32 ms·
Pandora papers: biggest leak of offshore data exposes financial secrets of rich
- 1024core 5y agoI would much prefer that the ICIJ make the original raw data available. Right now we don't know what they have omitted from the data. ICIJ: stop being the gatekeepers.
- xojoc 5y agoPrevious leaks can be downloaded from here: https://offshoreleaks.icij.org/pages/database https://offshoreleaks.icij.org/pages/database So probably the Pandora Papers will be downloadable in the near future too.
- tpmx 5y agoThe database does not divulge raw documents or personal information en masse. It contains a great deal of information about company owners, proxies and intermediaries in secrecy jurisdictions, but it doesn’t disclose bank accounts, email exchanges and financial transactions contained in the documents.
- nojito 5y agoWhy would they release raw data? That would be a massive break of journalistic integrity.
- moffkalast 5y agoPeople still have journalistic integrity these days? Now that's a real joke.
- 1024core 5y agoWithout access to the raw data, you don't know what's being omitted. Say, for example, NK's Kim threatens the ICIJ journalists, and they remove any mention of his assets from their reporting. Who's to know? IMHO, releasing the raw data in its entirety protects the journalists; if you're the gatekeeper, you automatically become a target.
- nojito 5y agoThis is nonsensical. They are journalists not vigilante hackers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blobbers 5y agoNot loading for me. DOS? Or blocked by our friends above?
- erk__ 5y agoLoading fine for me so probably some routing issues
- marcodiego 5y agoELI5 please
- mplewis 5y agoHere's a link to an article which is a tidy summary of what the Pandora Papers are: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/03/pandora-papers-biggest-ever-leak-of-offshore-data-exposes-financial-secrets-of-rich-and-powerful https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/03/pandora-papers-...
- bloqs 5y ago[flagged]
- klyrs 5y ago"High school socialists" is unnecessary sneering at the community. I suspect you could express these opinions without such flamebait.
- bloqs 5y agoYou are right. It just feels like the worldliness and maturity is plummeting across the board, people deciding so brazenly and arrogantly that they know how the world should be ordered despite not even scratching the surface of adult life, all while making endless contradictions. The confidence or lack of upbringing/culture to curtail these impulses is what is so frustrating - it rots discussion as much as flaming does.
- hashimotonomora 5y agoThey are making it look bad or controversial, but offshore banking in itself is not wrong. They should concentrate on corruption at the source level. This report is worrying from a privacy perspective, looks like generalized blackmailing, and attempts to generate attention to ICIJ who benefits from it. Edit: please articulate why you disagree with my comment instead of downvoting, as this comment is on topic and downvoting should be reserved for irrelevant or offensive comments.
- young_unixer 5y agoThis is why Monero is the future. With Monero, anyone can hide as much money as they want, and transact with trusted parties without anyone knowing, and there's no practical way for any government or journalist to snoop on them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ostenning 5y agoMaybe, governments are on the offensive against privacy coins like Monero. I believe Australia outlawed it. I wouldn't be surprised if increasingly harsh penalties were imposed as their popularity grows
- Zircom 5y agoI was just reading today the IRS has an outstanding bounty of 625,000 for anyone that can find a privacy vulnerability in Monero, not that anyone is gonna sell it to the US Government for that little when you can get so much more on the dark net/black market
- moffkalast 5y agoThe thing about decentralized things though... they tend to be nigh impossible to effectively ban.
- tgv 5y agoAnother way to withhold money from the poor. Excellent thinking. What's next? A little execution every now and then to keep them under control?
- young_unixer 5y agoAnother way to protect your money from being stolen, yes. Having money is not violent, so I don't know why you bring up executions. The violent ones here are the governments.
- anonu 5y agoWhy is this going to change anything? As the article points out, people burned by the Panama papers just moved their business elsewhere. This is probably just the tip of the iceberg. If you want to solve anything just crack down on the tax havens themselves. Plus, it's as if the Treasury is not aware of all these dealings. You can't move USD between any institution in this world without the US Treasury knowing about it...
- sabujp 5y agotop sink is british virgin islands : https://www.businessinsider.com/tax-havens-for-millionaires-around-the-world-2019-11#1-british-virgin-islands-15 https://www.businessinsider.com/tax-havens-for-millionaires-...
- bawolff 5y agoI kind of hate how when its rich people, suddenly everyone is, if you did nothing wrong you have nothing to hide. So far all that's known is some bank accounts that are suspicious. That's a far cry from committing a crime. Yes it should be investigated further, but nobody has uncovered an actual crime yet.
- matkoniecz 5y agoIn general, I think that politicians are entitled to far less privacy. Especially for finances. Note that in many places at least some politicians are obligated to list their income, what they own etc. Which is made public. While for regular citizens such info is private. Even if somehow not strictly illegal, then Babiš part seems really suspicious if true. https://www.occrp.org/en/the-pandora-papers/anti-graft-czech-prime-minister-used-offshores-to-disguise-funds-for-french-chateau https://www.occrp.org/en/the-pandora-papers/anti-graft-czech... > Babiš has goaded rivals who have used offshore companies to evade public scrutiny. Shortly after the 2016 publication of the Panama Papers, based on a leak of offshore documents, he said: “I think everyone who does business knows that Panama is not exactly a territory where they do business transparently.” (...) > In 2009, Babiš sent 15 million euros to a shell company in the British Virgin Islands that had just been set up for him. That money appears to have been invested in the French Riviera, including a chateau just outside Cannes. But how it got there wasn’t straightforward.
- schmorptron 5y agoNah, I think it's fair that very rich people who can be suspected to be skipping taxes lose their right to privacy, at least financial privacy.
- input_sh 5y agoFor those wondering how this compares to Panama and Paradise Papers, those were leaks from mostly one company. This one includes 14 spread across many jurisdictions.
- beermonster 5y agoThank you. I was in fact wondering ! :)
- loufe 5y ago@dang could this and the other trending story from ICIJ be merged?
- EGreg 5y agoCan someone summarize the main strategies we should be aware of? Which ones can help the plebes?
- fallingknife 5y agoNone, of course. If any of these loopholes could be used by a significant fraction of the population, they would quickly be closed.
- loufe 5y agoCouldn't it just be a matter of scale? In order for the tax savings to outweigh the expensive consultant and account fees, you'd likely have to have a large sum of money to hide.
- ashtonkem 5y agoYes, that is usually the barrier to entry. My go to example is how the Bezos of the world fund their lifestyles by taking out low interest loans backed by their stocks. The loans are rolled forward continually and only paid off once they die. This avoids capital gains, which is higher than the loan interest. This technique is legal for anyone, but good luck convincing Goldman Sachs to loan you money based on 0.001% of Facebook’s outstanding shares. GP’s argument, I believe, is that if these techniques were usable by you and I they’d close the loop holes quickly. The reason why they’re not usable by the plebs is immaterial to the basic point. Tax code is very much a “rules for thee and not for me” area of the law.
- vmception 5y agoAnyone can get a loan against securities. That isnt special. Collateralized lending is very common such that its not newsworthy.
- fallingknife 5y agoThis is correct, but just wanted to point out that 0.001% of FB is worth about $10 million, so you could definitely get a loan on that.
- david_allison 5y ago502s. Is this mirrored?
- xojoc 5y agoIt loads fine for me.
- mathattack 5y agoI was ok on the main page. I got 502 when I went to the Secrecy Brokers section. Appropriate I guess.
- ta1234567890 5y ago504s here
- jumelles 5y agoThis is fascinating - but who decided to name them Pandora, Panama, and Paradise? Way too easy to mix them up.
- rescbr 5y agoParadise - "tax haven" is translated as "tax paradise" in many languages. Panama - well, Mossack Fonseca was in Panama.
- megous 5y ago...Papers Some alliteration fetish.
- VladimirGolovin 5y agoAlliteration makes the names more catchy.
- lordnacho 5y agoIt's time to have a big talk about transparency. Some of the people who defend the ultra-rich are also the ones who claim to be in favour of free markets. A small bit of economic orthodoxy is that for free markets to work, parties need to be informed (and externalities priced in, but that's another story). This is not just in terms of "this is the price of bananas" but also in terms of knowing eg what various salaries are, which businesses are profitable, etc. How can we have free markets when we don't even know who owns what? As for taxation, there needs to be an overhaul. Things need to be simpler, and I say this as someone who has used international tax advisors. There's no reason the tax guy's diagram of your business should be more complicated than your own diagram. Moving profits to other countries shouldn't be possible, or rather, it should be more fixed by the nature of the business than by the desires of the CFO. We simply hear too much about "selling IP rights" to subsidiaries and similar schemes that are clearly meant to lower tax rather than increase revenue. Granted some things will be legitimate, but it's important that some vague concept of fairness is adhered to. This again goes back to transparency. We invented corporations to help improve society, so we ought to know what kinds of things people are doing with them. Edit: Perhaps the way to see it is, if you say "we make money by selling coffees in the UK" you would expect that entity to report a tax structure that contains a bunch of coffee and UK related entries. Reporting to investors ought to mirror reporting to the taxman.
- dennis_jeeves 5y ago>A small bit of economic orthodoxy is that for free markets to work, parties need to be informed Free markets: my definition, almost complete lack of rules on how to trade, exchange information, barter etc. ( except bare minimum rules of protecting one's property, life etc. from direct harm)
- chiefalchemist 5y ago> How can we have free markets when we don't even know who owns what? Good point, but take a number. We can't have free markets because most "regulation" is set up to favor some side or the other. There isn't even and fair competition. What we have is government sanctioned winners (and losers). Before we get to who owns what, let's talk about how Uncle Sam can shamelessly put his thumb on the scale (read: bias and corruption) and too rarely be called out for doing so.
- EarlKing 5y agoLink currently returning 502 Bad Gateway. Probably should've wrapped this in an archive.is link.
- Melting_Harps 5y agoDone: https://t.co/JxKKwYqrtt?amp=1 https://t.co/JxKKwYqrtt?amp=1
- justinclift 5y agoNope, that just directs to the original article rather than a snapshot saved for posterity.
- dredmorbius 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20211003164029/https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/03/pandora-papers-biggest-ever-leak-of-offshore-data-exposes-financial-secrets-of-rich-and-powerful https://web.archive.org/web/20211003164029/https://www.thegu... https://archive.is/rwHBj https://archive.is/rwHBj
- au8er 5y agoI guess just like the Panama papers, leading journalists will be killed, investigations stop being reported in mainstream media, and the world goes quiet again with nothing changing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alexgmcm 5y agoAnd the Paradise Papers as well.. but who knows - third time lucky?
- edoceo 5y agoParadise Papers? I missed those, 2017 I guess. https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/
- sofixa 5y agoThere were politicians in Iceland, Spain, Ukraine who resigned. There were multiple criminal investigations, and convictions. There were no earth shattering mass arrests and government topplings, but it's unrealistic to expect such a thing.
- kzrdude 5y agoAnd the current US president has mentioned international tax treaties as an issue he wants progress on.
- nuclearnice3 5y agoAnd PM of Pakistan Nawaz Sharif was disqualified from office. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers_case
- Hokusai 5y agoThings happened: https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/five-years-later-panama-papers-still-having-a-big-impact/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/five-years... E.g. In Denmark, the country’s tax minister cited the Panama Papers to justify hiring hundreds of new employees to bolster the fight against tax fraud. It was high news and had consequences. There is much work to be done, but 'nothing changing' is not the case.
- xyzelement 5y agoOn superficial reading, this story conflates tax minimization with cases of corruption. Corruption means a politician becoming wealthy in an inappropriate way from their position of power. Even if they were to pay taxes this is still a huge negative for society. Wherhers it's the president of Azerbaijan or Nancy Pelosi, it's should rise to the level of criminal enrichment if properly investigated. On the flip side are people who made their money legitimately and employ legal strategies available to them to minimize their tax bill. I have a hard time moralizing this because we all do it. Be it writing off donations, using tax loss harvesting, holding on to investments just long enough to not trigger capital gains taxes, etc - we all use strategies available to us to pay no more tax that we have to. I would expect nothing else from a more wealthy person. I would be totally fine if society made moves to close loopholes but I can't blame people for leveraging loopholes that exist because we should all do that.
- vmception 5y agoThese stories always do that as it fulfills a fetish. But in any case, would your opinion change if the tax resident or provider wrote the tax law that got passed? In Mossack Fonsaco’s case that is what they did in a variety of island nations.
- xyzelement 5y agoI am not very familiar with this but on the surface what you describes sounds like corruption to me so yes very much against that.
- crispyambulance 5y ago> I would be totally fine if society made moves to close loopholes but I can't blame people for leveraging loopholes.. The first step in the right direction, then, is for people to become aware of these highly unsavory (but legal) practices. It's not going to be an easy fight. The kind of people that setup multiple shell companies to obfuscate the ownership of their assets have worked deliberately to extract wealth and game the system to a level that is unimaginable (at least for me before I heard about the related Panama Papers story that broke a couple years ago). Ultimately, as we approach a global society with insane levels of wealth inequality and where public infrastructure and social safety nets have started to come apart at the seams, it's imperative that these "loopholes" get closed. Otherwise, we're going to be revisiting Feudalism in 21st century western democracies. Sadly some people seem to want that. They see it as a kind of gilded age lords and their servants.
- jrexilius 5y agoHmm.. the article reads more like biased, sensationalism than unearthing some grand cosnpiracy. If there are some actual crimes mixed up in this they undercut the importance of those with foaming-at-the-mouth hype bits like "billionaire owns a $22mil home in france".. Are they saying it was purchased with tax payer money? or bribes? That is just one exmaple of the overwrought nature of the piece. I think they do justice a disservice by trying to imply (without explicitly calling _or_ substantiating) wrong-doing everywhere there may be wealth. Focus on the actual crimes..
- cblconfederate 5y agoYup, nothing to see here, taxes are for losers
- Wronnay 5y agoNormally they don't pay taxes on offshore havens - so what they are trying to say is that these leaders and billionaires don't pay taxes like us normal ppl.
- splix 5y agoBefore transferring the money to an offshore you earn them, which includes paying all of the taxes, like normal ppl. When you get money from the offshore (as dividends or whatever) you pay taxes on that income, like normal ppl. What happens with the money between these moments is different story though. Depends on how the money are spent. And to my understanding, if they used to buy a property, say in US, the offshore still pays the US property taxes.
- inovica 5y agoIn some respects, true, but that isn't always the case. Say you own a company in the UK which sells widgets, but you also own an offshore company that also sells widgets. If you are dealing with a Chinese company, you could use the offshore company to do the deal, paying little to no tax. The money then resides in the offshore company and has never gone through the UK - either as a business or personal. As an individual you could own a credit card that you use to spend in the UK, which goes back to the offshore company. In additional, the offshore company could buy property in the UK and no tax is paid. There are various other tricks and nuances that can be employed to help minimise tax paid - completely legally.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoAlternative coverage. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-58780465 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-58780465 https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/03/pandora-papers-biggest-ever-leak-of-offshore-data-exposes-financial-secrets-of-rich-and-powerful https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/03/pandora-papers-... https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/10/03/takeaways-pandora-papers/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/10/03/takeaways...
- verisimi 5y agoI'm cynical, but I think if the bbc, guardian and wapo are reporting on this, this is a controlled release.
- lysp 5y agoIt's similar with other leaks. It's shared amongst journalists worldwide who analyse it for a few weeks/months. Then they all release on the same day. It allows local coverage and doesn't give those mentioned a heads up.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoThis touches on something that HN readers should be quite familiar with. The immediate issue here in every case is not legality, ethics, morality, etc., it is privacy. As we can see demonstrated by this story, some folks do have things they want to hide. Tech employees supporting efforts to violate people's privacy at mass scale, collecting data about people to feed advertising-dependent business plans, and creating conditions for data breaches that leak personal information, please take note.
- miohtama 5y agoIt is always about balancing public, the interest of many, over private, the interest of one. When transaction size goes to millions and publicly funded politicians get involved, the public interest becomes more dominant. Especially if you have crooked deals like a friend of Putin buying a movie theater price under the market value, funded by a government loan.
- seibelj 5y agoSince the beginning of written history there have been taxes and there has been corruption. And people respond very strongly to financial incentives - notice how people drive out of their way to save a few pennies on gas. Now imagine you have millions or billions of dollars. You do not want to hand over 50% of your income to tax authorities, especially if a legal way exists not to. And if you make the current legal ways illegal, the money will just keep flowing to invented ways. There will never be a way to avoid this, unless you have a centralized AI super computer that cannot be manipulated by fallible humans watching everyone’s cash globally and enforcing strict rules. And that will never happen. Most of the Panama Papers revelations were not illegal behavior. This article says most of this is perfectly legal. I’m not sure what the scandal here is other than humans don’t want to give half their money away to the government.
- CyanBird 5y ago> There will never be a way to avoid this Yeah, there are no perfect solutions to the problem, yet that doesn't mean tat our current imperfect solutions don't work to deter and reduce it, if anything it shows that these imperfect solutions need to be expanded upon, not discarded due their inherent human imperfection
- seibelj 5y agoRather than playing the same failed whack-a-mole that has been attempted since the beginning of civilization, maybe we should try and keep taxes low, services more efficient, and have alternatives to government-provided services for features we want of society. You may feel better when taxes are changed / raised but they will fail to do what you intend.
- ur-whale 5y ago> maybe we should try and keep taxes low, services more efficient, and have alternatives to government-provided services for features we want of society. Yes, but the army of parasites whose livelihood depend on the inefficiencies you describe beg to differ, and do so most efficiently.
- xs 5y agoWhat I see here is tax evasion. But done in a roundabout legal loopholish kind of way. 1. Establish profitable company in your home country. 2. Establish 2nd company in a tax haven country. 3. Give 2nd company some kind of ownership, and then pay rental fees, licensing fees, or simply set up a high interest loan that the 2nd company loaned the first. 4. Once you set up a way to make it look like you owe the 2nd company tons of money, now your 1st company no longer is "profitable" and actually in debt losing money, which means it doesn't need to pay taxes on the massive profit it's making. While I believe it's legal it hinges on bad ethical practice. But many large companies do this, such as cruise ships and I think Apple.
- Iv 5y agoSeveral EU countries (France and UK) have, IIRC, made very clear that fictive debt or fictive licensing fees are fraud an would be judged as such.
- earnesti 5y agoHow can you say what is fictive and what not? Licensing fees and loans exist on market anyway.
- kemitche 5y agoThe existence of valid licensing fees does not mean all licensing fees are valid. Surgeons are allowed to legally cut people, that doesn't mean we can't figure out when someone was illegally stabbed. Let's not give up without even trying.
- burnished 5y ago"oh no, our publicly very profitable company actually doesn't make any money because of all the.. license fees we pay, that we are clearly in a position to bargain for better, yet mysteriously do not! oh its such a coincidence that everyone in the C-Suite still makes money off the the shell company." You can obfuscate fraud. But don't try that post-modern horseshit "what is being, man" on us.
- 5y ago
- trashtestcrash 5y agoSo where do we find the list of names by country?
- r721 5y ago>Of the more than 300 politicians and public officials unearthed in the PandoraPapers, we profiled more than 50 of the biggest names – and their secret offshore holdings — in the Power Players interactive. https://twitter.com/ICIJorg/status/1444703221558259714 https://twitter.com/ICIJorg/status/1444703221558259714 https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/power-players/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/power-pla...
- trashtestcrash 5y agoI guess we have to wait for the full list. There was a map with names from other countries than the 56ish shortlisted.
- miohtama 5y agoYes, it would be much more interesting to see the corruption of your local small and middle tier politicians.
- vmception 5y agoImagine the hubris necessary to think everyone has to store all their wealth in the country they were born in. These discussions assume people didn't pay taxes before purchasing assets elsewhere. Cute.
- jrexilius 5y agoIt also seems a foregone conclussion that if you are wealthy, you don't deserve privacy. Admittedly, some of that gets fuzzy if you run for a public office, but that isn't really the underlying notion being put forward here.
- seibelj 5y agoSince the beginning of written history there have been taxes and there has been corruption. And people respond very strongly to financial incentives - notice how people drive out of their way to save a few pennies on gas. Now imagine you have millions or billions of dollars. You do not want to hand over 50% of your income to tax authorities, especially if a legal way exists not to. And if you make the current legal ways illegal, the money will just keep flowing to invented ways. There will never be a way to avoid this, unless you have a centralized AI super computer that cannot be manipulated by fallible humans watching everyone’s cash globally and enforcing strict rules. And that will never happen. Most of the Panama Papers revelations were not illegal behavior. This article says most of this is perfectly legal. I’m not sure what the scandal here is other than humans don’t want to give half their money away to the government.
- Iv 5y agoThat's like saying murder should be legal as it is impossible to totally prevent it.
- seibelj 5y agoAnd now you are comparing tax evasion to murder! I would say there’s a difference. Otherwise we need to give the IRS execution abilities(?)
- jyscao 5y agoAmen. While far from being super wealthy, many if not most people on HN could probably benefit significantly from better tax planning on their own personal incomes.
- mandmandam 5y ago>many if not most people on HN could probably benefit significantly from better tax planning on their own personal incomes. Those people are comfortable, well into the top 10% of earners. And I think it's nice that they don't spend money hiring a slimeball tax accountant to help avoid paying their part to society. I think it's sick that there are people making 6 or 7 figures a year helping cunts to save 7 or 8 figures a year that should be going into schools and infrastructure, and it's even sicker that those people are looked up to because they drive nice cars and wear expensive suits. But that's not what these papers are about - they're about systematic secretive theft, from all society, on a massive scale. And this at a time when people are still dying from hunger and deprivation even in the richest countries.
- Wronnay 5y agoWhy do politicians send their money to offshore havens when they could reduce the tax in their own country? So that it doesn't affect their source of income? (The taxes we ordinary ppl pay)
- vnjxk 5y agoso they could keep pour money into whatever makes their voters happy
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y ago> Why do politicians send their money to offshore havens when they could reduce the tax in their own country? Maybe because the people actually want to tax the rich? And because the politicians who evade taxes don't intend to pay their fair share anyway?
- moffkalast 5y agoWhen has the will of the people ever effected what politicians do?
- lugu 5y agoHow do you know what the will of the people is?
- moffkalast 5y agoYou call for a referendum, and block all Murdoch media for a few months before it.
- odiroot 5y agoBy taxing one group of people you have the means to "buy" votes from other groups of people. Helps staying in power.
- lifty 5y agoMany of the fortunes you see in these leaks are illegally obtained through political favoritism.
- __turbobrew__ 5y agoIn Canada, shell companies -- run by the owner's lawyers -- can hold property and there is no way to trace the property back to the original owners. The courts have found that the lawyers cannot be compelled to divulge the property ownership under lawyer-client confidentiality. It is kind of insane that this is even allowed. How do you plan to tackle money laundering, corruption, and transparency when you cannot even figure out who owns the property in the first place?
- turbinerneiter 5y agoIf there is no owner to be found, it becomes government property. I think the owners would present themselves quickly. We let this happen. We don't have to.
- goatsi 5y agoAt least in BC a new law means that the Beneficial owner needs to be identified. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/housing-tenancy/real-estate-bc/land-owner-transparency-registry https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/housing-tenancy/real-esta...
- __turbobrew__ 5y agoWe will see if this will hold up in court. When the ultra rich are threatened you can bet that a long lawsuit will follow.
- Iv 5y agoIt is time to cut down the tax havens from international financial circuits.
- unreal37 5y agoThe United States is a tax haven. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/toddganos/2019/09/19/worlds-best-tax-haven-the-united-states/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/toddganos/2019/09/19/worlds-bes...
- piokoch 5y agoHow could you cut off City of London Corp from international financial circuits. Or the Netherlands, which is one big tax paradise even though it may seem it is not. Luxembourg? Don't think that tax heavens are some remote, distant islands governed by some petty lord. Taxation is really hard to enforce in the modern World. The biggest problem is that small, local companies cannot compete with big ones because they don't have resources to overcome taxation. For me it make sense more sense to abandon corporate tax at all and make sure that all the resources, public services that company uses in a given country are paid by the company. If company uses trucks, it should pay for roads, etc. I don't think that Facebook that operates from US and uses US resources and services should pay CIT tax in, say, France. If it uses internet infrastructure, just make Facebook to pay for it fair amount and that's all.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y ago>Taxation is really hard to enforce in the modern World. No, City of London only exists as it is, because the rest of the country let it do its thing and destroy the fabric of the society. It's not hard to enforce taxation when those who make the laws actually intend to have it enforced. Right now, those who write and enforce the law keep siding with those who evade taxes. Maybe we should change the people in power, and that is not that hard. The problem is that most media are owned by the ones who evades taxes, so the level of noise made these scandals remains under control.
- earnesti 5y agoJust ban them from using bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies and we should be fine.
- craigr1972 5y agoI want to know who exactly did this, on whose instructions, and why right now.
- throwawayay02 5y agoThe world needs more wikileaks and less ICIJs.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy? ICIJ did the work here.
- input_sh 5y agoNot to mention that the Panama Papers leaker did indeed contact Wikileaks and they've never responded. From the manifesto published afterwards: > The media has failed. Many news networks are cartoonish parodies of their former selves, individual billionaires appear to have taken up newspaper ownership as a hobby, limiting coverage of serious matters concerning the wealthy, and serious investigative journalists lack funding. The impact is real: in addition to Süddeutsche Zeitung and ICIJ, and despite explicit claims to the contrary, several major media outlets did have editors review documents from the Panama Papers. They chose not to cover them. The sad truth is that among the most prominent and capable media organizations in the world there was not a single one interested in reporting on the story. Even Wikileaks didn’t answer its tip line repeatedly. https://panamapapers.sueddeutsche.de/articles/572c897a5632a39742ed34ef/ https://panamapapers.sueddeutsche.de/articles/572c897a5632a3...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TechBro8615 5y agoThe website is unreadable on mobile.
- klyrs 5y agoReader mode fixed that for me
- I_am_tiberius 5y agoI don't understand why they release names of people who they also say did not do anything wrong.
- mygoodaccount 5y agoAnother leak that will have people "outraged" by aggressively upvoting and commenting on articles for two weeks. The news cycle will move on, the leakers will be car bombed [0], and these papers will be memoryholed. You can wait around for four years til a new set of old rich people get voted into power (maybe they'll be blue/red this time!!!!) and hope they get rid of the loopholes they all use. Maybe a couple more """revolutionary""" politicians will be elected who VERBALLY DISMANTLE AND DESTROY a couple billionaires in a senate hearing (OMG SO AWESOME!!!). Decide for yourself if you think anything will change. There does exist a great equalizer, but I won't mention it. I like staying unb&. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/16/malta-car-bomb-kills-panama-papers-journalist https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/16/malta-car-bomb...
- adflux 5y agoWhat's the equalizer? Revolution?
- esarbe 5y agoIn all honesty, that's the suitor they are toying with, isn't it? As long as they can squeeze some more profit out of the common people, there's no reason not to do it. (Just see how Amazon treats it's workers.) It's only when people are on the barricades that they will relent.
- culi 5y agohttps://www.britannica.com/topic/guillotine https://www.britannica.com/topic/guillotine (/s)
- petre 5y agoNo, justice. What currently happenes to Szarkozy. Of course, all of this happens in a country that guilotined their king and his wife, so the revolution helped a bit in that regard.
- namdnay 5y agoI really really wouldn’t take France as an example of how to deal with corrupt politicians. There’s an astounding complacency around corruption here, a politician in the US or UK wouldn’t have been able to get away with 1% of what Chirac or Juppé or Sarkozy got up to in the 80s-90s
- rich_sasha 5y agoI was very excited when Panama papers came out. Intrigued when Paradise papers leaked. But now? Damning evidence of outright crimes came out and nothing happened. In the UK IIRC it was found that David Cameron evaded some taxes via offshore funds, and? He said he’s very sorry and didn’t mean to, and that was it. Everyone knew before and after the rich don’t pay taxes. We don’t need more evidence, we need action.
- jl6 5y agoHe didn’t evade any taxes. He avoided taxes and did nothing illegal. Same story with a lot of these latest leaks. Immoral? Debatable. But the lack of action is because of the lack of a crime. The action should be to propose new legislation that changes what taxes are collected, where, and when. The main crimes exposed in these are money laundering rather than tax evasion.
- gentoo 5y ago> Immoral? Debatable. What is the argument that what they're doing is moral? How is anything about tax avoidance ethical?
- rsj_hn 5y ago> How is anything about tax avoidance ethical? This is a bit odd for two reasons. 1. Taking steps to minimize your taxes is neither ethical or unethical, it's just basic common sense. It's like choosing to buy the cheaper apple when you go to the store. The whole reason why we have sin taxes and tax breaks is because legislators believe that it influences behavior and so they create this byzantine tax code in order to try to manage behavior. I guess whether you believe contributing to your 401K or claiming the mortgage interest deduction is immoral depends on your ethical code. To me, this is a category error -- if you think financial management can either increase or decrease your morality then you have a very decadent (and broken) moral code. One can argue that such a complex tax code is bad policy, because it results in such a complex system that you need teams of lawyers to really understand it and take advantage of it, meaning that for ordinary people it's not worth it and the economy as a whole wastes far too much on tax professionals. But that never seems to stop anyone from clamoring for tax breaks for their pet cause. 2. The whole point of globalism as an enterprise is to support (and encourage) cross border capital flows. It is a system intended to allow foreigners purchasing up capital in the home country and home citizens doing the same overseas. These cross border capital flows finance trade deficits (without them, there would be no trade deficits). But different nations have very different tax codes so this encourages a race to the bottom. Much like outsourcing labor. This race to the bottom effect is not some secret that requires an expose, it is an intended feature of the system. Why I am shocked, shocked, that americans would invest their money in the jurisdiction that yields the greatest tax-adjusted return. Just shocked! This is why many people (such as myself) are opposed to globalism, but we are painted as silly xenophobes who don't want to eat French Brie. Well, OK, you wanted globalism -- this is globalism. And the only alternative to globalism is nationalism. Now one can make a claim that globalism as a value system is unethical and that only nationalism (or even better localism -- let each region have its own currency and borders and trade policy -- is ethical), but an individual who is stuck in a legal code that encourages and subsidizes globalism is not acting ethically or unethically when he buys a cheap TV from china, a car from Japan or sends his money to the Bahamas, as he is stuck with the tab of globalism (low interest rates, de-industrialization, political unrest, decline of solidarity, undermining of democracy, global financial crises) so he may as well enjoy the benefits -- access to the benefits of low wages in China and to the benefits of low taxes in the Bahamas. If you think one is unethical, then what about the other? And if you are being paid wages or earning returns determined by competition from the world, why not take advantage of cheap products and cheap taxes overseas? You cannot create your own private economic system just because you think the current one is a disaster. Bottom line, if you don't like this type of tax arbitrage, then put a stop to it by discouraging (taxing) cross border capital flows. It would also put a stop to outsourcing and cheap TVs as well, and you would be instantly painted as a nationalist trade-war fighting xenophobe, but this is how you solve the problem, not by appealing to people to "buy American" or "store their wealth" in America with some faux ethical argument. Appeals to personal virtue to pay more than is needed (whether for TVs or taxes) ring pretty hollow.
- WanderPanda 5y agoIf they don't release the raw data I suspect it will be mostly about left/right wing populism
- maybelsyrup 5y agoI've wondered a lot about this with the Snowden and Wikileaks stuff, and I wonder about it with this topic too: the most salient part of this story, and about Panama Papers etc. before it, is how small a dent it seems to make in the discourse, and in the world as a result. At best, these stories get a good chunk of the airwaves for a couple of weeks, and then it's on to the next thing. In history books, you get a sense sometimes that there were eras in which stuff like this sent people into the streets in rages. In which governments were voted out or overthrown, in which meaningful legislative responses were made. Or, you know, riots. But I look around after reading those books and wonder what makes us so different. It's weird to live in this era. I read a Guardian article like this and look at the staggering sums, this entire "shadow financial system" devoted solely to one notion: I'm going to take as much as I can, in whatever way that I can, regardless of legality, and I'm going to give nothing back because I sincerely don't believe I owe anything back -- oh, and I'm going to keep it all a secret. And I look around and not only don't see any riots; I sometimes get the feeling that people are actually envious, sometimes even respectful of the ingenuity it takes to manufacture these schemes. It's tough. The only silver lining I can think of is what all the secrecy says: we're not just doing this in the open because we're still afraid we'll end up like the Romanovs if too many of you get angry. I think that while they're still afraid, there's still some hope. EDIT: Reading some replies. It's weird to have to say this to such a smart crowd, but I'm not advocating riots as such; I'm advocating a substantive response. Of course riots are "bad" in some sense, but my observation is really about the odd contrast between the huge size of the "stimulus" (theft of wealth, much of it yours, on a staggering scale) and the tiny size of the "response" (newspaper articles and web forum discussions), especially when contrasted with other historical periods. So while I wouldn't "want a riot", seeing one would make me go "well, that makes sense".
- ztjio 5y agoI suggest you reconsider your position about nothing happening. Many people think nothing happened in response to the Panama Papers and those people are all wrong. https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/what-happened-after-the-panama-papers/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/what-happe...
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago
- TheChaplain 5y agoI don't mind people being filthy rich, but I'd rather see that they invest in their country instead of moving them off-shore. If I had such level of riches I'd invest in stocks, companies, research, properties etc.. I'm certain it would open more job opportunities.
- ur-whale 5y ago> they invest in their country Why? Their country might be a terrible place to invest in. Also: define what "their country" actually means. I think a much better take on this would be "I'd rather they invest their money in productive endeavors, that benefit society and/or humanity in general". On other words, I agree with your general sentiment (the money should be put to good use), but find the "their country" part completely weird.
- 8ytecoder 5y agoThey usually do. Even money parked in remote islands in companies end up as investment in their home countries. Except now with another layer to hide their identity and ability to dodge taxes.
- Hokusai 5y ago> I don't mind people being filthy rich You do not like that they move money offshore, and that is for a good reason, the super rich have so much resources that they can unilaterally distort the economy. The more concentrated the wealth the more fragile is the economy and the more is dependent on the mood of a few lucky people.
- helloguillecl 5y agoThe resources actually don't go anywhere. You can have deposits and investment in many countries owned by these shell companies. There are mostly used to conceal the actual owner of those assets, if nothing else.
- gremIin 5y agoWhy would they? In our global world, there is very little tying the rich to the countries they amassed their wealth in.
- esarbe 5y agoThis is so annoying. These people got rich by living in a society that gives them language, concepts, ideas, a rich foundation of knowledge to draw from, social stability. All this requires a social contract whose benefits they are willing to reap but whose costs they are quick to discard. I think the German constitution hat something the lines of "Eigentum verplichtet", roughly translated "property obliges". It's really a shame that these gentlepeople that benefited so much from a stable society are willing to go to such lengths to keep society from their fair share. And that they don't even have any immediate need for the wealth their are hiding is all the more frustrating. This is all done for the sake of a bigger number on a virtual accounting sheet, not because it is required to create anything of value. This money could instead to productive purposes; education, rehabilitation and reintegration of criminals, child care, rewilding of abandoned industrial wasteland, the list goes on an on and on. Instead it's hidden in the most convoluted financial constructs, all the while benefiting people - lawyers and banker and yes, also software engineers, I know because I've earned my pound of flesh - that themselves have ambitions to 'become rich', as if that were of any use in itself. It would be only half as enraging if ordinary people that are barely able to just scrape by on a full time job were in a position to make use of such shenanigans. I guess that would almost make it 'fair'. But as it is, "tool" like these allow for superwealthy people to have a lower tax range than your regular car mechanic or plumber or service employee. And this just breaks it for me.
- baybal2 5y agoSomebody very big keeps going, hacking those offshore law firms for years in a row. This cannot be just leaks keeping consistently popping up like that. I am trying to guess whose doing it may be?
- jedberg 5y agoThe thing with all of these is that the rich people are probably just as surprised as you are to show up in these leaks in most cases. When you get barely rich, like single digit millions, the banks will start to offer you "family office" services. They basically just take care of everything for you. You send them all your money and all your debts (even your phone bills and stuff), and they promise to make sure there is more at the end of the year than the start. They invest for you, they do accounting and file taxes for you. You give them limited power of attorney so you don't even see the tax forms. If you ask how it all works, they tell you it's really complicated and you should just focus on doing whatever it is that made you rich and let them worry about managing the money for you. Sometimes they do ethical stuff, sometimes not, depending on which bank and which consultant you hire. I'm not excusing the people who are here, just explaining how some people who you thought were good people end up in these leaks.
- jplr8922 5y agoI like the way you view it. A lot of non-rich people do not feel responsible at all for their wealth management. Some get lucky, and are very happy using their extra money to pay people to keep not thinking about this.
- cblconfederate 5y agoI doubt there are such people, they know at least nominally. The thing is, it is not illegal, so unless you re an active politician it doesnt register as something materially unethical
- ALittleLight 5y agoIt seems pretty preposterous to me that people could be surprised by finding out they have shady offshore bank accounts and what not. If you have a money person and he's not telling you what he's doing with your money that seems like it would set off red flags. Regardless of if people really are completely ignorant of their own finances and financial strategy I think they are still responsible for it. If I told a judge that I wasn't paying attention to my toxic chemical collection which I kept on the front lawn next to a neighborhood park I wouldn't expect that defense to protect me from legal liability.
- lmeyerov 5y agoThis would be fun to visualize! If someone is doing a jupyter notebook of it, I'd love to try doing some GPU graph views, let me know!
- eyeball 5y agoWonder if the person who leaked it will be killed in a car bombing like the journalist who broke the Panama papers.
- wolverine876 5y agoCan you provide some evidence of that happening?
- eyeball 5y agohttps://nypost.com/2017/10/16/panama-papers-journalist-killed-by-car-bomb/ https://nypost.com/2017/10/16/panama-papers-journalist-kille...
- input_sh 5y agoAs someone who worked in an organisation that was a part of both Panama Papers and Pandora Papers (I wasn't there during Paradise Papers), it's a gross overexaggeration. Like it is the case now, the work was done by hundreds of journalists spread across dozens of media outlets around the world. It is true that one Maltese journalist that worked on it was killed and it is completely accurate to call her Panama Papers journalist, but calling her the "original leaker" is just inaccurate. She also went through decades of various forms of intimidation before Panama Papers came out. I'm not talking just about death threats, IIRC her pet was found killed, her house was broken into, etc. For all I know, the original Panama Papers leaker was never identified beyond John Doe pseudonym, and is presumably still out there.
- harikb 5y agoI read 3/4th of the article and the title entirely as “Panama Papers” and wondered why the 2013 news is still being discussed until I realized….
- BrandoElFollito 5y agoWell, I read Panama Papers until your comment... I just read the comments, though, and somehow nothing seemed strange, I just thought some more information emerged after a few years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- manquer 5y agoA lot of negative comments that this is yet another leak and nothing is going to change. I see a lot of positives, Panama and paradise leaks were from one firm, this is from 14 different ones and by far the largest one in terms of number of documents, that's progress. More transparency is always good , as an immediate impact asset owners like the British crown are now going to be lot more careful who they are buying from, the optics of enabling laundring is quite important for such buyers. Removing such buyers from the market for dictators will limit who they can deal with making it more difficult and likely less lucrative for them in dealing with property
- Vinnl 5y agoAnyone know what kind of source has such documents from 14 different companies spread across jurisdictions?
- miohtama 5y agoIs there any way to get access to the source material?
- fmakunbound 5y ago> For a few hundred or a few thousand dollars, offshore providers can help clients… Heh this is totally affordable for regular jack offs like me. Perhaps someone will create a public benefit corporation (benefit for the irony), democratize access to these schemes for everyone, draw the ire of government when tax revenue plummets and lead to new laws enacted.
- wallace01 5y agoHow come all the players are from anywhere but US?
- wallace01 5y agohow come all the players in the pandora papers are from any country but the US?
- ur-whale 5y agoAn excellent question.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThird time’s a charm? Or nothing is going to happen again?
- missedthecue 5y agoNone of the named people are American. Interesting. https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/power-players/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/power-pla...
- petr_tik 5y agoI am not American and don't know how much coverage of European/World news an average American consumes (without US-centric commentary). It's also worth noting that earlier this week, this came out as confirmation of insider trading by the policy makers, who are even less elected than Erdogan https://www.ft.com/content/b899a77f-9853-4d20-ad84-21848b7e7ce2 https://www.ft.com/content/b899a77f-9853-4d20-ad84-21848b7e7...
- slowmovintarget 5y agoNone of the named people in the article are from the US, yet the actual papers have Americans aplenty: > ...more than 130 billionaires from Russia, the United States, Turkey and other nations. But you right, zero politicians from the US appear in the Pandora Papers themselves.
- uni_rule 5y agoI would be under the impression that Americans would show up less often in the papers because slimebag tax avoidance in the US is still done domestically. Not like Delaware seems to exist for any other reason.
- cyber_kinetist 5y agoThe people who are funding the ICIJ: https://www.icij.org/about/our-supporters/ https://www.icij.org/about/our-supporters/
- twofornone 5y ago>The files include disclosures about major donors to the Conservative party, raising difficult questions for Boris Johnson as his party meets for its annual conference. Not to start a flamewar but its increasingly blatant bullshit like this that makes me extremely wary of modern news media. The disingenuous implication here is that in all 11.9MM documents there were only ties to conservatives. It's lying without telling a lie. In fact this paragraph serves no purpose except to push a political agenda and take a dig at the British analog to Trump, who seems to get the same treatment in media.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoThe only people who will be punished by this leak are journalists and anyone remotely close to making a fuss about the corruption
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's not that hard, legally, to resolve this problem. What is the obstacle? It's a serious question, and intended to bypass the distraction and debate about despair. What is the obstacle?
- TheAlchemist 5y agoWhat problem ? And what solution ? I think you should start with explaining those first. Thing is, it's probably easy in theory, but very hard in practice.
- lamontcg 5y agoSo who is the modern day robinhood out there that is sponsoring these hacks and leaks?
- cyber_kinetist 5y agohttps://www.icij.org/about/our-supporters/ https://www.icij.org/about/our-supporters/
- m00dy 5y agoI would like to download these files if possible.
- nofrills 5y agoRothschild, Rockefeller, Warburg, Zuck, Musk, Bezos on the list? Oops, no? Then you know its entertainment.
- hermitcrab 5y agoI don't understand the greed of these people. Once you have health care, education, a nice house, a nice car and you can afford to go on holiday, what else do you need? What is the point of having 10 super cars or a 100 room mansion? Showing off to other shallow people?
- archsurface 5y agoAspiring to be monarchy, which condones "sacred people" above all others.
- amelius 5y agoBuilding a huge render farm would come to my mind, but I'm not a billionaire.
- IanSanders 5y agoGamification maybe? "Status" among (similar) peers? Disconnect from reality and living in a bubble? (which most of us do, in different ways to a different extent)
- Leherenn 5y agoIt's probably not the incentive for most billionaires, but there are stuffs that legitimately cost billions. Creating your own space company, wanting to invest in research like nuclear fusion or vaccines, owning a sport team, influencing politics, ... It's certainly arguable whether this is good or not, but I can see the appeal for a rich football fan to buy his own team and the best players and play fantasy football, but in real life. I am sure a lot of people here, if given billions, would try to tackle their own pet issue. Having billions available makes having a noticeable impact on the world much easier, if that's what you want to do, you need billions. > What is the point of having 10 super cars or a 100 room mansion? What's the point of having 10 pairs of shoes? You could say that some are better in some specific circumstances, but you probably don't really need all of them. How many people here have a 64-core CPU that is almost never fully used? Or people that have an offroad vehicle that will never see dirt? Your examples are the same behaviour, just at a different scale.
- emmelaich 5y agoAnother good read is https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-10-04/pandora-papers-australian-accountant-asiaciti-graeme-briggs-leak/100482936 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-10-04/pandora-papers-austra... Australia's ABC TV will be doing a "Four Corners" program on the subject tonight.
- mastazi 5y agoModerators, please replace the link with the original source: https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/pandora-papers/
- simonblack 5y agowhat correlation is there between this 'leak' and the previous Panama 'leak'.? I am extremely skeptical about the veracity of leaks like these. To see where they come from, look to see whose leaders are NOT included.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geomark 5y agoWe have all this teeth gnashing about how the rich won't pay their fair share of taxes because they want to keep it all for themselves. But among those rich are people who don't want to pay taxes because of the things the government does with those taxes. Afghanistan anyone? War on terror? on and on.
- eluusive 5y agoPeople should call income taxes what they really are: Labor taxes. "Capital" doesn't pay taxes.
- victorbstan 5y agoEndless greed.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoNytimes has nada on this.
- stefanwlb 5y agoI don't get it. If it's tax evasion they should go to jail, if it's not, then what is the story?
- adminscoffee 5y agoi wonder at what point where the masses will say enough is enough and take justice into their own hands. one era comes to mind tho, the french revolution. i really do not want to see or be any nearby when people lose their shit. watching all the protests, and people freaking out in washington on tv was terrifying and anxious enough for me. maybe something will change through something positive for once
- BiteCode_dev 5y ago> Notably, the richest people in the United States - like Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Bill Gates, and Warren Buffett - are not in the so-called Pandora Papers, the Washington Post reported.
- streamofdigits 5y agoTwo conclusions that are leaking about the "rich", like pus from an abscess: * their abysmal greed and asocial psyche: When you already have billions, what does it matter if you pay any percentage in taxes? How does it have any material or imaterial impact on your quality of life if you contribute back to society a fraction of what it gifted you with? * their deep fear of the societies they plunder: most people do accept some spread in wealth distribution if it is somehow "legitimate" and "kosher". Hidding their tracks and actions in complex constructions is how to engineer top-heavy, artificial, pyramids of wealth and power that exceed what would be acceptable under the cleansing light of transparency
- heurisko 5y ago> their abysmal greed and asocial psyche: When you already have billions, what does it matter if you pay any percentage in taxes? How does it have any material or imaterial impact on your quality of life if you contribute back to society a fraction of what it gifted you with? I don't think welfare should be based on philanthropy, but I do think some billionaires are still philanthropic, e.g. Bill Gates. I think there is also the situation where these tax arrangements arise out of a lack of thought, rather than conscious greed and asociality. If you pay a team of accountants and say "save me money", they're going to do everything possible to minimise your tax, some methods which should be classed as tax evasion, not avoidance. I don't expect billionaires to have a conscience. I vote for our system to stop damage from people acting without a conscience.
- null_object 5y ago> I don't think welfare should be based on philanthropy, but I do think some billionaires are still philanthropic, e.g. Bill Gates. Billionaires shouldn't get a pass because of 'philanthropy'. That is an extra contribution that any person can make if they choose and can afford it. Paying your taxes - that is, contributing back to society to keep it functioning in a healthy, balanced way, is not only a requirement of civilization (in my view) it's even in these ultra-rich peoples' self-interest: they help to maintain the stability that underpins their massive wealth.
- bsd44 5y agoSomewhat related to this story and more so to the wider context, I strongly recommend a documentary on Youtube called "Spider's Web - Britain's Second Empire" that talks about this very problem of dirty capital. It describes how offshore entities work, how they came to be and how City of London operates them through legislation.
- arbus_dev 5y agoThe concept of 'corruption' differs depending of the frame of reference' as we call it in physics. Is 'Pandora Papers' corrupt?...well...
- epinephrinios 5y agoBitcoin fixes this.
- euroderf 5y agoThe root of this is companies owning companies. From there onward it's a web of concealment & evasion. New rule: Shares in corporations may owned ONLY by clearly identified individuals.
- rsorero 5y agoThe Internet is hustling and bustling these days. Cyber-Climatic changes? I've a feeling no one is ready of whats around the corner.
- h0nd 5y agoWhere is the data available at? I could not find any leak yet, just the interpretation of it.