28 ms·
Covid-19 may have killed nearly 3M in India, far more than official counts show
- rep_movsd 5y agoWow Look at China! 1000 people died on April 15th, 2020 and then not a single death. Imagine such an advanced country, we should all move there or adopt their form of government! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29873938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29873938
- rei_ayanami 5y agoYeah, communism for the win, we want more Tienanmen square stuff and concentration camps for certain minority groups.
- glogla 5y agoI think you missed the sarcasm.
- ceejayoz 5y agoEnough information leaks out of China that we can be fairly confident they at least don't have massive waves of deaths and overwhelmed hospitals. Totalitarian governments can do better in this sort of scenario, for a while. It's not a great trade-off 99.9% of the time, but there's a reason wars, disaster recovery, etc. tend to be fought by executive fiat rather than democratic decision making.
- codeflow2202 5y agoThe only source of their stats is the party. It's part of their politics to downplay the bad and show off the good. They have nothing to gain by showing to their population that they are weak in front of this pandemic.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe only source of statistics is the party, but that's not the only source of information. If the healthcare system was collapsing in China due to COVID megadeaths, we'd know.
- bagacrap 5y agoWhether the healthcare system "collapses" has to do with how hard it actually tries. We did get reports early on that the crematoriums were working far more than usual.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> We did get reports early on that the crematoriums were working far more than usual. That's precisely what I'm talking about, right? That information got out; the world was able to see information indicating a higher death toll that official numbers implied, despite attempts to keep it quiet.
- tzs 5y agoThere are only 22 countries that do not have diplomatic missions to China. The remaining countries have embassies, counsel general offices, and similar throughout China. Beijing has 172 embassies plus missions from the EU, African Union, Arab League, and the UN. 24 other cities throughout China have counsel general offices [1]. All of these have extensive contact with the local populations, and all of them have secure means of communication back to the home governments. There are a large number of foreigners from a wide variety of countries living in China for business reasons, or visiting China for business reasons, who have extensive contact with the local populations. The party might be able to control the domestic flow of information sufficiently to keep their own people in the dark, but for events with wide impact such as epidemics and pandemics they can't stop other governments from finding out through reports from all those foreigners. Conclusion: either China's death rates are actually quite low from COVID, or they are not and the other governments (including the US, all of the EU, Japan, Australia, Korea) know this but are keeping it secret themselves as are the numerous non-government workers who regular are in China. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_diplomatic_missions_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_diplomatic_missions_in...
- jacquesm 5y agoThis really should not be a surprise. There are many countries that have extremely low covid case counts and deaths compared to their population and development status. And even some of the developed countries get it terribly wrong, for instance, NL, where I live has a 50% gap between the official COVID deaths and the excess deaths taken over the same period (about 21000 officially, and about 40000 when looking at excess deaths). The government publications, debates and various websites all use the first number, only the CBS, the bureau for statistics uses the second.
- johnchristopher 5y agoLet's hope somehow all kind of numbers were recorded anyway (instead of only one kind reported in mass media) and we can get a better picture of what happened in coming years and start comparing impacts, costs, benefits, disadvantages of different covid policies.
- oblio 5y agoThey are recorded, as part of regular, normal statistics (cause of death, etc).
- Zigurd 5y agoNow that there are good updated numbers on excess deaths, that should be observed before saying, for example, that South Africa is not suffering much from omicron. There are some plausible reasons to think omicron is not as dangerous as Delta, but it remains very dangerous. The gap between official numbers and excess deaths means that, unfortunately, South Africa's numbers are not a reliable indicator. The Economist has a web page that tracks excess deaths. I'm sure there are others.
- logifail 5y ago> The Economist has a web page that tracks excess deaths. I'm sure there are others. EuroMOMO[0] is one everyone should take a look at. The "pooled number of deaths by age group" graphs I found thought-provoking, particularly the 0-14 years and 15-44 years graphs. [0] https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps
- reacharavindh 5y agoNot very surprised. An Indian expat living in NL, with parents living back home in India. My (retired, old) parents are afraid to get tested for COVID because they hear way too many incidents from their neighbourhood about “hospitals faking COVID test results just so that they can admit them for 4 days, administer expensive drugs, charge them some hefty bill, and send home”. As stupid as it sounds, I could not force my parents to go and wait in the line to get COVID test, after he says “I believe I don’t have COVID now. But if I go to the testing center that is so badly managed and understaffed where only people with obvious high level of COVID are brought to get official result, I will get COVID there!”. Say what you will, but if the basic trust in doctors and healthcare is lost, how would people get tested, and how can you trust any statistics from there?! I’m ashamed, stupefied and angry at the same time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 5y ago> hospitals faking COVID test results just so that they can admit them for 4 days, administer expensive drugs, charge them some hefty bill, and send home Why would hospitals admit someone who isn't actually in need of care? If you need hospital care for Covid, it's (almost exclusively) because you need supplemental oxygen, and that's something that's pretty hard to fake. Edit: the question is: how are these hospitalizations actually done practically. Are doctors faking diagnoses (e.g. hypoxia), convincing patients they need care, which they are persuaded to accept? Or are patients forcibly admitted without being asked?
- panini_tech 5y ago
- keskadale 5y ago> The analyses find that India’s cumulative COVID deaths by September 2021 were 6-7 times higher than reported officially. The officially reported number of Covid deaths are ~483k. So according to this analysis, the real number of deaths should be closer to 3.3 million.
- bigodbiel 5y agoFor >70% seroprevalence, with IFR 0.5 (best estimates pre-vaccination), and a population of 1.4 billion would still give around 5 million deaths. I would expect India’s IFR baseline to be lower than average western (younger population, low obesity), but surges would lead to healthcare collapse raising it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- christmm 5y ago
- rei_ayanami 5y agoOr... its being over reported in the west. US counts people who died with covid in the total number, maybe India is a bit more sensible in that regard.
- kmos17 5y agoThis is so easily disproved, just look at total deaths for the period. Where do you think they are coming from?
- mk81 5y ago
- everforward 5y agoDUIs are up, suicides are up, overdoses are up, and we keep putting off both routine and urgent medical procedures. There are people with cancer whose procedures are getting bumped because hospitals are full. There's a meaningful difference between "died from COVID", "died with COVID", and "died due to circumstances surrounding COVID". Our excess deaths are the sum of those 3 categories. I can tell you for a fact that "died from COVID" is not 100% of those excess deaths, because suicides and overdoses are up. I can't tell you what percentage are in each category, but this "all excess deaths are from COVID" idea is obviously untrue. The CDC data doesn't even agree with equating excess deaths to COVID deaths. [1] Note that they call out accidents and diabetes deaths increasing 15%. 1. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/podcasts/2022/20220107/20220107.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/podcasts/2022/20220107/20...
- FabHK 5y ago> suicides and overdoses are up Do you have reliable statistics on that? Quick ducking showed that suicide rates in the US rose during the 2010's, but it's hard to find more recent numbers. This article claims that suicide rates fell in 2020. https://edition.cnn.com/2021/11/03/health/suicide-rate-2020-us-cdc/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/11/03/health/suicide-rate-2020-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- evancoop 5y agoExcess deaths will need to become the standard statistic used to compare nations. Otherwise, we'll be debating "deaths FROM vs. deaths WITH COVID" and the differing statistical definitions from nation to nation. Moreover, is a death from lack of access to medical care due to the collapse of a medical system a COVID death? Is a death of despair from isolation and unemployment a COVID death? My sense is, when the pandemic is analyzed historically, "excess deaths" will be the only salient statistic in the literature.
- donkeyd 5y agoUnfortunately, it's still not a great comparison. Countries with lockdowns had less deaths from things like other illnesses, traffic accidents, et cetera.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoIt's still a better metric than some guy on science.com effectively saying "I feel this number should be much higher"
- lordnacho 5y agoThe point is to capture all those effects together. People who died in car crashes after 9/11 grounded all the planes have in some sense died from the terrorist attack, even though nothing at the scene suggests it. Same with covid, if someone dies from undiagnosed cancer due to lockdowns, they have been affected by covid in one way or another. That's what the "with or from" comment is about, we get past it by looking at the total effect.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Same with covid, if someone dies from undiagnosed cancer due to lockdowns, they have been affected by covid in one way or another. If a death would have been prevented by just not having lockdowns, then tallies that it's included in being high shouldn't be used to justify having lockdowns.
- 5y ago
- Aldipower 5y agoIndia: 3,000,000 / 1,300,000,000 = 0.002307692307692308 Of course a lot and too much. Germany: 120000 / 83000000 = 0.0014457831325301205 But why arguing with absolute non-comparable numbers without context? Click rate?
- cosenal 5y agoThe point of the article is how India cases are very under-reported. If it was just about officially reported death rate of the country normalized by population, as you did in your math, there wouldn't be an article at all.
- Aldipower 5y agoYes, I understand, my point is, why putting this absolute number into the article title?
- tgv 5y agoBecause it's a pretty high number. It shows that if an epidemic breaks out in an where it cannot be controlled, the toll is high. If Andorra would have denied the existence of COVID and refused to take measures, the numbers would be a bit lower.
- shagie 5y agoGermany has reported 114K deaths. India has only reported 484K deaths. There are other aspects to the underreporting of deaths - https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm5154 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm5154 > The analyses find that India’s cumulative COVID deaths by September 2021 were 6-7 times higher than reported officially. From back in June - https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/07/20/1018438334/indias-pandemic-death-toll-estimated-at-about-4-million-10-times-the-official-co https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/07/20/1018438... > The analysis, from the Center for Global Development, a think tank in Washington, D.C., looks at the number of "excess deaths" that occurred in India between January 2020 and June 2021 — in other words, how many more people died during that period than during a similar period of time in 2019 or other recent years. > Drawing death data from civil registries and other sources, the report came up with three estimates for undercounts. The conclusion is that between 3.4 and 4.7 million more people died in that pandemic period than would have been predicted. That's up to 10 times higher than the Indian government's official death toll of 414,482. The story isn't about the number of deaths itself but rather the underreporting of deaths. Another possible title would be "Covid-19 believed to be underreported by 6-10x in India" - though that fails to capture the sheer toll of the death and isn't as eye catching. There is nothing to compare it with in Germany (for example) because the number of unreported covid-19 deaths is likely very small in comparison to the totals.
- godmode2019 5y ago"He also focused on the large cities, where death rates may have been lower than in the countryside" Didn't the WHO estimate 120 million people would die in developing countries of hunger brought on by economic conditions of the pandemic. This seems to meet the criteria. They also said delta was much more deadly than alpha, 2021 being more deadly than 2020, ie hunger, malnutrition, my guess is 2022 will be more deadly than 2021. Due to the same reasons, mainly in the country side, poorer communities. The average age of registered people in India is 26, you should expect a low IFR in such a population living in a warm climate, with limited air conditioning - where you see summer spikes in Texas for example.
- rg111 5y agoI was seeing the image of the funeral pyres, and was thinking that this is the easiest way to make a body disappear. As 70-85% of Indians are Hindus and they burn their deceased, if someone wanted to count total number of deaths by dead bodies, they would not be able to. All bodies are gone.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoBirths and deaths are registered with the government. can't burn in the burning grounds unless a death certificate is produced
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoWell, there were stories of unburned bodies found floating in the rivers, there are many who couldn't afford the cremation. There's the official rule (registration needed) and the reality on the ground: insufficient government service coverage leading to undocumented births and deaths. Even China has a lot of undocumented births, because of the 1-child-policy: https://thediplomat.com/2015/03/chinas-hidden-children/ https://thediplomat.com/2015/03/chinas-hidden-children/ (IMO the accepted "legend" that there were a lot of abortions just demonized the Chinese, whether nefariously or on purpose)
- hnbad 5y agoYou can't just cremate a corpse by throwing it on some wood and pouring gasoline on it. Even proper cremation still leaves behind some "scrap" (of course medical devices and prosthetics, but also some bones can be very difficult to fully turn to ashes).
- nkoren 5y agoUnfortunately it's too easy to believe this. During the height of the delta wave, my old classmates from India were frantically sharing tips on our alumnae Whatsapp group on how to source ventilators for family members. Everybody had a parent, aunt, or uncle in the ICU. Many didn't make it. One classmate reported that in the space of a 2-week period, 10 members of his extended family had died. This is all anecdotal, but seems indicative of a situation that goes far far FAR beyond the official statistics.
- hnbad 5y agoI remember when I saw the first reports about Covid in India in 2020 locals on social media were suggesting that despite the reported mass deaths the unofficial numbers would likely be significantly higher because only people who actually made it to hospitals were counted and many people dying in rural/poorer areas (where tests or even medical care weren't widely available) were cremated without a diagnosis. I'm not at all surprised to see that this may still be the case now a year an a half later.
- hereforphone 5y agoOf course the daily stats aren't accurate. Not nearly so, I believe. Some nations have better capability for testing. Some nations have people wealthy enough to get tested or provide free testing, whereas others do not. In some places, knowledge of COVID-19 does not exist. Does / did anyone really believe that the USA is the leading the death count, when countries with more questionable infrastructure and huge populations like China and India exist?
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoChina has pretty good testing infrastructure that they use aggressively when any cases are found. Surely the residents of Xi’an are being swabbed every week now. But China is much more developed than India.
- hereforphone 5y agoDoes China have a motivation to be honest about their figures? Did they a year ago, or two years ago? Even if they're honest now, no doubt they were first hesitant once the cat (COVID-19 in this case) got out of the bag?
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoChina isn’t North Korea, there are plenty of information paths between China and the rest of the world that doesn’t go through the party. The party has motivation to be honest in so much that if they weren’t honest, it would be obvious very quickly that they weren’t tame they’d lose face. Back when COVID first came out, local officials on the ground were hesitant to bring attention to what they thought was a minor problem at the time. Even when the deaths began piling up, they were still trying to hide from the central government, and even then, plenty of information was leaking to the outside, everyone knew something was up even if they weren’t sure what it was. However, once the central government got involved, well, any chance of deception at the local level was off the table. The central government doesn’t really have a boss to hide things from, so in that case, things work out for transparency (but, ya, if they thought they could hide something, they would be tempted to for face reasons).
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoWe have a post like this every month. What incentive does the country have to under report COVID deaths? Get some glorious trophy from the west on its stellar COVID management? Save face with people and continue winning elections? The people don't blame the government for covid. Not to mention, the numbers are reported independently by the states, ruled by very different political parties.
- Jedd 5y ago> We have a post like this every month. I'm not sure that's true. And if it were to be true, I'm not sure how it speaks against the claims made in this article? > What incentive does the country have to under report COVID deaths? Get some glorious trophy from the west on its stellar COVID management? I don't think TFA is trying to establish what incentives an administration may have to try to demonstrate their administration was more effective than it actually was. (Though, having written that out loud ...) > Save face with people and continue winning elections? The people don't blame the government for covid. I admire your optimism regarding the passive objectivity of 'the people'. Generally, I'd expect a population (within any ersatz democracy) to evaluate the quality of its administrators based on their performance during a pandemic, and subsequently vote accordingly. > Not to mention, the numbers are reported independently by the states, ruled by very different political parties. How would you expect this to play out if every incumbent politician / political party in each state, was incentivised to downplay mortality rates from COVID19?
- mohanmcgeek 5y ago> And if it were to be true, I'm not sure how it speaks against the claims made in this article? I'm not sure how this somehow, every month, is "hacker" "news"
- toast0 5y ago> What incentive does the country have to under report COVID deaths? Get some glorious trophy from the west on its stellar COVID management? It's about incentives and costs at every level. If the person filling out the death paperwork writes covid, does that require more work than not writing covid (paperwork, cleaning, testing, etc)? Does it bring shame to their work, their colleagues or facility or community?
- formula_ninguna 5y agoAnd? What should an average person do with this knowledge -- "may have killed"? Get petrified once again and, of course, rush to get jabbed, or get a new booster? And then, of course, keep waiting for other scary news, and yet new solutions dictated by the governments and corrupted doctors, which will always involve jabs and boosters, and QR codes. What's the point in this kind of knowledge? Does it impove or harm your life? Compare the mortality rates of bubonic plague and covid, and see whether the latter is really dangerous for an average person.
- rhines 5y agoSame thing you do with knowledge of more people having died in anything, say "damn, that sucks" and continue living your life, unless you're in a position to do more than that. As for the mortality rates of bubonic plague and covid, it is quite a bit more sensible to be concerned about covid right now and want to avoid catching it.
- t_minus_4 5y agoClickbaity and really questionable science. The author did 0.1% sample survey of adults and asked about covid deaths in the family. I am sure a common man is no expert to tell if someone died of covid, or with covid or during covid - unless there is a medical report. I would not trust any conclusions of phone survey of such small size of general population. The paper would have more credibility if the looked at health records. I am just saying, this is hard problem and the authors of the paper did a very lousy job and with questionable standards.
- 101011 5y agoAny surveys of India are going to amount to a small sample size across the entire population - India is massive. Also, they're almost certainly undercounting the extremely poor, a very sizable group that is going to fall through the cracks no matter what standards you're trying to abide by. There's a reason the title says "may" - there's an acknowledgement of room for error here. The point is, India, in spite of their lack of adequate healthcare, are showing mortality rates well below other countries. I applaud the attempt to discern what the toll may truly be, flawed as it may be. I'm sure if it was as simple as looking at public health data then they wouldn't have spent the money calling people in a survey. I'm fine with people calling out error margins for research, but do you really have to say this is lousy clickbaity work?
- silentguy 5y agoDid you read the attached paper? Where did you find the 0.1% number and what do you mean by it? Do you mean that the sample size was 0.1% of Indian population? And, do you know what the minimum sample size should be for such study? Here is the attached paper: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(21)00746-5/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...
- jimbob45 5y agoAfter the Spanish Flu and now COVID-19, I think it's time we admit that deaths in a pandemic are fully susceptible to Goodhart's Law. It may be best if each country's number of deaths is kept under wraps until everything is over.
- 99_00 5y agoHigh-risk Covid gene more common in South Asians They say around 60% of people from South Asian backgrounds and 15% of people of European ancestry carry the high-risk version of the gene. They estimate the risky version of the gene is present in about 2% of people from African-Caribbean backgrounds and 1.8% of people of East Asian descent. https://www.bbc.com/news/health-59165157 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-59165157 I'm surprised how little press this study got. What is the explanation for the lack of coverage I'm missing?
- m33k44 5y agoIndia desperately needs a public institution like the NHS of the UK! Few years ago my father died of ILD(Interstitial Lung Disease), as per the doctors. I had my doubts about the diagnosis, but I had no where to go to for second opinion. There is a private hospital syndicate in every city of India; no hospital goes against other hospitals in the same city; they will cover each others back because most of the hospitals have the same "consulting doctors". They just loot the patient's relatives by prescribing same drug but from different manufacturer. And if they realise that the patient is going to die, then the family members are pressured to take the patient home or elsewhere, this is to avoid "death count" on their register. I was literally asked to take my father home the day he died suggesting that "take him home, we will provide the ambulance and he will die on the way home so it won't be on anyone of us!" The medicine profession in India is not just joke, it is inhumane and lacks any value for humanity. India should have looked at some of the European countries when setting up it's healthcare, education and news media policy. Unfortunately the country has copied verbatim everything in this regard from the US!
- llampx 5y agoThe value of life is negative in India, unfortunately.
- AlbertCory 5y ago"I think all governments want to downplay the degree of deaths” That is really unsupported. There is also the opposite desire, e.g. to justify unpopular covid control measures. Hospitals definitely have a financial incentive to classify any death "with covid" as a death "from covid."
- geodel 5y agoYeah, but is it surprising? Government would like to put only confirmed cases in covid death and non-confirmed ones in 'other' category. Media would like to put unconfirmed cause of death in covid category and hence the higher number. Somehow there is this assumption that higher number would lead to outrage and cause changes for the better healthcare infrastructure. I for one can't not agree that with current per capita income level and tax revenues an order of magnitude improvement in healthcare infra is possible.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoWe (US) are at 850k. No way India is doing better than us per capita. The Omicron new cases reported surge on worldometers is up to 800,000 new cases PER DAY, this is more than 300% higher than at any point in COVID ever. The death curves trail the new cases by a bit, so we'll see. But holy cow is something up. I really really hope Omicron has substantially less mortality.
- nsxwolf 5y agoWe seem not surprised that India could undercount millions of deaths, but my impression is that China's near-perfect suppression of all variants of the virus in their population of 1.4 billion is taken at face value. Is it not possible that China is also covering up their real death toll?
- rootsudo 5y agoOf course not, there's no incentive for China to lie. None at all, they first established the virus existence, where it came from and took appropriate action. What else do you expect? /s
- eldaisfish 5y agoThe Chinese state has the ability and means to do what few other countries can - lock down millions of people and mean a lockdown where people are confined to their homes. There are also millions of Chinese citizens outside china. If China were hiding millions of deaths, we would have heard about it.
- swagasaurus-rex 5y agoI've heard anecdotally by a Chinese immigrant that many people back home had family members that mysteriously didn't make it. Just the usual "Nothing to see here, move along" that's common to authoritarian regimes who would rather sweep things under the rug than admit failure.
- nsxwolf 5y agoI can accept their extreme methods could potentially suppress outbreaks. But could anything really work this well? And shouldn't it have a breaking point - at some point you run into something like omicron that spreads so quickly it has to overwhelm your ability to track and trace and you can't make testing supplies fast enough or hire people to police it fast enough. And if you're not being given good information, how does an overseas Chinese individual spot anything amiss? Their parent or grandparent dies in China. Well, that's not unusual in itself. It's only unusual if it is happening more frequently than it should, and if that information isn't being made available, how could they know? COVID is rampant in the United States, yet it doesn't seem like my friends parents and grandparents are dying at any particularly worrying rate - and yet overall, they absolutely are. If the data weren't there, it would be hard to notice anything were happening at all. You could lie to me and make me think supply chain issues were caused by something else, that my occasionally crowded local hospital was seeing a bad flu season, etc.
- rajeshp1986 5y agoIn rural places in India most deaths are not registered at all. There are no funeral and memorial services. Family members and neighbors get together and perform the last rituals without notifying the authorities in any way. The death is counted only when family approaches govt for death certificate which is needed for bank accounts, transferring real-estate or any other govt formalities that needs to be closed. It is hard to get the exact count of deaths with such an unorganized system. I don't deny govt conspiracy to lower the numbers but I think majority of deaths didn't even reach govt books.
- obelix74 5y agoI live in the Bay Area. I just visited my parents who caught Covid in November. Nobody wants to get tested in India. If you test positive, the local Government gets notified of it and they harass you. My father had GI issues so he was in the hospital for a week (and hated it), my Mom had mild symptoms. She had to get a doctor's note to stay home. Even then, multiple people harassed her at home ("we have to sanitize the home" - take money and throw random chemicals). I spent Christmas to Jan 7th in India. I carried a bunch of antigen tests and delayed my RT PCR tests till the last day. Did not leave home, just spent time with parents. In general, nobody cares about Covid in India anymore. Every family has lost one or more family members (my family lost 7) during Delta in April - July 2021, so there is a general resignation. The general Hindu / Indian resignation to karma kicks in and they have largely moved on. My parents felt comfortable doing antigen tests with me and not a RT PCR - and I don't blame them. I struggled quite a bit. Relied heavily on Gerson Duckbill N95 masks. Not surprised by these numbers at all.
- srean 5y agoI see many comments dissing corrupt doctors and hospitals. I think this is really unfair and demoralizing to the many in the medical profession who have been working in the middle of this crisis often at the cost of great personal sacrifices, showing up for yet another grueling long day of work, day after day, holding consultation sessions on youtube (https://www.youtube.com/c/drkkaggarwal https://www.youtube.com/c/drkkaggarwal) by finding slivers of time, even when they themselves are infected (more than once) and would eventually succumb, braving lynching and the attitude of the government that does little apart from vapid token gestures of flower showers and setting the brutality of the police force on medical students should they complain about their lot. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIrOLwQtwYo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIrOLwQtwYo Disclaimer: I am not in the medical profession