15 ms·
S.Korea broadband firm sues Netflix after traffic surge from 'Squid Game'
- apex_sloth 5y agoNice subscription service you have there Netflix, would be a shame if your customers couldn't view it.
- evgen 5y agoNice ISP you have there SK Broadband, would be a shame if your users could not access one of the most popular sites on the internet.
- freemint 5y agoNice costumers you have there SK Broadband, would be a shame if your costumers leave you. Oh? They are unlikey with Netflix not in a monthly cancelable contract but Internet plans generally require contracts of 2 to 3 years in South Korea.
- moate 5y agoNice contracts you have there SK Broadband, it would be a shame if your anti-consumer behaviors started to nullify their enforcability...
- monocasa 5y agoLol, in SK? Not a chance.
- ev1 5y agoNice courts you have there, it would be a shame if they were protected and paid off by the SK Group chaebol
- evgen 5y agoNice chaebol you have there, would be a shame if its behavior became the subject of international trade sanctions from the country that is providing you protection against your crazy and heavily armed cousin who lives next door.
- meibo 5y agoIsn't this what ISP subscribers are supposed to pay for? How big are the operating margins for major ISPs nowadays?
- NullPrefix 5y agoNo no, subscribers are supposed to pay and not use what they pay for.
- adventured 5y agoI can't speak to South Korea's ISP market, but in the US the major cable providers are now doing very well. Comcast is at $18b in operating profit, with roughly 18% operating income margins. Charter Communications is at $9.6b in operating income, with 19% operating income margins. Those are the two biggest cable companies in the US. In the early decades of cable, profitability was notoriously flaky for the industry. Enormous amounts of required capital investment, and it took a long time to saturate - scale into - the US market. Now the market is settled and they're printing consistently giant profits. Interestingly Charter has become a giant, worth $133 billion, and Paul Allen used to own a controlling interest in the early incarnation of it. It was part of his so called wired world collection of investments. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/economy/paul-allen-charter-and-what-might-have-been-jon-talton/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/economy/paul-allen-cha...
- lifthrasiir 5y ago> How big are the operating margins for major ISPs nowadays? In 2020, KT: 1.18 trillion KRW (1.00bn USD), SKT: 1.34 trillion KRW (1.13bn USD), LG U+: 886 billion KRW (749m USD). Their revenues range from 10 to 25 trillion KRW for the reference.
- fuzzy2 5y agoEveryone pays for their internet access, so why should Netflix (or anyone else) suddenly pay for mine? Netflix isn’t pushing data, I’m pulling it. If my ISP is losing money then I guess they better raise their prices, no?
- Vaderv 5y agoNo.
- xwdv 5y agoHmm, I guess ISPs could just drop traffic if they can’t afford it, but maybe if you push a lot of data you could pay more to have the content actually delivered to end users.
- Jensson 5y agoBut that would raise subscription prices. Should every user really pay extra for each subscription based on the data they might use on that subscription?
- tgv 5y agoAkshually ... that could make a bit of sense. Instead of paying for bandwidth you rarely use to your ISP, you could pay for bandwidth you actually use to the content provider. However, that would leave free content inaccessible, and probably create another wealth divide.
- Jensson 5y agoBut bandwidth is really cheap and this problem doesn't exist anywhere else. Worst case the ISP can increase their rates by a couple of dollars and improve their cables.
- tgv 5y agoNo argument from me. I just saw a tiny bit of logic behind another model of balancing the costs. The ISP would still have to upgrade the infrastructure in the end (although my model could lead to e.g. Netflix buying up ISPs).
- codetrotter 5y ago> Netflix said it will review SK Broadband's claim, and seek dialogue and explore ways in the meantime to work with SK Broadband to ensure customers are not affected. In other words, they will ship some Open Connect Appliance boxes to the ISP. https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ And that’s nice for everyone. Some think it’s unfair that big players like Netflix can do so. But I think them doing that is far far better than the idea of ISPs charging content providers for the bandwidth. Like other said, the customers of the ISPs are already paying for the bandwidth. Having the ISPs charging Netflix for the bandwidth too, that’s no bueno.
- 3pt14159 5y agoThis is basically how the internet works though, isn't it? Your network and my network have parties interested in each others data. If parts of your network are generating traffic that I don't think is reasonable then I can either disable their access or negotiate with you or one of the parties on your network to pay more or I can deny or throttle access to the parties on my network. And a OCA box just makes everything better for everyone where it's possible to employ them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nisegami 5y ago"If parts of your network are generating traffic that I don't think is reasonable" But it's your customers (the end users) generating traffic by watching content on my network (Netflix shows). If your customers can generate more traffic than you can handle, regardless of its a single entity or multiple entities, then that's a contract issue between you and your customers.
- vlan0 5y agoExactly this. To say that Netflix is generating traffic pointed at SK broadband would not be fair. Those TCP connections are initiated by the end user. Without the user requests there would be no traffic. So the philosophical question really becomes, what exactly is the end user buying from their ISP?
- dmingod666 5y agoWhat if ISPs created their own CDNs or someone creates a CDN network behind major ISP providers -- Netflix and YouTube top consumed content seems to be a very good contender for this type of a offering.
- AegirLeet 5y agoNetflix already has https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/. YouTube probably has something similar.
- polkonos 5y agohttps://peering.google.com/#/options/google-global-cache https://peering.google.com/#/options/google-global-cache
- scandinavian 5y agoCorrect we have netflix, google and akamai caches in our datacenter. A very large chunk of our total traffic goes through these racks.
- himinlomax 5y agoThere's a big difference in usage patterns: Netflix has a small number of videos, each with huge viewer count. That's eminently cachable. Youtube otoh is the long tail, orders of magnitude more videos with small view counts. Some of it may be cachable, but that's going to shave off on the order of 20% of the traffic cost, whereas in Netflix's case the gain could easily be 99%.
- jonnat 5y ago> South Korean lawmakers have spoken out against content providers who do not pay for network usage despite generating explosive traffic It's impressive how this framing has gotten so much acceptance. The content providers are not generating the traffic, the users are, and they are paying their ISPs to be able to do so.
- mrpopo 5y agoIf anything, customers should be suing ISPs every time they don't get the expected bandwidth. It's the ISP that fails to deliver according to the contract.
- dwighttk 5y agoI bet there is fine print that says they are delivering exactly according to the contract
- xoa 5y agoYou're certainly right, and the specific term here for what consumers should, but generally don't, have is a "Service Level Agreement" (SLA). This is pretty standard for business links and nearly anything at all at the datacenter level, if you ever subscribe to a whole line at a colo you'll probably see that. SLAs tend to spell out not just maximum sustained bandwidth, but 90/95/97/99%, uptime, what if any burst bandwidth is available, any latency guarantees, etc. All of these are different measures that cost different amounts to hit at any given level, and SLAs spell out exactly what is being paid for in numbers that can be monitored fairly easily. If I could make one simple change to the home broadband market, it would be insisting on a standardized big number consumer level SLA. I certainly don't expect residential rates to cover the same 99.97% or worst case minimum that business class does, that's a major part of what higher end connections are paying for. But whatever they do offer should be transparent, fixed for contract period and measurable. ISPs should by law be required to spell out not just the top line bandwidth level, but also 75%/95% guarantees over a standard time (day/month maybe) and what the worst case guaranteed minimum is. This wouldn't be some big centralized bureaucratic decision about implementations or what numbers have to be hit, but rather merely make sure the market has clear information so customers can compare and ISPs could be held to their promises. Energy Star consumer information might be some guide to layout, but I think something like that would be low hanging fruit. Also to be clear, a distinction can and should be made for intra-network vs inter-network, and both should be accounted for. Obviously an ISP has the most control and is the most responsible for how traffic traverses their own network to their edges, but ISPs do have some responsibility (affected by size/location) for their peering agreements too. If they're purposefully choking that it's on them, though small/remote ISPs may be at a disadvantage in negotiations there which should ideally have some eyes on it.
- wccrawford 5y agoSeems like a good opportunity for Netflix to raise their prices in S.Korea and use a portion of that increase to pay what the courts seem like they're going to demand. The rest of the increase would go to offsetting the additional burden on Netflix that this will cause by forcing them to treat S.Korea differently than everyone else. I'm honestly surprised that any corporations are paying that there, but if the government is going to requirement, there's not a lot you can do about it. It's a very bad precedent and I don't see it actually going well for S. Korea. Putting up extra barriers is a way to keep companies out. We usually call it a "tariff", but that's generally for physical goods. And the goal is often to prevent as many of those goods from being imported. What would S.Korea's internet look like if even 1 of the major players decided to just block the country instead of paying the fees?
- marcus_holmes 5y ago> I'm honestly surprised that any corporations are paying that there, It benefits Netflix in the long term as it raises barriers to entry for disruptive competitors. If, in order to reach an ISP's customers, you have to pay the ISP for the privilege, then creating new startups is harder and the incumbents can just price it in. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this became more common elsewhere, as everyone involved benefits. Except us, the customers, of course, but we don't get a seat at this table and the people who should be fighting for us are taking bribes (sorry "campaign donations").
- criley2 5y agoWhile I see the logic in what you're saying, the Netflix business moat is already much deeper due to A) billion dollar content deals with major providers and B) billion dollar investments into first party content. Content is king and competitors are already priced out long before minor squabbles over bandwidth.
- marcus_holmes 5y agoThe disruptor may have an answer for the content problem that Netflix never thought of. It's a competition for attention, after all, and if someone else can provide a more compelling alternative than video for people's attention then that will mess with Netflix' business despite its content deals.
- ojhughes 5y agoSquid Game is one of those shows you can never "unwatch". It's quite harrowing but strangely addictive and a great critique of modern capitalism. Strongly recommended if you have the stomach for it
- injidup 5y agoI'm dubious of this common posture of "horrible violence in entertainment" is ok because it's a critique of XYZ. It's like "free guy" (spoiler boring) tries to be a critique of video Game violence by positing the existence of another gaming reality where people are nice to each other. But this other reality is just a Macguffin. We come to watch the violence and mayhem and we come to watch squid game for the same reason. It is better to own the fact that watching torture porn gives you the jollies rather than posturing that it gives you membership of some anti capalist intelligensia. It's just Romans and Christians and Lions. The crowd loves it because people love blood.
- latexr 5y ago> I'm dubious of this common posture of "horrible violence in entertainment" is ok because it's a critique of XYZ. The comment you’re replying to says the show is harrowing and a critique. There’s no “because” or apologia.
- breakfastduck 5y agoBecause all entertainment is the same right? And it's of course not possible for a piece of entertainment to be both violent and intelligent? Considering your comment seems to be targeted at pseudo-intellectualism the irony here is simply off the charts.
- hereforphone 5y agoThis violence is unrealistic to the point that it's not disturbing (to me, at least). Someone pulls an undamaged bullet from a guy's forehead with tweezers. Blood is the color of cranberry juice. It's so over the top it's lost all impact.
- drcode 5y ago
- wiradikusuma 5y agoLet customers vote with their wallet then. If I were the judge, I would ask Netflix to stream low bandwidth version of the content so it won't impact SK Broadband. AND, tell BOTH parties that they must put announcement in their respective website, "SK Broadband provides you internet at a cost (as per their claim). To enjoy Full HD of this content, pay extra to SK Broadband". See which party the customers will be angry to.
- Arrath 5y agoConsidering how often I've seen the "SK has the best/fastest consumer internet connections" news bits, I'd be awfully angry at the provider for drumming up the hype and failing to deliver.
- lifthrasiir 5y agoThere are three major nationwide broadband services in SK: Korea Telecom (KT), LG Uplus and SK Broadband (SKBB, a subsidary of SK Telecom). Among them SKBB is considered the worst because both KT and LG U+ operate their own infrastructures due to their pre-privatization history but SKBB don't, so SKBB has to perpetually lease infra from them. It is therefore no surprise that SKBB (and also SKT) is one of the biggest forces against net neutrality in SK, given their service is especially weak and net neutrality will make it worse.
- Jensson 5y agoBy this logic the consumer would have to pay the ISP fee to every new service they sign up for, like Netflix, Youtube, Disney etc. I prefer the way it works now where I only have to pay for my connection once.
- ninjinxo 5y agoSimilarly, Australia had problems when Netflix was first becoming popular here, putting huge strains on the network and causing widespread congestion issues from 6 to 10 pm. I wonder if we'll ever see a predictive home-caching system; if I watch the first three episodes of squid game in one night, it might be sensible to have my TV download the rest of the series overnight.
- m4tthumphrey 5y agoAnd then you'd have storage issues instead of bandwidth!
- okamiueru 5y agoDoesn't Netflix have a CDN in Australia, and doesn't Australia have fast Internet within the continent? I'm a bit surprised this is such a problem
- mewse 5y agoWe do now. The problem was when Netflix first opened here and the vast majority of people were still on ADSL links or even slower, and our NBN infrastructure was still just starting to come together (which I'm not going to go into details about because omg there's a huge political fight in that which I really don't want to think about) Short version: our Netflix is just fine now. There were just a couple rocky weeks/months at the start. :)
- Genmutant 5y agoDoesn't the Netflix app already do that? Or was that the Prime Video one?
- mercora 5y agohaving multicast working on the internet would make this extremly efficient for the distributors (i.e. netflix) but the last mile (i.e. your ISP) still would have to deliver the packets to their customers one by one. at Netflix scale it would probably be already very beneficial to do that by broadcasting the stream starting every 5 seconds or something for uncached viewing. (i.e make the player wait for the next broadcast and jump to different ones [or start a new one at desired offset if none exist] when seeking). Instead of using the internet its also feasible to use the DVB network like this. they could even broadcast a copy long before release so its guaranteed to be ready for offline watching when released. i am almost certain Sky Germany does something similar...
- FatalLogic 5y agoIn Korea, can popular shops, restaurants and similar destinations be sued by public transport operators for overloading their trains and buses?
- oefrha 5y agoThis seems to be the opposite of Internet behemoths zero rating their bandwidth to undercut smaller competitors: Internet behemoths being shaken down for transit technically already paid for. I suppose the ISPs didn't expect this level of utilization.
- niemandhier 5y agoI think it becomes easier to think about this, if I frame the problem in terms of more tangible objects than bandwidth and data. The public street network is in large parts paid for by taxes, so for everyone access to the network is already payed for. If I now envision a single company blocking all streets with its giant truck fleet, I could completely understand a motion to introduce a new form of toll to be payed by such companies to avoid having to rise taxes. That toll would most likely just increase the price of whatever said company is selling.
- viceroyalbean 5y agoI don't think that's a fair framing. As others have said, the users of the broadband pay for their bandwidth. It's not Netflix pushing data, it's the users pulling it. If you have 100 users that pay you for 1Gbps/s but your network can't handle 100Gbps/s that's your failure to adhere to the contract you made with your users. In the road example, it's more like if every person paid for the ability to put one truck on the road and everyone delegated their truck space to a shipping company who now has millions of trucks hogging the roads. Yes, they're using tons of infrastructure but their usage has been paid for already.
- Jensson 5y agoIts more like, there is a new stadium in town. Then the stadium holds a game with a team from a nearby town, everyone in that town wants to drive to see it, so all the streets in that town are now clogged. Should the stadium pay the other town money to hold a game because lots of people there drive to watch it? Or should the other town build their roads to meet the demand of their citizens? I think the second option is more reasonable, the problem was that there wasn't enough road for the citizens in general, not that there wasn't enough road for them to watch this particular game.
- resizeitplz 5y agoEnvision every driver owning a semi-truck made by the company. It's not a single company blocking the streets; it's the drivers who purchased the company's very large vehicles and who also paid for street access.
- 5y ago
- wodenokoto 5y agoA lot of commentors here are defending that netflix shouldn't pay data charges. I don't know how internet prices works for big players, but from the perspective of a little guy, it seems kinda reasonable that netlflix pay, doesn't it? I mean, why am I paying for bandwidth on AWS? Shouldn't that be paid for by the downloading party? If I download something from my neighbors computer over a p2p app, then we both still pay for our internet connection, and depending on the contract, we pay by the byte.
- yunohn 5y ago> why am I paying for bandwidth on AWS? That’s a great question; it’s because cloud providers have conditioned you to believe their rent-seeking is necessary. See Cloudflare R2 vs AWS S3: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28702997 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28702997
- fabbari 5y agoThat, though, is exactly how it works. Netflix pays for their traffic and infrastructure, the SK clients pay for access to internet for a given bandwidth and SK pays for the infrastructure and interconnections needed to give their clients what they paid for. Netflix doesn't get free interconnections.
- chii 5y ago> why am I paying for bandwidth on AWS? Shouldn't that be paid for by the downloading party? you're paying for it because it costs money to provide bandwidth on both ends, and AWS is just shunting the cost onto you itemized. Netflix, believe it or not, also charges for the bandwidth it uses, but it hides it unitemized into the subscription fee, and in sufficient quantities that when averaged across all it's subscribers, they come out at least breakeven.
- viceroyalbean 5y agoSomewhat unrelated, but your point about costs coming out breakeven when averaged over all users made me realize that this move by SK makes as much sense as Netflix suing an ISP because their customers consume a disproportionately large amount of Netflix' bandwidth. The ISP's role in facilitating the usage of Netflix bandwidth would be the same as Netflix faciliting use of SK's bandwidth in this case.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- glanzwulf 5y agoIn reality what should happen is the users of SK Broadband should sue the ISP for being unable to provide a service they pay for.
- justshowpost 5y agoSK Broadband's customers should be suing. The only guilt of Netflix (besides selling down-level show at rip-off price) is what their action helped to reveal SK Broadband can not actually service their customers with agreed bandwidth (and no, its ISP's sole responsibility to pay their uplink for required bandwidth). I'm pretty sure the problem was well known to geek minority, just this streaming spike uncovered the problem to general public.
- dewoleajao 5y agoIt's strange that SK Broadband would go to so much trouble rather than be happy for the profit opportunity that Netflix brings since their content is cacheable. In Nigeria which arguably is more broadband-challenged than Korea, it took me only a few weeks to ship in a Netflix OpenConnect appliance and integrate into the network at a local fiber company where I did some work last year. All we had to do was agree with Netflix that we would keep it powered up and cover the cache-fill bandwidth costs. Net results: Today, that ISP uses less than 2Gbps of Internet bandwidth for less than 8 hours daily to update their cached content which they deliver to thousands of Netflix users at wire speeds. Literally you're spending less than 2Gbps to acquire popular content and selling more than 10Gbps to your users during peak periods (if your local infrastructure can support it). https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/
- chii 5y ago> for the profit opportunity Sk broadband already got paid from their customers. Netflix is merely incurring more costs for them, which is why they are suing in court in the first place! Sk broadband would prefer that their customers don't have netflix, but only browse text websites!
- moate 5y agoI worked in pricing and I always framed it as a scale with "Greed" on the left and "Customer Service" on the right and the 2 ideas being in a tug of war. Greed wants to charge customers infinite money and provide 0 product in exchange for it. Customer Service wants to give away everything for free to as many people as possible. To be a real, viable business you need to find that sweet spot where neither of the two makes too many of the decisions.
- AlexAltea 5y ago> Netflix's data traffic handled by SK jumped 24 times from May 2018 to 1.2 trillion bits of data processed per second What an odd way of representing data transfer bandwidth: Was it so hard to just say 1.2 Tbps (or better 150 GB/s)? Also, maybe an ignorant question from my side: Is that bandwidth such a big deal at nation-scales? It feels like barely 1000 homes maxing out the fiber usage. All submarine cables being deployed today are already in the 100+ Tbps range, aren't they?
- gumby 5y agoNetflix pays for the packets that go in and out of its network. SK’s customers pay for the packets that go in and out of their home networks. So what am I missing? That’s sounds like the way things are supposed to work. When I read this description of SK’s complaint it appears they are unhappy with the deals they struck with their customers. Nor in other words they are unhappy their customers are actually using the product.
- mdip 5y agoI think it's fairly simple: in the original arrangement where ISPs provided access to content and that content was not video, ISPs were making out like bandits offering unlimited service at ridiculous speeds while not having to upgrade their own connections since customer demand was lower. Suddenly content comes along that increases customer demands on their "unlimited service" and instead of the ISP deciding correct the capacity imbalance (and accept that they "done screwed up"), they cry "unfair" and run to the courts. Back when peering agreements were in place it made sense for everyone involved; ISPs get great content they don't have to provide and/or pay for, content providers get access to customers. Now, however, ISPs are finding out that these agreements are very costly for them, they can't turn to their customers for more money due to competition and they can't just block Netflix because those same customers would leave for another ISP so they turn to the courts to repair their mistakes. If they win, Netflix gets screwed, the customer gets screwed and the ISP gets rewarded for their mistakes... that sounds like a heck of a public-private partnership. :)
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThe Internet is literally a series of erbium doped tubes, analogous to highway traffic. Videos of cats at high enough bandwidth can melt optical interconnects. For the same reason truckers pay some tax for brutalizing the roads, giant content providers beaming data through these systems must be taxed lest the Internet infrastructure be destroyed and the cost only be burdened by general taxpayers instead of users. (because Netflix would just charge users more, but in the meantime they will fight to have other non-user taxpayers maintain the infrastructure)
- the8472 5y ago> literally [...] analogous to highway traffic. No, it isn't. Cars can't spawn clones as they travel down a branching set of roads. But IP Multicast can do this, which is how IPTV works on the ISP level. And multicast is basically emulated by edge distribution boxes so that the traffic moving into the ISP can be multiplied to multiple customers.
- reportgunner 5y agoI don't think the parent was serious, I believe it's a reference to The Internet is a series of tubes[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_of_tubes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_of_tubes
- Illniyar 5y agoI think in your analogy netflix is more the shop that those truckers are delivering goods to. So if you want to be more accurate, the proposed payments won't be like a tax on truckers (in this analogy the truckers are the users, or maybe ISPs), rather it'll be a tax on supermarkets and shops that are getting the goods.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThey are sending the trucks out of their shop…
- mdip 5y agoI find this thinking just bizarre and displays quite a bit of hubris from the ISPs and/or S. Korean courts. What's happening here is simple: Netflix is so popular that an ISP dare not block their content. Really, put simply: Netflix costs money to deliver, yes, but it is an expectation of ISP customers that they have access to Netflix. If an ISP were to block/charge more for access to Netflix (assuming that's even legal, but let's just say it is), customers would move to another ISP. Outside of cases where moving to another would be impossible[0], that should be the end of it. It's interesting to me that the article focuses entirely on the courts getting involved. What's happened is that a business made assumptions about cost (that "unlimited" would mostly be users surfing lower-bandwidth web sites, not delivering video) and the market (all of their competitors likely land somewhere near eachothers' pricing) and discovered that those assumptions were wrong. Instead of either accepting that they are not a commodity that will always chase the lowest price and operating accordingly, they've gone to the courts to have the government require Netflix to reward them for their mistakes. This idea that as an ISP customer, you "paid for unlimited service at a certain rate" but "don't you dare actually use that unlimited service" is absurd. Watching Netflix, even the vast majority of the day/night, isn't a matter of abuse -- akin to bringing a sleeping bag and living at a 24-hour gym that you have a membership to -- it is what most ISPs are advertising as a reason to subscribe to them. They know they can't turn around and tell their customers (that have choices in service providers) that they're going to charge them for access to something that is central to that service, so they go after Netflix. What if Netflix refuses to pay and just leaves the S. Korean market or decides to say "screw it" and shut the business down (ala Atlas Shrugged)? Would that make S. Korean ISPs service more valuable? [0] In these cases, they're a monopoly to those customers and should be regulated accordingly; preferably in a manner that brings in an ISP that can handle Netflix traffic without the charges.
- drcongo 5y agoThere is no way that this is anything other than a clever bit of PR.
- naomeux 5y agoIsn't it at the consumer's discretion if they're going to watch Squid Game on Netflix? Is the firm blinded by greed and decided to take advantage of the sudden surge in the platform?
- CreateAccntAgn 5y ago"The move comes after a Seoul court said Netflix should "reasonably" give something in return to the internet service provider for network usage" Any additional info on why the courts said so?
- shadowgovt 5y agoIIUC, there's already a process for this for telecom providers. 1) Ban Netflix IP. 2) Netflix (and customers) complain 3) Come to an arrangement for Netflix to pay a cost Netflix already had to put together several peering deals in the US when the popularity of their service took off. Why is this scenario any different / what is it about South Korean law that entangles the government in this decision at all?
- breakfastduck 5y agoHow anyone could side with the ISP here is beyond baffling. They're essentially making the point that if I build a website, spend large portions of my own money hosting it, and it becomes popular, I should also be charged extra by the ISPs of the users who access my site. We're in clown world at this point.
- EmilioMartinez 5y agoThe lawsuit and court rule are not really about "siding" morally speaking. It's about deciding what money collection scheme to use. You can either charge user for the internet they use, or simply target the really large content providers and split the bill with them leaving the user with fixed charges to worry only about connection stability when choosing an ISP. I'm guessing it was mostly contingency that created a culture where the latter became the status quo, and everyone is rolling with that. This is a long shot from a mom-and-pop website like you describe.
- EmilioMartinez 5y agoThis is just a framing issue and I don't get the hate here. It would make sense that ISP's openly decide to charge flat rates to users while charging special fees to really large content providers. What's ridiculous is that this is being settled in courts of law, as if someone did something wrong, instead of being just business deals. Internet infrastructure and usage is relatively recent and quickly shifting, so the social/political/economic aspects are always trying to fit into legacy arrangements. In this case it was easier to preserve the ISP-user agreement of how content is served and billed, while using pre-existing infrastructures (courts of law) to settle who actually pays the extra bills. It feels out of place, but if you strip the legal content out it's just business deals about services.
- LatteLazy 5y ago"Sorry, your ISP is suing us so we can't let you watch anything popular right now. Here is a link to other ISPs and a coupon if you wanted to swap..." is about to become the most popular show on Korean netflix.
- yongjik 5y agoCouldn't have happened at a better time for Netflix. From what I've heard, Koreans are pretty pumped up that Squid Game is storming the global market (it's said that the producer of the show tried to make it for many years, except that nobody in Korea wanted to invest, thinking that it was too out-there), and then an unpopular ISP comes along and sues Netflix for profit ... I have to wonder what the SK Broadband PR team was thinking, or if they were overridden by old guys at the top.
- kevinpet 5y agoHave they considered degrading the stream to 320x240 and slapping a "get a real ISP" banner across the bottom?
- pkaye 5y agoI thought South Korea has fast cheap internet?
- Beldin 5y agoFrom the headline I thought this was something like where a phone number is shown in a serie, and it's viewers start calling it in droves. Not so. This is about an ISP having to deliver what its customers pay it for: bytes. Incredibly, this has gone to court and the ISP won. The judge found it isn't fair that the market changed, and that Netflix should pony up now that they've dared to become popular.
- op00to 5y agoWhy doesn’t Netflix bill SK? Netflix is providing a service to SK by fulfilling user requests for them. Each request is billed at $1,000,000 US. Care to negotiate?
- imbnwa 5y agoOne of the things Netflix got right over all its competition was capturing the best international programming, a lot of Netflix's best content in the US has been foreign material like Money Heist, Dark, Squid Game, Peaky Blinders, Green Frontier, the Criminal series, To The Lake, etc
- lswank 5y agoKorean perspective: This is totally normal. It's just "hey, help us out here, since you are reaping the rewards". But we can't sue our customers or they will go over to LG for their ISP, who will gladly have them.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoWould a Squid server caching Squid Game alleviate the problem? I'll see myself out.