things are so easy for men because we are in a patriarchy". And then when studies like the above are cited, we go around in the same circle: "men are so pathetic, they need to stop embracing toxic masculinity" while being blissfully unaware that we are the least "toxically masculine" that we've ever been in society, and yet men are suffering emotionally far more than they ever have in the past. Hint: it's the culture. We are driving innocent young men into depression, purposelessness, and masochism -- and it's shameful to see such a lack of care or empathy for it. Seriously, shame on everyone in this and the orginal article's comments that are pointing fingers and blaming this on men, rather than trying to root-cause why this is happening and working towards helping innocent young boys.
- jmeister 5y ago“We should raise boys like we raise girls.” — Gloria Steinem “—Boys are going from female-dominated home environments to female-dominated school environments, back to female-dominated home environments—where boys are being told to behave. —In our culture today, “boy energy” is at best not valued and at worse demonized.” https://ifstudies.org/blog/young-men-and-society-we-will-only-get-out-what-we-put-in https://ifstudies.org/blog/young-men-and-society-we-will-onl...
- 5y ago
- throwabaleofhay 5y agoI walked up around a local area recently. Most days I go for a walk, just to be outside, for silence, to keep a baseline level of fitness. I probably walk an average of 2-3km every day, sometimes no walk, sometimes a 16km walk. It's something that keeps me at least a little bit connected to life. On one of those walks recently I went across a bridge to a lake. There is a stream or river under the bridge, depends on your definition, its was about 30 foot wide but under one foot deep. It's a beautiful area, on the border of city and country. And it was quiet, peaceful, no people around. There was only 2 problems: a) while the water was shallow enough to not break my fall, the drop from the bridge was not high enough, and I would likely just break a bunch of bones and survive anyway b) I don't want to die. I am bitter, and I think I have a right to be bitter, even though I know it's not healthy or a smart thing to feel. But I _am_ bitter, because I was lied to.
- silent_cal 5y agoWhat was the lie?
- rilezg 5y agoPick your poison: Seeger: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9Zt0O2lyhk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9Zt0O2lyhk Cash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ppa__7ZLAU8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ppa__7ZLAU8 When a woman or other media-favored-identity (which can include gender, race, religion, different-abledness, or an intersection of several, changing day-to-day and year-to-year, and media source to media source) achieves great things, their status as a woman or favored-minority is highlighted alongside their achievements (I would say this is not a bad thing as maybe people sharing that identity will believe in themselves a bit more and be inspired to do great things). But when a man achieves success, their manness is certainly not highlighted. If the man is also a member of a media-favored-identity, then that will be highlighted. When was the last time you saw a headline: ‘First Man to [do thing]’? Instead, it would be ‘First Person to [do thing]’, or if someone else had already done that cool thing then it wouldn’t be a headline (unless it was like ‘first man to give birth to octuplets’, I can see that making the front page of the NYTimes). Also, as a society we celebrate woman-dominated professions such as teachers and nurses (very deserved imo, except for my 6th grade teacher), but, at least in the ‘liberal’ mainstream, there is no similar celebration of male-dominated professions (except when a media-favored-identity finds success at that profession and the media is like ‘breaking news! single-mother black woman Polly-Ann drives steel like a man’ [too much?]). Is it any surprise that those who identify as men are more likely to also identify with the political and intellectual movements that still glorify the man-identity (I would say the liberal mainstream also forgets about rural folks, with the same effect)? Example: many Republican-leaning outlets will celebrate those who work in our military, regardless of the soldier’s identity (well, maybe not regardless, but at least so long as they are a meat-and-potatoes sort of man). Maybe the answer is that we all ought to think of ourselves as people above all else. Maybe an achievement should be celebrated and highlighted equally no matter what sort of person you are, because it is no surprise that one sort of person is just as capable as a Man sort of person. I do not know the answer, but I would also say this: Did man-people have tens or hundreds or thousands of years of society saying that only man-people are capable of great achievements? Should we spend some time saying loud and clear that ‘yo, we got it wrong. not-man-people are also capable of great achievements’? But should we also hope towards a time where person-achievements are celebrated regardless of identity? Do we still have work to do before we get there? I would say yes. Looking forward, the media says automation will eat our jobs, from truck drivers (self-driving cars) to soldiers (self-shooting-missile-drones) to programmers (self-programming-program). If you listen close you can hear the clanging. The steam drill is a’coming for ya. But, man, watch Polly-Ann swing that hammer.
- pengaru 5y agoBased on the title I expected this to be about bisphenols and their detrimental effects on male fetus development. And now I'm left wondering how much of that effect actually contributes to what's being discussed in TFA. Underdeveloped males probably underperform in myriad ways.
- fnord123 5y agoData is now a mass noun in English. It should be "the data is clear". WaPo should update their style guide.
- pmarreck 5y agoWell, it can't be that we have to either support women OR men to the exclusion of the unsupported one. It cannot be a zero-sum game, no?
- sstoks 5y agoThis article feels tone deaf to me. Yes there's a real crisis going on that is impacting men. Let's make progress fixing it. But let's put more than one sentence towards the acknowledgement that the girls are not all right and have not been all right since the history of time. We need to fix things for both of them, not go on a disproportionate crusade to fix the world for boys. Perhaps we stop attributing as much as we do to "gender" and see how things start to improve? "Helping boys and men succeed should be a priority for all our society’s institutions. Schools that have succeeded in keeping boys on track should be expanded, by both increasing the number of students they serve and exporting their methods to other schools. Vocational education and opportunities should be redoubled; the nation’s public school system should start the process for early age groups, and apprenticeship programs should be supported by the federal government. Nonprofits helping boys and men — such as Big Brothers Big Sisters of America and the YMCA — should receive more investment." -- This whole paragraph is advocating for far more than we've done for women. We're still out here fighting for reproductive rights, the fairness in considering women when designing society, city planning, healthcare and pharmaceutical research studies, car safety tests. Let's put all of that on the agenda alongside Yang's plan to invest in institutions that better serve boys shall we? "we must stop defining masculinity as necessarily toxic" -- we're not defining masculinity as toxic. We're defining toxic masculinity as toxic. There's a difference. And boys have full agency to display healthy, positive masculinity instead of the toxic kind. "Here’s the simple truth I’ve heard from many men: We need to be needed. We imagine ourselves as builders, soldiers, workers, brothers — part of something bigger than ourselves. We deal with idleness terribly." -- Literally nobody is forcing men to be idle. And historically, men have had the least constraints imposed on them to do whatever they wanted to do. I imagine if a boy did not want to be idle today, they would have plenty of opportunity to not be. At least more than a girl typically has had.
- dusted 5y agoWow, imagine if this kind of comment followed every article focused on the fact that girls aren't alright _either_ (without even mentioning that boys aren't already with as much as a single sentence).
- 5y ago
- 02020202 5y ago
- phtrivier 5y ago> Here’s the simple truth I’ve heard from many men: We need to be needed. We imagine ourselves as builders, soldiers, workers, brothers — part of something bigger than ourselves. We deal with idleness terribly. Interesting to read that from a vocal proponent of UBI - which would, by design, allow people, including men, _not_ to get a job.
- helpfulmandrill 5y agoOn the contrary, UBI removes perverse anti-work incentives in means-tested benefits (the "if I get a job I'll lose my benefits and be no better off / barely better off" problem).
- dragonwriter 5y agoSometimes, given multiple means tested benefits with their own cliffs and clawbacks, materially worse off, not just no better off, because of outside income.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Interesting to read that from a vocal proponent of UBI - which would, by design, allow people, including men, _not_ to get a job. UBI replacing means tested support doesn't (unless benefit levels are also boosted) help people with no outside income, but it does make it easier to improve one’s condition by earning outside income. It enables people to work and benefit from that work compared to the status quo, it doesn't enable people not to work.
- jl2718 5y agoMen, especially if you are one of the outcasts, you should laugh at this. You don’t need any of the things promised by the path that has failed you. The correct move is to reject them before they reject you. Their world is crumbling, and yours is the Phoenix from their ashes. Doing things their way is giving up your one chance to live your life as the gift that was given to you. I don’t know what that is, but you’ll find it. I have seen that happen so many times, it’s certainty is only eclipsed by the ironclad guarantee of quiet despair that comes with living your life according to other people’s expectations. Even your judges are bored. Mostly I mean women, because you are biologically programmed to seek their approval, young and old alike. It doesn’t work. Live your life. Define your own values. Follow whatever interests you, and for no other reason. Really, seriously, it works. Of the people I grew up with, the only men of note today are the ones that dropped out, failed out, or otherwise lost their way and had to follow their own random path. And then, something miraculous happens, like a hobby website turns into an empire, or a car racing club turns into SpaceX, or an email list turns into a cryptocurrency, or even simpler, you like working outside with your buddies and you end up with a landscaping business. And you probably won’t know what that spark is yet, and that’s okay; you have a lot of time, as long as you don’t spend it on someone else. But if you do, wow, those years will disappear in your memory like you never even existed. I know only because I’ve done it both ways, probably poorly on all accounts, always trying to prove myself and shoulder way more responsibility for others than I could possibly bear. The opportunities I’ve passed up in exchange for self-imposed limitations were astonishing, like 11-digit market cap, and the guys that took them up were so casual and effortless about it, often not especially bright, sometimes remarkably not-so-bright, and certainly not disciplined, just unconcerned with anything else that might be considered a problem. It works, really. The neurotic achiever types that would be worried about all of those things in the article: unmarried staff engineers at some big company. I really wish that I could put names to the characters in this screed so that you would see exactly what I mean, maybe even get a little bit angry at the pressures you’ve succumbed to rather than pursuing self-actualization. One more thing. You don’t need any of the luxuries and conveniences that come with the elusive middle class lifestyle, and neither does a family, if you all practice extreme resourcefulness and overwhelming gratitude. The only thing you need is the right partner, maybe the most import decision of your life, especially in the avoidance of certain attitudes. You should have sympathy for the billionaire that lives in a toxic relationship, which is likely because they attract the worst. Imagine being one of the richest people on the planet, everybody wants to be you, but the person closest to you hates you, manipulates you, uses everything you have against you, and sometimes you think you’d rather be dead, but a lot of people depend on you to pretend that everything is great. Money only makes things worse. Practice gratitude also for the things you don’t have. Okay, enough of my soapbox. Thanks for reading.
- grvdrm 5y agoI commented elsewhere in the thread but wanted to add my own 2 cents. > Here’s the simple truth I’ve heard from many men: We need to be needed. We imagine ourselves as builders, soldiers, workers, brothers — part of something bigger than ourselves. Add: protectors This need is a very powerful piece of puzzle that is a man, IMO. It is, to me, completely inate, and something that emerges as you accumulate more of the traditional constructs of life: romantic partner, marriage, kid(s), dwelling. But it's also difficult to control and can cause unwelcome side effects like anxiety, tension with family, and etc. One solution: I can't recommend therapy enough for everyone out there, especially the guys reading through this thread. It doesn't need to be therapy because you think you have a problem. Just a session per week or every other week that gives you a place to export your feelings and emotions. I've talked with a therapist once a week for almost two months. It wasn't because I was feeling depressed about personal life or sad about a job. I just felt that it could help me balance some of the ups and downs in life, and it has accomplished EXACTLY that goal. Example: my therapist helped me better understand that some recent blood-boiling-level anxiety was caused by my desire to feel like the protector of my recently expanded (kid #2) family and desire to be the primary helper. Therapists help you unlock connections between things that currently bother you and your past and provide you with epiphany-like moments. Very difficult to produce those moments when your coping mechanism lives entirely in your own head.
- hiptobecubic 5y agoWe raise our kids using the same educational model that was in place back when we needed them to come out at 16, obedient and ready to work mindlessly screwing bolts onto cars for 8 hours a day, 6 days a week for 50 years. Yes if we take those children and cut them lose with no one to tell them what to do, they will be lost. I don't think the problem is that we aren't giving people busy work to do. It's that we're raising them to psychologically depend on it. My wife literally thought she was worthless as a person because she didn't have a job for a few years. It's kind of disgusting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]